View Full Version : Are IDW introducing too many characters?
PizzaPower1985
10-16-2017, 11:13 AM
Okay, so I haven't been on here in ages but have been following IDW TMNT religiously and while I still think Tom Waltz and Co. are an ingenious bunch (this is the best TMNT incarnation IMO) I wonder if by the early 60s in terms of issue #, are there too many characters in the series now?
I personally think the IDW team has done a masterful job at introducing the Mutanimals and the story is still very engaging... but the TMNT may be starting to feel like guest stars in their own book. What do you guys think? Is it just me?
Either way I hope the series continues well past issue #100.
What say you guys?
Not really; in any other comic, it could be an problem. However, Tom and Kevin have done a good job at creating certain groups and story-lines where only certain characters should appear
Utrommaniac
10-16-2017, 11:43 AM
I've heard that description a lot, and I personally disagree. Very strongly in fact. If the Mutanimals were dominating most of the stories, for instance, then that would be a reasonable complaint. But they don't.
I also feel like it really takes time to develop "extra" characters. Kitusne's Big Plan wasn't revealed for six years. The Mutanimals took their time, and it took Hob developing into his own (cat)man for that to happen. And after it might make sense for him to 'disappear' for a while. I even forgot that he used to work for Stockman on some occasions :lol: .
Ch'rell was even introduced last year and still hasn't been barrelled out like the Chekhov's Gunman that he is. It looks like he's set up to come into the story with fire and brimstone, but it's not time for that yet. Because there are other things for the main characters to do.
For all the new characters that come along, they take their time. Because what the turtles are doing is a little more important to the story than what they're doing, even when their paths cross.
PizzaPower1985
10-16-2017, 11:51 AM
^^^
Thanks. I started this thread because I wasn't sure how I felt about the "too many characters" argument. I'd like to see what more folks think too. Let's hope more chime in.
DrSpengler
10-16-2017, 11:57 AM
While IDW has introduced a lot of characters, I think they've managed to balance their use fairly well. It helps that there's never less than 3 titles a month with which to spread them all out, so the expanded cast rotates in and out at a mostly consistent basis.
I don't think that the Turtles are so much guest stars in their own book, I think the matter is more that they're relatively static characters. They can't develop in the same way as original characters or secondary characters like Hob and the Mutanimals, so their personalities and routines can feel a little stale in comparison to some of the more dynamic personalities. But it is a double-edged sword, though.
Even if Viacom allowed the writers to evolve the Turtles past their gimmick or theme song-based personality types, you'd eventually end up with characters that were either unrecognizable as who they are, or boring because they've overcome the flaws that made them colorful. It's a tightrope walk that eventually hits any long-running licensed comic and is ultimately the reason why original or supporting characters are so important; they get to do the developing that the core characters can't.
To be critical, though, I think that maybe the Turtles have been too reactionary, lately. Bad stuff finds them and they react to it; they don't display a lot of initiative. Admittedly, this goes back to the Mirage comic and tends to be how they're most commonly portrayed, but it gets a little dull when they're reduced to passive participants in adventures that find them, rather than exercising any control of their lives or narratives.
I mean, Hob and Krang and Bishop and Null and Kitsune and Rat King and even Splinter are all out there working angles, moving things along and getting crap DONE. The Turtles have just been along for the ride, lately.
CyberCubed
10-16-2017, 12:30 PM
While I don't agree, this is kinda why I feel old characters should have their arcs wrapped up. Like how Darius was literally killed off, or how Shredder is dead (for now, anyway, we know he'll be revived).
After issue 50, Karai for example had no screentime in the book until her Universe 4-parter. She was just completely absent in every issue from #51 till now. For such an important character like Karai, I feel like we should have caught up on her a lot earlier in Japan. After her Universe arc ends we also don't know how long it'll be till she shows up in the main series again. I was actually eager to see how she'd react to Splinter controlling the Foot Clan, but I guess we'll have to wait for that.
There are other characters IDW waited a long time to do things with, like Leatherhead, or the Triceratons or Bishop that we're only just now exploring. All these characters were hinted/name dropped/had cameos very early before they got any focus. There's also others like Ch'rell that were introduced but still sitting "on the bench" waiting to be used. I don't mind previews to characters early on, but when we're waiting nearly 2 years later for a character to do something, it feels a bit odd.
In a way IDW has introduced a lot of main characters, not to mention all the new Patheon characters we've just seen and haven't been explored yet, or how some Mutanimals like Mutagen Man are just kinda there, but I guess all will be explored in due time.
Powder
10-16-2017, 06:36 PM
I don't think there are too many in general (maybe too many mutants, however), but sometimes I feel there are too many in certain scenes/issues, if that makes sense. On occasion it does feel like they're guest stars, but not to an extent that I felt necessary to bring up previously.
Spengs makes some good points, as well.
Panda_Kahn_fan
10-16-2017, 06:39 PM
I think the comic is packed, but I don't think it's too many characters, though.
CyberCubed
10-16-2017, 06:59 PM
Well there are a LOT of recurring characters and villains now if you add everyone up.
Baxter, Bebop/Rocksteady, Hun, Karai, Koya/Bludgeon, Rat King/Kitsune and the whole Pantheon, Old Hob and all the Mutanimals (which is about 7 more characters in itself like Slash, Mondo Gecko, Mutagen Man, Pigeon Pete, Herman, Sally and Man Ray), Lindsey, Leatherhead, Bishop, Null, Krang, Hakk-R, Jennika, Fugitoid, Neutrinos, Metalhead who now has his own mind, etc.
This is not even counting the minor characters or characters who have been done away with that we might not see again, like Jammerhead/Street Phantoms, etc.
PizzaPower1985
10-19-2017, 10:04 AM
I wonder if the Mutanimals will ever eventually leave the series and just occasionally show up as guest stars. We have to assume that IDW's run is going to be short-lived (probably less than 200 issues though I hope not) and I would like to see more focus put on the turtles and less on Hob's brotherhood of mutants style arcs. If there is going to be a human vs mutate war, like Hob suspects I can't wait. Maybe after the Mutanimals will disappear or disband or something. It's not that I don't like them, its just that this is not their book!
I wonder if the Mutanimals will ever eventually leave the series and just occasionally show up as guest stars. We have to assume that IDW's run is going to be short-lived (probably less than 200 issues though I hope not) and I would like to see more focus put on the turtles and less on Hob's brotherhood of mutants style arcs. If there is going to be a human vs mutate war, like Hob suspects I can't wait. Maybe after the Mutanimals will disappear or disband or something. It's not that I don't like them, its just that this is not their book!
It's ironic you say that; but with what they've been building towards since the 50th milestone, I'm half expecting a civil divide to happen with the Mutanimals (those that follow Hob's beliefs and those who don't).
I just don't want them to go the way of the Archie Mutanimals... that's just too awful to think of (considering the Gang of Four have just been introduced in the IDW-verse)!
CyberCubed
10-19-2017, 12:47 PM
IDW TMNT is probably going to last at least 10 years. We started in 2011, we'll reach issue #100 by...2019, I think? I didn't do the math but somewhere around there.
ChosenOne
10-19-2017, 01:15 PM
It's ironic you say that; but with what they've been building towards since the 50th milestone, I'm half expecting a civil divide to happen with the Mutanimals (those that follow Hob's beliefs and those who don't).
I too want this to happen, but to be fair, considering Bishop's actions and the EPF experimentation on some of them, the vast majority if not the entire team will now be in full support of Hob's ideals.
I have no idea how this and everything else on the plate can be wrapped up before #100, but the unforeseen road getting there will be half the fun!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-19-2017, 01:23 PM
I too want this to happen, but to be fair, considering Bishop's actions and the EPF experimentation on some of them, the vast majority if not the entire team will now be in full support of Hob's ideals.
I have no idea how this and everything else on the plate can be wrapped up before #100, but the unforeseen road getting there will be half the fun!
Yeah, nobody's splitting from the Mutanimals in the current status quo. Only Slash was enough of a foolish idealist (thanks, Michelangelo) to do go off on his own.
Everyone else saw how that worked out. :trazz:
CyberCubed
10-19-2017, 01:45 PM
There's also whatever they do with Null, plus I totally forgot Dreadmon was introduced in one of the Universe issues. :lol:
ChosenOne
10-19-2017, 01:48 PM
There's also whatever they do with Null, plus I totally forgot Dreadmon was introduced in one of the Universe issues. :lol:
Dreadmon is a part of the Null subplot, which we know ties into the Mutanimals and Bishop. I'm guessing there will be a major arc before the run-up to #100 where that whole conflict comes to a head. It's either that, or another Mutanimals mini.
CyberCubed
10-19-2017, 01:56 PM
Well considering the Triceraton arc is 5 issues it will bring us up to issue 80.
After that there's only 20 issues till the big 100. So you're right, unless we get new mini's or Universe covers Null/Mutanimals, there's going to be quite a tight squeeze till number 100. I expect the Pantheon plot to take up most of the main series issues around that point and some stuff with Bishop, let alone if there are any breather issues.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-19-2017, 02:04 PM
Well considering the Triceraton arc is 5 issues it will bring us up to issue 80.
After that there's only 20 issues till the big 100. So you're right, unless we get new mini's or Universe covers Null/Mutanimals, there's going to be quite a tight squeeze till number 100. I expect the Pantheon plot to take up most of the main series issues around that point and some stuff with Bishop, let alone if there are any breather issues.
Yeah, but we can expect 10 of those 20 issues to be Pantheon/Foot related. Vengeance and City Fall were both tons of issues compared to previous story arcs.
So that's two or three story arcs in between the Triceratons and the Pantheon. And you KNOW Bishop isn't going to be wrapped up very quickly.
Based on this reasoning, I don't expect Null to come to a head until after #100.
myconius
10-21-2017, 04:26 PM
one of my favorite arcs in a while has been issues 1 through 4 of Tmnt Universe.
there was plenty of time spent with the Turtles, lots of action, but also some very good dialog.
we got a few good moments with April, plenty with Baxter, and even got to know Zodi. but the main stars of the story were the Ninja Turtles.
Sometimes they don't get enough focus in their own series for my personal taste. i love the series, but at times i do find that annoying.
CyberCubed
10-21-2017, 04:32 PM
Oh man, I completely forgot about Zodi till you mentioned her. I think that proves this topic, there's now a lot of new characters or mutants introduced that only have one or two appearances so far and are difficult to remember. And now we have Ocho tagging along with Karai too, which is another character in the pile.
I mean it's easy to remember the major characters, Mutanimals, and the main villains, but a lot of these side characters are getting lost in the shuffle. That's one of the reasons I wouldn't mind a "bloodbath" of sorts around issue 100, just to clean out the main cast a bit. ;)
myconius
10-21-2017, 05:09 PM
Oh man, I completely forgot about Zodi till you mentioned her. I think that proves this topic, there's now a lot of new characters or mutants introduced that only have one or two appearances so far and are difficult to remember. And now we have Ocho tagging along with Karai too, which is another character in the pile.
I mean it's easy to remember the major characters, Mutanimals, and the main villains, but a lot of these side characters are getting lost in the shuffle. That's one of the reasons I wouldn't mind a "bloodbath" of sorts around issue 100, just to clean out the main cast a bit. ;)
Cubed, i really like your idea of a culling! :D
MikeandRaph87
10-21-2017, 07:29 PM
This has come up before and I agree there is an excess of characters some of them are relatively minor and its fine. Null has been mentioned is the one plot thread I keep thinking will be added to,but nothing yet. As for addition of Malinga with the Triceratons finally getting attention it seems unnecessary. I can create a good guess as to what Null will do I have no idea how Malinga will fit into the story going forward.
Bobby said the Punk Frogs were coming up sooner than later however its been four to five months since then. I also believe those frogs severants were not being passed off as them under the Toad Baron so where will they be? Its hard to think its "sooner" with Trial of Krang wrapping up and the focus shifting to the Triceraton invasion. It would be in TMNT Universe's December issue at the earliest.
Powder
10-21-2017, 07:44 PM
I not only don't recall Bobby saying that but believe he in fact said they would not likely appear...
MikeandRaph87
10-21-2017, 07:58 PM
I not only don't recall Bobby saying that but believe he in fact said they would not likely appear...
I am going by a response in his Q&A thread which he was asked if the grog servants were to serve as the Punk Frogs analog in IDW. He said they are not and the Punk Frogs are scheduled to appear separately soon. I will have to dig through his thread for it. I believe it was during the solicits of TMNT Universe#9.
ChosenOne
10-21-2017, 08:09 PM
This has come up before and I agree there is an excess of characters some of them are relatively minor and its fine. Null has been mentioned is the one plot thread I keep thinking will be added to,but nothing yet. As for addition of Malinga with the Triceratons finally getting attention it seems unnecessary. I can create a good guess as to what Null will do I have no idea how Malinga will fit into the story going forward.
Bobby said the Punk Frogs were coming up sooner than later however its been four to five months since then. I also believe those frogs severants were not being passed off as them under the Toad Baron so where will they be? Its hard to think its "sooner" with Trial of Krang wrapping up and the focus shifting to the Triceraton invasion. It would be in TMNT Universe's December issue at the earliest.
I do believe the Punk Frogs will pop up in the new TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover next month.
What is your guess regarding Null's role, if you don't mind me asking?
MikeandRaph87
10-21-2017, 08:35 PM
I do believe the Punk Frogs will pop up in the new TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover next month.
What is your guess regarding Null's role, if you don't mind me asking?
I am guess ing she will play the unexpected third party in the storyline with Agent Bishop. She processed the mutagen for Shredder and she would be a target of Bishop. Bishop might want to confiscate the mutagen properties from her and that can bring her into the main title.
I noticed a lot of old characters on the cover of #4 of #5 including alternate versions of both Mondo Gecko and Ace Duck. I did not see them featured but that does not mean they are not going to be featured. Perhaps it's a quick reference and then move on? That would suck as they were favorites of mine growing up. Better than nothing though and if Mondo and Ace having an alternate version it does not rule out a proper appearance.
CyberCubed
10-21-2017, 09:19 PM
I noticed a lot of old characters on the cover of #4 of #5 including alternate versions of both Mundi Gecko and ACE Duck. I did not see them featured but that does not mean they are not going to be featured. Perhaps it's a quick reference and then move on? That would suck as they were favorites of mine growing up. Better than nothing though and if Mondo and Ace having an alternate version it does not rule out a proper appearance.
I'm not sure what you mean here, you do realize IDW's versions of Mondo and Ace Duck exist, right? Unless I'm reading what you're saying wrong, the alternate ones on the cover will probably only be in that issue as a one-shot thing.
MikeandRaph87
10-21-2017, 09:30 PM
I'm not sure what you mean here, you do realize IDW's versions of Mondo and Ace Duck exist, right? Unless I'm reading what you're saying wrong, the alternate ones on the cover will probably only be in that issue as a one-shot thing.
Take a look at the cover, Ace Duck, Mondo Gecko, and Leatherhead appear on the cover, but they are not the IDW incarnations so they are obiviously alternate versions. If we meet The Punk Frogs there in a cameo it will be an alternate version of them leaving room for an IDW proper version to still appear in the future. I will take the bone as they are childhood favorites, but I still await their proper introduction once some story-lines have played out.
http://www.imagebam.com/image/628091629193733
PApagreg
10-21-2017, 09:36 PM
I personally say yes but they do make up for it by developing most of them, now don't get me wrong a lot of them don't have the same level of depth like our main heroes but we do get a good understanding on why they do what they do.
CyberCubed
03-17-2023, 08:52 PM
This thread is from nearly 6 years ago from 2017 and the IDW comic has doubled down and gotten even worse in terms of introducing 100 characters they have no time to juggle or give screentime too. Made even worse that most of the old characters are still around in addition to all of Sophie's characters and then all the characters Waltz keeps introducing.
If you told me back in 2017 we'd have 3 female Turtles in the series (Jennika, Lita and Venus) I would have laughed.
Coola Yagami
03-18-2023, 09:26 AM
Lots of series have huge casts, I think the TMNT series needs to do a better job in separating them by location and circumstance.
Like don't have the turtles live in mutant town. That ways you restrict all the mutant town characters to whenever the story calls for it. Make the Mutanimals set up base in LA or something. Little things like that will help spread them out some and not have 100 or so characters per issue. Save the huge all-hands-on-deck situations for stuff like the Armageddon Game, but not in regular issues.
Like FMA had a huge cast spanning different countries. We don't see all these characters cross paths until the final chapters where the story came to the final boss fight.
Sir5R
03-18-2023, 10:18 AM
I definitely think there are too many characters & mutants and the guys have been sidelined mostly to make room for them. While up to 100 was still relatively done well, 101 to 120ish has been terribly bogged down and only barely come back with this new storyline across, what 3 books now? Its too slow & dragged out. My hope is that at the end of this storyline, I'd like to see 90% of the characters gone or spun off into its own book separate from the Turtles book.
staypuftweepel
03-18-2023, 12:58 PM
Yes, there’s way too many now. I haven’t really been enjoying Armageddon Game and the over abundance of new characters is part of the problem. It’s got the Mortal Kombat Annihilation (film) problem where they keep throwing as many new characters as they can in to the story and they move along so quickly it seems like there was no point in them being there at all. The Turtles roles are significantly reduced and out of the first 5 issues only Donatello’s arc stands out.
My biggest problem with the series is 5 issues in and it’s all been set up with not much of anything happening. I have 6 but haven’t read it yet. I think the alliance comics have been pretty pointless too.
CyberCubed
03-18-2023, 01:23 PM
Its been a problem prior to issue 100 as well. Bringing Shredder and Krang "back to life" also complicated things, and it took them way too long to give Ch'rell something to do. Rat King and Null have essentially been stagnant for over 50+ issues for the most part.
TheLabRat
03-19-2023, 08:13 AM
Another problem is how would they kill these villains, or remove them from the story in a way they can't come back? I can't expect The Turtles willing to kill these villains, since even Leo refuse to kill a demon. Most turtles can't even beat some minor vilains, like Gang of Four. These villains are either killed by other characters or be consumed by their own evil doings.
Andrew NDB
03-19-2023, 03:58 PM
Leo won't kill a demon? :roll:
ChosenOne
03-19-2023, 04:03 PM
More like an alien in this iteration but yeah, the Gang of Four schooling the Turtles was utter BS. Maybe if they'd kept them at a range it would've looked better.
Dangv
03-22-2023, 01:59 PM
Yes.
Just the turtles alone. How many are there now? 12? :lol:
I can't keep up with the story, characters and spin-off/side releases anymore.
I gave up a while ago, keep trying to get back into it but there's too much going on. At the same time it feels like nothing is really happening (if that makes sense). I lost interest and hope this event will kill off many of these useless characters and things will go back to normal.
CyberCubed
03-22-2023, 02:10 PM
There's more side characters than anything else.
For a 40 year old franchise and a 12-year-long comic run that has about 300 issues in the main title, minis/one-shots/etc, there are not too many characters. I think the issue sometimes is focusing on certain characters (Rat King/Old Hob, for example) for too many issues takes away the possibility of highlighting some of the other characters that haven't had space to grow.
CyberCubed
04-05-2023, 05:07 PM
The issue is more that there's too many characters in the story at once or the same time. We literally got a new character like Carmen introduced not too long ago, and already she's a background character because they have no time to do anything with her. We've had villain plots like Ch'rell and Null dangling for years because there was never enough time to do anything with them.
It seems every new "arc" they introduce like 5+ new characters but also keep all the old ones around, so naturally it gets crowded and half the characters wind up doing nothing anyway.
Stu_Padasso
04-05-2023, 11:30 PM
Too many characters if the Mutanimals, Neutrinos or Mutant Town had their own ongoings apart from the core title? No. For a single title? Yep. I don’t have the vitriol towards new characters like Jennika or Sheena that some here have, but their addition has definitely crowded out others like April or Alopex. They all need more room to breathe and develop.
TheLabRat
04-08-2023, 10:51 AM
For a 40 year old franchise and a 12-year-long comic run that has about 300 issues in the main title, minis/one-shots/etc, there are not too many characters. I think the issue sometimes is focusing on certain characters (Rat King/Old Hob, for example) for too many issues takes away the possibility of highlighting some of the other characters that haven't had space to grow.
Old Hob's story development is still poorly written. He said it was all in his plan make mutants no longer dependent on Mutanimals. I'm just confused. It's like the writers want us pretend to believe that Hob is a super mastermind.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.