View Full Version : Timeline between the original film and SOTO
The Turtle Terminator
10-18-2019, 03:33 PM
Is there a specific timespan given between these two films? The return of the Shredder seems like it should happen over a few days, however the film implies that the Turtles have been at April’s for several weeks
Musashi
10-18-2019, 03:54 PM
It doesn't really make any sense at all. How long does the Shredder spend in the back of that garbage truck...? It's kind of odd that the first two movies were actually written by the same guy - although SotO probably in a hurry given how quickly they managed to release it.
Several weeks seems about right for April to build a whole new life in a new apartment having lost everything in the destruction of her old home... and also become a different person. In my fanfics, the two films actually take place in slightly different universes.
snake
10-18-2019, 03:55 PM
Enough time for Casey Jones to be convicted of manslaughter and being mysteriously absent for the duration of the film.
Musashi
10-18-2019, 03:57 PM
Enough time for Casey Jones to be convicted of manslaughter and being mysteriously absent for the duration of the film.
I explain where he is, and answer a dozen other questions nobody ever wanted to know the answer to... :)
pferreira
10-24-2019, 05:02 PM
I would say no more than two or three days. That would be enough time for the Foot to reassemble back at the junkyard. They all looked like they were in panic and still were clinging to their secret rendezvous spot in case something happened to them.
Coola Yagami
11-24-2019, 04:06 PM
One or two days, the kids were acting like they just got there and were checking to make sure how many of them weren't caught by police and were able to make it.
Actually that would have worked better if the scene had some sort of 'several months later' thing right after it, cause it almost looked like that scene happened the same night Shredder was defeated.
What contradicts everything is April acts as if the Turtles had been living with her for quite a while, and not that they just moved in.
Leo656
11-24-2019, 06:12 PM
One or two days, the kids were acting like they just got there and were checking to make sure how many of them weren't caught by police and were able to make it.
Actually that would have worked better if the scene had some sort of 'several months later' thing right after it, cause it almost looked like that scene happened the same night Shredder was defeated.
What contradicts everything is April acts as if the Turtles had been living with her for quite a while, and not that they just moved in.
Yeah. It was always pretty obvious to me that no thought whatsoever went into it, due to all the conflicting information.
Logically, it couldn't have been more than a couple days for many reasons. Apart from what you mentioned, there's the fact that Shredder's still walking around wearing his Garbage Truck Variant armor and hadn't starved to death. And he bounces back almost immediately, so he absolutely couldn't have been very injured or malnourished or anything like that.
However, other things imply that at least a couple weeks had passed. It would have taken a while for April to find such a fancy apartment, for starters, and she seems to know her "new" neighbors sort of well, at least passingly. Meanwhile Keno implies that he's been delivering pizza to April's apartment for many days, sometimes multiple times per day. And I forget, but didn't April have a new boss in that one?
Logically, it couldn't have been more than three days for a few reasons, but other parts of the movie make it seem like it could have been about a month. I'm quite sure the filmmakers did not expect anyone to question it. "Time passed, let's move on." I get it, but even as a kid that bothered me, just because it's so incredibly lazy and wouldn't have taken any effort to fix. They simply didn't care.
pferreira
11-27-2019, 03:36 PM
What contradicts everything is April acts as if the Turtles had been living with her for quite a while, and not that they just moved in.It can get a bit confusing due to that part. They really should of given some time stamp or something. However I wouldn't say anything more than four days due to the Foot regrouping at the beginning as well as Shredder emerging from the dump.
Donnie
12-06-2019, 12:52 PM
I explain where he is, and answer a dozen other questions nobody ever wanted to know the answer to... :)
Cool project, I always wanted to write a fanfic comic based on the 90s movie universe. Not including SotO, though. I'd do an alternate take on events post movie 1.
Musashi
12-06-2019, 03:54 PM
Cool project, I always wanted to write a fanfic comic based on the 90s movie universe. Not including SotO, though. I'd do an alternate take on events post movie 1.
Thanks. :) Having recently rewatched the movies again, I have to acknowledge the first one is in a different league, largely down to Steve Barron's direction (Why didn't the other two directors oil the Turtles skin, or light their eyes...? Both great ways of making them look like real living creatures), but I still like II and III a lot.
Apart from a nostalgic fondness for the Fred Wolf cartoon, it's the 90s movies I'm really a fan of - not that fussed about any recent version. And I only read the Mirage Vol I comics - which are of course great - right before doing my fics so I could plunder ideas that might, in a parallel universe, have made their way into the movies if more had been made.
sgtfbomb
12-29-2019, 03:16 PM
However, other things imply that at least a couple weeks had passed. It would have taken a while for April to find such a fancy apartment, for starters, and she seems to know her "new" neighbors sort of well, at least passingly. Meanwhile Keno implies that he's been delivering pizza to April's apartment for many days, sometimes multiple times per day. And I forget, but didn't April have a new boss in that one?
April had a new boss, new clothes, and a fully furnished, lived-in apartment decked out with all her things which is amazing because most of her possessions went up in the fire. The Foot's even had enough time to place a spy in her crew and April seems familiar with him, like he's been her cameraman for at least a little while. So to me, it feels like the film takes place at least a few months later if not longer and the only scene that doesn't imply that is Shredder's first scene.
Andrew NDB
12-29-2019, 03:47 PM
I took it that April always had that apartment. That her place at the antique shop was just a home away from home.
Musashi
12-29-2019, 05:47 PM
April had a new boss, new clothes, and a fully furnished, lived-in apartment decked out with all her things which is amazing because most of her possessions went up in the fire. The Foot's even had enough time to place a spy in her crew and April seems familiar with him, like he's been her cameraman for at least a little while. So to me, it feels like the film takes place at least a few months later if not longer and the only scene that doesn't imply that is Shredder's first scene.
A lot of the stuff cluttering the apartment up belongs to the Turtles. If we assume that the place came fully furnished - I reckon it's a perk of her new contract, hastily negotiated at the end of the first movie - and that we see most of the clothes April owns in the course of that movie, some of which may even have been donated by a couple of similar-sized friends and/or colleagues, it doesn't seem impossible that she has had to basically rebuild her life in the past couple of weeks.
As for Freddy the spy, we actually see him dispatched on his mission by Shredder and Tatsu. The very fact that Channel 3 is getting used to a new (temporary?) boss suggests it's an ideal time for Freddy to make himself useful, and remember he is trained to hide in plain sight.
I have actually had to try to make sense out of some of this stuff. :)
oldmanwinters
12-29-2019, 07:05 PM
Just for fun, a link to all that remains of Peter Laird's original pitch for the film:
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/02/blast-from-past-483-thoughts-on-second.html
Wesley
12-30-2019, 12:00 PM
Just for fun, a link to all that remains of Peter Laird's original pitch for the film:
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/02/blast-from-past-483-thoughts-on-second.html
Thanks for sharing. I only saw III as a kid, but the original pitch sounds like it would’ve been the right direction to take II and how I imagined it would be like.
oldmanwinters
12-30-2019, 12:52 PM
Thanks for sharing. I only saw III as a kid, but the original pitch sounds like it would’ve been the right direction to take II and how I imagined it would be like.
AndrewNBD, you think Laird's could make a starting point for a future fan-canon comic book? You would have my support! :tsmile:
Andrew NDB
12-30-2019, 01:15 PM
AndrewNBD, you think Laird's could make a starting point for a future fan-canon comic book? :tsmile:
Probably. I'm not super interested in that, though.
oldmanwinters
12-30-2019, 02:12 PM
Probably. I'm not super interested in that, though.
Cue a "Sad Puppy Dog Eyes" meme for me.
I do think it would be fun to write out a TMNT 2 movie draft or comic book outline trying to do it like Eastman and/or Laird would have wanted it. Definitely no new mutant goons like Tokka/Rahazar, but more emphasis upon a sci-fi mystery story with TCRI/TGRI and the Utroms, but trying to incorporate a Baxter Stockman/Mousers angle to slice up the plot. I doubt the sequel would have ever had the Turtles using the Transmat to travel to far space, so the scope would still need to be confined to the city, especially the TCRI/TGRI building.
Man, I'm tempted to write something up now for my own amusement.
sgtfbomb
02-25-2020, 01:44 PM
Something I've never thought about before, does anyone think it's funny everyone left Shredder in the garbage truck and that his body just got dumped into the junkyard? :tlol: Like, did no one tell the cops about the strange man who fell from the rooftop and if not, wouldn't the garbagemen see his body (or at the very least, his blood) when they go to throw in more trash?
Andrew NDB
02-25-2020, 01:55 PM
:tlol: Like, did no one tell the cops about the strange man who fell from the rooftop and if not
The only person that even knew about that was Casey, and that'd be confessing to a murder.
wouldn't the garbagemen see his body (or at the very least, his blood) when they go to throw in more trash?
Not necessarily, since Casey hit the compactor button and mashed him up in there. And for all we know it was done picking up trash and its next stop was the dump.
sgtfbomb
02-25-2020, 02:28 PM
The only person that even knew about that was Casey, and that'd be confessing to a murder.
Casey wasn't the only one. There were people watching from the streets who would've seen Saki fall from the rooftop and land in the compactor.
Leo656
02-25-2020, 08:15 PM
Furthermore, why the hell was a garbage truck just sitting around in the middle of the street in the middle of the evening unattended, anyway?
I don't know how it works up there, but around here garbage pickup is between 5 and 6 in the morning. If they didn't require it for the ending scene, then logically there would be no garbage truck there to begin with.
Hmm.
sgtfbomb
03-02-2020, 09:56 PM
Furthermore, why the hell was a garbage truck just sitting around in the middle of the street in the middle of the evening unattended, anyway?.
There was a deleted bit where the garbagemen (played by Eastman & Laird in cameos) pull up on the street and run away. The Turtle Power doc has b-roll of it being shot.
The street fight could take place at any hour, but I've always assumed it was after sometime after 2am. It's already night when they return to NYC and we don't really know the time, but it seems late. Assuming it's likely an hour or two before everyone falls asleep in the lair and Danny leaves, if you figure in his walk to the warehouse (maybe a half hour to an hour), the time spent there before Shredder orders the assault, the time it takes for the Foot to travel to the sewer lair, and even the duration of the sewer fight, it could be possibly be 5 in the morning, especially if they didn't make it to NYC until well after midnight.
Leo656
03-03-2020, 01:57 AM
Fair points. But the movie as-is doesn't give us the necessary information to connect those dots. :)
ABrown
03-05-2020, 10:50 AM
Trying to make sense of it is a huge nightmare. It's almost as though they did a soft reboot with the SOTO film.
pferreira
03-05-2020, 01:04 PM
However, other things imply that at least a couple weeks had passed. It would have taken a while for April to find such a fancy apartment, for starters, and she seems to know her "new" neighbors sort of well, at least passingly. Meanwhile Keno implies that he's been delivering pizza to April's apartment for many days, sometimes multiple times per day.I was thinking about this and isn't it possible April already had that apartment? Think about how successful she was already in the first movie. Isn't it possible she already had the apartment from the second movie?
Trying to make sense of it is a huge nightmare. It's almost as though they did a soft reboot with the SOTO film.Well they essentially rebooted April with a new actress. :P
Not necessarily, since Casey hit the compactor button and mashed him up in there. And for all we know it was done picking up trash and its next stop was the dump.That's one way of taking out the trash. 8)
https://i.giphy.com/media/62PP2yEIAZF6g/200.webp
Leo656
03-06-2020, 12:15 AM
Well, for one thing her apartment in Part II was a lot nicer-looking than her cramped, sorta-dirty ("Unsightly bathtub ring" :trazz:) apartment in Part I, so aside from the fact that it was upstairs from her Dad's junk shop, it's a little baffling why she would willingly choose the "crummy" apartment as her primary living space and keep the nice one as a "spare".
Also, knowing what I do of what apartments - especially big ones like hers in either film - cost in NYC... then no, she couldn't have afforded it. The place they showed in Part I would have cost a fortune by itself since it was almost a whole entire building when the junk store was factored in. She also mentioned that she ran the junk shop at a loss, which doesn't help matters. Also, the first film presents her as being only a moderately-successful reporter, at best, not a celebrity. Sure, she got a raise and a new position at the very end of the film, but... the second film doesn't exactly reinforce that, either, as she's still not treated as a reporter with any significant "clout". And didn't she have an entirely new boss? Perhaps Charles got fired by the station for caving in to April's excessive demands for a raise and a corner office? :lol:
So... I don't know, I highly doubt she was able to maintain two semi-luxurious apartments AND a giant junk shop on a reporter's salary. I think the first place she had was tough enough to believe, frankly.
I mean, at the end of the day, it's all fake, so maybe? Kinda like the house in "Full House"; apparently Danny Tanner would have had to be a multi-millionaire to actually afford that place if it were real life, and he probably wasn't, at least when the show started. So in the entirely fictional movie world, perhaps April had both properties simultaneously at one point. But if we're using any kind of logic at all, then no. She was probably paying about three to five grand a month, minimum, in 1989 money, just for the original apartment building. The second place obviously would have cost less, since it was "just" an apartment, but it was also far nicer, so it also definitely wasn't cheap. NYC is a ridiculously expensive place to live; most people can't afford ONE apartment there, let alone two.
Ultimately, the people who made the second film simply weren't at all concerned about continuity, because they knew most people watching it were 7.
pferreira
03-24-2020, 02:38 PM
Ultimately, the people who made the second film simply weren't at all concerned about continuity, because they knew most people watching it were 7.I don't know. When I first watched the sequel at 8 I was really fussy about making sure there was continuity with the first. Anyway it's not like they didn't bother to make any attempts at continuity with the first movie at all.
sgtfbomb
03-25-2020, 05:41 PM
I don't think it is that they weren't concerned about continuity as much as they were trying to distance themselves from the darker first film while aligning closer to the more cheerful animated series.
Therefore, April's unkept (and burned-down) apartment in a rundown neighborhood became a posh suite in a high-rise residential complex. The dark alleyways and messy sewer lair were traded in for colorful shopping centers and an extravagant and theatrical subway station. Saki, who was probably meant to stay dead (a blood spurt was even deleted), was brought back to be killed again, but this time going out as the more "toyetic" Super Shredder. The score was lightened up and the humor became even more pronounced and cartoon-y. No more foot soldiers frying to death from electrocution, no more misguided teens being harshly beaten by their surrogate father figures. But personally, I think the most unfortunate thing lost in this transition was the sincerity and how the Turtles were treated as flesh and blood people capable of thoughts and feelings, not just caricatures with trademark personality traits and catchphrases.
I see SOTO as being somewhat akin to Batman Forever, another sequel that brought drastic tonal and conceptual changes to a series that started off darker, but still retained some of the cast and a vague level of consistency.
d_osborn
03-25-2020, 06:36 PM
I see SOTO as being somewhat akin to Batman Forever, another sequel that brought drastic tonal and conceptual changes to a series that started off darker, but still retained some of the cast and a vague level of consistency.
Exactly this. Similar outcomes, as well.
Leo656
03-25-2020, 10:42 PM
I don't think it is that they weren't concerned about continuity as much as they were trying to distance themselves from the darker first film while aligning closer to the more cheerful animated series.
Therefore, April's unkept (and burned-down) apartment in a rundown neighborhood became a posh suite in a high-rise residential complex. The dark alleyways and messy sewer lair were traded in for colorful shopping centers and an extravagant and theatrical subway station. Saki, who was probably meant to stay dead (a blood spurt was even deleted), was brought back to be killed again, but this time going out as the more "toyetic" Super Shredder. The score was lightened up and the humor became even more pronounced and cartoon-y. No more foot soldiers frying to death from electrocution, no more misguided teens being harshly beaten by their surrogate father figures. But personally, I think the most unfortunate thing lost in this transition was the sincerity and how the Turtles were treated as flesh and blood people capable of thoughts and feelings, not just caricatures with trademark personality traits and catchphrases.
I see SOTO as being somewhat akin to Batman Forever, another sequel that brought drastic tonal and conceptual changes to a series that started off darker, but still retained some of the cast and a vague level of consistency.
Boy, great job listing just about everything I hate about the sequel over the original in one tidy paragraph. :lol: Thanks brother!
pferreira
03-31-2020, 10:43 AM
I think the most unfortunate thing lost in this transition was the sincerity and how the Turtles were treated as flesh and blood people capable of thoughts and feelings, not just caricatures with trademark personality traits and catchphrases.
I see SOTO as being somewhat akin to Batman Forever, another sequel that brought drastic tonal and conceptual changes to a series that started off darker, but still retained some of the cast and a vague level of consistency.I love Batman Forever, great film. I never noticed the change in score. The score for the sequel was less electric guitar to make it gritty but the music could still be dark.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.