PDA

View Full Version : what in the IDW continuity might turn a original fan off?


turtlefanforever
07-20-2015, 08:05 AM
What things in the continuity of IDW comics might turn off a fan of the original comics?

neatoman
07-20-2015, 09:17 AM
Well...


The origin is changed to contain supernatural elements
Shredder, Nobody and Rat King have been altered in noticable ways.
Purists might take issue with the prominence of Fred Wolf and 4Kids elements


That's really just what I think fans of the Mirage comics might take issue with, I would have a lot more to say if the question included old fans in general. Personally I don't any problem with what I listed.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-20-2015, 09:22 AM
Reincarnation. That's really the only "divisive" element of the IDW TMNT. And if it sticks in your craw, you're depriving yourself of the best version of TMNT ever.

ToTheNines
07-20-2015, 09:33 AM
The turtles not being allowed to use lethal force, under any circumstances. Normally it doesn't effect the story, but sometimes it does. Particularly the Dark Leo stuff.

Other than that, not much.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-20-2015, 09:45 AM
The turtles not being allowed to use lethal force, under any circumstances. Normally it doesn't effect the story, but sometimes it does. Particularly the Dark Leo stuff.

Other than that, not much.

Ooh, that's a good point.

But honestly, that's not a problem specific to IDW. Rather, it's a problem to the entire TMNT franchise EXCEPT Mirage/Image. So I don't think it's entirely fair to cite this as a major turn off for IDW, as chances are most TMNT fans have either gotten over it by now or are strict Mirage-only fans.

Mutant Ninja Anole
07-20-2015, 09:47 AM
One thing I've found is that it really varies and sometimes can be downright puzzling what 'turns people off.' Maybe you really loved this one character or had one interpretation of this character and bam, they tweaked it. It's hard to say really and if you're writing you can't worry about those sort of things, just tell your story.

Zak The Neutrino
07-20-2015, 09:57 AM
I could see where the reincarnation could turn some off. For me I absolutely loved that change. I think it creates a greater bond for Splinter and the turtles. It also in my opinion creates a deeper conflict with Shredder.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-20-2015, 10:02 AM
I could see where the reincarnation could turn some off. For me I absolutely loved that change. I think it creates a greater bond for Splinter and the turtles. It also in my opinion creates a deeper conflict with Shredder.

Absolutely agree.

DarkLightDragon
07-20-2015, 10:11 AM
I'm pretty indifferent towards the reincarnation angle myself, but I will give credit for it expanding Tang Shen's role.

In other media, she's just someone who has to die to start or fuel the hatred between Yoshi/Splinter and Shredder. Here she actually serves as spiritual being watching over her family and comes to any of them whenever they are in a inner crisis. Leo for snapping him back from Shredder's brainwashing, Splinter for reassuring him that Leo will come around and now Don with stopping him from ascending to the afterlife.

Kind of shows a "Even in death, a mother's love is eternal" vibe which is admittedly very sweet.

Duke Nukem
07-20-2015, 11:02 AM
The turtles not being allowed to use lethal force, under any circumstances. Normally it doesn't effect the story, but sometimes it does. Particularly the Dark Leo stuff.

Other than that, not much.

This is what I dislike most about the comic. It basically pigeonholes the turtles into stereotypical hero roles.

I like the reincarnation origin, as well as Casey Jones' origin.

ToTheNines
07-20-2015, 12:08 PM
Ooh, that's a good point.

But honestly, that's not a problem specific to IDW. Rather, it's a problem to the entire TMNT franchise EXCEPT Mirage/Image. So I don't think it's entirely fair to cite this as a major turn off for IDW, as chances are most TMNT fans have either gotten over it by now or are strict Mirage-only fans.

Very true, but it's so frustrating that the writers and artists have given us some pretty sweet kills (mostly in the feudal Japan stuff), just none of them by the turtles. It's like, we're so close but we can't have it.

And the 4kids turtles had no problem with killing, it was just never shown.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-20-2015, 12:16 PM
Very true, but it's so frustrating that the writers and artists have given us some pretty sweet kills (mostly in the feudal Japan stuff), just none of them by the turtles. It's like, we're so close but we can't have it.

And the 4kids turtles had no problem with killing, it was just never shown.

Agreed. Dark Leo was kinda neutered by the no-kill policy.

4Kids Turtles not having a problem with killing isn't that compelling though, because the 4Kids producers obviously did.

You know if it ever came up, they told concerned parents, "No no no no! The bad guys aren't dead, they're just unconscious!"

At least the Foot were real humans, not robots.

Duke Nukem
07-20-2015, 12:37 PM
Well, the 4kids show was ostensibly for kids, even though it was the most mature of the TV series. IDW comics state that they're recommended for ages 12 and up, as opposed to 7 and up for the 4kids show there's no reason that they couldn't be more violent except that it's forbidden by Viacom. I believe that the comics would be much better if IDW had free reign over them.

Technogeek29
07-20-2015, 12:41 PM
Well, the 4kids show was ostensibly for kids, even though it was the most mature of the TV series. IDW comics state that they're recommended for ages 12 and up, as opposed to 7 and up for the 4kids show there's no reason that they couldn't be more violent except that it's forbidden by Viacom. I believe that the comics would be much better if IDW had free reign over them.

Not much better just able to take them places they can't go because the hand comes in and says no.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-20-2015, 12:42 PM
Well, the 4kids show was ostensibly for kids, even though it was the most mature of the TV series. IDW comics state that they're recommended for ages 12 and up, as opposed to 7 and up for the 4kids show there's no reason that they couldn't be more violent except that it's forbidden by Viacom. I believe that the comics would be much better if IDW had free reign over them.

No question there. Corporate oversight never has any positive impact on storytelling.

Just ask the New 52 "Nightwing" series... :tlol:

spookycookies
07-20-2015, 12:47 PM
I come from a very different school of thought I guess. I prefer IDW to Mirage. Honestly IDW is probably my favorite TMNT installment, I love the way it merges new stuff with old ideas and refines everything into one really solid story.

I know there are some mixed feelings about the guest era but I guess if you were a really big Mirage purist you might also notice that only a handful of people have been given the chance to write/draw for these turtles. But I guess it serves IDW's narrative to be very tightly written.

plastroncafe
07-20-2015, 12:48 PM
I love the reincarnation stuff.
What turns me off is the breakneck pace of the plotting. It stretches my disbelief a little too far, which keeps me from really engaging with the story.

CyberCubed
07-20-2015, 12:48 PM
I remember people being concerned about the reincarnation angle early on when the series first started, although I think everyone is pretty much fine with that now. It also explains why the Turtles are "teenagers" in this version despite their mutation being shown as instant to their adult forms, simply because they were teenage in their human lives.

The Big Bad
07-20-2015, 04:32 PM
Not continuity, but rather style and execution: the fact that the series is essentially a pop reinterpretation of a heavy metal (or jazz, or hip-hop, any other musical genre with a perceived edge) original. It may be very good pop (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcIy9NiNbmo), and it may be decent or better-than-decent TMNT, but it's not designed to satisfy the same itch as the original books, and if you're looking for stories done in the Mirage style (which may or may not be TMNT stories) the IDW books are likely not the place to go.

sdp
07-20-2015, 04:39 PM
The reincarnation origin is more stupid than the Platinum Dunes movies origin.

Venom
07-20-2015, 04:57 PM
Not continuity, but rather style and execution: the fact that the series is essentially a pop reinterpretation of a heavy metal (or jazz, or hip-hop, any other musical genre with a perceived edge) original. It may be very good pop (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcIy9NiNbmo), and it may be decent or better-than-decent TMNT, but it's not designed to satisfy the same itch as the original books, and if you're looking for stories done in the Mirage style (which may or may not be TMNT stories) the IDW books are likely not the place to go.

That's a good assessment. :tcool:

Mirage is definitely rock/metal, with all the little easter egg nods to metal back in the old issues.

The original movie trilogy is the hip-hop versions, simply because the soundtracks incorporated it so much.

snake
07-20-2015, 05:03 PM
Reincarnation and more mutants.

Cipher
07-20-2015, 05:50 PM
It's a serialized action comic that occasionally gives way to nostalgia-based plot elements drawing on disparate versions for various audiences instead of a bizarre underground playground that occasionally gives way to whatever the authors were interested in talking about.

They're not even comparable in terms of aesthetics or goals.

Basically what The Big Bad said.

That's a good assessment. :tcool:

Mirage is definitely rock/metal, with all the little easter egg nods to metal back in the old issues.

The original movie trilogy is the hip-hop versions, simply because the soundtracks incorporated it so much.
I don't think that's what he was going for. More that IDW is a clean, hooky, accessible and commercially savvy, cover of a piece that was originally about raw edge.

None of this is to say I'm "turned off" by IDW. But I don't think it'll ever grab me in the way Mirage's book did, because their mission statements are worlds apart.

Ninturtle
07-20-2015, 05:52 PM
The reincarnation origin is more stupid than the Platinum Dunes movies origin.

No it most certainly isn't. The PD origin lacked Hamato Yoshi which is a huge part of the turtles origin. Because of that PD has the worst origin and IDW's is superior in comparison.

The Big Bad
07-20-2015, 07:33 PM
I don't think that's what he was going for. More that IDW is a clean, hooky, accessible and commercially savvy, cover of a piece that was originally about raw edge.

Precisely this. The Mirage (and slightly lesser extent Archie) books were all about what a particular creator felt like doing at the time, regardless of whether or not it was appealing, well-considered, tasteful, or commercial. The IDW book is published with a complete understanding of what TMNT fans like, and is designed to be liked. This doesn't make one better than the other, but it does mean they can't be treated as interchangeable.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-20-2015, 08:25 PM
Precisely this. The Mirage (and slightly lesser extent Archie) books were all about what a particular creator felt like doing at the time, regardless of whether or not it was appealing, well-considered, tasteful, or commercial. The IDW book is published with a complete understanding of what TMNT fans like, and is designed to be liked. This doesn't make one better than the other, but it does mean they can't be treated as interchangeable.

I think you totally nailed it.

AquaParade
07-20-2015, 08:52 PM
As a long time fan, I feel lucky that tmnt has had so many rich incarnations within the comic book world. IDW and Mirage compliment eachother with how different they are.

spookycookies
07-20-2015, 09:01 PM
No it most certainly isn't. The PD origin lacked Hamato Yoshi which is a huge part of the turtles origin. Because of that PD has the worst origin and IDW's is superior in comparison.

Yeah the PD TMNT Origin lacks most of the elements found in the other origins. PD Shredder and Splinter don't even know each other iirc and their martial arts background came out of one book? Without that grudge the turtles loose a ton of motivation.

Reincarnation adds a whole new dimension to the Saki/Hamato feud that I openly welcome. It's no longer about a love triangle but purely betrayal and revenge, themes that have been refined through IDW Splinter & Shredder to the point where both of them are obsessed with another. I love seeing Splinter second guess his actions based on whether or not he is blinded by revenge. I love seeing Shredder making plays based not on the greater good of his clan but toward his personal agenda, it makes them more flawed and more human.

Splinter is one of the best father figures around, and IDW has given him so much more room to get off of that pedestal and be a more fleshed out character. I'm so thankful for that.

ToTheNines
07-20-2015, 09:47 PM
Not continuity, but rather style and execution: the fact that the series is essentially a pop reinterpretation of a heavy metal (or jazz, or hip-hop, any other musical genre with a perceived edge) .

As far as the Mirage books go, I would absolutely say "punk rock".

The reincarnation origin is more stupid than the Platinum Dunes movies origin.

Yeah.... **** you.

The Big Bad
07-20-2015, 10:10 PM
As far as the Mirage books go, I would absolutely say "punk rock".

Well, I said heavy metal mainly because of Kevin Eastman's connection to Heavy Metal the magazine, but I've just realized that that's only tangentially about the music genre. Oh, well. :P

turtlefanforever
07-20-2015, 11:20 PM
original turtle fans as well. What would they dislike about it?

Cryomancer
07-20-2015, 11:52 PM
Color masks and the fact that everything is "happening for a reason" in IDW pretty much. Everything is connected to something which is connected to something and so on forever, nothing just happens because it happens like Mirage.

Andrew NDB
07-21-2015, 12:56 AM
What things in the continuity of IDW comics might turn off a fan of the original comics?

Heavy, heavy cartoon elements. But it's not done poorly. After the red bandannas were switched out for the rainbow ones I felt angry and fairly bait-and-switched but it's not terrible, and these guys are putting genuine thought into things... and some time into the future.

neatoman
07-21-2015, 05:09 AM
Heavy, heavy cartoon elements. But it's not done poorly. After the red bandannas were switched out for the rainbow ones I felt angry and fairly bait-and-switched but it's not terrible, and these guys are putting genuine thought into things... and some time into the future.

"Rah! How dare they make use of a design aspect that has been in place for 30 years and prevents confusion over which character is which?!"

Seriously, the color coded masks bother you?

Powder
07-21-2015, 05:24 AM
It was a huge topic of discussion at the time, a lot of people were rubbed the wrong way by that decision.

Candy Kappa
07-21-2015, 05:50 AM
Besides the reincarnation bit, which I loathe. It's just badly shoe-horned in "deeper" connection with Splinter and the Turtles, now that 700 years ago one off the five souls where inhabiting the body who was the biological father off the other four souls.

It's a good comic. Would have preferred the continuation of the red masks, but people would apparently just be confused with four "Raphaels" :lol:

AquaParade
07-21-2015, 08:48 AM
The red masks were more than just a color choice, they represented the old school Mirage spirit and invited long time fans back into the fray. Losing them four issues in gave legitimate worry to which direction this book was going to head to in.

Thankfully, the book has been great ever since, but it was still hard to accept after so much promotion featuring Kevin Eastman's return, the red masks, and the general feel of "coming home" to tmnt's unique style in comics.

plastroncafe
07-21-2015, 09:55 AM
"Rah! How dare they make use of a design aspect that has been in place for 30 years and prevents confusion over which character is which?!"

Seriously, the color coded masks bother you?

"...allows us to make more action figures."

TMNachoT
07-21-2015, 10:29 AM
What things in the continuity of IDW comics might turn off a fan of the original comics?

Rencarnation... and that it is a reboot or remake, whatever you want to call it. The way i see, and it´s my opinion, there should be two kind of comics, the ones based on the films or toons and the mirage ones. Mirage version is kinda sacred for me, i`d rather seing a continuation of the mirageverse instead of a new take on that version.

HotJuicyBurgers
07-21-2015, 10:39 AM
It was a huge topic of discussion at the time, a lot of people were rubbed the wrong way by that decision.

I think it rubbed so many people wrong was because of the bait-and-switch they kind of pulled by making it seem like they would be classic red masks, and then in the end flip-flopping.

Zak The Neutrino
07-21-2015, 11:33 AM
Rencarnation... and that it is a reboot or remake, whatever you want to call it. The way i see, and it´s my opinion, there should be two kind of comics, the ones based on the films or toons and the mirage ones. Mirage version is kinda sacred for me, i`d rather seing a continuation of the mirageverse instead of a new take on that version.

I think that if they did a continuation of the Mirage run you would have to have 3 titles. In my opinion a continuation of the Mirage run would be niche to the Mirage fans but wouldn't necessarily bring in new fans.

For instance I would not be interested in that right now because I've never read the whole Mirage run. There is really no inexpensive way to acquire the whole run right now that I'm aware of.

plastroncafe
07-21-2015, 11:46 AM
Comixology has the IDW Reprints of the Mirage run at the same price as the new IDW series.

You could also check out your local library, which might have the old trades in circulation.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-21-2015, 11:51 AM
As a guy who loves the Mirage/Image TMNT, I have zero interest in any further Mirage stories unless/until somebody wraps up Volume 4.

Honestly (and I'm not trying to turn this into a Mirage-hate thread) it feels like Mirage TMNT has been reduced to Peter Laird's last stand against corporate TMNT and the (can't believe I'm saying this) multiverse. It stood on its own in its own little bubble, and it feels old, tired, and sad. My opinion would be kinder if Laird had any interest in finishing the volume, but he doesn't. It started off with some strong ideas, and some other interesting ideas, but then just... faded.

IDW and Nick are both doing exciting new things with TMNT while paying homage to old versions. Some of the things they've done I take issue with and dislike, but hey, at the end of the day, it's new and it's full of energy. I shouldn't expect to like everything about it. (There's also Platinum Dunes, but the less said about those motherf'ers the better.) Hell, even Andrew's "Odyssey", a non-licensed TMNT product, is doing exciting new things while paying homage to old versions. It's probably (I haven't read it yet) in the vein of what Mirage USED to be and SHOULD be.

Finally, I don't think Mirage TMNT could be continued without the involvement of a tiny group of people: Laird, Eastman, or Lawson. Maybe there are a few other names that could be added, but those three were the heart and soul of Mirage TMNT. Without them, there is no Mirage TMNT.

My two cents, although by volume, that might have added up closer to a nickel's worth...

neatoman
07-21-2015, 12:01 PM
Wheter or not associate the color coded masks with something you don't like is not really that important, they do serve an important function aside from making the toys more marketable.

Arguably the most fundamental problem with Mirage was that the four main characters were visually identical, when you couldn't see what weapon they were carrying (if they were carrying a weapon at all) it could easily lead to confusion if they weren't adressed by name. (And if you claim you have never been confused as to which was which, you're probably lying). Color coded masks might be the cheapest way of fixing this problem but unless you're color blind it really helps a lot.

Even if some future version of TMNT would go back to the all red masks for real, you'd still end up with some visual distinction between them. If not the masks then it would be body type, clothing or something else. I can understand people having a problem with pizza, Krang, the Technodrome, the Neutrinos, Bebop, Rocksteady, Hun, Angel, the Battle Nexus, Mondo Gecko, Slash, the 4Kids Foot Clan symbol or pretty much anything else taken from the cartoon, but the color coded masks being a problem? Seriously? Did anyone really expect them to permanently go back the one part of the Mirage comics that never stuck in anything else?

And if we're gonna be technical about this, Mirage printed most of it's material in black/white, so if you handed some Mirage issues with the covers ripped off to some person who wasn't aware of the red masks, he'd probably imagine the color coded masks in his head. The intention of the masks being red is virtually meaningless if there is no color to begin with.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-21-2015, 12:05 PM
Wheter or not associate the color coded masks with something you don't like is not really that important, they do serve an important function aside from making the toys more marketable.

Arguably the most fundamental problem with Mirage was that the four main characters were visually identical, when you couldn't see what weapon they were carrying (if they were carrying a weapon at all) it could easily lead to confusion if they weren't adressed by name. (And if you claim you have never been confused as to which was which, you're probably lying). Color coded masks might be the cheapest way of fixing this problem but unless you're color blind it really helps a lot.

Even if some future version of TMNT would go back to the all red masks for real, you'd still end up with some visual distinction between them. If not the masks then it would be body type, clothing or something else. I can understand people having a problem with pizza, Krang, the Technodrome, the Neutrinos, Bebop, Rocksteady, Hun, Angel, the Battle Nexus, Mondo Gecko, Slash, the 4Kids Foot Clan symbol or pretty much anything else taken from the cartoon, but the color coded masks being a problem? Seriously? Did anyone really expect them to permanently go back the one part of the Mirage comics that never stuck in anything else?

And if we're gonna be technical about this, Mirage printed most of it's material in black/white, so if you handed some Mirage issues with the covers ripped off to some person who wasn't aware of the red masks, he'd probably imagine the color coded masks in his head. The intention of the masks being red is virtually meaningless if there is no color to begin with.

Exactly.

I love the color-coded masks, and I prefer to collect the B&W Mirage whenever possible because I absolutely do see them as colored in my mind.

Candy Kappa
07-21-2015, 12:11 PM
(And if you claim you have never been confused as to which was which, you're probably lying)]

No, I am not ;)

But I can see why some would be.

spookycookies
07-21-2015, 12:38 PM
As a guy who loves the Mirage/Image TMNT, I have zero interest in any further Mirage stories unless/until somebody wraps up Volume 4.

Honestly (and I'm not trying to turn this into a Mirage-hate thread) it feels like Mirage TMNT has been reduced to Peter Laird's last stand against corporate TMNT and the (can't believe I'm saying this) multiverse. It stood on its own in its own little bubble, and it feels old, tired, and sad. My opinion would be kinder if Laird had any interest in finishing the volume, but he doesn't. It started off with some strong ideas, and some other interesting ideas, but then just... faded.

IDW and Nick are both doing exciting new things with TMNT while paying homage to old versions. Some of the things they've done I take issue with and dislike, but hey, at the end of the day, it's new and it's full of energy. I shouldn't expect to like everything about it. (There's also Platinum Dunes, but the less said about those motherf'ers the better.) Hell, even Andrew's "Odyssey", a non-licensed TMNT product, is doing exciting new things while paying homage to old versions. It's probably (I haven't read it yet) in the vein of what Mirage USED to be and SHOULD be.

Finally, I don't think Mirage TMNT could be continued without the involvement of a tiny group of people: Laird, Eastman, or Lawson. Maybe there are a few other names that could be added, but those three were the heart and soul of Mirage TMNT. Without them, there is no Mirage TMNT.

My two cents, although by volume, that might have added up closer to a nickel's worth...



Yeah good luck to the poor soul that tries to do anything in the mirage universe without tripping over Tales v2 and volume 4's unresolved stories. Honestly I wasn't a fan of how bleak and broken the TMNT felt when they went their separate ways. It lost something very important and I don't know if it even would be able to get it back. It really seems like Laird doesn't want to give it the send off it deserves but at least we have IDW's continuity.

I never understood why it was so important that they all wore red masks really. I prefer different colors but that's just me.

Zak The Neutrino
07-21-2015, 12:42 PM
Comixology has the IDW Reprints of the Mirage run at the same price as the new IDW series.

You could also check out your local library, which might have the old trades in circulation.

Call me old fashion but I'm not a fan of digital comics. I plan to buy the ultimate collection hardcovers soon but those don't have everything yet. I also get the color classics in my LCS pull box but again from my understanding those are missing issues and have many yet to be released.

My LCS got a full Mirage run a few months ago but the owner is a TMNT fan so he hasn't decided if he is going to sell it or keep it. I keep trying to get him to sell it as a full run. :tgrin:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-21-2015, 12:51 PM
Yeah good luck to the poor soul that tries to do anything in the mirage universe without tripping over Tales v2 and volume 4's unresolved stories. Honestly I wasn't a fan of how bleak and broken the TMNT felt when they went their separate ways. It lost something very important and I don't know if it even would be able to get it back. It really seems like Laird doesn't want to give it the send off it deserves but at least we have IDW's continuity.

I never understood why it was so important that they all wore red masks really. I prefer different colors but that's just me.

Actually, I think a lot of good stories can come out of the Turtles (temporarily) going their separate ways. It has just never been done that well.

The first few issues of Volume 2 do a great job, especially selling how lost and directionless Leonardo is as he has always found his identity in leading his brothers. On his own, what is he?

And Volume 3 did awesome things with Raphael on his own, leading the Foot Clan and trying to reform it and the Shredder's legacy.

Even Volume 4 was doing really interesting things with Michelangelo... tour guide, romance, alien prisoner of war. And all four of the Turtles going their separate ways after Splinter's death is thematically a great way of showing how they're sort of directionless and lost.

I would love to see IDW eventually send the four brothers off on their own, for no more than 12-18 months worth of issues and individual storylines, before reuniting them.

Andrew NDB
07-21-2015, 01:10 PM
Actually, I think a lot of good stories can come out of the Turtles (temporarily) going their separate ways. It has just never been done that well.

The first few issues of Volume 2 do a great job, especially selling how lost and directionless Leonardo is as he has always found his identity in leading his brothers. On his own, what is he?

And Volume 3 did awesome things with Raphael on his own, leading the Foot Clan and trying to reform it and the Shredder's legacy.

Even Volume 4 was doing really interesting things with Michelangelo... tour guide, romance, alien prisoner of war. And all four of the Turtles going their separate ways after Splinter's death is thematically a great way of showing how they're sort of directionless and lost.

You should give "Odyssey" a gander.

Andrew NDB
07-21-2015, 01:15 PM
"Rah! How dare they make use of a design aspect that has been in place for 30 years and prevents confusion over which character is which?!"

Seriously, the color coded masks bother you?

To no end. They're unnecessary, somewhat insulting to one's intelligence and borne only of an unapologetic Playmates-based need to make it easier for Little Tommy to tell Mommy which action figure he wants to buy.

They're supposed to be ninjas, part of a singular clan with a singular purpose (become badass and one day, kill Oroku Saki). They're not supposed to be making fashion statements, or concerning themselves with embracing individuality with mood ring colors or other rubbish. No, I don't care if you really, really love the Fred Wolf show when you were 5 and your buddy pretended to be the orange one and you were the blue one on the playground and them being all red tarnishing those happy memories.

And I'll throw this out there again: I challenged the board to produce any panels of anything with the Mirage TMNT where you literally couldn't tell which Turtle is which and to my recollection, no one could produce even one panel where it's ambiguous. Not even one panel, in 30+ years of comics. I think we can safely throw the "But I'll be unable to tell them apart!!! WHAT WILL WE DO?!?!?!" nonsense right out the window but I'm certain it'll just keep coming up ad nauseam every time a "Rainbow vs. Reds" debate comes up.

Sabacooza
07-21-2015, 01:22 PM
To no end. They're unnecessary, somewhat insulting to one's intelligence and borne only of an unapologetic Playmates-based need to make it easier for Little Tommy to tell Mommy which action figure he wants to buy.

They're supposed to be ninjas, part of a singular clan with a singular purpose (become badass and one day, kill Oroku Saki). They're not supposed to be making fashion statements, or concerning themselves with embracing individuality with mood ring colors or other rubbish. No, I don't care if you really, really love the Fred Wolf show when you were 5 and your buddy pretended to be the orange one and you were the blue one on the playground and them being all red tarnishing those happy memories.

And I'll throw this out there again: I challenged the board to produce any panels of anything with the Mirage TMNT where you literally couldn't tell which Turtle is which and to my recollection, no one could produce even one panel where it's ambiguous. Not even one panel, in 30+ years of comics. I think we can safely throw the "But I'll be unable to tell them apart!!! WHAT WILL WE DO?!?!?!" nonsense right out the window but I'm certain it'll just keep coming up ad nauseam every time a "Rainbow vs. Reds" debate comes up. I love the red bandanas myself but sometimes I wonder why they even wear red. It's an eye catching color and if you're a ninja, that's the last thing you'd want. Why not wear black?

Andrew NDB
07-21-2015, 01:24 PM
I love the red bandanas myself but sometimes I wonder why they even wear red. It's an eye catching color and if you're a ninja, that's the last thing you'd want.

They really ought to be black, if anything. Though a nice dark red seems more optimal to me than, say, bright baby blue or orange.

Candy Kappa
07-21-2015, 01:29 PM
stylistically crimson red looks really nice, but for a "realistic" approach, maroon would be more optimal, or dark navy.

Never black. Granted it's just a domino-esque bandana, but black really stands out in the dark. Black can be used in areas with no light sources, or outdoors when there are no moon up.

Bobby Curnow
07-21-2015, 01:43 PM
Not to derail this thread further, but I think the masks debate is always interesting.
In my mind, the colors don't matter at all. If the Turtles are seen, what people are going to remember seeing is four giant mutant Turtles. If they're doing their ninja job properly, they won't be seen, so what they wear shouldn't matter at all, other than functionality. (and masks on Turtles are functionally useless-- so it's just an aesthetics question.)
Since it's functionally useless, it's just a matter of one type of nostalgia versus another (Mirage vs. OT).

One can make the claim that they're a clan, and they should have a set uniform as a result, but I would counter that Yoshi has seen the evil that can arise from that mentality and chose to do something different with his 'clan' and embrace his sons individuality. That was Tom's reasoning that sold me on using the colored bandanas. Mirage is my favorite TMNT though, so I was skeptical for the same reasons Andrew is. As such, I can still see why the colored masks would rub some the wrong way.

Still hope we can do a "Year One" TMNT and revisit the all red for a longer period of time.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-21-2015, 01:49 PM
Not to derail this thread further, but I think the masks debate is always interesting.
In my mind, the colors don't matter at all. If the Turtles are seen, what people are going to remember seeing is four giant mutant Turtles. If they're doing their ninja job properly, they won't be seen, so what they wear shouldn't matter at all, other than functionality. (and masks on Turtles are functionally useless-- so it's just an aesthetics question.)
Since it's functionally useless, it's just a matter of one type of nostalgia versus another (Mirage vs. OT).

One can make the claim that they're a clan, and they should have a set uniform as a result, but I would counter that Yoshi has seen the evil that can arise from that mentality and chose to do something different with his 'clan' and embrace his sons individuality. That was Tom's reasoning that sold me on using the colored bandanas. Mirage is my favorite TMNT though, so I was skeptical for the same reasons Andrew is. As such, I can still see why the colored masks would rub some the wrong way.

Still hope we can do a "Year One" TMNT and revisit the all red for a longer period of time.

Now I want to see some TMNT designs that keep the colors but lose the masks. :tgrin:

Duke Nukem
07-21-2015, 02:16 PM
And I'll throw this out there again: I challenged the board to produce any panels of anything with the Mirage TMNT where you literally couldn't tell which Turtle is which and to my recollection, no one could produce even one panel where it's ambiguous. Not even one panel, in 30+ years of comics. I think we can safely throw the "But I'll be unable to tell them apart!!! WHAT WILL WE DO?!?!?!" nonsense right out the window but I'm certain it'll just keep coming up ad nauseam every time a "Rainbow vs. Reds" debate comes up.

We just discussed this a couple weeks ago, where in the Raph/Leo fight in return to New York, most of us had trouble in some panels telling which was which.

neatoman
07-21-2015, 02:24 PM
To no end. They're unnecessary, somewhat insulting to one's intelligence and borne only of an unapologetic Playmates-based need to make it easier for Little Tommy to tell Mommy which action figure he wants to buy.

They're supposed to be ninjas, part of a singular clan with a singular purpose (become badass and one day, kill Oroku Saki). They're not supposed to be making fashion statements, or concerning themselves with embracing individuality with mood ring colors or other rubbish. No, I don't care if you really, really love the Fred Wolf show when you were 5 and your buddy pretended to be the orange one and you were the blue one on the playground and them being all red tarnishing those happy memories.

And I'll throw this out there again: I challenged the board to produce any panels of anything with the Mirage TMNT where you literally couldn't tell which Turtle is which and to my recollection, no one could produce even one panel where it's ambiguous. Not even one panel, in 30+ years of comics. I think we can safely throw the "But I'll be unable to tell them apart!!! WHAT WILL WE DO?!?!?!" nonsense right out the window but I'm certain it'll just keep coming up ad nauseam every time a "Rainbow vs. Reds" debate comes up.

I think it's more likely they were either not interested in humoring your stupid challenge, or you simply just denied their arguments for why it was ambigious. But if you want an example, Tales volume 1, Issue 1, page 2. I got that one from just opening up a trade, I could give you more if you'd like.

spookycookies
07-21-2015, 02:52 PM
Actually, I think a lot of good stories can come out of the Turtles (temporarily) going their separate ways. It has just never been done that well.

The first few issues of Volume 2 do a great job, especially selling how lost and directionless Leonardo is as he has always found his identity in leading his brothers. On his own, what is he?

And Volume 3 did awesome things with Raphael on his own, leading the Foot Clan and trying to reform it and the Shredder's legacy.

Even Volume 4 was doing really interesting things with Michelangelo... tour guide, romance, alien prisoner of war. And all four of the Turtles going their separate ways after Splinter's death is thematically a great way of showing how they're sort of directionless and lost.

I would love to see IDW eventually send the four brothers off on their own, for no more than 12-18 months worth of issues and individual storylines, before reuniting them.


Oh Yeah I'm all for the Turtles going on their own adventures but they should always have a family and a home to come back to. There was an issue of Tales v2 that inferred that Mikey may have never returned from space leaving his family to wonder what ever happened to him, that just makes me feel so down. There's no problem individual growth and an interesting couple of solo turtle stories but Mirage shut their doors without bringing the brothers back together in any satisfying way.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-21-2015, 02:58 PM
Oh Yeah I'm all for the Turtles going on their own adventures but they should always have a family and a home to come back to. There was an issue of Tales v2 that inferred that Mikey may have never returned from space leaving his family to wonder what ever happened to him, that just makes me feel so down. There's no problem individual growth and an interesting couple of solo turtle stories but Mirage shut their doors without bringing the brothers back together in any satisfying way.

Yeah, but Raph also had an inflatable April doll in that issue. Okay, she was a robot, but still...

The nice thing about a lot of the Volume 2 Tales issues is that you can cherry-pick which ones you like and which ones you prefer to ignore. Anything that involves the four Turtles eventually permanently parting as a family does not appeal to me.

Cryomancer
07-21-2015, 03:32 PM
The masks situation would have been less worrisome if they were just multicolor from the start, launching the comic with all red gave certain expectations and changing them shortly after seemed like a bad omen at the time.

Personally, I'd prefer it if they were multicolor/didn't wear them until some serious **** happens and then go all red during "wartime" or something but with IDW that seems like all the time anyway.

Sabacooza
07-21-2015, 04:07 PM
Like I said, I prefer red bandanas but it's not enough to prevent me from enjoying the series. It's really the only comic I have on my pull list that I'm excited to pick up every month.

spookycookies
07-21-2015, 05:27 PM
Yeah, but Raph also had an inflatable April doll in that issue. Okay, she was a robot, but still...

The nice thing about a lot of the Volume 2 Tales issues is that you can cherry-pick which ones you like and which ones you prefer to ignore. Anything that involves the four Turtles eventually permanently parting as a family does not appeal to me.

Yeah that isn't the kinda future I'd like to see for the Turtles. A big theme for TMNT has always been family and when that isn't embraced such as some of v4 and Tales v2 it can be disappointing.

Admittedly I'm a bigger fan of IDW's volume and a big part of that is the tight narrative where everything fits and fits well. I guess the Mirage advantage is like what you said you can cherry pick issues. It doesn't all have to count, so for a Mirage fan I could see them not appreciating how every issues pretty much counts for IDW.

ToTheNines
07-21-2015, 06:13 PM
And I'll throw this out there again: I challenged the board to produce any panels of anything with the Mirage TMNT where you literally couldn't tell which Turtle is which and to my recollection, no one could produce even one panel where it's ambiguous. Not even one panel, in 30+ years of comics. I think we can safely throw the "But I'll be unable to tell them apart!!! WHAT WILL WE DO?!?!?!" nonsense right out the window but I'm certain it'll just keep coming up ad nauseam every time a "Rainbow vs. Reds" debate comes up.

Tales of the TMNT vol. 1 #2 at the beginning is the only thing i can think of. The opening scene before they leave for Springfield.


Since it's functionally useless, it's just a matter of one type of nostalgia versus another (Mirage vs. OT).

Don't mean to ignore your other points, but I personally prefer the red bandanas... and I grew up with the OT, movies and 4kids show.

Probably never read Mirage until I was 16 or 17.

Powder
07-21-2015, 08:07 PM
Ditto, I came up on the rainbow brigade (& love it), but once I read the Mirage books when I was about 18/19, I was sold on the all red look forever after.

Cryomancer
07-21-2015, 08:25 PM
Yep, same here, but something like in my 20s when I finally read Mirage. I don't really care either way, but if given the choice, the matching is my preference.

Joey Kamikaze
07-21-2015, 08:40 PM
I can never tell them apart in the Mirage books unless they have their weapons. For example, that bit where Leo and Raph fight at beginning of Return to NY does nothing for me because I can't tell what the hell is going on.

It's not about whether you can eventually puzzle out which turtle is which by going through the pages and trying to keep track, it's whether or not you can know instantly just by looking.

Leo656
07-22-2015, 12:05 AM
:lol: This sh*t again.

plastroncafe
07-22-2015, 10:44 AM
I can never tell them apart in the Mirage books unless they have their weapons. For example, that bit where Leo and Raph fight at beginning of Return to NY does nothing for me because I can't tell what the hell is going on.

It's not about whether you can eventually puzzle out which turtle is which by going through the pages and trying to keep track, it's whether or not you can know instantly just by looking.

Or whether a person is capable of following the narrative flow of a scene...

Klunk1234
07-29-2015, 11:13 PM
The reincarnation origin is more stupid than the Platinum Dunes movies origin.

You're totally mistaken. The reincarnation origin make the IDW TMNT comics more interesting. Otherwise, they would have never been released to the public.

Powder
07-30-2015, 12:02 AM
You're totally mistaken. The reincarnation origin make the IDW TMNT comics more interesting. Otherwise, they would have never been released to the public.

It's his opinion, he can't be mistaken. I disagree with him but it's his right to feel that way.

CyberCubed
07-30-2015, 12:11 AM
You're totally mistaken. The reincarnation origin make the IDW TMNT comics more interesting. Otherwise, they would have never been released to the public.

What do you mean by, "never been released to the public?" IDW got the license for TMNT before they even knew what direction they would go with it.

Klunk1234
07-30-2015, 12:16 AM
What do you mean by, "never been released to the public?" IDW got the license for TMNT before they even knew what direction they would go with it.

Well, true. I mean if the comic would have been a failure after a few weeks of release.

Rooish
07-30-2015, 07:33 PM
There are plenty of moments in Mirage where you can't tell who is who; mostly this occurred when the artist didn't seem to care either.

You may think you can tell but you don't know who the artist/writer was intending because it doesn't say.

Particularly in the earlier writing where all the Turtles were kind of bravado and goofy.

For example, in one of the Tales Vol 1 issues, the All Hallows Eve one, the old TMNT website was saying it was Don who went downstairs to check what the crashing was. I would have thought Mike, and apparently so did the 4kids series. You can't tell.

Whenever Eastman did anything and there were no weapons, forget it.