PDA

View Full Version : The Quartering critisizes IDW Turtles


Dejablue
07-17-2019, 08:20 PM
xbpTUGXhe9E

So this guy isn't a fan of ninja turtles. But he is claiming that because Jennika is a turtle, the entire comic must be "woke" sjw garbage. He says "what happened to the ninja turtles?" But its incredibly obvious that he doesn't read the comics.

The main criticism I see from him and others is that Jennika isn't pretty. People want her to look like Venus, when years and years ago people hated the mere existence of that character. Also how dare the reptile monster not have boobs. Am I Rite guys??

He calls the IDW comic trash even though it is devastatingly obvious that he doesn't read it. This is infuriating. He needs to keep his mouth shut. He has no idea what he is talking about.

Chaotix12345
07-17-2019, 08:43 PM
Yeah, this kinda crap pops up whenever anything related to women or any sort of inclusive content happens in comics. Best to just ignore these big babies and let them yell into their cameras.

TigerClaw
07-17-2019, 08:48 PM
I woudn't take these youtubers seriously. They make a living on posting negative videos. In fact CNet did a hit piece about these Youtubers.
https://www.cnet.com/news/meet-the-angry-gaming-youtubers-who-turn-outrage-into-views/

Dejablue
07-17-2019, 09:51 PM
Yeah, this kinda crap pops up whenever anything related to women or any sort of inclusive content happens in comics. Best to just ignore these big babies and let them yell into their cameras.



I just thought that tmnt fans were the kind to be aware of the fact that turtle tits are a stupid idea best left on DeviantArt? Apparently not.

IndigoErth
07-17-2019, 10:03 PM
[This got long, sorry.]

Cripe, what do people really expect a female Turtle to look like? "She doesn't have human characteristics! This CONFUSES me! #HATEIT"

Generally, I wasn't in support of adding a female Turtle again. I don't hate Venus, she kind of got shorted on what she really could have been (sans reptile boobs), but how they went about her is annoying and Jennika here is, at least at this point in time of very limited information and insight, miles beyond her.

It gets a little old that male characters tend to get to be normal, basic characters and everyone assumes they're a guy... but in order for anyone to feel like they can even understand that one is a girl she has to be given stereotypical gender signifiers or unnatural human ones if they aren't human.

But on the occasion where it isn't made obvious in the way that everyone is so used to, it really only matters for, what, only a minute until the media points it out? Tigress from Kung Fu Panda has always been a good (and sadly rare) example of this, imo. Because of how things typically tend to be done, did I realize at first that she's a SHE? No... But the minute they call her by her name and use "her" and she" well then you know she's a she, no big deal, moving on. (And it's cool that a tiger wasn't given weird human characteristics so an audience, presumed to be dumb apparently, can figure it out.)


Sometimes I wonder what it would be like if male characters were forced into a particular gender "uniform" so we can be SURE to know that they're guys. Like, from now on, ALL males will wear a bow tie (forget the masks, all boy Turtles get their signature colored bow ties from now on!) as a male signifying accessory; if they are a species that normally doesn't have hair, they will and it will be a distinguishable human male haircut; and 75% of their clothing color palette will consist of the color red with orange and white as complimenting highlights.

:tlol::tlol:

As for my own opinion of Jennika at the moment... I'm a little concerned she could end up Mary Sued (I mean the number of weapons seems a little much...?) or forced to be someone's girlfriend (other than Casey), but at this point in time I actually kinda like her. I wouldn't have thought I'd like a new girl Turtle joining the gang, but going about it from this angle is kind of cool and helps that she sort of already has a background established.

My inner child is kind of digging this, because in a way, she's kind of a long ago childhood dream vicariously come true. A lot of kids back in the day (as I'm sure kids still now) wanted to be them, girls included; though as a girl, even though the guys were just as relatable, that kiddie wish always felt a step further away. Didn't help that back then the female representation tended to be all human.

Even, as the fan kid representatives, Zach comes around and wears a mask and is the honorary "fifth Turtle," but his friend Caitlyn shows up just once and corrects Zach, saying that, no, she doesn't want to be a Turtle like the actual Turtles... she wants to be a "Turtle... like April." So, no, girl viewer, you are a girl, so you can't actually be like them.

But then Jennika comes along and is a human woman who gets to be one of them. And I have to be honest, that inner kid is, for the time being, grinning a little. :D


And heck, I'm not even a official reader of IDW, only just peeking at some of it now and then and have the gist of what's going on at present. Someday I'll probably pick it up more, maybe. (Will be curious to see if she ever goes through a period of doing the Foot Turtle thing herself, maybe not through brain washing but perhaps being torn between 'worlds.')

Allio
07-17-2019, 10:25 PM
I've actually been surprised over the positivity from these kinds of videos. YellowFlash, someone that is just as negative as Quartering, was actually giving it a "Looks fine to me"

CyberCubed
07-17-2019, 10:31 PM
I always have no clue who these random youtube people are and why people care about them. They're no different than someone ranting on a message board, only it's in video form so it reaches more people.

Seriously, today's youtubers are like the old ranting posters on message boards in the early 2000's...only it's a bigger deal due to how mainstream youtube and then social media is compared to confined forums.

Dejablue
07-17-2019, 10:34 PM
I always have no clue who these random youtube people are and why people care about them. They're no different than someone ranting on a message board, only it's in video form so it reaches more people.

Seriously, today's youtubers are like the old ranting posters on message boards in the early 2000's...only it's a bigger deal due to how mainstream youtube and then social media is compared to confined forums.


That's the problem. People listen to these idiots and just take their word for it. Thousands of people. I actually read the comic so I can smell his horse **** through the screen.

Cloudrunner
07-18-2019, 01:14 AM
While it's clear he hasn't been reading the comics, his opinion is surely based purely on the negative reception that IDW has gotten on a lot of its other comics. Being an avid reader of this run of TMNT and someone who (usually) opposes SJW influence in the comics, this comic never struck me as having any of those influences. And if it does, it manages to hide them well and weave them properly into the story. Cause I sure as hell haven't noticed it. When you've got **** like Female Thor as the poster child for blatant agenda pushing, people should be praising comics like TMNT for understanding what the term subtlety means.

Whatever though, people shouldn't be paying the guy any mind. Even among his peers, The Quartering is widely considered the Kotaku/Polygon-level clickbait of the anti-SJW space. Even people that share similar opinions don't like him cause he uses the same kneejerk reactionary clickbait tactics as the sites he often complains about. At the end of the day he's just a hypocrite who doesn't know what he's talking about.

Ninjinister
07-18-2019, 03:52 AM
Literally who?

Candy Kappa
07-18-2019, 03:54 AM
https://i.imgflip.com/2ajtsw.gif

ChosenOne
07-18-2019, 04:58 AM
I absolutely loathe SJW crap. Just about as much as I loathe people who see a boogeyman lurking in every corner. Sometimes a mutant ninja turtle is just a mutant ninja turtle. She's a living nightmare, alright... For Karai and apparently for incels everywhere. #TeamJennika

Candy Kappa
07-18-2019, 05:01 AM
Where is turtle titty?! what SJW nonsense is this?! What about my boner?!

ChosenOne
07-18-2019, 05:02 AM
What about my boner?!

Are you assuming they can ever manage to get one? You are a bold one, Kappa.

Candy Kappa
07-18-2019, 05:05 AM
not without turtle titty probably :lol:

snake
07-18-2019, 05:43 AM
F*cking idiots.

Igglet
07-18-2019, 06:10 AM
TheQuartering is an absolute troglodyte. Here's a fun game. Scroll down through his videos to about 4 months ago, CTRL+F and type 'Brie Larson' and then 'Captain Marvel'. Can you guess how many times each of the names will pop up?

Spoilers, Brie Larson pops up 15 times, Captain Marvel pops up 25 times. I can get not liking the movie but this guy is absolutely obsessed with it. He's like the manifestation of all those neckbeard "anti-SJWs" who are just as bad as the people they are criticizing - actually, no, they are worse. I really don't recommend that anyone else watches that sorry excuse for a video, giving this mong any Ad Revenue in exchange for getting pissed off about dumb **** is not worth it. He's literally got nothing worth saying.

snake
07-18-2019, 06:23 AM
On the flipside, I appreciate the Star Wars bitching from all these channels. Those movies need to be hated and anything done to sway public opinion is good. They should just stick to bashing the sequel trilogy like it deserves.

80gmrp
07-18-2019, 06:35 AM
I’m just going to say I’m somewhat indifferent over there being a fifth turtle beyond the likelihood of it generating more shippers, even if this particular situation overrides the incest taboo.

As for the original subject, if it gives people assurance over this particular IDW criticism, I personally never heard of TheQuartering before I saw this thread, and I do use YouTube, even if for marketing my music.

Igglet
07-18-2019, 06:38 AM
TheQuartering is actually fairly popular among a certain group of people, but those guys probably wouldn't even buy the comics in the first place. Not much of a loss either way.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-18-2019, 09:00 AM
https://i.imgflip.com/2ajtsw.gif

My man Roy Wood Jr! :tlol:

Diorm
07-18-2019, 09:17 AM
All TheQuartering videos are based on reading articles about female characters or feministe agenda. He's annonying.

Coola Yagami
07-18-2019, 10:16 AM
How are the comments, is everyone blindly agreeing with him or are there people saying 'have you read the comics?' If not it's time some turtle fans give him a piece of our minds

Weapons@theready
07-18-2019, 10:28 AM
How are the comments, is everyone blindly agreeing with him or are there people saying 'have you read the comics?' If not it's time some turtle fans give him a piece of our minds

Initial comments that I saw before I stopped reading because I was rolling my eyes so much, but it seems like people who are probably subscribers to the channel who actually agree with his line of thinking

SaurusX
07-18-2019, 11:01 AM
I saw the video and actually commented that he should probably read the IDW comics since they’re the best incarnation of the Turtles to come along since the Mirage days. Later I saw my comment got posted to an entirely different video. X( Don’t know how that happened, so I deleted it.

I do agree that this Turtle better not be Mary Sued and turned into the leader or consistently showing up the OG’s. That would be ridiculous.

hypered1
07-18-2019, 11:08 AM
I saw the video and actually commented that he should probably read the IDW comics since they’re the best incarnation of the Turtles to come along since the Mirage days. Later I saw my comment got posted to an entirely different video. X( Don’t know how that happened, so I deleted it.

I do agree that this Turtle better not be Mary Sued and turned into the leader or consistently showing up the OG’s. That would be ridiculous.

Having read all of IDW's Ghostbusters comics, I can say that those problems are unlikely. Several new female 'busters have been introduced and NONE have had more focus than the original team, heck even the 2016 ladies were tolerable when they appeared.

Dejablue
07-18-2019, 11:48 AM
I wonder if he and his fans realize that its weird to want a female mutant turtle to be conventionally attractive. Like...are they outing themselves as furries or...

https://media.giphy.com/media/4HcW7p5pIIeLdvkj2X/giphy.gif

Eh, they probably didn't think it through.

Sophie Campbell
07-18-2019, 12:30 PM
I wonder if he and his fans realize that its weird to want a female mutant turtle to be conventionally attractive. Like...are they outing themselves as furries or...

https://media.giphy.com/media/4HcW7p5pIIeLdvkj2X/giphy.gif

Eh, they probably didn't think it through.

I've already heard from a surprising amount of people whining that I didn't draw Jennika with boobs. :tlol:

ChosenOne
07-18-2019, 12:33 PM
I've already heard from a surprising amount of people whining that I didn't draw Jennika with boobs. :tlol:

Funny how the same people and others didn't complain about Koya way back when...

neatoman
07-18-2019, 01:36 PM
I've already heard from a surprising amount of people whining that I didn't draw Jennika with boobs. :tlol:

Not sure why they even want to see her with boobs, do they have a thing for reptilian mammaries?

Dejablue
07-18-2019, 01:41 PM
There seems to be an ongoing argument about reptilian boobs in the Elderscrolls series. But I think the most popular idea is even anthropomorphic non mammals shouldn't have them.

Turtles doubly so. Even in a world where reptiles can produce milk, the plastron would make those assets functionally useless.

Also people used to loathe Venus. Now they want her back? Since when? I'm ultimately indifferent to Venus but still...since the heck when?

Sophie Campbell
07-18-2019, 01:47 PM
Also people used to loathe Venus. Now they want her back? Since when? I'm ultimately indifferent to Venus but still...since the heck when?

Seriously! I've been so surprised by how many people have come at me asking where the heck Venus is or why we didn't use Venus instead, etc. But part of me thinks they're not really Venus fans, per se, they just saw a trolling opportunity. I'm sure if we actually had introduced Venus instead, these people would be just as mad about that.

IndigoErth
07-18-2019, 01:49 PM
Not sure why they even want to see her with boobs, do they have a thing for reptilian mammaries?
Maybe it would hurt their masculine feels to find a girl cool, so they NEED it to be made super clear to them that "this one is a girl" so they don't accidentally go liking any "girl stuff." Not being sure enough scares them.

Andrew NDB
07-18-2019, 01:58 PM
I wonder if he and his fans realize that its weird to want a female mutant turtle to be conventionally attractive. Like...are they outing themselves as furries or...

It's not as disturbing as the large group of TMNT fans that seem to be really drawn to and loudly advocate the "Turtle Tots" or "Lil TMNT" or whatever. Because c'mon... something's definitely going on there.

And nothing about Jennika suggests agenda or anything. They just wanted to do a female Turtle, so they did.

Sophie Campbell
07-18-2019, 03:29 PM
Nothing wrong with having an agenda. :tcool:

But Andrew, have you SEEN the Turtle Tots? ADORABLE.

Coola Yagami
07-18-2019, 03:38 PM
Nothing wrong with having an agenda. :tcool:

But Andrew, have you SEEN the Turtle Tots? ADORABLE.

Honor to speak with you directly. No matter those Twitter/Tumblr crazies say, never submit. Keep Jennika to your original vision.

Sophie Campbell
07-18-2019, 03:47 PM
Honor to speak with you directly. No matter those Twitter/Tumblr crazies say, never submit. Keep Jennika to your original vision.

I won't, don't worry! Angry fans have already started emailing/messaging me personally to insult me and everything, but this isn't my first rodeo. Angry Jem & the Holograms fans make angry TMNT fans seem like a walk in the park, haha.

neatoman
07-18-2019, 03:55 PM
Nothing wrong with having an agenda. :tcool:

But Andrew, have you SEEN the Turtle Tots? ADORABLE.

Turtle Tots?

Dejablue
07-18-2019, 05:20 PM
It's not as disturbing as the large group of TMNT fans that seem to be really drawn to and loudly advocate the "Turtle Tots" or "Lil TMNT" or whatever. Because c'mon... something's definitely going on there.

And nothing about Jennika suggests agenda or anything. They just wanted to do a female Turtle, so they did.

It's mostly female fans who like cute things. Liking cute things is what's going on.

PizzaPower
07-18-2019, 05:40 PM
Just have to remember that this is his/her/their opinion. Id rather not click on it. I will say IDW TMNT comics are one of the best incarnation of TMNT we have. Do your research. There was a fourth TMNT movie thats was supposed to come out in the 90s, and by all means please correct me if I am wrong. But there was supposed to be a 5th turtle who had a yellow mask. Anyway, when I saw this art when I got to the last page I thought Venus. I wish Venus had came into the series but I also wish that there was a season 2 of Next Mutation.

I'm super excited to see what this new turtle brings to the table!

pferreira
07-19-2019, 02:14 PM
Yeah I'm not surprised by this video. I can see why it would upset some. I wonder what Peter Laird thinks of them adding a female Turtle? I did point out in the comments of the video that Turtles has been popular recently, it's not faded in popularity right now anyway. Not a fan of IDW and the sales figures Jeremy shows aren't exactly inspiring. Part of the problem with IDW's TMNT as a comic is that it borrows too much from previous iterations, in this case Venus. I just kind of wish they did more of their own thing.

I remember was it last year (?) I made a thread where I asked what would happen if they created a female Turtle, whether it was being done for SJW purposes and whether fans would end up being seen as mysgnositic for simply not wanting massive changes to the source material. I don't think many chimed in with an answer. I'm sure someone can find the thread if they wanted to.

I always have no clue who these random youtube people are and why people care about them. They're no different than someone ranting on a message board, only it's in video form so it reaches more people.

Seriously, today's youtubers are like the old ranting posters on message boards in the early 2000's...only it's a bigger deal due to how mainstream youtube and then social media is compared to confined forums.They get their message across more easily in visual form rather than people having to read a post. Kind of obvious.

That's the problem. People listen to these idiots and just take their word for it. Thousands of people. I actually read the comic so I can smell his horse **** through the screen.Nah, he's correct. IDW is rubbish. :P

Spoilers, Brie Larson pops up 15 times, Captain Marvel pops up 25 times. I can get not liking the movie but this guy is absolutely obsessed with it. He's like the manifestation of all those neckbeard "anti-SJWs" who are just as bad as the people they are criticizing - actually, no, they are worse. I really don't recommend that anyone else watches that sorry excuse for a video, giving this mong any Ad Revenue in exchange for getting pissed off about dumb **** is not worth it. He's literally got nothing worth saying.I think all those videos reporting on her rubbish behaviour to be honest is the least she deserves. I'm all for it. :lol:

All TheQuartering videos are based on reading articles about female characters or feministe agenda. He's annonying.Not all. He calls out corruption by game developers for short changing consumers. If he calls out feminist agendas that's because that's what's popular right now.

While it's clear he hasn't been reading the comics, his opinion is surely based purely on the negative reception that IDW has gotten on a lot of its other comics. Being an avid reader of this run of TMNT and someone who (usually) opposes SJW influence in the comics, this comic never struck me as having any of those influences. And if it does, it manages to hide them well and weave them properly into the story.To be fair I remember Bobby Curnow saying the decision to have a female Turtle was something they felt they had to do. Make of that what you will.

Maybe it would hurt their masculine feels to find a girl cool, so they NEED it to be made super clear to them that "this one is a girl" so they don't accidentally go liking any "girl stuff." Not being sure enough scares them.The argument Jeremy makes is that artist Sophie Campbell (apparently formly Ross Campbell according to the video) is just recycling her deviant art.

Andrew NDB
07-19-2019, 02:29 PM
To be fair I remember Bobby Curnow saying the decision to have a female Turtle was something they felt they had to do. Make of that what you will.

I don't think he said that. Did he say that? If so, why?

ChosenOne
07-19-2019, 03:16 PM
The argument Jeremy makes is that artist Sophie Campbell (apparently formly Ross Campbell according to the video) is just recycling her deviant art.

I fail to see how this is relevant.

And I don't agree with the recycling sentiment either. An artist working on a TMNT comic did some original TMNT artwork on a personal basis that she later used as a starting point when called upon to come up with a professional sketch of a new TMNT character? *gasp* Shocking!

How many different ways and colors can a female ninja turtle be drawn, anyway? It's hardly like doing a background character in Frieza's army for DBZ.

Dejablue
07-19-2019, 03:20 PM
I don't think he said that. Did he say that? If so, why?


It hardly matters. Why can't there be a female turtle? And technically its not even a new charactere. It's just Jennika. What rules in this universe prohibit this? Nothing far as I can see. It all comes down to the fans being anal and not liking change. Even if the change is inoffensive (at least not offensive yet).

Its just a text book example of people looking for boogymen in the dark so hard that they start making up shapes out of nothing.

For the sake of argument though I do predict that Jennika won't remain a turtle forever. The IDW team probably saw the failure of Venus as a challenge.


Nah, he's correct. IDW is rubbish. :P


Prove it.

Speaking of change. Its something most fans don't want. Remember when fans were screaming because the Shredder wasn't going to be in Rise? So if nothing else IDW is giving them everything they want but with a new twist.

Andrew NDB
07-19-2019, 03:44 PM
It hardly matters. Why can't there be a female turtle?

There can be. My question was intended to help get an understanding of why he felt that was something they "had to do." Like, why would they possibly have to do that? On the basis of what, exactly?

But I also don't think he said that.

ChosenOne
07-19-2019, 03:55 PM
I dig the self-imposed challenge angle. Let's face it, the franchise isn't going anywhere even if this development falls flat (which it won't) since it has already bounced back from much worse. And at some point down the line, someone else would take a crack at incorporating a female turtle into the mythos. Why not let the people whose track record has been spotless and successfully meshed together so many disparate elements of TMNT history have a go at it? If they can't make it work, then quite honestly no one can. And they probably wanted to test themselves and see if they could indeed make it work.

IDW has more than earned their right to try. To hell with the criticisms.

Dejablue
07-19-2019, 03:59 PM
I wouldn't call IDW's track record spotless. But they are certainly not 'rubbish'. Far from it.

The Deadman
07-19-2019, 04:25 PM
The Quartering is a guy who constantly cries about SJW-ism in just about everything comic book related. Not sure why anyone takes his criticism seriously.

Sabacooza
07-19-2019, 06:11 PM
I've already heard from a surprising amount of people whining that I didn't draw Jennika with boobs. :tlol:That was part of the criticism with the Next Mutation design so I find it ridiculous that they want boobs now. Honestly, it didn't make sense then and it certainly wouldn't make sense now.

TigerClaw
07-19-2019, 06:25 PM
Its funny because no one complained when Alopex didn't have any boobs. Yet they are now complaining that a female mutant turtle doesn't have any.

Candy Kappa
07-19-2019, 06:34 PM
Its funny because no one complained when Alopex didn't have any boobs. Yet they are now complaining that a female mutant turtle doesn't have any.

Or Koya


It's probably a turtle tiddy thing :lol:

Mutant Ninja Anole
07-19-2019, 06:46 PM
Oh I’ve definitely seen people complain about Alopex’s design.
I’ve also seen people complain about Jennika wearing pants.
People will complain about anything.

pferreira
07-19-2019, 08:01 PM
I don't think he said that. Did he say that? If so, why?Found it, maybe I'm misinterpreting?: http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=54235&page=147

Post 2932

"I can only speak for myself, but fan reaction isn't something that I ever think about, so folks reactions to Venus in the past isn't anything I worried about.

I can't speak for Tom, but I know he's felt it important to have a female Turtle for a while. I think it's as simple as that!"

And I don't agree with the recycling sentiment either. An artist working on a TMNT comic did some original TMNT artwork on a personal basis that she later used as a starting point when called upon to come up with a professional sketch of a new TMNT character? *gasp* Shocking!Yeah I get that of course. I think Jeremy is trying to say that it was self-indulgence. To be fair, we've all done that at some point so he's overreacting a little there. :)

It hardly matters. Why can't there be a female turtle? And technically its not even a new charactere. It's just Jennika. What rules in this universe prohibit this? Nothing far as I can see. It all comes down to the fans being anal and not liking change. Even if the change is inoffensive (at least not offensive yet). I think that's why I started a thread about this a couple of years ago because of these kind of reactions and possible arguments in case it happened. :D

I wouldn't call IDW's track record spotless. But they are certainly not 'rubbish'. Far from it.Not an IDW TMNT fan. Check the Unpopular Opinions thread on these forums. :)

Cloudrunner
07-20-2019, 12:11 AM
Its funny because no one complained when Alopex didn't have any boobs. Yet they are now complaining that a female mutant turtle doesn't have any.

Whether or not Alopex has boobs is entirely dependent on who's drawing her. Sophie drew her without wrappings and no boobs, but Santolouco definitely drew her with them while under wraps. Regardless, she has a pretty feminine figure so I don't think anyone ever mistook her for a boy. Most people who I've shown Koya for the first time assumed they were a guy.

Allio
07-20-2019, 12:20 AM
Depending on who you ask, some would say that Sophie's (Ross at the time) deign of Alopex in her micro made her clearly furry bait.

I mean I still see some people that prefer her more animalistic design from Raph's micro and Santa's design,to Sophies.

Cloudrunner
07-20-2019, 01:16 AM
Depending on who you ask, some would say that Sophie's (Ross at the time) deign of Alopex in her micro made her clearly furry bait.

I mean I still see some people that prefer her more animalistic design from Raph's micro and Santa's design,to Sophies.

I think she looked fine in her micro. It was her Northhampton look that I think made her too cute and attracted the tumblr/furry crowd. Right now I think my favorite look for her is in the two part TMNT Universe where she and Raph infiltrated Null's labs. Santolouco's design is alright but has one major problem, and that's that he draws her (and the turtles) really short, and when they're standing side by side with human characters it looks pretty awkward. I really don't think the animalistic design pre-micro fit her character much. She was too monstrous and looked more like a wolf than a fox. And with there being so many monstrous Foot mutants (literally all of them besides Alopex), it was nice to have at least one who looked like they fit the role of "ninja".

Andrew NDB
07-20-2019, 02:37 AM
That was part of the criticism with the Next Mutation design so I find it ridiculous that they want boobs now. Honestly, it didn't make sense then and it certainly wouldn't make sense now.

Playing devil's advocate but actually it would make sense now, more than in NT:TNM. Now I'm anti-shell boobs entirely and wouldn't want to see them anywhere period (now 4-6 boobs on Alopex, as probably there would be? maybe).. but Jennika is a human becoming turtle, not a turtle becoming a big turtle, which is what happened to the main Turtles in IDW as well as NT:TNM. Could be some latent human DNA doing weird stuff there, no?

Sophie Campbell
07-20-2019, 10:53 AM
Andrew. No.

Sophie Campbell
07-20-2019, 10:54 AM
Also can you guys stop using my old name for like 5 minutes? :tgrumble:

hypered1
07-20-2019, 11:14 AM
Also can you guys stop using my old name for like 5 minutes? :tgrumble:

I agree with this sentiment, it's incredibly offensive.
Additionally I'd like to see this thread be locked and disposed of; giving any airtime to people like the 'Quartering' and his ilk on youtube, or some of the attitudes I've seen in this thread is nothing but waste of time and energy or to put it another way: DO NOT FEED THE TROLLS.

I'd like to think the members of this forum can be better than that.

BIN THIS THREAD IMMEDIATELY

pferreira
07-20-2019, 11:29 AM
I agree with this sentiment, it's incredibly offensive.
Additionally I'd like to see this thread be locked and disposed of; giving any airtime to people like the 'Quartering' and his ilk on youtube, or some of the attitudes I've seen in this thread is nothing but waste of time and energy or to put it another way: DO NOT FEED THE TROLLS.

I'd like to think the members of this forum can be better than that.

BIN THIS THREAD IMMEDIATELYI personally think it's important certain topics he brings up are important. Perhaps not the subject of this thread but certainly most I've seen. I mean is this okay? Should it not be reported on?

vEytypfwVQw

hypered1
07-20-2019, 11:52 AM
I personally think it's important certain topics he brings up are important. Perhaps not the subject of this thread but certainly most I've seen. I mean is this okay? Should it not be reported on?


That kind of video has a valid purpose and there will always be exceptions (and the Quartering is by no means the worst of the "reporter"-type youtubers), but the general negative click-bait videos focusing on various fandoms (TMNT, Star Wars, Star Trek, etc) are nothing a cheap and easy way of getting ad revenue from the ignorant vocal minorities associated with them.

As I've posted on a number of these videos: Wait until you've seen the final product before passing judgement, until then everything is hearsay and wild theories.

As for the disgusting comments about Sophie; none of that bears any witness to the quality of her work and does not belong on here.

Sophie Campbell
07-20-2019, 12:05 PM
Thank you, hypered1! <3

The Deadman
07-20-2019, 12:31 PM
I agree with this sentiment, it's incredibly offensive.
Additionally I'd like to see this thread be locked and disposed of; giving any airtime to people like the 'Quartering' and his ilk on youtube, or some of the attitudes I've seen in this thread is nothing but waste of time and energy or to put it another way: DO NOT FEED THE TROLLS.

I'd like to think the members of this forum can be better than that.

BIN THIS THREAD IMMEDIATELY

IMO legit criticism isn't offensive and shouldn't be silenced if someone doesn't like it.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 12:35 PM
Playing devil's advocate but actually it would make sense now, more than in NT:TNM. Now I'm anti-shell boobs entirely and wouldn't want to see them anywhere period (now 4-6 boobs on Alopex, as probably there would be? maybe).. but Jennika is a human becoming turtle, not a turtle becoming a big turtle, which is what happened to the main Turtles in IDW as well as NT:TNM. Could be some latent human DNA doing weird stuff there, no?


I personally headcanon that human mammalian traits could show up on a human to reptilian mutant. But not shell boobs. On a chameleon or gecko or something maybe. But it's just dumb on a turtle because its not like they can be used behind the plastron. At most you could maybe denote a more feminine build with a suggestion of hips and slimmer body. But the whole "shell" thing gets in the way.

Mr Salk
07-20-2019, 12:38 PM
The best thing about this forum is that everyone knows the definition of Plastron.

hypered1
07-20-2019, 12:38 PM
IMO legit criticism isn't offensive and shouldn't be silenced if someone doesn't like it.

That's my point, most of those videos aren't legitimate criticism. They take tiny scraps of often rumoured information, twist them around and then spew out a tirade of nonsense created by their own demented minds.

Allio
07-20-2019, 12:39 PM
I'm assuming that since it was Leonardo's blood itself that did the trick, that Jenny's mutation takes more after Leonardo rather than just being a turtle itself.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 12:44 PM
The best thing about this forum is that everyone knows the definition of Plastron.

I thought you were being sarcastic so I googled plastron to make sure I wasn't being stupid.

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 01:29 PM
The best thing about this forum is that everyone knows the definition of Plastron.

I know, right? As a zoology/biology nerd, I really enjoy that. :D

Regarding the criticisms, I'll say this: IDW TMNT was built on different concepts and pushing the envelope from the get-go. The resurrection angle, Hob as a Magneto-like figure for mutants, Shredder and Krang being mortal enemies, Splinter taking over the Foot Clan, yada, yada, yada. And everyone loves them. But all of a sudden a new concept that pushes the envelope of what can be done with the franchise pops up, and people start losing their minds? Why, exactly? Because it's a female Turtle? Meh, I say. It's not legitimate at all. It's cherry picking. Smart money says the loudest critics aren't even fans of this iteration.

Sabacooza
07-20-2019, 01:37 PM
Playing devil's advocate but actually it would make sense now, more than in NT:TNM. Now I'm anti-shell boobs entirely and wouldn't want to see them anywhere period (now 4-6 boobs on Alopex, as probably there would be? maybe).. but Jennika is a human becoming turtle, not a turtle becoming a big turtle, which is what happened to the main Turtles in IDW as well as NT:TNM. Could be some latent human DNA doing weird stuff there, no?You bring up a valid point.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 01:48 PM
Yeah imagine lactating breasts leaking inside of her shell and then the milk starts to rot inside her body. Totally valid point. Because bewbs r hawt.

The Deadman
07-20-2019, 01:57 PM
I know, right? As a zoology/biology nerd, I really enjoy that. :D

Regarding the criticisms, I'll say this: IDW TMNT was built on different concepts and pushing the envelope from the get-go. The resurrection angle, Hob as a Magneto-like figure for mutants, Shredder and Krang being mortal enemies, Splinter taking over the Foot Clan, yada, yada, yada. And everyone loves them. But all of a sudden a new concept that pushes the envelope of what can be done with the franchise pops up, and people start losing their minds? Why, exactly? Because it's a female Turtle? Meh, I say. It's not legitimate at all. It's cherry picking. Smart money says the loudest critics aren't even fans of this iteration.

Isnt it because the character in question came to being as a DeviantArt fanfic?

Allio
07-20-2019, 01:57 PM
Are you implying rotting milk isn't hot?

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 02:01 PM
Isnt it because the character in question came to being as a DeviantArt fanfic?

The character in question isn't called Artemisia, is she? Like I asked before somewhere around here, how many different ways and colors can a mutant ninja turtle be drawn? Especially if it's a character meant to fit in with the OG Turtles, which of course rules out Slash's various artistic interpretations.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 02:01 PM
Isnt it because the character in question came to being as a DeviantArt fanfic?

I dont think so. Jennika wasnt derived from fanfiction. But the basic design...maybe? Just because her bandanna is yellow I guess? Personally I'm against Jennika having a mask....already. Feels like she might be adapting to the idea of being a mutant turtle too quickly.

And yes rotting milk is hot but not in the context I'm talking about. Also it's usually room temperature.

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 02:03 PM
I dont think so. Jennika wasnt derived from fanfiction. But the basic design...maybe? Just because her bandanna is yellow I guess? Personally I'm against Jennika having a mask....already. Feels like she might be adapting to the idea of being a mutant turtle too quickly.

It's a mutant ninja turtle. Even the originals couldn't be told apart except for their weapons, and later their colors. There's hardly any leeway there to innovate wildly in her design. Mutant Jennika was always gonna look like Artemisia or Venus or what-have-you, because that's what they all are: mutant ninja turtles.

And yes rotting milk is hot but not in the context I'm talking about. Also it's usually room temperature.

Okay, now I vote this thread should be closed. And hurled into the sun.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 02:15 PM
Whaaat? I was just answering Allio.

But honestly I don't care. I've made my case. If the higher ups want to close this thread so be it. I think it's been mostly civil so far. Surprisingly. Shockingly.

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 02:20 PM
Whaaat? I was just answering Allio.

But honestly I don't care. I've made my case. If the higher ups want to close this thread so be it. I think it's been mostly civil so far. Surprisingly. Shockingly.

I was joking, of course. The "hurled into the sun" bit should've tipped you off. :lol:

Allio
07-20-2019, 02:24 PM
Okay, now I vote this thread should be closed.



Chosen, don't minimod.


As for the coloring, yeah. If you were to actually add another turtle to the group yellow is the only one you can go with as to represent the primary and secondary colors (With green being a no-go) and not make the new turtle stand up.

The only thing that really connects Jenny and Art, is that they have a bow and arrow - and even then we have just seen Jenny with it only in concept art. The two official images we have seen (a cover and panel) she doesn't have it.

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 02:32 PM
Chosen, don't minimod.

Guys, where's your sense of humor? :tgrumble:

As for the coloring, yeah. If you were to actually add another turtle to the group yellow is the only one you can go with as to represent the primary and secondary colors (With green being a no-go) and not make the new turtle stand up.

You know, depending on the Turtle's skin tone, since they can vary subtly, the right tone of green miiight just work... I'd actually like to see someone give that a go, actually, just to sate my curiosity. Assuming there isn't some fan art like that out there already.

The only thing that really connects Jenny and Art, is that they have a bow and arrow - and even then we have just seen Jenny with it only in concept art. The two official images we have seen (a cover and panel) she doesn't have it.

She will probably wield a bow again at some point, though. I can't recall any specific examples but I do believe she used one in battle when the Foot ambushed the Triceratons, and aimed it at Karai to get her to leave after the negotiations went sour. It's as much her signature weapon as the claws.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 02:34 PM
Sorry. Sometimes I can't read humor in text lol.

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 02:39 PM
Sorry. Sometimes I can't read humor in text lol.

Don't apologize, I'm the one who should've used a smilie on there.

I do agree it's actually been quite a civil thread, but that's what happens when 98% of the people here are in agreement that such criticisms are plain dumb.

Candy Kappa
07-20-2019, 02:41 PM
Isnt it because the character in question came to being as a DeviantArt fanfic?

Most things come from fan fiction, I donno if you throw in devantart with negative intention but it doesn't change that most ideas and characters at one point was "fan fiction"

Allio
07-20-2019, 03:22 PM
I think there is a difference between a new character that moves to town and
"I'm Character A and B child from the future, I also have the same powers as A and B, but also the powers of character C whom is my uncle. and I am really super powerful, I might more powerful than everyone."

But I suppose it also comes down to the execution and how the story is written. Like Trunks could have easily been hated over the fact that he easily dispatch Frieza and his father, but the fact he still lost to goku with a finger at least gave us the idea of "nothing special." meanwhile had the story gone about with Trunks being better than everyone else, yeah, he probably would be called "bad fanfiction"


Then, of course, you have an example of a character having a sister that has never been mentioned before even though that literally everything about said character has been written as an only child and they even have a family photo of just the 2 parents and 1 child. Seriously, *UCK Ramona.

Then of course you got people who just love a bad original character for some god forsaken reason. Looking at you Lord Drakkon. You and your little "Ooo, look at me. I'm an evil Tommy from the future. I'm just like normal tommy but I am twice as powerful because of a bad ass suit of White/Green powers. I killed both Jason and Billy, as well as Rita and Zordon. I am the evil overlord of my time. Oh, but woe is me, nobody loves me as much as they love the other tommy.

Sophie Campbell
07-20-2019, 03:36 PM
I think there is a difference between a new character that moves to town and
"I'm Character A and B child from the future, I also have the same powers as A and B, but also the powers of character C whom is my uncle. and I am really super powerful, I might more powerful than everyone."

But I suppose it also comes down to the execution and how the story is written. Like Trunks could have easily been hated over the fact that he easily dispatch Frieza and his father, but the fact he still lost to goku with a finger at least gave us the idea of "nothing special." meanwhile had the story gone about with Trunks being better than everyone else, yeah, he probably would be called "bad fanfiction"


Then, of course, you have an example of a character having a sister that has never been mentioned before even though that literally everything about said character has been written as an only child and they even have a family photo of just the 2 parents and 1 child. Seriously, *UCK Ramona.

Then of course you got people who just love a bad original character for some god forsaken reason. Looking at you Lord Drakkon. You and your little "Ooo, look at me. I'm an evil Tommy from the future. I'm just like normal tommy but I am twice as powerful because of a bad ass suit of White/Green powers. I killed both Jason and Billy, as well as Rita and Zordon. I am the evil overlord of my time. Oh, but woe is me, nobody loves me as much as they love the other tommy.

You've just described writing vs. silly writing (very subjective, obvs), not writing vs. fanfiction.

Also "I'm Character A and B child from the future, I also have the same powers as A and B, but also the powers of character C whom is my uncle. and I am really super powerful, I might more powerful than everyone." sounds pretty cool... *writes down in TMNT idea notebook*

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 03:39 PM
You've just described writing vs. silly writing (very subjective, obvs), not writing vs. fanfiction.

Also "I'm Character A and B child from the future, I also have the same powers as A and B, but also the powers of character C whom is my uncle. and I am really super powerful, I might more powerful than everyone." sounds pretty cool... *writes down in TMNT idea notebook*

IDW Armaggon will be the son of Renet and Bludgeon confirmed! :lol:

Allio
07-20-2019, 03:43 PM
I was speaking that from experience. Ah. My Inuyasha fan character. He had all four swords. Those days I just laugh at my young self that couldn't even finish one fanfic.

IDW Armaggon will be the son of Renet and Bludgeon confirmed! :lol:

Dude. Everyone knows that KoyaxBludgeon is OTP.

neatoman
07-20-2019, 03:48 PM
IDW Armaggon will be the son of Renet and Bludgeon confirmed! :lol:

So how do they make out without Renet losing her tongue?

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 03:52 PM
Dude. Everyone knows that KoyaxBludgeon is OTP.

Cross a time traveller with a shark, you get a time travelling shark. Cross a hawk with a shark, you get a penguin. It's basic biology, man. :D

So how do they make out without Renet losing her tongue?

You got me there. Though sharks' tongues work differently than a mammal's and aren't even tongues per se, so maybe the real answer is... Not at all?

(I knew we should've hurled this thing into the sun when we had the chance!)

Sophie Campbell
07-20-2019, 03:54 PM
Dude. Everyone knows that KoyaXBludgeon is OTP.

Seriously!!!

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 03:56 PM
I used to ship Koya and Bludgeon but now they feel more like brother and sister. If they were ever to become an official couple, it just wouldn't feel quite right. To me, anyway, and that's not worth much in the grand scheme of things.

Sophie Campbell
07-20-2019, 03:58 PM
I used to ship Koya and Bludgeon but now they feel more like brother and sister. If they were ever to become an official couple, it just wouldn't feel quite right. To me, anyway, and that's not worth much in the grand scheme of things.

I kind of agree, yeah. But I feel like they're still an OTP even without romance, like they're a platonic OTP!

neatoman
07-20-2019, 04:01 PM
Well clearly the best ship is Bebop/Rocksteady.
http://i.imgur.com/RmCrh2g.jpg

Allio
07-20-2019, 04:21 PM
You've just described writing vs. silly writing (very subjective, obvs), not writing vs. fanfiction.

*

Which ultimately is what it comes down to. It’s the idea that official material is treated seriously while FanFiction is something silly, despite it can be reversed with fanfiction can be treated more seriously than source material.

Honestly the only difference between writing and fanfiction is a seal of approval of the franchise owner.

Sabacooza
07-20-2019, 04:23 PM
Yeah imagine lactating breasts leaking inside of her shell and then the milk starts to rot inside her body. Totally valid point. Because bewbs r hawt.Stop being an ass.

Dejablue
07-20-2019, 04:37 PM
Stop being an ass.

Oh my~~ I knew it wouldn't be long before some butt hurt started to manifest.

Anyway, character who is child of character a & b from the future is super cheesy but isn't it kinda an old school trope? I don't recall it in TMNT but I wouldn't be surprised if it's been done with Shadow. Or at least thought about.

Powder
07-20-2019, 04:53 PM
Well clearly the best ship is Bebop/Rocksteady.
http://i.imgur.com/RmCrh2g.jpg

The bedroom eyes. Oh lord.

ChosenOne
07-20-2019, 04:57 PM
The bedroom eyes. Oh lord.

That poor parrot has seen things! :o

neatoman
07-20-2019, 05:20 PM
The bedroom eyes. Oh lord.

That poor parrot has seen things! :o

Well clearly Rocksteady is into men with hairy chests and piercings, teeth sticking out is maybe not that attractive but nobody's perfect.

lonewarrior20
07-20-2019, 05:34 PM
i think this bit represents the best way this thread has gone.
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/88/70/4a/88704a2b6aaf9c4f9f2ec7e090ce8c2f.jpg

Shark_Blade
07-21-2019, 03:35 AM
Well clearly the best ship is Bebop/Rocksteady.
http://i.imgur.com/RmCrh2g.jpg

I think I've read this comic somewhere before... didn't they go shopping butt naked or something? :tlol::lol: And the turtles looking at them weird but they themselves are naked this wholetime ...

Anyone know what the book title is? Nevermind, found it (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2014/05/tmnt-30th-anniversary-special.html)

edit: I was right! XD

https://i.imgur.com/YQxN2ir.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/Lb1IpTi.jpg

Utrommaniac
07-21-2019, 11:38 AM
That whole subplot was wild, but the best of it was the turtles "Oh please god no" (Though didn't Rocksteady talk about his "best girl" rhino?).
"Yeah, we got bored of plants on Animal Paradise Planet, so we're stopping in for some snacks"

Blugeon and Koya are absolutely siblings.

As for the OTP. Me. For the past three years.

https://i.imgur.com/SjkNkhQ.png
https://i.imgur.com/WeU6vNd.png

He drops face-first out of stasis and the first thing he does is demand to see his boss? Instead of his last remaining family? The same family who was concerned about how he'd respond to his boss's imprisonment? And if I'm going way over my head (and gahh, I probably am), is he okay? Did any therapists make it to Burnow Island? What was so important that he had to see Krang right away instead of his own sister?
I don't care how crazy loyal you are! Who does that?
(Honestly, he was TAME when he confronted Ma'riell about everything, but he had bigger things to worry about at the time)


The ship I'm going down with as this whole train derails right off a cliff and inevitably burns in the incinerator where it belongs...but for once, I may as well ride the train for a moment.

(Also, wouldn't that just be a cousin's cousin's former roommate? I've been questioning that for a while)

Cloudrunner
07-22-2019, 06:55 PM
I take the cowards way out and ship the pair that the comic ships. Alopex and Raph all the way.

rickwj324
07-23-2019, 12:08 PM
I barely got a minute into the video...saw no reason to continue. The guy is a moron. And reading through the posts ... holy s**t...the internet really is full of a**holes, isn't it!!?? :roll:

Dejablue
07-25-2019, 12:51 AM
I barely got a minute into the video...saw no reason to continue. The guy is a moron. And reading through the posts ... holy s**t...the internet really is full of a**holes, isn't it!!?? :roll:

Certainly full of people who will blindly believe 1 person's opinion instead of reading the comic to form their own opinion.

pferreira
08-02-2019, 03:01 PM
Additionally I'd like to see this thread be locked and disposed of;Where's Cybercubed when we need him? :D

That kind of video has a valid purpose and there will always be exceptions (and the Quartering is by no means the worst of the "reporter"-type youtubers), but the general negative click-bait videos focusing on various fandoms (TMNT, Star Wars, Star Trek, etc) are nothing a cheap and easy way of getting ad revenue from the ignorant vocal minorities associated with them.Yeah I mean even I get exasperated and tired with all these negative YouTubers but then I see the other side who tell people they can't object to something. The best way to see sites like The Quartering is like a newspaper, except in visual form.

Most things come from fan fiction, I donno if you throw in devantart with negative intention but it doesn't change that most ideas and characters at one point was "fan fiction"Could TMNT be considered fan fiction since it began life as a parody by Eastman and Laird who were trying to come up with the most craziest ideas for a comic?

Well clearly the best ship is Bebop/Rocksteady.
Oh you... :lol:

I think I've read this comic somewhere before... didn't they go shopping butt naked or something? :tlol::lol: And the turtles looking at them weird but they themselves are naked this wholetime ...
Th-they did a sequel? :o

IMO legit criticism isn't offensive and shouldn't be silenced if someone doesn't like it.This is where it becomes a difficult matter, it depends on the subjectivity and objectivity of those in charge on a discussion page.

corvus
08-03-2019, 12:36 PM
Sophie Campbell was the target of this kind of thing awhile back cause of her work on tmnt and Jem and holograms (and before anyone asks I absolutely refuse to post a link to this filth). The jerk writing this article seemed to think idw tmnt was aimed at children which should tell you enough.
I've seen incel types like this claiming x-men had been "turned into sjw propaganda" cause Ice-man came out out as gay...like yeah, the x-men are literally social justice warriors, thats the premise of the comic and has been since Claremont was writing.
With a few Notable exceptions (Ditko and Miller) Comics have been a progressive medium for a long time, the golden age happened because of anti-nazi propaganda.

People like this are not worth acknowledging.

neatoman
08-03-2019, 08:02 PM
Could TMNT be considered fan fiction since it began life as a parody by Eastman and Laird who were trying to come up with the most craziest ideas for a comic?


Homage, not parody, very important distinction.

Secondly, no it doesn't count fan fiction in the slightest. Fan fiction does by definition make use of other people's characters (specifically characters that are still under copyright protection), and was written/published without the copyright holder's involvement.

You can draw clear parallels between Splinter and Stick, TMNT to the X-Men, Utroms to Skrull, Triceratons to Kree, Baxter Stockman to Spencer Smythe, Savanti to Kang, Shredder to the Silver Samurai, so on and so forth. All the mentioned characters are however distinct, they don't qualify as the same ones. Likewise, anything made by Sophie for IDW can't be considered fan fiction as anything she makes is under the license and approval of TMNT's copyright holders.

And in case you're wondering, when TMNT goes public domain (2079), any TMNT stories written using only characters established in the first year will not be considered fan fiction regardless of who the author or publisher is.

pferreira
08-16-2019, 11:04 AM
Playing devil's advocate but actually it would make sense now, more than in NT:TNM. Now I'm anti-shell boobs entirely and wouldn't want to see them anywhere period (now 4-6 boobs on Alopex, as probably there would be? maybe).. but Jennika is a human becoming turtle, not a turtle becoming a big turtle, which is what happened to the main Turtles in IDW as well as NT:TNM. Could be some latent human DNA doing weird stuff there, no?Did you see my quote from the Ask Editor thread? Am I totally misinterpreting what was said or is it what I originally said?

With a few Notable exceptions (Ditko and Miller) Comics have been a progressive medium for a long time, the golden age happened because of anti-nazi propaganda.

People like this are not worth acknowledging.There's social justice...and there's social justice. ;)

Secondly, no it doesn't count fan fiction in the slightest. Fan fiction does by definition make use of other people's characters (specifically characters that are still under copyright protection), and was written/published without the copyright holder's involvement.

Oh okay I see. But then Wiki is wrong? If so it needs to be changed neatoman:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles

The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles first appeared in an American comic book published by Mirage Studios in 1984 in Dover, New Hampshire. The concept arose from a humorous drawing sketched out by Eastman during a casual evening of brainstorming and bad television with Laird.[3] Using money from a tax refund, together with a loan from Eastman's uncle, the young artists self-published a single-issue comic intended to parody four of the most popular comics of the early 1980s: Marvel Comics’ Daredevil and New Mutants, Dave Sim’s Cerebus, and Frank Miller’s Ronin.[4] The TMNT comic book series has been published in various incarnations by various comic book companies since 1984.

ChosenOne
08-16-2019, 11:07 AM
Parody isn't the same as fan fiction. For instance, The Naked Gun is a parody of police procedurals and noir crime stories, would you say it's fan fiction?

pferreira
08-16-2019, 06:42 PM
Parody isn't the same as fan fiction. For instance, The Naked Gun is a parody of police procedurals and noir crime stories, would you say it's fan fiction?I get that now but neatoman called TMNT homage when Wiki states it was intended as a parody. So if it's wrong maybe someone should change it?

neatoman
08-17-2019, 09:21 AM
I get that now but neatoman called TMNT homage when Wiki states it was intended as a parody. So if it's wrong maybe someone should change it?

Yes, someone should. TMNT isn't intended to mock these comics, it doesn't even qualify as comedy. I see why people might assume it's parody considering the main characters are mutant turtles, but anyone who's familiar with the comics would know it's played too straight.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-18-2019, 08:57 AM
The first issue was intended as a parody of Daredevil, X-Men, Fantastic Four, etc. It was originally most likely going to be a one and done. It sold so well that Eastman and Laird decided to do a series instead.

neatoman
08-18-2019, 10:26 AM
The first issue was intended as a parody of Daredevil, X-Men, Fantastic Four, etc. It was originally most likely going to be a one and done. It sold so well that Eastman and Laird decided to do a series instead.

That issue isn't parody either because it's not meant to be humorous, if anything it's the least humorous in the series.

Damo
08-18-2019, 07:47 PM
Not everyone agrees on what's funny.

And I would argue that there's something at least a little amusing about a comic that's basically "let's take those grim and gritty stories about ninjas, vengeance, and honor duels... and it's going to star giant turtle people."

At least initially, the series deliberately tried not to take itself too seriously. Casey was initially conceived (and written) as a crazy vigilante whose origin was literally "he watched too many movies/shows like Dirty Harry."

But it's worth noting that the term "parody" doesn't just refer to things that are humorous in content. James Joyce's Ulysses is considered a parody of Homer's Odyssey. Watchmen is a parody of traditional superhero comics. Shows like The Twilight Zone (and more recently Black Mirror) have long done "parodies" of popular genres.

Sometimes a parody is nothing more than just an author asking questions not asked in the original stories... what DOES happen during "happily ever after" is a popular source of parody.

tldr: Parodies don't have to be funny.

neatoman
08-19-2019, 05:17 PM
Not everyone agrees on what's funny.

And I would argue that there's something at least a little amusing about a comic that's basically "let's take those grim and gritty stories about ninjas, vengeance, and honor duels... and it's going to star giant turtle people."

At least initially, the series deliberately tried not to take itself too seriously. Casey was initially conceived (and written) as a crazy vigilante whose origin was literally "he watched too many movies/shows like Dirty Harry."

But it's worth noting that the term "parody" doesn't just refer to things that are humorous in content. James Joyce's Ulysses is considered a parody of Homer's Odyssey. Watchmen is a parody of traditional superhero comics. Shows like The Twilight Zone (and more recently Black Mirror) have long done "parodies" of popular genres.

Sometimes a parody is nothing more than just an author asking questions not asked in the original stories... what DOES happen during "happily ever after" is a popular source of parody.

tldr: Parodies don't have to be funny.

Watchmen is typically called a deconstruction, not parody. Anyway, here are some definitions of parodies I could find.

writing, music, art, speech, etc. that intentionally copies the style of someone famous or copies a particular situation, making the features or qualities of the original more noticeable in a way that is humorous:
A parody is a humorous or mocking imitation of something, using the same form as the original. To parody a poem, you have to write another poem.
A parody is a form of humor that spoofs — or satirizes — something using the same form. For example, shows like "Saturday Night Live" and "The Daily Show" parody newscasts by doing fake newscasts that look like the real thing. Comedians and comedy writers love to parody the President. Anything in the public eye could be the object of a parody.
par·o·dy (păr′ə-dē)
n. pl. par·o·dies
1.
a. A literary or artistic work that uses imitation, as of the characteristic style of an author or a work, for comic effect or ridicule.
b. A genre, as in literature, comprising such works.
parody noun
par·​o·​dy | \ ˈper-ə-dē , ˈpa-rə-\
plural parodies
Definition of parody (Entry 1 of 2)
1 : a literary or musical work in which the style of an author or work is closely imitated for comic effect or in ridicule
wrote a hilarious parody of a popular song
2 : a feeble or ridiculous imitation
a cheesy parody of a classic western

Even ignoring how all of these definitions emphasise mockery, homage would still be a better word to describe TMNT, as it's is more closely associated with non-mocking imitations.

pferreira
08-23-2019, 12:49 PM
Yes, someone should. TMNT isn't intended to mock these comics, it doesn't even qualify as comedy. I see why people might assume it's parody considering the main characters are mutant turtles, but anyone who's familiar with the comics would know it's played too straight.Do you think perhaps the TMNT creations started off as a parody but when Laird and Eastman starting thinking about TMNT as a comic it quickly turned into an homage?

Andrew NDB
08-23-2019, 01:04 PM
Do you think perhaps the TMNT creations started off as a parody but when Laird and Eastman starting thinking about TMNT as a comic it quickly turned into an homage?

Not really, no.

neatoman
08-23-2019, 05:33 PM
Do you think perhaps the TMNT creations started off as a parody but when Laird and Eastman starting thinking about TMNT as a comic it quickly turned into an homage?

No I agree with Andrew here, it really doesn't work like that either. The official story behind the creation is that Kevin drew a turtle carrying ninja weapons, which lead to brainstorming between him and Peter. That story would imply they were an original idea at first and any similarities were added later on.

An actual example of what you're talking about would be how Super Dimension Fortress Macross (or Robotech season 1 if you prefer) relates to Mobile Suit Gundam and Space Battleship Yamato (Starblazers). While Macross was initially pitched as "parody" (can't really find any reliable sources that it was intended to be humorous but let's assume that's the case) the show can't really be called a comedy, but it is still clearly inspired by Gundam and Yamato from the start.

pferreira
09-02-2019, 03:11 PM
Not really, no.Did you see my quote from the Ask Editor thread? Am I totally misinterpreting what was said or is it what I originally said?

No I agree with Andrew here, it really doesn't work like that either. The official story behind the creation is that Kevin drew a turtle carrying ninja weapons, which lead to brainstorming between him and Peter. That story would imply they were an original idea at first and any similarities were added later on.Right! Someone call Wiki, they got it wrong! :lol:

No really, if it's wrong, it needs correcting as whenever sources talk about the history of TMNT they're going to use Wiki. The Wikipedia site doesn't validate my edits so I can't do it. :ohwell:

The Purple Dragon
09-11-2019, 02:11 PM
I am sorry if i did miss the boat or stepping on some feets but i have to Ask is Sofia cambell the same AS ross campbell??perhaps i rember wrong but a long time ago i mean that it was printed a pic of ross campbell with glasset, almost no hair and skinny and it did say something like he did like to go to cafe and comic stores etc.was it a cover identety like some writers do and publish a book under a diffrent name?or is it a other story to it??in the end it dosent matter because he/she is one of my top tmnt artist with Peter,kevin,farly.just did Wonder because all this time i did think it was a man and now its a she it seems.

neatoman
09-11-2019, 02:14 PM
I am sorry if i did miss the boat or stepping on some feets but i have to Ask is Sofia cambell the same AS ross campbell??perhaps i rember wrong but a long time ago i mean that it was printed a pic of ross campbell with glasset, almost no hair and skinny and it did say something like he did like to go to cafe and comic stores etc.was it a cover identety like some writers do and publish a book under a diffrent name?or is it a other story to it??in the end it dosent matter because he/she is one of my top tmnt artist with Peter,kevin,farly.just did Wonder because all this time i did think it was a man and now its a she it seems.

Yes. Sophie Campbell is the same person as Ross Campbell.

The Purple Dragon
09-12-2019, 08:10 AM
Ok thank you fore clearing that up😊

Andrew NDB
09-12-2019, 11:12 AM
Did you see my quote from the Ask Editor thread? Am I totally misinterpreting what was said or is it what I originally said?

Right! Someone call Wiki, they got it wrong! :lol:

No really, if it's wrong, it needs correcting as whenever sources talk about the history of TMNT they're going to use Wiki. The Wikipedia site doesn't validate my edits so I can't do it. :ohwell:

It's pretty simple.

We asked Kevin: "Hey Kevin, is or was TMNT a parody?"

Kevin: "No."

We asked Peter: "Hey Peter, is or was TMNT a parody?"

Peter: "No."

Case closed. But people still like to often pretend the opposite, and/or call them liars.

Dejablue
09-17-2019, 09:40 AM
I guess similarities would be entirely coincidental? When did the parody narrative spring to life?

Andrew NDB
09-17-2019, 11:22 AM
I guess similarities would be entirely coincidental? When did the parody narrative spring to life?

Mostly fans looking for ways to belittle or poke holes in the Mirage TMNT or otherwise illustrate, "See? The whole thing is silly, just like Fred Wolf! It was made to be a parody! Lighten up!" Etc..

The Deadman
09-18-2019, 07:20 AM
Why are we still talking about the Quartering?

TommyT
09-18-2019, 10:47 AM
Mostly fans looking for ways to belittle or poke holes in the Mirage TMNT or otherwise illustrate, "See? The whole thing is silly, just like Fred Wolf! It was made to be a parody! Lighten up!" Etc..

So Splinter being named for Stick, and naming the Foot clan instead of the hand. The whole daredevil connection, you're washing that away?

Andrew NDB
09-18-2019, 10:50 AM
So Splinter being named for Stick, and naming the Foot clan instead of the hand. The whole daredevil connection, you're washing that away?

Some homage elements do not a parody make. And what's to wash away? We asked Kevin and Peter and they said no. We know better than them what they had in mind?

TommyT
09-18-2019, 11:35 AM
Some homage elements do not a parody make. And what's to wash away? We asked Kevin and Peter and they said no. We know better than them what they had in mind?

It's a soft parody, if they cop to it or not. There's evidence all through the Mirage books. It evolved into it's own thing, but that wasn't where it started.

It's in the name, as we all know.

Andrew NDB
09-18-2019, 11:39 AM
It's a soft parody, if they cop to it or not.

https://media.giphy.com/media/l4FsoQeVeMBqp662c/giphy.gif

Whatswiththeheadbands?
09-18-2019, 11:59 AM
So as someone has never read the IDW, largely because it came out when i lost interest in the franchise and when I got back into it, it had a large number of issues that I couldn't catch up with.

I heard about Jennika a few days after the initial issue came out. I started thinking it was a bad idea, but after reading her backstory and seeing her design, I liked the idea. She doesn't look female. She looks like a Mutant Turtle. The other four don't look overly male, so why does Jennika need to look overly female?

Also, due to her backstory, the idea of her wearing clothes is perfectly fine.

The idea that people are calling this 'SJW pandering' is pathetic really. They wanted to make a female Turtle, and they did. Not because of an agenda, but because they wanted to

pferreira
09-20-2019, 12:35 PM
It's in the name, as we all know.Yeah I mean any person who hears the name understands how wacky it is. I'm guessing Laird and Eastman knew how crazy the concept was but just went for it albeit with a wink in their eyes.

Case closed. But people still like to often pretend the opposite, and/or call them liars.What about the Ask Editor quote?

The idea that people are calling this 'SJW pandering' is pathetic really. They wanted to make a female Turtle, and they did. Not because of an agenda, but because they wanted toHowever is it something as Bobby Curnow related about his colleague Tom that had to be done? If so why? The problem people have is that because everything is being gender flipped or female orientated just for left wing agendas people are complaining every time it happens as well as rightly calling it out. I personally feel for example there is something wrong in the industry when DC allow a crowdfunding scammer to work for them. This is ignoring the fact said 'creator' may or may not have contributed to the suicide of a former boyfriend/colleague.

Andrew NDB
09-20-2019, 12:40 PM
What about the Ask Editor quote?

What are you talking about? Bobby Curnow doesn't get to tell us if Mirage TMNT was created to be a parody or not.

Bobby Curnow
09-20-2019, 05:21 PM
I don't recall ever saying TMNT was a parody. Certainly doesn't sound like something i'd say or reflect my thoughts. Or that we had to mutate Jennika. That's just something Tom wanted to do and went ahead and did with the rest of our blessing.

pferreira
09-20-2019, 06:30 PM
What are you talking about? Bobby Curnow doesn't get to tell us if Mirage TMNT was created to be a parody or not.Was talking about the quote in relation to what Bobby Curnow said on the Ask Editor part of the forum. I quoted what was said.

Or that we had to mutate Jennika. That's just something Tom wanted to do and went ahead and did with the rest of our blessing.But why was it something your colleague Tom felt was so important for a long time?

ChosenOne
09-20-2019, 06:34 PM
(ducks in)

Wait, two months later and this thread is still going...? Yikes!

(ducks out)

Bobby Curnow
09-20-2019, 06:46 PM
Was talking about the quote in relation to what Bobby Curnow said on the Ask Editor part of the forum. I quoted what was said.

But why was it something your colleague Tom felt was so important for a long time?

I don't want to speak for Tom. But my personal answer would be that there's no reason not to and it's important for different people to be able see themselves represented in their favorite media. If you can do that in a natural way that works in the story, then everyone wins in my personal opinion.

Now, maybe some would say it doesn't work for the story and that it feels forced... that's fine, everyone is entitled to their opinion. But I know we took steps to make Jennika a fully-realized character before the mutation so in my mind it works as a surprise twist for her that opens up more story potential.

Igglet
09-20-2019, 06:53 PM
You honestly shouldn't waste braincells even thinking about TheQuartering's opinion. He just pretends to be outraged by everything for views.

TommyT
09-20-2019, 11:06 PM
https://media.giphy.com/media/l4FsoQeVeMBqp662c/giphy.gif

You want Kevin to clear that up for you?

What are you talking about? Bobby Curnow doesn't get to tell us if Mirage TMNT was created to be a parody or not.

What makes you qualified? Fans have a special kind of blindness, I suppose.

I don't recall ever saying TMNT was a parody. Certainly doesn't sound like something i'd say or reflect my thoughts. Or that we had to mutate Jennika. That's just something Tom wanted to do and went ahead and did with the rest of our blessing.
Can we get an official comment then?

pferreira
09-21-2019, 09:39 AM
You honestly shouldn't waste braincells even thinking about TheQuartering's opinion. He just pretends to be outraged by everything for views.His video showed a number of incorrect statements. As far as I'm aware while the IDW comic doesn't do fantastic sales it still does pretty well compared to others.

I don't want to speak for Tom. But my personal answer would be that there's no reason not to and it's important for different people to be able see themselves represented in their favorite media. If you can do that in a natural way that works in the story, then everyone wins in my personal opinion.

Now, maybe some would say it doesn't work for the story and that it feels forced... that's fine, everyone is entitled to their opinion. But I know we took steps to make Jennika a fully-realized character before the mutation so in my mind it works as a surprise twist for her that opens up more story potential.Thanks for the clarification. While you're here do you know the contact email to ask about reprints? I know you don't handle that part of IDW so just wondered who to ask. :)

Kamekichi
09-21-2019, 09:42 AM
It's pretty simple.

We asked Kevin: "Hey Kevin, is or was TMNT a parody?"

Kevin: "No."

We asked Peter: "Hey Peter, is or was TMNT a parody?"

Peter: "No."

Case closed. But people still like to often pretend the opposite, and/or call them liars.

The 1985 Comic's Interview with Pete and Kevin both have them acknowledge TMNT was a parody of how comic were at that time.

They go on to say how it's not a direct parody of any particular comics just the elements from Ronin, Cerebus, Daredevil with the humor that this serious story was being done with turtles.

https://i.imgur.com/gQ2b6jy.png

And to make it more official this screenshot comes from Kevin's site.
(https://fan.kevineastmanstudios.com/comics-interview/)

TommyT
09-21-2019, 10:16 AM
The 1985 Comic's Interview with Pete and Kevin both have them acknowledge TMNT was a parody of how comic were at that time.

They go on to say how it's not a direct parody of any particular comics just the elements from Ronin, Cerebus, Daredevil with the humor that this serious story was being done with turtles.

https://i.imgur.com/gQ2b6jy.png

And to make it more official this screenshot comes from Kevin's site.
(https://fan.kevineastmanstudios.com/comics-interview/)


Thanks for pulling this up. I didn't have the time to go searching my boxes to find proof, but also thought none was really needed.
Perhaps the point of contention was that it wasn't a parody of any one comic, but comics in general.

Kamekichi
09-21-2019, 11:59 AM
Thanks for pulling this up. I didn't have the time to go searching my boxes to find proof, but also thought none was really needed.
Perhaps the point of contention was that it wasn't a parody of any one comic, but comics in general.

I just felt it best to point out that it is not the interviewer putting the word parody out there, it is in fact Peter Laird himself calling the series a parody. Whether it is a parody of a specific comic, comic genre, or just elements of comics in the '80s is another thing.

More recently:
2019 interview with Kevin using parody to describe the creation. (https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/226884-A-Life-In-Comics-Kevin-Eastman-Interview)

2014 interview with Kevin (https://redheadedmule.com/comics/kevin-eastman-interview-sac-con-2014/10218/)

What I'm most interested in are these interviews when they said that they were not parodies at all...

TommyT
09-21-2019, 02:55 PM
I just felt it best to point out that it is not the interviewer putting the word parody out there, it is in fact Peter Laird himself calling the series a parody. Whether it is a parody of a specific comic, comic genre, or just elements of comics in the '80s is another thing.

More recently:
2019 interview with Kevin using parody to describe the creation. (https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/226884-A-Life-In-Comics-Kevin-Eastman-Interview)

2014 interview with Kevin (https://redheadedmule.com/comics/kevin-eastman-interview-sac-con-2014/10218/)

What I'm most interested in are these interviews when they said that they were not parodies at all...

Maybe, it’s difficult for lifelong fanboys to admit when they are wrong, and instead they choose to double down on incorrect assumptions. Imagine being wrong about a fundamental fanboy fact. Sad!

Cloudrunner
09-21-2019, 05:56 PM
I don't want to speak for Tom. But my personal answer would be that there's no reason not to and it's important for different people to be able see themselves represented in their favorite media. If you can do that in a natural way that works in the story, then everyone wins in my personal opinion.

Now, maybe some would say it doesn't work for the story and that it feels forced... that's fine, everyone is entitled to their opinion. But I know we took steps to make Jennika a fully-realized character before the mutation so in my mind it works as a surprise twist for her that opens up more story potential.

Most of the time, when people (myself included) complain about stuff like this, it's because they're altering an existing character to fit some new progressive theme or taking the character in name only and applying it to some completely new unrelated character. What you guys have done is neither of those things. You created a new character, who fits in the lore, who has a reason to exist alongside the turtles. She's not a Mary Sue, she's not some race/gender/sexuality swap. She's her own character.

You all did everything right in Jennika's creation. If people still want to complain about it... well then there's no pleasing them.

TommyT
09-21-2019, 06:02 PM
Jennika won’t last, anymore than dead Donatello did. I doubt they’ll kill her off, but she’ll be gone in 20 issues or less.

IDW is bleeding, badly. Expect all the stunts, in quick succession.

ChosenOne
09-21-2019, 06:09 PM
Expect all the stunts, in quick succession.

They're called story beats, actually. Y'know, just like "climate change" is really called seasons by people old enough to not be surprised by them.

TommyT
09-21-2019, 08:47 PM
They're called story beats, actually. Y'know, just like "climate change" is really called seasons by people old enough to not be surprised by them.

I’m not opposed to the character, but the fact remains that IDW is a sinking ship. The female turtle/fifth turtle is scraping the bottom of the proverbial barrel, but in other respects, a hail mary.

I’d hazard a guess that Laird is not pleased with this move, but then again, maybe the resident experts here would know better.

ChosenOne
09-21-2019, 09:08 PM
What makes you think of it as a sinking ship? IDW TMNT is only now getting to that point in any ongoing series where it can tell its best and most intricate stories atop the foundation of its own continuity. It's never been as exciting.

Dejablue
09-21-2019, 11:50 PM
So as someone has never read the IDW, largely because it came out when i lost interest in the franchise and when I got back into it, it had a large number of issues that I couldn't catch up with.

I heard about Jennika a few days after the initial issue came out. I started thinking it was a bad idea, but after reading her backstory and seeing her design, I liked the idea. She doesn't look female. She looks like a Mutant Turtle. The other four don't look overly male, so why does Jennika need to look overly female?

Also, due to her backstory, the idea of her wearing clothes is perfectly fine.

The idea that people are calling this 'SJW pandering' is pathetic really. They wanted to make a female Turtle, and they did. Not because of an agenda, but because they wanted to

Lol I'm just coming back to say I agree with this post. So far at least I think Jennika is being handled mostly okay as the dreaded "5th Turtle."

TommyT
09-21-2019, 11:58 PM
What makes you think of it as a sinking ship? IDW TMNT is only now getting to that point in any ongoing series where it can tell its best and most intricate stories atop the foundation of its own continuity. It's never been as exciting.

“IDW Media Holdings, the parent company of IDW Publishing, continues to lose money, their latest financial report for Q3 2019 reveals. IDWM reported over $1.5 million in losses for the period from May 1st to July 31st, listed in the opening statement of the press release as “a net loss per share of ($0.20) on revenue of $11.5 million.

In Q2 2019, IDW Media Holdings lost $3.7 million dollars, leading one large investor, ADW Capital, to call for a sale of the company and IDW to engage J.P. Morgan Chase to evaluate the prospect of taking on a “strategic partner.” However, IDW was able to raise $23 million by selling more Class B stock to existing investors, though the largest buyer of said stock was Howard Jonas himself.

At press time, IDW could not be reached for comment.”

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 08:19 AM
As I understand it, the entire comic industry is facing a downturn at the moment. Why should IDW be any different? Doesn't seem like a cause for alarm.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 11:52 AM
As I understand it, the entire comic industry is facing a downturn at the moment. Why should IDW be any different? Doesn't seem like a cause for alarm.

That was 2017/2018.

The industry is healthy again, with sales up for most high profile books.
I’ve supported the argument. IDW is losing millions quarter over quarter. You could try googling it for yourself, if you still feel you need further proof that a FEMALE 5th TURTLE isn’t a stunt.

Especially given it will be helmed by a trans woman. How much more headline grabby could it get? Laird has a blog post about how cheap he feels the idea is, but I don’t feel it’s worth linking.

The Quartering, as loathsome as he is, has a point.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 12:03 PM
Laird's distaste for the concept of a female turtle is hardly breaking news, and certainly not originated by Jennika. We'll just have to wait and see.

Especially given it will be helmed by a trans woman.

I fail to see the relevance of this point to the discussion. She's not allowed to write female characters now? Dude...

Candy Kappa
09-22-2019, 12:09 PM
Sophie Campbell is more then qualified to write Ninja Turtles

TommyT
09-22-2019, 12:47 PM
Laird's distaste for the concept of a female turtle is hardly breaking news, and certainly not originated by Jennika. We'll just have to wait and see.



I fail to see the relevance of this point to the discussion. She's not allowed to write female characters now? Dude...

Sophie Campbell is more then qualified to write Ninja Turtles

Of course. Is that what I wrote?
Its headline grabbing clickbait. Sophie taking control alone is not something to talk about, Sophie taking control with a new character that she created that was sort of her personal avatar and is the 5th female turtle...

I mean, it’s a swissarmy knife of clickiness. This is man bites dog, to spike sales.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 12:52 PM
Sorry, I don't see it that way. You're glossing over the fact that all big developments in comics (such as Donnie's death, Splinter taking over the Foot Clan, etc) are meant to attract the public's attention, and that the concept of a female turtle was around long before Sophie, not to mention she didn't have as much of a hand in making Turtle!Jennika canon as you seem to think. We'll just have to agree to disagree.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 01:04 PM
Sorry, I don't see it that way. You're glossing over the fact that all big developments in comics (such as Donnie's death, Splinter taking over the Foot Clan, etc) are meant to attract the public's attention, and that the concept of a female turtle was around long before Sophie, not to mention she didn't have as much of a hand in making Turtle!Jennika canon as you seem to think. We'll just have to agree to disagree.

Are you serious? Tom Waltz published his correspondence with her about his plans, asking her to design the character!

How blind are you? You’ve argued that IDW isn’t sinking, but the news is the opposite, now Sophie didn’t get tapped to create Jennika? Do your research, please.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 01:09 PM
Are you serious? Tom Waltz published his correspondence with her about his plans, asking her to design the character!

How blind are you? You’ve argued that IDW isn’t sinking, but the news is the opposite, now Sophie didn’t get tapped to create Jennika? Do your research, please.

Uh... I have read those, and IIRC their correspondence was about using her pre-existing sketches to adapt to another character. She created Artemisia(sp?), not Jennika. Jennika was a pre-existing character, dating back to the first post-#50 arc and later turned into a mutant. Do your research, please. I've asked this a few times somewhere around here before and I'll ask it again with added color: how many f***ing ways can you design a female mutant ninja turtle? The differences come down to bandanna color and boobs/no boobs. That's it.

You seem to be trying to shoehorn your agenda into the facts merely to rain on IDW's parade. I'm done with that. Cheers!

Candy Kappa
09-22-2019, 01:36 PM
Jenn and Artie share like 2 things on common, color yellow and not designed to be boneriffic ie no shell boobs.

Their origin, personality and primary weapons are different

TommyT
09-22-2019, 01:39 PM
Uh... I have read those, and IIRC their correspondence was about using her pre-existing sketches to adapt to another character. She created Artemisia(sp?), not Jennika. Jennika was a pre-existing character, dating back to the first post-#50 arc and later turned into a mutant. Do your research, please. I've asked this a few times somewhere around here before and I'll ask it again with added color: how many f***ing ways can you design a female mutant ninja turtle? The differences come down to bandanna color and boobs/no boobs. That's it.

You seem to be trying to shoehorn your agenda into the facts merely to rain on IDW's parade. I'm done with that. Cheers!

No agenda here, but yours is on full display.
For the record, It’s not the female/5th turtle at issue, it’s context.

It’s like if Batman sales really slumped, and their go to was to have him use a gun. Superman isn’t interesting, so let’s kill him.

It’s hack writing. Put the pitchforks away and recognize this move for what it is.

Laird himself has written extensively on how brainless and over suggested a 5th turtle idea was, how it was suggested by every executive, at every meeting. He also eloquently write all the reasons he refused to use said idea, and his reasoning was sound.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 01:44 PM
Alright, now I'm curious. What is my "agenda"?

TommyT
09-22-2019, 01:59 PM
Alright, now I'm curious. What is my "agenda"?

One of them seems to be to pick a fight with me, and level pillory accusations against a truth you refuse to acknowledge.

As I said before, this is a hack move. If you can put out an argument to the contrary, you might change my mind. The burden of proof for how this isn’t a stunt is on you, not me.

CyberCubed
09-22-2019, 02:22 PM
Laird himself has written extensively on how brainless and over suggested a 5th turtle idea was, how it was suggested by every executive, at every meeting. He also eloquently write all the reasons he refused to use said idea, and his reasoning was sound.

Laird also hates most mutants, Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady, etc. It's not just a female Turtle, Laird dislikes all mutants outside of Leatherhead which is why he didn't allow the 4kids writers to use any of them in the 2k3 cartoon.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 02:24 PM
One of them seems to be to pick a fight with me, and level pillory accusations against a truth you refuse to acknowledge.

As opposed to picking a fight with everyone else because IDW "dared" to introduce a female turtle and you don't like it? :roll: I'm one of the least tolerant people of the whole SJW shtick you'll ever meet, and I like to think I'd be one of the first to denounce this whole affair if that's all it amounted to. But I also believe that people are worth more than just their gender or skin color or what-have-you. It doesn't matter that the next person to take over is trans, or that she had a hand in introducing (notice I don't say created) a major female character that's bound to be controversial. What matters is how she works that concept.

In other words, wait and see. I wholeheartedly put my faith in Sophie Campbell. She's earned it.

As I said before, this is a hack move. If you can put out an argument to the contrary, you might change my mind. The burden of proof for how this isn’t a stunt is on you, not me.

You're certainly free to think so. It doesn't necessarily align with reality, though. And you're mistaken in thinking I want or need to change your mind. It'll change by itself, or not at all, and the latter will be your loss.

Laird also hates most mutants, Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady, etc. It's not just a female Turtle, Laird dislikes all mutants outside of Leatherhead which is why he didn't allow the 4kids writers to use any of them in the 2k3 cartoon.

Also this.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 03:07 PM
Laird also hates most mutants, Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady, etc. It's not just a female Turtle, Laird dislikes all mutants outside of Leatherhead which is why he didn't allow the 4kids writers to use any of them in the 2k3 cartoon.

That's not true at all. He hated the characters of Bebop and Rocksteady, for how they were written, not all mutants.
His argument was that mutation shouldn't be a crutch, and should be substantive, not a vehicle for creature of the week. Bebop and Rocksteady are special cases of hatred for him, but the truth to why has yet to come to light, if we're being honest.

As opposed to picking a fight with everyone else because IDW "dared" to introduce a female turtle and you don't like it?

Who said I don't like it? That wasn't what I said. I said, it is a desperate measure, reserved for a very desperate time, like now.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 03:12 PM
Who said I don't like it? That wasn't what I said. I said, it is a desperate measure, reserved for a very desperate time, like now.

We'll just have to wait and see how desperate of a time it is. If you're right, I'll publicly acknowledge it. But you won't be.

Bear in mind, though, the comic will have to end at some point... But it's safe to say it'll continue at least up to #150.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 03:18 PM
We'll just have to wait and see how desperate of a time it is. If you're right, I'll publicly acknowledge it. But you won't be.

Bear in mind, though, the comic will have to end at some point... But it's safe to say it'll continue at least up to #150.

When shareholders are publically calling for sale of a company, I'd place bets that I am right. When Jennika disappears in a time warp, or an alternate dimension, or is kiiled off, or joins the Muteanimals, or is spun off for her own solo adventure, you'll have to contend, STUNT. She will not remain, the addition is transient, to boost sales, nothing more.

I'd also add this isn't what most people would consider to be good writing. Sensationalism, is just that, and should be acknowledged and treated as such.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 03:22 PM
When shareholders are publically calling for sale of a company, I'd place bets that I am right. When Jennika disappears in a time warp, or an alternate dimension, or is kiiled off, or joins the Muteanimals, or is spun off for her own solo adventure, you'll have to contend, STUNT. She will not remain, the addition is transient, to boost sales, nothing more.

As my cat's vet replied when I asked her if she thought a petition to build a local animal shelter from which people could adopt strays had any actual traction and chance to achieve its goal: people call for things publicly all the time, for all sorts of reasons. Doesn't mean they all come to pass.

We'll wait and see. If it goes your way, remind me. All I ask is that you keep the crow warm for me.

Sensationalism, is just that, and should be acknowledged and treated as such.

What did you think of Donnie's "death"? Sensationalist? Transient? It's the nature of comics. Plus les choses changent...

TommyT
09-22-2019, 03:35 PM
As my cat's vet replied when I asked her if she thought a petition to build a local animal shelter from which people could adopt strays had any actual traction and chance to achieve its goal: people call for things publicly all the time, for all sorts of reasons. Doesn't mean they all come to pass.

We'll wait and see. If it goes your way, remind me. All I ask is that you keep the crow warm for me.
I think it's very important, as fans, to not be myopic. IDW isn't failing BECAUSE of TURTLES, it's failing for a whole host of reasons, Turtles is one of it's stronger brands.
That said, Rise, and Micheal Bay, have spent a huge chunk of the social cred Turtles once held, (squandered, if you ask me), and diluted. Inspite of that, the love for the core idea remains.
My larger concern, is the stunts will be more dirt on the proverbial coffin, as TMNT is held up as the sacrificial lambs to bail out a company that thought Wyatt Earp was a good idea, or that anyone gives a damn about their barn of broken IP's.

Turtle-mania had an element of self sabotage, that while funny in hindsight, has real world repercussions. The brand is a buisness first and formost, and if Sophie is set up as the last thing the public see's, holding Jennika out as the latest and greatest TMNT has to offer, and it all goes tits up anyway (i almost said turtle tits, but that's both crude and rude) she'll wear the Venus hairshirt, and none of it will be her doing.

Donnies death? VERY stuntterrific. I did not approve, but I would have, if he stayed dead.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 04:02 PM
Alright, I see your point. But only time will truly tell.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 04:45 PM
Alright, I see your point. But only time will truly tell.

Cool. Also, for the record, not anti-Sophie, and not a Trump supporter.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 04:47 PM
Cool. Also, for the record, not anti-Sophie, and not a Trump supporter.

Well, nobody's perfect. :tcool:

TommyT
09-22-2019, 04:50 PM
Well, nobody's perfect. :tcool:

¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I just hope they don’t end up at DC. Image or Marvel, okay. They don’t belong at DC.

ChosenOne
09-22-2019, 04:51 PM
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I just hope they don’t end up at DC. Image or Marvel, okay. They don’t belong at DC.

On the odd chance it comes to that... Prepare to be disappointed, most likely. The groundwork's already laid out with all these crossovers.

Damo
09-22-2019, 04:59 PM
October 2015: Tom Waltz introduces a human Foot Soldier named Jennika into the book, giving the Foot Clan a human face.

Some time in 2016: Tom Waltz decides to get permission to turn Jennika into a female turtle. He has indicated that this was a long and laborious process because he needed permission from a lot of higher-ups.

January-April 2017: Jennika's origin is featured in TMNT Universe.

May 2017: Tom Waltz communicates with Sophie Campbell about coming up with a design for Jennika as a turtle. He indicates Jennika will have a yellow bandanna. Campbell is struck by the fact that she had done a fancomic with a turtle sister named Artemisia, with a yellow bandanna. Sophie suggests maybe lifting some stuff from that character. Waltz points out that Jennika was probably too fleshed out for incorporating things like personality (since her origin had just come out), and Campbell moves away from that suggestion, not incorporating any visuals from Artemisia.

July 2019: News of Jennika's mutation is announced, a culmination of years of work from Tom Waltz and an extensive process of getting permission and planning things out. Of the elements that Campbell suggested in the pitch art, the things that seem to have been used are Jennika's main weapon being claws (in reference to Shredder, and Jennika being a Foot) and... well, a decent pair of pants (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGQEAiZJMco).

TommyT
09-22-2019, 05:05 PM
On the odd chance it comes to that... Prepare to be disappointed, most likely. The groundwork's already laid out with all these crossovers.

Oh, I know. I have already made peace with it, but hate it None the less.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 05:12 PM
Do you think perhaps the TMNT creations started off as a parody but when Laird and Eastman starting thinking about TMNT as a comic it quickly turned into an homage?

This is exactly what happened, not to retread, but this point was shot down, when it is infact the official story. Why anyone is arguing it is beyond me.

Sophie Campbell
09-22-2019, 06:11 PM
May 2017: Tom Waltz communicates with Sophie Campbell about coming up with a design for Jennika as a turtle. He indicates Jennika will have a yellow bandanna. Campbell is struck by the fact that she had done a fancomic with a turtle sister named Artemisia, with a yellow bandanna. Sophie suggests maybe lifting some stuff from that character. Waltz points out that Jennika was probably too fleshed out for incorporating things like personality (since her origin had just come out), and Campbell moves away from that suggestion, not incorporating anything from Artemisia except a bow and arrow.

Not quite! I've never drawn Jennika with the bow-and-arrow, that was Michael Dialynas's addition.

Damo
09-22-2019, 07:38 PM
Not quite! I've never drawn Jennika with the bow-and-arrow, that was Michael Dialynas's addition.

Thank you for the correction! I had been incorrectly remembering you as the artist for all the design stuff in https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1148400099522801664

Always interesting to get insight into a long character creation/design process.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 07:48 PM
Not quite! I've never drawn Jennika with the bow-and-arrow, that was Michael Dialynas's addition.

To clear it up, are you considered to be a co-creator on Jennika?

Damo
09-22-2019, 07:59 PM
To clear it up, are you considered to be a co-creator on Jennika?

Tom Waltz and Ken Garing created Jennika in issue 51. Sophie and Michael Dialynas were much later asked to come up concept art for a turtle form. Sophie seems to have contributed the use of claws and something of the "clothing". A turtle's signature weapon is pretty important, but Jennika was very much created by Waltz and Garing well before Sophie and Dialynas were asked for input.

TommyT
09-22-2019, 08:15 PM
Tom Waltz and Ken Garing created Jennika in issue 51. Sophie and Michael Dialynas were much later asked to come up concept art for a turtle form. Sophie seems to have contributed the use of claws and something of the "clothing". A turtle's signature weapon is pretty important, but Jennika was very much created by Waltz and Garing well before Sophie and Dialynas were asked for input.

Lol, are you Sophie? No offence, wanted to get it from the source, you know?

Sophie Campbell
09-22-2019, 08:29 PM
To clear it up, are you considered to be a co-creator on Jennika?

Hmm, that's a complicated question. Like Damo said above Jennika showed up in #51 and wasn't mutated until over 40 issues later (not even including TMNT Universe issues, where her backstory was done by Brahm Revel), and I never worked on the character even once during that entire time. But I DID design her mutant turtle form which is obviously a huge, defining thing for the character, even though it came 3-4 years after her actual introduction.

So.. I don't know. I'd love to take some kind of co-creator credit but maybe that's just pride talking, haha. I'd say The most important people in her development over the years are Tom Waltz, Ken Garing, Brahm Revel, Michael Dialynas, and myself. Maybe co-developer is a better term than co-creator?

pferreira
10-10-2019, 10:29 AM
The 1985 Comic's Interview with Pete and Kevin both have them acknowledge TMNT was a parody of how comic were at that time.

They go on to say how it's not a direct parody of any particular comics just the elements from Ronin, Cerebus, Daredevil with the humor that this serious story was being done with turtles.So both neatoman and Wiki are in fact correct, it's just whether you view the parody as spoofing something specific or the industry as a whole?

He also eloquently write all the reasons he refused to use said idea, and his reasoning was sound.What was his reasoning?

That was 2017/2018.

The industry is healthy again, with sales up for most high profile books.
I’ve supported the argument. IDW is losing millions quarter over quarter. You could try googling it for yourself, if you still feel you need further proof that a FEMALE 5th TURTLE isn’t a stunt.I'm not a financial expert when it comes to the production of comics but does anybody know whether IDW doing variant covers is losing them money that could be saved? They do a lot of variant covers but I wonder if its needlessly wasting money. Anybody know?

They're called story beats, actually. Y'know, just like "climate change" is really called seasons by people old enough to not be surprised by them.Does anybody know the longest a comic has gone on for with its continuity before being rebooted? Superman maybe?

Peter Palmer
10-10-2019, 12:55 PM
Does anybody know the longest a comic has gone on for with its continuity before being rebooted? Superman maybe?

I'm by no means a Superman/DC expert, but the bare minimum that I understand is that DC continuity is all over the place with multiple reboots and crises shaking things up every few years/decades.

What I can tell you is that both Cerebus and Spawn had/have very long runs, each reaching 300+ issues in their respective main titles. Dave Sim and Todd McFarlane remained close to their respective projects to guide the narratives, so I'd say that continuity was maintained fairly faithfully.

pferreira
10-24-2019, 04:48 PM
I'm by no means a Superman/DC expert, but the bare minimum that I understand is that DC continuity is all over the place with multiple reboots and crises shaking things up every few years/decades.

What I can tell you is that both Cerebus and Spawn had/have very long runs, each reaching 300+ issues in their respective main titles. Dave Sim and Todd McFarlane remained close to their respective projects to guide the narratives, so I'd say that continuity was maintained fairly faithfully.That's good to know about Spawn. I know Superman was rebooted in 1986 but not sure when the next reboot in continuity was and if there was a reboot before the 1986 Crisis events.

Going back to the topic I just want to add that while The Quartering comes across like a money making troll there is more of a point to what he does. He has stated many times as has other drama news sites like Geeks & Gamers that yeah they are in it for the money but also they're making a point to protest against scummy business practices and political agendas. They've also pointed out many times they wouldn't have to keep making repetitive videos on various topics if whoever they talk about behave more properly. I would say Jeremy has it correct about 85% of the time. This particular video he was however pretty wrong with his facts, which I pointed out at the time in the YT comments. You may not like the reasons Jeremy does what he does but he is correct to report on a lot of the stuff he reports on.