PDA

View Full Version : Would anyone be interested in discussing "classic" TMNT books?


HotJuicyBurgers
06-24-2015, 05:12 PM
I've seen this done before in other places but I was wondering if anyone here would be interested in doing maybe a weekly discussion of the original mirage run?

I bet a ton of people haven't read some of these books in a while, and I thought it might be interesting to look at them and discuss them in a fresh new light. Like as if these books were coming out nowadays and we could discuss them on here like we do the new IDW series. Obviously for this to work we'd need at least a few people or else it would just be me talking to myself. (Nothing interesting)

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-24-2015, 07:00 PM
I'm game. I've got the three TPBs for Volume 2 coming in the mail tomorrow, so yeah, good timing. And I do have MOST of what I consider my personal canon for Volume 1. (Still need The River and Sons of the Silent Age)

I will say though that ever since IDW, I have a REALLY hard time getting back into the Mirage TMNT. At least the original run of #1-11 and Return to New York.

HotJuicyBurgers
06-25-2015, 09:05 AM
I will say though that ever since IDW, I have a REALLY hard time getting back into the Mirage TMNT. At least the original run of #1-11 and Return to New York.

Any reason why? I recently read through issue 3 after pulling it out yesterday and it was just as awesome.

Also doesn't seem like too many people are interested. 100 views and just your comment :tlol:

Mew
06-25-2015, 09:40 AM
LET'S DO THIS!!!!!!
Mirage is the original and best TMNT!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 10:07 AM
Any reason why? I recently read through issue 3 after pulling it out yesterday and it was just as awesome.

Also doesn't seem like too many people are interested. 100 views and just your comment :tlol:

A few (totally nitpicky) reasons:


The art is REALLY not my style until around, I dunno, the Leo Micro-Issue and the Foot ambush at the antique store

Return to New York is just pretty much action all the way through, with not enough character moments compared to other great action stories in TMNT. However, I think RtNY is THE single best Leo/Raph rivalry story EVER. It feels true to both characters, while letting them both grow. And what's awesome is that they're BOTH right.

The stories (mainly Issues #1-3 and Raphael #1) feel really dated to me. I prefer more modern takes.


Now, let me be clear: I love Mirage TMNT and still love these stories. But when I feel like reading a TMNT story, I stare at my shelf for a minute, then feel guilty and grab an IDW volume or the City at War storyarc. :tlol:

HotJuicyBurgers
06-25-2015, 10:10 AM
A few (totally nitpicky) reasons:


The art is REALLY not my style until around, I dunno, the Leo Micro-Issue and the Foot ambush at the antique store

Return to New York is just pretty much action all the way through, with not enough character moments compared to other great action stories in TMNT. However, I think RtNY is THE single best Leo/Raph rivalry story EVER. It feels true to both characters, while letting them both grow. And what's awesome is that they're BOTH right.

The stories (mainly Issues #1-3 and Raphael #1) feel really dated to me. I prefer more modern takes.


Now, let me be clear: I love Mirage TMNT and still love these stories. But when I feel like reading a TMNT story, I stare at my shelf for a minute, then feel guilty and grab an IDW volume or the City at War storyarc. :tlol:

Awesome points to bring up in the discussion thread :twink:

And I agree to an extant. While I love the books, in the discussions I'm going to try and be a little critical in order to try and appreciate the books from a different light

Mormegil
06-25-2015, 12:20 PM
I'm reading through the mirage material for the first time. I started out with the IDW comic and couldn't pass up those B&W ultimate editions.

I think the Leo micro might have been my favorite so far.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 04:06 PM
I'm reading through the mirage material for the first time. I started out with the IDW comic and couldn't pass up those B&W ultimate editions.

I think the Leo micro might have been my favorite so far.

Oh friend... you have no idea of the treasure in store for you.

Ultimate Vol 4 and 5 are THE ABSOLUTE PINNACLE of any version of TMNT EVER. It is, quite simply, supreme. And amazeballs.

Mew
06-25-2015, 05:05 PM
I like the Leo micro. It was good.

plastroncafe
06-25-2015, 05:10 PM
I'm always up for talking Mirage, though...I give the fair warning:

I love the Dale Evans McGuillicutty stuff.

CyberCubed
06-25-2015, 05:19 PM
Didn't we have a Mirage thread like this a few months ago? There was some discussion but then the thread died because nobody knew what to talk about.

HotJuicyBurgers
06-25-2015, 05:30 PM
Didn't we have a Mirage thread like this a few months ago? There was some discussion but then the thread died because nobody knew what to talk about.

I was on break from the forums for a while so I didn't see them, but if not knowing what to say was an issue, I wouldn't be opposed to thinking up questions once a week about the book we will be discussing.

Would anyone be opposed to that? Of course anything could be discussed but we could fall back on those questions.

I'm always up for talking Mirage, though...I give the fair warning:

I love the Dale Evans McGuillicutty stuff.

The more the merrier!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 06:03 PM
Didn't we have a Mirage thread like this a few months ago? There was some discussion but then the thread died because nobody knew what to talk about.

Must've been before I was rejoined the 'Drome. I will talk about the stories and characters I love until people sincerely threaten bodily harm to me. :tlol:

I'm always up for talking Mirage, though...I give the fair warning:

I love the Dale Evans McGuillicutty stuff.

Remind me which issues those are? Please tell me it's not the time-travel trilogy stuff... or the weird Raph/aliens/cow trilogy. :teek::tlol:

Duke Nukem
06-25-2015, 06:14 PM
Remind me which issues those are? Please tell me it's not the time-travel trilogy stuff... or the weird Raph/aliens/cow trilogy. :teek::tlol:

It is indeed Mark Martin's trilogy (#16, #22, #23). I liked the first one and thought the second two sucked.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 06:19 PM
It is indeed Mark Martin's trilogy (#16, #22, #23). I liked the first one and thought the second two sucked.

I'm always up for talking Mirage, though...I give the fair warning:

I love the Dale Evans McGuillicutty stuff.

... :teek:

Oh well, just don't defend Roach-April in Volume 4 and we're good. Agree to disagree. :tlol:

ctt4lfecw
06-25-2015, 07:11 PM
A few (totally nitpicky) reasons:


The art is REALLY not my style until around, I dunno, the Leo Micro-Issue and the Foot ambush at the antique store

Return to New York is just pretty much action all the way through, with not enough character moments compared to other great action stories in TMNT. However, I think RtNY is THE single best Leo/Raph rivalry story EVER. It feels true to both characters, while letting them both grow. And what's awesome is that they're BOTH right.

The stories (mainly Issues #1-3 and Raphael #1) feel really dated to me. I prefer more modern takes.


Now, let me be clear: I love Mirage TMNT and still love these stories. But when I feel like reading a TMNT story, I stare at my shelf for a minute, then feel guilty and grab an IDW volume or the City at War storyarc. :tlol:

Me too man. There's nothing like the Mirage source material. But IDW I feel gives me everything I'd ever want in TMNT.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 07:28 PM
Me too man. There's nothing like the Mirage source material. But IDW I feel gives me everything I'd ever want in TMNT.

Agreed.

It doesn't really surprise me because IDW gets to stand on the shoulder of giants. It has hindsight; it can look back and see, "people really love Bebop and Rocksteady, but we can make them much more than just bumbling goofy cartoon characters!" or "Image comics really shocked readers by killing Donatello and resurrecting him... let's try a new take on that!"

IDW gets to cherry-pick all of the best of TMNT, and then weave it into an awesome new setting and framework. And plus, now that TMNT is a major brand, it doesn't have to limp along for years at a time when, say, Eastman and Laird let whoever the heck do whatever the heck they wanted with the Turtles. (Yes, I'm looking at YOU, Volume 1 Guest Era. If you were a person, you'd be on medication for bipolar disorder!" :tlol:

But then, of course, IDW also doesn't get the luxury of telling a TMNT story aimed at adults. They had to market themselves to ALL TMNT fans, including kids. Which means that, as awesome as IDW is, we will never get the dark, moody, morally ambiguous stories like Mirage's "City at War" or "Sons of the Silent Age." IDW will always be "safer." Which isn't a problem... but for the REALLY stellar TMNT, you gotta go Mirage.

And for reliable consistent awesomeness in every single issue, IDW, of course. :twink:

Powder
06-25-2015, 07:30 PM
I'm into this, but not if we're going in order. I've been sporadically revisiting Mirage comics in the last few weeks & I'd like to keep it that way. If we can do voting on standalone issues or something, I'm game. Otherwise I'm just gonna keep going at my own pace.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 08:01 PM
I'm into this, but not if we're going in order. I've been sporadically revisiting Mirage comics in the last few weeks & I'd like to keep it that way. If we can do voting on standalone issues or something, I'm game. Otherwise I'm just gonna keep going at my own pace.

Personally, I think it'd get a little chaotic if we just randomly bounced around. I like going in order. But we could discuss one issue or one story arc a week.

Like, discuss all three issues of "Return to New York" one week. Or dicuss all seven "Tales of the TMNT Volume 1" in one week. Issue #1 definitely deserves one week all to itself... and break City at War into, I dunno, three weeks' worth, discussing 3-4 issues a week.

How does that sound?

Powder
06-25-2015, 08:05 PM
How does that sound?

Like not the thing I said, so count me out. :lol: I don't see what's chaotic about each thread having a poll to pick the next issue when there are tons of accessible standalone books.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 08:15 PM
Like not the thing I said, so count me out. :lol: I don't see what's chaotic about each thread having a poll to pick the next issue when there are tons of accessible standalone books.

Sorry, dude! :tlol:

I'm not running the show on this one, and I wouldn't want to exclude anyone who might be otherwise interested. It doesn't sound like there's gonna be that many of us yet anyway. From #1 or jumping around, whatever. Either way, I'm excited.

(One point of jumping around is we can TOTALLY keep overlooking the Guest Era until PlastronCafe calls us out on it!) :tlol:

Powder
06-25-2015, 08:20 PM
The guest era is some of the best stuff, though...

plastroncafe
06-25-2015, 08:36 PM
... :teek:

Oh well, just don't defend Roach-April in Volume 4 and we're good. Agree to disagree. :tlol:

The hills that I'm willing to die on with regards to Volume 4 are few and far between, fear not.

I just...love me some camp now and again, and the Martin trilogy are nothing but camp.

Mayhaps we could do a series of posts for certain issues, and people can join in as they are feeling saucy about it?

Duke Nukem
06-25-2015, 08:37 PM
But then, of course, IDW also doesn't get the luxury of telling a TMNT story aimed at adults. They had to market themselves to ALL TMNT fans, including kids. Which means that, as awesome as IDW is, we will never get the dark, moody, morally ambiguous stories like Mirage's "City at War" or "Sons of the Silent Age." IDW will always be "safer." Which isn't a problem... but for the REALLY stellar TMNT, you gotta go Mirage.

You'll really like Odyssey if you haven't read it yet. It avoids the problem of having to be thematically appropriate for kids in a way that IDW has to do.

I like a lot of the guest era Mirage. Soul's Winter and Hall of Lost Legends are among the best of Mirage Vol. 1. Many of the rest is at least good if not great. I'd put the River trilogy and a few others in that category. Of course there's bad ones as well, like Sky Highway and Spaced Out.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-25-2015, 08:43 PM
The guest era is some of the best stuff, though...

And some of the worst. But I really should stop saying this; in my mind, I only see the Guest Era as the bad part of the Guest Era, and the good parts of the Guest Era (Sons of the Silent Age, The River, et al) are part of the Volume 1 canon. But that's unclear and technically incorrect, so I should be more accurate in my statements. :trazz:

You'll really like Odyssey if you haven't read it yet. It avoids the problem of having to be thematically appropriate for kids in a way that IDW has to do.

I like a lot of the guest era Mirage. Soul's Winter and Hall of Lost Legends are among the best of Mirage Vol. 1. Many of the rest is at least good if not great. I'd put the River trilogy and a few others in that category. Of course there's bad ones as well, like Sky Highway and Spaced Out.

I haven't read Odyssey yet... probably should get around to acquiring myself a copy, as soon as I have funds. I just got my copies of Color Classics Volumes 7-10 in the mail today, so I'm done for this month at least. :tlol:


The hills that I'm willing to die on with regards to Volume 4 are few and far between, fear not.

I just...love me some camp now and again, and the Martin trilogy are nothing but camp.

Mayhaps we could do a series of posts for certain issues, and people can join in as they are feeling saucy about it?

I can't wait to get started! Lead us, HotJuicyBurgers, that we may follow and discuss! :tlol:

ctt4lfecw
06-25-2015, 09:07 PM
Agreed.

It doesn't really surprise me because IDW gets to stand on the shoulder of giants. It has hindsight; it can look back and see, "people really love Bebop and Rocksteady, but we can make them much more than just bumbling goofy cartoon characters!" or "Image comics really shocked readers by killing Donatello and resurrecting him... let's try a new take on that!"

IDW gets to cherry-pick all of the best of TMNT, and then weave it into an awesome new setting and framework. And plus, now that TMNT is a major brand, it doesn't have to limp along for years at a time when, say, Eastman and Laird let whoever the heck do whatever the heck they wanted with the Turtles. (Yes, I'm looking at YOU, Volume 1 Guest Era. If you were a person, you'd be on medication for bipolar disorder!" :tlol:

But then, of course, IDW also doesn't get the luxury of telling a TMNT story aimed at adults. They had to market themselves to ALL TMNT fans, including kids. Which means that, as awesome as IDW is, we will never get the dark, moody, morally ambiguous stories like Mirage's "City at War" or "Sons of the Silent Age." IDW will always be "safer." Which isn't a problem... but for the REALLY stellar TMNT, you gotta go Mirage.

And for reliable consistent awesomeness in every single issue, IDW, of course. :twink:

But I think IDW has done a great job of catering to the older crowd. There's a lot of examples I could point out, but they're there. As long as Viacom/Nick just keep things the way they are and just let IDW do whatever they want. Keep the comic separate from the Nick show(even though I love the Nick show) The comic is its own thing for us to enjoy.

ctt4lfecw
06-25-2015, 09:10 PM
You'll really like Odyssey if you haven't read it yet. It avoids the problem of having to be thematically appropriate for kids in a way that IDW has to do.

I like a lot of the guest era Mirage. Soul's Winter and Hall of Lost Legends are among the best of Mirage Vol. 1. Many of the rest is at least good if not great. I'd put the River trilogy and a few others in that category. Of course there's bad ones as well, like Sky Highway and Spaced Out.

Woah, you read Odyssey? You got an English copy from Andrew? Or is this the Russian version off ebay?

Powder
06-25-2015, 09:20 PM
He's not the only one. :trazz:

Duke Nukem
06-25-2015, 09:22 PM
Woah, you read Odyssey? You got an English copy from Andrew? Or is this the Russian version off ebay?

It's the hardcover one from eBay, printed in Russia. But they're English language, so no worries there, and it's well worth it. My Russian isn't really good enough to read a comic book anyway without missing important details.

ctt4lfecw
06-25-2015, 10:11 PM
It's the hardcover one from eBay, printed in Russia. But they're English language, so no worries there, and it's well worth it. My Russian isn't really good enough to read a comic book anyway without missing important details.

You're so lucky. I'll admit I am getting a little restless waiting for my copy that I pre-ordered. I don't know if it will ever come out.

HotJuicyBurgers
06-25-2015, 10:28 PM
Ok ok ok. I'll consider this enough participation :tlol:

Why don't we throw out some ideas for what books we should read? My first thought was going to be to just go in order 1 book at a time, but it might be a bit slow that way. I wouldn't mind doing a couple of books at a time.

I don't think we should just skip books that people consider bad either. If you never see anything bad you don't have perspective for the good.

So I'm going to propose a couple of sets of books, and then any more people want just shout them out here, and maybe we can try and get a consensus on what to do. After the first one I'll try and throw a poll up with the discussion to decide the next discussion.

Mirage 1-4
RTNY
Reading the 4 original micros and comparing them

Any other suggestions?

Mechapod
06-25-2015, 11:26 PM
Count me interested in this idea. Either with a sequential read/discussion or jumping around, I am excited.

I'm nearly complete with my collection of the first vol.; missing only 9 books yet, but I've got most all the key issues. And a couple I am missing I've got the IDW reprints until I acquire the originals.

plastroncafe
06-25-2015, 11:34 PM
Lead us, HotJuicyBurgers, that we may follow and discuss! :tlol:

I'm sorry...but this right here?
Is the best sentence I've read all night.

Well played, both of you.
Well played.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-26-2015, 09:13 AM
But I think IDW has done a great job of catering to the older crowd. There's a lot of examples I could point out, but they're there. As long as Viacom/Nick just keep things the way they are and just let IDW do whatever they want. Keep the comic separate from the Nick show(even though I love the Nick show) The comic is its own thing for us to enjoy.

Well, IDW has admitted that Nick has put their oar into the water on at least two occasions. When they were toying with the idea of Saki being Leo's biological father (there's a thread on here somewhere for that...) and also Dark Leo not being able to kill (although I believe all Bobby said was along the lines of "if we'd been allowed to have Dark Leo kill someone, we would have").

And I definitely agree that IDW has done a GREAT job in being accessible and marketed to everyone. But they will never be able to do a full-on depressing gray story arc like "CaW" or "SotSA". Which is okay; nobody's ever gonna top those stories anyway.

Ok ok ok. I'll consider this enough participation :tlol:

Why don't we throw out some ideas for what books we should read? My first thought was going to be to just go in order 1 book at a time, but it might be a bit slow that way. I wouldn't mind doing a couple of books at a time.

I don't think we should just skip books that people consider bad either. If you never see anything bad you don't have perspective for the good.

So I'm going to propose a couple of sets of books, and then any more people want just shout them out here, and maybe we can try and get a consensus on what to do. After the first one I'll try and throw a poll up with the discussion to decide the next discussion.

Mirage 1-4
RTNY
Reading the 4 original micros and comparing them

Any other suggestions?

TMNT Volume 1, Issue #1

I would honestly have no idea where else to start. But wherever it is, I promise to have an opinion. :trazz:

HotJuicyBurgers
06-26-2015, 03:57 PM
I think right now, it's gonna be best if we just discuss the first book, I'll let the thread run for a week, and I'll throw a poll in that thread in order to decide what the next set of books will be.

Even if you don't want to discuss the first book at least pop your head in to vote powder. I'll be sure to throw in some guest era books

Powder
06-26-2015, 04:24 PM
Sure thing. I haven't read the first issue in a while anyway, maybe I will do so. :)

Duke Nukem
06-26-2015, 09:05 PM
I'm down, going to re-read it now for the million and first time. I'm assuming by first book, you mean only Vol. 1 #1, and not the collection of the first few issues?

Cipher
06-27-2015, 03:05 PM
Oh friend... you have no idea of the treasure in store for you.

Ultimate Vol 4 and 5 are THE ABSOLUTE PINNACLE of any version of TMNT EVER. It is, quite simply, supreme. And amazeballs.
There's no guilt in grabbing "City at War" over any other part of Mirage. That's where the series really grows into itself. I still tell new readers to start there; night and day difference. One of the best stories ever told using (by that point somewhat) commercial characters.

I'm always up for talking Mirage, though...I give the fair warning:

I love the Dale Evans McGuillicutty stuff.
Dale Evans McGuillicutty is boss. #16 is a great issue.

ctt4lfecw
06-27-2015, 08:00 PM
There's no guilt in grabbing "City at War" over any other part of Mirage. That's where the series really grows into itself. I still tell new readers to start there; night and day difference. One of the best stories ever told using (by that point somewhat) commercial characters.


Dale Evans McGuillicutty is boss. #16 is a great issue.

^
Maybe it's because it confuses the hell out of me, but I can't say #16 is on my all time favorite list. To me it's kind of just there. I read it twice and I still don't get it.

TMNachoT
07-15-2015, 02:04 PM
I like Mirage, lets talk about it!