PDA

View Full Version : TMNT III or Out of the Shadows, which is the bigger pile of crap?


neatoman
03-18-2019, 04:37 PM
So I can't quite decide which one is is worse.

TMNT III is hardly a good movie by any means. It's horribly paced, it's full of jokes that fall flat and the quality of the puppetry dropped quite signifigantly from the previous movies. The time travel mechanics are very poorly explained and the story is just uninteresting. However, I ultimately just find the movie really boring, it's certainly bad but all it does is make me want to fall asleep.

Out of the Shadows might technically win out in terms of special effects and technically having better pacing. However, unlike TMNT III, it doesn't just bore me. It actively made me angry watching it, in addition to being boring. The Turtles and April are more or less unchanged from the previous PD movie, which is hardly a plus. Shredder feels generic as hell. Krang comes out of nowhere, is given no explaination, is pretty cringeworthy and gets the big fight scene at the end despite barely being in the movie. Casey is a bland shell of himself. Then there's Bebop and Rocksteady, who might possibly be the worst characters in any TMNT movie ever and wish the movie's failure means we'll never see them in another movie ever again. The plot is pure nonsense, everything either makes you wish there was an explaination or the explaination is so stupid you wish there was none. The movie could possibly be a simulation of what it's like to experience hell.

So what do you think? Boredom or Anger? Which is worse?

Leo656
03-18-2019, 04:51 PM
TMNT III was a bit of a slog, and the overall execution wasn't good, but there's still a little bit of heart to it. You can tell that a group of people who were lacking in money and technical skill really tried to make the best movie they could within the circumstances.

"Out of the Shadows" was nothing but a superficial fan-wank toy commercial, A-to-the-Z. No heart, no funk, no soul. Just 'Member Berries and Run D.M.C.

TMNT III frustrates me, and it's objectively not "good", but the BayTurtles films create a very real anger inside of me that III or even II fall short of.

FredWolfLeonardo
03-18-2019, 05:03 PM
As a whole, I think tmnt 3 is better.

I really enjoy parts of Out of the Shadows such as those with Krang, Baxter, Bebop and Rocksteady.

But I have to sit through parts featuring Casey Jones, April and that lady officer, just to get to them, so its really a mixed bag.

Atleast the entirety of turtles 3 is more consistent.

Andrew NDB
03-18-2019, 06:11 PM
The entire Uwe Boll collection, Batman & Robin, Gigli, Ishtar, + Son of the Mask > OotS

Candy Kappa
03-18-2019, 06:14 PM
Hands down, OotS is the worst movie of the two.

sdp
03-18-2019, 06:23 PM
I voted incorrectly, I meant to say III: Turtles in Time was worse. Yeah OOTS has problems but at least following the story is more interesting than the snoozefest that is III: Turtles in Time.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-18-2019, 06:28 PM
To me, the worst is the Secret of the Ooze because it ruined the extraterrestrial origin of the mutagen. After all, that's what was supposed to be the secret (it could still have been an accident).

sdp
03-18-2019, 06:33 PM
The original never said the mutagen was alien so it doesn't ruing anything, also the second one doesn't show if the scientist is really an Utrom, he was intended to be before the idea was scrapped but he could still be an Utrom and we just didn't see that happen in the film. Same headcanon says the time scepter from the third movie was held by Renet we just don't see her.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-18-2019, 06:41 PM
The original never said the mutagen was alien so it doesn't ruing anything, also the second one doesn't show if the scientist is really an Utrom, he was intended to be before the idea was scrapped but he could still be an Utrom and we just didn't see that happen in the film. Same headcanon says the time scepter from the third movie was held by Renet we just don't see her.

Jordan Perry doesn't need to be an Utrom himself, but he could have been their link to Humans (like April O'Neil is for the turtles).

pferreira
03-21-2019, 10:01 AM
I voted wrong but I meant to choose OotS. In a way the PD sequel hangs together better than TMNT III however the third movie still exists within the original movie universe so it at least to some extent feels like a better movie. Plus III's location direction and cinematography is way better than OotS. I would say neither is the weakest TMNT movie, that honour goes to the first PD movie or the 2007 movie. III and OotS aren't great movies but there are things to enjoy in both.

RaphaelinSTL
03-22-2019, 10:11 AM
Out of the Shadows is easily the worse movie of the two as TMNT III at least has this fun "so bad, it's good" quality to it like Batman & Robin does. I can laugh at TMNT III for its dumb rules for the time scepter, horrible puppetry and "made for TV" cinematography cause it's cheap and harmless.

Out of the Shadows is loud, noisy, has an expensive but a waste of money look about it and fundamentally breaks a lot of fun elements of TMNT lore.

Andrew NDB
03-22-2019, 11:25 AM
To me, the worst is the Secret of the Ooze because it ruined the extraterrestrial origin of the mutagen.

You mean you don't like that we all have animal DNA in us? Like, maybe I have trace amounts of dachshund.

Prowler
03-22-2019, 11:47 AM
You mean you don't like that we all have animal DNA in us? Like, maybe I have trace amounts of dachshund.
We share about 95-99 percent of our genes with a lot of ape and monkey species. 95% with chimpanzees and 97% with orangutans iirc.

RaphaelinSTL
03-22-2019, 11:55 AM
You mean you don't like that we all have animal DNA in us? Like, maybe I have trace amounts of dachshund.

"mahhhhhh mannnnn"

Andrew NDB
03-22-2019, 12:44 PM
We share about 95-99 percent of our genes with a lot of ape and monkey species. 95% with chimpanzees and 97% with orangutans iirc.

But not rhinos and warthogs? Waittaminute here...

neatoman
03-22-2019, 12:58 PM
We share about 95-99 percent of our genes with a lot of ape and monkey species. 95% with chimpanzees and 97% with orangutans iirc.

But we don't have what's in that 1-5% remaining, nor does the monkey's have what we do, that's what makes us different.

The reason we humans, rhinos, warthogs, turtles and rats is because of divergent evolution. They can all be traced back to the same lifeform but the paths can't really remerge once they take on incompatible traits, that's when they become noticably different (like fingers and hooves).

The only way the movie's explaination makes any sense is if you don't think evolution works like tree branches, but rather like train tracks or adding ingredients to a soup.

Prowler
03-22-2019, 03:35 PM
But not rhinos and warthogs? Waittaminute here...

We probably do, but dunno how much we share with them.

neatoman
03-22-2019, 03:40 PM
We probably do, but dunno how much we share with them.

Not enough to grow horns or hooves. In fact, virtually no features emblematic of them would be present in human DNA.

pferreira
03-23-2019, 06:04 PM
Out of the Shadows is easily the worse movie of the two as TMNT III at least has this fun "so bad, it's good" quality to it like Batman & Robin does. I can laugh at TMNT III for its dumb rules for the time scepter, horrible puppetry and "made for TV" cinematography cause it's cheap and harmless.Ooooo okay wouldn't go that far, all three movies you mentioned have good (positive) things about them but I respect where you're coming from. :)

Leo656
03-23-2019, 06:06 PM
Did you seriously just imply there's anything good about "Batman & Robin"?

C'mon. COME ON.

DarkFell
03-25-2019, 10:21 PM
I think that despite the cheese, TMNT 3 had a story plot in there somewhere.

I still haven't had the desire to buy OOTS, or even the first BayTurtles movie.

Leo656
03-25-2019, 10:29 PM
Me neither, and they're positively clogging up every $5 bin I see.

Not worth it. I can buy a chicken caesar wrap for that and still have change left over.

Andrew NDB
03-26-2019, 12:52 AM
Buy? I still haven't even watched OotS yet, with no plans existing ever to do so.

I'll watch it if someone wants to pay me to probably spit bile over it for an hour and a half.

snake
03-26-2019, 01:18 AM
Is is even a goddamned question? I’d watch TMNT3 100 times in a row before touching OOTS again.

neatoman
03-26-2019, 08:58 AM
I refuse to buy OotS. I only bought the first PD movie on DVD to get a discount on 9 movies I actually wanted when a local video rental went out of business, but I would not do the same for OotS.

Redeemer
03-26-2019, 10:01 AM
TMNT II should be in this discussion... it is by far a worse movie than TMNT III

Voltron
03-28-2019, 04:09 AM
Oh, man. You and I are going to have to disagree, there. TMNT II wasn't anywhere near as good as the original, but it's also no where near as bad as III.

I'm voting for OotS, because I found the characterization in it lacking. The Turtles need to have their personalities shine through better. They're so wonderfully deep and nuanced. Everyone has their favorite, and I feel that a lot of that has to do with the personality they exude.

Bay missed the mark on that. He basically just switched out the Transformers for the TMNT. They're waaaay too big and weird looking, too. Too much was happening in the design. It's distracting.

III was crap, yes, but it still preserved the charm of the guys.

Andrew NDB
03-28-2019, 10:51 AM
II was the mortal wound to the film franchise. III was the bullet to the brain, the mercy kill. Everything after is experiments in suck.

oldmanwinters
03-28-2019, 12:58 PM
II was the mortal wound to the film franchise.

Do you think things could have gone differently if "Ninja Rap" was never born? :tlol:

pferreira
03-28-2019, 08:09 PM
Did you seriously just imply there's anything good about "Batman & Robin"?

C'mon. COME ON.I tell you something. When I first watched the film I couldn't even make it all the way through. It was just too much excess of everything and nothing exciting or interesting about it. However some years back I caught a bit of the movie and I realised that in five or ten minute doses the film isn't that bad, it's just watching the whole thing feels very uninspiring and excessive. There are good moments in Batman & Robin but not enough. I also can't ignore that the film is competently made in terms of production. The visual effects are high quality, shame about the script. :ohwell:

Do you think things could have gone differently if "Ninja Rap" was never born? :tlol:Is the film only known just for that scene??? I mean that's not the only thing that comes to mind when I remember the sequel.

TMNT II should be in this discussion... it is by far a worse movie than TMNT IIIhttps://thumbs.gfycat.com/TornDefinitiveIzuthrush-small.gif

Leo656
03-28-2019, 09:05 PM
I've only ever even SEEN "Batman & Robin" in 5/10-minute doses - by now I'm sure I've seen the entire thing, though, just out of order - and it's STILL one of the 5 Worst Movies I've Ever Seen. "Meet The Feebles" ranks higher. "Teenage Catgirls In Heat", though, I'd have to get back to you on.


Is the film only known just for that scene??? I mean that's not the only thing that comes to mind when I remember the sequel.


For 99% of people, yes.

Find a random person on the street, ask them if they've seen TMNT II, and if they have, they'll either bust out the "Ninja Rap", yell "COMBAT COLDCUTS!", OR, bungle the "Traditional Pre-Fight Donuts" line.

That's all anyone remembers from SotO.

pferreira
03-29-2019, 06:51 PM
I've only ever even SEEN "Batman & Robin" in 5/10-minute doses - by now I'm sure I've seen the entire thing, though, just out of order - and it's STILL one of the 5 Worst Movies I've Ever Seen.I mean I can't really argue the effects are bad. It has some nice moments as well. There are many worse films for me you'd have to pay me to rewatch five minutes of. :lol:

Find a random person on the street, ask them if they've seen TMNT II, and if they have, they'll either bust out the "Ninja Rap", yell "COMBAT COLDCUTS!", OR, bungle the "Traditional Pre-Fight Donuts" line.

That's all anyone remembers from SotO.I remember the film really well, I guess because I enjoyed it. Watched it tons as a kid. Still a fun movie for me on rewatch. :)

Leo656
03-29-2019, 10:59 PM
I've seen it hundreds of times but even as a kid I recall feeling a tremendous sense of letdown. Because ain't no way anyone can argue that it's a good follow-up to the first movie. An "acceptable" kids movie in and of itself if you pretend the 1990 film never happened? Fair enough. But going from TMNT 1990 into "Secret of the Ooze" is like listening to Metallica's "Load" record right after listening to "Kill 'Em All". They don't fit together and have NOTHING in common, even if they're supposedly in the same universe. And I actually like "Load" quite a lot, but I fully confess that it sounds a lot better if you pretend a different band recorded it.

I wanted more of what I got in the first movie. I still want that. I'm never, ever going to get that, and I haaaaaaaaaate that fact more than I hate goddamn disco.

So yeah, even to 9-year-old me, Part II was a misfire. It literally only "works" if you ignore the far-superior prequel, and WHY would anyone do that? Why would ANYONE say, "Y'know, to hell with your filet mignon, I think I'd rather eat a Sack O'Ten from White Castle and spend the next three days sh*tting blood." Who DOES that?

FredWolfLeonardo
03-29-2019, 11:13 PM
If most kids were able to pretend that Razhar and Tokka were a Pig and a Rhino, I'm sure they were able to enjoy SoTo just as much as the first film.

Leo656
03-30-2019, 12:10 AM
Kids, perhaps. Kids also eat boogers and forget to not poop themselves.

Nobody should let what kids enjoy be any kind of objective standard of quality, and that really should go without saying.

ZariusTwo
04-02-2019, 08:08 AM
I tell you something. When I first watched the film I couldn't even make it all the way through. It was just too much excess of everything and nothing exciting or interesting about it. However some years back I caught a bit of the movie and I realised that in five or ten minute doses the film isn't that bad, it's just watching the whole thing feels very uninspiring and excessive. There are good moments in Batman & Robin but not enough.

The Alfred sub-plot and Dick and Bruce's rift is great, and the third act ain't too bad. Also, again, great soundtrack. It could probably fare better today in a world resistant to Zack Snyder and very accepting of risk free quip-before-edge Marvel movies.

Whatswiththeheadbands?
04-02-2019, 10:11 AM
TMNT III. Why?

Because it belonged to a movie series that showed so much promise at the start, and only got worse. Every time I see anything from SOTO or III, I think "this is supposed to be the same universe as TMNT 1990?" then I get mildly sad

OTTS was objectively worse as a film, but it was the sequel to an equally terrible first film,so the quality didn't decrease or increase, it stayed the same

Leo656
04-02-2019, 05:40 PM
The Alfred sub-plot and Dick and Bruce's rift is great, and the third act ain't too bad. Also, again, great soundtrack. It could probably fare better today in a world resistant to Zack Snyder and very accepting of risk free quip-before-edge Marvel movies.

If "Batman and Robin" came out tomorrow exactly as it is it would make $2.4 billion dollars.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-02-2019, 07:03 PM
If "Batman and Robin" came out tomorrow exactly as it is it would make $2.4 billion dollars.

Even with nipples?

CyberCubed
04-02-2019, 08:25 PM
TMNT III is basically "Citizen Kane" compared to Michael Bay's nostril Turtle movies.

Leo656
04-02-2019, 08:36 PM
Even with nipples?

People would love it. "This movie revels in its own stupidity, the way ALL comic book films should know well enough to do!"

See also: Every Single Review for "Thor: Ragnarok" and "SHAZAM!"

Darkest Timeline.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-02-2019, 09:37 PM
People would love it. "This movie revels in its own stupidity, the way ALL comic book films should know well enough to do!"

See also: Every Single Review for "Thor: Ragnarok" and "SHAZAM!"

Darkest Timeline.

Did Barry Allen go back in time and save his mommy? Is that why all of our CBMs suck? We're in Flashpoint?

Leo656
04-02-2019, 09:44 PM
No, I think Dr. Manhattan had something to do with it. Allegedly.

Garfield
04-03-2019, 03:46 PM
hmph. I think Ninja Turtles III is a good movie. with the exception of the 1990's film I think it had more heart to it than any other turtle movie. Its my second fav Ninja turtles movie next to the 1990 film. So of course I'd choose it over Out of the Shadows, Though calling Out of the Shadows a "Pile of crap" is a bit much to me. I thought it was kind of okay. I much prefer Out of the SHadows to the first Platnium Dunes movie.

pferreira
04-07-2019, 04:41 PM
I've seen it hundreds of times but even as a kid I recall feeling a tremendous sense of letdown. Because ain't no way anyone can argue that it's a good follow-up to the first movie. An "acceptable" kids movie in and of itself if you pretend the 1990 film never happened? Fair enough. But going from TMNT 1990 into "Secret of the Ooze" is like listening to Metallica's "Load" record right after listening to "Kill 'Em All". They don't fit together and have NOTHING in common, even if they're supposedly in the same universe. I don't know man. I thought the sequel followed on quite nicely from the first. Sure the sequel critically speaking isn't as good as the original but not many are. On a technical level it was as good as the original and in terms of story it progressed that film universe pretty well, something III didn't bother to do. In terms of tone yeah it's very simplified and childish but in terms of story it ain't half bad. :)

If most kids were able to pretend that Razhar and Tokka were a Pig and a Rhino, I'm sure they were able to enjoy SoTo just as much as the first film.Nah, even as a child I knew it was different mutants. Didn't care though.

If "Batman and Robin" came out tomorrow exactly as it is it would make $2.4 billion dollars.Exactly but then it's a moot point as any colourful superhero movie that actually LOOKS LIKE an actual superhero movie is not in fashion today.

The Alfred sub-plot and Dick and Bruce's rift is great, and the third act ain't too bad. Also, again, great soundtrack. It could probably fare better today in a world resistant to Zack Snyder and very accepting of risk free quip-before-edge Marvel movies.Agreed. Also the beginning battle with them skydiving away from that explosion is amazing to watch, a hell of a lot better technically staged than stuff in today's superhero movies. That cannot be denied.

Leo656
04-07-2019, 07:20 PM
If a sequel movie changes every single thing including tone, visual style, and most of the cast, then by its very DEFINITION it is a poor follow-up to the previous film. It is barely even a "sequel" at that point, and simply a "follow-up", which is not the same thing.

III was an acceptable sequel to II. Those movies are consistent with each other. I and II have almost nothing in common, and furthermore, one of the mission statements involved in its making was to be as different from the first movie as possible.

By definition, it's a bad sequel. If you enjoy it that's fine but a sequel is supposed to be consistent with the previous movie. SotO was designed to be almost a "do-over". This is simple math.

pferreira
04-21-2019, 06:41 PM
If a sequel movie changes every single thing including tone, visual style, and most of the cast, then by its very DEFINITION it is a poor follow-up to the previous film. It is barely even a "sequel" at that point, and simply a "follow-up", which is not the same thing.
(thinks it over) I don't know man. Yeah the visual style and tone was different but it didn't change so drastically that I wouldn't call it a sequel. It followed on fine and considering it's got this reputation as a comedy there's still enough serious moments and mystery to take the movie seriously. I can't say the same about the third movie which was worse in a lot of regards and applies quite well to your views on what a sequel isn't.

ProactiveMan
04-23-2019, 11:17 PM
We probably do, but dunno how much we share with them.

Enough to make us mammalian tetrapods i.e. four limbed mammals. You could probably trace our genetic linage back to a common ancestor but you would have to go back a long way; before primates diverged from the rest of Mammalia, and pigs and rhinos similarly diverged.

Pigs and rhinos evolved their distinctive traits in parallel to us and ours, so it would be unlikely that we posses the genetic information to simply turn genes on that would allow us to look exactly like them. Sadly, the magic space goo from the cartoons makes way more sense than OOTS attempt at a more believable explanation.

Wesley
07-28-2019, 10:52 AM
Tmnt 3 and Out of the Shadows are both decent enough films imo, though they could’ve been much better. They were still better than Secret of the Ooze anyway. I agree OotS was worse.

IndigoErth
07-28-2019, 12:50 PM
That's hard to say, both have pros and cons I could argue for either of them.


Just some thoughts on both...

TMNT 3's story is better and more interesting than OotS.

TMNT 3 is a bit money grabby itself, but not as much as OotS and 2014; TMNT 3 existed at a time when film was at least partly still seen as an art form, not just largely a money maker.

Some of OotS brother interactions and issues are deeper and hold more weight across the duration of the film than TMNT 3's. TMNT 3 however has some heartfelt moments among characters (both TMNT and humans).

TMNT 3 has one of the two good movie Aprils. OotS once again looks like Megan Fox herself knows the TMNT for some reason.

Casey Casey Casey... This might be a tie. TMNT 3: No real Casey involvement, mostly just a guy that looks like his ancestor for brief portions of the films. OotS is 95% Casey in-name-only, so they're both not quite Casey, therefor that is pretty close to being an even score.

TMNT 3's time travel is almost more believable than the OotS Turtles managing to not only land on and ride on top of an airplane, but also survive it crash landing in a jungle. Not to mention Donnie someone managing to fly it sans cockpit, as if the air speed is not problem for multiple reasons.

OotS tweaked designs and lighting and decreased the amount of stuff they're wearing so they made them look a little better. TMNT 3 however lost the Henson company, the designs look worse, and adding stuff to wear via the samurai armor was a short term improvement.

Con OotS: Turtles are huge, still. (But at least no mention or use of being "bullet proof.")

Pro TMNT 3: Managing Turtle suits and horses together.

Pro OotS: Turtle truck.

Con OotS: Loony Tunes-like BS.

Con TMNT 3: Look a little puppety at times.

Con Oots: Hand animated portions of Krang fight feel hand animated and lacking weight, thus the equivalent of looking a little puppety at times.

Con TMNT 3: These Turtle suits in particular require more effort on the suspension of disbelief than previous films.

Pro OotS: Motion capture of even small movement detail lets them fit into reality pretty well, making them easier to accept as living, breathing beings.

Con OotS: Character rigging doesn't seem to account for maintaining ridged look of plastron when visible breathing (rise and fall of chest) is noticeable and looks odd.

Pro TMNT 3: Cool lair. Additional pro point for being held over from prior film and inspired by existing former subway station.

Pro OotS: Cool lair. Additional point for the addition of some real furniture, etc, suggesting some amount of improvement in their living situation.

Pro TMNT 3: Opportunity to interact with more people, and in a way that is less departmental to them since it happens in the past.

Con TMNT 3: People accept them awfully fast after getting past the initial shock.

Pro OotS: Opportunity to interact with more people, and carries more weight because it's risky to them and actions actually earn those peoples' trust and acceptance.

And whatever other pros and cons I could compare...

pferreira
08-02-2019, 03:25 PM
Still one of my favourite scenes from OotS:

HnG0TTHB4bs