View Full Version : Favorite IDW artist
Toitlefan
05-06-2015, 10:10 AM
The art for the current IDW series seems to vary tremendously. There is the darker, grittier work of Eastman and Kuhn and then there is the refined and highly detailed stuff from Smith and Santolouco. Just in terms of artist/pencils, who is your favorite? I've included an 'other' choice for variant cover artists and artists that may have appeared in other Microseries.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-06-2015, 10:29 AM
Cory Smith, with Dan Duncan as a very close runnerup. Loved the first twelve issues, and loved Attack on Technodrome. Mateus' only work that doesn't irritate me was "SHotFC." So sick of preTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles... :tgrumble::trolleye:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-06-2015, 10:40 AM
The art for the current IDW series seems to vary tremendously. There is the darker, grittier work of Eastman and Kuhn and then there is the refined and highly detailed stuff from Smith and Santolouco. Just in terms of artist/pencils, who is your favorite? I've included an 'other' choice for variant cover artists and artists that may have appeared in other Microseries.
Oh, BTW: you might want to change Campbell's name to Sophie.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=51234
PangolinFeets
05-06-2015, 10:50 AM
Oh, BTW: you might want to change Campbell's name to Sophie.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=51234
I was just about to point this out. IDW has started updating all the digital editions to say Sophie Campbell. :)
I really love all the artists for different reasons and I love that IDW gets tha chance to switch up styles for corresponding tones. Its one of my favorite things about the series.
Santolouco's work got me into the series. Everything in City Fall was so gorgeous. Then Campbell kept me there. The contrast was so perfect and necessary as a cooldown after all the mind-****ery of CF and I did not expect it from something like TMNT. Then I went back and read everything.
So I'm really biased, but my order is Campbell, Santolouco, Bates, and Smith.
neatoman
05-06-2015, 10:57 AM
Ben Bates... He is perfect...
DrSpengler
05-06-2015, 11:02 AM
Ben Bates is probably my favorite; he finds a nice middleground between action and humor. He can make the Turtles look silly without making them look 10 years old, but also knows when to make them look threatening or serious depending on the tone called for by the scene.
Unfortunately, he hasn't really done many issues compared to the rest of the folks on the list, so I felt a tad hesitant to choose him.
I don't think IDW's TMNT has had any bad artists at all. Some who have made aesthetic choices I don't agree with, sure, but none of them have been what I'd call bad by any measure. We're kinda spoiled for choice; we don't know how good we've really got it.
PangolinFeets
05-06-2015, 11:11 AM
Ben Bates is probably my favorite; he finds a nice middleground between action and humor. He can make the Turtles look silly without making them look 10 years old, but also knows when to make them look threatening or serious depending on the tone called for by the scene.
Unfortunately, he hasn't really done many issues compared to the rest of the folks on the list, so I felt a tad hesitant to choose him.
I don't think IDW's TMNT has had any bad artists at all. Some who have made aesthetic choices I don't agree with, sure, but none of them have been what I'd call bad by any measure. We're kinda spoiled for choice; we don't know how good we've really got it.
Agreed. I definitely have a preference, but I would never not buy an issue because so-and-so worked on it. I'm also insanely excited for the Casey and April micro because I really like Irene Koh's art too.
And we can't forget we have a pretty amazing colorist behind all that ink. Rhonda does almost all the coloring and has been blowing me away in the past few issues.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-06-2015, 11:17 AM
Agreed. I definitely have a preference, but I would never not buy an issue because so-and-so worked on it. I'm also insanely excited for the Casey and April micro because I really like Irene Koh's art too.
And we can't forget we have a pretty amazing colorist behind all that ink. Rhonda does almost all the coloring and has been blowing me away in the past few issues.
Art has never kept me away from TMNT comics. After all, the art for the first few original Mirage comics is... well, I think it's pretty ugly. Yes it's the original and it started the whole franchise, but I don't like it.
Doesn't stop me from owning it or enjoying it. :tsmile:
PangolinFeets
05-06-2015, 11:32 AM
I'm just gonna put this here because I don't know who saw it this already, but since I'm seeing a lot of Cory Smith fans, he is selling some really sweet limited prints through my LCS. The black and white ones are sold out, but there are really nice colored ones still available.
http://images.cdn.bigcartel.com/bigcartel/product_images/157475248/max_h-1000+max_w-1000/exclusive_teenage_mutant_ninja_turtles_fcbd2015_pr int_by_cory_smith.jpg
Here's the link: http://fourthworldcomics.bigcartel.com/product/exclusive-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-fcbd2015-print-by-cory-smith
Toitlefan
05-06-2015, 11:33 AM
Oh, BTW: you might want to change Campbell's name to Sophie.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=51234
Interesting. I guess I missed that thread. I will keep the name for now, not out of disrespect, just because that is the name that appears on the comics.
Cory Smith was my first choice. His interpretations of the turtles are exactly how I imagine them. Santolouco is definitely a talented artist but he needs to make the turtles look like they didn't just come back from a cross-over with My Little Pony.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-06-2015, 11:50 AM
Santolouco is definitely a talented artist but he needs to make the turtles look like they didn't just come back from a cross-over with My Little Pony.
Shhhh... we don't want that to happen. :tshifty: Speak no evil!
Powder
05-06-2015, 02:29 PM
Hard for me to pick just one, really. Duncan, Campbell, & Bates would probably get my top 3 spots, though with no specific order.
The Fifth Turtle
05-06-2015, 02:35 PM
Dan
Duncan
Mormegil
05-06-2015, 03:09 PM
I really like Dan Duncan but Ben Bates gets my vote. Dan 's style is great but i can understand some people not liking it. Ben is kind of the best of everything.
pl212
05-06-2015, 03:15 PM
Huge fan of Sophie Campbell and Ben Bates art. Love the tone and life they bring to these characters. Overall IDW has chosen a great mix of artists for sure.
funatic
05-06-2015, 05:56 PM
For me its a 3-way tie between Eastman, Bates, and Campbell.
Eastman is the orginal Mirage-era grit that got me into the turtles, and if his art was still crossbred with Laird's that would be my top choice.
Bates, as others have said, finds that perfect middle-ground between edgy and cartoony, and I think his art is truly the most well-suited to the IDWverse. I'd love to see him back on the ongoing after Santolouco and Smith (both awesome in their own right) end their run.
But I ultimately gave my vote to Campbell. Hers is the freshest take I've seen on the turtles since Zuli's hyperealism 20 years ago. They exude a true 'teenage' aspect, but can also flip the badass switch if need be. Plus, Campbell geeked out with me about turtles for over 30min at con appearance a few years back, so that helped break the tie. :trazz:
Really all of these artists are great though. Not a bad one in the bunch. IDW has been pretty blessed with talent, or rather, does a great job at finding it.
Joey Kamikaze
05-06-2015, 05:58 PM
It's hard to choose between Santalouco and Smith. I'd be happy if they keep alternating.
Plasticplayhouse
05-06-2015, 09:52 PM
campbell and santolouco have been my favs, but cory smith has been doing some nice stuff; he rounds out my top three.
funatic
05-07-2015, 12:19 AM
Wow, Sophie just jumped from 2nd to last to 2nd since my last post. Nice to see Santalouco take the clear lead despite the frequent complaints about his change in turtle designs. Surprised to see Kevin in the bottom 2, but I guess he's done the least actual issues of IDW... EDIT: Just noticed Bobby Curnow voted for 'other,' playing it safe not picking favorites Bobby? :trazz:
shuriken
05-07-2015, 11:21 AM
Ross and Duncan are great. Duncan always reminds me of the beginning of the series. But Mateus is my fave thus far.
plastroncafe
05-07-2015, 11:23 AM
I try to get the Eastman covers, out of loyalty...but I honestly don't have a favorite. The art has all around been so solid I can't choose.
Wentos
05-08-2015, 03:09 AM
If I could pick two artists, it would be Mateus Santolouco and Cory Smith. Not only are they absolute masters of the form by themselves, but they complement each other beautifully. The Santolouco/Smith art rotation is the most aesthetically cohesive the book has been by FAR. They're a perfect match.
But if I have to pick one, it has to be Mateus Santolouco. Like Spengler said, the art for the book has never been outright bad, but History of the Foot Clan was on a completely different level. Only Cory Smith and Ben Bates even come close to matching his combination of dynamic layouts and attention to detail. The guy's a rock star.
joefsas
05-08-2015, 03:40 AM
Dan Duncan for me. I love his style.
Not a fan of Andy Kuhns take on the turtles. It might grow on me but....meh.
I can't vote for more than one sadly.
Santolouco, Campbell and Smith are all at the top.
Duncan did a great job to start things. Kuhn has really come to life on Mutanimals.
Candy Kappa
05-08-2015, 07:18 AM
Sophie Campbell is my absolute favorite, second would be shared by Mateus Santolouco and Ben Bates.
The Gunslinger
05-08-2015, 08:37 AM
Have to go with Dan Duncan because of the amazing job he put in on the first 5 issues. If only he could have continued to be consistent with the Turtles look instead of altering their head shapes and plastrons.
Cory Smith would be 2nd as his work is pretty consistent and really detailed.
Mateus 3rd only because he has slowly made the turtles look younger and younger. Nobody can deny this man's talent and attention to detail.
Sophie Campbell and Ben Bates tie for 4th. I haven't seen enough of Ben Bates to move him up the ranking but he has always been solid. Campbell's work on the Leo micro was unreal, but I felt that after that it never matched that same quality.
Cipher
05-08-2015, 12:37 PM
Campbell's work on the Leo micro was unreal, but I felt that after that it never matched that same quality.
I think that was a deliberate stylistic shift. Although maybe the slight difference in style was due to the Leo issue being a one-off assignment while the later style lends itself more to the expediency of a monthly book. She posts here from time to time, so maybe she can shed some light.
For what it's worth, I slightly prefer the "Northampton" style.
Re: thread: My favorite of the run has been Dan Duncan (the way he captures movement is crazy, and I love his way of drawing the Turtles), but everyone's been good.
senpai
05-08-2015, 03:31 PM
I honestly can't decide. I liked Dan Duncan's work, Mateus Santolouco, and Cory Smith.
Sophie Campbell
05-08-2015, 05:18 PM
I think that was a deliberate stylistic shift. Although maybe the slight difference in style was due to the Leo issue being a one-off assignment while the later style lends itself more to the expediency of a monthly book. She posts here from time to time, so maybe she can shed some light.
For what it's worth, I slightly prefer the "Northampton" style.
i'm glad you like my Northampton stuff, thanks so much!
the style changed for a few reasons, one being that Northampton was simply a couple years later than the Leo micro, so my work is going to be different, that's just how things go.
another reason is that the Leo issue was early on in the series and i didn't have as much freedom as i did on later comics, and also the issue was kind of rushed because there were a lot of approvals to go through which took forever and backed me up against a wall on the deadline. it was tough. not to mention i was working on Glory at the same time! i don't know how i ever did that, haha. on Northampton i had more time and freedom.
another reason is that the Leo issue and Northampton have a different tone, the micro is darker and grimier, and Northampton is about healing and togetherness. different tones should get different artwork that fits that. same with my Turtles in Time issue. if i ever come back to TMNT i want to do something darker, and i'll do yet another style shift. ;)
anyway, thanks to everyone who voted for me! i feel like i'm always coming in here and derailing threads, so feel free to carry on. :)
senpai
05-08-2015, 06:52 PM
So TMNT staff check the forums frequently? That is so cool! :D I feel like we're mingling with celebs, guys. :tlove: hehe
Toitlefan
05-08-2015, 07:18 PM
another reason is that the Leo issue and Northampton have a different tone, the micro is darker and grimier, and Northampton is about healing and togetherness. different tones should get different artwork that fits that. same with my Turtles in Time issue. if i ever come back to TMNT i want to do something darker, and i'll do yet another style shift. ;)
I bet if you had free reign to do something darker it would be awesome!
Thanks Sophie for giving us some behind-the-scenes insight, it means a lot to us fans.
Andy Kuhn has yet to get a vote. I thought he'd at least have a couple although he is probably my least favorite of the bunch. I'm sure Eastman would have more if he did full issues. Besides that, things are turning out about as I expected. Looking back, I should have made it a top 2-3 artist poll.
Mormegil
05-08-2015, 07:28 PM
That's the thing though. I really like all the art in this series. This thread just asked what your favorite was. Andy Kuhn has done some wonderful stuff and he's towards the top of the list.
ianke_2002
05-10-2015, 11:16 AM
Valerio Schiti DESERVES TO BE WORKING IN THIS UNIVERSE AGAIN!
PangolinFeets
05-10-2015, 12:54 PM
Valerio Schiti DESERVES TO BE WORKING IN THIS UNIVERSE AGAIN!
Yea, I loved his work on the Donatello micro. I hope we see him again.
There are a lot of artists I'd love to see do a cover or a guest issue. Like, I'd love a Jon Sommariva guest cover on the main series with his SY-esque turtles. And I'd love to see what Tradd Moore could come up with.
inksb
05-10-2015, 05:25 PM
Campbell get's my vote. She blew me away with the Leo micro and I was so happy to see her return on North Hampton which didn't disappoint. I haven't had a chance to see what she did on the Turtles in Time yet so I'm excited there.
Every one has their positive and negatives in my mind, but the original series did as well. At least with this run they are keeping it more consistent from artist to artist.
My only real complaint goes towards Santolouco, I really hate the way he draws the turtles faces. It bugs me to no end, why do they have this weird upturned snout. On the other hand I love his human characters and other mutants, it's just the turtles that bother me.
Sophie, thanks for stopping in and clearing that up, I always wondered myself.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.