View Full Version : TMNT #106 Preview and Discussion
AlZarkovski
07-06-2020, 09:29 AM
First look:
https://is3-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication124/v4/92/60/42/926042db-9c56-8e73-1540-d1c020349641/img_2.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication114/v4/f3/04/cc/f304cc25-676c-86d0-e765-58f8f024b69e/img_3.jpg/900x0w.jpg[https://is5-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication114/v4/1f/bf/cb/1fbfcb3f-517b-7b2b-c0ed-343fcef53cbf/img_4.jpg/900x0w.jpg
MikeandRaph87
07-06-2020, 09:48 AM
So Baxter Stockman is using his mousers to keep tabs on Mutant Town. Wonder if he has anything to do with the dweller teased.
lonewarrior20
07-06-2020, 11:20 AM
K4_N4D7e6r4
It's frogger! or street frogs
ke74gtmpVXk
Dang it, now i'm gonna have to get one done of this guy playing a frogger arcade cabinet. I'm also kinda reminded of that one scene from scary movie 2 cause of those claw marks.
AquaParade
07-06-2020, 12:06 PM
Really nice looking preview. The line work, inks, and colors come together really well.
ChosenOne
07-06-2020, 12:55 PM
Great preview, but... How exactly did that mutant make those marks on the concrete while being dragged away like that...?
CyberCubed
07-06-2020, 02:06 PM
Looks like Newtralizer.
lonewarrior20
07-06-2020, 02:16 PM
Anyone else reading him in kermits voice?
CyberCubed
07-06-2020, 02:30 PM
Wait scratch that, he reminds me of Chameleon from the Archie comics. I knew he reminded me of something.
MikeandRaph87
07-06-2020, 03:30 PM
Anyone else reading him in kermits voice?
https://disney.fandom.com/wiki/Robin_the_Frog
He looks like Robin, Kermit's nephew.
ChosenOne
07-06-2020, 06:11 PM
He's definitely (I'm gonna say 98% sure) a tree frog, though.
TigerClaw
07-06-2020, 06:21 PM
Could he be one of the Punk Frogs?
PizzaPower1985
07-06-2020, 06:33 PM
Could he be one of the Punk Frogs?
That was my first thought as well, but I'm sure if it was one of the four the character would have a different design.
hypered1
07-07-2020, 09:43 AM
That was my first thought as well, but I'm sure if it was one of the four the character would have a different design.
I think the frogs have had a cameo before now but I can't remember which issue exactly.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-07-2020, 10:46 AM
I think the frogs have had a cameo before now but I can't remember which issue exactly.
One of the issues in the Ghostbusters/TMNT II crossover mini-series. Issue #3, I think?
ChosenOne
07-07-2020, 10:48 AM
I think the frogs have had a cameo before now but I can't remember which issue exactly.
It was somewhere in the second Ghostbusters crossover.
hypered1
07-07-2020, 03:16 PM
One of the issues in the Ghostbusters/TMNT II crossover mini-series. Issue #3, I think?
Thanks, yeah it was issue 3, pages 16 to 19. They're called frogs but not given individual names.
ProphetofGanja
07-10-2020, 01:06 PM
Great preview, but... How exactly did that mutant make those marks on the concrete while being dragged away like that...?
Adrenaline is a hell of a drug :lol:
MekaGojira3k
07-13-2020, 11:52 AM
Glad to see Mousers. I've been wondering what Stockman is up to.
AlZarkovski
07-14-2020, 06:13 AM
Full preview: https://popculthq.com/2020/07/14/preview-idws-7-15-release-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-106/
lonewarrior20
07-14-2020, 08:36 AM
Full preview: https://popculthq.com/2020/07/14/preview-idws-7-15-release-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-106/
hey, its mrs Gonzalez.
CyberCubed
07-14-2020, 09:28 AM
Seems like it might be another slow-burn issue story wise, which I'm fine with. I suspect all the "big plots" are on hold until whenever Tom Waltz starts writing the ongoing again, so I suspect this will be the status quo going forward exploring life about Mutant Town for a good while.
AquaParade
07-14-2020, 09:57 AM
The credits say that Ronda Pattison, the colorist, did the script for this issue. Interesting.
Ninjinister
07-14-2020, 10:16 AM
The credits say that Ronda Pattison, the colorist, did the script for this issue. Interesting.
Not out of the ordinary. She wrote the Jennika mini backup strips.
Joey Kamikaze
07-14-2020, 10:46 PM
So Donny's the writer in the family now? :p
So Donny's the writer in the family now? :p
Yeah, that's suppose to be Mickey's thing. I'd like to see him try to make comics (hell, why not manga too, he knows japanese and he gives me weeboo vibes).
Mutant Ninja Anole
07-15-2020, 01:05 PM
I thought Mikey was the artist, not the writer?
I thought Mikey was the artist, not the writer?
In Image TMNT he wrote a best seller novel and in an issue of Tales of the TMNT Vol.2 he goes to an abandoned apartament complex to try to write a novel showing he is well versed with the classics.
Mutant Ninja Anole
07-15-2020, 01:54 PM
In Image TMNT he wrote a best seller novel and in an issue of Tales of the TMNT Vol.2 he goes to an abandoned apartament complex to try to write a novel showing he is well versed with the classics.
Different continuity.
As for the issue itself, it?s interesting that urban legends amongst the kids have already started to take place. Maybe I?ve been thinking too much about DnD but this has the feel of a starter mission for a tabletop game party: ?Travel into the bowels of the city to stop a monster that has been kidnapping NPCs.? Time to slay the Yuan-Ti and level up so Jennika can unlock her next set of assassin skills.
Also, what is Stockman up to? I honestly have trouble squaring his handling of the Mutant Town scenario with one that plays in his favor at this point unless there?s a larger hidden agenda.
neatoman
07-15-2020, 02:18 PM
So, an eel that may or may not actually eat people (please let actually eat people), sounds like a neat monster.
lonewarrior20
07-15-2020, 02:24 PM
i almost feel like this should start playing after we see the mouser.
lIh8VPoPBhk
ChosenOne
07-15-2020, 02:46 PM
Alopex: a trained killer who dreamed of going up against polar bears, currently afraid of three miniature weasels.
Calling it now, Eel Guy is just kidnapping mutants in a bid to keep them safe from Stockman for whatever reason, like an inversion of the first Leatherhead arc's plot twist.
Also, I love that mutant capybara kid! So cute!
MikeandRaph87
07-15-2020, 03:08 PM
Alopex: a trained killer who dreamed of going up against polar bears, currently afraid of three miniature weasels.
Calling it now, Eel Guy is just kidnapping mutants in a bid to keep them safe from Stockman for whatever reason, like an inversion of the first Leatherhead arc's plot twist.
Also, I love that mutant capybara kid! So cute!
The fact the eel abducted isolated mutant children when mousers are present is curious. I read it the way you did and noted that Stockman wanted to use mutants that he believed no one would miss to experiment on to find a cure.
lonewarrior20
07-15-2020, 04:37 PM
glad to see the rabbit and her son are finally taking a part in the story. when ever we've seen alopex's shelter they've been there. heck we saw them in the street in 101.
CyberCubed
07-15-2020, 09:03 PM
This issue went by very quickly as I was reading it, surprised when I hit the last page already. For some reason seeing a whole bunch of talking animals around kinda makes me forget this is a TMNT comic, I know we've always had mutants but of course now the designs for most of the mutant town mutants is kind of generic (where they look like regular animals, rather than "TMNT mutants" if that makes any sense) so it makes me think of something else.
Considering the hiatus with Covid-19 and everything it does feel like the TMNT series is in a breather/filler-era of sorts. I don't mind the slow burn but I wish they didn't leave so many old plot threads hanging (Ch'rell/Utroms and the Triceratons, along with whatever Null is up to), for so long. At the very least Karai, Baxter and Hob are back in their usual roles.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-15-2020, 10:37 PM
This barely feels like the same Ninja Turtles comic anymore.
I am not a fan.
I am hanging on, because I'm obviously a big enough TMNT fan to be talking about it online with my own profile and $hit, but this series is losing me.
Weapons@theready
07-15-2020, 10:57 PM
Same thing as the last few issues, its not that I don't like the story, because I do enjoy reading them, but this still feels like a miniseries that should be called Mutant Town and doesn't feel like its the ongoing. It feels like a side story. Anxiously awaiting the annual.
CyberCubed
07-15-2020, 11:49 PM
I agree that if this was a set of specials or mini similar to the Jennika mini currently coming out it'd probably fare better. We do need issues exploring mutant town and the characters within, but I'd rather the main ongoing focus on more of the core plots.
At least April is getting pissed off at Baxter. :P
Zog The Magnificent
07-16-2020, 04:32 AM
I dunno, guys, we just spent over 50+ issues on nonstop plot, action, and high stakes, never having even a brief respite as we moved from one gigantic battle to the next. I think we are well overdue for an extended low stakes breather, and I think these last six issues have done the job well. Though I do totally get what you mean regarding the mutant designs. I think the less complex designs are for the best when there's this many of them. Having super detailed "TMNT" mutants for everything would be hard to do and ultimately distracting, and would probably smother the page.
Enscripture
07-16-2020, 07:04 AM
I was hoping it was going to be Null's snake mutant
MekaGojira3k
07-16-2020, 08:29 AM
I liked it, didn't like the art as much as I do Sophies but it served its purpose. I also felt like the last page came too quickly. This is a deliberately paced arc and after everything that's happening it's hard not to read and go "Yes and?" I want more clarity on the goings-on and I want them a lot faster than they're going to give us answers.
Mutant Ninja Anole
07-17-2020, 12:24 AM
Yeah, I?m guessing the Yuan-Ti...er, Slitherer is actually saving kids from the mousers. Interesting choice given Campbell has expressed a phobia about snakes in the past, unless I?m wrong?
I was hoping it was going to be Null's snake mutant
Nah, she?s a loyal soldier, and Null?s been rather quiet since issue 100, which surprises me.
Might be fun for them to meet, similar mutant types with less humanoid bodies and all.
Ninjinister
07-17-2020, 01:34 AM
Eels aren't snakes, homeslice.
Mutant Ninja Anole
07-17-2020, 06:56 AM
Eels aren't snakes, homeslice.
Ah that was an eel? Guess I read too quickly.
ProphetofGanja
07-17-2020, 07:15 AM
This was a fun installment; I really like the one-two punch of the last two issues. I like more character-focused, relation-building type stories every once in a while but I think it's best when balanced by some type of mystery or drama, like this story looks to be. Eager to see where this goes.
Ninjinister
07-17-2020, 10:00 AM
Ah that was an eel? Guess I read too quickly.
Look at their face! It's 100% moray
Leo656
07-17-2020, 10:26 AM
This barely feels like the same Ninja Turtles comic anymore.
I am not a fan.
I am hanging on, because I'm obviously a big enough TMNT fan to be talking about it online with my own profile and $hit, but this series is losing me.
I remember it was only a couple years ago when you were hard-selling the book to me as like, the one and only "saving grace" of the entire franchise.
I still haven't gotten around to it, maybe I will and maybe I won't, but I do check out little bits here and there just to kinda see what's going on, and I'm with ya man, nothing I'm seeing right now speaks well to me at ALL. Not the story, not the art... it's like, kinda making me not even wanna go back and read the earlier stuff, because in the back of my mind the entire time I'm gonna be dreading the foregone conclusion that at some point it's gonna slip into being All This. :ohwell:
Eh, meh. I feel for you, man, I know how much you were really into it at one point.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-17-2020, 11:21 AM
I remember it was only a couple years ago when you were hard-selling the book to me as like, the one and only "saving grace" of the entire franchise.
I still haven't gotten around to it, maybe I will and maybe I won't, but I do check out little bits here and there just to kinda see what's going on, and I'm with ya man, nothing I'm seeing right now speaks well to me at ALL. Not the story, not the art... it's like, kinda making me not even wanna go back and read the earlier stuff, because in the back of my mind the entire time I'm gonna be dreading the foregone conclusion that at some point it's gonna slip into being All This. :ohwell:
Eh, meh. I feel for you, man, I know how much you were really into it at one point.
For a long time, I do think IDW TMNT WAS the saving grace of the franchise post-sale to Nickelodeon.
I don't think it's a completely lost cause yet, I think these arcs could still be made to work retroactively and if things improve, I'll view these less harshly.
But the points you made over in the #105 thread stand. I think it's a safe assumption the series continues steering this way.
Which is fine. If it brings in new readers or pleases some of the current readers, go ahead. But I'm free to voice my dissent and I will continue to do so until I entirely check out of this series and walk away.
MikeandRaph87
07-17-2020, 11:58 AM
For a long time, I do think IDW TMNT WAS the saving grace of the franchise post-sale to Nickelodeon.
I don't think it's a completely lost cause yet, I think these arcs could still be made to work retroactively and if things improve, I'll view these less harshly.
But the points you made over in the #105 thread stand. I think it's a safe assumption the series continues steering this way.
Which is fine. If it brings in new readers or pleases some of the current readers, go ahead. But I'm free to voice my dissent and I will continue to do so until I entirely check out of this series and walk away.
Our preferences within TMNT differ as I love anything related to the 1987 cartoon and you lean towards the black and white comics. Despite this we have found common ground in TMNT and we intersect here as well. I also admit it is hard for me reading most of the first 14 issues of the title. I am accepting that it like before could cater more towards my liking with time. Let's get to #120 and see where we are. This title since #15 has been one I read the day it comes out. Now I keep looking for a way out of Mutant Town. That is the main problem for us both. I am really excited about the annual and the featured villains. I also hope to see another second title, a mini that might cater o us and other plots we want followed up.
Leo656
07-17-2020, 12:04 PM
I just kinda get the same feeling seeing you vent about it, that I do watching my Trek fan friends rage about Picard. Like I'm not as invested as you/they in the material but I kinda feel the same way and I have nothing but empathy and understanding.
But I mean yeah, nothing lasts forever, after all, maybe it'll turn around. And again, "Slice of life" isn't a bad thing sometimes but I don't think that's what some people are reacting negatively to, it's the specific execution that I think is off-putting to some.
I mean, I practically write nothing BUT "slice of life" but that's for my own amusement; if I were putting out a mass-market TMNT comic book, I'd try and write it accordingly knowing full well that that's not what most of the audience signs up for, nah'mean? Like, it's still a commercial medium.
I do recognize how some are saying the previous 50 issues were so action-packed that breathing room is necessary, and that's fair as well. But again, I don't think that the idea of a "breather" arc is as much the issue as how it's been presented. Peoples' points of discontent seem very specific and not directly related to the broader attempt at what they're trying to do; rather, that it seems like Too Much of what they're trying to do. If that makes any sense.
AquaParade
07-17-2020, 12:37 PM
Leo, how far in to IDW did you get?
I have to say, it's easily the most interesting thing to happen to the TMNT in decades. I'd say it's about the same level of quality as tmnt 2012, but in it's own, slightly more adult way. Still not taking the place of Mirage in my heart anytime soon, but if there was anything TMNT-related worth giving a chance to these days, that would definitely be it, in my mind.
I haven't read every issue, but I started collecting the hardcovers during lockdown so I can start over and catch up. Honestly, my favorite parts are finishing a story and seeing a beautiful or unique variant cover for the issue, and getting that fix of seeing the story envisioned through a slightly different lens. Or an Eastman variant to bring in some of the Mirage spice to the series. The stories are good enough to keep me going, but the variants have a way of "boosting" me along.
Again, not perfect, but pretty dang good at points. I hate when people recommend **** to me, but I'm just a bit surprised is all.
Leo656
07-17-2020, 01:16 PM
Hmmm... I don't have the first issue, but I think I have (and have read) most of the first 12-15 issues. My opinions were mixed and I haven't looked at it much since then. Right when I was gonna start getting into it, they started doing the five hundred one-shots and mini-series deal, and I'm like "F*ck that". I'm not even reading Superman and Batman steadily for the last however-many years because it costs too much (and because they're awful, sometimes), so I'm not gonna spend the same amount of money on goddamn Ninja Turtles, that simply isn't in the cards.
TMNT is one of my longest-running Things That I Like, but it's never been in first place, or second or third. So for me to care about whatever TMNT Thing I'm looking at, I have to REALLY like what I see. I don't EXPECT it to be "written for me", but at the same time, if I'm not feeling the material then my urgency to stick with it is low. Because I also have Superman, Batman, wrestling stuff, He-Man, and Ghostbusters all in front of TMNT "on line" demanding my attention at any given moment, and all'a that stuff is WAY cooler than anything TMNT ever put out. I mean, c'mon. I mean, wrestling is pretty stupid, sure, but if anyone ever tried to argue with me that TMNT was cooler or more interesting than Superman, Batman, He-Man or Ghostbusters, I wouldn't mean to spew my drink all over them and piss myself laughing but that's absolutely what would happen.
So with all that explanation... I thought the first dozen or so issues of IDW TMNT were Just Fine but they didn't grab me too deeply, and gave me no real impetus to dig any deeper or keep following the book regularly once it became 500 issues long inside of three years. I saw potential, but I really don't dig the reincarnation stuff, and that's a fundamental building block of the series, so right from the jump I had my dukes up. Like, I get that every version has to add their own New Stuff, usually Just Because, but I feel like The Origin, more than anything, needs to be Clean And Simple and not have all these extra layers of separation and convolution. Same thing whenever there's someone to blame for Krypton blowing up; can't it just be A Thing That Happens, and NOT something Superman needs to punch someone about 30+ years later? WHY get so complicated with stuff that needs to be knocked out halfway before the first issue is over? Just to be "different and new"? Here's an idea, instead of going out of the way to be "Different and New", how about Simple and Good?
So yeah, I kinda wasn't in love from the start. I mean it's not BAD, but it's not really what I'd like to see, although I saw bits that were intriguing. I "check in" from afar, sometimes, and I kinda have to agree with Andrew - although not to the same degree - that very, very much of it seems like it's hellbent on cramming old, familiar TMNT stuff in there (particularly FW stuff) just to cram it in there and it doesn't seem to always be handled very well. I've said elsewhere that by this point, I think you kind of HAVE to make "TMNT Jambalaya" with every new version that comes out, because so many of the versions conflict so greatly with each other that they're hardly even the same thing, but they each have their own fans and their own recognizable traits, so if you DON'T reference This or That version it feels like you're leaving stuff out on purpose, which risks alienating certain fans, so you just have no choice but to kinda reference everything. Which is why there should NOT have been so much conflict between all the TMNT versions and they all should have a LOT more in common and be a LOT more consistent with each other than they are, but that's a whole other can of worms. But it contributes to the current "problem" of how every new version HAS to make Turtle Soup even though lots of people would like something that didn't have that obligation, and could thus have a simpler and more direct focus, rather than being occupied with, "Well, we NEED Bebop, we NEED Mondo Gecko", etc. It's like they "need" everybody except the four Turtles, kinda seems like, sometimes. They're so busy playing Catch The Reference that the storytelling gets lost.
I mean, I'm not gonna lie, this book has always seemed mostly aimed at people who mark out for Spot The Reference games, and I don't pop as big for that stuff as others do. Like Nuclear Man showing up in Bendis's Superman run; no context, he's just there, so it's terrible, why should I react to it? There's no GOOD reason he shows up, he's only there because Bendis saw the movie and knows we all did too. Some people go "Hey! That's awesome! I saw that movie when I was five!" and thus, that issue is great. To me, it's terrible because it doesn't fit and serves no purpose other than for that Cheap Pop. IDW is a bit better about it with their "Classic TMNT" homages, from what I've seen, but it comes from a similar place of selling Nostalgia instead of Story, which I can't say I'm a fan of. "'Member Mona Lisa? 'Member The Neutrinos? 'Member Bebop and Rocksteady and Ace Duck and Mondo Gecko and..." I don't know. I'm not saying DON'T revisit familiar characters and elements, in fact I've often said you kind of have to sometimes. But I do see a lot of people who've long bemoaned the fact that the book sometimes seems a lot more concerned with those Remix Shuffle type things than actually telling its own story, and I haven't seen much but I've seen enough to say it makes me wary as well.
Bottom line, I didn't hate what I read in those first few issues, but the first dozen or so issues are (or should be) a good idea of how any book is gonna go, what it's all about, and if I really, really wanted to stick with it, I would've. I'm not saying I'll never go back and read the whole thing, in fact I probably will someday, but my urgency is low, and frankly, lower now than probably ever. That's just the way it is.
By the way, comparing anything to the Nick TMNT cartoon is never a way to try and endorse it to me, because I'm one of, like, three people that never thought much of that show, either. :lol: Unpopular Opinion Theater again, I know, but I had more Jeers than Cheers on that series before the first episode was even over, so that wasn't the best comparison you could've made, even if it was sincere. :trazz: If you ever care about me actually reading IDW, please do not try and compare it to one of my least-favorite TMNT cartoons. You're gonna have a bad time. :lol: I keep meaning to re-watch Season 1, but I don't have anywhere near enough beer OR weed to make that anything but an exercise in frustration.
So yeah, I'unno, one day, probably. I didn't HATE what I read in the issues I own but I've definitely questioned their priorities along the way when watching from afar, and what they're doing right now is just... nah. So I'unno, I hope to live close to 100 so if that pans out I should have plenty of time yet. And if it grabs me at that point, I'll shrug and say "Well, that's fine." but again... Urgency Very Low.
If people like it that's also fine, I just have very particular taste in TMNT, given that it was never close to my favorite thing to start with. So I'm probably a lot less forgiving than a lot of people on this forum are. They're mostly here because TMNT is their favorite thing, or maybe second favorite. I might be the only one here who cared a lot briefly but always had it in the back seat. So obviously, my perspective is gonna be much different than most. Doesn't mean I don't care, just means that what speaks to me maybe isn't gonna be the same as what speaks to some or most other fans.
((Shrug))
ProphetofGanja
07-17-2020, 02:32 PM
By the way, comparing anything to the Nick TMNT cartoon is never a way to try and endorse it to me, because I'm one of, like, three people that never thought much of that show, either. :lol: Unpopular Opinion Theater again, I know, but I had more Jeers than Cheers on that series before the first episode was even over, so that wasn't the best comparison you could've made, even if it was sincere. :trazz: If you ever care about me actually reading IDW, please do not try and compare it to one of my least-favorite TMNT cartoons. You're gonna have a bad time. :lol: I keep meaning to re-watch Season 1, but I don't have anywhere near enough beer OR weed to make that anything but an exercise in frustration.
Unlike you I'm a fan of the IDW comic, but I agree with you that the Nick show was just fvcking terrible. Couldn't get through the first episode, just turned it off.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-17-2020, 02:39 PM
2k12 cartoon was better than Rise.
But that's like saying a bullet in the foot is better than a bullet in the head.
ChosenOne
07-17-2020, 02:42 PM
2k12 cartoon was better than Rise.
But that's like saying a bullet in the foot is better than a bullet in the head.
Well, it is... Plus, the side effects of a bullet in the head is how you end up producing the 2014 movie.
Leo656
07-17-2020, 03:00 PM
Well, hey now, "Terrible" is a very strong word. I don't entirely think that Nick 2012 was "terrible". It had some intriguing bits and pieces but I didn't like how they came together.
No, I think "Rise" is terrible. :lol: 2012 just wasn't at all to my taste but I get what they were trying to do, I just think most of it was heavily flawed but they executed on their priorities well. Should they have had those priorities in the first place? Eh. Mileage obviously varies. Most people love it, some say it's the Best TMNT Thing Ever, even.
It's got Teen April, Apriltello shipping, Magic Powers April (Geez, can you tell I didn't care much for this show's April? :lol:), Brick-Stupid Casey, Also Pretty Damn Stupid Michelangelo, Mutagen That Does Absolutely What-The-F*ck-Ever, Tons of "Wacky, No-Reason Mutants", "Snarky Teen Karai", Donnie The Stalker, the Pie-F*cker Guy being Leo's voice for the first batch of episodes, and lots and lots of movie parodies and FW "homages", to the point where sometimes it felt more like Tiny Toons. So no, nuh-uh, ain't ever gonna hold much water with me. I hate alllllllllll that stuff more than I feel like going into detail about. BUT, some people like it so obviously I'm the outlier.
People can like it if they want, that's fine, I just don't. When people tell me that Nick 2012 is their FAVORITE version of the TMNT, though... well... pretty sure that's a crack enthusiast I'm dealing with, or at least a crack neophyte. :lol: But I can't say it's so bad that nobody should like it or could ever. I personally just feel like they pretty much took the exact wrong approach from day one and doubled-down on all the worst things every step of the way. I can't imagine why it's anyone's favorite version and I'll never understand that at all, I think it's a complete mess of sh*t flung at a wall and that they pretty much were proud of that.
But "terrible"? Eh. If it were objectively "terrible" I doubt it'd be so beloved as it is. No, "Rise" is terrible, Nick 2012 was just well-intentioned but horribly misguided. :lol: :trazz:
AquaParade
07-17-2020, 03:05 PM
I get that, Leo. I mean, I'm in a similar boat to a lesser extent. I pretty much dropped off somewhere around issue #35, for the most part, and am just now catching up since I have some extra time on my hands. I have a lot of mixed feelings about it, but at the end of the day I do think it's good stuff.
I will defend the reincarnation angle, however. While it's not the definitive origin to me, it adds a certain gravitas to the series that I really appreciate. But yeah, if you're a traditionalist all day, every day, then that's obviously going to be a roadblock.
It's one of my favorite things about the series, personally. Plus it's nice to see a few adult themes in a TMNT story for practically the first time in the 21st century. I mean, the 4Kids series has an awesome reverence for the comics, but even there, the kiddy-gloves are on all day long.
Anyways, I'm rambling on and about to die on a hill I don't really care about. IDW is a solid effort that I'm enjoying, but I'm not going to be the one to push it as the definitive version by any means.
Leo656
07-17-2020, 04:09 PM
Well, I'm hardly a purist - I've compared all of Mirage and particularly Vol. 4 to Ambien far too many times to have that label stuck to me :lol: - but I am a big subscriber of the KISS Theory, also known as "Keep It Simple, Stupid". There should be very, very few degrees of separation between the story and the audience, especially during Origin Moments.
Things that seem small can become a bridge too far very easily. For example, some stories about Krypton show Jor-El actually observing and becoming familiar with Earth by watching on a screen, and that's kinda alright. But still other versions of the tale sometimes show Jor-El actually traveling to Earth somehow before Krypton blows up and even interacting with Jonathan Kent, so that now not only does Jor-El know that IF Krypton ever blows up he's gonna point the rocket straight at Earth, now he's even met his son's future foster Dad and is gonna aim the rocket straight at their backyard. :roll: It's "a new wrinkle", sure, just like Krypton being blown up on purpose by Brainiac or whoever is a new wrinkle, but what's it add, really? It's too "cute", too contrived, and it doesn't really help as much as it hurts in the long run, when they do that kinda stuff. It's the stuff that always gets retconned away, also, and I'm on record, I want as FEW conflicting versions of a character or brand as possible because whenever you have 87 versions of One Thing, all it causes is headaches. So these things kinda have to matter, a lot.
Maybe that's "not creative" to some folks, but I kinda don't care. The world runs a lot more smoothly when a person can ask, "What's the TMNT's origin story?" and there's ONE answer, not fifty. Most people who'd even ask such a question aren't expecting a novel, or to be met with more questions, like "Do you mean in the Mirage comics or the IDW comics? Because they're both very different!" Sh*t like that is why people don't read comics in the first place. Simple questions deserve simple answers, but they don't get 'em, because every writer's gotta put their own "spin" on the ball. Then you get a million different reasons why Krypton blew up and that's the single biggest reason why nobody wants to read comic books. And more people really should. But they're not gonna, because there's far too much conflicting information. That's a bug, not a feature, when it comes to Brand Identity.
I mean, obviously each "new version" - and again, there should be as few "New Versions" of a thing as possible, but the ship's already sailed on this and many other brands, so let's move forward - has its own details that matter and there's going to be some degree of variance. BUT. I feel like Origin Stories should be the MOST consistent thing across a brand because they're the bedrock, they're what everything grows out from. That Big Popular Character's first movie is gonna be the origin story, their first cartoon is gonna be the origin story, and so on... it's just best that the story not deviate too much. It's the ONLY story about the character(s) that most people are ever going to know well enough to recite from memory, so most of the details should be consistent throughout. Origin stories are too important to just add and subtract details all willy-nilly, and only the most essential bits of story should remain. They should be easily understood, easy for most of the audience to accept, and easy to adapt across all mediums, be they print, film, TV, what have you.
So when you add things like reincarnation to a TMNT origin, you're now cutting an already divided audience (and potential audience) down even further, by making something so potentially controversial a part of the "bedrock" of your new version. You have a "For Everyone" property, except now you've annoyed or pissed off the hardline atheists and the Chinese, along with a few Christians and others as well. Now some people are simply never going to read your book - or it can even be banned outright in some countries - because you made an odd creative decision that really didn't have to be made. It wasn't there before, and things were fine. Do *I* have a problem with it? Eh, not on a moral level or anything, I just think it's kinda hokey, I just think reincarnation as a plot device is a reach. I roll my eyes when it's Hawkman, I roll my eyes when it's Ninja Turtles. Without getting into any theological debates, I personally think reincarnation is a rather silly idea, and I think most people do. Sure, it's a "silly" franchise, but again... any One Thing can be "a bridge too far", and that's the kind of thing that a lot of people for one reason or other aren't gonna like, so to me it's a very questionable choice. I can't help it, I think of the idea of "spirits" or "souls" just kinda floating around the ether, trying on a new body every few generations like a new suit, and I can't help but laugh at the story.
Yes, I think reincarnation is much sillier on its face than Radioactive Waste Animals Who Talk And Do Karate. The latter thing has at least a .00001% chance of ever happening in this reality, especially if we let people tinker with eugenics and then wait a while. You'll get some goddamn ninja turtles, pal. :lol: The former? Eh. Again, I don't wanna get into theology, but I'm fairly Agnostic. I believe all things are possible, but that most things that are "technically possible" are also pretty ridiculous to consider, and I personally find reincarnation to be one of those things.
Now, does that mean that plot device is forever off the table? Nah, not at all. I think that if you have a book that runs for a while, and has good reader confidence and a solid reputation for executing on the ideas they present, you can totally introduce some very outlandish things and people will accept them. But right away, in the Very First Story? You wanna put things like reincarnation into the foundation of a story that's already really complicated, what with all the Yoshi and Splinter and Saki and Tang Shen and Utroms and Ooze and all the other moving parts, and now you start by saying "Our story REALLY starts hundreds of years ago starring a bunch'a dead people"? Too much, man. Way, way, WAY too much going on now. It's new. It's different. It's A Way To Go, Sure. Also? It's cluttered. It's kinda hokey. It's more than a little contrived. It's something a lot of people might even be offended by depending on their personal beliefs.
I think you get what I'm getting at. I can get why some people like it, but I feel like it was another well-intentioned but ultimately misguided decision that they probably didn't need to bother with. My first impression out of the gate when I read the first few issues was, "This book is seriously trying to do Too Much". Fast forwards 100+ issues, and... hey, man, some of it may have been a fun ride, but it's pretty much the poster child of "Trying to do Too Much", most people seem pretty clear in agreement on that. But right away, when I saw the New Wrinkle in the origin, that was my impression. Not "This is awful", not "This is unacceptable", just, "This is Too Much, this book seems to have misplaced priorities. It doesn't know where the focus of the story belongs." And it seems like that's STAYED a problem all along.
Now like, if 50 issues in, they reveal that Yoshi and Saki had beef in a past life or something? Sure, whatever, you're 50 issues in now and the audience hopefully trusts you to screw with them like that. You don't LEAD with that "Everything You, The Reader, Thought You Knew Was Wrong!" kinda stuff, it just leaves a sour taste for MOST people.
That's what I mean about how these kinda things matter, and why I feel they do, and what effect they have on the wider audience. You only get one chance to make a first impression, don't tinker too much with origin stories, it does more harm than good. I feel like a good story should be like a tree; the seeds and the root are humble, but the branches and leaves can become quite elaborate and even outlandish while still remaining beautiful as time goes on and nature (or The Story) takes its course. But a tree whose visible root is more extravagant and intricate than its branches and blossoms is incredibly rare, indeed.
Humble first, Extravagant later. That's what generally works, especially in comic book stories. That's my biggest problem with the reincarnation angle; the book starts out really outlandish before they've even hooked the audience, yet, and right away some of 'em are like "Nope!", and that's just a questionable way to lay a foundation. Plus, yeah, some people are actually offended by stuff like that and it's never a good idea to just shrug that off. I don't think people should take that kinda thing so seriously, but they do, can't pretend otherwise. Again, first impressions.
If they'd have done a more straightforward and streamlined version of the "basic" origin that just combined the Mirage and FW versions, I probably would have liked it more, I'll admit. And even if the reincarnation story was the same, and it came in at Issue 50 and not Issue 1, even then I might've liked it better, or at least I could shrug it off and say "In my head, that's not what happened" if I didn't like how they did it. You can't do that with Issue 1 stuff, it's too entrenched.
Leo656
07-17-2020, 04:10 PM
I know that a great deal of this is a Me Issue, I'm just explaining. Also, though, it's not a "JUST Me" problem and so I totally understand why some people disregarded this book from the start. And that's a shame, didn't have to be that way. But that's what happens when you fall in love with your own ideas just because they're "New and Different". I admire their pluck, but again: Weird Priorities.
Like, if this TMNT book had a subtitle, that'd be it: "Weird Priorities". :trazz:
I'm rambling far worse, obviously. :lol: But since you mentioned you liked the angle, I felt obligated to explain why I and some others don't care much for it, and how it's indicative of a larger issue/problem with the book as a whole. It's not the end of the world to me, either, there's been way more stuff they've done that's way more questionable than that. But that's the topic that came up, so... I'unno. :lol:
AquaParade
07-17-2020, 05:58 PM
I think that's a sound reasoning for why you don't dig it.
I'm not sure I can agree with the logic that it turns "most people" off, or that it is a rocky foundation because the book seems to be doing really well critically and seems to have gathered quite a few fans in the comic community. The web is full of people claiming this as the definitive version of TMNT, so all things considered, it worked out well for them.
I get you though. The origin is a bridge too far for many people. I couldn't digest it at first until it grew on me. That's not me pretending I have more sophisticated taste, obviously, I just came around on it.
Really my main complaints regarding the series is the lack of focus, pacing, corny dialogue (imo), and occasional handholding by Viacom that has interfered with stories in the past. That said, they've been lenient with the book compared to most tmnt stuff.
TomWaltz
07-17-2020, 06:51 PM
If they'd have done a more straightforward and streamlined version of the "basic" origin that just combined the Mirage and FW versions, I probably would have liked it more, I'll admit. And even if the reincarnation story was the same, and it came in at Issue 50 and not Issue 1, even then I might've liked it better, or at least I could shrug it off and say "In my head, that's not what happened" if I didn't like how they did it. You can't do that with Issue 1 stuff, it's too entrenched.
Technically, we didn't talk about reincarnation until issue #5 (second arc) and Shredder's return wasn't revealed until the very end of issue #9, and his identity as a resurrected Oroku Saki in issue #10. But who's counting?
That said, I sincerely appreciate your honest opinions/critiques. In the end, I wrote the story I wanted to tell for this particular run alongside Kevin and Bobby... the TMNT tale that made me happy and excited enough to continue for nearly 10 years and 100+ months straight. Otherwise, I'd have been faking it, and then nobody would've liked it, including me. There's no way to please everyone -- it's impossible and, frankly, the least of my worries. Some folks dug it, and some, like you, didn't... and that's okay. The TMNT is bigger than me, bigger than Sophie, bigger than our great team at IDW, bigger than Nickelodeon... even bigger than Kevin and Peter at this point. We'll all be long gone before TMNT stories ever stop being told, and there will always be new fans and old fans and satisfied fans and disgruntled fans.
But most importantly, there will always be Turtles... forever.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
P.S. And I'm not yet done disappointing some fans. Keep watching...
:tcool:
Enscripture
07-17-2020, 06:57 PM
Look at their face! It's 100% moray
I was just going by yellow skin on the covers. But its obviously an eel. Still it could've been a past mutant instead of random new mutant
Leo656
07-17-2020, 07:00 PM
Aqua: For me, every version has at least One Thing that keeps it from being "definitive TMNT", except for the first film.
For FW, it's the general tone and "zaniness". Archie? No Casey Jones, can't be "definitive" (although for me it's Way Up There). Nick 2012, it's lots of things, including Everything About April and Donnie The Stalker, but plenty more. With Rise, it's absolutely everything about it. For the BayTurtles, it's their ability to make me vomit at any given moment. IDW, it's a wonky origin, Way Too Many Mutants and a whole lotta Fan Wank-y kinda stuff that seems to get in the way of things even if it's somewhat "necessary". With Mirage, it's that they killed off the best villain immediately due to a lack of foresight. I do like that he remains a spectral sort of "presence" over the remainder of the book's events for a long time, but you know for a fact that if they knew they were gonna print more than one issue, they would NOT have killed Shredder off right away like that. Total misfire that the entire rest of the series paid the price for, as the series entirely lacked direction for large chunks of time. It's cute that they went all "meta" with it by making that part of the story - "We killed our Big Bad Guy, so now what's our purpose?" - but still, that was just them making the best of a situation they'd accidentally created for themselves, and nothing more. Also, April being a stupid drawing and All The Sh*t that went along with that dumb story. So even the original series that everything sprung from, to me still has some big flaws that keep it from being the "true" version of TMNT.
2K3 comes the closest besides Archie, for me, except for Utrom Shredder. And I don't even HATE it, it's just not something I ever really cared to see. They did fine for what it was, but we all know that the "real" Shredder's just some Japanese guy and not an alien, that's silly. Like IDW's reincarnation origin, or Nick's Teen Magical April, or Mirage's Magic Sketch April, Utrom Shredder in 2K3 is an idea that is "fine" within its own universe but I wouldn't want it to cross over into another one, and like all of those other things, one can strongly argue that it wasn't even necessary. Every one of those things jumps out as being like the answer to a question no one ever bothered to ask.
So that leaves the 1990 film. Unless a person NEEDS Bebop and Rocksteady, I don't think how it gets any more "definitive" than that right there. I mean, yeah, Turtles needed more screen time, whoooo, it's a movie with 12 central rotating characters, time management is an issue. Their world, though, their personalities, the whole story itself, the look and the "feel" and even the way they talk... that's TMNT, right there. I mean, that's it. They'd literally have to breed mutant turtles and film it to get any closer to What It Ought To Be. It's not a perfect movie, but it IS "perfect" TMNT. Nothing's ever come any closer to the pure "essence" and I don't think anything ever will.
Everybody can claim whatever version they want as "definitive", obviously, but I kinda feel like that's just plain crazy talk. :lol: They'd be welcome to explain how it trumps the first movie by way of being "definitive" but it would be an uphill battle for them, for sure. Not that I'm immune to changing my mind, it's just very, very difficult. :trazz:
Leo656
07-17-2020, 07:19 PM
Technically, we didn't talk about reincarnation until issue #5 (second arc) and Shredder's return wasn't revealed until the very end of issue #9, and his identity as a resurrected Oroku Saki in issue #10. But who's counting?
That said, I sincerely appreciate your honest opinions/critiques. In the end, I wrote the story I wanted to tell for this particular run alongside Kevin and Bobby... the TMNT tale that made me happy and excited enough to continue for nearly 10 years and 100+ months straight. Otherwise, I'd have been faking it, and then nobody would've liked it, including me. There's no way to please everyone -- it's impossible and, frankly, the least of my worries. Some folks dug it, and some, like you, didn't... and that's okay. The TMNT is bigger than me, bigger than Sophie, bigger than our great team at IDW, bigger than Nickelodeon... even bigger than Kevin and Peter at this point. We'll all be long gone before TMNT stories ever stop being told, and there will always be new fans and old fans and satisfied fans and disgruntled fans.
But most importantly, there will always be Turtles... forever.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
P.S. And I'm not yet done disappointing some fans. Keep watching...
:tcool:
Ah, hey there. I had no idea, it's been forever since I read it and at the time I wasn't committing the creative names to memory, so no offense, the name wouldn't have rung a bell with me.
Thanks for clarification on the details; as I said, this was off the cuff and from memory of several years ago. I couldn't even tell you which issues I own and thus have read without grabbing my checklist, just that it was "most of the first 12-15 minus one or two". So obviously I was gonna whiff a few. I mean I knew the entire thing didn't "literally" happen or all unfold in Issue #1 but it felt easier than saying "over the first several issues" repeatedly. I figured or hoped that most people would still get the gist of what I meant. But anyway yeah, That's When It Happened, I forgot. :trazz:
At the end of the day, people can say what they want; ultimately, you got paid to write it and everyone else heckles from the cheap seats for free. "Ain't That America." I will say, even though I don't pay much attention (again, no offense, I just don't often recognize people by name until/unless they address me directly), that you come off as pretty gracious and polite in dealing with people, even when they flat out don't have a lot of nice things to say, and that's admirable.
Thanks for the time and the effort. I promise, I'll get around to giving it a proper spin one day. That's always been the plan, generally. In case I haven't been clear, even though there's a lot of things I don't care for in what I've seen, and I can go on about those things quite a bit, that doesn't mean I outright hate it. Pretty sure that's understood, but y'know... some people make a person wonder, sometimes. You know how it is.
Anyways, thanks for the heads up.
hypered1
07-17-2020, 08:09 PM
it's a movie with 12 central rotating characters
I'm curious as to who you are counting to get to 12?
I can only think of 11: the turtles, Splinter, Shredder, April, Casey, Tatsu, Danny and Charles. Or were you just rounding up?
Leo656
07-18-2020, 04:51 AM
Ballpark figure, pal. :lol: No counting at all, just pitched a random number because it was more colorful than saying "a lot of characters", that's all. :)
Pretty funny it was kinda close, though. Although that kinda ruins the hyperbole by being Almost Accurate.
Shinigami
08-03-2020, 09:36 AM
It doesn?t do it for me the same without Sophie?s art. I know she can?t write and draw every issue, but I guess I had gotten spoiled and hopeful she was somehow gonna do it monthly? Nelson Daniel isn?t bad at all, but his style is not my personal taste and reminds me of some of the guest Mirage artists that I did not enjoy for their lack of grit. Although Sophie has removed most of her grit in the turtles too, I am just a fan girl I guess.
Jazzfox
08-10-2020, 06:48 PM
106... I have to say, it was a little jarring moving from 105 to this issue, simply because it does make me suddenly appreciate 105 all the more
It felt very different, a bit closer to earlier issues of the turtles and maybe I've spoiled myself a little on Sophie's 101-105 how the dialogue went and how much went into the art there
Nelson and Ronda's work on art and script aren't bad, but, maybe this one just didn't hit me in the right areas... now, issue 107 HOWEVER? Well, maybe that's the luck in hindsight and being able to come back and comment on these like way later~
As for the issue itself? Well, I'm a sucker for seeing characters pop back up in the Mutant Town folk, and seeing Mrs Gonzalez show up again after issue 1 of the Jennika micro was a very welcome treat
Nelson also does some really nice expression work on the turtles, I do love Lita's 'haunted' look as she describes the story of the Slithery in particular, but there are plenty other expressions to pick from!
Welp, at least now I can jump straight over to 107 with my thoughts there!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.