PDA

View Full Version : A Nagging Issue About IDW's Donatello


CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2015, 08:50 PM
This has been bugging me since Issue #45, and the current issue, even in all its awesomeness, has exasperated this for me a little more. Why is the treatment and care for Donatello's current physical predicament so blatantly wrong!?

In Issue #44, Donnie is lying on his stomach trying to fight off Bebop when Rocksteady brutally smashes in his carapace (shell) and spine with a sledgehammer. There's blood everywhere, and Donnie practically dies. Paralysis, blood loss, internal hemorrhaging, and shock (to say nothing of excruciating pain) all send him into a coma. His heartbeat and pulse slow so far down that only Honeycutt detects it, and Donnie's body has MINUTES before he's 100% dead. Honeycutt and Harold transfer Donnie's mind to Metalhead, then see about stabilizing his physical body.

The treatment SHOULD BE blood transfusions, somehow repairing the shell damage, and tons and tons of bandages. Donnie should also totally be lying on his plastron (his stomach) but he is ALWAYS shown on his (DESTROYED) carapace. No bandages, just an IV and an oxygen mask. Plus, somehow the Turtles carry the comatose "shell" of their brother all the way from Harold's lab to their lair. And nobody seems to even be thinking about how to fix Donnie's body, even though they should feel like they have time. As far as they know, Krang and Shredder are both dead; why aren't they trying to find some healing ooze to repair Donnie's shell?

Why is IDW not portraying Donnie's predicament and treatment with any degree of realism or accuracy?

I thought about it a bit before I posted this, and I realized after a minute why this is bothering me so much. It seemingly makes light of Donatello's dire predicament; it feels like backpedaling and pretending that Donnie's injuries weren't THAT bad, he just got shellshocked.

Bobby or Tom, can you guys please shed a little light on this situation? I love your work so much, and I always repeat that of all incarnations of the TMNT, even the original stuff by Laird and Eastman, YOUR IDW comics are what I love most. So I'm not trying to throw rotten tomatoes, I'm just a little frustrated and really want to know if you guys can shed any light on this.

Would depicting Donnie's treatment and care more accurately be either too distracting or graphic? Is that why?

Mew
07-01-2015, 09:28 PM
I liked Donnie's mind going into Metalhead's body. Gave me a Baxter Stockman vibe.

oldmanwinters
07-01-2015, 09:34 PM
I know it's kinda morbid, but I feel a little cheated that Bebop and Rocksteady got to see the insides of a mutant turtle's shell and we readers never got the "pleasure."

Kinda reminds me of the strategic camera angle censorship and no-mess healing in regards to that time Karai stabbed Leonardo in the 4Kids cartoon.

ChosenOne
07-01-2015, 09:39 PM
I know it's kinda morbid, but I feel a little cheated that Bebop and Rocksteady got to see the insides of a mutant turtle's shell and we readers never got the "pleasure."

Well, I for one certainly hope you never try to satisfy that particular curiosity elsewhere other than a comic book or maybe Google Images... :o

These things always work best if left somewhat vague, makes it even more gruesome somehow if the reader/viewer has to fill in the blanks.

Eurydemus
07-02-2015, 01:10 AM
I've always wondered about that, too. In fact, I vaguely recall when Donnie's being carried away, they grab his arms and legs and he's facing up. I thought, "Wouldn't his gooey centre leak out from the hole in his shell?".

I try not to dwell on it too much. I'm doubly glad we didn't get a detailed look at mutant turtle anatomy. The whole thing was dramatic enough without seeing poor Donatello's insides.

MsMarvelDuckie
07-02-2015, 01:32 AM
This has been bugging me since Issue #45, and the current issue, even in all its awesomeness, has exasperated this for me a little more. Why is the treatment and care for Donatello's current physical predicament so blatantly wrong!?

In Issue #44, Donnie is lying on his stomach trying to fight off Bebop when Rocksteady brutally smashes in his carapace (shell) and spine with a sledgehammer. There's blood everywhere, and Donnie practically dies. Paralysis, blood loss, internal hemorrhaging, and shock (to say nothing of excruciating pain) all send him into a coma. His heartbeat and pulse slow so far down that only Honeycutt detects it, and Donnie's body has MINUTES before he's 100% dead. Honeycutt and Harold transfer Donnie's mind to Metalhead, then see about stabilizing his physical body.

The treatment SHOULD BE blood transfusions, somehow repairing the shell damage, and tons and tons of bandages. Donnie should also totally be lying on his plastron (his stomach) but he is ALWAYS shown on his (DESTROYED) carapace. No bandages, just an IV and an oxygen mask. Plus, somehow the Turtles carry the comatose "shell" of their brother all the way from Harold's lab to their lair. And nobody seems to even be thinking about how to fix Donnie's body, even though they should feel like they have time. As far as they know, Krang and Shredder are both dead; why aren't they trying to find some healing ooze to repair Donnie's shell?

Why is IDW not portraying Donnie's predicament and treatment with any degree of realism or accuracy?

I thought about it a bit before I posted this, and I realized after a minute why this is bothering me so much. It seemingly makes light of Donatello's dire predicament; it feels like backpedaling and pretending that Donnie's injuries weren't THAT bad, he just got shellshocked.

Bobby or Tom, can you guys please shed a little light on this situation? I love your work so much, and I always repeat that of all incarnations of the TMNT, even the original stuff by Laird and Eastman, YOUR IDW comics are what I love most. So I'm not trying to throw rotten tomatoes, I'm just a little frustrated and really want to know if you guys can shed any light on this.

Would depicting Donnie's treatment and care more accurately be either too distracting or graphic? Is that why?


You know, I haven't even read the issue yet (my copy of the TPB comes in on Friday or Saturday,) but the few "leaked" panels I've seen, and the FCBD comic I have, made me wonder the same thing. The FCBD issue has him lying on his back, which is a big no-no with a busted carapace. I've seen images of broken shells, and it's NOT pretty, nor is it easy to fix. Involves a lot of epoxy, thin wire, and/or other adhesives or glues that would dissolve or be easily removed after healing.

Bobby Curnow
07-02-2015, 12:27 PM
In all honesty, it bugs me a little too.

FCBD needed to be finished months ahead of the issues surrounding it, so Mateus didn't actually know the exact injuries that Don would sustain during Cory's arc, just that he would be in a coma. So we started with him on his back in the first FCBD pages. From there, it became a race against deadlines. I had to make the decision to either delay the book to have pages redrawn or to send them out as they appeared.

I rationalized it in my mind that these are mutant turtles-- not real turtles. We don't know what their anatomy is like, especially 'inside'. They could very well have ribs, muscles, etc, protecting their inner organs. And it was a conscious decision not to 'examine' any of this in great detail. As others have mentioned, better left to the imagination. Further, in my mind they have protected the wound off-panel and made sure he's as okay as he can be-- Fugitoid and Harold would make sure of that. In short, they would know better how to take care of him than we would.

Is that all sort of BS? Yeah, kinda. Ultimately we ran up against a deadline wall, and I made the judgement call that it wouldn't detract from the story too much. But it does bother me a little, and can see why it would ping on other's radars as well.

plastroncafe
07-02-2015, 12:39 PM
Maybe I'm alone in this, but I'm way more interested in seeing the insides of the production process than I am of seeing the chest cavity of a mutant turtle.

Thank you so much for sharing that with us!

PangolinFeets
07-02-2015, 12:45 PM
Agreed. This has been bugging me too so thanks for clearing things up!

Out of all the comics I read, this is the only one that I buy digitally the second it comes out so I can read it before I pick up the physical. Especially all the stuff with Donnie (cuz favorite). I can't wait to see how things come together.

TomWaltz
07-02-2015, 01:35 PM
All this said, keep reading, folks. All deadline issues, etc., aside, we haven't forgotten about Donnie's physical predicament by any means... nor its need for a drastic solution, if one exists.

So. Please. Keep. Reading.

Talk soon...

Tom W.

ProphetofGanja
07-02-2015, 02:43 PM
All this said, keep reading, folks. All deadline issues, etc., aside, we haven't forgotten about Donnie's physical predicament by any means... nor its need for a drastic solution, if one exists.

So. Please. Keep. Reading.

Talk soon...

Tom W.

you don't have to ask me twice!

I'm enjoying the build-up to #50 and I'm sure I'll enjoy the stories that come after

Metalhead 2.0
07-02-2015, 03:29 PM
I can't come up with a good excuse for him lying on his back. He obviously needs to be lying on his stomach otherwise the internal bleeding is just going to cause the blood to pool in the damaged tissue which will cause a whole host of new problems. Flip that turtle!

As far as blood transfusions go: I would imagine his mutant blood could cause some issues with that. I wouldn't think he could feasibly accept blood from just any human without some sort of possibly adverse reaction and the other turtles may not be his blood-type. So what if one of the other mutants are his blood-type? What are the medical complications of transfusing mutant cat blood or mutant fox blood into a mutant turtle? Would it be ok? Would it trigger a secondary mutation? No one involved has any knowledge or experience with such a thing. The only people who may have the answers to those questions are Lindsey, Jillian, and.... BAXTER.

And to make things REALLY f*cked up: What if he can't accept blood from ANY of the other mutants, what if ONLY SHREDDER's blood is the answer?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-02-2015, 04:06 PM
In all honesty, it bugs me a little too.

FCBD needed to be finished months ahead of the issues surrounding it, so Mateus didn't actually know the exact injuries that Don would sustain during Cory's arc, just that he would be in a coma. So we started with him on his back in the first FCBD pages. From there, it became a race against deadlines. I had to make the decision to either delay the book to have pages redrawn or to send them out as they appeared.

I rationalized it in my mind that these are mutant turtles-- not real turtles. We don't know what their anatomy is like, especially 'inside'. They could very well have ribs, muscles, etc, protecting their inner organs. And it was a conscious decision not to 'examine' any of this in great detail. As others have mentioned, better left to the imagination. Further, in my mind they have protected the wound off-panel and made sure he's as okay as he can be-- Fugitoid and Harold would make sure of that. In short, they would know better how to take care of him than we would.

Is that all sort of BS? Yeah, kinda. Ultimately we ran up against a deadline wall, and I made the judgement call that it wouldn't detract from the story too much. But it does bother me a little, and can see why it would ping on other's radars as well.

Okay, that makes perfect sense. Knowing the FCBD issue had to release a couple of months ahead, and this throwing a wrench in schedules... makes perfect sense.

Knowing you sorta feel the same way I do but had to make a judgment call pretty much solves everything in my mind. It's a naggling little detail, but knowing it naggles you guys too, and not just the readers, makes it okay for me. Thanks Bobby!

All this said, keep reading, folks. All deadline issues, etc., aside, we haven't forgotten about Donnie's physical predicament by any means... nor its need for a drastic solution, if one exists.

So. Please. Keep. Reading.

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Looking forward to it. And believe me, if one day I had a choice between eating dinner that night or buying the latest issue of TMNT, my diet would thank me. :tlol:

Candy Kappa
07-02-2015, 04:31 PM
Honestly didn't bother me as much, since I kinda thought it was some miscommunication with writer and artists when rendering Donnie being on his back. It's a easy "fix" though.

PangolinFeets
07-02-2015, 07:05 PM
My headcanon was that the combination of the damage to his internal organs and the positioning of his shell, he couldn't breath properly if he was lying prone. Even this, he should be on his side so the wound can breathe.

AquaParade
07-02-2015, 08:00 PM
Bobby, I love the no nonsense answer. It's so much less of an issue when you guys are factual with us, as opposed to the b.s. type of answers one might receive from other editors in the field.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-02-2015, 08:11 PM
Bobby, I love the no nonsense answer. It's so much less of an issue when you guys are factual with us, as opposed to the b.s. type of answers one might receive from other editors in the field.

What this guy said. :tgrin:

Klunk1234
07-02-2015, 10:27 PM
This has been bugging me since Issue #45, and the current issue, even in all its awesomeness, has exasperated this for me a little more. Why is the treatment and care for Donatello's current physical predicament so blatantly wrong!?

In Issue #44, Donnie is lying on his stomach trying to fight off Bebop when Rocksteady brutally smashes in his carapace (shell) and spine with a sledgehammer. There's blood everywhere, and Donnie practically dies. Paralysis, blood loss, internal hemorrhaging, and shock (to say nothing of excruciating pain) all send him into a coma. His heartbeat and pulse slow so far down that only Honeycutt detects it, and Donnie's body has MINUTES before he's 100% dead. Honeycutt and Harold transfer Donnie's mind to Metalhead, then see about stabilizing his physical body.

The treatment SHOULD BE blood transfusions, somehow repairing the shell damage, and tons and tons of bandages. Donnie should also totally be lying on his plastron (his stomach) but he is ALWAYS shown on his (DESTROYED) carapace. No bandages, just an IV and an oxygen mask. Plus, somehow the Turtles carry the comatose "shell" of their brother all the way from Harold's lab to their lair. And nobody seems to even be thinking about how to fix Donnie's body, even though they should feel like they have time. As far as they know, Krang and Shredder are both dead; why aren't they trying to find some healing ooze to repair Donnie's shell?

Why is IDW not portraying Donnie's predicament and treatment with any degree of realism or accuracy?

I thought about it a bit before I posted this, and I realized after a minute why this is bothering me so much. It seemingly makes light of Donatello's dire predicament; it feels like backpedaling and pretending that Donnie's injuries weren't THAT bad, he just got shellshocked.

Bobby or Tom, can you guys please shed a little light on this situation? I love your work so much, and I always repeat that of all incarnations of the TMNT, even the original stuff by Laird and Eastman, YOUR IDW comics are what I love most. So I'm not trying to throw rotten tomatoes, I'm just a little frustrated and really want to know if you guys can shed any light on this.

Would depicting Donnie's treatment and care more accurately be either too distracting or graphic? Is that why?


You are not alone this issue. I was bother, too. I even wrote about this to the writers of the comic about Donnie's situation and poor handling of somebody severely injured as he is.

Some patients with spinal injuries are laying on their backs after an emergency surgery. In Donnie's case there's no surgery scene. His body is not even bandaged and he didn't wear a cervical collar, nor even a heart monitor. Just an oxygen mask and an I.V. line. He needs to be laying on his stomach or on his side. He needs to wear a pressure device on his legs to avoid clots. A catheter connected to his bladder for the pee. Bloods transfusion are a must and not only for his siblings but for anyone who can match his blood type. Mr. O'Neil has mutagen on his body. But Donnie's siblings could have a 100% of being compatible with him. Instead of being transported to the lair, he needed to stay in Harold's lab/ clinic in a sterilized environment making everybody wearing a sterilized gown, gloves and surgical masks. Bacteria is dangerous on his situation. He needs 24/7 care.

We don't know what Mrs. O'Neil profession is. But it would be nice if she is a nurse so she can also take care of Donnie besides Harold and professor Honeycutt. She would know important is Donnie to her daughter. He is April's best friend. Also, he is like the little brother she never had.

Davin
07-03-2015, 12:24 AM
I know it's kinda morbid, but I feel a little cheated that Bebop and Rocksteady got to see the insides of a mutant turtle's shell and we readers never got the "pleasure."

Kinda reminds me of the strategic camera angle censorship and no-mess healing in regards to that time Karai stabbed Leonardo in the 4Kids cartoon.

There's a little movie called Cannibal Holocaust that can satisfy anyone's desire to see turtle innards among other gory sights. If you are so inclined. :tgrin:

Candy Kappa
07-03-2015, 02:49 AM
My headcanon was that the combination of the damage to his internal organs and the positioning of his shell, he couldn't breath properly if he was lying prone. Even this, he should be on his side so the wound can breathe.

Which is actually a fair backpedaling. When his breathing is stabilized he can lie on his plastron to heal his carapace.

There's a little movie called Cannibal Holocaust that can satisfy anyone's desire to see turtle innards among other gory sights. If you are so inclined. :tgrin:

probably mention that it's real turtle innards, and that movie is not minors.

And the movie's production history is way more interesting then the actual movie, as the cast was contracted to go into hiding after the movie was out which lead to the director ending up on murder trial for killing his cast members. The cast had to come out of hiding to prove he "only" was responsible for the killing off several animals, but no humans was killed.

Mormegil
07-03-2015, 05:49 AM
We didn't need to see don's insides. That scene was one of the best writing in the series. Here we have bebop and rocksteady, we've seen all the gruesome stuff they've done in the series so far but when bebop sees the inside of his shell it kinda grosses him out. It gave me chills when he said that.

The human imagination will always picture something worse than what any artist could draw in a scene like that.

As far as how their handling don's body, I just figured they were doing the best with what they had. It's not like they can take him to s hospital. And what are they going to do steal hospital equipment?

Candy Kappa
07-03-2015, 06:17 AM
The human imagination will always picture something worse than what any artist could draw in a scene like that.

Totally, seeing the gore would have lessen the experience.

oldmanwinters
07-03-2015, 08:16 AM
Totally, seeing the gore would have lessen the experience.

Yeah, you got a point.

In all honesty, it bugs me a little too.

FCBD needed to be finished months ahead of the issues surrounding it, so Mateus didn't actually know the exact injuries that Don would sustain during Cory's arc, just that he would be in a coma. So we started with him on his back in the first FCBD pages. From there, it became a race against deadlines. I had to make the decision to either delay the book to have pages redrawn or to send them out as they appeared.

I rationalized it in my mind that these are mutant turtles-- not real turtles. We don't know what their anatomy is like, especially 'inside'. They could very well have ribs, muscles, etc, protecting their inner organs. And it was a conscious decision not to 'examine' any of this in great detail. As others have mentioned, better left to the imagination. Further, in my mind they have protected the wound off-panel and made sure he's as okay as he can be-- Fugitoid and Harold would make sure of that. In short, they would know better how to take care of him than we would.

Is that all sort of BS? Yeah, kinda. Ultimately we ran up against a deadline wall, and I made the judgement call that it wouldn't detract from the story too much. But it does bother me a little, and can see why it would ping on other's radars as well.

Thanks for the behind-the-scenes info on the publication process! Coordination months in advance must be such a constant challenge!

Davin
07-03-2015, 08:59 AM
probably mention that it's real turtle innards, and that movie is not minors.

You are right. Sometimes I forget this is an all ages forum. :toops:

To add my two cents to the subject. I thought there was nothing wrong with how the scene was handled. As for laying on his back during recovery, I never gave it a second thought. Maybe there is a hole in the bed he's on that relieves any pressure to the shell and allows it to breathe.