View Full Version : Do the Mirage Comics Work for New Readers in 2016?
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 12:09 AM
To what extent are the Mirage comics inviting and convincing for a new reader in 2016?
I started reading the modern IDW series this month. I'm on the fourth volume right now. I like it well enough, but I don't know that I would enjoy it without the benefit of my thirty years of TMNT fandom.
Where the original Mirage comics are concerned, I only ever read the first issue or three, and that was many years ago. It didn't do a lot for me at the time, but I've always assumed the first few issues are not the best.
Whatever the case, while it's almost impossible for most geeks and fans and enthusiasts of any given property to set aside their nostalgia and take an objective look at something they love, I want to ask:
If an adult fan of the Ninja Turtles property tried reading the classic Mirage comics for the first time today, without the benefit of nostalgia... how good do you suspect those comics would seem to the reader?
Thank you in advance for your input.
Powder
03-31-2016, 12:22 AM
Hard to say. They're pretty unique comics, especially to someone going into it with expectations of them being anything like the OT or society's generalized notion of what the TMNT are. I'd think there is a distinction between the average "modern reader" & fans who are dedicated enough to use these forums & ask this kinda question, though. You'd be more open to it than someone whose main experience with the turtles was Fred Wolf's cartoon 20 some-odd years ago.
While there's plenty of familiar ninja stuff & humor, that particular universe is defined more by it's brooding nature. A lot of the time it is dismissed by casual fans for being nothing more than "dark & gritty", the antithesis to their pizza loving bro-dudes, which people assume is chalked up to violent imagery or heavy inks, but really, Mirage is just thematically grim. Revenge, rage, isolation, existential crisis, introspection, grey morality, etc. There's a lot of wit & emotional depth scattered across the volumes, through the exploration of spirituality, consequence, family values, & so forth. You could pick up 5 random issues & find none of that, though, as there were a large number of books that relied solely on combat, or shenanigans, but the heart of Mirage is, well, it's heart.
They're at their best when either introspective or truly action oriented, with that being said, reading those kinda issues would be an optimal way to test the waters. Try reading Sons Of Silence, for example.
In a more broad sense though, while they are in some ways very much products of their era, I think a lot of the material within is timeless & can appeal to open minded comic readers who enjoy the turtles & want a bit more than high-kicks & Cowabunga.
Utrommaniac
03-31-2016, 12:34 AM
I am probably a good example of someone who would be best to give my two cents, since I am a new to just about everything TMNT.
And what I will say is that Mirage simply hasn't captured my heart. It's my love affair with Utroms that made me at least a little interested, with so many other names to them...but even then, there was only a single one that was even remotely interesting (Obligado!). Then there's the latter half of the fourth volume, and it just has "nope" sprayed all over the walls. It has the same problem with the Nick series in that it doesn't really finish its storylines very well, or doesn't care about finishing its storylines and that can get problematic.
The main art style doesn't help either. It's just too hard on the eyes. My favorite art styles are Jim Lawson's and Dario Brizuela's.
"Dark and gritty" would be okay - and even great - if it's done right (IDW!), and I don't think Mirage TMNT really grasps it. It comes off as baiting and heavy handed. Maybe that's because my idea of a truly dark story is fully realized in Little Shop of Horrors...which would say a lot about me as a person.
Powder
03-31-2016, 12:49 AM
I don't wanna be disrespectful, but you clearly don't "get" Mirage. For one thing, Utroms were never meant to be this captivating race of cuties, they're aliens. Logic over emotion. Individuality is a concept so very human by design, in that our emotions makes us feel the need to stand apart & be noticed, beings who operate primarily if not solely on logic don't work that way, so naturally they'd be a bit lacking in personality.
Volume 4 was panned both by fans & critics, but you've gotta understand, that isn't Mirage to most of it's fans. I mean, yeah, it is, it's a canon extension of what came before, but nobody's gonna suggest it to you. Very few are entirely happy with it, let alone consider it a favorite. Besides that, most of Mirage's loose threads were tied up in Tales Of The TMNT, that's literally why it exists; not simply to throw in additional adventures but to close gaps & finish plots. The only unresolved stuff that I can think of is what goes on between the turtles' middle age life & their passing, but considering we know their life-paths & where/when/how they die (sans Mike, though there are fair assumptions to be made), it's not necessary to address.
I dunno what you consider the "main art style" to be, considering how many different artists came & went. Eastman & Laird did the first dozen, Jim had wildly different looking runs in volumes 2 & 4, but Tales & most of volume 1 were a revolving door of indie interpretations, many of which highly detailed, though there are also very wacky & basic looks too. Maybe I'm being unfairly defensive, you are after all a modern/new reader, whose opinion this thread serves to bring about. I guess you prefer simpler/cleaner design aesthetics (Jim & Dario's work being your favorites is definitely suggestive of that), which is a completely fair stance to take!
But uh, yeah, I think maybe your idea of dark & gritty is a bit off. IDW, while great, has not really come anywhere close to Mirage in that respect. Beheading Shredder was a bold move, that I give major props for, but otherwise it has been hindered by the awareness of young readers, accessibility, this "no-kill" rule, etc. Mirage, being the original, had the benefit of pure creative freedom, which is why it's "dark & gritty" has everything from bloodthirst & depravity to suicidal allusions. Mind you, their Donatello is one who literally kept Baxter chained to a wall in an area of the sewers unknown to his family for like 15 years, killed a dog for science, etc. Raph tried to kill Michelangelo. There's some crazy sh*t in there. :tlol:
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 12:53 AM
Powder, I couldn't have asked for a more insightful and generous reply to start off this thread. Thank you.
I'd think there is a distinction between the average "modern reader" & fans who are dedicated enough to use these forums & ask this kinda question, though. You'd be more open to it than someone whose main experience with the turtles was Fred Wolf's cartoon 20 some-odd years ago.
I suspect you are probably right, and thanks for the implied vote of confidence. Like so many people my age, I was in fact introduced to the TMNT concept through the '80s cartoon. However, while I will always have affection for it, I find it difficult to get through an episode as an adult. (Except the five-episode story that started it off. I've watched that a few times). Same with G.I. Joe, Transformers, and most any other cartoon from my '80s childhood; I love 'em, but I love 'em from afar, and I do not believe they are better than cartoons today simply because they came out when I was young and impressionable.
When Nickelodeon released the first teaser for the new cartoon, Rob Bricken, then of Topless Robot, defended the silly tone with a quote that has always stuck with me:
”Look, I just can’t look at an anthropomorphic turtle wielding ninja weapons and say, ‘They’re not taking this seriously enough!’ I just can’t.”
I feel the same way, and yet I like stories that have the courage to take themselves seriously, and while I have a strong dislike for Man of Steel (to cite a random, recent example) because it does a disservice to (my personal take on) what Superman is supposed to be, I'm also wearying of all the Marvel fanboys who dismiss DC for not being buoyant.
Not everything should be quippy. People have come to dismiss Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight in recent years, but I just revisited it last year and I'm not sure anything from the Marvel Cinematic Universe has topped that movie.
The idea of a series of Ninja Turtles stories that tackle dark themes is almost counterintuitive to me, and yet it's the series that started it all, and so I am intrigued at the notion.
Which is my longwinded way of saying two things:
1. I'm a walking contradiction and a bit of an A-hole who's hard to please.
2. I love silliness and levity in my Ninja Turtles stories, and yet this:
Mirage is just thematically grim. Revenge, rage, isolation, existential crisis, introspection, grey morality, etc.
...is also in my wheelhouse.
Which just leaves the question of where to begin. I'd rather not start at the beginning, but instead with something commonly regarded as a high-water mark. (After making fun of Buffy the Vampire Slayer for years despite having never seen it, I decided one night to watch an episode, expecting to laugh at it the entire time. The episode was "The Body". I was crying five minutes into it. That experience made me realize that context is meaningless; if a story is sufficiently stirring, the lack of context for plot and characters will do nothing to diminish the reader's or viewer's conviction that "this series is for me".)
Powder, you were kind enough to make a suggestion:
Try reading Sons Of Silence, for example.
Which volume or collection includes that story? I find the labyrinthine TMNT comics library a bit overwhelming. :)
(Utrommaniac, your reply appeared when I was in the middle of this bloated rant. I'll comment on it in a moment).
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 01:03 AM
Thanks for chiming in, Utrom!
Mirage simply hasn't captured my heart.
I worry on the one hand that this will prove to be the case for me, as well. On the other hand, the Ninja Turtle "universe" I carry around with me in my mind (and which I think about more frequently in a given day than I care to admit, heh-heh) is such a hodgepodge of Old Toon and 1990 live-action film and toy designs and original ideas of my own that I like to think I still might find things to love in the Mirage comics, even if the entire run doesn't wow me.
It's my love affair with Utroms that made me at least a little interested...
See, while I can have a good chuckle at Krang's goofiness in the old cartoon, the utroms and kraang and the more cosmic, inter dimensional aspect of the property has never appealed to me much. I like my Turtles in an urban setting.
The main art style doesn't help either. It's just too hard on the eyes. My favorite art styles are Jim Lawson's and Dario Brizuela's.
I respect the art I've seen, but it's not really my style. I'm not sure which artist was responsible for whichever issues and pinups and such I've studied, but I don't care much for the art style that I think of as "classic Mirage," and yet I flipped through some Mirage collection ten years or so ago and loved its artwork, which was less stylized and more lifelike and realistic.
You've given me more to think about. Thanks again!
Chabrendeki
03-31-2016, 01:11 AM
I found my way as an adult back to Turtles-fandom because of the Mirage comics.
As a kid, I was a big fan of the first movie and the Achie comics, the Playmates toys and the Fred Wolf cartoon. But it wear of with the time, my toys and comics were spent to some poor kids, and I almost forget about the turtles.
For some years I stumbled upon a picture from Mirage #1 - the full page shot of Raph on a rooftop. It was a complete different look on the turtles I knew. I investigated, read some articles on Wikipedia, and after a few months I grabbed vol. 1 of the Ultimate Collection. The others followed in the next months.
The first step for my newly found love for the turtles.
So: yes, I think Mirage can be appealing for an adult in 2016.
Cryomancer
03-31-2016, 01:15 AM
I think the older colorized "book 1-4" releases help a lot in getting over the "i'm reading an old black and white comic" hump some people would experience, but those are also not so easy to come by these days. But if you can, I think that might be a potential best way to hook in a new reader.
The halftone stuff will look totally different, though.
Utrommaniac
03-31-2016, 01:16 AM
Powder, you are absolutely right about me not getting Mirage and preferring cleaner art styles. In fact, you're right about a lot of what you just said.
Now that I think about it, my idea of "dark and gritty" is more psychological, and the tearing down of one's stability and integrity (again I say, Little Shop of Horrors.) Another example I can think of is the John Gardner's take on Grendel. It's still incredibly violent, but that's not the grit I was interested in. Yeah, it's got bloodlust and depravity, but that wasn't the part I was interested in. It was the psychology.
Being from younger generation, Mirage might just be best described as "tedious", and I'm not quite sure why. The AP English student in me wants something to dissect and analyze, and I'm sure Mirage has it, but something about it makes me not want to.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 01:28 AM
Thank you, Chabrendeki, that is quite an endorsement!
Cryomancer, I've got no problem with black and white comics, and I'd prefer to skip the origin and introduction and get right to a story that many fans cite as one of the best, even if it means I'm confused and a bit lost.
Powder
03-31-2016, 01:29 AM
You're quite welcome. You can probably tell it's an iteration I am very passionate about, :tlol: as well as an avid spokesman for, given it is the underdog wing of the franchise despite everything else being built from it's bricks.
The idea of a series of Ninja Turtles stories that tackle dark themes is almost counterintuitive to me, and yet it's the series that started it all, and so I am intrigued at the notion.
See, part of why it works so well, at least to me, is that it can be so unbelievably human & adult (in the mature sense, not the boobs & blood sense) for something based on a bunch of mutant animals with hardcore weapons. Unlike their animated counterparts, they don't go looking for things to fix, they don't consider themselves heroes, they're not big fans of humans. They're teenagers, they struggle with their place in the world, when to use words or fists, how to find happiness in a society they can never be a part of. These are things we can all relate to, but sometimes it just feels better coming from cool-ass creatures. :trazz: In other universes, jokes are just jokes. They're there to make the viewer laugh. Mirage Humor, it's kinda like, these guys are making themselves laugh. Making light of the situation is the only way to get through it sometimes. I'm probably giving it a bit more credit than deserved, to be entirely fair, but there are some issues that make that quite clear, & you carry that insight with you as you ride along for other events.
Which just leaves the question of where to begin. I'd rather not start at the beginning, but instead with something commonly regarded as a high-water mark. (After making fun of Buffy the Vampire Slayer for years despite having never seen it, I decided one night to watch an episode, expecting to laugh at it the entire time. The episode was "The Body". I was crying five minutes into it. That experience made me realize that context is meaningless; if a story is sufficiently stirring, the lack of context for plot and characters will do nothing to diminish the reader's or viewer's conviction that "this series is for me".)
A lot of people will surely suggest Return To New York, City At War, & The River, arguably the 3 most popular story arcs. Dramatic, dark, action-packed, heavily detailed art. If that sounds good to you, have at it! If you're specifically looking for issues with emotional impact, that's another thing. http://www.miragelicensing.com/html/comics.html You can read issue synopses here, if our suggestions aren't enough or you have curiosities, that'll be a helpful guide. Tales Of The TMNT Vol. 2 (70 issues total) was my main gateway into the Mirageverse, because many of the issues are standalone stories, but plenty of them pick up from random issues that are 10, 20 years old, so it can also be daunting depending on which you get. Maybe check out the descriptions on those & pick a few out. #20 made me cry the first time I read it, there's a short about an encounter with hunters that really tugs at the heart strings if you're an animal person.
Which volume or collection includes that story? I find the labyrinthine TMNT comics library a bit overwhelming. :)
I'll have to leave that to one of my well-read peers, I collected the individual issues before IDW ever got the license, so I'm unsure which works contain certain stories. The lone issue was Mirage Vol. 1 #28 though.
I worry on the one hand that this will prove to be the case for me, as well. On the other hand, the Ninja Turtle "universe" I carry around with me in my mind (and which I think about more frequently in a given day than I care to admit, heh-heh) is such a hodgepodge of Old Toon and 1990 live-action film and toy designs and original ideas of my own that I like to think I still might find things to love in the Mirage comics, even if the entire run doesn't wow me.
It might be, & that's alright. Giving it a fair shake is all anyone can ask of you. Though I do think all TMNT fans kinda owe it a chance, I personally think it's important people understand that that "their" TMNT, while the most iconic, are not "the" TMNT. But I realize I'm a bit of a turtle snob... At any rate, the first movie is almost entirely comprised of Mirage stories, actually! The only elements that weren't, were the inclusion of those new human characters, the foot being a youth group, & April's job. There are a few small changes, naturally, but the Casey encounter, all the Raph trouble, the farmhouse, roof-top scene, so much if it was directly lifted from the comics. It's so rad. If you like/love that movie, you should at least be able to appreciate Mirage, even if you don't necessarily want to read it all the time. Better still, 4kids adapted all sorts of stuff, so the same applies there if you watched that show.
See, while I can have a good chuckle at Krang's goofiness in the old cartoon, the utroms and kraang and the more cosmic, inter dimensional aspect of the property has never appealed to me much. I like my Turtles in an urban setting.
The Utroms play a very significant part in TMNT lore, but they're not too active across the series. Early volume 1 deals with them a bit, & they're around a lot more in volume 4 (as well as some Tales issues that take place during that part of the timeline) but they're hardly equal to Krang or even The Kraang in terms of involvement.
I respect the art I've seen, but it's not really my style. I'm not sure which artist was responsible for whichever issues and pinups and such I've studied, but I don't care much for the art style that I think of as "classic Mirage," and yet I flipped through some Mirage collection ten years or so ago and loved its artwork, which was less stylized and more lifelike and realistic.
The art is a big mixed bag. You'd probably be a Michael Dooney fan.
Now that I think about it, my idea of "dark and gritty" is more psychological, and the tearing down of one's stability and integrity (again I say, Little Shop of Horrors.) Another example I can think of is the John Gardner's take on Grendel. It's still incredibly violent, but that's not the grit I was interested in. Yeah, it's got bloodlust and depravity, but that wasn't the part I was interested in. It was the psychology.
Being from younger generation, Mirage might just be best described as "tedious", and I'm not quite sure why. The AP English student in me wants something to dissect and analyze, and I'm sure Mirage has it, but something about it makes me not want to.
Word, I get that. I didn't think I was muddying the waters, but my mentioning the high-octane violence was not meant to imply that's it's main drive, in the context of being dark. The psychological side is very much prevalent. Like I said in my previous post, there's plenty of mental anguish & emotional turmoil.
While some people don't consider it canon, volume 3, done by Image, was written as a continuation in the Mirage universe, & I think it explored some of those themes better than anyone else. Donatello has serious issues with being brought back to life as a cyborg, bringing on an identity crisis stemming from being reborn to a metal body whose tech is self-aware & can act on your behalf, but not necessarily in your best interests. He reaches a point of putting a gun to his head in front of his brothers. That sh*t is heavy. Their master is captured & subsequently mutated a second time, losing his humanity in the form of a mindless beast. The turtles kinda fall apart; Mikey turns to writing, Raphael rebuilds the Foot Clan as their new leader, Casey has to accept that he's a father/husband & put aside the vigilantism. I'd highly recommend that run to any interested turtle fan. :tcool:
Mewzard
03-31-2016, 01:51 AM
Well, I'm probably not the most normal example, but my love for the TMNT came from the first movie, not the cartoon, so that was for nearly two decades my gold standard as to what made a great TMNT story.
Turtles Forever actually ended up being what got me to check out the Mirage books out of curiosity. It didn't take long to realize that the film I enjoyed so as a child took heavy influence from the early Mirage run (specifically various bits of the first 11 issues and the One-Shots).
I think whether a new reader can get into it factors into two important questions:
1. Can they enjoy a more grim/serious take on the Turtles?
2. Can they enjoy or at least accept the art that comes with it?
If so, I think it's reasonable.
The first issue is a fantastic single-issue read (which we don't get much of in comics these days, something one and done), and is compelling, but the Turtles don't quite start coming into their own until a little later in the comic (Raph is quick to his role, that's for sure).
That said, I think Mirage provided some fantastic stories, and once the Turtles started to grow, you could really care about them and their struggles. I liked that they weren't really beholden to some set arc structure and could just go about things at the pace they felt appropriate. Sometimes, you can really enjoy those slower issues.
At this point, Mirage's TMNT is my #1 Turtles thing. It's the first thing I think of when I think Turtles. Given I started with the 1990 movie around the time it came out, yet only got to Mirage in the last few years via IDW's release is rather impressive.
Honestly, I recommend going from the beginning. Not every issue's a winner, but a lot of them are enjoyable, and it gives you an appreciation of how far they go when you do make it further into the story.
I doubt Return to New York or City at War would be quite as appreciated if you skipped right to them (If you'd prefer to focus on Eastman/Laird issues, the Ultimate Collection Hardcovers are good with that).
Also worth checking out the Tales of the TMNT.
If you'd like a non Eastman/Laird story to check out, I was rather partial to Soul's Winter myself.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 01:57 AM
Buy the first 5 Ultimate Collections that IDW put out, they collect the most important and best Mirage issues.
Those are the absolute best Mirage comics worth reading, so make sure you get those before anything else.
Nortock Diab
03-31-2016, 03:38 AM
I started reading and collecting Mirage comics in late 2013 (not exactly 2016 :tsmile:). I love this iteration and truly consider it the one and only. Other iterations may be pleasant but do not please me as much as Mirage does. Now in 2016, I own most of Mirage issues (all volumes considered) and recently started IDW and Archie.
Yet I have to admit I was already a comic collecting zealot before 2013. I even already had most of TMNT vol.3 issues (buying them was driven by my Savage Dragon completism) but I had barely read them because I was waiting to have the whole set (it is only on the Technodrome forum that I realized how hard they were to come by).
Regarding my ninja turtles affinity, I loved the original cartoon as a child in the 90’s and owned several of the playmates action figures (classic turtles, Bebop, Shredder, Ace Duck) so of course I was receptive to trying Mirage material. Yet I am aware only now that I knew nothing of the turtles then such as all the weird characters you guys are always referring to when asking IDW to expand their cast.
While I’ve been a long-time comic book collector and always found the Ninja Turtles appealing, I guess I can still say with my example that Mirage is inviting and convincing to new readers :tgrin:.
bjaxx87
03-31-2016, 05:16 AM
I started collecting/reading the Mirage comics 5 years ago (I was 24). Before that I wasn't really into TMNT or comic books (except for some Batman novels like "Year One" or "The Man Who Laughs"). But when I accidentally discovered the 4kids show I loved it and wanted to check out its roots.
Well, I am very close to having read every single Mirage story in existence now and it's by far my favorite TMNT incarnation (I also checked out IDW, Nick, the OT, the movies, etc.). It's so great to never know what to expect whenever opening another book - Action? Sci-Fi? Horror? Drama? Comedy? It's all there! Of course, there were issues which I don't care much for but considering the diversity that's not much of a surprise. :)
So, recommendations? Of course the original Triceraton arc, the exile to Northampton and Return to New York are some of the most commonly known highlights. But you should also check out the already mentioned "Sons of the Silent Age" (collected and colorized in this tpb (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Turtles-Classics-Volume/dp/1613775385)), "A Day in the Life" (Tales Vol.2 #55, not yet collected by IDW), World’s Deadliest (Tales Vol. 2 #50, not yet collected by IDW), Twilight of the Ring (collected and colorized in this tpb (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Turtles-Classics-Volume/dp/1613775679)), Halls of Lost Legends (collected and colorized in this tpb (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Turtles-Classics-Volume/dp/1613777124/)), Masks (collected and colorized in this tpb (http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Turtles-Classics-Volume/dp/1613777981)) and the Gang Wars (Tales Vol. 2 #36, #56, #59, #61 and #64, not yet collected by IDW).
Sons of the Silent Age, A Day in the Life, Twilight of the Ring and Halls of Lost Legends are very calm, philosophical stories. World’s Deadliest, Masks and the Gang Wars are more action oriented.
Mormegil
03-31-2016, 06:33 AM
I watched the cartoon as a kid, for me the action figures and the NES games was were i spent most of my time.
Sometime in 2012 or 2013 i stumbled on the IDW series and once i figured out it was a complete reboot, i jumped on.
It wasn't until after the IDW city fall arc came out in trade that i started looking for the original B&W comics in some kind of collected format.
I own the first 5 ultimate collections and all of the trade classics that have been released so far. I really enjoyed the first ultimate collection. Once i got into the guest era of Vol. 1 i kinda slowed down. I still haven't read the city at war arc even though it gets such high praise. I still need to read classics vol 7 trade to get to that arc.
Shedder
03-31-2016, 10:29 AM
My story is a lot like others on here. When I was young I lived for the cartoon and the movie. Those were my first real introductions into all things TMNT as well as the action figures which were the real driving force.
I tried at the time to read the comics but every time I looked, I saw TMNT books with turtles I didn't recognize (Zullies Souls Winter Comes to mind) which turned me off and the Archie books were too heavily environmental for me. Because I was coming in in the middle and couldn't recognize them, I shied away from the comics. Eventually my interest faded and I lost contact with the franchise.
Then some time in 2012 I herd that the comics were being rebooted. I had just had a retro craving to watch the first couple of FW cartoons and started researching. I went and got the first IDW trade and instantly was hooked. I was about 10 issues behind and was able to get the individual floppies and i got the collecting bug. I joined as a member here and everyone said I had to go back and read the originals. I found a copy of the collected Vol 1 books and instantly loved them. I think I read the first 3 Ultimate Collection books in one night. Since then I have tried to get my hands on every story I can of the TMNT with only the Archie Series missing some higher issues now.
Now when I think of TMNT I instantly think of the original Mirage books. Those Eastman and Laird stories (as well as what IDW are doing) are my favorite parts of the franchise to date.
So from my point of view its all about finding a point that interests you.
When I was a kid I couldn't and that lost me. Now as an adult I found my spring board to my re-found love for all things Turtles (except Next Mutation...That s**t is just unbearable)
P.S. the 4kids TMNT is a great way to get through the Mirage stuff as MOST of it is adapted there
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
03-31-2016, 10:48 AM
I'm too late to contribute anything, as Powder beat me to it. :tlol:
Mirage is not only what started TMNT, it's main themes and heart is what TMNT always SHOULD be. The closer a retelling of TMNT reaches that, the better it is.
City at War is simply the best TMNT story there ever will be. Because at its heart, it's not about the action, violence, or chaos; it's about the Turtles wondering what their place in the world is and why they should even continue fighting a battle that they were forced into long ago by their father.
So when people come along and say "screw the Mirage TMNT" or that they don't like it, or it's too dark and violent for them, I say that they have a fundamental misunderstanding of what TMNT was and should be. Don't settle for the kiddie versions. We've all grown up and we should let our understanding of characters grow up with us.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 10:57 AM
At any rate, the first movie is almost entirely comprised of Mirage stories, actually...
I've heard that. And that connection does intrigue me, although I hope Don and Casey's alphabetical insult game isn't taken verbatim from the comic, 'cause sheesh, that was some distractingly goofy dialogue.
But while I do like the movie...
If you like/love that movie, you should at least be able to appreciate Mirage...
So much of what I love about it is the Henson suits. It's not like the plot is particularly amazing (though I do find their flight to rural isolation compelling), so I'm not sure I'll like Mirage simply because the movie's plot is taken from it.
(I'm pretty set on giving the Mirage comics a chance, mind you; I just don't think this particular selling point is relevant for me).
Although I do like the visual tone of the film, so if that's similar to the comic, that's a solid endorsement.
Better still, 4kids adapted all sorts of stuff, so the same applies there if you watched that show.
That's a funny case for me. I only ever caught glimpses here and there of that series as it was airing, and I was blown away by the quality and seriousness. But when I finally tried to actually watch the series, I found it something of a chore.
A few years ago I bought the first DVD, collecting the initial ten episodes or so, and I watched it with my daughter, who was probably six or seven at the time, 'cause I'd gotten her into the OT when she was very young. She and I both enjoyed the 4Kids episodes well enough.
Last week, I wanted to watch some 4Kids episode I'd read about. I think it might have been the episode that introduced Usagi, but I can't recall for sure. Whatever the case, my daughter, twelve now (twelve today, in fact) sat down with me while I watched it on YouTube, and the opening credits sequence gave her a nostalgic thrill ("I've missed this!"), but she was mostly quiet throughout the episode, and when Leo got especially earnest near the end, she said, "That's kind of cheesy."
And she was right.
I admire that the 4Kids series was willing to take itself so seriously, but its animation and dialogue were not quite strong enough to carry that seriousness, in my opinion, with the result that, lacking opportunities to laugh with the series, it is discouragingly easy to laugh at it.
I still admire the show, and the 2003 versions of the Turtles action figures remain some of my favorites. It's just another thing I have to love from afar.
While some people don't consider it canon, volume 3, done by Image, was written as a continuation in the Mirage universe...
I've been reading about that series for a long time, and while it sounds like a trainwreck, I am definitely interested in checking it out.
I wish IDW would publish a secondary archive of the Mirage material. Low-grade paper, black and white, any other budgetary cutbacks necessary; I am interested in reading these old stories, but when they're only available (or so it seems to me, anyway) in deluxe, high-end tomes that reprint only four or five issues each, I get discouraged. I don't want to put together a literary museum, I just wanna read some stories. Hell, unless I am mistaken, even the Comixology versions of the Mirage are pricey!
plastroncafe
03-31-2016, 11:04 AM
I can't speak for new readers of the Mirage books, because I started reading them in the early 1990, but...the Fred Wolf cartoon was my first introduction to the characters and I had no issue transitioning from one to the other.
I find Volume 1 far less dated with regards to storytelling and overall design than say...Volume 3, which is so late late 90s it's damn near painful.
I think it all really depends on how you like your stories told. Mirage has always had a slower pace. It's more "show" than "tell," which is almost the exact opposite of the IDW run.
Chabrendeki
03-31-2016, 11:11 AM
I wish IDW would publish a secondary archive of the Mirage material. Low-grade paper, black and white, any other budgetary cutbacks necessary; I am interested in reading these old stories, but when they're only available (or so it seems to me, anyway) in deluxe, high-end tomes that reprint only four or five issues each, I get discouraged. I don't want to put together a literary museum, I just wanna read some stories. Hell, unless I am mistaken, even the Comixology versions of the Mirage are pricey!
The Ultimate Collection collects 7-8 40 pages issues per volume... They cost approx. the double as a 4-issue TPB, so they are cheap in comparison and are worth every cent.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 11:28 AM
Turtles Forever actually ended up being what got me to check out the Mirage books out of curiosity.
Ah, Turtles Forever. I know it isn't perfect, but has there ever been a more delightful and unlikely bit of fan service? In any medium? I should revisit it.
1. Can they enjoy a more grim/serious take on the Turtles?
2. Can they enjoy or at least accept the art that comes with it?
I can handle bleakness, provided there is insight and characterization to back it up.
As for the art, I will probably be more bothered by the many changes in style rather than the low quality of some of the art.
Honestly, I recommend going from the beginning. Not every issue's a winner, but a lot of them are enjoyable, and it gives you an appreciation of how far they go when you do make it further into the story.
I will definitely read the entire series from the beginning if I like the first taste, but I stand by the Buffy model; sample the series at its best, and then consume the whole thing chronologically if you liked that sample taste.
Moving on...
Buy the first 5 Ultimate Collections that IDW put out, they collect the most important and best Mirage issues.
Those are the absolute best Mirage comics worth reading, so make sure you get those before anything else.
Are those the ones that only collect a handful of issues each? 'Cause I was excited for them until I learned that each contains only four or five issues.
[COLOR="Lime"]I started reading and collecting Mirage comics in late 2013 (not exactly 2016 :tsmile:).
I suppose I can allow a passage of three years. :)
Thank you, bjaxx, for the recommendations. And for the links!
myconius
03-31-2016, 11:31 AM
To what extent are the Mirage comics inviting and convincing for a new reader in 2016?
I started reading the modern IDW series this month. I'm on the fourth volume right now. I like it well enough, but I don't know that I would enjoy it without the benefit of my thirty years of TMNT fandom.
Where the original Mirage comics are concerned, I only ever read the first issue or three, and that was many years ago. It didn't do a lot for me at the time, but I've always assumed the first few issues are not the best.
Whatever the case, while it's almost impossible for most geeks and fans and enthusiasts of any given property to set aside their nostalgia and take an objective look at something they love, I want to ask:
If an adult fan of the Ninja Turtles property tried reading the classic Mirage comics for the first time today, without the benefit of nostalgia... how good do you suspect those comics would seem to the reader?
Thank you in advance for your input.
i think the level of attraction for the very first series of Mirage Tmnt comics was the art!!
the stories had some silliness and fun mixed in with the darkness, violence and action, though i think muck of those jokes are pretty dated due to references and will go over most new reader's heads? "i pity the man"
but from and artistic standpoint the early issues are absolutely breathtaking!
the level of craftsmanship that went into them really needs to be seen by any new fan.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 11:40 AM
...as well as the action figures which were the real driving force.
The action figures remain the primary focus of my TMNT fandom. :)
Mirage is not only what started TMNT, it's main themes and heart is what TMNT always SHOULD be... I say that they have a fundamental misunderstanding of what TMNT was and should be.
I hope I enjoy the Mirage comics, and I agree that no one should dismiss them, but I disagree with the suggestion that there should only be one take on the franchise. After all, if it hadn't been for those absurd, poorly animated '80s cartoons, this forum would not exist, and the comics would be a strange, obscure footnote.
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has had so many iterations, each of which is someone's favorite. No iconic character or series should ever be too beholden to its earliest stories. If they were, Batman would be gunning people down, Superman wouldn't fly, etc.
Mirage has always had a slower pace. It's more "show" than "tell," which is almost the exact opposite of the IDW run.
Yeah, this is actually a powerful endorsement, for me. I enjoy the IDW series for what it is, but it's quite rushed and clunky.
The Ultimate Collection collects 7-8 40 pages issues per volume... They cost approx. the double as a 4-issue TPB, so they are cheap in comparison and are worth every cent.
Oh! Thank you for clarifying. I'll look into those!
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 11:57 AM
Now that Chabrendeki has schooled me on the content of the Ultimate Collections (now that I know just how much content each book includes, in other words; now that I know they're a pretty great value), I am definitely going to pursue them.
But I have a follow-up question, if you'll indulge me.
http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Collection/dp/1613770073/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1459442453&sr=1-1&keywords=idw+mirage+tmnt+ultimate
I see on Amazon that the Comixology version of the first Ultimate collection is only $10. For over 300 pages! Wow!
Now, I'm no Luddite, but for whatever reason, I can't get into reading ebooks. I bought a kindle a few years ago, but ended up giving it to one of my students. I much prefer reading novels in printed form. (I'm not arguing that they are superior in this form; it's simply what I prefer.)
I naturally assumed that this print bias would extend to comic books (which I almost never read anymore in any form, whatever the case).
However, I started reading the IDW series via Comixology, and was stunned to find that I love reading comic books in digital format. Love it. Like, I don''t foresee going back to print.
I love the navigation tool; I can blow it up to full screen and scroll through a panel at a time, which you'd think would be tiresome, but man, it helps the pacing and delivery so much. No more turning the page and spoiling a revelation a few panels too soon. Everything has more impact. It's much more immersive. Digital comics for the win!
(The fact that they're so much cheaper? Just icing on the cake).
So at long last, my follow-up question:
Is there any particularly compelling reason why this would not be the smart route to take for the Mirage comics?
I get that many of you are big fans of the artwork, which presumably fares much better on glossy, oversized pages than on my laptop screen. But I have always been more concerned with the story in a given comic rather than the art, so that's not really relevant for me.
If any person here can show cause why this man and this $10 300-page digital comic should not be joined in the happy reading equivalent of holy matrimony, speak now or forever hold your peace. :)
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
03-31-2016, 11:57 AM
I hope I enjoy the Mirage comics, and I agree that no one should dismiss them, but I disagree with the suggestion that there should only be one take on the franchise. After all, if it hadn't been for those absurd, poorly animated '80s cartoons, this forum would not exist, and the comics would be a strange, obscure footnote.
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has had so many iterations, each of which is someone's favorite. No iconic character or series should ever be too beholden to its earliest stories. If they were, Batman would be gunning people down, Superman wouldn't fly, etc.
No no no, I wasn't saying there should be only one take on TMNT; I'm saying that the closer new takes hold to the heart and themes of Mirage TMNT, the better it is.
Chabrendeki
03-31-2016, 12:00 PM
No iconic character or series should ever be too beholden to its earliest stories. If they were, Batman would be gunning people down, Superman wouldn't fly, etc.
The Mirage series is not just the earliest iteration.
Vol. 1 and 2 ran 1984-1995, and ended with the City at War story arc. The Mirage comic started before but ran than then paralel to the OT (1987-1996), or to the Archie comics (1988-1995).
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 12:02 PM
No no no, I wasn't saying there should be only one take on TMNT; I'm saying that the closer new takes hold to the heart and themes of Mirage TMNT, the better it is.
I'd suggest that "it's main themes and heart is what TMNT always SHOULD be" and "they have a fundamental misunderstanding of what TMNT was and should be" is close to suggesting that your preferred take on the franchise is the only valid one, but perhaps I am simply misreading your passion. :)
plastroncafe
03-31-2016, 12:03 PM
Is there any particularly compelling reason why this would not be the smart route to take for the Mirage comics?
I get that many of you are big fans of the artwork, which presumably fares much better on glossy, oversized pages than on my laptop screen. But I have always been more concerned with the story in a given comic rather than the art, so that's not really relevant for me.
If any person here can show cause why this man and this $10 300-page digital comic should not be joined in the happy reading equivalent of holy matrimony, speak now or forever hold your peace. :)
Jump on that deal.
JUMP ON IT!
If you like the stories enough to go and seek out the original floppies, then all the better. (Mirage on glossy paper? Make mine newsprint!)
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 12:06 PM
Jump on that deal.
JUMP ON IT!
Will do! :)
If you like the stories enough to go and seek out the original floppies, then all the better.
I abandoned floppies in the late '90s. Graphic novels and trade paperbacks for the win. I don't care for all the organizational efforts required to read floppies.
Chabrendeki
03-31-2016, 12:08 PM
Just a note: The printed Ultimate Collection has no glossy paper... it's on a high quality thick bookpaper. :D
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 12:34 PM
Just a note: The printed Ultimate Collection has no glossy paper... it's on a high quality thick bookpaper. :D
My bad. Dumb assumption on my part.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 12:36 PM
Buy the first 5 Ultimate Collections. If you like those, the rest of the Mirage comics have been reprinted under the "Classics" tpb line from IDW, as well as the "Tales of the TMNT" TPB line.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 12:57 PM
Buy the first 5 Ultimate Collections. If you like those, the rest of the Mirage comics have been reprinted under the "Classics" tpb line from IDW, as well as the "Tales of the TMNT" TPB line.
Excellent, thanks for the tip!
Mewzard
03-31-2016, 01:37 PM
Once you make it past volume 3 of the Ultimate Collection hardcovers, you should read IDW's first two trades of Tales of the TMNT. They introduce some characters who later appeared in volumes 4 and 5 of the Ultimate Collection.
There's also Volume 6 of the Ultimate Collection if you want a collection of assorted short stories released throughout the Volume 1 run for the Mirage Comics.
Cryomancer
03-31-2016, 02:06 PM
I feel like a lot of the things I like about Mirage are either hard to put into words, or hard to put into non-spoilers. I guess the main thing is the fact that it's very much a comic about a family living it's lifetime and all the problems that come along with that, and also them being a weirdness magnet in general. Mirage is a truly "adult" and "mature" comic in that sense. Not because it's violent or they swear a little, but because it deals with stuff like brothers drifting apart and living in shaky temporary housing situations and so on.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 03:31 PM
What's also interesting about Mirage is that...there's no real recurring villains. Almost all the villains are dealt with in their first or second appearances, or become allies with the Turtles. Savanti Romero was the only recurring villain in the Mirage universe.
Powder
03-31-2016, 03:41 PM
Baxter's sorta recurring. I mean, he & Shredder respectively have like, what, 3-4 different visits, yeah? Triceratons make a return as well. But yeah, overall, none of them bounce back & forth in the way that cartoon villains do.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 03:44 PM
Technically Baxter only has two times he is a villain to the Turtles, issue #2 and then Volume 2. His appearance in Volume 4 is nothing more than a cameo and Donatello immediately kills him.
Unless there's some other appearance of his I've forgotten about from Tales, but I don't think there was.
Andrew NDB
03-31-2016, 03:45 PM
and the comics would be a strange, obscure footnote.
Even if true, at least it would still have its dignity.
Andrew NDB
03-31-2016, 03:46 PM
Technically Baxter only has two times he is a villain to the Turtles, issue #2 and then Volume 2. His appearance in Volume 4 is nothing more than a cameo and Donatello immediately kills him.
Unless there's some other appearance of his I've forgotten about from Tales, but I don't think there was.
The Brain Thief mini. And V3 #24 and #25, if you want to count those.
Powder
03-31-2016, 03:47 PM
Technically Baxter only has two times he is a villain to the Turtles, issue #2 and then Volume 2. His appearance in Volume 4 is nothing more than a cameo and Donatello immediately kills him.
Unless there's some other appearance of his I've forgotten about from Tales, but I don't think there was.
Brain Thief is another appearance. Was his involvement in City At War strictly a 4kids thing? I haven't read that story in ages.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 03:51 PM
Baxter's return in Volume 2 was only his second appearance since #2.
In fact Baxter was originally just a one-shot character in Mirage, and then they brought him back around 10 years later for Volume 2. It might have had to do with his popularity in the cartoon prompting a return for him.
The Don Brain thief mini I've forgotten all about.
Andrew NDB
03-31-2016, 04:04 PM
In fact Baxter was originally just a one-shot character in Mirage, and then they brought him back around 10 years later for Volume 2. It might have had to do with his popularity in the cartoon prompting a return for him.
That sounds suspiciously like... nothing Laird would do. Ever.
Seems like in retrospect with the later payoff of Baxter's comeback in V2 occurring much later in V4, the idea was to bring in pretty much the only character who ever had a grudge with April and create a subplot in which she's infected, etc., all leading to her discovering her origins and all of that. It just got unnecessarily spread out over years.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 04:07 PM
Maybe it was subconciously, but the fact that Baxter became a recurring character in the cartoon whereas in Mirage he was just a one-shot character for like 10 years....and then he suddenly came back, might have had something to do with it.
I mean if we just look at issue #2 alone, Baxter's just a generic mad scientist and the main point of that issue is to introduce April. Baxter's character didn't really have anything going for him until Volume 2.
Also its rather obvious Baxter's popularity in the OT is what cemented him as a major TMNT villain, which is why the 2k3 series, Nick cartoon, and IDW comics all use Baxter heavily too.
Mewzard
03-31-2016, 04:17 PM
Let's not go too spoilery guys, the TC was looking to check out Mirage after all.
Technogeek29
03-31-2016, 05:09 PM
Maybe it was subconciously, but the fact that Baxter became a recurring character in the cartoon whereas in Mirage he was just a one-shot character for like 10 years....and then he suddenly came back, might have had something to do with it.
I mean if we just look at issue #2 alone, Baxter's just a generic mad scientist and the main point of that issue is to introduce April. Baxter's character didn't really have anything going for him until Volume 2.
Also its rather obvious Baxter's popularity in the OT is what cemented him as a major TMNT villain, which is why the 2k3 series, Nick cartoon, and IDW comics all use Baxter heavily too.
I don't know, he is kind of used sparingly in IDW
Donnie
03-31-2016, 05:16 PM
In agreement with Powder's point on the first page about IDW not being close to Mirage in grittiness. IDW is nothing like Mirage. It's way more OT influenced than it is Mirage. Hell, it's more Archie influenced than it is Mirage. The writers can try to shock readers all they like with Leonardo's turn to the dark side, Donatello's unnecessary near-death experience, Shredder's behind-the-scences beheading, Michelangelo's going off to join that OT-inspired group (:roll:), but at the end of the day they are writing an OT inspired spin-off which peaked awhile ago.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 06:22 PM
Once you make it past volume 3 of the Ultimate Collection hardcovers, you should read IDW's first two trades of Tales of the TMNT. They introduce some characters who later appeared in volumes 4 and 5 of the Ultimate Collection.
There's also Volume 6 of the Ultimate Collection if you want a collection of assorted short stories released throughout the Volume 1 run for the Mirage Comics.
Cool, thanks for the info. Definitely gonna be referring back to this thread once I start buying.
...but because it deals with stuff like brothers drifting apart and living in shaky temporary housing situations and so on.
Sounds compelling to me!
What's also interesting about Mirage is that...there's no real recurring villains. Almost all the villains are dealt with in their first or second appearances, or become allies with the Turtles. Savanti Romero was the only recurring villain in the Mirage universe.
That works, 'cause Shredder is iconic, but he's seldom been an interesting villain.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 06:27 PM
and the comics would be a strange, obscure footnote.
Even if true, at least it would still have its dignity.
I'm sure Eastman and Laird would take lots of comfort from the inherent dignity of their Daredevil parody comic... in the alternate reality wherein they're penniless.
I respect your intense admiration for the Mirage comics, but sometimes your tone is reminiscent of a fourteen-year-old who just discovered punk rock.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 06:36 PM
[/B]
I don't know, he is kind of used sparingly in IDW
Baxter's literally been in the bulk of IDW, he's introduced in the first issue and works for Krang and then briefly for Shredder for most of it leading up to the issue 50 finale.
Candy Kappa
03-31-2016, 06:50 PM
I'm sure Eastman and Laird would take lots of comfort from the inherent dignity of their Daredevil parody comic... in the alternate reality wherein they're penniless.
I respect your intense admiration for the Mirage comics, but sometimes your tone is reminiscent of a fourteen-year-old who just discovered punk rock.
I don't think they would have been penniless. Maybe not the sum laird sold off the entire franchise.
The 1990 movie was a-go before the cartoon show took off and Palladium had a very successful RPG that lasted quite a bit, and only died out due to the FW cartoon. And there could have been other products akin to the licensed Solson comics.
Of course, I doubt Eastman & Laird would have buried the Turtles when they got tired of making comics in a alternative-universe where no FW cartoon happened, Instead I'm pretty sure they would have (hesitantly) sold the property to Marvel.
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 06:53 PM
I don't think they would have been penniless. Maybe not the sum laird sold off the entire franchise.
Oh, certainly not. I was being a smartass.
I don't think they would have been penniless. Maybe not the sum laird sold off the entire franchise.
Huh. I'd like to visit that alternate reality, if only for a day.
CyberCubed
03-31-2016, 07:08 PM
Eastman has already worked on plenty of properties after TMNT (in fact he abandoned the TMNT franchise for more than a decade to work at Heavy Metal), and Peter Laird also was a freelance illustrator.
Had the cartoon never happened and the Mirage comics died out in the early 90's, they would still be rich and work on other products.
psychturtle
03-31-2016, 08:10 PM
There is some really great, caring, honest discussion in this thread. Nice change of pace for this forum
Monte Williams
03-31-2016, 09:33 PM
There is some really great, caring, honest discussion in this thread. Nice change of pace for this forum
I've been on this forum for eight years, and for roughly six of those years I mostly avoided the place because I found the tone of a few members to be off-putting and uninviting when I first started posting. But I've come to learn that, generally speaking, it is a friendly and supportive place populated with enthusiastic, articulate, friendly, encouraging fans.
Cryomancer
04-01-2016, 12:20 AM
Mirage people always want to make more Mirage people! It's a good time! In that it's mostly about bad times!
TMNTooze
04-01-2016, 12:54 AM
Although I grew up with the FW Cartoon and the Archie Comics, I have really enjoyed reading the IDW comics. I also really like the Mirage comics. Different times and different comics. I like them all the same and just enjoy reading the comics to escape the stresses of work. If it wasn't for my kids getting into the new turtles cartoon and various comics, I probably wouldn't have read any of the Mirage. Thanks kids! There is just something special about the beginnings of TMNT in comics and what it has become today.
shuriken
04-01-2016, 02:02 AM
I think it honestly depends on the person and what they like, as well as what kind of a mood you're in. In my most retrospective days nothing beats reading some James O' Bar or Mirage TMNT. It's not "dark and gritty" for the sake of dark and gritty, but there is an essence of melancholy isolation to it. And Every one of us feels that way at one point or another. I "discovered" Mirage when I was 8, but never got to read one until I was 12. It was essentially when TMNT was dead. No comics, shows or movies. It was so different from anything I had seen. And as much as I like IDW, Mirage takes the top spot in my heart cuz I dunno, it connects with me in a way very few comics do.
CyberCubed
04-01-2016, 02:19 AM
While I had scattered issues of Mirage in the 90's (basically whatever my parents bought for me that we found in old comic shops back in the day), I didn't start following it seriously until 2001 when Volume 4 came out. Got every issue of Volume 4 when it was new and released.
At that point I went to ninjaturtles.com and bought the entire Mirage lineup from them over the next few years. They had all the Image comics too, I was so glad to buy them when I could and they were cheap.
This was back in 2001-2005 or so...so it was literally a decade ago.
Andrew NDB
04-01-2016, 11:43 AM
I'm sure Eastman and Laird would take lots of comfort from the inherent dignity of their Daredevil parody comic...
Unlikely, I've never heard of them making one.
plastroncafe
04-01-2016, 11:59 AM
Mirage people always want to make more Mirage people! It's a good time! In that it's mostly about bad times!
What's great about this statement is how true it is....for everything. It's like...the one true universal.
People who like a thing always want to make more people who like that thing! It's a good time! In that it's mostly about bad times.
Utrommaniac
04-01-2016, 01:53 PM
Unlikely, I've never heard of them making one.
The original TMNT issue IS the Daredevil tie-in parody :D . The "young guy gets blinded by toxic goop while pushing a blindman out of the way of a runaway truck" part of the origin is Daredevil himself. Eastman and Laird just added a kid dropping his pet turtles into the sewer as part of the chaos of that moment.
The Foot is even a parody of the Hand criminal sect in Daredevil.
I've heard of weirder superheroes they could be tied to, but at least it wasn't Aquaman??? (Okay, I might actually want to see the universe where they're tied to Aquaman...just for fun)
Andrew NDB
04-01-2016, 01:54 PM
The original TMNT issue IS the Daredevil tie-in parody. The "young guy gets blinded by toxic goop while pushing a blindman out of the way of a runaway truck" part of the origin is Daredevil himself. Eastman and Laird just added a kid dropping his pet turtles into the sewer as part of the chaos of that moment.
A few parodic elements doesn't make it a parody. Both Eastman and Laird have flat out disagreed that it's a parody.
Utrommaniac
04-01-2016, 02:01 PM
I guess I've just been Snoped then :teek: . At least I learned.
plastroncafe
04-01-2016, 02:01 PM
Homage. The word you're both dancing around is homage.
Though I personally prefer the word spoof, myself.
Especially given the dedication to Frank Miller as inside cover art.
ProphetofGanja
04-01-2016, 02:40 PM
Homage. The word you're both dancing around is homage.
Though I personally prefer the word spoof, myself.
Especially given the dedication to Frank Miller as inside cover art.
I think 'tribute' would be an appropriate term as well
Lot of good points in this thread. I've only read the first issue cover to cover (which I liked), and then bits and pieces of other issues (definitely a mixed bag, but what isn't). I hope I come across one of the collected editions at the library because I can't justify spending money on them until I know a little bether how I feel about the Mirage run as a whole
Candy Kappa
04-01-2016, 02:52 PM
never mind about the satire part, double checking where I found it from. It's incorrect that satire comes from plays that was done straight, bt the cast was dressed as satyrs. Which is kinda sad that it's not true. :/
TMNT's tie to Frank Miller's run in Daredevil is very superficial. The Foot have very little in common with The Hand, and the origin while similar, we never see "Matt" again.
plastroncafe
04-01-2016, 03:00 PM
I think 'tribute' would be an appropriate term as well
Lot of good points in this thread. I've only read the first issue cover to cover (which I liked), and then bits and pieces of other issues (definitely a mixed bag, but what isn't). I hope I come across one of the collected editions at the library because I can't justify spending money on them until I know a little bether how I feel about the Mirage run as a whole
HIGHLY recommend using the library.
Be sure to check out their digital offerings as well. Depending on the system they might have them as e-books.
I've friends who've used their local inter-library loan desk to read the last 15-20 years work of Marvel back issues as a way to save money while also avoiding the local color at their nearest comic shop.
ProphetofGanja
04-01-2016, 04:01 PM
TMNT's tie to Frank Miller's run in Daredevil is very superficial. The Foot have very little in common with The Hand, and the origin while similar, we never see "Matt" again.
Why would we see him again? Eastman and Laird's comic focuses on the Turtles from that scenario, not the boy who went blind. It's really just a neat little easter egg, a reference to a comic property of which they were fans
CyberCubed
04-01-2016, 04:03 PM
TMNT was based on everything that was popular at the time:
- Teenagers. Teenage superheroes are always popular as seen with X-men, Teen Titans, or teens in general.
- Mutants. Again, X-men and mutants have always been popular.
- Ninja's. Everyone has always found ninja's cool, ninjitsu and martial arts are always incredibly popular with western fans. Asian culture has influenced the U.S. heavily.
- Turtles. Well, this is what they are.
plastroncafe
04-01-2016, 04:34 PM
And also Frank Miller's run on Daredevil, which was very popular at the time.
ProphetofGanja
04-01-2016, 05:08 PM
TMNT was based on everything that was popular at the time:
- Teenagers. Teenage superheroes are always popular as seen with X-men, Teen Titans, or teens in general.
- Mutants. Again, X-men and mutants have always been popular.
- Ninja's. Everyone has always found ninja's cool, ninjitsu and martial arts are always incredibly popular with western fans. Asian culture has influenced the U.S. heavily.
- Turtles. Well, this is what they are.
this kid gets it
https://media.giphy.com/media/lXiRoPt9Rkzt7yLYY/giphy.gif
:lol: :lol: :lol:
Monte Williams
04-01-2016, 05:23 PM
HIGHLY recommend using the library.
If and when I get around to buying the Mirage material, it'll be the first time I've spent money on comics in years. It's all about the library.
...except for Ms. Marvel, which one of my eighth graders lets me borrow whenever a new trade is released. :)
neatoman
04-01-2016, 05:43 PM
Well let's put it like this, while there is a lot creativity and passion behind Mirage's material it's kind of hard to deny that a lot of it feels like a web comic. I probably admire Mirage more than I enjoy it, not that I don't enjoy it but the flaws are too big to ignore.
Cryomancer
04-01-2016, 06:27 PM
What's great about this statement is how true it is....for everything. It's like...the one true universal.
People who like a thing always want to make more people who like that thing! It's a good time! In that it's mostly about bad times.
I'm old and cynical enough now that I know that sometimes though, you don't want more people to like your thing you like, because then it gets dumbed down! If this applies strongly to Mirage fans or not you can decide for yourself, heh.
Powder
04-01-2016, 07:06 PM
We're in the clear, dumb people don't like Mirage. :)
plastroncafe
04-01-2016, 07:12 PM
I'm old and cynical enough now that I know that sometimes though, you don't want more people to like your thing you like, because then it gets dumbed down! If this applies strongly to Mirage fans or not you can decide for yourself, heh.
That's not old and cynical, that's just hipster.
Cryomancer
04-02-2016, 11:48 AM
That's not old and cynical, that's just hipster.
It's old and cynical if you feel that way because you've seen it happen too many times, haha.
plastroncafe
04-02-2016, 12:08 PM
It's old and cynical if you feel that way because you've seen it happen too many times, haha.
HA! Okay, point taken.
CyberCubed
04-02-2016, 12:26 PM
Mirage really is the only series that the Turtles don't behave like superheroes. Every other series (the 3 cartoons, Archie, and even IDW at times), have that superhero stigma to them where they're trying to save the world, etc.
The Mirage Turtles were...just there. They didn't go looking for trouble, they just lived their lives and whatever villains there were came to them. In Mirage there is no, "world saving" aspect to it.
Andrew NDB
04-02-2016, 12:52 PM
Mirage really is the only series that the Turtles don't behave like superheroes. Every other series (the 3 cartoons, Archie, and even IDW at times), have that superhero stigma to them where they're trying to save the world, etc.
The Mirage Turtles were...just there. They didn't go looking for trouble, they just lived their lives and whatever villains there were came to them. In Mirage there is no, "world saving" aspect to it.
And why would there be? There is no compelling reason the Turtles should be out saving the world. They're barely even a part of the world, forced to live in sewers, mausoleums, etc..
Cipher
04-04-2016, 04:06 AM
Yes, but fortunately/unfortunately it probably holds the most appeal for a completely different crowd from most commercial comics readers, and very likely from those captivated by the IDW run or any of the more popular cartoons.
If you're a weirdo like me and part of a literature/comic iconography cross-over demographic, hell yeah, especially if you start with the later material or can vibe on the pure joy of the fun Eastman and Laird are having early in the series. I still recommend it to those into art and indie comics as well.
If you really want to dip your toes into Mirage, or have someone else do the same, and you want to give them something a little more indicative of where the series goes than the first dozen issues, it's hard to go wrong with "Sons of the Silent Age."
Big, hearty second to that "Mirage is mostly about bad times" comment. I will always love the Mirage series to death. There isn't anything else quite like it -- an anything-goes hard-genre/comics world using recognized commercial characters to play out absurd, bleak and emotionally resonant stories. That's when it isn't just having fun (whatever that means to the creator of that particular issue--which can be played completely straight or also bleak and bizarre).
If you had to attach a genre label to the Mirage series as a whole, it'd probably be "new weird," but even that doesn't capture what a strange beast it is, continuing to be helmed by its we-do-what-we-want creators even as its characters exploded into icons of all-ages pop-culture in other media. I don't think that'll ever happen again. (And the few times the comic acknowledges this are fantastically weird and glorious.)
Well let's put it like this, while there is a lot creativity and passion behind Mirage's material it's kind of hard to deny that a lot of it feels like a web comic. I probably admire Mirage more than I enjoy it, not that I don't enjoy it but the flaws are too big to ignore.
There was a magical and strange time when "web comics" would actually be printed in small runs for underground consumption. It was called independent publishing and some say it continues as a practice to this very day, unbelievable as that may seem. If you stop into a small book- or comic shop, you may just be able to see the rare 'zine scurry away into the mist, only for a second, out of the corner of your eye.
We're in the clear, dumb people don't like Mirage. :)
http://www.reactiongifs.com/r/otcg.gif
they're not big fans of humans.
Michelangelo is a big fan of humans. It's pretty consistent from his micro-issue onward that he's the one most frustrated by their inability to live normal human lives.
Michelangelo has never, ever been a better character than he is in Mirage.
City at War is simply the best TMNT story there ever will be. Because at its heart, it's not about the action, violence, or chaos; it's about the Turtles wondering what their place in the world is and why they should even continue fighting a battle that they were forced into long ago by their father.
Agreed. "City at War" is handily the best Ninja Turtles story ever told, and by a pretty ridiculously wide margin. I actually do think you can skip right to it, as long as you know the overall outline of the plot that precedes it. It's better in context, but I first read it as a young teen having only gone through maybe the first ... four? ... issues of Mirage beforehand and still appreciated the hell out of it. (Though the Rat King Tales issue (#4), which factors into it, is a great issue on its own, and very tonally Mirage. Lawson was a godsend for scripting.)
Monte Williams
04-04-2016, 06:54 AM
Back on page one, I said to Powder, "I couldn't have asked for a more insightful and generous reply to start off this thread."
Likewise, Cipher, as this thread slows down, I couldn't have asked for a more insightful and generous reply to start to draw it to a close.
I can tell the Mirage comics mean a lot to you, but it's clear, too, that for you it's not some knee-jerk nostalgic thing.
Thank you.
Panda_Kahn_fan
04-05-2016, 11:55 PM
So when people come along and say "screw the Mirage TMNT" or that they don't like it, or it's too dark and violent for them, I say that they have a fundamental misunderstanding of what TMNT was and should be. Don't settle for the kiddie versions. We've all grown up and we should let our understanding of characters grow up with us.
Mirage is an excellent TMNT comic, and has a place of honor as the first version. Yes it's core theme of the TMNT as a family should be the foundation of every TMNT version. But I do understand what TMNT is about, and I still don't like Mirage. My understanding of the characters has grown up with me, and IDW is my favorite TMNT version, Mirage just isn't my thing (with the exception of the first image arc, the river, a few vol.1 stories, and city at war). Mirage is darker and grittier and has more complex themes, but I reject the notion that IDW is immature.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
06-13-2016, 07:14 AM
As there is a Turtles sale on at comixology , due to the release of the new movie, I bought Ultimate collection Volumes 1 - 5, reading 1 issue a night.
Honestly, it's very different. I like the art style, and the overall tone, but the narrative is different than what i expected. The pace goes quite quickly to start, with the turtles going into space in issue 4.
it's not bad, but it's certainly different. I like how they kill shredder in the first issue. I find too many versions of the turtles seem to only have the Shredder as the main villain. With him being killed in the first issue, means we spend more time with other villains, instead of the Shredder for the millionth time.
I am looking forward to City at War, since I quite liked the 2k3 version, and I've heard that they butchered the story line in 2k3 and the original Mirage version is much better.
Powder
06-13-2016, 07:17 AM
One of us! One of us! ... :)
Technogeek29
06-13-2016, 07:28 AM
One of us! One of us! ... :)
http://stream1.gifsoup.com/view5/3902116/gooble-gobble-o.gif
Gooble Goble, Gooble Goble
Monte Williams
06-13-2016, 11:15 AM
I still need to give it a whirl. I have mostly caught up with the IDW goodness via ComiXology. Still looking forward to starting Mirage, and honestly, had I realized there was a sale I might have taken advantage of it instead of buying Buffy toys with my money.
AquaParade
06-13-2016, 11:18 PM
Every fan of tmnt should read City at War.
Monte Williams
03-02-2017, 12:47 AM
I bought the first five volumes of the Ultimate Collection and read the first three a while back, and then...
Well...
And what I will say is that Mirage simply hasn't captured my heart...
The main art style doesn't help either. It's just too hard on the eyes...
I am pretty much in agreement with you.
I just posted the following on Facebook:
This week in... Geek Blasphemy:
I mostly don't care for the Mirage TMNT.
The artwork is all over the place, the earnest tone is way too much (the street gangs and such make the whole thing seem like an After-School Special at times), and the cumulative result too frequently feels awkward and off-putting. I respect and admire it for various reasons, but I derive so little pleasure from it that I forgot for several months that I even have access to them, and when I dipped back into them tonight I almost immediately started skimming recklessly through dozens of pages at a time, as I did when last I tried to explore them.
Or...
Well let's put it like this, while there is a lot creativity and passion behind Mirage's material... I probably admire Mirage more than I enjoy it, not that I don't enjoy it but the flaws are too big to ignore.
I wonder if I subconsciously remembered your comment, 'cause if not that's a strange coincidence.
In closing:
To be fair, part of the problem is my weird lack of stamina with comics in general; they exhaust me in a way prose doesn't. I don't know when or why this became the case. I used to read comics all the time, and if anything you'd think prose books might be daunting and comic books more inviting, but something weird has happened to my brain. Perhaps I'd like the Mirage stuff more if this weren't the case.
I'm a bit bummed that I'm not more into these comics, but it's mostly because I enjoyed this thread last year and I appreciate all your generous comments and suggestions. I'd hoped to come back and reciprocate, and instead I feel like a party-pooper, ha ha.
Still, thanks, everybody!
Coola Yagami
03-02-2017, 06:32 AM
It's actually easier to get into mirage since the major stories were already adapted twice. You can look at it as reading the original version of 'the foot nearly kills Leo and they escape to Northampton until they return to face shredder' story.
City at War must be read because it does bring a good point. Why should the turtles continue to fight Splinter's war for him? Plus Karai. She wasn't Shredder's daughter, hell, she had a daughter of her own!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.