View Full Version : The IDW/Nickelodeon character revival conspiracy
neatoman
03-06-2015, 11:31 AM
Shortly after announcing Mondo Gecko's return in the Nickelodeon cartoon, Mondo Gecko appeared in the IDW series. That got me a bit suspicious so I started to think about it. Slash, Mutagen Man, Mondo Gecko, Traag, Granitor and Metalhead are all characters that haven't been used for decades, yet both IDW and Nickelodeon decided to revive within a similar timeframe.
Coincidence?! Probably...
Ninjinister
03-06-2015, 11:40 AM
More like the fact that they're just finally using characters that Mirage/4Kids denied or were denied.
More like the fact that they're just finally using characters that Mirage/4Kids denied or were denied.
This. Exactly.
CyberCubed
03-06-2015, 06:45 PM
And almost all these characters would have appeared in the 4kids cartoon too if Peter Laird wasn't there to veto everything.
neatoman
03-07-2015, 02:35 AM
And almost all these characters would have appeared in the 4kids cartoon too if Peter Laird wasn't there to veto everything.
Really? What's the evidence?
liugeaux
03-07-2015, 11:45 AM
Yeah I'm sure has nothing to do with Slash, Mutagen Man, Mondo Gecko, and Metalhead being fan favorites.
By your logic, the Neutrinos should be showing up in the Nick cartoon soon and the Mutant Frogs will be in the IDW soon too.
Just take it for the coincidence that it is and move on.
Ninjinister
03-07-2015, 12:12 PM
Really? What's the evidence?
A decade of his blog?
neatoman
03-07-2015, 12:39 PM
A decade of his blog?
Any blog posts in particular that point to it?
Yeah I'm sure has nothing to do with Slash, Mutagen Man, Mondo Gecko, and Metalhead being fan favorites.
By your logic, the Neutrinos should be showing up in the Nick cartoon soon and the Mutant Frogs will be in the IDW soon too.
Just take it for the coincidence that it is and move on.
Of course the "conspiracy" is just a joke, although I do find it amusing that such a minor character as the Mutagen Man got to be a fan favourite.
CyberCubed
03-07-2015, 02:06 PM
By your logic, the Neutrinos should be showing up in the Nick cartoon soon and the Mutant Frogs will be in the IDW soon too.
That might very well happen eventually.
In all seriousness Nick and IDW are simply cherry-picking the most popular or well known mutants from the past from either the cartoon, toyline or Archie series and using them. Mutagen Man's toy was always very popular so hence why he got a revival despite only being in 1 episode of the original toon.
neatoman
03-07-2015, 02:15 PM
That might very well happen eventually.
In all seriousness Nick and IDW are simply cherry-picking the most popular or well known mutants from the past from either the cartoon, toyline or Archie series and using them. Mutagen Man's toy was always very popular so hence why he got a revival despite only being in 1 episode of the original toon.
Well of course they're cherry-picking characters, I doubt we'll ever see characters like Pinky McFingers ever again.
CyberCubed
03-07-2015, 03:11 PM
Well of course they're cherry-picking characters, I doubt we'll ever see characters like Pinky McFingers ever again.
You never know. I certainly never expected to see characters like Null, Muckman/Joe eyeball, or Mutagen Man ever again.
I wouldn't be surprised if we see Lord Dregg appear in the IDW comic in a few years time as another warlord from Dimension X.
Mr. Stay Puft
03-13-2015, 06:13 PM
Of course the "conspiracy" is just a joke, although I do find it amusing that such a minor character as the Mutagen Man got to be a fan favourite.
I don't think it's the character himself as much as the fact that he had such an awesomely grotesque appearance. Plus his toy was a lot of fun, much like Muckman.
Joey Kamikaze
03-13-2015, 07:32 PM
You never know. I certainly never expected to see characters like Null, Muckman/Joe eyeball, or Mutagen Man ever again.
I wouldn't be surprised if we see Lord Dregg appear in the IDW comic in a few years time as another warlord from Dimension X.
I had a feeling Null would show up eventually; he's one of the strongest personalities in the TMNT rogue gallery and it was past time another iteration did something with him (or her?). Mutagen Man was less expected but I remember how widespread ownership of his toy was when I was a kid.
Really with Null in the game I think the next character revival I'm crossing my fingers for is Wingnut & Screwloose. I always had a soft spot that that couple of plankton chips, and now that the Mutanimals are up and running...
Let's be honest - most of these guys weren't "characters" to begin with. They were toys first and foremost, made one-off and/or one-note appearances in the cartoon, and if they were lucky, got fleshed out more in the Archie comics, like Mondo and Slash.
In the case of the Mutagen Man, he has a really striking design (which originated with Peter Laird's character sketch (http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/9/98/TheUnknownMutagenManLaird02.jpg), it's worth mentioning) and that's basically the whole initial appeal. The fact that Nick and IDW have gone in such different directions with the character speaks to that. I like both directions, but it's not like there's any specific, ingrained traits or personality attached to the character, y'know? And that's the case with a lot of the revived '87-era mutants, really. They look cool, but whatever personalities they were given were pretty one-note and forgettable for the most part. They're cool-looking blank slates - kind of perfect choices if you want the freedom to take a "known" character and treat them like a new creation.
Cryomancer
03-15-2015, 01:52 PM
I think it's quite possible that some of the production staff are/were specifically into the toy line and not the show.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.