View Full Version : What do you think about different skin-colored TMNT?
Andrew NDB
07-26-2015, 03:31 PM
Let's forget the bandanna color debate, that's a separate matter. But when I think about it, I think the different skin-colored TMNT that seems to be being pushed as the norm is even more ridiculous and insulting to one's intelligence than that whole matter.
Red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors. And even if there were, if these guys are supposed to be brothers, from the same Mama Turtle...? I think in IDW they're supposed to be sea turtles but even with those I'm pretty sure there's no disparity within a single batch of eggs.
It's like literally, even factoring out the always-asinine letters on the belts thing (and nothing is more insulting than having the letters on the belts AND different skin colors), TPTB are telling you, "We don't trust you to be able to recognize which Turtle is which because of the weapons they're carrying, or their body types, or even their individualized rainbow bandanna colors... we need to give them different skin colors so you can really, really tell them apart."
neatoman
07-26-2015, 03:59 PM
Uh-huh, why do have such a problem with trying to make them seem less like clones of each other? Can't you accept that most people get confused by four visually identical characters? There's a reason Ben Reilly dyed his hair and Evil Spock had a beard.
As for the skin colors, they're mutants. Who cares if red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors in real-life, they don't really resemble that species after the mutation. They're not always red-earred sliders either, in the IDW series they're sea turtles and in the 4Kids cartoon it appears they were tortoises.
PangolinFeets
07-26-2015, 04:01 PM
Or to give them more personality? I like the newer designs where they're pretty different-looking. I don't think it's hand-holding.
Duke Nukem
07-26-2015, 04:31 PM
I doubt it was designed to make it easier to tell them apart in comics and film as much as making the toys look as different as possible so that people were more likely to buy all four of them.
Edit: Also:
5HidBZCu58s
At around 1:20 "Hey man take yo light green ass to the next room!"
Powder
07-26-2015, 04:31 PM
I've always been a fan of it. I like the red-masked Playmates-skinned look. Best of both worlds IMO.
Leo656
07-26-2015, 04:33 PM
It kinda is a little bit hand-holding. Like Andrew said, it is kind of pandering. There's logically no reason at all they'd be different colors. Whether people like it or not isn't the issue. The point he's making is that realistically, it makes no sense at all, especially IF they're supposed to all be related.
It kinda doesn't bother me, but it's definitely a little odd. Anything, ever, where it's like, "So, why'd they do that?" "Eh, no reason. Just Looks Cool." I kinda hate that. I get annoyed by anything that can't justify itself. "Why's Batman have a thousand piped seams all over his costume now, even in places there wouldn't logically be seams?" "Eh, just looks cool." "Why'd that one wrestler do like 6 flips when he jumped off the top rope onto the other guy, why didn't he just drop an elbow on his sternum?" "Eh, just looks cool." I hate that sh*t. Not always, like, violently, but it's like, at least have a reason for things beyond "Why not?"
In this case I kind of don't care and I can live with it, but it's not how I personally would have done it. I always picture them the same color by default as there's no reason at all that they wouldn't be.
spookycookies
07-26-2015, 04:34 PM
The skin tones don't bother me, I mean they are mutants so I don't expect them to be 100% similar to any species of turtle. The initials on the their belt buckles was like a kiddy super hero thing that I don't expect to see outside of the original cartoon. I do like seeing them with individual gear but I wasn't a fan of the costumes they all had in the 2014 movie, it was too busy for me.
Andrew NDB
07-26-2015, 05:02 PM
Or to give them more personality?
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.
Leo656
07-26-2015, 05:07 PM
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.
https://aspoonfulofsuga.files.wordpress.com/2014/03/4b59915ecce0dee4bfa3f60680308695e4491ea42d23781bb3 f10bd043621643.jpg?w=620
I had to. :lol: The chance was NEVER going to come again in this lifetime.
PangolinFeets
07-26-2015, 05:28 PM
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.
:trolleye: We're talking about cartoon mutant turtles written by not-the-best writers*. It's not a new concept.
*To clarify, I thought this was the 2k3 cartoon thread. I do not think the comics are poorly written. Sorry Paul&IDW stafflurkers. :p
neatoman
07-26-2015, 05:37 PM
https://aspoonfulofsuga.files.wordpress.com/2014/03/4b59915ecce0dee4bfa3f60680308695e4491ea42d23781bb3 f10bd043621643.jpg?w=620
I had to. :lol: The chance was NEVER going to come again in this lifetime.
You know, Hulk Hogan has pretty dark skin himself...
Leo656
07-26-2015, 05:39 PM
I think that's why George Foreman's still his friend and forgave him. :tgrin:
PangolinFeets
07-26-2015, 06:00 PM
I think that's why George Foreman's still his friend and forgave him. :tgrin:
Now that's racist. :-X
(I had to look that up, actually. HH dropped a racial slur in a podcast and now WWE cut their ties with him? I'm surprised I didn't hear more about it.)
Getting back on topic, the turtles don't really look much like any specific turtle species to begin with so that argument against color variations doesn't really hold water. I've heard some version are based on based on RES, but have none of their features, aside from the physical turtle-y ones (Not to mention that I'm pretty sure there is some color variation among RES). I still think the best canon rational is that the mutagen has all sorts of weird properties that would mess with how they look.
Redeemer
07-26-2015, 06:02 PM
https://aspoonfulofsuga.files.wordpress.com/2014/03/4b59915ecce0dee4bfa3f60680308695e4491ea42d23781bb3 f10bd043621643.jpg?w=620
I had to. :lol: The chance was NEVER going to come again in this lifetime.
lol so awesome !!!!!!! :lol:
Leo656
07-26-2015, 06:05 PM
I usually excel at extremely dated jokes and references, so I figured I'd be topical for a change. :lol:
Candy Kappa
07-26-2015, 06:45 PM
I like that the Turtles have different skin color, cause y'know what. Turtles do have different skin color, it may not be as apparent for someone who's not used to seeing turtles often, but they do. Markings, color, size, shape, it's all unique.
One of my favorite designs have different skin color and body build on the Turtles, and that's the OotS version off the Turtles, not only that, but they also have more proper turtle markings which I'm a huge fan off. As they are supposed to be Red-Eared Sliders, which are not a very "mundane" colored turtle, they can be quite colorful in their youth.
And the vintage Playmates skin color paired up with the red masks is a very solid look too. I'm a sucker for Don's dark olive, almost brown skin color.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-26-2015, 07:01 PM
Personally, I don't like how each turtle has a drastically different skin tone than the other three. Or even when Mikey and Raph are darker green, and Leo and Don are lighter green.
I've always assumed four baby turtles from the same mother turtle, and these guys are TURTLES, not kittens. They should look pretty much the same.
And as a little kid, I was always confused by how Don was brown not green. I'd never seen any brown-skinned turtles. At least the other three were shades of green...
Jester
07-26-2015, 07:03 PM
The thing I always wonder is do we really know that the Turtles were from the same clutch of eggs? I mean they're pet shop turtles. Born and breed on a turtle farm. Can we say with certainty they all came from the same mama slider?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-26-2015, 07:44 PM
The thing I always wonder is do we really know that the Turtles were from the same clutch of eggs? I mean they're pet shop turtles. Born and breed on a turtle farm. Can we say with certainty they all came from the same mama slider?
Not really, because we do only first see them in a pet shop glass bowl.
But again, they are all the same breed of turtle. And turtles don't have the genetic diversity or cosmetic diversity or whatever the hell gives you a litter of kittens all black and white, calico, orange tabby, everything under the sun all from one mama.
qt.bangerang
07-26-2015, 08:45 PM
It doesn't bother me. I have a different skin tone then my 3 siblings and the 4 of us come from the same 2 parents...so why can't 4 mutant turtles whose father is a mutant rat have different skin tones?
Metalhead 2.0
07-26-2015, 09:25 PM
I haven't read all the other responses, but I don't remember reading anything in IDW to suggest that the 4 baby turtles all came from the same mother turtle. But I think the important thing to remember is that the mutagen is laced with human DNA, so between the injections being administered in the lab and the vial broken by the Foot they certainly could have come into contact with DNA of humans with varying skin tones leading to the differences in their own.
Rooish
07-26-2015, 09:39 PM
It always seemed weird to me, but maybe it was an attempt to give parents even more justification for buying four nearly identical toys?
Or to teach kids about respecting everyone regardless of race? Although they made the dorky one the black guy.
I never liked it much. It's best in the 2003 series, I feel.
And if the Turtles really are red eared sliders (I feel like only Murphy said that), they should have greyish green and yellow stripes anyway.
Cipher
07-26-2015, 10:23 PM
I have absolutely no problem with this, since they already fall pretty far from featuring the distinct features of any real-world turtles, which don't look identical to one another even if overall skin color isn't what separates them.
Personally, I've always thought this would be a fine compromise for keeping the red masks in a full-color comic, if another visual distinction must be had. Really doesn't bother me at all.
Mutant Ninja Anole
07-27-2015, 08:57 AM
One of the biggest problems the turtles have had since day one is differentiating between each other. It's something I constantly here, especially from mainstream sources, i.e. parents, movie reviewers, etc. The more variety you can add, the better, in my opinion.
member_removed
07-27-2015, 09:58 AM
The thing I always wonder is do we really know that the Turtles were from the same clutch of eggs? I mean they're pet shop turtles. Born and breed on a turtle farm. Can we say with certainty they all came from the same mama slider?
Over the years, I had always been curious to whether they were ninja "brothers" or biological siblings. I think the closest we've come to a direct answer was in the 2007 movie. When Mikey says the monster looks like Donnie’s mom. To which Donnie replies that would make her your mom too. But that's just one of many interpretations of the TMNT.
Today it doesn't bother me, but back in 1990 when I was youngster and collecting the Playmates figures it did bug me. It seemed like a cynical ploy to sell identical figures to our parents.
Sophie Campbell
07-27-2015, 10:29 AM
i like how there's no "i like/love it" poll option. oh, Andrew. ;)
personally i like the skin colors. i see a lot of talk about logic and realism (and aside from that real turtles actually DO have differing skin and markings, that's a real thing) i don't think there's any ILLOGICAL reason not to have the colors, either. the Turtles become more human when they mutate, they get teeth, they get human eyes, etc. they become humanoid to the point that the only really turtle trait they have is their shell. they're more human than turtle in my opinion, and all humans have visibly different skintones than one another, as opposed to the perhaps more subtle differentiations of real turtles, and even siblings and sometimes twins have complexions that differ from each other. if we're really bringing "science" and genetics into this rather than a purely artistic/design/style standpoint, then it seems more scientific and believable to me that they'd have different complexions.
neatoman
07-27-2015, 11:37 AM
I find it somewhat disturbing that there are people (or at least one person) who is seriously bothered by the idea of the turtles having different skin colors. I can see the argument against the color coded masks or the belt buckles, since these can be seen as very childish changes, but the color coded masks do help make the turtles easier tell apart so I don't mind it (and the belt buckles have been ignored for about two decades now so who cares?).
The skin colors seems like way too much of a purist thing to complain about however. I mean seriously, making them different shades of green? Why would that bother anyone in their right mind? They're still frickin' green! I mean Jesus Christ, what's the next thing to complain about? The fact that people have started giving them different heights?
Need I point out that there has been far less subtle ways of differentiating the turtles?
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/37/3.jpghttps://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/09/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_film_July_2014_poster .jpghttp://g.cz/sites/default/files/g/2014/05/cyboer.jpghttp://www.tribalpages.com/tpphotos/fullphotos24/shul_246015.jpghttp://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/8/8f/Don,Future_Leo,Future_Raph_and_Future_Mikey_1.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20091205223941
Andrew NDB
07-27-2015, 11:53 AM
Need I point out that there has been far less subtle ways of differentiating the turtles?
All of which unnecessary.
neatoman
07-27-2015, 12:02 PM
All of which unnecessary.
Right, ripping out Raph's eye or turning Don into a giant cyborg is of course overkill. But most people don't share your notion that four visually identical characters is perfectly fine, wheter you like it or not there will always be attempts at making them look different.
So with that considered, aren't you happy that skin colors and color coded masks are what stuck, instead of gamera mutations and chopped off arms?
plastroncafe
07-27-2015, 12:40 PM
You want to go realistic?
Let's go realistic.
Slider markings are specific to an individual, with no two looking exactly the same. Saying that they should all look exactly the same is also akin to the racist:
All [blank] look alike to me.
Plasticplayhouse
07-27-2015, 01:09 PM
doesnt bother me either way. i'm ok with a little color variation.
Lordmylar06
07-27-2015, 01:33 PM
I've actually seen red eared sliders with differing skin tones. Darkness of the skin in sliders is caused by age. The older one is, usually the darker the tone. This isn't so true for sliders in captivity though. Also, the red ear markings can sometimes fade to an orange or more yellow tone over time.
That being said, differing skin tone due to age wouldn't apply to the TMNT as they were all around the same age.
I do however entertain the thought of red ear slider accurate skin on them. I think if done properly with a top notch colorist it could be beautiful.
neatoman
07-27-2015, 02:05 PM
You want to go realistic?
Let's go realistic.
Slider markings are specific to an individual, with no two looking exactly the same. Saying that they should all look exactly the same is also akin to the racist:
All [blank] look alike to me.
You don't even need to argue that, realism flies out the window when you remember it's a story about baby turtles who touched alien goop and turned into humanoids.
plastroncafe
07-27-2015, 02:27 PM
You don't even need to argue that, realism flies out the window when you remember it's a story about baby turtles who touched alien goop and turned into humanoids.
I felt I did in the face of the argument: Red-Eared Sliders have the same skin tone. Realism.
Commenter 42
07-27-2015, 02:38 PM
I think the different skin-colored TMNT that seems to be being pushed as the norm is even more ridiculous and insulting to one's intelligence than that whole matter.
Red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors. And even if there were, if these guys are supposed to be brothers, from the same Mama Turtle...?
I'm with you. It's true RES colors can vary a lot, but within a clutch, the variation is minimal. I'm a big fan of them looking almost identical. I'd be more comfortable with markings distinguishing them, if anything.
What really irritates me is when they are pushed as sea turtles. It makes absolutely no sense.
My biggest frustration is the "they're mutants" excuse, as in "they're mutants, who's to say they they wouldn't look like x,y,z?"
Bollocks.
I do however entertain the thought of red ear slider accurate skin on them. I think if done properly with a top notch colorist it could be beautiful.
Agreed. I doubt that day will ever come. :(. It would be cool though.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-27-2015, 03:21 PM
Right, ripping out Raph's eye or turning Don into a giant cyborg is of course overkill. But most people don't share your notion that four visually identical characters is perfectly fine, wheter you like it or not there will always be attempts at making them look different.
So with that considered, aren't you happy that skin colors and color coded masks are what stuck, instead of gamera mutations and chopped off arms?
I love the way you put that. :tlol: You have now won this debate, and I yield my former criticisms to this logic.
Bombshell
07-27-2015, 03:21 PM
I think its completely plausible for the four turtles to have different skin tones. If you look at turtles in a petstore, they all have different markings on them, even in the same species. The yellow stripes are different, even the red markings are different (for RES). Their shells are different and yes, skin tone is different. Pigment is what the specialty breeders look for when picking out what male and female to mate to achieve what color for color mutations.
I always liked the different color skin tone. It gives them individuality outside of their weapons and headbands. They're not the same, just like the petstore turtles are not the same. So in essence, they shouldn't look the same. Even scientific genetic clones have differences from their host animal, and they have identical dna!
Along with the differences every turtle has, throw in some human dna and you've got a huge color pallet to work with. My skin tone is different from my sister's skin tone and we have the same parents. Hers is pinkish while mine is a hint yellow. Its not a far cry to see that four sibling turtles from the same parents (if thats what they are) can have different markings and shades of skin tone.
Joey Kamikaze
07-27-2015, 03:42 PM
Obviously a serious about turtle mutants who battle Ninja clans and aliens should be as scientifically accurate as possible. As such, the four turtles should all look the same to us humans, not be able to hear or speak, and have gigantic penises (http://youtube.com/watch?v=aqW5upASa-8).
plastroncafe
07-27-2015, 03:45 PM
Turtles aren't deaf.
They have ears and everything.
Commenter 42
07-27-2015, 04:43 PM
Obviously a serious about turtle mutants who battle Ninja clans and aliens should be as scientifically accurate as possible. As such, the four turtles should all look the same to us humans, not be able to hear or speak, and have gigantic penises (http://youtube.com/watch?v=aqW5upASa-8).
That video is at most 10% accurate. The penis size is true of some species, not all. Salmonella is an issue as well. That's about it. Snappers, not res, have a worm shaped tongue. RES live 20-30 years, (longer out of captivity) not 200. Their shells can bleed they don't spontaneously bleed.
Also, most city dwelling animals are vectors for disease, not just rats. Humans are pretty high up there too, as are most livestock from factory farms. Proximity is the real problem.
But sure, hahaha...yep, this video is full of hilarious misnomers. Yippee for stupid.
PangolinFeets
07-27-2015, 04:44 PM
They might actually have the correct amount of fingers and toes too.
If anything, that's always been my pet peeve. Stylistically, it looks cool. But it makes no sense. (Ohwaitshit... They're mutants. :p)
Commenter 42
07-27-2015, 05:07 PM
I think its completely plausible for the four turtles to have different skin tones. If you look at turtles in a petstore, they all have different markings on them, even in the same species. The yellow stripes are different, even the red markings are different (for RES). Their shells are different and yes, skin tone is different. Pigment is what the specialty breeders look for when picking out what male and female to mate to achieve what color for color mutations.
I always liked the different color skin tone. It gives them individuality outside of their weapons and headbands. They're not the same, just like the petstore turtles are not the same. So in essence, they shouldn't look the same. Even scientific genetic clones have differences from their host animal, and they have identical dna!
Along with the differences every turtle has, throw in some human dna and you've got a huge color pallet to work with. My skin tone is different from my sister's skin tone and we have the same parents. Hers is pinkish while mine is a hint yellow. Its not a far cry to see that four sibling turtles from the same parents (if thats what they are) can have different markings and shades of skin tone.
Yeah, but again though, they are supposedly from the same clutch. What you see in the pet store are not often from the same clutch, and if their markings are that different, they may not even be of the same species. There are hundreds of species. The human influence in their genetic make up is from a single donor, not two humans mating. There's also the possibility that the mutagen itself is a chemical compound that simply activates certain genes in the turtle itself, and the human component is meaningless.
plastroncafe
07-27-2015, 05:11 PM
You're speaking specifically about Cartoon Canon, because in Mirage Canon there's no "human DNA" to be considered.
Also...there's no specific mention in Mirage canon about the turtles being from the same clutch at all, or at least there isn't to my knowledge. Can someone provide evidence to the contrary?
Short of a DNA test there's no real way to know whether or not they're genetically related, not that it should matter. They were raised as brothers and that right there is enough.
Powder
07-27-2015, 05:26 PM
The adoptive family theme has been in every iteration from day one, blood relation has never mattered & it should remain that way (barring the IDW reincarnation angle).
Jester
07-27-2015, 05:36 PM
Short of a DNA test there's no real way to know whether or not they're genetically related, not that it should matter. They were raised as brothers and that right there is enough.
The adoptive family theme has been in every iteration from day one, blood relation has never mattered & it should remain that way (barring the IDW reincarnation angle).
Exactly why i bring it up. I LOVE the adoptive family aspect of the TMNT and it always makes me wince when people argue that they have to be genetically related....I'm looking at you Next Mutation Leo.
neatoman
07-27-2015, 05:44 PM
The adoptive family theme has been in every iteration from day one, blood relation has never mattered & it should remain that way (barring the IDW reincarnation angle).
Well it is questionable if they're a family in the Fred Wolf cartoon (the last couple of episodes I watched they never used any stronger words than "Buds" to describe their relationship to each other) but it does tend to be prominent.
Powder
07-27-2015, 05:46 PM
Splinter does call them "My sons" at one point or another, at least I think so. Either way, whether or not certain terms are used, they live as a family & love each other.
Commenter 42
07-27-2015, 06:05 PM
Exactly why i bring it up. I LOVE the adoptive family aspect of the TMNT and it always makes me wince when people argue that they have to be genetically related....I'm looking at you Next Mutation Leo.
If they are related, then they should look almost identical, (except for markings, of course) and while they may exhibit other attributes of differentiation (shell length and symmetry, overall size) they would look quite similar, barring any extreme melanistic traits.
If not, then it doesn't matter, clearly, and they could even be of varying species. The overarching point, I think, is the need to differentiate them by color at all. It's somewhat insulting, as it suggests the audience is too feeble minded to distinguish each brother on their own (OT's young audience excluded of course).
Jester
07-27-2015, 06:32 PM
Splinter does call them "My sons" at one point or another, at least I think so. Either way, whether or not certain terms are used, they live as a family & love each other.
He says, "My sons" a couple times, he even calls them Donatello's "Brother Turtles" in an episode. I know one of the episodes where the Turtles get de-aged, the younger Turtles call the teen-aged ones big brothers....but I think they call Splinter an uncle....eek.
Cryomancer
07-27-2015, 06:44 PM
I can go either way on this. As a ninja clan, it makes sense for them to be essentially clones, appearance wise. Like it's their uniform. There are also things you could, potentially, do with it in a story, like if someone thinks they have one turtle captured but really it's another.
But Mirage is also quite focused on it's adoptive family aspect, and being straight up different colors from each other would probably reinforce that further. Obviously it was a toys / tell them apart method, and I doubt the people that decided that thought beyond that, but this also has the happy side effect of giving kids a TV show where a bunch of dudes with different skin colors consider themselves equal brothers and never once even mention it.
Joey Kamikaze
07-27-2015, 10:57 PM
My head canon for the old universes were that Leo and Raph would be genetically brothers. Because of course they are.
Commenter 42
07-27-2015, 11:22 PM
I think there's something interesting in the 4 of them being almost identical. It reinforces that who they are matters over what they look like.
I also agree it would be a useful psychological mind f*ck in battle.
Leo656
07-28-2015, 12:09 AM
Yeah, I've leaned on both of those ideas briefly back in my ficcin' days. :lol:
I'unno... I mostly see them as the original movie versions. Different enough to tell them apart pretty easily, but still close enough so that at a glance or if they switched gear you might take a second to figure it out. I don't have a big problem exactly when they're given a lot of clearly distinguishing physical characteristics, but I don't find it at all necessary, either. I just don't find it plausible, for some reason, that they'd look that much different from each other post-mutation. And from there it just goes back into wanting a better reason than "Why Not?" to just go ahead and do that.
I get it, it's fake, but I like a little verisimilitude in my stories, too. "Well, why CAN'T they look different?" I'unno. Why would they? It just goes back and forth. Me, I think it's more likely they'd look similar.
Doesn't "break" anything if they do look a lot different, I just think it's kind of an arbitrary thing to do.
MsMarvelDuckie
07-28-2015, 12:49 AM
Red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors. And even if there were, if these guys are supposed to be brothers, from the same Mama Turtle...? I think in IDW they're supposed to be sea turtles but even with those I'm pretty sure there's no disparity within a single batch of eggs.
Au contrare. As others have pointed out, there are variations, even between clutch-mates. It doesn't take much digging to find plenty of different color and marking variations in RES's, up to and including rare pigment mutations such as melanism or albinism- EVEN IN THE SAME CLUTCH! You can get individuals with very dark or light pigment, or changes in the red patch, etc, even with the same parents- because markings and shell size, pigmentation, and even how high the shell's keel is are all determined by the genes of the parents.
I like that the Turtles have different skin color, cause y'know what. Turtles do have different skin color, it may not be as apparent for someone who's not used to seeing turtles often, but they do. Markings, color, size, shape, it's all unique.
One of my favorite designs have different skin color and body build on the Turtles, and that's the OotS version off the Turtles, not only that, but they also have more proper turtle markings which I'm a huge fan off. As they are supposed to be Red-Eared Sliders, which are not a very "mundane" colored turtle, they can be quite colorful in their youth.
^This.
I've always assumed four baby turtles from the same mother turtle, and these guys are TURTLES, not kittens. They should look pretty much the same.
And as a little kid, I was always confused by how Don was brown not green. I'd never seen any brown-skinned turtles. At least the other three were shades of green...
So maybe Donnie had more melanin pigment in his skin? It can happen. No two animals of ANY species are ever exactly the same, except in the rare case of identical twins. Heck, in some cases, animals of drastically different appearance can be born into the same litter/clutch, whatever. And reptiles are also prone to the odd phenomenon of Siamese twinning, more so than most animals. See also: two-headed turtles, conjoined turtles, etc....
Not really, because we do only first see them in a pet shop glass bowl.
But again, they are all the same breed of turtle. And turtles don't have the genetic diversity or cosmetic diversity or whatever the hell gives you a litter of kittens all black and white, calico, orange tabby, everything under the sun all from one mama.
Here's the thing, though. Female cats are notorious for breeding with multiple males, so those same kittens may NOT even all have the same father! The mother's genes are only HALF the story. And it's the same with turtles.
i like how there's no "i like/love it" poll option. oh, Andrew. ;)
personally i like the skin colors. i see a lot of talk about logic and realism (and aside from that real turtles actually DO have differing skin and markings, that's a real thing) i don't think there's any ILLOGICAL reason not to have the colors, either. the Turtles become more human when they mutate, they get teeth, they get human eyes, etc. they become humanoid to the point that the only really turtle trait they have is their shell. they're more human than turtle in my opinion, and all humans have visibly different skintones than one another, as opposed to the perhaps more subtle differentiations of real turtles, and even siblings and sometimes twins have complexions that differ from each other. if we're really bringing "science" and genetics into this rather than a purely artistic/design/style standpoint, then it seems more scientific and believable to me that they'd have different complexions.
I love this! A purely realistic approach, and it really DOES make perfect sense for why they would all be so different.
I've actually seen red eared sliders with differing skin tones. Darkness of the skin in sliders is caused by age. The older one is, usually the darker the tone. This isn't so true for sliders in captivity though. Also, the red ear markings can sometimes fade to an orange or more yellow tone over time.
That being said, differing skin tone due to age wouldn't apply to the TMNT as they were all around the same age.
I do however entertain the thought of red ear slider accurate skin on them. I think if done properly with a top notch colorist it could be beautiful.
Absolutely. I have this personal head-canon that they DO have faint markings remaining, but the most obvious one (the red patch) is always covered by the masks. The rest have just faded so much that they're barely visible except on VERY close inspection. And perhaps they simply had two very differently toned parents, thus the disparity.
I'm with you. It's true RES colors can vary a lot, but within a clutch, the variation is minimal. I'm a big fan of them looking almost identical. I'd be more comfortable with markings distinguishing them, if anything.
What really irritates me is when they are pushed as sea turtles. It makes absolutely no sense.
Not necessarily. If the parents are very different from each other (ie if one is an albino or very dark, for instance) then you could very well get several distinct color variations, depending on the genetic lottery of how the DNA fell.
As for the sea turtle thing, I agree. I don't even know how ANYONE thinks the IDW TMNT were ever sea turtles, since they are clearly in a freshwater semi-aquatic terrarium!
I think its completely plausible for the four turtles to have different skin tones. If you look at turtles in a petstore, they all have different markings on them, even in the same species. The yellow stripes are different, even the red markings are different (for RES). Their shells are different and yes, skin tone is different. Pigment is what the specialty breeders look for when picking out what male and female to mate to achieve what color for color mutations.
I always liked the different color skin tone. It gives them individuality outside of their weapons and headbands. They're not the same, just like the petstore turtles are not the same. So in essence, they shouldn't look the same. Even scientific genetic clones have differences from their host animal, and they have identical dna!
Along with the differences every turtle has, throw in some human dna and you've got a huge color pallet to work with. My skin tone is different from my sister's skin tone and we have the same parents. Hers is pinkish while mine is a hint yellow. Its not a far cry to see that four sibling turtles from the same parents (if thats what they are) can have different markings and shades of skin tone.
Exactly!
That video is at most 10% accurate. The penis size is true of some species, not all. Salmonella is an issue as well. That's about it. Snappers, not res, have a worm shaped tongue. RES live 20-30 years, (longer out of captivity) not 200. Their shells can bleed they don't spontaneously bleed.
Also, most city dwelling animals are vectors for disease, not just rats. Humans are pretty high up there too, as are most livestock from factory farms. Proximity is the real problem.
But sure, hahaha...yep, this video is full of hilarious misnomers. Yippee for stupid.
Oh, thank the gods that someone else saw that video for the idiocy that it truly is!
Yeah, but again though, they are supposedly from the same clutch. What you see in the pet store are not often from the same clutch, and if their markings are that different, they may not even be of the same species. There are hundreds of species. The human influence in their genetic make up is from a single donor, not two humans mating. There's also the possibility that the mutagen itself is a chemical compound that simply activates certain genes in the turtle itself, and the human component is meaningless.
I notice no one has mentioned hybridizing. There are at least four different subspecies of Slider, of which the RES is only one. There are also the yellow-bellied, the Cumberland, and the Puerto Rican, and apparently there are several other subspecies that are only semi-recognized, but all can interbreed, and each is distinct from the others. SO if the mama was a typical RES but the father was, say, a yellow-belly, then there could indeed be some big differences in the four!
Commenter 42
07-28-2015, 03:07 AM
So maybe Donnie had more melanin pigment in his skin? It can happen. No two animals of ANY species are ever exactly the same, except in the rare case of identical twins. Heck, in some cases, animals of drastically different appearance can be born into the same litter/clutch, whatever. And reptiles are also prone to the odd phenomenon of Siamese twinning, more so than most animals. See also: two-headed turtles, conjoined turtles, etc....
Not necessarily. If the parents are very different from each other (ie if one is an albino or very dark, for instance) then you could very well get several distinct color variations, depending on the genetic lottery of how the DNA fell.
As for the sea turtle thing, I agree. I don't even know how ANYONE thinks the IDW TMNT were ever sea turtles, since they are clearly in a freshwater semi-aquatic terrarium!
I think they were drawn with flippers in IDW, IIRC...
I notice no one has mentioned hybridizing. There are at least four different subspecies of Slider, of which the RES is only one. There are also the yellow-bellied, the Cumberland, and the Puerto Rican, and apparently there are several other subspecies that are only semi-recognized, but all can interbreed, and each is distinct from the others. SO if the mama was a typical RES but the father was, say, a yellow-belly, then there could indeed be some big differences in the four!
It's really hard to find good information on the subspecies of sliders beyond the ones you've mentioned.
I think, barring the sort of breeding that intentionally drives high color sliders, or caramels, (both of which are not often found in the wild precisely due to their high visibility, and thus not surviving through to adulthood) You'd have to admit, to the likely hood of drastic variation is small, especially if we take time and place into account (15 years ago from today, or as far back as 15 years prior to 1984.) Hybridization wasn't, to my knowledge, a big thing. Sure, the parents may have been two sub sliders...I'll give you that, but I again defer to Andrews point; NONE of this was the reason behind the different tones of green, it all exists for marketing purposes, nothing more, and in the larger sense is very much a statement about the audience.
I get what you and Candy Mean about variation - I see it, but to the non-Herp, when you see a mature clutch together, it looks like this:
http://www.redearedslider.net/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/lot-of-red-ear-sliders.jpg
We can tell them apart, but will most people?
And the emerald green is long gone. They don't look like this as teens:
http://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/1c/b6/a7/1cb6a730809187770a33f89af2fc18ab.jpg
the toy variation is more like this:
http://www.theturtlesource.com/turtleContainer/GHOSTCOMPARISON.jpg
Which you'd be hard pressed to find in the average clutch together.
neatoman
07-28-2015, 04:00 AM
If we're going to go by what RES turtles look like in real life, we can clearly see a number of flaws in the design of the TMNT within the Mirage continuity:
Why do they have teeth?
Why do they have three thick fingers and two thick toes instead of five claws on each hand and foot?
Why are their tails so thick?
Why isn't their skin striped?
And why don't they have red markings on their heads?
Pointing out the lack of accuracy to the RES species to argue against different skin colors doesn't really work when the general design isn't very accurate to begin with.
Commenter 42
07-28-2015, 05:15 AM
If we're going to go by what RES turtles look like in real life, we can clearly see a number of flaws in the design of the TMNT within the Mirage continuity:
Why do they have teeth?
Why do they have three thick fingers and two thick toes instead of five claws on each hand and foot?
Why are their tails so thick?
Why isn't their skin striped?
And why don't they have red markings on their heads?
Pointing out the lack of accuracy to the RES species to argue against different skin colors doesn't really work when the general design isn't very accurate to begin with.
You're absolutely correct, except that when asked on numerous occasions, Laird has always said that they were indeed RES, so it's an issue for sure. He's also said that they didn't have much in the way of reference material whenthey were in the creation process.
Laird's general response to the number of fingers, seems to be "we thought it would be neat and goofy!"
Sooo, I guess you could take it up with them? :lol::lol:
Cryomancer
07-28-2015, 02:18 PM
They were smart putting mutant in the title, any and all physical questions can be answered with "well, they are mutants".
Candy Kappa
07-28-2015, 07:53 PM
Why do they have three thick fingers and two thick toes instead of five claws on each hand and foot?
Their heel is actually the third toe, very much like X-Men's Nightcrawler. The pseudo-heel was also at one point able to grip things, stated in the Solson's How to Drawn the TMNT book. But to my recollection it's never been used and was probably scrapped (but kept in the character sheets) alongside with other traits such as the retractable claws.
http://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--kG6NwGEh--/c_fit,fl_progressive,q_80,w_636/vubqxxwur9ou6eku5khc.jpg
Rooish
07-28-2015, 08:38 PM
LOL! I would love if they had retractable claws. That's awesome.
I think the third toe thing was seriously scrapped before it was implemented, along with the claws.
I still don't get why everyone is so insistent they are red eared sliders. They never as baby pre mutated Turtles look like red eared sliders. Nor do they currently. It was just something Steve Murphy made up one time. And he made up a lot of things.
Andrew NDB
07-28-2015, 08:52 PM
I still don't get why everyone is so insistent they are red eared sliders. They never as baby pre mutated Turtles look like red eared sliders. Nor do they currently. It was just something Steve Murphy made up one time. And he made up a lot of things.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2013/01/ask-pl-10.html
"To which species or sub species of testudines do the TMNT belong? My understanding is that they were red eared sliders, but in recent IDW books they have been called terrapins and box turtles, (even though they were drawn with flippers). As IDW isn't really cannon - i'd like to hear your take!
b) Are all four turtles of the SAME species, from the same clutch, and if not how do they differ?
Peter Laird: I'll answer these two together. First, I have no firm idea what species the Turtles are. Kevin and I never thought that deeply about this particular aspect of the characters. I think we just assumed they were your classic pet shop turtles -- and I think those are red-eared sliders, usually. Second, whether all four of the Turtles are from the same species or clutch of eggs… well, see my answer to the first part."
Yes, there's the Murphy revelation in the comics flat out that they're red-earred sliders. But coupled with Laird's comments and the fact that we see them as red-earred sliders in the original Steve Barron TMNT movie (which is supposedly so faithful to Mirage), it seems fairly a given. And I'm fairly certain I've been both Laird and Eastman pipe that the Turtles were intended to be brothers both in function and genetically. The only exception was NT:TNM.
Jester
07-28-2015, 08:57 PM
So....you get that from, "I dunna, never really gave it that much thought..."
Commenter 42
07-28-2015, 09:01 PM
They were RES in the 1990 film pre-mutation, and PDMT. If you look at the anatomical poster in Donnies lab on the Nick show, it appears to be a RES.
So, just a few more examples beyond that pannel with Donnie from Mirage.
I think Eastman called them box turtles, and they were called box turtles in IDW, but had flippers, and Sacks referred to them as box turtles, even though they used RES in the shots.
Retractable claws are stupid, as is the hind toe/claw.
Rooish
07-28-2015, 10:16 PM
So....you get that from, "I dunna, never really gave it that much thought..."
Ha that's what I saw him saying too! It's like the other eternal questions, are the turtles blood related and what's the age order, where Kevin and Peter just did not care and only after much pressuring and questioning came to any belief system. Kevin can't even remember which turtle has "always" been his favourite.
Andrew NDB
07-28-2015, 11:47 PM
Retractable claws are stupid, as is the hind toe/claw.
I'd say those things sound stupid to me now, but had they been established and developed from the start we'd probably be singing a different tune now. Given the Mirage mutagen seemed to be more about "hyper-evolution" than any kind of a human DNA mix, I could buy that they might get retractable claws and hind claw as such.
Cryomancer
07-28-2015, 11:56 PM
They would be cool if they were there to be natural ninja tools for them. Like they used the claws as climbing tools and the feet would let them "stand" upright on poles and stuff by wrapping around them, or maybe even hold a weapon.
That's one of those things that is almost never mentioned, how being turtles actually helps them being ninjas. Hell the movies might have had the most of that out of anything, since they crushed enemies with their shells at least once. Other than that all I can think of is head-retracting and that was pretty much always a joke and is the most biologically dubious of their potential turtle "moves". I can't even recall a moment where them being shorter/smaller than a human was particularly advantageous.
I'm indifferent about it. I like and agree with both sides of the arguments. On the other hand I never actually think of the turtles as biological brothers.
Andrew NDB
07-29-2015, 12:22 AM
I'm indifferent about it. I like and agree with both sides of the arguments. On the other hand I never actually think of the turtles as biological brothers.
I've never doubted it. And it's been implicitly stated by TPTB for eons now.
And it'd be pretty weird if one pet shop suddenly, inexplicably, adopted 4 baby red earred slider hatchlings of precisely the same dimension and size all simultaneously. And they were from different Mama Turtles. To suggest otherwise really only suits one mileau... NT:TNM, where TPTB decided all of the Turtles needed to be trying to have sex with Venus DeMilo every episode.
Commenter 42
07-29-2015, 12:25 AM
I'd say those things sound stupid to me now, but had they been established and developed from the start we'd probably be singing a different tune now.
That, I can agree with. :lol:
Given the Mirage mutagen seemed to be more about "hyper-evolution" than any kind of a human DNA mix, I could buy that they might get retractable claws and hind claw as such.
I only think it's stupid because felines are the only animals with retractable claws.
Retractable claws are cool as a concept for a reptilian monster, or an imaginary creature idea - something based purely on fantasy.
The back claw/retractable claws/teeth/3 fingers/ they all look really cool, until you try to explain it.
I still love the designs (early Mirage especially) for what they are, so you're not wrong, I am a hypocrite, sure.
I don't know, I still feel that if it's not chelonian or human, it has no business being in the design? :lol: yep, Crazy town! :)
I also like to look up research that validates the possibility of the premise. How could Splinter learn Ninjitsu? Articles like this one (http://phys.org/news/2015-02-evolving-bigger-brain-human-dna.html)
concerning rodents, human DNA, and brain development seem to validate the idea.
Kendamu
07-29-2015, 01:33 AM
I don't really care one way or the other. Similar to how Eastman and Laird didn't think that deeply into what exact species of turtle our Turtles are, I don't really think that deeply about their skin tones nor do I think that they exist primarily because some industry people think that the audience is stupid.
I think getting worked up over it is pretty dumb, actually, but I'm no authority on what you should and shouldn't lose sleep over.
MsMarvelDuckie
07-29-2015, 01:58 AM
I think they were drawn with flippers in IDW, IIRC...
It's really hard to find good information on the subspecies of sliders beyond the ones you've mentioned.
I think, barring the sort of breeding that intentionally drives high color sliders, or caramels, (both of which are not often found in the wild precisely due to their high visibility, and thus not surviving through to adulthood) You'd have to admit, to the likely hood of drastic variation is small, especially if we take time and place into account (15 years ago from today, or as far back as 15 years prior to 1984.) Hybridization wasn't, to my knowledge, a big thing. Sure, the parents may have been two sub sliders...I'll give you that, but I again defer to Andrews point; NONE of this was the reason behind the different tones of green, it all exists for marketing purposes, nothing more, and in the larger sense is very much a statement about the audience.
I get what you and Candy mean about variation - I see it, but to the non-Herp, when you see a mature clutch together, it looks like this:
http://www.redearedslider.net/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/lot-of-red-ear-sliders.jpg
We can tell them apart, but will most people?
And the emerald green is long gone. They don't look like this as teens:
http://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/1c/b6/a7/1cb6a730809187770a33f89af2fc18ab.jpg
the toy variation is more like this:
http://www.theturtlesource.com/turtleContainer/GHOSTCOMPARISON.jpg
Which you'd be hard pressed to find in the average clutch together.
Well, since they DID come from a pet shop, it's far more likely that the breeders were trying for color variations, as the more rare ones sell for higher. Incidentally, that sort of breeding has been around for a lot longer than you'd think. I know of at least one instance (a python, mind, but he was around for a LONG time, even before the TMNT!) who has been in high demand as a breeder for YEARS due to his size and notoriety. (His name was Excalibur and he has been in at least two movies, and numerous magazines and other media.) Though he LOOKED like any other ball python, his genes included color mutations for lavender, albino, and yellow varieties, piebalds, and even some pure white. His offspring (and theirs) have gone for upwards of 2-6 thousand $. Not kidding. Turtle (and fish!) breeders have been doing the same thing for decades now. I tried it myself with bettas back when I was a kid. And this was around the same time as TMNT were big, mind you.
And while we're on the subject, pet shops USUALLY get their stock from only one or two local breeders of a particular species, so what they have is more than likely all from the same genetic stock. Which means they are quite likely to all have the same parents if they are shipped together. (Because any breeder knows that it's a BAD idea to put larger/older animals in with smaller/younger ones, due to competition and the occasional urge to cannibalize.) So the TMNT very likely WERE all from the same mother! (Though it's possible she mated with more than one male.)
If we're going to go by what RES turtles look like in real life, we can clearly see a number of flaws in the design of the TMNT within the Mirage continuity:
Why do they have teeth?
Why do they have three thick fingers and two thick toes instead of five claws on each hand and foot?
Why are their tails so thick?
Why isn't their skin striped?
And why don't they have red markings on their heads?
Pointing out the lack of accuracy to the RES species to argue against different skin colors doesn't really work when the general design isn't very accurate to begin with.
I think I can answer at least the tails question- they're males. Male turtles have longer and thicker tails, to house the- well, you know. So humanoid turtles = big thick tails- if they're as anatomically proportionate as I think they are....
As for the red marks- how do we KNOW they don't have them? The original comics were black and white, and in the movies they are always covered on that part of the head by the bandanas. True, the cartoons and IDW don't have them, but they COULD if the artists chose to. I think that would actually be kind of cool to show that they still have them. I've seen some fan-art that has them, and it looks really stunning visually.
You're absolutely correct, except that when asked on numerous occasions, Laird has always said that they were indeed RES, so it's an issue for sure. He's also said that they didn't have much in the way of reference material when they were in the creation process.
Laird's general response to the number of fingers, seems to be "we thought it would be neat and goofy!"
Sooo, I guess you could take it up with them? :lol::lol:
I've always pretty much known they were RES, just from the first movie. It was obvious even then. (Though those were some darn big "babies" in the film, I give you that! So was Tokka, if we're to believe that was a "baby" snapper!)
I still don't get why everyone is so insistent they are red eared sliders. They never as baby pre mutated Turtles look like red eared sliders. Nor do they currently. It was just something Steve Murphy made up one time. And he made up a lot of things.
Why? Oh, I don't know- maybe THIS? VVV
They were RES in the 1990 film pre-mutation, and PDMT. If you look at the anatomical poster in Donnies lab on the Nick show, it appears to be a RES.
So, just a few more examples beyond that pannel with Donnie from Mirage.
I think Eastman called them box turtles, and they were called box turtles in IDW, but had flippers, and Sacks referred to them as box turtles, even though they used RES in the shots.
Retractable claws are stupid, as is the hind toe/claw.
Ditto to all that. Sachs was an idiot, And IDW never specifically called them ANY kind of turtles. Though the flippers was probably just either artistic license (based on pictures of baby sea turtles rather than baby RES), or just easier to draw than claws.
While I don't like the idea of retractable claws, I DO like the idea that they might keep them filed down to avoid their nails growing INTO claws. (And thus accidentally injuring each other or themselves with them.)
Candy Kappa
07-29-2015, 05:21 AM
I still don't get why everyone is so insistent they are red eared sliders. They never as baby premutated Turtles look like red eared sliders. Nor do they currently. It was just something Steve Murphy made up one time. And he made up a lot of things.
They are shown to be RES in both the first movie and the Platinum Dunes movie, although they are referred to as Box Turtles, the baby turtles shown in the footage are RES. They are also confirmed as RES by Donnie in Mirage in one of the Tales issues pin-ups where he finds a turtle in the sewers and talks to it. And the video game Out of the Shadows displays the Turtles with strong RES/Pond Slider markings
and, basing their pre-mutated looks on real Turtles don't really works in the other versions where their looks are not defined, cause being cartoon animals drawn by a animators layman idea off what a turtle is, they don't resemble any actual real turtle species, they just look like cartoon turtles.
Even the baby turtles drawn with flippers in IDW is highly questionable at best, as Eastman's original drafts do not have the baby turtles with flippers, it's all entirely the artists rendition. And as an add on, the baby turtles have a tank extremely ill fitted for sea turtles which could make them die prematurely and ruin Stockman's work, and sea turtles are illegal to keep, which also could ruin Stockman's work.
And to add for the irks about IDW's baby turtles, Mikey is spotted eating salad on land, RES don't produce saliva and can only eat while being in water, if that's the same for all semi-aquatic and sea turtles I don't know. Although, Mikey could be preparing to drag the salad leaf down to the water so he can properly eat it.
So it's strongly supported that they are RES, although Diamondbacks or Common Box Turtles is a alternative as well, something Donnie was musing in the Nick cartoon.
Jester
07-29-2015, 05:32 AM
Yeah...most live action depictions of the baby Turtles, even the god-awful musical VHS tapes, use Red Eared Sliders. The Barron original, Turtle Tunes/Christmas, PD, if they are shown as babies, they are Sliders.
Commenter 42
07-29-2015, 06:07 AM
...
So it's strongly supported that they are RES, although Diamondbacks or Common Box Turtles is a alternative as well, something Donnie was musing in the Nick cartoon.
What episode did that happen in? How would that work? They're not green at all!
Just for those who don't know what a Diamondback is (and to save you the Google trip):
http://cdn1.arkive.org/media/16/162A42DA-8FFF-42AF-A2E0-E6F4B32A54B8/Presentation.Large/Diamondback-terrapin-portrait.jpg
Box turtle is possible, but soooo much uglier! :lol: Sliders are much more attractive.
Hard to find green box turtles through Google. Must be rare? I don't know much about them, or the Diamondback.
http://euclid.nmu.edu/~jophilli/eastern-box-turtle23.1.jpg
I think it's pretty safe to say they're neither of these.
Candy Kappa
07-29-2015, 08:23 AM
What episode did that happen in? How would that work? They're not green at all!
Never Say Xever, I think.
Andrew NDB
07-29-2015, 01:27 PM
Might have been "cooller" if each of the Turtles had been a different kind of turtle. I'm surprised there's been no new incarnation of TMNT that's done that.
My vote:
Raphael: Common Snapping Turtle
Donatello: Box Turtle or Herman's Tortoise
Michelangelo: Razorback Musk Turtle
Leonardo: Red-Earred Slider
Ninturtle
07-29-2015, 02:42 PM
What episode did that happen in? How would that work? They're not green at all!
Just for those who don't know what a Diamondback is (and to save you the Google trip):
http://cdn1.arkive.org/media/16/162A42DA-8FFF-42AF-A2E0-E6F4B32A54B8/Presentation.Large/Diamondback-terrapin-portrait.jpg
Box turtle is possible, but soooo much uglier! :lol: Sliders are much more attractive.
Hard to find green box turtles through Google. Must be rare? I don't know much about them, or the Diamondback.
http://euclid.nmu.edu/~jophilli/eastern-box-turtle23.1.jpg
I think it's pretty safe to say they're neither of these.
Box turtles are indeed uglier which explains why the bay turtles are referred to as box turtles.
Candy Kappa
07-29-2015, 02:49 PM
Might have been "cooller" if each of the Turtles had been a different kind of turtle. I'm surprised there's been no new incarnation of TMNT that's done that.
My vote:
Raphael: Common Snapping Turtle
Donatello: Box Turtle or Herman's Tortoise
Michelangelo: Razorback Musk Turtle
Leonardo: Red-Earred Slider
Although a nice idea, it just seems a bit off.
There's a pretty good artist that have done realistic takes on the TMNT where he did a line-up where the Turtles where of different turtles.
http://onetruth.deviantart.com/art/NINJATURTLE-V1-Theboys-454208883
I've never doubted it. And it's been implicitly stated by TPTB for eons now.
I still never really thought about it and even knowing they're supposed to be biological siblings I view them more as adopted siblings. But it's not something I really think about.
And they were from different Mama Turtles. To suggest otherwise really only suits one mileau... NT:TNM, where TPTB decided all of the Turtles needed to be trying to have sex with Venus DeMilo every episode.
Actually that is far from truth since only in the East Meets West movie/episodes/pilot is it ever "hinted" and even then the turtles just show slight interest when they see her, this is before being revealed that it's their "sister" and there's only one scene later with Leo where he mentions how they're not actually biological siblings, but that scene is far from "romantic" or showing much interest in her. I mean I do think they mentioned it in case they ever took that somewhere but in the rest of the 26 episode season it's never even slightly hinted and yet people take 2 minutes of dialog and make a point out of it.
Might have been "cooller" if each of the Turtles had been a different kind of turtle. I'm surprised there's been no new incarnation of TMNT that's done that.
My vote:
Raphael: Common Snapping Turtle
Donatello: Box Turtle or Herman's Tortoise
Michelangelo: Razorback Musk Turtle
Leonardo: Red-Earred Slider
I'm surprised the new movies didn't do something like that or even the IDW book. It'd be interesting to see but I'm not sure I'd like it too much.
Powder
07-29-2015, 10:19 PM
Box turtles aren't ugly! :tmad:
MsMarvelDuckie
07-29-2015, 11:00 PM
Here's a thought- maybe the difference in color indicates ACTUAL age order? Since turtles tend to darken as they age, the darker pair might be the older of the four, while their lighter siblings are slightly younger. In which case, Raph and Mikey would be the oldest in 2003, while in Nick it would be Raph and then Leo. That would actually make Leo third and Donnie the youngest in 2003! (Which is incidentally in line with Don being youngest in the comic strips....) In Nick, on the other hand, Donnie would be third and Mikey the youngest, going by color.
Klunk1234
07-29-2015, 11:01 PM
It doesn't bother me at all. Like any siblings they have their likeness and differences. Not even identical twins are exactly alike; their fingerprints are different and their personalities.
Andrew NDB
07-29-2015, 11:10 PM
Here's a thought- maybe the difference in color indicates ACTUAL age order? Since turtles tend to darken as they age, the darker pair might be the older of the four, while their lighter siblings are slightly younger. In which case, Raph and Mikey would be the oldest in 2003, while in Nick it would be Raph and then Leo. That would actually make Leo third and Donnie the youngest in 2003! (Which is incidentally in line with Don being youngest in the comic strips....) In Nick, on the other hand, Donnie would be third and Mikey the youngest, going by color.
That's assuming they're not DNA brothers. The order of which they actually popped out of the same batch of eggs is really only academic... they were there at the same time.
Okay! Replying to this having only read the first page, so go easy on me if this stuff is covered. :trazz:
It's kinda either/or to me. I like the Turtles having different body types and facial structures, and I think that alone should be enough. But I'm totally fine with the different-colour headbands, so long as that never touches the original Mirage characters.
The Turtles having wildly different skin tones like the original toys? I have some nostalgia for it. It doesn't make as much sense... Though I feel like I've seen some variance in skin tone in Red Eared Sliders (I had two as pets when I was a kid and I seem to recall one had slightly darker skin than the other). But it makes more sense that difference in skin tone between them would be fairly subtle.
I get wanting to differentiate them physically. But it does seem it's gotten increasingly exaggerated over the years. The comic expected that the weapons and their dialogue would be enough. Every cartoon since has used different colours and/or skin tones to make them distinct. Most recently, the BayTurtles movie has them wearing all sorts of ugly (literal) garbage to look as different as possible from one another, jumping the hell over the shark. And it all feels rooted in this dumb idea that audiences aren't smart enough to figure it out. And that bugs me.
I think keeping them relatively uniform but with a few different design elements is plenty enough. I think the current IDW designs hit an decent balance.
Commenter 42
07-29-2015, 11:26 PM
Although a nice idea, it just seems a bit off.
There's a pretty good artist that have done realistic takes on the TMNT where he did a line-up where the Turtles where of different turtles.
http://onetruth.deviantart.com/art/NINJATURTLE-V1-Theboys-454208883
I guess that answers that.
http://img06.deviantart.net/2f98/i/2015/172/6/b/ninjaturtle__v1_theboys_by_onetruth-d7if9tf.jpg
I could get behind the design of Leo, if all 4 of them looked like that, but it needs more work; also TMNT without bandana's isn't really TMNT.
I think mixing up the different species makes them too individualized.
I don't know, I think it's too different, but I don't hate it. Hey Mrs duckie - They have claws here! :lol:
Box turtles aren't ugly! :tmad:
http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/naturelibrary/images/ic/credit/640x395/t/te/terrapene_carolina/terrapene_carolina_1.jpg
Okay, Fine they're not the ugliest.
The mata mata are: :lol:
http://www.ryanphotographic.com/images/JPEGS/Chelus%20fimbriatus%20Matamata%20turtle.jpg
I'm surprised the new movies didn't do something like that or even the IDW book. It'd be interesting to see but I'm not sure I'd like it too much.
Anything would be better than PDMT.
oldmanwinters
07-29-2015, 11:59 PM
I actually like the Turtles to resemble the action figures, so I'm 100% pro-diversity of skin color.
MsMarvelDuckie
07-30-2015, 12:01 AM
That's assuming they're not DNA brothers. The order of which they actually popped out of the same batch of eggs is really only academic... they were there at the same time.
Actually, it could also indicate growth rate. Some individuals DO grow faster than others of the same age, so maybe they just grew faster! Doesn't have to mean they're not related, just that someone was hogging all the food.... (My guess would be Raph and Mikey in the 2003 version, or Raph and Leo as the alphas in Nick.) In any case, it was just a thought.
@ 42- I've seen that, LOL! I actually DO like the idea of them having claws (if they didn't keep them filed down short, that is) so that's kind of cool, IMHO. I just think that accidental injuries might be more likely if they let them grow out naturally like a normal turtle's claws. Especially in the dojo.
Commenter 42
07-30-2015, 12:24 PM
Actually, it could also indicate growth rate. Some individuals DO grow faster than others of the same age, so maybe they just grew faster! Doesn't have to mean they're not related, just that someone was hogging all the food.... (My guess would be Raph and Mikey in the 2003 version, or Raph and Leo as the alphas in Nick.) In any case, it was just a thought.
@ 42- I've seen that, LOL! I actually DO like the idea of them having claws (if they didn't keep them filed down short, that is) so that's kind of cool, IMHO. I just think that accidental injuries might be more likely if they let them grow out naturally like a normal turtle's claws. Especially in the dojo.
I like the claws too - but it might make weilding a katana difficult.
That white Don is... interesting? They definitely look like turtles. Curious what the herps in the room think. :lol:
PangolinFeets
07-30-2015, 01:04 PM
This person on Tumblr did Leo as a Diamondback in the more classic TMNT style.
http://i.imgur.com/ng4biI3.jpg
Powder
07-30-2015, 02:29 PM
That, I like.
Cryomancer
07-30-2015, 05:03 PM
http://img06.deviantart.net/2f98/i/2015/172/6/b/ninjaturtle__v1_theboys_by_onetruth-d7if9tf.jpg
This is ********, April is a pen drawing!
Ninjinister
07-30-2015, 07:13 PM
Yo why do all of the turtles in that lineup look super different but when it comes to April it's like "lol 80's cartoon"?
Cipher
07-31-2015, 03:18 AM
But Mirage is also quite focused on it's adoptive family aspect, and being straight up different colors from each other would probably reinforce that further.
This has nothing to do with the different skin tones discussion, but this is why I've always preferred they not be, or not definitely be, blood-related. It plays better thematically with the series.
Although apparently it's unlikely they'd have come from different broods, which is fair enough.
neatoman
07-31-2015, 03:58 AM
This is ********, April is a pen drawing!
Hah! Just noticed that, nice.
Although, she's a pencil drawing here.
Yo why do all of the turtles in that lineup look super different but when it comes to April it's like "lol 80's cartoon"?
Probably the "Yo dood, I tots gots me a boner from when I watched her as a kid, Imma draw her like dat even though that design didn't make sense even back then!" excuse, I hear that a lot.
Andrew NDB
07-31-2015, 12:22 PM
The mata mata are: :lol:
http://www.ryanphotographic.com/images/JPEGS/Chelus%20fimbriatus%20Matamata%20turtle.jpg
I've wanted a Mata Mata for so long. But they're so expensive. They don't even bite, they just suck the fish in and expel the water.
darthsmozers
07-31-2015, 05:57 PM
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.
LOL not even.
darthsmozers
07-31-2015, 05:58 PM
I enjoyed giving them their "comic book" look in turtle in time.
Commenter 42
07-31-2015, 08:04 PM
I've wanted a Mata Mata for so long. But they're so expensive. They don't even bite, they just suck the fish in and expel the water.
Defnately one of the more fantastic faces out there! :lol:
Do you keep other species right now?
oldmanwinters
08-06-2015, 07:00 PM
This is ********, April is a pen drawing!
Yo why do all of the turtles in that lineup look super different but when it comes to April it's like "lol 80's cartoon"?
That is actually a plot point in the TMNT universe that the fan artist, "onetruth" is imagining. He's trying to make April as odd a standout as possible when comparable to more realistic portrayals of mutants and other humans. Basically, it's a real world setting in which April looks the same every day: exaggerated figure, perfect hair, and wears the same outfit everyday... just like a cartoon character would.
Here's his explanation:
For anyone interested in the design process;
Some have mentioned that April isn't a true redesign, so it's not as interesting as my approach to the Turtles. Well, I felt I should explain.
April's Mirage backstory states that she was never human, only a drawing that had come to life thanks to her father, who was an artist, and a magic pencil. It's a divisive bit of cannon for TMNT fans, but I really dig it, so I started there.
So, if she is in fact a drawing, drawn by a man, then her proportions should be exaggerated in all the ways male artists typically do. By including Irma, we see an average woman in her early 20's with normal body proportions, and so further push the comic stereotype by contrast.
The jumpsuit is both a nod to the 87 cartoon, and a symbol of just how out-of-step April is with the rest of the world. Cartoon and comicbook characters often wear the same clothes in every episode (one of Peter Lairds' complaints on his blog about the Fred wolf version of April).
So I figured April would quite likely wear the same bright yellow jumpsuit every day, as she is a drawing, who comes from comicbook land, and likely uses comic book logic. None of her co-workers ever comment on it simply because she's very pretty, and very pretty people, in my experience, get a pass on odd behavior all the time.
I thought about putting her in an office with other normal characters, to really hammer home how alien April actually is.
I'm somewhat happy with April's face. I had a very specific face in mind, but couldn't find ideal reference anywhere. Unfortunately, most of the line quality throughout the drawing still blows, but after so many revisions it just became a mess.
I'm still not comfortable inking in photoshop, but at some point I'll go back and clean her up for a true final.
http://onetruth.deviantart.com/art/April-O-neil-and-Irma-497458518
Sophie Campbell
08-06-2015, 07:30 PM
why would April's DAD draw her all sexy?!? gross!!! plus isn't the idea that she was drawn as a child and then grew up? oh whatever. XD
why would April's DAD draw her all sexy?!? gross!!! plus isn't the idea that she was drawn as a child and then grew up? oh whatever. XD
I thought she was drawn as an adult.
Leo656
08-06-2015, 07:38 PM
There's no justification for an idea as sh*tty as "April is just a magic drawing" to begin with, so, it really doesn't matter either way. :lol:
oldmanwinters
08-06-2015, 08:17 PM
why would April's DAD draw her all sexy?!? gross!!! plus isn't the idea that she was drawn as a child and then grew up? oh whatever. XD
I suppose you'd have to ask the author. He's very open to questions about his work and style. Honestly, I don't think anything about a magic drawing come to life going through normal human life cycles makes any sense. But... blame that on Peter Laird. :tlol:
Commenter 42
08-06-2015, 08:20 PM
I've never actually read the storyline... is it anything like the Donatello Kirby story? I remember reading something somewhere about a cockroach.
oldmanwinters
08-06-2015, 08:22 PM
I've never actually read the storyline... is it anything like the Donatello Kirby story? I remember readings something somewhere about a cockroach.
DrSpengler sums it up well.
http://www.tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/07/tmnt-vol-4-22.html
Commenter 42
08-06-2015, 08:37 PM
DrSpengler sums it up well.
http://www.tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/07/tmnt-vol-4-22.html
Thanks!
Well that was weird.
Cryomancer
08-06-2015, 10:02 PM
That is actually a plot point in the TMNT universe that the fan artist, "onetruth" is imagining. He's trying to make April as odd a standout as possible when comparable to more realistic portrayals of mutants and other humans. Basically, it's a real world setting in which April looks the same every day: exaggerated figure, perfect hair, and wears the same outfit everyday... just like a cartoon character would.
Here's his explanation:
http://onetruth.deviantart.com/art/April-O-neil-and-Irma-497458518
That is damn hilarious.
Leo656
08-07-2015, 08:10 AM
Thanks!
Well that was weird.
Right? :lol: Spengs did a great job describing/extrapolating upon it, but man, that story is plain awful. Lack of any payoff makes the whole dumb idea even worse.
I remember when Splinter training her to be a ninja in the Archie comics was considered a huge sin by many fans, on account of making April "less normal". We should've counted our blessings; now on any given day she's either a psychic mutant or a magic inkblot. Or the "uber-hot" linchpin of the entire TMNT universe, if you count the sh*tty movies.
I'unno. Every time I go back to most anything from Vol. 4... it's just one of the worst comic series I've ever read. It's just really, really Not Good. It's bad on a whole different level than bad "mainstream" books done without care for a quick buck are bad; it's much worse when the person creating something actually does care and their "best" attempt is a tragic joke. It'd be more forgivable if literally anyone but the co-creator of the entire franchise had written Vol. 4, but the fact that one of the "Founding Fathers" put out such a meandering, plotless, pointless waste of everyone's time is discouraging, because it flies in the face of all conventional logic. After all, "Who could write TMNT better than the guy who created it?!" Anyone else, apparently.
And then that bullsh*t with April. I always say, Vol. 4 as a whole was solid proof that Laird had lost It. The April "secret origin" debacle makes one question if he ever even had "It" to begin with.
TMNTChris1980
08-07-2015, 09:35 AM
I like the TMNT having different skin colors. Why isn't that a choice in the poll?
Commenter 42
08-07-2015, 10:18 AM
Or the "uber-hot" linchpin of the entire TMNT universe, if you count the sh*tty movies.
I do like that dudes explanation of the jumpsuit. It's also nice to see her drawn all sexy - I hate when artists make her homely and un attractive, or over weight and nerdy. It's a disturbing trend in comics these days. There's realism, then there's down right pandering. I'd never want to see Superman with a paunch and a bald spot, or dashing Playboy Bruce Wayne look like Mark Zuckerberg. I get that most millionaires aren't handsome, but Bruce wayne isn't most millionaires. Comics can do with some fantasy - If I want reality, I've got a mirror in the bathroom, and the world outside. I'm reading a comic to escape that, not remind myself of it. Next we'll see that Superman doesn't actually have heat vision, he just glares really, really hard. Thrilling.
But you know, the idea, at least the kernel of the idea, of being a drawing, ...it's interesting. In a world where most of the metaphors bouncing around are oxymoronic, and the themes are predominantly discordant and melancholic, It has a certain logic to it.
Like, start with the basic question, who is April O'Neil? The answer, who really cares. She's the worst selling toy, she's the plot device that gets the turtles from a to b in the TV show, she's a window into the world, that we look through, not at. Sometimes she's window dressing.
She might as well be a cockroach. She's Nobody.
At least that's how I'm reading it, now that I've had a little time to digest that summation in the link.
It's a little meta, but aren't all the idea's in TMNT built on that? Well, that and a lot of drugs, I think.
Leo656
08-07-2015, 09:33 PM
When even Grant Morrison can't pull off being Grant Morrison half the time, Peter Laird should NOT try to be Grant Morrison. That's my position. :lol: "She's a magical drawing given life by the power of imagination... just like every other fictional character, get it?!" I'm like "No, yeah, I got it... it's not that I didn't get it, it's that... Dude, you're not as clever as you think you are and I kinda wanna smack you now, because I paid $4 for this book, and it's awful." :lol:
Not for nothin', but Pete on his best day wasn't even in the same league as Grant Morrison to be tryin' that "meta" sh*t... no, forget same league, not even the same sport. :lol: And there's a lot of stuff Grant writes that I hate... but he's much better at writing comics than Laird ever was. I think Laird's ideas might work better in a different format, like novels or short stories. I know he always resented the fact that TMNT kept him from doing other things in life, and I can't blame him. I think he's kind of a crummy comic book style writer, but not bad as a "writer" writer. He'd have done better in a less-commercialized form of writing, is all, although he would definitely have made less money. I think he knows that, too, and it's why he's so bitter. I don't think his heart was ever in writing comics, specifically, but writing in general.
But yeah I hate that meta-fictional nonsense, unless it's brilliant. That April sh*t was far from brilliant. :lol: That was the last gasp of a struggling writer who just didn't care about the book anymore, was what that was. "Well, gotta do somethin'." :lol: I like to suspend disbelief to the point where, when I see a story unfold, I try to imagine that it's organic, that this was what the writer(s) originally intended and how they always wanted things to go. I know it's 99% made up as things go along, but I like to pretend otherwise because it's easier to get into the stories that way and pretend they're "really happening". And I can't do that at all with April as a magic drawing (or a psychic mutant or whatever, either). It's too hard for me to pretend that that's what Kevin and Pete always saw in their heads, and that takes me out of things. It just feels like a gimmick, rather than adding depth to a character.
I'unno. I just hated that f*cking story. :lol:
MsMarvelDuckie
08-07-2015, 10:42 PM
I totally agree with you on that, Leo. Never read it, but even the CONCEPT is just- blech. It makes the character too hard to relate to, and takes some of the disbelief out, like you said.
Leo656
08-07-2015, 10:50 PM
AND... she f*cked a cockroach.
WHY would you f*cking write that? It's fake. You could have made ANYTHING happen, and you have April f*ck a cockroach. Whatever "Creativity" points you may have earned with the basic concept of the story, you lose ALL points for that ridiculous garbage. Blech. Horrible stuff.
MsMarvelDuckie
08-07-2015, 11:17 PM
Yeah, that makes NO sense. Not even in a comic book context.
Commenter 42
08-07-2015, 11:41 PM
When even Grant Morrison can't pull off being Grant Morrison half the time, Peter Laird should NOT try to be Grant Morrison. That's my position. :lol: "She's a magical drawing given life by the power of imagination... just like every other fictional character, get it?!" I'm like "No, yeah, I got it... it's not that I didn't get it, it's that... Dude, you're not as clever as you think you are and I kinda wanna smack you now, because I paid $4 for this book, and it's awful." :lol:
Not for nothin', but Pete on his best day wasn't even in the same league as Grant Morrison to be tryin' that "meta" sh*t... no, forget same league, not even the same sport. :lol: And there's a lot of stuff Grant writes that I hate... but he's much better at writing comics than Laird ever was. I think Laird's ideas might work better in a different format, like novels or short stories. I know he always resented the fact that TMNT kept him from doing other things in life, and I can't blame him. I think he's kind of a crummy comic book style writer, but not bad as a "writer" writer. He'd have done better in a less-commercialized form of writing, is all, although he would definitely have made less money. I think he knows that, too, and it's why he's so bitter. I don't think his heart was ever in writing comics, specifically, but writing in general.
But yeah I hate that meta-fictional nonsense, unless it's brilliant. That April sh*t was far from brilliant. :lol: That was the last gasp of a struggling writer who just didn't care about the book anymore, was what that was. "Well, gotta do somethin'." :lol: I like to suspend disbelief to the point where, when I see a story unfold, I try to imagine that it's organic, that this was what the writer(s) originally intended and how they always wanted things to go. I know it's 99% made up as things go along, but I like to pretend otherwise because it's easier to get into the stories that way and pretend they're "really happening". And I can't do that at all with April as a magic drawing (or a psychic mutant or whatever, either). It's too hard for me to pretend that that's what Kevin and Pete always saw in their heads, and that takes me out of things. It just feels like a gimmick, rather than adding depth to a character.
I'unno. I just hated that f*cking story. :lol:
i don't know about that - but I don't exactly know the mind of Laird. I mean, they didn't have a master plan, as we well know. Most of the art is incredibly juvenile when compared with other artists. The writing was off beat, and incongruous pretty much all the time; it had some sort of pseudo philosophy, and half baked existentialism. If I had to guess, Laird is predominantly a deconstructionist, and writing was his way of solving his personal problems. Eastman came up with a neat design one day, added a few other wacky characters, then turned it over to Laird to fill in the blanks.
When i bang on about Mirage - it's because I sort of enjoy of the odd nature of his writing. The simplicity of the narrative and the illustrations ask the reader to bring more of themselves into the story. It requires your mind to see things that might not actually be there - like those stupid trippy sailboat illusions from the 90's.
I mean, we are talking about two guy's who literally failed upwards. It was bound to happen that, at one point or another, the Emperor's wrinkled ass would reveal itself.
I'm sorry you hate it. I hate Zack Snyder and his MOS. You win, you lose :P :lol:
In other news, you hear that Kim Jong-Un has arbitrarily made up his own time zone for North Korea? That's some pretty crazy stuff. That's f*ck a cockroach cray cray that is...
Leo656
08-07-2015, 11:59 PM
I mean there's stuff in Mirage I do like, I just think some of it's even worse than the good stuff is good. Which is fine. There's good and bad in everything. But I've seen enough of Laird's work to know I'm not the biggest fan of his comic book writings. Not that he's awful, I mean, he's certainly no hack like McFarlane or Liefeld (to clarify, I can take or leave McFarlane's artwork personally, but I can't say he's a "hack" in that area... his writing, on the other hand... OOOOF). But the TMNT comics he's written were by and large not my very favorite, although the best of them were better than most.
That One Story, though, is the worst TMNT story I've ever endured and it's kind of a hard black mark for me to just ignore, because it's Word of God, the creator of the book and the characters made it a point to tell that story and it's terrible. It's very frustrating. To borrow a quote from Riley Freeman, "It's like goin' to Heaven an' findin' God smokin' crack!" :lol:
Commenter 42
08-08-2015, 12:05 AM
I mean there's stuff in Mirage I do like, I just think some of it's even worse than the good stuff is good...
That One Story, though, is the worst TMNT story I've ever endured and it's kind of a hard black mark for me to just ignore, because it's Word of God, the creator of the book and the characters made it a point to tell that story and it's terrible. It's very frustrating.
Oh, I know the feeling. I get it everytime I think about this:
http://cdn2.screenjunkies.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/superman-kansas.jpg
I mean, that didn't come from the creators...
BUT WHAT THE **** DOES THAT EVEN MEAN?
Leo656
08-08-2015, 12:28 AM
That movie needed a dialog doctor pretty friggin' bad, I'll give ya that one. I'unno if a lot of people making movies really understand how important dialog is. So many movies just have people say the absolute dumbest sh*t.
Commenter 42
08-08-2015, 12:46 AM
That movie needed a dialog doctor pretty friggin' bad, I'll give ya that one. I'unno if a lot of people making movies really understand how important dialog is. So many movies just have people say the absolute dumbest sh*t.
When do you think that changed? At what point was it suddenly okay to let people talk complete nonsense? Like, back in the day technobable was excusable to an extent, with lines like
"What do they do with the other half?"
"Nobody knows where it goes, but the computers know where!"
There were B movies in the 90's, but generally, if it was a top tier film, the language was sound. In the last 5 years I've lost count of the number of times I've thought...WTF did they just say? Or worse, WTF did they just do?
And that's the difference - Laird was clearly using symbolism, or at least attempting to convey his ideas through symbolism. Hollywood is flat out just getting facts wrong. It's not even obscure things like dates and locations that most people are ignorant of - it's things like basic physics.
I don't get it. They'd fail most high school exams, but they get paid hundreds of thousands to write scripts.
MsMarvelDuckie
08-08-2015, 12:46 AM
Man, ain't THAT the truth! STILL groaning over that moronic "drain them of every last drop of blood- even if it kills them" line.
Commenter 42
08-08-2015, 12:57 AM
Man, ain't THAT the truth! STILL groaning over that moronic "drain them of every last drop of blood- even if it kills them" line.
Exactly, unfortunately, it was also everything else.
Why eschew the happy-accident-mutagen for research based, lab experimentation in a controlled environment, but ignore ALL SCIENTIFIC PRINCIPALS. You can't have a character state that this was their life's work, yet not know what species of turtle they were working with. The adrenaline would have killed them. The list of WTF goes on and on.
If you're doing metaphors and myth, that's FINE, do that, and do it well. If you want to employ magic, then it's magic, if it's a world where science and magic co-exist, then you need to establish those rules, and there limitations. You need to set things up properly, so that the audience understands the framework of the world their immersing themselves in. At the very least, you do your research, and make damned sure your not breaking the fourth wall with your own stupidity.
MsMarvelDuckie
08-08-2015, 01:25 AM
I get what you're saying, but I still enjoyed the movie as the pure popcorn-fest, big-budget action B-movie it was. I mean, there were SOME redeeming qualities, even though they were half-buried in craptastic schlock. I guess I'm just the kind of person who can pan out the nuggets of gold in the dross, and appreciate them all the more for where they came from.
Leo656
08-08-2015, 05:38 PM
I mean, there were SOME redeeming qualities
Nah. :lol: Nahhhhhhh. Anyone who says so is the most cockeyed of cockeyed optimists. I seen worse, but not many, and few that were so bad despite being so expensive they should've HAD to be good just to justify the budget. That movie fails by existing.
42: We sure do think alike on lots of stuff. :lol: I find that neat. People should be more like us, in that we strongly agree on much, strongly disagree on much else, and instead of being a couple of tw*ts about it, we can talk and debate and give each other a little sh*t. That's how this stuff is s'posed to go, right? :trazz:
Getting back to dialog, that's like one of the biggest things to me in movies and TV, and writing in general, that people talk the way they talk. I have a really acute ear for things like that and I get a brain cramp when I hear people in movies talk complete and total nonsense that nobody would ever say. It's like "Say the line out loud, and if you sound like a moron, then change it." Don't put stupid sh*t in other people's mouths, these things matter.
As for when it started, I have no idea, because guys like Tarantino and Smith were elevating dialog into an art form all its own for a while there. Honestly could'a been when comic book movies started taking over huge with "Spider-Man". I mean that was a good flick, but that's another one with some absolute sh*t dialog (all three films in fact). I still remember opening night in the theater, really getting into it, and then Green Goblin does the "We'll meet AGAIN, Spider-MAAAAAAAAAN!" and it completely took me out of the moment, because it was the cheesiest, dorkiest goddamn thing ever. Like I know they talk like that in comic books and cartoons but you can't do that in live action, it just doesn't work! But I've noticed that since then, and as more and more movies about "spectacle" have been released and accepted/praised, the importance of good dialog has been pushed deeper into the background.
Shame. Because it can really tie things together... or make the whole thing fall apart.
MsMarvelDuckie
08-08-2015, 06:31 PM
Nah. :lol: Nahhhhhhh. Anyone who says so is the most cockeyed of cockeyed optimists. I seen worse, but not many, and few that were so bad despite being so expensive they should've HAD to be good just to justify the budget. That movie fails by existing.
Look, I know you hate it, but it DID have some good parts. The action was good, the score well-done, and if nothing else, the turtles LOOKED good. (From a graphic standpoint- I know some didn't like their designs, and it took a while to really grow on me, but I liked them.) Also, the set designs! The lair was kitsch, but neat. Loved some of the little touches.
Powder
08-08-2015, 06:34 PM
I'll give you set design, but the action was a shaky-cam slam & jam with very little actual martial arts, the CGI was like that of a Playstation 4 game, & the score couldn't have been more generic.
Leo656
08-08-2015, 06:35 PM
If that movie... were a person... I would skin it alive and burn it to death.
Powder
08-08-2015, 06:37 PM
You're a far kinder man than I.
Leo656
08-08-2015, 06:39 PM
Well, I'm in no way above desecrating a corpse, I just generally don't plan that far ahead.
MsMarvelDuckie
08-08-2015, 06:50 PM
I'll give you set design, but the action was a shaky-cam slam & jam with very little actual martial arts, the CGI was like that of a Playstation 4 game, & the score couldn't have been more generic.
Honestly, I barely even noticed the shaky-cam. I was referring more to the subway scene, the lair battle, and the fight in the estate, not the snow chase and the tower falling or stuff like that. I thought the score worked just fine, it wasn't some big epic opus, but it was decent.
If that movie... were a person... I would skin it alive and burn it to death.
You are a sick man.
Well, I'm in no way above desecrating a corpse, I just generally don't plan that far ahead.
Why does this NOT surprise me?
Leo656
08-08-2015, 06:52 PM
There are few things I wouldn't do - or haven't done - for a Klondike bar. Let's just leave it at that.
Andrew NDB
04-10-2017, 02:32 AM
I mean... the Turtles don't even have different colors in the cartoons, beyond 2K3. Or the movies. Why does it need to be a thing in the new TMNT comics, or revisionist stuff? They're red-earred slider brothers that came from the same mama turtle, we're led to believe (and yes, it's tough to believe a single pet shop in NYC is getting just tons of different red-earred slider hatchlings from multiple sources at exactly the same time).
FredWolfLeonardo
04-10-2017, 02:52 AM
I don't mind them having different shades of skin color are bad. I think the different personalities are sufficent. I'd enjoy seeing a version where they have all red bandanas though.
Sophie Campbell
04-10-2017, 11:32 AM
Andrew, why did you suddenly reply to this thoroughly-discussed topic TWO YEARS later?! :tlol:
Cryomancer
04-10-2017, 11:41 AM
Having read this again now that it's back up, I am shocked at the quality of my own posts. Good job, past me.
Nortock Diab
04-10-2017, 12:31 PM
They're red-earred slider brothers that came from the same mama turtle.
This remains to be confirmed.
I still believe finding out that not all of them are blood brothers would be a good story plot :tgrin:.
DisKosh
04-10-2017, 12:59 PM
There's no justification for an idea as sh*tty as "April is just a magic drawing" to begin with, so, it really doesn't matter either way. :lol:
I wasn't too keen on that idea but I liked the way it was executed.
neatoman
04-10-2017, 02:19 PM
Andrew, why did you suddenly reply to this thoroughly-discussed topic TWO YEARS later?! :tlol:
Because he really hates the idea of making the turtles look different from each other?
PaulAllor
04-10-2017, 08:27 PM
Several times a week for the last two years, I have checked this forum in the hope -- the desperate hope -- that this vital discussion has been resurrected!
It's a good day, y'all.
IndigoErth
04-10-2017, 08:39 PM
I don't really have any place speaking for comics since I've seen very few (someday with more time and money to catch up), but why not be different shades...? Real life siblings aren't always the same exact skin tones. Not really a stretch that the Turtles could be the same way.
(How far did you have to dig to find this? lol)
AlessandraDC
04-11-2017, 11:39 AM
I love that they all look a bit different in 2012 and IDW comics! (I hadn't even noticed this topic til now! lol)
darthsmozers
04-11-2017, 12:42 PM
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.
Maybe naive, but not racist, particularly when talking about cartoon turtles. :roll:
I always chose the "comic" skin color for TMNT4 on SNES. They resembled the toys.
oldmanwinters
04-11-2017, 12:56 PM
Personally, I prefer it. Thanks for including that option in the poll, ANDREW. :tgrumble:
Andrew NDB
04-11-2017, 12:59 PM
Maybe naive, but not racist, particularly when talking about cartoon turtles. :roll:
Wow. You're the first one to invoke Crisler's Law (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s+Law) in quite some time.
Andrew NDB
04-11-2017, 01:04 PM
This remains to be confirmed.
In story, maybe. Laird has commented in his Q&A that he always wrote them with it in mind that they are blood-related.
You don't get a bunch of hatchlings from the same batch of eggs with 50 Shades of Green. You get one. In fact, there really isn't much variation in pigmentation amongst red-earred sliders at all, beyond albinos.
Utrommaniac
04-11-2017, 01:05 PM
It doesn't bother me too much. And would be useful in the case of them all wearing red bandanas. I even think about doing that...when I actually get around to drawing them.
Andrew NDB
04-11-2017, 01:11 PM
And would be useful in the case of them all wearing red bandanas.
Useful how? In helping people tell them apart? We've done this before... out of the entirety of the Mirage TMNT in B&W, people could only find like 3 or 4 panels where there was any trouble telling them apart.
It seems 50% lazy of the artist to not give the Turtles their own unique touches in body and face, 50% insulting by the colorist (or whoever above is forcing the issue) to basically tell the readers -- and this is particularly ridiculous in things like IDW or 2K3, where they already have the rainbow bandannas -- "I don't really trust you to know which Turtle is which, so I'm going to color code their skin for you."
DestronMirage22
04-11-2017, 01:19 PM
Andrew has a point, doing the different skin-tone stuff is just overkill. It's enough with muli-colored bandannas, if they decide to go that route.
Cryomancer
04-11-2017, 01:20 PM
This remains to be confirmed.
I still believe finding out that not all of them are blood brothers would be a good story plot :tgrin:.
It's very real, and thus very TMNT, that they will not and cannot ever truly know.
OK well Renet could probably figure it out but I mean thematically it's way more "life is at best bittersweet", OK.
Utrommaniac
04-11-2017, 01:25 PM
I personally think it sets them apart just a little bit more from each other. Personally, I wouldn't do anything as drastic as the toys with a nearly-brown Donatello, but variations on the same tint.
Something grouped in this range (http://www.color-hex.com/color/89c989), maybe #89c989, #7bb47b, #6da06d, #5f8c5f .
I'll mess with it when I have time to play with color theory and triadic colors.
darthsmozers
04-11-2017, 02:08 PM
Wow. You're the first one to invoke Crisler's Law (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s+Law) in quite some time.
OK.
The fact that that's a thing is :lol:
It still stands that suggesting something sounds racist when talking about cartoon turtles is a little bit of a stretch. Look at Mufasa and Scar from The Lion King: different colors, different personalities, but brother lions. One bad, one good. It's a visual thing, considering they don't wear clothes... either for sales, for marketing, for creativity. That's all, nothing more, and certainly not racist.
Rooish
04-11-2017, 05:13 PM
OK.
The fact that that's a thing is :lol:
It still stands that suggesting something sounds racist when talking about cartoon turtles is a little bit of a stretch. Look at Mufasa and Simba from The Lion King: different colors, different personalities, but brother lions. One bad, one good. It's a visual thing, considering they don't wear clothes... either for sales, for marketing, for creativity. That's all, nothing more, and certainly not racist.
I think you mean Scar and Mufasa. And I think that was a little racist. Villains often have darker skin tone. Not to mention kind of homophobic as he had a gay actor with a heavy lisp. Anyway!!
Different skin tone is a bit dumb and unnecessary. If they have slightly different tints in a live action movie that's one thing. But different shades of neon is too much. Their differences have already been beaten into our heads in terms of rainbow bandannas and alarmingly different builds. Just seems silly.
darthsmozers
04-11-2017, 06:48 PM
I think you mean Scar and Mufasa. And I think that was a little racist. Villains often have darker skin tone. Not to mention kind of homophobic as he had a gay actor with a heavy lisp. Anyway!!
Different skin tone is a bit dumb and unnecessary. If they have slightly different tints in a live action movie that's one thing. But different shades of neon is too much. Their differences have already been beaten into our heads in terms of rainbow bandannas and alarmingly different builds. Just seems silly.
Yes, I meant Scar. Thanks.
How can it be racist if villains "often have darker skin tones"? Should a villain have a blazing white wardrobe? No, villains have always been dark, brooding, etc. Again, we're talking cartoon animals. And homophobic? :roll: Oh boy, I give up.
Andrew NDB
04-11-2017, 06:52 PM
Should a villain have a blazing white wardrobe? No, villains have always been dark
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/a3/b7/a7/a3b7a7fab3ff446687c9e72156079953.jpg
***First of Two Latin Kings***
04-11-2017, 07:17 PM
I always thought in IDW that it was a throw back to the Playmates line and 4Kids show.
Andrew NDB
04-11-2017, 07:43 PM
And it does strike me as a little racist. I mean, if I was working on a book about 4 African American guys who are brothers, would the inclination be to make one light-skinned, and the others different shades of "black"... so readers can tell them apart better?
Of course not. That's ludicrous.
neatoman
04-12-2017, 04:06 AM
And it does strike me as a little racist. I mean, if I was working on a book about 4 African American guys who are brothers, would the inclination to make one light-skinned, and the others different shades of "black"... so readers can tell them apart better?
Of course not. That's ludicrous.
No but you'd probably give them other distinguishing features. With the obvious exception of the twins, the Harry Potter books go into detail about how the Weasley brothers look similar yet clearly different. The only way you'll get away with four characters who look exactly the same is if they were all clones of the same person.
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/a3/b7/a7/a3b7a7fab3ff446687c9e72156079953.jpg
Isn't he a twist villain though? I know the movies had his betrayal come pretty much right away, but it was still a twist. While I haven't read books, I know they take place on a longer time scale, so I would imagine they at least talk about him more before the twist or at least that more happens before it.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
04-12-2017, 02:25 PM
And it does strike me as a little racist. I mean, if I was working on a book about 4 African American guys who are brothers, would the inclination to make one light-skinned, and the others different shades of "black"... so readers can tell them apart better?
Of course not. That's ludicrous.
By this logic, wouldn't the Cosby Show be racist, since Lisa Bonet's character and one other sister are considerably light skinned, while all the other siblings are considerably darker?
Andrew NDB
04-12-2017, 02:56 PM
By this logic, wouldn't the Cosby Show be racist, since Lisa Bonet's character and one other sister are considerably light skinned, while all the other siblings are considerably darker?
I'm not aware of any Cosby Show comic book with mandated skin color codings. I'd kind of like to read it.
Utrommaniac
04-12-2017, 03:10 PM
Isn't he a twist villain though? I know the movies had his betrayal come pretty much right away, but it was still a twist. While I haven't read books, I know they take place on a longer time scale, so I would imagine they at least talk about him more before the twist or at least that more happens before it.
Maybe a twist for Gandalf, but not necessarily for us as an audience. He just kind of reeks evil at the start.
IndigoErth
04-12-2017, 05:12 PM
Why does skin tone even have to be about telling them apart? Maybe it could just be design choice. After all, even if all from the same nest originally, they'd be more like fraternal twins, not identical. And even if color wouldn't very much for sliders born together, they are no longer those little sliders, none of them are actually 'slider colored,' and the mutagen-caused changes doesn't have to be cookie cutter for all four.
Most versions don't even portray them as looking scaly (even for Bay Turtles its only to a certain extent and some less than others) and most have the ability to sweat, so I never found it hard to just assume that mutation changed qualities about their skin along with the rest of them.
Cryomancer
04-12-2017, 06:37 PM
Clearly they should all be super pale, because they've lived underground their whole lives. Can't get a tan in the sewer.
Utrommaniac
04-13-2017, 01:19 AM
I was just re-reading the IDW comics, and I realized another factor to having them in different skin tones, which Ronda Pattison uses pretty consistently between different artists.
It's more visually interesting. Several pages/panels of the same tone of green blobbed together would get a little straining after a while. It's more about color theory than aesthetics. When I'm able, I'll find some bigger and better panels to test this out, but for the moment...
They all have the same background, so it might not be the BEST example, but I'll find a more complex one later on.
Here's the original, where they're all different colors
http://i120.photobucket.com/albums/o191/Bat-Snake/Screen%20Shot%202017-04-13%20at%2012.36.09%20AM_zpsxelx3gan.png
And my altered version, where they're the same. I used Raphael because it seemed closest to "Traditional" TMNT colors as far as I could grasp for the moment. I also almost made Pepperoni the same tone of green as a joke, but didn't feel like it pulling it off.
http://i120.photobucket.com/albums/o191/Bat-Snake/recolor_zpszvjvfu4j.png
Granted, Sophie's style would make them a little more appealing in a single tone example, but imagine that single tone where they're drawn at a great distance and grouped together.
When it comes down to it, it seems like the different colors are done so they'd stand out apart from each other on paper. It would be easier on printers, colorists won't lose their minds having to use the same tone of green for four characters, and there's more sense in it from a perspective of color theory.
But hey...they all have the same eye color???
DisKosh
04-13-2017, 01:43 AM
I'll give you set design, but the action was a shaky-cam slam & jam with very little actual martial arts, the CGI was like that of a Playstation 4 game, & the score couldn't have been more generic.
Really? I personally love the score it's one of the best things about the movie (not that there are many).
Why does skin tone even have to be about telling them apart? Maybe it could just be design choice. After all, even if all from the same nest originally, they'd be more like fraternal twins, not identical. And even if color wouldn't very much for sliders born together, they are no longer those little sliders, none of them are actually 'slider colored,' and the mutagen-caused changes doesn't have to be cookie cutter for all four.
Most versions don't even portray them as looking scaly (even for Bay Turtles its only to a certain extent and some less than others) and most have the ability to sweat, so I never found it hard to just assume that mutation changed qualities about their skin along with the rest of them.
Yeah, I never thought it was to make them easier to tell apart. I just saw it as a design choice and I like it.
Clearly they should all be super pale, because they've lived underground their whole lives. Can't get a tan in the sewer.
That makes sense but it does bring up with question of why they don't suffer rickets or other health problems resulting from lack of sunlight. Man, this show would be so sad if it was realistic.
Andrew NDB
04-13-2017, 01:48 AM
Why does skin tone even have to be about telling them apart? Maybe it could just be design choice.
It's definitely not a design choice. Not at large.
Most versions don't even portray them as looking scaly (even for Bay Turtles its only to a certain extent and some less than others) and most have the ability to sweat, so I never found it hard to just assume that mutation changed qualities about their skin along with the rest of them.
Why would they be scaly? Turtles don't have scales.
Clearly they should all be super pale, because they've lived underground their whole lives. Can't get a tan in the sewer.
While red-earred sliders are basking turtles that like their sunlight at times, they don't require it. It just increases the risk of shellrot and soft shell and all of that (but then again, red-earred sliders are submersed in water 100% of the time they're not basking or laying eggs... TMNT isn't doing that). Either way, no pigment is changed in either light. And then there's turtles like snappers and alligator snappers, who are perfectly content to lay in the bottom of ponds in the muck and mud for many hours... they require 0 sunlight. You could raise them to adulthood in a pitch black room with no problem, as long as they have food. No pigment change.
The "it's the mutagen!" argument is really the only thing a hat could be hung on in this. And that's a bit of a copout, because that's not why it exists.
IndigoErth
04-13-2017, 02:04 AM
That makes sense but it does bring up with question of why they don't suffer rickets or other health problems resulting from lack of sunlight. Man, this show would be so sad if it was realistic.
:( That would be so sad. Vitamin deficiency, malnutrition, illness and parasites... Heck, one infected wound and they're probably done for.
Might be more of a story of people who come across them, somehow refrain from entirely losing their you-know-what then take pity on them and help them out.
Why would they be scaly? Turtles don't have scales.
Really...
I think most people know that rough, bumpy texture to reptile skin is generally regarded to as being "scaly" (heck, badly dried out human skin is too), and widely understood not to be mistaken with actual scales such as those of snakes or fish.
DisKosh
04-13-2017, 02:16 AM
:( That would be so sad. Vitamin deficiency, malnutrition, illness and parasites... Heck, one infected wound and they're probably done for.
Might be more of a story of people who come across them, somehow refrain from entirely losing their you-know-what then take pity on them and help them out.
I've made this comparison before but it would be a little like the 1987 Beauty and the Beast serious where they have a small network of people above to help them.
Actually, that would be an adaptation I'd love to see. Basically if TMNT was written by Victor Hugo, with toddler turtles.
Andrew NDB
04-13-2017, 02:17 AM
Really...
I think most people know that rough, bumpy texture to reptile skin is generally regarded to as being "scaly" (heck, badly dried out human skin is too), and widely understood not to be mistaken with actual scales such as those of snakes or fish.
"Scaly" denotes scales. Turtles don't have any. They don't even shed skin, like other reptiles do.
IndigoErth
04-13-2017, 03:28 AM
*shrug* I dunno, Andrew, I didn't make up the lingo. You're going to have to take that up with whoever did that, but good luck finding them. Might need a time machine.
Although dare I argue that being referred to as "scaly" doesn't necessarily require "scales," per se, any more than "amphibious" requires being an "amphibian." Both simply refer to something of only limited similarity. The world and language is, unfortunately, not always that black and white.
neatoman
04-13-2017, 07:41 AM
I was just re-reading the IDW comics, and I realized another factor to having them in different skin tones, which Ronda Pattison uses pretty consistently between different artists.
It's more visually interesting. Several pages/panels of the same tone of green blobbed together would get a little straining after a while. It's more about color theory than aesthetics. When I'm able, I'll find some bigger and better panels to test this out, but for the moment...
They all have the same background, so it might not be the BEST example, but I'll find a more complex one later on.
Here's the original, where they're all different colors
http://i120.photobucket.com/albums/o191/Bat-Snake/Screen%20Shot%202017-04-13%20at%2012.36.09%20AM_zpsxelx3gan.png
And my altered version, where they're the same. I used Raphael because it seemed closest to "Traditional" TMNT colors as far as I could grasp for the moment. I also almost made Pepperoni the same tone of green as a joke, but didn't feel like it pulling it off.
http://i120.photobucket.com/albums/o191/Bat-Snake/recolor_zpszvjvfu4j.png
Granted, Sophie's style would make them a little more appealing in a single tone example, but imagine that single tone where they're drawn at a great distance and grouped together.
When it comes down to it, it seems like the different colors are done so they'd stand out apart from each other on paper. It would be easier on printers, colorists won't lose their minds having to use the same tone of green for four characters, and there's more sense in it from a perspective of color theory.
But hey...they all have the same eye color???
Actually, I think Andrew might prefer this.
DestronMirage22
04-13-2017, 10:49 AM
"Scaly" denotes scales. Turtles don't have any. They don't even shed skin, like other reptiles do.
A lot of turtles do have scales, on their arms and legs. The stuff their shells are made of are called scutes.
Actually, I think Andrew might prefer this.
The weird thing is, I can still make a fair guess at which turtle is which in that illustration, but it's a good argument to make : The skin tones are most probably a decision driven by marketting, but the result also makes the comics slightly easier to follow, and adds a little more individuality to the characters.
As someone who owns reptiles, but knowns nothing about the genetics of turtles, I would assume that even though they all come from the same clutch of eggs, they would have slightly different morphs. Someone who spends even less time around reptiles than I do would probably jump to the same conclusion?
neatoman
04-17-2017, 04:05 PM
All this talk about skin tones and mask color... How about this?:
http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/a/a8/Wild_Clones_Appeared.PNG/revision/latest?cb=20121024115448
Netkeeper
04-17-2017, 04:08 PM
Yeah, and not all these design decisions have to have any scientific/realism basis, because I mean, the white eyes were originally drawn on the turtles to give them a "glowing eyes" look just for the coolness of it/possibly also a ninja feel more than anything else
Realistically turtles also have detail in their eyes
neatoman
04-17-2017, 04:19 PM
Yeah, and not all these design decisions have to have any scientific/realism basis, because I mean, the white eyes were originally drawn on the turtles to give them a "glowing eyes" look just for the coolness of it/possibly also a ninja feel more than anything else
Realistically turtles also have detail in their eyes
I just thought it was a comic book tradition.
http://www.caseycardiniakids.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/20018_41d9zip1lwL._SY300_.jpghttp://insidepulse.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/JUSTICE-LEAGUE-47-faces-Green-Lantern-300x311.jpghttp://www.myteespot.com/images/Images_d/img_R3nl2e.jpghttps://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/f7/1a/fd/f71afdf84af6eaf69bf0191df78ad83b.jpg
Andrew NDB
04-17-2017, 06:22 PM
A lot of turtles do have scales, on their arms and legs. The stuff their shells are made of are called scutes.
Well the actual shells, sure. We're talking about skin here.
Netkeeper
04-17-2017, 06:26 PM
I just thought it was a comic book tradition.
http://www.caseycardiniakids.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/20018_41d9zip1lwL._SY300_.jpghttp://insidepulse.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/JUSTICE-LEAGUE-47-faces-Green-Lantern-300x311.jpghttp://www.myteespot.com/images/Images_d/img_R3nl2e.jpghttps://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/f7/1a/fd/f71afdf84af6eaf69bf0191df78ad83b.jpg
Yes, I'm just saying I think I read that was the specific reason for it on the turtles. Of course my memory is **** so someone that knows more than me is free to tell me if I'm misremembering
MsMarvelDuckie
04-20-2017, 08:31 PM
"Scaly" denotes scales. Turtles don't have any. They don't even shed skin, like other reptiles do.
Actually they DO shed like other reptiles. Not all in one piece like snakes tend to do, but they shed both skin(in small shreds) AND the outter layer of the scutes- they are essentially like fingernails or hair and grow from the "base" in the same way, with older layers peeling off as new ones grow in- like a cat claw being shed. And they have scales mostly on the limbs and top of the head.
Rooish
04-21-2017, 11:08 AM
Not sure why people are so insistent the guys are red eared sliders. Didn't Murphy come up with that? Didn't Murphy come up with lots of things? I'm sure E and L didn't figure out what species they wanted and wouldn't care. They could be any little turtle species.
Andrew NDB
04-21-2017, 11:37 AM
Not sure why people are so insistent the guys are red eared sliders. Didn't Murphy come up with that? Didn't Murphy come up with lots of things? I'm sure E and L didn't figure out what species they wanted and wouldn't care. They could be any little turtle species.
Laird has agreed they're red-earred sliders. They're the most common pet shop turtles. And they put them in their 1990 movie in the ooze scene.
ProphetofGanja
04-21-2017, 11:56 AM
Laird has agreed they're red-earred sliders. They're the most common pet shop turtles. And they put them in their 1990 movie in the ooze scene.
I wonder what possessed IDW to make them sea turtles in their comics
Andrew NDB
04-21-2017, 12:04 PM
I wonder what possessed IDW to make them sea turtles in their comics
Seems odd to me, but points for originality. And I guess being mutant versions of turtles that are, in reality, endangered species... there's a certain poetry to that. Last of their kind, that sort of thing, and now even their non-mutated race's days might be numbered. Though it's a little lost on something like IDW where you can't walk 5 feet without tripping over tons of other mutants.
It also just might have been Dan Duncan doing his own thing in a script that just called for drawing "baby turtles."
ProphetofGanja
04-21-2017, 12:16 PM
Seems odd to me, but points for originality. And I guess being mutant versions of turtles that are, in reality, endangered species... there's a certain poetry to that. Last of their kind, that sort of thing, and now even their non-mutated race's days might be numbered. Though it's a little lost on something like IDW where you can't walk 5 feet without tripping over tons of other mutants.
It also just might have been Dan Duncan doing his own thing in a script that just called for drawing "baby turtles."
Yeah, I wondered if the script/page layout notes said something vague and Duncan just freestyled something. Because some of the things the turtles do later in the series are definitely not in-line with sea turtles' abilities, like pulling their head all the way into their shells, or just the fact that they have fingers and toes instead of flippers. But it's no biggie, I ain't tripping on it.
It's like the radioactive spider that bit Peter Parker; it can be retconned to be whatever type of spider it needs to be to suit whatever story is being told. And I just looked at the wiki page for that spider and am astounded at just how many retcons there have been.
Candy Kappa
04-21-2017, 01:35 PM
The flippers in IDW have to be a thing Duncan came up with since in Eastman's layouts they don't have flippers.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-21-2017, 01:41 PM
The flippers in IDW have to be a thing Duncan came up with since in Eastman's layouts they don't have flippers.
Eastman did layouts for those early issues? Where have you seen that?
neatoman
04-21-2017, 01:46 PM
Speaking of the flippers, pay attention to the mutants that didn't have fingers/toes in their animal forms. Notice anything? They all have three fingers, not a single one more.
https://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/e/ee/Scumbug_idw.png/revision/latest?cb=20160622042106http://comicwow.tv/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/TMNT_Universe_03-pr-1.jpghttp://turtlepedia.wikia.com/wiki/File:Ray_idw_1.pnghttps://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/4/4e/IDW_Pete.png/revision/latest?cb=20140702212552https://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/0/0e/Bludgeon_koya.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20140814000855https://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/tmnt/images/d/d8/Screen-Shot-2014-03-12-at-7.36.38-PM.png/revision/latest?cb=20140527163411
Candy Kappa
04-21-2017, 01:47 PM
IDW showed Eastman's sketches of the first pages when the comic started.
Edit: Here we go
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1006126&postcount=2
ProphetofGanja
04-21-2017, 01:55 PM
Speaking of the flippers, pay attention to the mutants that didn't have fingers/toes in their animal forms. Notice anything? They all have three fingers, not a single one more.
Hmm. So maybe the First Law of Mutation is "All mutants shall have 3 digits on their limbs"
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-21-2017, 02:03 PM
IDW showed Eastman's sketches of the first pages when the comic started.
Edit: Here we go
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1006126&postcount=2
Thanks, CK!
The flippers have always bugged me... not a big deal, but irritating.
Papenbrook
10-15-2018, 11:24 AM
I will say my opinion ...
It doesn't really bother me.
newfan
10-15-2018, 11:39 AM
I notice no selection for 'I like it' ;)
With this being an old thread it's all be discussed already. Besides the points being made about them not being regular turtles I also think for the toons they can get away with it more, I mean other toon characters don't always resemble reality with features etc. I don't like the very weak green as much
tilallr1
11-28-2018, 07:04 AM
Laird has agreed they're red-earred sliders. They're the most common pet shop turtles. And they put them in their 1990 movie in the ooze scene.
With 90% of those purchased, either later dumped, deliberately killed or flushed down the toilet. Probably why they changed them to Sea Turtles. Impossible to buy at a local pet store. The murder of red-earred sliders must stop. ;)
https://www.today.com/parents/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-movie-spawns-pet-turtle-warning-1D79964551
Andrew NDB
01-02-2019, 11:27 AM
With 90% of those purchased, either later dumped, deliberately killed or flushed down the toilet. Probably why they changed them to Sea Turtles. Impossible to buy at a local pet store. The murder of red-earred sliders must stop. ;)
The thing is, it's pretty hard to reconcile the TMNT origin with them being sea turtles. You'd have to approach it completely differently.
Sumac
01-02-2019, 01:01 PM
I like it.
It helps Turtles to stand out from each other.
Utrommaniac
01-03-2019, 10:00 AM
In regards to sea turtles, I'm not really sure they make much sense as lab animals either.
Especially since part of their purpose was for "exo-armor" creation very early on, and you're not going to get very tough shells on sea turtles. Box turtles might make more sense if they wanted a break from the "red eared slider" depiction.
They don't even look like they have flippers in those early sketches; pretty sure they have little toes in the Eastman layouts.
pferreira
01-25-2019, 04:16 PM
Am I right in thinking the Nick TMNT are all the same colour apart from Leo? If that's the case I wonder why they did that just for one of them?
Candy Kappa
01-25-2019, 04:21 PM
The nick Turtles got each a different skin color
daggio
01-26-2019, 09:28 AM
I personally like each of the Turtles having their own shade of green, not for purposes of differentiating them, but just cuz it gives each of them a little more. They each have their own colored bandana, their own weapon(s), and their own personality, motivation, etc., so having a different shade of green seems OK to me.
Leo656
01-26-2019, 09:42 PM
I kinda get why some people like it, but I don't think it makes much sense.
Please, no one invoke the ancient "none of it makes sense" reply. I'm aware. I still believe in a little thing called "Verisimilitude".
pferreira
02-01-2019, 01:11 PM
The nick Turtles got each a different skin colorOh yeah they did, I just didn't notice it previously when looking at images online. There goes my eyesight... :D
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.