View Full Version : Sophie Campbell ordered by IDW to stop work.
TobeyP
04-03-2020, 06:22 PM
According to Newsarama, Sophie Campbell has been ordered by IDW to stop work on TMNT after issue #105. link below.
https://www.newsarama.com/49712-idw-publishing-s-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-stopping-with-105.html?fbclid=IwAR13N7HkHfCZ7hZIOsKJhHjEJimAGHeQ YHocoTRD56yrzHJ0NcxfOEVUlDg
Weapons@theready
04-03-2020, 06:32 PM
I need to know the status of The Last Ronin, immediately.
80gmrp
04-03-2020, 06:43 PM
Thanks for the notice. As much as I dread the IDW comics as a whole, I have grown respect for Sophie, and whether she can return later or not, I hope for the best for her.
Dejablue
04-03-2020, 06:48 PM
This is very unfortunate. And it sucks! :cry: The IDW comic is like...the one tmnt thing I had in my life right now.
Mutant Ninja Anole
04-03-2020, 07:04 PM
Wow, I hope this is just a delay. Having the TMNT IDW run end like this would be really, really disappointing. And it stinks to have someone’s first run as writer stopped like this.
At least we’ll close up this arc with 105 and can pick up after that when this thing finally dies down.
ChosenOne
04-03-2020, 07:11 PM
One word for this: ****.
MikeandRaph87
04-03-2020, 07:22 PM
This is very unfortunate. And it sucks! :cry: The IDW comic is like...the one tmnt thing I had in my life right now.
Same here. Its an alternative to Rise of the TMNT. I want to see it continue and the article is vary vague if its a change in writer earlier than planned ( see Batman 2016 as example) or if IDW is trimming publication of its comics line and the TMNT ongoing falls victim because of the Coronavirus or if Nickelodeon pulled the license. The industry is put on hold, but the TMNT ongoing is being signaled out. So many questions. I don't care for this slice of life in Mutant Town personally, but the series as a whole has taken TMNT into a direction that fans of various iterations can truly appreciate. We will get answers in time and hopefully it is good news around the corner. Until then though its sitting on our hands and waiting..
ChosenOne
04-03-2020, 07:30 PM
Hopefully Sophie, or someone else at IDW, is at liberty to speak about this development and can clarify what it means/might mean when she drops by.
It'll really suck if this is the end for the comic, nothing had me as hyped as the concept of the Turtles running a dojo and especially having Saki as a guardian angel of sorts, with the potential to evolve into a full-blown mentor. I think I speak for everyone who's ever been a TMNT fan when I say just that mere notion sends chills down our spine. The good kind, too.
Fingers crossed!
Weapons@theready
04-03-2020, 07:43 PM
Waltz used the term hiatus on Twitter,
https://twitter.com/tomwaltz/status/1246221761672142849?s=21
hypered1
04-03-2020, 07:45 PM
I think this is more of hiatus in the sense that they don't want to stockpile too many products and create a massive backlog because A: we don't know when things will be back to normal and B: releasing too many different things in a short amount of time would negatively affect sales figures and profit margins.
Put it this way trying to sell 4/5/6 times the usual amount of issues, tpbs, etc in the time they would plan to sell a month or two's worth of releases makes no sense as most people simply don't have the time or money to buy that many comics in such a short timespan.
My work has done a similar thing with some of our staff, where some have been placed on furlough - effectively our government is paying the wages of those furloughed until at least the end of April but they are not allowed to do any work as there isn't enough for all of our employees to do.
It's all a very alien situation.
CyberCubed
04-03-2020, 07:46 PM
We already knew IDW as a whole was stopping comic releases for May and onward due to the virus. IDW TMNT isn't ending and they'll obviously continue where they left of once they start printing again.
Issues 106-107 are already far into production.
MikeandRaph87
04-03-2020, 07:56 PM
We already knew IDW as a whole was stopping comic releases for May and onward due to the virus. IDW TMNT isn't ending and they'll obviously continue where they left of once they start printing again.
Issues 106-107 are already far into production.
We all assumed as much of the above with everything on hold , but why was Sophie Campbell signaled out to stop working on TMNT? Why not tell the My Little Pony writer to stop work? Why not tell the Transformers writer or the Sonic writer?
Sophie Campbell
04-03-2020, 07:59 PM
It's not ending! I realized my tweet sounded dire after I hit send but I just meant work was stopping for the time being and I don't know for how long. I don't know when we'll be back, hopefully sooner rather than later. :) Thanks for the support, you guys!!
80gmrp
04-03-2020, 08:03 PM
It's not ending! I realized my tweet sounded dire after I hit send but I just meant work was stopping for the time being and I don't know for how long. I don't know when we'll be back, hopefully sooner rather than later. :) Thanks for the support, you guys!!
...so, you're only temporarily gone? If so, that's comforting to know.
TigerClaw
04-03-2020, 08:07 PM
It's not ending! I realized my tweet sounded dire after I hit send but I just meant work was stopping for the time being and I don't know for how long. I don't know when we'll be back, hopefully sooner rather than later. :) Thanks for the support, you guys!!
That's good to know.
Sophie Campbell
04-03-2020, 08:15 PM
...so, you're only temporarily gone? If so, that's comforting to know.
But you just said you DREADED the comic!!! :tcry:
MikeandRaph87
04-03-2020, 08:16 PM
It's not ending! I realized my tweet sounded dire after I hit send but I just meant work was stopping for the time being and I don't know for how long. I don't know when we'll be back, hopefully sooner rather than later. :) Thanks for the support, you guys!!
You do realize that for a full hour my TMNT world came to an end,right?:tcry: Now I can breathe again!
80gmrp
04-03-2020, 08:19 PM
But you just said you DREADED the comic!!! :tcry:
Perhaps I should've clarified; apologies for not doing so. It's true that I have gotten pretty emotional in bad ways over certain nameless issues, but you weren't involved with those, combined with my catching you tell someone on Reddit what you hope to do regardless of whether it actually happens.
Sophie Campbell
04-03-2020, 08:21 PM
We all assumed as much of the above with everything on hold , but why was Sophie Campbell signaled out to stop working on TMNT? Why not tell the My Little Pony writer to stop work? Why not tell the Transformers writer or the Sonic writer?
Everyone is stopping, I wasn't signaled out.
TigerClaw
04-03-2020, 08:22 PM
Its gonna be a while until we get to see the Turtles, Alopex, Mona Lisa, Sally Pride, and Jennika having a wild time at this heavy metal concert.
ChosenOne
04-03-2020, 08:22 PM
Perhaps I should've clarified; apologies for not doing so. It's true that I have gotten pretty emotional in bad ways over certain nameless issues, but you weren't involved with those, combined with my catching you tell someone on Reddit what you hope to do regardless of whether it actually happens.
"Nameless issues". Subtle. :D Well, I'll be direct: #SaveLeatherhead!
I'm so happy and relieved to hear this is just a hiatus! Hope to have you writing the comic for many years to come, Sophie!
80gmrp
04-03-2020, 08:28 PM
Everyone is stopping, I wasn't signaled out.
Thanks for this clarification as well. Admittedly when I first saw the news, I personally thought you were. Which, while I do have my reservations about some issues, I was hoping wasn't the case, because I also have enjoyed the few conversations we did have in the past elsewhere.
CyberCubed
04-03-2020, 08:28 PM
To be honest issue 105 if it comes out is a good stopping point for now, the Turtles are all reunited and it's before whatever the next big storyline is. We're essentially in a slice of life breather moment for the series...can you imagine if production was stopped between issue 99 and 100?
Thank god issue 100 came out last year. :lol:
Mutant Ninja Anole
04-03-2020, 08:41 PM
Good to see this seems to be just a hiatus. Hopefully it can pick up momentum after the break.
And yes, all things considered if a stoppage had to happen we could have done a lot worse than after 105.
King Kahn
04-03-2020, 08:42 PM
We all assumed as much of the above with everything on hold , but why was Sophie Campbell signaled out to stop working on TMNT? Why not tell the My Little Pony writer to stop work? Why not tell the Transformers writer or the Sonic writer?
Larry Hama on the GIJOE comic was told to stop along with most others I would assume.
MikeandRaph87
04-03-2020, 08:44 PM
Thanks for this clarification as well. Admittedly when I first saw the news, I personally thought you were. Which, while I do have my reservations about some issues, I was hoping wasn't the case, because I also have enjoyed the few conversations we did have in the past elsewhere.
Yes, thank you for the clarity of the matter!
neatoman
04-03-2020, 09:37 PM
Well at least it's not straight up cancelled, though it might be a little sad that it's going to take a while for publication to resume. I'm also guessing it could mean they might scrap the consecutive numbering? I know that's actually irrelevant in terms of the content, and that the series is still the longest TMNT comic by 33 issues (and way longer than most other comics that started in 2011) but seeing the high number getting even higher did imbue some superficial quality.
Then there is the worst case scenario in which the series does indeed get cancelled because of this which would really suck. I wouldn't want to license to go to some other publisher anytime soon. While I'm not going to lie and say the series hasn't been messy for the past 30 or so issues, I've still grown fond of these iterations of these characters and some of the ongoing plots. A new publisher most almost certainly mean new writers, new artists and a new continuity. And considering that Boom and their Power Rangers crossover went straight for Reporter April, The Technodrome as Shredder's default base, Bebop/Rocksteady as his main henchmen, Turtle Van and even a white Stockman (and also 4Kids Karai oddly enough), it has me a little worried that another publisher might assemble a more careless creative team that just superficially apes the FW cartoon without considering better source material or even care enough to make the characters compelling.
ChosenOne
04-03-2020, 10:53 PM
Well at least it's not straight up cancelled, though it might be a little sad that it's going to take a while for publication to resume. I'm also guessing it could mean they might scrap the consecutive numbering? I know that's actually irrelevant in terms of the content, and that the series is still the longest TMNT comic by 33 issues (and way longer than most other comics that started in 2011) but seeing the high number getting even higher did imbue some superficial quality.
Then there is the worst case scenario in which the series does indeed get cancelled because of this which would really suck. I wouldn't want to license to go to some other publisher anytime soon. While I'm not going to lie and say the series hasn't been messy for the past 30 or so issues, I've still grown fond of these iterations of these characters and some of the ongoing plots. A new publisher most almost certainly mean new writers, new artists and a new continuity. And considering that Boom and their Power Rangers crossover went straight for Reporter April, The Technodrome as Shredder's default base, Bebop/Rocksteady as his main henchmen, Turtle Van and even a white Stockman (and also 4Kids Karai oddly enough), it has me a little worried that another publisher might assemble a more careless creative team that just superficially apes the FW cartoon without considering better source material or even care enough to make the characters compelling.
Please don't give them any ideas regarding the issue numbering!
As for a possible outright cancellation, with everything that's going on, would that really be more cost- and time-effective than just resuming the current comic as-is whenever the virus thing finally clears up? I mean, it's not like they're the only ones lagging behind, as it were... Not to mention, the current comic still sells pretty well and even hits on milestones like Jennika being mutated every once in a while that provide momentary sales boosts. Doesn't make much sense from a business standpoint to cancel this one and start over just because of the virus-induced, industry-wide (if not civilization-wide) hiatus. Remember, the different iterations of the franchise in almost every crossover has been a thing for pretty much all of the IDW TMNT run; it's not necessarily an ill omen.
CyberCubed
04-03-2020, 11:55 PM
I think the series would only get canceled before it's time if IDW as a whole goes bankrupt. They did post a pretty big loss last year, and the virus is going to hit the entire industry pretty hard, but overall they should survive. Keep in mind IDW is a lot more than just comics, they also have a small TV show division and of course license board games/toys, etc.
TommyT
04-04-2020, 01:05 AM
I think the series would only get canceled before it's time if IDW as a whole goes bankrupt. They did post a pretty big loss last year, and the virus is going to hit the entire industry pretty hard, but overall they should survive. Keep in mind IDW is a lot more than just comics, they also have a small TV show division and of course license board games/toys, etc.
Yeah, the stock is half of what it was just a few months ago, with a two year downturn.
They have a huge debt they were going to pay off through Tax credits, but the virus is forcing a Suspension of production. They took that huge hit with October Faction, and have had to resort to kickstarters to patch holes.
The last round of funding only brought in 12m.
Honestly, the future is bleak, at best.
shredder orokusaki
04-04-2020, 05:19 AM
most companies worldwide have closed their offices until the virus is gone. Many companies has delayed the release of their products because of it. Not even if i with my foot ninjas attacked the evrywhere something like this would had happend!
Jazzfox
04-06-2020, 01:59 PM
Gah, glad I wasn't on here a day or two ago to see this topic go up or I'd have went STRAIGHT into panic mode, now on the other side of Sophie's comments and whatnot at least feel a little bit better about where things are currently
(ESPECIALLY since I've seen a share of topics/videos flash up on Youtube about this very subject)
I'm very much a person who despises self-fulfilling prophecies, so I'd like to look on the positive side and say that until the worst ever happens, there's still plenty ways things can go
A metric ton of businesses are all in the same boat and it's gonna be a thing to see when everything gets to some measure of normality again folks picking up the pieces and getting back up
Is there anything we can do to support IDW in the interim? I know Marvel and DC are doing things with comic stores and Comichub so that folks can buy digital and then use their receipt to get physical copies of the books later? Anyone know more on that topic?
Sophie Campbell
04-06-2020, 02:22 PM
Unfortunately the Comic Hub digital program thing fell apart: https://www.newsarama.com/49692-comichub-temporary-distribution-system-isn-t-going-forward.html
There's a lot of weird tension and politics between publishers, retailers, Diamond (the distributor, not the mutant porcupine, lol) and digital comics, so I'm not surprised it fell apart so quick. It would've been cool though!
CyberCubed
04-06-2020, 02:24 PM
Is there an ETA for when the comic will resume? I imagine nothing is coming out in May either...so I guess June/July at the earliest? Waiting till the Fall would be something.
Sophie Campbell
04-06-2020, 02:31 PM
Is there an ETA for when the comic will resume? I imagine nothing is coming out in May either...so I guess June/July at the earliest? Waiting till the Fall would be something.
I guess it depends on the virus. Also with the lackluster way the pandemic is being handled in the States, who knows.
MikeandRaph87
04-06-2020, 02:33 PM
Unfortunately the Comic Hub digital program thing fell apart: https://www.newsarama.com/49692-comichub-temporary-distribution-system-isn-t-going-forward.html
There's a lot of weird tension and politics between publishers, retailers, Diamond (the distributor, not the mutant porcupine, lol) and digital comics, so I'm not surprised it fell apart so quick. It would've been cool though!
Anything that we IDW loyalist can do for you, Tom, Bobby, etc. al between now and late June? If it means keeping my favorite title going I am in. Just give us a clue to the sewers dweller in return.
neatoman
04-06-2020, 02:34 PM
It says a lot when I hate this virus on so many levels that the actual risk of getting sick is what I'm the least concerned about...
Jazzfox
04-06-2020, 03:49 PM
Unfortunately the Comic Hub digital program thing fell apart: https://www.newsarama.com/49692-comichub-temporary-distribution-system-isn-t-going-forward.html
There's a lot of weird tension and politics between publishers, retailers, Diamond (the distributor, not the mutant porcupine, lol) and digital comics, so I'm not surprised it fell apart so quick. It would've been cool though!
Gaaaaaaah D=
Wish there had been a happier ending there, and I guess that there's a lot of folks with stokes in the fire who all want their interests first, with so many parties involved I guess it would be hard to find happy mediums at the best of times
Still, hope holds that someone can think out an interim of some kind-
Anything that we IDW loyalist can do for you, Tom, Bobby, etc. al between now and late June? If it means keeping my favorite title going I am in. Just give us a clue to the sewers dweller in return.
Yeah, this, same question please! Looking for any way to help pitch in to show some support!
pferreira
04-07-2020, 02:01 PM
Yeah, the stock is half of what it was just a few months ago, with a two year downturn.
They have a huge debt they were going to pay off through Tax credits, but the virus is forcing a Suspension of production. They took that huge hit with October Faction, and have had to resort to kickstarters to patch holes.
The last round of funding only brought in 12m.
Honestly, the future is bleak, at best.Not totally bleak, it'll probably just mean comics will get released exclusively online, rather than just in printed form.
schickler
04-08-2020, 08:38 PM
I'm hoping we can see the ongoing arc and Jennika mini getting wrapped up with their remaining issues, even if digital-only for the time being.
I can understand putting things on hold, especially if it's going to be a months-long pause. Shop-owners aren't going to want to purchase stock that immediately become back-issues once this all clears up.
Here's to hoping folks have enough runway to get through the downtime. I guess there's always commissions or something to help pay the bills in the meantime, or a renewed focus on other indie projects.
TommyT
04-08-2020, 08:58 PM
Not totally bleak, it'll probably just mean comics will get released exclusively online, rather than just in printed form.
Without the film grants from Canada to pay down the 50 million loan, what will they do? They’ve been paid for mist of their deep pocket expenses, and are still crazy in the red.
Stock is 5.5 right now. I’ll bet come next quarter it’s half that again.
Sophie Campbell
04-08-2020, 10:23 PM
What I want to know is why TommyT seems so obsessed with IDW financials.
Andrew NDB
04-08-2020, 10:34 PM
I've been pretty suspicious about the specific things he seems to dig at. Either he's somebody on the inside or formerly on the inside (of what? Mirage? IDW? something else? I have no idea) or just a dedicated troll looking for blood in various waters. Maybe both!
hypered1
04-09-2020, 06:53 AM
I've been pretty suspicious about the specific things he seems to dig at. Either he's somebody on the inside or formerly on the inside (of what? Mirage? IDW? something else? I have no idea) or just a dedicated troll looking for blood in various waters. Maybe both!
Never, ever feed the trolls!
Igglet
04-09-2020, 07:17 AM
As a professional internet virgin, I can confirm, without a shadow of a doubt, this guy isn't someone with inside knowledge or experience, nor is he a troll. As a matter of fact, he's probably in the camp that gets super salty about getting labeled as trolls. He's just toxic.
TigerClaw
04-09-2020, 09:16 AM
As a professional internet virgin, I can confirm, without a shadow of a doubt, this guy isn't someone with inside knowledge or experience, nor is he a troll. As a matter of fact, he's probably in the camp that gets super salty about getting labeled as trolls. He's just toxic.
We come across people like that in all fandom these days.
pferreira
04-09-2020, 12:16 PM
We come across people like that in all fandom these days.People get called trolls for seeing the value in one iteration of TMNT. This is kind of the reason a lot of people stay away from these forums.
Igglet
04-09-2020, 12:23 PM
People get called trolls for seeing the value in one iteration of TMNT. This is kind of the reason a lot of people stay away from these forums.
Are you sure that's the reason that people stay away from these forums, and not that it literally looks like an artifact of an early age of the internet and that, every now and again, people will randomly burst out into political rants with no sense of awareness that they're on a site meant for discussing a property aimed at children?
rayfillet101
04-09-2020, 12:49 PM
There is a lot of uncertainty these days, but really want is important is people's lives. TMNT has survived a lot, it will be around after this COVID scare is finally behind us. Right now just hope everyone stays safe and stays home. Not sure what will come of this, if new stories will find a different way to come out, that is up to Nick and IDW. Comics are pretty adaptable to online (webcomics, who knew?!) but comic retailers are unfortunately not. It is hard to move forward without retailers nor does anyone want to forget about them.
Myself, looking forward to digging out my issues of City at War to read over the past 14 of so issues.
TigerClaw
04-09-2020, 12:54 PM
Sophie Campbell given our experiences during this Pandemic. Is this something that you may want to tackle in a future story line for the Comic?
How would the Turtles, The Mutants and the Foot Clan handle a Pandemic similar to this one?
funatic
04-09-2020, 01:08 PM
How would the Turtles, The Mutants and the Foot Clan handle a Pandemic similar to this one?
Classically, the turtles have always been pretty good at social distancing. :twink:
TigerClaw
04-09-2020, 01:10 PM
Classically, the turtles have always been pretty good at social distancing. :twink:
That's true. I don't know about the Mutants in Mutant Town. and I don't know if such a virus would affect them. Even though animals can get such a virus. But it won't kill them. Or could it? Who knows.
ChosenOne
04-09-2020, 01:12 PM
That's true. I don't know about the Mutants in Mutant Town. and I don't know if such a virus would affect them. Even though animals can get such a virus. But it won't kill them. Or could it? Who knows.
Now that you mention it, I can see Stockman engineering just such a virus to turn public opinion against Mutant Town if they start to garner way too much sympathy for his liking.
Mutant Ninja Anole
04-09-2020, 03:27 PM
I fear such a storyline would probably be seen as in bad taste.
ChosenOne
04-09-2020, 04:45 PM
I fear such a storyline would probably be seen as in bad taste.
Right now? Absolutely. A couple of years down the line? Absolutely not.
Didn't even take studios five whole years before they started working on 9/11-themed movies, and that was a very specific set of circumstances. This is quite different. Tales of apocalyptic plagues - with or without zombies - are among some of the most successful ever in fiction, no one's going to give up on that for long. Even tne sequel to The Last of Us will be a huge hit despite the pandemic.
frank_one
04-09-2020, 08:26 PM
"It's all mutants' fault! The virus generated in their town and now it's spreading over the world! Mutants are filthy, no one knows what they eat! Mutants must pay!"
Yeah, I can see this stuff adapted into a new tmnt story arc.
Shinigami
04-10-2020, 08:27 AM
Are you sure that's the reason that people stay away from these forums, and not that it literally looks like an artifact of an early age of the internet and that, every now and again, people will randomly burst out into political rants with no sense of awareness that they're on a site meant for discussing a property aimed at children?
I second this.
ChosenOne
04-10-2020, 08:53 AM
Is it aimed at children, though? Is it really? Why? Because it's been adapted to cartoons? Because the first one made it out to be a kid-friendly franchise?
At its core, TMNT isn't that kid-friendly at all, starting with Mirage all the way down to IDW and some of its more intense moments. That's like insisting that Harry Potter is kid-friendly just because its always been marketed that way (even though most of its success was due to adults picking up the books) and then handing some kid a copy of Deathly Hallows and having them read, say, the Godric's Hollow bit. That's how you get lifelong nightmares as a child.
Mutant Ninja Anole
04-10-2020, 09:03 AM
Are you sure that's the reason that people stay away from these forums, and not that it literally looks like an artifact of an early age of the internet and that, every now and again, people will randomly burst out into political rants with no sense of awareness that they're on a site meant for discussing a property aimed at children?
Is it bad that one reason I hang out here is the message board format makes me nostalgic for the early 2000s?
Sumac
04-10-2020, 09:47 AM
"It's all mutants' fault! The virus generated in their town and now it's spreading over the world! Mutants are filthy, no one knows what they eat! Mutants must pay!"
Yeah, I can see this stuff adapted into a new tmnt story arc.
If they eat raw ****, which was known for spreading viruses before...:D
TigerClaw
04-10-2020, 09:53 AM
Is it aimed at children, though? Is it really? Why? Because it's been adapted to cartoons? Because the first one made it out to be a kid-friendly franchise?
At its core, TMNT isn't that kid-friendly at all, starting with Mirage all the way down to IDW and some of its more intense moments. That's like insisting that Harry Potter is kid-friendly just because its always been marketed that way (even though most of its success was due to adults picking up the books) and then handing some kid a copy of Deathly Hallows and having them read, say, the Godric's Hollow bit. That's how you get lifelong nightmares as a child.
Most of the blame should be put into Nickelodeon. In there eyes TMNT is for children. Its the reason why they canceled TMNT 2k12 after 5 seasons and created ROTTMNT instead. Because 2k12 was attracting older people that isn't part of there demographic.
The fact to the matter is. IDW's version of TMNT is appealing to all ages. More so to the older crowd who grew up with these characters. With every issue. We are seeing them grow and become more mature.
Igglet
04-10-2020, 11:12 AM
Different versions of the property are appealing to different demographics. However, as a whole, it definitely is primarily aimed at kids, considering the fact that the most popular adaptations are mainly catering towards them. While the writing often has enough maturity for older audiences to enjoy it as well, that doesn't change who the target audience is.
I would argue that IDW's TMNT is aimed at teens for the most part, I believe I've heard Bobby say so himself. Evidently, older audiences can enjoy it, but that's not to say that younger ones can't either. I don't know about you guys, but a lot of the cartoons that we were shown here in Serbia had content that was a lot darker than most of what the IDW run has to offer, with the exception of, perhaps, Donnie's "death".
ChosenOne
04-10-2020, 11:37 AM
TV adaptations of TMNT are definitely geared towards a younger audience, but the franchise's true roots are in comics where it's always been far more mature, even the Archie comic which broke off from the 90s cartoon at first. Not just in terms of violence, but even its very themes. It's a tremendous shame that the general public pigeonholes this franchise as mere kids' stuff when it could be so much more.
And to me, Donnie's "death" isn't even up there with the most disturbing moments of the IDW comic. He was a soldier fighting in a war, he knew the risks and still elected to stay behind. No, the most disturbing moment is from the second Bebop & Rocksteady mini when we see them trying to live normal lives as humans but quickly reverting to their violent ways and butchering innocent people, even an old lady IIRC. I had to stop reading for a moment there.
Mutant Ninja Anole
04-10-2020, 11:40 AM
This discussion is pretty funny as someone who grew up with 1987 and occasionally hears how that version ruined it for teen and older Mirage comic fans.
Sophie Campbell
04-10-2020, 12:06 PM
I wish I was allowed to have the Turtles drink beer, kill bad guys, and swear. At least we can have them say "ass" and "damn." :tlol:
Candy Kappa
04-10-2020, 12:13 PM
Can do like the Biker Mice from Mars, it's totally root beer :lol:
MikeandRaph87
04-10-2020, 12:35 PM
I wish I was allowed to have the Turtles drink beer, kill bad guys, and swear. At least we can have them say "ass" and "damn." :tlol:
Sounds like Wolverine.:P
Diorm
04-10-2020, 12:51 PM
I wish I was allowed to have the Turtles drink beer
Well, they ARE still teenagers right? Maybe when they change the title to regular "Ninja Turtles"
But is there any reason why they cant kill and swear?
neatoman
04-10-2020, 12:53 PM
I wish I was allowed to have the Turtles drink beer, kill bad guys, and swear. At least we can have them say "ass" and "damn." :tlol:
Didn't Bobby say that "light drug use" was OK?
Cloudrunner
04-11-2020, 06:06 AM
Didn't Bobby say that "light drug use" was OK?
Have Donny shoot smack into his shell cavity to cope with the trauma.
lonewarrior20
04-11-2020, 07:22 AM
maybe light drug use is Donnie having a ton of caffeine to stay awake, one of the others taking pain killers for an injury or headache, or taking nigh quill for the cold and flu season. it is winter after all.
Jazzfox
04-11-2020, 01:34 PM
I like to think that the comic hits a nice middle ground, it can deal with a lot of heavy issues like Casey's dad or losing Splinter or even this version's origin story of the turtles
In the same way Samurai Jack (pre-Adult Swim) could be very brutal and visceral without actual bloodshed, I think a huge pip goes to some of the art team too in being able to give big moments a lot of weight without pushing into Marvel MAX territory in how they present it on the page
Back in issue 66, Alopex freeing herself from Kitsune's thrall was one of my fave shots of her time in the IDW continuity, and I think it hits JUST that sweet spot of barbaric and beautiful
Soooooo....
Iunno how I'd feel at things ramping up, I guess, much like my earlier preference, it would all depend on portrayal and presentation
(Although with it brought up? I do wanna imagine in the Biker Mice Root Beer vs real Beer? That maybe Mikey tries it and then just spurts it back out everywhere thinking that it would have been like root beer or something, lol)
(Also, goddamn it, I'd crack a root beer with those biker mice any day, is there ANY chance one of the Biker Mice from MASS is still around in Mutant Town and turned into a mouse at all?)
Andrew NDB
04-11-2020, 01:57 PM
Didn't Bobby say that "light drug use" was OK?
What does that even mean?
neatoman
04-11-2020, 02:09 PM
What does that even mean?
Here's the exact thing he said:
In Mirage, the Turtles were depicted as drinking alcohol. Are you allowed to depict them drinking or does that fall under some kind of rule against depiction of underage drinking?
In practical application, I'd have to inquire with Nickelodeon, but in theory yes! Back when we first got the license we were given a list of what's permissible and I remember drinking and light drug use (!!) was on it. But I suspect that list was what was able to appear in the pages of the comic, not necessarily what the Turtles themselves could do.
Shinigami
04-11-2020, 02:13 PM
Is it aimed at children, though? Is it really? Why? Because it's been adapted to cartoons? Because the first one made it out to be a kid-friendly franchise?
At its core, TMNT isn't that kid-friendly at all, starting with Mirage all the way down to IDW and some of its more intense moments. That's like insisting that Harry Potter is kid-friendly just because its always been marketed that way (even though most of its success was due to adults picking up the books) and then handing some kid a copy of Deathly Hallows and having them read, say, the Godric's Hollow bit. That's how you get lifelong nightmares as a child.
I read it that this forum was. Because it was made for the 87 toon.
CyberCubed
04-11-2020, 08:38 PM
I'm curious what IDW will do when the comic resumes production, assuming the hiatus goes on for a few months, that's 3+ or more issues missed. Will they make up the lost time with double length issues or just release one issue a month at 20 pages or so and just pick up where they left off? Obviously issue 105 must be mostly done, but I'm referring to the issues that come after.
Seems we might lose almost half a year of releases depending how long this hiatus goes on for.
frank_one
04-11-2020, 09:22 PM
They could release a double length issue at regular price to incentivate readers to come back after the hiatus. A lot of people could have less money to spend after this covid crisis or could have forgotten about the comics, the double length issue could help them jump back on the idw turtles train.
pferreira
04-20-2020, 12:32 PM
Are you sure that's the reason that people stay away from these forums, and not that it literally looks like an artifact of an early age of the internet and that, every now and again, people will randomly burst out into political rants with no sense of awareness that they're on a site meant for discussing a property aimed at children?An early 'artifact'? Uh-huh. :o
This discussion is pretty funny as someone who grew up with 1987 and occasionally hears how that version ruined it for teen and older Mirage comic fans.Occasionally? :lol:
Didn't Bobby say that "light drug use" was OK?You want the TMNT doing drugs now? :roll:
neatoman
04-20-2020, 03:30 PM
You want the TMNT doing drugs now? :roll:
... No? I was referencing something Bobby said, I even posted the exact quote when Andrew asked what it meant. And it was clearly in response to Sophie's post about her not being allowed to write the Turtles drinking beer.
I honestly don't know how you keep missing context, it's right there in what you're responding to.
AquaParade
04-20-2020, 03:43 PM
Well, I don't want them to not be allowed to drink beer.
Redeemer
04-20-2020, 08:04 PM
They could release a double length issue at regular price to incentivate readers to come back after the hiatus. A lot of people could have less money to spend after this covid crisis or could have forgotten about the comics, the double length issue could help them jump back on the idw turtles train.
That would be awesome, but unfortunately I don't think that is possible due to the fact they have to pay a licensing fee on top of everything else.
shredder orokusaki
05-01-2020, 12:04 PM
Also sonic comics stopped. It seems like IDW closed temporary like many other companies did,
Jazzfox
05-06-2020, 05:44 PM
AND WE'RE BACK!
https://twitter.com/mooncalfe1/status/1257398879697453057
Official from Sophie herself, the crew are back and creating! May only be the first baby steps, but still, feels damned good to hear progress again <3
benea
05-06-2020, 09:12 PM
YAAAAAAY and BOYAKASHAABUNGA
lonewarrior20
05-06-2020, 09:58 PM
yeah, for a while I felt a bit of deja vu with rise of tmnt on waiting for new episodes.
https://66.media.tumblr.com/4411df2c1d66f172c44c120a2f7ff5db/tumblr_mi34m02vK51qgdah3o1_400.gif
TigerClaw
05-06-2020, 10:54 PM
That's good news.
hypered1
05-07-2020, 06:33 PM
That's good news.
Agreed, also it means it shouldn't be too hard (at least Turtles comics-wise) to get back on track regarding the release schedule considering that really only the main ongoing has any long-term plans, the rest are all mini-series with no more than 4 or 5 issues left in their runs or tpbs/ collected editions which don't hold to any strict release pattern.
The Great Saiyaman
05-07-2020, 07:35 PM
I REALLY want to see what this Mutant Ghetto story line turns into.
I hope I don't have to wait too long to find out.
Mutant Ninja Anole
05-07-2020, 10:34 PM
Great to hear this.
pferreira
05-08-2020, 11:04 AM
... No? I was referencing something Bobby said, I even posted the exact quote when Andrew asked what it meant.But it doesn't make sense what Bobby quoted as saying. :ohwell:
TommyT
05-21-2020, 08:51 PM
Hopefully they won’t ban me for sharing the news.
Also of note, stock is now 3.95, very close to what I predicted before they had me banned.
The ship continues to sink. Sophie wonders why I’m so concerned with IDW financials, I have to wonder why she is not.
l1uZPYTW2Mg
Sophie Campbell
05-21-2020, 09:12 PM
Hopefully they won’t ban me for sharing the news.
Also of note, stock is now 3.95, very close to what I predicted before they had me banned.
The ship continues to sink. Sophie wonders why I’m so concerned with IDW financials, I have to wonder why she is not.
l1uZPYTW2Mg
I am concerned, but that's because I work for them. You don't, and you don't even seem to like their comics so it just seemed weird to me that you seem so interested in it to the point that it's nearly the only thing you talk about around here.
Leo656
05-21-2020, 09:15 PM
I mean, it's only common sense that there's problems. I admit I don't follow the business end obsessively or even very closely, but it just stands to reason. IDW is a distant third in the market behind Marvel and DC. Most of their most popular books are licensed properties such as TMNT, Transformers, Sonic, etc., which means that their overhead has to be enormous. Those licenses cost a lot of money, so they need a huge return on investment just to break even. Right now, nobody is making any money and people are not likely to be buying comics even once production is back up and things settle down in the world. DC and Marvel are taking huge hits from this situation, so if they're hurting, IDW simply has to be struggling to an exponentially greater degree.
It's not doomsaying, it's simple math plus Cause-And-Effect.
Hopefully the situation will improve.
TommyT
05-21-2020, 09:25 PM
I am concerned, but that's because I work for them. You don't, and you don't even seem to like their comics so it just seemed weird to me that you seem so interested in it to the point that it's nearly the only thing you talk about around here.
Here’s the deal. I really liked your subtle blending in of a few of the elements from the RPG. I think you’re great, and have a bunch of good stuff to offer. IDW, is in trouble, and I though Jenika was a terrible idea, for all the reasons I’ve said, including using the 5th turtle idea as a life raft. It was a cheap move, and exploited both long term fans, and comics gate.
All I’ve been doing, us trying to gently hold up a mirror, for Tom, hoping he pays attention.
There’s such a big world to explore, why would you focus on gender politics? The most toxic part of the comic world, and the editor drove head first.
I don’t want to see IDW take TMNT down with them, anymore than I want Netflix to own the master licenses. The brand needs a stable home, and good creative. So you bring the creative, but diversity of thought is also important. IDW is not playing to its strengths.
I think you will be fine. You’re very sought after.
Sophie Campbell
05-21-2020, 09:41 PM
Here’s the deal. I really liked your subtle blending in of a few of the elements from the RPG. I think you’re great, and have a bunch of good stuff to offer. IDW, is in trouble, and I though Jenika was a terrible idea, for all the reasons I’ve said, including using the 5th turtle idea as a life raft. It was a cheap move, and exploited both long term fans, and comics gate.
All I’ve been doing, us trying to gently hold up a mirror, for Tom, hoping he pays attention.
There’s such a big world to explore, why would you focus on gender politics? The most toxic part of the comic world, and the editor drove head first.
I don’t want to see IDW take TMNT down with them, anymore than I want Netflix to own the master licenses. The brand needs a stable home, and good creative. So you bring the creative, but diversity of thought is also important. IDW is not playing to its strengths.
I think you will be fine. You’re very sought after.
I'll definitely be fine, yeah, I have lots of work lined up with other publishers, but it still sucks because I care about TMNT and I like working on it, and I care about other people who work at IDW like Bobby, Tom, and Ronda.
It's worrying but at the moment things are running smoothly at TMNT HQ right now so I'm sure it'll be fine for the time being.
I'd say introducing a female Turtle that rankles comicsgate-type people means you're doing something right, not wrong. Jennika was a masterstroke in my opinion! And IDW is focusing on diversity of thought, that's why they hired me to steer the TMNT ship for a while. :tcool:
In any case, thanks for the compliments!! :)
ChosenOne
05-21-2020, 10:19 PM
Whatever else it entails and whatever other plot elements might come into play before or around it, I'll be absolutely devastated if this comic doesn't continue until at least #150 and properly explores the concept of the Turtles running a dojo-cum-neighborhood watch, quite likely under a reedemed Saki's mentorship. There's absolutely no TMNT fan who wouldn't get weak in the knees upon hearing that notion, and we really, really need to see it materialize.
TommyT
05-21-2020, 10:39 PM
I'd say introducing a female Turtle that rankles comicsgate-type people means you're doing something right, not wrong. Jennika was a masterstroke in my opinion! And IDW is focusing on diversity of thought, that's why they hired me to steer the TMNT ship for a while. :tcool:
In any case, thanks for the compliments!! :)
No, poking the eye of those you don’t like is a major mistake.
The smart move, given the state of the world is either diversify the product line, (TMNT Dems AND TMNT Rep, make content for both) or you unify.
You need a doppelgänger- a inverse Sophie, on a book that isn’t what you would do.
Star Wars did both. Mandelorian is not Rise of Skywalker. The new MOTU is split as well.
Diversity of thought goes beyond diversity of staff.
Help them save themselves. The restart is not going to be DOA, but it will be close, three months out, it will be very rough.
ChosenOne
05-21-2020, 10:50 PM
No, poking the eye of those you don’t like is a major mistake.
The smart move, given the state of the world is either diversify the product line, (TMNT Dems AND TMNT Rep, make content for both) or you unify.
You need a doppelgänger- a inverse Sophie, on a book that isn’t what you would do.
Star Wars did both. Mandelorian is not Rise of Skywalker. The new MOTU is split as well.
Diversity of thought goes beyond diversity of staff.
Help them save themselves. The restart is not going to be DOA, but it will be close, three months out, it will be very rough.
:roll::roll::roll::roll:
Speaking of diversity, by now we've all seen Quirrell running into the Great Hall shouting about what's in the dungeon, so I thought I'd try something new:
https://i.imgur.com/yzUsr8W.jpg
Guy doesn't even bother concealing it anymore... Smfh.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-21-2020, 10:59 PM
He's jealous of Cubed running off Ciro, wants to one up him by pissing off Sophie.
Allio
05-21-2020, 11:01 PM
Thing is with jennika is... she isn’t bad? At worst I’ve seen was the similarities to your oc. Which I get it. Tom wanted her yellow and you can only do turtle with yellow mask is so many designs as well as I agree that yellow was the best choice to fit a color scheme with the guys.
Now I would say that had those preview designs avoided the designs of turtle jennika with the bow and arrow and the hoodie, we probably could have avoided some comparisons- but that’s my opinion.
Also, any reason idw is still promoting her with the arrows and sword? She basically has dropped them since.
As for idw finances? I don’t know. I just hope that they last long enough for turtle team to create a satisfying ending. Though I am glad you do have other places just in case.
Leo656
05-21-2020, 11:02 PM
He's jealous of Cubed running off Ciro, wants to one up him by pissing off Sophie.
:lol::lol::lol: Nah, that ain't happenin', anybody who puts up with my sh*t and sticks around this place just ain't leavin', period.
TommyT
05-22-2020, 01:19 AM
He's jealous of Cubed running off Ciro, wants to one up him by pissing off Sophie.
I have a career, as does Sophie. She can take the advice, or watch IDW fold, and lose her opportunity to tell her stories.
You on the other hand, well, if being forgettable is the goal, congratulations.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 01:32 AM
HAH! You haven't seen him naked.
I mean, neither have I, frankly, but... well, I hear things.
TommyT
05-22-2020, 01:41 AM
HAH! You haven't seen him naked.
I mean, neither have I, frankly, but... well, I hear things.
If I misgendered Cylons, I apologize. I often mistakenly assume most people in forums are men.
Sorry for that, bad habit.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 01:48 AM
Well he's definitely a Dude. One of my favorite dudes! But I don't think he likes beer, so I'm not sure I can call him a "man". :trazz:
And if he drinks White Claw then forget about it. But he never shared that information with me, so I don't know. But everyone who drinks Claws either has a vagina or grows one. It's science.
Andrew NDB
05-22-2020, 03:09 AM
I don't like beer. Mostly because I don't like remembering myself as a 250 pound fatso.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-22-2020, 01:25 PM
Well he's definitely a Dude. One of my favorite dudes! But I don't think he likes beer, so I'm not sure I can call him a "man". :trazz:
And if he drinks White Claw then forget about it. But he never shared that information with me, so I don't know. But everyone who drinks Claws either has a vagina or grows one. It's science.
I am a glorious Adonis when sky-clad.
And I make a fantastic Mint Julip, as befits someone in the South. I even sit on the porch and remind people that "the South shall rise again!" as I sip at it.
I have a career, as does Sophie. She can take the advice, or watch IDW fold, and lose her opportunity to tell her stories.
You on the other hand, well, if being forgettable is the goal, congratulations.
Technically, everybody collecting a paycheck that isn't from disability or unemployment has a "career." So what? For all I know, you fry chicken and aren't allowed to say "you're welcome", and must instead say "my pleasure." Quit trying to swing your d!ck around.
MikeandRaph87
05-22-2020, 02:14 PM
I am a glorious Adonis when sky-clad.
And I make a fantastic Mint Julip, as befits someone in the South. I even sit on the porch and remind people that "the South shall rise again!" as I sip at it.
You sound like my undergrad college advisor. The only thing left is you tell me your idol is Andrew Jackson....:trazz:
So what is the status of TMNT books with the layoff and pandemic? June wraps up TMNT/Power Rangers and Jennika? #105 to get through this arc?
ChosenOne
05-22-2020, 02:22 PM
Technically, everybody collecting a paycheck that isn't from disability or unemployment has a "career." So what? For all I know, you fry chicken and aren't allowed to say "you're welcome", and must instead say "my pleasure." Quit trying to swing your d!ck around.
Must... Resist... Temptation... To post... Meme... About... Walter... Peck... :lol:
You sound like my undergrad college advisor.
You mean some guy you knew in college got butt-naked in front of you while he made you a drink? Sounds ominous.
(JK)
MikeandRaph87
05-22-2020, 02:28 PM
Must... Resist... Temptation... To post... Meme... About... Walter... Peck... :lol:
You mean some guy you knew in college got butt-naked in front of you while he made you a drink? Sounds ominous.
(JK)
No mint julip sipping sitting in a rocking chair and expressing south sympathy while praising Andrew Jackson.
ChosenOne
05-22-2020, 02:36 PM
No mint julip sipping sitting in a rocking chair and expressing south sympathy while praising Andrew Jackson.
Oh... Now I want that too.
TommyT
05-22-2020, 06:17 PM
I am a glorious Adonis when sky-clad.
And I make a fantastic Mint Julip, as befits someone in the South. I even sit on the porch and remind people that "the South shall rise again!" as I sip at it.
Technically, everybody collecting a paycheck that isn't from disability or unemployment has a "career." So what? For all I know, you fry chicken and aren't allowed to say "you're welcome", and must instead say "my pleasure." Quit trying to swing your d!ck around.
The adults were talking, and you interrupted. When you actually publish something, I'll be interested in what you have to say.
No offense.
FredWolfLeonardo
05-22-2020, 06:36 PM
When you actually publish something, I'll be interested in what you have to say.
Technically, Cylons is a published author.
Igglet
05-22-2020, 06:36 PM
God, I hate this place.
TommyT
05-22-2020, 06:47 PM
Technically, Cylons is a published author.
It's always interesting when people preface things this way.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 07:22 PM
God, I hate this place.
The gods have abandoned us.
But yeah, I'm always shocked that this place gets new members. Most of the people already here never even talk because anything you say out loud just leads to arguments.
But I've said this before: Expecting mature conversation from a bunch of 30-somethings who are in romantic love with cartoons is a fool's errand on its face.
It's like George Carlin said: "F*ck those people, if they knew anything they wouldn't be riding the bus."
Cloudrunner
05-22-2020, 07:54 PM
To be fair, I do agree on one point. This obsession creators in the industry have with pissing off comicsgate is pretty pathetic. Considering their industry is on a steady decline, and artists who DO support comicsgate have found great success PURELY through fan support via their kickstarters. So it's clear that there is a large group of fans that are looking to throw their money at creators, if only those creators would stop spitting in their face.
Frankly I find it hard to care at this point. The entire comics industry wants to dig their own grave and at this point I'm content to watch them do it. It's the constant pissing in the wind they do while doing it that's annoying to see.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 08:08 PM
I do think it's kind of not smart business to openly tell potential customers "You're not the kind of people we want". Like, there's "If this thing isn't for you, it's not for you," which is one thing, and then there's "We actively, openly don't want you along for the ride." I find that to be questionable.
The most successful people I keep in touch with in the entertainment industry generally don't get "political" at all in public. They have their views at the end of the day like everyone else, but it's not part of their job and they're not about to cut off their nose to spite their face and lose millions of dollars doing so. Except for a few who are set for life regardless and therefore have nothing to lose. But that's different.
I kinda think that if you make your money in the public eye then it pays to play conservatively. And by that I don't mean "right-leaning", I mean "Don't openly tell potential customers that you don't want their money because of how they feel on unrelated issues which probably don't have much to do with your products".
But that's me. I also don't know what "comicsgate" is and now I'm afraid someone's gonna tell me.
CyberCubed
05-22-2020, 08:16 PM
I hope IDW TMNT lasts 150 issues before it concludes. We're up to issue 106 now so by issue 150 it should be enough time to wrap up most storylines if they have to.
It is true that Coronavirus really screwed over a lot of industries and is causing a lot of companies to fold or mass layoffs, and the comic book industry is definitely hit hard, but let's hope TMNT goes on for the time being.
Sumac
05-22-2020, 08:18 PM
I'd say introducing a female Turtle that rankles comicsgate-type people means you're doing something right, not wrong. Jennika was a masterstroke in my opinion! And IDW is focusing on diversity of thought, that's why they hired me to steer the TMNT ship for a while.
Female turtle is definitely not a diversity of thought in any way shape or form.
And I don't think some people are pissed purely because she is "female turtle". Though, I won't deny that those people exist too, (which doesn't make pinnacle of all evil or whatnot).
But that's me. I also don't know what "comicsgate" is and now I'm afraid someone's gonna tell me.
People who dislike SJWs and their "diversity", basically.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-22-2020, 08:20 PM
The adults were talking, and you interrupted. When you actually publish something, I'll be interested in what you have to say.
No offense.
It's always interesting when people preface things this way.
Technically, because only self-published to date. No luck with the solicits and agents and houses so far.
Working on novels 9 and 10 this year (started with #9, switched to #10 when it came to mind). Not super proud of the first four, but they're still on my shelf so they count. Redheaded stepchildren, but they count.
Make sure you apologize to me BEFORE they send you away again for a 2-3 week vacation, cowboy. Hell, I'll even share my bourbon with you.
I really don't give a $hit what you think of me, but lay off with the passive-aggressive $hit towards Sophie. It's rare enough TMNT personnel post here, and I like hearing what they say.
lonewarrior20
05-22-2020, 08:37 PM
sometimes I swear the poster child for this place is a beaten up baxter stockman saying "can't we all just get along?"
on a plus note sophie said she's at least be working till 116 so that's a plus. had another prediction on a future story line, at some point I predict that some rich jerk is going to come to mutant town to go on safari, after all if man is the most dangerous animal, then what is a mutant?
MikeandRaph87
05-22-2020, 08:42 PM
sometimes I swear the poster child for this place is a beaten up baxter stockman saying "can't we all just get along?"
on a plus note sophie said she's at least be working till 116 so that's a plus. had another prediction on a future story line, at some point I predict that some rich jerk is going to come to mutant town to go on safari, after all if man is the most dangerous animal, then what is a mutant?
#116? I thought it was through #112? I take it that Campbell has an outline through that point?
I am hopeful that it will pick up with #106 after the new status quo stuff is over.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 09:03 PM
Technically, because only self-published to date. No luck with the solicits and agents and houses so far.
Working on novels 9 and 10 this year (started with #9, switched to #10 when it came to mind). Not super proud of the first four, but they're still on my shelf so they count. Redheaded stepchildren, but they count.
Make sure you apologize to me BEFORE they send you away again for a 2-3 week vacation, cowboy. Hell, I'll even share my bourbon with you.
I really don't give a $hit what you think of me, but lay off with the passive-aggressive $hit towards Sophie. It's rare enough TMNT personnel post here, and I like hearing what they say.
Dude, getting published is hard. I know a lot of people in that business and it's like, unless you write tween fiction or stuff for horny housewives, you're pretty much stuck self-publishing. It's not even a reflection of any author's work, it's just that "print is dead" thanks to the internet breeding an entire generation of functionally illiterate people who only know meme-speak.
One of the girls I took writing classes in high school with was published at age 16, but even that was like, partly the gimmick of being able to market a "prodigy". She was a very good writer (specifically poetry) but who knows if he even would have gotten looked at if she was 26 or 36, rather than 16 at the time. Not saying she wouldn't, but she might not have.
I definitely count self publishing as "being published". Due to external market forces it's pretty much the only way to get your stuff seen anymore. No shame in the game, brother.
Plus, a lot of people self-publish their autobiographies nowadays, and they still get paid a lot of money for it. I think we're officially past the point where being approved by Random House makes you any more or less "legitimate".
Good for you, buddy. I couldn't do it.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
05-22-2020, 09:33 PM
Dude, getting published is hard. I know a lot of people in that business and it's like, unless you write tween fiction or stuff for horny housewives, you're pretty much stuck self-publishing. It's not even a reflection of any author's work, it's just that "print is dead" thanks to the internet breeding an entire generation of functionally illiterate people who only know meme-speak.
One of the girls I took writing classes in high school with was published at age 16, but even that was like, partly the gimmick of being able to market a "prodigy". She was a very good writer (specifically poetry) but who knows if he even would have gotten looked at if she was 26 or 36, rather than 16 at the time. Not saying she wouldn't, but she might not have.
I definitely count self publishing as "being published". Due to external market forces it's pretty much the only way to get your stuff seen anymore. No shame in the game, brother.
Plus, a lot of people self-publish their autobiographies nowadays, and they still get paid a lot of money for it. I think we're officially past the point where being approved by Random House makes you any more or less "legitimate".
Good for you, buddy. I couldn't do it.
I've made my peace with not making it in "real" publishing, but I accept that a lot of people are always going to be dismissive of self-publishing.
At the end of the day, I write for myself and am okay with that. But I'm going to keep trying; I've got two more novels I haven't pitched around yet (one finished, one in progress) that I'm pretty hopeful for. I didn't purposely gear it towards the target markets most sci-fi and fantasy publishing houses want, but it did naturally end up checking a lot of boxes.
One big problem, though, is that a number of publishers are now explicitly asking for non-white, non-straight male authors to pitch to them. Because it's exciting and heroic when a queer woman writes a story, or a gay Muslim, or a transgender person... but us white guys who like girls are old news.
And to a certain extent, I understand that. I just wish these publishers would focus primarily on the story, not the author.
ChosenOne
05-22-2020, 09:37 PM
(...) or a gay Muslim (...)
Posthumous works always do well.
Seriously, though, you have my respect for sticking to your guns and not letting it keep you down.
TommyT
05-22-2020, 09:57 PM
Technically, because only self-published to date. No luck with the solicits and agents and houses so far.
Working on novels 9 and 10 this year (started with #9, switched to #10 when it came to mind). Not super proud of the first four, but they're still on my shelf so they count. Redheaded stepchildren, but they count.
Make sure you apologize to me BEFORE they send you away again for a 2-3 week vacation, cowboy. Hell, I'll even share my bourbon with you.
I really don't give a $hit what you think of me, but lay off with the passive-aggressive $hit towards Sophie. It's rare enough TMNT personnel post here, and I like hearing what they say.
I meant what I said to Sophie, She's good, but i think there's a missed opportunity to feed the other side of the conversation. It's honest feedback, or don't we do that around here?
He's jealous of Cubed running off Ciro, wants to one up him by pissing off Sophie.
^^
This, bud is you being a juvenile white knight. Grow up. Complain all you want, TECHNICALLY I did nothing wrong.
One big problem, though, is that a number of publishers are now explicitly asking for non-white, non-straight male authors to pitch to them. Because it's exciting and heroic when a queer woman writes a story, or a gay Muslim, or a transgender person... but us white guys who like girls are old news.
And I'm sure Sophie is just LOVING this from her "defender". You're actually complaing about the EXACT SAME ISSUE I was, but because it's about you, hey, we all take a knee??
Perhaps you need the time out. You step to me, then ask for an apology? Nah.
hit that ignore or don't, but swing at me, I swing back.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 10:21 PM
Speaking of "swinging", I remember someone mentioning the ol' "Helicopter Dick" gimmick. Are we all still gonna do that, or should I just put mine away?
I mean, my wife likes it, but I'unno, some people here might not.
I've made my peace with not making it in "real" publishing, but I accept that a lot of people are always going to be dismissive of self-publishing.
At the end of the day, I write for myself and am okay with that. But I'm going to keep trying; I've got two more novels I haven't pitched around yet (one finished, one in progress) that I'm pretty hopeful for. I didn't purposely gear it towards the target markets most sci-fi and fantasy publishing houses want, but it did naturally end up checking a lot of boxes.
One big problem, though, is that a number of publishers are now explicitly asking for non-white, non-straight male authors to pitch to them. Because it's exciting and heroic when a queer woman writes a story, or a gay Muslim, or a transgender person... but us white guys who like girls are old news.
And to a certain extent, I understand that. I just wish these publishers would focus primarily on the story, not the author.
Yeah, I can see that. It's a bummer. But it's like what I do, kinda, I never wanted to wrestle in arenas and never would be tapped for that anyway, but I still get paid to wrestle regardless of venue. You get paid to do a job, you're a "professional", that's how I look at it.
You study a craft, you execute said craft, people pay you for it, to me that equals "legitimate professional" regardless of whose name is on the check. Some people just cut bigger checks than others.
lonewarrior20
05-22-2020, 10:29 PM
Speaking of "swinging", I remember someone mentioning the ol' "Helicopter Dick" gimmick. Are we all still gonna do that, or should I just put mine away?
I mean, my wife likes it, but I'unno, some people here might not.
you have no idea how tempted I was to post a puni puni poemy gif just now.
at least the comic series is back on track.
TommyT
05-22-2020, 10:33 PM
Maybe, just maybe, handing out speeding tickets while also speeding, is obnoxious.
Just saying.
Sophie is talented, but as Cloudrunner said, the point is, not everybody wants fullbore woke comics all day, everyday. Some of us are looking for stories that speak to redblooded American/Canadian men.
Even jerkyboy up there is having a tough time because people think the extreeme left is the only market with buying power. It's wrongheaded and incredibly nearsighted.
That doesn't mean I have any issues with Sophie or the work she's doing, but single flavor isn't the best way to run an icecream shop.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 10:46 PM
you have no idea how tempted I was to post a puni puni poemy gif just now.
at least the comic series is back on track.
I had to Google that and I'm still not sure I get the reference. :lol: Regardless, I'm glad some people find me amusing.
Sophie Campbell
05-22-2020, 11:02 PM
Female turtle is definitely not a diversity of thought in any way shape or form.
And I don't think some people are pissed purely because she is "female turtle". Though, I won't deny that those people exist too, (which doesn't make pinnacle of all evil or whatnot).
I didn't introduce Jennika, and the "diversity of thought" statement was a separate thing from a female Turtle being introduced. I got brought on to write the series because I had a different, unique take.
Some of us are looking for stories that speak to redblooded American/Canadian men.
That's fine, and there's PLENTY of that out there. Letting the rest of us have TMNT for a little while won't hurt you.
ChosenOne
05-22-2020, 11:05 PM
That's fine, and there's PLENTY of that out there. Letting the rest of us have TMNT for a little while won't hurt you.
Don't take the bait, Sophie. This guy's a troll who'll gladly keep this argument going forever while slipping in as many jabs, barbs and stealth insults as he can. He's just mad he can't impose his point of view on the whole world and so settles for raging pointlessly while everyone else is having fun and enjoying stuff.
I can't wait to finally see what you've been cooking up for us after this hiatus!
lonewarrior20
05-22-2020, 11:08 PM
I had to Google that and I'm still not sure I get the reference. :lol: Regardless, I'm glad some people find me amusing.
the uh, joker looking badguys have something they spin to deflect stuff, i'll just leave it at that and walk away. my brain has seen some weird stuff over the years. sometime look up one called return of the dinosaurs. its the worst anime I've ever seen. it has live action, stop motion, puppets, models and more. you will have so many questions after watching.
Leo656
05-22-2020, 11:10 PM
Ah, okay, thanks for clarification. :lol: Much obliged.
my brain has seen some weird stuff over the years. sometime look up one called return of the dinosaurs. its the worst anime I've ever seen. it has live action, stop motion, puppets, models and more. you will have so many questions after watching.
Can't be any more bizarre than some of the stuff on P.H. Especially nowadays. :lol:
TommyT
05-22-2020, 11:38 PM
I didn't introduce Jennika, and the "diversity of thought" statement was a separate thing from a female Turtle being introduced. I got brought on to write the series because I had a different, unique take.
That's fine, and there's PLENTY of that out there. Letting the rest of us have TMNT for a little while won't hurt you.
It's not me I'm worried about. I'm just suggesting you might not want to hog the toys.
The stock is 3.95, and dropping. IDW could use another revenue stream. It's just a suggestion.
Don't take the bait, Sophie. This guy's a troll ... He's just mad he can't impose his point of view on the whole world.
Always has to be a troll, never acknowledging what I'm saying.
You're admitting this an ideological fight? I mean, yeah, it is, but I'm not pushing for my point of view. I'm saying if you only cater to a very small group on the left, there is money being left on the proverbial table. You want to flag wave, youNEED a platform to do it from. If you can't afford that platform, or you torch it by only speaking to the most marginalized of people, intentionally putting a thumb in the eye of those who aren't 100% onboard with your politics?
This a'int the front lines of a revolution.
It's bad business, that's all. putting out more than one title to fill the coffers, especially when the entire industry is in the hole...
Not exactly a crazy idea.
Sophie Campbell
05-23-2020, 12:33 AM
I'm just suggesting you might not want to hog the toys.
But I'm being paid to hog the toys. :tcool:
TommyT
05-23-2020, 12:41 AM
But I'm being paid to hog the toys. :tcool:
Fair enough.
Jazzfox
05-23-2020, 06:50 AM
But I'm being paid to hog the toys. :tcool:
I love this response. Just, all of this, had to say. <3
Blagedaggaha, I go idle for a while and it looks like folks in here have been recreating the Mutant Town storyline with a big line splitting the forum down the middle
Soooo, I feel a little conflicted, on the one hand, Wander over Yonder had an episode specifically telling me NOT to feed the trolls, on the other, I’d like to play peace and just offer folks a slice of pizza and chill out
But really, I just wanna talk turtles and look forward to what’s coming up
It feels DAMNABLY good to see one week left of this month on the calendar and think that from next month onwards we may finally be able to open up some new pages, so many Turtles comics all coming to a head between the metal show, the Jennika mini and the Power Rangers/Turtles crossover
As for anything else?
New content is kind of outweighing anything else in my head right now, it’s been a long couple of months since last issue, in way more ways than I wanna count. Stuff like the stock prices? Comicsgate? Don’t know much on them and don’t know if I wanna delve that deep, but one point I do wanna argue?
These turtles comics not being for red blooded folks? Hell, I’d argue that one and do an Obi-Wan Kenobi impression at the same time yelling about having the high ground, that action in 101? I can FEEL some of it. That injury detail against Diamond? I grimace some, even Jennika didn’t get off easy with how painful the damn scene afterwards got having to see Alopex pulling all the spikes out.
There’s action here, even in a more reflective Northampton-style arc, which is core turtles. The art rocks, I’m excited to see where the story goes and hells yes, I wanna see where these brand new characters get to go!
105 can’t come fast enough!!
(Also? Super credit on the theory tossed in about a Most Dangerous Game idea of someone looking to hunt mutants in the town, would wanna see that one too!)
Sophie Campbell
05-23-2020, 12:22 PM
I don't even feel like I've done anything in TMNT so far that would turn off "red-blooded men" or whatever, I've been pretty reined in. I guess there's more crying than usual but Splinter died but it's not like there's been a shortage of moping in TMNT, that's not really new. If I went whole hog I would've just made everyone super gay or something.
snake
05-23-2020, 12:26 PM
But I'm being paid to hog the toys. :tcool:
I knew it. That's why there's no IDW action figures. You're keeping them all to yourself.
TommyT
05-23-2020, 02:10 PM
If I went whole hog I would've just made everyone super gay or something.
Yes. Do that. Make a turtle Gay. Make it Raph, with his frustrations of being closeted the real reason for his anger issues.
Go on. Grab headlines. Push the boundaries. What fun.
EDIT*
OKAY, okay, I admit it, I'm being way too tough. I'm not nearly as right leaning as this exchange has suggested. If Raph was gay, it wouldn't make any difference to me or most people. Maybe it should be Mike. Maybe both. She-ra is gay, Harley is gay, Batman is gay, Wodnerwoman is gay, at this point all fictional characters are gay.
It's fine. It's your sandbox right now, build any castles you want. If the ship is sinking anyway, it doesn't really matter what happens at this point, plus it is the kind of salacious headline that would sell a BUNCH of books.
Jester
05-23-2020, 02:45 PM
Well, Sophie's back to work. I guess the subject of the thread is moot.
Goodnight, everybody.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.