PDA

View Full Version : Shredder of TMNTA

MikeandRaph87
01-31-2020, 03:01 PM
Forever War got me thinking about a possible continuity error .So Shredder appears in 1-6,9-13,20-25,36-37,42-44 and a pair of flashback stories involving Mammoth and the Frakenwolf creature. The Shredder from #36-#37 and #42-#44 was extracted from the climax of #4.Yet he knew about owing the Turtles after #25. Was that a continuity error? He should not have known and gave up Splinter like he did. What Shredder are we getting in Forever War? The time portal refugee who abandoned Baxter in TMNTA#4 or the jailed one from #25? My head hurts trying to figure out Shredder's chronology.
Darth Knuckles
01-31-2020, 09:49 PM
Forever War got me thinking about a possible continuity error .So Shredder appears in 1-6,9-13,20-25,36-37,42-44 and a pair of flashback stories involving Mammoth and the Frakenwolf creature. The Shredder from #36-#37 and #42-#44 was extracted from the climax of #4.Yet he knew about owing the Turtles after #25. Was that a continuity error? He should not have known and gave up Splinter like he did. What Shredder are we getting in Forever War? The time portal refugee who abandoned Baxter in TMNTA#4 or the jailed one from #25? My head hurts trying to figure out Shredder's chronology.I'm actually hoping The Forever War addresses this issue because it is a problem that I had reading the original TMNTA comics. It doesn't make sense to me either and did seem like a continuity error. So here's hoping.
Lordmylar06
02-10-2020, 12:37 PM
After being extracted from the climax of #4, Shredder had access to his own history and every encounter his past self would have had with the turtles. It's not hard to imagine that his actions here were entirely self preserving in a weird timeline erasure sort of way. Reacting differently than the non extracted Shredder from the timeline could have resulted in some sort of shift that could have wiped him from existence. That's just a patchwork theory I have for that moment.
Andrew NDB
02-10-2020, 12:38 PM
I'm actually hoping The Forever War addresses this issue

Oh, it does. Majorly.
Darth Knuckles
02-12-2020, 01:55 AM
Oh, it does. Majorly.Oh well that is really great to hear! I'm really glad it will be addressed in the finale. I can't wait for this series to come out in a few months time. :tcool:
MikeandRaph87
02-12-2020, 05:57 AM
After being extracted from the climax of #4, Shredder had access to his own history and every encounter his past self would have had with the turtles. It's not hard to imagine that his actions here were entirely self preserving in a weird timeline erasure sort of way. Reacting differently than the non extracted Shredder from the timeline could have resulted in some sort of shift that could have wiped him from existence. That's just a patchwork theory I have for that moment.

This is a good explanation until we know what Forever War states.
Lordmylar06
02-12-2020, 11:02 AM
This is a good explanation until we know what Forever War states.

Thanks! I'm sure whatever the full explanation Forever War gives will be even better, but it's just been a theory I've had for a long time.
It still blows my mind that we're getting all these story endings so many years later. It's a good time to be a part of the fandom for this stuff!