View Full Version : Single issues or trades for side series?
RaphaelsIsolation
11-16-2015, 01:56 PM
So here's my issue.
I love getting the single issues. I have lots of doubles based on covers I like.
Should I just sell my Eastman covers and then buy the large book that has them all later?
The big draw for any single issue is any extras at the back, and TMNT does the fan letters, which I love reading. Does the Casey April/Turtles in Time and other little mini series have anything in the back? Or is it just blank with advertisements?
If so, I might go for the trades of those.
CyberCubed
11-16-2015, 03:12 PM
I sold all my single issues of the entire IDW run and repurchased them in trades. All the alternate covers are including in the trades in a pin-up gallery anyway so you still have all the comic variants.
Powder
11-16-2015, 10:09 PM
I still get the single issues but the cost adds up & I'm running out of space. The thought of moving over to trades becomes more & more appealing as everything is so quickly spoiled these days. & most modern arcs are written to suit that format, anyway. Prolly better off reading experience-wise, too, with that being said.
I guess starting off with that big thing they just put out with Dan Duncan's Raph as the cover would suffice.
Joey Kamikaze
11-16-2015, 11:52 PM
I'm collecting singles and then buying the big collections that combine main and side issues in chronological order. The trades are organized by title and arc instead of recommended reading rder, and that annoys me.
funatic
11-17-2015, 12:05 AM
I'm collecting singles and then buying the big collections that combine main and side issues in chronological order. The trades are organized by title and arc instead of recommended reading rder, and that annoys me.
I'm doing the same. That way I'm getting the immediate gratification on the singles, plus the letters, and then can read the big trades when they come out a good while later and it's all fresh and easy to access in chronological order. They're also a good way to introduce new peeps to the comic without them getting overwhelmed by where the mini-series fit in. The only drawback is they don't include all the variant covers, so you'll have to collect the basic TPBs for those, but I can live without that, and if I'm really keen on some variant art I'll track down the single issue. Oh, and to answer the OP's question the mini-series do NOT have letters or any bonus material (that I can remember).
neatoman
11-17-2015, 04:34 AM
I pretty much just keep trades, it's way easier to keep track of 13 trades than it is to store and sort 50 issues. I did collect issues 45-50 but that was a special thing, I only did it so I could put them in a frame.
myconius
11-17-2015, 07:38 AM
i have to collect both.
every month when the new TMNT issue comes out it's the first thing i read, so i like having the set.
but i also like having the TPB version for collecting all the variant cover art inside.
RaphaelsIsolation
11-17-2015, 10:08 AM
nice. thanks for the comments guys.
I'll just stick with single issues of the main stuff, then probably go trade paperback for the mutianimals, utron, and whatever else there was in the side.
If there's no fan letters or anything in addition to the "comic" than what is the point since it is a side story?
funatic
11-17-2015, 10:51 AM
If there's no fan letters or anything in addition to the "comic" than what is the point since it is a side story?
Immediate gratification! (And some events in the minis run concurrently with and even affect the main series.) Not to mention buying singles keeps the comics published! But yeah, no bonus material and buying singles is an expensive hobby...
RaphaelsIsolation
11-17-2015, 02:11 PM
Right I understand ya... I used to be one of those guys that would buy EVERY issue or everything TMNT IDW series.
Since I'm like 2 years behind on things... I think TPB would be best for the side stuff.
Klunk1234
11-25-2015, 09:09 AM
I have both of them. Actually, I'm focused on collecting single issues, but I'm planning to collect more volumes (TPB), in case I have to sell my single issues.
RaphaelsIsolation
11-25-2015, 10:29 AM
I'm still torn between the singles of the mini series.
Like the Casey and APril stuff and the Turtles in Time, that stuff... the issues would cost me around 14 bucks for the issues, or the trade is around the same. the issues offer nothing extra inside. I love the ninja notes on the main series.
Pretty annoying situation as I have issues for everything up to #38 now. I love it. Trades would be a bit easier to deal with. Then for continuity I guess issues makes it easier to get out and all that.
hell i don't know
Gloworm
11-25-2015, 12:08 PM
I pretty much just keep trades, it's way easier to keep track of 13 trades than it is to store and sort 50 issues. I did collect issues 45-50 but that was a special thing, I only did it so I could put them in a frame.
Got any shots of them framed up?
Gloworm
11-25-2015, 12:40 PM
I started reading the IDW series back in August. Bought issues 1 and 2 at a Comic Con and have been snatching up back-issues, including the IDW Collection Vol.1, everywhere I go. It's been a little expensive but I am now 2 issues short of having all 95 issues on the IDW Chronological Timeline. I have been reading them in chronological order and it's by far my favorite iteration of the Turtles. Though, I am a bit frustrated at the moment, in anticipation for issue 25 to arrive in the mail... The TPB's are good but, thanks to a few sellers that were able to provide me with big lots, I found it just as hard if not harder and more expensive than tracking down the individual issues. Plus, since I'm buying all ongoing issues, I want a complete set. :trazz:
myconius
12-08-2015, 06:04 PM
I'm still torn between the singles of the mini series.
Like the Casey and APril stuff and the Turtles in Time, that stuff... the issues would cost me around 14 bucks for the issues, or the trade is around the same. the issues offer nothing extra inside. I love the ninja notes on the main series.
Pretty annoying situation as I have issues for everything up to #38 now. I love it. Trades would be a bit easier to deal with. Then for continuity I guess issues makes it easier to get out and all that.
hell i don't know
single issues do make it a lot easier to read the story in a timeline.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.