PDA

View Full Version : Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows-One More Chance


Pages : 1 [2] 3

ZariusTwo
01-03-2017, 06:54 AM
More of the fight

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C1NLl44WIAQPp8o.jpg

You actually sort of get the feeling these are the kind of tiffs that bring a smile to your face. Just from what I can see from Peter and MJ's facial expressions, the argument is sort of being played for "oh I know this situation"-type laughs by Stegman, who's married with kids himself. Trust me, from how the fight has been steadily building over the past two issues, the fight here is based entirely out of love and concern for the other. It's a safe kind of fight because they're thinking selflessly about the other, and want what's best for the family and their crusade going forward.

ZariusTwo
01-05-2017, 03:02 AM
Some interesting news regarding an ASM Epic Collection coming out. Amongst the reprints in the edition (The end of the Hobgoblin Saga, Spider-Man vs Wolverine, Kraven's Last Hunt) will be the entire Wedding story arc, marking the first time Peter and MJ's marriage has been reprinted since the 90s. Also included in this collection will be the Spectacular Spider-Man annual that served as the follow up (Peter and MJ's honeymoon), which has never seen reprint before.

The first trade of Conway and Stegman's RYV is scheduled for the same month also, so it's likely to tie into that, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was something else going on.

https://www.amazon.com/Amazing-Spider-Man-Epic-Collection-Kravens/dp/1302907050/

Oh, and this tickled me

http://static9.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275590/5630969-leaving+616.jpg

WebLurker
01-05-2017, 03:01 PM
Some interesting news regarding an ASM Epic Collection coming out. Amongst the reprints in the edition (The end of the Hobgoblin Saga, Spider-Man vs Wolverine, Kraven's Last Hunt) will be the entire Wedding story arc, marking the first time Peter and MJ's marriage has been reprinted since the 90s. Also included in this collection will be the Spectacular Spider-Man annual that served as the follow up (Peter and MJ's honeymoon), which has never seen reprint before.

The first trade of Conway and Stegman's RYV is scheduled for the same month also, so it's likely to tie into that, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was something else going on.

https://www.amazon.com/Amazing-Spider-Man-Epic-Collection-Kravens/dp/1302907050/

So, all that material's in the "Kraven" volume in the link?

Wish the RYV trade had an unique cover, but it's not a bad one. Well, six issues in the first set isn't too bad. May have to see about the pre-order offer.



Oh, and this tickled me

http://static9.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275590/5630969-leaving+616.jpg

So, it's become a meme now? Guess the series is picking in popularity to some extent.

ZariusTwo
01-06-2017, 10:03 AM
Yeah, it's been taking off, not just memes too. Fan art and cosplayers are starting to crop up for this.

An interesting side to Annie's spider-sense is shown in the official preview of Renew Your Vows#3, seems she shares the same kind of future flashes Kaine used to have (as Peter and MJ only wound up being chained up trying to rescue Annie, when she has yet to arrive here)


http://www.cbr.com/amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-3-3/

WebLurker
01-06-2017, 11:10 AM
Yeah, it's been taking off, not just memes too. Fan art and cosplayers are starting to crop up for this.

Well, Marvel certainly found a new audience. Hope it's not a bubble that'll burst sometime soon.

An interesting side to Annie's spider-sense is shown in the official preview of Renew Your Vows#3, seems she shares the same kind of future flashes Kaine used to have (as Peter and MJ only wound up being chained up trying to rescue Annie, when she has yet to arrive here)


http://www.cbr.com/amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-3-3/

Huh. Wonder if that'll replace the standard spider-sense or is just a extra trick? It does make her sneaking out to the warzone make more sense and more sympathetic.

ZariusTwo
01-10-2017, 05:55 AM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C1w_nRhVEAAoDED.jpg

ZariusTwo
01-11-2017, 10:14 AM
RYV#3

A splendid introduction to Annie's world, we get to meet Gloria's kid at last, and a new character who befriends Annie when she's sent to the Principal's office, Stephanie Kim.

Normie sees Annie fight the dinosaur and is impressed by what he says, "Who is that marvelous girl?" he asks (really...what kind of kid, or anyone, talks like that? Only thing wrong with the whole issue).

Peter and MJ don't say much in the issue, but Peter does make a cracking joke about how only he gets to make bad jokes of any kind.

And lastly, the comic has a letters page, with the editor of the book, Darren, revealing that he too is a massive Spider-Marriage fan and saying some encouraging things about MJ ought to be remembered for her days as Peter's wife!

ZariusTwo
01-13-2017, 12:44 PM
December 2016 sales (http://comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2016/2016-12.html)

Renew Your Vows took a steep drop last month, and was beaten by Clone Conspiracy and it's tie-ins. That said, it did far better than Miles Morales and Spider-Gwen (which was number 100)

WebLurker
01-13-2017, 12:57 PM
December 2016 sales (http://comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2016/2016-12.html)

Renew Your Vows took a steep drop last month, and was beaten by Clone Conspiracy and it's tie-ins. That said, it did far better than Miles Morales and Spider-Gwen (which was number 100)

Well, it seems like first issues tend to sell better. It could be we also overestimated the market for the series. As long as the series continues to do respectful business, it'll hopefully stay around, but it is kind of annoying that it's not exactly curbstomping ASM.

ZariusTwo
01-13-2017, 02:41 PM
Well, it seems like first issues tend to sell better. It could be we also overestimated the market for the series. As long as the series continues to do respectful business, it'll hopefully stay around, but it is kind of annoying that it's not exactly curbstomping ASM.

I think it's possible people went in to buy the book thinking it'd be more Peter-focused with MJ and Annie in supporting role, but the truth is it treats them all as equals, and Peter has'nt had a hell of a lot to do in either MJ's issue or Annie's issue, and the title does say "Amazing Spider-Man".

I want the book to succeed as well (and this number is by no means bad for an AU book), I'm just trying to work out what is turning some people off of it.

ASM has more going for it because, much as we wish it wasn't, it has the distinct advantage of "mattering" because it's mainline canon, and a fan favorite in Ben Reilly came back. However, Clone Conspiracy is still underperforming and being beaten soundly by Superman (a book with a happily married hero which just happens to have the advantage of being mainline)

WebLurker
01-13-2017, 08:51 PM
I think it's possible people went in to buy the book thinking it'd be more Peter-focused with MJ and Annie in supporting role, but the truth is it treats them all as equals, and Peter has'nt had a hell of a lot to do in either MJ's issue or Annie's issue, and the title does say "Amazing Spider-Man".

Maybe. From about the point that it was announced that MJ and Annie were going to be superheroes as well, I kind of assumed that it would be an ensemble instead of one star with supporting characters. I actually like that it's an ensemble instead, but if others don't, fair enough.

I want the book to succeed as well (and this number is by no means bad for an AU book), I'm just trying to work out what is turning some people off of it.

It's not very scientific, but from what I've seen, RYV has been getting consistently good reviews, while the contemporary ASM comics are mixed, at best.

the more issues released and pre-order sales to examine, we may get a better idea what the numbers really are. For what it's worth, I'm having to wait to buy and read until my local store can get another order in; it was sold out on day one, and I came in on day two (I made darn sure to get a pull list on RYV then and there, believe you me). The guy at the counter made an offhand comment that the series was starting to pick up readers, at least in our area. I also saw him ordering additional copies of RYV#2 while he was getting my order for #3 taken care of. So, I think there's still a chance of it not flatlining on us just yet.

ASM has more going for it because, much as we wish it wasn't, it has the distinct advantage of "mattering" because it's mainline canon

True. ASM will outlast RYV, no question, and largely due to it being the main series. (However, I do question the relevancy of ASM now; superhero characters are becoming more defined by movie and TV adaptations. On top of that, the Ultimate Spider-Man comics are almost always being used as the source material.)

...and a fan favorite in Ben Reilly came back.

Given that he's just a clone of the original character and the villain, I actually thought that was going to make more people drop the book.

However, Clone Conspiracy is still underperforming and being beaten soundly by Superman (a book with a happily married hero which just happens to have the advantage of being mainline)

Superman is the Big One, so I wouldn't be surprised at anything being beaten by it. I am really curious about how Clone Conspiracy will be viewed in retrospect. I haven't heard that much praise for it, and a lot of mixed reviews.

ZariusTwo
01-14-2017, 02:55 AM
I agree with you that ASM has minimal relevance these days. Bendis' USM seems to be the stories Marvel take the most inspiration from for their films and tv shows, although from what I hear, the new Spider-Man cartoon will be heavily influenced by Slott's run (it helps that the Marvel animation department is run by Slott's old BND editor)

Given that he's just a clone of the original character and the villain, I actually thought that was going to make more people drop the book.

It's funny how some of the storyline's defendents are going on about how the "psychic imprint" of the clones somehow means they're the same individual and that they possess their "soul". I find that a bit of a reach.

Besides, Ben won't be a villain much longer, given he has his own book coming out (and one they may possibly be sacrificing 2099 for since Peter David will write it)

BTW, Ryan Stegman says that RYV's numbers are perfectly sustainable despite the low ranking in the December charts. Some people also took note of the dollar share and concluded RYV sat in the higher 30s.

WebLurker
01-14-2017, 09:59 AM
I agree with you that ASM has minimal relevance these days. Bendis' USM seems to be the stories Marvel take the most inspiration from for their films and tv shows,..

That could be partially since it was centered around a teenage Spider-Man (it seems like most adaptations like being able to use that era), although I suspect that the series arguably being one of the best runs in the franchise and the way it mixed a lot of classic elements together probably helps.

although from what I hear, the new Spider-Man cartoon will be heavily influenced by Slott's run (it helps that the Marvel animation department is run by Slott's old BND editor)

Hope that goes well; From what I've heard, I'd probably like some of Slott's stuff or characters if it had been used in a pre-OMD setting. Given that it sounds like the cartoon is about a teen Spider-Man (again), I'm guessing most of the offending stuff (OMD itself, Parker Industries, etc.) will probably not be used.

It's funny how some of the storyline's defendents are going on about how the "psychic imprint" of the clones somehow means they're the same individual and that they possess their "soul". I find that a bit of a reach.

Maybe they think Slott's intent is that it's a real resurrection and are willing to overlook the description in favor of the perceived intent?

Besides, Ben won't be a villain much longer, given he has his own book coming out (and one they may possibly be sacrificing 2099 for since Peter David will write it)

I question how that will work, given what we know about the Jackal Ben clone now.

BTW, Ryan Stegman says that RYV's numbers are perfectly sustainable despite the low ranking in the December charts. Some people also took note of the dollar share and concluded RYV sat in the higher 30s.

That's good to hear. As nice as it would be for it to regularly outsell RYV, I'm most concerned about the series remaining in print.

ZariusTwo
01-19-2017, 12:52 PM
So it looks like we got another potentially big clue that OMD may be undone this year in the Clone Conspiracy

Peter and Gwen's reanimated clone/whatever have a heart-to-heart and Gwen reveals she always sort of knew Peter loved MJ more than her, and asks Peter how he is with her. When he tells her they're not on good terms, Gwen berates Peter, saying his guilt forever robs him of happiness.

This is the latest in a long line of hints and teases stemming from last year, someone also brought up a good point that the people Peter and MJ associate themselves with tend to have tragic events thrusted upon them (including Tony on MJ's end) which could also be the result of the Mephisto deal

WebLurker
01-19-2017, 01:34 PM
So it looks like we got another potentially big clue that OMD may be undone this year in the Clone Conspiracy

Peter and Gwen's reanimated clone/whatever have a heart-to-heart and Gwen reveals she always sort of knew Peter loved MJ more than her, and asks Peter how he is with her. When he tells her they're not on good terms, Gwen berates Peter, saying his guilt forever robs him of happiness.

This is the latest in a long line of hints and teases stemming from last year, someone also brought up a good point that the people Peter and MJ associate themselves with tend to have tragic events thrusted upon them (including Tony on MJ's end) which could also be the result of the Mephisto deal

Very interesting (esp. since I've gathered that it's been a popular idea in the past to try and suggest that Gwen was the one that Peter loved more.

Truth be told though, I don't think they're going to be undoing OMD anytime soon; they've invested too much into making Spider-Man single again and they have the RYV comic now for readers that prefer the characters married. My gut says that, while they may do some kind of followup to OMD, any suggestion that they're going to undo the story is misdirection that'll string us along.

ZariusTwo
01-19-2017, 03:30 PM
Very interesting (esp. since I've gathered that it's been a popular idea in the past to try and suggest that Gwen was the one that Peter loved more.

Truth be told though, I don't think they're going to be undoing OMD anytime soon; they've invested too much into making Spider-Man single again and they have the RYV comic now for readers that prefer the characters married. My gut says that, while they may do some kind of followup to OMD, any suggestion that they're going to undo the story is misdirection that'll string us along.

There is that possibility OMD will be dealt with, but not reversed, but there is wiggle room to beleive there will be something done to reconcile them given the wedding era stories are being reprinted and Marvel can't seem to stop promoting Peter and MJ as a couple continuously (before RYV was even a thing, we still got significant use of the marriage in the newspaper strip, and it is depicted pretty healthfully there)

Also keep in mind Superman recently won the IGN People's Choice award for best comic, and Vision won best overall comic. Both titles deal specifically with superheroes and thier families. That kind of acclaim is something Marvel would really want a peice of, perhaps in a way that, like the two I mentioned, "matters" to the overall continuity.

WebLurker
01-19-2017, 11:49 PM
There is that possibility OMD will be dealt with, but not reversed, but there is wiggle room to beleive there will be something done to reconcile them given the wedding era stories are being reprinted and Marvel can't seem to stop promoting Peter and MJ as a couple continuously (before RYV was even a thing, we still got significant use of the marriage in the newspaper strip, and it is depicted pretty healthfully there)

Maybe. Although, the newspaper comic was always its own thing and the characters as a couple were always fan favorites, so I could see them doing it for marketing purposes; like how you can buy merchandise from the '80s TMNT cartoon, despite the fact that different iterations of the characters are being used now.

Also keep in mind Superman recently won the IGN People's Choice award for best comic, and Vision won best overall comic. Both titles deal specifically with superheroes and thier families. That kind of acclaim is something Marvel would really want a peice of, perhaps in a way that, like the two I mentioned, "matters" to the overall continuity.

Maybe, although I'm not sure if they would be bothered by RYV being a parallel universe story.

(Now, I hope I'm wrong, but I have little to no trust in Marvel's comic branch, regardless of them making RYV and the Star Wars: Doctor Aphra ongoing.

WebLurker
01-21-2017, 10:03 AM
Finally got to read #3. Liked it overall, although not quite as much as the previous two.

ZariusTwo
01-24-2017, 05:06 AM
The X-Men return in all their 90s glory for April's sixth issue

http://www.newsarama.com/images/i/000/189/145/original/ASMRENEW2016006_cov.jpg

WebLurker
01-24-2017, 10:04 AM
The X-Men return in all their 90s glory for April's sixth issue

http://www.newsarama.com/images/i/000/189/145/original/ASMRENEW2016006_cov.jpg

Looks like fun, although I think I prefer Professor X's wheelchair (like in the movies) to that flying car thing he's in.

ZariusTwo
01-25-2017, 07:52 AM
A preview of Wolverine from Renew Your Vows #6

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C2-R0WGXgAE2S3f.jpg

ZariusTwo
02-02-2017, 10:23 AM
I really think the recent newspaper strip storylines have been a fine example of how RYV could have been handled without the "MJ as superhero" aspect. In the latest one, Peter and MJ have been working in tandem with Rocket Racoon to try and prevent Ronan the Accueser from aqquiring a Kree Sentry. In this story so far, Peter tried confronting Ronan out of coustume when he threatened some civilians, MJ defied his instruction not to get involved in the search for him, and she's even helped her husband google information online about a set of stone carvings at a national park where Ronan is heading.

Really strong examples of teamwork as well as Peter being confident enough to try things outside of his costume. A shame the strip gets repeatedly grilled for how "dated", "decompressed" and "cheesy" it can occasionally be. I know it can be viewed in that light, but I for one consider the last decade of it an unappreciated golden age, at least if you like MJ and the marriage...and why I will always consider OMD's legacy to be that of a failiure because it ultimately did'nt kill what it set out to end...and ultimatley made me become a fan of something I've found more enjoyable than the mainline representation of the characters (prior to RYV helping to enrich my experiances)

ZariusTwo
02-03-2017, 04:56 AM
Ramos variant for Renew Your Vows#4 (out next week)

http://static7.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11130/111300880/5681254-8917165694-ASM_R.jpg

Preview for the Issue (good news for us, the plot's actually moving along)

http://www.newsarama.com/32999-spider-man-family-goes-underground-in-renew-your-vows-4.html#s7

Interestingly enough, at one point MJ makes reference to her, Annie and Peter destroying Regent's tower...and the book advises you to read the RYV mini-series for information on that, but that book is'nt supposed to be in precise continuity with this one.

WebLurker
02-03-2017, 11:13 AM
Ramos variant for Renew Your Vows#4 (out next week)

http://static7.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11130/111300880/5681254-8917165694-ASM_R.jpg

I kind of wish my store sold variant covers now (although the regular cover is my favorite regular cover to date).

Preview for the Issue (good news for us, the plot's actually moving along)

http://www.newsarama.com/32999-spider-man-family-goes-underground-in-renew-your-vows-4.html#s7

Sounds good. (Wonder how the story will read when read in one sitting?)

Interestingly enough, at one point MJ makes reference to her, Annie and Peter destroying Regent's tower...and the book advises you to read the RYV mini-series for information on that, but that book is'nt supposed to be in precise continuity with this one.

My understanding is that the Secret Wars miniseries represents an alternate timeline; the incursions and Battleworld caused the RYV timeline to unfold in a slightly different manner. After the multiverse was fixed, the Secret Wars timeline was erased and the original one was restored. However the rough idea of what happened was close enough that even though we didn't get the "original" timeline version of the mini-series, we can infer more or less what happened from the Secret Wars timeline version. So, I'm taking it as a "it happened, but the new series overwrites the old one in times of conflict."

Also, Regent's tower wasn't destroyed in the original miniseries. So, apparently, in the original/restored timeline, the final battle with Regent was more destructive than it was in the Secret Wars timeline.

ZariusTwo
02-06-2017, 07:07 AM
Nate Stockman will be tackling art duties on Renew Your Vows for it's fifth issue, here's some previews

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C16qDmoXcAAJGq_.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C2Uj3JYWIAYa4-X.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C3b15UzW8AADfLk.jpg

WebLurker
02-06-2017, 09:56 AM
Nate Stockman will be tackling art duties on Renew Your Vows for it's fifth issue, here's some previews

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C16qDmoXcAAJGq_.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C2Uj3JYWIAYa4-X.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C3b15UzW8AADfLk.jpg

Looks good. It's lively and similar in style to Stegman's work, so I think it'll mesh well with the rest of the series, based on the previews.

ZariusTwo
02-07-2017, 08:29 AM
90s Jean in a jubliant mood in a preview from Renew Your Vows#6

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C4AwX0LWIAALYIu.jpg


Looks like Marvel will be toning down the politically charged storytelling and restoring several heroes to factory settings in the fall of 2017 (although there is no word on plans for Spider-Man)

https://www.comicbookmovie.com/comics/marvel_comics/comics-expect-the-marvel-universe-to-look-a-lot-more-like-a148744

WebLurker
02-07-2017, 11:26 AM
90s Jean in a jubliant mood in a preview from Renew Your Vows#6

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C4AwX0LWIAALYIu.jpg

Nice, the old costume looks better here than it did on the cover. Looks like fun,


Looks like Marvel will be toning down the politically charged storytelling and restoring several heroes to factory settings in the fall of 2017 (although there is no word on plans for Spider-Man)

https://www.comicbookmovie.com/comics/marvel_comics/comics-expect-the-marvel-universe-to-look-a-lot-more-like-a148744

Guess that'll be nice for fans who read those series and prefer the traditional status quos over ones with legacy characters and other changes. Wonder if the legacy characters, like RiRi Williams, will be written out or will still have their own series, but not be the "main" bearer of the mantle, like how Miles Morales co-exists with Peter Parker now?

As far as Spider-Man himself goes, I think it's likely that Parker Industries will go by the time of this new direction is implemented. Not so sure if he and Mary Jane will get remarried, though; Marvel really has invested a lot in rebranding that as being a "what if?", not the "canonical" version of the characters and a single, blue collar Spider-Man is a classic status quo for the franchise.

I do hope that this new direction doesn't mean that RYV will get canceled to increase comics synergy or something. (Ironically, I suppose if 616 Peter and MJ got back together, RYV looses one of the main elements that justifies its existence.)

ZariusTwo
02-07-2017, 11:39 AM
I do hope that this new direction doesn't mean that RYV will get canceled to increase comics synergy or something. (Ironically, I suppose if 616 Peter and MJ got back together, RYV looses one of the main elements that justifies its existence.)

It'd be exactly what happened with the Lois and Clark series, once DC settled on making the classic Superman and Lois the main characters again instead of the New 52 versions, that book was swiftly cancelled.

What was curious about that was that the Lois and Clark series in itself wasn't actually a big seller for DC, yet it got all the acclaim from the fans at the time where as the N52/DC You mainline titles continued to struggle. RYV is in a similar posistion right now...not a big seller, but getting all the acclaim while the mainline book struggles to satisfy it's audience

Whether Marvel does something similar to Rebirth (i.e merge the RYV canon with the mainline canon using the reality-bending character responsible for turning Steve into Hydra Cap) is up to them, but Secret Empire can offer a pretty quick fix for everything if they go that route.

ZariusTwo
02-07-2017, 01:34 PM
Coincidently in relation to that, Dan Slott was inserted into the original Renew Your Vows mini-series by Adam Kubert.

WebLurker
02-07-2017, 02:05 PM
It'd be exactly what happened with the Lois and Clark series, once DC settled on making the classic Superman and Lois the main characters again instead of the New 52 versions, that book was swiftly cancelled.

Ironically, that's one reason I'd hope that OMD wasn't undone for 616; I'm not interested in reading 616 comics (at this point, I'm pretty sure as second OMD would come around somewhere along the line), but I am following the RYV series and am interested in this iteration of the characters.

What was curious about that was that the Lois and Clark series in itself wasn't actually a big seller for DC, yet it got all the acclaim from the fans at the time where as the N52/DC You mainline titles continued to struggle. RYV is in a similar posistion right now...not a big seller, but getting all the acclaim while the mainline book struggles to satisfy it's audience

Yeah, that's a lot of irony there.

Whether Marvel does something similar to Rebirth (i.e merge the RYV canon with the mainline canon using the reality-bending character responsible for turning Steve into Hydra Cap) is up to them, but Secret Empire can offer a pretty quick fix for everything if they go that route.

Well, we've have to see what they have in mind. It could very well be that Spider-Man will be business as usual. After all, I've gathered that Parker Industries Spider-Man hasn't been as hated as, say, Hydra-Cap, the X-Men being replaced by the Inhumans, RiRi Williams Iron Man, etc.

ZariusTwo
02-08-2017, 08:16 AM
Renew Your Vows#4 was passable,

Most of it was Peter and MJ getting in each other's way and squabbling until Annie put her neck on the line again, but it was a comfy kind of quarraling so I did'nt much mind it.

Thought MJ saying Normie made her skin crawl was a bit out-of-character, is'nt Normie her godson?

And Annie has a codename, and it is'nt Amp, it's Spiderling. She wants to be called Spider-Girl, but Peter says it's already taken. Does this mean there's an Anya in the Vows 'verse?

Well, we've have to see what they have in mind. It could very well be that Spider-Man will be business as usual. After all, I've gathered that Parker Industries Spider-Man hasn't been as hated as, say, Hydra-Cap, the X-Men being replaced by the Inhumans, RiRi Williams Iron Man, etc.

Parker Industries does have it's detractors, and Marvel are hinting at ending that angle with the arc following Clone Conspiracy, "The Osborn Identity"

WebLurker
02-08-2017, 11:33 AM
Parker Industries does have it's detractors...

Yeah, I've poked around a comic forum and I've gathered that there are plenty of readers who're sick of it. (There are also readers who love it, too, but that par for the course.[/quote]

...and Marvel are hinting at ending that angle with the arc following Clone Conspiracy, "The Osborn Identity"

It could very well be that that this was Slott plan regardless of what the larger Marvel comics plan is.

ZariusTwo
02-08-2017, 03:06 PM
It could very well be that that this was Slott plan regardless of what the larger Marvel comics plan is.

Yeah, Slott has been tying up all of his loose ends lately, it's possible he's either moving on to new ideas or he's about to step down from the book. He's boasted about staying on the book 'till he's fired or drops dead, but he's been known to lie a lot.

What did you think of the latest RYV issue?

WebLurker
02-08-2017, 09:21 PM
Yeah, Slott has been tying up all of his loose ends lately, it's possible he's either moving on to new ideas or he's about to step down from the book. He's boasted about staying on the book 'till he's fired or drops dead, but he's been known to lie a lot.

Time will tell, although given that Marvel has been ostensibly happy with his run, it would seem if he's stepping down, it's not because he's being ordered to.

What did you think of the latest RYV issue?

Haven't had a chance to get it yet. I may have to wait until next week.

ZariusTwo
02-09-2017, 04:18 AM
Time will tell, although given that Marvel has been ostensibly happy with his run, it would seem if he's stepping down, it's not because he's being ordered to.

Did you happen to read CBR's latest article on "Worst Comic Events?", they actually listed Slott's Superior Spider-Man as being worse than OMD.:lol:

WebLurker
02-09-2017, 10:40 AM
Did you happen to read CBR's latest article on "Worst Comic Events?", they actually listed Slott's Superior Spider-Man as being worse than OMD.:lol:

You mean this (http://www.cbr.com/worst-events-in-comic-book-history/)?

Wow, you're right. I thought that it was generally liked once it got started. I tried it and hated it, but for some reason, I got the idea that it was generally considered Slott's last really great story in the main ASM line. The stuff between SSM and Secret Wars seems to be considered okay at best, I'm getting really mixed reviews over the post-Secret Wars stuff. The only thing Slot did after SSM that really seems to be considered great was his RYV miniseries.

Amazing that Civil War II is still brand new and already getting flack.

Kind of surprised that "One More Day" got so low on the list, much lower that Clone Saga. I've heard that the latter has some redeeming stuff, while I have yet to hear anyone say anything good about OMD; even people who think it was the right call and ultimately fixed the comics seem to agree that it was a basically a bad story overall.

Given that it's one opinion, though, I'm not sure how much it reflects the fanbase at large or Marvel's opinion on Slott's work. At long as it sells well, I'm guessing his job security is probably okay. I mean, as of right now, none of the other Spider-Man-themed books are outselling his stuff.

ZariusTwo
02-09-2017, 11:37 AM
Wow, you're right. I thought that it was generally liked once it got started. I tried it and hated it, but for some reason, I got the idea that it was generally considered Slott's last really great story in the main ASM line. The stuff between SSM and Secret Wars seems to be considered okay at best, I'm getting really mixed reviews over the post-Secret Wars stuff. The only thing Slot did after SSM that really seems to be considered great was his RYV miniseries.

Haven't you noticed Slott's best work in 2014 and 2015 were when he was reined in by familiar status quoes? Learning to Crawl was leagues better than his ASM V3 work because it was based in the Lee/Ditko era, and RYV was a smash because he wrote Peter and MJ as a stable loving couple with a fresh element in a young child.

Amazing that Civil War II is still brand new and already getting flack.

CW II was'nt desired right out of the gate I feel, everyone saw it as a petty cash-grab for the movie, delays from the artist meant it did'nt tie up sooner and many books had to initiate their new status quoes while it was going on, Ms. Marvel's usually upbeat book was largely derailed and reduced to monthly misery, Miles had more to do in the story than Peter Parker (who's sole contribution to the event was barely doing anything in some lame-ass tie-in mini-series) , and worst of all, it became public knowledge Bendis had completly changed his mind on how it should end, so fans became frustrated that there was no real long-term plan for it.

Kind of surprised that "One More Day" got so low on the list, much lower that Clone Saga. I've heard that the latter has some redeeming stuff, while I have yet to hear anyone say anything good about OMD; even people who think it was the right call and ultimately fixed the comics seem to agree that it was a basically a bad story overall.

It's a bad story in concept and mostly execution (there's just no way to justify half of the motivations), but I actually think it has some pretty powerful scenes in it, which is a credit to JMS' writing ability, and Quesada for all his flaws as an editor, is a good artist.

The one thing that gets overlooked is how, despite how tragic the ending is, MJ's speech to Peter about how their love will ultimately overcome whatever Mephisto does to them one day leaves you with a sense of hope, and sort of excuses all of their behaviour up 'till now as just the influence of chaos magic.

Clone Saga had it's moments, storylines within it that were good included "The Lost Years" "The Exile Returns", "Web of Death", "Web of Life", it pretty much turns to s*it as soon as Aunt May dies in "The Gift" (ASM#400) and does'nt get much better until half-way through Ben Reily's tenure as Spider-Man.

WebLurker
02-09-2017, 02:01 PM
Finally did get my Issue 4 copy. Liked it overall. The story did seem a little rushed, but as an opening stretch, I liked it. I read these things for the characters, and they delivered on that front.

Haven't you noticed Slott's best work in 2014 and 2015 were when he was reined in by familiar status quoes? Learning to Crawl was leagues better than his ASM V3 work because it was based in the Lee/Ditko era, and RYV was a smash because he wrote Peter and MJ as a stable loving couple with a fresh element in a young child.

Never read "Learning to Crawl," so I can't speak for that one. As for the RYV, who can say? It could've well been a badly written story, so I guess he put in the work needed to bring it up to par.

I'm actually more curious why his RYV Peter is closer to the more traditional character, given that a common complaint I've heard is that his 616 Peter feels out of character a lot of the time. Why did Slott not do that in RYV, or use the RYV characterization in his 616 stuff, for that matter?


CW II was'nt desired right out of the gate I feel, everyone saw it as a petty cash-grab for the movie, delays from the artist meant it did'nt tie up sooner and many books had to initiate their new status quoes while it was going on, Ms. Marvel's usually upbeat book was largely derailed and reduced to monthly misery, Miles had more to do in the story than Peter Parker (who's sole contribution to the event was barely doing anything in some lame-ass tie-in mini-series) , and worst of all, it became public knowledge Bendis had completly changed his mind on how it should end, so fans became frustrated that there was no real long-term plan for it.

I understand that it hasn't been a fan favorite. I guess I was kind of surprised that it being quantified so quickly, esp. since some of the other ones on that list made it on because of their legacies, like Superior Spider-Man got put on largely because of how pointless it was in the long run, or how DC's Flashpoint was on because it lead the way to the New 52 stuff, despite the fact that I've heard good things about the "Flastpoint" story itself.

I guess if I was going to analyze CWII, I'd take more time so that it could examined after more time had passed and we could see the effects of it; was it just a weak story, or did it screw up comics that were created after it as well.


It's a bad story in concept and mostly execution (there's just no way to justify half of the motivations), but I actually think it has some pretty powerful scenes in it, which is a credit to JMS' writing ability, and Quesada for all his flaws as an editor, is a good artist.

Okay. That's one thing I'm never going to read, given how distasteful I find the whole point of it. I'd sooner read Ultimatum, personally.

The one thing that gets overlooked is how, despite how tragic the ending is, MJ's speech to Peter about how their love will ultimately overcome whatever Mephisto does to them one day leaves you with a sense of hope, and sort of excuses all of their behaviour up 'till now as just the influence of chaos magic.

I've honestly taken that as Marvel stringing the readers around. Maybe they left it in as a trap door in case it completely blew up in their faces, but, at this point, I think the storytelling decisions Marvel has made were calculated to burn as many bridges as possible to prevent OMD from being undone. Heck, the Superior comics had ghost Peter thinking that breaking up with MJ was the right decision and it ended with MJ severing ties with Peter completely. I'm 99% sure that the promise at the end of OMD is pretty much worthless right now (unless you count the Ultimate comics and RYV series as fulfillment in the meta sense).

ZariusTwo
02-09-2017, 04:18 PM
I've honestly taken that as Marvel stringing the readers around. Maybe they left it in as a trap door in case it completely blew up in their faces, but, at this point, I think the storytelling decisions Marvel has made were calculated to burn as many bridges as possible to prevent OMD from being undone. Heck, the Superior comics had ghost Peter thinking that breaking up with MJ was the right decision and it ended with MJ severing ties with Peter completely. I'm 99% sure that the promise at the end of OMD is pretty much worthless right now (unless you count the Ultimate comics and RYV series as fulfillment in the meta sense).

I disagree, Marvel have made it clear from hints last year that Peter and MJ's behaviour has been the result of devil magic and that their characters would, without that influence, make rational decisions and find common ground and understanding as before, as is evident by how the characters continue to be written together in RYV and the Newspaper Strip. Marvel KNOW that's how Peter and MJ act, and expect you to get angry or disheartened at the fact the post-OMD versions are nothing like that anymore.

I don't view RYV and the Strip as "wish fulfilment", they are legit universes with valid characters, the latter has been around since the 70s. It's perfectly fine to be invested in them without feeling like they're just a bone being thrown to us. The strip has ensured the marriage has made it to thirty years uninterupted. I know you like to play the strip down as being niche or it's own thing or whatever, but to me that's a seminal acheivement and it shouldnt be brushed off because it's not mainline canon.

Why would they have Mephisto taunt Peter about his loss, have Peter sucker punch a simulcrum of Mephisto in Silver Surfer, and acknowledge RYV via deja vu in 616 if it wasn't leading anywhere?

I think between you and me, I'm more of the optimist. I beleive the marriage will be mainline agan.

And Ghost Peter was thankful Doc Ock breaking up with MJ was the right decision, the alternative was her being raped by him.

The real MJ would never severe ties with Peter, just as I know Peter would never make half the childish decisions he's made since OMD. It's all to do with the deal, and I feel my views will be validated sooner or later, just as they were today with Superior being decreed worse than OMD by a site that normally heaps praise on Marvel in return for exclusives.

WebLurker
02-09-2017, 11:00 PM
I disagree, Marvel have made it clear from hints last year that Peter and MJ's behaviour has been the result of devil magic and that their characters would, without that influence, make rational decisions and find common ground and understanding as before, as is evident by how the characters continue to be written together in RYV and the Newspaper Strip. Marvel KNOW that's how Peter and MJ act, and expect you to get angry or disheartened at the fact the post-OMD versions are nothing like that anymore.

That's really wonky marketing, IMHO. I don't want to read something to get mad at it.

I don't view RYV and the Strip as "wish fulfilment", they are legit universes with valid characters, the latter has been around since the 70s. It's perfectly fine to be invested in them without feeling like they're just a bone being thrown to us.

I didn't mean that. I guess what I was trying to say is that I'm wondering if, with the RYV series running currently, if Marvel will see the need to undo OMD in 616.

The strip has ensured the marriage has made it to thirty years uninterupted. I know you like to play the strip down as being niche or it's own thing or whatever, but to me that's a seminal acheivement and it shouldnt be brushed off because it's not mainline canon.

I don't hate it. Often on, I will catch up on it online. However, the pacing and tone is not exactly what I'd want for my main source of Spider-Man material.

Why would they have Mephisto taunt Peter about his loss, have Peter sucker punch a simulcrum of Mephisto in Silver Surfer, and acknowledge RYV via deja vu in 616 if it wasn't leading anywhere?

Fan service? Lead up to a second OMD installment that won't undo the status quo? The RVY reference could've just been an in-joke; it doesn't make any sense in any case, even from a "they're building up to an OMD reversal?"

I think between you and me, I'm more of the optimist. I beleive the marriage will be mainline agan.

I don't trust them, based on their track record and all the time and effort put into the "OMD is good" bandwagon.

And Ghost Peter was thankful Doc Ock breaking up with MJ was the right decision, the alternative was her being raped by him.

Oh. Okay.

The real MJ would never severe ties with Peter, just as I know Peter would never make half the childish decisions he's made since OMD. It's all to do with the deal, and I feel my views will be validated sooner or later, just as they were today with Superior being decreed worse than OMD by a site that normally heaps praise on Marvel in return for exclusives.

Time will tell.

ZariusTwo
02-10-2017, 01:44 AM
iV8zpgfwJ7k

Peter and MJ make number two on this official Marvel Couples video, and we get another OMD reference.

WebLurker
02-10-2017, 12:47 PM
iV8zpgfwJ7k

Peter and MJ make number two on this official Marvel Couples video, and we get another OMD reference.

Kind of funny how so many of those couples didn't work out. It's like the writers don't like it or something. ;)

ZariusTwo
02-10-2017, 04:28 PM
Kind of funny how so many of those couples didn't work out.

We'll probably be saying the same thing about Sharon and Steve by the end of Secret Empire:)

That's just the persistent bane of an ongoing soap opera...some writers will want to take the characters North and South and put their own stamp on them, and might not take to the fact they have to be saddled with an existing relationship, it feels sort of like you sign on to be the guy to keep a house in order, and you're told to keep one room in it exactly the way it is. Some writers can feel constrained to that, even if it's the good of the house ultimately.

At least Peter and MJ still have ongoing universes where they have made it work, and where the writers don't seem to have ever tired of it.

ZariusTwo
02-11-2017, 03:28 AM
Here's some fan-art from a professional friend of mine

http://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_medium/11127/111275590/5694877-normie+crane+game.jpg

WebLurker
02-11-2017, 08:20 AM
Here's some fan-art from a professional friend of mine

http://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_medium/11127/111275590/5694877-normie+crane+game.jpg

That's pretty good. Looks like it should be the subject of a special alternate cover.

ZariusTwo
02-13-2017, 01:16 PM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C4kHurJXAAEBmOe.jpg

WebLurker
02-13-2017, 02:14 PM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C4kHurJXAAEBmOe.jpg

Thumbs up.

So, Mary Jane has her hair down on the cover, but is wearing the bun in the story proper. Wonder if that's going to factor into the plot somehow, or if it's like the last issue, where the cover doesn't reflect the contents exactly.

ZariusTwo
02-15-2017, 11:56 AM
Daredevil#17 has another OMD Nod

Hellstrom brings up that Mephisto has experiance with erasing people's memories of secret identities (this is a flashback issue detailing how Matt made everyone forget he was Daredevil

WebLurker
02-16-2017, 10:13 AM
Daredevil#17 has another OMD Nod

Hellstrom brings up that Mephisto has experiance with erasing people's memories of secret identities (this is a flashback issue detailing how Matt made everyone forget he was Daredevil

I thought Doctor Strange did the erasing for in Spider-Man's case.

ZariusTwo
02-16-2017, 12:40 PM
I thought Doctor Strange did the erasing for in Spider-Man's case.

That's what they all beleive, but it's looking likely that was a false memory given to everyone.

WebLurker
02-16-2017, 03:14 PM
That's what they all beleive, but it's looking likely that was a false memory given to everyone.

That sounds a little needlessly convoluted. Granted, this is comics, but still.

ZariusTwo
02-16-2017, 03:33 PM
That sounds a little needlessly convoluted. Granted, this is comics, but still.

I think Soule covered his bases just fine, as Doctor Strange also camoes in the issue turning down Matt's request, so you can take it either way, it's referencing OMD and OMIT, but since they've made a big deal out of Mephisto taunting Peter in Spider-Man/Deadpool, it's a safe bet it's more to do with OMD.

Dan Slott answered a Spider-Marriage question on Twitter today. I thought the way he worded it was interesting, he points to Renew Your Vows as a present option for marriage fans, but for him it's "been there, done that", he pointed out that this was just "his take", meaning it might not be the company's take anymore. Just food for thought.

https://twitter.com/DanSlott/status/832323064507617284

WebLurker
02-16-2017, 10:27 PM
I think Soule covered his bases just fine, as Doctor Strange also camoes in the issue turning down Matt's request, so you can take it either way, it's referencing OMD and OMIT, but since they've made a big deal out of Mephisto taunting Peter in Spider-Man/Deadpool, it's a safe bet it's more to do with OMD.

Okay. I do have to admit that, given that a lot of recent ASM comics have started with an interesting premise but fallen flat in the finale, I'm not really sure that any revisiting of OMD will bear anything good for classic Spider-Man fans, but that's just me.

Dan Slott answered a Spider-Marriage question on Twitter today. I thought the way he worded it was interesting, he points to Renew Your Vows as a present option for marriage fans, but for him it's "been there, done that", he pointed out that this was just "his take", meaning it might not be the company's take anymore. Just food for thought.

https://twitter.com/DanSlott/status/832323064507617284

Well, to Slott's credit, that's a pretty polite response, considering his reputation with dissenting readers, if in effect he's saying that he thinks that status quo has run it's course, but there is new material out there for those who want it. My initial reading of Slott saying that's his "take" was that he just meant that he was just giving his personal opinion, but I guess we'll have to see what Marvel wants to do in the long run.

ZariusTwo
02-17-2017, 05:00 AM
Gerry Conway confirms Jean Grey is happily married in Renew Your Vows (https://twitter.com/gerryconway/status/831214383292248064)

...He does'nt specify if she's married to Scott or not though. Given we have seen artwork of Scott looking 'interested' in MJ, Gerry could be another Marvel writer who likes pairing her up with maybe Logan.

Okay. I do have to admit that, given that a lot of recent ASM comics have started with an interesting premise but fallen flat in the finale, I'm not really sure that any revisiting of OMD will bear anything good for classic Spider-Man fans, but that's just me.

I agree...Slott is unfortunatly the type that gives readers something they demand, but adds a critically damaging 'twist' to the story that makes everyone come off looking worse...it'd be better to tie up OMD's loose ends long after he's finished his story, but Slott would love to be the guy to finally bring the marriage back just for the publicity it would generate, and would add to his legacy.

Well, to Slott's credit, that's a pretty polite response, considering his reputation with dissenting readers, if in effect he's saying that he thinks that status quo has run it's course, but there is new material out there for those who want it. My initial reading of Slott saying that's his "take" was that he just meant that he was just giving his personal opinion, but I guess we'll have to see what Marvel wants to do in the long run.

That's how I read it too. He acts as if he's more resigned to the fact the fans for marriage haven't gone anywhere, they have a place of refuge, but for him personally there's just more to Spidey than it...but I also think Marvel no longer quite have the same disdain they have for the marriage as they did under Quesada's eager eye. They're slowly easing readers back into that status quo while trying to also get more out of the Spidey they want in the mainline books...but ultimately I just think they will restore it. As you say, we need to wait it all out. At this point, I think Slott is the only one now holding back it's return, assuming he has'nt got something planned already.

BTW, some friends of mine have been working on a new ongoing Spider-Man fan 'comic' featuring a married Peter and MJ with Annie as their infant daughter, but is slightly more grounded and tries to utlize all the best elements of the last ten years. Check out the latest issue if you'd like:

http://www.spidermancrawlspace.com/2017/02/16/friendly-neighborhood-spider-man-2016-6/

WebLurker
02-17-2017, 10:05 AM
Gerry Conway confirms Jean Grey is happily married in Renew Your Vows (https://twitter.com/gerryconway/status/831214383292248064)

...He does'nt specify if she's married to Scott or not though. Given we have seen artwork of Scott looking 'interested' in MJ, Gerry could be another Marvel writer who likes pairing her up with maybe Logan.

Interesting.

I agree...Slott is unfortunatly the type that gives readers something they demand, but adds a critically damaging 'twist' to the story that makes everyone come off looking worse...it'd be better to tie up OMD's loose ends long after he's finished his story, but Slott would love to be the guy to finally bring the marriage back just for the publicity it would generate, and would add to his legacy.

He wanted to bring it back? I could very well be wrong, but I got the impression that having written the RYV miniseries, he'd done what he wanted with that premise, that he wanted to have a chance to write a story based on that iteration, not bring it back full time.

Although, I wouldn't blame him for wanting to leave more of a legacy for his run; as of late, his run hasn't been exactly earning high praise, I've gathered a recurring theme from online commenters that they think he's running out of steam and his current stuff doesn't compare to his earlier work, not to mention that his run has made very little impression on the franchise as a whole.

That's how I read it too. He acts as if he's more resigned to the fact the fans for marriage haven't gone anywhere, they have a place of refuge, but for him personally there's just more to Spidey than it...

Well, to be fair, the decision to reinstate it isn't his, and I would get tetchy if people kept asking me about it. I also know that there are people who base their dislike of his run largely because of the absence of the marriage, which would be an annoying thing to deal with (if I was a writer, I'd want my work taken for what it was, too). And I have seen some online fans be pretty rude to him on occasion, so I think the breakdown of civility between Slott and fans isn't completely one-sided.

However, I'm really sure why people at Marvel would be surprised that the marriage fans are still around. As I understood it, back in '07, they thought that within a year OMD would be accepted and things would go one. That never really happened. The fanbase that wants nothing to do with post-OMD Spider-Man (or prefers pre-OMD regardless of if they like the new run for what it is) have remained vocal. I mean, when Slott made the official Q and A for Marvel's introduction to his RYV miniseries, he specifically commented that the marriage was a thing that Spidey fans had strong opinions on, and that he may have been understating it.

...but I also think Marvel no longer quite have the same disdain they have for the marriage as they did under Quesada's eager eye.

Wonder why? Most of the people who put OMD into place are still there and since last year, at least, the comics were toeing the line that OMD fixed the franchise.

They're slowly easing readers back into that status quo while trying to also get more out of the Spidey they want in the mainline books...but ultimately I just think they will restore it. As you say, we need to wait it all out. At this point, I think Slott is the only one now holding back it's return, assuming he has'nt got something planned already.

We'll see. My personal guess was that someone eventually would mess with it again, even if was a halfway with Peter and MJ dating; but I was thinking it would be after the readers who grew up with that version became the ones creating the comics. That is essentially how OMD came about; the people in charge weren't happy with what the character had become and wanted him to be like how he was when they were the civilian readers.

We'll have to see, though, where the future takes us.

BTW, some friends of mine have been working on a new ongoing Spider-Man fan 'comic' featuring a married Peter and MJ with Annie as their infant daughter, but is slightly more grounded and tries to utlize all the best elements of the last ten years. Check out the latest issue if you'd like:

http://www.spidermancrawlspace.com/2017/02/16/friendly-neighborhood-spider-man-2016-6/

Yeah, I've been collecting the script PDFs. Pretty good. Not sure if the first couple of scripts being a reimagining of the RYV miniseries #1 is quite what I would've done (I think Venom was a better choice than Doc Ock for the villain in question, although I will concede that the FNSM script version did have more room to breathe). I also really wish they could get an artist to make an actual comic over a script, but it has been worth the reading so far.

ZariusTwo
02-17-2017, 11:28 AM
He wanted to bring it back?

I think I brought this up before here, but apparently he told fans at conventions he'd been pitching a marriage comeback for a while, and only got permission to do RYV when Secret Wars came about.

I could very well be wrong, but I got the impression that having written the RYV miniseries, he'd done what he wanted with that premise, that he wanted to have a chance to write a story based on that iteration, not bring it back full time.

Yes, but Slott also said elements from RYV would greatly impact the books later on. We've seen that manifest through the use of Regent in 616, the "deja vu" Peter and MJ had when fighting him, and in promoting the RYV ongoing, Conway hinted there would be potential for a crossover between the two universes eventually. I suspect Slott would relish the oppertunity to compare and contrast Peter the single CEO with Peter the humble working-class family man who has everything that Mephisto said his devil-dealing counterpart would pretty much never have.

However, I'm really sure why people at Marvel would be surprised that the marriage fans are still around. As I understood it, back in '07, they thought that within a year OMD would be accepted and things would go one. That never really happened. The fanbase that wants nothing to do with post-OMD Spider-Man (or prefers pre-OMD regardless of if they like the new run for what it is) have remained vocal. I mean, when Slott made the official Q and A for Marvel's introduction to his RYV miniseries, he specifically commented that the marriage was a thing that Spidey fans had strong opinions on, and that he may have been understating it.

I don't think they're as surprised as they let on. When they found out the newspaper strip was going to bring the marriage back after running for only a few months with a single Peter, they simply said "they can do their story, we'll do ours", they've always been aware there was something to keep the marriage fans going. Slott has brought up the strip several times, even telling fans to read it while Superior Spider-Man was running, and then he wrote a strip story himself for Spide-Verse, taking credit for "sparing" the strip's version of Peter from the events of that story that had already claimed the life of the happily married MC2 Peter (or rather a version similar to him)

Wonder why? Most of the people who put OMD into place are still there and since last year, at least, the comics were toeing the line that OMD fixed the franchise.

I think some of the people in those posistions disagreed with Quesada on some things related to the execution of OMD. Tom Brevoort is of the opinion MJ was still pregnant during The Clone Saga, but Quesada's One Moment In Time story establishes otherwise.

Quesada in a rare interview last year insisted removing the marriage was the 'right thing' to do...though this is the same Quesada who actually produced a variant cover for the last issue of Slott's Renew Your Vows.

Axel Alonzo, now the EIC, was the man in charge of the Spider-line when OMD went down, so maybe he has a lot to do with the recent Mephisto references, perhaps he feels like some of us do that the time travel retcon is perhaps a little too damaging to long-term investment and it's probably better they reveal it was a mind-wipe job, that allows Quesada's story to stand, but allows Brevoort's opinion to become factual and it does'nt create this idea that post-OMD canon does'nt "count"


We'll see. My personal guess was that someone eventually would mess with it again, even if was a halfway with Peter and MJ dating; but I was thinking it would be after the readers who grew up with that version became the ones creating the comics. That is essentially how OMD came about; the people in charge weren't happy with what the character had become and wanted him to be like how he was when they were the civilian readers.

Yes, there is that possibility we've going to enter a vicious cycle with generations of fans...there will be people who have spent their entire young life beleiving Peter and MJ have always been at odds and that Gwen Stacy was always a Web Warrior (something the new cartoon won't be helping with), or that Peter never worked for Jameson and went straight to Horizon. There's always that danger, but that's probably why Marvel are reprinting The Wedding saga this year..to inform that generation (or to inform people new to Renew Your Vows, take your pick)

Yeah, I've been collecting the script PDFs. Pretty good. Not sure if the first couple of scripts being a reimagining of the RYV miniseries #1 is quite what I would've done (I think Venom was a better choice than Doc Ock for the villain in question, although I will concede that the FNSM script version did have more room to breathe). I also really wish they could get an artist to make an actual comic over a script, but it has been worth the reading so far.

I read that they plan to at least illustrate a couple of pages of the first issue...but whether that means commisioning a pro to do it or not is up to them. I don't really like the front covers they come up with themselves, they'd be much better off just using established artwork and make use of some clever photoshopping until they can get a pro in.

WebLurker
02-17-2017, 02:39 PM
I think I brought this up before here, but apparently he told fans at conventions he'd been pitching a marriage comeback for a while, and only got permission to do RYV when Secret Wars came about.

I do remember that. I guess I'm not sure if Slott wanted it long-term or just short-term, or if he's satisfied with what he did with it now.

Yes, but Slott also said elements from RYV would greatly impact the books later on. We've seen that manifest through the use of Regent in 616, the "deja vu" Peter and MJ had when fighting him, and in promoting the RYV ongoing, Conway hinted there would be potential for a crossover between the two universes eventually.

True, however did Slott want more than just Regent to carry over?

I suspect Slott would relish the oppertunity to compare and contrast Peter the single CEO with Peter the humble working-class family man who has everything that Mephisto said his devil-dealing counterpart would pretty much never have.

Well, considering all the suggestions that Parker Industries may be going down the tubes, Slott and Conway might want to work out a crossover soon, if they want to do one. Having the Peter Parker who wound up single but running a big corporation meeting a version of himself who's been less successful career-wise, but is raising a family with the woman that in his own life things fell apart with is a more interesting contrast between a bachelor and family man Peter who're both in a similar financial position. There's a bigger contrast into the circumstances and choices they made, and what they gave up and what they gained instead.


I don't think they're as surprised as they let on. When they found out the newspaper strip was going to bring the marriage back after running for only a few months with a single Peter, they simply said "they can do their story, we'll do ours", they've always been aware there was something to keep the marriage fans going. Slott has brought up the strip several times, even telling fans to read it while Superior Spider-Man was running, and then he wrote a strip story himself for Spide-Verse, taking credit for "sparing" the strip's version of Peter from the events of that story that had already claimed the life of the happily married MC2 Peter (or rather a version similar to him)

Could be. I have gotten the impression that Marvel's official stance is that the "real" Spider-Man can't be married, but "non-canon" versions or "What ifs?" are okay.

I think some of the people in those posistions disagreed with Quesada on some things related to the execution of OMD. Tom Brevoort is of the opinion MJ was still pregnant during The Clone Saga, but Quesada's One Moment In Time story establishes otherwise.

Interesting.

Quesada in a rare interview last year insisted removing the marriage was the 'right thing' to do...though this is the same Quesada who actually produced a variant cover for the last issue of Slott's Renew Your Vows.

Well, a job is a job. (I have to admit that him doing a cover for that series seemed a little in bad taste to me, but I think I was being overly sensitive.)

Axel Alonzo, now the EIC, was the man in charge of the Spider-line when OMD went down, so maybe he has a lot to do with the recent Mephisto references, perhaps he feels like some of us do that the time travel retcon is perhaps a little too damaging to long-term investment and it's probably better they reveal it was a mind-wipe job, that allows Quesada's story to stand, but allows Brevoort's opinion to become factual and it does'nt create this idea that post-OMD canon does'nt "count"

Could be. However, from where I stand, I think's it too little, too late. Besides, for most people who don't like OMD, it's the story and retcon itself that are the offensive part, not the details. For me, even if it was changed to mind-wipe, not time travel, that wouldn't make things any better, IMHO.

Yes, there is that possibility we've going to enter a vicious cycle with generations of fans...there will be people who have spent their entire young life beleiving Peter and MJ have always been at odds and that Gwen Stacy was always a Web Warrior (something the new cartoon won't be helping with), or that Peter never worked for Jameson and went straight to Horizon. There's always that danger, but that's probably why Marvel are reprinting The Wedding saga this year..to inform that generation (or to inform people new to Renew Your Vows, take your pick)

The irony that I, as someone who oppose OMD, am pretty much coming from the same place that Quesada and others were when they created OMD in the first place isn't lost on me. Not to mention if they did undo OMD, I'd probably be using much of the same arguments that have been brought out to defend OMD, as well.

I read that they plan to at least illustrate a couple of pages of the first issue...but whether that means commisioning a pro to do it or not is up to them. I don't really like the front covers they come up with themselves, they'd be much better off just using established artwork and make use of some clever photoshopping until they can get a pro in.

Yeah, I do understand that having artwork would be really hard, but maybe a few pictures (like in a kid's storybook) would be nice. Agreed that the front covers aren't all that.

ZariusTwo
02-17-2017, 03:59 PM
Could be. I have gotten the impression that Marvel's official stance is that the "real" Spider-Man can't be married, but "non-canon" versions or "What ifs?" are okay.

I find the whole "real" thing sort of amusing because if we want to get technical, the "real" canon ended in 2007, and the MC2 universe probably could make a bolder claim for being "real" given that Peter and MJ are much older than 616 Peter and MJ and have all of the same history with the exception of anything that went on in the 2000s. The strip Spider-Man probably ought to have that claim also given it's the more vintage canon, having started in the 70s, it's ran by the Liebers and currently has the longest-lasting version of the marriage in the Spider-Man medium, at least in real time, at 30 years. I still look at post-OMD Spidey as a reletively "new" continuity at just ten years.

Yeah, I do understand that having artwork would be really hard, but maybe a few pictures (like in a kid's storybook) would be nice. Agreed that the front covers aren't all that.

I also gave Doug Ernst a link to the stories, he's intrigued by the first issue and understands where they went with Doc Ock, but thought that the Billy Mays joke dates the series to a certain period (kind of like a lot of jokes Slott has in his books that'll make a generation go "huh?" later on...though this is'nt exclusively a problem he has either)

WebLurker
02-18-2017, 12:38 AM
I find the whole "real" thing sort of amusing because if we want to get technical, the "real" canon ended in 2007, and the MC2 universe probably could make a bolder claim for being "real" given that Peter and MJ are much older than 616 Peter and MJ and have all of the same history with the exception of anything that went on in the 2000s. The strip Spider-Man probably ought to have that claim also given it's the more vintage canon, having started in the 70s, it's ran by the Liebers and currently has the longest-lasting version of the marriage in the Spider-Man medium, at least in real time, at 30 years. I still look at post-OMD Spidey as a reletively "new" continuity at just ten years.

I suppose that's the crux of the question, is the post-OMD stuff a continuation of the "real" deal or is it a new thing? I guess you could make cases both ways.

I find the question silly since there have been so many renditions and continuities over the years, and different ones will mean more or less to different people. Kind of like that old Superman quote: "This is a fictional story. Aren't they all?"


I also gave Doug Ernst a link to the stories, he's intrigued by the first issue and understands where they went with Doc Ock, but thought that the Billy Mays joke dates the series to a certain period (kind of like a lot of jokes Slott has in his books that'll make a generation go "huh?" later on...though this is'nt exclusively a problem he has either)

Think I saw that. Topical humor is pretty tricky. Some thing'll age well or work anyways, others won't (for example, most of the late Robin Williams' impersonations as the Genie in Aladdin are still funny even if you don't know who he's pretending to be, while the "let it go" joke in Zootopia will date as soon as Frozen looses it's infamous place in pop culture).

ZariusTwo
02-18-2017, 04:02 AM
I suppose that's the crux of the question, is the post-OMD stuff a continuation of the "real" deal or is it a new thing? I guess you could make cases both ways.

I find the question silly since there have been so many renditions and continuities over the years, and different ones will mean more or less to different people. Kind of like that old Superman quote: "This is a fictional story. Aren't they all?"

Superman's another funny example...DC have bent over backwards to fold pre-flashpoint Superman back into the "Rebirth" version of continuity after fans did'nt take to the five year old New 52 version, and yet pre-flashpoint Superman is'nt as old as the Superman of the Golden or Silver Ages.

WebLurker
02-18-2017, 09:35 AM
Superman's another funny example...DC have bent over backwards to fold pre-flashpoint Superman back into the "Rebirth" version of continuity after fans did'nt take to the five year old New 52 version, and yet pre-flashpoint Superman is'nt as old as the Superman of the Golden or Silver Ages.

Wasn't the pre-Flashpoint Superman a rebooted version of the original comics? I understood that DC used the Crises events to create in-universe reboots of the comics, a la the 2009 Star Trek movie or X-Men: Days of Future Past.

ZariusTwo
02-18-2017, 10:53 AM
Wasn't the pre-Flashpoint Superman a rebooted version of the original comics? I understood that DC used the Crises events to create in-universe reboots of the comics, a la the 2009 Star Trek movie or X-Men: Days of Future Past.

Golden Age Superman was a seperate character. At the end of Crises, he journeyed into Alex Luthor's paradise dimension with Golden Age Lois and Superboy, and did'nt return until 2006's Infinite Crisis to try and "fix" the ever increasingly dark DC universe. ("Rebirth" is pretty much rehashing the same idea, only blaming Watchmen characters for how dark the N52 was) Golden Age Superman and Lois wound up dying in that event, while Superboy went insane and became Superboy Prime.

Silver Age Superman ended with the 'imaginary' story "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorow" from Alan Moore, it was never really ellaborated on whether or not that reality 'became' Pre-Flashpoint or not. The Silver Age Superman carried on for a little while longer after the original Crisies event before the John Byrne relaunch.

WebLurker
02-18-2017, 10:24 PM
Golden Age Superman was a seperate character. At the end of Crises, he journeyed into Alex Luthor's paradise dimension with Golden Age Lois and Superboy, and did'nt return until 2006's Infinite Crisis to try and "fix" the ever increasingly dark DC universe. ("Rebirth" is pretty much rehashing the same idea, only blaming Watchmen characters for how dark the N52 was) Golden Age Superman and Lois wound up dying in that event, while Superboy went insane and became Superboy Prime.

Silver Age Superman ended with the 'imaginary' story "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorow" from Alan Moore, it was never really ellaborated on whether or not that reality 'became' Pre-Flashpoint or not. The Silver Age Superman carried on for a little while longer after the original Crisies event before the John Byrne relaunch.

That sounds really confusing.

ZariusTwo
02-19-2017, 04:57 AM
That sounds really confusing.

At least when DC are convoluted, they make it fun.

NYC Toyfare revealed the new wave of Marvel Legends figures...including the new Mary Jane/Spider-Man two-pack, which, interestingly, pairs her with the Parker Industries version.

tKaQ5u1i6gI

ZariusTwo
02-19-2017, 12:32 PM
Top 100 for January

https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/190578-Exclusive-Januarys-Top-100-Best-Selling-Comics

Probably the most noteworthy thing for this thread is Hydra Cap, the centerpiece of Secret Empire, was outsold last month by an issue of Renew Your Vows focusing on Annie May Parker. People are more interested in Peter's kid than the centerpiece of the 2017 summer blockbuster event. Let that sink in.

WebLurker
02-19-2017, 12:51 PM
NYC Toyfare revealed the new wave of Marvel Legends figures...including the new Mary Jane/Spider-Man two-pack, which, interestingly, pairs her with the Parker Industries version.

Heard that Mary Jane was getting a figure. Was hoping to get one when they come out. Not sure I'd want the Tron Spider-Man though. Hope you can get them separately (also hope that they sell a regular Spider-Man at the same scale). As far as them packaging the two together, I have noticed that while the comics themselves were trying to sell the idea that MJ and Peter are over and done and were never a good idea in the first place, the merchandising and other tie-ins seemed to present them as star-crossed lovers, at worse. (I specifically recall a post-OMD reference book that specifically labeled MJ as Peter's "one true love," something I was a little surprised they were allowed to do.)

So, it could be a clue of future plans, or just the marketing being a little more flexible. (After all, Spider-Man and MJ are consistently one of the more popular couples in the Marvel franchise.)

At any rate, the toys look nice. I hope that this line doesn't have the stiff hinge problem I've sometimes seen with hyper-jointed action figures like this.

Top 100 for January

https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/190578-Exclusive-Januarys-Top-100-Best-Selling-Comics

Probably the most noteworthy thing for this thread is Hydra Cap, the centerpiece of Secret Empire, was outsold last month by an issue of Renew Your Vows focusing on Annie May Parker. People are more interested in Peter's kid than the centerpiece of the 2017 summer blockbuster event. Let that sink in.

Wasn't HYDRA Cap almost universally hated? I may not know how comics work, but wouldn't a smaller series about a more popular character's franchise, that was building off of a smash hit and was part of a series that has been a fan-favorite be more likely to do better by default?

ZariusTwo
02-19-2017, 01:41 PM
the merchandising and other tie-ins seemed to present them as star-crossed lovers, at worse. (I specifically recall a post-OMD reference book that specifically labeled MJ as Peter's "one true love," something I was a little surprised they were allowed to do.)

Well, the afterword in the OMD trade from Stan Lee even labels them as 'star-crossed', so they're probably honoring the original voice of Spider-Man mythos, and the man credited with the marriage concept in the first place.

During the Clone Conspiracy, Gwen admitted to Peter that she figured sooner or later he would choose MJ over her even if she had continued to live, and was saddened to hear the two were not presently seeing much of each other.

As I've maintained, I doubt very much these days this sort of thing is just coincidental or signs of the company "trolling" fans. I'm sure there is a plan to make Peter and MJ happen again in the mainline books, we just have to wait and see.

Wasn't HYDRA Cap almost universally hated? I may not know how comics work, but wouldn't a smaller series about a more popular character's franchise, that was building off of a smash hit and was part of a series that has been a fan-favorite be more likely to do better by default?

You're right on that, Hydra Cap also suffers from heavy-handed political commentary, very much one of the major critiques that led to Marvel's lousy performances in 2016 and presently (hence their "Make Mine Marvel" about face), where as RYV is loose, breezy, and just focuses on a more wholesome story.

Spencer's very public meltdowns over Trump and DC sales outperforming his books haven't helped make him entirely likeable with fans either. He may just outperform Dan Slott in that area.

It still has to stick in Marvel's craw though, considering that, regardless of what fans think, Hydra Cap is supposed to be THE biggest deal in the Marvel Universe right now, with Secret Empire announced last month, and it can't seem to get a sales spike over an alternate-reality title.

WebLurker
02-19-2017, 04:56 PM
Well, the afterword in the OMD trade from Stan Lee even labels them as 'star-crossed', so they're probably honoring the original voice of Spider-Man mythos, and the man credited with the marriage concept in the first place.

Maybe. I just thought it was a funny situation thay the source material was making the case that they didn't belong together, while the rest of the franchise was suggesting they did (or at least that them as a viable couple was a legitimate premise).

During the Clone Conspiracy, Gwen admitted to Peter that she figured sooner or later he would choose MJ over her even if she had continued to live, and was saddened to hear the two were not presently seeing much of each other.

How accurate is that to the character in the source material? While I have gotten them impression that 616 Gwen didn't hate MJ, I also got the impression she didn't appreciate her being a potential rival. I also seem to recall that Peter wanted to marry Gwen at the time of her death, and that he and MJ didn't fall in love with each other for real for sometime after.

(Really ironic turn of events for Clone Conspiracy, given that Ultimate Spider-Man also had a scene with a clone Gwen telling Peter she knew that MJ was the one he was truly in love with.)

As I've maintained, I doubt very much these days this sort of thing is just coincidental or signs of the company "trolling" fans. I'm sure there is a plan to make Peter and MJ happen again in the mainline books, we just have to wait and see.

I don't trust them, but you never know.

You're right on that, Hydra Cap also suffers from heavy-handed political commentary, very much one of the major critiques that led to Marvel's lousy performances in 2016 and presently (hence their "Make Mine Marvel" about face), where as RYV is loose, breezy, and just focuses on a more wholesome story.

I have heard negativity to some of Marvel's recent stuff, but I have a very hard time telling if that's the overall opinion, or just the more vocal one.

Spencer's very public meltdowns over Trump and DC sales outperforming his books haven't helped make him entirely likeable with fans either. He may just outperform Dan Slott in that area.

Huh.

I'm frankly through with Trump, so if Spencer doesn't like him, I don't blame him. But still, I think the best revenge is to have a happy life in cases like this and then vote for the people that match your beliefs next election. The man's not worth getting upset over, if you're not planning to write to your representatives or be more constructive in how you handle your displeasure with the commander-in-chief.

As for DC, it is what it is, and what it is is and it's always been a series of ups and downs. Marvel will have its turn soon enough.

It still has to stick in Marvel's craw though, considering that, regardless of what fans think, Hydra Cap is supposed to be THE biggest deal in the Marvel Universe right now, with Secret Empire announced last month, and it can't seem to get a sales spike over an alternate-reality title.

Spider-Man is a bigger name that Captain America. I don't think Cap is anywhere near Marvel's biggest properties; Spider-Man and X-Men.

(Also worth noting: RYV is still below ASM.)

ZariusTwo
02-20-2017, 08:04 AM
(Also worth noting: RYV is still below ASM.)

Why focus on that? We know RYV is niche. Would we like it to be a bit higher? Sure, but it's still at a sustainable number.

WebLurker
02-20-2017, 10:26 AM
Why focus on that? We know RYV is niche. Would we like it to be a bit higher? Sure, but it's still at a sustainable number.

Fair enough, (I guess I was wondering how much of a hit it was in the grand scheme of things, but good point.)

ZariusTwo
02-20-2017, 10:33 AM
A pic from issue five

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C5Dy9Z5XAAAU6Lk.jpg

WebLurker
02-20-2017, 03:05 PM
A pic from issue five

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C5Dy9Z5XAAAU6Lk.jpg

Nice. Looks like it similar enough Stegman's style to feel unified.

ZariusTwo
02-21-2017, 09:14 AM
http://www.comicscontinuum.com/stories/1702/21/amazingrenew7.jpg

Welcome to Die

WebLurker
02-21-2017, 02:30 PM
http://www.comicscontinuum.com/stories/1702/21/amazingrenew7.jpg

Welcome to Die

Alternate cover?

ZariusTwo
02-22-2017, 04:50 AM
No, it's the cover for RYV#7 in May.

Pretty rare for Peter to tussel with Magneto...he did so in the 1980s animated series, and he also faced him in the newspaper strip (in a storyline where MJ was considering having a kid with Peter)

WebLurker
02-22-2017, 11:34 AM
No, it's the cover for RYV#7 in May.

So, is it an alternative to the one with the Parkers and the X-Men, or did they change it?

Pretty rare for Peter to tussel with Magneto...he did so in the 1980s animated series, and he also faced him in the newspaper strip (in a storyline where MJ was considering having a kid with Peter)

They also had a brief meet up in Ultimate Spider-Man (the "...And His Amazing Friends" story arc) and in Marvel Adventures: Spider-Man, a light-hearted story about the two clashing in Greece.

ZariusTwo
02-22-2017, 12:06 PM
So, is it an alternative to the one with the Parkers and the X-Men, or did they change it?

The one with the X-Men on the cover is Issue Six, this is the next issue.

WebLurker
02-22-2017, 05:21 PM
The one with the X-Men on the cover is Issue Six, this is the next issue.

Oh, so a two-parter. Huh, I though it was going to be a one-shot story. Guess I was wrong. Well, a longer story sounds like more fun. Bring it on!

(Wait, what was with the "Welcome to die?" thing?)

ZariusTwo
02-23-2017, 03:22 AM
(Wait, what was with the "Welcome to die?" thing?)

It's an actual quote from the X-Men Arcade game.

IdAmkx8eAos

ZariusTwo
02-28-2017, 05:23 AM
So apparently 616 Mary Jane and Peter will be interacting in the Free Comic Book Day edition of Spectacular Spider-Man. I'm going to be on the cautious side about this

WebLurker
02-28-2017, 10:23 AM
So apparently 616 Mary Jane and Peter will be interacting in the Free Comic Book Day edition of Spectacular Spider-Man. I'm going to be on the cautious side about this

Who's writing?

ZariusTwo
02-28-2017, 11:26 AM
Who's writing?

Chip Zrdasky, who's helming the Spetacular title when it launches soon after the FCBD issue, he says the oppertunity to write Peter and MJ banter "thrills him to bits".

WebLurker
02-28-2017, 07:42 PM
Chip Zrdasky, who's helming the Spetacular title when it launches soon after the FCBD issue, he says the oppertunity to write Peter and MJ banter "thrills him to bits".

Hope that's a good thing.

ZariusTwo
03-01-2017, 08:08 AM
Hope that's a good thing.

Yeah, Chip's apparently a Peter/MJ fan, so here's hoping he rebuilds the relationship, he's said in an interview his book will still follow ASM's leading developments while doing it's own thing (and there will be consequential storylines in Spectacular that ASM will also fold into it's narrative)

Back to Renew Your Vows material

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C5yCnDgU8AAOR15.jpg

WebLurker
03-01-2017, 12:42 PM
Yeah, Chip's apparently a Peter/MJ fan, so here's hoping he rebuilds the relationship, he's said in an interview his book will still follow ASM's leading developments while doing it's own thing (and there will be consequential storylines in Spectacular that ASM will also fold into it's narrative)

While I suppose at the very least having a supporter onboard will make things more friendly for old school fans, even if the author can't directly change stuff.

Back to Renew Your Vows material

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C5yCnDgU8AAOR15.jpg

The Institute, I presume. I'm guessing that it's MJ with an X-Man?

ZariusTwo
03-01-2017, 05:06 PM
The Institute, I presume. I'm guessing that it's MJ with an X-Man?

Probably Cyclops, as seen in most of the imagery Stegman has provided from the issue.

WebLurker
03-03-2017, 09:38 AM
Probably Cyclops, as seen in most of the imagery Stegman has provided from the issue.

Saw an announcement that Marvel is doing a Venom event. That might explain why they're having that RYV variant cover with MJ and the Venom symbiote; it's supposed to be in honor of that event.

ZariusTwo
03-03-2017, 10:32 AM
Yeah I read that too. Apparently they're going to 'canonize' all the Marvel symbiote variants, meaning 616 MJ will finally bond with a symbiote for this event (oh joy:roll:)

WebLurker
03-03-2017, 11:48 AM
Yeah I read that too. Apparently they're going to 'canonize' all the Marvel symbiote variants, meaning 616 MJ will finally bond with a symbiote for this event (oh joy:roll:)

Guess I won't be reading that ever, then.

ZariusTwo
03-03-2017, 11:53 AM
I know this does'nt affect RYV, but It appears Marvel may go back to legacy numbering

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2017/03/03/make-mine-marvel-will-relaunch-titles-not-1-legacy-numbers/

WebLurker
03-03-2017, 11:29 PM
I know this does'nt affect RYV, but It appears Marvel may go back to legacy numbering

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2017/03/03/make-mine-marvel-will-relaunch-titles-not-1-legacy-numbers/

Frankly, I think that comic book numbering has become a confusing mess and the constant shifting and renumbering just makes things worse.

(I'd be surprised if this affects RYV in and of itself, unless they decide to count the miniseries as the first five issues and then convert the rest into numbers 6, 7, 8, 9, etc. :D.)

ZariusTwo
03-04-2017, 04:32 AM
(I'd be surprised if this affects RYV in and of itself, unless they decide to count the miniseries as the first five issues and then convert the rest into numbers 6, 7, 8, 9, etc. :D.)

Well at least people knew to it would actually have the Regent backstory:lol:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C6Bl8isWMAAfD-S.jpg

ZariusTwo
03-05-2017, 06:05 AM
February Top 100 list is in...RYV drops to number 71.

https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/191245-Exclusive-Februarys-Top-100-Best-Selling-Comics

WebLurker
03-05-2017, 03:24 PM
February Top 100 list is in...RYV drops to number 71.

https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/191245-Exclusive-Februarys-Top-100-Best-Selling-Comics

Ouch. Hope that this doesn't mean that we get smug post-OMD Spider-Man fans using this as proof that Slott's version is better than the old one, or something.

ZariusTwo
03-05-2017, 04:17 PM
I'm sure there will be types who'll argue this proves "nobody's interested in Spider-Dad", but for a title that has minimal promotion and is an AU (and AU titles often do poorly), it's outselling the likes of Champions, Infamous Iron Man and Jessica Jones (two Bendis veichles no less, and one with a Netflix show backing it), as well as it's fellow AU title, the unfortunate Spider-Gwen.

WebLurker
03-05-2017, 10:13 PM
I'm sure there will be types who'll argue this proves "nobody's interested in Spider-Dad", but for a title that has minimal promotion and is an AU (and AU titles often do poorly), it's outselling the likes of Champions, Infamous Iron Man and Jessica Jones (two Bendis veichles no less, and one with a Netflix show backing it), as well as it's fellow AU title, the unfortunate Spider-Gwen.

Well, the series may always be a niche market. As long as it sells enough to keep publication going, I don't mind.

Spider-Gwen isn't doing that well? Thought it was like a fan favorite AU series or something.

ZariusTwo
03-06-2017, 03:29 AM
Well, the series may always be a niche market. As long as it sells enough to keep publication going, I don't mind.

I still don't think even with these numbers that it will be axed abruptly, Spider-Girl wasn't a big seller in it's run, but it's fanbase enable it to last twelve years and it was only permanently cancelled because Marvel wanted to push Arana at the time and give her the Spider-Girl name.

Spider-Gwen isn't doing that well? Thought it was like a fan favorite AU series or something.

Spider-Gwen was riding high a couple of years ago after the second and last of the Marc Webb movies, Marvel cashed in big on that with the Spider-Verse story and it worked out well...but now we're three years or so removed from Emma Stone's tenure as Gwen and that following has vanished. Marvel clearly are still trying to keep Spider-Gwen relevant though, shoe-horning it into everything like the recent Clone Conspiracy and a relationship with Miles Morales, and there's also her upcoming role in the new animated series.

WebLurker
03-06-2017, 09:30 AM
I still don't think even with these numbers that it will be axed abruptly, Spider-Girl wasn't a big seller in it's run, but it's fanbase enable it to last twelve years and it was only permanently cancelled because Marvel wanted to push Arana at the time and give her the Spider-Girl name.

Well, hope it has a change to tie everything up before everything's said and done.

Spider-Gwen was riding high a couple of years ago after the second and last of the Marc Webb movies, Marvel cashed in big on that with the Spider-Verse story and it worked out well...but now we're three years or so removed from Emma Stone's tenure as Gwen and that following has vanished.

Wonder what changed? People still seem to have fond memories of Emma Stone's Gwen (which I really don't get).

Marvel clearly are still trying to keep Spider-Gwen relevant though, shoe-horning it into everything like the recent Clone Conspiracy and a relationship with Miles Morales, and there's also her upcoming role in the new animated series.

Wonder why it's so important for them to keep Spider-Gwen around and important? You'd think if it's running out of steam, they'd have more than enough characters and materials to replace her.

ZariusTwo
03-06-2017, 09:56 AM
Wonder why it's so important for them to keep Spider-Gwen around and important? You'd think if it's running out of steam, they'd have more than enough characters and materials to replace her.

It's just the current 70s era fanboy regime holding on to thier idealized notions of the character and trying to "inform" a fresh generation of how special she could be when developed in a different context...though hopefully MJ's Spinerett shows in the cartoon too before long.

ZariusTwo
03-06-2017, 02:42 PM
Read a report from a fan who attended Emerald City Comic Con on the Spider-Man Crawlspace forums

-He talked with Christos Gage, Stan Lee, Joe Kelly, and Dan Slott

-Joe Kelly revealed Spider-Man/Deadpool sort of exists within it's own bubble and that you should not expect the other books to bother too much with the Mephisto and OMD callbacks in quite the way he has been handling it, but he also said "you never know"

-Slott also tweeted a photo of two cosplayers dressed as RYV Peter and MJ to Gerry Conway and Ryan Stegman

WebLurker
03-06-2017, 05:46 PM
-Joe Kelly revealed Spider-Man/Deadpool sort of exists within it's own bubble and that you should not expect the other books to bother too much with the Mephisto and OMD callbacks in quite the way he has been handling it, but he also said "you never know"

So, where do you think that leaves your theory that Marvel was building to some kind of revisiting to OMD?

ZariusTwo
03-07-2017, 04:53 AM
So, where do you think that leaves your theory that Marvel was building to some kind of revisiting to OMD?

Does'nt really change it. I did'nt expect Kelly to tell them something juicy before it's time, and I'm interested in what he meant by "you never know", it's non-commital, but it still hints at something. He could very easily have just been blunt and said nothing's happening.

WebLurker
03-09-2017, 03:07 PM
Does'nt really change it. I did'nt expect Kelly to tell them something juicy before it's time, and I'm interested in what he meant by "you never know", it's non-commital, but it still hints at something. He could very easily have just been blunt and said nothing's happening.

Slott's been recently posting on the CBR forums. He's been pretty adamant that OMD is not going away. Of course, he also said that Peter Parker was not coming back after SSM got started and that Clone Conspiracy was about resurrection not cloning, so take it for what it's worth.

Found this interesting post online (http://mrsspidermanmaryjanewatsonparker.tumblr.com/post/157654711083/amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-1-3-supercut); someone edited the first three RYV issues together in roughly chronological order. I think it reads better as originally written, but an interesting way to try and piece together how the overlaps work.

ZariusTwo
03-09-2017, 03:16 PM
Slott's been recently posting on the CBR forums. He's been pretty adamant that OMD is not going away. Of course, he also said that Peter Parker was not coming back after SSM got started and that Clone Conspiracy was about resurrection not cloning, so take it for what it's worth.

He also said noone was interested in writing "Spider-Dad" adventures, then proceeded to do one himself, and then Conway and Stegman stepped forward afterwards.

Interesting how he brings this up just as MJ is going to have interaction with Peter in Free Comic Book Day, and just before ASM#25 is due out next week with a "game-changing" short story. Stay tuned to this station, when Slott says something's not going down, you know damn well he's rubbing that ol' monkeys paw of his (meaning we'll get what we want, but not how we like it)

Found this interesting post online (http://mrsspidermanmaryjanewatsonparker.tumblr.com/post/157654711083/amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-1-3-supercut); someone edited the first three RYV issues together in roughly chronological order. I think it reads better as originally written, but an interesting way to try and piece together how the overlaps work.

Yeah, I have seen that, I brought it to the attention of my friends over on ComicVine. It definitely flows better.

WebLurker
03-10-2017, 12:02 AM
He also said noone was interested in writing "Spider-Dad" adventures, then proceeded to do one himself, and then Conway and Stegman stepped forward afterwards.

When was that?

Interesting how he brings this up just as MJ is going to have interaction with Peter in Free Comic Book Day, and just before ASM#25 is due out next week with a "game-changing" short story. Stay tuned to this station, when Slott says something's not going down, you know damn well he's rubbing that ol' monkeys paw of his (meaning we'll get what we want, but not how we like it)

I forget the context, but I think it was in response to someone else's comment. Personally, I'm inclined to believe him in this case, but that's more of my distrust of Marvel on this than his track record.

ZariusTwo
03-10-2017, 03:21 AM
I forget the context, but I think it was in response to someone else's comment. Personally, I'm inclined to believe him in this case, but that's more of my distrust of Marvel on this than his track record.

I read his comments, but I stopped the minute he said he'd only lied once ("Peter ain't coming back in Superior"):P

WebLurker
03-10-2017, 10:40 AM
I read his comments, but I stopped the minute he said he'd only lied once ("Peter ain't coming back in Superior"):P

We'll see. If the franchise was planning some kind of followup to OMD (for good or bad), Slott would have good reason to throw us off. I just doubt that Marvel will undo OMD, given how much time and effort they've invented in the idea that the 616 characters being a married couple ruined the franchise.

ZariusTwo
03-10-2017, 12:52 PM
We'll see. If the franchise was planning some kind of followup to OMD (for good or bad), Slott would have good reason to throw us off. I just doubt that Marvel will undo OMD, given how much time and effort they've invented in the idea that the 616 characters being a married couple ruined the franchise.

I just read his last two posts on CBR about this...a few things I took from it

-He's dismissing the reversal of OMD it in the same hyperbolic style he dimisses everything the fans have thought of before he winds up doing it...this is the same attitude he had during Clone Conspiracy and was plauged with Ben Reily questions, saying bringing him back was an impossibility as he "could'nt work with goo".

-Then he boasts about how he'll be telling readers he'll be here next year telling them the same thing (which to me was a big neon sign that it may just be back next year and he'll be boasting the opposite)

-He does'nt rule out Peter and MJ getting back together without the marriage. This is a pivotal hypothesis given this is the man who's been doing his best to keep Peter and MJ as far apart as possible.

WebLurker
03-10-2017, 02:18 PM
I just read his last two posts on CBR about this...a few things I took from it

-He's dismissing the reversal of OMD it in the same hyperbolic style he dimisses everything the fans have thought of before he winds up doing it...this is the same attitude he had during Clone Conspiracy and was plauged with Ben Reily questions, saying bringing him back was an impossibility as he "could'nt work with goo".

-Then he boasts about how he'll be telling readers he'll be here next year telling them the same thing (which to me was a big neon sign that it may just be back next year and he'll be boasting the opposite)

-He does'nt rule out Peter and MJ getting back together without the marriage. This is a pivotal hypothesis given this is the man who's been doing his best to keep Peter and MJ as far apart as possible.

We'll have to see, but frankly, given his track record, I'm not sure any good is going to come out of it, regardless of what happens.

ZariusTwo
03-10-2017, 03:00 PM
Now he's saying anyone who wants the marriage reinstated has a poor grasp of reality...

..Meanwhile, over at DC, they're essentially doing the happy ever after version of OMD with Superman Reborn and soaking up all the good will from fans with such "poor grasps of reality"

WebLurker
03-10-2017, 06:28 PM
Now he's saying anyone who wants the marriage reinstated has a poor grasp of reality...

Think I was semi-part of that conversation. My retort, to put it bluntly, is that I'm not sure Marvel has gotten that the franchise as a whole doesn't reflect OMD and that's not changing anytime soon.

..Meanwhile, over at DC, they're essentially doing the happy ever after version of OMD with Superman Reborn and soaking up all the good will from fans with such "poor grasps of reality"

Well, Marvel is doing the RYV series, so they don't seem to mind cashing in on our "poor grasps of reality."

ZariusTwo
03-11-2017, 07:22 AM
Think I was semi-part of that conversation. My retort, to put it bluntly, is that I'm not sure Marvel has gotten that the franchise as a whole doesn't reflect OMD and that's not changing anytime soon.

It might not in the likes of the Unlimited game, RYV, and the newspaper strip, but I have concerns about the next animated series, which Slott reportedly has creative influence over.

The same concerns stretch back to the last Spidey series, Ultimate Spider-Man. In that cartoon Peter and MJ were mainly portrayed as friends who had a romantic past when they were kids. USM ended without them getting together, although you could sort of work out that they probably would get together due to all of the flirting they did after MJ became the Carnage Queen and learned Peter's identity.

Well, Marvel is doing the RYV series, so they don't seem to mind cashing in on our "poor grasps of reality."

Yep. Say one thing, mean another. Dan flip-flops so much on the importance of marriage fans, labelling us a small and stubborn minority, yet insists we, in our perceived "small number", do everything we can to push RYV's sales up. He expects us to take an insult and from there take an instruction right after diminishing our importance and voice.

Not the most logical approach. "Try to make this book matter, even if you don't matter anyway"

WebLurker
03-11-2017, 10:15 AM
It might not in the likes of the Unlimited game, RYV, and the newspaper strip, but I have concerns about the next animated series, which Slott reportedly has creative influence over.

I guess I'd wait and see; besides, I think the movies will have more influence.

The same concerns stretch back to the last Spidey series, Ultimate Spider-Man. In that cartoon Peter and MJ were mainly portrayed as friends who had a romantic past when they were kids. USM ended without them getting together, although you could sort of work out that they probably would get together due to all of the flirting they did after MJ became the Carnage Queen and learned Peter's identity.

I didn't see much of that cartoon, but at least it did show MJ as being an important part of Peter's life, not really something that can be said for the comics.



Yep. Say one thing, mean another. Dan flip-flops so much on the importance of marriage fans, labelling us a small and stubborn minority, yet insists we, in our perceived "small number", do everything we can to push RYV's sales up. He expects us to take an insult and from there take an instruction right after diminishing our importance and voice.

Not the most logical approach. "Try to make this book matter, even if you don't matter anyway"

Well, I've got my subscription, so I've done all I can. As far as size goes, he could very well be right. It's not the comics are being mass-embargoed or anything. Although whether that speaks more to the fanbase as a whole being more accepting or that most people don't really care about the comics as long as the movies and other stuff are good, I don't know.

The official explanation right now is, as Slott as stated elsewhere, is that OMD will never be reversed because the way Marvel's corporation works (apparently, heaven and earth had to be moved to okay RYV in the first place). There was no elaboration, so I'm not really sure what that means or how much hyperbole that is (like if there's legal restrictions or if his reading is that there too many things that would need to happen to make a reversal plausible, or what).

I'm not good at reading people, esp. though posts, but Slott's writing did have a feel of "I'm really tired of getting bugged about this," so I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt in this case. Anyways, I'm not sure that current management would have any benefit in undoing OMD.

ZariusTwo
03-11-2017, 11:53 AM
I'm not good at reading people, esp. though posts, but Slott's writing did have a feel of "I'm really tired of getting bugged about this," so I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt in this case. Anyways, I'm not sure that current management would have any benefit in undoing OMD.

I can imagine it's all down to Slott feeling the pressure, he comes across as a guy losing a lot of battles. Clone Conspiracy was a critical flop and the core story was'nt a big seller, where as ASM was orbiting the top ten but seldom cracking it. The event also had a hand in ending Silk and Prowler.

Also, there is a new Spider-Man book editor that took over from Nick Lowe who apparently IS a marraige fan, so Slott may be feeling pressured by him to do something about it and has been fighting tooth and nail to keep things the way they are. He's praising RYV and wants us to help keep it afloat, but at the same time he definitely should temper what he says about us being a 'minority', as it's a minority backed up by virtually every other wing of Marvel's promotional spectrum.

But, again, from the way Slott's acting, I'm convinced he's misdirecting at this point. I just do. I think the marriage may definitely be coming back, but as you say, despite everything, we'll see.

ZariusTwo
03-12-2017, 09:37 AM
Over on CBR, Dan's no longer ruling out the possibility of OMD being revisited and resolved, but rules out that the marriage will be reinstated.

I think I just got my confirmation we're getting something this year, and that we'll get our first taste of it this Wednesday when ASM V2#25 comes out.

I'm also certain he's also given away the outcome...that the marriage WILL be reinstated, but he's saying it in the same silver tounged way he said Peter would never come back in Superior or that Ben would not be ressurected.

WebLurker
03-12-2017, 01:18 PM
I can imagine it's all down to Slott feeling the pressure, he comes across as a guy losing a lot of battles. Clone Conspiracy was a critical flop and the core story was'nt a big seller, where as ASM was orbiting the top ten but seldom cracking it. The event also had a hand in ending Silk and Prowler.

I think I've seen Slott allude to ASM's sales. The gist of his take boils down to the notion that "orbiting the top ten" is not a failure (and proves that the fan love his take on ASM, despite what the haters day). I do have to admit I do see that point about the sales, if not the fan love; a bronze-level Olympian is still among the top of their professions. Although sales to have their weak points when used to gauge fan popularity, so it's hardly conclusive. I do agree that Clone Conspiracy has not been the crowning jewel of the franchise that the creators were hoping for; reviews seem to be mixed at best (and the fact that the ASM tie-ins outsold the core miniseries can't be good, no matter how you slice it).

Also, there is a new Spider-Man book editor that took over from Nick Lowe who apparently IS a marraige fan...

First I've heard of it. Wonder what effect, if any it'll have on the comics going forward?

...so Slott may be feeling pressured by him to do something about it and has been fighting tooth and nail to keep things the way they are.

Possibly, but Marvel is a still a business. If Slott's OMD series is selling well enough, what's the motivation to shake things up? Changing a "good thing" just because a higher up personally prefers a different variation isn't responsible from a business standpoint.

He's praising RYV and wants us to help keep it afloat...

Well, it is based on one of Slott's projects, as an AU series, it's hardly a threat to him, and there's no reason he couldn't enjoy it for what it is regardless of other factors.

...but at the same time he definitely should temper what he says about us being a 'minority', as it's a minority backed up by virtually every other wing of Marvel's promotional spectrum.

I have brought up the fact over on CBR, that the Spider-Man franchise, as a whole, tends to be based on or friendly to, the pre-OMD stuff and the idea of Spider-Man and Mary Jane as a couple. I don't think the pro-OMD people were esp. impressed, despite it being a good possibility that the non-comics part of the franchise are now the most influential parts of the franchise in terms to informing people's opinions of what Spider-Man is. (However, the idea that ASM is no longer the thing that defines the Spider-Man franchise was not very well received, although I didn't feel that I was given a very good reason why the points I cited were wrong.)

But, again, from the way Slott's acting, I'm convinced he's misdirecting at this point. I just do. I think the marriage may definitely be coming back, but as you say, despite everything, we'll see.

More on that below.


Over on CBR, Dan's no longer ruling out the possibility of OMD being revisited and resolved, but rules out that the marriage will be reinstated.

I'm not sure that makes any real sense. If the characters aren't going to be married off again, what's there to resolve? And, if there's no idea to undo it, why dredge it up again. Regardless of whether people think that "Brand New Day" and the rest was worth it, OMD is near-universally considered one of the worst comic book stories ever put to paper.

I think I just got my confirmation we're getting something this year, and that we'll get our first taste of it this Wednesday when ASM V2#25 comes out.

I'm also certain he's also given away the outcome...that the marriage WILL be reinstated, but he's saying it in the same silver tounged way he said Peter would never come back in Superior or that Ben would not be ressurected.

Possibly, but two things:

I'm not sure that Marvel has any motivation to undo OMD; they think that Spider-Man being single is an essential trait, they seem to be content with the sales they're getting from the post-OMD stuff, and they have the RYV series to direct fans who're refusing to let go of the past.

Secondly, the upcoming Spectacular sub-series has been teasing that they'll introduce a new possible love interest character. While not conclusive, that doesn't mesh well with an "undo OMD" plan. (Also, part of Slott's pitch for the Parker Industries setup was that Spider-Man could once again get in love triangles, which were ostensibly a core part of the character and supposedly what the fans wanted. :roll: They've hardly played this angle out so far, which would suggest that they may not be done with it.)

My conclusion? I don't think OMD is going away anytime soon, given Marvel's current interests and what they seem to want to do for the future. However, unless further evidence or clarification come up, Slott's insistence that it cannot be undone, even if the Powers That Be wanted to, is probably hyperbole, at best.

ZariusTwo
03-12-2017, 02:15 PM
I'm not sure that makes any real sense. If the characters aren't going to be married off again, what's there to resolve? And, if there's no idea to undo it, why dredge it up again.

Because the chance of resolving it, even partially, gives Slott a notch in his belt in his legacy as a "seminal" voice in the Spider-Man creative pool. He's ticked a lot of boxes. Man who made Doc Ock a superhero, man who brought back Ben Reily, man who fought tooth and nail "politically" to give the marraige a new ongoing...his surpreme claim to fame as the man who redeemed Peter Parker for the devil deal is something he will want to take credit for so he is left in slightly more positive standing with the critics he still has out there.

I'm not sure that Marvel has any motivation to undo OMD; they think that Spider-Man being single is an essential trait, they seem to be content with the sales they're getting from the post-OMD stuff, and they have the RYV series to direct fans who're refusing to let go of the past.

Hard to let go of something perceived to be from "the past" when, as we've both been pointing out, it continues to have fresh material produced for it in the present even ten years removed from the OMD detour.:)

Secondly, the upcoming Spectacular sub-series has been teasing that they'll introduce a new possible love interest character. While not conclusive, that doesn't mesh well with an "undo OMD" plan. (Also, part of Slott's pitch for the Parker Industries setup was that Spider-Man could once again get in love triangles, which were ostensibly a core part of the character and supposedly what the fans wanted. :roll: They've hardly played this angle out so far, which would suggest that they may not be done with it.)

That, or plans changed, or were delayed. I'm inclined to beleive the latter because of the Mockingbird title at the time, and the intentions of that book's writer to involve her with Clint again. However, that book has now been cancelled, which means Slott is free to again make use of his original plans for Bobbi. The triangle thing was promised in 2015 and has taken until now to manifest with this Rebecca London character (who Chip has said will be more interested in Spider-Man than Peter Parker) and whatever Slott plans to do with Mockingbird. Mary Jane will be part of the Free Comic Book Day issue, although whether or not that means she'll be a part of the Spectacular title is up in the air.

My conclusion? I don't think OMD is going away anytime soon, given Marvel's current interests and what they seem to want to do for the future. However, unless further evidence or clarification come up, Slott's insistence that it cannot be undone, even if the Powers That Be wanted to, is probably hyperbole, at best.

Of course it's hyperbole. I believe there are layers of truth in it, but at the same time plenty of exaggeration and half-truths. He knows what to say to readers, and it's usually not what they want to hear...until he dictates the time is right for them to hear something different. He's already doing that with "OMD might be resolved some day...but don't expect the marraige back EVER, EVER, FOREVER EVER, EVER AND FOREVER", which, as I've pointed out several times, is stuff that harkens back to similar tricks he's pulled with Superior and Clone Conspiracy.

It does of course open up a larger can of worms...i.e Slott choosing this particular weekend to start hyperbowling. This is the week ASM#25 comes out, and he faces being accused after it's release of trying to convince us, the "pro-marraige minority" into picking up the issue in the hopes that it will contain something tied to OMD. He knows he has a reputation for misdirection, and he is counting on that to increase publicity for the issue. The rational course of action is to wait until you hear from someone who has the issue, and then make an informed decision.

Apparently the conclusion to Osborn Identity will also mark his 200th issue of ASM overall, at least according to his Twitter updates today. Quite a feat, wonder how he'll mark the occasion?

WebLurker
03-12-2017, 10:39 PM
Because the chance of resolving it, even partially, gives Slott a notch in his belt in his legacy as a "seminal" voice in the Spider-Man creative pool. He's ticked a lot of boxes. Man who made Doc Ock a superhero, man who brought back Ben Reily, man who fought tooth and nail "politically" to give the marraige a new ongoing...his surpreme claim to fame as the man who redeemed Peter Parker for the devil deal is something he will want to take credit for so he is left in slightly more positive standing with the critics he still has out there.

Does Slott even care about doing that, esp. if the fans he would be appeasing are such a minority in his opinion? I'm not trying to put words in his mouth, but I've kind of gotten the impression that having done the RYV miniseries now, he's through with married Spider-Man. I mean, what is there to suggest that he wants to undo OMD in order to pad his resume?

Hard to let go of something perceived to be from "the past" when, as we've both been pointing out, it continues to have fresh material produced for it in the present even ten years removed from the OMD detour.:)

Maybe I should say in 616. The rule seems to be that non-616 stuff can do it under certain circumstances, but 616 is off-limits.

That, or plans changed, or were delayed. I'm inclined to beleive the latter because of the Mockingbird title at the time, and the intentions of that book's writer to involve her with Clint again. However, that book has now been cancelled, which means Slott is free to again make use of his original plans for Bobbi. The triangle thing was promised in 2015 and has taken until now to manifest with this Rebecca London character (who Chip has said will be more interested in Spider-Man than Peter Parker) and whatever Slott plans to do with Mockingbird. Mary Jane will be part of the Free Comic Book Day issue, although whether or not that means she'll be a part of the Spectacular title is up in the air.

As we've been saying ad nauseam, we'll have to wait and see.

Of course it's hyperbole. I believe there are layers of truth in it, but at the same time plenty of exaggeration and half-truths. He knows what to say to readers, and it's usually not what they want to hear...until he dictates the time is right for them to hear something different. He's already doing that with "OMD might be resolved some day...but don't expect the marraige back EVER, EVER, FOREVER EVER, EVER AND FOREVER", which, as I've pointed out several times, is stuff that harkens back to similar tricks he's pulled with Superior and Clone Conspiracy.

Sure (my guess that "it can't happen, ever" is probably mostly meaning that too many people need to be onboard to sign off on it to make it likely to happen in the near future), but there is always the possibility that he's being totally honest with us.

It does of course open up a larger can of worms...i.e Slott choosing this particular weekend to start hyperbowling. This is the week ASM#25 comes out, and he faces being accused after it's release of trying to convince us, the "pro-marraige minority" into picking up the issue in the hopes that it will contain something tied to OMD. He knows he has a reputation for misdirection, and he is counting on that to increase publicity for the issue.

Could be, although, as I recall, other posters on CBR were the ones who brought it up as a tangent (which now has its own thread). Slott came in later, so he wasn't the one who brought it up. From my very limited experience with CBR, he has been hanging around and denying for a lot longer than he sometimes does in the past. A clue that he's misdirecting? Maybe, but it could also just mean that he's sinking his teeth into trying to clear the record as he sees it once and for all.

The rational course of action is to wait until you hear from someone who has the issue, and then make an informed decision.

Very true.

Apparently the conclusion to Osborn Identity will also mark his 200th issue of ASM overall, at least according to his Twitter updates today. Quite a feat, wonder how he'll mark the occasion?

In the comics or online? (200? That's is impressive, regardless of whether you like his stuff or not, but he still hasn't quite caught up with Brian Michael Bendis's duration on Ultimate Spider-Man/Miles Morales.

[Update: Dan Slott did essentially confirm on CBR that when he said "OMD will never be undone," he meant that it would have be okayed by an insanely huge number of people at Marvel, all committed to keeping it around to keep the brand viable. Howe he knows that years later down the road that keeping OMD intact will still be considered a good idea by the people in those positions I can't say, but there it is.]

ZariusTwo
03-13-2017, 06:25 AM
Does Slott even care about doing that, esp. if the fans he would be appeasing are such a minority in his opinion? I'm not trying to put words in his mouth, but I've kind of gotten the impression that having done the RYV miniseries now, he's through with married Spider-Man. I mean, what is there to suggest that he wants to undo OMD in order to pad his resume?

I know I flip-flop a lot, because I have to keep one side of my brain in "realist" paradigm, and another part in a "idealized" paradigm, but I think for this particular thing, Slott 'resolving' OMD in a way that appeases the higher-ups is what I was getting at more if there is the chance he's being honest. As he says on CBR, he's pretty sure MJ will be the main interest again...and he's the one that decreed her relationship with Peter was "no fun" without having the marraige as a natural endgame for it.

There's no gurantee Slott has interest in being the one to make MJ the main interest again if his comments about her love for Peter being "anti-marvel" are to be taken seriously...but looking back on those comments he made years ago, and looking at his comments this weekend, I think I understand more of what he meant by that...that he's referring to Marvel's philosophy on the brand, not his own personal opinion, because he also said at Emerald Comic Con he loves every era of Spider-Man, marriage era included.

ZariusTwo
03-13-2017, 12:36 PM
So the major twist of ASM#25 turns out to be

More of fecking Doc Ock as Superior, using what I assume is the proto-clone body, and he's joined Hydra.

Ah well, there goes a fresh hope. Still, glad that Dan had his big moment for this week spoiled ahead of the curb. That's what you get for being a braggadocious ass arguing away all weekend on the internet with a "niche" audience

WebLurker
03-13-2017, 12:58 PM
So the major twist of ASM#25 turns out to be

More of fecking Doc Ock as Superior, using what I assume is the proto-clone body, and he's joined Hydra.

Weren't most fans already assuming that this turn of events would happen anyways? And what's with the obsessions with SSM? (I will concede though, that I don't find this setup for an "SSM" thing offensive like I did the actual SSM series.)

ZariusTwo
03-13-2017, 02:38 PM
Weren't most fans already assuming that this turn of events would happen anyways? And what's with the obsessions with SSM? (I will concede though, that I don't find this setup for an "SSM" thing offensive like I did the actual SSM series.)

I can understand the urge to keep going back to Superior, it's considered Slott's magnum opus and the most commercially succesful run of the post-OMD era so far.

I bet we'll have a Superior title before the end of the year, or possibly to replace Spider-Man 2099, since I hear cancelation for that is immenent.

ZariusTwo
03-15-2017, 03:06 PM
Well, while we did'nt get much of anything related to Peter and MJ in ASM#25 outside of variants (Mockingbird and Sable seem to be the love triangle Slott's been promising), I had a hunch we'd get something after Dan's CBR posting storm...as it is, we have to settle for a little in-joke in Miles Morales' book about the marraige's twenty-year longevity in the mainline canon...applied to a reality where Gwen and Miles were married for that duration.:P

A nod is a nod.

WebLurker
03-15-2017, 10:53 PM
Well, while we did'nt get much of anything related to Peter and MJ in ASM#25 outside of variants...

Okay.

...(Mockingbird and Sable seem to be the love triangle Slott's been promising)...

Ick.

I had a hunch we'd get something after Dan's CBR posting storm...as it is, we have to settle for a little in-joke in Miles Morales' book about the marraige's twenty-year longevity in the mainline canon...applied to a reality where Gwen and Miles were married for that duration.:P

A nod is a nod.

I think Dan Slott was just being Dan Slott.

They really want to push Miles and Gwen together. Not sure if that's going to work long-term.

ZariusTwo
03-16-2017, 07:32 AM
Annie proving a handful in the preview for RYV#5

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/articles/exclusive-preview-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vo/1100-156418/

WebLurker
03-16-2017, 11:06 AM
Annie proving a handful in the preview for RYV#5

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/articles/exclusive-preview-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vo/1100-156418/

Can't wait.

WebLurker
03-18-2017, 06:53 PM
Slott's CBR Forums postings that OMD will "never" be undone gotBleeding Cool (https://www.bleedingcool.com/2017/03/18/peter-parkermary-jane-watson-marriage-will-never-ever-return-infinity-says-dan-slott/)'s attention.

ZariusTwo
03-18-2017, 08:27 PM
I was alerting them of those a few days ago, good to see they listened.:D

WebLurker
03-18-2017, 10:56 PM
I was alerting them of those a few days ago, good to see they listened.:D

Oh, that was you? Didn't know that.

ZariusTwo
03-20-2017, 06:15 AM
The newspaper strip fired a shot at Slott and Marvel on Sunday. Peter leaves MJ in charge of Ronan the Accuser's unconscious body so he and Rocket can head into the city to battle the Kree Sentry. Rocket tells Peter his mate is quite a catch and Peter responds with "I never could understand why so many superheroes stay single":lol:

ZariusTwo
03-20-2017, 02:31 PM
http://media.comicbook.com/2017/03/pun2016013-dc21-239270.jpg

And loads more MJ variants on the way in June.

Whenever Dan says "never happening", please just don't use one particula word from that sentence.

WebLurker
03-20-2017, 02:45 PM
http://media.comicbook.com/2017/03/pun2016013-dc21-239270.jpg

And loads more MJ variants on the way in June.

Whenever Dan says "never happening", please just don't use one particula word from that sentence.

Saw it (there's also another one with MJ as X-23, with a claw-scratching of her and Peter's name in a heart -- with Spidey himself in the background).

Wonder how the acolytes will explain stuff like this.

ZariusTwo
03-21-2017, 01:13 PM
Full Marvel June Solicits

http://www.newsarama.com/33666-marvel-comics-june-2017-solicitations.html

https://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275673/5761415-asmrenew2016008-cov.jpg

Hmm...interesting. While Conway has said in the past Peter and MJ will have disagreements but will always emerge from their troubles as a unified whole...I can see maybe Annie coming out of this with Mommy issues, Venom kidnapped her in the original mini-series and it gave her nightmares for eight years. Not sure if she had the same experience in this reality.

WebLurker
03-21-2017, 07:16 PM
Hmm...interesting. While Conway has said in the past Peter and MJ will have disagreements but will always emerge from their troubles as a unified whole...I can see maybe Annie coming out of this with Mommy issues, Venom kidnapped her in the original mini-series and it gave her nightmares for eight years. Not sure if she had the same experience in this reality.

If Venom's alive here, I doubt the miniseries incident with him happened, although I could be wrong.

The story looks interesting, but I'm a little worried that the circumstances that get MJ with Venom could make her look bad (like she chose to use it despite knowing what a bad idea it was or something). So, I hope it's good and I think Conway has a fair chance of making it work based on the series so far.

The cover artwork is good, if nothing else.

ZariusTwo
03-22-2017, 11:45 AM
Had a lot of fun with RYV.

Peter doesn't like the Spider-Fam song, which we know in our own world as the Spider-Pig song from The Simpsons Movie.

MJ and Peter are confirmed to be in their thirties, and Harry is definitely dead.

Betty's getting a lot to do, and boy howdy Normie gets more like his supreme schemer granddaddy every issue. Looking forward to his long game, and I hope RYV last as long as it takes to tell it.

Letters page was good too..with the assistant editor letting us know what a joy it is to work on a book with the marriage. What was that Slott said about the interns of tomorrow not being interested in the marriage today? Yeah, more bunkem, I bet he reads these things in full before they come out and goes off and says the exact bloody opposite to rile fans up

WebLurker
03-22-2017, 04:54 PM
Had a lot of fun with RYV.

Peter doesn't like the Spider-Fam song, which we know in our own world as the Spider-Pig song from The Simpsons Movie.

Huh?

MJ and Peter are confirmed to be in their thirties, and Harry is definitely dead.

Glad that some of that stuff was nailed down, esp. what had happened to Harry and a start at addressing why Normie was in charge of the company.

Betty's getting a lot to do, and boy howdy Normie gets more like his supreme schemer granddaddy every issue. Looking forward to his long game, and I hope RYV last as long as it takes to tell it.

Yeah, should be interesting. Worst case scenario (if RYV gets axed before it's time), do you think it'd be better to have a quick wrap-up to the "Project G" story to fit it within the scope of the series, or just leave the whole series as incomplete without risking making a botch job of changing gears too late.

Letters page was good too..with the assistant editor letting us know what a joy it is to work on a book with the marriage. What was that Slott said about the interns of tomorrow not being interested in the marriage today? Yeah, more bunkem, I bet he reads these things in full before they come out and goes off and says the exact bloody opposite to rile fans up

I think "no one" is interested (and that "everyone" wanted the marriage gone) is just hyperbole; probably best to read it as Slott doesn't think anyone calling the shots for 616 is interested in a reinstatement and doesn't see that changing. Either way, it's really not his or our call.

Liked the issue overall, although I'm reminded of why I like decompressed comics; the story seemed to move too quickly. Did like that the seemingly one-off story ties into bigger stuff and wasn't just "filler." Also like that the replacement artist managed to capture the look and style that Stegman set with the first four issues.

ZariusTwo
03-22-2017, 05:19 PM
Yeah, should be interesting. Worst case scenario (if RYV gets axed before it's time), do you think it'd be better to have a quick wrap-up to the "Project G" story to fit it within the scope of the series, or just leave the whole series as incomplete without risking making a botch job of changing gears too late

Marvel do hate to leave loose ends in doomed comics, they always try to give something closure. I could see maybe an abrupt two-part wrap-up if it ever gets axed.

But it's best we don't speculate on RYV's prospects just yet. I want to really savor what we have right now.

WebLurker
03-22-2017, 09:11 PM
Marvel do hate to leave loose ends in doomed comics, they always try to give something closure. I could see maybe an abrupt two-part wrap-up if it ever gets axed.

But it's best we don't speculate on RYV's prospects just yet. I want to really savor what we have right now.

I think I'd prefer closure (at least what we have would be something of a complete story in and of itself), but fair enough to not worry about how it'll end when it's still tracking to stay around for awhile.

ZariusTwo
03-29-2017, 04:44 AM
I read on CBR that Joe Quesada and Stan Lee are going to be holding a special live Cup O'Joe panel on April 14th in Beverly Hills.

ZariusTwo
04-01-2017, 02:53 PM
Really pleased to hear Marvel listed RYV as a success story (alongside Venom) in that retailer summit, even if it hasn't been showing in the sales charts...maybe they're factoring in overall digital sales?

WebLurker
04-01-2017, 07:04 PM
Really pleased to hear Marvel listed RYV as a success story (alongside Venom) in that retailer summit, even if it hasn't been showing in the sales charts...maybe they're factoring in overall digital sales?

Maybe they were only counting the first issue? I got the idea that the sales they were looking at were from a few months ago. Conversely, they could be taking into account that it's an AU title, which are rarely as successful as the main ones, and saying that it was successful for that. (I find that attempting to use sales to judge success is really hard, given so many variables and that confirmation bias to one's previous views is super easy.)

I do know that on the CBR forums, the pro-OMD crowd is marginalizing the success comment, so it'll be interesting to see how it goes forward.

ZariusTwo
04-02-2017, 04:30 AM
I do know that on the CBR forums, the pro-OMD crowd is marginalizing the success comment, so it'll be interesting to see how it goes forward.

Those guys are idiots, I read you schooling them utterly with the overwhelming evidence of support for the Peter/MJ pairing in the medium and alternate universe, if anything proving the s*it they support is the one out of step, and they're acting like a bunch of ostriches about it and reiterating the same points and telling people to "give up", when it seems more like a desperate plea from people who have lost the argument so decisively.

Oh, and give this guy's comic strips a look over, they're pretty funny. (http://robertmacquarrie1.deviantart.com/)

http://img01.deviantart.net/49b4/i/2017/091/3/6/clone_conspiracy_rundown_pt_9_by_robertmacquarrie1-db4b5nm.jpg

ZariusTwo
04-04-2017, 02:44 PM
Jubilee?

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C8liIYeXgAAQj06.jpg

ZariusTwo
04-06-2017, 04:42 AM
So I've seen Slott's latest posts on CBR...shortly after his persistent "this won't happy yadda yadda" responses came up, this dropped...the preview for RYV#6, where the Parker/Watson motto is said to be "family first"

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/articles/exclusive-preview-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vo/1100-156445/

Note how Slott times his responses virtually every time something to do with Peter and MJ crops up either within a day or hours. It's a very noticeable pattern.

ZariusTwo
04-06-2017, 09:35 AM
Oh crap...is Slott seriously getting into a debate about THE BIBLE on CBR?

WebLurker
04-06-2017, 10:09 AM
So I've seen Slott's latest posts on CBR...shortly after his persistent "this won't happy yadda yadda" responses came up, this dropped...the preview for RYV#6, where the Parker/Watson motto is said to be "family first"

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/articles/exclusive-preview-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vo/1100-156445/

Note how Slott times his responses virtually every time something to do with Peter and MJ crops up either within a day or hours. It's a very noticeable pattern.

Funny coincidence, at least. I also find it really interesting that CBR is getting a lot of threads questioning OMD and its philosophy lately.

Oh crap...is Slott seriously getting into a debate about THE BIBLE on CBR?

Yeah, another poster brought that up, basically using it to explain why people of that faith would be offended by OMD (deal with the devil, sanctity of marriage, all that). Personally, having the same religious views myself, I do agree with the point, although, since its fiction, I guess I tend to take more ire with the idea itself and that they wrote a bad story to advance their own agenda.

I'm not really sure I get why Slott wants to get involved in these things. His attitude comes across as "I'm tired of this being dredged up again" and "Why are we still talking about this?". Well, it's a fan forum where all sorts of stuff like this get rehashed all the time and its something that been an ongoing debate for ten years now. He's also not obligated to obey the forum posters and supposedly has the support of the majority. I'm not sure what he gets out of debating people on a subject that no one will compromise on.

ZariusTwo
04-06-2017, 10:40 AM
I'm not sure what he gets out of debating people on a subject that no one will compromise on.

The answer boils down to a repeating question

"Am I bothering you yet?"
"Am I bothering you yet?"
"Am I bothering you yet?"

WebLurker
04-06-2017, 11:22 AM
The answer boils down to a repeating question

"Am I bothering you yet?"
"Am I bothering you yet?"
"Am I bothering you yet?"

Maybe.

I do know that on the thread, in response to his statement that Marvel doesn't want Spider-Man married and that it won't happen, I did ask why, if that was the case, we have the RYV series in the first place and so much of the branding for the franchise supports Spider-Man and Mary Jane as a couple. He didn't reply, for whatever reason.

We also have the preview, for the next RYV issue. Looks like a fun piece with a lot of character moments, the kind of stuff ASM isn't exactly known for there days.

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/articles/exclusive-preview-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vo/1100-156445/

ProphetofGanja
04-06-2017, 11:45 AM
Okay, I'm trying to get some clarification:

So One More Day is that story arc where Spider-Man made a deal with Mephisto, and it changed history to where his marriage to Mary Jane was erased and he didn't remember it?

and the Renew Your Vows series is an alternate timeline where that didn't happen, and now he and MJ have a kid with spider-powers?

Do I have that right?

I haven't read a Spider-Man solo series in a while but in Spider-Man/Deadpool there was a story that lead to Spider-Man starting to feel off, empty inside, and it's implied that he will soon remember what happened with Mephisto (thanks, Wade!).

ZariusTwo
04-06-2017, 12:51 PM
Maybe.

I do know that on the thread, in response to his statement that Marvel doesn't want Spider-Man married and that it won't happen, I did ask why, if that was the case, we have the RYV series in the first place and so much of the branding for the franchise supports Spider-Man and Mary Jane as a couple. He didn't reply, for whatever reason.

Same thing with the newspaper strip, which features Peter and MJ married and is older than RYV, Spider-Girl, and even post-OMD ASM combined

We also have the preview, for the next RYV issue. Looks like a fun piece with a lot of character moments, the kind of stuff ASM isn't exactly known for there days.

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/articles/exclusive-preview-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vo/1100-156445/

I just posted that.

Okay, I'm trying to get some clarification:

So One More Day is that story arc where Spider-Man made a deal with Mephisto, and it changed history to where his marriage to Mary Jane was erased and he didn't remember it?

Neither of them allegedly remember it. JMS hinted MJ did, but Marvel retconned that in OMIT (although OMIT itself may be retconned now)

and the Renew Your Vows series is an alternate timeline where that didn't happen, and now he and MJ have a kid with spider-powers?

Do I have that right?

Civil War didn't happen in this universe, hence no need for OMD

I haven't read a Spider-Man solo series in a while but in Spider-Man/Deadpool there was a story that lead to Spider-Man starting to feel off, empty inside, and it's implied that he will soon remember what happened with Mephisto (thanks, Wade!).

We don't know where that storyline is leading. Marvel have been deathly quiet or misleading on that matter and it's been up to the fans to decipher the clues from statements, hyperbole, clues in ASM and other comics. I personally beleive there will be a resolution to OMD soon and possibly RYV will be revealed as having more to do with the original Parkers than we think. It would be very easy for Marvel to emulate what DC have done with Superman and his family.

WebLurker
04-06-2017, 01:57 PM
Okay, I'm trying to get some clarification:

So One More Day is that story arc where Spider-Man made a deal with Mephisto, and it changed history to where his marriage to Mary Jane was erased and he didn't remember it?

and the Renew Your Vows series is an alternate timeline where that didn't happen, and now he and MJ have a kid with spider-powers?

Do I have that right?

You got it right. It does appear though, that the RYV timeline diverged from 616 a long time before OMD came into play though, so it's not like: "In this series, the Parkers said no to Mephisto and life continued on," more like an alternate take on the married years period.

I haven't read a Spider-Man solo series in a while but in Spider-Man/Deadpool there was a story that lead to Spider-Man starting to feel off, empty inside, and it's implied that he will soon remember what happened with Mephisto (thanks, Wade!).

Heard about that. It will be interesting to see where that goes.

ZariusTwo
04-08-2017, 01:24 PM
Noticed Slott was on a substantially ruder rampage on CBR over the last 24 hours...and he even admits it's because he turned in all of his homework to the teachers and was too lazy to get some half-way decent exercise.:lol:

And in keeping with the pattern of only doing this when news of MJ springs up, it was then reported that FCBD titles will be plugged on Good Morning America.

WebLurker
04-09-2017, 12:11 AM
Noticed Slott was on a substantially ruder rampage on CBR over the last 24 hours...and he even admits it's because he turned in all of his homework to the teachers and was too lazy to get some half-way decent exercise.:lol:

Yeah, I was there. Same old same old.

And in keeping with the pattern of only doing this when news of MJ springs up, it was then reported that FCBD titles will be plugged on Good Morning America.

Could be. It's also very interesting that there's a lot of chatter about OMD right now; you got a thread about whether OMD was good or not, whether Spider-Man being married was good or not, there's even a thread about whether Slott understands Spider-Man. Funny happenstances all around.

ZariusTwo
04-09-2017, 04:42 AM
Could be. It's also very interesting that there's a lot of chatter about OMD right now; you got a thread about whether OMD was good or not, whether Spider-Man being married was good or not, there's even a thread about whether Slott understands Spider-Man. Funny happenstances all around.

It's the anniversary of when this all started, and next year marks ten years of when Slott started on the title. Expect more of this.

ZariusTwo
04-09-2017, 07:16 AM
Also over on CBR, Slott finally took to addressing his infamous "Peter's love for MJ is anti-Marvel" comments when someone brought them up to counter-argue. He claims he was misquoted, and now reckons RYV MJ and the MJ he wrote in Spider-Man/Human Torch show she is beautiful on the inside and out.

Curious that he opts to bring up his take on pre-OMD MJ as a good example of what the character ought to be

WebLurker
04-09-2017, 12:34 PM
Also over on CBR, Slott finally took to addressing his infamous "Peter's love for MJ is anti-Marvel" comments when someone brought them up to counter-argue. He claims he was misquoted, and now reckons RYV MJ and the MJ he wrote in Spider-Man/Human Torch show she is beautiful on the inside and out.

Maybe he was misquoted? A broken clock is still right twice a day and all that. While I don't think he's a good Spider-Man writer (or that good a comic writer period), that doesn't mean that he's wrong about everything (he did do right by the characters in RYV, for example).

Curious that he opts to bring up his take on pre-OMD MJ as a good example of what the character ought to be

According to Slott, he writes within Marvel's guidelines; if Spider-Man was married, he'd do that, since he's not, he doesn't. He also claimed that he has no hostility to either iteration. Whether you believe him or not, that his story.

ZariusTwo
04-10-2017, 10:19 AM
RYV did remarkably better in March, and continues to outsell Miles and Spider-Gwen

https://icv2.com/articles/markets/view/37229/top-300-comics-actual-march-2017

WebLurker
04-10-2017, 11:28 AM
RYV did remarkably better in March, and continues to outsell Miles and Spider-Gwen

https://icv2.com/articles/markets/view/37229/top-300-comics-actual-march-2017

Good to see. Hope that means a brighter future for it.

ZariusTwo
04-11-2017, 09:04 AM
Slott on CBR saying he and the company want RYV to succeed and that crossovers are entirely possible. Plus we're getting more MJ variants.

DestronMirage22
04-11-2017, 01:40 PM
RYV did remarkably better in March, and continues to outsell Miles and Spider-Gwen

https://icv2.com/articles/markets/view/37229/top-300-comics-actual-march-2017

As it should be.

ZariusTwo
04-12-2017, 05:08 AM
Renew Your Vows Issue Six is packed with twists and insights into more of how this world works

-We learn from Cyclops that Xavier and the Avengers came up with an alternative to the registration act...self-monitoring of all heroes and mutants. Mary Jane's never even heard of the registration act until now. Cyclops tells her Xavier beleived the act would have led to Civil War, but...well..who knows eh?

-Cyclops is pretty bitter, as Xavier's actions cost him the woman he loved. Jean is now married to Logan and they have a red-headed daughter called Kate, whose codename at the school is "Shine". who Annie takes a liking to.

-Annie argues a bit with Jubilee about her new friend at school.

-Mary Jane stands up to Xavier, not wanting Annie to be taken away from a normal life, which she insists she can provide for her above everyone else. Go Spider-Mom.

-Annie's latest vision is of her father and Wolverine being pummeled by someone with a bit of a spark in her

-Magneto and the brotherhood attacks the school and kill Beast (he also kills Banshee earlier in the comic), before infiltrating the room containing Cerebro. Jubilee is revealed as a traitor!

WebLurker
04-12-2017, 03:10 PM
Renew Your Vows Issue Six is packed with twists and insights into more of how this world works

-We learn from Cyclops that Xavier and the Avengers came up with an alternative to the registration act...self-monitoring of all heroes and mutants. Mary Jane's never even heard of the registration act until now. Cyclops tells her Xavier beleived the act would have led to Civil War, but...well..who knows eh?

-Cyclops is pretty bitter, as Xavier's actions cost him the woman he loved. Jean is now married to Logan and they have a red-headed daughter called Kate, whose codename at the school is "Shine". who Annie takes a liking to.

-Annie argues a bit with Jubilee about her new friend at school.

-Mary Jane stands up to Xavier, not wanting Annie to be taken away from a normal life, which she insists she can provide for her above everyone else. Go Spider-Mom.

-Annie's latest vision is of her father and Wolverine being pummeled by someone with a bit of a spark in her

-Magneto and the brotherhood attacks the school and kill Beast (he also kills Banshee earlier in the comic), before infiltrating the room containing Cerebro. Jubilee is revealed as a traitor!

Liked the issue overall. In regards to spoilers:

The question of whether it'd be better for the Parkers to put Annie in superhero boarding school or a closer semblance of a normal life is an interesting question that I like the idea of exploring.

It's nice to get a little more info, like how Civil War didn't happen. I gathered on some message boards that the idea of Wolverine and Jean Grey being married wasn't a popular idea, so I wonder what the reaction will be (I was indifferent to it, but being lukewarm to the traditional X-Men love stories in the movies and gravitating more to the less conventional ones in the Evolution cartoon, I'm not exactly a purist here).

Did the Brotherhood actually kill Beast? I couldn't tell.

Wonder how readers will react to Jubilee being the turncoat; I've gathered she's a fan favorite?

ZariusTwo
04-12-2017, 03:20 PM
Did the Brotherhood actually kill Beast? I couldn't tell.

I'm only kind of gathering that from the (seemingly) gaping hole in the chest where the blast struck him. I could be wrong. We'll see next issue.

WebLurker
04-12-2017, 06:51 PM
I'm only kind of gathering that from the (seemingly) gaping hole in the chest where the blast struck him. I could be wrong. We'll see next issue.


Forgot about that, took a closer look at the page. We see him getting hit by the blast, but no blood or guts flying or a clear indication that it penetrated the skin (it doesn't look 3-D enough, if that makes any sense). We next see him lying on the ground with the wound smoking, but no clarity if he's dead or just dazed (with a huge bald spot on his front).

When reading it, I assumed that he wasn't dead, but I think it's vague enough that he could've been killed or survived depending on what suites future storytelling, so you could be right. Considering that the issue appears to open with Banshee being killed, it seems that Conway is writing with the idea that supporting characters do not have plot armor.

ZariusTwo
04-13-2017, 04:17 AM
Yeah, I remember Claremont's X-Men Forever saw him kill off Iron Man early on in the issue's run too

I honestly hate it when AU titles take liberties like that, just to reenforce "hey, this is an AU", it does'nt help most Marvel What Ifs tend to be bloodbaths

ZariusTwo
04-18-2017, 12:31 PM
Cover for July's RYV

https://static2.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275673/5809754-6434008110-14925.jpg

And that month's Spidey/Deadpool (hur hur)

https://static4.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275673/5809752-4245798585-14925.jpg

ZariusTwo
04-18-2017, 12:57 PM
Ryan Stegman will now be co-writing the comic, starting with issue 9

https://twitter.com/RyanStegman/status/854380829170057216

WebLurker
04-18-2017, 08:07 PM
Cover for July's RYV

https://static2.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275673/5809754-6434008110-14925.jpg

Like that cover.

And that month's Spidey/Deadpool (hur hur)

https://static4.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275673/5809752-4245798585-14925.jpg

Too soon.


Ryan Stegman will now be co-writing the comic, starting with issue 9

https://twitter.com/RyanStegman/status/854380829170057216

Hope that goes well.

ZariusTwo
04-27-2017, 12:18 PM
Read over on Comicvine that Chip Zradsky revealed he's writing mainline Peter and MJ like they're best friends again, eroding all the bitter tension they've had under Slott's run

I suppose it's something anyway...

ZariusTwo
04-28-2017, 12:20 PM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C-XydrdWsAE1TwE.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C-XOgaOWAAAOPla.jpg

Couple of new images

WebLurker
04-28-2017, 02:05 PM
Read over on Comicvine that Chip Zradsky revealed he's writing mainline Peter and MJ like they're best friends again, eroding all the bitter tension they've had under Slott's run

I suppose it's something anyway...

That might be the best case scenario we're going to get for 616 for the time being.

ZariusTwo
04-28-2017, 03:55 PM
It's got me thinking about what Slott said on CBR about Marvel letting status quoes come back instantaneously, so far we've had

-Eddie and the Symbiote back together all in one issue
-Peter and MJ back on good terms all in a few panels of a back-up story


Hope for instantaneous Felicia face turn?

ZariusTwo
04-30-2017, 01:00 PM
CBR with a list of Peter and MJ's steamier moments

http://www.cbr.com/sensational-spider-mans-cheekiest-bedroom-antics/

ZariusTwo
05-02-2017, 11:32 AM
'https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C-1CUNUXsAA9UKq.jpg

Found it on CBR

ProphetofGanja
05-02-2017, 11:43 AM
So, this is that "event" they've been hyping up with all the variant covers featuring MJ and/or symbiotes?

ZariusTwo
05-02-2017, 03:18 PM
So, this is that "event" they've been hyping up with all the variant covers featuring MJ and/or symbiotes?

It's looking like that, though I don't think it'll tie in to the other Venomverse event that will happen in the core books this summer, it'll just be it's own thing.

ProphetofGanja
05-02-2017, 05:30 PM
It's looking like that, though I don't think it'll tie in to the other Venomverse event that will happen in the core books this summer, it'll just be it's own thing.

Ah that's right, because RYV is an offshoot universe or parallel dimension or whatever you want to call it, yes?

ZariusTwo
05-03-2017, 10:00 AM
Ah that's right, because RYV is an offshoot universe or parallel dimension or whatever you want to call it, yes?

Yes, it's an alternate reality in appearance (which might be linked to the core stuff)

myconius
05-03-2017, 07:13 PM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C-1CUNUXsAA9UKq.jpg

Found it on CBR

that's actually very cool!

ZariusTwo
05-04-2017, 12:32 PM
Preview of Issue 7

http://13thdimension.com/exclusive-preview-spider-man-renew-your-vows-7/

ZariusTwo
05-10-2017, 02:23 PM
Not a bad issue, but very rushed, and the cover lied, Peter and Magneto don't have a bloody scrap at all, and MJ saves the day with one or two punches. Weak.

Seemed more intent on telling an X-Men story than a Spider-Family story, although Annie had some choice words for Jubilee throughout.

At least the final page revealed more about how Harry's marriage went down in this universe...Liz divorced him rather than wait for him to die on her in the original universe, and she has the Venom symbiote.

WebLurker
05-10-2017, 03:36 PM
Not a bad issue, but very rushed, and the cover lied, Peter and Magneto don't have a bloody scrap at all, and MJ saves the day with one or two punches. Weak.

I've come to the conclusion that covers always lie except when the don't. Also, factor in variants that have nothing to do with the issue in question, I don't see a need to knock the issue over it.

However, yeah, the conclusion was rushed. I think it needed one or more issues to have the space it needs. Hopefully the series won't suffer too much because of it (I've gathered that sales aren't exactly improving that much).

Seemed more intent on telling an X-Men story than a Spider-Family story, although Annie had some choice words for Jubilee throughout.

I guess I like the idea that Jubilee wasn't beyond redemption, but I think there needed more story for it to work like it should've.

I was actually kind of surprised that, rather than saying no then and there, the Parkers were going to think it over on enrolling Annie. I guess I assumed that, since it wouldn't work with the comics' premise, it would be closed off here. Wonder if it'll come back again?

At least the final page revealed more about how Harry's marriage went down in this universe...Liz divorced him rather than wait for him to die on her in the original universe, and she has the Venom symbiote.

I really like how questions like this are getting answered. Also, I think the cliffhanger sold me on the Venom story.

My assessment is that I liked it, but it's the weakest installment in the series so far (counting both the original mini and the ongoing).

ZariusTwo
05-11-2017, 07:26 AM
Some positive RYV sales spin here from CBR's Confuzzled

http://community.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?95240-Spider-Man-Sales-For-April-2017/page9

Someone had posted the shipping numbers of RYV #2-3 for the month and right then the amount of copies shipped were lower than that for ASM. But its number of copies actually sold against number of copies shipped percentage was much higher than that of most Marvel titles, and it was selling more than many other titles that had more copies being shipped.

Of course there were people who fit into the overlap between marriage fans and Current ASM non-fans hoping RYV beats out ASM but even then a lot of marriage fans pointed out that it is very unlikely for an AU title to beat a main universe book, especially one that is technically still the company flagship title. Still, RYV is one of the best selling AU Marvel titles ever not from the Ultimate line in its prime.

WebLurker
05-11-2017, 10:44 AM
Some positive RYV sales spin here from CBR's Confuzzled

http://community.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?95240-Spider-Man-Sales-For-April-2017/page9

That's good to hear; I remember seeing articles that sales for number 6 (the first X-Men crossover) had unexpectedly dropped. Now, I guess it could've started stronger and still dropped, but still.

ZariusTwo
05-11-2017, 12:53 PM
That's good to hear; I remember seeing articles that sales for number 6 (the first X-Men crossover) had unexpectedly dropped. Now, I guess it could've started stronger and still dropped, but still.

Yeah, maybe it did better digitally? We never see estimates for those, I imagine it's that sort of thing that's keeping Spider-Gwen in buisness, and maybe even Silver Surfer too (I also reckon it'd have been axed long ago if Slott wasn't doing so well with ASM)

ZariusTwo
05-24-2017, 09:59 AM
So August's issue is written soley by Stegman with Nate Stockman on art...interesting. Also, we get more on Normie's backstory.

Pity the VenoMJ saga seems to be pretty short

ZariusTwo
05-30-2017, 12:21 PM
RYV Mary Jane will participate in Venomverse

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2017/05/30/venomverse-new-event-will-spread-symbiote-many-fan-favorite-characters/

https://cbr1.imgix.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/VENOMVERSE-by-Clayton-Crain.jpg?auto=format&cs=tinysrgb&q=20&w=864&h=265&fit=crop

ProphetofGanja
05-30-2017, 12:49 PM
Oh wow, look, another event that hijacks multiple series and forces readers to pick up extra books

MsMarvelDuckie
06-03-2017, 06:03 PM
Who's the blue one? And do we know whatever happened to Toxin?

ToTheNines
06-03-2017, 06:10 PM
Oh wow, look, another event that hijacks multiple series and forces readers to pick up extra books

Wasn't there a Marvel press release saying they were taking, at least, a two year breakf from "Events" after Secret Wars?

ZariusTwo
06-04-2017, 02:41 PM
Wasn't there a Marvel press release saying they were taking, at least, a two year breakf from "Events" after Secret Wars?

I think they meant line-wide events, not events specifically designed for certain franchises like this one is.

WebLurker
06-05-2017, 11:07 AM
Oh wow, look, another event that hijacks multiple series and forces readers to pick up extra books

Well, is MJ being involved mean that she'll actually be taking a vacation from the RYV series to appear in another event or is it just referring to the upcoming RYV story connecting to Venom-verse somehow?

Even if it's the former, there are ways that it could be handled without hijacking the main series (like it being written to be extra optional reading, the comics being written so that it takes place between the regular RYV issues instead of concurrent with them, etc.)

(I will agree though that I'm not sure I really want RYV feeding into an event just yet, but there's a chance that it won't suffer for it.)

ZariusTwo
06-05-2017, 12:25 PM
Well, is MJ being involved mean that she'll actually be taking a vacation from the RYV series to appear in another event or is it just referring to the upcoming RYV story connecting to Venom-verse somehow?

Even if it's the former, there are ways that it could be handled without hijacking the main series (like it being written to be extra optional reading, the comics being written so that it takes place between the regular RYV issues instead of concurrent with them, etc.)

(I will agree though that I'm not sure I really want RYV feeding into an event just yet, but there's a chance that it won't suffer for it.)

I sort of think this is why Conway is not writing RYV in August, he'll be writing the RYV story for one of the Venomverse tie-in comics while Stegman's issue is what Peter and Annie get up in the meantime back on their homeworld

WebLurker
06-06-2017, 01:16 PM
I sort of think this is why Conway is not writing RYV in August, he'll be writing the RYV story for one of the Venomverse tie-in comics while Stegman's issue is what Peter and Annie get up in the meantime back on their homeworld

Maybe. I'll have to keep my ears open about the Venom-verse solicits to see if that happens.

Stegman's issue actually seems to be an origin story for Normie Osborn, but it could be very well designed as a way to do a story that will allow Venom-verse to "interrupt" the series without causing reading problems.

ZariusTwo
06-07-2017, 07:07 AM
This week is the thirtieth wedding anniversary of Peter and MJ:D

ZariusTwo
06-15-2017, 09:57 AM
The VenoMJ arc got off to a reasonable, if slightly rushed, start. MJ's reasons for donning the suit made sense, and I like that we got some insight into how she views her character flaws, believing that she empties the tank in the relationship and Peter has to fill it up. I wonder if something will come out of the ''take a break'' suggestion from her friend, with her taking time away from her family to participate in Venomverse?

Peter still has a very black-and-white view of good and evil that will no doubt be challenged when he discovers what the fate of those men at sea were who were attacked by MJ. MJ is a mental prisoner of the symbiote, so it will be interesting how she tries to reconcile with it over the coming months, as well as hope that Peter does'nt find ways to resent her one morning, as there's an even more believable reason for that now than there ever was.

WebLurker
06-15-2017, 11:50 PM
I liked the first piece of the Venom story. I was a little worried about how getting MJ with the suit would work, but I think it felt organic to the story and not "do it because the plot demands it."

It did feel on the rushed side, so I hope that the second half works and doesn't abruptly end to fit a longer story into two issues, like the X-Men one did.

WebLurker
06-19-2017, 08:36 PM
Apparently last month's RYV issue didn't crack the top 100 comics for preorders.

A lot of speculation about this on the CBR forums on what happened and what that might mean for the future of the series.

Plenty of pro-OMD/Dan Slott users expressing the opinion that this probably means that married Spider-Man is not viable for an ongoing series.

Suppose we'll have to see what happens down the road (the issue did outsell Spider-Gwen a bit apparently, if one doesn't count the latter's being double-shipped.)

ZariusTwo
06-20-2017, 03:55 AM
Apparently last month's RYV issue didn't crack the top 100 comics for preorders.

A lot of speculation about this on the CBR forums on what happened and what that might mean for the future of the series.

Plenty of pro-OMD/Dan Slott users expressing the opinion that this probably means that married Spider-Man is not viable for an ongoing series.

Suppose we'll have to see what happens down the road (the issue did outsell Spider-Gwen a bit apparently, if one doesn't count the latter's being double-shipped.)

On the other hand, the Comicron estimates indicate the sales aren't as drastically bad as the lack of placement in the top one hundred indicates. It wasn't that far down actually, it was only two numbers below one hundred in the chart. If it weren't for new number ones filling up certain spots, it'd have been higher in my estimation.

It also wasn't a healthy month for any of the Spider-Titles. Once again, Slott's ASM didn't even crack the top twenty, and the book is now selling at it's worst rate since the launch after Superior.

Those pro-OMD fans are of course being selective with their bias...when the original Renew Your Vows series came out, it was marketed and hyped as ''meaning something'', prioritized as THE essential Spider-Man book of the summer, and had the A-list writer of the current book penning the tale, and the result was the biggest success story of Secret Wars

ZariusTwo
06-20-2017, 03:57 PM
Lots of Renew Your Vows news today

The September solicitation reveals that they are tying up the current plot threads, with Normie Osborn's big master-plan revealed as a Mecha-Goblin, MJ is back to being Spinerett, and Ryan Stegman is again credited as the sole writer. Art chores are now by Bryan Level.

Level also confirmed that a twelfth issue will follow in October with him on art duties, which means Renew Your Vows has made it to a full year of publication thus far.

MsMarvelDuckie
06-20-2017, 05:25 PM
Glad to hear it! Hope it continues, since this series may be my only hope of seeing the "REAL" Spidey that I've come to know and love. I haven't picked up any of the series yet but it is on my list of "must reads". Might have to start getting the trades since I'm in a dry spell comic-wise while I wait for the next IDW TMNT trades to come out. (I don't do preorders as I never know from one month to the next if I might need to cancel an order due to needing the funds elsewhere.)

WebLurker
06-20-2017, 11:43 PM
On the other hand, the Comicron estimates indicate the sales aren't as drastically bad as the lack of placement in the top one hundred indicates. It wasn't that far down actually, it was only two numbers below one hundred in the chart. If it weren't for new number ones filling up certain spots, it'd have been higher in my estimation.

I did see that it was a couple spots down after my previous post. Yea?

It also wasn't a healthy month for any of the Spider-Titles. Once again, Slott's ASM didn't even crack the top twenty, and the book is now selling at it's worst rate since the launch after Superior.

First I've heard of it.

Those pro-OMD fans are of course being selective with their bias...when the original Renew Your Vows series came out, it was marketed and hyped as ''meaning something'', prioritized as THE essential Spider-Man book of the summer, and had the A-list writer of the current book penning the tale, and the result was the biggest success story of Secret Wars

Well, the mini also didn't have to compete with ASM (kind of forcing a "real" vs "non-canon" situation, so to speak). There are differences between the mini and the ongoing as well. So, I think it's fair to say that just because the mini sold well doesn't mean by default that the ongoing will also sell well.

On the other hand, I don't think the ongoing has gotten much publicity in comparison to the mini, which goodness knows how that changes stuff.

The September solicitation reveals that they are tying up the current plot threads, with Normie Osborn's big master-plan revealed as a Mecha-Goblin, MJ is back to being Spinerett, and Ryan Stegman is again credited as the sole writer. Art chores are now by Bryan Level.

Level also confirmed that a twelfth issue will follow in October with him on art duties, which means Renew Your Vows has made it to a full year of publication thus far.

Really hope that just means that they're just wrapping up the story and not the series is being canceled.

Wonder if Conway is leaving the series or is just on hiatus.

Glad to hear it! Hope it continues, since this series may be my only hope of seeing the "REAL" Spidey that I've come to know and love. I haven't picked up any of the series yet but it is on my list of "must reads". Might have to start getting the trades since I'm in a dry spell comic-wise while I wait for the next IDW TMNT trades to come out. (I don't do preorders as I never know from one month to the next if I might need to cancel an order due to needing the funds elsewhere.)

Not counting the trade for the original mini, the first RYV ongoing trade paperback is coming out June 27 and will have Issues #1 -5. Vol. 2 is set for December 12 and contains Issue #6 - 10. (They're sixteen bucks cover price but you can pre-order for around ten on Amazon.)

ZariusTwo
06-21-2017, 09:49 AM
Really hope that just means that they're just wrapping up the story and not the series is being canceled.


I'm worried that this may be it too, as there's currently speculation that Marvel want to launch a new Spider-Man title by Nick Spencer. If that comes true, then it's possible RYV ties up in October and the new title takes it's spot the following month in November.

WebLurker
06-22-2017, 12:14 AM
I'm worried that this may be it too, as there's currently speculation that Marvel want to launch a new Spider-Man title by Nick Spencer. If that comes true, then it's possible RYV ties up in October and the new title takes it's spot the following month in November.

Well, there's no concrete info one way or the other and we'll find out soon enough when the solicits catch up (they're always several months in advance). No point in worrying over something we don't even know will happen and don't have any control over.

ZariusTwo
06-22-2017, 11:29 AM
in what I hope is a reversal of fortunes, The Venomized MJ saga kick-off sold out in stores and will go to a second printing. Other sell-outs going to second printings include Darth Vader, Old Man Logan, The Defenders, Weapon X, and X-Men Blue and Gold

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2017/06/22/marvel-second-prints-mary-jane-venom-defenders-ultimate-wolverine-appearances/

ZariusTwo
06-23-2017, 03:44 AM
Stegman shared some new art on his Twitter...looks like MJ is still in her Venom suit, and you can spot the Mecha-Goblin behind her, so this might be the cover to Issue Twelve. In Spidey's half, you can make out Normie.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DC9jjNnU0AAUnkF.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DC92rYVXUAA584s.jpg

Since MJ is in her Spinerette costume in Issue Eleven's cover, it's possible she hasn't told Peter and Annie about her symbiote and still goes out on patrol with them in her costume, and this battle forces her to use the symbiote in front of them

ZariusTwo
06-23-2017, 09:43 AM
Annie ages up as Renew Your Vows is announced as the first Spider-Book of the line

https://cdn.bleedingcool.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/asmrenewvows-1004369.jpg

WebLurker
06-23-2017, 01:29 PM
Annie ages up as Renew Your Vows is announced as the first Spider-Book of the line

https://cdn.bleedingcool.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/asmrenewvows-1004369.jpg

Nice cover. Wonder if they really are going to have the character be older in the stories, or if it's just a cover thing for the sake of the design?

ZariusTwo
06-23-2017, 02:11 PM
Nice cover. Wonder if they really are going to have the character be older in the stories, or if it's just a cover thing for the sake of the design?

Three possibilites

-Pointless variant [a lot of the other Legacy covers seem to be this too]
-The title is tying up loose ends, this is the final issue, and it's a flash-forward
-The title is undergoing a time skip and we'll see an older, more experianced Spider-Family.

ZariusTwo
06-24-2017, 02:21 PM
Ryan Stegman confirms that Adult Annie is not just a variant gimmick and that more will be revealed at San Diego. Looks like Renew Your Vows is safe for the long term, with Ryan now definitely the main plotter

https://twitter.com/RyanStegman/status/878431633929646081

WebLurker
06-26-2017, 09:21 PM
Ryan Stegman confirms that Adult Annie is not just a variant gimmick and that more will be revealed at San Diego. Looks like Renew Your Vows is safe for the long term, with Ryan now definitely the main plotter

https://twitter.com/RyanStegman/status/878431633929646081

Good to hear that the series is going on. Not so sure if there's been confirmation that the cover isn't just a gimmick; deferring an explanation allows any possibility to be plausible (from gimmick to plot point). But I guess we'll know for sure soon enough.

ZariusTwo
06-27-2017, 03:33 AM
Good to hear that the series is going on. Not so sure if there's been confirmation that the cover isn't just a gimmick; deferring an explanation allows any possibility to be plausible (from gimmick to plot point). But I guess we'll know for sure soon enough.

Why would they tease something for comiccon about it if it were a gimmick? Come on.

ZariusTwo
06-29-2017, 11:18 AM
http://pre04.deviantart.net/ae03/th/pre/i/2017/179/4/9/failing_a_spot_check_by_robertmacquarrie1-dbeeg8s.jpg

ZariusTwo
06-29-2017, 03:32 PM
Stegman posts a partial preview image from RYV [possibly the cover to Issue Twelve]

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DDgffNVXYAMp2Wi.jpg

Also, issue nine of RYV is amongst the titles moving the needle on pre-orders

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2017/06/29/astonishing-x-men-batman-and-generation-gone-top-advance-reorders/

ZariusTwo
07-01-2017, 02:46 AM
So we're going to have a time skip following the current storylines...interesting. I know some have been taking issue with this over on CBR and Comicvine, but I really think this change, while admittedly abrupt, helps ease criticisms of how young Annie is to be fighting crime, and maybe also shows how strong Peter and MJ's bond is that they can afford to skip another decade or so with them having adventures as a stable unit to get to the heavier stuff,

WebLurker
07-01-2017, 11:11 AM
Also, issue nine of RYV is amongst the titles moving the needle on pre-orders

Good to hear.

So we're going to have a time skip following the current storylines...interesting. I know some have been taking issue with this over on CBR and Comicvine, but I really think this change, while admittedly abrupt, helps ease criticisms of how young Annie is to be fighting crime, and maybe also shows how strong Peter and MJ's bond is that they can afford to skip another decade or so with them having adventures as a stable unit to get to the heavier stuff,

Could be, although I kind of wish that the series had built up to the new timeframe rather than jumping ahead.

ZariusTwo
07-01-2017, 11:34 AM
Could be, although I kind of wish that the series had built up to the new timeframe rather than jumping ahead.

Me too. We only ever had one issue of Annie's early school life, now she'll be close to graduation.

WebLurker
07-01-2017, 11:20 PM
Me too. We only ever had one issue of Annie's early school life, now she'll be close to graduation.

Yeah, I was really curious about what they'd be doing with the Stephanie Kim character.

ZariusTwo
07-19-2017, 04:03 PM
Another rushed issue. but I liked that Peter was more of a strategist here, and plays the role of MJ's emotional anchor helping her to overcome the symbiote and bring it to order.

And apparently the continuity of Dan Slott's RYV mini series is still in play here after all, with Peter finally revealed to have still killed Eddie Brock, with the symbiote out for revenge.

ZariusTwo
07-22-2017, 06:04 AM
As was suspected for a time, Gerry Conway has indeed left the book, with Ryan now solo writer

ZariusTwo
07-28-2017, 05:07 AM
The listing for the third volume of the RYV trades guarantees a further three issues for the book after November.

ZariusTwo
08-09-2017, 05:25 AM
More WIP art from Stegman

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DGvu_eMXgAAvgQl.jpg

ZariusTwo
08-11-2017, 05:16 AM
Renew Your Vows#10 preview, which is out next week. First issue with Stegman as solo writer.

http://www.cbr.com/amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-10/

Peter and Annie tackle Lizard

(hmm...wonder what happened to Weblurker? He hasn't posted here in over a month)

WebLurker
08-13-2017, 10:23 PM
(hmm...wonder what happened to Weblurker? He hasn't posted here in over a month)

I'm still here, just been elsewhere a lot lately (the fact that I've haven't been watching TMNT much lately and am behind on that hasn't helped).

The tenth issue looks interesting, although I'm not sure I'm quite as eager for an Oscorp-centric story as I was for, say, the Venom story.

And yea that we've getting at least three trade paperbacks worth of material!

ZariusTwo
08-14-2017, 05:06 AM
Good to hear from you again. I notice you're still active a lot on CBR.

I'm sure you've heard also RYV was in 90th place on the top 100 last month. The lowest ranked Spider-Title in that particular part of the chart, but still performing better than Scarlet Spider and Spider-Gwen, which failed to reach the top 100 at all.

WebLurker
08-15-2017, 09:28 AM
Good to hear from you again.

Thanks.

I notice you're still active a lot on CBR.

Yeah, that I am.

I'm sure you've heard also RYV was in 90th place on the top 100 last month.

Yep.

The lowest ranked Spider-Title in that particular part of the chart, but still performing better than Scarlet Spider and Spider-Gwen, which failed to reach the top 100 at all.

Well, top 100 is still top 100. The fact that an AU title like this is generally doing that well is good enough news, IMHO.

ZariusTwo
08-16-2017, 02:16 PM
Renew Your Vows#10

Mary Jane is absent from the present day portions of the story due to a doctor's appointment, but appears in the flashbacks to Normie's childhood, and Harry's death from Spectacular Spider-Man#200 still happened in this title's continuity.

Oscorp is targeted by the Lizard family, Curt and Billy. Billy transformed himself into a Lizard like his dad and they are looking to use Regent tech to cure Billy of his condition.

Peter, Annie, and an armed Normie stop them, but Normie blames Peter for ruining his birthday and vows revenge

ZariusTwo
08-18-2017, 12:56 PM
In addition to an eight year time skip, Renew Your Vows is getting a brand new creative team this November, writer Jody Houser (DC Young Animal) and IDW Transformers artist Nick Roche

https://img.purch.com/h/1400/aHR0cDovL3d3dy5uZXdzYXJhbWEuY29tL2ltYWdlcy9pLzAwMC 8yMDUvOTE2L29yaWdpbmFsL0FTTVJFTkVXMjAxNjAxM19GT0Nf Unlhbl9TdGVnbWFuLmpwZz8xNTAzMDY0OTIx

(yeah. the cover is still by Stegman)

https://www.newsarama.com/36007-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-13-jumps-to-annie-s-teenage-years-in-marvel-legacy.html

WebLurker
08-19-2017, 04:01 PM
Really liked the tenth issue. Was not expecting that much, given that the Osborn story wasn't exactly grabbing me that much, but I think it worked well and really set up another Spider-Man'/Green Goblin clash in the right way; giving everyone a personal stake in it all.

In addition to an eight year time skip, Renew Your Vows is getting a brand new creative team this November, writer Jody Houser (DC Young Animal) and IDW Transformers artist Nick Roche

https://img.purch.com/h/1400/aHR0cDovL3d3dy5uZXdzYXJhbWEuY29tL2ltYWdlcy9pLzAwMC 8yMDUvOTE2L29yaWdpbmFsL0FTTVJFTkVXMjAxNjAxM19GT0Nf Unlhbl9TdGVnbWFuLmpwZz8xNTAzMDY0OTIx

(yeah. the cover is still by Stegman)

https://www.newsarama.com/36007-amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-13-jumps-to-annie-s-teenage-years-in-marvel-legacy.html

Heard of that. Sorry to see that Stegman and Conway are leaving, as I really liked their work. Hope the new team brings good stuff to the table.

ZariusTwo
08-22-2017, 03:48 PM
More teen Annie

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DH2d3shXsAEA7t2.jpg

ZariusTwo
09-11-2017, 12:42 PM
Stegman wrapping up his run as writer today

https://twitter.com/RyanStegman/status/907261954183647233/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fcomicvine.gamespot.com%2Fspi der-man%2F4005-1443%2Fforums%2Fspider-man-comics-discussion-739993%2F%3Fpage%3D614

ZariusTwo
09-14-2017, 05:08 AM
So Peter, MJ and Annie are going to Coney Island in issue fourteen

ZariusTwo
09-20-2017, 02:43 PM
Another cover from Stegman

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DKRiOeeUMAArKOj.jpg

ZariusTwo
10-11-2017, 07:30 AM
Issue 12

In a twist, it's revealed it's Mss. January, not Normie, who is controlling the Mech Goblin. Normie had a change of heart off-panel and got into an argument with January, which led to him being knocked unconscious. I presume it was January that gave the order to wipe out the board of directors in the previous issue as Normie says to MJ and Liz he did not want to commit any more bad deeds, but I guess it's ambiguous enough.

Peter and the X-Men battle the Mech Goblin but they are easily overpowered by the machine, which absorbs their powers. Peter tries to siphon the power with his own Regent tech, but he winds up being completly drained of his own abilities. MJ saves him, but the symbiote is caught in the line of fire and disintegrated, leaving MJ intact, but powerless, and the two smash into the window of a nearby building.

Normie and Annie team up and Annie journeys inside the Mech Goblin to take out it's pumpkin bomb-shaped energy core (this is a bit like the finale of the first season of the 1987 TMNT animated series) and they manage to bring it down. Normie and Annie patch things up and embrace, with Normie giving Peter an orb that contains all of his and the X-Men's stolen powers. MJ webs up her face to conceal her identity after losing the symbiote.

Flash forward to eight years later, and Peter and MJ give Annie her new outfit for her birthday

ZariusTwo
10-25-2017, 04:46 AM
Sheesh, Weblurker really doesn't come here anymore does he? Him and I are virtually the only ones who post in here nowadays


From RYV's new regular artist Nick Roch

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DM57wGwX4AABqoh.jpg

ZariusTwo
10-29-2017, 12:59 PM
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11127/111275673/6121741-5741183677-STL06.jpg

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11127/111275673/6121733-3085085763-STL06.jpg

ZariusTwo
11-30-2017, 03:35 PM
https://s18.postimg.org/egjkmh5wp/ASMRENEW2016014003-col.jpg

I've waited ten years for this:lol:

ZariusTwo
12-16-2017, 03:35 PM
Renew Your Vows was the best selling Spider-Man title of November. Ace.

oldmanwinters
12-16-2017, 03:52 PM
Renew Your Vows was the best selling Spider-Man title of November. Ace.

It deserves it! I've only read the first 10 issues but it's very well done and a fresh concept. Kinda like taking the Spider-man mythos and injecting a little bit of The Incredibles into it.

ZariusTwo
12-17-2017, 08:50 AM
It deserves it! I've only read the first 10 issues but it's very well done and a fresh concept. Kinda like taking the Spider-man mythos and injecting a little bit of The Incredibles into it.

Yeah, it's had it's ups and down a bit, but the Conway/Stegman era was very consistent. If only their stories had time to breath. This is great news for the new creative team of Jodi Houser and Nich Roache.

MsMarvelDuckie
12-21-2017, 03:33 PM
So is it continuing then? I might have to pick it up. I feel like this is the only Spidey book I'd even be interested in anymore.

MikeandRaph87
12-21-2017, 03:39 PM
So is it continuing then? I might have to pick it up. I feel like this is the only Spidey book I'd even be interested in anymore.

Amen to that.

ZariusTwo
12-22-2017, 09:58 AM
Preview of next week's issue

https://www.cbr.com/amazing-spider-man-renew-your-vows-14/

ZariusTwo
01-26-2018, 04:11 PM
Looks like the book could be cancelled:(

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2018/01/26/rumours-marvel-comics-2018/

MikeandRaph87
01-26-2018, 04:14 PM
Looks like the book could be cancelled:(

https://www.bleedingcool.com/2018/01/26/rumours-marvel-comics-2018/
The link did not work, said it was dead. What is it that would cause the best-selling Spider-Man title to stop publication?

ZariusTwo
01-26-2018, 04:17 PM
The link did not work, said it was dead?

It's working for me

And RYV has only ever out sold the main book twice, though it often outsells Spider-Gwen (without a Venom boost) and Miles, so I don't know the reason...unless

1. Marvel really don't want a married Spidey to suceed
2. They're bringing the marriage back to the main book so it is'nt needed anymore

MikeandRaph87
01-26-2018, 04:45 PM
It's working for me

And RYV has only ever out sold the main book twice, though it often outsells Spider-Gwen (without a Venom boost) and Miles, so I don't know the reason...unless
1. Marvel really don't want a married Spidey to suceed
2. They're bringing the marriage back to the main book so it is'nt needed anymore

I switched browsers and it worked. How would the marriage be brought back? It was really foolish to take away something that fans truly appreciate because of a misguided believe of limited story potential.

ZariusTwo
01-27-2018, 06:06 AM
How would the marriage be brought back?.

Some seeds have been planted for a restoration in the Spidey books lately

There was something in ASM back in 2016 where Peter MJ and Regent all experienced a "deja vu" sensation when battling to save Marvel heroes. This was a direct reference to the Parkers fight against the Regent in the original Renew Your Vows series, so this was implying the two versions of Peter and MJ are connected

Mephisto has also been appearing in books such as Spider-Man/Deadpool, and will appear in Scarlet Spider later this year. He's taunted Peter in his dreams, reminding him he was responsible for his ultimate downfall, and the solicits for April say he has had a "years long obsession with the Parker family"

They're building to something.

ZariusTwo
02-01-2018, 04:38 AM
So Mr. Sinister has possession of Annie's DNA..this'll go well.

This book sure loves it's X-Men