PDA

View Full Version : NOT looking forward to batman/TMNT


Panda_Kahn_fan
11-04-2015, 07:06 AM
I know I'll probably get flamed for this, but... is anyone else NOT looking forward to the upcoming crossover with Batman? I know a lot of fans are excited, but I lost interest in bats a long time ago, and have no desire to see him and the TMNT team up. I also hate we're not getting a mini or microseries because of the crossover, and are stuck with the main series pushing the IDW-verse forward. I dunno, at least the ghostbusters x-over pushed the storyline forward, even if I didn't care for it. I dunno, am I the only one unexcited about this?

neatoman
11-04-2015, 07:26 AM
It's probably for the best that the story is completely non-canon, obviously Batman won't pop up ever again and the mini itself might get hard to find once it's out of print.

corvus
11-04-2015, 08:27 AM
I'm with you on this. Since #50 and #51 there's been so much going on. Another canon miniseries is needed or we're gonna have the pacing issues we had early on. One issue a month is slow. It took over a year for the turtles to actually meet Krang face to face even though he was in the first issue.

MrTrikey
11-04-2015, 08:48 AM
I suppose the main thing that's a bit sad is that the lack of hype can be felt from both sides. Most Batman fans I talk to either a) don't care or b) would rather not see Bats saddled with a franchise they think is beneath the Caped Crusader (due to TMNT's kiddy image).

I'll probably enjoy the read, but I still can't help but feel that they should've completed Eastman and Laird's old homage and had him team up with Daredevil instead! :D

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-04-2015, 09:09 AM
75% with you.

I've NEVER liked crossovers. Even when they're done well, a part of me resents the crossing of two separate stories/shows/books and forcing me to come reasonably up to speed on the other half. Plus most crossovers are terribly done...

Unless you're Usagi, I don't think it's ever been natural. Although Ghostbusters was pretty awesome.

Plus, we're gonna be down to one canon TMNT book for until... when, May? June?

Duke Nukem
11-04-2015, 09:30 AM
I agree on all points. I'm not much of a Batman fan and although I'll probably end up liking the crossover, I already resent it for slowing the main ongoing story down to a crawl.

spookycookies
11-04-2015, 11:09 AM
I do wish they would publish a micro series since DC appears to be handling this book entirely. What gives?

Unless there is some glaring contradiction in the series that makes it non canonical I am going to squeeze this book in somewhere in my IDW TMNT reading order. The writer said he knows exactly where this book will fit and I don't think he would just up and say that if he didn't mean it. As for the story never impacting the future and the turtles never mentioning it again that isn't enough for me to write a book out of existence.

I guess I'm on the fence. I'm looking forward to reading and collecting it, but I'm upset that IDW is slacking on publishing their own 2nd Turtle title each month for more than half a year.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-04-2015, 11:14 AM
I do wish they would publish a micro series since DC appears to be handling this book entirely. What gives?

Unless there is some glaring contradiction in the series that makes it non canonical I am going to squeeze this book in somewhere in my IDW TMNT reading order. The writer said he knows exactly where this book will fit and I don't think he would just up and say that if he didn't mean it. As for the story never impacting the future and the turtles never mentioning it again that isn't enough for me to write a book out of existence.

I guess I'm on the fence. I'm looking forward to reading and collecting it, but I'm upset that IDW is slacking on publishing their own 2nd Turtle title each month for more than half a year.

I don't think it's fair to say IDW is "slacking." They did, after all, negotiate a crossover deal with what is arguably (and financially) THE single most lucrative and recognized comic book character of all time.

But yeah, half a year of a non-canon crossover is personally galling. Although I can't help continuing to pair up each Turtle with each Robin...

Leo with Dick, but does Raph go with Jason or Damian? And does Tim go with Don or Mikey? (It's not happening, no Robins in this crossover... but still.)

CyberCubed
11-04-2015, 01:54 PM
I am very excited. TMNT teaming up with the legendary Batman is something I never expected to ever happen. Its like a childhood fantasy come true.

I bet all of you will change your tune once it comes out and you read it. Even if some of you aren't big Batman fans, (and I don't see why, Batman is the greatest superhero on the planet), you might think differently.

Joey Kamikaze
11-04-2015, 02:02 PM
Yeah. I mean, frankly? DC mostly sucks nowadays. Maybe I'm a bit biased because I lost interest in heroes in tights after junior high. I'm expecting a fairly bland, by-the-numbers book.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-04-2015, 02:06 PM
I am very excited. TMNT teaming up with the legendary Batman is something I never expected to ever happen. Its like a childhood fantasy come true.

I bet all of you will change your tune once it comes out and you read it. Even if some of you aren't big Batman fans, (and I don't see why, Batman is the greatest superhero on the planet), you might think differently.

Nope. I'll probably enjoy it, but I 100% stand by my "No Crossovers" policy.

Huge fan of Batman, huger fan of TMNT. Excited for the crossover due to the big publicity boost it'll give TMNT, but story-wise? Eh.

EDIT: Upon further thought, let me restate: I am 100% against crossovers done solely to boost the popularity of lagging secondary characters. I like the current MCU slate of movies (except Thor... looking at you, Norse boy), so I can't say I'm against crossovers 100%. I just think they're usually a trainwreck of continuity and characters.

CyberCubed
11-04-2015, 02:13 PM
Well for example I have no interest in Ghostbusters at all, yet I absolutely loved the Ghostbuster crossover. If I can like a crossover involving a franchise I have no interest in, then it says a lot.

Batman is obviously 100% more mainstream than Ghostbusters is, everyone has watched/read SOMETHING of Batman at some point in their lives, so its likely going to be more exciting.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-04-2015, 02:23 PM
Well for example I have no interest in Ghostbusters at all, yet I absolutely loved the Ghostbuster crossover. If I can like a crossover involving a franchise I have no interest in, then it says a lot.

Batman is obviously 100% more mainstream than Ghostbusters is, everyone has watched/read SOMETHING of Batman at some point in their lives, so its likely going to be more exciting.

This is very true; after reading the Ghostbusters/TMNT crossover, I went and devoured the entirety of IDW's Ghostbusters series. Love it, good stuff.

But that story was canon for both the Turtles AND the Ghostbusters. Whereas, this story will be non-canon for both parties involved. It could be fun, and it will boost sales for TMNT. But in terms of personal worth? I'd rather have another Mutanimals mini-series.

But hey. We can ALL agree this crossover will be FAR SUPERIOR to the horror that was Casey & April. :tlol:

CyberCubed
11-04-2015, 02:29 PM
BTW, who is the writer doing the Batman crossover? Is his other work generally well received? I wonder if he's generally considered a good writer.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-04-2015, 02:35 PM
BTW, who is the writer doing the Batman crossover? Is his other work generally well received? I wonder if he's generally considered a good writer.

James Tynion IV; he wrote a badass little series in Gotham City called "Talon", a spinoff from the "Court of Owls" story arc. He's good stuff.

Etsyturtle2
11-04-2015, 02:42 PM
If this has better writing than gokus posts, I'm in.
Edit: not really excited for this. Tmnt and marvel is enough for me.

spookycookies
11-04-2015, 05:26 PM
James Tynion IV; he wrote a badass little series in Gotham City called "Talon", a spinoff from the "Court of Owls" story arc. He's good stuff.

Yeah I think he's a good pick to do this. The artist is pretty great too I can't wait to see him do interiors after looking at the covers we've gotten so far.

AquaParade
11-04-2015, 10:25 PM
I will definitely check it out. I love all these characters, but crossovers in general don't really excite me based purely on premise. If it's a well made book, I am all in.

Leo656
11-04-2015, 11:11 PM
Bunch'a f***in' Grinches in here, man.

CyberCubed
11-04-2015, 11:27 PM
Well to be fair complaining about something that hasn't even come out yet is kinda ridiculous. If after the crossover releases and the story really is bad or its a disappointment, then its understandable.

I have high hopes.

Powder
11-04-2015, 11:29 PM
Bunch'a f***in' Grinches in here, man.

I've not seen literally anyone more cynical about this particular crossover than you, though.

Well to be fair complaining about something that hasn't even come out yet is kinda ridiculous.

This is satire, right? Need I direct you to the Platinum Dunes section, Mr. Crusader Of The Nostrils? :tlol:

Panda_Kahn_fan
11-05-2015, 12:04 AM
Bunch'a f***in' Grinches in here, man.

Hey, I didn't day I hated it or didn't want it to come out- this is just the first piece of IDW-era TMNT original material I'm not interested in. All I said was I'm not excited for this story, I never said anything negative about it as a work.

Jephael
11-05-2015, 05:57 AM
I kinda wish it was more a cross-over with the JLA, or at the very least include Superman.

Jester
11-05-2015, 06:11 AM
Non-conon crossover with the Mirage Turtles or bust.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-05-2015, 09:13 AM
Non-conon crossover with the Mirage Turtles or bust.

Would that be Volume 1 TMNT or Volume 4 TMNT? :tlol:

CyberCubed
11-05-2015, 12:15 PM
I can't believe so many people feel this way about the legendary Batman. After seeing the 1989 movie and Batman: TAS a kid, Batman was a huge part of my childhood after TMNT.

I always said that if the TMNT franchise never existed and was never created, I'd probably be some huge Batman fan on some Batman website right now. Either that or I'd be more of a Star Wars fan. But since TMNT is my #1 franchise all the others got pushed to secondary.

I mixed my Batman toys with my TMNT figures when I was a kid. I had Shredder and Joker team up against the Turtles. My 10 year old boy self always dreamed of seeing Batman and the Turtles meet.

This is 30 years in the making! My 10 year old self would be jumping for joy. Plus our little TMNT franchise is finally getting to hang out with the "big boys." We've done it, it feels like TMNT finally made it. *breaks open champagne bottle*

Metalhead 2.0
11-05-2015, 12:41 PM
I don't think it's fair to say IDW is "slacking." They did, after all, negotiate a crossover deal with what is arguably (and financially) THE single most lucrative and recognized comic book character of all time.

But yeah, half a year of a non-canon crossover is personally galling. Although I can't help continuing to pair up each Turtle with each Robin...

Leo with Dick, but does Raph go with Jason or Damian? And does Tim go with Don or Mikey? (It's not happening, no Robins in this crossover... but still.)

If you're talking about Jason as Robin then Raph goes with Damian, but if you're talking about Jason as RedHood/Arkham Knight then Raph goes with Jason. Don goes with Tim, Mikey goes with Carrie Kelley.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-05-2015, 12:47 PM
If you're talking about Jason as Robin then Raph goes with Damian, but if you're talking about Jason as RedHood/Arkham Knight then Raph goes with Jason. Don goes with Tim, Mikey goes with Carrie Kelley.

I was thinking Red Hood... Damian's a killer, but he's not ANGRY like Jason is. But really, Raph could go well with either Damian or Jason.

Yeah, Mikey would go pretty well with Carrie or maybe Stephanie Brown, too.

Metalhead 2.0
11-05-2015, 01:33 PM
I was thinking Red Hood... Damian's a killer, but he's not ANGRY like Jason is. But really, Raph could go well with either Damian or Jason.

Yeah, Mikey would go pretty well with Carrie or maybe Stephanie Brown, too.

Yeah, Jason wasn't that angry until AFTER he came back, so then I could see the pairing with Red Hood.

I thought about Stephanie, but didn't want to project her torture-death onto little Mikey.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-05-2015, 01:52 PM
Yeah, Jason wasn't that angry until AFTER he came back, so then I could see the pairing with Red Hood.

I thought about Stephanie, but didn't want to project her torture-death onto little Mikey.

Yeah, but Stephanie as Batgirl was vivacious and fun-loving... very Mikey. :twink:

Metalhead 2.0
11-05-2015, 02:23 PM
Yeah, but Stephanie as Batgirl was vivacious and fun-loving... very Mikey. :twink:

So I guess this would be our order of hierarchy:

Henri Ducard / Master Masato
Batman / Hamato Yoshi
Leonardo / Nightwing
Raphael / Red Hood
Donatello / Red Robin
Michelangelo / Batgirl

?????

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-05-2015, 02:26 PM
Don't forget:

Batcow/Klunk :tlol:

Metalhead 2.0
11-05-2015, 03:12 PM
Don't forget:

Batcow/Klunk :tlol:

Lol.

In the New 52 there are supposedly six people who trained Bruce to be Batman one of those is Henri Ducard so if Henri is to Batman as Masato is to Splinter and Splinter and Shredder trained as brothers under Masato then we would have to suppose that Shredder would fulfill the role of Morgan Ducard aka NoBody and by extension Karai would be Nobody II, Morgan's daughter Maya.

Now of the six to train Bruce, at the time I was reading there was one that was never revealed, but most people assumed it was Ra's Al Ghul (contrary to what the Nolanverse would have you believe, Henri Ducard and Ra's Al Ghul are NOT the same person). Some of you probably know better than I do if that was ever revealed or not, but if you follow that logic and sub Ra's Al Ghul in as Masato then that would lead to Shredder being Talia? And by extension make Karai Damian? Which leads back to the whole Nick-verse of is Karai/Damian truly Splinter/Batman's daughter/son or is he/she Talia/Shredder's son/daughter?

http://bashoh.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/hypnotic-animated-gifs-03.gif

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-05-2015, 05:26 PM
Lol.

In the New 52 there are supposedly six people who trained Bruce to be Batman one of those is Henri Ducard so if Henri is to Batman as Masato is to Splinter and Splinter and Shredder trained as brothers under Masato then we would have to suppose that Shredder would fulfill the role of Morgan Ducard aka NoBody and by extension Karai would be Nobody II, Morgan's daughter Maya.

Now of the six to train Bruce, at the time I was reading there was one that was never revealed, but most people assumed it was Ra's Al Ghul (contrary to what the Nolanverse would have you believe, Henri Ducard and Ra's Al Ghul are NOT the same person). Some of you probably know better than I do if that was ever revealed or not, but if you follow that logic and sub Ra's Al Ghul in as Masato then that would lead to Shredder being Talia? And by extension make Karai Damian? Which leads back to the whole Nick-verse of is Karai/Damian truly Splinter/Batman's daughter/son or is he/she Talia/Shredder's son/daughter?

...

I think you broke my brain, bro. :tlol:

Coola Yagami
11-05-2015, 10:10 PM
Y'all crazy. This is BATMAN we're talking about. It's high time the Turtles rubbed elbows with the big leagues.

For the one that mentioned Usagi, while those crossovers are fun... I have to admit, I know nothing of Usagi, his story or his supporting cast... so for me, and I'm sure 99% of TMNT fans, the story is very one-sided towards the Turtles. For the most of us was the Turtles... and some random samurai bunny. IMO crossovers work best when you're familiar with both parties.... and I'm sure most of us here know about the Turtles, and who doesn't know about Batman, Robin, the Joker, Gotham City and so forth? This is gonna be awesome!

CyberCubed
11-05-2015, 10:11 PM
Y'all crazy. This is BATMAN we're talking about. It's high time the Turtles rubbed elbows with the big leagues.

Damn straight, this is what I'm talking about. It's history in the making.

myconius
11-05-2015, 11:21 PM
i'm with CyberCubed on this!
Batman is ####ing AMAZING!!!! and to see the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles team up with the Dark Knight is 100% PURE AWESOME SAUCE!!!!!!
:tthumbsu::tthumbsu::tthumbsu::tthumbsu::tthumbsu:
there aren't enough thumbs for this crossover!! :D

cannon, non-cannon .... it doesn't matter!
this is a HUGE deal for TMNT!

at first i really wanted this to be an IDW publication, but i'm glad it'll be DC.
just because it'll hopefully attract some DC readers to look into the IDW TMNT ongoing series?

either way, i myself am very excited for this! :D

jackieson97
11-06-2015, 12:38 AM
I suppose the problem that I have with the crossover isn't the individual characters themselves, but their respective themes. Batman has that darker, more cynical vibe whereas the turtles don't (with the exception of the most recent story line). Although there can be some grim times in IDW, I would say the overall tone is not nearly as heavy and burdensome as Batman which, in my mind, causes concern for incompatibility. Also, I can't help but think that any interaction between the turtles and Batman will inevitably result in some sort of condescension.

To me it would have made so much more sense to have a crossover with a different superhero. For instance, Spider-Man would have made a lot of sense to me. He's young, witty, fun-seeking, hopeful, and from New York. The characters are more similar right off the bat and the overall mood/tone of Spider-man are more in line with that of the IDW series.

My hesitations aside, I'll definitely still buy the series.

Powder
11-06-2015, 01:01 AM
The tone is pretty comparible to me. Moreso in Mirage, for sure, but for all it's color & spark, IDW's turtleverse has a fairly harsh reality all the same. I think it's just that it gets a bit obscured by the somewhat toyetic nature of having such a large mutant rogues gallery.

myconius
11-06-2015, 08:12 AM
ALL excellent points!

after all Mirage has had the Turtles kill Shredder in most gruesome ways.
they've written plenty of heart wrenching stories like 'Old Times', or the final fate of Mikey's cat Klunk.

IDW TMNT has never had any shortage of darkness or tragedy either.
the Flashbacks from issue #5 were plenty heartbreaking,
as were the recent events of issue #44 with Bebop, Rocksteady and Donatello.

but the death and violence of the series is usually balanced out in lighthearted moments, or nice character moments between the brothers and/or Splinter.

Batman can be overly Dark and Morbid (depending on who's writing him.)
there is levity to be found in his relations with Alfred, Nightwing and Robin (take your pick of Robin)

Grant Morrison and Peter Tomasi both add the right touch of humanity to the character.
but there are plenty of Batman writers (i won't mention names) that are just going out of the way to depress people.

anyway, i could go on and on.....

both TMNT and Batman are two of my favorite comic characters,
and i've been wanting this cross over for a LONNNG LONG time!!!
to see them join forces for me personally is a dream come true!!

would be truly amazing to see Kevin Eastman and Frank Miller team up to give us this cross over, but i'm just happy to see it finally happen! :D

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-06-2015, 08:20 AM
ALL excellent points!

after all Mirage has had the Turtles kill Shredder in most gruesome ways.
they've written plenty of heart wrenching stories like 'Old Times', or the final fate of Mikey's cat Klunk.

IDW TMNT has never had any shortage of darkness or tragedy either.
the Flashbacks from issue #5 were plenty heartbreaking,
as were the recent events of issue #44 with Bebop, Rocksteady and Donatello.

but the death and violence of the series is usually balanced out in lighthearted moments, or nice character moments between the brothers and/or Splinter.

Batman can be overly Dark and Morbid (depending on who's writing him.)
there is levity to be found in his relations with Alfred, Nightwing and Robin (take your pick of Robin)

Grant Morrison and Peter Tomasi both add the right touch of humanity to the character.
but there are plenty of Batman writers (i won't mention names) that are just going out of the way to depress people.

anyway, i could go on and on.....

both TMNT and Batman are two of my favorite comic characters,
and i've been wanting this cross over for a LONNNG LONG time!!!
to see them join forces for me personally is a dream come true!!

would be truly amazing to see Kevin Eastman and Frank Miller team up to give us this cross over, but i'm just happy to see it finally happen! :D

Took you seriously until "Kevin Eastman and Frank Miller team up"... :tlol:

Metalhead 2.0
11-06-2015, 08:53 AM
Took you seriously until "Kevin Eastman and Frank Miller team up"... :tlol:

Ugh, what a clusterf*ck that would be, I cringe at the thought.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-06-2015, 08:55 AM
Ugh, what a clusterf*ck that would be, I cringe at the thought.

With all the boobs, bullets, and blood, I don't think we'd get more than 2 or 3 panels' worth of the Dark Knight and the Turtles. :tlol:

Metalhead 2.0
11-06-2015, 09:01 AM
With all the boobs, bullets, and blood, I don't think we'd get more than 2 or 3 panels' worth of the Dark Knight and the Turtles. :tlol:

May as well let Michael Bay and Joel Schumacher write it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-06-2015, 09:05 AM
May as well let Michael Bay and Joel Schumacher write it.

ROFL. They'd be perfect to adapt the miniseries to film. #bringbackthebatnipples #tmntcreditcard

myconius
11-06-2015, 09:56 AM
Took you seriously until "Kevin Eastman and Frank Miller team up"... :tlol:


sorry, i keep forgetting that the Frank Miller that wrote Batman: Year One and Dark Knight Returns is LONG gone replaced by one of the pod people.

but i think most people online don't like to have actual serious conversations.
the only way to get most people's attention is when they are poking fun at something or saying what they don't like.

i mean, look at this topic's header?

'NOT looking forward to...'

it's all just negativity.

and people say that Batman is too dark????

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-06-2015, 10:04 AM
sorry, i keep forgetting that the Frank Miller that wrote Batman: Year One and Dark Knight Returns is LONG gone replaced by one of the pod people.

but i think most people online don't like to have actual serious conversations.
the only way to get most people's attention is when they are poking fun at something or saying what they don't like.

i mean, look at this topic's header?

'NOT looking forward to...'

it's all just negativity.

and people say that Batman is too dark????

Well, it is negative but it's also starting a conversation. Some of us WOULD prefer to not have this crossover, even though we understand it makes astounding business sense and is a great public coup.

Nobody's arguing that crossovers are great publicity, this crossover in particular is crossover GOLD for IDW and the TMNT, and that our favorite characters are gonna get a jump in status.

Metalhead 2.0
11-06-2015, 11:31 AM
sorry, i keep forgetting that the Frank Miller that wrote Batman: Year One and Dark Knight Returns is LONG gone replaced by one of the pod people.

but i think most people online don't like to have actual serious conversations.
the only way to get most people's attention is when they are poking fun at something or saying what they don't like.

i mean, look at this topic's header?

'NOT looking forward to...'

it's all just negativity.

and people say that Batman is too dark????


Welcome to the Internet.

As Batman himself said "The Internet is a communication tool used the world over where people can come together to bitch about movies and share pornography with one another."

I would propose that that extends beyond just movies and includes all forms of entertainment, in this case comics.

BUT I for one, am actually looking forward to this crossover regardless of whether it is canon or not and despite it decelerating the main storyline and I hope it is as entertaining as it potentially could be.

myconius
11-06-2015, 06:09 PM
Welcome to the Internet.

As Batman himself said "The Internet is a communication tool used the world over where people can come together to bitch about movies and share pornography with one another."

I would propose that that extends beyond just movies and includes all forms of entertainment, in this case comics.

BUT I for one, am actually looking forward to this crossover regardless of whether it is canon or not and despite it decelerating the main storyline and I hope it is as entertaining as it potentially could be.

that's true! i forgot Batman had said that! :D

IF this is actually supposed to be canon it'll have to be some time before 'Attack on the Technodrome' since Shredder is alive, and Donatello isn't in Metalhead.

but i kind of hope 'Batman/TMNT' isn't canon. since DC is writing, drawing and publishing the cross-over. there's always the possibility that IDW could publish a mini-series that does tie into the ongoing series.

weren't the 'TMNT/Ghostbusters' and 'Turtles in time' mini-series pretty close to one another?

Leo656
11-06-2015, 09:50 PM
I've not seen literally anyone more cynical about this particular crossover than you, though.


Only insofar as, some people are kinda thinking/hoping it's gonna be a huge deal with lasting repercussions, and it's not going to be. It's gonna be a fun one-and-done and it's never going to be referenced again in-story on either side. Which is fine.

People need their daily dose of reality. Especially nerds. Dispensing that reality is kind of my thing; you know that.

It doesn't mean the book's not worth looking forward to. It's probably going to be pretty good. Some folks are just already projecting way too much relevance into it. It'll probably be good, but it's not gonna count for much. Which should be fine regardless.

CyberCubed
11-06-2015, 09:56 PM
I'll probably be in tears as I read it. History in the making.

PangolinFeets
11-06-2015, 10:00 PM
I'm getting this crossover just in time for my birthday sooo....

http://i752.photobucket.com/albums/xx164/casaluna298/excited2.gif

Commenter 42
11-06-2015, 10:13 PM
People need their daily dose of reality. Especially nerds. Dispensing that reality is kind of my thing; you know that.


Translation: everyones entitled to my opinion.

Leo656
11-06-2015, 10:34 PM
Well when you're right about everything that's a privilege you earn, my son.

I'm not sure how the "opinions" thing actually applies in this case specifically, though. It's a foregone conclusion it's never going to be mentioned again once it's complete. That's not an opinion, that's how DC handles cross-overs. "Every character involved always magically forgets it ever happened." That's an actual longstanding DC rule regarding inter-company cross-overs. You can look it up if you don't believe me. People were asking whether anything in the mini-series will be canon; I explained why it won't be. "Everyone Forgets/It Never Really Happened" is the rule. I didn't f***ing write it.

Actually, pretty much nothing I say is "opinions" so I don't know what you're even getting at. Opinions are for people who don't care about Facts. That's why I generally don't place much stock in peoples' opinions and am so openly dismissive of them; everyone has one but they sure don't weigh much. Truth, facts, not "opinions" and philosophy. No time for that. The people who constantly crow about "opinions" are generally the people I disdain the most. You know that. Everyone knows that. C'mon.

Commenter 42
11-06-2015, 10:46 PM
Right. You're still posing an opinion, nothing more. You may, at some point, be proven correct, but at the moment you're stating an opinion.

That wasn't really my point, though. You know that, c'mon, everyone knows that. :lol:

Joey Kamikaze
11-06-2015, 11:03 PM
I like the idea of good crossovers that have lasting repercussions. I loved the Ghostbusters crossover, but of course that was an intra-IDW story that involved creators who knew both properties, and it set up future TMNT stories (and has already been referenced in the main book). And both licenses fit together on multiple levels: 80's classics, take place in New York, feature a hodge-podge cast of different personalities taking on weird sci-fi/fantasy opponents, etc.

If I seem kinda humbuggy about this crossover, it's mostly because DC is responsible for it. If this was an IDW-run project, things might be different, but I have zero confidence in modern DC. Beyond that, IMO the best Batman stories are the ones that eschew any heavy sci-fi or fantasy elements, and his stories have a darker feel to them. I could see maybe the Mirage turtles fitting with Batman, though even then the Mirage turtles could get pretty goofy. I'm expecting this to be the weirdest feeling TMNT crossover since the time they met Archie.

(Though a crossover with Afterlife With Archie? Then we might be talking.)

PangolinFeets
11-06-2015, 11:21 PM
And don't forget that Harold totally brought up the Ghostbusters again after the crossover. >.>

Leo656
11-06-2015, 11:32 PM
Right. You're still posing an opinion, nothing more. You may, at some point, be proven correct, but at the moment you're stating an opinion.

That wasn't really my point, though. You know that, c'mon, everyone knows that. :lol:

"Speculation", "educated guess based on historical precedent"... either would fit the blank better than "opinion", wouldn't it? It's totally not the right word for what you're getting at. Even "supposition" would fit better. As in, "I don't suppose they're going to." I'm saying what's probably going to happen based on what always happens, not just subjectively expressing how I feel.

Nah, "opinion" doesn't fit the usage. It's clumsy. An example of Opinion would be, "Frank Miller is just about the sh*ttiest Batman writer of all time." Which is both an opinion AND a fact, which on a Triple Word Score will get you Switzerland.

So huh.

Commenter 42
11-06-2015, 11:52 PM
Nope.

10char

Leo656
11-06-2015, 11:56 PM
You must be Mickey Mouse, kid, because you're f*ckin' Goofy.

Commenter 42
11-07-2015, 12:22 AM
Wait, I'm Goofy?

https://scontent-lga3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xat1/v/t1.0-9/11218857_713325582100437_3162394175929885144_n.jpg ?oh=ddbe0c291cbd438e4c11ae513d22893a&oe=56B19E9E


You really don't see it, do you. :ohwell:

Anyway, I'm done. I tried too many times to make peace.


On topic:
It would be nice to see what IDW would do with the idea instead.

Leo656
11-07-2015, 12:29 AM
I imagine they don't have Halloween on your planet. More's the pity.

Commenter 42
11-07-2015, 12:40 AM
Can't help yourself? I said I'm done. This is the kind of crap that everyone hates. It's over.

Leo656
11-07-2015, 12:55 AM
You followed me into the thread to jump my sh*t for reasons known only to you, and I replied. I don't even know what the f***ing rest of it has to do with anything, other than I didn't start it. So I don't even know what you're f***ing angry about, frankly, because if anyone has reason to be angry I'm not sure why it would be you. It sure seemed like you initially wanted my attention but weren't happy at all when you got it.

So yeah, pretty goddamn confused. But whatever.

Commenter 42
11-07-2015, 01:52 AM
I was referring to the thread. You were saying this whole thing doesn't matter, because you think it's unimportant. You do that all the time. Then you wanted to argue semantics. I simply said "nope", as in "nope, not gonna go there", then you called me a goof.

Man, get it together. You're cracking up a bit. Ease off the caffeine.

Leo656
11-07-2015, 02:27 AM
I didn't mean it won't matter as in it won't be worth reading or enjoying or that the project itself is "unimportant", it's just most likely not going to have long-term story repercussions. People like Cubed who are hoping it's going to be some essential expansion to IDW TMNT canon are going to be very sad when they don't get their way if they expect too much. That's all. The odds of it ever being mentioned again in-story are infinitesimally small and I'm not an asshole for pointing that out. Sure, it's "just" speculative, but it's also a statistical certainty! Why so angry about it? You do it too, yourself, after all. You do plenty of speculating and forecasting. And that's fine; that's the game we play here. For some reason, though, I'm being put on the defensive for doing it. That doesn't work for me.

More than anything I was just trying to keep Cubed's head out of the clouds so he doesn't float away. He's essential to this place but he needs a good head-check every now and again. He's a dreamer, and sure that's poetic and beautiful but I have very little patience for it because he whines long and loud when he doesn't get his way. Sometimes even when he does. If we can curb his enthusiasm early, I think it's to everyone's benefit.

I was sitting on that line about "f***ing Goofy" for a while and you just happened to be the one who got hit with it. I read "Nope" as a dismissive "Nope, you're wrong". Fine, I take it back. It was originally "Bugs Bunny" and "f***ing Daffy" anyway, feel free to swap that back in if you find it funnier. I didn't know if "daffy" was still a thing people called each other. Clearly, my clever wordplay is hopelessly lost on this room. Figures.

And once more, I'm fine. As far as you and I are concerned, all that's going on is that now that I've limited myself to sh*tting on the TMNT movies once or twice a week, we're discovering how shockingly little in common we actually have aside from that. It happens. But I'm no different than I've always been, aside from the fact that I've probably always been way too nice to everyone until very recently and kind of don't feel like it anymore because it's pointless. But I don't know why that would bother you. I'm not coming at you with it.

And I nailed "infinitesimally" on the first try without Google. F*** all y'all, my game's never been tighter. Holla.

Joey Kamikaze
11-07-2015, 03:15 AM
http://i.giphy.com/GjYjLvGErsggg.gif

Seriously, this is entertaining as hell because I'm envisioning you both as your avatars so it's a dog in sunglasses arguing with some roided out professional wrestler.

Commenter 42
11-07-2015, 03:50 AM
http://i.giphy.com/GjYjLvGErsggg.gif

Seriously, this is entertaining as hell because I'm envisioning you both as your avatars so it's a dog in sunglasses arguing with some roided out professional wrestler.

Awesome! and, you're welcome?


all that's going on is that now that I've limited myself to sh*tting on the TMNT movies once or twice a week, we're discovering how shockingly little in common we actually have aside from that.

Not true. I agree with you almost 90% of the time, actually. We have 1 big divide. I even made the BVS all nice an cozy with nice news stories for you to have back. I don't want to play with it anymore. That tree house is all yours. Nobody wanted to stay and party once you left. Even Cubed vanished....even cubed.

I'm just trying to make nice.

http://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/f0/b8/33/f0b833cacbff03d2724e127c94a2ea59.jpg

also

Why so angry about it? You do it too, yourself, after all. You do plenty of speculating and forecasting. And that's fine; that's the game we play here. For some reason, though, I'm being put on the defensive for doing it. That doesn't work for me.
^ that was my point, all along.....all...a....lonnnnnnhgggggggdggdsgsgshhsx bcbschscewjcxnsbcsjdbshdhsbchjdjcnjbahbchbcjcj.... ooonnngg."

now....

Rub my belly.

http://images.shibashake.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/7/files/2010/03/IMG_1911-520x390.jpg

Leo656
11-07-2015, 04:11 AM
We disagree a lot more than you think but that's fine. It's nice to know you don't keep that close of score.

Nothing new by the way and it doesn't bother me. If you take a poll, you'll find most of my friends here are people I have nothing in common with at all. Yet, life finds a way. Amazing, inspiring, puzzling, and occasionally, it makes me hungry.

But yeah, it's fine. Everything's fine.

Dogz.

Commenter 42
11-07-2015, 04:16 AM
We disagree a lot more than you think but that's fine. It's nice to know you don't keep that close of score.

Nothing new by the way and it doesn't bother me. If you take a poll, you'll find most of my friends here are people I have nothing in common with at all. Yet, life finds a way. Amazing, inspiring, puzzling, and occasionally, it makes me hungry.

But yeah, it's fine. Everything's fine.

Dogz.

This belly rub feels more like a head lock...

http://stream1.gifsoup.com/view2/1557458/call-him-george-o.gif

Leo656
11-07-2015, 04:20 AM
I don't have a soft side! That's as fuzzy as I get!

I'm Irish damn it. "F*ck You" is "Hello". Nobody gets it!

Shark_Blade
11-07-2015, 06:20 AM
HOW DARE YOU HATE ON BATMAN? AND WHEN TMNT IS FINALLY HAVING A MILESTONE WORTHY CROSSOVER EVEN?

how dare you. How ****ing dare you?

Nah, it's your opinion. I'm pretty excited tbh. :D

Coola Yagami
11-07-2015, 12:34 PM
Shark Blade brings up a good point. The fandom is never happy, no matter what.

When will the TMNT finally stop being saddled with obscure characters like Flaming Carrot and Savage Dragon and finally make it to the big leagues????

They're finally being paired off with the Dark Knight himself, probably one of the most popular comic book characters ever other than Superman and Spider-Man..... and fans are still complaining.

It never really does end....

CyberCubed
11-07-2015, 12:43 PM
This thread really needs to be locked.

Coola Yagami
11-07-2015, 12:45 PM
This thread really needs to be locked.

D'awwwwww there he goes with that witty catchphrase again.

*cues Cybercubed theme music and the APPLAUSE sign flashes for the live studio audience*

CyberCubed
11-07-2015, 12:46 PM
This thread is just bad. We still have the other thread to discuss this crossover in.

This thread is such a debbie downer. People are being negative nancies and such sourpuss. Its embarrassing to read.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-07-2015, 01:47 PM
OMFG, do we have to let Commentator42 derail every thread now by going after Leo656? Did we learn nothing from the Batman V Superman thread? For fvck's sake.

Panda_Kahn_fan
11-07-2015, 01:53 PM
Given how popular and high-profile Batman is, this crossover is one of the best things to happen to the TMNT. It's just not something I intend to be picking up.

Duke Nukem
11-07-2015, 04:40 PM
I don't see how Batman's popularity is really such a positive thing for us, though. TMNT are popular enough on their own that anyone would have at least heard of them (as opposed to Flaming Carrot and Usagi Yojimbo, neither of which I'd have ever heard if not for TMNT). So, I doubt this crossover will bring in any new comic readers.

GoldMutant
11-07-2015, 07:21 PM
OMFG, do we have to let Commentator42 derail every thread now by going after Leo656? Did we learn nothing from the Batman V Superman thread? For fvck's sake.

Preach to the choir of angels!

Maybe one day I can pick up the IDW comics, but we're talking a beloved superhero combined with the reptiles themselves, what's not to love. Maybe me on thinking this, but I personally feel the TMNT might benefit from crossing with Marvel next time, especially with either the X-Men or the obvious Spider-Man.

slingtheory
11-07-2015, 07:30 PM
I for one am pretty excited about this happening. Yeah it sucks that there won't be any new mini's for the length of its run but man its two of my favorite properties coming to together for the first time. Some of my greatest childhood heros teaming up to fight to fight side by side. As far as comic book characters go I've got three loves. The turtles, the bat family and and spiderman. If only they found a way the fit the ol' web head in there this would hit the trifecta for me. My 8 year old self would explode from the awesomeness

MikeandRaph87
11-07-2015, 08:51 PM
I for one am pretty excited about this happening. Yeah it sucks that there won't be any new mini's for the length of its run but man its two of my favorite properties coming to together for the first time. Some of my greatest childhood heros teaming up to fight to fight side by side. As far as comic book characters go I've got three loves. The turtles, the bat family and and spiderman. If only they found a way the fit the ol' web head in there this would hit the trifecta for me. My 8 year old self would explode from the awesomeness

Those are mine too. TMNT, Batman, Robin, Batgirl, and Spider-Man. I cannot help it, but am very cautious about how good a childhood team up can end up. As a 90's kid TMNT was my favorite and MMPR was my number two. It actually did happen, but it was a huge disappointment since it was not the Power Rangers just replacements of replacements and Venus was involved too. Hope this will live up to its potential.

Commenter 42
11-07-2015, 11:24 PM
OMFG, do we have to let Commentator42 derail every thread now by going after Leo656? Did we learn nothing from the Batman V Superman thread? For fvck's sake.

You with the stupid sandwich comments and flat jokes, have something to say?
Don't start dude. You don't have the reach to punch up this high.

Put me on ignore like you promised, m'kay?

Leo656
11-08-2015, 01:30 AM
Fight nice, kids. C'mon.

Someone said some folks are bummed there won't be any other TMNT mini-series coming out while they're doing the Batman/TMNT cross-over. Boy, people are spoiled nowadays; you already had like 87 side minis, haven't you (it's actually part of why I can't/haven't gotten into picking up the IDW books, way too much stuff to pick up now)? I mean I haven't collected too many comics in like 5 years, but is that the new standard, you don't just get a main book, you have to have a never-ending stream of side-minis, too? (Ahem) "Back in my day", that was called "gouging", and if a story wasn't strong enough for the main book it was considered extraneous. I'unno, people are never satisfied.

Anyways, you'll live with "just" the ongoing series for a little while. You're spoiled enough as it is. I haven't picked up anything past issue 10 but I'll probably pick this up, mostly because it's not guaranteed to get a TPB or a reissue anytime soon and I'd hate to have to track it down later in case they don't.

AquaParade
11-08-2015, 09:24 AM
Fight nice, kids. C'mon.

Someone said some folks are bummed there won't be any other TMNT mini-series coming out while they're doing the Batman/TMNT cross-over. Boy, people are spoiled nowadays; you already had like 87 side minis, haven't you (it's actually part of why I can't/haven't gotten into picking up the IDW books, way too much stuff to pick up now)? I mean I haven't collected too many comics in like 5 years, but is that the new standard, you don't just get a main book, you have to have a never-ending stream of side-minis, too? (Ahem) "Back in my day", that was called "gouging", and if a story wasn't strong enough for the main book it was considered extraneous. I'unno, people are never satisfied.

Anyways, you'll live with "just" the ongoing series for a little while. You're spoiled enough as it is. I haven't picked up anything past issue 10 but I'll probably pick this up, mostly because it's not guaranteed to get a TPB or a reissue anytime soon and I'd hate to have to track it down later in case they don't.

It looks tacky when calling people spoiled who would like to purchase another mini series soon. No one is berating, bitching, or hoping to have it for free. It's a product they would like to purchase. Spoiled isn't the right word.

It's just a gross word to throw around at people when no one really knows who is more spoiled outside of this little forum. Sounds judgemental and ignorant.

Commenter 42
11-08-2015, 02:21 PM
It looks tacky when calling people spoiled who would like to purchase another mini series soon. No one is berating, bitching, or hoping to have it for free. It's a product they would like to purchase. Spoiled isn't the right word.

It's just a gross word to throw around at people when no one really knows who is more spoiled outside of this little forum. Sounds judgemental and ignorant.

Uh, I really don't think that was the intent in the post. He's saying, there was a time, not that long ago, where fans would expect more from the main series, because lot's of added books were looked upon as extra expenses to the fans, akin to foil covers etc, just another ay to prop up dwindling sales.

It's a point of view, not mis-use. We are spoiled, in that, there is an abundance of stuff more than one could possibly need.

If spoiled becomes the new "derogatory" word to be forced out of use by the PC police, you all really are spoiled.

Gunstar_Red
11-08-2015, 04:01 PM
I'm also one who isn't excited. I wasn't excited about the Ghostbusters crossover and I'm a huge fan of the boys in gray (the movies and cartoon, not much on the comics). Crossovers are often disappointing mainly because either both sides of the crossover are writen with cursory knowledge or favorably writing for one side.

I'm also not a fan of official noncanon. I mean, what's fanficion for then? ^^;

Leo656
11-08-2015, 05:52 PM
Uh, I really don't think that was the intent in the post. He's saying, there was a time, not that long ago, where fans would expect more from the main series, because lot's of added books were looked upon as extra expenses to the fans, akin to foil covers etc, just another ay to prop up dwindling sales.

It's a point of view, not mis-use. We are spoiled, in that, there is an abundance of stuff more than one could possibly need.

If spoiled becomes the new "derogatory" word to be forced out of use by the PC police, you all really are spoiled.

Gets it. :)

Plus, I mean, I'm old enough to have lived through several periods where there were NO TMNT books coming out, and now some people are sad that only like two will be out for a couple months instead of 3 or 4 or whatever. It's like, you'll live.

Like my man said, everyone's drowning in TMNT product right now, so having the Batman book take precedent for a brief time won't hurt anybody.

CyberCubed
11-08-2015, 07:16 PM
There's not much TMNT releases not counting re-releases of old Mirage books.

There's the IDW main ongoing, the special/mini companion, and then the Nick animated comic based on the cartoon. That's it.

Leo656
11-08-2015, 07:19 PM
That's plenty.

CyberCubed
11-08-2015, 07:21 PM
Its pretty much the same we had under Mirage. Volume 4, Tales of the TMNT, and the occasional bonus comic based on the 2k3 series, the 4th movie, or just an extra Mirage special.

Leo656
11-08-2015, 07:41 PM
Which is still plenty.

Superman fans have had zero books to read since 2011. You're fine.

Joey Kamikaze
11-08-2015, 09:33 PM
Which is still plenty.

Superman fans have had zero books to read since 2011. You're fine.

Do Superman, Action Comics, Batman/Superman, Superman/Wonder Woman and Lois & Clark all not count for some reason?

I mean, I'm not reading the Nick book or the reprints, which means there's only one TMNT book going that I care about, but the others still exist.

Leo656
11-08-2015, 09:36 PM
If you read any of them you'd know the reason. :lol:

spookycookies
11-08-2015, 10:20 PM
True Fact: This book will be better than April & Casey, that's all I want from any TMNT book these days.

mrmaczaps
11-08-2015, 11:37 PM
Which is still plenty.

Superman fans have had zero books to read since 2011. You're fine.

Superman sucks these days. I have been an avid reader of the Man of Steel since Doomsday... it's a sad time to be a Fan of Steel...

Not big on Batman or DC in general, but I do see the potential this mini has for the Bros...

@

Commenter 42
11-09-2015, 01:17 AM
I'm also one who isn't excited. I wasn't excited about the Ghostbusters crossover and I'm a huge fan of the boys in gray (the movies and cartoon, not much on the comics). Crossovers are often disappointing mainly because either both sides of the crossover are writen with cursory knowledge or favorably writing for one side.

I'm also not a fan of official noncanon. I mean, what's fanficion for then? ^^;

With this, I agree.

True Fact: This book will be better than April & Casey, that's all I want from any TMNT book these days.

HAHA!

I know right? lol. I keep kicking it out of my pull bin, but they always creep back in.

They can't even give them away.

Leo656
11-09-2015, 09:59 PM
I'm also not a fan of official noncanon. I mean, what's fanficion for then? ^^;

I love me some ElseWorlds-type stuff anytime, personally, since "canon" can be a little bit too constrictive at times when it comes to telling some bang-up stories. Like some of the best Superman and Batman stuff ever written exists in this weird "half-canon/half-not" sort of in-between, where it kind of counts if you want it to but otherwise not really. I am like THE biggest defender of canon and continuity, but I also understand that you lose out on some great storytelling if you keep too tight a lock on everything.

A good story is a good story even if it "doesn't count". I mean things like "canon" and "continuity" are fluid; it's never, ever set in stone, it only lasts until someone with a new story comes along to supersede it. And if you can tell a good story "between panels" or just outside of canon, then you might as well.

I mean it's all made-up anyway. :trazz:

PangolinFeets
11-09-2015, 10:52 PM
I love me some ElseWorlds-type stuff anytime, personally, since "canon" can be a little bit too constrictive at times when it comes to telling some bang-up stories. Like some of the best Superman and Batman stuff ever written exists in this weird "half-canon/half-not" sort of in-between, where it kind of counts if you want it to but otherwise not really. I am like THE biggest defender of canon and continuity, but I also understand that you lose out on some great storytelling if you keep too tight a lock on everything.

A good story is a good story even if it "doesn't count". I mean things like "canon" and "continuity" are fluid; it's never, ever set in stone, it only lasts until someone with a new story comes along to supersede it. And if you can tell a good story "between panels" or just outside of canon, then you might as well.

I mean it's all made-up anyway. :trazz:

I don't know about youse guys, but I ****ing love 'What ifs...'.


http://i.imgur.com/0WV29IT.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/kqHJeV0.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/dcSXgQE.jpg


Ok that last one isn't real, but its really funny.

MsMarvelDuckie
11-09-2015, 11:28 PM
ROFL! That last one is frakking hilarious! And yes, I love the old "What If"s too. Even wrote a couple myself. A Red-Back(Peter Parker's kid)/Evil Dead one, and a co-written one of Red-Back & Stark Jr./Predator. Fun stuff. We had a sequel in the works for the Predator one that never got finished (I really SHOULD finish that tale, as it was a hilarious body-switching gig) and another that dealt with Loki that is still in the planning stages.

As for the Batman one, I'm not REAL excited for it, as if it's non-canon, then it kind of deflates the whole purpose, unlike the Ghostbusters one, which WAS canon to both. That made that one all the more awesome, since it actually MATTERED to the two series. Not that the TMNT will likely ever revisit that world, but it was cool that they actually mentioned it and it had some lasting repercussions on both sides. But if as Leo says it's not going to amount to a hill of beans for either franchise story-wise, it's not a HUGE deal other than as a "interest-booster" for Bat-fans to maybe pick up TMNT out of curiosity. I can get behind that, but only for the sake of increasing interest and respect for the TMNT in general. Otherwise, it's just a gimmick that won't amount to much. I see his point in that, and kind of agree, based on how DC has done other out-of-house crossovers. None of the Marvel one they ever did were really "canon", either, which is a shame, because the Batman/Spider-Man one was SWEET! Joker and Carnage causing mayhem together? What's NOT to love?! Would've been better if it wasn't just a glorified "What If", though.

Leo656
11-09-2015, 11:34 PM
Nobody says you can't just pretend. It's all fake, stories can "count" if you want them too. Like Superman/Terminator: Death to the Future. I love that story, I say it counts. The fact they've never mentioned it again doesn't slow me down one bit. F*ck 'em.

Same here. "Officially", it won't count. Eh. If you wanna make believe that it does, knock yourself out.

My attitude towards canon and continuity is basically, "The good stories count and the bad ones don't." :trazz:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-09-2015, 11:51 PM
My attitude towards canon and continuity is basically, "The good stories count and the bad ones don't." :trazz:

I'll raise a glass to that.

Jephael
11-10-2015, 12:29 AM
There's this great moment in an episode of The Simpsons from a few years back where Comic Book Guy is showing Bart and Milhouse an issue of Jimmy Olsen where Jimmy got a concussion and had a dream about Superman moving to Gotham City. CBG says "Since it was a dream, it didn't really happen." to which Bart cleverly replied "None of this stuff really happened.", which really p*sses off the fat a-hole who kicks the kids out of his store. I've been dieing to see somebody make a friggin meme of that moment because if one existed out there, I sure as hell would've posted it here since it's a perfect example of how we must look when we whine and argue about FICTIONAL CHARACTERS!!!

Joey Kamikaze
11-10-2015, 12:37 AM
Like how the Star Wars prequels aren't canon. :)

Jephael
11-10-2015, 12:48 AM
Like how the Star Wars prequels aren't canon. :)

Exactly! Who gives a flying fortress?! In the end it's all make believe!!!

CyberCubed
11-10-2015, 08:05 PM
As long as there are no story contradictions it will be canon in my headcanons. Since Shredder is alive here I simply place it before the latest story arc, somewhere back when the Turtles returned to New York after Northampton.