View Full Version : IDW comics tv series?
shredder orokusaki
09-24-2015, 01:40 AM
Do you think it is possible that in the future when IDW series ends they might make a new show based on it? Also why they decided to make another comic series when they coud had made two different cartoons? If it was a cartoon then it could had been much more succesful for Nickelodeon and IDW. Evryone knows how nich the comic audience is nowdays/
Unworthy tinker
09-24-2015, 01:49 AM
That'd be awesome, but it seems unlikely. Nick/Viacom doesn't seem like the company to do something like that. Fans can dream though.
CyberCubed
09-24-2015, 02:12 AM
There isn't enough material for a TV series. 4 issues of comics would only make one episode.
neatoman
09-24-2015, 03:53 AM
There isn't enough material for a TV series. 4 issues of comics would only make one episode.
Not sure I'd go with that average but even if I did, we'd still end up with about 25 episodes of a TV show. That is enough for one season or two shorter ones, you might have to be very loose when adapting the Ghostbusters crossover though :lol:. If there's any need for filler episodes, you could just adapt some of the stand alone issues of Mirage with very little problem or just make up new stories.
And that's just if I really thought that 4 issues would only work for one episode, if most manga to anime adaptations can find a way to turn 15 pages of a very serialised comic into 20 minutes of animation, I don't see why it'd be necessary to use 90-120 pages of a somewhat less serialised comic for the same amount of animation. By my own estimate of what would work (I'm still assuming most episodes use more than one isse to work with by the way), we'd be somewhere between 40 and 80 episodes. Hell if we're going by the "15 pages is good enough" idea, we'd have enough material for 160 episode but that may not be practical:lol:.
Bottom line, I think there's anough material to work for for a little while at least.
old_hob88
09-24-2015, 09:20 AM
I definitely think it could work. Also, it'd be down the line a ways anyway, so there would be more material to pull from. This comics going to run at least 100 issues, hopefully more. In addition to that, there's all of the current minis, and there will be more minis in the future. I could definitely see them using roughly 2 issues per episode, and maybe adapt each micro to its own episode.
When all's said and done, I think there could be at least 4 seasons worth of material IF IDW ends at 100 issues. Hopefully if sales stay strong, it continues past that.
I do not however see it happening while Viacom owns the franchise, or at least not anytime soon. Maybe it'll be like Mirage to 4Kids and we'll see an IDW based turtles cartoon in 2030 :tsad:
spookycookies
09-25-2015, 11:32 AM
I'm not sure, there really hasn't been much of one incarnation directly adapting another to the T. TMNT is more of a mythos than anything and I'm sure we will see the same elements we always have reinterpreted by new folks forever and ever telling the same story differently.
Panda_Kahn_fan
09-26-2015, 09:30 AM
A 26-episode anime series could work, faithfully adapting the comic the way anime often adapts manga... complete with filler each season to allow the comic to catch up! :lol:
CyberCubed
09-26-2015, 01:23 PM
It could be possible for DVD specials for IDW complete with the violence. I don't want to see it toned down for kids though.
Erik Burnham
09-27-2015, 02:47 AM
There isn't enough material for a TV series. 4 issues of comics would only make one episode.
Your timing is a little bit off. Depending on the way the action is paced, you're going to get anywhere from 20-35 minutes worth of animated content per comic issue.
The dialogue of an average issue alone, being read aloud verbatim, could take up a full half hour episode.
AquaParade
09-27-2015, 03:44 AM
Didn't IDW recently say that their version of the turtles were currently involved in an undisclosed project? Perhaps it's something animated.
Redeemer
09-27-2015, 12:10 PM
Didn't IDW recently say that their version of the turtles were currently involved in an undisclosed project? Perhaps it's something animated.
that would be awesome....
Honestly, I would think a animated movie would be best for the IDW comics
:D
PangolinFeets
09-27-2015, 12:22 PM
Didn't IDW recently say that their version of the turtles were currently involved in an undisclosed project? Perhaps it's something animated.
I doubt we will ever see a series, but this led me to believe that a straight-to-dvd movie may be in the works. If there was a one-shot animated movie in the style of the Batman animated movies, that would be incredible.
CyberCubed
09-27-2015, 12:30 PM
Your timing is a little bit off. Depending on the way the action is paced, you're going to get anywhere from 20-35 minutes worth of animated content per comic issue.
The dialogue of an average issue alone, being read aloud verbatim, could take up a full half hour episode.
Yeah you're right, I also wasn't thinking about how the fight scenes in the comics only take up a few panels/pages, but in animation the fight scenes could go on for a few minutes.
In any case I think it would be awesome if the IDW comics were turned into an animated series. Maybe released direct to DVD for older fans so it doesn't compete with the Nick cartoon.
ToTheNines
09-27-2015, 12:51 PM
Didn't IDW recently say that their version of the turtles were currently involved in an undisclosed project? Perhaps it's something animated.
Pretty sure they were just referring to the table top game coming out next year.
Pacing is very different in comics, it's preposterous to think a every comic is a 24 minute episode or 4 issues is one episode. It would really depend, action scenes that can drag for a few pages could only be a short time in an animated show. Tons of dialog like you sometimes see text in comics cannot be done the same way or you'd bore the audience. Those are only a few examples, you can adapt things slower or faster depending on what the material is not to mention an animated series would not be a direct adaptation so there would already be many differences there as well.
Mugic
09-27-2015, 03:33 PM
Pretty sure they were just referring to the table top game coming out next year.Eh, i highly doubt its the Table top game when it comes to merchandising there's no way Nick or Playmates would opt to market the IDW turtles over the 2K12 or Bay turtles.
If anything the "Undisclosed Project" is probably another special comic in the similarly the Batman crossover.
ToTheNines
09-27-2015, 03:41 PM
http://idwgames.com/idw-games-to-adapt-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-into-big-box-adventure-board-game/
Mugic
09-27-2015, 06:22 PM
I stand corrected:P
Erik Burnham
09-28-2015, 02:49 AM
Pacing is very different in comics, it's preposterous to think a every comic is a 24 minute episode or 4 issues is one episode. It would really depend, action scenes that can drag for a few pages could only be a short time in an animated show. Tons of dialog like you sometimes see text in comics cannot be done the same way or you'd bore the audience. Those are only a few examples, you can adapt things slower or faster depending on what the material is not to mention an animated series would not be a direct adaptation so there would already be many differences there as well.
Of course these would be adapted, but 1 page of screenplay = 1 minute of screentime; there is some elasticity, but it's really not too far off in comics. You can condense or or expand some, sure, and a different format would require it, but it's not preposterous as rule of thumb. (And I did say 20-35.) (;
MrTrikey
09-28-2015, 08:44 PM
I doubt we will ever see a series, but this led me to believe that a straight-to-dvd movie may be in the works. If there was a one-shot animated movie in the style of the Batman animated movies, that would be incredible.
It certainly would be the dream to see a direct-to-DVD thing based exclusively on IDW TMNT.
I mean, Marvel and DC throw their fans a bone here and there, while still having the mainstream movies and/or tv shows out there. I hope Viacom/Nick sees it the same way.
shredder orokusaki
09-30-2015, 05:17 AM
Pacing will not be a problem as some of you are saying. In 2003 series evry episode that was based on a Mirrage issue was 25 minutes just like all the others new stories. The adaptiojn of many Mirrage issues in 2003 series proved that comics to tv show can work. The question now is will a IDW cartoon happen after the current Nickelodoen ends? Are there any plans? Has anyone from IDW talked with Nickelodoen about that?
neatoman
09-30-2015, 06:32 AM
Pacing will not be a problem as some of you are saying. In 2003 series evry episode that was based on a Mirrage issue was 25 minutes just like all the others new stories. The adaptiojn of many Mirrage issues in 2003 series proved that comics to tv show can work. The question now is will a IDW cartoon happen after the current Nickelodoen ends? Are there any plans? Has anyone from IDW talked with Nickelodoen about that?
Well not every episode was adapting the comics:
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=25918
But yeah, quite a lot of them were.
CyberCubed
09-30-2015, 12:43 PM
The 2k3 series wasn't an adaption of the Mirage comics though, it used the stories with brand new ideas and different scenes.
If IDW is translated to animation I'd rather it be a 1:1 adaption or as close as possible, not loosely based on it like the 2k3 series was to Mirage.
Redeemer
09-30-2015, 01:45 PM
The 2k3 series wasn't an adaption of the Mirage comics though, it used the stories with brand new ideas and different scenes.
If IDW is translated to animation I'd rather it be a 1:1 adaption or as close as possible, not loosely based on it like the 2k3 series was to Mirage.
Really bud???? It was a loose adaptation, but still an adaptation from the comics
Klunk1234
10-01-2015, 08:42 AM
It would be really nice to watch a series based on the IDW comics.
Desslok
10-01-2015, 10:05 AM
The dialogue of an average issue alone, being read aloud verbatim, could take up a full half hour episode.
From my experience working with the full cast on my project I'd say it's more like 12~16 minutes, and that's with the intro video and credits. However, that said, with animated action sequences and standard time allotted for commercial breaks, each issue could fill a normal half hour slot on its own.
So hypothetically speaking, it is possible.
Metropoliskid41
10-01-2015, 10:43 AM
If I'm remembering correctly, the Spawn Animated TV Show was a fairly faithful 1:1 adaption of the comics, which had a much more decompressed storytelling method than IDW's Turtles series, and they still made great full length episodes. So there should be no problem filling up an entire episode by solely adapting one comic for 95% of the IDW Turtleverse comics.
The Casey and April 4 issue mini could probably be compressed into 2 episodes.
Other 4 issue story arcs could possibly even be broken up into 5 episodes.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.