PDA

View Full Version : Are you glad there aren't that many TMNT comics out there so you can experience it?


CyberCubed
05-17-2015, 11:19 PM
For example I've often considered getting into DC and Marvel, but I always stop because I get overwhelmed. There are what...10,000 Batman comics published from the 1930's till now? Hundreds of different Spiderman and X-men series? Tons of different continuities and retcons?

What I like about TMNT is we've only had 3 major comic continuities (Mirage, Archie and IDW), and all of them haven't gone on that long. Mirage may include 4 Volumes and Tales...but each volume is very short (Volume 2 only 13 issues, Volume 4 only 32 for example), and Archie has only a little over 100 comics.

IDW might shape up to be the longest lasting (and we're probably over 100 already with all the mini's and specials combined with the main run), but even then its manageable thanks to trades and everything being connected. I don't know how things will be 10 years from now, but I'm glad TMNT comics don't have thousands of issues to shift through.

Powder
05-17-2015, 11:45 PM
Yes. I am glad the brand is accessible & of a relatively consistent quality.

mrmaczaps
05-18-2015, 07:25 AM
As someone who reads a ton of comics, its really not that hard... I have every Superman/Flash/Green Lantern comic from about 1980 until now. The hard part is finding room to keep everything! I like the hunt for missing issues... I always enjoyed heading to shows with some cash and a list of what I wanted to find. Not too many shows like that today, and even less money to go around for purchases... And two decent sized bedrooms full of comics!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-18-2015, 08:32 AM
Absolutely. As an example, there have been a ton of Batman comics in the New 52 being published right now, but how many of them are worth reading?

Answer: how many are written by Scott Snyder? :tlol:

Duke Nukem
05-18-2015, 09:06 AM
Couldn't agree more, it's the reason I haven't gotten much into Marvel/DC. Way too much to catch up over the past 70-80 years and way too many coming out every month, all connected in some way. When I'm waiting in line on Wednesday to pick up my TMNT comics, I always see people paying $100+ for their comics and it seems like they do that every week. I couldn't keep up with that even if I wanted to.

Shark_Blade
05-18-2015, 09:25 AM
I have all issues on my ipad, very convenient indeed. No space, and easily accessible anywhere. God I love technology. :tlove: And yeah they're not overwhelmingly abundant like other comics, so it's nice and easy to play followup.

Toitlefan
05-18-2015, 09:36 AM
This is exactly one of the reasons I only buy TMNT comics. Every once in a awhile I will pick up a Batman, Wolverine or other random comic that looks interesting only to find I am way behind on the backstory and trying to catch up is far too daunting. I tell myself that I will start on a new collection after I get up to date with TMNT. I've been telling myself that for about 2 years now. If only IDW didn't release so many damn cover variations...

I am grateful for easily finding most of the original turtles comics. The only one that always seems elusive is #29 from vol 4. I'm starting to believe in its existence less than I believe in Sasquatch.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-18-2015, 09:39 AM
Not only is it easy to understand and read due to its limited scope, but it also means that the series has a point to it. It exists to follow an overarching story, to develop characters, and to try bold new things. (Or put bold new spins on things.)

CyberCubed
05-18-2015, 03:58 PM
The total Mirage run is only a little over 200 issues. Tales V. 2 had the most issues at a 70 issue run, but the others are so short. Volume 1 only 62 issues plus 4 micros, Volume 2 only 13, Image only 23, Volume 4 only 32, and Tales V. 1 only 7 issues.

There are a few specials and mini's but other than that there are just back-up shorts.

RatKingLeo
05-18-2015, 04:59 PM
I am very happy that I have been able to follow the TMNT story because of the lower amount of comics and great continuation of the stories. As a person who has gotten into comics only over the past few years I am extremely grateful for IDW. They are making it so easy for someone like me to read old mirage and archie stories without going crazy trying to track them all down.

I have been tempted to get into Marvel/DC stuff myself but like you say it seems to be a very daunting task to try to find the right place to start.

spookycookies
05-18-2015, 05:06 PM
I love how tightly woven the IDW story is and how each micro or mini has more or less furthered the plot, (with some exceptions.) However, at times I do feel like there are plenty of characters that don't get enough time to shine and I really wish that we had maybe 1 more book let some of these plots stretch their legs. The Purple Dragon's are a huge subplot but we only really see them through Casey or Angel's point of view. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has always had to balance out a street level crime saga along with an epic space adventure, and IDW has given us a very level field in making sure that the street stuff isn't too boring compared to the larger universe and the supernatural aspects of the story.

I love this compact story where every page matters but no matter how much of IDW's TMNT I get I'm always going to want more, more, more.

Shark_Blade
05-18-2015, 06:29 PM
The best thing about IDW is their characters treatment. For example, I can't stress enough how well done IDW Mikey is. He's badass, smart, doesnt make idiotic jokes, even Raph doesn't bully him - nope.. actually Mikey snapped and puts Raph in his place, TWICE! (One in Dark Leo saga, and one in Donnie's death saga) :o

That's just... Omigosh mind blown!!! I love this fearless Mikey!! :tlove:

spookycookies
05-18-2015, 07:50 PM
The best thing about IDW is their characters treatment. For example, I can't stress enough how well done IDW Mikey is. He's badass, smart, doesnt make idiotic jokes, even Raph doesn't bully him - nope.. actually Mikey snapped and puts Raph in his place, TWICE! (One in Dark Leo saga, and one in Donnie's death saga) :o

That's just... Omigosh mind blown!!! I love this fearless Mikey!! :tlove:

On the other side of that coin is Bludgeon, yeah he's only been around 9 or so months but we know next to nothing about him. Heck he didn't even meet the Turtles until FCBD and even then they didn't really acknowledge that he was new in town. All we are ever really told about Bludgeon is that he's loyal to Shredder and will protect him with his life, until he doesn't.

Just nitpicking of course he won't be as developed as an actual turtle but hopefully we don't have to wait more than a year to get some more solid info on this guy and what he's like.

oldmanwinters
05-18-2015, 08:47 PM
If anybody feels there aren't enough TMNT comics around, you can always start collecting the international releases. Between the United Kingdom (and its translations across Europe), Mexico, Japan, China, and Russia, there's quite a plethora of unique TMNT stories and adaptations. As far as quality control, however... well, that's up to an individual's sense of taste!

boywonder26
05-18-2015, 09:41 PM
I like the consistency with idws tmnt, that it flows and that there's not like 5 or 6 tie in issues to get the whole story.

Powder
05-18-2015, 11:34 PM
I like the consistency with idws tmnt, that it flows and that there's not like 5 or 6 tie in issues to get the whole story.

Isn't that totally not true at all given how many mini-series there are tying into the main narrative? Not that I'm complaining, I like it this way. Lots. :)

spookycookies
05-19-2015, 12:44 AM
Isn't that totally not true at all given how many mini-series there are tying into the main narrative? Not that I'm complaining, I like it this way. Lots. :)

Yeah imagine trying to read CityFall without ever even looking at SHotFC or Villians Micros... A 7 issue story bled into a nearly 20 issue event. We don't need this to happen every summer, but I love how these stories all build up and expand across so many different issues.

CyberCubed
05-19-2015, 05:36 PM
Well what's great about the way IDW is handling things is the trades come out not too long after the issues. So if someone is behind collecting issues of the mini's or specials, they can simply get the trades instead.

I also like it that the specials/mini's are all labeled and numbered competently, so you don't get confused if a comic is from a different series or continuity.

Powder
05-19-2015, 08:38 PM
Yeah, the trades are super easy to follow. Kinda wish I had gone that route but there's no way I can wait. :trazz:

neatoman
05-20-2015, 02:29 AM
So here's a question, won't the amount of TMNT comics just keep growing? IDW could very well keep the license for 20 years or even longer. If IDW does lose the license, some other publisher will just pick it up to make even more TMNT comics.

So if IDW does keep publishing TMNT comics for another 20 years and they stick to the "one regular issue, one mini-issue per month" format, they will end up with roughly 570 issues total. And what of other books? Wheter they last long or not, there almost seems to be some obligation to produce cartoon tie-in book.

Wentos
05-20-2015, 03:23 AM
My two favorite comic book properties are TMNT and Superman, so I definitely appreciate the benefits of a younger, less prolific comic franchise. I've made my peace with the fact that I'm never going to read every Superman comic, but with TMNT it's entirely possible.

The only thing that bugs me is how scattered the old Mirage material is. There's stuff like Turtle Soup, Plastron Cafe, and a whole host of other TMNT-related books that most people don't even remember, much less have read. And the fact that some TMNT stories were only printed once in a later printing of a given issue, or in a certain edition of a trade paperback? That kind of thing drives me nuts.

Duke Nukem
05-20-2015, 03:37 AM
Sure, 50 years from now, people could be saying, "It's great that comic X has a reasonable amount of issues, better than having to catch up on 80 years of TMNT or 130 years of Batman"

neatoman
05-20-2015, 04:46 AM
Sure, 50 years from now, people could be saying, "It's great that comic X has a reasonable amount of issues, better than having to catch up on 80 years of TMNT or 130 years of Batman"

Won't Batman have been public domain for 31 years by 2065? I wonder what kind of Batman comics we'll have when the character is no longer on DC's leash?

Duke Nukem
05-20-2015, 11:06 AM
Won't Batman have been public domain for 31 years by 2065? I wonder what kind of Batman comics we'll have when the character is no longer on DC's leash?

With Disney's strangehold over the US legislature, I doubt anything will ever enter the public domain again. Every time the copyright on Mickey Mouse is near expiration, copyrights get extended so that doesn't happen. The Supreme Court ruled that infinite copyright terms aren't allowed, but an infinite series of finite extensions are okay.

CyberCubed
05-20-2015, 12:32 PM
So here's a question, won't the amount of TMNT comics just keep growing? IDW could very well keep the license for 20 years or even longer. If IDW does lose the license, some other publisher will just pick it up to make even more TMNT comics.

So if IDW does keep publishing TMNT comics for another 20 years and they stick to the "one regular issue, one mini-issue per month" format, they will end up with roughly 570 issues total. And what of other books? Wheter they last long or not, there almost seems to be some obligation to produce cartoon tie-in book.

I can see IDW TMNT lasting about 10 years, then it being concluded. Also I'm not so sure Nick will license out the TMNT comics to anyone else immediately after, they'll probably drop the comic aspect of TMNT at that point.

neatoman
05-20-2015, 01:05 PM
I can see IDW TMNT lasting about 10 years, then it being concluded. Also I'm not so sure Nick will license out the TMNT comics to anyone else immediately after, they'll probably drop the comic aspect of TMNT at that point.

And why would Nickelodeon not want there to be TMNT comics after IDW's run? I don't really follow your logic here, comics tend to be so cheap to produce you can find a licensed comic for just about anything that used to be popular, even stuff that fell into obscurity decades ago. I don't understand why Nickelodeon would refuse the creation of new TMNT comics as long as TMNT is even remotely profitable.

ProphetofGanja
05-20-2015, 01:22 PM
I am really glad I jumped on this series when it was only 14 issues in or so. I may get around to reading the first four TMNT volumes but I don't feel its necessary to enjoy IDW'S TMNT series.

I've always loved Marvel properties, but reading their comics is rather daunting. Spider-Man and Fantastic Four have over 600 issues in their main continuities, not even including alternate universe mini-series and whatnot. There are some Marvel and DC characters I love but it almost feels like they're suffocating under the weight of their own mythology (Spider-Man, Fantastic Four, Dr. Strange, Guardians of the Galaxy, Deadpool, and then Batman, who's the only cool DC character even though he's basically a sociopath). Marvel NOW had some good runs for some characters but now they're all ending with this Secret Wars event.

I've definitely been reading more "indie" comics lately, Saga, Locke & Key, Samurai Jack, East of West, The Umbrella Academy, because they're easier to get into and the quality is top notch.

CyberCubed
05-20-2015, 03:35 PM
And why would Nickelodeon not want there to be TMNT comics after IDW's run? I don't really follow your logic here, comics tend to be so cheap to produce you can find a licensed comic for just about anything that used to be popular, even stuff that fell into obscurity decades ago. I don't understand why Nickelodeon would refuse the creation of new TMNT comics as long as TMNT is even remotely profitable.

The Nick cartoon will be over by then. I don't think Nick is going to bother having a comic licensed long after the cartoon is done. Remember Viacom makes most of their money off the cartoon and toy sales and merch, profit for the comics is split between IDW and Nick. I doubt Nick makes that much money off the comics.

neatoman
05-20-2015, 03:54 PM
The Nick cartoon will be over by then. I don't think Nick is going to bother having a comic licensed long after the cartoon is done. Remember Viacom makes most of their money off the cartoon and toy sales and merch, profit for the comics is split between IDW and Nick. I doubt Nick makes that much money off the comics.

The fact that He-Man hasn't had a cartoon in 11 years did not stop DC from publishing He-Man comics, the fact that Ghostbusters haven't had a cartoon for 18 years did not stop IDW from picking up the license, the fact that the recent Robocop movie didn't do that well did not prevent a recent Robocop comic. Edward Scissorhands had a comic recently, Edward ****ing Scissorhands.

So yeah, just because there isn't a recent cartoon or a movie in production does not mean a comic book series won't be considered profitable.

Groovy
05-20-2015, 04:30 PM
In general I'm more into indie comics than the big two publishers, for a lot of reasons. The constant crossover tie-in events that interrupt every series, the revolving door of creative teams that may not suit your taste, various publicity stunt style marketing etc. So I can see how it's easier to get into say Ninja Turtles. That said I do always enjoy some gems from Marvel and DC.

On the other hand, you don't need to read everything ever published on a character or series you like. :D Reading every turtle comic published would be quite the daunting task on it's own, even if I had the attention span to just focus on that one thing. It'd take quite a long time.

If we're just talking about the IDW run, this series actually has more tie-ins and extra mini-series related to it than many other books. It'd technically be easier to follow say Mark Waid's Daredevil run than IDW's TMNT at the moment, oddly enough.

Something like say Savage Dragon (who has crossed paths with the turtles) is an even more self-sufficient comic. It's just that one issue a month and there are no tie-ins or anything. Although granted there were some back in the 90s.

To answer the topic question, if we're looking at the total number of Turtle comics as how easy it is to experience it all, there are many many comics out there where it'd be easier to experience it all. But maybe I'm answering this a bit literally.

biganimefan
07-16-2015, 01:06 AM
I do like that Turtles currently has relatively few comics compared to say X-Men, Superman, or Batman. I absolutely love that IDW is releasing the comics in trades and have recently caught up with those. I've also thought of the idea of getting into the X-Men comic book franchise but haven't ever felt a real need to. The cartoons and movies are sufficient for my needs(I'll leave the 1000's of X-Men comic books to fans that actually care).



Also, I know that a lot of you probably don't, but to me Usagi Yojimbo is closely enough related to the TMNT franchise to count.

aliena
07-16-2015, 09:55 PM
Well what's great about the way IDW is handling things is the trades come out not too long after the issues. So if someone is behind collecting issues of the mini's or specials, they can simply get the trades instead.

I also like it that the specials/mini's are all labeled and numbered competently, so you don't get confused if a comic is from a different series or continuity.

This is precisely why I was able to catch up to the present so easily. I'm so glad they put them out so soon after the comics release. They make it easy to follow in order. I love that they care about that.

HotJuicyBurgers
07-17-2015, 09:51 AM
With Disney's strangehold over the US legislature, I doubt anything will ever enter the public domain again. Every time the copyright on Mickey Mouse is near expiration, copyrights get extended so that doesn't happen. The Supreme Court ruled that infinite copyright terms aren't allowed, but an infinite series of finite extensions are okay.

This always gets brought up as a bad thing, but should a company really lose their copyright if they are actively using it? I think properties in disuse should definitely eventually enter the public domain, but it would be weird for something like Mickey Mouse, or Spiderman to be public domain.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-17-2015, 10:07 AM
This always gets brought up as a bad thing, but should a company really lose their copyright if they are actively using it? I think properties in disuse should definitely eventually enter the public domain, but it would be weird for something like Mickey Mouse, or Spiderman to be public domain.

If creators continue to use their characters, or inherited characters, they absolutely should have that right. Public domain is for works such as Sherlock Holmes, Jules Verne, etc... old stuff.

This is precisely why I was able to catch up to the present so easily. I'm so glad they put them out so soon after the comics release. They make it easy to follow in order. I love that they care about that.

That's how I caught up; easy to acquire, too... I love that they are regularly reprinting all former TMNT material, too: Mirage, Archie, and (soon) Image. Some of that stuff is OBSCURE! Either that or EXPENSIVE.

If Bobby, Tom, or any of the IDW TMNT guys ever show up in Austin, I'll buy them all beers. Multiple beers. Like, so many beers. :tlol:

I do like that Turtles currently has relatively few comics compared to say X-Men, Superman, or Batman. I absolutely love that IDW is releasing the comics in trades and have recently caught up with those. I've also thought of the idea of getting into the X-Men comic book franchise but haven't ever felt a real need to. The cartoons and movies are sufficient for my needs(I'll leave the 1000's of X-Men comic books to fans that actually care).

Also, I know that a lot of you probably don't, but to me Usagi Yojimbo is closely enough related to the TMNT franchise to count.

That's pretty much how I feel. I don't do Marvel or DC comics, as I have the (sometimes) awesome movies and (sometimes) awesome shows for that. I was never an X-Man fan until First Class, which got me hooked on the whole film series, and now I'm enough of a fan (thank you, Wikipedia) to be pissed off at the poor handling of Storm, Cyclops, Rogue, et al. Sigh...

Duke Nukem
07-17-2015, 04:32 PM
This always gets brought up as a bad thing, but should a company really lose their copyright if they are actively using it? I think properties in disuse should definitely eventually enter the public domain, but it would be weird for something like Mickey Mouse, or Spiderman to be public domain.

Yes, they should. Having nearly a century of protection is more than enough. Also, "actively using" is not clear enough to be able to make a legal ruling. And even once a definition is established, they may be able to "actively use" their properties forever, which is unconstitutional.

From Article 1, Section 8 of the United States constitution:
To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.

It was in Eldred v. Ashcroft that allows Congress to keep extending the terms, but in my opinion they're already too long. Copyrights were meant to protect the authors, not to allow a company to profit indefinitely. Do you think E&L would have been put off from creating TMNT if they had thought at the time that their heirs would "only" have gotten rights for 20 years after their death instead of 50 or 70 years?

HotJuicyBurgers
07-17-2015, 05:19 PM
Yes, they should. Having nearly a century of protection is more than enough. Also, "actively using" is not clear enough to be able to make a legal ruling. And even once a definition is established, they may be able to "actively use" their properties forever, which is unconstitutional.

From Article 1, Section 8 of the United States constitution:
To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.

It was in Eldred v. Ashcroft that allows Congress to keep extending the terms, but in my opinion they're already too long. Copyrights were meant to protect the authors, not to allow a company to profit indefinitely. Do you think E&L would have been put off from creating TMNT if they had thought at the time that their heirs would "only" have gotten rights for 20 years after their death instead of 50 or 70 years?

Just because it was in the constitution does not make something de facto correct. Imagine if african americans were still considered 3/5 of a person? Honestly I'm a huge disney fan, so I don't think Mickey Mouse SHOULD fall into public domain.

And as for actively using, how much more active could a company be than disney and mickey mouse? He is the face of the entire company. Mickey Mouse appears at the front of every film they create, they have toys, and shirts and cartoons with the guy.

To put it a different way, how much time is enough protection? 5 years? 3 years? 1 year? Why do they need protection at all? If you create something why can't I just rip it off the day after?

Duke Nukem
07-17-2015, 06:56 PM
Just because it was in the constitution does not make something de facto correct. Imagine if african americans were still considered 3/5 of a person? Honestly I'm a huge disney fan, so I don't think Mickey Mouse SHOULD fall into public domain.

That's why the framers of the constitution recognized this and provided a way to amend it. It's always possible that there could be an amendment granting Congress the power to allow for perpetual copyrights, which I wouldn't be in favor of. Still, the constitution is the law of the land, and passing laws that blatantly violate the constitution sets an extremely bad and dangerous precedent.

And as for actively using, how much more active could a company be than disney and mickey mouse? He is the face of the entire company. Mickey Mouse appears at the front of every film they create, they have toys, and shirts and cartoons with the guy.

Sure, whatever definition you would use, Disney will probably meet, but it's extremely important that laws be clear, otherwise they become arbitrarily enforced. What if Mickey Mouse fell out of popularity in a few decades and they hardly use it as much?

To put it a different way, how much time is enough protection? 5 years? 3 years? 1 year? Why do they need protection at all? If you create something why can't I just rip it off the day after?

Well, everyone will have a different opinion on the exact length of time that works "should" have. Before the Sonny Bono act, life + 50 years for individuals and 75 years for corporations was even erring on the side of the creators. I don't think extending it was based on ethical considerations as much as Disney's financial contributions. And of course we all understand why it's important to have some type of copyright and patent system. If it were solely up to me, I'd say life + 20 years for individuals and 50 years for work for hire would be sufficient.

I think that Mickey Mouse should be in the public domain by now, since he was created almost a century ago, and if Disney still wanted to profit off of it, they should have to do so in a competitive market where they would need to create better content than their competitors, as well as having the exclusive rights to re-release all but the oldest Mickey Mouse films.

Edit: To clarify my position, I think the terms should be the shortest that wouldn't discourage any reasonable creators from creating their work, which is what their original purpose was.

sdp
07-18-2015, 08:54 PM
Isn't technically Vol.3 another universe? That one is hard to follow with all the image crossovers, is there even an archive of all the crossovers the turtles had?

What other comic series exist?

Dreamwave - Technically part of 2k3?

New TMNT Adv. - Technically part of Nick TMNT?

Mexican TMNT Adventures - TMNT Adventure inspired spin-off?

Manga - Technically part of the OVA continuity? Where there any original stories or just manga adaptations of a few episodes? I think I remember reading there were some original stories.

Am I missing any?

Powder
07-18-2015, 10:50 PM
No, Volume 3 is the same universe as Mirage.

neatoman
07-19-2015, 04:15 AM
No, Volume 3 is the same universe as Mirage.

Or at least it was until Peter Laird said otherwise.


Mexican TMNT Adventures - TMNT Adventure inspired spin-off?


Mexican TMNT comics? I'd like to see that.

sdp
07-19-2015, 11:12 AM
No, Volume 3 is the same universe as Mirage.
Officially it isn't. I know there was a fanmade comic with people who worked on V.3 to write a "bridge" but that's not official. It can be in continuity in our headcanon since it's meant to be the same universe but it's not.

Mexican TMNT comics? I'd like to see that.
From what I remember the early issues were just re-drawn versions of the TMNT Adventure comics but there were a few original stories here and there.

This always gets brought up as a bad thing, but should a company really lose their copyright if they are actively using it? I think properties in disuse should definitely eventually enter the public domain, but it would be weird for something like Mickey Mouse, or Spiderman to be public domain.

To put it a different way, how much time is enough protection? 5 years? 3 years? 1 year? Why do they need protection at all? If you create something why can't I just rip it off the day after?
Companies don't want to lose things, every time a property would hit public domain because of disuse they would just print a comic or make a low budget movie and release it quietly to keep the rights. This is why we got those terrible Marvel movies like Fantastic Four and Captain America that no one knew about in the 90s.

Yeah, the thought of another company using a property does seem odd. I mean yeah anyone being able to publish Superman comics you would think it might diminish the "brand". It's difficult for me to picture to see IPs be used by everyone who wants, I kind of picture all these terrible fanfictions now being somewhat legitimate or now we would have hundreds of different continuities to follow and what not. But look at it from the other side, DC has mishandled Superman for how many decades now? how many hundreds of continuities do we have just from DC comics? Now think about how many awesome interpretations that wouldn't make the cut at DC would be allowed to be movies or cartoons. The bad stuff just wouldn't be able to survive and we would only be getting top notch Superman content. This is an example with Superman but it works with pretty much every property.

When was the last time Disney even used Mickey Mouse as anything but a mascot? I can't recally any TV shows or movies being released outside some Christmas direct to video projects. Maybe other companies would be able to actually use the character. Hell Disney made its name by using Public Domain properties, if it weren't for the public domain then Disney as they are now wouldn't exist. Does Cinderella and the other stories being public domain really affect Disney? Anyone can make movies out of them, is it weird walking into Disneyworld and seeing all this "public domain" stuff? Of course not. Disney uses those characters in merchandising everywhere and yet other companies can do it too if they really wanted, it'd be the same with mickey.

Yes, there has to be a limit of years. Copyright was created so people could be assured that they wouldn't copy their ideas and they would be able to profit off of them and they wouldn't be stolen hence people would want to innovate knowing they'd be able to make money off of it. Of course companies don't die, so a company owning a creation is not fair. But yeah there has to be a limit if not it also hurts creativity, if no one else can use the idea of a man from krypton with superpowers then imagine if no one else could use the idea of a person who steals from the poor and gives to the rich because Robin Hood never became Public Domain. Not only that think about it with other things, how many of the things you use in your daily life were able to be created because patents were in the public domain, most of your technology and even affordable medicine. If you want to protect Copyright then I hope you can afford $100 for some flu pills because the patent never expired and only one company can make them and sell it for however long.

So yeah, Public Domain is a good thing and Disney won't be able to extend copyright much longer and even if they somehow were able to continue doing this in the US it doesn't matter since other countries won't play ball with them and allow the properties to be in public domain and in a globalized world that means Disney will eventually have to budge as well.

Powder
07-19-2015, 02:52 PM
Officially, it is. It was written into Mirage continuity, officially. That's factual. Pete discounting it a few years later means nothing to me.

CyberCubed
07-19-2015, 04:37 PM
Why do people even care what PL considers canon? He sold the franchise and can't even be bothered to finish Volume 4.

Danetello
07-29-2015, 09:20 AM
Officially, it is. It was written into Mirage continuity, officially. That's factual. Pete discounting it a few years later means nothing to me.

Why do people even care what PL considers canon? He sold the franchise and can't even be bothered to finish Volume 4.

Completely agree!

oldmanwinters
07-29-2015, 12:01 PM
Mexican TMNT Adventures - TMNT Adventure inspired spin-off?

I don't own any of the Division Comics, but by courtesy of the index on Demon-Alukard's site, I think it's clear that the series mixed some Archie TMNTA stories (redrawn by other artists for some reason I don't understand) with their own original stories. They apparently introduced a number of original recurring characters too during its later issues.

The Fleetway UK comics had a similar structure, mostly alternating Archie reprints with original stories (2 original comics per issue). The original stuff was probably far less ambitious than the Division Comics, as they pretty much stuck to generic Turtles vs. Shredder one-shot stories using the status quo cast of Turtles, April, Splinter, Shredder, Krang, Rocksteady, and Bebop with lots of Foot Soldiers and Mousers. I like them for the artwork and coloring. They all look nice to my eye.

The Fleetway stuff was reprinted across most of Europe.


Manga - Technically part of the OVA continuity? Where there any original stories or just manga adaptations of a few episodes? I think I remember reading there were some original stories.

Both! Dengeki Comics published 15 volumes adapting episodes from the first three seasons of the TV show (2 comics per volume), plus 1 bonus volume adapting the 3rd movie. Dengeki also published four original volumes: 3 building upon the OVA universe and 1 being a reimagining of the TMNT story. I think some of these comics initially ran in video game magazines before being collected into bound volumes.


Am I missing any?

There was a ton of unique stuff to come out of Japan. Comic Bom Bom released many short comics with a more humorous tone based on the Fred Wolf show's characters. CBB also did a re-vamp of the 3rd movie. Other Japanese book companies (Shogokukan, for instance) seemed to do semi-adaptations of episodes by adding some new twists to stories.

There has been tons of original and reprinted stuff in the Russian market... much of it with dubious legal status, I'm sure.

I'm still learning a lot about Chinese TMNT comics. Most of what I've seen so far has been TV episode adaptations or reprints of Mirage comics, but there may yet be some original material.

Besides the Division Comics, the Central and South American licenses are a mystery to me. There were definitely some other original stories put out in various book formats.

sdp
07-29-2015, 09:33 PM
Officially, it is. It was written into Mirage continuity, officially. That's factual. Pete discounting it a few years later means nothing to me.
Why do people even care what PL considers canon? He sold the franchise and can't even be bothered to finish Volume 4.
It had the background of the Mirage continuity like say TMNTA had the background of the OT but Pete did discount it, it may mean nothing to you but "officially" it is not canon since he was Mirage even if he sold it or didn't finish V.4, heck he still has the rights to publish new issues of Mirage continuity. Also in the anniversary book they had both an Image and Mirage story didn't it? so That book also considered them separate.

I don't own any of the Division Comics, but by courtesy of the index on Demon-Alukard's site, I think it's clear that the series mixed some Archie TMNTA stories (redrawn by other artists for some reason I don't understand) with their own original stories. They apparently introduced a number of original recurring characters too during its later issues.
I'm living in Mexico but trying to find these comics has been nearly impossible, the only times you ever see them are in mexcan online auction sites and they have random issues in terrible shape with outrageous prices, not because they're actually rare but because here the collectors market is f-cked up and they think anything that is old is automatically super valuable.

The Fleetway UK comics had a similar structure, mostly alternating Archie reprints with original stories (2 original comics per issue). The original stuff was probably far less ambitious than the Division Comics, as they pretty much stuck to generic Turtles vs. Shredder one-shot stories using the status quo cast of Turtles, April, Splinter, Shredder, Krang, Rocksteady, and Bebop with lots of Foot Soldiers and Mousers. I like them for the artwork and coloring. They all look nice to my eye.
That's really interesting, how come I never knew about this? Does no one care about this being reprinted? I'd love to read those stories...


Both! Dengeki Comics published 15 volumes adapting episodes from the first three seasons of the TV show (2 comics per volume), plus 1 bonus volume adapting the 3rd movie. Dengeki also published four original volumes: 3 building upon the OVA universe and 1 being a reimagining of the TMNT story. I think some of these comics initially ran in video game magazines before being collected into bound volumes.
There was a ton of unique stuff to come out of Japan. Comic Bom Bom released many short comics with a more humorous tone based on the Fred Wolf show's characters. CBB also did a re-vamp of the 3rd movie. Other Japanese book companies (Shogokukan, for instance) seemed to do semi-adaptations of episodes by adding some new twists to stories.

Wow, the Japanese stuff also all sounds amazingly interesting, even more so than the UK and Mexican stuff. Wish there was some way or interest in reprinting some of this stuff and translated. I guess TMNT comics really isn't as "easy" as Cybercubed speculated, it's just a different mess than DC and Maravel.

oldmanwinters
07-29-2015, 09:48 PM
Wow, the Japanese stuff also all sounds amazingly interesting, even more so than the UK and Mexican stuff. Wish there was some way or interest in reprinting some of this stuff and translated.

*Ahem*
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=35210

Powder
07-29-2015, 10:17 PM
It had the background of the Mirage continuity like say TMNTA had the background of the OT but Pete did discount it, it may mean nothing to you but "officially" it is not canon since he was Mirage even if he sold it or didn't finish V.4, heck he still has the rights to publish new issues of Mirage continuity. Also in the anniversary book they had both an Image and Mirage story didn't it? so That book also considered them separate.

No, it was literally written to be Mirage canon. It's not based on it, is IS it. That is what makes/made it official. Whether or not Pete went back on that doesn't change the original intention of the book or that one could fit it into continuity with ease to this day given the gap between it & Volume 4. He has dismissed & reneged on many things, if you go by what he says, half of the comics out there never happened, & that's no fun. Most fans consider just about everything done under the Mirage/Image banner as one solid timeline, & so do I. As for the 30th anniversary book, it simply treats the Image run as just that, a run done by a different publisher. There is no mention whatsoever about it's place in history/canon. Wouldn't matter to me if it did, as I don't think I'd consider IDW to be an authority on what came before them, nor would I expect them to make that sort of call knowing the way our fanbase operates.