View Full Version : Why was the 2007 movie CGI?
Prowler
03-21-2019, 01:46 PM
Perhaps this has been answered before, but I've been wondering why this movie is CGI? It's still the only non-live action TMNT movie to this date. What was the reason behind this decision? Was it originally the plan? Was an animation studio the only one showing interest in a TMNT movie in 2007? Or did they reach the best deal with them?
Or was it simply a matter of "hmm, an animated TMNT movie has never been done before, let's try and see if it works"?
snake
03-21-2019, 01:49 PM
They probably didn’t want to create complex practical costume effects for the turtles, but didn’t want to spend enough to make CGI turtles that could pass in the real world as organic beings, so they met in the mdidle and made it all animated.
FredWolfLeonardo
03-21-2019, 01:54 PM
I'm guessing partially because CG animated movies were more cool and trendy at the time.
I'm glad they did though, because the movie is still very pretty to look at.
Prowler
03-21-2019, 02:04 PM
I'm guessing partially because CG animated movies were more cool and trendy at the time.
I'm glad they did though, because the movie is still very pretty to look at.
Yeah probably. I've never been very in touch with cinema and such, so I wasn't sure. Makes sense, though.
Yes, it looks good. And the video game based on it was quite solid for what it was. It was kind of like a Prince of Persia clone, right?
You did feel like a Ninja Turtle jumping all over rooftops. in that game haha
Andrew NDB
03-21-2019, 03:03 PM
They probably didn’t want to create complex practical costume effects for the turtles, but didn’t want to spend enough to make CGI turtles that could pass in the real world as organic beings, so they met in the mdidle and made it all animated.
Right. Enough of a budget to make a cost-effective CGI movie outsourced to Hong Kong... not nearly enough of one to make it live-action with costumes and animatronics and all that.
Always seemed like an... interesting choice. I also don't think they had much of a marketing budget because very few people even knew there was a movie out.
Prowler
03-21-2019, 03:13 PM
Right. Enough of a budget to make a cost-effective CGI movie outsourced to Hong Kong... not nearly enough of one to make it live-action with costumes and animatronics and all that.
Always seemed like an... interesting choice. I also don't think they had much of a marketing budget because very few people even knew there was a movie out.
I remember it barely being talked about. It's like, 1 week before it came out some peopel were like "oh a new turtles movie, cool"... then a week later no one cared anymore. It's like it came and went. Plus, the 2k3 toon was not as popular as the FW or the 2012 ones were, so no wonder its tie in movie was a mere blip in the radar in the grand scheme of things as well. Plus it came out in 2007 already when either the Ninja Tribunal or Fast Forward were already airing. By then, the show wasn't as hot anymore.
And ofc, a lot of people were like "WAIT, NO SHREDDER ,BEBOP, ROCKSTEADY AND KRANG?! **** IT"
snake
03-23-2019, 12:21 AM
Somehow I saw it in theaters in 2007. I "liked" TMNT at the time, but I'm surprised my parents knew that there was a movie out.
I remember waiting for a sequel, too- but it never came.
Still, 2007 is a very underrated piece of TMNT history. I genuinely like it more than 2k12 in some aspects.
Andrew NDB
03-23-2019, 12:34 AM
Somehow I saw it in theaters in 2007. I "liked" TMNT at the time, but I'm genuinely surprised my parents knew that there was a movie out.
I remember waiting for a sequel, too- but it never came.
Still, 2007 is a very underrated piece of TMNT history. I genuinely like it more than 2k12 in some aspects.
Sometimes I feel like I am way too hard on it. It's less that it wasn't a decent, random TMNT movie... and more that it just wasn't anything near the movie it needed to be to kickstart anything meaningfully.
snake
03-23-2019, 12:38 AM
To be fair, I have no idea what they were going for either, but it's nice that the folks behind it were clearly fans. You don't get that covered up canister obscuring either TCRI/TGRI from people with only casual TMNT knowledge.
The Raph/Leo fight scene stuck with me- and seemingly everyone else who watched the movie- the most.
Redeemer
03-23-2019, 01:42 AM
To be fair, I have no idea what they were going for either, but it's nice that the folks behind it were clearly fans. You don't get that covered up canister obscuring either TCRI/TGRI from people with only casual TMNT knowledge.
The Raph/Leo fight scene stuck with me- and seemingly everyone else who watched the movie- the most.
Yeah I enjoy the movie solely bc of that fight. If the movie just had a better antagonist/villain it would have been leaps and bounds better.
Karia should have been the villian along with the foot clan or they could have done a city at war movie with different factions of the foot clan fighting and tearing up the city. The turtles come back together ect....
I know there were talks and even plans for a sequel movie along with a promotional poster released with Mikey by himself with shredder in the background, but it was scrapped in favor of a supposedly hardcore Mirage reboot and then the property got sold. :ohwell:
Andrew NDB
03-23-2019, 01:54 AM
Yeah I enjoy the movie solely bc of that fight. If the movie just had a better antagonist/villain it would have been leaps and bounds better.
Karia should have been the villian along with the foot clan or they could have done a city at war movie with different factions of the foot clan fighting and tearing up the city. The turtles come back together ect....
Yeah, Karai in it seemed to exist to #1, get knocked down by April F***ing O'Neil, and #2, tell us that Shredder was coming back.
I know there were talks and even plans for a sequel movie along with a promotional poster released with Mikey by himself with shredder in the background, but it was scrapped in favor of a supposedly hardcore Mirage reboot and then the property got sold. :ohwell:
True, but these things weren't connected. Imagi had their idea for a sequel that I think I read Peter was OK with (not entirely sure there)... then Imagi fell apart for unrelated reasons. Then years later Frank Fusco (yes, Fusco, not Fosco) wrote a draft of a live action reboot that Kevin Eastman told me was, "Like Batman Begins," "awesome," and "the best thing Turtles" that he's ever read or seen conceptualized. And yeah, that's about the time the sale happened... and everything got twisted.
Redeemer
03-23-2019, 02:07 AM
Yeah, Karai in it seemed to exist to #1, get knocked down by April F***ing O'Neil, and #2, tell us that Shredder was coming back.
True, but these things weren't connected. Imagi had their idea for a sequel that I think I read Peter was OK with (not entirely sure there)... then Imagi fell apart for unrelated reasons. Then years later Frank Fusco (yes, Fusco, not Fosco) wrote a draft of a live action reboot that Kevin Eastman told me was, "Like Batman Begins," "awesome," and "the best thing Turtles" that he's ever read or seen conceptualized. And yeah, that's about the time the sale happened... and everything got twisted.
Kevin Eastman or Peter Laird???? I thought only Laird was involved with TMNT at that point?
Andrew NDB
03-23-2019, 02:10 AM
Kevin Eastman or Peter Laird???? I thought only Laird was involved with TMNT at that point?
Kevin sold his half of rights to Peter in 2000. But yes, he was involved in the Fusco incarnation in the same way he's involved with the IDW TMNT comics.
snake
03-23-2019, 02:14 AM
This is the first I’m hearing of the mirage-style movie planned before the sale. Anyone else have any more info on it?
CyberCubed
03-23-2019, 09:35 AM
Imagi is an all CG studio.
This is the first I’m hearing of the mirage-style movie planned before the sale. Anyone else have any more info on it?
https://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2009/04/what-it-all-about.html
The-Shredder
03-23-2019, 10:45 AM
https://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2009/04/what-it-all-about.html
I remember seeing YouTube videos of people on the streets auditioning to become Foot Soldiers. It's a shame that it all fell apart.
Prowler
03-23-2019, 01:04 PM
I remember seeing YouTube videos of people on the streets auditioning to become Foot Soldiers. It's a shame that it all fell apart.
Weird, I don't remember any of that.
A few years ago someone mentioned here that a FW animated movie was planned around the time the show was ending. I wonder how it would have turned out. An epic final battle between the Turtles and Shredder & Krang?
The-Shredder
03-23-2019, 03:48 PM
Weird, I don't remember any of that.
Found it. It was during the 25th anniversary in 2009. Speaking of which, I don't remember the 30th anniversary having as big of a hype as the 25th one. Aside from the IDW comic, it just came and went. Hopefully, the 35th anniversary is different.
qs1k0e3g-74
Roseangelo
03-23-2019, 03:58 PM
Found it. It was during the 25th anniversary in 2009. Speaking of which, I don't remember the 30th anniversary having as big of a hype as the 25th one. Aside from the IDW comic, it just came and went. Hopefully, the 35th anniversary is different.
In retrospect, I feel like a lot of the 25th anniversary effort was put together to help make the TMNT "saleable." I wouldn't be surprised if there were Nickelodeon suits watching the general interest that the events they held garnered. Especially at the Turtles Forever screening that was at Comic-Con that year.
Thank you for the YouTube link to that audition video - I don't think I've seen that before. I always felt bad for those people because a lot of them traveled from far away for that (some from overseas), and the fact that they held it on an open street instead of a proper facility made it pretty obvious that it was a publicity stunt instead of a true tryout.
Redeemer
03-23-2019, 04:29 PM
https://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2009/04/what-it-all-about.html
Its honestly depressing. I feel like this movie would have been leaps and bounds better than what we got with viacom.....
Andrew NDB
03-23-2019, 05:25 PM
Yeah! That was the one. And the script writer they chose was Frank Fusco. And it was decided it was "too dark."
Everything I've heard about it suggests it was the best TMNT thing we'll never get.
In retrospect, I feel like a lot of the 25th anniversary effort was put together to help make the TMNT "saleable." I wouldn't be surprised if there were Nickelodeon suits watching the general interest that the events they held garnered. Especially at the Turtles Forever screening that was at Comic-Con that year.
Like we all said, those of us that attended it... "We had no idea it was going to turn out to be a wake."
The teaser for the movie was great. Looked like it could have been a very Mirage movie, then it turned out to be the 4th in the series, which I don't think was a great choice. I would have much preferred starting a new series than giving it the Superman Returns formula where we're revisiting a world that's changed a lot since we last saw it.
pferreira
03-28-2019, 08:10 PM
I also don't think they had much of a marketing budget because very few people even knew there was a movie out.Quite the opposite where I was. Between previews of the game online, a competition to win the game via Channel 4 (WHICH WAS HACKED!!!) as well as press news either about Patrick Stewart's involvement or Mako's death I never not knew the film was coming out. Kind of sad that pretty much every film Kevin Munroe has directed has been a flop.
And ofc, a lot of people were like "WAIT, NO SHREDDER ,BEBOP, ROCKSTEADY AND KRANG?! **** IT"I went to see the film with some buddies of mine and that wasn't out lasting concerns. It was more to do with the lack of an exciting plot or action although Shredder's absence was noticeable to us.
I just found it a disappointing movie to be honest. The Raph/Leo fight scene was just fan service and something nobody outside of the ultrahardcore wanted to see. We get they don't get along, we don't need them to spend ten minutes on them having a pointless fight just because. There was also a tendency for some reason back in 2007 to shoehorn Kevin Smith into every returning movie franchise because "he's a fan". Found it pretentious even back then.
Imagi had their idea for a sequel that I think I read Peter was OK with (not entirely sure there)... then Imagi fell apart for unrelated reasons.Yep, Laird said he wanted to see a live action sequel with Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr reprising their roles while the TMNT being CGI. Obviously the idea of doing things this way ultimately led to the PD movies. :D
Leo656
03-28-2019, 09:11 PM
Speak for yourself, the Leo/Raph fight is the only part of the movie that I still remember, and the only part of the entire thing that feels like anything important is happening when I do watch it. I liked it a lot in the theater - I generally do have a good time at the theater regardless of what the movie is, it's on the ride home when some things start to fall apart - but a while after that I realized that the movie itself wasn't very memorable. So I re-watched it a few times and while it's definitely not bad, it's completely "Meh". A lot of interesting ideas, none of which were explored to their full potential. And saving the conflict everyone actually DID want to see for the sequel (which we never got) was a Very Bad Idea. Regardless of whether seeing Shredder again was a rehash or not, it's what most people would have preferred to spend money on.
I knew the thing wasn't gonna take off when I went to see it opening night and the theater was 2/3s full. That's always a bad sign.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
03-28-2019, 09:16 PM
https://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2009/04/what-it-all-about.html
That is the most depressing thing I've read all day.
I'd give IDW TMNT over for one single modern decent "Batman Begins" TMNT movie in a heartbeat. And throw in my Mirage/Image collections, too.
Leo656
03-28-2019, 09:19 PM
Wish in one hand, and you know what to do with the other... :lol:
It'll never happen. Never, ever ever. Real shame.
snake
03-28-2019, 10:17 PM
I think a sequel featuring Shredder would've been cool as f*ck, but I kind of applaud them for doing an original villain for the movie.
Like, the Stone Generals and Max Winters were kind of sh*tty, but at least it wasn't the same thing we've seen before.
Leo656
03-28-2019, 10:41 PM
What's the trade-off, though? What weighs more? An original idea, executed poorly, or a re-hashed idea done well?
I personally vote for Option B, but then, I'm a fairly conservative person and I don't believe in taking risks.
snake
03-28-2019, 10:44 PM
Original idea, IMO. Maybe I'm too jaded by the Star Wars sequels and the general direction of the TMNT franchise, but I'm sick and tired of seeing the same sh*t.
Hell, I like TNM's villains just because they're new ideas, and if executed a little better- could probably work.
Leo656
03-28-2019, 11:05 PM
Fair enough, but SO many "new ideas" end up that way - "If only they were better executed" - that it almost seems like wasted energy.
"Potential" is a word people use for things that are ultimately not very satisfying, after all. Nobody ever says, "That thing totally lived up to or exceeded its potential." Hardly ever, about anything. They say, "That thing had so much potential, it's a shame it didn't do better."
Who knows WHY it's so hard to get a New Idea to actually work. Maybe it's because they haven't had a chance to polish it into a diamond, the way older ideas get to be? I honestly don't know. I do think some things persist and become "iconic" for a reason, though.
With regard to this film, I think using a brand new (and ultimately underwhelming) villain for the first TMNT film in 15 or so years was a HUGE mistake. They absolutely should have used Shredder. It's impossible to say how many people skipped seeing it and said "I'll wait for the sequel" once they heard that Shredder wasn't in it, BUT, it had to have been A Lot Of People.
Like, people often do crap on "The Force Awakens", but it's absolutely the movie they HAD to make in their situation. They needed to do a "safe picture" since the Prequels were so divisive. Business-wise, it was the right move and I don't fault them for that at all, I fault them for completely botching the follow-up.
If Disney had come out of the gate with an entirely New And Original Idea for their very first Star Wars flick, they would have gotten ten times more sh*t from people, for "not understanding Star Wars" and "Not giving people what they wanted."
I get wanting to see fresh stuff, but there's a time for that and a time to play it safe. The wisdom is knowing when to do which. Unfortunately, that usually only becomes clear with hindsight, and by then you've either made or lost the money and you can't go back and do it over.
snake
03-28-2019, 11:11 PM
Here's where I disagree. Star Wars was going to make money regardless. I don't care what anyone says. There is no way it was not going to succeed and TFA was absolutely not their only choice.
The problem with the ST, and TFA in particular, is that it doesn't even rehash the right things. Do we get the rehash elements we SHOULD be getting? Like the OT Trio, Luke training jedi, the original character's having offspring and having a happy outcome, the new republic, or an interesting conflict? No. We get sh*tty sets, wide-eyed earth tone aliens that all look the same, a bare bones story, awful new characters, cheap looking effects, zero worldbuilding, basically no interaction with ANY of the OT characters, Rebels vs the f*cking Empire again, and the end result is a galaxy that in size more resembles my penis.
F*ck Disney. I should not be this fired up this late at night, but whenever that movie is brought up- that's the point I'm driven to.
Leo656
03-28-2019, 11:30 PM
I agree with some of that for sure. And I agree they would have made money regardless. But I kinda think that TLJ only did as well as it did because they had everyone in the palm of their hand after TFA was considered "Acceptable" by the majority. Like I don't think anyone thought TFA was mind-blowing, but it was at least "Acceptable and Recognizable as a Star Wars Product", which TLJ kind of isn't, and that's why it's so divisive.
I do agree that they've chosen to focus on the wrong things, however. And I'm just about as "F*ck Star Wars, I Give Up" as you are, for sure. But I don't think TFA was the problem, I think they were right to make that movie. I think the mistake was doing a complete 180 and making a sequel that mostly pretends that movie didn't even happen, despite everything depending on it for the story to function. TLJ could have been FULL of Fresh New Ideas, and tried to be... but they f*cked it up by giving it to someone who didn't even "get" Star Wars, so all his "new ideas" were terrible.
If it makes you feel any better though man, these are conversations worth having. Thanks for raising the bar.
pferreira
03-29-2019, 06:07 PM
Speak for yourself, the Leo/Raph fight is the only part of the movie that I still remember, I had to remind myself I actually saw the movie at the cinema. I just felt the fight scene didn't have a purpose. The film had some interesting things about it. I liked that the villain wasn't actually a villain but there wasn't much I enjoyed. I remember a fair bit about the movie even though I've only seen it once. Like the PD movies I don't have a big desire to see the 2007 movie again.
Like, people often do crap on "The Force Awakens", but it's absolutely the movie they HAD to make in their situation. They needed to do a "safe picture" since the Prequels were so divisive. Business-wise, it was the right move and I don't fault them for that at all, I fault them for completely botching the follow-up.No way in hell did Disney have to make The Force Awakens. The film single handedly ruined the entire franchise while undoing all the good work Return of the Jedi ended with. It's only now after the disappointment of TLJ that people are starting to realise that. It was a travesty of a movie. If The Last Jedi is guilty of anything is being more of the same sh*t. :x
F*ck Disney. I should not be this fired up this late at night, but whenever that movie is brought up- that's the point I'm driven to.I get you. Say what you will about the prequels but at least there was a vision and somewhat of a consistency to the universe Lucas created.
Leo656
03-29-2019, 10:52 PM
- Eh. Leo/Raph fight was entertaining, but the wrong guy went over. Rest of the movie wasn't offensive but easily could've been sponsored by Ambien. I stand by that opinion.
- Eh. Disney made any other movie than TFA, people would've nerd-raged at them even worse than they did at Lucas about the prequels. It was a decent (if completely safe and corporately-mandated) launchpad that could have led to some interesting stories, but they pooched the follow-up by making TFA completely not matter. I stand by that opinion.
- Star Wars should have stopped having movies entirely after Episode III, and become a completely TV and comic books-only franchise. I stand by that opinion.
Prowler
04-03-2019, 07:35 PM
- Star Wars should have stopped having movies entirely after Episode III, and become a completely TV and comic books-only franchise. I stand by that opinion.
I don't care about Star Wars movies besides the original trilogy. Didn't like Phantom Menace and I certainly did not like Attack of the Clones.
Leo656
04-03-2019, 09:17 PM
Interesting. I thought the Prequels got successively better overall as they went along, although Hayden Christensen certaily was a mistake. But Obi-Wan kept getting more and better lines, so that was what I was mostly paying attention to.
If you focus JUST on what he's doing and ignore almost everything else, the Prequels aren't too bad. :lol: But holy sh*t, how Lucas managed to get such terrible performances out of such award-winning actors I will never know. It's very obvious that he was far more concerned with playing with his shiny new computer toys than anything having to do with his actors. Total case of misplaced priorities.
In case I haven't been completely clear about it, I loathe CGI with the fury of a thousand suns. I'd settle for stop motion/"Claymation" and goddamn puppets before I'd ever say, "Yeah, use CGI, that's gonna look great." No exceptions.
Prowler
04-03-2019, 09:42 PM
Interesting. I thought the Prequels got successively better overall as they went along, although Hayden Christensen certaily was a mistake. But Obi-Wan kept getting more and better lines, so that was what I was mostly paying attention to.
If you focus JUST on what he's doing and ignore almost everything else, the Prequels aren't too bad. :lol: But holy sh*t, how Lucas managed to get such terrible performances out of such award-winning actors I will never know. It's very obvious that he was far more concerned with playing with his shiny new computer toys than anything having to do with his actors. Total case of misplaced priorities.
In case I haven't been completely clear about it, I loathe CGI with the fury of a thousand suns. I'd settle for stop motion/"Claymation" and goddamn puppets before I'd ever say, "Yeah, use CGI, that's gonna look great." No exceptions.
I watched those movies not too long after they came out, so I no longer remember most of the details.
Anyway, SW is a huge universe and the extended universe seems cool judging by what I've played of KOTOR so far.
Leo656
04-04-2019, 01:11 AM
I can't believe you haven't finished it yet. When I first played that game it was ALL that I did besides go to work for almost two weeks, and upon beating it I immediately restarted it so I could play Dark Side as well as find all the stuff I knew I'd missed. If that game had a moist orifice I for sure would have gotten it pregnant by now.
Your mother and I are very disappointed in you for this. And I'm not even your real Dad, nor do she and I talk. But nonetheless, we both expect better from you in the future.
I won't hold it against you if you skip the second game, though. Some big improvements, but it's also kind of a letdown. First one is all you really need.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-04-2019, 06:47 AM
Yeah, Karai in it seemed to exist to #1, get knocked down by April F***ing O'Neil, and #2, tell us that Shredder was coming back.
True, but these things weren't connected. Imagi had their idea for a sequel that I think I read Peter was OK with (not entirely sure there)... then Imagi fell apart for unrelated reasons. Then years later Frank Fusco (yes, Fusco, not Fosco) wrote a draft of a live action reboot that Kevin Eastman told me was, "Like Batman Begins," "awesome," and "the best thing Turtles" that he's ever read or seen conceptualized. And yeah, that's about the time the sale happened... and everything got twisted.
There were plans for two sequels, with City at War and Triceratons.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_in_film#Canceled_proj ects
d_osborn
04-04-2019, 04:35 PM
Yeah! That was the one. And the script writer they chose was Frank Fusco. And it was decided it was "too dark."
Everything I've heard about it suggests it was the best TMNT thing we'll never get.
I just wish the damn script would leak!
Prowler
04-06-2019, 04:31 PM
I can't believe you haven't finished it yet. When I first played that game it was ALL that I did besides go to work for almost two weeks, and upon beating it I immediately restarted it so I could play Dark Side as well as find all the stuff I knew I'd missed. If that game had a moist orifice I for sure would have gotten it pregnant by now.
Your mother and I are very disappointed in you for this. And I'm not even your real Dad, nor do she and I talk. But nonetheless, we both expect better from you in the future.
I won't hold it against you if you skip the second game, though. Some big improvements, but it's also kind of a letdown. First one is all you really need.
What :lol: This is one of the funniest things I've ever read. Is that a common saying/joke in the US or something :lol:
And for the record, if anything I think my mum would be glad I'm not playing videogames for once. She's part of a generation that didn't grow up with games. She actually expected my brother to outgrow video games for good once he went to university.
Baby boomers are funny.
Leo656
04-06-2019, 04:38 PM
Nah, I just generally say the first thing that comes to mind. :lol:
But the disappointment is real. I love that damn game. Bastila's my Baby Mama and that bitch don't even know yet.
Prowler
04-06-2019, 04:40 PM
Nah, I just generally say the first thing that comes to mind. :lol:
But the disappointment is real. I love that damn game. Bastila's my Baby Mama and that bitch don't even know yet.
More like I got distracted meanwhile and forgot about it. I'm a bit like that with games at times. But I'm not TOO FAR into the game for it to be a hassle to go back to it yet. So I'll get on to it eventually.
Leo656
04-06-2019, 04:53 PM
There's so many hidden subplots and things to do. I hope you find at least most of them. I was amazed at how things just kept getting bigger the longer I played it. I mean, again, this was like 2004 I think, but I'm still impressed with it.
Talk to everyone, multiple times, including everyone in your party. And definitely try exploring the same areas multiple times with different party members accompanying you. Some things only open up under very certain and specific conditions, but they're all fun and worth getting involved in. Some stuff, like the assassin's guild, are very sneakily hidden but very cool. Every time I play it I find something I missed before.
I don't even remember specifically how I got into it, but once I did it was very engaging. Second one was also good but they shipped it unfinished so that's a real bummer.
Prowler
04-06-2019, 05:11 PM
There's so many hidden subplots and things to do. I hope you find at least most of them. I was amazed at how things just kept getting bigger the longer I played it. I mean, again, this was like 2004 I think, but I'm still impressed with it.
Talk to everyone, multiple times, including everyone in your party. And definitely try exploring the same areas multiple times with different party members accompanying you. Some things only open up under very certain and specific conditions, but they're all fun and worth getting involved in. Some stuff, like the assassin's guild, are very sneakily hidden but very cool. Every time I play it I find something I missed before.
I don't even remember specifically how I got into it, but once I did it was very engaging. Second one was also good but they shipped it unfinished so that's a real bummer.
Yeah it does seem like a game you're supposed to play several times.
pferreira
04-07-2019, 04:41 PM
- Eh. Disney made any other movie than TFA, people would've nerd-raged at them even worse than they did at Lucas about the prequels. It was a decent (if completely safe and corporately-mandated) launchpad that could have led to some interesting stories, but they pooched the follow-up by making TFA completely not matter. I stand by that opinion.The Farce Awakens was a total travesty for me. I knew they'd screw it up as soon as they announced they were doing away with the EU. It's like the writers found out at the last minute that all the good ideas had already been used by the EU and so just provided a crap remake of ANH. And no, fans wanted them to create a plot that was set in the EU, I know this talking to other fans online. Lucasfilm/Disney effectively killed Star Wars as a brand with TFA and then Bernie'd its corpse through all these other movies. I'm sorry, it still makes me really angry talking about this. :x
Leo656
04-07-2019, 07:12 PM
"Expectations are the first step towards Disappointment."
Anyone who expected Disney to use the EU as part of their new plans should have had their head examined. That was never on the table. Look, I prefer the old EU stuff that I bothered to look at much better than Disney's new slop, too, but it was never going to be put back in play.
TFA was exactly the movie I expected them to make, and within that, it was fine. And - more importantly for Disney - it was good for business. The Mouse knows full well that for as much as people whine and complain, 99% of those people will STILL go see the new movies, even if it's just so they have an excuse to complain f*cking more.
TLJ on the other hand was irredeemable, because not only was it inconsistent with Star Wars in almost every way, it wasn't even consistent with the previous movie.
I agree that the franchise is a mess and I am probably done with it, but TFA was simply a case of Disney proving that they do in fact know what a Star Wars movie looks like, even if they had to prove it by being derivative. TLJ was the bigger misfire because they went into business for themselves and ALSO made a really bad movie. TFA wasn't a bad movie, just a very "safe" one that leaned heavily on nostalgia. It did its intended job. TLJ tried a "scorched earth" approach with the whole, "Don't care about what you already care about, care about what we TELL you to care about," and also the movie itself told a very bad story with very unlikable characters and a plot that was pure nonsense to anyone over the age of 5.
TFA may not have been the movie some people WANTED, but it was still Just Fine. TLJ, on the other hand, is a very bad movie from every possible angle.
pferreira
04-21-2019, 06:34 PM
And for the record, if anything I think my mum would be glad I'm not playing videogames for once. She's part of a generation that didn't grow up with games. She actually expected my brother to outgrow video games for good once he went to university.
Baby boomers are funny.Reminds me of my mum. :D
Anyone who expected Disney to use the EU as part of their new plans should have had their head examined. That was never on the table. Look, I prefer the old EU stuff that I bothered to look at much better than Disney's new slop, too, but it was never going to be put back in play.Firslty they should never have made a new trilogy but if they did the EU should have been made canon so we could have been spared the torture of The Farce Awakens and whatever came after. People moan about TLJ but TFA is what ruined Star Wars, no two ways about it. It destroyed the characters, destroyed that universe, destroyed everything ROTJ did and clearly showed that current Lucasfilm have no clue what they are doing. Clearly allowing the EU as part of future canon would have made sense to a point while being extremely doable. Such a wasted opportunity.
Also my head is perfectly fine thank you. ;)
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.