View Full Version : The 2007 movie is a mess, a good one.
D-ray
03-31-2020, 02:13 AM
The 2007 movie is really good in my opinion, but I think that is the most confused movie of all.
There are alot of characterstics from the 2003 serie and some of the 1987 one. Some parts of the storyline are from a show, and some other not.
I've recently heard (4 months ago) that the 2007 movie, not only was supposed to be a trilogy, but it was a continuation of the 1987 show's storyline.
But it doesn't make any sense to me...
Some examples of weird stuff:
- 1987 Shredder in the beginning
- The turtles say that the Shredder DIED, even if in both 1987 and 2003 Shredder is not said to be 100% dead
- 2003 Casey and April
- There is Karai mixed between the classic movies and the 2003 series
- Foot ninjas are normal people instead of androids
- Who the hell is Max Winters? (not gonna lie, I liked him, but his presence makes everything even more confusing)
- 1987 Shredder's helmet among Splinter's "trophies"
- Karai doesn't seem to hate the turtles, even if in the 2003 series she spent her last episodes trying to kill the turltes
And probably even more!
What you guys think? There could be an explanation or the explanation could have been given in the later scrapped sequels?
victory_angel
03-31-2020, 04:52 AM
The 2007 movie is really good in my opinion, but I think that is the most confused movie of all.
There are alot of characterstics from the 2003 serie and some of the 1987 one. Some parts of the storyline are from a show, and some other not.
I've recently heard (4 months ago) that the 2007 movie, not only was supposed to be a trilogy, but it was a continuation of the 1987 show's storyline.
But it doesn't make any sense to me...
Some examples of weird stuff:
- 1987 Shredder in the beginning
- The turtles say that the Shredder DIED, even if in both 1987 and 2003 Shredder is not said to be 100% dead
- 2003 Casey and April
- There is Karai mixed between the classic movies and the 2003 series
- Foot ninjas are normal people instead of androids
- Who the hell is Max Winters? (not gonna lie, I liked him, but his presence makes everything even more confusing)
- 1987 Shredder's helmet among Splinter's "trophies"
- Karai doesn't seem to hate the turtles, even if in the 2003 series she spent her last episodes trying to kill the turltes
And probably even more!
What you guys think? There could be an explanation or the explanation could have been given in the later scrapped sequels?
It’s never specified what it was based around since we see elements of the 2k3 version/ the 90’s movie trilogy/ and the mirage comic. I’ve mostly heard this story takes place after the original film trillogy. Largely I do see this as an attempt towards a new animated incarnation of the turtles.
The main problem was that it didn’t really explain crucial plot elements. Such as why Leo was on that training mission or how Raph got his night watcher armor. There were some tie in comics explaining that, but the film is expecting the viewers to have read those comics.
Karai does have some hostility towards the turtles in the film because when the Turtles jump in to help take down that monster Karai notices Leo and angrily says ‘you’. While he has no idea about who she is or what he’s done to infuriate her. She later decides the monsters were the bigger problem and helps them, though her last line in the film did imply that the Shredder would return.
There were other movies planned but they were never used since this film wasn’t received as well as hoped and of course imagi studios hitting the tank.
The blue prints for the sequel films center around Mikey and Donnie. It’s a shame as these plots did actually sound intriguing, perhaps someone may get the rights to the blueprints for these films someday.
The first sequel was going to have Mikey feeling like the odd turtle out among his brothers. So he makes the decision to run away from home. In this act he encounters Karai and when she hears about his plight she suggests that he might be more welcome in the Foot Clan. We see Mikey exchanging his orange mask for a black one. In the mean time the turtles travel to Japan and the events with Karai there lead to the Return of the Shredder. They also apparently were going to lose Splinter in this film.
The second sequel was going to have the Triceraton's and the arrival of the technodrome from dimension x. And Donatello was the catalyst for those events taking place.
D-ray
03-31-2020, 05:03 AM
It’s never specified what it was based around since we see elements of the 2k3 version/ the 90’s movie trilogy/ and the mirage comic. I’ve mostly heard this story takes place after the original film trillogy. Largely I do see this as an attempt towards a new animated incarnation of the turtles.
There were other movies planned but they were never used since this film wasn’t received as well as hoped and of course imagi studios hitting the tank.
The blue prints for the sequel films center around Mikey and Donnie. It’s a shame as these plots did actually sound intriguing, perhaps someone may get the rights to the blueprints for these films someday.
The first sequel was going to have Mikey feeling like the odd turtle out among his brothers. So he makes the decision to run away from home. In this act he encounters Karai and when she hears about his plight she suggests that he might be more welcome in the Foot Clan. We see Mikey exchanging his orange mask for a black one. In the mean time the turtles travel to Japan and the events with Karai there lead to the Return of the Shredder. They also apparently were going to lose Splinter in this film.
The second sequel was going to have the Triceraton's and the arrival of the technodrome from dimension x. And Donatello was the catalyst for those events taking place.
The one with the Triceratons looked incredibly cool tho...
The animation was nice and the design was greater.
I think it didn't reached the top just because it wasn't really clear it's storyline.
Andrew NDB
03-31-2020, 01:43 PM
It’s never specified what it was based around since we see elements of the 2k3 version/ the 90’s movie trilogy/ and the mirage comic.
It had been specified, over and over again by the writer/director. And press releases of the time. It's a movie continuation, nothing else.
There were some tie in comics explaining that, but the film is expecting the viewers to have read those comics.
Nonsense. The comics weren't even commissioned until long after the script was written and most work on the movie completed.
AquaParade
03-31-2020, 01:53 PM
I see the film as taking place in it's own universe. Sorry, but it takes more than a scepter on a shelf to sell me on the idea that these interpretations of TMNT have anything in common.
frank_one
03-31-2020, 02:01 PM
While we are on the subject, are those comics any good?
victory_angel
03-31-2020, 02:22 PM
The one with the Triceratons looked incredibly cool tho...
The animation was nice and the design was greater.
I think it didn't reached the top just because it wasn't really clear it's storyline.
That we could agree. They set up how the Turtles would face something that could break apart their brotherhood. That sounds ominous, but nothing is broken apart except for Leo getting captured and nearly sent to a parallel universe. The turtles do eventually go their separate ways, at least in the comic books. That's never been used in the tv series or films, as of yet though the concept has been hinted occasionally. If Tales of the TMNT could have continued another season, perhaps that even would have been a plotline since the Turtles were finding that without the Shredder or the Kraang they had no further purpose. So the next step possibly would have been maybe the Turtles going off on training journey's to hone their skills and discover themselves as individuals. That also could be an interesting plot if used in a movie as well.
But then it starts talking about the warlord Yaotl who opens a portal to a parallel universe and rendering him immortal and his siblings encased in stone. That is more of an "Excuse me, I think we wandered into another movie." Kinda thing.
The major plot with the 13 monsters had nothing to do with the turtles, they just happen to stumble upon it.
I mean it would have been interesting if they had just made Yaotl the villain from the start. Rather than a man who used a force he didn't completely understand, unleashed several horrors upon the Earth, saw his companions frozen in stone, became cursed with immortality, and had been spending the last several millennia living in regret.
Have Yaotl and his siblings all get immortality when they first use that planets alinement portal. This was meant to be a test of the portal, when they see what the portal can do for them they lay in wait for the next time the planets align in that fashion. One because if they miss that moment they would lose their immortality, and two so they can bring a whole army of monsters to display their might. They would hire Karai and the Foot Clan to help capture the original 13 monsters so Yaotl can get them under his control.
D-ray
03-31-2020, 05:02 PM
While we are on the subject, are those comics any good?
If I could find them, I would be more than happy to read 'em.
Sadly, only now I've developed a great interest in "old" comics, just when I started to read the Usagi Yojimbo saga (Myamoto Usagi's personal stories outside TMNT).
So I need to remedy!
(p.s. Sei mica Italiano?)
D-ray
03-31-2020, 05:05 PM
I see the film as taking place in it's own universe. Sorry, but it takes more than a scepter on a shelf to sell me on the idea that these interpretations of TMNT have anything in common.
That's what I think now, but because they said it's a continuation of the 1987 movies, I found hard to understand some stuff.
frank_one
03-31-2020, 06:25 PM
(p.s. Sei mica Italiano?)Yes, I'm Italian. How did you find out? :D
victory_angel
03-31-2020, 06:37 PM
Nonsense. The comics weren't even commissioned until long after the script was written and most work on the movie completed.
I didn't say they weren't but the whole thing with Raph being the Nightwatcher and stuff does play out like it's expecting you to have read them. Or at least read them after the movie to fill in gaps.
If I could find them, I would be more than happy to read 'em.
Sadly, only now I've developed a great interest in "old" comics, just when I started to read the Usagi Yojimbo saga (Myamoto Usagi's personal stories outside TMNT).
So I need to remedy!
(p.s. Sei mica Italiano?)
I remember coming across a couple of them one time. The comics were all prequels stories to the movie and they were done in a Mirage style. And there were five of them.
The prequel centered on Raph is the first of the five is titled Disposable Heros.
Raph is talking to Casey about how he's been finding it hard to get along with his brothers as of late. Leo in particular because they are all focused on the major threats and overlooking the innocent people who are being terrorized in the city.
He then thinks back to 18 months ago when the four of them are tracking down some Triceratons. Raph notices this old man getting jumped by a bunch of street thugs. He informs his brothers of this and says they need to help him, but Leo says he's not important right now. The Triceraton's are the greater problem. They take out the Triceratons after they are done Raph sneaks away to help the man only to find the thugs gone. The man gets up and trudges away commenting that when he was younger he would have mopped the floor with those punks. Raph returns to his brothers and gets an earful from Leo about leaving without his permission and about how Splinter had taught them not to interfere with humans. While this is going on Mikey and Donnie are discussing Mike's plans for creating his party entertainment business.
Splinter appears to them and tells them that he had determined that Leo has earned the privilege to go on a year-long training pilgrimage. Both Donnie and Mikey are enthused about this, but Raph just storms out of the room. As he leaves Leo snipes that Splinter would have chosen him if he had trained harder and followed orders.
Raph goes out looking for trouble and sees some thugs harassing a prostitute. He beats up the thugs, the old man from earlier sees this and introduced himself as David Merryweather. Inviting Raph back to his home, he tells Raph that in his younger days he had been a vigilantly known as the Night Watcher. The two swap stories until Splinter calls and tells Raph to come home so he could see Leo off. Moments after Raph leaves David's house he hears gunshots coming from David's house. He returns to find David dying of his wounds. Before he passes on David makes Raph give two promises. One he would make sure the punks who shot him were put behind bars and two remove his Night Watcher gear from his house so no one can learn his identity.
In the present Raph takes out the thugs who murdered David and vows to put his armor to good use.
The second prequel centers on Mikey. It's titled “The Continuing Story of Cowabunga Carl”
Mikey and Donnie are perfecting their Mascot Idea. Mikey works as an entertainer, while Donnie works IT and stuff from the back of the van. The two of them go to a hockey rink to that Mikey can entertain a bunch of shelter kids that Casey had gathered together. Mikey sees a thug grab a purse from an old lady, despite Donnie repeatedly warning him that they weren't to interfere with human affairs Mikey chases after the thug. He gets tackled by security and taken to a back office while he radios Don to help him get out of this jam. Donnie calls up schematics of the hockey rink and tells Mikey how he can escape, while Casey pulls the fire alarm to distract security.
After reconvening with Donnie the two see the thug who stole the lady's purse. They take off after him, as they give chase they catch sight Nightwatcher. Mikey idolizes the vigilante, while Donnie doesn't trust him. The thug gets away but Donnie managed to plant a tracking device on the getaway vehicle.
Mikey manages to stop the criminal and get the lady's purse back. Splinter is less then happy with the two of them and says if he hears they have been interfering with humans again he would forbid them from continuing their business. Mikey protests by saying that with Leo away and Raph brooding who knows where he and Donnie are just trying to find their own path and do the right thing.
The third prequel centers on Donnie. It's titled Strangers in the Night
In his comic, he is using the money with his tech-job and also Mikey's 'Party Business" to fund his engineering. He's created a device tracks the brainwaves of all unknown species in Manhatten. That way if they have something such as the Triceraton's arrive they would be able to deal with it. Splinter is impressed, but suddenly a blip appears on the screen. They both know it isn't Mikey or Raph, so both Donnie and Splinter go to check it out. They find themselves confronted by one of the 13 monsters (the Giant Bat one). It attacks and then flys off with Donatello in its grasp.
Finding no recourse Splinter seeks out his sons for help. Mikey arrives and the two of them find Donnie trying to communicate to the bat creature. Mikey and Splinter chase it away, but when they ask Donnie what he learned about it. He says that it wanted to return home. Donnie checks his brainwave scan and finds there are 13 unknown creatures in the city, unfortunately, his device shorts out before he can amplify his scan range.
The next prequel centers on April it's titled "Bungle in the Jungle"
April and Casey are living together and it's not a happy relationship. Max Winters has hired April to help find items that catch his interest. This comic includes the scene in Costa Rica where April and Leo encounter one another in the movie. She is seeking out the "Fourth General" one of the statues of Yaotl's siblings. April's guide Sabastion leads her to the statue that Winters was wanting. But before she can receive payment, a group of cultists arrive and kill her assistants. Sabastion ties April to an altar as a sacrifice to the statue. the Costa Rican Army show up and kill Sabastion and take out the cultists. April is about to return to Winter's empty-handed when she overhears one of the soldiers say they intend to sell the statue to the highest bidder. April manages to get the statue of the Fourth General and takes off in Max Winter's private jet. She asks the pilot about what was going, the pilot tells her the soldiers are all ex-military who have been looking for that statue for a while. April begins to wonder what Winter's would want with the statue considering all the people who have died for it.
The final prequel centers on Leo. It's titled Five to one
Leo is continuing to exist as his ghost of the forest persona we see him having in the beginning of the movie.
Thinking back to when Splinter first sent him on this journey he remembers Splinter leaving him with a riddle of "The five-fold path shall lead you to the one." Leo makes it his goal to figure out the answer.
In Iceland, he learns the path of courage. A whaling ship is about to harpoon an endangered Fin Whale. Leo stops them and tells them to take another look at their pray. The whalers realize the Fin Whale has a baby and if they had killed it, its baby would have been orphaned and died.
The next path is compassion, he finds this when he is on a Portuguese ship bound for Liverpool. He discovers various African and Middle Eastern children who were going to be sold off as slaves. Leo then slaughters all the crew aboard the ship and calls the cops to rescue the kids.
The third path he finds in Mongolia, the path of Selflessness. He sees a group of hunters capturing a Yeti. Leo offers himself as their capture instead, the hunters respond by beating him up and capturing him as well since two cryptids would fetch a greater price. A tribe of Yeti arrives and chase off the hunters, they then thank Leo by tending his injuries and nurse him back to health.
the fourth path is humility. Leo travels to Japan and meets with the Ninja Tribunal and the Ancient One. He declares that he is the best of his brothers and he has the right to receive the same training as Hamato Yoshi. The Tribunal, however, turns from him stating that by forsaking his family he has learned nothing. He can't complete the five-fold path alone.
The final path is Community, in Costa Rica where Leo has that talk with April in the movie. He tells her he can't return home after everything he's seen. He's come to view humanity as awful and beyond hope. He refuses to live with them or under them any longer. April then suggests he look at what he learned from a different angle. He thinks about the riddle Splinter told him and realizes the five paths lead to the one which stood for family and he needed to go home to be with them.
Zog The Magnificent
03-31-2020, 06:49 PM
I like this movie, but the way it's set up, it feels like it's the second movie in a trilogy. The problem is that it's also the ONLY movie in the trilogy.
D-ray
04-01-2020, 01:26 AM
Yes, I'm Italian. How did you find out? :D
I've joined the Italian group of the forum, and you were inside of it, among some other three guys. Also, your location is "Southern Europe"!
Good to know that I'm not the only one here that keeps giving love to the turtles, in Italy.
Andrew NDB
04-01-2020, 01:33 AM
I didn't say they weren't but the whole thing with Raph being the Nightwatcher and stuff does play out like it's expecting you to have read them. Or at least read them after the movie to fill in gaps.
It's accidental, if that. Munroe certainly never wrote the movie with the idea in his head, "The Mirage comics tie-ins will fill in the blanks later, people can read those" because he had no idea they would even be a thing. They were a last minute thing by Mirage like, "Oh wait, maybe we should try to take this opportunity, kind of like we did with movie adaptations in the past." Which made sense.
Peter Palmer
04-01-2020, 11:50 AM
I didn't say they weren't but the whole thing with Raph being the Nightwatcher and stuff does play out like it's expecting you to have read them. Or at least read them after the movie to fill in gaps.
I suppose I just don't see any insurmountable gaps. What exactly did you want to know about Raph being the Nightwatcher? He's frustrated with the direction his family has taken and he vents this frustration by dressing up and going out at night to fight crime as a vigilante. He keeps this life a secret from his family who just see him as lazy for sleeping all day. This was all conveyed pretty succinctly in the movie.
You mentioned that you want to know how it got his suit. That might have an interesting story, but I certainly wouldn't consider it crucial to the plot. In my mind, it played out similar to how Daredevil got his armor in the Netflix show. In his vigilante travels, he comes across a metalworker who he either threatens or protects in exchange for the armor. Would I like to see that? Sure! But I'd like to see a lot more of this world, but I don't think any of it is crucial to the story we see in the film.
I've never read the tie-in comics. I enjoy this movie and don't view them as necessary for understanding the plot of the movie.
Peter Palmer
04-01-2020, 11:56 AM
I see the film as taking place in it's own universe. Sorry, but it takes more than a scepter on a shelf to sell me on the idea that these interpretations of TMNT have anything in common.
100% agree.
I'm fine with subtle nods to other incarnations, but these are more fan service than anything. As far as we know, the Time Scepter or Shredder's helmet could have completely different back stories than what we saw in the live action movies.
For example, the last time that the live action TMNT in the movies saw the Shredder, he was Super Shredder, which had a different helmet than the one we saw on the shelf in the 2007 movie.
I saw that trophy room as nods to the fans without necessarily tying these turtles to any specific continuity. As far as I'm concerned, they are their own incarnation.
Wesley
04-01-2020, 12:23 PM
100% agree.
I'm fine with subtle nods to other incarnations, but these are more fan service than anything. As far as we know, the Time Scepter or Shredder's helmet could have completely different back stories than what we saw in the live action movies.
For example, the last time that the live action TMNT in the movies saw the Shredder, he was Super Shredder, which had a different helmet than the one we saw on the shelf in the 2007 movie.
I saw that trophy room as nods to the fans without necessarily tying these turtles to any specific continuity. As far as I'm concerned, they are their own incarnation.
Agreed. Despite the weird stuff (which I never paid much attention to lol), it’s still my second favourite TMNT movie, behind 1990.
sgtfbomb
04-01-2020, 01:11 PM
I enjoyed it when it was in theaters, but not quite as much when I revisited a few years back. I remember wishing it had a better A-plot.
It also had a great cast, including Sarah Michelle Gellar as April, Chris Evans as Casey, and Ziyi Zhang as Karai, and that would have been great to see realized in a live action medium. That's the kind of talent they should went for when casting the PD films.
Leo656
04-01-2020, 02:38 PM
I liked it fine but it's the least memorable, to me, of the TMNT movies I've seen. It also doesn't call to me to watch it again very strongly, for whatever reason. Saw it opening night and it didn't get the overwhelming response from the audience that I'd expected, that kinda told me what was going to come of it.
I think the characters were mostly portrayed pretty well but that plot was all over the place. I definitely think that they kinda recycled the script from some generic CGI kids movie about monsters that they had sitting in a drawer and added the TMNT elements after the fact once they got the license or whatever. I highly doubt that it was written from the ground up to be a TMNT movie. I guess it's possible but it feels like a retrofit. We'll probably never know but that kinda thing happens ALL the time, and who gets the official writing credit on a movie is generally based one some rather shady stuff. But if it was written from scratch to be a TMNT movie, I'd be shocked.
It's alright, but I don't think it's the movie the franchise needed at that moment. Something a little more iconic would've played better and possibly gotten a sequel. I understand why they wanted to "try something new" and all that, but too many movies save "the good stuff" for a sequel that never comes and this was one of them. Teasing Shredder at the end makes the whole thing feel even dumber since they never got to make that movie. "Safe and predictable" or no, they should've come out of the gate swinging with Shredder and then they could have done this same plot, or ANY plot, really, for the sequel. They banked on everyone showing up just for the novelty of seeing TMNT in movie theaters for the first time in 15 years or whatever and that wasn't enough of a draw for most people once they heard that it wasn't "really" a TMNT movie in any significant sense.
I apparently like it more than a lot of people but it's very, very flawed.
ABrown
04-01-2020, 02:42 PM
I see the film as taking place in it's own universe. Sorry, but it takes more than a scepter on a shelf to sell me on the idea that these interpretations of TMNT have anything in common.
I agree. And this doesn't really prove anything, but in Turtles Forever the 2007 turtles are shown to be in an alternate universe from the original movies. But regardless, when I watch the 2007 film, I don't get the sense that I'm watching a continuation of those movies.
That's what I think now, but because they said it's a continuation of the 1987 movies, I found hard to understand some stuff.
1987 movies? What in the helicopter are you talking about? :D
Yes, I'm Italian. How did you find out? :D
I've joined the Italian group of the forum, and you were inside of it, among some other three guys. Also, your location is "Southern Europe"!
Good to know that I'm not the only one here that keeps giving love to the turtles, in Italy.
I hope you both are doing well over there, with everything that's going on.
But to answer the original question, I don't see anything that the OP mentioned that would've confused me at all in regards to this movie. I mean that only thing that might've confused me is if I were watching the 2007 movie as my introduction to the franchise. It's probably best to have prior exposure to the TMNT, otherwise that might make one have questions.
frank_one
04-01-2020, 03:18 PM
The 2007 movie is just uninteresting, generic. It has a couple of great moments but overall it is not a satisfying experience. Even as a sequel of the old movies it doesn't work, it's different, it's something else.
The cgi was good but I honestly hate the design of the humans, I remember thinking it was out of place, something taken from a Pixar movie.
If I have to choose, I would rather rewatch Turtles Forever.
victory_angel
04-01-2020, 03:19 PM
I suppose I just don't see any insurmountable gaps. What exactly did you want to know about Raph being the Nightwatcher? He's frustrated with the direction his family has taken and he vents this frustration by dressing up and going out at night to fight crime as a vigilante. He keeps this life a secret from his family who just see him as lazy for sleeping all day. This was all conveyed pretty succinctly in the movie.
You mentioned that you want to know how it got his suit. That might have an interesting story, but I certainly wouldn't consider it crucial to the plot. In my mind, it played out similar to how Daredevil got his armor in the Netflix show. In his vigilante travels, he comes across a metalworker who he either threatens or protects in exchange for the armor. Would I like to see that? Sure! But I'd like to see a lot more of this world, but I don't think any of it is crucial to the story we see in the film.
I've never read the tie-in comics. I enjoy this movie and don't view them as necessary for understanding the plot of the movie.
I did post up summaries in each of the tie in prequels further up. The prequel comics were based around production and backstory notes the director had.
In Raph's prequel, it explains how he got his armored suit.
The issue was called "Disposable Heros"
Splinter had been telling the Turtles not to get involved with human problems.
18 months prior to the movie's present time: The four turtles were going after some Triceratons. Raph sees an old man being attacked by some street thugs and suggests to his brothers they go help, only for Leo to shoot him down by reminding him they were told not to. Raph sneaks off to help the man only to find him walking away muttering about how he would have mopped the floor with them.
Raph later encounters the man again who introduces himself as David Merryweather. David takes Raph into his confidence as he reveals he used to be a vigilante hero back in the day. Raph is told to return home so he can see Leo off on his training journey, but minutes later he hears gunshots coming from David's place. He returns and finds David dying of his injuries. David then tells Raph to promise him that he would put the thugs who murdered him behind bars and that he would remove his armor and vigilante gear from the house so no one would know his secret identity.
That is how Raph got the Night Watcher Armor.
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-bDwUEd7N2QU/VTvl6fWCd4I/AAAAAAAAPvg/fP08gwm74Qo/s1600/004.png
sgtfbomb
04-01-2020, 03:57 PM
Teasing Shredder at the end makes the whole thing feel even dumber since they never got to make that movie.
That line made me cringe, unfortunately. Some of the dialogue really needed another pass.
Regarding the script, I may need to check The Ultimate Visual History to see if it elaborates more on the story development, but I'm fairly certain the director also wrote the script and that much of the story was his idea. He seemed like a fairly nice guy. IIRC, he actually did a Q&A here just prior to the release.
D-ray
04-02-2020, 01:39 AM
As far as we know, the Time Scepter or Shredder's helmet could have completely different back stories than what we saw in the live action movies.
The Time Scepter?
There is the Time Scepter in the movie?
1987 movies? What in the helicopter are you talking about?
Awhr I'm not the best with dates! I can easily make confusion...
D-ray
04-02-2020, 01:41 AM
I did post up summaries in each of the tie in prequels further up. The prequel comics were based around production and backstory notes the director had.
In Raph's prequel, it explains how he got his armored suit.
The issue was called "Disposable Heros"
Splinter had been telling the Turtles not to get involved with human problems.
18 months prior to the movie's present time: The four turtles were going after some Triceratons. Raph sees an old man being attacked by some street thugs and suggests to his brothers they go help, only for Leo to shoot him down by reminding him they were told not to. Raph sneaks off to help the man only to find him walking away muttering about how he would have mopped the floor with them.
Raph later encounters the man again who introduces himself as David Merryweather. David takes Raph into his confidence as he reveals he used to be a vigilante hero back in the day. Raph is told to return home so he can see Leo off on his training journey, but minutes later he hears gunshots coming from David's place. He returns and finds David dying of his injuries. David then tells Raph to promise him that he would put the thugs who murdered him behind bars and that he would remove his armor and vigilante gear from the house so no one would know his secret identity.
That is how Raph got the Night Watcher Armor.
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-bDwUEd7N2QU/VTvl6fWCd4I/AAAAAAAAPvg/fP08gwm74Qo/s1600/004.png
Where did you find these comics? Is there a website where you can read them?
victory_angel
04-02-2020, 03:18 AM
Where did you find these comics? Is there a website where you can read them?
There aren't any official sites where you can find them...at least not for legally free standard reading. There are places where you can find them for sale. I found a blog that summarized each of the five prequel stories and gave reviews on them.
The Bloggers consensus was the Prequel comics attempt to fill in things, but are largely forgettable. Though they did like April being essentually Laura Croft since Winters hires her as a globe-trotting treasure hunter.
I also posted summaries of the five prequels earlier on this thread.
It's a bit of a long post so I guess no one really bothered to read it.
The second prequel centers on Mikey.
It's titled “The Continuing Story of Cowabunga Carl”
Mikey and Donnie are perfecting the Party entertainment business that they were shone discussing during the flashback in Raph's prequel. Mikey works as an entertainer, while Donnie works IT and stuff from the back of the van. The two of them go to a hockey rink to that Mikey can entertain a bunch of shelter kids that Casey had gathered together. Mikey sees a thug grab a purse from an old lady, despite Donnie repeatedly warning him that they weren't to interfere with human affairs Mikey chases after the thug. He gets tackled by security and taken to a back office while he radios Don to help him get out of this jam. Donnie calls up schematics of the hockey rink and tells Mikey how he can escape, while Casey pulls the fire alarm to distract security.
After reconvening with Donnie the two see the thug who stole the lady's purse. They take off after him, as they give chase they catch sight Nightwatcher (Raph, unknown to them). Mikey idolizes the vigilante, while Donnie doesn't trust him. The thug gets away but Donnie managed to plant a tracking device on the getaway vehicle.
Mikey manages to stop the criminal and get the lady's purse back. Splinter is less then happy with the two of them and says if he hears they have been interfering with humans again he would forbid them from continuing their party entertainment business. Mikey protests by saying that with Leo away and Raph brooding who knows where he and Donnie are just trying to find their own path and do the right thing. All the while still wished to become a hero like the Nightwatcher.
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-x-088cR4Uh4/VVdumSR6p3I/AAAAAAAAP0c/mvnw_UtOfkk/s1600/mike2.png
Sumac
04-02-2020, 04:06 AM
Probably my most favorite movie about Turtles.
Aside from Winter's storyline it is cool. And I can forget a lot of its problems just for visuals and work of the operator.
Andrew NDB
04-02-2020, 04:48 AM
I've honestly only seen it the once in the theater. I feel bad because I've always talked bad about it but I had some minor say in things. I was a lot younger and maybe didn't use as strong of a voice as I would now. I wonder if I was brought in as the strong opposing voice and I failed as that. So that's a little bit of a component... my shame. But blegh. It's still the best sequel TMNT (1990) ever got.
pferreira
04-09-2020, 11:48 AM
Saw it in the cinema with some guys and we all left feeling pretty disappointed.
Sumac
04-09-2020, 12:01 PM
The main problem of the movie, IMO, is that it tries to tell personal story about relationship between the Turtles, but shoehorns the whole Winter's story. I think if they just got rid of it and kept story purely about Turtles, maybe with some minor enemies, like Shredder-less Foot Clan or Purple Dragons, it would have been a better and less divisive movie.
AquaParade
04-09-2020, 12:06 PM
I've honestly only seen it the once in the theater. I feel bad because I've always talked bad about it but I had some minor say in things. I was a lot younger and maybe didn't use as strong of a voice as I would now. I wonder if I was brought in as the strong opposing voice and I failed as that. So that's a little bit of a component... my shame. But blegh. It's still the best sequel TMNT (1990) ever got.
Well that sounds interesting. I'd be curious to hear more.
This film really does have a lot going for it. The trailers were able to take a lot of the footage and show off how stylish this movie can be at times. But for some reason, the story just feels lifeless and dull to me.
cloud
04-12-2020, 02:20 AM
It's a feature film that's loosely based on the live action movies. It's too expensive to do a proper live action film so the movie went CGI which was pretty awesome with IMAGI.
The movie doesn't really have much reference to the cartoons. So if you are looking for connections to the cartoons it doesn't make sense.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-12-2020, 07:59 AM
The second sequel was going to have the Triceraton's and the arrival of the technodrome from dimension x. And Donatello was the catalyst for those events taking place.
Still waiting for the Triceratons to show up on the big screen.
Andrew NDB
04-12-2020, 03:01 PM
Still waiting for the Triceratons to show up on the big screen.
We still have a ways to go on that -- we haven't even had one good take on the Turtles themselves yet.
D-ray
04-13-2020, 05:15 AM
Still waiting for the Triceratons to show up on the big screen.
A CGI Traximus and Zog...
my dream.
Leo656
04-13-2020, 05:21 PM
We still have a ways to go on that -- we haven't even had one good take on the Turtles themselves yet.
I'unno about all that. I know you feel the first film is far too human-centric, but ever since then, as far as the Turtles' personalities go, those are the versions I see in my head and I don't think that's ever gonna be superseded by anything else.
Maybe there could have been MORE of them in the first movie but I feel like they really nailed them regardless.
pferreira
04-20-2020, 12:49 PM
The movie doesn't really have much reference to the cartoons. So if you are looking for connections to the cartoons it doesn't make sense.The 2007 movie seemed quite influenced by the 2003 series.
AquaParade
04-20-2020, 01:18 PM
I'unno about all that. I know you feel the first film is far too human-centric, but ever since then, as far as the Turtles' personalities go, those are the versions I see in my head and I don't think that's ever gonna be superseded by anything else.
Maybe there could have been MORE of them in the first movie but I feel like they really nailed them regardless.
I love the movie so much it hurts. I just appreciate it more over time. I agree with some of Andrew's complaints, but just the fact that the visual style of the film, with the grain and the grit actually matches the look and feel of the Mirage comics is enough for me to geek the hell out when watching that thing.
I think if we were to see the director's cut, with Baron's choice of music and maybe a little more "bite" to the action (I can't remember if this was one of the rumored changes to the movie - anyone?) it'd be the perfect TMNT movie for me. Minus the colored masks - nitpick.
- Broken record.
sgtfbomb
04-20-2020, 03:36 PM
I think if we were to see the director's cut, with Baron's choice of music and maybe a little more "bite" to the action (I can't remember if this was one of the rumored changes to the movie - anyone?)
The apartment fight was trimmed down. Some of this can be found in the original UK cut, which includes an extra bit where April pulls the rug out from a foot soldier's feet. Other bits included Leo fighting down the stairs and Donnie fighting a Foot Soldier who keeps trying to spit one liners at him ("I'm gonna turn you into turtle soup.") But these were more likely cut for pacing reasons, not violence.
There was allegedly a blood splatter trimmed from Shredder's "death," but I cannot find the source for that.
Du Prez's score is said to have softened the film a lot. Although nothing I've heard about Malcolm McLaren's score has suggested it wouldn't have done the same.
The movie does seems to retain a lot of "bite." A foot soldier is electrocuted and Shinso is beaten harshly. Shinso's death was changed not by removing anything, but by adding "coughing" effects and ADR.
AquaParade
04-20-2020, 03:47 PM
The apartment fight was trimmed down. Some of this can be found in the original UK cut, which includes an extra bit where April pulls the rug out from a foot soldier's feet. Other bits included Leo fighting down the stairs and Donnie fighting a Foot Soldier who keeps trying to spit one liners at him ("I'm gonna turn you into turtle soup.") But these were more likely cut for pacing reasons, not violence.
There was allegedly a blood splatter trimmed from Shredder's "death," but I cannot find the source for that.
Du Prez's score is said to have softened the film a lot. Although nothing I've heard about Malcolm McLaren's score has suggested it wouldn't have done the same.
The movie does seems to retain a lot of "bite." A foot soldier is electrocuted and Shinso is beaten harshly. Shinso's death was changed not by removing anything, but by adding "coughing" effects and ADR.
Thanks for chiming in. I'll take the blood splatter the removal of "cough" effects. But I agree that the film does have a surprising amount of "bite" given the popularity of the cartoon at the time. It feels pretty in-line with a lot of those early Mirage books in tone. Those weren't 100% serious all the time.
The fight scenes would probably still play better if they spliced in those small UK bits, which do look pretty cool, as short as they are, and by even removing maybe a few of the goofier bits, such as Leonardo tricking the Foot Soldier with his swords. Sort of cuts the tension, imo.
Andrew NDB
04-20-2020, 05:21 PM
The apartment fight was trimmed down. Some of this can be found in the original UK cut, which includes an extra bit where April pulls the rug out from a foot soldier's feet.
Oh wow, that would make the fight so much darker and Mirage-like. Like the rest of the movie, starring Danny, Dude Mikey, and Darth Shredder's Halfway House of Troubled Youths.
Block-block-kick, block-block-kick, block-block-kick.
AquaParade
04-20-2020, 05:31 PM
Oh wow, that would make the fight so much darker and Mirage-like. Like the rest of the movie, starring Danny, Dude Mikey, and Darth Shredder's Halfway House of Troubled Youths.
Block-block-kick, block-block-kick, block-block-kick.
I get your point, but I think you are actually looking for the Image comics adaption.
Eastman and Laird's TMNT was nothing if not goofy and irreverent at times. Alongside the stories that were dark, gritty, and somber. Like, I'm pretty sure you take the TMNT more seriously than the creators themselves do. And that's not to say that TMNT isn't and can't be serious. "City at War" is peak TMNT for me and I can't think of a single joke cracked in that whole story. But Mirage TMNT has always been more than just that.
Andrew NDB
04-20-2020, 06:44 PM
I get your point, but I think you are actually looking for the Image comics adaption.
No, I just want fight scenes that resemble the comics they're trying to adapt. Not slapstick Three Stooges skits with an occasional kick.
I'm probably being way unfair to the movie. It's head and shoulders the best thing TMNT to ever come out on the screen, and with anything else, it's not even close. I'm just saying let's not pretend it's this 1:1 adaptation of Mirage. It's like... 65%, and that's being really generous. Am I being a curmudgeon for wanting that last 35%, in spite of the pretty OK 65%? Maybe. Over the years I just take annoyance with folks treating TMNT 1990 like it's synonymous with "Mirage: The Movie."
Eastman and Laird's TMNT was nothing if not goofy and irreverent at times. Alongside the stories that were dark, gritty, and somber. Like, I'm pretty sure you take the TMNT more seriously than the creators themselves do. And that's not to say that TMNT isn't and can't be serious. "City at War" is peak TMNT for me and I can't think of a single joke cracked in that whole story. But Mirage TMNT has always been more than just that.
Yeah, I've read an issue or two of Mirage.
AquaParade
04-20-2020, 07:42 PM
No, I just want fight scenes that resemble the comics they're trying to adapt. Not slapstick Three Stooges skits with an occasional kick.
I'm probably being way unfair to the movie. It's head and shoulders the best thing TMNT to ever come out on the screen, and with anything else, it's not even close. I'm just saying let's not pretend it's this 1:1 adaptation of Mirage. It's like... 65%, and that's being really generous. Am I being a curmudgeon for wanting that last 35%, in spite of the pretty OK 65%? Maybe. Over the years I just take annoyance with folks treating TMNT 1990 like it's synonymous with "Mirage: The Movie."
Yeah, I've read an issue or two of Mirage.
You totally have. I just mean to say that you seem to paint a picture that goofy and irreverent TMNT is somehow anti-Mirage, and I don't think that is the case.
I'd give it more than a 65% "Mirage score".
One great point you brought up in the past was that these movie turtles weren't raised to be assassins and that actually twisted my opinion slightly. I think that right there is the biggest diff between Mirage and the film, but it's extremely faithful elsewhere, from many of the story beats to the visual identity of the film.
I agree that the fights would be cooler and closer to Mirage if they were allowed to have more intensity.
Andrew NDB
04-20-2020, 08:20 PM
I don't care if they go to outer space, encounter a ghost, sit there for ten minutes making fun of each other. I just care that when actual fighting starts, the fighting is taken absolutely seriously beyond a bit of wisecracks (it's to be expected) and the like. It should be "ninja-like." And they should be using their weapons for something other than blocking (I know, Leo got that oooone scratch in on the Shredder, but that's it). And that doesn't even necessitate an R-rating.
Yes, the Mirage TMNT being raised to kill Saki vs. the 1990 TMNT not being raised that way is probably the biggest point of divergence. It's a fairly fundamental change, though, when you think about it.
Peter Palmer
04-21-2020, 06:37 AM
Over the years I just take annoyance with folks treating TMNT 1990 like it's synonymous with "Mirage: The Movie."
To be fair, I don't think I've ever seen someone make the case that the 1990 movie is a direct adaptation of the Mirage comics. You may be making that leap in your head. The 1990 movie is certainly the darkest of the movies released so far, thus making it inherently closer to the dark tone of the original comics than any other incarnation.
The movie adapts some beats from the original comics, but that's about as close as it gets. It's clearly meant to be a hybrid of the original comics and the 80's cartoon, which makes sense given that those were the only sources to draw from at the time. I'm sure the creators wanted to adapt their own comics but had to lean heavily on the 80's cartoon elements to make it recognizable to the masses.
I just don't see anyone making the case that the 1990 movie is Mirage: The Movie.
As an aside, I recently picked up a complete set of the Image comics and I was flipping through them. You got your fan letters published quite a bit! That's pretty cool. I saw "Andy Modeen" a number of times and I thought that it had to be the same guy, right? Then I saw a picture drawn by Andy with a turtle holding the severed head of his defeated foe and I was like "Yep, that's him!". How many issues are you in?
AquaParade
04-21-2020, 10:10 AM
Good points, but I’ll also be fair and say that I, myself, have sort of implied the film heavily captures the feel of Mirage. Especially when you look at Mirage as a whole, not just stories like “RTNY”, “CaW”, etc..
And it is worth noting that Kevin Eastman feels the same. Please don’t take that as me shielding my opinion by using Kevin, but it’s a relevant point. And if anyone is tempted to criticize Kevin’s “cheerleading”, which he is known for, keep in mind, that he is typically pretty honest afterwards. You don’t see Kevin talking up the Platinum Dunes films these days - quite the opposite.
But hey, at this point we’ve all read the books and we are all versed well enough in the TMNT to make our own call on that. I feel like the look and feel of Mirage is translated quite strongly, but if y’all see much more of the cartoon in there, I respect that too.
Again, I don’t think it’s a perfect adaption but pretty damn close.
Edit: Accidentally quoted myself - dangerously close to talking to myself. The quarantine is setting in.
Peter Palmer
04-21-2020, 01:21 PM
Good points, but I’ll also be fair and say that I, myself, have sort of implied the film heavily captures the feel of Mirage. Especially when you look at Mirage as a whole, not just stories like “RTNY”, “CaW”, etc..
And it is worth noting that Kevin Eastman feels the same. Please don’t take that as me shielding my opinion by using Kevin, but it’s a relevant point. And if anyone is tempted to criticize Kevin’s “cheerleading”, which he is known for, keep in mind, that he is typically pretty honest afterwards. You don’t see Kevin talking up the Platinum Dunes films these days - quite the opposite.
But hey, at this point we’ve all read the books and we are all versed well enough in the TMNT to make our own call on that. I feel like the look and feel of Mirage is translated quite strongly, but if y’all see much more of the cartoon in there, I respect that too.
Again, I don’t think it’s a perfect adaption but pretty damn close.
Edit: Accidentally quoted myself - dangerously close to talking to myself. The quarantine is setting in.
I think you're supporting my point without realizing it.
Of course the film attempts to capture the feel of Mirage comics. It loosely adapts quite a few issues: Raph and Leo one-shots, #10 (the fight at April's), the Northampton arc, the Return to New York arc. While there are some obvious differences, the themes are very similar between the two. And of course Kevin would admit that the movie tries to capture the feeling of Mirage. Why wouldn't he? It's a fact that would be pretty hard to refute.
However, it's hard to ignore the influence of the 80's cartoon to make the movie appealing to the country at large. Colored bandannas. Surfer talk. Bloodless violence. I'm sure Kevin would also agree that there is a fair amount of influence from the 80's cartoon in the movie.
Someone earlier mentioned that the split may have been around 65% Mirage, 35% 80's cartoon. That's probably pretty close.
All I'm saying is I don't think anyone is making the case that the movie is 100% Mirage as Andrew suggests. That doesn't seem to be what you're suggesting. It's definitely not what I'm suggesting. Influenced by the comics? Absolutely! 1:1 adaptation? Not a chance.
Andrew NDB
04-21-2020, 03:55 PM
To be fair, I don't think I've ever seen someone make the case that the 1990 movie is a direct adaptation of the Mirage comics. You may be making that leap in your head.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=59264
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=62286
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=24834
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19213
"looks like it was ripped right off the pages," etc., etc..
As an aside, I recently picked up a complete set of the Image comics and I was flipping through them. You got your fan letters published quite a bit! That's pretty cool. I saw "Andy Modeen" a number of times and I thought that it had to be the same guy, right? Then I saw a picture drawn by Andy with a turtle holding the severed head of his defeated foe and I was like "Yep, that's him!". How many issues are you in?
Hah. More than not, I think. And 1 issue of Vol. 4. I really tried to get a letter printed for TMNTA (Archie) but they never would. :) Pretty sure I sent them art, too (no, it wasn't involving severed heads).
Good points, but I’ll also be fair and say that I, myself, have sort of implied the film heavily captures the feel of Mirage. Especially when you look at Mirage as a whole, not just stories like “RTNY”, “CaW”, etc..
And it is worth noting that Kevin Eastman feels the same. Please don’t take that as me shielding my opinion by using Kevin, but it’s a relevant point. And if anyone is tempted to criticize Kevin’s “cheerleading”, which he is known for, keep in mind, that he is typically pretty honest afterwards. You don’t see Kevin talking up the Platinum Dunes films these days - quite the opposite.
Citing Kevin in this regard isn't much of anything, for the very reason you mention. It's also worth noting that he once said the Platinum Dunes movies possess "the darker edge of the comic books."
http://www.thenational.ae/blogs/scene-heard/back-to-the-drawing-board-for-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-creator-kevin-eastman
d_osborn
04-21-2020, 07:35 PM
"looks like it was ripped right off the pages," etc., etc..
It was ripped straight from the pages of the Mirage comics. Barron used the issues as storyboards in early development.
Just because the fight choreography was inhibited by the creature FX/budget/fight directorial experience or the TMNT's sole purpose of killing Shredder was changed, doesn't negate the fact that the Mirage comics were a heavy source of visual/tonal inspiration for the film.
Loosely paraphrasing Laird, it's a miracle it turned out as good as it did (and that miracle is surnamed Barron). The film simply wouldn't have been financed if it were developed as tonally dark as the early issues. It barely got made as it was.
No movie, much smaller Turtlemania, much smaller legacy, much smaller fanbase, much smaller crowd funding for fan comics.
Peter Palmer
04-22-2020, 08:49 AM
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=59264
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=62286
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=24834
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19213
"looks like it was ripped right off the pages," etc., etc..
Hah. More than not, I think. And 1 issue of Vol. 4. I really tried to get a letter printed for TMNTA (Archie) but they never would. :) Pretty sure I sent them art, too (no, it wasn't involving severed heads).
Citing Kevin in this regard isn't much of anything, for the very reason you mention. It's also worth noting that he once said the Platinum Dunes movies possess "the darker edge of the comic books."
http://www.thenational.ae/blogs/scene-heard/back-to-the-drawing-board-for-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-creator-kevin-eastman
Fans sure have a proclivity for exaggeration, don't they? Alright, you've proven your case. It's not all in your head.
Though, I would find it hard to believe that any of these people would say with a straight face that the 1990 movie was a 100% faithful adaptation of the comics.
Factually speaking, it isn't. But you're right, some of those posts would have you believe that the movie is a strict adaptation of the comics, which just isn't true.
D Piddy 1982
04-22-2020, 11:14 AM
Just to add to the other 2007 movie comments.
I've said on other threads and I'll say it again - I think this movie stinks. I watched it once on DVD and have zero desire to ever watch it again. The plot from what I can remember was boring. Possibly even confusing? They brought in new characters (enemies) that I didn't care for. I also think the Turtles themselves, design wise is just bad. Hardly any differences between the 4 brothers. I'm not calling for RiseOTTMNT differences but at least in the 1990 film (for example) if someone showed me a B&W pic of one of the Turtles I could tell you exactly which one it is. I realise you would have the same issue with FW Turtles - they essentially are all the same design.
Anyhow, just to add to the discussion, this movie gets a big fat thumbs down from me. In someways I am surprised that so many on here like it, but it is refreshing to see there are also some on here that also look back on this negatively. Some people speak as if this is literally the second coming.
AquaParade
04-22-2020, 11:34 AM
I think you're supporting my point without realizing it.
Sort of. I actually do believe the 1990 film is closer to like 85% Mirage in spirit, than 65%, so I wanted to point out that Andrew's opinion might be in "opposition" to people who think like me.
Citing Kevin in this regard isn't much of anything, for the very reason you mention. It's also worth noting that he once said the Platinum Dunes movies possess "the darker edge of the comic books."
http://www.thenational.ae/blogs/scene-heard/back-to-the-drawing-board-for-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-creator-kevin-eastman
I think it's worth a lot, given he created the thing. Not to diminish personal subjective opinion. But if the creator says "yeah, this is what I was going for", you have to put some stock in that.
Again, Kevin is pretty honest in retrospect.
I mean, the PD films did try to capture "the darker edge of the comics books" in some ways. Obviously the film was a mess and complete disaster, but at times they were going for a mature edge with the 2014 film. Alas, they ended up just slapping all the disparate elements they had together into a gnarly gross pizza.
Claiming that PD went for a darker edge with the first film is a harmless thing to say and doesn't reflect the quality of the movie. Probably Kevin's way of avoiding having to say something bad about the film, but you can hear him voice his negative opinion on those movies in any recent interview.
To wrap it up, I think there is clear evidence that you can depend on Kevin to be honest...eventually. I trust he isn't blowing smoke up anyone's ass by praising TMNT 1990 as representative of his vision, thirty years later. Especially when he is openly criticizing the PD films in interviews now.
It was ripped straight from the pages of the Mirage comics. Barron used the issues as storyboards in early development.
Yup.
And it's another opportunity to praise just how well the low-budget visuals of the film represented the indie, homemade feel of the Mirage comic. Maybe it was just coincidence, or maybe it's just the natural order of things for a low-fi comic to receive a low-fi movie adaption, but when people talk about comic books "truly being brought to life on screen", I think of this movie, alongside Into the Spider-Verse or Infinity War.
ABrown
04-22-2020, 12:09 PM
Sort of. I actually do believe the 1990 film is closer to like 85% Mirage in spirit, than 65%, so I wanted to point out that Andrew's opinion might be in "opposition" to people who think like me.
I agree. I mean I think even 80/20% would would be more accurate than 65/35.
AquaParade
04-22-2020, 12:19 PM
I agree. I mean I think even 80/20% would would be more accurate than 65/35.
The turtles occasionally goofing around and joking isn't exclusive to the cartoon, but it seems like that aspect gets played up heavily as being cartoon-influenced.
I sort of get it - they are goofier in the cartoon than in Mirage, so it's easy to attribute that to the toon. That doesn't go very far with me, however. I can think of plenty of Mirage comics, especially the short stories, where the turtles are acting aloof, calling each other silly nicknames (chuckle-head is a personal fav of mine), etc.
I definitely see the colored masks and the pizza as holdovers from the cartoon, April being a reporter - sure. And it pulls a few punches. I don't want to downplay that, but it really isn't much in comparison to how many faithful elements there are.
Peter Palmer
04-22-2020, 03:24 PM
I also think the Turtles themselves, design wise is just bad. Hardly any differences between the 4 brothers. I'm not calling for RiseOTTMNT differences but at least in the 1990 film (for example) if someone showed me a B&W pic of one of the Turtles I could tell you exactly which one it is. I realise you would have the same issue with FW Turtles - they essentially are all the same design.
I disagree with this. I thought they did a nice job actually giving them different body types and I really think they fit the turtles.
Raph has a broader body and has a much more pronounced brow. Seems like he's had a lot more strength training than his brothers.
Leo looks like he's very athletic. He looks like a solid balance between strength and flexibility. He also has very focused eyes and a wider-set mouth than his brothers.
Don seemed to be the most slender with the least definition to his physique, likely because he probably only kept up with the bare minimum of his physical training, throwing himself into his job and his research.
Mikey looks athletic, probably keeping up with some ninja training but a lot more with his extreme sewer skateboarding. He's the only turtle with blue eyes in this one and his eyes are much bigger/rounder than his brothers.
Was this the first animated version of the TMNT that had different body types? Either way, I really enjoyed the subtle differences and feel I could definitely tell them apart in a black & white photo...or without belts/masks for that matter.
Leo656
04-23-2020, 02:06 AM
I think Aqua's 80% Mirage assessment is fairly accurate.
Also, I think expecting super-dynamic fight scenes in a movie where a bunch of guys are wearing 80-lb semi-animatronic foam rubber suits, and constantly on the verge of passing out, is kinda like expecting Hulk Hogan to do a top-rope legdrop anywhere except 1981 Japan. "I really wish he'd busted out that sweet Enzuigiri against Andre the Giant in '87!" "Hah... no, no... we don't do that here, pal."
It's like, yeah, it's a shortcoming... but you also have to consider the limitations of your medium and be fair. I always got the sense that the fight scenes in the 1990 TMNT movie were literally the best that they could do, and that the cheesy stuff was simply a way to make up for the fact they couldn't actually do a lot, physically. Can't go full Jackie Chan, can't just have guys standing around, so you do shtick. And it would remind people of the cartoon, so it wasn't entirely out of place.
I mean yeah... tighter fight scenes definitely would be an improvement. But let's be real, that was a little beyond their reach at the time. And even with what they were finally able to achieve motion-wise in the third movie, those suits looked comparatively like sh*t. So they never really managed to nail it 100% with those suits. But they gave it their best shot.
I just feel like it's not entirely fair to take points off for something that wasn't reasonably within the filmmakers control. One could say, "Why even bother if they couldn't do it perfectly?", and I'd see the logic in that, but that's a bit too close to "Why even bother making the movie?" for my liking. The entire film itself is a testament to compromise and making the best of what you've got to work with, for better and worse, and how sometimes a compromise can still lead to something good. That's just one more thing.
Andrew NDB
04-23-2020, 02:33 AM
I don't believe for one second the "limitations" of the fights in TMNT 1990 had anything to do with the logistics of the suits or anything. Now, don't get me wrong... they exceeded all expectations with what could be done with animatronic suits in an action sense, especially then and what budget they were working with. But I can't fathom that was the deciding factor in why "Let's have the Turtles strike their opponents with their weapons and hurt them" wasn't a thing. That was only ever a "ehh... we better tread lightly around these angry parent groups and such, and SURGE has that toy stuff and all" thing, and nothing else.
And then they STILL kowtowed to it, with the aftermath. That's why there was no weapons usage at all in TMNT II, just a nunchuk sausage.
Leo656
04-23-2020, 03:19 AM
I have no doubt that was part of the conversation, sure. But the actors were practically keeling over from dehydration just walking around, so there's absolutely an issue of practicality involved as well.
For them to try and assemble anything "exciting and dramatic" out of the fight scenes would have required, shall we say, very liberal and excessive use of jump cuts, in order to hide the very frequent edits, which would have threatened to make the whole thing look like an even bigger farce. They certainly wouldn't have been going full-blown, "Cobra Kai Season 2 Finale" with the choreography. More like "3 Ninjas: High Noon At Mega Mountain", or "Side Kicks". That wouldn't have been very good, either.
It's like why Keaton's Batman spent most of his time scowling and knocking guys out with one punch, rather than engaging in Batfleck-level shenanigans. Dude couldn't f*cking move! Doesn't make his movie retroactively "bad" or even "lesser" for being trapped within the restraints of 1989's technology; it's simply something that later films managed to do better. Y'gotta grade these things on a curve, it's only fair.
Yes, there was almost definitely a lot of conversation about "not being too violent for the kiddies", but I'm inclined to believe that at least some of the choices made for the choreography was simply put down to not wanting to literally bury these guys after they died of heat stroke, and/or not wanting the movie to be a choppy-looking piece of sh*t. I'm inclined to believe they could have still managed more than "block-block-kick" and not had to resort to so much comedy, BUT, it probably would have come at a trade-off that ultimately might not have served anyone all that well in the end.
Now, you wanna talk about a movie that always get put over despite the fight scenes being wretched, I'll see your TMNT 1990 and raise you a Superman II. That whole movie's pretty much a flaming wreck, but it comes with the "bonus" of the most boring and hack-ish "fight" scenes between all-powerful demigods that anyone's ever put to film. And they didn't have the "excuse" of being buried in foam rubber, either. They could've done just about anything they wanted, and that pansy-ass slap fight is the best they came up with. I mean, I know a thing or two about setting up make-believe fights, and I'm inclined to believe just about anyone could have staged a better climax than that pile.
I know you agree with me about that movie. I'm just putting things into perspective. :lol:
sgtfbomb
04-23-2020, 09:43 AM
Oh wow, that would make the fight so much darker and Mirage-like. Like the rest of the movie, starring Danny, Dude Mikey, and Darth Shredder's Halfway House of Troubled Youths.
Block-block-kick, block-block-kick, block-block-kick.
I didn't say "it would make the film darker." You seemed to have ignored the part where I said, "But these were more likely cut for pacing reasons, not violence. "
d_osborn
04-23-2020, 12:35 PM
But I can't fathom that was the deciding factor in why "Let's have the Turtles strike their opponents with their weapons and hurt them" wasn't a thing. That was only ever a "ehh... we better tread lightly around these angry parent groups and such, and SURGE has that toy stuff and all" thing, and nothing else.
I'm sure MPAA would have loved Shredder's head being cut off by Leo. :roll: You can't just willy nilly do what you want in a film when there are investors and contractual ratings obligations. Not to mention, Henson was apprehensive about taking on the project, so I'm sure there was consideration by Barron there.
AquaParade
04-23-2020, 01:40 PM
I'm sure MPAA would have loved Shredder's head being cut off by Leo. :roll: You can't just willy nilly do what you want in a film when there are investors and contractual ratings obligations. Not to mention, Henson was apprehensive about taking on the project, so I'm sure there was consideration by Barron there.
Not to speak for Andrew, but I don't think that is what is in question here. He knows there are restrictions, he just isn't happy with the end product.
I didn't say "it would make the film darker." You seemed to have ignored the part where I said, "But these were more likely cut for pacing reasons, not violence. "
Yeah, to be fair, that sort of came out of nowhere, Andrew.
d_osborn
04-23-2020, 01:53 PM
...he just isn't happy with the end product.
Really? He hasn't whined enough about to make that apparent.
We're discussing the reasoning and decisions behind the lack of brutal, violent fight scenes in an early-90s family film. They're absolutely what's in question.
Andrew NDB
04-23-2020, 01:57 PM
I'm sure MPAA would have loved Shredder's head being cut off by Leo. :roll: You can't just willy nilly do what you want in a film when there are investors and contractual ratings obligations. Not to mention, Henson was apprehensive about taking on the project, so I'm sure there was consideration by Barron there.
20 years, and me saying "I sure wish the Turtles can strike the bad guys with their weapons in a movie" still seems to = "OMG, you madman... Turtles can't be R rated, you idiot!!"
Moronic. They can easily use them and it fall under PG-13. They've been intentionally tying both arms behind their back since 1990. Nobody is asking for a bloodbath. It's IN the title, for f***'s sake.
d_osborn
04-23-2020, 02:06 PM
20 years, and me saying "I sure wish the Turtles can strike the bad guys with their weapons in a movie" still seems to = "OMG, you madman... Turtles can't be R rated, you idiot!!"
Moronic. They can easily use them and it fall under PG-13. They've been intentionally tying both arms behind their back since 1990.
I don't disagree, but I understand the reasoning behind the decisions. Yelling at a brick wall for 20 years is your fault. :lol:
pferreira
05-08-2020, 11:23 AM
Am I being a curmudgeon for wanting that last 35%, in spite of the pretty OK 65%? Maybe. Over the years I just take annoyance with folks treating TMNT 1990 like it's synonymous with "Mirage: The Movie."To be fair there have been worse comic book adaptations in film. I do get your frustration though, you want something completely exact and faithful.
And then they STILL kowtowed to it, with the aftermath. That's why there was no weapons usage at all in TMNT II, just a nunchuk sausage.That was parental groups getting angry about TMNT. A shame Mike doesn't even use his weapons in the sequel.
That whole movie's pretty much a flaming wreck, but it comes with the "bonus" of the most boring and hack-ish "fight" scenes between all-powerful demigods that anyone's ever put to film. And they didn't have the "excuse" of being buried in foam rubber, either. They could've done just about anything they wanted, and that pansy-ass slap fight is the best they came up with. Wow, I thought Superman II had an awesome fight. I mean could have done without Richard Lester's added on humour but the fights itself looked amazing. Sure as hell more exciting and interesting than Man of Steel. :o
They can easily use them and it fall under PG-13. They've been intentionally tying both arms behind their back since 1990. Nobody is asking for a bloodbath. It's IN the title, for f***'s sake.I suppose they could have the TMNT stab people but not show blood. :ohwell:
It was ripped straight from the pages of the Mirage comics. Barron used the issues as storyboards in early development.
You're right, I do remember Barron mentioning specific shots being translated from the comics.
Leo656
05-08-2020, 02:51 PM
Wow, I thought Superman II had an awesome fight. I mean could have done without Richard Lester's added on humour but the fights itself looked amazing. Sure as hell more exciting and interesting than Man of Steel. :o
That's a terrible opinion but that's fine, it's yours, you can keep it. :lol:
Two guys who could individually punch out the sun if they wanted to should cause a little more of a ruckus when they clash than casually whipping manhole covers at each other or indulging in product placement for giggles' sake. If you're not gonna knock over a city, then don't even book that fight. MoS had entirely the right idea while Superman II wasted everyone's time on sight gags and nonsense. I can't even sit through that one anymore, it's terrible. Donner Cut is a moderate improvement but still incredibly flawed. But either cut of Superman II would need a rocket up its ass to match MoS.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.