PDA

View Full Version : Mirage vs IDW (part Uno)


Allio
01-16-2016, 07:40 PM
you know what, let's do it. let's have a vote of which was better between Mirage and IDW...though for this, it will only be part 1 of both series (Vol 1. Mirage vs Up to 50 of IDW)

MikeandRaph87
01-16-2016, 07:42 PM
IDW started off slow, but by their first fight with Shredder I saw sold. Beyond RTNY I don't care for Mirage. In other words IDW wins this handily for me.

Mewzard
01-16-2016, 08:57 PM
I have to go with Mirage Volume 1.

IDW might be more consistently good, but the Eastman and Laird issues alone are the absolute pinnacle of TMNT to me.

That said, IDW is quite enjoyable and I've just begun rereading it today (read issue 1 earlier).

mrmaczaps
01-16-2016, 09:22 PM
Mirage, the origin of the Turtles... Eastman & Laird together. The more mature look of their Turtles (& most of the others drawing them in the later issues)...

IDW is a great read and a great mishmash of all previous incarnations, but it wouldn't be without Mirage.

CyberCubed
01-16-2016, 09:53 PM
If we're speaking as a whole, IDW, but in terms of the best Mirage stories (#1-11, Return to New York, City at War, and maybe of the one-shots), than Mirage.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-16-2016, 11:18 PM
If we're speaking as a whole, IDW, but in terms of the best Mirage stories (#1-11, Return to New York, City at War, and maybe of the one-shots), than Mirage.

He doesn't do it often, but by all that's holy, Cubed spoke MY EXACT OPINION. It's bizarre.

...

Maybe Cubed is me from a parallel reality. :teek:

Nortock Diab
01-17-2016, 05:07 AM
Mirage with no hesitation (1-11, RTNY, City at War, guest issues such as The River...).
From what I read of IDW, it is good yet rather tasteless compared to Mirage vol.1.

The real turtles are and will always be Mirage's anyway :tgrin:.

Candy Kappa
01-17-2016, 05:44 AM
I prefer Mirage over IDW.

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-17-2016, 05:41 PM
A well written saga in full color with all the characters I love....yeah, no brainer here.

Powder
01-17-2016, 09:57 PM
Do you have to put down Mirage every time you bring it up? :trolleye:

myconius
01-17-2016, 10:54 PM
as much as i absolutely love the IDW TMNT, Mirage Studios was the Genesis of something truly amazing!!!

without that series, none of these conversations would even be happening right now!

i will have to also add the IDW series earns extra love for keeping the franchise going and gaining momentum (as does the Nick Cartoon)
but the Black and White comics are what i first fell in love with, and still enjoy reading over and over today!

Cipher
01-18-2016, 01:31 AM
I dropped off with IDW before #50, though I've read most of it.

It's a fine series and will undoubtedly be a more thrilling read for a certain type of audience. But nothing in it has left me feeling one tenth of what "City at War" or even one-offs like "Sons of the Silent Age" provide.

Casey
01-18-2016, 07:16 PM
Wow Allio, you really are a mad scientist. I just can't vote. I can't do it.

TMNTChris1980
01-18-2016, 09:03 PM
Mirage, the Volume 1 stuff is just perfect TMNT.

I really liked IDW a lot in the beginning. Now I'm not as into it. Before it was a new take on the TMNT that I really dug. Now it is like they're trying to make a PG-13 version of the Nick toon.The art has gotten softer. Hoping that it starts getting darker with harsher artwork...if that makes any sense.

Powder
01-18-2016, 09:27 PM
Now it is like they're trying to make a PG-13 version of the Nick toon.The art has gotten softer. Hoping that it starts getting darker with harsher artwork...if that makes any sense.

What color is the sky in your world?

http://i68.tinypic.com/34612jm.png

discordiatookie
01-19-2016, 02:11 AM
Wow, that's a very close poll. 19 - 18 with Mirage winning as I write this. Great testament for IDW, they're doing awesome things with the book. I did vote Mirage, I have a great love for those stories.

shuriken
01-19-2016, 06:35 AM
My mind says IDW but my heart says Mirage. gotta go with Mirage

TMNachoT
01-19-2016, 07:47 AM
Mirage anytime but not the guess era

myconius
01-19-2016, 01:00 PM
i had to vote Mirage Vol. 1, but both comic series are awesome!!!

reading some people's opinions on the subject... there are some very "interesting" points of view out there!!! :lol:

MrTrikey
01-19-2016, 06:09 PM
IDW, but only by the slimmest of margins.

I guess what it really boiled down to was how I feel like IDW made sure that every central character felt fully realized, and still had a good deal of energy left over to roll over to secondary characters like Hob, Stockman, Angel, Slash and so on. Even Eastman & Laird admitted that while Leo, Raph and Don got their fair share of development, it took a while for Mikey to really get up to speed and stop being an auxiliary character who played off of his bros. And he was part of the main four!

Still, Volume 1 is still very much a classic. And there's nothing changing that! :D

TMNTChris1980
01-19-2016, 10:41 PM
What color is the sky in your world?

http://i68.tinypic.com/34612jm.png


Besides that, you have to admit there was a lot of fluffy stuff before that. There was only 2 times that it went dark.

Mikey is way more OT style now. Before he was slightly funny, but not goofy, like he is now.

Duncan's early art had a Mirage vibe to it. It seems like a lot of the art now is very close to the Nick toon.

Powder
01-19-2016, 10:49 PM
The only stuff I'd consider somewhat cute would be Sophie's work, but the book hardly suffered for it (quite the opposite, for me). That style was perfectly suited to the mood/tone of it's time. Mikey's been like that since the beginning, I'd know because I used to ride Tom's ass about it off the jump. :tlol: Like, the guy was just born & he's already talking like a bro & playing Game-Gear. The art itself is not close to the Nick toon at all, it's just that the turtles themselves have similar designs. Besides, that's not the case across the board. Ken Garing's stuff, the various crossovers, there have been more 'old school' looking turtles along the way. Even so, having a Nick inspired aesthetic hasn't prevented the art itself from being wonderfully detailed, or violent, it's the same as it's ever been in those respects. I don't really see the neutering you speak of.

Bry
01-19-2016, 10:53 PM
It's a lot closer than I would've expected, but... gotta go Mirage. The heights of the E/L run alone (1-11 and microseries, Return to New York, and City at War) are all-time definitive to me and still hold up as the best TMNT stories out there, IMO. The fill-ins were a mixed bag, but there's enough truly great, interesting stuff in there that I wouldn't trade for anything.

I do truly love the IDW series, but there's no shame in silver here.

The Shelf
01-25-2016, 08:41 AM
I think limiting Mirage to only Vol. 1 in this poll is unfair. Personally, I just can't find much in the guest issues that I would consider very good. I think excluding those and replacing them with Vol. 2 and Tales Vol. 1 makes for a much better comparison. Since we're only comparing Vol. 1 against IDW, I have to go with IDW.

shuriken
01-25-2016, 10:48 AM
I may be in the minority but the guest issues were some of my favorite issues. Sky Highway, Twilight of the Ring and Toitle Anxiety are all boss in my book. Hell even Turtle dreams is fun and ridiculous.

CyberCubed
01-25-2016, 12:40 PM
Yeah a lot of Vol. 1's guest issues were great, don't understand the hate for some of them.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-25-2016, 12:48 PM
A perfect tie? That pretty much sums up my feelings on the subject. :tlol:

The Shelf
01-25-2016, 04:07 PM
I don't think there's a lot of hate for the guest stories so much as indifference. They're there, they exist, but they don't really contribute much. For me, if it's not canon, then I'm just not interested. I was never a big fan of "what if" stories, and I treat most of the guest books that way.

Contrast that with IDW which is so well written that even the tiniest loose threads somehow manage to tie in to everything else, and every character gets so much attention and development that not a single character feels like a waste of time. Every new story that comes out doesn't just build on what came before it but actually enhances everything that came before it.

Mirage Vol. 1 has better individual story arcs, but as a series overall I think IDW wins easily. Like I said before, though, if we allow IDW to go up against a more complete Mirage selection that includes Vol. 2 and Tales, then Mirage jumps ahead; however, I have little doubt IDW will even overtake that before long.

CyberCubed
01-25-2016, 04:11 PM
Mirage was supposed to be episodic. Aside from the big plotlines like City at War, Mirage was supposed to be a, "jump in at any time and get a full TMNT story" type of series.

That's why most issues were one-shots. Almost all of Tales (and the second run has 70 issues) was comprised of one-shots, and a few two or three part stories.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-25-2016, 04:25 PM
Mirage was supposed to be episodic. Aside from the big plotlines like City at War, Mirage was supposed to be a, "jump in at any time and get a full TMNT story" type of series.

That's why most issues were one-shots. Almost all of Tales (and the second run has 70 issues) was comprised of one-shots, and a few two or three part stories.

Only Tales Volume 2 was ever that, Cubed.

Tales Volume 1 tied in more often than not to the ongoing story in Volume 1, and Volume 1 can be divided into about three main narratives: the first 11 issues with one-shots; the Northampton arc that culminates in Return to New York; and then Masks, Leatherhead Too, Shades of Gray, and City at War. Plus a year or two of forgettable random issues, with SOME bright spots like "Sons of the Silent Age."

Volumes 2 and 4? Absolutely not at all "jump in at any time."

mrmaczaps
01-25-2016, 07:28 PM
Mirage: still better than long drawn out stories where it takes 50++++ issues for the Turtles to take down the Shredder (except, you know, Splinter takes him down)... also, trade writing. IDW suffers for this. Mirage was different. Other than City at War, most primary tales were one or two issues, they still moved the story along though. Tales v2 jumps around and still manages to add to the primary universe/narrative. Even if/when there are gaps, you didn't need to know every detail to read the next part.

But then again, all moden comics suffer from slow stories that never seem to end...

CyberCubed
01-25-2016, 07:30 PM
Mirage was never really building to some huge conclusion either, it was just showing the lives of the Turtles throughout the years.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-25-2016, 07:56 PM
Mirage was never really building to some huge conclusion either, it was just showing the lives of the Turtles throughout the years.

It never had to build to some jawdropping finale. That would've been weird. It already had a finale, "City at War." Everything after, while great at best, has been downhill from that shining moment of endgame awesome.

CyberCubed
01-25-2016, 08:02 PM
It never had to build to some jawdropping finale. That would've been weird. It already had a finale, "City at War." Everything after, while great at best, has been downhill from that shining moment of endgame awesome.

All the Old Turtle stories are as much a finale we'll get too. We already know what happens. They get old, go their separate ways and die.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-25-2016, 08:17 PM
All the Old Turtle stories are as much a finale we'll get too. We already know what happens. They get old, go their separate ways and die.

Gah, I hate that. Yay for happy endings. :tlol:

miru
09-17-2018, 09:33 PM
IDW, due to quality control preventing us from getting “Spaced Out”, Volume 4 issue 22, or the Flaming Carrot Crossover. For mixing elements so well it feels truly definitive. For the exciting new twists and turns, yet avoiding feeling as hackneyed as the Big Two.

Icegaze
09-18-2018, 05:37 PM
IDW for me, no hesitation whatsoever.
It is the superior material IMHO.

I like the artwork and storytelling better. Only thing I don’t like (in both versions actually) is the emphasis on aliens (minus kraang) and time travelling.

Zog The Magnificent
09-18-2018, 11:34 PM
I like both for different reasons, and the shared reason that they are both good stories. However, I personally have to go with IDW, for the reason that IDW is more consistently good. When Mirage is good, it tends to be really good, but when it's bad, it tends to be really bad. IDW is good throughout most of the time. Additionally, I feel it has a much more cohesive universe and story than all of the various Mirages series.

Andrew NDB
09-19-2018, 12:53 AM
Mirage. IDW might have been able to make something truly great and early on it seemed like they might, but Nickelodeon holds a tight leash on certain rather basic aspects of things that prevent it from being elevated to a higher level. And, strictly on a personal level, just way too much Fred Wolf for me to really invest myself in it or take it too seriously. But it is very impressive what they've been able to accomplish on a lot of levels.

Nortock Diab
09-19-2018, 02:21 AM
Mirage with no hesitation (1-11, RTNY, City at War, guest issues such as The River...).
From what I read of IDW, it is good yet rather tasteless compared to Mirage vol.1.

The real turtles are and will always be Mirage's anyway :tgrin:.

I'm digging through this topic like others and I just read my previous comment.

I have to say I changed my mind regarding IDW since then.
It is definitely better than "rather tasteless".
The storyline is very well built and edited, you can see the hard work in it especially when you compare to editing management with the big two which is rarely flawless.
I really enjoy reading the IDW Collection HC to get the whole picture.

However, my vote remains unchanged and I still stick to Mirage because it has more soul in my opinion.
While IDW knows where it goes, Mirage wanders and leaves more space for the reader's imagination. That is what I am looking for in my readings as I feel more active and not only fed with entertainment material :tcool:.

Andrew NDB
09-19-2018, 11:08 AM
It never had to build to some jawdropping finale. That would've been weird. It already had a finale, "City at War." Everything after, while great at best, has been downhill from that shining moment of endgame awesome.

It's funny to think about. "City at War" was the last clearly defined story arc/storyline of any kind in Mirage. As that marked the last involvement of Kevin of any kind beyond covers and after that it was strictly Peter... I think it's safe to conclude that Peter doesn't like clearly defined story arcs/storylines but rather just a free-flowing narrative that keeps continuing. I'm pretty sure if Vol. 2 hadn't have been discontinued, that story would have eventually bled seamlessly into what we know of now as Vol. 4 without any storyline conclusions or anything.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-19-2018, 11:11 AM
It's funny to think about. "City at War" was the last clearly defined story arc/storyline of any kind in Mirage. As that marked the last involvement of Kevin of any kind beyond covers and after that it was strictly Peter... I think it's safe to conclude that Peter doesn't like clearly defined story arcs/storylines but rather just a free-flowing narrative that keeps continuing. I'm pretty sure if Vol. 2 hadn't have been discontinued, that story would have eventually bled seamlessly into what we know of now as Vol. 4 without any storyline conclusions or anything.

I disagree. Lawson was more heavily involved in Volume 2's plot and direction, whereas Volume 4 he did art only and it was all Laird's brainchild.

Isn't that how it went? Or am I misremembering the credits?

Andrew NDB
09-19-2018, 11:25 AM
I disagree. Lawson was more heavily involved in Volume 2's plot and direction, whereas Volume 4 he did art only and it was all Laird's brainchild.

Isn't that how it went? Or am I misremembering the credits?

Shoot, I don't know. I do remember hearing Lawson was more heavily involved in Vol. 2's storyline than initially thought, but much, much later on Laird talked about the writing process with Lawson, how it's largely a multi-step process. 1) Laird writes up rough summaries of an issue's story and gives them to Jim, 2) Jim draws all the pages and writes initial blurbs of dialogue and captions on his own, 3) Peter goes back in and revises/fluffs up/adds to what Jim wrote. I kind of assumed their process in Vol. 4 was the same as their process in Vol. 2. That's my understanding, anyway.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-19-2018, 11:45 AM
Shoot, I don't know. I do remember hearing Lawson was more heavily involved in Vol. 2's storyline than initially thought, but much, much later on Laird talked about the writing process with Lawson, how it's largely a multi-step process. 1) Laird writes up rough summaries of an issue's story and gives them to Jim, 2) Jim draws all the pages and writes initial blurbs of dialogue and captions on his own, 3) Peter goes back in and revises/fluffs up/adds to what Jim wrote. I kind of assumed their process in Vol. 4 was the same as their process in Vol. 2. That's my understanding, anyway.

I guess that would make more sense.

neatoman
09-19-2018, 12:08 PM
Huh, I could have sworn I commented on this topic before...

Anyway, that's some even poll after two years.

Tetsu Deinonychus
09-19-2018, 02:16 PM
Mirage, easily.

IDW is an impressive remix of all previous versions. And, it's pretty entertaining, but the pacing is frustratingly slow and it doesn't have quite as much of a "bite" as Mirage (not just in action/violence, as I don't care as much about that, but emotionally).


Mirage in addition to being the original source material (TMNT doesn't get much more pure than that). And, it has all the grit and all the emotional punch (both the somber "Life at best is bitterweet" moments,and the heartwarming "Life is good and life goes on" moments) that I feel are what really make Mirage the "mature" version.

Now continuity is a bit of a mess, and there's unfinished stories all over the place, and the "guest era" is hit (Souls Winter) or miss (Spaced Out), but I still say Mirage gets the nod, by a fairly wide margin.

pferreira
09-20-2018, 12:02 PM
Mirage by far.

PizzaPower1985
06-14-2020, 02:05 PM
I just broke the tie! It was 37 to 37 as of June, 14th, 2020. Now IDW is in the lead by a hair @ 38.

I am torn on this however. I want Mirage to be the best because of Issues 1-11, NORTHAMPTON Return to New York, Tales Vol. 1 (The Rat King issue is amazing), City At War, plus the wonderful micros... and then the brilliant moments of the guest era like The River. They're some of the best Turtle stories and some of the best comic books I have ever read. A lot of the guest era just plain blows chunks.

That said, IDW (more particularly the first 50 issues, along with background in the micros) gave me nearly everything I ever wanted in a turtle book. IDW's Shredder was exactly the Shredder I have always wanted. Post issue 50, Splinter's character arc and journey to bad-ass, relentless leader of The Foot Clan, flirting with his own inner darkness, was what kept me onboard. Seeing the TMNT grow and change throughout a nearly ten year continuity has been a blast. It's adult and mature enough to be worth my time yet has some of the kiddie-turtleisms that tickle my childhood too. Most importantly though, TMNT was cohesive. That said, a lot of the side-plots and introductions of new characters has made me exhausted.

So, each version is great. Each has its flaws. Neither are perfect. For me IDW edges out for the win. And I JUST BROKE THIS TIE, mofos!

hypered1
06-14-2020, 04:40 PM
So when does this poll end exactly?

PizzaPower1985
06-14-2020, 05:24 PM
So when does this poll end exactly?

Let's keep it open. I love polls like this.

Allio
06-14-2020, 06:13 PM
Would you guys want to do a volume 2/3 vs 51-100 thread?

PizzaPower1985
06-14-2020, 06:55 PM
Would you guys want to do a volume 2/3 vs 51-100 thread?

YES! Why not?

LUIS
06-14-2020, 09:56 PM
Mirage has some great highs (RtNY, City at war, the micro series and a lot of Tales Vol. 2 issues and the guest era)but it has a lot of lows too (Most of the guest era, I find Vol. 2 and 4 rather boring too) Same for IDW (City Fall, Krang War, SHotFC, the Ghostbusters crossovers, the Bebop and Rocksteady minies to name a few are great) but I would lie if I don't feel some sort of spark was lost after #50, it felt without direction (though I don't find it as boring as Vol. 2 and 4) and some horrible minies like Casey and April and most of Krank's trial mini too. So yeah, Mirage highs are greater than IDW's but so are it's lows.