View Full Version : Movie blurays
cammy85
06-15-2018, 09:21 AM
Hey, all!! Who here has had experience with this movie Blu-ray set?
https://www.bestbuy.ca/en-ca/product/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-movie-1990-dvd/m2162497.aspx?
I've heard mixed reviews after the fact which I should've read first. It was either this or a four part DVD set. Who else has this that could shed some light on it? Thanks. :)
sgtfbomb
06-15-2018, 11:07 PM
Hey, all!! Who here has had experience with this movie Blu-ray set?
https://www.bestbuy.ca/en-ca/product/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-movie-1990-dvd/m2162497.aspx?
I've heard mixed reviews after the fact which I should've read first. It was either this or a four part DVD set. Who else has this that could shed some light on it? Thanks. :)
The 4 Film Favorites (Blu Ray) and the Blu Ray gift set are the same discs. The transfers aren't perfect, but they are far better than the DVD editions.
For some reason, people think "Blu Ray" means "no grain," but the grain is a part of the film. In the case of the first film, it is the result of the dark, moody photography, and I believe the heavy grain during the flashback shots were a stylistic choice. However, the noise, which is sometimes confused with grain, is not as prominent as it was on the DVD version. (On the DVD, when Casey sneaks into the warehouse, the shot had so much noise, it had the same quality as watching a basic channel with bad reception on a tube television.)
Heavy grain on origin story was because Steve used 16mm film on it as stylistic choice to make it old but producers werent that happy about it and it almost didnt made it to the film.Normally its shot on 35mm.
First movie is dark because comics were and its was great choice.
cammy85
06-16-2018, 03:18 PM
The 4 Film Favorites (Blu Ray) and the Blu Ray gift set are the same discs. The transfers aren't perfect, but they are far better than the DVD editions.
For some reason, people think "Blu Ray" means "no grain," but the grain is a part of the film. In the case of the first film, it is the result of the dark, moody photography, and I believe the heavy grain during the flashback shots were a stylistic choice. However, the noise, which is sometimes confused with grain, is not as prominent as it was on the DVD version. (On the DVD, when Casey sneaks into the warehouse, the shot had so much noise, it had the same quality as watching a basic channel with bad reception on a tube television.)
Heavy grain on origin story was because Steve used 16mm film on it as stylistic choice to make it old but producers werent that happy about it and it almost didnt made it to the film.Normally its shot on 35mm.
First movie is dark because comics were and its was great choice.
Thanks, guys!! Yeah, I figured it's just part of the charm/transfer. I'm happy just to have them. I also read that Splinter's story to Danny in the first movie has a lost of sound issues too for example.
cloud
07-15-2018, 12:00 PM
I like the release. Best resolution so far with all 3 movies.
Too bad there's no bonus material with them not even short interviews or TV spots.
Welmanshire
08-18-2018, 10:51 PM
Watching SOTO on Bluray right now. Pleasantly surprised by the quality of it. Noticing a lot of detail in the picture that I hadn't before.
The cover is terrible though -
https://www.jbhifi.co.nz/FileLibrary/ProductResources/Images/61574-L-HI.jpg
TigerClaw
08-19-2018, 07:56 AM
I have the 3 original movies on Blu-Ray as well. But they did a poor job on the transfer. You have that film grain all over it. Its like they didn't do any cleaning after the transfer. They just transferred straight from the film and did nothing else with it. Movies today don't have that film grain since they digitally remaster them.
raph27
08-19-2018, 12:29 PM
I have the 3 original movies on Blu-Ray as well. But they did a poor job on the transfer. You have that film grain all over it. Its like they didn't do any cleaning after the transfer. They just transferred straight from the film and did nothing else with it. Movies today don't have that film grain since they digitally remaster them.
Literally on the same page. Five posts above yours. Not too hard to find:
The 4 Film Favorites (Blu Ray) and the Blu Ray gift set are the same discs. The transfers aren't perfect, but they are far better than the DVD editions.
For some reason, people think "Blu Ray" means "no grain," but the grain is a part of the film. In the case of the first film, it is the result of the dark, moody photography, and I believe the heavy grain during the flashback shots were a stylistic choice.
sgtfbomb
08-21-2018, 08:15 PM
If you think the Blu Ray is bad, check out the DVD version. It had a horrendous amount of noise. The scene where Casey sneaks into the warehouse looked like it was recorded off the USA Network on a crummy tube television with bad reception. The Blu Ray is a godsend compared to that.
Let's face it, the first movie will never look like a contemporary film. There are a number of contributors: the film stock, the lighting, some of it may even be by choice. Personally, I like it. It gives the film a gritty street vibe, kind of like The Warriors.
pferreira
09-13-2018, 10:30 AM
I have the 3 original movies on Blu-Ray as well. But they did a poor job on the transfer. You have that film grain all over it. Its like they didn't do any cleaning after the transfer. They just transferred straight from the film and did nothing else with it. Movies today don't have that film grain since they digitally remaster them.Apparently according to one site (blu-ray.com?) the second film suffers the worst.
THRILLHO
10-26-2019, 11:38 PM
so is the 4-film favorites bluray the best picture quality available on blu of the original 2 films? i own the trilogy on dvd and the 07 on blu but would double dip if these are the best available. i have an all region player so i'm not looking for strictly american releases.
TigerClaw
10-27-2019, 10:18 AM
These movies need to be re-released and put out on 4K Blu-Ray. But they gotta clean them up. Because they would look 10x worst in 4k resolution.
These movies need to be re-released and put out on 4K Blu-Ray. But they gotta clean them up. Because they would look 10x worst in 4k resolution.
I've never understood people who adamantly argue that they love film grain. I lost any taste for it, even in the smallest doses, the first time I watched my copy of 300 on HD-DVD during the 1080p format wars days.
And it drives me nuts when it resurfaces - my copy of the Fifth Element on Bluray looked better in 1080p than the 4k transfer I picked up.
THRILLHO
10-27-2019, 11:00 PM
I've never understood people who adamantly argue that they love film grain. I lost any taste for it, even in the smallest doses, the first time I watched my copy of 300 on HD-DVD during the 1080p format wars days.
And it drives me nuts when it resurfaces - my copy of the Fifth Element on Bluray looked better in 1080p than the 4k transfer I picked up.
some of us dont like the actors to look like wax figures.
some of us dont like the actors to look like wax figures.
Hm. I don't like that either. But I've never experienced that on my setup, either in cinema replication or in a high frame rate. Strange.
By the way, welcome to the boards. Four posts in and you are already part of the vitriol poster crowd, with that tonality. -big thumb's up- Nice work!
THRILLHO
10-28-2019, 10:05 AM
Hm. I don't like that either. But I've never experienced that on my setup, either in cinema replication or in a high frame rate. Strange.
By the way, welcome to the boards. Four posts in and you are already part of the vitriol poster crowd, with that tonality. -big thumb's up- Nice work!
Predator and T2 are huge examples of this. so bad that they were redone by the studios.
vitriol? you're an extremist. you're the first i've heard of the "no grain please ever" crowd. it doesnt look like a movie at that point. 300 is nearly entirely green screen anyways, it looks like a video game on par with the prequels.
Ninjinister
10-28-2019, 05:01 PM
Since Blu-Rays have massive storage, I think the best thing to do for like an "essential" release would be to have both a good original transfer and a cleaned-up version. That way there's options for who want either/or, or to make a comparison. I feel that way for most things that are released on more modern formats where there would be enough room for both the original presentation and a remaster. Of course, they'd have to factor in whether it's worth it for them to do it, but if they're doing the remaster anyway it'd be less of a tough choice.
THRILLHO
10-28-2019, 05:03 PM
Since Blu-Rays have massive storage, I think the best thing to do for like an "essential" release would be to have both a good original transfer and a cleaned-up version. That way there's options for who want either/or, or to make a comparison. I feel that way for most things that are released on more modern formats where there would be enough room for both the original presentation and a remaster. Of course, they'd have to factor in whether it's worth it for them to do it, but if they're doing the remaster anyway it'd be less of a tough choice.
this reminds me of the SW original trilogy special editions dvds that included the unaltered originals as a bonus feature.
mikey0
10-28-2019, 06:15 PM
Watching SOTO on Bluray right now. Pleasantly surprised by the quality of it. Noticing a lot of detail in the picture that I hadn't before.
The cover is terrible though -
https://www.jbhifi.co.nz/FileLibrary/ProductResources/Images/61574-L-HI.jpg
The cover is great for fans of the 1991 and 1993 TMNT sequels. Surprised Paige Turco from either sequel was not on the cover.
vitriol? you're an extremist. you're the first i've heard of the "no grain please ever" crowd. it doesnt look like a movie at that point. 300 is nearly entirely green screen anyways, it looks like a video game on par with the prequels.
Did you just call me an extremist because I don't prefer film grain? :lol:
Go create a thread where you post your home theater calibration (if you're old enough to actually own a home theater, which I'm guessing is no). All of your settings are probably at ten.
Since Blu-Rays have massive storage, I think the best thing to do for like an "essential" release would be to have both a good original transfer and a cleaned-up version. That way there's options for who want either/or, or to make a comparison. I feel that way for most things that are released on more modern formats where there would be enough room for both the original presentation and a remaster. Of course, they'd have to factor in whether it's worth it for them to do it, but if they're doing the remaster anyway it'd be less of a tough choice.
Sounds like a great idea for a modern rebranding of the Superbit or Criterion collections....... One of the best releases akin to what you are getting at would still be Blade Runner's HD was release. The 4k transfer of the film is nice and not overly grainy -ahem-, but you can't beat the content in that 1080p release....
THRILLHO
10-28-2019, 11:43 PM
Did you just call me an extremist because I don't prefer film grain? :lol:
Go create a thread where you post your home theater calibration (if you're old enough to actually own a home theater, which I'm guessing is no). All of your settings are probably at ten.
Sounds like a great idea for a modern rebranding of the Superbit or Criterion collections....... One of the best releases akin to what you are getting at would still be Blade Runner's HD was release. The 4k transfer of the film is nice and not overly grainy -ahem-, but you can't beat the content in that 1080p release....
no i called you an extremist based on your assumptions about me based on one snarky comment i made, that was vitriol in your definition apparently.
i'd post my home theater info and age but hey, you already know all about me so that's redundant right?
Ninjinister
10-30-2019, 11:43 PM
Sounds like a great idea for a modern rebranding of the Superbit or Criterion collections....... One of the best releases akin to what you are getting at would still be Blade Runner's HD was release. The 4k transfer of the film is nice and not overly grainy -ahem-, but you can't beat the content in that 1080p release....
Yeah Criterion was what I had in mind. I mean it'd be a long shot to see one specifically for TMNT, since it's ultra-niche and not even film nerd niche. I mean we still don't even have a Director's Cut in most countries.
long shot to see one specifically for TMNT, since it's ultra-niche and not even film nerd niche.
It shouldn't be this way either. For example, if people allegedly have all sorts of strange film respect for The Dark Crystal - an uncompelling morbid puppet show of strangeness - then the original TMNT flick should have some clout for the at-the-time cutting edge puppetry and pretty solid urban narrative & cinematography.
But then again, I suppose if that happened then film snobs would sort of have to acknowledge Garbage Pail Kids by proxy and we know that isn't going to happen, soooo......
:lol:
Ninjinister
10-31-2019, 08:24 PM
It shouldn't be this way either. For example, if people allegedly have all sorts of strange film respect for The Dark Crystal - an uncompelling morbid puppet show of strangeness - then the original TMNT flick should have some clout for the at-the-time cutting edge puppetry and pretty solid urban narrative & cinematography.
But then again, I suppose if that happened then film snobs would sort of have to acknowledge Garbage Pail Kids by proxy and we know that isn't going to happen, soooo......
:lol:
If I remember right, it was also the highest-grossing indie film of all time up to that point.
I do think I personally would argue it has historical and artistic merit, but Turtles is always considered small fish even in contexts where it dominated.
d_osborn
10-31-2019, 10:09 PM
https://i.imgur.com/WVGzcID.jpg
There's precedent for non-art house releases by Criterion. Hell, there's a Criterion DVD for The Rock!
And they wouldn't get rid of the grain! :D
LOL!
I don't mind film grain as much as was perceived by that other dufus. But my point was take a movie like 300, where film grain was introduced to the film as an artistic measure and then greatly exacerbated by high-def.
I just don't like it to overwhelm the image because it reduces verisimilitude and takes you out of the immersion of the story.
d_osborn
10-31-2019, 10:26 PM
To each their own!
From what I understand, the film is so grainy in parts due to Golden Harvest pushing the film exposure because they thought it was too dark. "Pushing" is the process of leaving it in the chemical bath longer, making the image brighter AND grainy.
Whoever our hero publisher is, I hope they hire Isaac and the Definitive Film "TURTLE POWER" guys to produce the supplemental content.
sgtfbomb
11-03-2019, 10:58 AM
There's precedent for non-art house releases by Criterion. Hell, there's a Criterion DVD for The Rock!
And they wouldn't get rid of the grain! :D
It's been a while since I've seen Criterion handle films like The Rock and Armageddon.
I'd imagine, if anyone, it would Shout Factory. They're currently licensing titles from WB and have a history of doing of like-titles, such as Power Rangers and Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation. They've also delivered long-requested alternate cuts, like Nightbreed and Exorcist III.
Plus, they'd most likely handle all 3 films.
Then again, Warner Archives has been stepping up a little. About a year or so ago, they released the 3-hour cut of Superman and recently they released the international cut of Mr. Nice Guy, which is a Golden Harvest title.
To each their own!
From what I understand, the film is so grainy in parts due to Golden Harvest pushing the film exposure because they thought it was too dark.
This was an interesting factoid I hadn't heard before. -thumb's up-
sgtfbomb
11-05-2019, 11:41 AM
Even with the exposure push, the 1990 film has arguably the best cinematography of the series. With its use of shadows and natural lighting in the farm scenes, it gives the film a sense of rawness (the extreme graininess is straight up punk rock-ish at times, flashbacks especially) and compliments the creature designs in a way its successors never did. To me, it's still the only film where it genuinely feels like the Turtles are in the real world.
d_osborn
11-05-2019, 12:03 PM
Even with the exposure push, the 1990 film has arguably the best cinematography of the series. With its use of shadows and natural lighting in the farm scenes, it gives the film a sense of rawness (the extreme graininess is straight up punk rock-ish at times, flashbacks especially) and compliments the creature designs in a way its predecessors never did. To me, it's still the only film where it genuinely feels like the Turtles are in the real world.
110%. The DP and Barron did a lot of testing to give it that exact feel, too. It's a shame they didn't stick with the look for SOTO.
pferreira
11-08-2019, 04:24 PM
Predator and T2 are huge examples of this. so bad that they were redone by the studios.They didn't even get it right with T2. The whole thing has been drenched in a vat of teal! The horror...why does every film have to be filtered in teal today? :-?
LOL!I don't mind film grain as much as was perceived by that other dufus. But my point was take a movie like 300, where film grain was introduced to the film as an artistic measure and then greatly exacerbated by high-def.But wasn't 300 shot digitally? I mean I'm pretty sure it would have no grain if it wasn't shot on film. :-?
From what I understand, the film is so grainy in parts due to Golden Harvest pushing the film exposure because they thought it was too dark. "Pushing" is the process of leaving it in the chemical bath longer, making the image brighter AND grainy. From what I understand the first movie is very grainy because that film was shot with Golden Harvest's standard film stock. It ended up looking unsurprisingly like one of their martial arts movies. When the first movie took off they then had the money to use better film stock for the sequels.
Yeah Criterion was what I had in mind. I mean it'd be a long shot to see one specifically for TMNT, since it's ultra-niche and not even film nerd niche. I mean we still don't even have a Director's Cut in most countries.If you look at the stuff Shout Factory in the US release or Arrow in the UK release a lot of that stuff makes the 90s TMNT famous as hell. If that really obscure stuff can get a 4K or 2K scan with tons of extras these movies can as well as they're more well known.
But wasn't 300 shot digitally? I mean I'm pretty sure it would have no grain if it wasn't shot on film. :-?
That's why I said verbatim that it was introduced to the film as an artistic measure. That one in particular looked fine and carried the vibe in the theater, but under HD it's completely over saturated.
sgtfbomb
11-09-2019, 06:28 PM
They didn't even get it right with T2. The whole thing has been drenched in a vat of teal! The horror...why does every film have to be filtered in teal today? :-?
It is awful and even worse when you view the other cuts of the film, which intercut the new transfer with the old.
I love 4K and HDR, but the need to check off the later by giving it those ugly teal/orange gradings is a real turn off.
pferreira
11-27-2019, 03:32 PM
It is awful and even worse when you view the other cuts of the film, which intercut the new transfer with the old.
I love 4K and HDR, but the need to check off the later by giving it those ugly teal/orange gradings is a real turn off.I held off buying it. I will wait for Cameron or another studio to do the film justice. :)
d_osborn
11-27-2019, 09:11 PM
From what I understand the first movie is very grainy because that film was shot with Golden Harvest's standard film stock. It ended up looking unsurprisingly like one of their martial arts movies. When the first movie took off they then had the money to use better film stock for the sequels.
Barron discussed Golden Harvest pushing the exposure on an old podcast-- I believe I have the file. I have no doubt that a cheap film stock was used. Other than the creature FX, TMNT 90 was low budget.
SOTO looks wildly different for a variety of reasons-- different director, different DP, larger budget (better stock), producer notes/direction/demands, etc.
That one in particular looked fine and carried the vibe in the theater, but under HD it's completely over saturated.
Is your TV calibrated?
Slap-Happy
11-29-2019, 05:30 AM
Heavy grain on origin story was because Steve used 16mm film on it as stylistic choice to make it old but producers werent that happy about it and it almost didnt made it to the film.Normally its shot on 35mm.
First movie is dark because comics were and its was great choice.
Just to set the record straight, the first film was not shot on 16mm, it is still 35 albeit occasionally very grainy. There is a depth to the images of most shots that simply isn’t there with 16mm.
Barron discussed Golden Harvest pushing the exposure on an old podcast-- I believe I have the file. I have no doubt that a cheap film stock was used. Other than the creature FX, TMNT 90 was low budget.
SOTO looks wildly different for a variety of reasons-- different director, different DP, larger budget (better stock), producer notes/direction/demands, etc.
Is your TV calibrated?
It is indeed calibrated. I use a THX HD optimizer (can be found on several discs) as a base calibration, then Sony line resolution tools (can be found on select discs) along with a more recent Spears and Munsil (you'd have to buy that, but you knew that, right?) deep color HD gradient to match modern color delivery. I have a photometer and laser measure for distances and ambient room lighting, but I barely break those out anymore after the initial use both at home and for a few friends and some family as well. Home theater is a past time of mine, my friend. I've come {this} close to adding a wing under my LLC to start an installation and calibration business, but I'm too busy with my store efforts and properties.
Is your TV calibrated?
Because if you really are knowledgeable about home theater, then it would make more sense to be discussing the HD transfer of 300 just as we have discussed the production of TMNT '90 (the only tangible examples I've cited) before asking me about whether or not my entire TV was calibrated. And even then after hammering out the HD transfers of 300, you should be asking me about how I attenuate sharpness instead of whether or not the entire TV is calibrated. I mean, we are talking about film grain. Not refresh rate, or fine line quality or verisimilitude of shadowing. But film grain.
Just to set the record straight, the first film was not shot on 16mm, it is still 35 albeit occasionally very grainy. There is a depth to the images of most shots that simply isn’t there with 16mm.
Factoid #2 that I didn't know about TMNT '90. Very cool stuff, when the conversation is normalized.
d_osborn
11-29-2019, 01:00 PM
It is indeed calibrated. I use a THX HD optimizer (can be found on several discs) as a base calibration, then Sony line resolution tools (can be found on select discs) along with a more recent Spears and Munsil (you'd have to buy that, but you knew that, right?) deep color HD gradient to match modern color delivery. I have a photometer and laser measure for distances and ambient room lighting, but I barely break those out anymore after the initial use, and having done calibration for a few friends and some family as well. Home theater is a past time of mine, my friend. I've come {this} close to adding a wing under my LLC to start an installation and calibration business, but I'm too busy with my store efforts and properties.
Is your TV calibrated?
Because if you really are knowledgeable about home theater, then it would make more sense to be discussing the HD transfer of 300 just as we have discussed the production of TMNT '90 (the only tangible examples I've cited) before asking me about whether or not my entire TV was calibrated. And even then after hammering out the HD transfers of 300, you should be asking me about how I attenuate sharpness instead of whether or not the entire TV is calibrated. I mean, we are talking about film grain. Not refresh rate, or fine line quality or verisimilitude of shadowing. But film grain.
Easy killer! :D If you really are knowledgeable about home theater, then you would know a large bulk of people complaining about over-saturation simply didn’t calibrate. :)
I haven’t seen 300 in a LONG time (and don’t really have a desire to), so I have no skin in the game there. I actually gave up the home theater hobby, as well, about ten years ago. I was getting too deep into technical details rather than simply enjoying movies. I was looking at weak points in my setup rather than admiring gorgeous cinematography.
I save my technical richard-waving for cameras and lenses and grip gear, oh my. Even that’s starting to get a bit blasé. The DP at my production company handles my screen calibration.
Just out of curiosity, what kind of store do you run?
Just to set the record straight, the first film was not shot on 16mm, it is still 35 albeit occasionally very grainy. There is a depth to the images of most shots that simply isn’t there with 16mm.
From what I understand, Barron had Brian Henson shoot the second unit flashback sequences on 16mm.
sgtfbomb
12-29-2019, 02:54 PM
From what I understand, Barron had Brian Henson shoot the second unit flashback sequences on 16mm.
Which I think is a great choice. The extra grain from the blow up from 16 to 35 plus the minimalist look of the scene really cranks up that "urban punk" vibe the film carries. I can't imagine it without the grain. The film would look too basic, too clean.
pferreira
03-05-2020, 01:10 PM
Which I think is a great choice. The extra grain from the blow up from 16 to 35 plus the minimalist look of the scene really cranks up that "urban punk" vibe the film carries. I can't imagine it without the grain. The film would look too basic, too clean.Got around to watching the TV series Street Hawk on DVD and even for DVD it looks as grainy as hell yet it gives it that gritty urban street feel so that may have been a choice at the time.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.