PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Classic Book Discussion (Issue 1)


HotJuicyBurgers
06-26-2015, 09:05 PM
Here we are at the first classic book discussion. If I do something wrong, don't hesitate to scream at me. :tlol:

One of the complaints I heard was that often time people had a hard time thinking of things to talk about, so with that in mind, I'm going to put forth some questions for people to talk about if they so choose. Feel free to also talk about anything that comes your mind.

-What did you think of the book in terms of character development? Did you think that all of the turtles had distinct personalities? Did you think of them as fleshed out characters by the end of the book?

-Is Splinter any better than shredder in this case? Shredder may have murdered Splinter's master, but he was only taking his revenge. Just as Splinter did. Is Shredder even a "bad guy?"

-Why does the guy on page 21 look kind of like Kevin?

Also, please remember to vote in the poll above to decide what books we discuss next time!

Duke Nukem
06-26-2015, 09:18 PM
I don't think the individual turtles were too distinct from each other in this.

Splinter definitely _is_ a much better person than Shredder here. He's taking revenge for the right reasons. Shredder took revenge because his brother was killed out of justifiable anger while trying to perform a rape/murder. Splinter wants revenge because his "family" was murdered in cold blood.

I think the guard looks like Kevin for the same reason April looked like his wife, because he enjoys the publicity. He also had a cameo in the 1990 TMNT movie, when Laird turned it down because he's more of a private person than Kevin.

For the next book discussion, I nominate the often overlooked and underrated Fugitoid #1.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-26-2015, 10:01 PM
I find it hilarious how blatantly Eastman and Laird ripped off the Daredevil comics. Evil ninja clan, the wise mentor, the blind man nearly getting hit by a truck and a young man saving him only to get hit in the face by a cannister...

It's so cool how Daredevil and the Turtles share the same origin, in a way. Wouldn't it be so freaking cool if we could once, just once, get a limited crossover series with Daredevil and the Turtles?

And as far as personalities or character development, only Raph gets any. Leo, Mike, and Don are just fighting, but with Raph, we get to see a little of what makes him tick... a loner attitude, a desire to live above the streets. I don't see any of them as fleshed out characters except Raph and Splinter.

And as far as Splinter? Can you imagine if your pet dog or cat or hamster grew up to avenge your murder? That's a pretty damn loyal pet... I could see it with a dog, but if Splinter had been a cat? Sucks to have been you, the cat will move on. :tlol:

I don't see Splinter or Shredder as anymore evil than each other, honestly; we're coming into the cycle of vengeance and bloodshed after it's already started. Oroku Nagi, not Saki, is the true villain of the TMNT universe. He begins a cycle of vengeance and hatred, is killed, and then is forgotten. But Saki remembers, and only knows that Hamato Yoshi killed his older brother. And so the vengeance continues, and Splinter then takes the place of the avenger. And this cycle of vengeance continues ALL THROUGHOUT the Mirage continuity: Oroku Nagi, Tang Shen and Hamato Yoshi, Splinter and Oroku Saki, the Turtles, the Shredder Elite Guard, Oroku Pimiko and Tang Amaya...

It's beautiful in its bleakness. I can't think of another similar cycle of vengeance in fiction that is so far-reaching and compelling. :tcool:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-26-2015, 10:02 PM
I personally nominate TMNT Volume 1 Issues #2-4 next, 'cause I'm a sucker for chronological order. But I also voted for Return to New York, 'cause I've got me some thoughts on that there issue! :tlol:

HotJuicyBurgers
06-26-2015, 10:03 PM
I don't think the individual turtles were too distinct from each other in this.

Splinter definitely _is_ a much better person than Shredder here. He's taking revenge for the right reasons. Shredder took revenge because his brother was killed out of justifiable anger while trying to perform a rape/murder. Splinter wants revenge because his "family" was murdered in cold blood.

I think the guard looks like Kevin for the same reason April looked like his wife, because he enjoys the publicity. He also had a cameo in the 1990 TMNT movie, when Laird turned it down because he's more of a private person than Kevin.

For the next book discussion, I nominate the often overlooked and underrated Fugitoid #1.

The 4 turtles did have some characterization. Mostly Leo and Raph though. Raph gets "alone" time during this issue, and you can start to see the idea of him being a hothead coming to form. Of course, Leo is the leader and commands, but during the fight with shredder lands the first major blow, pointing a bit to his possible increased skill

How is Splinter a better person? He raised 4 impressionable youngsters with the sole purpose being to murder another person. And yes, his master was defending another person, but was the murder really necessary? Surely a severe beating would have been enough no?

That third question was a bit of a joke, I honestly never actually knew if it was supposed to be him or not lol

I'll definitely throw Fugitoid in the poll next week.

I personally nominate TMNT Volume 1 Issues #2-4 next, 'cause I'm a sucker for chronological order. But I also voted for Return to New York, 'cause I've got me some thoughts on that there issue! :tlol:

And 2-4

Cylon, you bring up an awesome point about the cycle of vengeance. It really is this vicious cycle that moves the story on at points, and the originators of it all aren't even alive at any point in TMNT history.

Duke Nukem
06-26-2015, 10:40 PM
How is Splinter a better person? He raised 4 impressionable youngsters with the sole purpose being to murder another person. And yes, his master was defending another person, but was the murder really necessary? Surely a severe beating would have been enough no?

Sure, but it's a fine line between a severe beating and a fatal one, particularly when in a rage. Maybe a ninja master like Yoshi would be able to easily stop short of killing, but it would be hard for most people in the midst of such a fight to know when to stop. Besides, many of us have known people like Oroku Nagi, and they don't change for the better, and Tang Shen would have likely still been killed by Nagi if he had remained alive. I could easily see myself either losing my temper the way Yoshi did, or straight up committing premeditated murder under those circumstances.

Maybe Shredder's actions were justifiable as well, if he wasn't told about his brother's true nature and grew up believing that Yoshi had killed his brother in cold blood, and decided to show him firsthand what the pain of losing family is all about, before killing him.

I guess maybe Splinter isn't much better than Shredder as far as vengeance goes, but Yoshi definitely was. If you look at the bigger picture, though, Shredder ran a branch of a major criminal organization for personal gain while Splinter was raising his adopted family. I'm sure Splinter used his ninja skills to steal as well, but only because it was necessary to allow him and his family to survive, since he couldn't work and the necessities of life don't all float down the sewer. You shouldn't really make furniture out of turds, used condoms, and tampons.

I give him a pass for raising his turtle children the way he did as well. As a pet rat, Yoshi probably fit somewhere between a father and a god in his life, so losing him the way he did pretty much redefined his personality. Since Splinter had little contact with the outside world, he didn't have much perspective to change his viewpoint over the 13 years of training them to kill Shredder. Most parents try to indoctrinate their children with morals and ethics as they see them, from religious fanatics to police officers to regular working people, and Splinter was no different in this regard.

Mechapod
06-27-2015, 10:07 AM
I recall the first time I read this story. As a 12 year old kid, when I turned the first page and saw the 2 page spread of the turtles launching into attack, I was hooked.

How is Splinter a better person? He raised 4 impressionable youngsters with the sole purpose being to murder another person. And yes, his master was defending another person, but was the murder really necessary?

Not quite a sole purpose though; Splinter had waited 13 years to tell the turtles why they were trained as ninja. These skills are probably far more useful for survival in NYC than just kickin some butt. Also he realized and said that what he asks, no one should ever ask of another.

As a pet rat, Yoshi probably fit somewhere between a father and a god in his life, so losing him the way he did pretty much redefined his personality

This is a good point, and further, Splinter roamed the streets for two years before coming in contact with the ooze and then mutating. While raising his adopted family, he was also having to come to terms with his own changes.

Is Shredder even a "bad guy?"

Absolutely. Even though he was manipulated by the foot as a child, when he came to the US as an adult, he expanded the Foot operations from assassination to include drug and arms running.

-EDIT-
I voted for Sky Highway, as I've not yet read it. But After thinking about it more, I would rather have voted for the TMNT micros to focus on the individual turtles. Which then could lead into the Triceraton battle arena arc #4-#5 and also Fugitoid. Just an idea, though I am good with whatever # is chosen next.

Cipher
06-27-2015, 02:56 PM
I give him a pass for raising his turtle children the way he did as well. As a pet rat, Yoshi probably fit somewhere between a father and a god in his life, so losing him the way he did pretty much redefined his personality. Since Splinter had little contact with the outside world, he didn't have much perspective to change his viewpoint over the 13 years of training them to kill Shredder. Most parents try to indoctrinate their children with morals and ethics as they see them, from religious fanatics to police officers to regular working people, and Splinter was no different in this regard.
This is actually something that comes up in Splinter's arc in "City at War," and it's cool to see people acknowledge it here. He's a pet rat. He has little understanding of the outside world, however much he'd like to. He may not even really know Yoshi in the way he thinks he does. He takes on the burden of human ideals and vengeance instead of simply trying to survive, and it -- long-term, over the course of the series as written by several creators -- dooms his family and everyone around them, even if they find moments of beauty along the way. The Mirage Turtles are walking timebombs of sorrow and destruction, but it all starts with Splinter taking up a feud that isn't really his.

Which isn't to say that Shredder isn't justifiably presented as the villain in this issue; he is. But his backstory with Nagi and particularly the mention that higher-ups in the Foot Clan channeled his hatred plants the seeds early for the headier vengeance plots, which is really remarkable for a tongue-in-cheek one-off, or maybe just fortuitous.

And to move away from where the series ultimately goes, the first issue is very much tongue-in-cheek from its overt Daredevil pastiches, to its request that the reader embrace easy, Hollywood-style ninja tropes, including the vengeance plot at its center. Raph and Leo, as mentioned above, begin to display their personalities here, though Mike and Don largely remain ciphers until the next issue (Don) and even later (Mike). I don't have a ton to say about it as a one-shot other than that it's full of energy, and the excitement of the creators (and their skill here) helps it leap off the page. It's a pastiche, but it's never cynical about what's doing. Though I ultimately prefer where the series ends up going and how it repurposes this issue for more somber plots, everything here is memorable and fun and it's easy to see why it caught the attention of both the underground comics market and toyline executives, as crazy as that sounds.

I vote we talk more questionable Splinter ethics and move on to Soul's Winter next.

HotJuicyBurgers
06-28-2015, 07:41 AM
And to move away from where the series ultimately goes, the first issue is very much tongue-in-cheek from its overt Daredevil pastiches, to its request that the reader embrace easy, Hollywood-style ninja tropes, including the vengeance plot at its center. Raph and Leo, as mentioned above, begin to display their personalities here, though Mike and Don largely remain ciphers until the next issue (Don) and even later (Mike). I don't have a ton to say about it as a one-shot other than that it's full of energy, and the excitement of the creators (and their skill here) helps it leap off the page. It's a pastiche, but it's never cynical about what's doing. Though I ultimately prefer where the series ends up going and how it repurposes this issue for more somber plots, everything here is memorable and fun and it's easy to see why it caught the attention of both the underground comics market and toyline executives, as crazy as that sounds.


I always thought it was interesting that a book that was clearly designed as a 1 and done parody grew to be what it is today. I mean, even if Kevin or Peter had never stated it, the book is a very well done self contained story that could have just stood alone forever.
The action is very high pace in this issue, and it's such a fun issue all around it doesn't come as a surprise that something here clicked with people.

DrSolarMOTA
06-29-2015, 05:42 PM
It's funny that you started this thread now, as I just started re-reading my Ultimate Collection Volume 1 the other day.

I might be speaking a bit (all right, a lot) through rose-colored glasses. I started reading Mirage TMNT with the First Graphic Novels back in 88-89, but once I found the original phone book in the early 90's, and saw the art in black-and-white, it was clear to me that that was the way the art was meant to be presented. I love, LOVE the Eastman/Laird combined working style. It's very different from each of them individually. Kind of like the sum is greater than the parts. Sure, it's crude in the first issue, but to watch it progress and culminate in the Leo Micro, and issues 10-11, is just awesome.

As for the story itself, I've read it so many times over the years, but I never get tired of it. I haden't put oo much thought into it before, but in my opinion, Splinter's motive is purely to defend his master's honor. Hamato Yoshi defended himself and his woman. He was then punished by his clan, and accepted his fate: banishment. To a life-long clansman, that would have been a fate worse than death, but he accepted it and took his woman to start a new life.

If Oroku Saki had truly been a member of the foot clan the way that Yoshi was, than he too would have understood that Yoshi's fate was worse than death, but he choose to disobey the clan rules, and tracked down Yoshi on his own. Splinter, not a member of the Foot, chose to enact revenge as well. Was he stooping down to Shredder's level? No, he never had the connection to the Foot that Yoshi had.

I'm pretty sure that Kevin and Peter didn't put too much thought in the morals of the story when writing the issue. Kevin and Peter have stated numerous times that this work was an homage to Frank Miller (note all the Ronin and Miller references throughout the first several issues). Splinter's name itself if a parody of Stick's, from Daredevil.

Moving on, I do have one question regarding their origin: has anyone ever heard an explanation regarding the inconsistent time references during Splinter's origin tale? Is it just that K&P didn't put too much thought into that aspect either? Or just a simple typo somewhere along the lines?

As for the characterization, of the turtles themselves, I agree with previous posts that only Leo and Raph get the briefest glimpses of personalities. Don's doesn't come out until issues 2 and 4, and Mike's not until a bit after that.

Sorry for the long rant, but the first 11 issues, along with the Raph and Leo micros are some of my favorite comics of all time.

I'd love to continue discussing the issues in order, for at least the first 11 issues before jumping around. Eventually, there should just be a thread for each issue, then as new readers find the Mirage issues for the first time, they can add to the discussion over time. These threads should be timeless.

-Greg

Cipher
06-29-2015, 06:54 PM
Splinter's motive is purely to defend his master's honor.
Right, but he doesn't need to do that. It's definitely in keeping with the pastiche elements of the first issue to not question it in a morally complicated way, but when the series does decide to go that route much later on, he comes up against the idea that it may have been more noble to eschew the trappings of human honor (which do nothing but bring pain to the Turtles and those around them throughout the series) and to simply survive and find purpose in doing so. Or at least that's the thrust of his arc with the Rat King in "City at War," and it's paralleled in the Turtles', April's and Casey's arcs as well.

Oroku Saki doesn't need to seek vengeance either, of course, but that works out even worse for him and the New York Foot that it does for the Turtles.

Fenryr
07-01-2015, 08:37 AM
So, ...

+ Characterization

There are a few spare moments of characterization for all four Turtles, but how much of that is me reading into what's there with knowledge of what comes later and how much of it was actually there, I don't know.

Leonardo is the easiest. He's the field leader, and a lot more of a gritty narrator here than he'll ever really be again. That's about it. He's Cyclops.

Raphael loves to fight, which we are first told, then shown, repeatedly, climaxing when he attacks The Shredder by himself. He also hates being cooped up and is given the mission to deliver the challenge to Oroku Saki in the first place, so either Leonardo or Splinter (or both) are aware that Raphael needs his alone time, prefers to spend that alone time exercising and/or busting heads, and are making the most of it. He's Wolverine.

The other two are a little more subtle.

To my memory, Donatello was often the one in the '87 cartoon to throw out proclamations that "this [was] the end" for Shredder, and he's the one to do it here, too. He's quick to underestimate the villain, but he also delivers the final blow, knocking Saki and the grenade off the roof. Even though all of them just eviscerated about a dozen ninjas, looking back, it feels distinctly like Donatello's first step towards morally grey.

Meanwhile, all three of Michelangelo's moments depict him as the youngest, and maybe simplest, of the four. He's obedient to their father, bowing to him when they return home after fighting the Purple Dragons, though a little boastful about their victory, and when all is said and done, he breaks the heavy silence of Saki's death with "I'm tired." Sounds like a little kid to me.

+ The Timeline

Holy crap. What a mess.

Twenty years prior to the events of TMNT #1, Hamato Yoshi kills Oroku Nagi while defending Tang Shen. Oroku Saki, Nagi's brother, is seven, and Splinter, as a mature rat, is probably about one year old, though he could be two or three. All of this is, ... 1964.

Fifteen years prior to the events of TMNT #1, Yoshi and Tang Shen are murdered in New York by Oroku Saki, now calling himself The Shredder. Oroku Saki is nineteen, having been made leader of the New York branch of The Foot at eighteen, and expanding their business for at least one year into drugs and arms. That's in, ... 1969?

Saki aged twelve years in five years? And Splinter must be almost eight. Or is he fifteen? And even if you made Oroku Saki fourteen when his brother was killed, rats still don't live to be eight years old. Most live about two. So, none of this really works.

The compromise of the '90 film, where Oroku Saki is the one competing with Hamato Yoshi, lusting after Tang Shen, and killing her and Yoshi when he can't have her, is incredibly effective, plus, the bit with Splinter scarring Saki's face (NOT HUN'S!), and Saki slicing off one of Splinter's ears is pretty great. But, the whole ordeal feels more complete when Oroku Saki has a legitimate beef with an organization behind him and Yoshi's had time to settle in and build a life to tragically lose.

Man. Now that I've sat down and done the math, this is gonna bug me forever.

+ Vengeance/Revenge

Cannonically, Daredevil and the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles share the same origin. Jessica Jones has ties to the same (or a similar) TCRI truck, too, for that matter. But even though Splinter's name is a parody of Stick's, and The Foot are a parody of The Hand, Splinter is actually more like Professor X than Daredevil's mentor.

Professor X perpetuates a cycle of hatred towards mutant-kind by funding a para-military squad of aesthetically-pleasing mutants and being a genuine creep about it for the past fifty years. Splinter perpetuates a cycle of vengeance by focusing his entire life, and the lives of the Turtles, on the murder of Oroku Saki who murdered Hamato Yoshi for the murder of Oroku Nagi who murdered Tang Shen.

That theme of violence begetting violence is pervasive in the Mirage comics, starting here fully-formed and self-contained, and getting stronger with each new iteration of The Foot, or The Shredder, or Karai, or the Purple Dragons, etc, etc. Splinter does get a little better about all that eventually, but in the first issue, the major difference between him and Shredder is that Shredder sought revenge for his brother's death, while Splinter sought vengeance for his master's death. Without noble intent, and even with it, sometimes, the TMNT are no better than their enemies.

+ Etc.

- WHAT DID SPLINTER TELL THE TURTLES THEY WERE TRAINING FOR IF NOT VENGEANCE?

- HOW DOES SPLINTER RECONCILE HAMATO YOSHI BEING AN ASSASSIN AND FORMER FOOT NINJA?

- HOW DID OROKU SAKI COME BY THE TITLE OF THE SHREDDER?

- HOW DOES SPLINTER EVEN KNOW OROKU SAKI'S LIFE STORY?

- WHAT HAPPENED TO THE DOJO HAMATO YOSHI STARTED BEFORE HE WAS KILLED?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2015, 08:56 AM
So, ...

+ Characterization

There are a few spare moments of characterization for all four Turtles, but how much of that is me reading into what's there with knowledge of what comes later and how much of it was actually there, I don't know.

Leonardo is the easiest. He's the field leader, and a lot more of a gritty narrator here than he'll ever really be again. That's about it. He's Cyclops.

Raphael loves to fight, which we are first told, then shown, repeatedly, climaxing when he attacks The Shredder by himself. He also hates being cooped up and is given the mission to deliver the challenge to Oroku Saki in the first place, so either Leonardo or Splinter (or both) are aware that Raphael needs his alone time, prefers to spend that alone time exercising and/or busting heads, and are making the most of it. He's Wolverine.

The other two are a little more subtle.

To my memory, Donatello was often the one in the '87 cartoon to throw out proclamations that "this [was] the end" for Shredder, and he's the one to do it here, too. He's quick to underestimate the villain, but he also delivers the final blow, knocking Saki and the grenade off the roof. Even though all of them just eviscerated about a dozen ninjas, looking back, it feels distinctly like Donatello's first step towards morally grey.

Meanwhile, all three of Michelangelo's moments depict him as the youngest, and maybe simplest, of the four. He's obedient to their father, bowing to him when they return home after fighting the Purple Dragons, though a little boastful about their victory, and when all is said and done, he breaks the heavy silence of Saki's death with "I'm tired." Sounds like a little kid to me.

+ The Timeline

Holy crap. What a mess.

Twenty years prior to the events of TMNT #1, Hamato Yoshi kills Oroku Nagi while defending Tang Shen. Oroku Saki, Nagi's brother, is seven, and Splinter, as a mature rat, is probably about one year old, though he could be two or three. All of this is, ... 1964.

Fifteen years prior to the events of TMNT #1, Yoshi and Tang Shen are murdered in New York by Oroku Saki, now calling himself The Shredder. Oroku Saki is nineteen, having been made leader of the New York branch of The Foot at eighteen, and expanding their business for at least one year into drugs and arms. That's in, ... 1969?

Saki aged twelve years in five years? And Splinter must be almost eight. Or is he fifteen? And even if you made Oroku Saki fourteen when his brother was killed, rats still don't live to be eight years old. Most live about two. So, none of this really works.

The compromise of the '90 film, where Oroku Saki is the one competing with Hamato Yoshi, lusting after Tang Shen, and killing her and Yoshi when he can't have her, is incredibly effective, plus, the bit with Splinter scarring Saki's face (NOT HUN'S!), and Saki slicing off one of Splinter's ears is pretty great. But, the whole ordeal feels more complete when Oroku Saki has a legitimate beef with an organization behind him and Yoshi's had time to settle in and build a life to tragically lose.

Man. Now that I've sat down and done the math, this is gonna bug me forever.

+ Vengeance/Revenge

Cannonically, Daredevil and the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles share the same origin. Jessica Jones has ties to the same (or a similar) TCRI truck, too, for that matter. But even though Splinter's name is a parody of Stick's, and The Foot are a parody of The Hand, Splinter is actually more like Professor X than Daredevil's mentor.

Professor X perpetuates a cycle of hatred towards mutant-kind by funding a para-military squad of aesthetically-pleasing mutants and being a genuine creep about it for the past fifty years. Splinter perpetuates a cycle of vengeance by focusing his entire life, and the lives of the Turtles, on the murder of Oroku Saki who murdered Hamato Yoshi for the murder of Oroku Nagi who murdered Tang Shen.

That theme of violence begetting violence is pervasive in the Mirage comics, starting here fully-formed and self-contained, and getting stronger with each new iteration of The Foot, or The Shredder, or Karai, or the Purple Dragons, etc, etc. Splinter does get a little better about all that eventually, but in the first issue, the major difference between him and Shredder is that Shredder sought revenge for his brother's death, while Splinter sought vengeance for his master's death. Without noble intent, and even with it, sometimes, the TMNT are no better than their enemies.

+ Etc.

- WHAT DID SPLINTER TELL THE TURTLES THEY WERE TRAINING FOR IF NOT VENGEANCE?

- HOW DOES SPLINTER RECONCILE HAMATO YOSHI BEING AN ASSASSIN AND FORMER FOOT NINJA?

- HOW DID OROKU SAKI COME BY THE TITLE OF THE SHREDDER?

- HOW DOES SPLINTER EVEN KNOW OROKU SAKI'S LIFE STORY?

- WHAT HAPPENED TO THE DOJO HAMATO YOSHI STARTED BEFORE HE WAS KILLED?

I don't really agree with your point regarding Donatello, 'cause I think that's reading into it a little much, but I'm certainly not going to hold it against you.

And looking back, Mikey's "I'm tired" is quite in character for him.

I think Splinter could very easily tell the Turtles that they're training to be like shadows because that is their life, trapped in the shadows and below a world that will never accept them. To survive, they must be quick, silent, and invisible.

I don't see why Splinter has to reconcile Yoshi's past; Splinter spent probably half of his normal lifespan as a normal rat, with a simpler view on things and an animalistic attachment to his owner. When Splinter mutated, he gained new perspective possibly, new intelligence, but I don't see any reason for him to grow beyond what defined him for so long; a pet. This could also explain a lot of what Splinter goes through in City at War... he's seen that the "simple" life of an animal has perpetuated the violence, but in reality, he must embrace his animal nature as well as his mutated human nature.

And for simplicity's sake, he was a pet who loved his master, no matter what. To him it made sense to avenge his slain master to honor him.

As for Saki becoming the Shredder, I like the way 4Kids framed his identity; Oroku Saki can't be seen bossing around a bunch of assassins and thieves, because he has a civilian identity to protect. Similarly, he wants to strike fear into the hearts of his enemies. Thus, a badass suit of blades and an alter ego.

HotJuicyBurgers
07-01-2015, 09:00 AM
Holy ****. Member for 11 years and this thread makes you post for the first time. Kind of honored

You make a lot of great points about the similarities between TMNT and x-men, and it is a bit of a compelling argument. Splinter is even similar to Xavier in the sense that over time they seem to soften a bit if I am understanding correctly (not a big x-men buff)


+ Etc.

- WHAT DID SPLINTER TELL THE TURTLES THEY WERE TRAINING FOR IF NOT VENGEANCE?

- HOW DOES SPLINTER RECONCILE HAMATO YOSHI BEING AN ASSASSIN AND FORMER FOOT NINJA?

- HOW DID OROKU SAKI COME BY THE TITLE OF THE SHREDDER?

- HOW DOES SPLINTER EVEN KNOW OROKU SAKI'S LIFE STORY?

- WHAT HAPPENED TO THE DOJO HAMATO YOSHI STARTED BEFORE HE WAS KILLED?
From what I understand the turtles always understood they were being trained to avenge their masters master. I'm sure it was a, here's how to defend yourself, but also we must avenge yoshi kind of deal

Is it ever explicitly stated that yoshi was an assassin? Was the foot clan bad before yoshi left? It is possible the clan was honorable and began to change around the time yoshi left

It makes a fun name? No answer there. Never really thought about it I guess

Possibly something he has learned over the years from reconnaissance and such?

I would assume it just fell by the wayside when Yoshi just didn't show up one day. Like any business, if the owner doesn't open its doors, I would assume it would go kaput, especially since there is no mention of any apprentice yoshi might have had

Fenryr
07-01-2015, 09:51 AM
I don't really agree with your point regarding Donatello, 'cause I think that's reading into it a little much, but I'm certainly not going to hold it against you.

Ha ha. Yeah. Donatello's just kind of, ... there. I tried!

From what I understand the turtles always understood they were being trained to avenge their masters master. I'm sure it was a, here's how to defend yourself, but also we must avenge yoshi kind of deal

When Splinter sits the turtles down after their fight, he tells them that the time has come for them to learn why they've been training. So this is the first time he's explained any of his past to them, which is weak, but improved upon in every other version where it's a story that they've all heard a hundred times before and he's just reiterating it, or telling someone new.

The stealth part of ninjitsu, I can see Splinter handwaving. It's the use of weapons and combat that I think he'd be a little hard pressed to explain away.

The Foot trains assassins. Yoshi was a member of the Foot. It's possible that his departure had something to do with changing policies, and I'm sure it's been explained that way at some point or another, but we don't get any of that from the first issue. For all intents and purposes, Yoshi is just as much a trained assassin as Saki or Nagi before him. And, while I suppose Splinter doesn't necessarily have much to come to terms with regarding Yoshi being a member of The Foot, since it was a life Yoshi willfully ran away from and Splinter was a simpler rat with limited cognitive skills at the time who might be missing some key details, it's something I'd like to see brought up more.

Also, how cool is it that there might be a third faction out there continuing on in Yoshi's teachings that neither the Turtles or The Foot have stumbled upon yet? It could be like that Tales v2 issue where they fight Nagi's ghost, but without the inexplicable field trip to Japan. Or it just got absorbed by The Foot and everyone moved on, but I like my version better.

HotJuicyBurgers
07-01-2015, 10:14 AM
Ha ha. Yeah. Donatello's just kind of, ... there. I tried!



When Splinter sits the turtles down after their fight, he tells them that the time has come for them to learn why they've been training. So this is the first time he's explained any of his past to them, which is weak, but improved upon in every other version where it's a story that they've all heard a hundred times before and he's just reiterating it, or telling someone new.

The stealth part of ninjitsu, I can see Splinter handwaving. It's the use of weapons and combat that I think he'd be a little hard pressed to explain away.

The Foot trains assassins. Yoshi was a member of the Foot. It's possible that his departure had something to do with changing policies, and I'm sure it's been explained that way at some point or another, but we don't get any of that from the first issue. For all intents and purposes, Yoshi is just as much a trained assassin as Saki or Nagi before him. And, while I suppose Splinter doesn't necessarily have much to come to terms with regarding Yoshi being a member of The Foot, since it was a life Yoshi willfully ran away from and Splinter was a simpler rat with limited cognitive skills at the time who might be missing some key details, it's something I'd like to see brought up more.

Also, how cool is it that there might be a third faction out there continuing on in Yoshi's teachings that neither the Turtles or The Foot have stumbled upon yet? It could be like that Tales v2 issue where they fight Nagi's ghost, but without the inexplicable field trip to Japan. Or it just got absorbed by The Foot and everyone moved on, but I like my version better.

I seem to have forgotten that part about that being the first time they had heard that.

Well... the nunchuks and staff and even the sai's I could see as viable non-lethal weapons that could be used for defense., but Leo's Katanas... definitely hard to swallow lol.

Also, the third organization is kind of similar to IDW having the french ninjas. Never though about that.

Duke Nukem
07-01-2015, 01:21 PM
I don't think self-defense has to always be non lethal. There's nothing wrong with killing someone who means to do harm to you. So, whether Leonardo uses a katana or a gun or any other type of weapon doesn't automatically make him an aggressor.

plastroncafe
07-01-2015, 01:28 PM
Shen wasn't killed by Nagi, she was beaten by him. Both Yoshi and Shen flee to New York together.

There'd been speculation in the fandom regarding Shen beating, and whether or not there was sexual assault involved as well...and while I still read that frame that way, Eastman has been quoted as saying that wasn't the intent of the image.

Duke Nukem
07-01-2015, 02:09 PM
Yeah, I don't think she was actually raped per se, but a guy beating a woman for not putting out is pretty much in the same ballpark, so to me it's not a big deal whether or not Nagi intended to rape her on that day.

HotJuicyBurgers
07-01-2015, 02:17 PM
Yeah, I don't think she was actually raped per se, but a guy beating a woman for not putting out is pretty much in the same ballpark, so to me it's not a big deal whether or not Nagi intended to rape her on that day.

Yah, I never took it as it having ever occurred, but the beating for not having done so is arguably just as bad.

Really great turn out for the first book so far guys, coming up on the second discussion on friday just to let everyone know, and unless there is a major upheaval, looks like we'll be discussing RTNY saga.

Still two more days to discuss anything you want about the first though :tgrin:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2015, 02:21 PM
Still two more days to discuss anything you want about the first though :tgrin:

I'm confused... where's Venus? Shouldn't she show up in this issue at some point? :teek:

Please don't kill me, guys, just having a wee bit of fun... and HJB did say discuss anything. :tlol:

plastroncafe
07-01-2015, 02:30 PM
I'm confused... where's Venus? Shouldn't she show up in this issue at some point? :teek:

Please don't kill me, guys, just having a wee bit of fun... and HJB did say discuss anything. :tlol:

http://media.giphy.com/media/MsZ7S2k8UVLr2/giphy.gif

:lol:

HotJuicyBurgers
07-01-2015, 02:31 PM
I'm confused... where's Venus? Shouldn't she show up in this issue at some point? :teek:

Please don't kill me, guys, just having a wee bit of fun... and HJB did say discuss anything. :tlol:

She's in the first page. She was killed tragically off screen. Sad really.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2015, 02:52 PM
She's in the first page. She was killed tragically off screen. Sad really.

If Venus had been machine-gunned instead of Donatello in the opening page of Image Volume 3 Issue #1, that series would have gone a lot farther... :tlol:

Candy Kappa
07-01-2015, 03:10 PM
+ The Timeline

Holy crap. What a mess.

Twenty years prior to the events of TMNT #1, Hamato Yoshi kills Oroku Nagi while defending Tang Shen. Oroku Saki, Nagi's brother, is seven, and Splinter, as a mature rat, is probably about one year old, though he could be two or three. All of this is, ... 1964.

Fifteen years prior to the events of TMNT #1, Yoshi and Tang Shen are murdered in New York by Oroku Saki, now calling himself The Shredder. Oroku Saki is nineteen, having been made leader of the New York branch of The Foot at eighteen, and expanding their business for at least one year into drugs and arms. That's in, ... 1969?

Saki aged twelve years in five years? And Splinter must be almost eight. Or is he fifteen? And even if you made Oroku Saki fourteen when his brother was killed, rats still don't live to be eight years old. Most live about two. So, none of this really works.

The compromise of the '90 film, where Oroku Saki is the one competing with Hamato Yoshi, lusting after Tang Shen, and killing her and Yoshi when he can't have her, is incredibly effective, plus, the bit with Splinter scarring Saki's face (NOT HUN'S!), and Saki slicing off one of Splinter's ears is pretty great. But, the whole ordeal feels more complete when Oroku Saki has a legitimate beef with an organization behind him and Yoshi's had time to settle in and build a life to tragically lose.

Man. Now that I've sat down and done the math, this is gonna bug me forever.


The math is a bit iffy, but Splinter does say "some 20 years ago". Although it's a bit weird wording it like that if he means 20 to 27 years ago instead of a few months before or after 20 years.

Maybe Splinter is a bit fuzzy on timelines when he was a rat, and time further away from the time he got mutated are less distinctive between days, months or years. Iirc he is listed to be 25 or 27 in TMNT & Other Strangness, my pdf version is missing huge chunks and Splinter's bio is hacked up and I can't verify it.

Cipher
07-01-2015, 08:27 PM
I don't see why Splinter has to reconcile Yoshi's past; Splinter spent probably half of his normal lifespan as a normal rat, with a simpler view on things and an animalistic attachment to his owner. When Splinter mutated, he gained new perspective possibly, new intelligence, but I don't see any reason for him to grow beyond what defined him for so long; a pet. This could also explain a lot of what Splinter goes through in City at War... he's seen that the "simple" life of an animal has perpetuated the violence, but in reality, he must embrace his animal nature as well as his mutated human nature.
Woah. Maybe we should save this for a future "City at War" discussion, but I have the exact opposite reading of his arc there. Splinter begins the arc searching for human enlightenment, traveling away from the farmhouse to mediate, perform tea ceremonies, etc. -- anything he can do to find himself while keeping all the pageantry of the human culture he's most familiar with. His quest for vengeance is predicated on the same ideas (if motivated by attachment from his time as a pet, and complicated by his possibly incomplete understanding as such). It's a human ideal that has brought nothing but pain to his family. What the Rat King encourages him to do is to embrace his roots -- the rat survives at all costs. Splinter's been doing the opposite, and in many ways it's prevented him from truly progressing or making meaning of his life. Searching for enlightenment in all the wrong places, and all that.

It's mirrored in at least the Turtles' arc and I believe Casey and April's as well (hell, even in the recovering old man the story follows as an indicator of time) -- the characters are all given the gift of a clean slate and open life, though it comes with the removal of what has, to that point, been a sense of purpose. Surviving is enough; what do you make of your life from there?

Re: Splinter's impression of Yoshi: I can't see any reason why Yoshi's possible work as a Foot ninja and assassin would ever be a concern for Splinter. That's the world he's always lived in. It is an interesting wrinkle to the reader, though, once the book starts taking itself seriously, that aside from having the moral high ground over Nagi, Yoshi is likely pretty far from being a hero. (So who have the Turtles really doomed themselves by avenging?) That's something the book never goes on to fully explore, although it's ripe with potential.

Is it ever explicitly stated that yoshi was an assassin? Was the foot clan bad before yoshi left? It is possible the clan was honorable and began to change around the time yoshi left
The Foot is a modern-day ninja organization. I'm not sure what the hell else Yoshi would've been if he were working for them in the capacity of a martial artist.

The Japanese Foot in Mirage is often portrayed as being more level-headed than Saki's New York branch, but they're never presented as being anything other than blatantly criminal, as far as I know. (We see them taking above-board security gigs, but it's never their entire operation.)

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2015, 08:58 PM
Woah. Maybe we should save this for a future "City at War" discussion, but I have the exact opposite reading of his arc there. Splinter begins the arc searching for human enlightenment, traveling away from the farmhouse to mediate, perform tea ceremonies, etc. -- anything he can do to find himself while keeping all the pageantry of the human culture he's most familiar with. His quest for vengeance is predicated on the same ideas (if motivated by attachment from his time as a pet, and complicated by his possibly incomplete understanding as such). It's a human ideal that has brought nothing but pain to his family. What the Rat King encourages him to do is to embrace his roots -- the rat survives at all costs. Splinter's been doing the opposite, and in many ways it's prevented him from truly progressing or making meaning of his life. Searching for enlightenment in all the wrong places, and all that.

It's mirrored in at least the Turtles' arc and I believe Casey and April's as well (hell, even in the recovering old man the story follows as an indicator of time) -- the characters are all given the gift of a clean slate and open life, though it comes with the removal of what has, to that point, been a sense of purpose. Surviving is enough; what do you make of your life from there?


No, I think we're in agreement; I brought up City at War, but my main theory on Splinter was specifically regarding him in Issue #1. I think the growing past the animalistic nature and trying to become more human is what leads him to distance himself from his actions and the feud he has brought upon his children. After all, after the Second Time Around ambush, Splinter never again faces off with Saki or the Foot. (Not counting all the random Tales of the TMNT.)

Return to New York? Splinter doesn't appear in a single panel.
Dealing with the Foot factions in City at War and Leatherhead, Too? No, he's off meditating... I think he's trying to find reconciliation for what he has caused. And I think that guilt is pushing him to reject everything he is, when the Rat King instead shows him that existence is savage and brutal...

Cipher
07-01-2015, 09:07 PM
I think he's trying to find reconciliation for what he has caused. And I think that guilt is pushing him to reject everything he is, when the Rat King instead shows him that existence is savage and brutal...
A fair read. Although I think I'd be more inclined toward that interpretation (I think ours vary by degrees) were we ever to see this kind of remorse and reflection post-#11. I do think it's a failure of the series that we don't get much of a reaction from him, nor any excuses for his absences.

I don't think the Rat King teaches him anything about brutality that would condone his actions in #1, though. It seems to be much less an instruction in the purpose of violence for anything other than survival, and more (I'm thinking specifically about the scene in which he's forced to eat the rats) a ritual in humiliation and pragmatism meant to get him thinking beyond -- above? below? -- human concepts. "In time, they will eat you." That's the Rat King's message: Get over yourself.

So, reconciliation: Maybe. But he's actually pushing himself further into everything he is, or thinks he should be, until the Rat King sets him on a different path. Splinter's mistake pre-"City at War" is letting his concept of human honor influence his and his sons' lives. Simply surviving, even if less honorable or dignified in his mind, was the answer and purpose he was seeking. His species has known for eons; he's simply too high-minded to accept it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2015, 09:25 PM
A fair read. Although I think I'd be more inclined toward that interpretation (I think ours vary by degrees) were we ever to see this kind of remorse and reflection post-#11. I do think it's a failure of the series that we don't get much of a reaction from him, nor any excuses for his absences.

I don't think the Rat King teaches him anything about brutality that would condone his actions in #1, though. It seems to be much less an instruction in the purpose of violence for anything other than survival, and more (I'm thinking specifically about the scene in which he's forced to eat the rats) a ritual in humiliation and pragmatism meant to get him thinking beyond -- above? below? -- human concepts. "In time, they will eat you." That's the Rat King's message: Get over yourself.

So, reconciliation: Maybe. But he's actually pushing himself further into everything he is, or thinks he should be, until the Rat King sets him on a different path. Splinter's mistake pre-"City at War" is letting his concept of human honor influence he and his sons' life. Simply surviving, even if less honorable or dignified in his mind, was the answer and purpose he was seeking. His species has known for eons; he's simply too high-minded to accept it.

I love how morally grey and conflicted all of the Mirage characters are. Cannot be topped. :tlol:

Fenryr
07-01-2015, 10:02 PM
The math is a bit iffy, but Splinter does say "some 20 years ago". Although it's a bit weird wording it like that if he means 20 to 27 years ago instead of a few months before or after 20 years.

Maybe Splinter is a bit fuzzy on timelines when he was a rat, and time further away from the time he got mutated are less distinctive between days, months or years. Iirc he is listed to be 25 or 27 in TMNT & Other Strangness, my pdf version is missing huge chunks and Splinter's bio is hacked up and I can't verify it.

If "some 20 years" meant up to 27 years, and we excuse Splinter's memory, since he was an unmutated rat (who was still intelligent enough to learn martial arts through mimicry at the time ), then that would also make him 27 or so. Maybe a little older. Which gives him a 14-year lifespan even before being mutated. Enough lifetime for four or five rats. Though it does fix the problem with Nagi's aging.

In the end, I suppose the math doesn't really matter. You paid to see mutant turtles fight ninjas. You get to see mutant turtles fight ninjas. Everyone goes home happy.

Moving on, ...

Re: Splinter's impression of Yoshi: I can't see any reason why Yoshi's possible work as a Foot ninja and assassin would ever be a concern for Splinter. That's the world he's always lived in. It is an interesting wrinkle to the reader, though, once the book starts taking itself seriously, that aside from having the moral high ground over Nagi, Yoshi is likely pretty far from being a hero. (So who have the Turtles really doomed themselves by avenging?) That's something the book never goes on to fully explore, although it's ripe with potential.

I think this is what I was really trying to get at with my question. The Turtles believe themselves to be on the right path: avenge the death of their master's master. Except, maybe Yoshi wasn't quite the white knight they've been told he was, ...

I love how morally grey and conflicted all of the Mirage characters are. Cannot be topped. :tlol:

Agreed!

HotJuicyBurgers
07-02-2015, 08:21 AM
I think this is what I was really trying to get at with my question. The Turtles believe themselves to be on the right path: avenge the death of their master's master. Except, maybe Yoshi wasn't quite the white knight they've been told he was, ...



I'd never really thought to much about this. I think every incarnation kind of hand waves over what who Yoshi was, but after a bit of thought, it's pretty clear he must have been a pretty efficient assassin. HOWEVER, an assassin isn't necessarily a bad person.