PDA

View Full Version : Why isn't IDW doing "The Forever War"?


miru
06-09-2016, 01:47 PM
With "The Forever War" canned at both Archie and Mirage, why hasn't IDW picked up the reins? They have done this with Marvel's Transformers comics, so why not these? Is it due to copyright reasons? Was there too much mature themes? Or would the material have just sucked?

I want an explanation.

Redeemer
06-09-2016, 01:58 PM
Why just not ask IDW themselves via Bobby?
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=54235

ToTheNines
06-09-2016, 01:59 PM
Because Steve Murphy.

Don't really understand your poll though. Usagi never had anything to do with Forever War. Or the TMNTA universe at all.

CyberCubed
06-09-2016, 03:29 PM
The other obvious reason is that outside of the 30th anniversary book, IDW generally doesn't publish new stories in old universes.

Andrew NDB
06-09-2016, 03:33 PM
Could be Nick's blockade, or the fact that their TPB line hasn't reached the end of the existing TMNTA. Though remember, according to Steve he doesn't even remember what was going to happen in The Forever War and lost all files on it (which is a little dubious).

Jephael
06-13-2016, 10:36 AM
Some days I wish they had never advertised that storyarc. All it's done is give us fans years and years of frustration and lost hope.

Andrew NDB
06-13-2016, 10:45 AM
Some days I wish they had never advertised that storyarc. All it's done is give us fans years and years of frustration and lost hope.

I've never been super excited about it. Curious, yes. But we never even really knew what it was supposed to be about, exactly, to get all that worked up about it. Something with time travel, Shredder, and the Future Turtles?

ProphetofGanja
06-13-2016, 11:04 AM
I've never been super excited about it. Curious, yes. But we never even really knew what it was supposed to be about, exactly, to get all that worked up about it. Something with time travel, Shredder, and the Future Turtles?

So was the Forever War teased in solicitations way back in the day and then it never came out? I've heard it mentioned frequently but I don't know anything about it, other than that some people really want it to finally be realized

Joey Kamikaze
06-13-2016, 12:11 PM
It was the next arc being teased just before Archie fired Steve Murphy and canceled TMNTA back in the day. As a result it's become something of a legend.

DrSpengler
06-13-2016, 12:25 PM
So was the Forever War teased in solicitations way back in the day and then it never came out? I've heard it mentioned frequently but I don't know anything about it, other than that some people really want it to finally be realized

Here's an article about it if you want all the specifics. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/08/whatever-happened-to-forever-war.html)

Andrew NDB
06-13-2016, 12:28 PM
First: It was promoted as the final TMNTA story arc with in-comic "NEXT: FOREVER WAR!" little blurbs and pics... but Archie scrapped it and did the two part "How did the Little Turtles first get their weapons?" story instead. Apparently some covers and at least a couple pages were created for it.

Second: It was brought back to be completed at Mirage around 2009. Steve Murphy scrapped all existing work on it and began redoing everything from scratch because he wasn't sure where he was going with it originally with where it had been left for so long. The sale to Nick/Viacom happened and the clock ran out on it so it never happened. Steve basically indicated that he and Chris Allan would have completed it faster had they known they had a limited time to work on it. Evidently no scripts were actually ever created this time around, only allegedly an issue-by-issue synopsis of events.

Third: A few years ago I reached out to Steve Murphy (and Chris Allan, who really wouldn't discuss this professionally unless it would be under official channels) about getting his scripts for The Forever War so Arseniy/DemonAlukard and I could do the finisher. He said absolutely, but he only had the aforementioned issue-by-issue synopsis to offer. That said, he still wanted to wait to January 1st of that given year (2012 or so, I think?) just in case IDW wanted to approach him officially to do it before promising to give them to me/Arseniy. The date came and went and after a few more months Murphy basically said he couldn't find his synopses, and didn't remember anything that happened in it at all, which is a little head-scratching.

So that's that.

ProphetofGanja
06-13-2016, 12:30 PM
First: It was promoted as the final TMNTA story arc with in-comic "NEXT: FOREVER WAR!" little blurbs and pics... but Archie scrapped it and did the two part "How did the Little Turtles first get their weapons?" story instead. Apparently some covers and at least a couple pages were created for it.

Second: It was brought back to be completed at Mirage around 2009. Steve Murphy scrapped all existing work on it and began redoing everything from scratch because he wasn't sure where he was going with it originally with where it had been left for so long. The sale to Nick/Viacom happened and the clock ran out on it so it never happened. Steve basically indicated that he and Chris Allan would have completed it faster had they known they had a limited time to work on it. Evidently no scripts were actually ever created this time around, only allegedly an issue-by-issue synopsis of events.

Third: A few years ago I reached out to Steve Murphy (and Chris Allan, who really wouldn't discuss this professionally unless it would be under official channels) about getting his scripts for The Forever War so Arseniy/DemonAlukard and I could do the finisher. He said absolutely, but he only had the aforementioned issue-by-issue synopsis to offer. That said, he still wanted to wait to January 1st of that given year (2012 or so, I think?) just in case IDW wanted to approach him officially to do it before promising to give them to me/Arseniy. The date came and went and after a few more months Murphy basically said he couldn't find his synopses, and didn't remember anything that happened in it at all, which is a little head-scratching.

So that's that.

Well it sounds like that's all she wrote, as it were

Andrew NDB
06-13-2016, 12:34 PM
I tend to think "The Forever War" was never a fully realized thing, at any point. He probably was pretty heavy into things mentally the first time around at Archie, but the hammer came down pretty early into that. The second time around at Mirage, he didn't seem too invested in it and just sort of chalked it off as an, "Ehh... whenever I get around to it I'll figure this out, maybe" thing. And it's just sort of sat there like that ever since.

CyberCubed
06-13-2016, 01:40 PM
Considering the, "Forever War" was originally supposed to come out back in 1995...I'm not all that surprised that Murphy has no memory what he was going to write literally 20 years ago.

Andrew NDB
06-14-2016, 02:03 PM
Considering the, "Forever War" was originally supposed to come out back in 1995...I'm not all that surprised that Murphy has no memory what he was going to write literally 20 years ago.

Though you would think, maybe, he would of the new synopsis of it he only wrote 3 years prior (at the time).

He did remember enough to tell me Null was not a part of The Forever War. That's something.

darthsmozers
06-15-2016, 08:44 PM
Even if its not as originally intended, or intended again a decade and a half later under Mirage, IDW would absolutely solidify the love of the fans by publishing something under that title. Even after their TPBs are finished, imagine something like "No more waiting. This is it: The last TMNT Adventures Story". Make it a 3 or 4 issue mini with art by Chris Allan (Steve not entirely necessary but would be nice), and many of us would likely eat it up.

After all, it was teased not once, but twice. Third time's the charm? :D

TigerClaw
06-15-2016, 09:24 PM
If I remember hearing about this, The Forever War was supposed to involve the future turtles, it was supposed to be another story set 100 years in the future, and right after the Cyber Samurai Mutant Ninja Turtles 5 part storyline.

darthsmozers
06-16-2016, 05:27 AM
If I remember hearing about this, The Forever War was supposed to involve the future turtles, it was supposed to be another story set 100 years in the future, and right after the Cyber Samurai Mutant Ninja Turtles 5 part storyline.

Yup. See Dr. Spengler's link above.

darthsmozers
06-16-2016, 05:37 AM
Here's an article about it if you want all the specifics. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/08/whatever-happened-to-forever-war.html)

Loved re-reading your article. At the end is a link to IDW's forums. Are the forums no more? Is there an easy way to pose questions (like this topic) to IDW?

DrSpengler
06-16-2016, 07:32 AM
Yeah, the IDW Forums don't look like they're coming back anytime soon. There's always the letters@IDW... option, though who knows if those requests/suggestions are ever heard beyond the intern reading the emails and deleting them.

There's always Bobby's Ask an Editor thread right here! He's been asked about a thousand times, but if we badger him enough maybe he'll make it happen (or leave us forever; it's a precarious balancing act).

darthsmozers
06-16-2016, 08:30 AM
Yeah, the IDW Forums don't look like they're coming back anytime soon. There's always the letters@IDW... option, though who knows if those requests/suggestions are ever heard beyond the intern reading the emails and deleting them.

There's always Bobby's Ask an Editor thread right here! He's been asked about a thousand times, but if we badger him enough maybe he'll make it happen (or leave us forever; it's a precarious balancing act).

Why did IDW close their forums?

CyberCubed
06-16-2016, 04:11 PM
Probably because forums are becoming an outdated form of internet communication that only use oldies from the early 2000's still use.

The young kids/teens of today use social media like twitter, tumblr, instragram, facebook, etc. and big companies like IDW know this. So forums have been abandoned for social media. That's why IDW has accounts on all of them.

Its kind of funny when you stop to think about it. It feels like traditional message boards like these are dying off. I barely use social media so it feels odd to me that fandom isn't discussed on forums anymore. The teens of today really are different than our generation in the early 2000's.

darthsmozers
06-16-2016, 07:03 PM
Probably because forums are becoming an outdated form of internet communication that only use oldies from the early 2000's still use.

The young kids/teens of today use social media like twitter, tumblr, instragram, facebook, etc. and big companies like IDW know this. So forums have been abandoned for social media. That's why IDW has accounts on all of them.

Its kind of funny when you stop to think about it. It feels like traditional message boards like these are dying off. I barely use social media so it feels odd to me that fandom isn't discussed on forums anymore. The teens of today really are different than our generation in the early 2000's.

But message boards allow for categorizing conversations and topics. For die hard enthusiasts of any genre, they hopefully will stay.

In IDW's case, maybe it was more likely that fans of different series already had a dedicated meeting place: This site for TMNT, gbfans.com for Ghostbusters, etc... ?

ProphetofGanja
06-16-2016, 07:10 PM
there is a definite lack of active forums. I would be on other sites too talking about other comics if there were any decent forums

TigerClaw
06-16-2016, 07:15 PM
But message boards allow for categorizing conversations and topics. For die hard enthusiasts of any genre, they hopefully will stay.

In IDW's case, maybe it was more likely that fans of different series already had a dedicated meeting place: This site for TMNT, gbfans.com for Ghostbusters, etc... ?
If that's the case, why aren't places like IDW or Nickelodeon posting stuff on this message board regarding all things TMNT?

anytime there's news, it's always the fans who post it, nobody official from other of those places ever come here.

Shark_Blade
06-16-2016, 07:36 PM
If that's the case, why aren't places like IDW or Nickelodeon posting stuff on this message board regarding all things TMNT?

anytime there's news, it's always the fans who post it, nobody official from other of those places ever come here.

Last time Ciro came here, someone bugged him off and he never returned...

So I'm not surprised if any officials wouldn't want to come here. Heck some people even harass certain fans of the new movies. What terrible people.

TigerClaw
06-16-2016, 07:39 PM
Last time Ciro came here, "someone" bugged him off and he never returned...

So I'm not surprised any officials wouldn't want to come here.
Cause this message board tends to get very toxic, which is what's been happening for the past few weeks, since the new movie came out.

ProphetofGanja
06-16-2016, 07:45 PM
Last time Ciro came here, someone bugged him off and he never returned...

So I'm not surprised if any officials wouldn't want to come here. Heck some people even harass certain fans of the new movies. What terrible people.

good thing this is the comic forum!

Joey Kamikaze
06-16-2016, 08:24 PM
Probably because forums are becoming an outdated form of internet communication that only use oldies from the early 2000's still use.

This is mostly true anymore, I agree. There are some young'uns on forums still, but the vast majority of forum-users on the net seem to be pre-Millennial.

Its kind of funny when you stop to think about it. It feels like traditional message boards like these are dying off. I barely use social media so it feels odd to me that fandom isn't discussed on forums anymore. The teens of today really are different than our generation in the early 2000's.

And yeah, they are. I have essays I've written about this somewhere, but I'll spare y'all. Short version, the way I see it, after the Babyboomers there were:

-Generation X: grew up during the Cold War watching John Hughes movies, teens and young adults under Reagan, tend to be more materialist since they came of age in the 80's, the parents of the bulk of Millennials (A lot of my older cousins, now in their 40's and 50's, fit here)

-What I think of as the Nintendo Generation: the Cold War was over by the time they knew about it, the internet wasn't common until high school/college but they were eager adopters, played outside unsupervised until dark when it was time to go inside and play 8- and 16-bit games, school shootings and terrorism weren't a thing for them growing up (I'm about smack dab in the middle of this group... and I started my forum career my first year of college in the dorms because it was the first time I had the net at home, waaaaay long ago :lol: )

-The Millennials: were still young when Columbine and 9/11 happened and don't realize how much the world has changed since then, used the internet in grade school or before and don't know a world before it either, the social media and YouTube generation, still defining themselves and IMO unfairly maligned by old farts (My 7 years younger sister is near the beginning of this generation)

-And there's actually another generation coming up now, mostly the children of Generation Nintendo and the Millennials (who are close enough in age that they're banging each other plenty), but it's too early to say much about them as the bulk of 'em haven't hit puberty yet.

So TL;DR: Obviously TMNT is doing fine with the later generations even if fan forums have slowed down or died. Young people have mostly all moved on to social media, and not just FB, but all those other sites and apps you and I have never heard of. Forums are for us dinosaurs who remember Web 1.0.

/way off topic

TigerClaw
06-16-2016, 08:42 PM
I would like to see that Forever War storyline happen some day, it would provide us with some closure for the archie series comics, since it ended so abruptly.