PDA

View Full Version : Batman/TMNT II #1 Preview and Discussion


bushido
12-04-2017, 08:12 AM
Preview here (https://www.cbr.com/exclusive-batman-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-ii-1/).

oldmanwinters
12-04-2017, 08:19 AM
Oh, wow, Karai is back in New York and Shredder is apparently in prison.

And... IDW Karai was never referred to as Shredder' daughter, so far as I can remember.

So I guess this cements this mini-series as an alternate continuity from the TMNT ongoing?

neatoman
12-04-2017, 08:44 AM
Oh, wow, Karai is back in New York and Shredder is apparently in prison.

And... IDW Karai was never referred to as Shredder' daughter, so far as I can remember.

So I guess this cements this mini-series as an alternate continuity from the TMNT ongoing?

I guess it would, yeah. There were some questionable continuity aspects in the first crossover, so I guess it's probably best to make it clear that it's not really the IDW turtles this time.

ProphetofGanja
12-04-2017, 09:16 AM
Oh, wow, Karai is back in New York and Shredder is apparently in prison.

And... IDW Karai was never referred to as Shredder' daughter, so far as I can remember.

So I guess this cements this mini-series as an alternate continuity from the TMNT ongoing?

I guess it would, yeah. There were some questionable continuity aspects in the first crossover, so I guess it's probably best to make it clear that it's not really the IDW turtles this time.

It was always specified that this wasn't the main IDW TMNT continuity, but rather an offshoot/parallel universe. I think it was stated in the Ask an Editor thread

I assume that unless something is mentioned specifically, then everything else in these TMNT's universe occurred just as in the main IDW Turtleverse. But it seems as if the aftermath of the Turtles' first encounter with Batman has effects that are still rippling outwards, so this universe will continue to become more different from the main IDW universe over time

Raptor86
12-04-2017, 09:35 AM
We all knew about the (non-)canonicity of these Batman crossovers. But what about the IDW reading guide then? http://www.idwpublishing.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/TMNTSampler.pdf

neatoman
12-04-2017, 09:45 AM
Yes of course we knew that from interviews but the story itself wasn't very clear on wheter or not it was part of continuity.

oldmanwinters
12-04-2017, 11:03 AM
We all knew about the (non-)canonicity of these Batman crossovers. But what about the IDW reading guide then? http://www.idwpublishing.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/TMNTSampler.pdf

Maybe it's a Splinter Timeline?

But that still wouldn't explain why Karai is identifying as the Shredder's daughter rather than granddaughter.

Weapons@theready
12-04-2017, 11:07 AM
Cubed is still going to show up here and talk about it being canon

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-04-2017, 11:25 AM
Maybe it's a Splinter Timeline?

But that still wouldn't explain why Karai is identifying as the Shredder's daughter rather than granddaughter.

They're going with IDW for visuals and maybe some basic story setup, but when IDW diverges from the more mainstream identities (e.g. Karai being Saki's daughter), they go mainstream.

Also, did the first crossover ever mention reincarnation? I don't remember, but I'm willing to bet no.

qt.bangerang
12-04-2017, 01:03 PM
Well I though IDW made a mistake not making the first one canon, but now that this really makes it impossible to be canon I wont be picking this up.

Redeemer
12-04-2017, 02:58 PM
I honestly think you guys are making a big fuss over something so trivial as to whether this mini-series is cannon or not. Just enjoy the story for what it is. Its pretty awesome how much love TMNT is getting.

Powder
12-04-2017, 03:34 PM
now that this really makes it impossible to be canon I wont be picking this up.

Why? That's dumb. Enjoy it for what it is. I'm glad it isn't, personally.

spookycookies
12-04-2017, 03:48 PM
I honestly think you guys are making a big fuss over something so trivial as to whether this mini-series is cannon or not. Just enjoy the story for what it is. Its pretty awesome how much love TMNT is getting.

I mean I'm going to enjoy it anyhow but I just need to know if I'm putting in with the rest of my IDW TMNT books or just over to the side on its own. I'd love to have it exist in the same universe and be part of my re-read list but it is just a tiny shame.

Andrew NDB
12-04-2017, 04:23 PM
I honestly think you guys are making a big fuss over something so trivial as to whether this mini-series is cannon or not.

Is it really trivial? A crossover with Batman and the TMNT is a big deal no matter what way you cut it, sure... but if it's a crossover with Batman and a made-up TMNT universe, that doesn't really help the IDW TMNT side too much.

Redeemer
12-04-2017, 06:22 PM
Is it really trivial? A crossover with Batman and the TMNT is a big deal no matter what way you cut it, sure... but if it's a crossover with Batman and a made-up TMNT universe, that doesn't really help the IDW TMNT side too much.

Thanks for making my point, the cross-over in itself is a big deal, not whether or not its cannon. The mere fact TMNT got a cross-over with arguably the biggest hero right now in the comic industry is huge in itself. Complaining about it not being cannon is hyper focusing that is not necessary.

Andrew NDB
12-04-2017, 06:40 PM
Thanks for making my point, the cross-over in itself is a big deal, not whether or not its cannon. The mere fact TMNT got a cross-over with arguably the biggest hero right now in the comic industry is huge in itself. Complaining about it not being cannon is hyper focusing that is not necessary.

It all depends, though. Devil's advocate... let's say it turns out that Batman/TMNT II is very bad. Let's say it makes the TMNT look very not good. Because IDW's label is on it, people will associate it with the IDW TMNT, even though it is not. And if it turns out to be great? People will open up the IDW TMNT comics and feel duped that the Turtles in Batman/TMNT were different/some random other incarnation. Seems sort of lose/lose to me on the comics side, even though just having these caliber of crossovers elevates the "stock" of the TMNT franchise.

DevilSpooky
12-04-2017, 08:34 PM
We all knew about the (non-)canonicity of these Batman crossovers. But what about the IDW reading guide then? http://www.idwpublishing.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/TMNTSampler.pdf

Bobby had this (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1721583&postcount=2220) to say about it.

Raptor86
12-05-2017, 02:38 AM
Bobby had this (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=1721583&postcount=2220) to say about it.

Ok, this definitely closes the discussion.

Ninjinister
12-05-2017, 03:36 AM
but if it's a crossover with Batman and a made-up TMNT universe, that doesn't really help the IDW TMNT side too much.

Bruh...

It's all made-up

That's how fiction works

***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-05-2017, 07:41 AM
This was probably done also so that Batman can't just show up in the Ongoing/Main Universe randomly anytime the turtles are in way over their heads. Any guy who would take on Superman would be quite an asset against pretty much any villain Tom and his crew can dream up.

Coming in Winter of 2018: Batman vs. The Pantheon!

Andrew NDB
12-05-2017, 11:01 AM
This was probably done also so that Batman can't just show up in the Ongoing/Main Universe randomly anytime the turtles are in way over their heads. Any guy who would take on Superman would be quite an asset against pretty much any villain Tom and his crew can dream up.

But aren't these crossovers treating the Turtle universe and the DC universe as two different things? And their actual crossovers as multiversal travel?

***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-05-2017, 11:32 AM
I'm saying it wouldn't be logical for the turtles to be able to show up in Batman's reality and not vice versa. We can't have Batman just showing up in the Ongoing, now can we?

CyberCubed
12-05-2017, 12:59 PM
Since this is now confirmed a new universe, it's interesting that once again Karai is Shredder's daughter instead of being unrelated to him. This makes the fourth universe (after 4kids, Nick, and IDW), that Karai was Shredder's daughter, adopted daughter, or great great+ granddaughter.

At this rate Karai being related to Shredder is being cemented in canon in 4 different continuities. I guess ol' Mirage Karai is now the anomaly despite being the source material.

oldmanwinters
12-05-2017, 01:48 PM
Even if it is a new continuity, I am wondering if Donatello's shell crushing defeat by Bebop and Rocksteady will be referenced in this mini-series, especially considering how prominent a role Donatello seems to be playing in the cover previews and issue solicits.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-05-2017, 02:08 PM
Even if it is a new continuity, I am wondering if Donatello's shell crushing defeat by Bebop and Rocksteady will be referenced in this mini-series, especially considering how prominent a role Donatello seems to be playing in the cover previews and issue solicits.

Pretty sure it will.

Redeemer
12-05-2017, 03:30 PM
It all depends, though. Devil's advocate... let's say it turns out that Batman/TMNT II is very bad. Let's say it makes the TMNT look very not good. Because IDW's label is on it, people will associate it with the IDW TMNT, even though it is not. And if it turns out to be great? People will open up the IDW TMNT comics and feel duped that the Turtles in Batman/TMNT were different/some random other incarnation. Seems sort of lose/lose to me on the comics side, even though just having these caliber of crossovers elevates the "stock" of the TMNT franchise.

Well Honestly I don't think that will matter even if TMNT is portrayed poorly for the simple fact that there has been 2 Nick based comic books series with IDW's name on it haha :lol:

If it turns out to be great so be it, its a great story that you can reread anytime you want.

CyberCubed
12-05-2017, 05:14 PM
It would be pretty funny if this continually spinoffs to it's own universe regularly, assuming we get more sequels to this.

It is loosely based on IDW TMNT, I remember Splinter saying they were reincarnated from ancient Japan unless I'm remembering wrong in the first crossover.

neatoman
12-06-2017, 03:53 PM
So I've read this first issue and I gotta say, this does seem more interesting than the first one. If you take away the "OMG, BATMAN MEETS THE TURTLES! MY CHILDHOOD FAN FICTION IS COMING TRUE!!!" angle from the first one, all you got was a few fight scenes and dicussing strategy. It was pretty cool to see the Batman villains as monsters at the end but it was a bit underwhelming for me. This seems more like it has an actual story to tell. I also like that it's more clear about not exactly being the IDW turtles meeting Batman, gives me the feeling like there might be more of a point at the end if they're not beholden to continuity.

There is just one nitpick, even if they don't have to care about continuity...
... Bebop and Rocksteady leading a faction of the Foot? And hitting the Purple Dragons "hard"? Bull, crap. In what universe do the characters known for being idiots have the brain power for leadership? And hitting the Purple Dragons "hard"? Give me a break, if Hun (who does exist, Casey mentioned the abuse) is in charge he'd recruit Bebop and Rocksteady for muscle, not getting his ass kicked. Hell, even if he's not there, anyone can at least outsmart Bebop and Rocksteady well enough to not get hit "hard".

Andrew NDB
12-06-2017, 04:00 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady leading a faction of the Foot?

https://media.giphy.com/media/27EhcDHnlkw1O/giphy.gif

neatoman
12-06-2017, 04:09 PM
https://media.giphy.com/media/27EhcDHnlkw1O/giphy.gif

Yeah, it's a pretty cringeworthy concept...

CyberCubed
12-06-2017, 04:29 PM
The continuity is a bit confusing. Casey talks about his father (who in IDW is Hun), and how he stitched him up in bar fights. April also says, "So that's how your father got all those frankenstein scars." But Hun is never name-dropped, so I'm not sure if that's him.

Meanwhile Don goes to Harold's lab and they see the same portal they used in the Ghostbusters crossover. Harold only exists in IDW continuity, as does this particular portal. So uh...?

Lastly we know it's not IDW TMNT because Karai calls herself Shredder's daughter (and not great great granddaughter), and she's at war with the Elite Guard of the Foot Clan. Both Splinter and Shredder are still alive, so even if you say it takes place before issue 50, it still doesn't fit.

Lastly Hamato Yoshi was mentioned and Bebop/Rocksteady exist. So it's almost like this is some weird off-shoot of IDW TMNT with similar events that played out in both.

ProphetofGanja
12-06-2017, 05:03 PM
It is the IDW Turtles, but one's from a parallel dimension, basically.

Everything else about them is the same as the IDW Turtles we already know unless specified otherwise. So in this universe Karai is Shredder's daughter, not great-granddaughter or whatever. Don't overthink it, they definitely aren't.

I think that was the main thing that bothered me about this first issue. I was pretty excited for it, but this crossover really felt like nobody at DC did their homework and read up on what's been going on with the Turtles lately. Even knowing that this isn't the prime IDW continuity, it felt a bit jarring. They really overplayed the whole "OMG I'm Donnie I can'ts fights goods I does machines" thing, way too hard.

That aside, I have higher hopes for the rest of this series. The first issue is usually just building up steam

Redeemer
12-06-2017, 08:20 PM
Best part of the issue.....
Donatello- .....I think he could even hold his own against you, father. Splinter- Well,no.....

:lol: best part of this issue. hands down :lol:

Bane was portrayed really well too.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-06-2017, 08:29 PM
Eh.

Can't say I cared for it much. When the main driving force of a story is "Donatello sucks at fighting and wishes he was better at it", I tend to check out.

ProphetofGanja
12-06-2017, 09:11 PM
Eh.

Can't say I cared for it much. When the main driving force of a story is "Donatello sucks at fighting and wishes he was better at it", I tend to check out.

What's most frustrating to me is that they had a perfect opportunity in the actual IDW continuity to have a story with a similar (and better written) plot—Donatello's brutal beatdown and near-death at the hands of Bebop and Rocksteady. I could see him having some kind of lasting trauma from that event and it's not a stretch to think it could manifest in some form of fear of inadequacy, leading him to make foolish choices.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-06-2017, 09:27 PM
What's most frustrating to me is that they had a perfect opportunity in the actual IDW continuity to have a story with a similar (and better written) plot—Donatello's brutal beatdown and near-death at the hands of Bebop and Rocksteady. I could see him having some kind of lasting trauma from that event and it's not a stretch to think it could manifest in some form of fear of inadequacy, leading him to make foolish choices.

Oooooh, well thought. +5 points for Gryffindor!

ProphetofGanja
12-06-2017, 09:37 PM
Oooooh, well thought. +5 points for Gryffindor!

Ravenclaw actually but thanks all the same! :trazz:



I hope this series at least gives us some good fight scenes if the writing isn't gonna be great

Joey Kamikaze
12-10-2017, 10:14 PM
I still include the original Batman crossover on re-reads as, um, semi-canon, as it slots in nicely just before the first Ghostbusters crossover without too much trouble, and it was a fun read. But hoo boy, this one is obviously not the main IDW universe right off the bat. More like a universe next door to IDW, like the one-shot where all the Turtles joined the Foot, or the X-Files crossover.

Far as the actual issue goes... I was lukewarm on it. Maybe it will pick up, but I'm not crazy about the whole "Don sucks as a fighter because he's a nerd" plot point. Maybe that's just because Don has become my favorite of the bros in the IDW run. But I'm not so sure the writers are really nailing the TMNT characters just right so far. I haven't read Batman in like 20 years, so no idea if that problem goes both ways.

DrSpengler
12-17-2017, 12:03 PM
Here's my full summary and review of Batman/TMNT II #1 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2017/12/batmantmnt-ii-1.html)

Late to the party, but I've got a lot of issues to catch up on. IDW was really churning these Turtle books out November/December!

I like the sandbox approach to continuity that these Batman/TMNT minis are taking, allowing Tynion to pluck the ideas he likes from wherever and roll with it. Adhering to a hardline continuity would make these crossovers a little less fun, especially if they stifle the writer's imagination. And for something as crazy as Batman and TMNT, I want the writer to be able to do whatever they feel like.

Donnie being portrayed as too useless to live was maybe a little over the top in this issue; they REALLY stress how much he sucks to set up his story arc for the miniseries. I don't think they needed to trash the character quite as much as they did, but I guess they had a point to make. And if it leads to a fun storyline, then whatever.

The Williams/Colwell art and colors are as spectacular as ever, btw.