PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Classic Book Discussion (Issues 2-4)


HotJuicyBurgers
07-27-2015, 05:50 PM
Hey everyone! If you were waiting for this post to go up last friday I'm really sorry but for the next two weekends i'm going to be pretty busy so I figured I'd post this one one monday so that I can post the next two "on time." Basically, these threads will come one monday (hopefully) from now on.

Without further ado, lets begin the discussion! There are a lot of questions to ask in these issues, so i'll try to pick my best ones.

Issue 2
-What do you think of April in this issue? What of Baxter? From just this one issue would you have inferred they would become long time recurring characters for the TMNT?
- What of the mousers? Are they a believable threat?
-What do you think of how much more personality the turtles have in this issue? (Don is clearly emerging as the "Tech Turtle" in this issue)
Issue 3
-Splinter is gone! Has there been enough time with him for us as the reader to care?
-What do you think of the "longest car chase in comics?"
-How about that twist ending? Alien brains in robots?
Issue 4
-It is revealed that these alien brains are connected to the origins of the turtles! Does it feel shoehorned or does it feel natural?
-What did you think of the person spying on April's apartment? Doesn't seem like anything came from that directly.

That's all for this week folks. As always don't forget to vote for next week!

CyberCubed
07-27-2015, 05:52 PM
While issue 2 and Baxter and Mousers are now classic characters, I honestly wonder how people reacted to it when it first came out. You go from the first issue with the Turtles fighting ninja's and Shredder to a black scientist with little tiny robots. Had Baxter not gone on to become a classic character he would have seemed like a one-off generic mad scientist, which is what he essentially was.

HotJuicyBurgers
07-27-2015, 05:55 PM
While issue 2 and Baxter and Mousers are now classic characters, I honestly wonder how people reacted to it when it first came out. You go from the first issue with the Turtles fighting ninja's and Shredder to a black scientist with little tiny robots. Had Baxter not gone on to become a classic character he would have seemed like a one-off generic mad scientist, which is what he essentially was.

But is there anything iconic about him besides the fact that he was their second villain? The only other thing he invents that is even iconic are the mousers.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-27-2015, 07:09 PM
Issue #2:

I love that Leo is reading Dune

Donnie is also showing personality, soldering a circuit board... this issue is definitely Don's debut. We also kinda get to see more of Leo being a leader. But Mikey is just... there. Buddies with Raph, which is nice (I miss the Raph/Mike bromance) but doesn't really say much about Mikey himself.

I never noticed it before, but Baxter deliberately shows April his entire operation so that he can kill her. Truly psychopathic. After all, he dismisses her concerns about those holes in the bank vaults or whatever, and then takes her down, shows her the operation and kills her. Or rather, tries to.

Sigh... April and Baxter are just kind of pathetic in this issue. Honestly, this Baxter is more Fred Wolf / Saturday morning cartoon than the whitewashed blonde Baxter from the first cartoon. "Bwahahahaha I'm evil!" :trolleye: Really glad Volume 2 made him a genuine threat in the Mirage continuity.

Retxab building? Really? :trolleye:

Also, can we all agree that the Mousers would never have happened? That's a pretty damn brutal and bloody way to take out pests. Pretty sure PETA would be doing everything they could to stop that. :tlol: More realistic would be suffocating the rats in the Mouser's jaws, I think. Or even just having the Mousers serve as a live-trap and take the rats back to a facility for processing, relocating, or even euthanizing. I dunno, maybe I'm giving the PETA types more credit than they deserve, and this totally could've happened in the '80s.

Still no real personality for Mikey. :tsad:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-27-2015, 07:20 PM
Issue #3:

Definitely plenty of personality and character development for Raph. I love that the other Turtles have to hold him back for going back for Stockman and killing him. :tlol:

We find out more about April, a secondary character, than anything about Mike.

Honestly, this issue is really poor. I don't like it much at all. The car chase, the coincidences of the identical vans, the "holy hippo spit" exclamation... it all bugs me. But hey, Mirage is still finding its feet.

And I love that this is the first issue to set up a continuing storyline. TMNT could've ended after Issue #2, but this issue comes along, references the previous events with April and Stockman, and then doesn't resolve the mystery of Splinter's disappearance.

Oh, wait! Epilogue! I thought Splinter's Mouser battle was the start of Issue #4, but apparently not!

"That was my favorite walking stick?" "Speak of the devil?" Splinter's really not very in character yet, is he? This is more 4Kids / Nick Splinter than Mirage Splinter, but at least it's character development. I also feel like he should have held up better against the Mousers... but do we ever really see Mirage Splinter kick ass and take names? I can't think of anything, outside of "The Bait" in Tales Volume 2.

Was the sudden "about-face" of the Mousers hunting Splinter ever explained? Was that when Stockman called all the Mousers to destroy his lab? I'm assuming so... I honestly am just skimming these early issues. They are ROUGH compared to later issues. :tlol:

STILL no character development for Mikey. :tsad:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-27-2015, 07:32 PM
Issue #4:

Lots of banter, but still no actual individual unique character development or personality for Mikey. Honestly, in these early issues, Raph is hogging both his own and Mikey's personalities: he's equal parts goofy and angry. No fair, Raph!

Giant talking turtles crashing through the window are the ultimate c*ckblock. :tlol:

I do love how Raphael is so protective of Mikey. Y'think he's making up for the Raph micro-issue (which came first)?

I don't care what Peter Laird says, early Mirage April is definitely black. It would have been pretty cool having a prominent black character. But then, Fred Wolf probably would've whitewashed her along with Baxter. :trolleye:

The guy spying on April and the Turtles is Casey Jones, which we can figure out by the time of his timely intervention in Issue #10... still, it would've been helpful if Laird and Eastman had made this a bit more explicit.

Mikey finally gets to be awesome, covering for his brothers and then diving after them into the Transmat. But still... where's the Mikey we know and love? Where's the tender heart, the compassion, the most "human" of the Turtles?

HotJuicyBurgers
07-28-2015, 11:10 PM
Issue #4:

The guy spying on April and the Turtles is Casey Jones, which we can figure out by the time of his timely intervention in Issue #10... still, it would've been helpful if Laird and Eastman had made this a bit more explicit.



I went back and read my ultimate collection, and it seems not even Kevin seems to remember that :tlol:

HotJuicyBurgers
07-30-2015, 08:21 AM
Issue #4:

Lots of banter, but still no actual individual unique character development or personality for Mikey. Honestly, in these early issues, Raph is hogging both his own and Mikey's personalities: he's equal parts goofy and angry. No fair, Raph!

Giant talking turtles crashing through the window are the ultimate c*ckblock. :tlol:

I do love how Raphael is so protective of Mikey. Y'think he's making up for the Raph micro-issue (which came first)?

I don't care what Peter Laird says, early Mirage April is definitely black. It would have been pretty cool having a prominent black character. But then, Fred Wolf probably would've whitewashed her along with Baxter. :trolleye:

The guy spying on April and the Turtles is Casey Jones, which we can figure out by the time of his timely intervention in Issue #10... still, it would've been helpful if Laird and Eastman had made this a bit more explicit.

Mikey finally gets to be awesome, covering for his brothers and then diving after them into the Transmat. But still... where's the Mikey we know and love? Where's the tender heart, the compassion, the most "human" of the Turtles?

I'd kind of forgotten how long it takes Mikey to have a personality in the original books. Kind of weird to think of. It always seemed to weird to me that Kevin and Peter even have clear favorites. Mikey kind of gets the shaft because he isn't a favorite, and he isn't the leader.

As for April... It is possible that is the original idea they had, but I don't think I agree with you. She is totally rocking that afro though.

TMNachoT
08-01-2015, 10:48 AM
Issue 2
April and Baxter, they are cool characters, I like the story even the mad scientist thing is kinda cliché, but still it´s good story and a key part of any tmnt version. Shame it took so long to see Baxter again in the comics,

I knew first about April and Baxter thanks to the Fred Wolf cartoon before knowing about the comics, so i have to read more comics to realize that at least, Abril was a recurrent character, at least more than Baxter.

I do think Mousers are a believable thread, again, shame we didn´t see them again in the first volumen.

Yes, the personality of the turtles were more developed, although i don´t remember too much about mikey´s persona in this issue.

This issue have a lost of contrast compared to issue 1, maybe the story with baxter/April/Mousers should have been printed for issue 3 or 4 to give more oportunities for at least another 1 or 2 issues with the Foot Clan. That didn´t happen but it´s not a big deal for me.

Issue 3

Because of the car chase, issue 3 is not appealing to me like the other first comics, but I like the story with Splinter.

I don´t remember my reaction about the Utroms. Bad memory! :roll:

Issue 4
Cool issue, and happy to have the first print.

-Again, a big chance of plots and situations compared with issue 1, 2 and 3. We see the turtles fighting with humans and then there are aliens. It happened kinda too fast, from "street fight" to "space adventures".

-About the guy at the apartment, Peter or Laird said they didn´t know exactly who that was, typical with the Mirage, they use one character and then they forget about him.