View Full Version : Casey & April #3 Preview & Discussion
ChosenOne
08-23-2015, 08:25 AM
Preview here (http://www.comicbookresources.com/comic-previews/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-casey-april-3-idw-2015).
boywonder26
08-23-2015, 09:40 AM
I've really enjoyed this series and can't wait to pick this up Wednesday.
PangolinFeets
08-23-2015, 12:47 PM
Yay Pantheon things are gonna happen! :D :D :D
spookycookies
08-23-2015, 03:55 PM
Hopefully this is a turning point for this mini...
qt.bangerang
08-23-2015, 04:34 PM
Well that was another slow, dull 4 pages. Ready for this mini to be over.
old_hob88
08-23-2015, 07:53 PM
Looks like this issue might start to turn me around on this mini-series. Hopefully this issue does pick up the pace.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-23-2015, 11:02 PM
Rat King and the maze? Promising.
But April and her identity crisis... mmm. Eh. We'll see.
MikeandRaph87
08-23-2015, 11:08 PM
Rat King and the maze? Promising.
But April and her identity crisis... mmm. Eh. We'll see.
I appreciate the irony of a maze. Lab rats forced to work their ways through a maze and then the bit with Rat King. Rat King is making this miniseries worthwhile.
Hope you are in or some retro Bat reading, CKD.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-23-2015, 11:16 PM
I appreciate the irony of a maze. Lab rats forced to work their ways through a maze and then the bit with Rat King. Rat King is making this miniseries worthwhile.
Hope you are in or some retro Bat reading, CKD.
Ooooooooooooh, I didn't pick up on that! Good point!
And if I can find 'em, ya never know... :twink:
ChosenOne
08-26-2015, 07:51 AM
The best thing about this issue? Only one more left to go before it's thankfully over.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-26-2015, 08:07 AM
The best thing about this issue? Only one more left to go before it's thankfully over.
Owch. But I think we all were kinda expecting that... :tsad:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-26-2015, 10:32 AM
That's... it!?
Holy crap, this is the most useless story ever. How do you take characters like Rat King, April, Casey, and the Pantheon and make it boring!?
You can literally just take the last page of each issue, read that, and get the full story. That's truly it.
I've often said IDW can do no wrong. I've gotta take it back. This is wrong.
I still have full faith in the main ongoing story, and I've loved every other story. But this is the first black mark against IDW TMNT. A godawful boring story that should be balls-to-the-walls fantastic.
Edit: No matter how better the fourth issue may be, there is no making up for the epic wasted potential of this series.
CyberCubed
08-26-2015, 11:37 AM
Definitely a lot of weird padding here. Whole panels are used just for the characters to say like one line or calling out to each other. Some of the panels take up the whole page, as if this was meant to be a 2-part story that got stretched out to a 4 issue one.
I liked some of the introspective look on the characters personalities but it didn't seem as well done as it could of.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-26-2015, 11:47 AM
Definitely a lot of weird padding here. Whole panels are used just for the characters to say like one line or calling out to each other. Some of the panels take up the whole page, as if this was meant to be a 2-part story that got stretched out to a 4 issue one.
I liked some of the introspective look on the characters personalities but it didn't seem as well done as it could of.
There is nothing new getting added to the characters. Okay, maybe a slight bit for April.
But Casey? We already know PLENTY about his background after 50 issues (plus the micro-series and mini-series). This story has added nothing.
I don't get how you feature Rat King only to have him eat barbeque. That'd be like having Agent Bishop in a story arc, only to ever see him eat sushi while watching the Turtles on his monitor. (Mmmm... sushi.)
Where is the violence and mind-f*ckery!?
Metalhead 2.0
08-26-2015, 12:23 PM
So basically to summarize:
One time April was doing a report on birds, but felt like she was putting too much work into it and her dad told her not give up. The End.
Oh, and Rat King still likes barbeque.
More specifically short-ribs.
ChosenOne
08-26-2015, 12:28 PM
So basically to summarize:
One time April was doing a report on birds, but felt like she was putting too much work into it and her dad told her not give up. The End.
Oh, and Rat King still likes barbeque.
More specifically short-ribs.
And "Red" only appears in one or two panels. I came here for the Pantheon, gosh darn it! :tmad:
How come Utrom Empire with its rich setting was only three issues long, yet this snoozefest gets four?
Metalhead 2.0
08-26-2015, 12:42 PM
I would have put Spoiler tags, but that didn't seem appropriate and there isn't a "I Just Saved Your Ass $3.99" tag.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-26-2015, 12:49 PM
So basically to summarize:
One time April was doing a report on birds, but felt like she was putting too much work into it and her dad told her not give up. The End.
Oh, and Rat King still likes barbeque.
More specifically short-ribs.
It's amazing when you realize, of the three issues released so far, THIS one has the least story content yet.
And "Red" only appears in one or two panels. I came here for the Pantheon, gosh darn it! :tmad:
How come Utrom Empire with its rich setting was only three issues long, yet this snoozefest gets four?
Utrom Empire... damn, I'd completely forgotten about that. Three badass issues versus four coma-inducing issues. Seriously, by the time we read Issue #4, we're not gonna be amazed by any Pantheon secrets revealed. Instead, (and rightly so), we'll be astonished that we had to put up with so much BS to get what will probably amount to one page's worth of useful intel.
But hey, if we set a mousetrap for Rat King, we at least now know to bait it with BBQ.
I would have put Spoiler tags, but that didn't seem appropriate and there isn't a "I Just Saved Your Ass $3.99" tag.
:tlol:
Metalhead 2.0
08-26-2015, 02:09 PM
I don't know who this "target audience" is they're trying to appeal to, but I imagine they look like this.
https://i.imgflip.com/q3uaf.jpg
ChosenOne
08-26-2015, 02:18 PM
I don't know who this "target audience" is they're trying to appeal to, but I imagine they look like this.
https://i.imgflip.com/q3uaf.jpg
I was going to post some sort of BBQ meme in honor of the Rat King's choice of nibbles but I couldn't make up my mind, they all look so delicious. :tcool:
Metalhead 2.0
08-26-2015, 02:31 PM
Something like this?
http://perlbal.hi-pi.com/blog-images/102158/gd/1195579579/RECETTE-DU-RAT-2.jpg
ChosenOne
08-26-2015, 02:36 PM
Something like this?
http://perlbal.hi-pi.com/blog-images/102158/gd/1195579579/RECETTE-DU-RAT-2.jpg
Hey now, not fair. Those rats had more fun lying there than I did reading this issue.
I'm curious to see what the sales numbers for this mini will look like.
CyberCubed
08-26-2015, 02:45 PM
I don't know who this "target audience" is they're trying to appeal to, but I imagine they look like this.]
Judging by the way Casey looks like an anime pretty-boy, I thought this mini was attracted to female anime/manga fans who like shoujo romances.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-26-2015, 02:46 PM
I'm curious to see what the sales numbers for this mini will look like.
Worst case scenario, this mini-series sells like gold-pressed latinum donuts. :tgrumble:
Stugehen
08-26-2015, 06:26 PM
I don't know who this "target audience" is they're trying to appeal to, but I imagine they look like this.
https://i.imgflip.com/q3uaf.jpg
I came on here ticked that IDW shorted my LCS on my prepaid copy. This made me laugh all that away.
Technogeek29
08-26-2015, 07:13 PM
I don't know who this "target audience" is they're trying to appeal to, but I imagine they look like this.
https://i.imgflip.com/q3uaf.jpg
http://31.media.tumblr.com/292277a667ed0761e9570de974a277c7/tumblr_ntm77tmXCQ1roqtzko6_r1_500.gif
ToTheNines
08-26-2015, 07:15 PM
Man, you mofos are brutal. I personally enjoyed it.
The art was great again, and I liked that they kept the suspense up from the end of #2. And Red is obviously gonna be a really interesting character. Maybe it was kind of a quick read for 4 bucks, but I'd rather they cut to the chase than be unnecessarily verbose just to make it feel longer.
Only criticism I have would be April's flashback being kinda silly. I appreciate they didn't reveal anything ridiculously dramatic about her past just to have more drama for this mini though.
Enscripture
08-26-2015, 07:52 PM
Booooooooooooooooooooorrrrrring!
http://orig03.deviantart.net/837d/f/2014/080/b/e/just_resting_my_eyes_a_little_by_sneefee-d7b40oz.jpg
The Big Bad
08-26-2015, 10:25 PM
Worst case scenario, this mini-series sells like gold-pressed latinum donuts. :tgrumble:
Yup, other people enjoying things is totally the worst.
----
I mentioned in the thread for last episode that this is the Mirage-iest thing the IDW-verse has put out--with the possible and obvious exceptions of the Eastman Annuals--but looking at this issue, the mini-series now seems far more reminiscent of the Archie series, where storyarcs could be about a million different things and somewhat unfocused, in a way that allowed it to explore things a longer attention span would not have allowed for. Either way, I continue to enjoy this arc, which manages to feel satisfyingly different from the more familiar stylings of the main book.
Klunk1234
08-26-2015, 11:23 PM
If you don't like this series, simply don't buy it and don't comment. For me, the series is been interesting. April and Casey finally crossedf the maze in order to find clues about the Pantheon.
Next issue will be the grand finale of this story.
Donny's computer84
08-26-2015, 11:45 PM
I like this series it is an interesting sidestep from the turtles series even though there is not a lot of action it does make you think a little. :toops:
MikeandRaph87
08-26-2015, 11:48 PM
That's... it!?
Holy crap, this is the most useless story ever. How do you take characters like Rat King, April, Casey, and the Pantheon and make it boring!?
You can literally just take the last page of each issue, read that, and get the full story. That's truly it.
I've often said IDW can do no wrong. I've gotta take it back. This is wrong.
I still have full faith in the main ongoing story, and I've loved every other story. But this is the first black mark against IDW TMNT. A godawful boring story that should be balls-to-the-walls fantastic.
Edit: No matter how better the fourth issue may be, there is no making up for the epic wasted potential of this series.
Just think, we are one more issue away from getting information on The Pantheon and one more month closer to TMNT : The Gotham Adventure.
Technogeek29
08-26-2015, 11:55 PM
Man, you mofos are brutal. I personally enjoyed it.
The art was great again, and I liked that they kept the suspense up from the end of #2. And Red is obviously gonna be a really interesting character. Maybe it was kind of a quick read for 4 bucks, but I'd rather they cut to the chase than be unnecessarily verbose just to make it feel longer.
Only criticism I have would be April's flashback being kinda silly. I appreciate they didn't reveal anything ridiculously dramatic about her past just to have more drama for this mini though.
I didn't like this particular issue but hey its one of the few times I can say I didn't like something IDW TMNT related so I still think that's pretty good.
shredder orokusaki
08-27-2015, 02:28 AM
I also didnt like it because it dosent have lot of action. But sill read it for the story.
Enscripture
08-27-2015, 05:31 AM
In the last issue. We found out Rat King likes BBQ. In this one, we got to see him eat it. Oh. And he stood up. Oooooh. Such suspense! Lol oh and April and Casey walked around. This reminds me of the Archie April May East Saga cause of how bad it is.
Joey Kamikaze
08-27-2015, 05:32 AM
I'll not nab it till this weekend, but good to know it sounds as gripping as the first two issues. :lol:
old_hob88
08-27-2015, 08:24 AM
That's... it!?
Holy crap, this is the most useless story ever. How do you take characters like Rat King, April, Casey, and the Pantheon and make it boring!?
You can literally just take the last page of each issue, read that, and get the full story. That's truly it.
I've often said IDW can do no wrong. I've gotta take it back. This is wrong.
I still have full faith in the main ongoing story, and I've loved every other story. But this is the first black mark against IDW TMNT. A godawful boring story that should be balls-to-the-walls fantastic.
Edit: No matter how better the fourth issue may be, there is no making up for the epic wasted potential of this series.
Taking the last page of each issue leads us to the tale of "OMG it's the Rat King!" It seems like every single issue ends with the big reveal that yes, in fact, the Rat King is in this story. I'm optimistic about the last issue of the series, and this was better than the first two, though only marginally. Still, the pacing in this mini has been painful.
Metalhead 2.0
08-27-2015, 08:51 AM
If you don't like this series, simply don't buy it and don't comment. For me, the series is been interesting. April and Casey finally crossedf the maze in order to find clues about the Pantheon.
Next issue will be the grand finale of this story.
No, I reckon I WILL buy it, read it, form an opinion on it, and voice those opinions here on this board whether they be negative or positive. That's one of the perks of consumerism, "One dollar, One voice."
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-27-2015, 09:14 AM
Taking the last page of each issue leads us to the tale of "OMG it's the Rat King!" It seems like every single issue ends with the big reveal that yes, in fact, the Rat King is in this story. I'm optimistic about the last issue of the series, and this was better than the first two, though only marginally. Still, the pacing in this mini has been painful.
I think you've summed it up best.
Issue #1: Road trip... HOLY CRAP, RAT KING!
Issue #2: Road trips... HOLY CRAP, RAT KING!
Issue #3: Walking around... HOLY CRAP RAT KING! Also BBQ.
No, I reckon I WILL buy it, read it, form an opinion on it, and voice those opinions here on this board whether they be negative or positive. That's one of the perks of consumerism, "One dollar, One voice."
Our discontent shall be heard! Verily, we shall cry it from the rooftops!
I don't mind stories like this, but the problem is that right from thestart it was obvious what the story will be like. Casey and April having a quarrel, going seperate ways, having hallucinations. the they somehow coming out of it, and coming together. It's such a cliché... It could be an okay story, but it's told in a really boring way, and while it is a character drama, I still don't think it achieved any major (or even minor) character develepment.
The art is also not very good, e.g. characters facial built changes between panels, etc.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-27-2015, 09:55 AM
I don't mind stories like this, but the problem is that right from thestart it was obvious what the story will be like. Casey and April having a quarrel, going seperate ways, having hallucinations. the they somehow coming out of it, and coming together. It's such a cliché... It could be an okay story, but it's told in a really boring way, and while it is a character drama, I still don't think it achieved any major (or even minor) character develepment.
The art is also not very good, e.g. characters facial built changes between panels, etc.
It's not even the fact that it's cliche, but that it's wasted potential. That's my biggest gripe with this arc.
Three issues in, and the only thing I've learned about the Pantheon is that Rat King likes barbeque.
ctt4lfecw
08-27-2015, 01:06 PM
For the love of God will something please happen in this book? I mean c'mon. I feel so ripped off.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-27-2015, 01:12 PM
For the love of God will something please happen in this book? I mean c'mon. I feel so ripped off.
You don't like paying $11.97 plus sales tax for three pages of Rat King wanting to eat barbeque? :tlol:
FunkyDoesIt
08-27-2015, 08:04 PM
Even if I try, I still cannot point one single thing I like about this mini so far. Oh wait I can!
BBQ.
ChosenOne
08-27-2015, 08:12 PM
I'm a glutton for punishment, so I went and reread this issue.
Funny how in April's flashback one of the books is titled Japanese Fauna, and another one is open on a page with a photo of what looks like a red-crowned crane... You can bet that whole bird research thing with her dad will come up again later when she finally meets Red.
(I'm just in it for the Pantheon stuff, really.)
swing_kinker
08-27-2015, 08:25 PM
http://bigglasgowcomic.com/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-casey-and-april-3/
Uncharacteristically negative review from me this time. Can't believe how the good pacing from the first 2 issues has been messed up. Whole load of nothing, like they're making it up on the spot
oldmanwinters
08-27-2015, 09:36 PM
I didn't think the newest issue was bad, and I generally enjoyed it. It was definitely a pretty weird chapter, and I can't help but think the Rat King and the Pantheon angle has been underused thus far. Casey's moments of introspection definitely seems to have more weight than April's. I can't help but think the last thing that would come to my mind when walking through a dark maze inside a random "old lady" trailer would be some night when studying a bunch of text books made me tired. The deep dark corridors of April's soul don't really seem so bad compared to what we've seen with Leo and Casey.
I had hoped IDW would have struck a better balance between trippy ghost story/frustrated love story dynamic. But... there's still one more chapter to go.
Anyhoo, looking forward to the conclusion!
ChosenOne
08-27-2015, 09:57 PM
I didn't think the newest issue was bad, and I generally enjoyed it. It was definitely a pretty weird chapter, and I can't help but think the Rat King and the Pantheon angle has been underused thus far. Casey's moments of introspection definitely seems to have more weight than April's. I can't help but think the last thing that would come to my mind when walking through a dark maze inside a random "old lady" trailer would be some night when studying a bunch of text books made me tired. The deep dark corridors of April's soul don't really seem so bad compared to what we've seen with Leo and Casey.
I had hoped IDW would have struck a better balance between trippy ghost story/frustrated love story dynamic. But... there's still one more chapter to go.
Anyhoo, looking forward to the conclusion!
If April's flashback ties in somewhat to Red's totemic beast of choice, then at least that aspect of the story won't feel so random.
We'll just have to wait for #4 and find out if it's a genuine Chekhov's gun or not.
oldmanwinters
08-27-2015, 10:03 PM
We'll just have to wait for #4 and find out if it's a genuine Chekhov's gun or not.
If it is, I can't help but think the Phaser will be set to merely "stun" rather than "kill." :tcool:
ChosenOne
08-27-2015, 10:22 PM
I've tried to remain optimistic in regards to this mini ever since it was first announced and some people voiced their concerns.
Even now, after three months of disappointment, I want to believe the whole thing will be tied up nicely and end on a better note than what we've seen so far, which I guess speaks volumes about the faith I have in the IDW crew.
If it does end up as bad as it started, then, well... Everyone has their missteps. We as comic book readers are very lucky it took them over 80 issues to get to this point, and can only hope this mini is a fluke in terms of pacing and content.
oldmanwinters
08-27-2015, 11:57 PM
I've tried to remain optimistic in regards to this mini ever since it was first announced and some people voiced their concerns.
Even now, after three months of disappointment, I want to believe the whole thing will be tied up nicely and end on a better note than what we've seen so far, which I guess speaks volumes about the faith I have in the IDW crew.
If it does end up as bad as it started, then, well... Everyone has their missteps. We as comic book readers are very lucky it took them over 80 issues to get to this point, and can only hope this mini is a fluke in terms of pacing and content.
And it's worth remembering that IDW really was trying to write this series for a different type of target audience than might regularly follow the main series. Sales seem to suggest that strategy hasn't panned out too well, but I hate that a story revolving around Casey & April had to fall into a "niche" demographic in the first place. I really like both characters, and I'd like to think that a story arc built around the one or both of them could still appeal to the majority of TMNT fans, even if the Turtles themselves have little or no direct involvement with the storyline. Remember the original Archie Comics April O'Neil mini-series? That was a pretty good development of various loose ends in the TMNTA continuity, and I don't think the TMNT appeared at all.
DrSpengler
08-28-2015, 12:19 PM
Here's my review of Casey & April #3 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/08/tmnt-casey-april-3.html)
I'm just not feeling this miniseries, I'm afraid. The set piece of the labyrinth felt a bit squandered, as it was rendered as nothing but blackness. The issue wound up looking like a lot of empty space.
That said, there are interesting qualities underneath the surface that I'd like to learn more of. Mostly regarding the Rat King, of course.
oldmanwinters
08-28-2015, 12:57 PM
Here's my review of Casey & April #3 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/08/tmnt-casey-april-3.html)
I'm just not feeling this miniseries, I'm afraid. The set piece of the labyrinth felt a bit squandered, as it was rendered as nothing but blackness. The issue wound up looking like a lot of empty space.
That said, there are interesting qualities underneath the surface that I'd like to learn more of. Mostly regarding the Rat King, of course.
I appreciate your analysis of the problems of trying to structure a 20-page American comic like a traditional manga. Very good insight.
Metropoliskid41
08-30-2015, 12:03 AM
This whole series very much reads as an Indy comic from the era of decompressed storytelling. It very much reminds me of the first 12-15 issues of Jeff Lemire's Sweet Tooth story from Vertigo. It is an interesting premise with very slow pacing and little story content, resulting in a fast read and nothing much happening. Like Sweet Tooth, it has very simple art (don't read that as bad) just mostly figure work with a lot of negative space. Simple art for me (at least at this level) where there isn't much action, works best when being paired with heavy dialog (like Bendis & Gulacy's Alias series from Marvel) but we aren't getting that here. This will most likely read a lot better in collected form, the pacing won't seem so slow in that format, but this one should have either been a larger one-shot or a two-issue mini-series, not stretched to 4 monthly issue moving at this slow of pace.
I have enjoyed the series premise, reread issues 1-3 back to back to back tonight and had less issues with it than reading them one at a time with a month between issues.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-30-2015, 03:55 PM
This whole series very much reads as an Indy comic from the era of decompressed storytelling. It very much reminds me of the first 12-15 issues of Jeff Lemire's Sweet Tooth story from Vertigo. It is an interesting premise with very slow pacing and little story content, resulting in a fast read and nothing much happening. Like Sweet Tooth, it has very simple art (don't read that as bad) just mostly figure work with a lot of negative space. Simple art for me (at least at this level) where there isn't much action, works best when being paired with heavy dialog (like Bendis & Gulacy's Alias series from Marvel) but we aren't getting that here. This will most likely read a lot better in collected form, the pacing won't seem so slow in that format, but this one should have either been a larger one-shot or a two-issue mini-series, not stretched to 4 monthly issue moving at this slow of pace.
I have enjoyed the series premise, reread issues 1-3 back to back to back tonight and had less issues with it than reading them one at a time with a month between issues.
Sweet Tooth had storytelling that was nowhere NEAR this slow. I mean, c'mon... the old guy with a shotgun (name escapes me) showed up at the end of page 1. There was TONS of awesome stuff in that series, and it was nowhere near slow.
FlawedCoil82
08-30-2015, 04:49 PM
Yea, I read this issue last night and was amazed at how "empty" it felt. I was expecting some grand "reveal" but it was just an uneventful event. IDW still has some "good faith wiggle room" built up for taking some missteps here or there since they are regularly killing it in the main books, but this mini-series is definitely on the low end of their otherwise stellar output. Yet like April learned in this issue, "The Only Way Out Is In", so that means only one more issue until we are out of this mess.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-30-2015, 05:29 PM
Yea, I read this issue last night and was amazed at how "empty" it felt. I was expecting some grand "reveal" but it was just an uneventful event. IDW still has some "good faith wiggle room" built up for taking some missteps here or there since they are regularly killing it in the main books, but this mini-series is definitely on the low end of their otherwise stellar output. Yet like April learned in this issue, "The Only Way Out Is In", so that means only one more issue until we are out of this mess.
Good way to put it.
I'm personally interested to know how much of the next issue's revealed facts will be unique/independent to this issue, and how much of it will be reiterated in the ongoing series' new few issues. Because if there's enough overlap, I may forgo purchasing the TPB. And except for the two abysmal annuals, which have also been both terrible and mostly standalone, I've bought everything for my bookshelf.
Still, we could learn some interesting stuff... but honestly, at this point, I wonder if the Rat King will reward April and Casey with ANYTHING. I thought "Red" would be more sympathetic and more antagonistic towards Rat King, but so far, she doesn't seem like she's anymore of an ally to the TMNT than the Rat King himself. And if that's the case... this whole desert excursion may turn out to be more of a trap than a fact-finding mission.
Joey Kamikaze
08-30-2015, 10:56 PM
Got hold of the issue, just read it.
...That was maybe five pages worth of story spread out over an entire issue. Jesus. I can see calling this miniseries manga-influenced, but if you're dragging out your stories as long as humanly possible, I think you're taking the wrong lesson away from the medium.
ChosenOne
08-30-2015, 11:31 PM
Got hold of the issue, just read it.
...That was maybe five pages worth of story spread out over an entire issue. Jesus. I can see calling this miniseries manga-influenced, but if you're dragging out your stories as long as humanly possible, I think you're taking the wrong lesson away from the medium.
Maybe it was specifically influenced by Dragon Ball? :D
spookycookies
08-31-2015, 01:25 PM
My favorite part of this whole series so far is when Casey meets up with April again and says "I hate California" that's exactly how I feel about this whole mess.
This series wasted so much time and potential doing nothing. This Rat King doesn't feel at all like the character from last year. I repeat this every Casey & April thread but I don't think the different audience thing is a valid excuse to alienate the people that have been buying your books since day one. If IDW expects to find new readers from this series they are going about it the wrong way. It's like locking the front door and opening the bathroom window, how could anyone who only picked up Casey and April be willing to start buying Flyborg Smash Fest 2015?
I don't think that the creative team for this mini series should be doing any more work in this comic's universe again. I wish them the best of luck elsewhere but they really bored me all summer long with this book.
People say in this book's defense things like "If you don't like it don't buy it," "It was made with a different audience in mind not you," but I can't accept that. IDW's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is my favorite comic by far and I want this universe to continue and it's regular staff to succeed. IDW TMNT is the only book I purchase every month and when I do I buy a copy of each variant cover I can get a hold of. I'm not saying that I'm entitled to some type of content or that the publisher should be beholden to my tastes but literally I am the apex customer and if someone like me is consistently groaning through this book for 3 months than it is a sign that it just doesn't fit in with the rest of the series in a major way.
Casey & April is the worst mini in the IDW TMNT volume. I would rather have waited for a 4 part Eastman annual than this junk.
ChosenOne
08-31-2015, 02:13 PM
Casey & April is the worst mini in the IDW TMNT volume. I would rather have waited for a 4 part Eastman annual than this junk.
Please don't give them ideas...
Metalhead 2.0
08-31-2015, 02:17 PM
Please don't give them ideas...
Yeah, the only thing that could make Casey & April worse is if Eastman was on art.
ChosenOne
08-31-2015, 02:25 PM
Yeah, the only thing that could make Casey & April worse is if Eastman was on art.
Didn't Eastman write, and I use the term very loosely, the annuals as well? Can you imagine what this mini would be like if he introduced every single character Casey and April come across in the desert in the same manner that he introduced the lowlifes of New York in the first annual?
(I'm not trying to give y'all nightmares, honest!)
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-31-2015, 02:34 PM
Didn't Eastman write, and I use the term very loosely, the annuals as well? Can you imagine what this mini would be like if he introduced every single character Casey and April come across in the desert in the same manner that he introduced the lowlifes of New York in the first annual?
(I'm not trying to give y'all nightmares, honest!)
Or maybe Laird could write for an IDW mini-series... nothing but Mikey waxing eloquent on alien corn, and Leo musing on tap water. (Sorry, I just read DrSpengler's latest Volume 4 review.) :tlol:
Metalhead 2.0
08-31-2015, 02:37 PM
Didn't Eastman write, and I use the term very loosely, the annuals as well? Can you imagine what this mini would be like if he introduced every single character Casey and April come across in the desert in the same manner that he introduced the lowlifes of New York in the first annual?
(I'm not trying to give y'all nightmares, honest!)
They haven't really met many people. Rednecks at the diner, chick with the car, Rat King as old man, and the weirdos in the armory. Anyone else I missed in all those empty panels?
I just couldn't deal with looking at THESE two jackasses doing absolutely NOTHING for four solid months.
http://media-cache-ec0.pinimg.com/736x/a9/a4/64/a9a46443d38001b1f852e42ef1811cb3.jpg
AT LEAST the current April is fairly attractive in some panels.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-31-2015, 02:41 PM
They haven't really met many people. Rednecks at the diner, chick with the car, Rat King as old man, and the weirdos in the armory. Anyone else I missed in all those empty panels?
I just couldn't deal with looking at THESE two jackasses doing absolutely NOTHING for four solid months.
http://media-cache-ec0.pinimg.com/736x/a9/a4/64/a9a46443d38001b1f852e42ef1811cb3.jpg
AT LEAST the current April is fairly attractive in some panels.
I don't like the art of Casey & April, but hell, if I can stomach the art of Mutanimals for an awesome story, I'm down for whatever visual style.
Terrible writing and wasted potential, however, are sins I do not ever forgive. If this writer shows up on the main ongoing, I will flip my lid and lose my S. Like, moreso than I've already done. :tlol:
ChosenOne
08-31-2015, 02:51 PM
They haven't really met many people. Rednecks at the diner, chick with the car, Rat King as old man, and the weirdos in the armory. Anyone else I missed in all those empty panels?
It's all a blur to me, what about the lady with the kids? Anyway, those are more than enough for Eastman to write another epic bore as seen through the eyes of completely irrelevant background characters.
I'm actually okay with the art, mostly so long as it stays confined to this mini. It's the story and pacing that gets me.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-31-2015, 02:57 PM
It's all a blur to me, what about the lady with the kids? Anyway, those are more than enough for Eastman to write another epic bore as seen through the eyes of completely irrelevant background characters.
I'm actually okay with the art, mostly so long as it stays confined to this mini. It's the story and pacing that gets me.
I still don't think they've met any real people except the rednecks and the diner waitress. Creepy lady and creepier kids, hippies... probably none of them real. What's even funnier is that even though so much time was spent with these walk-on characters, they mean NOTHING. Absolutely pointless.
But hey, April worked on a really hard report one time and her dad told her it was worth it...
Yay. Character development. :trolleye:
EDITED: Oh, and as for Casey... that was actually okay, but the only problem is, it's nothing new! We already know about all that. Why couldn't we see Casey worrying about becoming like his dad, instead of just reflecting, Yeah, I had a messed up childhood?
ChosenOne
08-31-2015, 03:03 PM
Since we're dissecting the mini (again! yay, fun!) I was half expecting to see Hun re-imagined as the Minotaur in Casey's mind when the Rat King starts talking about the myth and there are sounds of a hoofed, snorting beast approaching... Too bad I turned the page and there was nothing of the sort there.
Metalhead 2.0
08-31-2015, 03:14 PM
Since we're dissecting the mini (again! yay, fun!) I was half expecting to see Hun re-imagined as the Minotaur in Casey's mind when the Rat King starts talking about the myth and there are sounds of a hoofed, snorting beast approaching... Too bad I turned the page and there was nothing of the sort there.
I still don't understand what he was hearing back in issue 2(?) and why he was having such a damned difficult time getting into the armory that was shown to have an entrance opening large enough to drive 3 semis through side by side.
??
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-31-2015, 03:14 PM
Since we're dissecting the mini (again! yay, fun!) I was half expecting to see Hun re-imagined as the Minotaur in Casey's mind when the Rat King starts talking about the myth and there are sounds of a hoofed, snorting beast approaching... Too bad I turned the page and there was nothing of the sort there.
I was expecting to see Casey fight a monstrous version of Hun in a hockey mask, only for the hockey mask to fall off and reveal Casey himself.
Yeah, a little stereotypical. Also not as boring as waiting for water to boil. Would also tie in to the ongoing series.
ChosenOne
08-31-2015, 03:20 PM
I still don't understand what he was hearing back in issue 2(?) and why he was having such a damned difficult time getting into the armory that was shown to have an entrance opening large enough to drive 3 semis through side by side.
??
I believe Casey was hearing the chanting and drumming of the hippies, which he mistook for someone in trouble. As for getting in, that wasn't the hard part. He was just annoyed that he rode all the way out there expecting to find an armory and found an abandoned, overgrown mess instead. Then as he ventures inside, the brambles (think Maleficent) give him some trouble.
The whole thing is kinda awkwardly presented, though. Doesn't make much sense.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-31-2015, 03:25 PM
I believe Casey was hearing the chanting and drumming of the hippies, which he mistook for someone in trouble. As for getting in, that wasn't the hard part. He was just annoyed that he rode all the way out there expecting to find an armory and found an abandoned, overgrown mess instead. Then as he ventures inside, the brambles (think Maleficent) give him some trouble.
The whole thing is kinda awkwardly presented, though. Doesn't make much sense.
The whole damn story is kinda awkwardly presented. :tlol:
boywonder26
08-31-2015, 04:41 PM
I've really been enjoying this mini can't wait to see what happens next.
Joey Kamikaze
08-31-2015, 05:47 PM
Casey & April is the worst mini in the IDW TMNT volume. I would rather have waited for a 4 part Eastman annual than this junk.
Let's not say things we can't take back.
Metalhead 2.0
08-31-2015, 09:26 PM
I believe Casey was hearing the chanting and drumming of the hippies, which he mistook for someone in trouble. As for getting in, that wasn't the hard part. He was just annoyed that he rode all the way out there expecting to find an armory and found an abandoned, overgrown mess instead. Then as he ventures inside, the brambles (think Maleficent) give him some trouble.
The whole thing is kinda awkwardly presented, though. Doesn't make much sense.
I haven't seen Maleficent, so I'm not sure what brambles are but I'm guessing that's some kind of magical, semi-aware plant life that reaches out and grabs you? If so, who was controlling it? Rat King? And why did he even go that way? Why didn't he just go through the giant frickin' opening they showed?
ChosenOne
08-31-2015, 09:46 PM
I haven't seen Maleficent, so I'm not sure what brambles are but I'm guessing that's some kind of magical, semi-aware plant life that reaches out and grabs you? If so, who was controlling it? Rat King? And why did he even go that way? Why didn't he just go through the giant frickin' opening they showed?
English isn't my native language but I do believe "brambles" is a catch-all term for a variety of thorny plants growing wildly out of control, like so:
https://dreamsofeden1.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/brambles-before-1024x768.jpg
Whenever I see something like this, I'm reminded of the thorny trees and bushes Maleficent puts up as a makeshift wall in the original animated movie and then in the live-action adaptation with Angelina Jolie.
They don't necessarily grab at you but they do tend to snag on clothing and puncture skin, so it's enough of a pain to navigate through a thicket of these that it gave Casey pause until he thought someone was in danger on the other side. At least that's how I took it.
As for the opening in the bushes, I do think he heads that way to cross to the other side, but a natural tunnel like that will only take him so far before he has to struggle to make his way through, like we see him doing a page or two later. And all that so "save" some hippies. Sheesh.
Kingoji
09-01-2015, 08:44 AM
Welp, I was gonna pop in here and mention that I was finding this mini rather disappointing, but you guys seem to have that covered, so...
*Pops back out*
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-01-2015, 09:51 AM
So I was walking to my desk this morning counting down the days to TMNT #50, and I remembered that C&A #4 comes out a week before.
Mayhaps one of the reasons this mini-series is so slow is because the team didn't want to give away any Pantheon secrets too far in advance of Kitsune's big reveal in Issue #50?
But that doesn't really make sense; they could still be writing three issues with enough action, dread, and purpose without revealing Pantheon secrets.
Screw this.
MikeandRaph87
09-01-2015, 10:08 AM
So I was walking to my desk this morning counting down the days to TMNT #50, and I remembered that C&A #4 comes out a week before.
Mayhaps one of the reasons this mini-series is so slow is because the team didn't want to give away any Pantheon secrets too far in advance of Kitsune's big reveal in Issue #50?
But that doesn't really make sense; they could still be writing three issues with enough action, dread, and purpose without revealing Pantheon secrets.
Screw this.
I thought the timing of it all was to give us a big reveal on what the Pantheon is and give us insight to Kitsune's true motivations. One thing strikes me odd is how Shredder seems to be in the dark of her having bigger plans. It seems she is a blind spot for him. I would say it is because he has a stereotype of women being beneath men, but Karai has stepped out of line and he approves eventually so that would not necessarily be it. Maybe it is some spell of influence that Shredder has had on him the whole time not just that one moment from the latest issue.
Besides CKD, I gave you a list of comics to look for that may be better. ;)
spookycookies
09-01-2015, 12:05 PM
I thought the timing of it all was to give us a big reveal on what the Pantheon is and give us insight to Kitsune's true motivations. One thing strikes me odd is how Shredder seems to be in the dark of her having bigger plans. It seems she is a blind spot for him. I would say it is because he has a stereotype of women being beneath men, but Karai has stepped out of line and he approves eventually so that would not necessarily be it. Maybe it is some spell of influence that Shredder has had on him the whole time not just that one moment from the latest issue.
Besides CKD, I gave you a list of comics to look for that may be better. ;)
I think Shredder places so much of his trust in Kitsune, if it weren't for her he wouldn't be immortal, she's been there for him in 3 lifetimes so far. Of course she's working some sort of influence over him, nothing at all like she pulled with Leonardo, sometimes when someone does want something, (in this case finally defeating the Hamato Clan,) all she needs to do is give that little push and Saki is going through with this whole thing he initially didn't agree to.
What a complex and intricate plot. I'm glad at least Kitsune isn't wasting her time eating BBQ at Foot headquarters all day...
DarkLightDragon
09-01-2015, 12:07 PM
^Nah, she'd just be having some tea instead.:P
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-01-2015, 12:53 PM
I think Shredder places so much of his trust in Kitsune, if it weren't for her he wouldn't be immortal, she's been there for him in 3 lifetimes so far. Of course she's working some sort of influence over him, nothing at all like she pulled with Leonardo, sometimes when someone does want something, (in this case finally defeating the Hamato Clan,) all she needs to do is give that little push and Saki is going through with this whole thing he initially didn't agree to.
What a complex and intricate plot. I'm glad at least Kitsune isn't wasting her time eating BBQ at Foot headquarters all day...
Spookycookies, you have won the Technodrome Forums for the day! :tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:
Joey Kamikaze
09-01-2015, 04:35 PM
SHotFC and other past issues suggest Kitsune is Shredder's lover and mother of his children. Karai is presumably descended from the results of their coupling. So yeah, it's understandable if Kitsune's a huge blind spot for him.
ChosenOne
09-01-2015, 05:00 PM
SHotFC and other past issues suggest Kitsune is Shredder's lover and mother of his children. Karai is presumably descended from the results of their coupling. So yeah, it's understandable if Kitsune's a huge blind spot for him.
How would the two having children even work, given that she's not exactly a normal human? Did she give birth naturally? Do their kids inherit any sort of innate abilities from their supernatural mother? I wonder...
Joey Kamikaze
09-01-2015, 06:02 PM
Presumably Kitsune is fully functional in human form. We see the children she bore for Shredder in SHothFC. As to the rest, I wonder too. But it could be a Lost Odyssey style thing where gods, having taken human form, will give birth to completely normal human children.
spookycookies
09-01-2015, 06:46 PM
Spookycookies, you have won the Technodrome Forums for the day! :tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:
I'm overjoyed that we could all bond over the grueling monotony that is Casey & April.
ChosenOne
09-01-2015, 06:57 PM
I'm overjoyed that we could all bond over the grueling monotony that is Casey & April.
No kidding... Even discussing the workings of Kitsune's womb is more engrossing that this mini.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-01-2015, 07:00 PM
I'm overjoyed that we could all bond over the grueling monotony that is Casey & April.
This is like one of those "Coming of Age" ceremonies some tribes or cultures made their young people go through. Pain, fasting, torture, mental anguish, deprivation...
Fortunately, I have the mindset and stubbornness of a Klingon. Today is a good day to read sh!tty comics. :tlol:
No kidding... Even discussing the workings of Kitsune's womb is more engrossing that this mini.
:tcouch: This ain't the AD, so I'm just gonna stay behind the couch and wiggle my eyebrows suggestively.
spookycookies
09-01-2015, 07:22 PM
This is like one of those "Coming of Age" ceremonies some tribes or cultures made their young people go through. Pain, fasting, torture, mental anguish, deprivation...
Fortunately, I have the mindset and stubbornness of a Klingon. Today is a good day to read sh!tty comics. :tlol: .
It would seem like it. I really wish this was a decent book, if it brought in a new audience that would be great, but this is just too far out of right field. I'm positive this story could have been told with half the pages it got and it would be a much more satisfying read. We are all just being dragged along for the ride and I just wanna get off this crazy thing.
I guess it's time to shine the Bat-signal and hope for the best next month.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-01-2015, 07:54 PM
I'm starting to feel bad about ragging on this comic, but I'm a writer and I can't not trumpet my opinions on writing. Probably shooting myself in the foot, but oh well... hey, TMNT pun! :fshifty:
Here's how this mini-series could have been done:
Issue #1:
Cold open with April lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. She doesn't know how she got here or what happened to Casey... but noises in the shadows spur her to begin walking.
As she walks, trying to rationally figure out the maze by her spatial surroundings and a smattering of architecture, physics, and common sense, she remembers what's happened.
She and Casey traveled into the California desert in search of answers regarding the Pantheon, but their van ran an older man in a motorcycle off the road; agreeing to help him, Casey sets off to check out a possible location (the armory) while April heads out to find the old man's sister.
She found the trailer and walked inside... but found herself in this maze.
As she walks, April is haunted by recent events: Donatello smashed and crippled, the Turtles going up against the Foot, her parents and Casey being attacked by Hun...
April is then confronted by a spectral vision of Donatello, claiming to be dead... we're ALL dead. Because April couldn't help them, they're all dead.
Donatello then forcibly shows April visions of the Foot hench mutants standing victorious over the smashed bloodied bodies of Leo, Raph, and Mikey; Shredder stabbing Splinter and throwing his body to the ground in triumph; Hun returning to the antique store and attacking her parents, crippling and killing Beth and John...
Flashback to the beginning of the adventure, and we see April heading off... watched by the old man who turns into the spectral Rat King, who smiles grimly to himself
Issue #2:
Cold open with Casey lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. He doesn't know how he got here or what happened to April... but noises in the shadows spur him to begin walking.
As he walks, Casey is worried... what's going on, and is April okay? As the maze continues to baffle and confound him, Casey loses his temper finally and begins punching the walls of the maze
Only to have Hun appear behind him, laughing mockingly at his son's futile frustration
Hun declares that the Jones boys are worthless, good for nothing and never able to protect the women they love...
Casey turns on Hun and attacks, but Hun is no longer there... instead, it's a younger version of Casey that he smashes in the face
Knocked to the floor, bleeding and crying, the young Casey picks himself up and flees into the darkness of the maze
Horrified at what he's done, Casey runs after his younger self, apologizing and trying to explain...
But instead, Casey finds April, lying crumpled and bloody on the floor and screaming for help as a large hulking man (who looks just like Hun, but with his upper body hidden in shadow) threatens to hit her again
Casey lunges for the man, screaming that he'll kill Hun if he touches April again--but the figure turns, as Casey knocks off the man's hockey mask and sees that the man is dark-haired, not blond... and it's an older version of Casey, not his father
Reveal Rat King and a mysterious other figure watching the nightmarish scene, as the other figure (a woman) asks if the Rat King is enjoying the spectacle...
Issue #3:
Lost in the maze and tormented by a spectral Donatello, April's trying to remain calm and rational; there's no way this is real
But Donatello mocks her, reminding her that she hangs out with reincarnated Japanese warriors who fight aliens and mutants, and who have encountered spirits before...
April failed them... failed everybody
April continues to insist that it's not real, but she's wavering... as the unseen Rat King watches with a devilish grin
Elsewhere, Casey is haunted by the image of his older self, violent and out of control, and can only stand numbly as Hun walks up behind him
"No matter what, Casey, you turn out just like me; angry, lashing out in pain and driving away everyone you love... it's in our blood, Casey. You're a Jones."
Casey refuses to accept this, but Hun vows to make him accept it one way or another, and lunges to attack him
As Donatello bitterly tells April that she's useless and let her friends and family die, April finally rallies and denounces the spectral figure
She's here because she's not useless; she's determined to do everything she can, even when it feels like she can't contribute to this crazy mess of aliens, mutants, gods, and monsters
If everyone else dies, and she can't stop it, she can at least avenge them; she can find and fight the Pantheon herself, even if she has to do it alone
Casey starts to raise a fist to attack his father, but then stops. He's not like his father; he's not going to allow violence to control him.
Hun can do whatever he wants to him, but he won't let him hurt April... so go ahead and hurt him instead. He won't stop him. Casey then folds his arms, stands motionless, and stares up at Hun...
The spectral visions haunting both Casey and April vanish, and they see each other only yards away
The two are reunited, realizing that something or someone is watching them...
On cue, the Rat King steps from the shadows, congratulating their cleverness. They've made it through the maze... now they be granted an audience with the Pantheon.
spookycookies
09-01-2015, 08:09 PM
I'm starting to feel bad about ragging on this comic, but I'm a writer and I can't not trumpet my opinions on writing. Probably shooting myself in the foot, but oh well... hey, TMNT pun! :fshifty:
Here's how this mini-series could have been done:
Issue #1:
Cold open with April lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. She doesn't know how she got here or what happened to Casey... but noises in the shadows spur her to begin walking.
As she walks, trying to rationally figure out the maze by her spatial surroundings and a smattering of architecture, physics, and common sense, she remembers what's happened.
She and Casey traveled into the California desert in search of answers regarding the Pantheon, but their van ran an older man in a motorcycle off the road; agreeing to help him, Casey sets off to check out a possible location (the armory) while April heads out to find the old man's sister.
She found the trailer and walked inside... but found herself in this maze.
As she walks, April is haunted by recent events: Donatello smashed and crippled, the Turtles going up against the Foot, her parents and Casey being attacked by Hun...
April is then confronted by a spectral vision of Donatello, claiming to be dead... we're ALL dead. Because April couldn't help them, they're all dead.
Donatello then forcibly shows April visions of the Foot hench mutants standing victorious over the smashed bloodied bodies of Leo, Raph, and Mikey; Shredder stabbing Splinter and throwing his body to the ground in triumph; Hun returning to the antique store and attacking her parents, crippling and killing Beth and John...
Flashback to the beginning of the adventure, and we see April heading off... watched by the old man who turns into the spectral Rat King, who smiles grimly to himself
Issue #2:
Cold open with Casey lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. He doesn't know how he got here or what happened to April... but noises in the shadows spur him to begin walking.
As he walks, Casey is worried... what's going on, and is April okay? As the maze continues to baffle and confound him, Casey loses his temper finally and begins punching the walls of the maze
Only to have Hun appear behind him, laughing mockingly at his son's futile frustration
Hun declares that the Jones boys are worthless, good for nothing and never able to protect the women they love...
Casey turns on Hun and attacks, but Hun is no longer there... instead, it's a younger version of Casey that he smashes in the face
Knocked to the floor, bleeding and crying, the young Casey picks himself up and flees into the darkness of the maze
Horrified at what he's done, Casey runs after his younger self, apologizing and trying to explain...
But instead, Casey finds April, lying crumpled and bloody on the floor and screaming for help as a large hulking man (who looks just like Hun, but with his upper body hidden in shadow) threatens to hit her again
Casey lunges for the man, screaming that he'll kill Hun if he touches April again--but the figure turns, as Casey knocks off the man's hockey mask and sees that the man is dark-haired, not blond... and it's an older version of Casey, not his father
Reveal Rat King and a mysterious other figure watching the nightmarish scene, as the other figure (a woman) asks if the Rat King is enjoying the spectacle...
Issue #3:
Lost in the maze and tormented by a spectral Donatello, April's trying to remain calm and rational; there's no way this is real
But Donatello mocks her, reminding her that she hangs out with reincarnated Japanese warriors who fight aliens and mutants, and who have encountered spirits before...
April failed them... failed everybody
April continues to insist that it's not real, but she's wavering... as the unseen Rat King watches with a devilish grin
Elsewhere, Casey is haunted by the image of his older self, violent and out of control, and can only stand numbly as Hun walks up behind him
"No matter what, Casey, you turn out just like me; angry, lashing out in pain and driving away everyone you love... it's in our blood, Casey. You're a Jones."
Casey refuses to accept this, but Hun vows to make him accept it one way or another, and lunges to attack him
As Donatello bitterly tells April that she's useless and let her friends and family die, April finally rallies and denounces the spectral figure
She's here because she's not useless; she's determined to do everything she can, even when it feels like she can't contribute to this crazy mess of aliens, mutants, gods, and monsters
If everyone else dies, and she can't stop it, she can at least avenge them; she can find and fight the Pantheon herself, even if she has to do it alone
Casey starts to raise a fist to attack his father, but then stops. He's not like his father; he's not going to allow violence to control him.
Hun can do whatever he wants to him, but he won't let him hurt April... so go ahead and hurt him instead. He won't stop him. Casey then folds his arms, stands motionless, and stares up at Hun...
The spectral visions haunting both Casey and April vanish, and they see each other only yards away
The two are reunited, realizing that something or someone is watching them...
On cue, the Rat King steps from the shadows, congratulating their cleverness. They've made it through the maze... now they be granted an audience with the Pantheon.
I like this run at it, let's call this version............April & Casey :trazz:
Great job including Donatello, I can't wrap my head around how insanely absent everyone but the titular characters are. You would think that even though they are going through Rat King's discount haunted house that April would still be shaken up by Donnie's condition. Also it would tie the story in better with the main book and maybe interest a few of those coveted new readers to check out what exactly happened to Donnie in the main book.
The core story that this book is trying miserably to tell is that Casey & April are both hung up on their own personal issues to be in a strong relationship/partnership. They have the same problem but are on different sides of it: Casey is afraid of his past and that it will catch up with him, April is afraid of her future and that nothing meaningful will come from her efforts to help her friends. I wish that this message was clearer.
Metalhead 2.0
09-02-2015, 09:34 AM
I'm starting to feel bad about ragging on this comic, but I'm a writer and I can't not trumpet my opinions on writing. Probably shooting myself in the foot, but oh well... hey, TMNT pun! :fshifty:
Here's how this mini-series could have been done:
Issue #1:
Cold open with April lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. She doesn't know how she got here or what happened to Casey... but noises in the shadows spur her to begin walking.
As she walks, trying to rationally figure out the maze by her spatial surroundings and a smattering of architecture, physics, and common sense, she remembers what's happened.
She and Casey traveled into the California desert in search of answers regarding the Pantheon, but their van ran an older man in a motorcycle off the road; agreeing to help him, Casey sets off to check out a possible location (the armory) while April heads out to find the old man's sister.
She found the trailer and walked inside... but found herself in this maze.
As she walks, April is haunted by recent events: Donatello smashed and crippled, the Turtles going up against the Foot, her parents and Casey being attacked by Hun...
April is then confronted by a spectral vision of Donatello, claiming to be dead... we're ALL dead. Because April couldn't help them, they're all dead.
Donatello then forcibly shows April visions of the Foot hench mutants standing victorious over the smashed bloodied bodies of Leo, Raph, and Mikey; Shredder stabbing Splinter and throwing his body to the ground in triumph; Hun returning to the antique store and attacking her parents, crippling and killing Beth and John...
Flashback to the beginning of the adventure, and we see April heading off... watched by the old man who turns into the spectral Rat King, who smiles grimly to himself
Issue #2:
Cold open with Casey lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. He doesn't know how he got here or what happened to April... but noises in the shadows spur him to begin walking.
As he walks, Casey is worried... what's going on, and is April okay? As the maze continues to baffle and confound him, Casey loses his temper finally and begins punching the walls of the maze
Only to have Hun appear behind him, laughing mockingly at his son's futile frustration
Hun declares that the Jones boys are worthless, good for nothing and never able to protect the women they love...
Casey turns on Hun and attacks, but Hun is no longer there... instead, it's a younger version of Casey that he smashes in the face
Knocked to the floor, bleeding and crying, the young Casey picks himself up and flees into the darkness of the maze
Horrified at what he's done, Casey runs after his younger self, apologizing and trying to explain...
But instead, Casey finds April, lying crumpled and bloody on the floor and screaming for help as a large hulking man (who looks just like Hun, but with his upper body hidden in shadow) threatens to hit her again
Casey lunges for the man, screaming that he'll kill Hun if he touches April again--but the figure turns, as Casey knocks off the man's hockey mask and sees that the man is dark-haired, not blond... and it's an older version of Casey, not his father
Reveal Rat King and a mysterious other figure watching the nightmarish scene, as the other figure (a woman) asks if the Rat King is enjoying the spectacle...
Issue #3:
Lost in the maze and tormented by a spectral Donatello, April's trying to remain calm and rational; there's no way this is real
But Donatello mocks her, reminding her that she hangs out with reincarnated Japanese warriors who fight aliens and mutants, and who have encountered spirits before...
April failed them... failed everybody
April continues to insist that it's not real, but she's wavering... as the unseen Rat King watches with a devilish grin
Elsewhere, Casey is haunted by the image of his older self, violent and out of control, and can only stand numbly as Hun walks up behind him
"No matter what, Casey, you turn out just like me; angry, lashing out in pain and driving away everyone you love... it's in our blood, Casey. You're a Jones."
Casey refuses to accept this, but Hun vows to make him accept it one way or another, and lunges to attack him
As Donatello bitterly tells April that she's useless and let her friends and family die, April finally rallies and denounces the spectral figure
She's here because she's not useless; she's determined to do everything she can, even when it feels like she can't contribute to this crazy mess of aliens, mutants, gods, and monsters
If everyone else dies, and she can't stop it, she can at least avenge them; she can find and fight the Pantheon herself, even if she has to do it alone
Casey starts to raise a fist to attack his father, but then stops. He's not like his father; he's not going to allow violence to control him.
Hun can do whatever he wants to him, but he won't let him hurt April... so go ahead and hurt him instead. He won't stop him. Casey then folds his arms, stands motionless, and stares up at Hun...
The spectral visions haunting both Casey and April vanish, and they see each other only yards away
The two are reunited, realizing that something or someone is watching them...
On cue, the Rat King steps from the shadows, congratulating their cleverness. They've made it through the maze... now they be granted an audience with the Pantheon.
But where's the barbecue?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-02-2015, 09:55 AM
But where's the barbecue?
End of Issue #2, Rat King is eating spareribs as he and Red watch the spectacle...
oldmanwinters
09-02-2015, 10:34 AM
I'm starting to feel bad about ragging on this comic, but I'm a writer and I can't not trumpet my opinions on writing. Probably shooting myself in the foot, but oh well... hey, TMNT pun! :fshifty:
Here's how this mini-series could have been done:
Issue #1:
Cold open with April lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. She doesn't know how she got here or what happened to Casey... but noises in the shadows spur her to begin walking.
As she walks, trying to rationally figure out the maze by her spatial surroundings and a smattering of architecture, physics, and common sense, she remembers what's happened.
She and Casey traveled into the California desert in search of answers regarding the Pantheon, but their van ran an older man in a motorcycle off the road; agreeing to help him, Casey sets off to check out a possible location (the armory) while April heads out to find the old man's sister.
She found the trailer and walked inside... but found herself in this maze.
As she walks, April is haunted by recent events: Donatello smashed and crippled, the Turtles going up against the Foot, her parents and Casey being attacked by Hun...
April is then confronted by a spectral vision of Donatello, claiming to be dead... we're ALL dead. Because April couldn't help them, they're all dead.
Donatello then forcibly shows April visions of the Foot hench mutants standing victorious over the smashed bloodied bodies of Leo, Raph, and Mikey; Shredder stabbing Splinter and throwing his body to the ground in triumph; Hun returning to the antique store and attacking her parents, crippling and killing Beth and John...
Flashback to the beginning of the adventure, and we see April heading off... watched by the old man who turns into the spectral Rat King, who smiles grimly to himself
Issue #2:
Cold open with Casey lost in the dark, utterly alone in the maze. He doesn't know how he got here or what happened to April... but noises in the shadows spur him to begin walking.
As he walks, Casey is worried... what's going on, and is April okay? As the maze continues to baffle and confound him, Casey loses his temper finally and begins punching the walls of the maze
Only to have Hun appear behind him, laughing mockingly at his son's futile frustration
Hun declares that the Jones boys are worthless, good for nothing and never able to protect the women they love...
Casey turns on Hun and attacks, but Hun is no longer there... instead, it's a younger version of Casey that he smashes in the face
Knocked to the floor, bleeding and crying, the young Casey picks himself up and flees into the darkness of the maze
Horrified at what he's done, Casey runs after his younger self, apologizing and trying to explain...
But instead, Casey finds April, lying crumpled and bloody on the floor and screaming for help as a large hulking man (who looks just like Hun, but with his upper body hidden in shadow) threatens to hit her again
Casey lunges for the man, screaming that he'll kill Hun if he touches April again--but the figure turns, as Casey knocks off the man's hockey mask and sees that the man is dark-haired, not blond... and it's an older version of Casey, not his father
Reveal Rat King and a mysterious other figure watching the nightmarish scene, as the other figure (a woman) asks if the Rat King is enjoying the spectacle...
Issue #3:
Lost in the maze and tormented by a spectral Donatello, April's trying to remain calm and rational; there's no way this is real
But Donatello mocks her, reminding her that she hangs out with reincarnated Japanese warriors who fight aliens and mutants, and who have encountered spirits before...
April failed them... failed everybody
April continues to insist that it's not real, but she's wavering... as the unseen Rat King watches with a devilish grin
Elsewhere, Casey is haunted by the image of his older self, violent and out of control, and can only stand numbly as Hun walks up behind him
"No matter what, Casey, you turn out just like me; angry, lashing out in pain and driving away everyone you love... it's in our blood, Casey. You're a Jones."
Casey refuses to accept this, but Hun vows to make him accept it one way or another, and lunges to attack him
As Donatello bitterly tells April that she's useless and let her friends and family die, April finally rallies and denounces the spectral figure
She's here because she's not useless; she's determined to do everything she can, even when it feels like she can't contribute to this crazy mess of aliens, mutants, gods, and monsters
If everyone else dies, and she can't stop it, she can at least avenge them; she can find and fight the Pantheon herself, even if she has to do it alone
Casey starts to raise a fist to attack his father, but then stops. He's not like his father; he's not going to allow violence to control him.
Hun can do whatever he wants to him, but he won't let him hurt April... so go ahead and hurt him instead. He won't stop him. Casey then folds his arms, stands motionless, and stares up at Hun...
The spectral visions haunting both Casey and April vanish, and they see each other only yards away
The two are reunited, realizing that something or someone is watching them...
On cue, the Rat King steps from the shadows, congratulating their cleverness. They've made it through the maze... now they be granted an audience with the Pantheon.
You know, I've been giving some thought to doing my own fan-rewrite of this series' plot structure. Mind would be played more for humor and action, but your's sounds so SO good. I especially like your idea for the opening hook.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-02-2015, 10:47 AM
You know, I've been giving some thought to doing my own fan-rewrite of this series' plot structure. Mind would be played more for humor and action, but your's sounds so SO good. I especially like your idea for the opening hook.
Thank you! :tgrin:
For my mind, I wanted a much darker, horror feel to it. Basically a repeat of the mood and atmosphere from when Kitsune was brainwashing Leonardo.
Metalhead 2.0
09-02-2015, 10:56 AM
Thank you! :tgrin:
For my mind, I wanted a much darker, horror feel to it. Basically a repeat of the mood and atmosphere from when Kitsune was brainwashing Leonardo.
Yes, it SHOULD be horror. I mean it's Rat King, he SHOULD be the equivalent of Jigsaw/Riddler/Freddy combined. Makes perfect sense.
Edited to add in a cup of Arkham Knight Scarecrow.
spookycookies
09-02-2015, 01:37 PM
Yes, it SHOULD be horror. I mean it's Rat King, he SHOULD be the equivalent of Jigsaw/Riddler/Freddy combined. Makes perfect sense.
Edited to add in a cup of Arkham Knight Scarecrow.
Exactly, they totally missed out here. The Rat King issue we got last summer was incredible and one of the best introductions in this whole series. This mini gets permission to use him and they wasted it entirely! Honestly I feel like I know nothing about this other family member and I think maybe she should have gotten the spotlight instead of RK.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-02-2015, 01:44 PM
Exactly, they totally missed out here. The Rat King issue we got last summer was incredible and one of the best introductions in this whole series. This mini gets permission to use him and they wasted it entirely! Honestly I feel like I know nothing about this other family member and I think maybe she should have gotten the spotlight instead of RK.
I don't mind that we're not finding out about her yet. I'm sort of guessing that "Red" is not into conquest and manipulation, eventually had a falling out with the rest of the Pantheon, and is the "prize" at the end of Rat King's maze. She'll give Casey and April all of the intel on who, what, and why the Pantheon is, but that's it.
But... given this mini-series, I'm not expecting anything worthwhile in the last 22 pages.
old_hob88
09-02-2015, 01:56 PM
I don't mind that we're not finding out about her yet. I'm sort of guessing that "Red" is not into conquest and manipulation, eventually had a falling out with the rest of the Pantheon, and is the "prize" at the end of Rat King's maze. She'll give Casey and April all of the intel on who, what, and why the Pantheon is, but that's it.
But... given this mini-series, I'm not expecting anything worthwhile in the last 22 pages.
I really hope you're wrong here. I hope there is at least some kind of payoff to this series in the end. At least some info on who "Red" is. Also you mean 20 pages lol. This mini is 9% less comic for the same $3.99 as the rest of them. And it's 20 pages of nothing lol
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-02-2015, 02:03 PM
I really hope you're wrong here. I hope there is at least some kind of payoff to this series in the end. At least some info on who "Red" is. Also you mean 20 pages lol. This mini is 9% less comic for the same $3.99 as the rest of them. And it's 20 pages of nothing lol
At this point, there is no light at the end of the tunnel for me. Just a merciful end.
But you're right... there'd better be some damn payoff. :tgrumble: And Rat King eating barbecue would be a helluva lot more entertaining if it wasn't the only interesting thing to happen in the entire series so far.
But hey. Maybe we'll find out Red is a vegan.
old_hob88
09-02-2015, 02:17 PM
At this point, there is no light at the end of the tunnel for me. Just a merciful end.
But you're right... there'd better be some damn payoff. :tgrumble: And Rat King eating barbecue would be a helluva lot more entertaining if it wasn't the only interesting thing to happen in the entire series so far.
But hey. Maybe we'll find out Red is a vegan.
Just so long as we find something out that would be good lol. I just hope the series doesn't meander aimlessly for another 20 pages before abruptly ending. I'm not counting on that not happening though with the way the series has been thus far.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-02-2015, 02:33 PM
Just so long as we find something out that would be good lol. I just hope the series doesn't meander aimlessly for another 20 pages before abruptly ending. I'm not counting on that not happening though with the way the series has been thus far.
Sarcasm aside, there will be some sort of payoff. The payoff of the Pantheon reveal (whatever it is) is the reason they're doing this mini-series.
Now, will the payoff be substantial or just a tease? Will it be worth it? THAT is what is worrying me...
Jay $tarkiller
09-16-2015, 02:30 PM
Not a fan of this mini series at all. Storyline & artwork are weak imho. Quite frustrating, since Casey is usually my main man!
funatic
09-21-2015, 01:35 PM
One of my friends just had her first graphic novel published and she recently did a panel with Mariko Tamaki. Mariko told my friend she never reads her reviews, which might be a good thing for her in this case. :p
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-21-2015, 01:46 PM
One of my friends just had her first graphic novel published and she recently did a panel with Mariko Tamaki. Mariko told my friend she never reads her reviews, which might be a good thing for her in this case. :p
In other words, no one ever tells her to her face that this story sucks and she never learns from it?
Introduce me to her, I'LL tell her how much most of us hated these last three issues. :tlol:
ctt4lfecw
09-21-2015, 07:00 PM
In other words, no one ever tells her to her face that this story sucks and she never learns from it?
Introduce me to her, I'LL tell her how much most of us hated these last three issues. :tlol:
Lol can I come with?
Duke Nukem
09-21-2015, 07:38 PM
It almost feels like IDW gave us this mini series so that when we don't get any more mini series for the better part of a year (if ever) that are canon to the ongoing, we won't miss them as much.
ToTheNines
09-21-2015, 07:41 PM
You guys are harsh...
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-21-2015, 08:05 PM
It almost feels like IDW gave us this mini series so that when we don't get any more mini series for the better part of a year (if ever) that are canon to the ongoing, we won't miss them as much.
That's insidious, calculating, and devious. :tlol: Fortunately, I still have faith in Bobby Curnow and Tom Waltz.
Mariko Tamaki, though? Her reputation is ruined for me. I'll never pick up anything else by her.
Joey Kamikaze
09-21-2015, 10:10 PM
One of my friends just had her first graphic novel published and she recently did a panel with Mariko Tamaki. Mariko told my friend she never reads her reviews, which might be a good thing for her in this case. :p
Ah, the George Lucas strategy. :lol:
spookycookies
09-22-2015, 08:14 AM
That's insidious, calculating, and devious. :tlol: Fortunately, I still have faith in Bobby Curnow and Tom Waltz.
Mariko Tamaki, though? Her reputation is ruined for me. I'll never pick up anything else by her.
Ditto, I hope she never gets near this franchise ever again.
Metalhead 2.0
09-22-2015, 09:37 AM
One of my friends just had her first graphic novel published and she recently did a panel with Mariko Tamaki. Mariko told my friend she never reads her reviews, which might be a good thing for her in this case. :p
Well then her stories will always be the same terrible, slow paced, drivel.
"Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body. It calls attention to an unhealthy state of things." - Winston Churchill
"There is no defense against criticism except obscurity." - Joseph Addison
"The final proof of greatness lies in being able to endure criticism without resentment." - Elbert Hubbard
"The trouble with most of us is that we would rather be ruined by praise than saved by criticism." - Norman Vincent Peale
"The man who cannot endure to have his errors and shortcomings brought to the surface and made known, but tries to hide them, is unfit to walk the highway of truth." - James Allen
"The dread of criticism is the death of genius." - William Gilmore Simms
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-22-2015, 09:51 AM
Well then her stories will always be the same terrible, slow paced, drivel.
"Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body. It calls attention to an unhealthy state of things." - Winston Churchill
"There is no defense against criticism except obscurity." - Joseph Addison
"The final proof of greatness lies in being able to endure criticism without resentment." - Elbert Hubbard
"The trouble with most of us is that we would rather be ruined by praise than saved by criticism." - Norman Vincent Peale
"The man who cannot endure to have his errors and shortcomings brought to the surface and made known, but tries to hide them, is unfit to walk the highway of truth." - James Allen
"The dread of criticism is the death of genius." - William Gilmore Simms
"You suck. Stop sucking." - CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy :tlol:
I just read and reviewed #4 today.
I've not been a fan of this series at all, and was wondering if I was being harsh on it. Thank you guys! I need to go back and read the whole thread.
Nothing happens! It's been a complete waste of time. So frustrating with the bar usually so high.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-29-2015, 11:50 AM
I just read and reviewed #4 today.
I've not been a fan of this series at all, and was wondering if I was being harsh on it. Thank you guys! I need to go back and read the whole thread.
Nothing happens! It's been a complete waste of time. So frustrating with the bar usually so high.
Bro, you are not being harsh on it. Inexplicably, some people are enjoying this. I suspect drugs are involved.
old_hob88
09-29-2015, 12:19 PM
Bro, you are not being harsh on it. Inexplicably, some people are enjoying this. I suspect drugs are involved.
I definitely wasn't fond of this whole series either. I feel this could have been done better either as an aside in the ongoing or as a backup in the ongoing or a different mini. There just wasn't enough story there, and not enough payoff either. I just found it to be a massive disappointment, and thus far, haven't really been disappointed with anything IDW has put out (except the annuals..)
Metalhead 2.0
09-29-2015, 12:51 PM
Bro, you are not being harsh on it. Inexplicably, some people are enjoying this. I suspect drugs are involved.
The question is: Is it undeservedly harsh? I think not.
BUT it's IDW, so all is forgiven and we move forward.
I was reading and reviewing in a vacuum, so it's nice to know I'm not the only one!
If anything, I've tried to be very reasonable in all my reviews, so maybe I'm going soft on it.
myconius
11-05-2015, 10:04 PM
this series was ok, nothing amazing.
but i suspect it was a seed planted for some development in the coming months ahead.
let's just hope DC doesn't mess up the Batman/TMNT cross-over!!!!
TMNT Kirby
11-07-2015, 10:49 AM
Love the different spin and look of this new Ratking
myconius
01-03-2016, 11:00 AM
i was curious why this particular thread had a sticky?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-03-2016, 11:36 AM
i was curious why this particular thread had a sticky?
Because NEVER FORGET. :trazz:
myconius
01-05-2016, 12:10 AM
Because NEVER FORGET. :trazz:
but we all might be better off if we did? :lol:
spookycookies
01-06-2016, 07:28 PM
but we all might be better off if we did? :lol:
I would love to simply shove this mini series under the rug and forget about it, but I think this is going to be the big example of what can go wrong when we get the wrong people to handle these characters.
What we got was something that "wasn't meant for us" but yet clearly occupied the same space as a series that it is almost entirely disjointed from. It's a low point in the IDW TMNT series and it's made me more cautious toward what we might see in the future from outside writers who have no experience writing anything that even closely resembles TMNT.
I'm sure I sound irrational here in my detest for these 4 books that simply weren't be exciting, I'm aware. But as I've said before IDW's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is my absolute favorite comic book. Not only is it the only comic I purchase every month but I always buy 3 copies of it. I know IDW doesn't owe me anything and it's my choice to be so very invested in their product or not but I just don't understand why if they would be seeking a wider audience for TMNT that they wouldn't also consider alienating people like me who consistently support the book.
TL;DR Love IDW TMNT? Skip Casey & April
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-06-2016, 07:44 PM
I would love to simply shove this mini series under the rug and forget about it, but I think this is going to be the big example of what can go wrong when we get the wrong people to handle these characters.
What we got was something that "wasn't meant for us" but yet clearly occupied the same space as a series that it is almost entirely disjointed from. It's a low point in the IDW TMNT series and it's made me more cautious toward what we might see in the future from outside writers who have no experience writing anything that even closely resembles TMNT.
I'm sure I sound irrational here in my detest for these 4 books that simply weren't be exciting, I'm aware. But as I've said before IDW's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is my absolute favorite comic book. Not only is it the only comic I purchase every month but I always buy 3 copies of it. I know IDW doesn't owe me anything and it's my choice to be so very invested in their product or not but I just don't understand why if they would be seeking a wider audience for TMNT that they wouldn't also consider alienating people like me who consistently support the book.
TL;DR Love IDW TMNT? Skip Casey & April
I will buy you as much beer and cookies as you want should we ever meet in RL. You, sir, are of impeccable taste. And common sense.
myconius
01-06-2016, 08:40 PM
I would love to simply shove this mini series under the rug and forget about it, but I think this is going to be the big example of what can go wrong when we get the wrong people to handle these characters.
What we got was something that "wasn't meant for us" but yet clearly occupied the same space as a series that it is almost entirely disjointed from. It's a low point in the IDW TMNT series and it's made me more cautious toward what we might see in the future from outside writers who have no experience writing anything that even closely resembles TMNT.
I'm sure I sound irrational here in my detest for these 4 books that simply weren't be exciting, I'm aware. But as I've said before IDW's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is my absolute favorite comic book. Not only is it the only comic I purchase every month but I always buy 3 copies of it. I know IDW doesn't owe me anything and it's my choice to be so very invested in their product or not but I just don't understand why if they would be seeking a wider audience for TMNT that they wouldn't also consider alienating people like me who consistently support the book.
TL;DR Love IDW TMNT? Skip Casey & April
i wouldn't say you sound irrational at all!
you sound very passionate!
and i too hold the IDW TMNT series in the highest regards of any comic series i read on a monthly basis.
and i really hope IDW is more careful with who they let handle their writing in the future.
TBH, i really was on the edge of my seat expecting something dramatic would happen in the series...
but it ended with absolutely nothing.
PangolinFeets
01-06-2016, 09:30 PM
It's funny how damn polarizing this is for me.
It's not my favorite mini, but I really liked Casey & April. And IDW TMNT is also my favorite comic. I just really like all of it.
myconius
01-07-2016, 04:16 PM
It's funny how damn polarizing this is for me.
It's not my favorite mini, but I really liked Casey & April. And IDW TMNT is also my favorite comic. I just really like all of it.
hey, don't feel bad.
i was really enjoying it in the beginning of the mini-series until it ended and realized nothing really happened.
it did have promise, i just think the writer got lazy or just had NO idea what to do next?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-07-2016, 07:53 PM
I stopped at my LCS to pick up Vengeance Part II, and when I asked out of curiosity if they had Casey & April in stock (which I hadn't even seen on the shelf), the guy looked it up in the system and said he couldn't even find a listing for it.
My LCS has good taste. :tlol: :tcool:
MsMarvelDuckie
01-07-2016, 08:59 PM
I just ordered the trade and it came in last week. I read it, and while it wasn't "exciting", I was intrigued by the larger story going on between Rat King and Aka. And the stuff about the scroll, and what's in the book April and Casey were searching for. It read as more of a mystery serial. I actually kind of liked that. Much of the plot was more subtle and less about action than about solving a puzzle.
CyberCubed
01-07-2016, 10:11 PM
I also ordered the April/Casey trade online from amazon, I wonder if my opinion on it will be different when you can read all 4 issues back to back.
spookycookies
01-07-2016, 10:17 PM
I also ordered the April/Casey trade online from amazon, I wonder if my opinion on it will be different when you can read all 4 issues back to back.
I think the book might be exciting and better paced if you do the mad fold in on every page. It'll save you a lot of blank or bloated panels.
CyberCubed
01-07-2016, 10:26 PM
I think the book might be exciting and better paced if you do the mad fold in on every page. It'll save you a lot of blank or bloated panels.
Yeah, it felt like this was a 2 issue story stretched out to 4 issues just to meet a quota.
If this was only a 2 parter I think it would have been much, much better.
spookycookies
01-07-2016, 11:01 PM
Yeah, it felt like this was a 2 issue story stretched out to 4 issues just to meet a quota.
If this was only a 2 parter I think it would have been much, much better.
Yeah I think the biggest flaw is that nothing happened for much of it. Even the smallest bits that were exciting ended up being dulled by how few and far between they were.
Casey fighting the guys in the diner and seeing the dragon premonition was some nice bits but but I couldn't handle Casey spilling juice in issue 2 and Rat King's cook out...
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-08-2016, 09:36 AM
Yeah I think the biggest flaw is that nothing happened for much of it. Even the smallest bits that were exciting ended up being dulled by how few and far between they were.
Casey fighting the guys in the diner and seeing the dragon premonition was some nice bits but but I couldn't handle Casey spilling juice in issue 2 and Rat King's cook out...
Don't you go hating on Rat King's BBQ. :tlol:
myconius
01-08-2016, 11:46 AM
i was reading the issues one a month as they were released.
while i was intrigued really hoping for a Rat-Minotaur or something to be chasing Casey & April through the Labyrinth, their escape seemed pretty easy and quite frankly ..... Obstruse!!!
i wrote of this Mini figuring it'll make more sense down the line.
and i'll keep the issues so i can re-read them once we see more later on from the Rat King.
he's always been one of my favorite supporting characters from 'Tales of' Vol.1 and 'City at War'.
hopefully his presence in the IDW Turtles will be equally as cool?
spookycookies
01-09-2016, 12:55 AM
Don't you go hating on Rat King's BBQ. :tlol:
Trust me, Rat King's BBQ will probably be the thing that stays with me the longest from this whole mess.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.