PDA

View Full Version : Aside from Vol. 1, which TMNT incarnation of COMICS is the best??


RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 11:47 AM
That doesn't mean your "favorite" because that would conflict with what I'm trying to see.

What is the best stories etc? The best art? Covers?

What do you guys think is the best stuff outside vol 1?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 11:50 AM
IDW. IDW is even better than Mirage Volume 1, because it doesn't have a sh!tty "guest era" section in the middle.

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 11:53 AM
Nice. Thanks for voting brother.

Yeah I left our Vol 1... cause it would conflict with people I think. Vol. 1's first like 11 issues are jsut killer, but yeah overall it might not be the best, but I didn't want people voting for it just because it was the origin, and the first several issues were great etc...

plastroncafe
12-30-2015, 11:58 AM
Missing the short-lived Dreamweave series based on the 2k3 cartoon...which I really rather liked.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 12:16 PM
For me, Mirage/Image has always been a mixed grab-bag.

The bookends of Mirage Volume 1 are the epitome of TMNT, #1-11, a few canon Northampton stories, Return to New York, Masks, Tales Vol 1, and City at War (with the Shades of Gray prequel). But there is no forgiveness in my heart for the middle of Volume 1.

Mirage Volume 2 started strong but got rushed at the end, through no fault of the actual content. Casey Jones was misused, and the interval with the giant turtle and fishwoman were utterly random, but Stockman and the Turtles splitting up was great. Thematically it's a perfect continuation of Volume 1; it just didn't get enough time to shine.

Image Volume 3 is another mix of awesome and meh-some. The Image crossovers are tedious (except for Horridus, who is adorable with the Mikester) and Donny gets turned into an ongoing plot device / enforcer, but Shadow, Raph, Mikey, and the Foot Clan are all awesome.

Mirage Volume 4 starts somewhat strong, #1-11 or thereabouts, and the plot developments of Utroms landing on Earth publicly and Splinter's death of old age are excellent. But as soon as Splinter dies, the plot threads unravel to a certain extent. Leo's drags on, Donnie's drags on, Raph's is utterly pointless, and Mikey's is great. But considering we'll never get an ending, eh.

I don't think it's fair to lump Tales Volume 1 into it's own category; it's very much an essential part of Mirage Volume 1. Also, you forgot Tales Volume 2, which IS it's own thing.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 12:20 PM
(splitting into two posts due to length)

Compared to Volumes 1-4 from Mirage/Image, IDW has had a far stronger track record. The other volumes are critically 50% awesome, 50% tedious. Whereas for its 75-85 issues (don't remember the exact number offhand), IDW and its accompanying tie-ins and mini-series are ALL excellent. The ONLY issues of IDW TMNT that have not been excellent are (most of us will agree) the Casey & April miniseries and the two Eastman annuals.

Utrommaniac
12-30-2015, 12:43 PM
IDW!

I find that the story and characters are far more investing. The turtles seem more like teenagers than any other incarnation, besides the Nick show, but it takes it seriously.
Family conflict is more relevant and seems more real.
Baxter Stockman's not a pushover or a boot kisser or a one-note mad scientist. Or constantly getting the short end of the the stick, but greatly deserving of it when he does. Most of all, he's terrifying in his own special way that Krang and Shredder do not have.
April and Casey retain their usual roles of being clearly much older than the turtles, but I like that they're still incredibly young; young enough to be peers to the turtles. Reporter April and scientist/shop keeper April just seemed too old to be associating with the turtles at the level she does. Tech school April seems at just the right spot. Same with Casey. Other incarnations didn't quite hit the "good kid from a bad neighborhood" area quite as well for me.
The Fugitoid has a lot more character, and I like the gold color better than silver; it shows how valuable he is.
The feud between Splinter and Shredder is labeled as petty and pointless, as it should have been for decades. Applause to Donatello for seeing this.

And, of course, the Utrom story having a lot more meat to their story than "we crashed because of a solar flare/psychopath", and the same goes for Krang. I have a lot more to say abut him and his psychology, but I'll get to that in another topic, if I can find it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 12:46 PM
I'm quite curious to see if anyone will vote against IDW. :tlol:

DON'T YOU DARE, WHOEVER YOU ARE! DON'T. YOU. DARE.

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 12:49 PM
Yeah I didn't include Vol 2 Tales because it was later, and if I had to include one of them it was be Vol 1. Which is just better overall... and has that old school famous Mirage vibe to it.

I didn't want to add in every single comic thing... I wanted to keep it chunky and headling.

Which is what I did. All MAJOR comic lines are shown here. Tales Vol 2 didn't deserve to be in this. I know it is longer than Vol 1 and all that, but Vol 1 was during the classic era 87-89 right?

THanks for the great inputs very fun.

plastroncafe
12-30-2015, 01:01 PM
Oh, so the exclusions weren't oversights, they were intentionally left off to suit your own biases.

Good to know.

Toitlefan
12-30-2015, 01:11 PM
Basically what CKDOhMY said. Each series has some really great content but they usually have an equal amount of not-so-great stuff within the same series. With very few exceptions, IDW has consistently produced quality stories, art and execution.
With that being said, IDW has advantages over the previous volume's teams and, I think, has taken somewhat of an easy way out by not creating an entirely new story. It seems they have learned from the other volumes mistakes by taking what worked in the past and regurgitating it but tweaking it slightly to make it their own. I'm not saying it doesn't work, because it does.
IDW has succeeded in harnessing the awesome creative imaginings of the '80s cartoons/comics and I really think that's the reason for their popularity.
I guess what I'm trying to say is, the main reason I like IDW so much is because I liked many of the previous stories so much.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:11 PM
Yeah I didn't include Vol 2 Tales because it was later, and if I had to include one of them it was be Vol 1. Which is just better overall... and has that old school famous Mirage vibe to it.

I didn't want to add in every single comic thing... I wanted to keep it chunky and headling.

Which is what I did. All MAJOR comic lines are shown here. Tales Vol 2 didn't deserve to be in this. I know it is longer than Vol 1 and all that, but Vol 1 was during the classic era 87-89 right?

THanks for the great inputs very fun.

Okay, you're being deliberately biased and thus this poll is a crock if you're DELIBERATELY leaving Tales Volume 2 out. :trolleye: At 70 issues, it's a hell of a lot more MAJOR than Tales Volume 1 (which again, isn't really it's own thing), Mirage Volume 2, or hell, pretty much everything except Mirage Volume 1.

That's like if I were to set up a poll asking "Which is the Greatest U.S. President of the 21st Century?" and gave you the options of Bill Clinton and Barack Obama only. Love him or hate him, George W. Bush should be in that poll. Tis a fact.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:12 PM
Oh, so the exclusions weren't oversights, they were intentionally left off to suit your own biases.

Good to know.

Dammit, PC, ya beat me to it. :tlol:

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 01:15 PM
OMG

I was just trying to have some fun. I thought about including Tales Vol 2 but didn't because I was trying to keep the main ones in there.

Plus I didn't think anyone would actually vote for tales vol 2.

I wans't trying to be biased... so sorry. Just relax. I was simply trying to defend why I didn't include it. I just didn't think including every vol of every thing was that important. I stuck to adventures, the other official volumes the first tales because it is from that classical era and the idw

I just thought vol 1 tales should get there and not vol 1 based on its prestige and timing. Sorry guys.

Wasn't anything I was trying to do for myself. Just trying to have a friendly poll. If I could add it in I would.

Good lord.

mrmaczaps
12-30-2015, 01:21 PM
I voted for Image... Mostly I haven't cared for the ongoing art from IDW. It's not bad, but the Turtles are ugly as all heck. Fawn all over the artist if you want but its definitely not my cup of tea. The stories from IDW have been great but TMNT wasn't even supposed to be an ongoing... Just a one shot and done... It's not really a fair comparison for V1 to IDW... IDW was planned out... Anyways. I'll take all the original material over the IDW as "best" any day.

:)

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:24 PM
People who post polls are supposed to keep those polls unbiased and equal opportunity. This isn't politics, man, it's TMNT. We all already know some of the material sucks.

Give us a chance to rant against Tales Vol 2, man. I hate the majority of it for wasting space and never finishing its good story arcs.

Unbiased. Unprejudiced. Fair.

Plastroncafe, would you do me a solid and post a Harvey Dent GIF? I can never get that crap to work right. :tlol:

ToTheNines
12-30-2015, 01:24 PM
Well Tales 2 is the outlier, being an anthology and all. It bounces around and is part of each of the other eras, filling gaps and what not all over.

Anyways, kinda have to vote for IDW. Objectively speaking it's been highly consistent, and is accessible and organized enough that it's probably what I'd start someone on if they asked me where to start with TMNT.

plastroncafe
12-30-2015, 01:27 PM
Plastroncafe, would you do me a solid and post a Harvey Dent GIF? I can never get that crap to work right. :tlol:

https://thechive.files.wordpress.com/2011/01/1235288834174.gif
This one?

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 01:28 PM
Well Tales 2 is the outlier, being an anthology and all. It bounces around and is part of each of the other eras, filling gaps and what not all over.

Anyways, kinda have to vote for IDW. Objectively speaking it's been highly consistent, and is accessible and organized enough that it's probably what I'd start someone on if they asked me where to start with TMNT.

at least someone else here isn't killing me.

I honestly didn't think anyone would vote for it anyways with the options at hand

everything listed as options is MAJOR and classic things. a vol 2 of a series that went on way too long and is hit and miss just doesn't deserve it.

Would you guys have voted for Dreamwave...

no wait...

plastroncafe
12-30-2015, 01:32 PM
I'd have voted for Dreamweave, which is why I made mention of it's exclusion.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:35 PM
at least someone else here isn't killing me.

I honestly didn't think anyone would vote for it anyways with the options at hand

everything listed as options is MAJOR and classic things. a vol 2 of a series that went on way too long and is hit and miss just doesn't deserve it.

Would you guys have voted for Dreamwave...

no wait...

Yet again, you continue to completely miss the point and instead complain about being picked on.

I'm not going to list the logic and facts, again. I think I'll just let PC's "Muffin" comment ride. (She and I have to do a superhero team-up more often, this has been GREAT FUN.)

https://thechive.files.wordpress.com/2011/01/1235288834174.gif
This one?

Aw man, it's been ruined with carrot cake. :tlol: I don't blame Dent for screaming!

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 01:36 PM
I'd have voted for Dreamweave, which is why I made mention of it's exclusion.

try again lol

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:43 PM
Seeing how CyberCubed isn't around (somebody turn on the Cubedsignal!), I'm gonna steal a sheet out of his script.

This thread needs to be locked. :twink:

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 01:45 PM
yeah just lock it or just delete it.

I just tried to make a fun poll and it went so sour.

so sad

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:47 PM
Verily, life is but a pool of tears, its liquid sorrows clinging to us with every sodden step.

ToTheNines
12-30-2015, 01:47 PM
Seeing how CyberCubed isn't around (somebody turn on the Cubedsignal!), I'm gonna steal a sheet out of his script.

This thread needs to be locked. :twink:

https://media3.giphy.com/media/N9kZiAZw0odhK/giphy.gif

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:51 PM
https://media3.giphy.com/media/N9kZiAZw0odhK/giphy.gif

You're a silent guardian... a watchful protector...

A DARK KNIGHT.

ToTheNines
12-30-2015, 01:55 PM
You merely adopted the 'drome... I was born in it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 01:59 PM
You merely adopted the 'drome... I was born in it.

This great forum... it WILL survive.

RaphaelsIsolation
12-30-2015, 02:07 PM
I kinda wish my face was inside that batman signal as it was being broken...

Leo656
12-30-2015, 10:01 PM
Dreamwave huh? I liked that the first time, then I looked at it again and it's honestly pretty bad. That art is awful, especially. I mean some of the writing was hinting at something good but all that copy/paste art was so hackish and lazy and over-stylized, to boot. Huh. Go figure, guess everything is someone's favorite. I guess it's kinda like how some people like black licorice and nobody can figure out why. :trazz:

I honestly would have to give a mention to Tales Vol. 2. It's definitely better than most things. I'unno about "best" but it's better than most.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 10:03 PM
Dreamwave huh? I liked that the first time, then I looked at it again and it's honestly pretty bad. That art is awful, especially. I mean some of the writing was hinting at something good but all that copy/paste art was so hackish and lazy and over-stylized, to boot. Huh. Go figure, guess everything is someone's favorite. I guess it's kinda like how some people like black licorice and nobody can figure out why. :trazz:

I honestly would have to give a mention to Tales Vol. 2. It's definitely better than most things. I'unno about "best" but it's better than most.

Really? You'd take Tales Volume 2 over Mirage Volume 2?

Leo656
12-30-2015, 10:08 PM
I didn't say all that, they're not even the same thing. I know what I'm more apt to flip through but that doesn't say everything.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 10:17 PM
I didn't say all that, they're not even the same thing. I know what I'm more apt to flip through but that doesn't say everything.

Just curious. Assumed you found the tales more appealing than the second volume due to your vote, but hey, this whole poll fell apart LONG ago. :tlol:

Muffin, anyone?

Leo656
12-30-2015, 10:30 PM
Well I mean there's more stuff in Tales that I'd like to re-read before I'd re-read Vol. 2 of Mirage, but that's just me. Seeing how one's an anthology and one's more like a mini-series, it's hard for me mentally to compare them.

Most of Mirage in general outside of Tales is like dry turkey, to me. It's fine but it's not my first pick of meats. I feel like some of the stuff in Tales Vol. 2 did a better job of telling TMNT stories that the readers would enjoy and was a little more aimed at fans than the rest of Mirage's stuff. But I'unno if you'd say "better", exactly.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 10:34 PM
Well I mean there's more stuff in Tales that I'd like to re-read before I'd re-read Vol. 2 of Mirage, but that's just me. Seeing how one's an anthology and one's more like a mini-series, it's hard for me mentally to compare them.

Most of Mirage in general outside of Tales is like dry turkey, to me. It's fine but it's not my first pick of meats. I feel like some of the stuff in Tales Vol. 2 did a better job of telling TMNT stories that the readers would enjoy and was a little more aimed at fans than the rest of Mirage's stuff. But I'unno if you'd say "better", exactly.

I've never forgiven Tales for not finishing what were, for my money, the best plots they had: Mystics, Mistress, and Gang War.

But yeah, there is a lot of good stuff in there, too. And no Casey Jones doing an idiotic "Ahnuld" impression either. :tlol:

MikeandRaph87
12-30-2015, 10:39 PM
Now, to say Mirage vol.1 is the best in comic from is an opinion. I alsp lump together the seven issues of Tales vol. 1 with the volume one books. At this point I cannot officially say IDW yet. It is not a completed volume like the rest. At this point it is Archie's Adventures series. When all is said and done it likely will be IDW. It is just hard to jusge something that is still going on.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-30-2015, 10:41 PM
Now, to say Mirage vol.1 is the best in comic from is an opinion. I alsp lump together the seven issues of Tales vol. 1 with the volume one books. At this point I cannot officially say IDW yet. It is not a completed volume like the rest. At this point it is Archie's Adventures series. When all is said and done it likely will be IDW. It is just hard to jusge something that is still going on.

Well, technically Mirage Volume 4 is "ongoing." Give a volume long enough under the same creative team to establish its own tone, universe, and canon, and even if it's ongoing, you can critically judge it.

Volume 4 is, at best, tedious.
IDW is, at worst, a well-written love letter to every prior incarnation of TMNT.

PangolinFeets
12-30-2015, 11:09 PM
I read IDW first and later went back and read other series. IDW is still my favorite (I'm probably just as biased as anyone else).

Panda_Kahn_fan
12-31-2015, 01:11 AM
IDW, JUST... IDW.It has everything I wanted in a TMNT comic. I'd throw every other TMNT incarnation overboard to enjoy this one, without hesitation.

MsMarvelDuckie
01-02-2016, 07:00 PM
(splitting into two posts due to length)

Compared to Volumes 1-4 from Mirage/Image, IDW has had a far stronger track record. The other volumes are critically 50% awesome, 50% tedious. Whereas for its 75-85 issues (don't remember the exact number offhand), IDW and its accompanying tie-ins and mini-series are ALL excellent. The ONLY issues of IDW TMNT that have not been excellent are (most of us will agree) the Casey & April miniseries and the two Eastman annuals.


Agreed on all counts, except for the part about the April and Casey mini. I actually liked it! I mean, sure it's kind of weird and hard to follow in places, a bit slow, and not exactly exciting in the action sense, but it tells an interesting side-story and deals with some of their personal issues and relationship in a way that I found pretty effective. Plus, when read all together, it really is a pretty intriguing story. IMHO, anyway. And I liked the artwork, which was refreshingly different.


IDW!

I find that the story and characters are far more investing. The turtles seem more like teenagers than any other incarnation, besides the Nick show, but it takes it seriously.
Family conflict is more relevant and seems more real.
Baxter Stockman's not a pushover or a boot kisser or a one-note mad scientist. Or constantly getting the short end of the the stick, but greatly deserving of it when he does. Most of all, he's terrifying in his own special way that Krang and Shredder do not have.
April and Casey retain their usual roles of being clearly much older than the turtles, but I like that they're still incredibly young; young enough to be peers to the turtles. Reporter April and scientist/shop keeper April just seemed too old to be associating with the turtles at the level she does. Tech school April seems at just the right spot. Same with Casey. Other incarnations didn't quite hit the "good kid from a bad neighborhood" area quite as well for me.
The Fugitoid has a lot more character, and I like the gold color better than silver; it shows how valuable he is.
The feud between Splinter and Shredder is labeled as petty and pointless, as it should have been for decades. Applause to Donatello for seeing this.

And, of course, the Utrom story having a lot more meat to their story than "we crashed because of a solar flare/psychopath", and the same goes for Krang. I have a lot more to say abut him and his psychology, but I'll get to that in another topic, if I can find it.

Yes to all of this. I haven't read much of Mirage or Archie (and most of what I have is from the Classics reprints) so I can't really judge much about them beyond the issues I have, but IDW just feels so much more like an integrated universe.

myconius
01-03-2016, 10:45 AM
IDW. IDW is even better than Mirage Volume 1, because it doesn't have a sh!tty "guest era" section in the middle.

i'll probably be tarred and feathered for saying this?? but i did enjoy some of those "****** guest era" issues! :lol:

and not just the issues like AC Farley's #29 or #43 or #33 'Turtle's Take Time'

Matt Howath's #41 'Turtle Dreams' was a lot of fun! :D

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-03-2016, 11:49 AM
i'll probably be tarred and feathered for saying this?? but i did enjoy some of those "****** guest era" issues! :lol:

and not just the issues like AC Farley's #29 or #43 or #33 'Turtle's Take Time'

Matt Howath's #41 'Turtle Dreams' was a lot of fun! :D

You will not be tarred and feathered; you are entitled to like something I dislike.

The biggest objective problem with the Guest Era is not the quality or non-quality of each individual tale, but how it steered TMNT into a ditch for... was it 2 years? I feel like it was 2 years.

Powder
01-03-2016, 06:08 PM
IDW is even better than Mirage Volume 1, because it doesn't have a sh!tty "guest era" section in the middle.

I no longer like you.

Leo656
01-03-2016, 06:48 PM
Frankly I'm baffled when anyone defends the Guest Era. Yeah, there's one or two good things. Which amounts to almost nothing next to the pile of "Dafuq I just read?"

It'd be pretty harmless if it didn't take up a huge chunk of real estate during the run of the MAIN book. If it was just something like "Batman Confidential" full of non-canon stuff they didn't expect anyone to actually read (or pay for), that'd be different. As is, it's pretty unjustifiable that such a small percent of Vol. 1 is actual Story Content, and the rest is all goofy What-If/Elseworlds stories.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-03-2016, 07:09 PM
I no longer like you.

Yeah, you do. :twink:

Leo656
01-03-2016, 08:21 PM
I like both of you, this tears me in two.

Powder
01-03-2016, 09:00 PM
Frankly I'm baffled when anyone defends the Guest Era. Yeah, there's one or two good things. Which amounts to almost nothing next to the pile of "Dafuq I just read?"

It'd be pretty harmless if it didn't take up a huge chunk of real estate during the run of the MAIN book. If it was just something like "Batman Confidential" full of non-canon stuff they didn't expect anyone to actually read (or pay for), that'd be different. As is, it's pretty unjustifiable that such a small percent of Vol. 1 is actual Story Content, and the rest is all goofy What-If/Elseworlds stories.

It's not even so much a matter of the guest era being sacred (though I like pretty much all of it except for the Hedden & Mcweeney stuff). You can't just outright say IDW is better than Mirage in this house, nuh-uh, nope. It's great, but they're two very different beasts, & Mirage is just objectively the best version by default, duh. :)

Leo656
01-03-2016, 09:39 PM
If I ever read enough IDW to have a dog in the fight I'll think it over again. :lol:

One thing I've noticed is it seems people who are already familiar with TMNT from elsewhere, like cartoons or whatever, have an easier time getting into IDW than Mirage. IDW just seems to have more of a "something for everybody" vibe to it, from what people tell me mixed with the very little bit I've read. Mirage just seems like it's too different from what most people "expect" TMNT to be once they've been exposed to it elsewhere, and IDW meets more of those expectations, so maybe it's not as good in some ways but it definitely works better at satisfying the broader audience.

I'll say this, having had a few years to ponder it: Not a fan of the reincarnation angle. Not a deal-breaker, just don't think it helps anything, and since it actively turns a lot of people off I have to wonder what the point is. I mean you guys know me, I'm always against "different for different's sake" anyways, unless there's a solid reason justifying it. But I've only really read like the first 12 issues of IDW. But I can see why it's so many people's favorite.

MsMarvelDuckie
01-03-2016, 09:57 PM
Well, Leo, there IS justification for it, and it makes perfect sense for the story they are telling. It's had lasting repercussions throughout the series thus far, even into Donnie's "death", especially regarding Tang Shen and her role. In fact, the past life stuff is basically their version of what started the entire feud, the reason Saki and Yoshi/Splinter are constantly at each other's throats. Secret History of the Foot Clan went a LONG way toward explaining it all, and really enriched that aspect of the story. So did Sins of the Fathers and City Fall. Northampton touched on it, as well. So there's a lot there to mine, and a lot that relates directly to the current timeline in the story. I think it's one of the BEST origins ever, if not THE best.

Leo656
01-03-2016, 10:32 PM
Counter-point: If you don't believe in any of that stuff, or are actively offended by the idea of it, as some (not me) are, all of that falls apart.

Plus, it's a little convenient for my tastes as a plot device. Once you've established that reincarnation is a thing in a fictional universe, "death" loses all meaning. "Ahh, they'll get better." I mean I know they have to anyway because it's comic books. It just makes the writers' job a little too easy, in my opinion. It opens up a back door that's too hard to close, and raises a lot of questions instead of just moving the story forward.

Maybe one day I'll change my mind that it's a needless complication, but it will take a LOT. But as I said, it's not like it's a deal-breaker. I didn't like Utrom Shredder much, either, I thought it was a blatant cheat so they could do the "Leo decapitates Shredder" scene in a cartoon show without having to actually deal with it. I still like 2K3 more than most versions. Contrary to belief I can occasionally get over things.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-03-2016, 10:36 PM
It's not even so much a matter of the guest era being sacred (though I like pretty much all of it except for the Hedden & Mcweeney stuff). You can't just outright say IDW is better than Mirage in this house, nuh-uh, nope. It's great, but they're two very different beasts, & Mirage is just objectively the best version by default, duh. :)

I think IDW is actually better objectively, simply because it has had a more consistent run and fewer "dud" issues.

Mirage has stronger stories (City at War, it'll never be beaten) but there's a ton of poor or mediocre issues in the Mirage/Image run that bring it down. Objectively, as much as I love both, I do have to maintain that IDW is better. Simply a matter of QC in my opinion.

That, and IDW April hasn't banged any roaches yet. :twink:

Joey Kamikaze
01-03-2016, 10:46 PM
Yeah, if you haven't read it and want to know what the hype is about with IDW, read Secret History of the Foot Clan. It fits in chronology right before City Fall but also works as its own stand-alone story.

As for Volume 1 vs IDW... they're alpha and omega to me. V1 gets props as the origin of the whole mythos, and those first dozen some issues are still a fun read. City At War remains TMNT at its best. But a lot of iconic TMNT lore came out of TMNTA, or 2k3, or even Fred Wolf, and I feel like the license was waiting a long time for someone to finally bring that mythology all together. That's what IDW does, and it does a great job at it. Volume 1 is where it all began, IDW is a culmination of the 30 year history. If anything they complement each other.

MsMarvelDuckie
01-03-2016, 10:55 PM
Counter-point: If you don't believe in any of that stuff, or are actively offended by the idea of it, as some (not me) are, all of that falls apart.

Plus, it's a little convenient for my tastes as a plot device. Once you've established that reincarnation is a thing in a fictional universe, "death" loses all meaning. "Ahh, they'll get better." I mean I know they have to anyway because it's comic books. It just makes the writers' job a little too easy, in my opinion. It opens up a back door that's too hard to close, and raises a lot of questions instead of just moving the story forward.

Maybe one day I'll change my mind that it's a needless complication, but it will take a LOT. But as I said, it's not like it's a deal-breaker. I didn't like Utrom Shredder much, either, I thought it was a blatant cheat so they could do the "Leo decapitates Shredder" scene in a cartoon show without having to actually deal with it. I still like 2K3 more than most versions. Contrary to belief I can occasionally get over things.


For me, it's not even a matter of whether you believe in it (though I do) it's more about how it was used. TMNT has always had a strong supernatural element, we all know this, but it was used very intelligently here. Yoshi's dying prayer was that he and his family might be avenged, and that was simply how it came about. Contrived? Maybe, but it works for the story being told, and the door is closed merely by the fact that he had to pray for it to "whatever goods might hear", before it could happen. Saki's case was a bit more confusing, since he was ALREADY the soul of the Foot's founder who was killed, but Kitsune had a hand in that, so it's not like EVERYONE who dies can get reincarnated. Tang Shen certainly wasn't. Neither was anyone else from that past lifetime. It still required extraordinary circumstances and "divine intervention" to happen at all. Be it Kitsune, or whoever else was responsible. Rather than take away the meaning of death, it gives it greater meaning in this case, since they didn't even KNOW they had lived before until Splinter told them of his memories, and Leo began to have the visions of Shen. It made what had happened take greater meaning for them, because it was VERY personal. How many people get a chance to avenge their own murder? That's basically what happened here.

It also made for some interesting philosophical discussions among the characters, especially between Donnie and Honeycutt, Leo and Donnie, and even Shredder and Kitsune. The nature of souls, for example, and how the "soul" is transported through the trans-mat portal, even though the body itself is destroyed and recreated in the process. That was a really defining moment for Donatello, and it helped him to accept it when he finally DID see his mother after he was beaten by Rocksteady and Bebop. Loved that scene. (Sorry if that spoils anything.)

Leo656
01-03-2016, 11:04 PM
I think it's as simple as this: It works as much as the reader wants it to. I can readily understand how it might just be a bit too much of a stretch for a Ninja Turtles story in a lot of people's eyes.

For me personally, it's like a Christmas sweater. I never would have asked for it, I didn't really want it, I don't have much use for it but I'll find a way to make use of it since I don't have much by way of options and it's not like I can give it back.

It's just one of those things that is always going to be a bitter pill for a lot of people, which raises the question of why. I know, I know, "Why not?" is good enough nowadays, but not for everyone. I'm always going to question why they needed to inject something so controversial into the story, regardless of how they sell it.

Powder
01-03-2016, 11:23 PM
I think IDW is actually better objectively, simply because it has had a more consistent run and fewer "dud" issues.

Mirage has stronger stories (City at War, it'll never be beaten) but there's a ton of poor or mediocre issues in the Mirage/Image run that bring it down. Objectively, as much as I love both, I do have to maintain that IDW is better. Simply a matter of QC in my opinion.

That, and IDW April hasn't banged any roaches yet. :twink:

IDW also has the benefit of being written by professionals who have 30 years of history to pull from. They're catering to a very specific demographic & have everything to please with at their fingertips already. You've gotta adjust handicap, here. IDW's not been without duds, either. Michelangelo's micro, April & Casey's series, Kevin's solo work, The X-Files crossover, others depending on your mileage/taste, it's far from perfect. & frankly we may have very different ideas on what a "dud" is. Some people find Mirage boring, but the slice of life quality so much of it has is what wins many of us over. We don't get to see as much of the new turtles' human side because it's written for trades & has to keep up the pace. Obviously it's a matter of opinion & we're both biased, but IDW has yet to really hit any of the deep/depressing/existential/introspective notes that Mirage did. Scraped the surface here & there, but there's a ways to go. It's mature only in that it has very detailed art, lots of action, & an older fan-base, otherwise it's very much Fred Wolf on steroids with bits of old & new mixed in, at least to me. & that's fine, it's what people come to expect (Leo's post about that nails it), but no other version to date can compare with Mirage at it's best (except for the first film but we all know where they got their material). It's just kind of a shame. You can forgive Nick for a lot because they're bound to Playmates' will, television censors, parents groups, etc. IDW doesn't have much of that, yet it still feels very neutered & toyetic a lot of the time. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to be harsh. I own every issue + some collections, I commission the artists, I adore the thing. But if Mirage is Citizen Kane, IDW is... some other good ass movie from many years later that is less nuanced. :tlol: I don't have a good reference at the moment.

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-03-2016, 11:33 PM
Here's why the reincarnation works, and works better:

-It solves the problem of Yoshi and the rat that learned martial arts from him. It takes the OT splinter being Hamato Yoshi, and Mirage Splinter being a rat that mutated into being a humanoid, and puts them together. The one bit of disbelief-breaking silliness, a mimicking rat, is removed for a more plausable explanation (Well, plausable by TMNT standards).

-The vendetta is more personal- Yoshi wants revenge for HIS OWN DEATH, and the death of his beloved, rather than his pet, who wasn't even intelligent at the time and never knew Yoshi after he gained sentience, raising the turtles to take revenge for a human they never knew.

-The ninja clans are back in the feudal past, instead of running around in the modern world. it's their rebirth in the modern world that brings ninjitsu with them. The foot had become a yakuza crime family under the Oroku family's leadership until Karai was contacted by Saki's spirit- it never would have survived otherwise. And Yoshi brought his ninjitsu to the modern world with him when his reincarnated form was mutated. We don't have the idiocy of modern ninjas surviving historical changes that doomed their profession to extinction.

These are just some of the reasons I prefer this origin to others.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-04-2016, 12:12 AM
IDW also has the benefit of being written by professionals who have 30 years of history to pull from. They're catering to a very specific demographic & have everything to please with at their fingertips already. You've gotta adjust handicap, here. IDW's not been without duds, either. Michelangelo's micro, April & Casey's series, Kevin's solo work, The X-Files crossover, others depending on your mileage/taste, it's far from perfect. & frankly we may have very different ideas on what a "dud" is. Some people find Mirage boring, but the slice of life quality so much of it has is what wins many of us over. We don't get to see as much of the new turtles' human side because it's written for trades & has to keep up the pace. Obviously it's a matter of opinion & we're both biased, but IDW has yet to really hit any of the deep/depressing/existential/introspective notes that Mirage did. Scraped the surface here & there, but there's a ways to go. It's mature only in that it has very detailed art, lots of action, & an older fan-base, otherwise it's very much Fred Wolf on steroids with bits of old & new mixed in, at least to me. & that's fine, it's what people come to expect (Leo's post about that nails it), but no other version to date can compare with Mirage at it's best (except for the first film but we all know where they got their material). It's just kind of a shame. You can forgive Nick for a lot because they're bound to Playmates' will, television censors, parents groups, etc. IDW doesn't have much of that, yet it still feels very neutered & toyetic a lot of the time. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to be harsh. I own every issue + some collections, I commission the artists, I adore the thing. But if Mirage is Citizen Kane, IDW is... some other good ass movie from many years later that is less nuanced. :tlol: I don't have a good reference at the moment.

You make good points. And no, that's the one thing that's missing from IDW for me: slice of life. Man, I love that issue where Mikey is rescuing a feudal princess and it turns out to be the story he's writing.

I guess, for me, Mirage is the unfiltered TMNT, which is hardhitting and depressing and bittersweet (and also doesn't have a lot of the characters I love), and IDW is the condensed revamped "improved" TMNT with quality control--and that QC also, unfortunately, neuters some of the storytelling.

For me, it's not even a matter of whether you believe in it (though I do) it's more about how it was used. TMNT has always had a strong supernatural element, we all know this, but it was used very intelligently here. Yoshi's dying prayer was that he and his family might be avenged, and that was simply how it came about. Contrived? Maybe, but it works for the story being told, and the door is closed merely by the fact that he had to pray for it to "whatever goods might hear", before it could happen. Saki's case was a bit more confusing, since he was ALREADY the soul of the Foot's founder who was killed, but Kitsune had a hand in that, so it's not like EVERYONE who dies can get reincarnated. Tang Shen certainly wasn't. Neither was anyone else from that past lifetime. It still required extraordinary circumstances and "divine intervention" to happen at all. Be it Kitsune, or whoever else was responsible. Rather than take away the meaning of death, it gives it greater meaning in this case, since they didn't even KNOW they had lived before until Splinter told them of his memories, and Leo began to have the visions of Shen. It made what had happened take greater meaning for them, because it was VERY personal. How many people get a chance to avenge their own murder? That's basically what happened here.

It also made for some interesting philosophical discussions among the characters, especially between Donnie and Honeycutt, Leo and Donnie, and even Shredder and Kitsune. The nature of souls, for example, and how the "soul" is transported through the trans-mat portal, even though the body itself is destroyed and recreated in the process. That was a really defining moment for Donatello, and it helped him to accept it when he finally DID see his mother after he was beaten by Rocksteady and Bebop. Loved that scene. (Sorry if that spoils anything.)

EVERYTHING Duckie just said here in nail on the head. High-five, Duckie!

Powder
01-04-2016, 12:20 AM
I like you again.

For what it's worth, I also find Mirage lacking in the rogues gallery department. If I'm being real, a lot of the villains are kinda lame, or if nothing else, have lackluster designs. Though my monster loving self loves having certain mutants on board, I'd gladly trade them for something my sad ass self can identify with. :tlol:

Cipher
01-04-2016, 06:23 AM
You're missing the option I would've voted for by an enormous margin.

I think IDW is actually better objectively, simply because it has had a more consistent run and fewer "dud" issues.

Mirage has stronger stories (City at War, it'll never be beaten) but there's a ton of poor or mediocre issues in the Mirage/Image run that bring it down. Objectively, as much as I love both, I do have to maintain that IDW is better. Simply a matter of QC in my opinion.

That, and IDW April hasn't banged any roaches yet. :twink:
IDW is certainly the most consistent series. But it's also a commercial action serial whereas Mirage was ... weird, sad underground anything-goes comics that somehow amazingly continued to run as the IP blossomed into a commercial institution. Really different beasts.

I think I might say that IDW is objectively better storytelling, if consistency of plotting is your main criteria. Props to IDW as well for being conscientious about forming an inclusive cast. But at the end of the day, I never really felt anything while reading IDW. As many dud issues as Mirage had (which were usually at least strange enough to be interesting), I feel things all the time when I read it.

Mr._Mutant_Man
01-06-2016, 08:50 PM
Apparently I need to give IDW another chance.

I voted for Archie based on having lost interest in IDW at about the Volume 9, while I reread Archie as an adult (the back issues I could find, anyway) and didn't get tired of it.

I think I prefer the shorter stories of the past as opposed to everything being written with trades in mind. Then again, that's an industry wide thing so I can't fault IDW on that.

LeotheLateBloomer
01-09-2016, 10:40 AM
There's still a lot of issues I need to read when it comes to IDW. From what I read of IDW, it does a good job of telling stories that add a different layer to the turtles. With me so far though, I feel that they could do a whole lot more. Some of the stories I feel just don't grab me the way Mirage can. I don't think the situations they encounter are of the same impact.

This seems to be a problem I have with this series ever since Viacom bought the property but they don't seem to know what it's focus is. I know that it is at least trying do be dark or serious but there is still a lack of focus for me.

I know that some will say that Mirage lacks a rogue's gallery but one thing to keep in mind is that the TMNT are not superheroes. Peter Laird they were never meant to be. Part of the charm of the turtles for me was that they would come across or encounter strange events happening in front of them and their curious nature would like to see what's going on. If no one is around to stop any unfortunate event, they'll likely try to put a stop to it but if the police, firemen, or anyone else more than capable of taking care of the situation, they know when it's in good hands. Despite Mike's fascination for them and Raph occasionally "playing vigilante" with Casey, Splinter didn't train them to save the world (sans Fred Wolf and Bay). They were trained to avenge Splinter's Master Yoshi and possibly take care of themselves if they were in any real danger.

TMNachoT
01-09-2016, 12:36 PM
I like the Mirage comics, some of them, guest era is a no-no for me.

And, as I don´t read IDW nor Archie, i have to choose tales vol.

Tales vol. 1 is great, some characters have been seen in other versions, which give to this volume an advantage, and more important, the stories in those issues have an ending, more stuff can be told about those characters, but the basic plot is solved at the end, not like vol. 4 that have my things in hiatus.

I do like tmnt vol. 4, but feel kinda sad that peter doesn´t want to continue that volume.

Editor's Note Comics
01-09-2016, 02:44 PM
I'd pick Tales Vol. 2. I dig that run. It was coming out at a time when Vol. 4 lost all momentum and was released...occasionally. Tales still delivered monthly. The whole run is a mixed bag; sometimes you get Don trying to stop gold mining for an online game, but other times you got great stories like Klunk's death. It gave enough solid stories that I'd put it behind Vol. 1

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-09-2016, 03:06 PM
I'd pick Tales Vol. 2. I dig that run. It was coming out at a time when Vol. 4 lost all momentum and was released...occasionally. Tales still delivered monthly. The whole run is a mixed bag; sometimes you get Don trying to stop gold mining for an online game, but other times you got great stories like Klunk's death. It gave enough solid stories that I'd put it behind Vol. 1

Yeah, there were some real clunkers as well as some real gems.

Klunk's death was a real spotlight issue for Mikey; really showed the turtle's heart and soul like no other issue I know of.

myconius
01-11-2016, 02:44 PM
Yeah, there were some real clunkers as well as some real gems.

Klunk's death was a real spotlight issue for Mikey; really showed the turtle's heart and soul like no other issue I know of.

Tales of TMNT #9 didn't live up to what i had built up in my imagination it would be, but it still was very moving.

the series definitely had some nice stories as well as some real beauties hidden amongst the hoards of "MEH" stories.

myconius
01-11-2016, 02:47 PM
i am by NO means shocked that TMNT Vol.4 so far has absolutely NO votes!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-11-2016, 02:51 PM
i am by NO means shocked that TMNT Vol.4 so far has absolutely NO votes!

Screw that book. Once somebody finishes it, THEN maybe I'll let it sit down at the dinner table with the rest of the family.

Mewzard
01-11-2016, 03:35 PM
i am by NO means shocked that TMNT Vol.4 so far has absolutely NO votes!

I've yet to get to volume 2 of the Mirage run, much less volume 4 (I could have ordered the volumes from Amazon, but they've been shipping non-hardcover stuff poorly as of late, so I just want to have my LCS order them for me).

Not the most delayed series from what I've seen though.

It took Berserk 9 years to get off the boat.

Honestly, I'm too early in all non Volume 1 Mirage TMNT comics to render much of a verdict beyond Tales volume 1 (only read up to issue 8 of Archie, and I fell behind on IDW years ago, though I'm rereading all I read before starting this month to finally begin catching up). Not going to vote until I can progress a bit further.