View Full Version : Did the comic industry took the wrong lessons from the original comics?
JakeSully
04-25-2016, 12:45 AM
I mean the original Turtle comics were successes in the comic stores in the 80s and it with Ronin, Dark Knight Returns, Watchmen, Batman Year One, Swamp Thing, Heavy Metal Magazine, Akira by Katushiro Otomo, V For Vendetta and more made comics hip again and proved comics weren't just kids stuff.
Unfortunately some people took the wrong lessons in the 90s in the comic industry with imitators thinking dark/gritty/grim is the way to go and would sell.
Candy Kappa
04-25-2016, 05:16 AM
How many times are you gonna make threads and posts about "grimdark is bad you guyz"?
We get it.
neatoman
04-25-2016, 05:27 AM
Uh yeah sure, filling up stores with material that only has one tone is bad idea, but what's even worse (and I think this is probably far more important than the change of tone) is that American publishers started to make their product too expensive and obscure for most people who might want to start reading comics.
Not to mention the rather blatant use of crossover events and spin-off books Marvel/DC have put out since then, it intentionally makes it hard to just pick up just one or two books and enjoy it. If you want to read X-Men right now, Marvel has made it so that in order fully understand what's going on with the characters you have to read:
All-New X-Men
Extraordinary X-Men
Uncanny X-Men
All-New Wolverine
That's four books, assuming a 4$ price tag for all, that's 16$ every month just to read a tiny bit of the storyline every month. This is all ignoring the event comics, the upcoming Civil War II will cost about 324$ if you buy the back issues (this is why I typically go for the trades).
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-25-2016, 09:13 AM
How many times are you gonna make threads and posts about "grimdark is bad you guyz"?
We get it.
Hey, be nice. People who suffer from Alzheimer's have trouble remembering what they've previously said or done. Not his fault.
plastroncafe
04-25-2016, 11:14 AM
Monoculture will always kill a thing.
Panda_Kahn_fan
04-25-2016, 11:24 AM
Dark should be on the shelf with lighthearted fun, along with every shade of the spectrum in between.
Yes, turning everything dark in the early 90's was stupid and shortsighted. It's why by the late 90's manga like Pokemon was outselling western comics with kids, and the comedic and lighthearted Archie was still in the grocery stores, while western superhero comics had disappeared. In other counties there is a whole variety of tones in comic books, why we always drift toward one tone here I'll never know.
plastroncafe
04-25-2016, 11:32 AM
People don't like change in general. Fanboys don't like it specifically.
It's why Bruce Wayne will always be Batman, or Peter Parker will always be Spider-man.
People would rather re-invent the wheel, than let the one they have take them in new directions.
slingtheory
05-03-2016, 11:38 PM
I mean the original Turtle comics were successes in the comic stores in the 80s and it with Ronin, Dark Knight Returns, Watchmen, Batman Year One, Swamp Thing, Heavy Metal Magazine, Akira by Katushiro Otomo, V For Vendetta and more made comics hip again and proved comics weren't just kids stuff.
Unfortunately some people took the wrong lessons in the 90s in the comic industry with imitators thinking dark/gritty/grim is the way to go and would sell.
so from the title I thought you were talking about the original comics effect on
the brand in modern day so I was confused for a minute. As for your actual question I don't think so. It's not like we're seeing an overflow of grim and gritty stories in comics these days. In the stuff I'm into I see a pretty good balance. Things can get a little on the serious side sure but that comes with the territory when you realize adults are reading and you want to hold their attention.
Spike Spiegel
05-03-2016, 11:46 PM
Try reading comics without superheroes. There's a whole slew of different genres out there, as well as stuff from outside the U.S.
Comics are like film; they can be anything you want them to be. Maybe you haven't been looking in the right places.
Utrommaniac
05-04-2016, 12:21 AM
*Coughs loudly and heavily*
http://www.cbcbooks.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Bone-Logo.jpg
Okay, granted, that was self-published for most of its run. But that's not the point.
Bone is one of the highest selling comics of the century, and has stayed on top-ten lists for most of its existence once it was being big-published. It began publication in the early 90's, when you claim that comic writers thought staying grimdark like the 80's would sell. And maybe it did for some. And it didn't for others. But it didn't work. And Bone is my offering of reasoning.
While the latter half of the story is a little more grim, it has the reputation of being a comedy and a light-hearted romp. And that's what keeps it selling high to this very day. Its mixed tones. You can have the calm before the storm of an old lady beating cows in a race, and then have sh*t fly right out the window when her true origins are revealed. You can have the Wile E. Coyote duo of a truly terrifying species, struggling in vain to capture a meal for themselves, while the others are more interested in reclaiming their rightful homeland (and ultimately failing). It has its both ways, and that is part of what makes it a great story. The darkness is balanced by the humor, and in some occasions, they are one and the same.
Much later on, Jeff Smith would go on to do a story called RASL, which I haven't read all of...but it is a considerably darker story. But that's not what made me disinterested in it; just what it was about overall. I would love to read a grimdark Jeff Smith story because I know he can do it. Just a different kind of story.
It's not about grimdark failing because the 80's did it. Grimdark fails when the writing fails. Period. The original TMNT comics are not the bedrock for the grimdark of the 90's comics. Especially with everything TMNT in the 90's being connected to the Fred Wolf cartoon and not the comics. The publishers of the grimdark comics of the 80's were the very same ones from the 90's. When Marvel saw that grimdark sold then, they figured it would continue to sell later. And it did. The same with DC. And Darkhorse. And so forth. Not EVERY successful comic publication was saturated with it. Again, there was Bone.
There is the matter of darker comics getting pretentious, and that's probably why it stopped working in the end.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.