PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #50 Preview and Discussion


Pages : [1] 2

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-02-2015, 08:36 AM
Just found it!

http://www.ign.com/articles/2015/10/02/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-50-preview

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-02-2015, 08:38 AM
OMG, Mikey says it! Tom wrote it into the script! :tparty: THANK YOU, TOM!

And yes, Raph, it was too easy. :tlol:

ADDED: I still want to know why General Krang and Tragg are on the cover... flashback to "Attack on Technodrome", or is the squishy pink overlord going to factor back into the series already?

Weapons@theready
10-02-2015, 08:51 AM
Words cannot describe the joy of finally seeing just a preview! The best thing of a double sized issue is the preview wont feel like I read half the story when the comic comes out on Wednesday! And yes love that line from Mikey :tgrin:

Also great to see the difference between how Splinter rallies his sons and how Shredder orders his subjects

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-02-2015, 08:54 AM
Words cannot describe the joy of finally seeing just a preview! The best thing of a double sized issue is the preview wont feel like I read half the story when the comic comes out on Wednesday! And yes love that line from Mikey :tgrin:

Also great to see the difference between how Splinter rallies his sons and how Shredder orders his subjects

I was a little worried about how this fight would go in terms of delivery, but this is what I wanted to see. THIS is how ninja take down superior foes: stealth, agility, and planning. Go green machines!!! :tcool:

Sabacooza
10-02-2015, 10:58 AM
Man, I am so ready for this! Makes me wish we could get 48 pages worth of material all the time. I can't get enough.

SDCC
10-02-2015, 11:10 AM
Roll on Wednesday!!

Looked at the images but didn't read it. I wanted to look but didn't?

Vicky82
10-02-2015, 12:59 PM
I can't wait, i'm so hyped :D

cookie jar
10-02-2015, 01:18 PM
Awesome now I really can't wait! :)

Metropoliskid41
10-02-2015, 01:27 PM
Dangit! The preview is blocked by my work's web filter!

Editor's Note Comics
10-02-2015, 01:56 PM
I can't wait to see how everything gets resolved. Crazy how well everything has come together to get to this issue!

The Happy One
10-02-2015, 02:53 PM
I can't wait to see how everything gets resolved. Crazy how well everything has come together to get to this issue!

And just wait till after! It starts a whole new chapter for the turtles, which is pretty awesome. In an interview with Eastman, Curnow and Waltz on comicallience.com they said big things are gonna happen for Mikey as he tries to become his own 'hero' sort of. All in all, I can't wait for #50 !:D

spookycookies
10-02-2015, 03:58 PM
This is going to be awesome, I seriously can't wait to read this issue. I may re-read the whole Vengeance arc before I pick this up.

Anybody going after cover variants? My LCS is holding the 5 that they are getting in and I've got 3 RE covers pre-ordered already.

old_hob88
10-02-2015, 05:34 PM
This is going to be awesome, I seriously can't wait to read this issue. I may re-read the whole Vengeance arc before I pick this up.

Anybody going after cover variants? My LCS is holding the 5 that they are getting in and I've got 3 RE covers pre-ordered already.

I'm going after all the covers as well. I have all 5 of the regular covers plus 5 or so RE covers thus far. Still got a ways to go though lol.

I cannot wait for Wednesday to get here. The preview just makes me wanna read it more lol.

AquaParade
10-02-2015, 08:26 PM
"I've got a newsflash for you idiots...we didn't come here to lose!" ?

Weak quip, imo. Tom has some of the coolest ideas ever, such as the resurrection theme and Leo possibly being Saki's son. The dialogue though often has me cringing.

I feel like we should be feeling something more personal or escalated going on between Donatello, Bebop, and Rocksteady right now considering what happened in issue #44.

I also feel similar about Leo's retort to Raphael that "nothing's easy today". It almost feels as if every piece of dialogue needs to be a quip, which, to me, feels unnatural. Tom obviously knows what he is doing, so perhaps it's just a stylistic choice that doesn't mesh with me.


Personal Critiques aside, I am quite thankful for this book and am excited to read issue #50.

Thanks to Tom, Bobby, Kevin, Rhonda, and the rest of the idw team for consistently putting out a book that to me, feels more than welcome within tmnt history. It's been a blast so far. I have full faith that the next 50 issues will be even better.

funatic
10-02-2015, 08:42 PM
If anybody wants me to pick up the NYCC exclusive cover (http://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/TMNT-50_Cover-RE-IDW-Convention-Exclusive.jpg) for them next week at the con I will do so for $30, shipping included. Send me a PM if interested.

EDIT: I'm hoping these will be available as well - http://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/TMNT-50_Cover-RE-Dimenxion-X-Regular.jpg

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-02-2015, 10:08 PM
"I've got a newsflash for you idiots...we didn't come here to lose!" ?

Weak quip, imo. Tom has some of the coolest ideas ever, such as the resurrection theme and Leo possibly being Saki's son. The dialogue though often has me cringing.

I feel like we should be feeling something more personal or escalated going on between Donatello, Bebop, and Rocksteady right now considering what happened in issue #44.

I also feel similar about Leo's retort to Raphael that "nothing's easy today". It almost feels as if every piece of dialogue needs to be a quip, which, to me, feels unnatural. Tom obviously knows what he is doing, so perhaps it's just a stylistic choice that doesn't mesh with me.


Personal Critiques aside, I am quite thankful for this book and am excited to read issue #50.

Thanks to Tom, Bobby, Kevin, Rhonda, and the rest of the idw team for consistently putting out a book that to me, feels more than welcome within tmnt history. It's been a blast so far. I have full faith that the next 50 issues will be even better.

I agree with you that it should have felt a little more personal, but I think Tom has shown that it was (Rocksteady and Raphael going at it just a few minutes ago in #49) and now the Turtles need to focus and think clearly, not emotionally, to get the better of these mutant juggernauts.

And sorry, but I can't agree with you on the dialogue critiquing. I like it just fine. (Well, except for the candygram quip. Didn't feel that.) I think it's very TMNT, and they've always had dialogue like this.

Jester
10-02-2015, 10:11 PM
All I see is the cover....where's the rest of the preview?

AquaParade
10-02-2015, 10:20 PM
I agree with you that it should have felt a little more personal, but I think Tom has shown that it was (Rocksteady and Raphael going at it just a few minutes ago in #49) and now the Turtles need to focus and think clearly, not emotionally, to get the better of these mutant juggernauts.

And sorry, but I can't agree with you on the dialogue critiquing. I like it just fine. (Well, except for the candygram quip. Didn't feel that.) I think it's very TMNT, and they've always had dialogue like this.

I do still feel that it may be more of a stylistic preference, so I can surely understand why others may appreciate it more than I do.

It may be and unfair comparison, but I greatly prefer the way Kevin Eastman handles dialogue. He obviously gets the characters on a personal level and when they speak it feels natual and reminds me of my buddies in real life, as opposed to the approach Tom takes.

I think Tom is a wonderful at plotting and general kick-ass concepts.

Did anyone else notice that in the recent IDW interview, Eastman mentioning he was writing the script for issue #53? I nearly wonder if he is taking a more active role in writing as of late.

ChosenOne
10-02-2015, 10:25 PM
All I see is the cover....where's the rest of the preview?

You need to click the arrows on either side of the pages in the preview to navigate through them.

funatic
10-03-2015, 12:43 AM
I'd personally love to see Tristan Jones on dialogue, I think he captured the voice of the turtles best since Eastman & Laird. Although he might be better suited to the Mirage universe than IDW in that respect. Regardless, I'm sad we haven't seen anything Turtles from him since wayback with the Infestation crossover. Hey Bobby, give Tristan another mini-series, and while you're at it give Paul Harmon a call for art duties! :trazz:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-03-2015, 10:28 AM
I'd personally love to see Tristan Jones on dialogue, I think he captured the voice of the turtles best since Eastman & Laird. Although he might be better suited to the Mirage universe than IDW in that respect. Regardless, I'm sad we haven't seen anything Turtles from him since wayback with the Infestation crossover. Hey Bobby, give Tristan another mini-series, and while you're at it give Paul Harmon a call for art duties! :trazz:

I second the motion; bring back Tristan and Harmon!

I do still feel that it may be more of a stylistic preference, so I can surely understand why others may appreciate it more than I do.

It may be and unfair comparison, but I greatly prefer the way Kevin Eastman handles dialogue. He obviously gets the characters on a personal level and when they speak it feels natual and reminds me of my buddies in real life, as opposed to the approach Tom takes.

I think Tom is a wonderful at plotting and general kick-ass concepts.

Did anyone else notice that in the recent IDW interview, Eastman mentioning he was writing the script for issue #53? I nearly wonder if he is taking a more active role in writing as of late.

That's hilarious, 'cause I can't stand Eastman's dialogue. Different tastes, man, whatcha gonna do? :tlol:

MikeandRaph87
10-03-2015, 10:55 AM
Eastman's dialogue not your thing? I was actually going to suggest Kevin Eastman writing the third annual and asking Jim Lawson to come on board for a one off and draw it.

Also, when will the second annual pay off? It feels like it did not go anywhere.

Jester
10-03-2015, 12:36 PM
Oh...there's the arrows....

Loved Raph's reference to...
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/64/3c/c9/643cc9d57c12276ca616f7251a04247b.jpg

TomWaltz
10-03-2015, 01:57 PM
Oh...there's the arrows....

Loved Raph's reference to...
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/64/3c/c9/643cc9d57c12276ca616f7251a04247b.jpg

YES!!! Someone got it!

I know I'm showing my age with that reference, but I couldn't resist. I just figured Raph and Mikey caught old SNL reruns on Hulu or youtube or something.

Land Shark rules!!!

Talk soon...

Tom W.

TomWaltz
10-03-2015, 02:04 PM
"I've got a newsflash for you idiots...we didn't come here to lose!" ?

Weak quip, imo. Tom has some of the coolest ideas ever, such as the resurrection theme and Leo possibly being Saki's son. The dialogue though often has me cringing.

I feel like we should be feeling something more personal or escalated going on between Donatello, Bebop, and Rocksteady right now considering what happened in issue #44.

I also feel similar about Leo's retort to Raphael that "nothing's easy today". It almost feels as if every piece of dialogue needs to be a quip, which, to me, feels unnatural. Tom obviously knows what he is doing, so perhaps it's just a stylistic choice that doesn't mesh with me.


Personal Critiques aside, I am quite thankful for this book and am excited to read issue #50.

Thanks to Tom, Bobby, Kevin, Rhonda, and the rest of the idw team for consistently putting out a book that to me, feels more than welcome within tmnt history. It's been a blast so far. I have full faith that the next 50 issues will be even better.

Actually, Leo being Saki's son was Bobby's cool idea... The last half of the interview has a bunch of our answers mixed up. Not the reporter's fault... We did it on Skype w/o video and I'm sure it was hard to tell our voices apart at times.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I've gotta get back to writing some weak dialogue (love you, too, AquaParade). :P

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Wentos
10-03-2015, 02:27 PM
Regardless, I'm sad we haven't seen anything Turtles from him since wayback with the Infestation crossover. Hey Bobby, give Tristan another mini-series, and while you're at it give Paul Harmon a call for art duties! :trazz:

If Tristan Jones and Paul Harmon came back for the third annual, I think I might literally die of happiness.

Every writer has their own strengths and weaknesses. Some are good at dialogue, while others are better at plotting. TBH I would much rather have a writer like Tom, who can keep all these layers of craziness straight (all the while making it look easy), than a writer like Brian Michael Bendis who can write great dialogue but can't even keep his own stories straight, much less respect and acknowledge the work of other writers.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-03-2015, 05:07 PM
Eastman's dialogue not your thing? I was actually going to suggest Kevin Eastman writing the third annual and asking Jim Lawson to come on board for a one off and draw it.

Also, when will the second annual pay off? It feels like it did not go anywhere.

Naw, not at all.

Whenever I read Eastman's dialogue in IDW, it sounds so horribly generic: Donny sounds like Mikey sounds like Raph sounds like Leo. They don't sound individual at all... just all four the same flavor of tough and goofy at the same time. Can't stand it.

spookycookies
10-03-2015, 05:11 PM
Naw, not at all.

Whenever I read Eastman's dialogue in IDW, it sounds so horribly generic: Donny sounds like Mikey sounds like Raph sounds like Leo. They don't sound individual at all... just all four the same flavor of tough and goofy at the same time. Can't stand it.

Yeah Eastman's turtles are all cut from the same cloth, you don't get that nuanced individualism that you normally get from Tom or many other TMNT writers.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-03-2015, 05:20 PM
Yeah Eastman's turtles are all cut from the same cloth, you don't get that nuanced individualism that you normally get from Tom or many other TMNT writers.

Exactly. :tsmile:

PangolinFeets
10-03-2015, 05:52 PM
Mike Dialynas was doing signings at my LCS today and mentioned all the big stuff coming up that he wasn't allowed to divulge. Gaaaaaaah.... I need next Weds to be here nooooowwww.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 05:52 PM
Leo possibly being Saki's son? When/how did this happen? I'm confused and intrigued. I'm only up to the end of #44 in the TPB's, so someone enlighten me, PELASE!!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-03-2015, 05:56 PM
Leo possibly being Saki's son? When/how did this happen? I'm confused and intrigued. I'm only up to the end of #44 in the TPB's, so someone enlighten me, PELASE!!

In City Fall, the original pitch was that Leo was biologically Saki's son, not Yoshi's. But Nick nixed the idea.

Mike Dialynas was doing signings at my LCS today and mentioned all the big stuff coming up that he wasn't allowed to divulge. Gaaaaaaah.... I need next Weds to be here nooooowwww.

Mike D didn't drop any hints, did he? :tgrin:

Jester
10-03-2015, 05:58 PM
YES!!! Someone got it!

I know I'm showing my age with that reference, but I couldn't resist. I just figured Raph and Mikey caught old SNL reruns on Hulu or youtube or something.

Land Shark rules!!!

Talk soon...

Tom W.
I did wonder where they might have heard it....but that bits even before MY time and i got it...and the Turtles are literally old souls....so.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 06:00 PM
In City Fall, the original pitch was that Leo was biologically Saki's son, not Yoshi's. But Nick nixed the idea.



That's news to me. What was the pitch, exactly, and why did they nix it?

ChosenOne
10-03-2015, 06:01 PM
Sounds like they would've been writing themselves into a corner with that idea, TBH. City Fall worked out just fine the way it did.

PangolinFeets
10-03-2015, 06:02 PM
That's news to me. What was the pitch, exactly, and why did they nix it?

It was too dark for Nick's taste. Making Leo basically a rape baby is kinda dark even for TMNT.


And no, no hints from Mike. He was a rock. He just said to look forward to the ride.
Great guy. I picked up the original art he did for the print he's selling at NYCC. :3

James Tynion was also there. It kills me, because he's doing Batman/TMNT and can't talk about it. Rjdjeifnsjjwkf ga

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-03-2015, 06:19 PM
That's news to me. What was the pitch, exactly, and why did they nix it?

It's on here somewhere on the forums, I remember us all discussing it in greater detail.

Sounds like they would've been writing themselves into a corner with that idea, TBH. City Fall worked out just fine the way it did.

Yeah, honestly, I don't think it would have been as sustainable. Great idea, but more of an elseworlds-suited tale, where it's one-off and you don't have to worry about that being part of the narrative every issue.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 06:30 PM
Hmm, from a writing standpoint, it actually sounds like an interesting concept. But why would it have to be rape? It could just as easily have been a seduction or something that she chose to hide from Yoshi. An affair, even. Nick played with that in the cartoon in Tale of the Yokai, so it's not outside the realm of possibility. In fact, making it a seduction/affair on Saki's part that Tang Shen was too ashamed of and hid would have made the rivalry even more complex. It's even possible he could have bribed or coerced her "favors" to offer protection or something else that she would feel compelled to acquiesce to.

I know they made it seem like she hated him with that slap, but they could have just played it off as him coming on too strong, and she reacted to that with a knee-jerk manner. Later he might have gone back to "apologize" and offer a gift, etc, and perhaps even get her drunk or something, and she gives in. Or perhaps the slap could have even come AFTER the fact, and it was her way of telling him that she no longer wished to continue the affair- and given his comment to her, that route might have easily been worked in. Mind, I'm just brainstorming some ideas off the top of my head, but it could work!

MikeandRaph87
10-03-2015, 06:31 PM
I did wonder where they might have heard it....but that bits even before MY time and i got it...and the Turtles are literally old souls....so.

I heard it before as well. The first five are much better than anything after it. Only the late oughts can compare. The TMNT can watch it because the first five seasons are on DVD and I can see it in their DVD catalog with little difficulty.

PangolinFeets
10-03-2015, 06:48 PM
Hmm, from a writing standpoint, it actually sounds like an interesting concept. But why would it have to be rape? It could just as easily have been a seduction or something that she chose to hide from Yoshi. An affair, even. Nick played with that in the cartoon in Tale of the Yokai, so it's not outside the realm of possibility. In fact, making it a seduction/affair on Saki's part that Tang Shen was too ashamed of and hid would have made the rivalry even more complex. It's even possible he could have bribed or coerced her "favors" to offer protection or something else that she would feel compelled to acquiesce to.

I know they made it seem like she hated him with that slap, but they could have just played it off as him coming on too strong, and she reacted to that with a knee-jerk manner. Later he might have gone back to "apologize" and offer a gift, etc, and perhaps even get her drunk or something, and she gives in. Or perhaps the slap could have even come AFTER the fact, and it was her way of telling him that she no longer wished to continue the affair- and given his comment to her, that route might have easily been worked in. Mind, I'm just brainstorming some ideas off the top of my head, but it could work!
The info came from an interview with Mateus Santolouco on some turtle podcast. I can't remember what its called, but it features a British lady and man. But Mateus talked about some of the changes from SHotFC and the whole City Fall arc and that was the most extreme one. I wish they discussed it in more detail, but the way they talked about it, it seemed like the idea pitched wasn't something Nick was into and kinda hit a bit of a rapey-vibe. Who knows? It may have been a one night stand mistake if it took off. That was the gist I got from the interview.
I agree that it would of been cool. It makes you wonder what other cool plots have been snuffed out by Nick's morality board.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 06:58 PM
Indeed. It also makes me wonder why they would nix that, but allow some of the really dark and controversial stuff into the show, like what we got in Tale oft he Yokai regarding Shen, not to mention the original "shock" of learning Karai was Miwa, or Shredder giving the finger to the whole world (including Karai, whom he CLAIMED to love!) by killing Splinter at the last moment before he could stop the Triceraton weapon. There's so much they could do with these ideas, if they just left the creative team alone. Besides, isn't IDW supposed to be for a more mature audience anyway? Makes no sense to me to do that. Heck, they already went pretty dark with the reincarnation angle to begin with, they could have gone all the way with that and no one would complain- plus, it would make her seem more "human" by having flaws of her own, rather than this vague "perfect" memory of Splinter and Leo. (And Donnie, to a lesser extent.)

spookycookies
10-03-2015, 07:56 PM
I can see the shock value in making Leo Saki's son, it would even fit well with how Oroku finished off his own father so Leo would continue that cycle in a way.

On the other hand IDW turtles are really focused on the family aspect. Making Leo some kind of step brother would create this kind of otherness about him that would muddle the concept.

Also it would be very, very Star Wars...

At the end of the day I'm glad they went the route they took. I don't consider it censorship if it's something that could have possibly damaged the narrative.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 08:33 PM
Step-brother? Actually, more like half-brother. Step would be unrelated. He still has the same mother. But I can see your point there. I still think it would have been an interesting take, though. It would certainly have been interesting to see where they could take that idea, particularly as it would open up a new level to his rivalry/hostility with Karai as Shredder's "heirs". And the family aspect has always been there, even in versions where none of them were related at all. (*cough* Next Mutation, *cough*) In any case, I don't think it would damage the narrative. It would just change it a bit, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. But I guess we'll never know. Hmm, now I'm thinking that might make a good fic....

ToTheNines
10-03-2015, 09:31 PM
So there's obviously plenty of story and drama that could have been mined from Leo being his son, that by itself could have been cool.

But it seems extremely dumb to have that be the reason Leo joins the Foot. I mean brainwash might have been the easy way out, but the guest artist flashbacks were sick and it didn't insult Leo's intelligence.


Also it would be very, very Star Wars...

There is that.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 09:51 PM
So there's obviously plenty of story and drama that could have been mined from Leo being his son, that by itself could have been cool.

But it seems extremely dumb to have that be the reason Leo joins the Foot. I mean brainwash might have been the easy way out, but the guest artist flashbacks were sick and it didn't insult Leo's intelligence.



Who says he has to even know that? If Shen never told anyone, it could simply be something that figures in later. (IE, perhaps being the only way to permanently kill Shredder- if someone of his "own blood" does so.) It didn't necessarily have to be the reason he joined- that was covered in the brainwashing anyway. Shredder could play on his loyalty to "family" by informing him that Yoshi isn't his real father. Even more diabolical, he could do so long AFTER the brainwashing, as a means of casting doubts as to whether they were right to "rescue" him. From his REAL father.... Yeah, I can see some very dark and emotionally difficult places to take that idea.

I guess it just depends on whether they could find interesting ways to use the concept. I'm sure they had ideas, but we'll never see any of them, which is kind of a shame, since that could have been incredible in the hands of a competent writer, just from the few ideas I thought of off the top of my head, and I'm sure they had some good ones, too. A shame, IMHO.

Apologies if I seem to be stuck on this, it's just the writer in me coming out to play, and I really like that idea a lot. Might have to take a stab at it myself, in fact.

AquaParade
10-03-2015, 10:49 PM
Actually, Leo being Saki's son was Bobby's cool idea... The last half of the interview has a bunch of our answers mixed up. Not the reporter's fault... We did it on Skype w/o video and I'm sure it was hard to tell our voices apart at times.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I've gotta get back to writing some weak dialogue (love you, too, AquaParade). :P

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Who needs dialogue? Script us some kick ass silent issues!

I'm sure you and Mateus would kill it!

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 11:20 PM
Silent issues CAN be really cool if done right. Like the Captain Mar-vel Christmas issue from way back, that was completely silent. Completely told through the visual story, which was really very much in the spirit of the season. I studied it as part of an exercise in Peter David's "Writing for Comics" book. Later used the same idea for a comic story of my own, called "Hush: or When the Music Stops...." It was a story where Spider-Man's mutant son loses his hearing temporarily during a fight, and has to have others write out what they say to him. The fun part was trying to tell the story without anyone talking! Everyone else could hear just fine, but since it was from his POV, I had to work that in that he couldn't hear them, so they couldn't technically "speak" in dialog, and had to write their words out to him. It was harder to do than it sounds. Turned out pretty good though!

As an aside, that story got first place in a monthly writing competition on the Marvel forums. One of the other stories from that series did, too- this one about the young Parker son stopping a cat-burgler, and learning that the man has had a long run of bad luck and being pretty much forced into a life of petty crime to survive, and now is on his third "strike", which will cause him to lose his daughter, after his wife had already left them long before, and the girl has no other relatives so would go to the state. So Hunter (Peter's son) not only doesn't turn him in, he ends up helping him find a legitimate job with a restaurant-owner he's friends with. It was one of my best stories, and probably the least "comic-book-y" one in the series.

Anyway, you're right about silent issues being really cool. I'd like to see one in TMNT, actually! And as I pointed out above, they don't even have to revolve around action- as long as the story is compelling.

Technogeek29
10-04-2015, 12:10 AM
If you guys ever decide to make a story out of the Leo is Saki's real son please send me a link I would very much like to read it.:D

MsMarvelDuckie
10-04-2015, 07:52 AM
Will do! And I'm already working on the scenario as I type this. :trazz:

cookie jar
10-04-2015, 10:26 AM
Will do! And I'm already working on the scenario as I type this. :trazz:

I would love to read this if you or someone else were to write it. :D

You can read about this idea here
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=52127

ToTheNines
10-04-2015, 11:42 AM
Who says he has to even know that? If Shen never told anyone, it could simply be something that figures in later. (IE, perhaps being the only way to permanently kill Shredder- if someone of his "own blood" does so.) It didn't necessarily have to be the reason he joined- that was covered in the brainwashing anyway. Shredder could play on his loyalty to "family" by informing him that Yoshi isn't his real father. Even more diabolical, he could do so long AFTER the brainwashing, as a means of casting doubts as to whether they were right to "rescue" him. From his REAL father.... Yeah, I can see some very dark and emotionally difficult places to take that idea.

Well if Pangolinfeets is to be believed, then that's exactly what they were going to do.


-He mentions that in the original draft for City Fall, instead of brainwashing Leo, Saki was pre-reincartnation Leo's true father. He didn't outright say how that would have happened, but said that Leo would have ended up siding with Saki because he is his real father. This ended up getting nixed by Nickelodeon, but there could have been all kinds of craziness spawning from that idea. I reaaally wish they stayed on this convo more.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-04-2015, 12:25 PM
Nice to know Im on the same page as those guys creatively. Missed opportunity.....

Sophie Campbell
10-04-2015, 12:56 PM
i might be misremembering since this was a while ago, and maybe Bobby will step in and correct me, but when he told me about the Leo/Saki idea, i think it was simply that Tang Shen was romantically with Saki before she was with Yoshi. there was no rape or secret affair. although personally i think Shen having an affair with Saki would have been cool, it would make her more of a multi-faceted character.

PangolinFeets
10-04-2015, 01:42 PM
i might be misremembering since this was a while ago, and maybe Bobby will step in and correct me, but when he told me about the Leo/Saki idea, i think it was simply that Tang Shen was romantically with Saki before she was with Yoshi. there was no rape or secret affair. although personally i think Shen having an affair with Saki would have been cool, it would make her more of a multi-faceted character.
Ok that sounds good. They could have done soooo much more with those characters, had that been the case.

spookycookies
10-04-2015, 10:36 PM
Ok that sounds good. They could have done soooo much more with those characters, had that been the case.

I think Saki being in a relationship sort of dilutes his all consuming drive to conquer, sure he's had children with Kitsune but that was so he would have a bloodline capable of resurrecting him.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-04-2015, 10:38 PM
I dunno. he's still human, for all his hubris. He might have actually had, y'know, FEELINGS or something, LOL!

AquaParade
10-04-2015, 11:33 PM
I dunno. he's still human, for all his hubris. He might have actually had, y'know, FEELINGS or something, LOL!

Something I feel he desperately needs.

Sure, previous incarnations of Saki got by just fine without relatable human motivation, but they weren't going for as ambitious of a portrayal as IDW is admirably doing.

Joey Kamikaze
10-05-2015, 01:47 AM
I got the impression from SHotFC that Shredder loves Kitsune, in his own way. I'm pretty sure I remember a panel of them kissing somewhere in there; I don't think their relationship was strictly one of necessity (well, at least not for Shredder). Granted, Oroku Saki is a self-centered hardass, but the gist I got was he sees Kitsune as more than just a tool to be used; she's his partner in ruling the world, mother of his children, etc. Which is part of why he's so blind to her coming betrayal.

Technogeek29
10-05-2015, 01:53 AM
I got the impression from SHotFC that Shredder loves Kitsune, in his own way. I'm pretty sure I remember a panel of them kissing somewhere in there; I don't think their relationship was strictly one of necessity (well, at least not for Shredder). Granted, Oroku Saki is a self-centered hardass, but the gist I got was he sees Kitsune as more than just a tool to be used; she's his partner in ruling the world, mother of his children, etc. Which is part of why he's so blind to her coming betrayal.

The Irony is Kitsune has warned of betrayl from within the Foot Clan and so has Karai. If he does listen it is normally interpreted in the wrong manner such as Yoshi.

Joey Kamikaze
10-05-2015, 04:43 AM
Yeah. But then Shredder's short-sighted hubris leading to his downfall is the hallmark of his character going back to Mirage, so there ya go. IDW Shredder is just fitting the pattern. He may be the most badass version of Shredder we've ever gotten, but in the end he's still Shredder.

If you could teach any version of Oroku Saki two things that would prolong his life as a supervillain, they would be 1) don't be so full of yourself because it leads you to bad decisions, and 2) stay off rooftops.

MrTrikey
10-05-2015, 09:22 AM
Ok that sounds good. They could have done soooo much more with those characters, had that been the case.

Indeed.

But at the same time, I can also respect Nick's decision to not go ahead with such a thing that would have permanently affected central characters in this way. If nothing else, they may have wanted to avoid the possibility of anything similar to having "Goblin Babies" (Spider-man fans would get this ref) on their hands. :D

Metropoliskid41
10-05-2015, 11:04 AM
Indeed.

But at the same time, I can also respect Nick's decision to not go ahead with such a thing that would have permanently affected central characters in this way. If nothing else, they may have wanted to avoid the possibility of anything similar to having "Goblin Babies" (Spider-man fans would get this ref) on their hands. :D

True! Very good point!

Stormin Norman and Gwen, eww.

While Leo being Saki's Son is a cool idea that would be neat to explore for a bit, once you open that can of worms, it can never be closed again. While it would make for a good arc or two, is that really the dynamic you want for IDW's Turtles for the rest of run? (which is hopefully a very long run)

Going the route they did gave Leo a character development arc; he had to deal with and overcome the implications of abandoning and betraying his brothers while brainwashed, but ultimately he can grow and overcome it. So his downfall is a temporary hurdle to overcome and grow past. Being Shredder's son is a permanent thing. He may move past it, learn to accept it, and we could get an interesting character study out of it, but you never actually get over it or get that genie back in the bottle.

I think it also hurts the Leo-Splinter dynamic. Leo was the first to buy into and strongest supporter of the "Splinter is my father, we are reincarnated souls from fuedal Japan" in those early issues. That whole dynamic of the team rests on that Leo & Splinter Father & Son dynamic. Changing that I think hurts the entire IDW version of the Turtles. But your mileage may vary.

Anyway, completely stoked for #50, can't wait to read it in about 48 hours!

MrTrikey
10-05-2015, 06:29 PM
True! Very good point!

Stormin Norman and Gwen, eww.

While Leo being Saki's Son is a cool idea that would be neat to explore for a bit, once you open that can of worms, it can never be closed again. While it would make for a good arc or two, is that really the dynamic you want for IDW's Turtles for the rest of run? (which is hopefully a very long run)

Going the route they did gave Leo a character development arc; he had to deal with and overcome the implications of abandoning and betraying his brothers while brainwashed, but ultimately he can grow and overcome it. So his downfall is a temporary hurdle to overcome and grow past. Being Shredder's son is a permanent thing. He may move past it, learn to accept it, and we could get an interesting character study out of it, but you never actually get over it or get that genie back in the bottle.

I think it also hurts the Leo-Splinter dynamic. Leo was the first to buy into and strongest supporter of the "Splinter is my father, we are reincarnated souls from fuedal Japan" in those early issues. That whole dynamic of the team rests on that Leo & Splinter Father & Son dynamic. Changing that I think hurts the entire IDW version of the Turtles. But your mileage may vary.

Yeah, and that's the other thing. What would have been the value of the "Tweeest" after its unveiling and the shock value wore off, issues later? At best, it would've just added another dimension to the classic Leo-Shredder dynamic. At worst, it would have been rather pointless, because more than likely, the overall point of "family is who you make of it" would have been the central theme (again, and I think Casey-Hun already did that well enough) and it wouldn't have changed much of anything at all between Leo and his family.

So, while we can only guess how things would play out, again, I think they made the right choice, in the end.

Anyway...onward to Issue 50, indeed.

And here's hoping there's more Triceratons somewhere within the next 50! Love the IDW versions a lot and hope to see more of Zog and the others sometime soon! :D

Etsyturtle2
10-05-2015, 06:42 PM
OMG, Mikey says it! Tom wrote it into the script! :tparty: THANK YOU, TOM!

And yes, Raph, it was too easy. :tlol:

ADDED: I still want to know why General Krang and Tragg are on the cover... flashback to "Attack on Technodrome", or is the squishy pink overlord going to factor back into the series already?

What did mikey say?

Metropoliskid41
10-05-2015, 08:22 PM
And here's hoping there's more Triceratons somewhere within the next 50! Love the IDW versions a lot and hope to see more of Zog and the others sometime soon! :D

Totally with you there! Bring on more Triceratons!!

MikeandRaph87
10-05-2015, 08:31 PM
It is odd to me that how Triceratons are seen as dominant and more of a threat than The Federation. The Federation is the one who had control of a few solar systems and the Triceratons blew up their own planet. It would seem despite the savagery and cool design concept the Federation would be more a threat to the turtles and the galaxy.

MrTrikey
10-05-2015, 10:56 PM
It is odd to me that how Triceratons are seen as dominant and more of a threat than The Federation. The Federation is the one who had control of a few solar systems and the Triceratons blew up their own planet. It would seem despite the savagery and cool design concept the Federation would be more a threat to the turtles and the galaxy.

Well, let's be frank: the Mirage/Image Trikeys were the ones who were a bit more...persistent when it came to conducting active invasions of Earth. Obviously, the TMNT have a problem with uninvited saurian guests to their home planet, so, that's why the Trikeys were much more of a threat to at least the turtles.

As for the IDW Trikeys, they're still such a relative unknown, that I really want to see exactly how they've been handling themselves since their rebellion. Unless I missed something, last time we even saw Zog was in the Battle Nexus, so I just wonder how he's been doing!

SDCC
10-06-2015, 03:37 AM
Leo being Saki's son would be like Rick losing his hand in The Walking Dead.

It's a cool scene and great for shock value, but ultimately paints the writers into a corner.

I'm knocking up a review for #50 at the moment. Suffice to say it will be positive :tgrin:

spookycookies
10-06-2015, 10:06 AM
Leo being Saki's son would be like Rick losing his hand in The Walking Dead.

It's a cool scene and great for shock value, but ultimately paints the writers into a corner.

I'm knocking up a review for #50 at the moment. Suffice to say it will be positive :tgrin:

Exactly, it's very limiting storywise. If I remember right that show Heroes was overly fond of the secret parent trope and that ended up being a huge mess. You should be able to tell the kinds of stories you want to tell but at the same time be mindful about things you can't take back.

Can't wait for #50! But sadly I won't be getting my paws on a copy until Sunday. I'll see you all then.

Redeemer
10-06-2015, 02:02 PM
Exactly, it's very limiting storywise. If I remember right that show Heroes was overly fond of the secret parent trope and that ended up being a huge mess. You should be able to tell the kinds of stories you want to tell but at the same time be mindful about things you can't take back.

Can't wait for #50! But sadly I won't be getting my paws on a copy until Sunday. I'll see you all then.

crap that sucks bud, but I have good news I get my copy tomorrow :D

1 MORE DAY!!!!!!!

Raptor86
10-06-2015, 03:15 PM
http://bigcomicpage.com/2015/10/06/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-50-idw-publishing/

The best

Editor's Note Comics
10-06-2015, 03:28 PM
I just finished checking reading it. Without giving anything away, it's amazing. This has some of the most memorable moments from the series so far. Go pick this book up tomorrow!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-06-2015, 03:29 PM
I am so frakking jealous of you guys and your advance copies... I'm SERIOUSLY considering starting my own review blog just so I can eventually be one of you favored few. :tlol:

PangolinFeets
10-06-2015, 08:01 PM
These reviews are making me crazy. I wish I could go to bed early and sleep in to make the wait bearable. :(

The Happy One
10-06-2015, 08:25 PM
These reviews are making me crazy. I wish I could go to bed early and sleep in to make the wait bearable. :(

Agreed. I think I'll just call it a night just to make this tolerable. But seriously, though, these reviews are driving me nuts! I neeeed to know!

Shark_Blade
10-06-2015, 09:10 PM
Omigosh it should be out already today on iBook. I can download! :D

Editor's Note Comics
10-06-2015, 09:27 PM
It's worth going back and reading the beginning of the arc. It's interesting looking at some of the characters growth.

Shark_Blade
10-06-2015, 10:02 PM
It's worth going back and reading the beginning of the arc. It's interesting looking at some of the characters growth.

Yes. This comic series is one of the best, (if not the best!) I've ever read in my life. I still get choked up reading Raph's reunion with his brothers at the beginning. He was so lost and alone before.

http://i.imgur.com/k1xTgaW.jpg

And don't forget Mikey's "last pizza"..
http://i.imgur.com/4hJ2yde.jpg

Or when he confronted Raph! :o (I'm sure he did this again later on)
http://i.imgur.com/qoFwklP.png
http://i.imgur.com/iRoNww9.png

Or Donnie's "death".
http://i.imgur.com/MCw3yNn.png

Damn I love this comic. :tgrin:

Metropoliskid41
10-06-2015, 10:26 PM
Can't sleep, I seriously think it's the anticipation for #50, plus getting 2 sweet new pieces of TMNT original art tomorrow, so I'm going to go reread the first arc courtesy of my IDW Limited Red Label edition. Can't wait for 11 am central time tomorrow when I get my mits on #50.

PangolinFeets
10-06-2015, 11:20 PM
My LCS has alll the variants on hold for me and I'll be snagging the limited #50 at NYCC (with a bit of luck). Maybe see if Bobby can sign one for me? :3

Metropoliskid41
10-06-2015, 11:41 PM
Nice! Be sure to pick yourself up one of those KFC crisis of multiple Colonel comics while you're at NYCC as well!

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 12:07 AM
Nice! Be sure to pick yourself up one of those KFC crisis of multiple Colonel comics while you're at NYCC as well!

Is KFC really making comics or is that a jab at how fat Americans are..? I can't tell.

Vicky82
10-07-2015, 01:31 AM
I just read issue 50 and I didn't like it.

I f***ing loved it :D :D

Technogeek29
10-07-2015, 01:58 AM
I envy you all especially Shark_Blade

SDCC
10-07-2015, 03:11 AM
My review (http://www.superdstuff.com/2015/10/tmnt-50.html)!

Spoiler free.

Guys, I loved this issue. Couple of small issues but overall I thought if was a fitting #50.

Donnie woooo! Shredder really should stay away from rooftops. The whole Leatherhead thing confuses me though, where exactly did he come from?

SDCC
10-07-2015, 03:17 AM
Yes. This comic series is one of the best, (if not the best!) I've ever read in my life. I still get choked up reading Raph's reunion with his brothers at the beginning. He was so lost and alone before.

http://i.imgur.com/k1xTgaW.jpg

And don't forget Mikey's "last pizza"..
http://i.imgur.com/4hJ2yde.jpg

Or when he confronted Raph! :o (I'm sure he did this again later on)
http://i.imgur.com/qoFwklP.png
http://i.imgur.com/iRoNww9.png

Or Donnie's "death".
http://i.imgur.com/MCw3yNn.png

Damn I love this comic. :tgrin:

This sums it all up. Not only my love for IDW Mikey (surpassing my usual love for Leo), but the series as a whole. Nice one.

Technogeek29
10-07-2015, 04:04 AM
My review (http://www.superdstuff.com/2015/10/tmnt-50.html)!

Spoiler free.

Guys, I loved this issue. Couple of small issues but overall I thought if was a fitting #50.

Donnie woooo! Shredder really should stay away from rooftops. The whole Leatherhead thing confuses me though, where exactly did he come from?

Leatherhead first appeared in Turtles in time 3 and has lived for at least 200 years or close to.

Ninjinister
10-07-2015, 04:40 AM
Is KFC really making comics or is that a jab at how fat Americans are..? I can't tell.

http://io9.com/colonel-sanders-battles-himself-in-dc-and-kfcs-new-cros-1734741325

SDCC
10-07-2015, 05:03 AM
Leatherhead first appeared in Turtles in time 3 and has lived for at least 200 years or close to.
Thank you! I knew there was something going there. I'd just like to know more.

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 05:08 AM
http://io9.com/colonel-sanders-battles-himself-in-dc-and-kfcs-new-cros-1734741325
Well, first time I ever see Colonel Sanders so ****ing pissed off... :o:lol: now I've seen everything.
I envy you all especially Shark_Blade
Don't be, you'll get it too eventually. :D
This sums it all up. Not only my love for IDW Mikey (surpassing my usual love for Leo), but the series as a whole. Nice one.Ditto!

PangolinFeets
10-07-2015, 05:29 AM
Just read it! Oh my goodness what does the ending mean?

Are we going to see human clones of the original bodies of the Hamato clan? I'll lose my ****.

Allio
10-07-2015, 06:40 AM
I think Saki being in a relationship sort of dilutes his all consuming drive to conquer, sure he's had children with Kitsune but that was so he would have a bloodline capable of resurrecting him.

wait...what?

Hardshell
10-07-2015, 08:09 AM
Issue #50 was amazing! Some big things happened including one very awesome twist with Splinter and what his story going forward will be. Such a great comic. Completely satisfying in every respect.

Metropoliskid41
10-07-2015, 08:54 AM
Is KFC really making comics or is that a jab at how fat Americans are..? I can't tell.

No it's a real thing. The who's the real Colonel Sanders thing is playing out in a DC Special One-Shot comics. It's the Justice League and Colonel Sanders of Earth-1 vs. the evil Colonel Sanders from Earth-3. I kid you not. NYCC Exclusive.

Mutant Ninja Anole
10-07-2015, 09:21 AM
Wow, hard to put it all together right now but briefly:

Splinter made good on his threat to kill Saki, although he did give him an 'honorable' death. There seems to be a callback to the first comic, with the rooftop battle. They offered Shredder a chance to die honorably there to, but here he takes it. Also, that was formal seppuku, with the warrior cutting his intestines and his second, in this case Splinter, cutting his head off to give him a quick death. I'll confess that I know that from Usagi Yojimbo.

I'm really intrigued by where they will go. An actual massive break up of the status quo with Splinter leading the Foot and teaching Karai? Kitsune as a possible corrupting influence or other player? Mikey going on his own? Could we really get the "Mikey and the Mutanimals" book I was joking about?

So many questions: Will the rest of the Foot sign up under Splinter? What about Bebop and Rocksteady, Koya and Bludgeon? What is Leatherhead's deal?

I'll post more later I think, but a massive round of applause. It's rare a good serial story gets a satisfying 'end,' even if this isn't really the end of anything. But a great closing chapter.

Weapons@theready
10-07-2015, 09:52 AM
It was everything I ever wanted and more. Yet as we see it's never a completely happy ending. I love the guys who work on this comic and have put together 4 years of great story telling and have closed up some plots and opened up many more. Here's to 50 more issues!

Eurydemus
10-07-2015, 01:05 PM
This was quite possibly the most incredible comic I've read this year. :o Great setup for whatever the post-50 story arc has in store, too.

Also, while it doesn't excuse him from all the dickish stuff he has done, did anybody else detect the slightest hint of remorse on Shredder's part? It wasn't exactly kiss-and-make-up time, but I got a feeling he reached some sort of understanding with Splinter/Yoshi toward the end.

Mayhem
10-07-2015, 01:15 PM
Sadly I've got this feeling that my monthly comic delivery hasn't got this in the package, and thus I'm going to have to wait until NEXT month to read it! Unless one of the REs or RIs turns up prior to my subs being delivered.

turtlefan27
10-07-2015, 01:18 PM
WOW!that was just amazing!

Metropoliskid41
10-07-2015, 01:20 PM
Holy crap!!! What an amazing issue!!!

That was one Giant-Sized, action-packed romp!! Great work by all involved, it really was a great culmination and closing to the first 4 years of IDW's Turtles. So many threads wrapped up, and even though the majority of the issue was devoted to some gorgeously choreographed fight scenes, there was a whole lot of story telling and character development and pay off during it. We got to see so many seeds that had been planted and grown over the last 50 issues come to fruition and harvested during that fight. It was everything I hope for and so much more.


-Wow the death of Saki. That played it perfectly and added so many new layers to the dynamic between Saki and Yoshi. You see in the end that rivalry dropped, and once again the were clan members, brothers, staring at each other like they did so many years ago, and after this life lesson in the ways of a warrior, it was Yoshi that came out on top. I have a feeling Saki will be back, and learn from this, but hopefully not until issue #100. You know he's going to have a bone to pick with Splinter if he's still running the show and in charge of the Foot Clan.

-Speaking of that, what a Twist! Splinter in charge of the Foot Clan, and the Turtles now clan members with those who have tried to kill them in the past. There's got to be some bad blood there that will take a while to vanish. Interesting potential. And what's that mean for the evil mutants? Koya and Bludgeon appear to have honor, they could potentially fall in line, but I think their distrust and dislike of the Turtles has got to run pretty deep. They call Leonardo traitor during the fight, and after the butt kicking they got in the fight, I don't think they'll be calling the Turtles friend anytime soon.

And then there's Bebop & Rocksteady, they obviously have no place in a Splinter-run Foot Clan. Where do they find themselves next? A life of petty street crime? Join Hob & Hun, that's not going to go too well with Mikey if he's headed to hang-out with the Mutanimals. Possibly a schism there between Hob & his new recruits and Slash and the other Mutanimals?

-Kitsune hanging around Splinter and the Foot Clan is not a good deal, what does she have up her sleeve? I got to imagine that Rat King will be popping in soon to mess with Splinter in a very big way!

-And that last page, oh man, clones of the original Clan Hamato bodies! What will Splinter and the Turtles do when they literally square off against themselves? And how will Krang piece together that the Turtles are the re-incarnated versions of their clones?

Can't wait to see those questions answered and explored in the next 50 issues!!!

Redeemer
10-07-2015, 01:45 PM
I am honestly a little disappointed in the story. The art was awesome, but the story was definitely a let down. I just don't like the direction the story is taking.

I don't like the fact Saki was redeemed at the end. I thought he had a vengeful spirit in him or something along those line and also he was not so immortal. The ending was interesting though, it actually reminded me of the blue door script of the first movie seeing the turtles being tied to Krang.

Technogeek29
10-07-2015, 01:52 PM
I am honestly a little disappointed in the story. The art was awesome, but the story was definitely a let down. I just don't like the direction the story is taking.

I don't like the fact Saki was redeemed at the end. I thought he had a vengeful spirit in him or something along those line and also he was not so immortal. The ending was interesting though, it actually reminded me of the blue door script of the first movie seeing the turtles being tied to Krang.

It makes sense in the concept that Saki was arrogant but not evil, his father pushing him down and Kitsune making it seem like everyone was against him was what really made him what he was. Even Mirage Shredder isn't evil.

Metropoliskid41
10-07-2015, 02:32 PM
I am honestly a little disappointed in the story. The art was awesome, but the story was definitely a let down. I just don't like the direction the story is taking.

I don't like the fact Saki was redeemed at the end. I thought he had a vengeful spirit in him or something along those line and also he was not so immortal. The ending was interesting though, it actually reminded me of the blue door script of the first movie seeing the turtles being tied to Krang.

It makes sense in the concept that Saki was arrogant but not evil, his father pushing him down and Kitsune making it seem like everyone was against him was what really made him what he was. Even Mirage Shredder isn't evil.



I saw it very much as a once Saki was faced with his mortality, and his hubris shattered, he saw the situation for what it really was, a life lesson in the way of a warrior, and in this duel with his long time rival, it was he was on the losing end. Everybody eventually gets hit with a hard to learn life lesson, for some it just takes getting their abdomen ripped open with a katanna before they open their eyes and learn from it. I thought it was fitting and added new layers and depth to the Shredder-Splinter dynamic.



And at what point do we get to drop the spoiler tags? It's past noon out on the West Coast, if you're popping into this thread this late in the day that the issue went on sale, you should be expecting Spoilers!

cookie jar
10-07-2015, 02:38 PM
I just finished reading this. It was definitely worth waiting. This is truly an amazing piece of work. Wow fantastically well done. This is the best version of Turtles so far imo. Props to IDW and their writers. :)

Veg
10-07-2015, 02:49 PM
Regarding the last page..

This is not foreshadowing. This is explaining that Yoshi and his sons were bought back to life with biotech science at Stockgen. Not reincarnation.

Editor's Note Comics
10-07-2015, 03:05 PM
I am honestly a little disappointed in the story. The art was awesome, but the story was definitely a let down. I just don't like the direction the story is taking.

I don't like the fact Saki was redeemed at the end. I thought he had a vengeful spirit in him or something along those line and also he was not so immortal. The ending was interesting though, it actually reminded me of the blue door script of the first movie seeing the turtles being tied to Krang.

I thought it was a nice change on the original Shredder death. I would have preferred it was another character, other than Splinter, but it sets up something brand new. But I would have laughed so hard if he pulled out a grenade.

Weapons@theready
10-07-2015, 03:12 PM
Regarding the last page..

This is not foreshadowing. This is explaining that Yoshi and his sons were bought back to life with biotech science at Stockgen. Not reincarnation.


Yup which in a way means Krang won and the Turtles are just pawns.[/QUOTE]

Raptor86
10-07-2015, 03:34 PM
I have read it while listening to the Brian Tyler's soundtrack: EPIC!

I also think that the last pages mean that Krang allowed the creation of the turtles and splinter in the future/present. I guess QNA is something related to their memories and "souls" that the psychotropic ooze can activate somehow.

Splinter leading the foot could lead to a potential city at war kind of sotry, with war between the foot clan.

ChosenOne
10-07-2015, 03:38 PM
I tried my very best to remain spoiler free for the entire day, it's 9 PM where I live and I just finished reading the issue.

First off, I have to say my jaw hit the floor when Metalhead!Donnie fired off that strobe light just like in the dream I had:

I had a dream last night that two panels from #50 had leaked, I guess brought on by how many times I've read about Raph taking out someone's eyes.

The first panel had the 4-on-4 battle rage on in the background while Bebop with his shades off, looking panicked, was trying to pick himself up from the floor, having just been blinded by a strobe effect (Metalhead? Nobody's suit?) still visible in the panel, and Raph approaching him while in the foreground Splinter said that he (Raph) knew what must follow... And the second panel was a gory discretion shot of Raph stabbing Bebop's eyes with his sais.

I doubt we'll get anything remotely resembling this, but it's my first TMNT dream ever and contributes to the #50 hype, so I figured it was worth mentioning.

Okay, so, wrong character on the receiving end of it, but everything else was so similar that I was positively dumbstruck, and mutilation-happy Leo did have me going there for a bit, thinking even more blood would be shed. Coincidence? What do you guys think?

Like we said so many times in the run-up to this issue, all the speculation that goes on in this forum had to amount to some of us getting bits and pieces right. I know I saw the seppuku idea being floated around, and the whole Splinter-taking-over-the-Foot deal went through my mind a couple of days ago as well but I never bothered to post about it.

Still, all this precognitive and speculative business aside, I very much enjoyed the issue and it has to be one of the best, if not the very best, of the IDW run so far! Some thoughts:

Koya and Bludgeon seemed very smitten and devoted to each other here. The panel where Bludgeon cradles her in his arms made them seem like outright lovers, check out the expression on Koya's face. Color me intrigued.

So Bebop and Rocksteady soaked the usual crapload of damage, including the self destruction of Metalhead, and then get whacked into submission by one hit from Donnie each? What is that new bo made of?! (Especially considering Shredder took a couple more licks and still kept ticking...)

Speaking of Shredder, that moment when the truth dawns over him and he accepts what is going to happen and starts delivering parting words to the most important people in his life... Man, I kinda felt for the guy. He may have done some pretty evil stuff but he was deluded from the very beginning by Kitsune. It struck me a lot like Vegeta's first death in Dragon Ball Z, a possible turning point for the character wrapped in a cathartic death scene. Time and possibly issue 100 will tell.

As for Kitsune, why does Splinter want her around? I don't remember from SHotFC, but does he know who she is? Regardless, the Turtles and Splinter have now had their Wolfram & Hart moment (Joss Whedon fans will know what I mean) and the storylines that can result from it may very well be even better than everything we've seen so far. If a war with Hob's mutants and/or the Pantheon is in the cards, at least now they have the numbers to throw at whatever comes. Should be a blast.

Also, I can't wait to find out more about Leatherhead!

And finally... I'm not sure I understood the epilogue. Is it foreshadowing of things to come, or like some have said, proof that this whole centuries-spanning conflict just boils down to Krang and Kitsune's machinations?

All in all, a big round of applause to the IDW crew for delivering on this issue and paving the way for even bigger, better things!

Metropoliskid41
10-07-2015, 03:50 PM
Regarding the last page..

This is not foreshadowing. This is explaining that Yoshi and his sons were bought back to life with biotech science at Stockgen. Not reincarnation.

Yup which in a way means Krang won and the Turtles are just pawns.[/QUOTE]

Interesting theory, but I disagree. Go back and read the first story arcs.


The Turtles and Splinter being re-incarnated was a product of Saki's agents trying to steal the mutagen. The Turtles and Splinter got mutated and re-incarnated inspite of Krang, not because of him.

There was considerable time spent in the ongoing series where Hob and Stockman were trying to capture Splinter, dead or alive, to extract the serums from him.

If what you hypothesize is true, Krang would want to aim Splinter and Turtles at Shredder and pull the trigger, (which I take from your posts that you are saying he did) not hunt them down and boil them down to their basic components to regain the serums and mutagene that created them when the Foot Clan attacked. Which in actuality is what he had his forces do in the story, try to stop the Turtles.

Note that Krang wants the Hamato Yoshi and his children's DNA samples. Nothing about their current selves as Mutant Reptiles or Rat has anything to do with their human DNA. In no way does taking their human DNA equate to rpoducing the mutants they are in their current selves.

ChosenOne
10-07-2015, 04:04 PM
Something I forgot to mention:

From the way Splinter was holding Saki's helmet, I half-expected him to put it on in the final panels. That would've been too over-the-top, I think.

MrTrikey
10-07-2015, 04:13 PM
Preaching to the choir here, but yeah...I really loved this book. :D

I guess my only really qualm was with:

...Mikey.

Hopefully, the next few issues will go into more detail about why he felt like he had to be up out after his family FINALLY got a real win without obvious setbacks. The way he was just going all "No way" and then just ran off didn't do much for me to explain why he felt he had to do so. And if this is supposed to be Mikey's turn at an "epiphany discovered after a traumatic event" arc...it just wasn't as executed as well as I'd hoped. I at least expected him to shout at some one else, before storming off!

But I guess since this directly sets up for Mikey and Slash to hang out again, I guess I'll be willing to look the other way. I always love seeing those two together.

Beyond that, and how we still didn't get to see much of Leatherhead, I'm just that much more eager to see what will happen over the course of the next 50 issues. Bless you, IDW.

Vicky82
10-07-2015, 04:31 PM
With Mikey

Seeing his Father decapitate Shredder's head off was just too much to handle and I wonder if it's going to trigger memories of his past life's death and maybe we see him having a few flashbacks

Weapons@theready
10-07-2015, 04:51 PM
Regarding Mikey, it sucked to see everyone standing on the rooftop without Mikey, kinda feels like not a total victory. Also I hope the next few issues give us a little more insight into what Mikey is feeling and what he is thinking...I mean the rules were pretty clear that someone was going to die going into this and he didn't seem to be pulling any punches himself when he was fighting, so him taking the "moral high road" comes off a bit cheap

neatoman
10-07-2015, 05:29 PM
Just read it, holy hell was that insane!...

... So what does QNA stand for?

Eurydemus
10-07-2015, 05:43 PM
RE: Mikey

I don't think Mikey really understood the gravity of killing for the sake of their cause until Splinter lopped off Saki's noggin. It's one thing to be told Shredder has to die, but it's quite something else to actually witness him lose his head. Watching his father deliver the coup de grace followed by the revelation that his old man is now leader of the Foot must've been too much for poor Mikey.

Mutant Ninja Anole
10-07-2015, 05:52 PM
RE: Mikey

I don't think Mikey really understood the gravity of killing for the sake of their cause until Splinter lopped off Saki's noggin. It's one thing to be told Shredder has to die, but it's quite something else to actually witness him lose his head. Watching his father deliver the coup de grace followed by the revelation that his old man is now leader of the Foot must've been too much for poor Mikey.

I I think Mikey speaks for the readers who can't help but worry Splinter is being corrupted (I do need to point out that, per the traditional ritual of seppuku, Shredder had already sliced his gut open, Splinter just made sure he didn't suffer. Brutal though). I don't agree, but it makes a degree of sense. Of course, having Kitsune there does make me wonder...though I get why he's keeping her around. She's a super powered being, better to keep her close than try to dismiss her and make an enemy.

TonySiegel
10-07-2015, 06:01 PM
looking forward to reading this issue... its crazy how fast the years went by! thank you IDW tmnt for getting me back into comic books!

blessings to all at this site and beyond!

The Happy One
10-07-2015, 06:33 PM
With Mikey

Seeing his Father decapitate Shredder's head off was just too much to handle and I wonder if it's going to trigger memories of his past life's death and maybe we see him having a few flashbacks


[SPOILER] That's a real intriguing idea, Vicky. Even though Donnie is my absolute favorite, I have always admired how forgiving Mikey is and how he is always looking for a more peaceful way to handle things. I just really love that. And your idea is actually really cool. He could remember how it felt, the blade coming down. It could've triggered something and made Mikey see he wants no part of any killing. But, still it would've been cool to see him standing with his brothers and Sensei.
No matter what, I adore that and can't wait to see how his arc plays out.

MrTrikey
10-07-2015, 06:48 PM
RE: Mikey

I don't think Mikey really understood the gravity of killing for the sake of their cause until Splinter lopped off Saki's noggin. It's one thing to be told Shredder has to die, but it's quite something else to actually witness him lose his head. Watching his father deliver the coup de grace followed by the revelation that his old man is now leader of the Foot must've been too much for poor Mikey.

But I guess my thing is...

...the execution felt off. It just comes off as if they wanted to make SURE they got the stinger set up for their next arc for Mikey in that issue. Maybe we should've gotten a few more pages to make it feel a bit more "fleshed out". Or it could have been just saved for #51 (where I feel we'll likely get a better explanation for Mikey's choice, anyway).

Either way, I just feel as if the obvious setup from the last few issues, where he was already struggling, just didn't get the big "moment" it deserved. He just flipped the deuces and took his leave. Conversely, Leonardo's "descent to the dark side" and Donatello giving his all for a cause he believed in before he "died", just felt much better done.

Etsyturtle2
10-07-2015, 06:49 PM
9606yyyyyyaaaaaaaaaaaasssssssss

Stugehen
10-07-2015, 07:13 PM
The IDW team should be proud. What a great run so far. As I was reading the issue everything was moving along pretty much as expected...until it didn't. I'm in the camp of not knowing what the epilogue implied.

Splinter leading the Foot Clan was totally unexpected, and really am unsure about what that means for alliances going forward.

Etsyturtle2
10-07-2015, 07:30 PM
The IDW team should be proud. What a great run so far. As I was reading the issue everything was moving along pretty much as expected...until it didn't. I'm in the camp of not knowing what the epilogue implied.

Splinter leading the Foot Clan was totally unexpected, and really am unsure about what that means for alliances going forward.

I think the Dna samples was something that went into the creation of the ooze.and that is why it reincarnated the turtles and splinter.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-07-2015, 07:33 PM
We're seven pages in, I'm not doing spoilers except for the REALLY good stuff. :tlol:

Leatherhead seems to have a grudge against scientists... makes me wonder what his character is going to be up to, if not science bros with Don or Honeycutt? Really looking forward to seeing what he's all about.

I absolutely LOVED this issue. Mikey and Raph taking down Bebop and Rocksteady by making them smash each other; Leo grounding Koya; Donnie blinding Bludgeon; all four brothers getting their licks in on Shredder, only for him to beat them down.

And Splinter leading the Foot Clan!? :teek: "Vengeance" is totally channeling Image TMNT, with Donnie being "killed" and cyborgized, and the Hamato Clan trying to redeem the Foot Clan through taking over leadership! :tcool:

As for the epilogue... why on earth would you think this invalidates the reincarnation? There are no clones, just Krang taking samples from their bodies... we have no idea what's going to happen here, so that's all a bit too drastically jumping the gun here.

I also loved Shredder offering Raph voluntary membership in the Foot. Squee!

The ONE thing that didn't make sense to me is why Bludgeon would be so outraged that Leo kept hacking on Koya even after she was defeated. Bebop and Rocksteady killed Donnie, and all four of the Foot mutants were going to kill OR EAT the Turtles. WHY does Bludgeon suddenly think the Turtles shouldn't finish off Koya? Seriously, shark-dude... huge double standard.

Powder
10-07-2015, 08:27 PM
Pretty much perfect. Could not really have been better, in any respect. These characters have all become who they really should be. Great art & writing here, better than ever. I was quite sold on the color palette, it set the tone so well. Loved the homages to earlier parts of the series as well as older installments, like the roof top being a mish-mash of Mirage #1 & the first film, & what seemed to be a boat-load of references to Vol. 3 (Go Tom! Awesome of you to do that). I wholeheartedly dig the direction they went with for this final conflict with Shredder, it impacted me significantly. It was the first time I was truly taken aback & surprised by something, that I can recall at present, anyway. If this is ever un-done, I'm gonna be so miffed, 'cause that was just, damn. Y'all graduated to next level with this issue. It's setting up some really interesting themes & ideas, stuff I'm very eager to see. Really cool how this Shredder compares to Nick's. I won't spoil anything from their finale but they too took me by surprise with the path they laid out for Saki. Both worked really well, too, despite the unexpected turns. We're lucky fans. I am curious how things will go with Karai, though I imagine her route is a ways off yet. Congrats guys.

Re: Mikey

...the execution felt off. It just comes off as if they wanted to make SURE they got the stinger set up for their next arc for Mikey in that issue. Maybe we should've gotten a few more pages to make it feel a bit more "fleshed out". Or it could have been just saved for #51 (where I feel we'll likely get a better explanation for Mikey's choice, anyway).

Either way, I just feel as if the obvious setup from the last few issues, where he was already struggling, just didn't get the big "moment" it deserved. He just flipped the deuces and took his leave. Conversely, Leonardo's "descent to the dark side" and Donatello giving his all for a cause he believed in before he "died", just felt much better done.

That's my only complaint, really, & it's minor.

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 08:48 PM
I kinda wish we get to see Shredder's head being decapitated off clearly. Maybe add a shower of red blood and seeing actual chunks of his sliced neck meat, his jugular veins exposed or something. And his head would just dropped and rolled a bit on the ground near where Mikey was standing.

But other than that, great comic! :D

Redeemer
10-07-2015, 08:49 PM
It makes sense in the concept that Saki was arrogant but not evil, his father pushing him down and Kitsune making it seem like everyone was against him was what really made him what he was. Even Mirage Shredder isn't evil.

Honestly it does not make sense to me at all. I mean he is suppose to be a reincarnated spirit and then on top of that saki killed Tang shen out of spite and then goes on to kill yoshi and his sons. Literally he beheaded little kids!!!! That is a evil psycho!!!! :o



I saw it very much as a once Saki was faced with his mortality, and his hubris shattered, he saw the situation for what it really was, a life lesson in the way of a warrior, and in this duel with his long time rival, it was he was on the losing end. Everybody eventually gets hit with a hard to learn life lesson, for some it just takes getting their abdomen ripped open with a katanna before they open their eyes and learn from it. I thought it was fitting and added new layers and depth to the Shredder-Splinter dynamic.



And at what point do we get to drop the spoiler tags? It's past noon out on the West Coast, if you're popping into this thread this late in the day that the issue went on sale, you should be expecting Spoilers!

I still don't buy it. These guys aren't rivals, they may have started out that way, but they are mortal enemies. And again he was suppose to be the reincarnation of a evil/hateful spirit.

I thought it was a nice change on the original Shredder death. I would have preferred it was another character, other than Splinter, but it sets up something brand new. But I would have laughed so hard if he pulled out a grenade.

I do like they did something different, but it just flat out bothered me how Saki acted towards the end.
Again Shredder was so out of character. This dude Mercilessly beheaded children. How in the hell is he not evil and hateful???
Honestly imo they did not do shredder justice and they wrote his character flat out wrong

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 08:53 PM
^Umm, you might wanna spoiler quote your comments there, buddy. Sure you're frustrated but let's remember those who haven't read yet. :P

Powder
10-07-2015, 08:56 PM
People who haven't read the issue should not come into a thread discussing the issue & not expect to have it spoiled. He's fine.

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 09:02 PM
It's just we've been spoiler quoting in previous pages. I have no problem with spoilers of course.

I wonder what Kitsune plans to do with Alopex. She seems to be possessing that white wolf, taking control of her conscious self..

She had an encounter with her before, but I forgot what it's all about. Gotta read it up, I think it's in the Secret History of the Foot Clan...

Redeemer
10-07-2015, 09:09 PM
^Umm, you might wanna spoiler quote your comments there, buddy. Sure you're frustrated but let's remember those who haven't read yet. :P

what did I spoil?????? seriously I did not mention one thing that was specifically in the issue. Everything I mentioned was common knowledge from past issue and how what happened in this issue did not mesh

and powder is right. If someone doesn't want to read what happened in the issue why the hell would they look in a thread specifically dedicated to discussion?????

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 09:16 PM
The fact that Shredder's character is different from what he was, perhaps?

Strange... my iBook has an update for #50. Literally just added a few minutes ago. Were any content changed? :-? I'm updating now.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-07-2015, 09:17 PM
It's just we've been spoiler quoting in previous pages. I have no problem with spoilers of course.

I wonder what Kitsune plans to do with Alopex. She seems to be possessing that white wolf, taking control of her conscious self..

She had an encounter with her before, but I forgot what it's all about. Gotta read it up, I think it's in the Secret History of the Foot Clan...

Kitsune was first revealed to be manipulating Alopex in Volume 9 "Monsters, Misfits, Madmen."

I gotta be honest, I was really expecting to see Kitsune make a move this issue. Not... wait and bide her time some more.

Also, Mikey's reaction seems perfectly believable to me: it's not so much that Splinter killed Saki, but that Splinter agreed to take over and lead the Foot Clan, the "bad guys" to Mikey who still insists on viewing the world in black and white.

Redeemer
10-07-2015, 09:25 PM
Kitsune was first revealed to be manipulating Alopex in Volume 9 "Monsters, Misfits, Madmen."

I gotta be honest, I was really expecting to see Kitsune make a move this issue. Not... wait and bide her time some more.

Also, Mikey's reaction seems perfectly believable to me: it's not so much that Splinter killed Saki, but that Splinter agreed to take over and lead the Foot Clan, the "bad guys" to Mikey who still insists on viewing the world in black and white.

I believe its bc they had the series pre-planned to end at 50 incase the series was not doing so well. Thats why Kitsune did not make a move.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-07-2015, 09:38 PM
I believe its bc they had the series pre-planned to end at 50 incase the series was not doing so well. Thats why Kitsune did not make a move.

So you think they would've taken out Kitsune if it had all ended at #50? Probably wouldn't have had any other Pantheon members except Rat King. Huh.

FunkyDoesIt
10-07-2015, 09:40 PM
This was truly a great comic, couldn't be more pleased!

I really enjoyed the fight scene with R&B since it managed to take a little bit of the original cartoon feeling without beeing to much goofy. The rooftop fight was also a nice reference to the mirage comic and the first film as said earlier by another member!

I'm glad that Don is back. Having MetalHead around all the time kinda makes the fights scenes a little less interesting since he can always pull a gizmo to take advantage...

If I remember correctly Shredder is suppose to be in the Batman cross-over, so that would mean that this cross-over takes place before this story-arc I suppose..

Redeemer
10-07-2015, 09:49 PM
So you think they would've taken out Kitsune if it had all ended at #50? Probably wouldn't have had any other Pantheon members except Rat King. Huh.

Honestly I don't know. Thats just what Tom Waltz said. They originally had up to issue 50 planned out. I think Tom said they now have the series planned out up to issue 80 or so.

Weapons@theready
10-07-2015, 10:10 PM
One question that I have after reading this whole arc again is I'm wondering when or if we will see Baxter Stockman again?

ChosenOne
10-07-2015, 10:18 PM
One question that I have after reading this whole arc again is I'm wondering when or if we will see Baxter Stockman again?

I'm sure we will, it's just a matter of time. Him and Hob are now the biggest wild cards, going forward.

Joey Kamikaze
10-07-2015, 10:20 PM
Books's been out all day, we're several pages into the thread, you probably shouldn't be in here if you haven't read it, etc., so I'm not using spoiler tags. Beware.

If I remember correctly Shredder is suppose to be in the Batman cross-over, so that would mean that this cross-over takes place before this story-arc I suppose..

The Batman crossover isn't canon to IDW. It's a different universe's Shredder and different turtles.



Interesting theory, but I disagree. Go back and read the first story arcs.


The Turtles and Splinter being re-incarnated was a product of Saki's agents trying to steal the mutagen. The Turtles and Splinter got mutated and re-incarnated inspite of Krang, not because of him.

There was considerable time spent in the ongoing series where Hob and Stockman were trying to capture Splinter, dead or alive, to extract the serums from him.

If what you hypothesize is true, Krang would want to aim Splinter and Turtles at Shredder and pull the trigger, (which I take from your posts that you are saying he did) not hunt them down and boil them down to their basic components to regain the serums and mutagene that created them when the Foot Clan attacked. Which in actuality is what he had his forces do in the story, try to stop the Turtles.

Note that Krang wants the Hamato Yoshi and his children's DNA samples. Nothing about their current selves as Mutant Reptiles or Rat has anything to do with their human DNA. In no way does taking their human DNA equate to rpoducing the mutants they are in their current selves.



Splinter and the turtles are their reincarnated selves pre-mutation. In one of the early issues Splinter specifically mentions recognizing the turtles are his sons while he's wandering the lab in four-legged mode; that's why he pursues the Foot ninja who kidnap the turtles. So if I had my guess from the epilogue, Krang had Baxter use the family's DNA and Q(uantum?)NA (I'm interpreting this as basically "soul DNA") on a lab rat and four turtles, probably with the thought of using them as weapons against Shredder, which is what caused their souls to be reborn in those bodies; however, once the family escaped, Krang's major priority was recovering Splinter as a test subject and the other plans fell by the wayside.

As to other random things:
-I'm surprised Kitsune is still biding her time, but it looks like it won't be long before that **** hits the fan now
-I loved when Bebop & Rocksteady became free agents in TMNTA and I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of trouble they get into now that their time in the Foot is probably over
-I figured it was 50/50 on whether Shredder would die or not, but either way, I hope he stays gone for a few years, then I'll love it when he returns :tlol: If anything I was worried for a moment that Shredder would pull a last minute trick and gut Splinter just as his "brother" was about to behead him
-I liked how the last panel was a callback to Shredder looking out over the city at the beginning of "City Fall"

Oh, other thought: have the turtles changed the future? Things were pretty grim in the future of Turtles In Time #4. Has killing Shredder altered that timeline, or were these events still part of the past that led to that outcome? I wouldn't mind getting another glimpse at the future at some point, and if it involves more living future turtles, even better. Bonus points if it involves Renet because I'd love to see her in the ongoing.

turtlefan27
10-07-2015, 10:23 PM
I loved the teamwork that was displayed between raph and mikey. Splinter becoming head of the foot was definitely a surprise, I can't wait to see where that goes, and hopefully we'll get to see what karai does on her trip to Japan. One of the coolest/misterious things that happened was how don came back, I'm thinking they teleported him there..such a good read

Shark_Blade
10-07-2015, 10:24 PM
Is this the first time we see General Krang in OT Android body? :lol: Cause I don't remember seeing him in that form before. Gotta love the OT reference. :tlove:

Kitsune was first revealed to be manipulating Alopex in Volume 9 "Monsters, Misfits, Madmen."

I gotta be honest, I was really expecting to see Kitsune make a move this issue. Not... wait and bide her time some more.

Also, Mikey's reaction seems perfectly believable to me: it's not so much that Splinter killed Saki, but that Splinter agreed to take over and lead the Foot Clan, the "bad guys" to Mikey who still insists on viewing the world in black and white.

Cheers for the info. :D

Joey Kamikaze
10-07-2015, 10:31 PM
I loved the teamwork that was displayed between raph and mikey. Splinter becoming head of the foot was definitely a surprise, I can't wait to see where that goes, and hopefully we'll get to see what karai does on her trip to Japan. One of the coolest/misterious things that happened was how don came back, I'm thinking they teleported him there..such a good readDefinitely a teleporter. Don and Harold built one in Harold's lab (see "TMNT/Ghostbusters" and "Attack on Technodrome") and there's another back at the Technodrome on Burnow Island, which is where Don's body was being healed.

Is this the first time we see General Krang in OT Android body? :lol: Cause I don't remember seeing him in that form before. Gotta love the OT reference. :tlove:
It's the "Iron Demon" body he was riding in back in Secret History of the Foot Clan.

PangolinFeets
10-07-2015, 10:43 PM
If I remember correctly Shredder is suppose to be in the Batman cross-over, so that would mean that this cross-over takes place before this story-arc I suppose..

All I want to do is see Shredder fight Batman. :(

Regarding Mikey, his reaction wasn't a huge surprise tome. This brought me back to Woody. Mikey almost lost a good friend because of the violence that comes from being around him. And he's brought it up a few times. This being the one that stuck out to me most.
http://i.imgur.com/e87Grrwl.png

ProphetofGanja
10-07-2015, 10:46 PM
I gotta say the ending of this issue surprised the hell out of me. The action in this issue was top notch, but I totally didn't expect it to go in the direction it did. I'm curious to see where things go from here, and I'm sure there's more going on behind the scenes on the part of the Pantheon, possibly they even influenced the Gauntlet battle for their own ends. Kitsune is a tricky minx.

Eurydemus
10-07-2015, 11:12 PM
But I guess my thing is...

...the execution felt off. It just comes off as if they wanted to make SURE they got the stinger set up for their next arc for Mikey in that issue. Maybe we should've gotten a few more pages to make it feel a bit more "fleshed out". Or it could have been just saved for #51 (where I feel we'll likely get a better explanation for Mikey's choice, anyway).

Either way, I just feel as if the obvious setup from the last few issues, where he was already struggling, just didn't get the big "moment" it deserved. He just flipped the deuces and took his leave. Conversely, Leonardo's "descent to the dark side" and Donatello giving his all for a cause he believed in before he "died", just felt much better done.


Since we're doing away with spoiler tags this far into the thread...

As others have already said, the last stage of seppuku involves the cutter's decapitation by his second in order to spare the suicidee from prolonged suffering. In that light, I don't think Shredder's send off was contrived. It made sense since Yoshi and Saki had something akin to a reconciliation.

However, seppuku was more of a samurai thing and Saki was a ninja, so I don't know how that's supposed to pan out. Then again, we also have Leo the honourable ninja so maybe that's...yeah.

Speaking of Leo, I felt a wee bit bad for Koya when he started plucking her like a chicken. Poor birdy.

Metropoliskid41
10-07-2015, 11:23 PM
The blending of Samurai and Ninja traditions and actions has a constant presence in our culture and that's bled over into all eras of TMNT, this iteration included.

The Turtles have always been much more inline with Samurai, Warriors with a code of honor, essentially Bushido even if they don't come out and say it.

In all actuality, Ninjas were ends justify the means, ruthless assassins, spies, and thieves. So offering shredder an honorable death here via seppuku is really just following that blending of the two that has existed in the Turtle franchise since 1984.

Donny's computer84
10-07-2015, 11:25 PM
:) Most awesome issue, very powerful. I like how they brought Donny back into action. The fighting scenes were full of action, bebop and rocksteady got schooled. The final scene with Splinter and the Shredder was dramatic to say the least. The artwork was amazing. :D

Klunk1234
10-07-2015, 11:31 PM
What an awesome issue #50 is. Seeing "my" Donnie back in action was great. The fighting scenes against the villains was superb. And to my shocking surprise the Shredder, very injured, wants Hara-Kiri ( Seppuku) to be done by Master Splinter, so the former can recover his lost honor, and then Karai giving her Katana to Splinter by calling him Master, leaving the boys, perplexed.

Mikey feels abandoned and betrayed because he could not believe what he had witness leaving the group behind. Perhaps, to see consolation in his best friend, Woody. He doesn't want more violence as problem solving; he wants positive things to come off from situations like this. :D

Mutant Ninja Anole
10-07-2015, 11:58 PM
The blending of Samurai and Ninja traditions and actions has a constant presence in our culture and that's bled over into all eras of TMNT, this iteration included.

The Turtles have always been much more inline with Samurai, Warriors with a code of honor, essentially Bushido even if they don't come out and say it.

In all actuality, Ninjas were ends justify the means, ruthless assassins, spies, and thieves. So offering shredder an honorable death here via seppuku is really just following that blending of the two that has existed in the Turtle franchise since 1984.
Correct, I'm not sure if the real historical ninja practiced Samurai rites like seppuku but that's one area where TMNT can afford to take artistic license.

Alright, here's a more full reaction. Again, loved it to death.

The fight at the start was great, and I like the logic to it. The Turtles are smaller, less durable, but are a better trained, more cohesive team. They take their opponents down in style and have fun doing, and I didn't mind a little humor in the fight, despite the stakes. Koya and Bludgeon's love for each other has been notable, but comes to a head here. I confess, I hope they aren't permanently hurt. I do need to point out that, including the time they left Shredder for dead on Bunrow island, this is the second time they've essentially 'tapped out' of a fight. I guess their loyalty to the Shredder does have it's limits when each other are at risk.

You know, Donnie switching bodies mid fight to finally knock out Bebop and Rocksteady, then getting to fight in a new one, almost seems unfair. Can we get a ruling on that, side judge?

Of course the roof top is a call back to the first issue (and the first movie). One thing about Splinter going to the astral plane and having flashbacks is that it reminds us of the connection these two characters have. I have no problem with Splinter being the one to take down the Shredder. In the end, the fight was always between them. But I feel like the trip to the astral plane was more than finding a way to beat Saki physically, and this is key to understanding why, despite all the evil the Shredder has done, Saki is offered and receives a Samurai's death.

The Shredder was supposed to be immortal, an eternal ruler. His only competition was himself in the afterlife, at the end of eons. We've seen futures where he wins. He saw futures where he won. He was supposed to be a god. But Yoshi brought him back to their childhood, he saw through the mask. And when the illusion was shattered, and Saki saw that the Shredder was but a man, he accepted it. Yoshi in the end, hoped to in some way save Saki's soul, as heros do, even for the villain. In the first comic, on the rooftop, the turtles offer him the same honor and he refuses. In the movie, Splinter warns him that his death will come, 'without honor' as he is tossed into the garbage. Here, we see Saki accept the hero's offer of redemption, setting him apart from other interpretations.

Whether ritual suicide fits your definition of 'redemption' is something that I may not totally accept but these are men of another, ancient culture, and they ended their dispute as the honor of their fathers dictated. One thing I do wonder is, I wouldn't have gotten the full weight of the seppuku if I hadn't read Usagi Yojimbo. I wouldn't have gotten that Splinter's beheading was part of the 'mercy kill' half of the ritual, and several commenters on other forums seem to completely miss that Shredder gutted himself on his own blade. I wonder if it would have been to distracting to have say, Angel or Alopex ask what's going on and Kitsune soberly explain the ritual, the role of the second, etc. There it would have been clear that, per ancient Samurai culture, Yoshi was actually taking a place of 'honor' in it.

I agree the accepting of the Foot Clan headship was what really set Mikey off. Too much, can't deal with it. But then, it makes sense for Splinter to accept it. It was, and still is, his clan after all. Him redeeming it fits his character. I'd frankly have little worries about Splinter's sucess in making the Foot a force for good if not for Kitsune hanging about there.

I was a little surprised at them holding off on the reveal of Leatherhead, or what Kitsune has planned for Alopex. Do note that two of her rival, the Rat King's pawns, Splinter and Leo, are right next to her and her pawn now. Does she know? Does she know that the Krang and Shredder duel attack that set this in motion was subliminally suggested by him?

As for the epilouge...not sure what it means. At first I thought it meant that the reincarnation actually had a connection to Krang's actions but...what does that mean? That Krang had a Xanatos gambit and won? I'm guessing it actually means there are stored samples of the original warriors and we may see a dark version of the turtles and Splinter to come. But regardless, I'm pumped to see where this goes from here!

Shark_Blade
10-08-2015, 12:04 AM
You know, Splinter did the right thing. These are trained ninjas without a leader (since Karai decided to go to Japan), and if left unguided, NY will be swarming with even more enemies and fractions from the Foot Clan splitting up.

It's better to hold the cards close to you than leaving them off wondering what will they do next.

Mikey can't process these things yet it seems.

Redeemer
10-08-2015, 12:56 AM
You know, Splinter did the right thing. These are trained ninjas without a leader (since Karai decided to go to Japan), and if left unguided, NY will be swarming with even more enemies and fractions from the Foot Clan splitting up.

It's better to hold the cards close to you than leaving them off wondering what will they do next.

Mikey can't process these things yet it seems.

City at War arc next??????? maybe :D

It will be interesting to see what Rocksteady and Bebop will do now :P

I am curious to see if they will ever bring back shredder. I have a feeling he will be laid to rest for a while. If I was a betting man I am sure they will try to bring him back at one point, maybe by Ratking :D Hopefully down the road though. I want to see some original stories and characters for now.

Ninjinister
10-08-2015, 12:59 AM
Man they're going for the slow burn with this Leatherhead reveal, ain't they?

Also... mixed feelings about the book doing the bandwagon fake action figure cover with Shredder for this one. I love it and it looks amazing but like the other comics that are doing it just makes me wish so hard that it was real. Also it looks like it could be representing 3.75" scale which would make me so happy.

Mormegil
10-08-2015, 06:51 AM
This was great! The flashback idea really set a good pacing for the fight scenes. It wouldn't have been as moving if Splinter and Shredder would have just fought and been done in a couple pages. The flashbacks also helped bring the arc full circle with the earlier issues.

Hopefully we'll get to see a full drawing of Leatherhead soon. At this point i just want to see what he looks like in the IDW universe.

You guys are going to have a hard time topping this issue. But i can't wait to see what is in store for the next arc. I'm pumped about it because we're almost back to a blank slate. With the previous story lines you could kind of see where they were pulling from with previous versions of TMNT. But with the new arc it seems like they are going to have to create a lot more without as much inspiration from other iterations. Can't wait to see what happens.

ChosenOne
10-08-2015, 08:52 AM
I'm gonna go ahead and say this without spoiler tags: has anyone noticed that as Shredder defeats each of the Turtles in single combat, we get a close-up of one of their weapons being left behind in the arena, and then Splinter gets to use all of them in quick succession in the final fight?

I think it symbolizes how his sons are still fighting by his side until the very end, even if not physically.

TonySiegel
10-08-2015, 09:06 AM
Great issue not perfect but great...

- didn't like the dialogue at the beginning, it had alot of cheese factor at times between the turtles and the enemies

- the bebop and rocksteady fight was cheesy to, a bit cliche as well... koya and bludgeon's fight was much better...

- the 2nd half of the comic was amazing had me absorbed through and through

- great twist ending like really mad me feel wowed

[wouldnt a shredder and splinter prequel comic be amazing???!!! i would love to see how they grew up together, from children to adult men... show the story of them in ancient japan, that would be epic... how can we make this happen???!!!]

Panda_Kahn_fan
10-08-2015, 09:11 AM
Oh boy, what an issue! This is probably the top of the line for me when it comes to IDW TMNT comics. Just a few notes here though;

-To answer the question here earlier; no, ninjas did not practice seppuku, they had no honor at all. TMNT, like all western takes on Asian martial arts, simply slaps honor and customs down without caring about context. But in this case it does make sense; the foot were founded by an ex-samurai (even if he was a rotten fellow) and there may have been an attempt to instill honor into this particular clan of ninja.

-Shredder's life isn't over. remember he's going to become the ruler of the violent warrior's afterlife in limbo and have a long and despotic rule (until he is slain by his younger self.)

-Splinter taking over the foot could be an interesting plot point; what if Splinter tries to reshape the foot into an actual ninja clan (as Karai wishes), and Mikey is just the first to leave? What if, in there heart of hearts, the turtles aren't the ruthless ninja warriors their father desires, and decide to abandon the path of the ninja for the path of the (here's that dirty word) 'hero'? We could have a sad situation of the four turtles fighting the foot, wit their former Sensei being their opponent in place of the shredder?

Looking forward to next issue!

oldmanwinters
10-08-2015, 09:26 AM
what if Splinter tries to reshape the foot into an actual ninja clan (as Karai wishes), and Mikey is just the first to leave? What if, in there heart of hearts, the turtles aren't the ruthless ninja warriors their father desires, and decide to abandon the path of the ninja for the path of the (here's that dirty word) 'hero'? We could have a sad situation of the four turtles fighting the foot, wit their former Sensei being their opponent in place of the shredder?


I like the way you think! Starts to remind me a little of the alternate dimension "Sliver" from the 4Kids cartoon. I'd have a hard time seeing IDW Splinter actively persecuting his sons, but I could definitely see them ending up on very different sides of an issues as they pursue different goals.

Maybe we can look forward to an upcoming "Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles" arc to make the European fandom happy. :tlol:

Metropoliskid41
10-08-2015, 09:28 AM
-Splinter taking over the foot could be an interesting plot point; what if Splinter tries to reshape the foot into an actual ninja clan (as Karai wishes), and Mikey is just the first to leave? What if, in there heart of hearts, the turtles aren't the ruthless ninja warriors their father desires, and decide to abandon the path of the ninja for the path of the (here's that dirty word) 'hero'? We could have a sad situation of the four turtles fighting the foot, wit their former Sensei being their opponent in place of the shredder?

Looking forward to next issue!

I don't think Splinter, as he has been presented, desires his sones to be ruthless or killing ninja warriors. He has constantly stressed fighting in defense only, not actively seeking violent conflict. Some of the events leading up to and and culminating in #50, were the direct result of the Turtles trying to avoid conflict, until they got to the point where the only way the Turtles could know peace was to finally kill shredder.

Splinter's whole deal is avoiding conflict and upholding the promise he made to Tang-Shen, he has turned his back on that lifestyle, learned to control his anger, and only use violence as a final resort. He's worked very hard to instill that same concept to the Turtles.

The only way this would come into play, that Splinter wants the Turtles to become ruthless Ninjas, is if Rat King starts manipulating and corrupting him. Which is possible and has a lot of potential.

Panda_Kahn_fan
10-08-2015, 09:52 AM
I don't think Splinter, as he has been presented, desires his sones to be ruthless or killing ninja warriors. He has constantly stressed fighting in defense only, not actively seeking violent conflict. Some of the events leading up to and and culminating in #50, were the direct result of the Turtles trying to avoid conflict, until they got to the point where the only way the Turtles could know peace was to finally kill shredder.

Splinter's whole deal is avoiding conflict and upholding the promise he made to Tang-Shen, he has turned his back on that lifestyle, learned to control his anger, and only use violence as a final resort. He's worked very hard to instill that same concept to the Turtles.

The only way this would come into play, that Splinter wants the Turtles to become ruthless Ninjas, is if Rat King starts manipulating and corrupting him. Which is possible and has a lot of potential.

A lot of that was sarcasm. What I meant was what if the Turtles and Splinter don't exactly see eye-to-eye on how to run the foot clan, and what their purpose is now.While not being 'heartless' and 'ruthless', Splinter's methods were extreme enough to upset Mikey, and he and Leo were arguing over which enemy was more important to take down- the one Splinter wanted revenge on, or the one who wanted to take over the world.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2015, 09:55 AM
Maybe Karai will bring back a version of Pimiko from Japan.

Even though it won't happen, I can hope!

The Happy One
10-08-2015, 09:58 AM
I'm gonna go ahead and say this without spoiler tags: has anyone noticed that as Shredder defeats each of the Turtles in single combat, we get a close-up of one of their weapons being left behind in the arena, and then Splinter gets to use all of them in quick succession in the final fight?

I think it symbolizes how his sons are still fighting by his side until the very end, even if not physically.

Good point. I didn't even think of that! I overall loved this issue. The emotion captured was just spectacular. Karai's face- her emotion and the welling tears. It was gorgeous! And the point you just made is even more touching. That even if Leo, Don, Raph and Mikey are not there in body, they are in spirit.

ctt4lfecw
10-08-2015, 10:22 AM
Thank u IDW for this wonderful comic! Exceeded all my expectations!

Editor's Note Comics
10-08-2015, 10:43 AM
I think Splinters story has a lot of potential. We've really only seen him motivated by revenge until this point. Could be he only took the Foot clan as he had nothing else in his life to drive him with Shredder gone. Or maybe he just needs some red shirts for the Pantheon story.

Weapons@theready
10-08-2015, 10:53 AM
Something I forgot to mention:

From the way Splinter was holding Saki's helmet, I half-expected him to put it on in the final panels. That would've been too over-the-top, I think.

It would've been way to much and to me it would've been too cheesy and taken away from the seriousness of it all. I'm still laughing at the picture in my mind thinking about this...his nose would be sticking out lol

Metalhead 2.0
10-08-2015, 11:44 AM
"But the spoils of their victory? Those will go to those most sly." - Kitsune to Alopex

What do you guys think she means?

The Foot?
Koya/Bludgeon?
Shredder's body?
Splinter's new found peace/security?


Also, I've seen a few people saying that Bebop & Rocksteady are free agents now. Not necessarily, they are members of The Foot and Splinter as junin has given Karai permission to take members of her choice to Japan. Seeing as how they are basically her own pet creations I wager they're headed overseas with her.

One other thing on Karai, with Splinter in charge now will she remain chunin or will Leo take her place? Either way there's going to be some toes stepped on and some animosity surface.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2015, 12:02 PM
"But the spoils of their victory? Those will go to those most sly." - Kitsune to Alopex

What do you guys think she means?

The Foot?
Koya/Bludgeon?
Shredder's body?
Splinter's new found peace/security?


Also, I've seen a few people saying that Bebop & Rocksteady are free agents now. Not necessarily, they are members of The Foot and Splinter as junin has given Karai permission to take members of her choice to Japan. Seeing as how they are basically her own pet creations I wager they're headed overseas with her.

One other thing on Karai, with Splinter in charge now will she remain chunin or will Leo take her place? Either way there's going to be some toes stepped on and some animosity surface.

I freely admit, I don't have ANY IDEA what Kitsune's game plan is... apparently she didn't need Shredder anymore, but maybe she needs the Foot Clan? An army?

Metropoliskid41
10-08-2015, 12:09 PM
What are the lives of a few hundred pawns for immortals like Rat King and Kitsune? I have no idea what she has planned, but I'm hoping that it's going to be big!!!

cookie jar
10-08-2015, 12:11 PM
IGN review of TMNT #50

rating 8.1

http://www.ign.com/articles/2015/10/08/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-50-review

Metalhead 2.0
10-08-2015, 12:30 PM
I freely admit, I don't have ANY IDEA what Kitsune's game plan is... apparently she didn't need Shredder anymore, but maybe she needs the Foot Clan? An army?

Yeah, but who ultimately controls the Foot clan now, her or Rat King? Or perhaps there will be a divide?

Or maybe it has nothing to do with the Foot, maybe she means Mikey?

And if she's totally done with Shredder, then why will she be waiting for her "Dragon Warrior" to find his way back to her?

It'll be interesting to see the relationship that unfolds between Kitsune and Splinter, it's one of the things I'm most looking forward to. I was surprised he wanted to keep her around and the dialogue between the two should be excellent.

Yeah, I'm totally under her spell...

Redeemer
10-08-2015, 02:20 PM
"But the spoils of their victory? Those will go to those most sly." - Kitsune to Alopex

What do you guys think she means?

The Foot?
Koya/Bludgeon?
Shredder's body?
Splinter's new found peace/security?

.

You ever heard the term sly as a fox???? I think she means that her and alopex have or will truly win the day

Metalhead 2.0
10-08-2015, 02:43 PM
You ever heard the term sly as a fox???? I think she means that her and alopex have or will truly win the day

Yes, I get that, but the question is: How so? What are to be considered the spoils and how will they benefit from them?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2015, 02:48 PM
So... looking ahead to the solicitations for #51, #52, and #53. Now that we've read #50, what might be in store?

I would've thought the "devastating new foe" would be Kitsune unleashed, but that doesn't appear to be the case as she is still in the background. Other members of the Pantheon?

A Foot civil war seems obvious, but who will lead the forces against Splinter? Kistune is, again, possible but seems unlikely. Bebop and Rocksteady will be forces to reckon with if they stick around, but they don't really have the brains to lead anything.

Stugehen
10-08-2015, 03:44 PM
So... looking ahead to the solicitations for #51, #52, and #53. Now that we've read #50, what might be in store?

I would've thought the "devastating new foe" would be Kitsune unleashed, but that doesn't appear to be the case as she is still in the background. Other members of the Pantheon?

A Foot civil war seems obvious, but who will lead the forces against Splinter? Kistune is, again, possible but seems unlikely. Bebop and Rocksteady will be forces to reckon with if they stick around, but they don't really have the brains to lead anything.

If I recall, the Rat King seemed to have sensed Kitsune's lingering long presence after Leonardo had been brainwashed and didn't take to it very favorably. Interestingly, Kitsune doesn't seem to remember Rat King's influence on Splinter from a previous issue.

I concur there will be a Foot Clan civil war. I'd wager Rat King makes his move and forces Splinter's hand while Kitsune leads Alopex along with others unwilling to join Splinter.

Also, there seems to be hints of another divide incoming within the Mutanimals. They left off with Hob saving Hun at the expense of ticking off Slash. I wonder how that will turn out.

turtlefan27
10-08-2015, 03:53 PM
Now that April and Casey know about pantheon they are going to share that information with the turtles, they will then be aware of what's going on in the background and might try and prepare for anything to happen..possibly

Stugehen
10-08-2015, 03:54 PM
Another thought on the epilogue.

Maybe they added it simply to tease that someone may take DNA (or QNA?) samples of Shredder's corpse behind the scenes, and that's how he could be revived in the future. Perhaps after the Pantheon story is over.

CyberCubed
10-08-2015, 04:04 PM
Shredder's and Kitsune's last exchange in dialogue pretty much prove Shredder won't stay dead. He's probably going to be ressurrected as a dragon god and join Kitsune and the other god's.

Metropoliskid41
10-08-2015, 04:11 PM
Another thought on the epilogue.

Maybe they added it simply to tease that someone may take DNA (or QNA?) samples of Shredder's corpse behind the scenes, and that's how he could be revived in the future. Perhaps after the Pantheon story is over.

I certainly hope that's not the case. If it is, then there really isn't any true threat to anyone in the book, because samples can just be pulled from their dead body and they can be regenerated, personality/essence/soul etc intact.

That's why I'm really hoping that the last page doesn't mean that the Turtles came to be by Krang intentionally resurrecting them and inserted their personalities somehow.

If Utrom can simply walk up to a dead body and take DNA and QNA (whatever that is) samples and essentially use those to Synthesize someone's personality that is then able to be injected into another host, there really is no threat to anyone. They can just be repeatedly resurrected, apparently with all of their personality traits, characteristics, and memories leading up to the moment of their deaths able to be artificially grown, cultured, and implanted in new bodies.

That kind of lowers the stakes of things a bit.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2015, 04:12 PM
Shredder's and Kitsune's last exchange in dialogue pretty much prove Shredder won't stay dead. He's probably going to be ressurrected as a dragon god and join Kitsune and the other god's.

But why would a bunch of warring gods add a mortal to their number? Unless Rat King, god of chaos...

Hmmm. Maybe.

CyberCubed
10-08-2015, 04:21 PM
But why would a bunch of warring gods add a mortal to their number? Unless Rat King, god of chaos...

Hmmm. Maybe.

That's exactly what's going to happen. The whole Kitsune/Saki romance since Fuedal Japan was to make him a God.

Redeemer
10-08-2015, 04:24 PM
Yes, I get that, but the question is: How so? What are to be considered the spoils and how will they benefit from them?

I am assuming who ever the loser was.
If splinter loss she would have gained the turtles as allies. maybe
If shredder loss, she probably should have gained the foot and its mutants, but.....Karia and splinter put a big monkey wrench in those plans.

I am assuming she will try to gain control of the foot.


A lot of good speculation in the past few post.

Stugehen
10-08-2015, 04:26 PM
I certainly hope that's not the case. If it is, then there really isn't any true threat to anyone in the book, because samples can just be pulled from their dead body and they can be regenerated, personality/essence/soul etc intact.

Well, I think they’ve given us lots of indications that people have souls and there’s a spiritual afterlife. Enough that I don’t think that’s what QNA is supposed to be. So if the epilogue was meant to tease a future return of Shredder, it could just be via deformed clones or even Shark-Shredder (essentially a soul-less Shredder).

That's exactly what's going to happen. The whole Kitsune/Saki romance since Fuedal Japan was to make him a God.

If this were the case, do you think Shredder was aware that would happen? If so, that'd seem to negate the whole reconciliation between Splinter and Shredder. Maybe just a ploy?

ToTheNines
10-08-2015, 04:27 PM
You guys are forgetting the Shredder micro where he meets his older self, who rules the afterlife.

He's in a time loop of getting killed by his younger self, but Saki swore he'd kill his younger self when the time came.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2015, 04:28 PM
That's exactly what's going to happen. The whole Kitsune/Saki romance since Fuedal Japan was to make him a God.

Yeah, but Kitsune is using him. Why? What you say could happen, but right now, I'm just utterly baffled.

But if Kitsune's intent was to use Saki as a God/Weapon against the rest of the Pantheon... why is she still waiting to "deploy" him? She doesn't want to tip her hand, maybe?

Stugehen
10-08-2015, 05:04 PM
You guys are forgetting the Shredder micro where he meets his older self, who rules the afterlife.

He's in a time loop of getting killed by his younger self, but Saki swore he'd kill his younger self when the time came.

I figured that issue was more metaphorical than anything. Time loops hurt my head when I think about them too much.

If it was real, then power-hungry Shredder killed himself in Feudal Japan, rode the afterlife loop-di-loop a few times, came back to life in the modern era and got killed again though seemingly learning a lesson of sorts this time, and maybe wont undergo the afterlife loop-di-loop and can come back as a dragon god...because comics.

Mutant Ninja Anole
10-08-2015, 05:13 PM
You guys are forgetting the Shredder micro where he meets his older self, who rules the afterlife.

He's in a time loop of getting killed by his younger self, but Saki swore he'd kill his younger self when the time came.

That was a dream, it no reason to assume it wasn't a deception by malevolent spirits. When Splinter defeated him, he seemed shocked that things weren't turning out as he had seen "This wasn't supposed to happen."

Yeah, but Kitsune is using him. Why? What you say could happen, but right now, I'm just utterly baffled.

But if Kitsune's intent was to use Saki as a God/Weapon against the rest of the Pantheon... why is she still waiting to "deploy" him? She doesn't want to tip her hand, maybe?
It's all a game, she may or may not care about Shredder long term, she may simply be playing it by ear. That whether Shredder or Splinter or whoever is in power, she wins. Speculation: she may want Shredder to see himself as her champion, but I'm starting to suspect she sees Alopex as her true champion, or at least her key chess piece. Shredder's vision, the version of the future where he was in control of the Western Hemisphere, had a New York populated by mutants. Perhaps Kitsune's larger purpose is to reshape the world into something she finds more useful/interesting/whatever. That is, if she has a purpose beyond simple amusement and besting her brother in manipulation.

Rooish
10-08-2015, 07:08 PM
Also, Mikey's reaction seems perfectly believable to me: it's not so much that Splinter killed Saki, but that Splinter agreed to take over and lead the Foot Clan, the "bad guys" to Mikey who still insists on viewing the world in black and white.

Let's not make this a character flaw of Mikey's. Splinter's bull**** about "His confusion is understandable... We must give your brother the space he needs to understand it for himself" is just more of Splinter pulling his children through his madness and assuming that Stockholm syndrome is the more rational response for them. Keep in mind Mikey was a baby whose mother was murdered, and then who was decapitated when he was barely a preteen. He wants peace and for 50 issues has been dragged into a war. On top of that everyone treats him like he's a stupid kid who understands nothing (and he's sometimes written that way, unfortunately). It clearly wasn't just the beheading that alienated him (although I'm sure it triggered him); it was Splinter's decision to lead the Foot Clan and massively shift the status quo without consulting his children who had already been through too much **** because of him. Mikey has every right to ditch the insanity that is his family at this point.

Other than this, the issue was great. I do agree about the hokey dialogue but we should expect that at this point. Splinter taking over the Foot Clan is an awesome unexpected twist (despite what I just said).

The art was great. I'm glad that Mikey's appearance has improved a bit (the buck tooth is gone). I'm looking forward to seeing Santolouco's Leatherhead, Man Ray and Sally. :)

I don't entirely believe Saki's redemption. That man was pure psychotic evil. Also, why do the Turtles always fight big bad guys one after another? In all incarnations? Instead of actually teaming up?

I really hope we don't see the boys as human teens, reincarnated again. That sounds like a fanfic.

MikeandRaph87
10-08-2015, 08:26 PM
One big bad after the other instead of teaming up? Teaming with the enemy? There was the lose alliance of Shredder holding off Krang while the turtles decommissioned the Technodrome and other lose alliances with Karai, Agent Bishop, and Rat King at times in other incarnations. As for one big bad after another, honestly its the way I like it. Its the way most superhero series are. Ninja Turtles OII and TMNT are weak to me because the lack of a big bad. The first question I ask about a new Batman or Spider-Man film is who the villain will be. The weakest episodes of the cartoons the OT especislly are those that packed Shredder and gang, Rat King, or evil mutant.

As for the issue I was surprised Shredder admitted defeat and redeemed allowing for his beheading. Splinter always said that Shredder is the exception to the no-kill policy. Despite that I thought Shredder would die as a result of Kitsune's meddling. She did not act which was morw surprising than Splinter's slaying. Splinter is rhe leader of the Foot Clan? Not sure what to think of it. It cannot be an evil organization if crine and assasins so I dont see a problem with it. There eill be an immediate opposition according to solicits while Hob goes Magneto.

IronBoomer
10-08-2015, 08:46 PM
Well, certainly not where I expected them to take the story, and probably Mikey's very understandable "a pox on all your houses" towards Splinter was my most shocked moment.

A lot of this time, we've seen Donny as the brother on the verge of leaving, albeit for his own reasons, so for it to be Mikey to do it, well, that was very unexpected.
Curious IDW has Splinter take out the Shredder when Nick more or less did the reverse...

I'm curious as to how Splinter will manage the foot now, but does anyone get the feeling things are going to be super awkward between the turtles and Bebop and Rocksteady now, given they're working for the same organization?

Coola Yagami
10-08-2015, 08:49 PM
Awesome issue. Loved the whole thing. Great fighting and great character moments.

http://markandpaigerodriguez.blogspot.com/2015/10/idw-tmnt-50.html

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2015, 08:56 PM
One big bad after the other instead of teaming up? Teaming with the enemy? There was the lose alliance of Shredder holding off Krang while the turtles decommissioned the Technodrome and other lose alliances with Karai, Agent Bishop, and Rat King at times in other incarnations. As for one big bad after another, honestly its the way I like it. Its the way most superhero series are. Ninja Turtles OII and TMNT are weak to me because the lack of a big bad. The first question I ask about a new Batman or Spider-Man film is who the villain will be. The weakest episodes of the cartoons the OT especislly are those that packed Shredder and gang, Rat King, or evil mutant.

Agreed. I don't always have to have a big bad directly on the table, but knowing one is coming or moving in the shadows is enough. And TMNT does have enough big bads to keep us satisfied for quite awhile: Krang, Kitsune, Rat King, the rest of the Pantheon, Null, BISHOP, PIMIKO. A guy can dream. :tlol:

ChosenOne
10-08-2015, 09:00 PM
One big bad after the other instead of teaming up? Teaming with the enemy? There was the lose alliance of Shredder holding off Krang while the turtles decommissioned the Technodrome and other lose alliances with Karai, Agent Bishop, and Rat King at times in other incarnations. As for one big bad after another, honestly its the way I like it. Its the way most superhero series are. Ninja Turtles OII and TMNT are weak to me because the lack of a big bad. The first question I ask about a new Batman or Spider-Man film is who the villain will be. The weakest episodes of the cartoons the OT especislly are those that packed Shredder and gang, Rat King, or evil mutant..

I think he meant the Turtles tend to charge in individually instead of working as a team. We saw how easily they kicked Shredder's butt in their very first encounter, and to be fair, they did try that for a bit in #50 but it didn't take.

I imagine one-on-one moments within a battle are easier to write than four-on-one, and I would also like to point out that for the purposes of the story in this issue, ie, Splinter getting his hands on their discarded weapons, the Turtles kinda had to face Shredder one at a time.

Still, the discussion sparked by this (I believe) misunderstanding is interesting enough in itself. We comics fans are always looking for the villains of a story, sometimes even more than we focus on the heroes. I guess we've been spoiled by all the great villains in this franchise and the medium itself!

AquaParade
10-08-2015, 09:13 PM
I'm not really thinking this through so bare with me and/or correct me...

Perhaps the epilogue implies that Krang had a hand in the turtles creation, in order to see Saki defeated. Is it possible that Krang used the dna of the boys to convince the turtles they share some sort of past life with Yoshi's sons?

The resurrection concept has been mined in plenty of neat ways which I wouldn't want to go to waste. However, I am extremely tickled by the idea that the turtles and Splinter were never truly a family in Feudal Japan.

ProphetofGanja
10-08-2015, 10:26 PM
I know we were all expecting something a bit more obvious, but what if Kitsune did make her big move during the gauntlet battle? What if she was the reason Shredder was defeated, or that he had an apparent change of heart, or that Splinter accepted leadership of the Foot Clan, for some secret purpose of her own? Her specialty is in working behind the scenes, so I wouldn't put it past her. Just a thought, anyways.

CyberCubed
10-08-2015, 11:01 PM
I'm a bit surprised we still didn't see Leatherhead and they kept him off-panel for the most part. I assume he'll join the Mutanimals in the next arc.

Stugehen
10-09-2015, 12:22 AM
I continue to be intrigued by the Krang epilogue and Kitsune’s mysterious plan. I took the opportunity to read through SHOTFC again to gleam some clues about both of their pasts, but frankly I’m still confused because this series has so much science fiction and fantasy it’s hard to keep straight who can do what.

Here is some stuff I found interesting:


Kitsune was working with Krang prior to Takeshi Tatsuo/Oroku Saki. She tells Shredder “The Demon promised me the secret to life itself if I would but serve him.” I thought she was immortal, so perhaps she actually had other secret intentions for working with him?

Kitsune needs Krang’s ooze to prolong Oroku’s life so it’s clear she can’t make others immortal.

Kitsune’s curse is likely what enabled Takeshi’s soul to reincarnate into Oroku Saki, but interestingly she goes to Krang after Takeshi’s death saying she failed but has a plan for revenge. To which Krang says “I’m listening” and the issue ends. Maybe implying he had a hand in that as well.

Kitsune and Shredder eventually betray Krang after stealing one of his stasis tubes and they use it to keep Shredder alive until now. We know that, now, is significant in some way to the Pantheon but we don’t know why yet.

It seems like the only powers Kitsune actually has is the ability to transform into a fox, and to brainwash people (at least Leo and Alopex). Krang was the one with all the significant power.

TheCollector
10-09-2015, 01:27 AM
Gotta say, I'm really loving what they've done for IDW Karai the past few issues, showing it to all those people I know of who always said this version was just evil.

I'm so proud of her after this issue. :3

CyberCubed
10-09-2015, 01:52 AM
You know I tend to forget IDW's Shredder isn't as strong as he thinks he is, since the Turtles already beat him way back in issue #13, Shredder lost to Krang and nearly left for dead about 10 issues back, and the Turtles/Splinter fought him in "Secret History of the Foot Clan," and some other issues I'm forgetting.

I like that IDW's Shredder isn't so overpowered and he's beatable, I feel Nick's Shredder is way too overpowered in comparison.

Joey Kamikaze
10-09-2015, 02:32 AM
Shredder always likes to think he's way more badass than he actually is. He's that guy.

Though IDW Shredder is one of the more successful iterations when you think about it. Mirage Shredder goes out in the first issue. Fred Wolf Shredder is lol Fred Wolf Shredder. TMNTA Shredder gets tossed in prison in #13, gets out just long enough to be Krang's tool for a few issues, then mostly disappears afterward (maybe forever, depending on how you interpret the time travel shenanigans later in the series). Old movie Shredder gets creamed twice in a row. Bay movie Shredder goes out quick too. Compared to all that, IDW Shredder did pretty well for himself.

neatoman
10-09-2015, 05:11 AM
So do you think Shredder will reincarnate? There was a version of the Shredder in the future and his eyes didn't look human. If he does reincarnate, considering what has happened in the story and what Tom has said about what he likes about TMNT, I think I know what he'll come back as and I think you might as well ;)

Raptor86
10-09-2015, 06:28 AM
No worms this time, please.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-09-2015, 08:06 AM
No worms this time, please.

I heartily second the motion.

You know I tend to forget IDW's Shredder isn't as strong as he thinks he is, since the Turtles already beat him way back in issue #13, Shredder lost to Krang and nearly left for dead about 10 issues back, and the Turtles/Splinter fought him in "Secret History of the Foot Clan," and some other issues I'm forgetting.

I like that IDW's Shredder isn't so overpowered and he's beatable, I feel Nick's Shredder is way too overpowered in comparison.

Honestly, on the flip side, I think the IDW Turtles are some of the weakest Turtles EVER. The only enemies I can think of them successfully defeating are: Bludgeon, Koya, and a distracted General Krang. But they keep losing to Shredder, Bebop and Rocksteady, and Slash (plus they also seem intimidated by Hun in the FCBD issue). I really wish the guys had better fighting skills in this continuity...

I continue to be intrigued by the Krang epilogue and Kitsune’s mysterious plan. I took the opportunity to read through SHOTFC again to gleam some clues about both of their pasts, but frankly I’m still confused because this series has so much science fiction and fantasy it’s hard to keep straight who can do what.

Here is some stuff I found interesting:


Kitsune was working with Krang prior to Takeshi Tatsuo/Oroku Saki. She tells Shredder “The Demon promised me the secret to life itself if I would but serve him.” I thought she was immortal, so perhaps she actually had other secret intentions for working with him?

Kitsune needs Krang’s ooze to prolong Oroku’s life so it’s clear she can’t make others immortal.

Kitsune’s curse is likely what enabled Takeshi’s soul to reincarnate into Oroku Saki, but interestingly she goes to Krang after Takeshi’s death saying she failed but has a plan for revenge. To which Krang says “I’m listening” and the issue ends. Maybe implying he had a hand in that as well.

Kitsune and Shredder eventually betray Krang after stealing one of his stasis tubes and they use it to keep Shredder alive until now. We know that, now, is significant in some way to the Pantheon but we don’t know why yet.

It seems like the only powers Kitsune actually has is the ability to transform into a fox, and to brainwash people (at least Leo and Alopex). Krang was the one with all the significant power.

Wow. That is something to think about... still absorbing it all. Personally, I think Kitsune is already immortal but doesn't have the ability to bestow that upon others. But then... why did she bother with suspended ooze animation? A continued subterfuge to deceive Saki? Rat King doesn't appear to have had any trouble remaining alive for hundreds (if not thousands) of years.

I'm a bit surprised we still didn't see Leatherhead and they kept him off-panel for the most part. I assume he'll join the Mutanimals in the next arc.

So looking forward to it! Also to the prospect of free Utroms on Burnow Island!

I know we were all expecting something a bit more obvious, but what if Kitsune did make her big move during the gauntlet battle? What if she was the reason Shredder was defeated, or that he had an apparent change of heart, or that Splinter accepted leadership of the Foot Clan, for some secret purpose of her own? Her specialty is in working behind the scenes, so I wouldn't put it past her. Just a thought, anyways.

I suspect you're right. I'm also thinking Alopex is her weapon against the Turtles... after all, why else was she sent back to NYC except to become an ally to the TMNT?

Editor's Note Comics
10-09-2015, 01:25 PM
I'm a bit surprised we still didn't see Leatherhead and they kept him off-panel for the most part. I assume he'll join the Mutanimals in the next arc.

I hope not. He'd be too similar to Slash if they keep the rage side of his personality. I'd rather have him do some more of the cosmic stories with Fugitoid, Utroms, Neutrinos, or whatever else is coming next.

Gunstar_Red
10-09-2015, 01:50 PM
It was a wonderful issue! The things I loved most about it are the art and colors. Especially the colors. Some panels really popped with the great palette choices!

I might be the only one, but I was disappointed with the Koya and Bludgeon romance. It seemed a little shoehorned.

Poor Mike. I understand his confusion and frustration for the very same reasons others have mentioned. He just wants the cycle of violence to end, even if that's impossible.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-09-2015, 02:11 PM
It was a wonderful issue! The things I loved most about it are the art and colors. Especially the colors. Some panels really popped with the great palette choices!

I might be the only one, but I was disappointed with the Koya and Bludgeon romance. It seemed a little shoehorned.

Poor Mike. I understand his confusion and frustration for the very same reasons others have mentioned. He just wants the cycle of violence to end, even if that's impossible.

Unfortunate art aside (i.e. Koya's bedroom eyes), I don't think it's a romance; I think it's a deep fraternal bond, similar to the Turtles. They're siblings, and constantly refer to each other as "brother" or "sister."

This ain't Game of Thrones, yo. :tlol:

Gunstar_Red
10-09-2015, 02:28 PM
Unfortunate art aside (i.e. Koya's bedroom eyes), I don't think it's a romance; I think it's a deep fraternal bond, similar to the Turtles. They're siblings, and constantly refer to each other as "brother" or "sister."

This ain't Game of Thrones, yo. :tlol:

I sure hope it's not romance too. ^^;

MsMarvelDuckie
10-09-2015, 04:21 PM
Unfortunate art aside (i.e. Koya's bedroom eyes), I don't think it's a romance; I think it's a deep fraternal bond, similar to the Turtles. They're siblings, and constantly refer to each other as "brother" or "sister."

This ain't Game of Thrones, yo. :tlol:

That's never stopped the shippers! Besides, they could just as easily mean clan-brother or sister, since both work for and are part of the Foot clan.

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 05:18 PM
I thought the same thing but it was easily perceived that way upon presentation. Tom and the art team will see this cue and make sure not to imply interspecies romance between the mutant "siblings" next time. I think it is supposed to be clan family. Bebop and Rocksteady are "brothers" just as the turtles are. So are Bludgeon and Koya as "brother" and "sister".

So what is Splinter going to do with Foot Clan? We know there will be immediate opposition within the clan and it is not Karai, but what plan does Splinter have? Peace keeping corps? Disband?

Panda_Kahn_fan
10-09-2015, 05:23 PM
So what is Splinter going to do with Foot Clan? We know there will be immediate opposition within the clan and it is not Karai, but what plan does Splinter have? Peace keeping corps? Disband?

I'm afraid he'll try to turn them back into what ninja are supposed to be and drive a wedge between himself and the turtles.

ChosenOne
10-09-2015, 05:26 PM
I guess I'm in the minority here, but I wouldn't mind a Koya/Bludgeon romance. Not only does it give both characters more depth, but since they're IDW originals (despite Bludgeon's frequent association with Armaggon) they're pretty much blanks slates and the writers can do as they please with them without having to worry about upsetting fans of previous iterations. It's no sillier than Raph/Alopex (yes, I realize what I just said but it's a thing so let's deal).

neatoman
10-09-2015, 05:26 PM
So how did Nickelodeon allow Splinter to kill? Especially a major character and so graphically? I mean, you don't get to see the head pop off but you still see the sword cut through Shredder's neck and the blood afterwards.

Powder
10-09-2015, 05:29 PM
Maybe they made a deal from the get go "We'll try not to make it too violent/bloody if you'll allow us one big dramatic kill in #50." considering they had this all mapped out.

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 05:40 PM
Maybe they made a deal from the get go "We'll try not to make it too violent/bloody if you'll allow us one big dramatic kill in #50." considering they had this all mapped out.

And Shredder come back eventually. Shredder may find a way around his younger spirit from killing his older spirit in the other realm. It brings new meaning to the term suicide. If he does he will be back.

ChosenOne
10-09-2015, 05:41 PM
And Shredder come back eventually. Shredder may find a way around his younger spirit from killing his older spirit in the other realm. It brings new meaning to the term suicide. If he does he will be back.

Maybe the piece of the puzzle that was missing for him to be able to break free of that loop is the lesson in mortality that Splinter just taught him? If so... Nice job breaking it, hero!

CyberCubed
10-09-2015, 05:42 PM
So how did Nickelodeon allow Splinter to kill? Especially a major character and so graphically? I mean, you don't get to see the head pop off but you still see the sword cut through Shredder's neck and the blood afterwards.

Because Kitsune is going to ressurrect Shredder as a Dragon God. She more or less spelled it out in her final dialogue with him.

Powder
10-09-2015, 05:47 PM
If Shredder turns out to be Dragon Lord, well, that'd just be awesome as hell.

CyberCubed
10-09-2015, 05:58 PM
If Shredder turns out to be Dragon Lord, well, that'd just be awesome as hell.

I was thinking more of the Ninja Tribunal arc from 4kids. Remember Demon Shredder turned into a huge dragon to fight the Turtles (also in their dragon forms) in the last episodes.

neatoman
10-09-2015, 06:03 PM
Because Kitsune is going to ressurrect Shredder as a Dragon God. She more or less spelled it out in her final dialogue with him.

So you think they're gonna pull this ****?
f3B4T8LSRHs

CyberCubed
10-09-2015, 06:07 PM
That was great.

neatoman
10-09-2015, 06:19 PM
That was great.

The Dragon battle? Yeah sure but in a cheesy over the top sort of way, it felt really bizarre the first time I watched it though...

Panda_Kahn_fan
10-09-2015, 06:46 PM
Also remember that demon shredder was a tengu, not a dragon.

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 06:49 PM
CKD, I do not believe they are among the weakest incarnation of the turtlrs, but IDW wants them to uave rare clear victories to build up the story and the villain. Think of how Bebop and Rocksteady were portrayed especially seasons 2-7 of the original animated series. Now think of how vertually the same characters are portrayed in this comic series. They are a big threat and no comedic relief. As consequence of building the sesired story and rhe villains of the series rhe turtles are precieved as being weaker as their foes are deadlier.

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 06:53 PM
Also remember that demon shredder was a tengu, not a dragon.

The two part season 5 finale was actually my favorite episode (s) of the series. I liked the battle royale in the ancient japanese setting.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-09-2015, 07:41 PM
I'm afraid he'll try to turn them back into what ninja are supposed to bem and drive a wedge between himself and the turtles.

Splinter is absolutely going to try to redeem the Foot Clan. It's a retelling of that particular "redeem the Foot" plotline from Image Volume 3. Also, Splinter has already established that he has no war with Karai and that he wants only to restore the Foot's honor, which Saki sullied.

I guess I'm in the minority here, but I wouldn't mind a Koya/Bludgeon romance. Not only does it give both characters more depth, but since they're IDW originals (despite Bludgeon's frequent association with Armaggon) they're pretty much blanks slates and the writers can do as they please with them without having to worry about upsetting fans of previous iterations. It's no sillier than Raph/Alopex (yes, I realize what I just said but it's a thing so let's deal).

I honestly don't care one way or another if Koya and Bludgeon are romantic or not; but the way IDW has been protraying their relationship, I think it's fairly obvious to everyone but shippers that they're siblings. (And if you want to ship, go right ahead; that was not a condemnation, simply observation that it's what you guys do.)

Maybe the piece of the puzzle that was missing for him to be able to break free of that loop is the lesson in mortality that Splinter just taught him? If so... Nice job breaking it, hero!

Now THERE'S a great observation! You may be on to something!

If Shredder turns out to be Dragon Lord, well, that'd just be awesome as hell.

I second the motion!

I was thinking more of the Ninja Tribunal arc from 4kids. Remember Demon Shredder turned into a huge dragon to fight the Turtles (also in their dragon forms) in the last episodes.

Oh for the love of all that is holy, PLEASE do not let IDW become another anime DragonballZ spirit-guide fest. That was as bizarre a left turn as Fast Forward or Back to the Sewers, and it would really piss me off. Keep it for the non-canon "Souls' Winter" type stories, not mainline TMNT.

The Nick cartoon episode with the Mystic Turtles in the Northampton woods and IDW comics' Tang Shen are doing a MUCH BETTER representation of spirituality in TMNT.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-09-2015, 07:44 PM
All four Turtles transforming into giant spirit dragons and fighting giant tengu dragon Oroku Saki over the New York City skyline...

Forget Mikey hopping over Bludgeon, THAT is jumping the shark. And I'll stop hating on "The Ninja Tribunal" now. :tlol:

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 07:50 PM
Different strokrs for different folks as I completely block out TMNT history 1997-2001. That being said what'cha talkin about in reference to a plotline of redeeming the Foot?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-09-2015, 07:59 PM
Different strokrs for different folks as I completely block out TMNT history 1997-2001. That being said what'cha talkin about in reference to a plotline of redeeming the Foot?

Basically, after City at War, Karai disappeared and Raphael began training alongside the Foot. After a Foot/Mob war was instigated indirectly by the Turtles (who rescued Shadow from the Mob, and who had been delivered to the Mob by the Foot), mobsters massacred all of the Foot leadership. Raph donned Shredder's armor and slaughtered the mobsters, then went to the head of the mob and demanded a treaty at the point of his gauntlets.

After that, the remaining Foot ninja asked Raphael to lead them. He agreed, and led them... for a time. Then other awesome stuff happened. :twink:

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 09:11 PM
Basically, after City at War, Karai disappeared and Raphael began training alongside the Foot. After a Foot/Mob war was instigated indirectly by the Turtles (who rescued Shadow from the Mob, and who had been delivered to the Mob by the Foot), mobsters massacred all of the Foot leadership. Raph donned Shredder's armor and slaughtered the mobsters, then went to the head of the mob and demanded a treaty at the point of his gauntlets.

After that, the remaining Foot ninja asked Raphael to lead them. He agreed, and led them... for a time. Then other awesome stuff happened. :twink:

I stopped caring when you informed me that Raphael is a murderer. Not my cup of tea. Never envisioned the mob having much involvement in TMNT since it appeared in about three episode arcs of TMNT (2003). I do like the idea of a Big Louie-like figure that can being a callback to the gangster era and Godfather films in tribute and parody yet taken more seriously. In that I mean Big Louie consolidates the mafia figures under him and thus be a threat to the city and turtles as well.

Splinter leading the Foot. It would seem he would try to make it into a peace keeping organization. The question is, how? That would stir the immediate opposition if Karai is out of the picture in Japan. I like the idea of her father being Tatsu and taking charge. Maybe similar in Casey's father being a failure and stepping up in the wrong way becoming the treaded Tatsu.

So remind me what became of the Hun/Hob plotline.

Btw, CKD, I see your new signature and I must say, that was my favorite panel in issue #50 as well!

Technogeek29
10-09-2015, 09:21 PM
Only time will tell with Hun odds are Mikey will see him and that is what puts him at odds with Hob and the gang. But Old hob is a good fast talker I'm sure he'll think of something to keep Mike around?

CyberCubed
10-09-2015, 10:22 PM
Oh for the love of all that is holy, PLEASE do not let IDW become another anime DragonballZ spirit-guide fest. That was as bizarre a left turn as Fast Forward or Back to the Sewers, and it would really piss me off. Keep it for the non-canon "Souls' Winter" type stories, not mainline TMNT.

That made perfect sense for the direction of the show at the time. It was a mystical season fighting Demons.

Powder
10-09-2015, 10:23 PM
I stopped caring when you informed me that Raphael is a murderer.

A ninja that doesn't kill isn't a ninja.

It's a "Hero".

The turtles have killed in both Mirage & IDW (I think) at the very least.

MikeandRaph87
10-09-2015, 10:31 PM
A ninja that doesn't kill isn't a ninja.

It's a "Hero".

The turtles have killed in both Mirage & IDW (I think) at the very least.

Let's not go into this again. I like my Ninja Turtles as super heroes. Other don't. My TMNT don't kill. Yours do. If CDK and I can get past a thing like that so can we without being jerks about it. That is all I will say on the matter.

I wonder how Krang taking DNA samples of Yoshi and his four sons plays into the reincarnation in his funded project. It is an extra bit to tie it all together. It also makes we wonder about Slash and if he was just another experiment or there is something more to him as well. Saki and Kitsune's son reincarnated? Maybe I am thinking too much, but with the intricate story Tom, Kevin and Bobby are telling one cannot help it!

Duke Nukem
10-09-2015, 11:44 PM
This was a great issue, one of the best in the series so far, on par with SHOTFC. I'm curious to see what the next few issues will bring. Comics being what they are, no one can ever say how permanent something's death is. But, with the events of this issue, and now only one ongoing comic per month from here on, it definitely seems like it's a possibility that the story is winding down. Hopefully this isn't the case, because there are quite a few good directions it could take from here.

Ninjinister
10-10-2015, 12:21 AM
A ninja that doesn't kill isn't a ninja.

It's a "Hero".


That doesn't make any bloody sense.

Powder
10-10-2015, 12:32 AM
A joke, based on the UK's "Hero" branding.

One would think you of all the 'bloody' people here would get that... :tlol:

CyberCubed
10-10-2015, 01:29 AM
The idea of Koya and Bludgeon mating is sending me into furry deviantart territory. I don't know how it works with a shark and a bird, I don't want to imagine it. :lol:

Shark_Blade
10-10-2015, 07:00 AM
The idea of Koya and Bludgeon mating is sending me into furry deviantart territory. I don't know how it works with a shark and a bird, I don't want to imagine it. :lol:You act like this is a new thing.:-?

Yet you are fine with Raph and Ninjara, or Raph with Alopex, or Mikey with that alien woman whom he impregnated, or Leo sleeping with a human female wife?

Ain't no different if it's a mutant turtle banging a mutant furry ass wolf/fox, or a mutant turtle knocked up an extraterrestrial life to pregnancy, nor a mutant turtle inserting his erect penis into a human woman's vagina. It's fictional.

A mutant eagle pairing with a mutant shark is no biggie nor new. :roll: Get your head out of your ass.

Editor's Note Comics
10-10-2015, 10:30 AM
Maybe Mike can go become a movie producer. Bring back that weird dream sequence from Vol. 2!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-10-2015, 11:03 AM
I stopped caring when you informed me that Raphael is a murderer. Not my cup of tea. Never envisioned the mob having much involvement in TMNT since it appeared in about three episode arcs of TMNT (2003). I do like the idea of a Big Louie-like figure that can being a callback to the gangster era and Godfather films in tribute and parody yet taken more seriously. In that I mean Big Louie consolidates the mafia figures under him and thus be a threat to the city and turtles as well.

Splinter leading the Foot. It would seem he would try to make it into a peace keeping organization. The question is, how? That would stir the immediate opposition if Karai is out of the picture in Japan. I like the idea of her father being Tatsu and taking charge. Maybe similar in Casey's father being a failure and stepping up in the wrong way becoming the treaded Tatsu.

So remind me what became of the Hun/Hob plotline.

Btw, CKD, I see your new signature and I must say, that was my favorite panel in issue #50 as well!

Well, perhaps I worded it a bit too harshly. It's all in self-defense on Raph's part, and it's him or them. But sure.

As for Hun/Hob... we shall see!

MikeandRaph87
10-10-2015, 11:17 AM
I see and I would do the same thing in such a situation its just not something I want the turtles forced into.

I was under the impression it had played out already. I did not expect it to carry over beyond #50 and thought with all this excitement I just forgot how it all played out. If that is the case it may not be until #53 we see it played out when Mike meets up with Hob and the gang.

DrSpengler
10-10-2015, 01:57 PM
Here's my full summary and review of TMNT #50 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/10/tmnt-idw-50.html)

Whew! Heck of a finale! While I think "Vengeance" as a whole felt a little bloated and the Don-Metalhead subplot was a bit underdeveloped, they really pulled it together for the ending.

Loved the pacing of this issue, as the flashbacks slowly dial the relationship between Yoshi and Saki back from their confrontation to their more innocent days. By the time the big fight is over, you actually sympathize with Splinter and feel maybe a little willing to let Saki redeem himself with an honorable death.

Great art and great craftsmanship all around. Now I can't wait for #100!

spookycookies
10-11-2015, 11:20 PM
I'm not really thinking this through so bare with me and/or correct me...

Perhaps the epilogue implies that Krang had a hand in the turtles creation, in order to see Saki defeated. Is it possible that Krang used the dna of the boys to convince the turtles they share some sort of past life with Yoshi's sons?

The resurrection concept has been mined in plenty of neat ways which I wouldn't want to go to waste. However, I am extremely tickled by the idea that the turtles and Splinter were never truly a family in Feudal Japan.

Then why would only Mikey know how to read in Japanese? Personally I do believe that the Turtles and Splinter have been reincarnated and it's likely that Shen is somehow involved with it. Her appearances in #30 and #45 haven't been linked to anything besides her just being a spirit trying to help out her family and I'm sure her involvement will be connected to some of the other mystic things at play with the Pantheon and the after life in Shredder's Micro.

The best part about TMNT is that we get this big blending of genres, street crime and space opera, ninjas and monsters and everything in between. I'm sure that Sci Fi and Fantasy can both co-exist in this book and it can always be a little bit of both.


Ok I'm back.. Man it was so hard waiting until Sunday to read this issue, but it was entirely worth it. I was thinking about what would most likely happen by the end of this issue: Shredder was of course a goner for sure, but I was wondering if maybe Splinter would in some way sacrifice himself and maybe both of them would die? I also considered that if Splinter won that Karai may offer him leadership of the foot and I'm glad that happened, I like the concept of the Foot actually being a good clan that just went sour under Saki's leadership. This will be an interesting new era for IDW.

I guess this solves the problem of where the Hamato's are going to live now that the Church was torn up by Stockman.

tommyborregas
10-12-2015, 12:24 AM
I find it very hard to commit to purchasing 18 variant covers to #50. Let's see that's an average of $30 a comic ~$540 for some mass produced prints. It's a joke for variants to even advertise 1000 copies total when there are ~30,000 copies to choose from. Now to mention Jetpack variants and they still have not had one TMNT be sold-out yet. I guess it took me to issue 50 to notice, as if #1 wasn't a hint of what's to come with 13 variants. Many of us consumers on this forum are on the same quest as I am to Pokemon this TMNT collection but damn it just feels way too much of an indie cash grab for me to be content with justifying my purchases. Yah yah, milestone, I get it. My milestone for you is 'outsource to china $3.99'. Lol but seriously folks, love all of the artwork.

shredder orokusaki
10-12-2015, 02:32 AM
I will return! I will not allow Splinter to turn the foot into a good organization!
NO ONE CAN DEFEAT THE SHREDDER!! This will not end likd this!!

Etsyturtle2
10-12-2015, 06:04 AM
I will return! I will not allow Splinter to turn the foot into a good organization!
NO ONE CAN DEFEAT THE SHREDDER!! This will not end likd this!!

You tell'em shredder!

spookycookies
10-12-2015, 07:27 AM
I find it very hard to commit to purchasing 18 variant covers to #50. Let's see that's an average of $30 a comic ~$540 for some mass produced prints. It's a joke for variants to even advertise 1000 copies total when there are ~30,000 copies to choose from. Now to mention Jetpack variants and they still have not had one TMNT be sold-out yet. I guess it took me to issue 50 to notice, as if #1 wasn't a hint of what's to come with 13 variants. Many of us consumers on this forum are on the same quest as I am to Pokemon this TMNT collection but damn it just feels way too much of an indie cash grab for me to be content with justifying my purchases. Yah yah, milestone, I get it. My milestone for you is 'outsource to china $3.99'. Lol but seriously folks, love all of the artwork.

Yeah I love collecting as many variants as I can but I stopped at 8 for this issue. The Jetpack one looks awful frankly, I don't see the appeal of it and the blind box one is a total joke.

I just grabbed what was coming out at my LCS and 3 RE's that I liked.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-12-2015, 08:17 AM
I will return! I will not allow Splinter to turn the foot into a good organization!
NO ONE CAN DEFEAT THE SHREDDER!! This will not end likd this!!

Dude, you dead. You can't even get ahead in life.

PangolinFeets
10-12-2015, 08:18 AM
I managed to get my mitts on the NYCC ones and whatever my LCS was able to hold for me. For a really good issue, or a landmark issue, I always think its good to get whatever you can. And that's the only reason I have a signed, graded #44 variant. :3

But frankly, the real hot item I'm glad I snagged is thiiiiis:
http://i.imgur.com/N2cXt9u.jpg

Metropoliskid41
10-12-2015, 08:52 AM
That print is awesome! Nice pick up!

The Happy One
10-12-2015, 10:33 AM
I think I'll just borrow that print for a second....or forever :lol: