View Full Version : Black and White or Color?
Tetsu Deinonychus
11-16-2015, 11:05 AM
How do you prefer to read the original Mirage comics? Do you like them better in straight black and white published my Mirage themselves, or do you prefer the colorized versions that IDW puts out?
Let's not forget that First comics released colorized TPBs with some of the main issues between #1-#11. It only covers part of the series but there is much to be said for the nice watercolor look the colors had, which is different and more "classic" than the modern digital colors the IDW version has.
So, what are your opinions on this?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-16-2015, 11:07 AM
I absolutely prefer the B&W. However, I've been collecting the IDW trade paperbacks as it's making it much easier to collect hard-to-find TMNT issues that were never previously collected.
Now we just need Image Volume 3 and Mirage Volume 4 collected, and I'll be set for life. :tcool:
plastroncafe
11-16-2015, 11:14 AM
I prefer the B&W, but the water colored First trades have a special place in my heart, because they were some of the first Mirage Books I was able to get my hands on.
Duke Nukem
11-16-2015, 02:40 PM
I like the original B&W. I don't have many of the First trades to compare, but for a colorized version of #1, I prefer Steve Lavigne's 2009 colors to either the First Comics or IDW Color Classics versions.
CyberCubed
11-16-2015, 03:11 PM
The color breathes new life into many of these old issues, I just wish the actual coloring choices were made better.
AquaParade
11-16-2015, 06:36 PM
The color breathes new life into many of these old issues, I just wish the actual coloring choices were made better.
Exactly. I'd be all over colorized issues if the colors looked better.
Sabacooza
11-16-2015, 08:23 PM
On voted for First Comics water color look. Black and white is always pretty cool in that it's very old school. However, color sells and is more attractive. It brings everything to life...for me anyway. The watercolor look was a bit subdued helping to enhance and not hurt what was there. Some comics can be colored too dark and much gets lost.
This has more to do with the attention to detail or lack thereof but with the IDW colored versions I was not thrilled with Shredder's arms being colored blue and the multi colored mutant Shredder clones to name a few.
myconius
11-16-2015, 09:57 PM
i love them all, but the Original B&W will always be my ALL TIME favorite!!!
it's a shame the First Publishing books only had 1-11 and the Leo Micro series.
it'd been nice to see what their water colors might have looked like through North Hampton and Return to New York?
though i have to agree the IDW digital colors do breath new life into the classics for some nice reading variety! :D
myconius
11-16-2015, 10:06 PM
I absolutely prefer the B&W. However, I've been collecting the IDW trade paperbacks as it's making it much easier to collect hard-to-find TMNT issues that were never previously collected.
Now we just need Image Volume 3 and Mirage Volume 4 collected, and I'll be set for life. :tcool:
i doubt IDW will add this, but it'd be nice to see issues 24 and 25 added to their Image Comics collected books.
i wonder if they'd ever consider hiring some of the Mirage staff to conclude vol 4, or if that's just a wishful pipe dream of mine?
Powder
11-16-2015, 10:12 PM
I'm a fan of black & white, through & through.
Leo656
11-16-2015, 10:14 PM
I have Regular Human Being Eyes, not Hipster Eyes, so I'm gonna say I prefer Color.
myconius
11-16-2015, 10:16 PM
I have Regular Human Being Eyes, not Hipster Eyes, so I'm gonna say I prefer Color.
were there hipsters in '84?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-16-2015, 10:19 PM
i doubt IDW will add this, but it'd be nice to see issues 24 and 25 added to their Image Comics collected books.
i wonder if they'd ever consider hiring some of the Mirage staff to conclude vol 4, or if that's just a wishful pipe dream of mine?
Exceedingly unlikely, although I share your desire.
Actually, when I talked with one of the IDW staff about the future reprints of Volume 3 and brought up the possibility of the unofficial #24-25 being included, he replied that it was the stuff of lawyers and corporations, so probably not.
And our best chance at a Volume 4 conclusion is Andrew, although I'm not sure the project would interest him...
Leo656
11-16-2015, 10:26 PM
were there hipsters in '84?
Sh*t, dude, there's always been hipsters. From back when the first caveman to make fire told his buddy about it, and the other guy was all like, "Dude, you didn't know about fire? I saw that sh*t a week ago, I just didn't go around bragging about it to people because I didn't think it was a big deal."
myconius
11-16-2015, 10:43 PM
Exceedingly unlikely, although I share your desire.
Actually, when I talked with one of the IDW staff about the future reprints of Volume 3 and brought up the possibility of the unofficial #24-25 being included, he replied that it was the stuff of lawyers and corporations, so probably not.
And our best chance at a Volume 4 conclusion is Andrew, although I'm not sure the project would interest him...
it's such a damn shame!!! even though they're unofficial #24-25 really wrap up the image story perfectly!!!
even the lengths Andrew went through to confer with the original writer about the story as well!
damn the system!!! and damn all of it's filthy red tape!!!
well, even though it's MAD expensive there's always the Russian printed #24 and #25 still out there. that's what i ended up getting.
as for volume 4, i'm going to hold out for hope that one day it WILL get some sort of conclusion, aside from the nice pin-up that Jim Lawson drew. though it probably won't happen for a real long time?
Sh*t, dude, there's always been hipsters. From back when the first caveman to make fire told his buddy about it, and the other guy was all like, "Dude, you didn't know about fire? I saw that sh*t a week ago, I just didn't go around bragging about it to people because I didn't think it was a big deal."
hopefully those cavemen beat the hipsters into bloody pulps with their clubs? :D
It'll always be black and white for me. The Mirage stuff had the atmosphere that to me conveyed the feeling what NYC might be like. The duo toning process certainly lended to this look and the little details in the lighting and shadows, texture. The colored First Comics TMNT trades were the first time they conveyed the TMNT into color and the fact issue #1 was colored by Eastman, made it exactly what the TMNT would look like in color Mirage style. The issues after that were maybe done by Lavigne (I think) and it had that watercolor look, which was still OK to me. Eastman was already into painting some of his art so he knew how to color them in that sense of texture and lighting with his method. The IDW stuff is just done wrong that I don't stand behind it. I've always glanced at the colored reprints and it impresses just to see the other Mirage stuff in color. But if your gonna color and ignore how the colors should look, its right there in the original covers' coloring than that's ignorance. I'll admit the B&W was really hard to see in the Vol. 3 series since there was no duo toning or colors in the art. It could've used either one. Vol. 4 almost the same as well but it at least had Laird's more limited toning which helped to an extent.
Again why other TMNT fans think the fan made Image Vol. 3 conclusion #24 & 25 will end up in any Vol. 3 trades is ridiculous. IDW's, not gonna reprint fan made work. Plus Paramount has its best interest and their not gonna let this harm their property in terms of look and presentation. Plus its a logistical legal nightmare possibly. The logistics of should we pay them and should this be reprinted, will pop up? Do you all think its gonna see the light of day and end up in the end of the final Vol. 3 trade and say this is the ending and this is the art and this is the efforts from fans/amateurs. Nope. I'm not dissing the people who did it but its wrong to assume its gonna be reprinted too.
plastroncafe
11-16-2015, 11:32 PM
I have Regular Human Being Eyes, not Hipster Eyes, so I'm gonna say I prefer Color.
V-fRuoMIfpw
funatic
11-16-2015, 11:36 PM
Overall I have to go with B&W, presenting them as they were originally intended, but the First colors are a close second. They held some character that IDW's digital tones are missing. I actually prefer some issues in those colors, especially the stuff that's lighter fair thematically, like the space stories. Whereas darker story arcs like Return to NY & City at War read best in gritty B&W.
Joey Kamikaze
11-16-2015, 11:49 PM
It's too damn hard to follow the blak and white artwork sometimes. Color all the way.
myconius
11-17-2015, 07:12 AM
i doubt IDW will add this..... just a wishful pipe dream of mine?
Exceedingly unlikely..... so probably not.
hey CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy,
i guess the person trying to rain on our parade didn't read the part where we already acknowledged that it was just an unlikely pipe dream?
two people can't entertain their imaginations without making somebody grumpy? :D
neatoman
11-17-2015, 07:40 AM
Something IDW has been criticised for is that they chose to not remove the duo-shade before coloring, duo-shade is often used for greyscales which is there to subsitute color. When the duo-shade isn't removed, the greyscales instead come across as shading which makes for this really weird look, it looks there's way too much shadow or shadows where it makes no sense for there to be shadows.
Even if they had removed the duo-shade it's worth mentioning that these comics were originally printed in black and white, they were never originally intended to be printed in color and preserving them as close to their original print as possible is important.
myconius
11-17-2015, 09:30 AM
Something IDW has been criticised for is that they chose to not remove the duo-shade before coloring, duo-shade is often used for greyscales which is there to subsitute color. When the duo-shade isn't removed, the greyscales instead come across as shading which makes for this really weird look, it looks there's way too much shadow or shadows where it makes no sense for there to be shadows.
Even if they had removed the duo-shade it's worth mentioning that these comics were originally printed in black and white, they were never originally intended to be printed in color and preserving them as close to their original print as possible is important.
this is why i'll always prefer the original B&W, as it was intended to be viewed in.
some of the panels of the IDW Color Classics look really nice while others look like they were trying to force color into heavily shaded duo-tones and ended up with very muddy looking panels.
thankfully they didn't end up as muddy looking as some of the coloring done in the 25th anniversary book by Heavy Metal. the coloring of 'Raphael: Me, Myself and I' literally hurts to look at.
Andrew NDB
11-17-2015, 12:56 PM
I'm fully in favor of nice, lush digital colored pages vs. the B&W duotoned ones. But if it's going to be in B&W, it needs to be duotoned. And yes, if they're going to do it lush, digital coloring style, then the duotones need to be scraped out first or don't bother.
pferreira
11-19-2015, 09:20 AM
I'll go with colour. The first Turtles graphic novel I got my hands on from the late 80s was in colour and it added so much texture to the artwork.
Plasticplayhouse
11-19-2015, 12:06 PM
the black and white duoshade is the best. it provided an extra element that added grit.
myconius
11-19-2015, 03:18 PM
the black and white duoshade is the best. it provided an extra element that added grit.
Hear, hear! :D
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.