PDA

View Full Version : A cartoon based on the comic?


Yabuturtle
05-23-2015, 03:56 PM
I actually find it strange they still haven't really done that yet. Of course there's the 1987 one, the 2003 one and the 2012 one, but none of them are actually like the comic, in terms of grittiness and violence. They've taken pieces of the comic and put it in other shows and I like all 3 shows but would anyone like to see a cartoon based entirely on the comic? The closet adaptation I can think of was the 1990 Turtles movie which actually did base a lot of stuff in the comic, although not as violent and a few things were changed.

neatoman
05-23-2015, 04:31 PM
If you're talking about a cartoon that would depict the Turtles stabbing Shredder in the chest and blowing him up, that's not going to happen. Your best bet is a direct to DVD movie in (at least) ten years (if at all). There is that little problem that cartoons are largely seen as children's material, there is a niche market for violent animation but Viacom might not consider it profitable enough.


When tackling the structure, trying to adapt the comic in an accurate fashion would probably be a bad idea in general. You'd end up with a climactic battle in the first episode, the third episode would be dedicated to car chase and the fifth would send the main characters to space. You can get away with this sort of weird structure in a comic because it's originally published as a series of pamphlets that last several decades, but in a TV show it will end up looking like a weird uneven mix of serialised and episodic storytelling.

There is plenty of issues to adapt but if they didn't move stuff around, alter it and add scenes, then you'd end up with a show that starts out jumping around in setting, plot archetypes and the timeline. As a comic series it's fine, but as a TV show it would be a cluster****. Trust me, if you put together a crew out of people unfamiliar with TMNT to produce the next cartoon, and you gave them the comics and demanded they write as little new material as possible, you'd still end up with major alterations.

CyberCubed
05-23-2015, 04:36 PM
I would love to see the IDW comic adapted into a cartoon. Maybe years later after it ends. Seeing it done in animation just as it is would be great

Commenter 42
05-23-2015, 04:42 PM
This is the closest they've ever come, aside from Turtles Forever

http://i.imgur.com/fSMGl6Y.png

neatoman
05-23-2015, 04:48 PM
This is the closest they've ever come, aside from Turtles Forever

http://i.imgur.com/fSMGl6Y.png

Where does that come from?

Jester
05-23-2015, 04:52 PM
It's the WB series pitch:
Re89WZhbGSA

neatoman
05-23-2015, 05:03 PM
It's the WB series pitch:
Re89WZhbGSA

Never seen that before, can't tell if it would have been good or bad though.

ProphetofGanja
05-23-2015, 05:24 PM
I would love to see the IDW comic adapted into a cartoon. Maybe years later after it ends. Seeing it done in animation just as it is would be great

I think the IDW series would work perfectly adapted as a limited anime series, like a ten or 12 episode season based off of either the first few or middle few story arcs For example since in IDW's run Raph was separated from them at first it may be better to first do the "middle years" of IDW, like when they encounter Slash or something. I know if they did a show based on IDW I'd want to see the four bros together

ChosenOne
05-23-2015, 05:27 PM
I think the IDW series would work perfectly adapted as a limited anime series, like a ten or 12 episode season based off of either the first few or middle few story arcs For example since in IDW's run Raph was separated from them at first it may be better to first do the "middle years" of IDW, like when they encounter Slash or something. I know if they did a show based on IDW I'd want to see the four bros together

I'm pretty sure each 4-issue arc could fit into a single 30 minute episode, or a two-parter at the very most, so that wouldn't be much of a problem.

Yabuturtle
05-23-2015, 09:13 PM
If you're talking about a cartoon that would depict the Turtles stabbing Shredder in the chest and blowing him up, that's not going to happen. Your best bet is a direct to DVD movie in (at least) ten years (if at all). There is that little problem that cartoons are largely seen as children's material, there is a niche market for violent animation but Viacom might not consider it profitable enough.


When tackling the structure, trying to adapt the comic in an accurate fashion would probably be a bad idea in general. You'd end up with a climactic battle in the first episode, the third episode would be dedicated to car chase and the fifth would send the main characters to space. You can get away with this sort of weird structure in a comic because it's originally published as a series of pamphlets that last several decades, but in a TV show it will end up looking like a weird uneven mix of serialised and episodic storytelling.

There is plenty of issues to adapt but if they didn't move stuff around, alter it and add scenes, then you'd end up with a show that starts out jumping around in setting, plot archetypes and the timeline. As a comic series it's fine, but as a TV show it would be a cluster****. Trust me, if you put together a crew out of people unfamiliar with TMNT to produce the next cartoon, and you gave them the comics and demanded they write as little new material as possible, you'd still end up with major alterations.

I don't see how it couldn't be done. We are in the generation where cartoons aren't just for kids anymore. They've done it with super heroes like with Batman and Superman as well as some Marvel movies that added more adult material. If they could do it, I don't see why the Turtles couldn't do it. Especially since TMNT was never intended for kids to begin with. It was marketed for kids later on, but it was always adult. In Turtles Forever they showed the original comic versions which I thought was cool. Just picture that but imagine it in a series or at least a dvd movie of it.

But to me the only real alteration I'd make would be keeping the personalities of say, the 2003 version of the Turtles, like Don being the brains, Raph the angry guy, Mikey the goofball ect. to distinguish them AND I'd give them their own colored masks. I personally like the different colored masks as not only do I think it's better for them to have their own color but it would be so much easier to tell them apart. Because in the comics it was black and white and on the covers they all had red masks. You'd have no way of telling who's who unless you looked at their weapons. So really, just imagine the 2003 version but with more violence, adult themes and grittier style.

You don't have to base it on each individual comic issue as they could make their own adventures but still keep their style. That way it won't look so disorientating.

TigerClaw
05-23-2015, 09:32 PM
I actually find it strange they still haven't really done that yet. Of course there's the 1987 one, the 2003 one and the 2012 one, but none of them are actually like the comic, in terms of grittiness and violence. They've taken pieces of the comic and put it in other shows and I like all 3 shows but would anyone like to see a cartoon based entirely on the comic? The closet adaptation I can think of was the 1990 Turtles movie which actually did base a lot of stuff in the comic, although not as violent and a few things were changed.
a literal adaption of the comic would never work, Because, The comics were never made to be adapted as a series or movie, So they have to take some liberties in order to make it work as a cartoon.

And one of the biggest changes was the colored Bandanas, They all wear Red bandanas in the comics originally, But it was the decision of the studio to give them different colors.

After that, It all became standard for them to have different colors.

Yabuturtle
05-23-2015, 09:38 PM
a literal adaption of the comic would never work, Because, The comics were never made to be adapted as a series or movie, So they have to take some liberties in order to make it work as a cartoon.

And one of the biggest changes was the colored Bandanas, They all wear Red bandanas in the comics originally, But it was the decision of the studio to give them different colors.

After that, It all became standard for them to have different colors.

I'm confused. The 1990 movie was based on the comic. It was more so than the 1987 cartoon of course, since it has cussing, more violence and it's story line was a lot closer to the comic, but it obviously has some changes. They managed to do it so I don't see how making a cartoon is implausible. If you want, you don't have to base it entirely on the comic issues and write it word for word and scene for scene. The adventures could be different, but still have the same comic style.

I'm glad they had their own bandanas as I think all of them wearing red seemed kind of unoriginal and wearing colored bandanas makes it much easier to tell who's who.

TigerClaw
05-23-2015, 09:51 PM
I'm confused. The 1990 movie was based on the comic. It was more so than the 1987 cartoon of course, since it has cussing, more violence and it's story line was a lot closer to the comic, but it obviously has some changes. They managed to do it so I don't see how making a cartoon is implausible. If you want, you don't have to base it entirely on the comic issues and write it word for word and scene for scene. The adventures could be different, but still have the same comic style.

I'm glad they had their own bandanas as I think all of them wearing red seemed kind of unoriginal and wearing colored bandanas makes it much easier to tell who's who.
My favorite TMNT comics were the Archies series, TMNT Adventures, Which was a loose adaption of the 80s cartoon, Only going in a different direction.

That comic was better then the actual cartoon in my opinion, the way they handled Mondo Gecko in that, was better then what they did in the actual cartoon.

Coola Yagami
05-23-2015, 10:53 PM
Never seen that before, can't tell if it would have been good or bad though.

Now I'm curious as to how this series would have turned out.

But no, design aside, that was still nothing like the comic unless I missed that issue.

CyberCubed
05-23-2015, 11:48 PM
That KidsWB pitch was made after the failed CG pitch from 2001 (the one with the CG clips), and WB turned this down too.

Considering we got the 4kids series in 2003, Mirage went with the best choice of the 3.

Duke Nukem
05-23-2015, 11:53 PM
a literal adaption of the comic would never work, Because, The comics were never made to be adapted as a series or movie, So they have to take some liberties in order to make it work as a cartoon.

And one of the biggest changes was the colored Bandanas, They all wear Red bandanas in the comics originally, But it was the decision of the studio to give them different colors.

After that, It all became standard for them to have different colors.

I'm pretty sure the decision was made by Playmates, as well as the different shades of green skin colors, since it would be hard to get kids to buy all 4 different turtle toys that all look the same.

I don't think the comic (Mirage or IDW) should be a gold standard for a TV show/film adaptation to follow exactly. As mentioned, some things work well in one medium and not the other. I think the 2k3 series struck a good balance there (in the first few seasons). That said, I would like a more adult oriented TMNT show, maybe something appropriate for older teens as far as the level of violence and cursing. It wouldn't have to follow the comics any more strictly than 2k3, but it would be a good place to start. Of course, this will never happen.

Technogeek29
05-23-2015, 11:56 PM
Oh I remember that little teaser. I like Raph's voice in this short not so much tough sounding as it is snarky.

Panda_Kahn_fan
05-24-2015, 12:44 AM
I'm pretty sure each 4-issue arc could fit into a single 30 minute episode, or a two-parter at the very most, so that wouldn't be much of a problem.

Here's a way to divide up the IDW series into one season of episodes for an anime series. Relevant scenes, flashbacks, micro series stories and plot points can be moved around into various episodes where they are relevant to the plot, or they are needed chronoogically.

Episode 1: Looking for raph, turtles vs old hob. Origin/Casey jones.
Episode 2: Saki vs Yoshi; Flashbacks to feudal japan
Episode 3: Alopex introduction, Bebop and Rocksteady intro
Episode 4: Michelangelo costume party
Episode 5: Donny meets Dr. Harold Lyja
Episode 6: Turtles vs. eldritch abominations
Episode 7: Turtles vs. Mousers, Splinter kidnapped
episode 8: Leo's first fight with the foot
episode 9: Raid on stockgen, Splinter taken by the foot.
episode 10:Battle with foot and the shredder, splinter rescued
episode 11: Casey's story with father, Splinter adopts him into the 'family'
episode 12: Savate Ninja focused story, fight over the briefcase with the money.
episode 13: April steals mutagen, frees Slash. Slash's rampage and the TMNT's battle with him.
episode 14: Krang war, part one- fugitoid story in flashbacks
episode 15: Krang War, part two- neutrinoes, Dimension x
episode 16: Secret History of the foot clan, part one
episode 17: Secret history of the foot clan, part two
episode 18:Krang solo episode, utrom/krang back story told
episode 19: Cityfall, part one
episode 20: Cityfall, part two
episode 21: Northampton
episode 22: First Meeting with Renet
episode 23: Hun and the Purple dragons vs. Casey, Metalhead/April/Donnie/Harold subplot
episode 24: Leo and Splinter meet the Rat King, Shreddder/Krang alliance attempt and battle subplot
episode 25: Turtles in Time, part one
episode 26: Turtles in time, part two
episode 27: Turtles in Time, Part three
episode 28: Turtles in Time, part four
episode 29:New Mutant Order, part one- intro of the mutanimals, slash gets treatment to make him sane.
episode 30: New Mutant order, part two-vs rocksteady and bebop
episode 31: Attack on the Technodrome, part one
episode 32: Attack on the Technodrome, part two
episode 33: Mutanimals, part one- team solo adventure
episode 34: Mutanimals, part two- battle with null
episode 35: Final battle with Shredder, part one
episode 36: Final Battle with Shredder, part two

CyberCubed
05-24-2015, 01:49 AM
I wonder if IDW can make a deal with Nick to make an animated version of the comics and release it straight to DVD or something. It would be rated PG-13 because that's what IDW's comic is with the blood and cursing in some of the issues.

Duke Nukem
05-24-2015, 10:21 AM
I wonder if IDW can make a deal with Nick to make an animated version of the comics and release it straight to DVD or something. It would be rated PG-13 because that's what IDW's comic is with the blood and cursing in some of the issues.

Well, IDW is not an animation studio, so that would be a problem there. Certainly someone would be able to adapt the comic, but they wouldn't do it literally for the reasons mentioned already. I don't think the PG-13 rating would be a huge problem, since the Bay film was PG-13 for turtle dick jokes, but the level of violence might be. I guess the best we could hope for (even though it's a huge long shot) would be a TMNT Netflix series similar to Daredevil in tone.

TigerClaw
05-24-2015, 10:26 AM
Well, IDW is not an animation studio, so that would be a problem there. Certainly someone would be able to adapt the comic, but they wouldn't do it literally for the reasons mentioned already. I don't think the PG-13 rating would be a huge problem, since the Bay film was PG-13 for turtle dick jokes, but the level of violence might be. I guess the best we could hope for (even though it's a huge long shot) would be a TMNT Netflix series similar to Daredevil in tone.
That all depends if Nickelodeon would allow it, Since they are the owners of the IP, And they wouldn't want a series that would compete against there own.

stayunspoiled
05-24-2015, 07:23 PM
The best thing in my opinion would be multiple movies or series the same as the current DC animated movies. DC have tackled some pretty dark material and it just works.

Sabacooza
05-24-2015, 08:42 PM
The best thing in my opinion would be multiple movies or series the same as the current DC animated movies. DC have tackled some pretty dark material and it just works.This would be sweet for us fans that prefer the comics over the show. It would be nice to have a meatier direct to DVD series or movies to bite into. This would be perfect as some kind of detailed looking anime possibly mimicking Santolouco's style. Man, that would be a sight to behold.

Duke Nukem
05-25-2015, 05:07 AM
I'd be even more in favor of a live action series. Just because Next Mutation wasn't good doesn't mean it can't work if done right. I'm looking forward to the Punisher series next year, since Daredevil was good, I think the same idea could work with TMNT. But of course they'd never do that in the foreseeable future while the Nick show is still going.

Plasticplayhouse
05-25-2015, 07:51 AM
i'd love to see an IDW based cartoon/live action show/movie for sure! i think it would hold up very well.

Panda_Kahn_fan
05-25-2015, 08:46 AM
That all depends if Nickelodeon would allow it, Since they are the owners of the IP, And they wouldn't want a series that would compete against there own.

NOT NECESSARILY- a DTV series of movies or an anime is a possibility, DC does that with some of their properties.

Duke Nukem
05-25-2015, 12:42 PM
NOT NECESSARILY- a DTV series of movies or an anime is a possibility, DC does that with some of their properties.

In the history of TMNT, there have never been two simultaneous TV series, either cartoon or live action, so I'm thinking at the very least it couldn't happen until Nick TMNT cartoon's popularity wanes.

Yabuturtle
06-06-2015, 10:52 PM
In the history of TMNT, there have never been two simultaneous TV series, either cartoon or live action, so I'm thinking at the very least it couldn't happen until Nick TMNT cartoon's popularity wanes.

This is how I would want this adaptation to look like. I'd like the Turtles to basically look the same as they did in the 1987 toon except not have pupils when they wear their face masks. I personally think they are way too tall in the 2003 version and tmnt 2014 movie. I would want Leonardo to be voiced by Cam Clarke, Donatello by Rob Paulsen, Michelangelo by Townsend Coleman and Raphael to be voiced by Greg Abbey of the 2003 version.