PDA

View Full Version : The Puma Blues


Topsu
04-08-2015, 10:59 AM
I'm not sure if I should've put this in general forums comics section, but mods can move it if necessary.

Anyway, Puma Blues by Murphy & Zulli seems to be getting reprinted with some exclusive bonus material, and I thought maybe some of you are interested in this. I haven't personally read the whole story, just a couple of issues I've got my hands on. Am I right assuming that the story didn't actually end, since one of the bonus materials is "Never-before-seen ending by original creators"?

Here's the list of bonus material, and a link to pre-order in amazon. (http://www.amazon.com/Puma-Blues-Dover-Graphic-Novels/dp/0486798135)

Exclusive Bonus Material:
• Never-before-seen ending by original creators
• Hard-to-find The Puma Blues mini-comic
• New Foreword by Dave Sim, legendary creator of Cerebus
• New Afterword by Stephen R. Bissette, acclaimed artist on Alan Moore's Swamp Thing

Oh, and I did already pre-order it, found out about it after looking for info of Dover Publishing, which is also making collected book of Jim Lawsons Paleo. That's worth checking too, should have some all-new stories in it.

plastroncafe
04-08-2015, 11:13 AM
Sweet!
Thanks for sharing this, I had no idea!

Diorm
04-08-2015, 11:18 AM
Is the TMNT comic "Choices" be collected in this?

Topsu
04-08-2015, 11:40 AM
Is the TMNT comic "Choices" be collected in this?
I doubt it, since it's not published by IDW. Also, it wouldn't really make sense to have one TMNT story that kind of collection. I hope IDW puts it on Ultimate vol 6 or something.

DrSpengler
04-08-2015, 01:18 PM
Is the TMNT comic "Choices" be collected in this?

I wouldn't be surprised if all of The Puma Blues #20 is absent from the collection.

It was a benefit issue independently published after Diamond (dickishly) dropped Puma Blues from distribution as retaliation against Dave Sim ( who published Puma Blues via Aardvark One International) for self-distributing a Cerebus graphic novel.

None of the stories are part of the ongoing "canon" of Puma Blues and they're all shorts from guest creators. It'd be a mess of royalties and permissions to include in the collection and won't hurt the narrative by being omitted.

Powder
04-08-2015, 05:34 PM
Sweet. I've never checked out the original, so maybe this is the ideal way to go. I wanna get the collected Paleo book as well, I loved what I read of that series.

DK2
04-08-2015, 09:48 PM
This would be an interesting book to pursue. I always wanted to check it out but never had the chance to get them. Always remember some of the ads and wondered if I should check it out. Also wondering if Melting Pot will ever be collected? I wanted to check that out too. Jim Lawson stated Paleo wouldn't even be out til next February. I feel burned by this. I just acquired the old Paleo trade from Mirages store and also got #7. But I can't find #8 as Mirage was out of this already. Anyone know where to get Paleo #8? I know mycomicshop.com doesn't have it either or Milehighcomics.com.

Topsu
04-09-2015, 01:11 PM
Also wondering if Melting Pot will ever be collected?
It has been collected.
(http://www.amazon.com/Melting-Pot-Collection-Kevin-Eastman/dp/087816362X/)

DK2
04-09-2015, 09:05 PM
It has been collected.
(http://www.amazon.com/Melting-Pot-Collection-Kevin-Eastman/dp/087816362X/)

Didn't realise this til after I looked it up. Apparently an issue of Heavy Metal mag extended this mini series in 2007 issue. Wondered how I should get this now, the extended mag edition or the old trade? Is it good and worth it for the read if anyone would tell?

DrSpengler
04-09-2015, 09:24 PM
Didn't realise this til after I looked it up. Apparently an issue of Heavy Metal mag extended this mini series in 2007 issue. Wondered how I should get this now, the extended mag edition or the old trade? Is it good and worth it for the read if anyone would tell?

You'd be looking for the Fall, 2007 Heavy Metal issue (labeled the 30th Anniversary Special). That has the extended and remastered Melting Pot in it.

In the intro, Eastman says that it's the ideal version of the story, though he also says that he's still not satisfied with it and might update it more in the future (he hasn't yet).

If you're talking about the actual story in terms of quality? Oh man, it's one of the dumbest comics I've ever read. Really stupid stuff. Great art, but dumb, dumb story, The movie version (Heavy Metal 2000) is even worse.

But again, it's got some killer art so it's fun to look at. If you could enjoy Bodycount in some fashion then you might be able to get a kick out of Melting Pot.

Diorm
04-10-2015, 10:33 AM
Really? And here I though it was the same story. I only saw the movie and yes the story was going anywere.
If Kevin said he wasnt satisified with it, did he meant the art or the story?

DrSpengler
04-10-2015, 12:38 PM
Really? And here I though it was the same story. I only saw the movie and yes the story was going anywere.
If Kevin said he wasnt satisified with it, did he meant the art or the story?

I'd have to reread the intro, but I recall he wasn't 100% satisfied with various aspects of it, from artwork to story.

The Heavy Metal edition has tweaked artwork and extra pages and I think some redone dialogue, but I don't have the 1995 trade paperback version to compare it to.