View Full Version : Re-reading the entire IDW TMNT
myconius
01-14-2016, 10:02 AM
as the single IDW TMNT issues have been coming out i'd usually read each issue 2 or 3 times on release.
but it's been a while since i've read some of the older issues, so i decided to re-read the entire series from the beginning according to Dr. Spengler's continuity timeline.
http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-idw-tmnt-continuity-timeline.html
as much as i enjoyed the series month to month i'm enjoying it a LOT more on this re-through.
and there's a LOT of points i missed as well.
one of the biggest ones was the differentiation between Mutagen and Ooze!
i can't believe i didn't realize they weren't the same thing!
but in the Hob Micro-series he says that Ooze was an ingredient in Mutagen.
so this better explained to me why Ooze has been used to heal certain characters, but they didn't get Mutated or Re-Mutated. :)
i'm sure other people probably caught onto this right away, but it had completely flew over my head. :D
btw... thank you again Dr. Spengler for posting that timeline! :D
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-14-2016, 10:17 AM
Discussion re-reading time? Volume by volume? I'm game if anyone else is!
myconius
01-14-2016, 10:25 AM
Discussion re-reading time? Volume by volume? I'm game if anyone else is!
i've been re-reading the entire timeline, mini-series and all. :D
last one i JUST read up to and finished was City Fall. :)
after i read issues 1-4, i HAVE to immediately read 'a lot to learn' from the 30th Anniversary issue and then issue #5.
those are probably my most read issues from the entire run! ^__^
DrSpengler
01-14-2016, 11:12 AM
I've been wanting to reread the first year recently; I recall being pretty harsh on it when it first came out and would like to reevaluate it.
My continuity timeline is chronological but isn't the ideal reading order, mind you; I wouldn't break up the minis like Utrom Empire, Mutanimals or Casey & April as I have them (rather, shuffle them to the end of the Ongoing arcs they correspond to).
Have fun!
CyberCubed
01-14-2016, 12:42 PM
Its amazing how much the series has changed from the first year. What they've done with Old Hob alone since this is incredible, he received the most character development of the book.
PangolinFeets
01-14-2016, 12:48 PM
I remember Bobby answered a Ninja note about the difference between ooze and mutagen. I didnt realize there was a difference until then.
I reread the series over my Christmas break. Its such a great story!
myconius
01-14-2016, 12:49 PM
I've been wanting to reread the first year recently; I recall being pretty harsh on it when it first came out and would like to reevaluate it.
My continuity timeline is chronological but isn't the ideal reading order, mind you; I wouldn't break up the minis like Utrom Empire, Mutanimals or Casey & April as I have them (rather, shuffle them to the end of the Ongoing arcs they correspond to).
Have fun!
yeah, it's definitely been a nice treat!!! :D
there were many things i missed, or misinterpreted since i was still so very stuck on the continuity of the Original Mirage TMNT Vol. 1.
but now that i'm more accustomed to the IDW universe i can appreciate certain things a LOT More!
AH thank you! it's a good thing you said that about reading order, as i've just finished with 'City Fall' and was unsure if i really wanted to mix reading 'Northampton' and 'Utrom Empire'?
thank you! it's definitely been a LOT of fun so far! :D
myconius
01-14-2016, 12:52 PM
Its amazing how much the series has changed from the first year. What they've done with Old Hob alone since this is incredible, he received the most character development of the book.
absolutely!!!!
Hob's micro-series especially was absolutely amazing at what it did for his character!!!
still though, it's really hard for me not to get misty-eyed when i read the first few pages of the Hob micro! :tcry:
I remember Bobby answered a Ninja note about the difference between ooze and mutagen. I didnt realize there was a difference until then.
I reread the series over my Christmas break. Its such a great story!
i vaguely recall seeing that in 'Ninja Notes' as well, but it must've slipped my mind just as easily as it entered it! :P
Joey Kamikaze
01-14-2016, 03:28 PM
I think I did my last re-read around the time Northampton came out so I'm due too.
One thing that strikes me re-reading the first couple years is the amount of foreshadowing. Some hints you'll catch the first time through, but others only stick out once you have later stories in mind.
CyberCubed
01-14-2016, 05:26 PM
The whole Savate Ninja stuff from the early issues seemed to get swept under the rug rather quickly. I remember people thinking they would be a bigger deal when this series first started.
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2016, 05:29 PM
I am game if we can come up with a date range for reading the arcs/trades. I have been interested in doing so. I want to see if I like the first five issues I initially could care less about and if I still love #15-20 as much as I did which got me to love this title above any other.
Allio
01-14-2016, 05:32 PM
The whole Savate Ninja stuff from the early issues seemed to get swept under the rug rather quickly. I remember people thinking they would be a bigger deal when this series first started.
same thing could have been said about the police chick from Mikey's micro...which for all we know, that rock will be brought back.
PangolinFeets
01-14-2016, 05:35 PM
same thing could have been said about the police chick from Mikey's micro...which for all we know, that rock will be brought back.
Yea but Kara came back and I feel like she is going to play an even larger role in the future.
myconius
01-14-2016, 06:06 PM
one thing i find really amazing is all the little seeds planted in the series that later on built into major story points.
sure there are some loose threads that have gotten forgotten about, but overall this series is fantastic!!
my ONLY real gripe first time reading it and still doesn't sit right with me is issue #23 !!
Leo's turn to the Darkside wasn't very convincing!! :trolleye:
there was no real resistance or fight from Leo. no disbelief, NOTHING!!!
i just wish there was more development in that whole mind-warping, it just seemed rushed to me.
but that's my only real nit pick.
bringing back all the artists from previous arcs for the warped flashbacks was pretty awesome though!
turtlefan27
01-14-2016, 06:24 PM
I've been wanting to do this for some time now..
Casey
01-14-2016, 07:12 PM
one thing i find really amazing is all the little seeds planted in the series that later on built into major story points.
sure there are some loose threads that have gotten forgotten about, but overall this series is fantastic!!
my ONLY real gripe first time reading it and still doesn't sit right with me is issue #23 !!
Leo's turn to the Darkside wasn't very convincing!! :trolleye:
there was no real resistance or fight from Leo. no disbelief, NOTHING!!!
i just wish there was more development in that whole mind-warping, it just seemed rushed to me.
but that's my only real nit pick.
bringing back all the artists from previous arcs for the warped flashbacks was pretty awesome though!
It always felt rushed to me too and it was hard for me to suspend my disbelief.
myconius
01-14-2016, 07:27 PM
It always felt rushed to me too and it was hard for me to suspend my disbelief.
that's exactly my biggest thing with City Fall!
Leo is known for having such a strong resolve and being extremely disciplined!
and then it's just like -
Shredder - "Hey Leo, your Dad's really evil and i'm actually your bestest buddy!"
Leonardo - "OH! OK! say, can we stop and git sum Ice-Cream?" :P
well, maybe not AS bad as that? but yeah ...... WAY rushed!!!!
mikey22
01-14-2016, 07:30 PM
hello
ive been getting into the batman tmnt comics and noticed this idw.
can someone please pm me a link as to where to read these comics to buy them all? they seem great!
thanks
mike
mikey22
01-14-2016, 07:32 PM
i see something at barnes and noble the ultimate collection?
is this a good place to start?
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-dan-duncan/1120752520?ean=9781631401114
thank you
Powder
01-14-2016, 07:45 PM
is this a good place to start?
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-dan-duncan/1120752520?ean=9781631401114
In my opinion, yes, this is literally the best place to start. It's a great value for the price, & it's packed full of high quality content. It's got the benefit of being in chronological reading order, too, something you can't necessarily get in full with the standard 4 issue trades. Go for it!
mikey22
01-14-2016, 09:39 PM
thanks a lot powder i believe i will get started!!!
myconius
01-14-2016, 10:14 PM
so i re-read City Fall again over the last couple of days with the Micro-Series intermingled, and now i've just started re-reading City Fall again but this time without mixing in the Micros.
issue #22 was really good, and i did notice Leo's attitude towards Splinter seems shaken.
probably from the deception Splinter pulled on the Turtles in issue #21?
but still when i see Leonardo's hallucinations the Shredder come and rescue him from Splinter, and Leo doesn't question it in the least i really have to shake my head!
well i'll finish this re-read of City Fall yet again, but i REALLY have to look forward to getting to the Northampton arc!!!
that was so good that after issues 29-32 came out i had to re-read them over and over.
it's one of my most favorite arcs in the entire series.
one thing i will add about City Fall, the scenes of Mikey giving Slash candy bars are ABSOLUTELY Adorable!!!!!! ^__^
Joey Kamikaze
01-14-2016, 10:53 PM
It's been a while since I read City Fall, but in retrospect (especially given later appearances by the Rat King) I take Leo's brainwashing as a mostly mystical event. If you approach it as a realistic story, it kind of falls apart. But we know Kitsune has the godlike power to get inside someone's head and rearrange their reality--she's done it to Leo, she's doing it to Alopex, and we've seen other Pantheon members play similar head games. Leo falling fast makes sense in-universe.
myconius
01-15-2016, 12:08 AM
It's been a while since I read City Fall, but in retrospect (especially given later appearances by the Rat King) I take Leo's brainwashing as a mostly mystical event. If you approach it as a realistic story, it kind of falls apart. But we know Kitsune has the godlike power to get inside someone's head and rearrange their reality--she's done it to Leo, she's doing it to Alopex, and we've seen other Pantheon members play similar head games. Leo falling fast makes sense in-universe.
yeah, i can see what you are saying.
and even though i JUST re-read the entire City Fall arc with the micro-series, i'm glad i've decided to do yet another read-through without them.
the pacing of the City Fall is much faster and exciting by just reading the main series.
and plus getting the full dose of Mateus Santolouco's art is just amazing!!!
it's SO dynamic and action packed! some of the panels really look like they were taken from a high-quality Anime! ^__^
and seeing Dark-Leo in action is pretty Bad @$$!!!!!
so i'm just about to finish re-reading City Fall for the second time this week, and i am appreciating it much more this time!
MikeandRaph87
01-16-2016, 09:48 AM
Do we have an official date range to begin?
myconius
01-16-2016, 11:46 AM
Do we have an official date range to begin?
sorry, i didn't realize the forum had an actual group re-read system in place. D:
but if anyone wants to join in with re-reading the IDW TMNT and have discussions about it, i welcome it completely. :)
i've been re-reading the series this whole last week, and am up to Northampton & Utrom Empire so far.
but if anyone who wants to join in this re-read and discussion they are most welcome! :)
and i don't mind going back to talk about previous arcs.
we don't have to be so formal as to scheduled dates and ranges.
read and discuss as you wish. :)
turtlefan27
01-17-2016, 05:55 PM
I'm planning on starting the 1st 5 tomorrow
Casey
01-19-2016, 11:58 AM
i see something at barnes and noble the ultimate collection?
is this a good place to start?
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-dan-duncan/1120752520?ean=9781631401114
thank you
The Barnes and Noble website has Dan Duncan listed as the author!?
Etsyturtle2
01-19-2016, 12:08 PM
The Barnes and Noble website has Dan Duncan listed as the author!?
Hahahhaha:lol:lolololololozzzz
myconius
01-19-2016, 12:44 PM
The Barnes and Noble website has Dan Duncan listed as the author!?
at least they didn't do a mix up like i've seen on Amazon where they list someone who had absolutely NO involvement or relevance whatsoever. :/
myconius
01-19-2016, 12:53 PM
finally up to Turtles in Time.
the read-through a second time is SO much richer of an experience!
there are so many little nuances i missed along the way the first time!
like in issue #37 when Krang and Shredder go back and forth about their previous "meeting", i really was unclear about them referring to later portions of 'Secret History of the Foot Clan'.
or other nice little layers they weave into the story here and there.
and i do have to say that having read 'Casey & April' (back when it came out) as i re-read issue #36 it makes a lot more sense to me now.
turtlefan27
01-19-2016, 09:45 PM
I just re-read 1-5 yesterday and here's a few things that stood out to me that didn't the last time I read them..
Issue #1 page one guy appears to have a krang tshirt on. Page five the guy getting kicked by Leo has no face. Page 12 does krang have business partners with other companies other than stockgen and if so what do they do? Something is apparently going on due to the ships around the island.
Issue #2 only 3 things stick out to me. 1 is when splinter get thrown off the top of that building and the turtles are dropped off of it shouldn't that had killed them? Maybe I'm just nitpicking a tad. 2 is the cops arrived there super quick. And 3 if they are with April and heard yelling in a different room and then didn't see anyone there shouldn't they have known that someone was there and is now probably on the run??yet again probably just nitpicking..
Issue 4 page 16 why are the guys just leaving raph behind?
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 02:09 AM
Been rereading the series. The first 5 issues really bring back a lot of nostalgia (which is surprising cause this series is only 4 years old) from 2011. This pre-dates the Nick cartoon so I remember all the speculation back then.
Some people thought the Turtles were humans turned turtle (instead of reincarnated from ancient Japan), and everyone was wondering why the Turtles were teenagers, knew martial arts, and could speak already. The reincarnation origin is brilliant in retrospect.
I also really like April naming the Turtles, something I had forgotten about. Its also interesting to see Old Hob back when he was just a henchmen and tied into the Turtles origin.
Also love Dan Duncan's art.
myconius
01-20-2016, 05:45 PM
Been rereading the series. The first 5 issues really bring back a lot of nostalgia (which is surprising cause this series is only 4 years old) from 2011. This pre-dates the Nick cartoon so I remember all the speculation back then.
Some people thought the Turtles were humans turned turtle (instead of reincarnated from ancient Japan), and everyone was wondering why the Turtles were teenagers, knew martial arts, and could speak already. The reincarnation origin is brilliant in retrospect.
I also really like April naming the Turtles, something I had forgotten about. Its also interesting to see Old Hob back when he was just a henchmen and tied into the Turtles origin.
Also love Dan Duncan's art.
yeah right! for such a short period of 4 years so much has happened with the TMNT franchise, as well as comics in general.
i must admit when i heard TMNT was getting a reboot i was rather suspect of what we were getting especially since it was from a comic company i never really heard of before. but i'm SO glad i gave into my Ninja Turtle addiction and started reading the IDW series! one of the best decisions i've ever made as far as collecting new comics!!
yeah this comic series pre-dated the Nick series AND the Michael Bay movie, so there was a LOT of speculation!
the reincarnation was very jarring at first, but in hind-sight was one of the best decisions they made from a story stand point!
it definitely helped flesh out the characters backstory, and added SO many layers!
it's amazing how many times that execution scene of Yoshi and his Sons has been revisited, and it's always just as impactful!
that page of April telling Chet what she had named the Turtles was brilliant!
i loved how each Turtle even before Mutation was acting in character! :tlol:
most definitely!!! Duncan ROCKS!!!! :D
ProphetofGanja
01-20-2016, 08:29 PM
...and plus getting the full dose of Mateus Santolouco's art is just amazing!!!
it's SO dynamic and action packed! some of the panels really look like they were taken from a high-quality Anime! ^__^...
I have been dreaming about a Santolouco-style TMNT anime since he first took on art duties for the series
at least I can still dream
myconius
01-20-2016, 08:39 PM
I have been dreaming about a Santolouco-style TMNT anime since he first took on art duties for the series
at least I can still dream
i hear you on that!!!
as soon as i saw Santolouco's art in immediately reminded me of the Animation house that turned out Cowboy Bebop and Samurai Champloo!
i'd totally go Berserk if there was a Ninja Turtle anime put out by them!!!
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 08:55 PM
Its so funny to see how all the mutants went from lackies in the beginning of the book to what they are now:
Old Hob was Baxter's henchmutant. He spends the first 12 issues losing fights to Splinter/Turtles over and over and being bosses around and nearly killed. Now he's the leader of the Mutanimals.
Alopex was just a one-dimensional henchmutant of Shredder....now she's an actual character with likes/dislikes and a dynamic with Raphael.
Slash had no personality and was just a raging killing machine monster. Now he's an actual character and has a conscience.
Then there's Hun who started off just as Casey's abusive father, heh.
myconius
01-20-2016, 09:04 PM
almost forgot to mention my re-read of Northampton over the weekend.
absolutely LOVE that arc!!!
it really made City Fall feel worth it to me, just to get to this point!
the interactions of the characters was so heartfelt!
plus i really enjoyed the spiritual visits from Tang Shen!
and not to mention just how MAGNIFICENT Sophie Campbell's art is!!!
that very last page of issue #31 :o
https://retconpunchdotcom.files.wordpress.com/2014/02/leonardo-returns.jpg?w=593
when i first saw that panel the hairs stood on the back of my neck!!! :D
afterwards i got to re-indulge in Santalouco's awesome art in #33-40.
i swear that guy can make a single panel look like a splash page!!!
i was a bit confused with the placement of the 2014 annual and Turtles in Time?
it almost seems to me like Turtles in Time should follow directly AFTER the 2014 Annual, since Renet said the Turtles were bouncing through time after their last adventure when they were "accidentally oversaturated with Quantum Particles".
myconius
01-20-2016, 09:08 PM
Its so funny to see how all the mutants went from lackies in the beginning of the book to what they are now:
Old Hob was Baxter's henchmutant. He spends the first 12 issues losing fights to Splinter/Turtles over and over and being bosses around and nearly killed. Now he's the leader of the Mutanimals.
Alopex was just a one-dimensional henchmutant of Shredder....now she's an actual character with likes/dislikes and a dynamic with Raphael.
Slash had no personality and was just a raging killing machine monster. Now he's an actual character and has a conscience.
Then there's Hun who started off just as Casey's abusive father, heh.
i have to admit i DID NOT see that set up for Hun right under our noses!!!! :D
when they first did that reveal it was like :o
same with Chet/Honeycutt!!!
but Hob really did a complete turnaround!!!
i used to really hate his guts, but now i love that despicable furry critter!! :D
old_hob88
01-20-2016, 09:10 PM
Just finished rereading the first 5 issues and "a lot to learn". It is fun seeing how much Hob changes from that era. He was really just a dim, one-dimensional character then, but he's become one of my favorite all-time TMNT characters.
I also really enjoy "Attack Lot to Learn". It really helps to flesh out the time right after Raph's return and show his adjustment.
I really wish the ongoing would throw some stories like this as back-ups to the ongoing. I honestly feel Casey & April could have been well executed as a back-up running along with vengeance.
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 09:30 PM
Don't forget to read the Infestation 2 parter. IDW never collected those issues and they're not on the timelime either which is bizarre.
They take place after the first arc.
myconius
01-20-2016, 09:32 PM
Just finished rereading the first 5 issues and "a lot to learn". It is fun seeing how much Hob changes from that era. He was really just a dim, one-dimensional character then, but he's become one of my favorite all-time TMNT characters.
I also really enjoy "Attack Lot to Learn". It really helps to flesh out the time right after Raph's return and show his adjustment.
I really wish the ongoing would throw some stories like this as back-ups to the ongoing. I honestly feel Casey & April could have been well executed as a back-up running along with vengeance.
the Hob micro definitely stands out as one of my absolute favorite villain/micro-series!!
it's so hard to read that intro and not get misty-eyed!
i really wish 'a lot to learn' was printed into the collected editions!
sure it's only a few pages long, but it just adds so much to those early issues!
i'm very curious what it'll be like once i re-read Casey & April??
but for now i'm up to TMNT/Ghostbusters.
myconius
01-20-2016, 09:39 PM
Don't forget to read the Infestation 2 parter. IDW never collected those issues and they're not on the timelime either which is bizarre.
They take place after the first arc.
good point!
what's funny is i had completely FORGOT anything about Infestation 2 (parts 1 & 2) having read them SO long ago.
so before i decided to do this entire series re-read, i had JUST read Infestation 2 a few weeks earlier.
it was definitely entertaining, but i wish they had done a bit more with it.
maybe i didn't get it as much because it was a tie-in to a larger event?
Powder
01-20-2016, 09:40 PM
i really wish 'a lot to learn' was printed into the collected editions!
Isn't it in the latest one (HC Collection), or am I imagining things?
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 09:41 PM
Its essentially filler, but its a good Turtles Vs. Monsters story that hasn't been done in the series otherwise
myconius
01-20-2016, 09:51 PM
Isn't it in the latest one (HC Collection), or am I imagining things?
i just dug out my IDW Collection, and i stand corrected. :lol:
Its essentially filler, but its a good Turtles Vs. Monsters story that hasn't been done in the series otherwise
true! i do enjoy the freakish hell monsters the Turtles fight in that one!
needs more hacking and slashing gore IMO, but definitely a keeper!! :D
old_hob88
01-20-2016, 09:54 PM
I really enjoy the infestation 2 tie-in, mostly cuz I'm a huge fan of lovecraft and the cthulhu mythos.
Also I rather enjoy Mark Torres' artwork.
Hopefully I'll get a chance to read that tomorrow
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 11:24 PM
The only IDW story skippable is that ridiculous X-files crossover, I honestly forget it exists because its only 1 issue.
old_hob88
01-21-2016, 05:12 AM
The only IDW story skippable is that ridiculous X-files crossover, I honestly forget it exists because its only 1 issue.
It's for the best if we do forget it exists lol
Powder
01-21-2016, 06:30 AM
I thought it was harmless fun with decent art, personally.
myconius
01-21-2016, 07:39 AM
The only IDW story skippable is that ridiculous X-files crossover, I honestly forget it exists because its only 1 issue.
that x-files cross-over was the only IDW TMNT i've ever shipped!
i really wanted to try to get into it, but i just couldn't bring myself to.
i flipped through it when it came out and didn't see much Ninja Turtles in it, and since i know nothing of the X-Files i decided to overlook it.
i just finished re-reading TMNT/Ghostbusters last night.
with the exception of Casey getting possessed, i really forgot so much about what happened in that series!
the art is so damn beautiful!!!!
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/0/6063/4346765-tmnt_gb_04-pr-page-006.jpg
it looks like a still from a Ralf Bakshi or Don Bluth production!!
i'd really like to see this artist do another TMNT story! :)
It's for the best if we do forget it exists lol
so i shouldn't feel too bad for skipping it?? :lol:
old_hob88
01-21-2016, 08:28 AM
so i shouldn't feel too bad for skipping it?? :lol:
I was never into X-files so it did nothing for me. I personally wish I would have skipped it. It's 4 dollars I'll never get back lol. And it's non-canon anyways
myconius
01-21-2016, 10:15 AM
I was never into X-files so it did nothing for me. I personally wish I would have skipped it. It's 4 dollars I'll never get back lol. And it's non-canon anyways
hahaha!!! true! 4 bucks is almost enough to get a decent burger! :D
the closest i've ever gotten to actually getting into the x-files was when they were on The Simpsons.
and even then it was ALL about Homer!!!
nothing against x-files fans, but i just don't see it!
i'm not really huge into Mars Attacks or anything, but i think that would have made for a much more exciting cross-over with TMNT?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-21-2016, 10:38 AM
The best thing about IDW crossovers is that they don't derail the main story and they're not 100% essential to the main story. If you skip it, you're okay. But if you don't, hey, you get good stories!
Infestation? totally skippable, but pretty decent.
X-Files? totally skippable, pretty meh from what I've heard.
Ghostbusters? you COULD skip it, but if Chi-You ever comes back you'll wish you hadn't... and a damn good story to boot.
Compare that to the kind of crossover stories Marvel and DC do: derailing every comic series, going on for months, and half the time, doing nothing worth reading anyway.
ProphetofGanja
01-21-2016, 10:42 AM
I thought it was harmless fun with decent art, personally.
same here
I thought it was pretty decent, but then again I'm a fan of events where the conclusion of said event causes the event to have never occurred in the first place, as was the case with the whole X-Files crossover.
and I have this crossover to thank for getting me to watch The X-Files, so there's that. excited to see new episodes Sunday!
CyberCubed
01-21-2016, 12:59 PM
Infestation isn't even a crossover, there aren't any non-TMNT characters in those 2-issues. It was an event that had monsters appear in all of IDW's other comics at the time, but the 2 TMNT issues aren't a crossover.
The Ghostbusters crossover is definitely important, it ties directly into the main story arc with Kitsune.
Also the Batman crossover is canon and nobody can tell me otherwise. :lol:
myconius
01-21-2016, 06:05 PM
i find most of the IDW TMNT mini-series definitely add something to the lore, if not just for entertainment value alone.
it was the multi-title events and cross-overs that got me to stop collecting Marvel so many years ago, and DC is not too far behind with getting on my last nerve with crap-tacular cross-overs.
but you definitely are right Cylons, they really are not worth reading!
Cube has a good point, most of the TMNT side stories aren't cross-overs, but they are all mini-series.
and even though some are much better than others, more more often than not they are worth reading.
now this Batman/TMNT .... this is just the most amazing mash-up ever!!!
i like the fact that it has been said that it is not canon, yet both sets of characters appear exactly as they do in their respected ongoing comic series! :D
CyberCubed
01-21-2016, 08:29 PM
I never knew Koya made her first appearance as a normal bird landing on Shredder's arm in Cityfall. I had thought she appeared for the first time mutated in Northampton, but you see her as a bird and Shredder calls it Koya in City Fall.
That's another thing nobody would notice the first time around.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-21-2016, 10:25 PM
I never knew Koya made her first appearance as a normal bird landing on Shredder's arm in Cityfall. I had thought she appeared for the first time mutated in Northampton, but you see her as a bird and Shredder calls it Koya in City Fall.
That's another thing nobody would notice the first time around.
I noticed it the first time. :trazz:
Joey Kamikaze
01-22-2016, 12:08 AM
i was a bit confused with the placement of the 2014 annual and Turtles in Time?
it almost seems to me like Turtles in Time should follow directly AFTER the 2014 Annual, since Renet said the Turtles were bouncing through time after their last adventure when they were "accidentally oversaturated with Quantum Particles".
Turtles In Time does indeed take place chronologically after the 2014 Annual. The 2014 Annual's publication was just delayed from its original date; it was originally supposed to hit the streets first. I think its official placement is between "Northampton" and "Monsters, Misfits and Madmen."
Also, personally, the Infestation 2 tie-in was one of my favorite parts of the first year and I was kinda bummed it wasn't included in the hardcover collection. Those issues reminded me of something out of Tales.
CyberCubed
01-22-2016, 01:24 AM
Since Tristan Jones wrote those two Infestation issues its obvious why. Honestly if you ignore the color bandanas that story would fit into the Mirage universe perfectly. Splinter was even colored brown in those issues instead of gray like he is in the IDW series.
myconius
01-22-2016, 12:25 PM
i'll be honest i DID NOT pick up on Koya the first read!
and when i saw that on the second time through it was a pretty nice surprise!
i wish TMNT Infestation 2 had more to it that just the 2 issues!!
it seemed like it ended just as it was getting started.
it could have used at least one more issue?
(and more gore! LOTS MORE gore!!!) :D
CyberCubed
01-22-2016, 12:27 PM
Its also weird the Infestation 2-parter was never referenced again. In the main ongoing you always see them bring up events from them micros and mini's (and you get an asterisk telling you to see those issues), but the Infestation monsters were never brought up.
Even those awful TMNT Annual #1 characters like Kanada, those cops, that Irish guy, and those others boring characters showed up again in City Fall.
myconius
01-22-2016, 12:42 PM
yeah, it really feels like it wasn't canon!
plus the fact that it never made the IDW collection!
myconius
01-22-2016, 12:44 PM
Turtles In Time does indeed take place chronologically after the 2014 Annual. The 2014 Annual's publication was just delayed from its original date; it was originally supposed to hit the streets first. I think its official placement is between "Northampton" and "Monsters, Misfits and Madmen."
ah! thank you!
i had a feeling it was, but just wasn't sure! :)
CyberCubed
01-22-2016, 12:44 PM
The strange thing is Bobby has said those issues are canon too, yet they're never referenced.
myconius
01-22-2016, 12:52 PM
i guess it'll have to be classified like most of the continuity of "The Big Two"
a 'canon event' that has occurred but ....
A- doesn't have any lasting effect on any other stories
B- doesn't really coincide with any other story
C- never gets mentioned again :lol:
and the sad thing is that sort of thing happens ALL TOO often with both Marvel and DC.
MikeandRaph87
01-22-2016, 01:27 PM
I have now read through issue 4. Raphael being separated eas supposed to play off his anger and loner issues. Hob wanted a rurtle for food? I just don't see that. Would have preferred another way to fit in Hob. Turtles foghting to kill a gang? It's too Image for me. The ploy of all wearing red to honor Raphael while he is M. I. A. then putting on their favorite color? Another thing you have to just shut your brain off about. It was atill hard to get into even with a dew years past.
I did like the set up of the Turtles reuniting similar to how they came to Raphael and Casey Jones' aide in Meet Casey Jones episode of the 2003 cartoon and respective comic. It was interesting to have them meet Casey Jones first. It also shows how Old Hob has grown from being a bully who lives to kill the Turtles to having his own unique family trying to do what he thinks is right even if it is not so. One element remained in that instead of intimidating a group of teenage thugs to surround himself with and give orders to he has mutants like him he cares about. It's the fact he needs someone to lead and surround himself with.
CyberCubed
01-22-2016, 01:37 PM
The Turtles weren't trying to kill Hob's gang, what are you talking about? Splinter specifically forbids them to kill. That's brought up time and time in the series.
myconius
01-22-2016, 03:21 PM
yeah, Leo actually stopped Raph from crossing the line with Hob in issue #4.
i'm not 100% sure how i feel about the Turtles "no kill" policy?
but so far the only time one had come close was Leo with Slash, but that was an accident and Slash lived anyway.
HECK! Leo didn't even kill when he was brainwashed by Shredder!!!
the reasoning for the brothers all wearing red ...
sure it was a bit of a stretch ...
sure it might've been a bit hokey ...
but i still thought it was pretty cool! :D
CyberCubed
01-23-2016, 02:29 AM
I've re-read everything up until Attack on Technodrome so far. I'm amazed how many plot points are called back to and aren't forgotten, and how much great set-up there is for the villains.
We know all about Shredder and Krang's backstory for example. So much focus on Hun, and Old Hob, and a bit on Baxter and Karai. April's stolen ooze heals her father, Hob's mutagen mutates more Mutanimals, Karai's stolen mutagen makes Bebop/Rocksteady and Koya/Bludgeon.
Angel becoming Nobody, Alopex becoming good, all the focus on Metalhead of all things. Fugitoid and the Neutrinos struggle, the set up with Kitsune and The Rat King.
Man, reading everything back to back really makes you realize what a great series this is and how everything ties together. I can't believe how many iconic TMNT characters they've introduced and reinvented and how many new characters too in such a short time (closing in on 5 years), etc.
TristanHuwJones
01-24-2016, 05:05 AM
i'll be honest i DID NOT pick up on Koya the first read!
and when i saw that on the second time through it was a pretty nice surprise!
i wish TMNT Infestation 2 had more to it that just the 2 issues!!
it seemed like it ended just as it was getting started.
it could have used at least one more issue?
(and more gore! LOTS MORE gore!!!) :D
I'm pretty sure Nickelodeon wanted it swept under the rug. We butted heads. It wasn't as fun an experience as I'd hoped it would be. The second issue had a lot of 11th hour rewrites and was changed into something pretty different from what was originally intended because mid way through my working on it there was a change in the management at Nick. What I originally wrote had a lot more ambiguity to it. It was as Lovecraftian as I could make it, but the new powers at Nick didn't like it, and at this point the OLD powers-that-be had signed off on it. We basically had to rewrite the second half to completely change the story at the last minute because Nickelodeon suddenly had a direction they were taking the brand in. I get it, and from what I understand a lot of those teething problems from the early days are long, long gone, I just wish things were a little different then. It didn't help that I was juggling art on Ghostbusters and hadn't written in years, so I was lagging and some of the problems we had to work around basically made me lock up because I couldn't think of a decent way around it, but that first issue is one of my favourite things I've worked on.
Funnily enough, I wrote it as a Mirage story. The first draft actually opened like an issue of Tales with the whole "Let me tell you a story..." thing. There was actually art that had all four Turtles with their red masks, too. That was changed when it was decided they'd change in the comics, but I think this story ended up coming out just before the change happened in the main story. I do remember taking a small amount of heat for it online too.
Thanks for the kind words on it, too!
myconius
01-24-2016, 07:31 AM
I've re-read everything up until Attack on Technodrome so far. I'm amazed how many plot points are called back to and aren't forgotten, and how much great set-up there is for the villains.
We know all about Shredder and Krang's backstory for example. So much focus on Hun, and Old Hob, and a bit on Baxter and Karai. April's stolen ooze heals her father, Hob's mutagen mutates more Mutanimals, Karai's stolen mutagen makes Bebop/Rocksteady and Koya/Bludgeon.
Angel becoming Nobody, Alopex becoming good, all the focus on Metalhead of all things. Fugitoid and the Neutrinos struggle, the set up with Kitsune and The Rat King.
Man, reading everything back to back really makes you realize what a great series this is and how everything ties together. I can't believe how many iconic TMNT characters they've introduced and reinvented and how many new characters too in such a short time (closing in on 5 years), etc.
that's something i've been very impressed by in my re-read is how many plot points get placed early on that later develop into the story arcs.
there was so much treachery from Shredder it's no wonder why Krang wanted to kill him?
and i'm even seeing so many scenes with Kitsune as well as The Rat King that we have yet to discover where they are going?
i can really see how with all of the story-lines and characters developing over the years, how this series has easily become my #1 favorite comic series each month.
i finally finished with the remaining books in my re-read, (Mutanimals, Casey & April, all issues up to #53)
as much as i loved it the first time i was able to appreciate it a LOT more this time!
still wasn't any easier to see all the suffering poor Donatello had to go through!
it made for a truly compelling story, but i'm really relieved that it's now resolved.
and looking at the relationship of Hamato Yoshi and Oroku Saki re-reading this as a whole, makes a LOT more sense why they share so many kind words to each other at the very end.
myconius
01-24-2016, 07:44 AM
I'm pretty sure Nickelodeon wanted it swept under the rug. We butted heads. It wasn't as fun an experience as I'd hoped it would be. The second issue had a lot of 11th hour rewrites and was changed into something pretty different from what was originally intended because mid way through my working on it there was a change in the management at Nick. What I originally wrote had a lot more ambiguity to it. It was as Lovecraftian as I could make it, but the new powers at Nick didn't like it, and at this point the OLD powers-that-be had signed off on it. We basically had to rewrite the second half to completely change the story at the last minute because Nickelodeon suddenly had a direction they were taking the brand in. I get it, and from what I understand a lot of those teething problems from the early days are long, long gone, I just wish things were a little different then. It didn't help that I was juggling art on Ghostbusters and hadn't written in years, so I was lagging and some of the problems we had to work around basically made me lock up because I couldn't think of a decent way around it, but that first issue is one of my favourite things I've worked on.
Funnily enough, I wrote it as a Mirage story. The first draft actually opened like an issue of Tales with the whole "Let me tell you a story..." thing. There was actually art that had all four Turtles with their red masks, too. That was changed when it was decided they'd change in the comics, but I think this story ended up coming out just before the change happened in the main story. I do remember taking a small amount of heat for it online too.
Thanks for the kind words on it, too!
you are most welcome, and thank you for that in-depth explanation!
it does make a lot more sense now how things turned out in the second issue.
but that really is a shame though, i guess we'll just have to use our imaginations to what could have been?
that is really funny what you said about taking the Mirage direction with the story as there's been much speculation about that! ...and now we finally know!!! :D
that 'Tales of the TMNT' intro would have been TOO awesome!!!!!! :D
thank you again for sharing that!
CyberCubed
01-25-2016, 03:40 PM
Finished my re-read up to issue 52. The whole final battle with Shredder on the rooftop was gorgeous. Awesome art, great battle. I also like how IDW Shredder isn't overpowered, the Turtles already beat him once before, Krang nearly killed him, I like it when Shredder isn't portrayed as invincible like he is in the Nick cartoon.
Seems like Karai is going to turn to the side of good, and Bebop/Rocksteady were kicked out of the Foot Clan. I had forgotten Koya/Bludgeon are still with the Foot though, I thought they left as well. Surprised we haven't seen them in issues 51-53...
One thing that kinda bothers me is how often Angel/Alopex come to the rescue of the Turtles. Angel is starting to feel a little Mary-Sueish ever since she became Nobody, and it seems like she's always there helping out the guys. I like Angel but I hope they tone it down a bit and she's not used so much anymore.
old_hob88
01-25-2016, 07:26 PM
Finished my re-read up to issue 52. The whole final battle with Shredder on the rooftop was gorgeous. Awesome art, great battle. I also like how IDW Shredder isn't overpowered, the Turtles already beat him once before, Krang nearly killed him, I like it when Shredder isn't portrayed as invincible like he is in the Nick cartoon.
Seems like Karai is going to turn to the side of good, and Bebop/Rocksteady were kicked out of the Foot Clan. I had forgotten Koya/Bludgeon are still with the Foot though, I thought they left as well. Surprised we haven't seen them in issues 51-53...
One thing that kinda bothers me is how often Angel/Alopex come to the rescue of the Turtles. Angel is starting to feel a little Mary-Sueish ever since she became Nobody, and it seems like she's always there helping out the guys. I like Angel but I hope they tone it down a bit and she's not used so much anymore.
Koya and Bludgeon travelled to Japan with Karai, so we'll see them when she returns more than likely.
MsMarvelDuckie
01-25-2016, 10:08 PM
Actually, I just finished reading #51 earlier, and Koya and Bludgeon are still with Splinter and the rest of the Foot. They didn't go to Japan with Karai- they are shown in a panel in front of Splinter on the "throne". So they are still there. I don't think he really knows what to do with them, though.
CyberCubed
01-26-2016, 02:58 PM
#51 takes place at least a month after #50....so Karai/Bludgeon/Koya went to Japan and returned already.
Bobby Curnow
01-26-2016, 03:14 PM
Koya and Bludgeon are in Japan with Karai now. That scene in #51 was a flashback to immediately after #50, when Splinter took control of the Foot, sort of a crowning ceremony. We thought it was more clear and could be inferred, but I can see how it is not.
MikeandRaph87
01-26-2016, 03:45 PM
I have reread through #12 now.
I felt that the M.O.U.S.E.R.S. arc went on for one issue too long. The other plots were more interesting from Shredder kidnapping Splinter for Hob since both of them wanted the wise rat though for different reasons. It seeds the different goals of Shredder and Krang and shows that despite the dialogue those two share they are best as two separate enemies and create a great three way war easily one uping the TMNT/Triceraton/Federation three way struggle easily.
I like how Karai is being used. She is still Shredder's relative, but she is the one responsible for everything by reviving her ancestor. The Shredder/SPlinter dynamic on the first read was weird, but I like the exchange. I feel like pitting Splinter against one of Shredder's best soldiers was unnecessary as Saki should know by word exchange and demeanor. But hey we need action to drive the plot ot get to the turtles first fight with Shredder.
I question what a few thugs playing neighborhood watch are going to do against ninjas other than even some of the odds against the Turtles. I could see Splinter wanting them to leave so not to involve them and have their blood on his hands. The action sequences however were done very well as well as the battle's ending. A clear finish but know there is more to come.
Like with Karai, it was a good set up with Alopex. Really all the characters were set up well. I just did not like the tone of the first few issue and second arc drawn on a little longer. Then once Shredder's arc taken directly from the previous starts its skyrocket to the quality it is. Like any title it takes time to build and I am glad I went form skeptical to eager for the next issue as soon as I get the new one.
CyberCubed
01-26-2016, 03:51 PM
Wasn't the Mousers part only issues 7-9 or so? I know 10-12 is the climax with Shredder.
MikeandRaph87
01-26-2016, 04:00 PM
Wasn't the Mousers part only issues 7-9 or so? I know 10-12 is the climax with Shredder.
1-4, introduce characters, Raph meets Casey, vs Hob and his gang of humans. Splinter takes Casey in.
5-reincarnation origin, Mike, Leo, and Don receive their different mask.
6-9- Savate opposition to Shredder introduced and Splinter is made aware of the Foot's reemergence in modern day. TMNT and Casey go after Hob who wants revenge for humiliating defeat by working for Baxter overseeing M.O.U.S.E.R. attack on their lair. Karai appears to transition to #10-12.
10-12- Hob reports to Baxter that Karai takes Splinter for her own reason as Foot break into his lab a 2nd time angering Krang. Baxter gets sample anyway through Hob. Splinter realizes the lab brought back his opposition within the Foot after testing Splinter. Splinter order a no kill policy with Shredder the exception. Casey's friends the Purple Dragons reformed as a neighborhood watch help. TMNT hold their own, but escape to fight another day. Lair compromised they relocate to the 2nd Time Around Shop for three issues.
Joey Kamikaze
01-27-2016, 09:13 PM
Just to split hairs, Splinter accepts Casey's place as the family's first human friend right away, but Casey doesn't come to live with them until "Sins of the Fathers" (his micro and #13-14).
Speaking of which, I forgot and this seems to be a good place to ask... where is Casey living in the current part of the run? Still with the turtles? With the O'Neils at the shop? I don't remember.
Last time I did a re-read I wrote up my thoughts on the first year and a half or so (main and side stuff) here (https://templeofthesmilingjackalope.wordpress.com/2014/04/05/lets-talk-turtles/) and here (https://templeofthesmilingjackalope.wordpress.com/2014/10/20/lets-talk-turtles-2-abusers-and-mutants-and-aliens-oh-my/). Got distracted before I did the rest and at this point I need to do another re-read... :lol:
myconius
01-27-2016, 09:16 PM
Casey is staying with the O'neils at the shop.
CyberCubed
01-27-2016, 10:29 PM
Casey also apparently flunked out of school and doesn't bother going to it anymore. April's still in College though.
Joey Kamikaze
01-28-2016, 12:14 AM
Yeah, I'm expecting some kind of twist with both April and Casey in the next few issues. Originally I expected that in the miniseries... but you know, then something would have had to actually happen in that book. :lol:
CyberCubed
01-28-2016, 12:23 AM
I'm still expecting Casey/April to break up, and Casey to hook up with Angel for a while. They'll probably revert back to the April/Casey pairing for the endgame, but Casey/Angel has some potential in this series.
Seriously, you can tell Angel likes Casey a lot but doesn't go further because she knows he's with April.
myconius
01-28-2016, 06:50 AM
even though it's sad to see Casey flunking out of school and see his dreams of playing Hokey dashed before his eyes, at least he's being proactive in becoming the Hot-Headed Urban enforcer Vigilante that we've always known and loved! :D
if April and Casey DO break up, i hope he stays single instead of having to be shipped off with another character.
seeing Angel's reaction to Casey's in issue #52 she seemed pretty put off by his behavior.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-29-2016, 08:21 PM
Maybe, just maybe, Angel is this series' Gabrielle? I know she's already Nobody...
CyberCubed
01-29-2016, 09:27 PM
I'd rather not see Angel die in child labor.
myconius
01-29-2016, 10:03 PM
the IDW series isn't exactly following the Mirage plot enough to really need to include Gabrielle.
in fact the way the Mirage series ended, i'd much rather it not!!!
CyberCubed
01-31-2016, 12:40 AM
I wonder if they'll work in the Shredder clones in some day now that Shredder is dead.
Shark_Blade
01-31-2016, 02:16 AM
Casey to hook up with Angel for a while.
Ew, no. That feels like incest. Casey's been taking care of Angel since she's young, he's like a brother to her. Now you want them to date? ugh.
CyberCubed
01-31-2016, 02:17 AM
Apparently you never realized the whole childhood friends turned lovers is quite common in fiction.
Technogeek29
01-31-2016, 02:20 AM
Casey and Angel hooking up is about as likely as Leo and Karai (IDW version) hooking it up. In other words I don't see that happening.
myconius
01-31-2016, 11:35 AM
in the IDW series i don't see Leonardo and Karai hooking up in a romantic sense, but it should be interesting to see how they interact with one another now that they are both technically members of the Foot Clan.
Powder
01-31-2016, 11:51 AM
Casey and Angel hooking up is about as likely as Leo and Karai (IDW version) hooking it up. In other words I don't see that happening.
But Casey & Angel have 20 years of history together, they think highly of one another, & if I'm not mistaken, there were some hints of interest on her end earlier in the series. Karai & Leo on the other hand have barely had any interaction outside of violence & hostility.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.