View Full Version : Batman/TMNT crossover gets a TPB for all 6 issues
CyberCubed
01-05-2016, 03:35 PM
Remember people saying we wouldn't get a trade collection for this mini-series anytime soon? Well we're getting one in July which is only 2 months after the 6th and final issue comes out.
http://www.amazon.com/Batman-TMNT-Vol-James-Tynion/dp/1401262783/ref=pd_sim_14_67?ie=UTF8&dpID=61-EQYt0bOL&dpSrc=sims&preST=_AC_UL160_SR106%2C160_&refRID=0Y9CCWK41KG17TWE7Z3C
It collects all 6 issues and will be published by DC. I can't wait to buy this TPB.
Allio
01-05-2016, 03:58 PM
Why wouldn't we get a trade? that's like literally a stupid idea if they don't.
ProphetofGanja
01-05-2016, 04:09 PM
Why wouldn't we get a trade? that's like literally a stupid idea if they don't.
lmao yeah for real. In this day and age, everything gets collected
The Fifth Turtle
01-05-2016, 05:39 PM
Why is it listed as "vol. 1". Error in the listing?
Well this was a forgone conclusion. Why wouldn't it get a trade? Thats the way the comics industry is. If its something good, then beyond just making the comics and have it maintain revenue/money for the publisher(s), is to make a collected edition. Thats more money in their pockets again after all the comics have been released. Also keeping with extra revenue when its done or possible, is the digital comic version. Where they can again gain some extra few dollars from digital orders. In this day and age when print media is dying, ad revenues are lower then it ever was in the past, where they can still make revenue, its gonna be printed or made. Two properties like Batman and TMNT together? Its definitely an exception. They'd be smart too if they keep the trade in print forever. Why would it not still be a decent or big seller to both publishers in the long term?
Its still good news to me. I thought I'd wait for a trade anyways. I really enjoyed the TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover TPB. It felt like a good "Real GB" cartoon episode. The way its drawn and colored almost made it look like a cartoon episode.
Why is it listed as "vol. 1". Error in the listing?
Its the usual saying in these trades to say vol. 1 if I'm not mistaken. Like a one shot or one off kinda terming IMO. Doesn't mean theres gonna be anymore crossovers done either. Unless it sold like hotcakes and had really good reception from the readers and fans then that'll change things. I'm in the mind frame not to do too much of a good thing.
Ninjinister
01-05-2016, 11:17 PM
Um... who said there wouldn't be a TPB? Literally every comic does.
Leo656
01-05-2016, 11:43 PM
Well that's neat.
And no, it wasn't a foregone conclusion as DC rarely does TPBs of inter-company cross-overs specifically, for business reasons, and when they do, it usually takes them forever and they don't make a lot of noise about it. But it's rare that they even bother. They historically do not share well, especially profits.
So under the circumstances and how DC usually operates as a business entity, this was not a foregone conclusion but a welcome and pleasant surprise.
It's probably more likely in the current marketplace than it would have been, say, ten years ago, but it was by no means a certainty.
AquaParade
01-06-2016, 12:41 AM
Thanks for sharing.
I was actually hoping they might release it an oversized hardcover, slim as the chances were.
Leo656
01-06-2016, 01:02 AM
I'm not entirely surprised they are doing a TPB of this particular one, I am surprised it's already been announced. They must have done some good pre-order business on the mini-series.
It's just that usually, when it comes to reprinting any inter-company type deal, DC likes to conveniently point out the tons of in-house stuff they have yet to release in a collected format... stuff they conveniently get to make 100% profit from. Like, "Yeah, we'll get to it, eventually, but we have SO much else to do..." :trazz: Which completely makes sense, I mean why share if you don't have to?
But this makes sense. DC is in a real mess and they have no buzz-worthy projects going on, themselves, now or the last couple years even. This is new, this is different, and if a lot of people pre-ordered it and there's already that much buzz around it, then yes, it makes sense that they'd approach this project differently than they have others in the past. I mean it's money in the bank, and some is better than none, at this point in time.
It's nice. A hardcover, I think, would be pushing it. But hey, if the TPB and the single issues both do big numbers, who knows?
Well that's neat.
And no, it wasn't a foregone conclusion as DC rarely does TPBs of inter-company cross-overs specifically, for business reasons, and when they do, it usually takes them forever and they don't make a lot of noise about it. But it's rare that they even bother. They historically do not share well, especially profits.
So under the circumstances and how DC usually operates as a business entity, this was not a foregone conclusion but a welcome and pleasant surprise.
It's probably more likely in the current marketplace than it would have been, say, ten years ago, but it was by no means a certainty.
From all the crossovers DC's done with Dark Horse and Marvel they all had trade collections done at the time. Even DC and Top Cow crossovers got a trade. The DC/Marvel ones they evenly split that DC printed 2 books and Marvel printed the other 2 of the 4 trades. Of course they're now out of print but they kept going for awhile into the 2000's years. DC and Darkhorse are going back to the well again and making omnibus' of their past crossovers.
I think its a matter of the companies having interest in licensing and teaming up or wanting to present the material again. I can't think of any other examples of other crossovers DC has done with other companies. I can't see why Batman/TMNT would've stalled for a collected book or be held off for a long time to be collected. Pretty sure Star Trek/Planet of the Apes and Star Trek/Green Lantern will have/get trades. Theres money to be made for both parties. Its in their best interest to stretch the revenue where ever they can 50/50 I'd assume. Also usually the licence owner/holder (like movie studios) doesn't have much say other than present the property in respect or maybe a read through of things or someone with the companies checks up on things with an OK. Maybe a small percentage of sales possibly? They've been paid off already with the property licence fee. I could be wrong about this too but its somewhere along these lines. To me theres no way there wasn't ever gonna be a Batman/TMNT trade IMO. Doesn't the sound of that make everyone go, yes!
CyberCubed
01-06-2016, 12:41 PM
I'm surprised the TPB is only a little over $15 according to amazon. Isn't that very cheap for 6 issues?
The IDW trades of only 4 issues each usually go for the $15 range, but this DC one gives us 6 issues for only over $15.
Cipher
01-06-2016, 01:10 PM
I'm surprised the TPB is only a little over $15 according to amazon. Isn't that very cheap for 6 issues?
The IDW trades of only 4 issues each usually go for the $15 range, but this DC one gives us 6 issues for only over $15.
That's pretty standard for DC trades on Amazon, actually, which can run as low as $11 or $12 with pre-orders, and usually contain six or seven issues.
IDW charges more, but they're both a smaller company and their paperbacks are of much higher quality. (DC's are rough; always go for the hardcovers if you can.)
myconius
01-06-2016, 08:58 PM
Remember people saying we wouldn't get a trade collection for this mini-series anytime soon? Well we're getting one in July which is only 2 months after the 6th and final issue comes out.
http://www.amazon.com/Batman-TMNT-Vol-James-Tynion/dp/1401262783/ref=pd_sim_14_67?ie=UTF8&dpID=61-EQYt0bOL&dpSrc=sims&preST=_AC_UL160_SR106%2C160_&refRID=0Y9CCWK41KG17TWE7Z3C
It collects all 6 issues and will be published by DC. I can't wait to buy this TPB.
thanks for the heads up!!!! :D
gonna pre-order mine right now!!!!
Joey Kamikaze
01-07-2016, 11:47 AM
Cool then, think I'll trade-wait on this miniseries since it's not part of IDW continuity.
I'm surprised the TPB is only a little over $15 according to amazon. Isn't that very cheap for 6 issues?
The IDW trades of only 4 issues each usually go for the $15 range, but this DC one gives us 6 issues for only over $15.
To be honest, I think IDW's 4-issue trades are kind of a rip-off. You can go on Amazon right now and nab new trades of Saga (6 issues a pop) or Sex Criminals (5 issues) for under $10.
I know TMNT is going to 5-issue trades now, but that $18 cover price is still a bit much.
slingtheory
01-07-2016, 01:15 PM
Already saw this on amazon but I assumed it being volume 1 meant it would be split into 2 trades
CyberCubed
01-07-2016, 03:34 PM
To be honest, I think IDW's 4-issue trades are kind of a rip-off. You can go on Amazon right now and nab new trades of Saga (6 issues a pop) or Sex Criminals (5 issues) for under $10.
I know TMNT is going to 5-issue trades now, but that $18 cover price is still a bit much.
Yeah, I wish their Tales of the TMNT trades collected 5 issues too. The newest one they announced still only collects 4 issues. They're only up to Tales #24 when the new trade comes out...and as we know that volume has 70 issues.
It feels like its going to take forever for them to collect all 70 issues of Tales, especially since only two Tales trades at most come out a year.
turtlefanforever
01-08-2016, 01:49 PM
it's been known for a while. certainly worth it.
Joey Kamikaze
01-08-2016, 08:38 PM
Yeah, I wish their Tales of the TMNT trades collected 5 issues too. The newest one they announced still only collects 4 issues. They're only up to Tales #24 when the new trade comes out...and as we know that volume has 70 issues.
It feels like its going to take forever for them to collect all 70 issues of Tales, especially since only two Tales trades at most come out a year.
I feel the same way about TMNTA, which is 72 issues long (plus all the miniseries if you count them, though IDW is skipping most of them and even some mainline issues) and has been coming out in 4- and 5-issue clumps at $20 a pop.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-08-2016, 08:40 PM
Yeah, I wish their Tales of the TMNT trades collected 5 issues too. The newest one they announced still only collects 4 issues. They're only up to Tales #24 when the new trade comes out...and as we know that volume has 70 issues.
It feels like its going to take forever for them to collect all 70 issues of Tales, especially since only two Tales trades at most come out a year.
No kidding. I'm still waiting on them to start collecting Image Volume 3, dammit.
CyberCubed
01-08-2016, 09:07 PM
No kidding. I'm still waiting on them to start collecting Image Volume 3, dammit.
Its supposed to be happening sometime this year. So far the only stuff we know about is the next Tales volume that collects #21-24....and no word yet on anymore Mirage/Image stuff beyond that.
I mean Image has to be next, they've finished Vol. 1 and 2, they're already in the process of collecting Tales, and they're unlikely to collect Vol. 4 anytime soon...so its the next logical one.
The only thing else I can think of is collecting some of the Mirage specials, like the Turtle Soups and all the various mini's.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-08-2016, 09:16 PM
Its supposed to be happening sometime this year. So far the only stuff we know about is the next Tales volume that collects #21-24....and no word yet on anymore Mirage/Image stuff beyond that.
I mean Image has to be next, they've finished Vol. 1 and 2, they're already in the process of collecting Tales, and they're unlikely to collect Vol. 4 anytime soon...so its the next logical one.
The only thing else I can think of is collecting some of the Mirage specials, like the Turtle Soups and all the various mini's.
I'd ask on the IDW forum BUT IT'S STILL DOWN EVEN TWO MONTHS LATER.
zaktheneutrino
01-14-2016, 12:20 PM
This news kind of makes me want to just hold off on the single issues and read the entire run in the TPB come July. For some reason, I prefer TPBs over single issues for mini-series runs.
I did already buy issue #1 though and kind of want to get an Eastman variant from the second ish. Buying the TPB would save some $ though too and to be frank, I wasn't all that impressed with the first issue of this crossover...which pains me to say as I was so thrilled when this was first announced :ohwell:
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.