Konchadunga
05-30-2019, 09:59 PM
I apologize for asking what is quite possibly one of the most discussed things here, but I've been looking around TMNT merchandise and games, and for whatever reason 4Kids TMNT gets no love. This is very noteworthy to me because at least every other major incarnation does.
This wasn't always the case. It used to be that while the Fred Wolf cartoon was running, just about every adaptation of, and reference to, the brand took after that. Likewise, The Next Mutation got to be the brand's center, however briefly. Then it was this show, for as long as it was on.
Since then, though, things have changed. We still get new shows with merchandising pushes, of course but these days we're also getting callbacks to past versions in merchandise. The movies do, even if the first is the only one many people like these days. Even the Mirage series, which seemed rather unknown to the public during the run of the first three TV series, gets toys and video game appearances alongside merch based on the more childish adaptations. Yet again, the 4Kids turtles are absent--so why?
My best theory would be that the increasing popularity of the aforementioned Mirage series makes this show look redundant. Maybe they felt the need to hush up about it back when the Fred Wolf show was big with children, whether "they" means "Eastman and Laird", executives trying to persuade Eastman and Laird how to maintain a good brand image, or both. Maybe once Peter Laird was able to secure more control, he decided to make the Mirage series more well-known, although I don't remember much presence of it while the 4Kids show was running. Since then, though, now that everyone who was a child during both shows is an adult, and furthermore has access to the Internet, maybe the powers that be feel that there's no more point to keeping the Mirage series under rugs; plus it has its own nostalgic fanbase that gets vocal in reaction to how obviously nothing else is going to duplicate it.
The 4Kids show was noteworthy compared to the Fred Wolf show (and especially the even goofier derivatives, like the Coming Out of Their Shells Tour and The Next Mutation) for how much more closely it followed the Mirage series, but it could only go so far and still keep its child-friendliness. Thus a lot of what are arguably the better parts of 4Kids turtles are also arguably worse versions of the Mirage series. Back when people were too young for Mirage, that didn't matter; it was 4Kids TMNT or nothing, but now that they're adults, I'm assuming the people nostalgic for its better moments, or who prefer a more adventurous take on TMNT, go right to Mirage.
I could be wrong, though, although causes aren't mutually exclusive. I also read that ownership of the 4Kids series is split between several companies, and thus maybe callbacks bring up issues of rights. Not sure, though.
Anyhow, what are your theories?
This wasn't always the case. It used to be that while the Fred Wolf cartoon was running, just about every adaptation of, and reference to, the brand took after that. Likewise, The Next Mutation got to be the brand's center, however briefly. Then it was this show, for as long as it was on.
Since then, though, things have changed. We still get new shows with merchandising pushes, of course but these days we're also getting callbacks to past versions in merchandise. The movies do, even if the first is the only one many people like these days. Even the Mirage series, which seemed rather unknown to the public during the run of the first three TV series, gets toys and video game appearances alongside merch based on the more childish adaptations. Yet again, the 4Kids turtles are absent--so why?
My best theory would be that the increasing popularity of the aforementioned Mirage series makes this show look redundant. Maybe they felt the need to hush up about it back when the Fred Wolf show was big with children, whether "they" means "Eastman and Laird", executives trying to persuade Eastman and Laird how to maintain a good brand image, or both. Maybe once Peter Laird was able to secure more control, he decided to make the Mirage series more well-known, although I don't remember much presence of it while the 4Kids show was running. Since then, though, now that everyone who was a child during both shows is an adult, and furthermore has access to the Internet, maybe the powers that be feel that there's no more point to keeping the Mirage series under rugs; plus it has its own nostalgic fanbase that gets vocal in reaction to how obviously nothing else is going to duplicate it.
The 4Kids show was noteworthy compared to the Fred Wolf show (and especially the even goofier derivatives, like the Coming Out of Their Shells Tour and The Next Mutation) for how much more closely it followed the Mirage series, but it could only go so far and still keep its child-friendliness. Thus a lot of what are arguably the better parts of 4Kids turtles are also arguably worse versions of the Mirage series. Back when people were too young for Mirage, that didn't matter; it was 4Kids TMNT or nothing, but now that they're adults, I'm assuming the people nostalgic for its better moments, or who prefer a more adventurous take on TMNT, go right to Mirage.
I could be wrong, though, although causes aren't mutually exclusive. I also read that ownership of the 4Kids series is split between several companies, and thus maybe callbacks bring up issues of rights. Not sure, though.
Anyhow, what are your theories?