View Full Version : Kevin Eastman Brings up Director's Cut of 1990's TMNT
Autbot_Benz
03-30-2018, 07:33 PM
Kevin B. Eastman added 6 new photos.
16 mins ·
So many wonderful memories about today 28 years ago! This first film will always be the peak for me, of all the film and entertainment projects we worked on with the TMNT's. I have spoken with Steve Barron and Brian Henson over the last few decades - about the rumored "Directors Cut" of the film that was never released - I understand a version exists - I have personally seen several scenes that were filmed and cut from the final film - but getting Steve and Brian to dig up the material and see what it would take to pull it together would take a barrage of requests to New Line Warner Bros (who own all the rights now) maybe even a Kickstarter to raise the funds to get it back out there... Think we should give it a shot? Let me know what you think.
From Kevin's Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/kevin.b.eastman/posts/767306376802389
sgtfbomb
03-30-2018, 11:19 PM
Man, I hope this footage sees the light of day. I'd even just take the deleted scenes just as bonus features if it meant getting decent special features. I'd even be okay if they simply included the workprint, like The Burbs. Something's better than nothing...
Leonardo87
03-31-2018, 03:47 AM
With all the attention the 1990 movie is getting from NECA I don't see anything wrong with becoming a thing. I, along with the rest of everyone on here, would be so damned thrilled.
RaphaelinSTL
03-31-2018, 06:58 AM
Yeah, I mean ... I'm sure everyone here would be 100% for it, but I wonder how much of a strangle hold Viacom would put on the release of it at all or if they'd want to get a piece of the action? I'm not sure of the full legality, but if Warner Bros. owns the "movie rights" possibly, does Viacom own half of the merchandising rights ... hence why NECA is forced to slap the giant Nickelodeon logo on all the boxes for their 1990 products? I'm not sure and hopefully someone can enlighten me! Ha.
I've been wanting a "Director's Cut" or "Extended Edition" for this movie forever ... and like Leonardo87 said, the movie is getting even more of a resurgence in the eyes of the public with the NECA line doing so well.
I'm keeping my fingers crossed that for the 30th anniversary we'll see something ... so maybe in 2020 at this point.
Shark_Blade
03-31-2018, 08:50 AM
I’d love to but if it doesn’t happen I’m content with what we have.
d_osborn
03-31-2018, 09:37 AM
Yeah, I mean ... I'm sure everyone here would be 100% for it, but I wonder how much of a strangle hold Viacom would put on the release of it at all or if they'd want to get a piece of the action? I'm not sure of the full legality, but if Warner Bros. owns the "movie rights" possibly, does Viacom own half of the merchandising rights ... hence why NECA is forced to slap the giant Nickelodeon logo on all the boxes for their 1990 products? I'm not sure and hopefully someone can enlighten me! Ha.
The way I understand it, Golden Harvest (or whatever company currently owns GH) owns the film. New Line/WB/Time Warner have the US home video distribution rights. The distribution rights are different throughout the world, hence why Germany has already had a release with a few supplemental features. I'm guessing Viacom would get whatever contracted fee/percentage of the release as per the original contract with Mirage/Surge Licensing.
sgtfbomb
03-31-2018, 10:55 AM
Rights can often be an agonizing black hole of complexities. There are a ton of legal checkmarks WB would have to go through, but I don't see Viacom roadblocking a new blu ray release. For the most part, the stick in the mud for better releases has been a lack of motivation in spending the money to produce new supplementary material. At this time, the distributors only seems willing to spend the money that it costs to simply reprint and repackage the existing discs.
The-Shredder
03-31-2018, 12:07 PM
If a Kickstarter campaign happens, I would definitely consider pitching in.
AquaParade
03-31-2018, 03:05 PM
I made a facebook to comment that I would gladly support a directors cut kkckstarter.
I really want this.
AquaParade
04-03-2018, 03:38 PM
I have to say I'm a little bummed at how little discussion this generated. Hopefully some will go to Kevin's facebook and show support.
This could be our one shot at getting a director's cut.
Sabacooza
04-03-2018, 05:47 PM
I have to say I'm a little bummed at how little discussion this generated. Hopefully some will go to Kevin's facebook and show support.
This could be our one shot at getting a director's cut.It is a little surprising but at least there's a lot of love for it over on his Facebook page. Maybe something will happen.
Powder
04-03-2018, 09:11 PM
I have to say I'm a little bummed at how little discussion this generated. Hopefully some will go to Kevin's facebook and show support.
This could be our one shot at getting a director's cut.
It's been talked about over & over for like 20 years. The well's run dry on typed enthusiasm. Everyone wants it as bad as they ever did, I'm sure, but they've run out of energy to ask for it after all this time. :tlol: A lot of false hope has been drummed up over the possibility of this in the last decade.
AquaParade
04-04-2018, 10:12 AM
It's been talked about over & over for like 20 years. The well's run dry on typed enthusiasm. Everyone wants it as bad as they ever did, I'm sure, but they've run out of energy to ask for it after all this time. :tlol: A lot of false hope has been drummed up over the possibility of this in the last decade.
But we’ve never had someone like Kevin, who have a little pull and a big enough pedestal to reach a lot of tmnt fans and friends in the industry suggest starting s kickstarter for an actual director’s cut of the film. And if we don’t show support, the conversation will go on another 20 years, possibly.
sgtfbomb
04-04-2018, 07:34 PM
But we’ve never had someone like Kevin, who have a little pull and a big enough pedestal to reach a lot of tmnt fans and friends in the industry suggest starting s kickstarter for an actual director’s cut of the film. And if we don’t show support, the conversation will go on another 20 years, possibly.
Peter Laird once mentioned a vhs copy of the workprint cut with the same on Blast from the Past. This was a LONG time ago, though.
I don't know. We eventually got an approximation of the Richard Donner cut of Superman II, and that seemed like something that would never happen. So who knows?
Also, Shout Factory just announced they were releasing Memoirs of an Invisible Man and In the Mouth of Madness and I'm pretty sure New Line/Warner Bros. legitimately owns those titles. Maybe the chances of them doing a TMNT release has gotten bigger?
pferreira
04-05-2018, 03:37 PM
For some odd reason the original three TMNT movies get little care and attention when it comes out on DVD or blu-ray. I just don't get that considering how successful all them were.
The way I understand it, Golden Harvest (or whatever company currently owns GH) owns the film. New Line/WB/Time Warner have the US home video distribution rights. The distribution rights are different throughout the world, hence why Germany has already had a release with a few supplemental features. I'm guessing Viacom would get whatever contracted fee/percentage of the release as per the original contract with Mirage/Surge Licensing.I think that might be the reason for why Lost in Space Complete Series Blu-ray hasn't had a UK release yet. I believe someone at Fox told me that was the case.
And if we don’t show support, the conversation will go on another 20 years, possibly.That's how we should think. ;)
I would back it if they would release all behind the scenes footage as well, not just new scenes, id like to see more footage of turtles on set filmed with normal cameras and not just film cameras.
Krutch
05-10-2018, 03:39 PM
Would love to see the Director's Cut with the punk-rock soundtrack that Steve had in mind when shooting it.
AquaParade
05-10-2018, 03:57 PM
Would love to see the Director's Cut with the punk-rock soundtrack that Steve had in mind when shooting it.
Too good to be true. I did like parts of the soundtrack, but this sounds glorious. Wouldn't bet on it, of course.
Casey
05-11-2018, 02:05 PM
Would love to see the Director's Cut with the punk-rock soundtrack that Steve had in mind when shooting it.
Not quite punk rock, but music from the producer of The Sex Pistols Marshall McLaren. Could have been classical score mixed with drums and slap bass. Waltz on the Blue Danub can be heard in the trailer and that was sort of the vibe they were going for. Maybe one or two punk rock songs from The Pistols? It would have totally suited the property better.
sgtfbomb
05-11-2018, 05:56 PM
Not quite punk rock, but music from the producer of The Sex Pistols Marshall McLaren. Could have been classical score mixed with drums and slap bass. Waltz on the Blue Danub can be heard in the trailer and that was sort of the vibe they were going for. Maybe one or two punk rock songs from The Pistols? It would have totally suited the property better.
I like McLaren's remix of Blue Danube. It was fun for a trailer, but Barron's idea of McLaren composing an entire score in that style is one I'm glad didn't come to fruition. Du Prez's score is atmospheric, emotional, upbeat, intense, and hits all the right notes. If it's not broken, don't fix it.
Casey
05-14-2018, 02:08 PM
I like McLaren's remix of Blue Danube. It was fun for a trailer, but Barron's idea of McLaren composing an entire score in that style is one I'm glad didn't come to fruition. Du Prez's score is atmospheric, emotional, upbeat, intense, and hits all the right notes. If it's not broken, don't fix it.
I agree with you about how well it works. The intro song is somehow a reference to the cartoon that sounds nothing like the cartoon theme song. There are plenty parts where it’s perfect like the rooftop battle. I would still have loved to hear more of McLaren’s music in the mix though.
Spike Spiegel
05-28-2018, 10:32 AM
Also, Shout Factory just announced they were releasing Memoirs of an Invisible Man and In the Mouth of Madness and I'm pretty sure New Line/Warner Bros. legitimately owns those titles. Maybe the chances of them doing a TMNT release has gotten bigger?
They always do such a great job with their remasters. For the videophiles on this forum, do you foresee any substantial improvements to the visual quality of the 1990 film with a modern remastering job compared to whatever they did in 2009 for the initial BD release?
d_osborn
05-28-2018, 12:42 PM
They always do such a great job with their remasters. For the videophiles on this forum, do you foresee any substantial improvements to the visual quality of the 1990 film with a modern remastering job compared to whatever they did in 2009 for the initial BD release?
The BD was a pretty awesome transfer. No noise reduction-- it's a naturally grainy film, so this was nice. Hopefully the source was 4K and that can be used on subsequent releases.
4K transfer, add the VHS-sourced Menke/Barron cut, commission the Turtle Power doc producers to go nuts on content... my heart is going pitter patter.
pferreira
06-01-2018, 04:40 PM
They always do such a great job with their remasters. For the videophiles on this forum, do you foresee any substantial improvements to the visual quality of the 1990 film with a modern remastering job compared to whatever they did in 2009 for the initial BD release?A 4K transfer might become a selling point for them wanting to remaster it.
AquaParade
06-04-2018, 10:41 AM
A re-master is one thing. Deleted scenes, commentary...I'd be there day one with a purchase and take the night off to watch it with dinner. It'd be great.
But a director's cut? That's the sort of thing my entertainment-dreams are made of. To let Steve Baron back in the editing room, place in the missing pieces from the cutting room floor, a few touch-ups to the effects, etc.
To have a film that not only do I love, but am extremely nostalgic for be extended?
Seems too good to be true.
AquaParade
06-04-2018, 10:43 AM
A re-master is one thing. Deleted scenes, commentary...I'd be there day one with a purchase and take the night off to watch it with dinner. It'd be great.
But a director's cut? That's the sort of thing my entertainment-dreams are made of. To let Steve Baron back in the editing room, place in the missing pieces from the cutting room floor, a few touch-ups to the effects, etc.
To have a film that not only do I love, but am extremely nostalgic for be extended?
Seems too good to be true.
It's fun to think of the cool packaging they could do for this. How cool would a collector's edition, packaged with one small-scale Neca TMNT figure be?
Of course, that's hardly viable given the costs and legal-work it would involve.
Just a fun thought.
d_osborn
06-04-2018, 04:20 PM
To let Steve Baron back in the editing room, place in the missing pieces from the cutting room floor, a few touch-ups to the effects, etc.
...
Of course, that's hardly viable given the costs and legal-work it would involve.
Just a fun thought.
Scanning the original film elements would be super cost prohibitive, but Barron and Menke's edit exists on VHS. It's not out of the realm of possibility for this to make it's way on to an official release.
tmntgeoff
06-05-2018, 10:14 PM
I've read in several places that the original theatrical film had a lot of the deleted scenes, and alternate ending but were removed when released on vhs.
I saw the movie as a kid in theaters but I was 6 at the time. Wouldn't there be 35 film reels out there with the original version? Maybe they could create a transfer from those and do an official release that way.
Casey
06-06-2018, 10:38 AM
I've read in several places that the original theatrical film had a lot of the deleted scenes, and alternate ending but were removed when released on vhs.
I saw the movie as a kid in theaters but I was 6 at the time. Wouldn't there be 35 film reels out there with the original version? Maybe they could create a transfer from those and do an official release that way.
They have an alternate ending and some deleted scenes, but the alternate ending was never used in the theatrical release or the home video release. I guess there are usually edits done between those two things for most films, but the deleted scenes were not in either.
d_osborn
06-06-2018, 11:04 AM
I've read in several places that the original theatrical film had a lot of the deleted scenes, and alternate ending but were removed when released on vhs.
I saw the movie as a kid in theaters but I was 6 at the time. Wouldn't there be 35 film reels out there with the original version? Maybe they could create a transfer from those and do an official release that way.
Any sources on that, G? I've read a few rumors, but nothing ever solid.
From what I understand, Barron and Menke were let go once their rough cut was delivered to Golden Harvest, and that's when a bulk of the material was cut. From there, GH brought in another edit team, recut the film based on the direction to make it lighter, then hired DuPrez for the score and filled out the SBK music.
I would doubt that finished deleted scenes were ever included on prints, but you never know! Especially as low budget as GH was at the time-- I'm guessing they struck as few prints as possible. Was there even a test screening process on the movie? It's possible an early version got into circulation that way, I guess.
sgtfbomb
06-06-2018, 06:06 PM
There is some truth to this. The original UK version had some bits extended to compensate for the removal of Mikey's nunchucks. This is most noticeable during the fight at April's apartment. I recommend comparing this version of the scene to Sally Menke's superior version. It's very educational.
Wasn't the extended training sequence was rumored to be in the release prints? I think that was just another myth, like the alleged shot of the T-Rex bursting through the wall in Jurassic Park.
EDIT: There used to be a better upload of this, but here's the UK version of the apartment fight.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JktCccQlvmU
d_osborn
06-06-2018, 10:20 PM
A few clips here and there, but no full scenes.
Ghostbusters II is rumored to have had a few test screening prints released into theaters with full deleted scenes.
pferreira
06-07-2018, 09:12 AM
A few clips here and there, but no full scenes.
Ghostbusters II is rumored to have had a few test screening prints released into theaters with full deleted scenes.Over at Ghostbusters Fans to this day there's still users coming in saying they've seen an alternate cut of the movie either at the cinema or shown on British TV.
CJStyles
06-07-2018, 11:36 AM
If such a thing exist, I would love to see it.
sgtfbomb
06-07-2018, 09:29 PM
Ghostbusters II is rumored to have had a few test screening prints released into theaters with full deleted scenes.
From what I remember, people claim that the scene with Louis hunting Slimer and the deleted Liberty Island ceremony were in their versions. I also remember a rumor that Slimer flew by the Statue of Liberty in the theatrical cut, something I am not sure ever existed in the film.
I personally think people are misremembering. The deleted scenes were included in the tie in comics, storybooks, junior novelizations, and trading cards. It's possible that people remember seeing these scenes somewhere, but don't remember where they saw them, and just assume they saw them in theaters.
d_osborn
06-11-2018, 01:33 PM
I personally think people are misremembering. The deleted scenes were included in the tie in comics, storybooks, junior novelizations, and trading cards. It's possible that people remember seeing these scenes somewhere, but don't remember where they saw them, and just assume they saw them in theaters.
There were also some shots of the finished comped FX in Cinefex of Louis vs Slimer. I'm with you on the misremembering. I should be able to 110% confirm pretty soon. :D
ZacksSoUgly
06-13-2018, 12:45 AM
If this makes it to Kickstarter or somewhere similar, consider me a supporter. I would love to see a director's cut with solid bonus material. Give us the deleted scenes, the alternate ending, a commentary track from Steve Barron (and the writers?), and maybe featurettes on the costumes, actors, production, etc.
That may be a bit much to ask, but it would be a wonder to see!
sgtfbomb
06-13-2018, 07:29 PM
There were also some shots of the finished comped FX in Cinefex of Louis vs Slimer. I'm with you on the misremembering. I should be able to 110% confirm pretty soon. :D
My interest is piqued :D
Oh yes, I forgot about that. I actually have scans from that article. I love that magazine. It's a great resource for research and writing articles, and is a great source for information regarding deleted scenes. A good example is Something Wicked This Way Comes.
pferreira
06-15-2018, 06:04 PM
There were also some shots of the finished comped FX in Cinefex of Louis vs Slimer. I'm with you on the misremembering. I should be able to 110% confirm pretty soon. :DI ended up getting banned from GB Fans for sticking up for someone who says they remembered an alternate cut of the movie would you believe?
sgtfbomb
06-15-2018, 11:22 PM
I ended up getting banned from GB Fans for sticking up for someone who says they remembered an alternate cut of the movie would you believe?
I used to see heated battles of the mythic JURASSIC PARK T-Rex shot I mentioned earlier. I honestly think it's misremembering, either from a mental image they had when watching the film or from The Lost World teaser poster, which had the Rex breaking through a wall. But some people swear up and down that shot was there. Some even claim to have seen a version that was 10 minutes longer, with deleted scenes.
Some also claim that Luke made two attempts to throw the rope in the chasm on, missing the first time and trying again. Allegedly, it was on one of the theatrical prints of STAR WARS when it was released.
I myself remember a shot in BATMAN RETURNS that I'm sure never existed, of Catwoman finding her whip in the Schreck department store and grabbing it off a rack.
d_osborn
06-16-2018, 05:15 PM
I myself remember a shot in BATMAN RETURNS that I'm sure never existed, of Catwoman finding her whip in the Schreck department store and grabbing it off a rack.
THAT'S NOT IN THE MOVIE?! Could've sworn it was.
sgtfbomb
06-17-2018, 05:58 AM
THAT'S NOT IN THE MOVIE?! Could've sworn it was.
We never see where she gets it from in the film, but that's the first scene she has it in. But I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought this shot existed.
stcardinal
06-17-2018, 01:34 PM
I am not sure what else they could add to make a director's cut. The only scene that I really know of is the end scene where April tries to make them into a comics, but I am glad they cut that scene out because it's too meta for my liking.
I would be interested in seeing a more darker Mikey if that exists, or just extra battle or banter scenes that didn't make the cut to extend it a bit.
sgtfbomb
06-17-2018, 04:22 PM
I am not sure what else they could add to make a director's cut. The only scene that I really know of is the end scene where April tries to make them into a comics, but I am glad they cut that scene out because it's too meta for my liking.
I would be interested in seeing a more darker Mikey if that exists, or just extra battle or banter scenes that didn't make the cut to extend it a bit.
Here's a list of most of the known deleted scenes, if this helps:
Alternate Opening: Begins on a shot of a street. A sewer lid pops open and we go down it to the door of Turtle's lair. The sewer lid shot is in the trailer and the rest of the scene is detailed in the graphic novel adaptation.
April Leaves the Station Extended: She walks by a pier. The shot pans down to the water. Shells bob up. This is scene in the trailer.
Alternate/Extended April's Mugging: As shot, Sam Rockwell and his goons are not after April's purse. The implied intentions are far darker. The line "Grad her purse! Grab her purse!" was added in post and is overlaid a quick action shot where you don't see the person saying it. The original scene is detailed in the graphic novel adaptation.
Original Casey Jones Introduction: Casey flips through television, disgruntled by all thefts and muggings in the news.
Extended Casey/Raph Fight
Extended Shredder Intro/Shredder Fights Rockwell's Goons/Alternate Speech: After Shredder approaches the gathering and the carpet is rolled, he fights the gang that attacked April earlier in the film. They were released on bail. He defeats them quickly, while sitting. Apparently, it was not a punishment, but a test. The speech he gives to the wayward teens is different and does not include the "I am your father" line. A single camera angle from the fight can be found on the Turtle Power documentary while parts of the original speech can be heard in the theatrical trailer.
Extended Apartment Fight: Leonardo fights down the stairs and into the shop. Additional clips were included in the first UK cut, including a bit where April pulls a rug under a guy's feet.
Escaping the Fire: They carry Raph into the van.
April's Monologue About Mikey: He's the only one April doesn't talk about. But she originally did. He took Splinter's loss the hardest. In one scene, Mikey obliterates a punching bag. You can only see frames of this scene in the final cut.
Extended Training: There's more focus on the training and Donatello in a cowboy hat.
Alternate Tatsu/Shinso Scene (Kinda): Off-screen coughs and the line "You're going to be okay" were added in post. Shinso was originally killed.
Eastman/Laird Cameo: They played the garbageman manning the garbage truck during the street fight.
Blood Splatter: When Shredder is crushed, there was allegedly a little bit of blood that was cut out.
Extended Ending: The publisher sequence. This was included on a German DVD. Personally, I can live without this scene being in the film. It's a little too meta.
Alternate Origins: Oroku Nagi was originally a part of Splinter's origins.
I believe the screenplay also had a scene where a couple visit the antique shop while April is showing the Turtles around. Also, one of the trading cards had Casey interacting with a well at the farm.
These are just the ones off the top of my head. I'm sure I'm missing a few.
ZacksSoUgly
06-18-2018, 12:03 AM
Here's a list of most of the known deleted scenes, if this helps:
Alternate Opening: Begins on a shot of a street. A sewer lid pops open and we go down it to the door of Turtle's lair. The sewer lid shot is in the trailer and the rest of the scene is detailed in the graphic novel adaptation.
April Leaves the Station Extended: She walks by a pier. The shot pans down to the water. Shells bob up. This is scene in the trailer.
Alternate/Extended April's Mugging: As shot, Sam Rockwell and his goons are not after April's purse. The implied intentions are far darker. The line "Grad her purse! Grab her purse!" was added in post and is overlaid a quick action shot where you don't see the person saying it. The original scene is detailed in the graphic novel adaptation.
Original Casey Jones Introduction: Casey flips through television, disgruntled by all thefts and muggings in the news.
Extended Casey/Raph Fight
Extended Shredder Intro/Shredder Fights Rockwell's Goons/Alternate Speech: After Shredder approaches the gathering and the carpet is rolled, he fights the gang that attacked April earlier in the film. They were released on bail. He defeats them quickly, while sitting. Apparently, it was not a punishment, but a test. The speech he gives to the wayward teens is different and does not include the "I am your father" line. A single camera angle from the fight can be found on the Turtle Power documentary while parts of the original speech can be heard in the theatrical trailer.
Extended Apartment Fight: Leonardo fights down the stairs and into the shop. Additional clips were included in the first UK cut, including a bit where April pulls a rug under a guy's feet.
Escaping the Fire: They carry Raph into the van.
April's Monologue About Mikey: He's the only one April doesn't talk about. But she originally did. He took Splinter's loss the hardest. In one scene, Mikey obliterates a punching bag. You can only see frames of this scene in the final cut.
Extended Training: There's more focus on the training and Donatello in a cowboy hat.
Alternate Tatsu/Shinso Scene (Kinda): Off-screen coughs and the line "You're going to be okay" were added in post. Shinso was originally killed.
Eastman/Laird Cameo: They played the garbageman manning the garbage truck during the street fight.
Blood Splatter: When Shredder is crushed, there was allegedly a little bit of blood that was cut out.
Extended Ending: The publisher sequence. This was included on a German DVD. Personally, I can live without this scene being in the film. It's a little too meta.
Alternate Origins: Oroku Nagi was originally a part of Splinter's origins.
I believe the screenplay also had a scene where a couple visit the antique shop while April is showing the Turtles around. Also, one of the trading cards had Casey interacting with a well at the farm.
These are just the ones off the top of my head. I'm sure I'm missing a few.
A lot of these scenes sound REALLY cool, but I think the thing I want to see the most is the Mikey stuff. I always wondered why April never discussed him and that section always felt cut short 'cos there was no mention of Mikey. Seeing a brief glimpse of him in the barn working through his grief in a physical way (working the heavy bag) seemed like a really interesting aspect to Mikey's character development.
All of those scenes sound really cool, and seems like most of them would've only made the movie more thorough (and better in my opinion).
Andrew NDB
06-18-2018, 12:09 AM
Seeing a brief glimpse of him in the barn working through his grief in a physical way (working the heavy bag) seemed like a really interesting aspect to Mikey's character development.
It was probably some hack in the editing room or otherwise saying, "What? Mikey is upset? That's soooo out of character! Mikey is supposed to be the surfer, kids' heads will explode!"
ZacksSoUgly
06-18-2018, 12:15 AM
It was probably some hack in the editing room or otherwise saying, "What? Mikey is upset? That's soooo out of character! Mikey is supposed to be the surfer, kids' heads will explode!"
RIGHT?!
Especially when you think about the idea of comedians, artists, and musicians who use their talent to work through their own grief and help others work through their's. To me, it would've been really cool to show that the "funny guy" is the one most affected by Splinter's abduction/absence. Mikey's usually doing whatever he can to have fun and make others happy, but what about when he's not happy? Could've made for some really beautiful material.
sgtfbomb
06-18-2018, 10:16 AM
It was probably some hack in the editing room or otherwise saying, "What? Mikey is upset? That's soooo out of character! Mikey is supposed to be the surfer, kids' heads will explode!"
The editor of the film, Sally Menke, was no hack. Contrary to belief, most of the scenes removed from the film had little to due with darker content, but more to due with pacing.
The best version of this film would remove the ADR lines from the Shenso scene and re-insert the blood squirt from Shredder's death. As far as the other scenes go, simply being able to watch them would be cool.
EDIT: By the way, is that how you spell Shenso's name?
d_osborn
06-18-2018, 10:54 AM
The editor of the film, Sally Menke, was no hack. Contrary to belief, most of the scenes removed from the film had little to due with darker content, but more to due with pacing.
The best version of this film would remove the ADR lines from the Shenso scene and re-insert the blood squirt from Shredder's death. As far as the other scenes go, simply being able to watch them would be cool.
EDIT: By the way, is that how you spell Shenso's name?
Menke was also Tarantino's editing partner and a damn talented one.
From what I understand, the Mikey break-down scene was included in the Barron/Menke edit that was submitted to Golden Harvest. GH continued cutting down the film, handling score, adding soundtrack music, etc.
AquaParade
06-18-2018, 11:06 AM
I wonder about the music that played during Raphael and Casey meeting for the first time in the park. It has that very goofy baseball-themed music playing in the finished cut.
sgtfbomb
06-18-2018, 07:47 PM
From what I understand, the Mikey break-down scene was included in the Barron/Menke edit that was submitted to Golden Harvest. GH continued cutting down the film, handling score, adding soundtrack music, etc.
Great information! :) Man, I'd love to see the Menke/Barron cut!
d_osborn
06-18-2018, 10:07 PM
Great information! :) Man, I'd love to see the Menke/Barron cut!
Both Peter Laird and Steve Barron have mentioned having a VHS copy!
pferreira
07-13-2018, 02:31 PM
But some people swear up and down that shot was there. Some even claim to have seen a version that was 10 minutes longer, with deleted scenes.
Oh sure but I remember some real hostility from one user on that site when I defended that person and the mod had it in for me so sided with the rude guy. :ohwell:
Ninjinister
07-14-2018, 12:10 AM
RIGHT?!
Especially when you think about the idea of comedians, artists, and musicians who use their talent to work through their own grief and help others work through their's. To me, it would've been really cool to show that the "funny guy" is the one most affected by Splinter's abduction/absence. Mikey's usually doing whatever he can to have fun and make others happy, but what about when he's not happy? Could've made for some really beautiful material.
I think if they played up the more "putting on an act to mask the pain" in things, it'd show the whole thing in a different light. Two examples I can think of are Mikey in Back to the Sewer skateboarding around the lair and hitting everyone who's trying to set the place up, laughing the whole time, and Casey getting excited over the prospect of being in space in 2012. Both times a massive tragedy just happened (The Turtles think Splinter is dead, and at the very most he's scattered across the internet and missing, and in the latter the earth just exploded) and without that "I'm just trying to deal with this in my way" scene, it just makes them look like complete assholes.
EDIT: By the way, is that how you spell Shenso's name?
Shinsho, according to the credits.
Krutch
07-28-2018, 11:34 AM
I sometimes wonder what kind of effect it'd have on future incarnations of Mikey if they'd kept his "silent rage" scenes in. Maybe he'd be written less as just a comedic wisecracker with a soft heart and more of an sensitive, wreckless pendlulum of jokes and wrath.
Leonardo87
07-29-2018, 01:06 AM
Don't forget there is a small scene of April, Donnie, Mikey, and Leo ready to go downstairs as Leo closes it behind him. Also according to Issac there is a scene where a bunch of thugs crowd a kid, who is Ernie Reyes Jr, and he kicks their butts good. I'm sure this is part of the alternative opening.
Yes i agree that Mikey scene when he dismissed Donnie asking about "what it would be like not having splinter" while waiting for pizza was to buildup his character development/change to screaming on top of the roof and dealing with splinter's loss, it was cut out of the movie which is a dumb move, its was great idea and fit perfectly in the dark atmosphere of the film.
Thats the only movie where turtles were serious.
BUT.. i remember as a kid i thought it was raphael hitting heavy bad and screaming "splinter" so maybe the real reason they changed it was because footage was so dark it was hard to recognize it was mikey and Steve didnt had enought footage for proper buildup of character development for mikey to this scene.
Panther10
07-29-2018, 11:50 PM
I might be in the minority here but I would kind of like to see the Director's cut of this movie adapted to 4K resolution. if possible. And please offer it as a trilogy. Those movies really have to be watched as a saga rather than just as a one off. (despite most tmnt's fans objections to the latter two films.)
Andrew NDB
07-30-2018, 12:10 AM
I might be in the minority here but I would kind of like to see the Director's cut of this movie adapted to 4K resolution. if possible. And please offer it as a trilogy. Those movies really have to be watched as a saga rather than just as a one off. (despite most tmnt's fans objections to the latter two films.)
I would STILL think doing what you suggest is doing the same thing the 1990 movie did... which is sell the TMNT short, while still delivering an... OK movie.
That said, ignoring TMNT 2-4 entirely and just doing a "30 years later" sequel to the first movie (kind of like Robocop is doing now) would be far from the worst route they could take.
willtupper
07-30-2018, 01:09 AM
It's also foreshadowing.
"Hey, Mikey. Did you ever think about what Splinter said tonight? I mean about what it would be like, you know, not having him?"
The way it's framed, how it's presented in the story, it looks (at least to me) like Splinter is talking about some time in the future, when he'll be dead.
Only it's more than that.
Because not long after, he's abducted by the Foot. He's taken away from his sons. They quite literally no longer "have him."
It's a brilliant bit of writing, IMO.
Yes i agree that Mikey scene when he dismissed Donnie asking about "what it would be like not having splinter" while waiting for pizza was to buildup his character development/change to screaming on top of the roof and dealing with splinter's loss, it was cut out of the movie which is a dumb move, its was great idea and fit perfectly in the dark atmosphere of the film.
pferreira
08-02-2018, 10:49 AM
That said, ignoring TMNT 2-4 entirely and just doing a "30 years later" sequel to the first movie (kind of like Robocop is doing now) would be far from the worst route they could take.Yea...didn't work for Superman Returns however...that'll teach'em.
I might be in the minority here but I would kind of like to see the Director's cut of this movie adapted to 4K resolution. if possible. And please offer it as a trilogy. Those movies really have to be watched as a saga rather than just as a one off. (despite most tmnt's fans objections to the latter two films.)What we really need is special editions of all three movies. Maybe Shout or Arrow could do it.
Did You guys noticed how many shots from dailies are on turtle power documentary?
I think they had access to these by interviewing Steve Barron and they have a lot more of that.. maybe ?
Did they post here how they come to get these shots ? These are dailes from camera lens recorded to video camera, so all takes are there , deleted, bloopers and alll that.
Maybe we should ask them about that stuff and if they can show more.
On 1:20
Y6UQiyCIKzo
0:30
cvj7Uysd8v8
or this entire vid
Udib1rIYR1M
Just found this interview and Josh says Steve Barron was let go during the end of the film cause it was too dark
https://soundcloud.com/i-was-there-too/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-with-josh-pais
sgtfbomb
09-25-2018, 10:05 PM
Just found this interview and Josh says Steve Barron was let go during the end of the film cause it was too dark
https://soundcloud.com/i-was-there-too/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-with-josh-pais
I'm curious if Barron had anything to say about that in his commentary on that German DVD from a few years back.
pferreira
09-27-2018, 03:41 PM
Just found this interview and Josh says Steve Barron was let go during the end of the film cause it was too dark
https://soundcloud.com/i-was-there-too/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-with-josh-paisDoes he specify what exactly it was in terms of the footage that got Barron fired or sacked?
d_osborn
09-28-2018, 09:48 AM
I haven't had a chance to listen to the interview yet (COME ON LUNCH!), but it's my understanding that Golden Harvest thought the film was literally too dark. Not as in the tone of the film or script-- simply the cinematography exposure.
Director of Photography John Fenner did a ton of testing on style/intensity of lighting to make the Henson suits look as good as possible. Too bright and they looked utterly cartoonish (SOTO). They went with a very dim look to the film, but Golden Harvest wanted the film exposure "pushed" (over-developed... brightened) in post-production. Notice people complaining about the film grain? That's a result of pushing film exposure.
To my knowledge, Barron and Menke were let go from the film after their initial edit was complete. Golden Harvest took over from there, handling the score, soundtrack, further edits, etc.
The-Shredder
09-28-2018, 02:13 PM
I haven't had a chance to listen to the interview yet (COME ON LUNCH!), but it's my understanding that Golden Harvest thought the film was literally too dark. Not as in the tone of the film or script-- simply the cinematography exposure.
Director of Photography John Fenner did a ton of testing on style/intensity of lighting to make the Henson suits look as good as possible. Too bright and they looked utterly cartoonish (SOTO). They went with a very dim look to the film, but Golden Harvest wanted the film exposure "pushed" (over-developed... brightened) in post-production. Notice people complaining about the film grain? That's a result of pushing film exposure.
To my knowledge, Barron and Menke were let go from the film after their initial edit was complete. Golden Harvest took over from there, handling the score, soundtrack, further edits, etc.
Would it be possible to remaster the movie without the excessive film exposure from the negative or is the original unedited footage needed? The latter is most likely scrapped after production ended.
sgtfbomb
09-28-2018, 04:46 PM
Pais merely states Barron was taken off the film at the end. There isn't a whole lot of elaboration. Considering he probably had zero presence on the film during post-production, I doubt he knows many details about the issue either.
I haven't had a chance to listen to the interview yet (COME ON LUNCH!), but it's my understanding that Golden Harvest thought the film was literally too dark. Not as in the tone of the film or script-- simply the cinematography exposure.
Director of Photography John Fenner did a ton of testing on style/intensity of lighting to make the Henson suits look as good as possible. Too bright and they looked utterly cartoonish (SOTO). They went with a very dim look to the film, but Golden Harvest wanted the film exposure "pushed" (over-developed... brightened) in post-production. Notice people complaining about the film grain? That's a result of pushing film exposure.
To my knowledge, Barron and Menke were let go from the film after their initial edit was complete. Golden Harvest took over from there, handling the score, soundtrack, further edits, etc.
I stand corrected. I've always thought it was a stylistic choice, particularly in the minimalist flashback sequences. I do think the grain adds a little texture and gives it a gritty, urban look.
So many interesting details here. There needs to be an entire book or a feature length documentary centered solely on the making of this film.
Shinigami
09-28-2018, 10:19 PM
Just found this interview and Josh says Steve Barron was let go during the end of the film cause it was too dark
https://soundcloud.com/i-was-there-too/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-with-josh-pais
I heard this too, but had it confirmed that it wasn't like a firing. They just didn't really let him anywhere near the editing room.
pferreira
10-04-2018, 04:10 PM
They went with a very dim look to the film, but Golden Harvest wanted the film exposure "pushed" (over-developed... brightened) in post-production. Notice people complaining about the film grain? That's a result of pushing film exposure.I was under the impression the grainy look of the film was just typical of the film stock Golden Harvest used for it's films generally. Japanese films looked a lot more grainy than Hollywood ones back then.
d_osborn
10-04-2018, 04:59 PM
I was under the impression the grainy look of the film was just typical of the film stock Golden Harvest used for it's films generally. Japanese films looked a lot more grainy than Hollywood ones back then.
True, not every shot would have had a pushed exposure. A lot of the grain we see is the native film stock. I'm not 100% on exactly what shots Barron was referring to... maybe just the flashbacks? All dark scenes? It would be cool to have some clarification. Anyway, yeah... the film was low budget on everything save for the puppet FX. I'm guessing a faster film stock was used by Fenner, which would be more sensitive to light, therefore requiring less lights on set. A key feature of faster film stocks? Grain. I'll do some poking around.
On the firing thing-- I'm wondering if it was as simple as a contractual thing? Barron and Menke might have only been contracted for their initial cut. Perhaps internal Golden Harvest post-production teams in China were far cheaper than continuing to pay Barron and Menke? This is of course all speculation... Barron never seemed to have a negative tone while talking about the process, after all.
clockstomper
10-06-2018, 10:23 PM
This may be a little shallow, but damn, Judith looks good. The years have been very kind.
I loved hearing that Robin Williams was a fan. He would have been a great Professor Perry, especially if they stuck with him being a secret Utrom. Williams probably had a great Krang performance in him.
Leonardo87
10-06-2018, 11:15 PM
I'm really thinking this might just happen after all. We just got the recently announced to be released of the score on vinyl. Fingers crossed tightly.
pferreira
10-11-2018, 05:13 PM
True, not every shot would have had a pushed exposure. A lot of the grain we see is the native film stock. I'm not 100% on exactly what shots Barron was referring to... maybe just the flashbacks? All dark scenes? It would be cool to have some clarification. Anyway, yeah... the film was low budget on everything save for the puppet FX. I'm guessing a faster film stock was used by Fenner, which would be more sensitive to light, therefore requiring less lights on set. A key feature of faster film stocks? Grain. I'll do some poking around.I realize this is off topic but how's the Ghostbusters docs going? I don't visit the GB Fans site any more so not up to date with the Buenos documentaries.
sgtfbomb
10-12-2018, 05:44 AM
I realize this is off topic but how's the Ghostbusters docs going? I don't visit the GB Fans site any more so not up to date with the Buenos documentaries.
They announced on their FB pages that Cleanin' Up the Town is looking to hit right in time for the first film's 35th anniversary. So, knock on wood, it looks it's coming out next year, the first doc at least.
Andrew NDB
10-12-2018, 10:55 AM
So basically Barron finished shooting his movie and then wasn't allowed to be an editor? First of all, you generally don't have a director involved in the editing because they're not going to be objective. Second, how was he "fired"? Was Steve Barron at any point hired to be an editor? No. He was hired to direct the movie and he completed his job.
AquaParade
10-12-2018, 12:38 PM
So basically Barron finished shooting his movie and then wasn't allowed to be an editor? First of all, you generally don't have a director involved in the editing because they're not going to be objective. Second, how was he "fired"? Was Steve Barron at any point hired to be an editor? No. He was hired to direct the movie and he completed his job.
I'd think not having a director in the editing room is a recipe for disaster, but what do I know about filmmaking.
Shinigami
10-12-2018, 04:20 PM
I'd think not having a director in the editing room is a recipe for disaster, but what do I know about filmmaking.
It’s the polar opposite. An editor makes hard choices and a director is too attached to the stuff they shot to let it get cut. Ever noticed how while generally more informative, directors cuts usually suck.
Leo656
10-12-2018, 04:38 PM
directors cuts usually suck.
This has not been my experience. Almost every Director's Cut I've ever watched contained crucial pieces of plot and character development which were clearly cut for running time or to appease the ratings board, not to make the film any better.
It's entirely possible that we watch completely different kinds of films, but I'm curious what you're basing your opinion on.
I will say that the "Apocalypse Now" DC had a few slow spots, but so did the rest of the movie so it didn't really bother me. And the ending of the theatrical cut of "Legend" made more sense, while the rest of the movie was better served by the DC. That's all I can think of off the top of my head.
Andrew NDB
10-12-2018, 04:45 PM
It’s the polar opposite. An editor makes hard choices and a director is too attached to the stuff they shot to let it get cut.
Precisely.
sgtfbomb
10-12-2018, 09:19 PM
Whether or not a director has final cut is usually contractual and is often a luxury many directors have to fight for. Barron's work prior mostly consisted of music videos and a handful of episodes for Jim Henson's Storyteller. His only film prior to this was a lesser known film called Electric Dreams. The chances of him getting that luxury were probably slim.
A good director knows to "kill their babies" when they negatively impact the film. Not doing that isn't some overly generalized trait all directors have and there are a number of director's cuts that are better than the theatrical versions, including: Aliens, Blade Runner: The Final Cut, the entire Lord of the Rings trilogy, Dark City, The Abyss, Mimic, and although I'm partial to the 1977 theatrical cut, the general consensus is the director's cut of Close Encounters of the Third Kind is the best version. I'd even make arguments for The Frighteners and Nicholas Meyer's two Star Trek films. Plus, that number gets even larger when you consider the vast amount of films in which the theatrical cut is the director's cut.
Also, yes, directors do spend time in the editing room. Yes, the work is done by the editor, but directors do give input and are often involved in the editing of their film in some capacity.
EDIT: Of course, there are also a number of occasions in which directors such as Ridley Scott, Walter Hill, and George Lucas have gone back to some of their noteworthy films and delivered inferior versions. Things are very rarely generalized and all across the board as people claim. Sometimes something is good, sometimes it sucks.
d_osborn
10-12-2018, 11:37 PM
I realize this is off topic but how's the Ghostbusters docs going? I don't visit the GB Fans site any more so not up to date with the Buenos documentaries.
The GB docs are going REALLY well! Like the Sarge said above, the 2-hr version should be out by the 35th anniversary. I heard a sample of the score recently and it's KILLER. GBII is progressing really well.
Full throttle until the finish line. I wish there were more hours in the day.
Whether or not a director has final cut is usually contractual and is often a luxury many directors have to fight for. Barron's work prior mostly consisted of music videos and a handful of episodes for Jim Henson's Storyteller. His only film prior to this was a lesser known film called Electric Dreams. The chances of him getting that luxury were probably slim.
A good director knows to "kill their babies" when they negatively impact the film.
Exactly this. Every film is different. The director's job is to give direction. This isn't limited to actors-- production design, score, cinematography, etc. Big picture stuff. I'm sure Barron gave Menke plenty of direction in the first cut.
Golden Harvest just took over post-production on the film at a certain point. I kinda doubt it was anything dramatic. Barron did press for the film. It didn't sound like there was any bad blood at all.
Shinigami
10-18-2018, 04:59 PM
This has not been my experience. Almost every Director's Cut I've ever watched contained crucial pieces of plot and character development which were clearly cut for running time or to appease the ratings board, not to make the film any better.
It's entirely possible that we watch completely different kinds of films, but I'm curious what you're basing your opinion on.
I will say that the "Apocalypse Now" DC had a few slow spots, but so did the rest of the movie so it didn't really bother me. And the ending of the theatrical cut of "Legend" made more sense, while the rest of the movie was better served by the DC. That's all I can think of off the top of my head.
I’ll say Blade Runner is one of the only examples I feel this way about. I love Coppola’s cut of Apocalypse Now, but the added plot is wholly unnecessary and the movie is already a trash fire albeit a beautiful one. I’ve definitely watched his cut way more times than the original.
Leo656
10-18-2018, 05:38 PM
Seeing as how the entire film is about America's questionable military involvement in various places throughout history, the reinstated subplot in which a group of characters debate that very thing around the dinner table may be a bit slow and talky, but I'd argue that it's far from "wholly unnecessary". I don't know.
Frankly, if it were up to me every movie would be 5 hours long. So we're probably not gonna agree on much about what's "necessary" or not. :lol: I like movies, I especially like long movies, and I always appreciate getting as much as possible of something I already like.
I've only seen the "Final Cut" of Blade Runner, so I can't speak to it being better or worse than the original cut. My wife thought the movie was stupid, so I probably won't get to see it again anytime soon either way. I liked it; too slow for her. Sigh.
sgtfbomb
10-19-2018, 12:05 AM
I've only seen the "Final Cut" of Blade Runner, so I can't speak to it being better or worse than the original cut. My wife thought the movie was stupid, so I probably won't get to see it again anytime soon either way. I liked it; too slow for her. Sigh.
The theatrical cut included a narration that wasn't very good, although it does offer a few extra insights. The first "director's cut" was okay. It was the better version until the Final Cut. From what I understand, Ridley Scott as involved with the assembly of that cut as he was with the Final Cut, which perfectly the pacing of the film.
I've never watched the International Cut, so I am not sure how that particular version holds up.
Leo656
10-19-2018, 12:09 AM
Only having seen the Final Cut, and only once, I will say that it's a good movie, but a bit slow. I don't think it lives up to its reputation, necessarily, but then again nothing really does. I can see how some people might be disappointed with it.
Like I've heard a lot of people go into it and come out disappointed due to hearing about it's "masterpiece" status for several decades, and then when they see it it's like, "That's it?". That's why I try to remove myself from the hype before experiencing most things; helps me have more realistic expectations.
Haven't seen the recent sequel, since again, my wife didn't care for the original and everything I've heard about the new one suggests that it's the kinda movie I really like, and she really hates. But I'll pick it up one of these days and "force" her to watch it in exchange for me sitting through some junk starring Johnny Depp, or something.
Shinigami
10-19-2018, 09:51 AM
I've only seen the "Final Cut" of Blade Runner, so I can't speak to it being better or worse than the original cut. My wife thought the movie was stupid, so I probably won't get to see it again anytime soon either way. I liked it; too slow for her. Sigh.
The theatrical cut has a film noir voice over. In theory it could work, but it does not.
I personally agree with you on Apocalypse actually. I have a thing where I critically think something is bad, but personally enjoy it. My favorite Wes Anderson movie is The Life Aquatic and until Moonrise Kingdom, it was his worst film.
pferreira
10-20-2018, 03:58 PM
They announced on their FB pages that Cleanin' Up the Town is looking to hit right in time for the first film's 35th anniversary. So, knock on wood, it looks it's coming out next year, the first doc at least.
The GB docs are going REALLY well! Like the Sarge said above, the 2-hr version should be out by the 35th anniversary. I heard a sample of the score recently and it's KILLER. GBII is progressing really well.Great stuff. Any idea what year the Harold Ramis interview was conducted?
The theatrical cut included a narration that wasn't very good, although it does offer a few extra insights. The first "director's cut" was okay. It was the better version until the Final Cut. From what I understand, Ridley Scott as involved with the assembly of that cut as he was with the Final Cut, which perfectly the pacing of the film.I have to say I don't particularly care for the Final Cut and prefer the DC version. Scott fixed a couple of issues but also created a bunch of new ones like changing the colour grading and ruining the end credits theme music. DC all the way for me.
I've never watched the International Cut, so I am not sure how that particular version holds up.Not much different. It's the theatrical cut with a bit more extended violence. About five minutes difference if you call it that. The workprint version is cool to watch and not many people notice that watching the deleted scenes in entirety is essentially watching a totally different cut of the movie as well. It's about an hour I think.
So basically Barron finished shooting his movie and then wasn't allowed to be an editor? First of all, you generally don't have a director involved in the editing because they're not going to be objective. Second, how was he "fired"? Was Steve Barron at any point hired to be an editor? No. He was hired to direct the movie and he completed his job.That's not how it works. The director's job during the editing process is to sit down with the editor and basically go through the film piece by piece to put the film together. The director should have full creative control over the end product unless the producers somehow get in the way. In television it's slightly different: the director of each episode provides pointers to the editor and producers who then go and edit. The producers can choose to ignore any of these pointers and basically tell the editor what to do as they have full control over the end edit. Then the director looks over the final episode and pretty much most of the time goes "yeah it's 80% what I wanted". Unless you have producers in more power, have taken control over the movie due to distrust (Gilliam with Brazil) or you happen to be called 'Sean Connery' those are the only ways the director will not have a say over final edit.
d_osborn
10-22-2018, 08:46 PM
Great stuff. Any idea what year the Harold Ramis interview was conducted?
I wanna say 2008 or 2009.
I haven't even seen the BR FINAL CUT. That needs to be remedied.
pferreira
10-26-2018, 04:07 PM
I wanna say 2008 or 2009. Thanks for that clarification.
I haven't even seen the BR FINAL CUT. That needs to be remedied.You might like it. It didn't do much for me.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.