PDA

View Full Version : Most underrated TMNT comic? (any version)


GoldMutant
04-17-2016, 04:15 PM
For every Return to New York, #44 for IDW, and Future Shark Trilogy, there's a TMNT comic from every version glanced over. Whether by popularity by others or not as enjoyable, I've been curious on this. I've been meaning to start reading the Mirage Comics (though the art style in the second issue and my own life is stopping me for now) but wanted to ask this:

From any version of the comics, which do you find the most overlooked among the others? I'm curious so in the future, I can be on the look out when reading them.

Mew
04-17-2016, 04:26 PM
The Dreamwave comics.

funatic
04-17-2016, 07:36 PM
People rave about City At War and its prelude Shades of Grey, but right before that magnum opus are 3 of my favorite Mirage issues that I rarely see mentioned. 46 & 47, the "Masks" arc is brilliant, Dooney's art beautiful, and has one of the most monumental epilogues of any turtles book (but blink and you'll miss it). 45 might very well be my FAVORITE TMNT COMIC, PERIOD, due to Berger's killer inks and my soft spot for ol' Leatherhead. All three issues are canon as a bonus! Even better - they are all conveniently collected together in the IDW Classics v.7 TPB! Check it out!

Powder
04-17-2016, 08:33 PM
The entirety of Image's volume 3.

CyberCubed
04-17-2016, 09:14 PM
Tales of the TMNT #69. Most people don't even remember half the Tales issues (there were literally 70 issues), but 69 was a great issue about Shadow.

ianke_2002
04-17-2016, 10:00 PM
Easily the entire 7 issues of the Dreamwave comic. That is thought of by most people I find as a stain on the TMNT comics world but I absolutely friggin loved it and was really crushed when it was cancelled. Although I've heard it getting flak before on this forum, I thought LeSean's art in the book was fantastic and David's writing was really great, especially with the final 2(?) issues where they started not following the 2k3 show anymore. The covers of those seven issues might be some of the best tmnt comic book covers PERIOD. Man....just talking about this series again has got me misty eyed. Really miss it.

MikeandRaph87
04-17-2016, 10:11 PM
The Future Shark Trilogy is still my favorite TMNT comic storyline, but Raw Power from TMNT Adventures#23-25 and The Black Hole Trilogy from TMNTA#48-50 were great as well and standout.

Cryomancer
04-18-2016, 12:36 AM
Tales of the TMNT #69. Most people don't even remember half the Tales issues (there were literally 70 issues), but 69 was a great issue about Shadow.

I kinda want to say anything about Shadow in general. People don't talk about her very much, and a lot of the issues where she's important are pretty good.

Same for Leonardo entering the Battle Nexus, but that was unresolved of course so welp.

Nortock Diab
04-18-2016, 01:28 AM
People rave about City At War and its prelude Shades of Grey, but right before that magnum opus are 3 of my favorite Mirage issues that I rarely see mentioned. 46 & 47, the "Masks" arc is brilliant, Dooney's art beautiful, and has one of the most monumental epilogues of any turtles book (but blink and you'll miss it). 45 might very well be my FAVORITE TMNT COMIC, PERIOD, due to Berger's killer inks and my soft spot for ol' Leatherhead. All three issues are canon as a bonus! Even better - they are all conveniently collected together in the IDW Classics v.7 TPB! Check it out!

#45 is one of my favorite as well. One of the first issue I read.
I became an instant fan of Leatherhead after that!

funatic
04-18-2016, 01:58 AM
#45 is one of my favorite as well. One of the first issue I read.
I became an instant fan of Leatherhead after that!

No one does Leatherhead quite like Berger! The crown jewel of my TMNT collection is a huge commission he did for me of Leatherhead and the four turtles. The amount of linework he packs into the big guy is staggering! Doesn't hurt that he's also a mightyfine storyteller, turning out some of the best issues of Tales v2, like the aforementioned #69.

Nortock Diab
04-18-2016, 02:54 AM
Do you have this commission posted on the web somewhere?

Issue #23 of Tales Vol.2 which follows Leatherhead as well is very good in my opinion.

Utrommaniac
04-18-2016, 11:14 AM
Issue #23 of Tales Vol.2 which follows Leatherhead as well is very good in my opinion.

I'm agreed there. I just wish it could have been a two-parter or something to better establish those new characters, like Rikby...even though he was just going to die anyway? It also showcased why it's best that the Illuminated Utroms weren't shown a lot in Mirage. They're not exactly the brightest bunch.
The story itself is a little "cliffnote-y", and warrants a little bit more meat on it.

That development on Leatherhead, though. All that pining and work to go to the Utrom homeworld only to determine, with great sadness, that he belongs on Earth. It's quite bittersweet, really.


I don't know how this one is rated among fans, but another story I liked was the one with Michelangelo trying to save his dying cat. Probably because I had to deal with that twice last year, so I empathized. One was a two-day-old kitten that had no chance, and the other had been in my life since I was six.
While it's obvious that Michelangelo's slaughter fest in vol 4 is most certainly out of character, I think that story was a demonstration of what he is willing to due in a situation that dire - even though he didn't go through with it. If anything, this was remarkably more reasonable within his personality.
Lord knows what he would have done or felt if he saved Klunk and then found out that he killed a mother.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-18-2016, 11:20 AM
For as much as I rag on Tales volume 2, it does have some absolute gems:

"The Path" (death of Michelangelo's pet cat Klunk)
"Virus" / "Replicants" / "Splinter Cell" (the Leatherhead/Hana Hamato trilogy)
"Blind Faith" (Leo is blinded)

Honestly, I don't know. My viewpoint is skewed on "underrated" TMNT comics because I'm on here with fellow uber-geeks. No need to defend Image Volume 3; Andrew and Powder are even bigger fans of it than I am. Maybe Volume 4? It gets a lot of hate, but it does have some good ideas and its moments...

funatic
04-18-2016, 12:13 PM
Do you have this commission posted on the web somewhere?

I actually devoted an entire thread to it :P (this was before I knew about the art share thread)! You can see it, and other amazing pieces by Dan here: http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=40535

And not to completely derail this thread, hopping on the underrated Tales v2 train, #55, "A Day in the Life", is a sleeper hit emblematic of what I consider to be the heart and soul themes of Mirage TMNT: Family & Introspection.

Cipher
04-18-2016, 01:13 PM
Tales Vol. 2 #6 "Scars" gets no love, but it's an all-time great Leo issue, and, I think, just a great one-off on its own. DrSpengler notably ripped it a new one on TMNT Entity for its failure to launch its focal character (then simultaneously appearing in Vol. 4), but I think that ignores how good a stand-alone tale it is.

I think the entire Leonardo Blindsight mini-series is underrated. While it does needlessly undermine the stellar Tales Vol. 2 #5, there's some seriously interesting sh*t going on with Leo and Splinter in the last two issues that is rewarding if you've been following the whole Mirage arc.

Tales Vol. 2 #55 is pretty well-loved here, but I want to cite it again in case anyone hasn't read it. #69 "School Daze" is enjoyable for many of the same reasons. Both fantastic slice-of-life issues that nail a mix of whimsical and somber beats. If someone were looking to pinpoint the tone of the Mirage series, I'd offer these up as readily as "Sons of the Silent Age."

I want to give a shout-out to the brutally bizarre ending of Adventures #62 as well, which as far as I'm concerned could've capped off the whole series in an oddly satisfying way, depending on your tolerance for surreal conclusions.

Utrommaniac
04-18-2016, 01:22 PM
I think Mirage is so massive that anyone could say any small one-shot could be called underrated.

Another I liked was the story about the kid who joined the Foot, and ended up getting killed on his first mission like his father (and brother?). His younger brother then vows to take up the mantle. What a tangled web we weave. And yet, I don't think anyone has talked about that one...recently, that is. In the grand scheme of things, it's a very small event, and the tragedy of it gets swept up among all the other small tragedies within the medium.

It's the tiny ones like that that are some pretty gems, and there are so many that it's hard to pick out a single one. You could reach into the bucket and say "this one deserves more recognition", but then again, you might as well do it for every single one in there. Of course, there will be some little lumps of coal mixed in, maybe a bit of pyrite (pretty, but it's crumbly and sucks), but eventually, you just get another small pile in which the individuals are jumbled together.

Not that it's a bad thing. There's a sort of joy to digging through them and remembering the special qualities that could deem it "underrated".

If IDW City Fall is a gigantic geode pillar that's obvious to everyone, The Path is a tiny little turquoise that you'd have to pick up and observe personally, and maybe bring home in a pouch.

Cipher
04-18-2016, 01:24 PM
I think Mirage is so massive that anyone could say any small one-shot is underrated.
I mean, maybe, but that's why it's cool to point people to the real gems, although I just recommend going through whatever you can find, because even Tales Vol. 2's mediocre issues tend to be interesting.

Utrommaniac
04-18-2016, 01:39 PM
I mean, maybe, but that's why it's cool to point people to the real gems, although I just recommend going through whatever you can find, because even Tales Vol. 2's mediocre issues tend to be interesting.

I think that might just be the joy of Mirage. It's not something I think I could read linearly like IDW. More of a blindbag. I've found it to be the best way to get those little surprises that don't get a lot of recognition...or the ones that are rightfully forgotten.

funatic
04-18-2016, 04:57 PM
On the more recent front I think Tristan's Infestation 2-parter is overlooked in the IDW age. Tristan has the turtle voices down! It felt very much like an extension of Tales v2. I wish they brought him back to pen more micros and minis!

CyberCubed
04-18-2016, 05:12 PM
To be honest Mirage isn't even that big, at least not compared to other comic standards.

Volume 1 was only 62 issues plus the 4 TMNT one-shots. The original Tales was only 7 issues. Volume 2 is only 13 issues. Image is only 23 issues. Volume 4 is only 32 issues. Tales of the TMNT V. 2 is the longest with 70 issues plus the 16 mini's. Then there's the specials and mini's but even then there's not that much.

Mirage has under 200 issues overall.