View Full Version : Has IDW TMNT Lost Its Edge?
PizzaPower1985
08-12-2020, 11:42 AM
Multipart questions here...
I was perusing through my IDW TMNT back-issues and noticed that IDW started from the very beginning as a very street-level (almost Mirage-inspired????) comic book. The book had an edge. As it went on it began introducing various "cartoon" characters and through numerous art changes and story lines, seemed to get away from the edgy aspect.
When did it happen? Was it even edgy at all? Has it maintained its tone?
IF it has to be compared to any of the Mirage offshoots (cartoons, films, Archie etc.) which TMNT incarnation is it closest to? 2K3?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-12-2020, 12:20 PM
Yes, it had an edge. It's used shock value pretty effectively a few times (stuff with Slash, Shredder's death, Donnie getting cracked like a damn walnut). But the TMNT's own actions haven't ever really been a surprise or shocking; just the characters around them. And after a time, I think that grows pretty tiresome.
"Oh, sure, Slash gets to curbstomp an old man in a wheelchair. But none of the Turtles have ever killed even one enemy in over 200 issues? Whatever."
My problems with IDW TMNT are twofold: the Cast, and the Limits.
1) The Limits
It's all too easy to see the lines Nick executives have drawn around the IDW sandbox. These lines can't be crossed, and it's all too obvious now where they are.
The Turtles don't kill. There's not even an attempt to make it ambiguous.
Think back to 4Kids; Leonardo decapitated the Shredder. And yes, that moment was immediately neutered with what followed. But the intent was there; Leo was straight up willing to kill an enemy. And sometimes the fight scenes would be ambiguous. Raphael enters an elevator followed by Foot soldiers; when he walks out, they're all splayed on the ground. Dead or unconscious? Well, there's no blood, but it's a cartoon... of course there's no blood. But they've never talked about "we don't kill." They've TRIED to kill. It's a compromise, but it's easy enough to tolerate.
Whereas "we don't kill" is something we see hammered home OVER and OVER and OVER with IDW TMNT. They all discuss the "Shredder Manifesto", where Mikey is super uncomfortable with the thought of killing Shredder. SHREDDER. The guy who killed THEM in Japan.
And Raphael runs off to kill Arnold Jones, and is told by Splinter, "this is a bad thing to do, Raphael. Will it improve the situation?" And Raph says no. But later events show, UM, YES, this would have been a good thing to do. Hun causes a LOT of fvcking trouble later.
And all the Turtles bail on Splinter because he kills Darius Dun, that guy who straight up promises "I swear to you, some way, some how, I will destroy you, mutant. But not before I force you to watch your precious green monsters die slow, painful, pathetic deaths." And this is presented as a TERRIBLE thing.
So then, let's ask the question we've all asked before. "What's even the fvcking point of the Turtles carrying weapons? Things made to crack skulls and cut throats and stab chests?"
2) And the Cast
For years now, the Turtles have diminished in the IDW series. They don't ever win fights on their own; they're always calling in backup. We're always being treated to Angel and Alopex and Casey. And now we're in Mutant Town, a furry festival for shippers. Oh boy, baby Turtles! And baby weasels! And pig rock girls! And missing children! It's all so fvcking CUTE.
Not to mention that we still haven't seen Null do ANYTHING in 4 years. Or that Hob and Baxter still haven't faced off in... 6 years? I'm guessing here.
To sum my points, I've lost my love of IDW TMNT. It's moving into new territory that seems aimed at bringing in audiences who are fans of Zootopia and want to see as many mutants as possible. The Turtles are barely characters in these last issues. And while "City at War" set up some really interesting new plots, like Mayor Baxter, Shredder training the Turtles, Casey losing his dad who died saving him, Splinter being DEAD, and the Turtles dealing with a new sister... we're just fvcking around in Mutant Town, drawing a bunch of new mutants, squealing over Mona Lisa getting with Donatello, cooing over Alopex and Raphael finally kissing, and worrying about mutant kids.
Which previous incarnation of TMNT would I compare it to? I wouldn't. It's thrown in elements from all the previous TMNT iterations, but now, post #100, it seems to be driving forward into a world where the Turtles are citizens of some mutant community, mutants aren't special, and character introductions and focus seems calculated for maximum PC appeal. And I'm a fvcking LIBERAL, who wants more female characters.
I'm still reading. But I don't enjoy it. And I'm very, very close to walking away for good. My thinking right now is collect up to #100 in the hardbacks. And if the ongoing story hasn't brought me back by the time that last hardback is on my bookshelf, I'm gone for good.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-12-2020, 12:21 PM
Sorry. That's a big damn Wall of Jericho text wall. But I had a lot to get off my chest. :tlol:
AquaParade
08-12-2020, 12:47 PM
I enjoyed reading that. I can't really argue with any of it. I think the on-going series is pretty good for all the restrictions placed on it, but it does grow tiresome, like you put it. We crave that sense of consequence.
I'm enjoying seeing the conclusion to Urban Legends and I'm quite excited about The Last Ronin, though. I have some optimism that The Last Ronin will let the gloves off for a few moments. This is obviously just speculation, but I wouldn't surprised to see the ninja turtle(s) take a life in that book.
PizzaPower1985
08-12-2020, 12:56 PM
Besides the 1-page epilogue, Waltz's City At War did an incredible job of wrapping everything up and closing out the 100 issues. Could Sophie's Mutant Town be considered the beginning of IDW Vol. 2?
CyberCubed
08-12-2020, 01:19 PM
It has edge, maybe not in post issue 100 so far, but everything leading up to it had tons of deaths.
80gmrp
08-12-2020, 02:12 PM
Hmm. Personally, I do have concerns, but the only major one I seem to share is that it’s not so much about the characters we were already familiar with anymore (which includes but is not limited to the turtles).
I’ll take that a step further: there are some classic characters that still haven’t been developed much at all. My now-annoying concerns about Leatherhead aside, I know others had mixed feelings, at best, over Slash overcoming Bishop’s long-lasting mind control, only to die shortly after.
It has edge, maybe not in post issue 100 so far, but everything leading up to it had tons of deaths.
This is true, though I can’t help but notice that some of the deceased are classic, preestablished characters, as said earlier.
Powder
08-12-2020, 03:17 PM
I have never agreed with anyone more than I do right now with Cylons.
The book had some teeth at various points but largely cucked the TMNT themselves & for the last 6 or 7 issues it's felt like a Deviantart/Tumblr wet dream made for the furry shipping community.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-12-2020, 03:32 PM
I have never agreed with anyone more than I do right now with Cylons.
The book had some teeth at various points but largely cucked the TMNT themselves & for the last 6 or 7 issues it's felt like a Deviantart/Tumblr wet dream made for the furry shipping community.
I'm honored. :tsmile:
Sumac
08-12-2020, 03:48 PM
Think back to 4Kids; Leonardo decapitated the Shredder. And yes, that moment was immediately neutered with what followed. But the intent was there; Leo was straight up willing to kill an enemy. And sometimes the fight scenes would be ambiguous. Raphael enters an elevator followed by Foot soldiers; when he walks out, they're all splayed on the ground. Dead or unconscious? Well, there's no blood, but it's a cartoon... of course there's no blood. But they've never talked about "we don't kill." They've TRIED to kill. It's a compromise, but it's easy enough to tolerate.
In season 4 Leo straight up breaks neck of some goon (in an episode about monster who can regenerate himself). It's not shown, but its pretty obvious what happens.
Also, I don't like when Turtles world is oversaturated with mutants, makes TMNT looks less special. And this whole "mutant town" thing is indeed feels like something lifted straight out of generic fanfiction or Deviantart crappy picture, about Mary Sue falling in love with one of the Turtles.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-12-2020, 03:52 PM
In season 4 Leo straight up breaks neck of some goon (in an episode about monster who can regenerate himself). It's not shown, but its pretty obvious what happens.
Also, I don't like when Turtles world is oversaturated with mutants, makes TMNT looks less special. And this whole "mutant town" thing is indeed feels like something lifted straight out of generic fanfiction or Deviantart crappy picture, about Mary Sue falling in love with one of the Turtles.
Oh that's right! I knew there were other examples of legit killing in 4Kids. The episode with the mutant who used to be a servicemen who worked with Bishop... Leo and Casey on that train.
"Dragon's Brew", I think?
Leo656
08-12-2020, 04:01 PM
1) The Limits
It's all too easy to see the lines Nick executives have drawn around the IDW sandbox. These lines can't be crossed, and it's all too obvious now where they are.
The Turtles don't kill. There's not even an attempt to make it ambiguous.
Think back to 4Kids; Leonardo decapitated the Shredder. And yes, that moment was immediately neutered with what followed. But the intent was there; Leo was straight up willing to kill an enemy. And sometimes the fight scenes would be ambiguous. Raphael enters an elevator followed by Foot soldiers; when he walks out, they're all splayed on the ground. Dead or unconscious? Well, there's no blood, but it's a cartoon... of course there's no blood. But they've never talked about "we don't kill." They've TRIED to kill.
It's a compromise, but it's easy enough to tolerate.
Whereas "we don't kill" is something we see hammered home OVER and OVER and OVER with IDW TMNT. They all discuss the "Shredder Manifesto", where Mikey is super uncomfortable with the thought of killing Shredder. SHREDDER. The guy who killed THEM in Japan.
And Raphael runs off to kill Arnold Jones, and is told by Splinter, "this is a bad thing to do, Raphael. Will it improve the situation?" And Raph says no. But later events show, UM, YES, this would have been a good thing to do. Hun causes a LOT of fvcking trouble later.
And all the Turtles bail on Splinter because he kills Darius Dun, that guy who straight up promises "I swear to you, some way, some how, I will destroy you, mutant. But not before I force you to watch your precious green monsters die slow, painful, pathetic deaths." And this is presented as a TERRIBLE thing.
So then, let's ask the question we've all asked before. "What's even the fvcking point of the Turtles carrying weapons? Things made to crack skulls and cut throats and stab chests?"
Such great points, especially regarding 2K3 (which I can relate more deeply to having seen much more of that than IDW). There were quite a few moments in Season 1 where I was like "Huh... so that guy's probably dead" despite it not being overtly displayed. And the Turtles never once seemed overly concerned about whether or not the bad guys met a gruesome fate at their hands. "Business Is Business."
Like, you don't have to go full-blown blood-splatter as it's not necessary, but let's be real: Are they fighting to the death or are they dickin' around? Ninjas who don't kill aren't "ninjas".
It's like how certain writers and filmmakers have been taken to task about whether or not Superman or Batman would/should ever kill, and they've argued quite succinctly that the "Never, No Matter What" rule is simply a thing which was never story-driven, it was an editorial mandate based around selling toys to 5-year olds. The reality should/would be, they aspire to never kill anyone because they believe there's a better way, but if it was the only way to protect innocent people from dying then they'd be absolutely wrong to let those innocents die just because "Good Guys Don't Kill." If it's Zod or Ra's al Ghul, those "rules" go out the window because now we're talking about stopping genocide, and if you can't kill someone, or even just let someone die, "no matter what", not ever in order to prevent genocide just because you're a "Good Guy", then you're not a Good Guy.
Point being, even the purest and most noble of "good guys" shouldn't be afraid of doing the objective Right Thing just because it sets a bad example for the wee ones. I always cringe at editorial handcuffs because it's obvious that the Toy Agenda is in full swing. Like, we KNOW TMNT only exists to sell toys, but does it have to be SO obvious? The examples you point out are especially egregious and make them appear entirely impotent, something they should never be.
Sorry. That's a big damn Wall of Jericho text wall. But I had a lot to get off my chest. :tlol:
"Walls of Jericho", eh....?
https://thumbs.gfycat.com/AnotherBlackandwhiteBorzoi-size_restricted.gif
:lol::lol::lol:
I know you're not gonna get it, CKD, that one wasn't specifically for you. :tgrin:
----------------
In seriousness, though... I'm sure it says something that even as someone who doesn't actively read the IDW books, but moreso reads about them and occasionally skims previews... the vibe I've gotten all along is 100% in lock with what CKD and Powder are saying.
Like, I barely know anything about the book. But when I see certain things, I'm like "Huh, this seems a lot like..." And then come to find out "Yeah, as usual, my gut's telling me the whole story without actually needing to see it in full for myself."
I'm sure it says something, but what that "something" is, I'm not entirely sure.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-12-2020, 04:09 PM
Point being, even the purest and most noble of "good guys" shouldn't be afraid of doing the objective Right Thing just because it sets a bad example for the wee ones. I always cringe at editorial handcuffs because it's obvious that the Toy Agenda is in full swing. Like, we KNOW TMNT only exists to sell toys, but does it have to be SO obvious? The examples you point out are especially egregious and make them appear entirely impotent, something they should never be.
I quoted the Darius Dun threats verbatim; went and dug out my hardback collection to write it down.
Because it's the most cold, calculated threat ever. And all four Turtles are all "WHAT!? HOW COULD YOU KILL HIM, DAD!?"
Dumbasses.
"Walls of Jericho", eh....?
https://thumbs.gfycat.com/AnotherBlackandwhiteBorzoi-size_restricted.gif
:lol::lol::lol:
I know you're not gonna get it, CKD, that one wasn't specifically for you. :tgrin:
Dude, that's Chris Fvcking Jericho and he's awesome. You don't know me; you don't know my life. Crank up that Fozzy!
Leo656
08-12-2020, 04:54 PM
https://media1.tenor.com/images/598ebc44b3d12c845499b7515e4ebdd8/tenor.gif?itemid=14953180
I forgot you like Fozzy, I simply remembered you don't follow wrestling. :lol:
Nice guy. Loved that I used to use "God Pounds His Nails" as my entrance theme! That was a relief.
TigerClaw
08-12-2020, 05:07 PM
I love where the IDW comic is at with the whole Mutant Town thing. I'm into the more fantastical elements.
Leo656
08-12-2020, 05:15 PM
It's moving into new territory that seems aimed at bringing in audiences who are fans of Zootopia and want to see as many mutants as possible. The Turtles are barely characters in these last issues. And while "City at War" set up some really interesting new plots, like Mayor Baxter, Shredder training the Turtles, Casey losing his dad who died saving him, Splinter being DEAD, and the Turtles dealing with a new sister... we're just fvcking around in Mutant Town, drawing a bunch of new mutants, squealing over Mona Lisa getting with Donatello, cooing over Alopex and Raphael finally kissing, and worrying about mutant kids.
...Relevant.
Galactus
08-12-2020, 05:38 PM
I'm not sure IDW had much of an edge to lose. That is not necessarily a knock but these turtles were always much more responsible with their no killing rule and Leo beating himself up because he thought he killed Slash while defending his family.
I think right now Sophie is playing to her strengths as an artist. Clearly she is very skilled at drawing anthropomorphic animal characters and slice of life stories which is what we've gotten since she took over but I'm sure more is coming. I suspect it will read better in trade when you can whole picture in one sitting as opposed to waiting a whole month just to see whether the turtles enjoyed their metal concert.
PizzaPower1985
08-12-2020, 05:46 PM
It's like how certain writers and filmmakers have been taken to task about whether or not Superman or Batman would/should ever kill, and they've argued quite succinctly that the "Never, No Matter What" rule is simply a thing which was never story-driven, it was an editorial mandate based around selling toys to 5-year olds. The reality should/would be, they aspire to never kill anyone because they believe there's a better way, but if it was the only way to protect innocent people from dying then they'd be absolutely wrong to let those innocents die just because "Good Guys Don't Kill." If it's Zod or Ra's al Ghul, those "rules" go out the window because now we're talking about stopping genocide, and if you can't kill someone, or even just let someone die, "no matter what", not ever in order to prevent genocide just because you're a "Good Guy", then you're not a Good Guy.
Point being, even the purest and most noble of "good guys" shouldn't be afraid of doing the objective Right Thing just because it sets a bad example for the wee ones.
YOU NEED TO E-MAIL MARK WAID RIGHT F****** NOW and tell him this $hit! Dude still can't let Man of Steel go.
Leo656
08-12-2020, 05:57 PM
Unless it's "Flash", Mark Waid can take his Super-Friends jammies and go soak his head. He's a 60-something year old man who takes his character and writing sensibilities from bad cartoons he watched when he was 5. Nothing he has to say about anything at all is relevant.
"Kingdom Come" was all about Alex Ross with Waid merely tagging along, and the fact that "The Kingdom" is a pretty weak follow-up more or less proves that conclusively. When not paired with some outstanding art, Waid's writing shines through as merely "adequate" and very often ham-fisted. And legend has it that Ross had more to do with scripting KC than Waid did in the first place. Although "Superman quitting to go pout on his VR Farm and being perfectly willing to let the world go to hell without him, all because he doesn't like killing bad guys" is definitely, definitely some Waid bullsh*t. "I'd rather let MILLIONS of people die through my inaction, than even kill ONE super-villain who deserved it." Some f*cking "hero". :roll: That story really didn't treat my man well at ALL until the second act kicked in.
"Superman: Birthright" was terrible, easily the worst Superman origin story (ignoring anything and everything New 52-related, as any sane person should do).
The very definition of a "manchild". He's literally 60-something-going on-6. Standing up in a crowded movie theater and screaming bloody murder at the screen because your favorite cartoon character killed Space Hitler. And he tells that story like he's proud, as if it doesn't make him a goddamn lunatic. I'd have pelted him with my drink.
I mean, the fact that as a grown man he gushes un-ironically over goddamn SUPER-FRIENDS... not even the "pretty good by 80s cartoon standards", late-series "Super-Powers: Galactic Guardians" rebranding, but the universally-known-and-accepted-to-be-sh*tty SUPER-FRIENDS... tells you absolutely everything you need to know about him. I liked it as a kid, too, but at some point I stopped dropping sh*t in my drawers and gained a sense of taste and perspective, and moved on to better things. Pity that he never has.
I've often wondered how he can be so, so good at Flash... maybe The Best at Flash... and so pitifully brick-stupid and just plain wrong about absolutely everything else.
But yeah, f*ck Mark Waid.
PizzaPower1985
08-12-2020, 06:14 PM
One thing about this series though, edge or lack-thereof, is THE ART! IDW couldn't be bothered or couldn't afford to hire a classical comic book cartoonist in the vein of Jim Aparo, John Byrne etc. Instead every artist on this series is of the sketchy, abstract or "underground" variety. TMNT lacks the polish of a 70's or 80's Marvel book (IT ALWAYS HAS AS IT'S HISTORICALLY UNDERGROUND).
There is a middle ground though, right? I mean there has to be an underground polished artist in the vein of Peter Laird or hell, we could even settle for a Carl Barks type funny animal artist... but no! IDW TMNT always features artists that ape the 2012 show, try to do "THEIR VERSION" of Mirage or just draw cutesy cuddly teddy bear turtles.
WHY DID THAT HAPPEN? Why did KEN GARING come on board at issue 51 and NOT GET BRIEFCASES OF MONEY THROWN AT HIM? HIS TURTLES LOOKED LIKE MIRAGE. HIS TURTLES HAD AN EDGE. HIS TURTLES MADE ME THINK OF 1990 MOVIE TMNT AGAIN!
Why can TMNT NEVER be drawn like a 1980s MARVEL OR DC BOOK? Do those artists no longer exist? Have they all died? Somebody get Walt Simonson on the telephone.
ChosenOne
08-12-2020, 06:54 PM
Just a reminder that, according to the Bible, the Wall of Jericho ultimately didn't hold up. We'll see how it goes.
CyberCubed
08-12-2020, 08:55 PM
Tbh I'm also not too keen on both Shredder and Krang being alive again either. They were both pretty much killed off, and I know they're the main villains and all, but seeing them both back alive again after we thought their stories were over is kinda weird. I'm sure there will be some big payoff planned to justify it in the future, but it's not like this is a cartoon show that needs to keep Shredder/Krang around or else kids will lose interest. It's a comic that doesn't need to keep the two villains around.
As I said, I'm sure they already have good character arcs planned out to justify Shredder and Krang both being back, but of course we can't see the future right now, so as it is at the current time, I'm a little iffy on the idea.
TigerClaw
08-12-2020, 08:58 PM
Tbh I'm also not too keen on both Shredder and Krang being alive again either. They were both pretty much killed off, and I know they're the main villains and all, but seeing them both back alive again after we thought their stories were over is kinda weird. I'm sure there will be some big payoff planned to justify it in the future, but it's not like this is a cartoon show that needs to keep Shredder/Krang around or else kids will lose interest. It's a comic that doesn't need to keep the two villains around.
As I said, I'm sure they already have good character arcs planned out to justify Shredder and Krang both being back, but of course we can't see the future right now, so as it is at the current time, I'm a little iffy on the idea.
If there is one thing you learn about comics. Is that villains never really die in the comics. They always find ways to come back.
Andrew NDB
08-12-2020, 09:22 PM
I made it about 25 issues in before I had to throw the towel in. I felt a bit misled, and that things were becoming exactly how I'd feared they might become after the rainbow bandannas came on. The things that seem to interest TPTB creatively the most are almost precisely the things that I do not like the most in all the children's spinoff TMNT universes.
Also, yes. No interest in ninja Turtles that can't ninja (i.e., kill). For a while I thought IDW was building up to having the Turtles kill, or only do so rarely, but it became pretty clear pretty quick that it was a Nickelodeon moratorium. No bueno.
ChosenOne
08-12-2020, 11:11 PM
Tbh I'm also not too keen on both Shredder and Krang being alive again either. They were both pretty much killed off, and I know they're the main villains and all, but seeing them both back alive again after we thought their stories were over is kinda weird. I'm sure there will be some big payoff planned to justify it in the future, but it's not like this is a cartoon show that needs to keep Shredder/Krang around or else kids will lose interest. It's a comic that doesn't need to keep the two villains around.
As I said, I'm sure they already have good character arcs planned out to justify Shredder and Krang both being back, but of course we can't see the future right now, so as it is at the current time, I'm a little iffy on the idea.
Frankly, the notion of Saki acting as a mentor to the Turtles and what little we've already seen of him in that role more than justifies his return to life and is one of the most exciting things ever done with the character in the history of the franchise. I'm not as keen on Krang being back, though, especially seeing as how - as a Leatherhead fan - things already started off on the wrong foot. I wasn't a fan of Slash basically being gone from the comic for dozens of issues only to die the moment he was restored to his former self, and I really, REALLY don't want to see history repeated with Leatherhead.
TomWaltz
08-13-2020, 01:54 AM
Not sure about my edge, but I did lose one of my favorite baseball caps recently, and that really bummed me out. Still does.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
Andrew NDB
08-13-2020, 03:48 AM
I don't think "did it lose its edge?" is really the right thing to even ask, personally. I think it's exactly the comic its always tried to be, and that's fine. It's just not for everybody.
My personal wish was that it was somewhere between Mirage and Archie, with a smattering of Archie elements but still holding true to the Mirage "spirit"... while maintaining the teeth. I understand (well, in retrospect) that wasn't possible, by no fault of anyone at IDW.
Sharman
08-13-2020, 06:09 AM
There have been some excellent points made in this thread.
I think, ultimately, that I agree that IDW is balancing its tone (or 'edge') rather well especially given the Nickelodeon restraints (still puzzles me why they would buy an IP knowing its adult content and then proceed to file down its teeth until it can barely chew).
Yes, since #100 we've been going through a quiet period, but there's nowt wrong with that. Every story has to have light and shade to make it interesting - and, ultimately, it makes the contrast all the more glorious. At least, that's what I hope is happening.
It is understandable that people feel that the Turtles themselves seem to have taken a back seat and I hope that soon we see them come to the fore again. The IDW universe has become populated by a vast number of characters and I like to think that they haven't forgotten that its the core group that people really want to see.
Shark_Blade
08-13-2020, 07:11 AM
One thing about this series though, edge or lack-thereof, is THE ART! IDW couldn't be bothered or couldn't afford to hire a classical comic book cartoonist in the vein of Jim Aparo, John Byrne etc. Instead every artist on this series is of the sketchy, abstract or "underground" variety. TMNT lacks the polish of a 70's or 80's Marvel book (IT ALWAYS HAS AS IT'S HISTORICALLY UNDERGROUND).
There is a middle ground though, right? I mean there has to be an underground polished artist in the vein of Peter Laird or hell, we could even settle for a Carl Barks type funny animal artist... but no! IDW TMNT always features artists that ape the 2012 show, try to do "THEIR VERSION" of Mirage or just draw cutesy cuddly teddy bear turtles.
WHY DID THAT HAPPEN? Why did KEN GARING come on board at issue 51 and NOT GET BRIEFCASES OF MONEY THROWN AT HIM? HIS TURTLES LOOKED LIKE MIRAGE. HIS TURTLES HAD AN EDGE. HIS TURTLES MADE ME THINK OF 1990 MOVIE TMNT AGAIN!
Why can TMNT NEVER be drawn like a 1980s MARVEL OR DC BOOK? Do those artists no longer exist? Have they all died? Somebody get Walt Simonson on the telephone.
Because those styles are the past? It?s good in small doses instead of everything has to be that kind of style. It?s nice that they even bring him and the others back but you gotta let new/current artists to shine too. They are the present and future.
I personally love Sophie Campbell?s art. She knows how to work soft emotional scenes especially the way she drew caring/empathetic eyes like when Leo comforting Mikey when he broke down(#103) and when Donnie chatted with Raph in the back alley (#104) . And when it comes to action scenes she delivered too.
As for the ?loosing the edge? thing, I only started feeling that starting #106 & #107. Seems a bit too domesticated fluff and light on the story part. Hope theyll change the tide soon, I want more heavy action and impactful story. I love the downtime they had, they deserved it.
Jazzfox
08-17-2020, 03:55 PM
Tough question for me to think on this one, I've made it plenty public about my current enjoyment, but it does feel like the series is ready to pick up pace once more
And I think that's just as likely a statement as any on the subject, that the comic does lull and rise, it does sound like we've hit a similar pace that folks have mentioned is like 50 issues back after the comic hit the five-oh milestone =o
As far as the limits on the turtles and not killing... I get folks frustration over the turtles being ninjas and their aversion to killing, but, at the same time I just think about Batman and his 'One Rule' that's so well known on not killing and I don't know, I don't think the limitation has to be as big an issue. Conversely, I think if you give a character a limitation that it's how they DEAL with that limitation that makes them more interesting overall =O
Will agree though that the turtles being so aversely distanced from Splinter when he slew an opposing force that it could have been handled way better, one reason mayhap that I'm happy we're past that chapter of the turtles
I only wish in the changeover of these chapters that Nick's 2k12 Turtles hadn't been as daring to kill off Splinter there, it did detract a little from the impact his big sacrifice took in issue 100 herei n the comics =x
It'll always be a struggle about pushing the envelope I guess, looking to keep the comic fresh and relevant to try and attract new eyes while also trying to stay familiar enough not to send folks astray
I don't think we've hit Poochy levels yet though, lol, I'll just worry if Venus ever shows up
Andrew NDB
08-17-2020, 07:37 PM
As far as the limits on the turtles and not killing... I get folks frustration over the turtles being ninjas and their aversion to killing, but, at the same time I just think about Batman and his 'One Rule' that's so well known on not killing
Dumb. He's not a ninja, and not in a book called "30-SOMETHING BILLIONAIRE NINJA BAT-MAN" or anything.
Leo656
08-18-2020, 12:42 AM
Yeah, man. Restrictions like that just scream, "THIS IS A COMIC FOR LITTLE KIDS! PLEASE DON'T BE AFRAID TO BUY OUR TOYS!" If it was happening in a story that wasn't owned by a toy company they'd be killing bad guys without a second thought. What in-story reason would the Turtles ever have for the "role model" nonsense? Zero. It's SIMPLY about Nick and their toy sales. Those kinds of creative handcuffs are nonsensical and irritating.
Batman's also a bad example because he's either killed or let lots of people die, and not just in 1939 as people claim. He generally tries not to get anyone killed but when bad guys get killed he mostly just shrugs it off. Which is why it's just kinda chuckle-worthy whenever it comes up. Even in the Nolan movies, where the "One Rule" quote famously comes from, he killed lots and lots of people. It's kind of a running gag at this point. "Wishful Thinking" at best, but he's terrible at the follow-through.
But yeah, the "Heroes Don't Kill" thing is kiddie horsesh*t. Tell it to anyone who came back from Iraq, see how far it gets you. I hate it. I wouldn't wanna see the Turtles go all "Leatherface" but the fact that they even have a "rule" about killing is awful. It's nonsense!
Andrew NDB
08-18-2020, 02:15 AM
Yeah, man. Restrictions like that just scream, "THIS IS A COMIC FOR LITTLE KIDS! PLEASE DON'T BE AFRAID TO BUY OUR TOYS!"
Precisely. But we can't get mad at IDW, as their hands have been tied.
I wouldn't wanna see the Turtles go all "Leatherface" but the fact that they even have a "rule" about killing is awful. It's nonsense!
Asinine. I could maybe see a semi-retired samurai making such a rule for himself (probably in their later years after feeling bad about killing a whole lot of people), but a ninja? Apocryphal. That's their whole thing.
Powder
08-18-2020, 09:57 AM
Wasn't that "rule" a decision by Tom, like the colored bandanas?
AquaParade
08-18-2020, 11:31 AM
Great post, Leo. Although I'm sure that not every hero that comes back from Iraq would share the sentiment that heroes kill. It's an interesting conversation at the least.
I'd also say that sometimes it's okay for us to present our heroes as non-killers in the face of death. It can be aspirational, powerful, poetic. It's not necessarily realistic but neither is Batman's physical prowess. Sometimes the best the character can be is something aspirational, even if it's not quite obtainable.
Though again, I still agree with most of your post. It's certainly not the route you want to take if you're going for realism and/or dealing with ninja as your protagonists.
Like Andrew mentioned, and I alluded to earlier, there are ways to make it work even with a ninja or samurai, but in my mind, that would feel most natural after a lifetime of hard lessons and not at the expense of your youth or loved ones who may get caught in the crossfire if these characters won't step up and do what is, unfortunately, necessary in these situations they find themselves in.
My two cents, anyway.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-18-2020, 11:42 AM
When the Turtles killed in Mirage, it never felt gratuitous. And when some of them later stopped or grew disillusioned with it, it felt EARNED. It felt like it mattered to who they were, and was a natural development of every life they'd taken and every fight they'd survived.
Leo getting angry at Raph for killing guards in the beginning of Volume 3, and Don throwing away the gun in disgust after saving Karai from the Foot Elite in "City at War"...
Whenever "we don't kill" comes up in IDW, it just feels so incredibly trite. Because TMNT is for kiddies. :trolleye:
Leo656
08-18-2020, 12:13 PM
I guess the main thing to me with these kinds of stories is... are we REALLY dealing with matters of life-and-death consequence? Are the bad guys REALLY trying to eradicate our heroes, and in turn are our heroes REALLY fighting for their lives?
If so, then once in a while someone's gonna have to get mowed down. Otherwise they're all just playing a really "extreme" game of Tag. And if they're all just kinda screwing around, they don't need to be carrying deadly weapons around in the first place.
I agree that with some characters there might be more of an aspirational/inspirational take on it, but I generally can't see the Turtles being interested in too much of that. Like in their own universes, characters like Superman, Spider-Man and even Batman do try and lead by example to various degrees, but I don't really see the Turtles being that way very much. At least when they're young and in the heat of everything. I can definitely see some of the guilt and "What was it all for?" creep in later on in life, though, which would be rather interesting to see dealt with if the "official" canon in any TMNT universe was ever allowed to develop past Year Three or whatever.
It just makes the stories more engaging for me when you REALLY don't know what to expect or what's coming next. If someone tells you either directly or otherwise, "The protagonists of this story don't kill", then right there is one thing you already know not to expect, there's already a "fence" around certain parts of the story. "Well, we know it might creep Over Here, but we also know that it won't EVER go Over There...."
Like, part of why I was so impacted as a kid when Superman killed Zod in the comics was because "Wait... he can't... he can't DO that, can he...? That kinda thing doesn't happen..." Except it did happen, and that was a really cool feeling to have as a young reader, just knowing that there really were no "rules" to the stories I was reading, merely Guidelines.
AquaParade
08-18-2020, 01:24 PM
Yeah, seems most of us in the conversation generally agree on that point. And the lethal weapons actively make things worse. Were it me writing IDW, the turtles would be "losing" their weapons nearly every issue just to take away the dissonance that "sword-slapping" brings to a ninja book. Not an ideal solution.
Dejablue
08-18-2020, 06:27 PM
As of now I dont see a huge problem. I see it as a down shift or a lull before the next big kaboom. I've always argued that IDW is always full throttle and the turtles can barely take a bathroom break before the next big plot point came hurtling towards them.
I can see the complaints as reasonable to an extent but Splinters death is a good enough point for the turtles to finally take a fu*cking break. So for now, while I'd have handled Mutant town differently, I'm okay with it. I believe all of this is a set up to the next big event.
hypered1
08-18-2020, 07:14 PM
As of now I dont see a huge problem. I see it as a down shift or a lull before the next big kaboom. I've always argued that IDW is always full throttle and the turtles can barely take a bathroom break before the next big plot point came hurtling towards them.
I can see the complaints as reasonable to an extent but Splinters death is a good enough point for the turtles to finally take a fu*cking break. So for now, while I'd have handled Mutant town differently, I'm okay with it. I believe all of this is a set up to the next big event.
Agreed. As I've mentioned elsewhere it's just a breather before the series 10th anniversary next year.
ChosenOne
08-18-2020, 07:36 PM
Agreed. As I've mentioned elsewhere it's just a breather before the series 10th anniversary next year.
I hope IDW does something interesting with the covers to celebrate, and I don't mean just an avalanche of variants as per usual. I missed the connecting covers from Vengeance in the run-up to #100, those made the whole thing feel much more epic.
Mutant Ninja Anole
08-18-2020, 10:40 PM
Guys I’m sorry but I can’t take people using the word “edgey” unironically in 2020 seriously.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-18-2020, 10:43 PM
Guys I?m sorry but I can?t take people using the word ?edgey? unironically in 2020 seriously.
Well, you shouldn't. People who say "edgey" aren't spelling it properly. Why take them seriously?
Bad spelling just isn't edgy. It's lame.
And the OXFORD COMMA SHALL NEVER DIE. NOT AS LONG AS EVEN ONE OF US REMEMBERS. NAY, A REMNANT SHALL RISE, USHERING FORTH A NEW AGE OF GRAMMATICAL GLORY!
Leo656
08-18-2020, 10:50 PM
Well, you shouldn't. People who say "edgey" aren't spelling it properly. Why take them seriously?
Bad spelling just isn't edgy. It's lame.
And the OXFORD COMMA SHALL NEVER DIE. NOT AS LONG AS EVEN ONE OF US REMEMBERS. NAY, A REMNANT SHALL RISE, USHERING FORTH A NEW AGE OF GRAMMATICAL GLORY!
:lol::lol::lol: You love that sh*t.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-18-2020, 11:14 PM
:lol::lol::lol: You love that sh*t.
Some people stroke it to rock hard reptile titties, some people touch themselves to proper grammar.
Judge not, lest ye be judged, an' all that.
rs_jr
08-19-2020, 01:10 AM
I gave it the my best when it came out and bough every issues but had to drop it after utrom empire because i just couldn't get into it.
This year i tried again and bough all the 10 hardcover collection and couldn't make it through the fourth one:(
I wish they would just launch mirage issues like they do with G I joe RAH and give us the 18 issues a year from the mirage TMNT
Egon1982
08-19-2020, 06:51 AM
Yes, it did lost some steam.
daggio
08-21-2020, 09:19 AM
Do I believe its lost steam? Seemingly yes, BUT I think it's too early since 100 to declare that IDWs TMNT has lost steam forever. I think, hopefully, that these arcs since 100 will lead to major arcs and stories later. The potential, at least to me, is there. So, I'm hoping that, despite the book kinda slowing down in my view, that things will pick up since the tools are there.
Now, with that said, personally I miss the way Waltz scripted the dialogue. I know some had issues with what he did, but I liked it. I don't care for this "apologizing for my actions" kinda stuff or "getting in touch with my feelings" kinda stuff that's been happening since 101. Those aren't extremely common, but everytime they've happened, I cringe thinking that this isn't what I liked from before.
CyberCubed
08-21-2020, 09:34 AM
The only problem to me is the "putting on the shelf" of stories like the Utrom/Triceraton predicament for so long. Especially with Ch'rell awake and he hasn't really done anything.
I also think Null's stuff would have been better off resolved in mini-series/specials or not really introduced since the main ongoing never has time to include her.
I'm well aware The Patheon will be around the entire series and Rat King is essentially the main villain of all of IDW now.
daggio
08-21-2020, 10:11 AM
The only problem to me is the "putting on the shelf" of stories like the Utrom/Triceraton predicament for so long. Especially with Ch'rell awake and he hasn't really done anything.
I also think Null's stuff would have been better off resolved in mini-series/specials or not really introduced since the main ongoing never has time to include her.
I completely agree. The Burnow Island stuff, especially, is problematic in that it almost defies logic that nothing has eminated from that whole plot point with 6+ months since Battle Lines (from an in-story chronological standpoint). Its almost hard to believe that Ch'rell hasn't made any major moves off the island since.
ChosenOne
08-21-2020, 10:22 AM
I completely agree. The Burnow Island stuff, especially, is problematic in that it almost defies logic that nothing has eminated from that whole plot point with 6+ months since Battle Lines (from an in-story chronological standpoint). Its almost hard to believe that Ch'rell hasn't made any major moves off the island since.
I still think Ch'rell will turn out to be a very different character than what we were expecting. He won't just be Krang 2.0, aka 2 Krang 2 Furious. There would be no point in bringing him in for that, especially not when we have the original back from the dead... He already seemed much different than what the other Utroms described him as during Battle Lines.
Sophie Campbell
08-21-2020, 12:19 PM
The Utroms and Triceratons made friends with each other and are living happily and carefree together on Burnow Island. :tgrin:
daggio
08-21-2020, 12:51 PM
The Utroms and Triceratons made friends with each other and are living happily and carefree together on Burnow Island. :tgrin:
Until Krang shows up :D
ChosenOne
08-21-2020, 12:58 PM
The Utroms and Triceratons made friends with each other and are living happily and carefree together on Burnow Island. :tgrin:
They've... They've been eating the corpses of the fallen EPF soldiers, haven't they? :lol:
neatoman
08-21-2020, 02:07 PM
The Utroms and Triceratons made friends with each other and are living happily and carefree together on Burnow Island. :tgrin:
Yes, I'm sure a violent mass murderer like Ch'rell is happily having a picnic with a group of Triceratons on the barren ground right now...
King Kahn
08-21-2020, 10:23 PM
Has TMNT lost its edge?
No. Just ton of crying fan boys on here. From the looks of it anyway.
marcelangelo
08-22-2020, 05:22 AM
I gave it the my best when it came out and bough every issues but had to drop it after utrom empire because i just couldn't get into it.
This year i tried again and bough all the 10 hardcover collection and couldn't make it through the fourth one:(
I wish they would just launch mirage issues like they do with G I joe RAH and give us the 18 issues a year from the mirage TMNT
I hear ya.
AquaParade
08-22-2020, 08:45 AM
Has TMNT lost its edge?
No. Just ton of crying fan boys on here. From the looks of it anyway.
No, it's actually pretty mellow in here. Are you just venting or something? Yours is the most inflammatory post here.
rs_jr
08-23-2020, 09:05 PM
do you guys think IDW will end this current TMNT version and relaunch a new one like they did with transformers?
TigerClaw
08-23-2020, 09:13 PM
do you guys think IDW will end this current TMNT version and relaunch a new one like they did with transformers?
it doubt it I want them to continue doing it. I would like to see these characters grow into adults.
80gmrp
08-23-2020, 09:40 PM
it doubt it I want them to continue doing it. I would like to see these characters grow into adults.
As upset as I have been with a certain character’s portrayal for many of the issues, among other lesser gripes, I do agree with TigerClaw about one thing, other than the idea of adult turtles: it’s highly unlikely they will be rebooted any time soon. The only way I can picture the comics being rebooted is if the franchise changes publishers yet again, and even then, it’s hard to say if the story would be completely rewritten from scratch, especially as I don’t deny how much time was put into this iteration.
Shark_Blade
08-23-2020, 10:04 PM
do you guys think IDW will end this current TMNT version and relaunch a new one like they did with transformers?
Splinter literally just died in #100 and we?re just at #107 so I don?t think they?d hit the reboot button anytime soon.
It?s pretty edgy for them to live without a parent figure. See how they?re coping and struggling to fit back as a family unit.
What’s with this forum changing apostrophe to question mark???
Andrew NDB
09-03-2020, 08:34 PM
What?s with this forum changing apostrophe to question mark???
It's probably whatever software you're using to post to the board. Are you on a phone? Maybe it updated and now it's trying to use the fancy apostrophes instead of the standard ones, but the forum software (which is very old now) doesn't recognize it.
Leo656
09-03-2020, 08:41 PM
I noticed that it only happened to me one time so far, and I was indeed posting on my phone. So that almost certainly is a factor.
909 Turtle Fan
09-04-2020, 09:57 AM
I like turtles.
Not too interested in all the extra mutants. Especially the cutie baby girl ones.
Read every issue (only comic book I read actually. I?m a Star Wars novella guy) but kinda tuned out after Sally cracked Hob in the face and he literally walked away from her and the other girls with his tail between his legs.
Also don?t care for Jennika acting the way she does with the turtles as they?re supposed to be grieving. She should be making the pizza every night since they saved her life and now she gets all these special covers and a 2nd mini. Lol jk!
I get that it?s a down time and they?re supposed to be setting up another big story, but with that being said, yes it has lost a bit of steam for me.
Guess I?m interested in good guy shredder and LeatherKrang?
Wingnut II
09-12-2020, 02:09 AM
Krangerhead!
PizzaPower1985
11-04-2020, 07:55 AM
When the Turtles killed in Mirage, it never felt gratuitous. And when some of them later stopped or grew disillusioned with it, it felt EARNED. It felt like it mattered to who they were, and was a natural development of every life they'd taken and every fight they'd survived.
Leo getting angry at Raph for killing guards in the beginning of Volume 3, and Don throwing away the gun in disgust after saving Karai from the Foot Elite in "City at War"...
Whenever "we don't kill" comes up in IDW, it just feels so incredibly trite. Because TMNT is for kiddies. :trolleye:
that is probably the best Mirage/IDW killing comparison and analysis I have ever seen. Mirage treated the issue seriously. IDW is forced to dance around the issue and then deny the killing because, well your last sentence says it all.
AquaParade
11-04-2020, 08:03 AM
Yeah, I'd definitely have to agree there too. The whole thing becomes egregious when the turtles have to fight for, not only their lives, but the lives of those they care about, but aren't willing to kill.
I'm sorry, but if someone is attempting to murder you or a loved one, and you *slap* them with a sword instead of decisively taking them out...time and time again, then the immersion is completely shattered.
And don't put that onus on the readers. We aren't bloodthirsty.
But if you're going to play with swords, don't play around.
PizzaPower1985
11-04-2020, 08:10 AM
Yeah, I'd definitely have to agree there too. The whole thing becomes egregious when the turtles have to fight for, not only their lives, but the lives of those they care about, but aren't willing to kill.
I'm sorry, but if someone is attempting to murder you or a loved one, and you *slap* them with a sword instead of decisively taking them out...time and time again, then the immersion is completely shattered.
Yup. With IDW I had the advantage of reading the trades, 100 issues and minis in arcs released over a period of about 9 years... read them as they came out AND... as a result thee glaring no-kill rule was kind of not noticed as much because I was focused more on the current story... but it still doesnt make any sense for ninjas to have a code that would be better suited to an old, retired Samurai.
CyberCubed
11-04-2020, 10:28 AM
Hopefully by issue 120 we should see the "edge" come back.
PizzaPower1985
11-04-2020, 10:58 AM
Hopefully by issue 120 we should see the "edge" come back.
I think, given what little Sophie has shared about her favorite flavour of TMNT and her preferences/favorite stories, it is interesting that some feel it has lost its edge post 100. With Sophie doing the writing chores immediately after #100, you might think the story would have gone edgier, no?????
Sophie Campbell
11-04-2020, 01:19 PM
I don't agree with you guys about much, but we're on the same page with the killing thing. :tlol: It's very frustrating, not because I'm bloodthirsty (although I am) and want random ultraviolence in TMNT (I do), but because it takes some of the natural-ness out of the concept and can lead to narrative awkwardness.
I'm cool with non-killing Turtles but I feel like it needs to be baked into the overall concept better. Ninjas don't HAVE to kill, they still have the stealth technique angle and espionage and spying, that stuff is awesome and fun even without the assassination part. I actually tried to accommodate this in-universe by having Raph and Leo trade in their weapons for tonfa and bokken, respectively, but it fell through (you can even see Leo with a bokken on the #103 cover). Like might as well go all-in with it and have that be part of the characters' mission statement like how Batman does it, right?
But eh what can you do, that's the nature of licensed comics, you gotta play within certain boundaries. BUT that doesn't automatically mean the material is bad or compromised, it can still be its own thing and regardless of the restrictions I'm still having a blast doing TMNT. I get to do like 98% of what I want and that ain't bad, haha.
As for the "edge" thing, I feel like that doesn't really mean anything. If we're talking about edginess as in grittiness or whatever, yeah I guess IDW has lost that, but in terms of the regular definition of edginess being like "being at the forefront/experimental/etc." then I think IDW TMNT sort of is, I'm definitely trying a lot of stuff that's new to TMNT and stuff that's connecting with a lot of new younger female readers. That's pretty fresh, for better or worse.
I guess for the "edge" you guys are talking about, though, I don't think IDW TMNT ever had it. That's not a judgment call, it just is what it is, TMNT hasn't had that kind of Mirage-style grit since volume 2. Even by volume 4 I feel like it had lost it, or rather moved on to something else (which was fine because I love volume 4!!!). Then TMNT going to Viacom was definitely the nail in the edgy coffin, future TMNT incarnations will probably never have that again. But I think that's okay, it can be something else that has its own value on its own terms.
Diorm
11-04-2020, 02:10 PM
I don't agree with you guys about much, but we're on the same page with the killing thing. :tlol: It's very frustrating, not because I'm bloodthirsty (although I am) and want random ultraviolence in TMNT (I do), but because it takes some of the natural-ness out of the concept and can lead to narrative awkwardness.
I'm cool with non-killing Turtles but I feel like it needs to be baked into the overall concept better. Ninjas don't HAVE to kill, they still have the stealth technique angle and espionage and spying, that stuff is awesome and fun even without the assassination part. I actually tried to accommodate this in-universe by having Raph and Leo trade in their weapons for tonfa and bokken, respectively, but it fell through (you can even see Leo with a bokken on the #103 cover). Like might as well go all-in with it and have that be part of the characters' mission statement like how Batman does it, right?
But eh what can you do, that's the nature of licensed comics, you gotta play within certain boundaries. BUT that doesn't automatically mean the material is bad or compromised, it can still be its own thing and regardless of the restrictions I'm still having a blast doing TMNT. I get to do like 98% of what I want and that ain't bad, haha.
As for the "edge" thing, I feel like that doesn't really mean anything. If we're talking about edginess as in grittiness or whatever, yeah I guess IDW has lost that, but in terms of the regular definition of edginess being like "being at the forefront/experimental/etc." then I think IDW TMNT sort of is, I'm definitely trying a lot of stuff that's new to TMNT and stuff that's connecting with a lot of new younger female readers. That's pretty fresh, for better or worse.
I guess for the "edge" you guys are talking about, though, I don't think IDW TMNT ever had it. That's not a judgment call, it just is what it is, TMNT hasn't had that kind of Mirage-style grit since volume 2. Even by volume 4 I feel like it had lost it, or rather moved on to something else (which was fine because I love volume 4!!!). Then TMNT going to Viacom was definitely the nail in the edgy coffin, future TMNT incarnations will probably never have that again. But I think that's okay, it can be something else that has its own value on its own terms.
Well that's kinda not true since a lot of people seems to like what as been done with the "edge" part of the Last Ronin. So it CAN be done.
And I don't know what the others are talking about when they say "IDW lost it's edge". True it was never as edgy as the Mirage Volume 1 but it fell in the teen romance way too much (The new younger female readers thing I guess).
TMNT never really had complex plot neither, but IDW kinda had something with how it delivered plotwist after plotwist.
I'm not really good at putting my thoughs in words like others (language barrier and all that) but it sure lost something I can't really tell what.
And hey, no hard feelings, just trying to give some feedback. The comic is not BAD in any way, just missing something that was there before. Not the "edge".
(By the way, did you ever try to sneak something the publisher wouldn't want? Or is it really supervised?)
AquaParade
11-04-2020, 03:07 PM
Yeah, I was speaking of the series as a whole, which while I do appreciate immensely for the care and reverence put in, can never manage to hold my attention because of narrative dissonance like this, among a few other personal nitpicks. The resurrection angle is very cool though.
I actually find Sophie's story to be more captivating than the ongoing typically is. Different strokes, obviously.
And overall, I think IDW has done well with TMNT. They got Kevin involved again, reprinted a ton of rare material, brought in new fans with the ongoing, and The Last Ronin is off to a great start.
Andrew NDB
11-04-2020, 03:12 PM
I don't agree with you guys about much, but we're on the same page with the killing thing. :tlol: It's very frustrating, not because I'm bloodthirsty (although I am) and want random ultraviolence in TMNT (I do), but because it takes some of the natural-ness out of the concept and can lead to narrative awkwardness.
I'm cool with non-killing Turtles but I feel like it needs to be baked into the overall concept better. Ninjas don't HAVE to kill, they still have the stealth technique angle and espionage and spying, that stuff is awesome and fun even without the assassination part. I actually tried to accommodate this in-universe by having Raph and Leo trade in their weapons for tonfa and bokken, respectively, but it fell through (you can even see Leo with a bokken on the #103 cover). Like might as well go all-in with it and have that be part of the characters' mission statement like how Batman does it, right?
But eh what can you do, that's the nature of licensed comics, you gotta play within certain boundaries. BUT that doesn't automatically mean the material is bad or compromised, it can still be its own thing and regardless of the restrictions I'm still having a blast doing TMNT. I get to do like 98% of what I want and that ain't bad, haha.
As for the "edge" thing, I feel like that doesn't really mean anything. If we're talking about edginess as in grittiness or whatever, yeah I guess IDW has lost that, but in terms of the regular definition of edginess being like "being at the forefront/experimental/etc." then I think IDW TMNT sort of is, I'm definitely trying a lot of stuff that's new to TMNT and stuff that's connecting with a lot of new younger female readers. That's pretty fresh, for better or worse.
I guess for the "edge" you guys are talking about, though, I don't think IDW TMNT ever had it. That's not a judgment call, it just is what it is, TMNT hasn't had that kind of Mirage-style grit since volume 2. Even by volume 4 I feel like it had lost it, or rather moved on to something else (which was fine because I love volume 4!!!). Then TMNT going to Viacom was definitely the nail in the edgy coffin, future TMNT incarnations will probably never have that again. But I think that's okay, it can be something else that has its own value on its own terms.
That's a pretty fair post.
Though where does Nick draw the line, really? "The TMNT Shall Not Kill," OK, I get it, that's been clear since IDW TMNT began. Though can you guys have, like, at least Leonardo slice someone's tendon, disabling them? Raphael pinning someone's hand to the wall by ramming a sai into the palm, maybe? I feel like the answer even to things like that is "No," so it's not even as simple as just "The TMNT Shall Not Kill."
They got Kevin involved again
Well, Kevin got Kevin involved again. He was actively campaigning to get involved in things, wherever the deal ended up comic-wise post-2009 sale. I know because I helped.
AquaParade
11-04-2020, 03:39 PM
Sure, but IDW still deserves some credit for welcoming him into the fold and the fact that he stuck around means they probably treat him right.
Zog The Magnificent
11-04-2020, 04:15 PM
I don't even fully understand the no-killing rule in the comic, considering that in the actual Nickelodeon show, they totally kill. Leonardo literally beheads the Shredder. Twice. I don't think they necessarily need to kill (Batman's gotten a lot of milage out of that), but I don't get why it seems to be a hard and fast rule in the version that has less restrictions and that less people are going to see.
Groovy
11-05-2020, 03:43 AM
Interesting read, good to see people's takes on the TMNT of it all. And cool to see two writers of the comic stop by here.
I'll say, aside from the killing topic, I do love the freewheeling but atmospheric and somehow believable "lived in" vibe of the Mirage stuff. For me that's tough to top. And for art I love the Eastman/Laird style stuff best, or Archie etc. Their heads just look a little small in the IDW styles. :trazz: But I can certainly enjoy the visual storytelling of the different artists as well.
I'm way behind and haven't read the current stuff yet, so just saying, a cool read here.
bjaxx87
11-05-2020, 04:31 AM
I don't agree with you guys about much, but we're on the same page with the killing thing. :tlol: It's very frustrating, not because I'm bloodthirsty (although I am) and want random ultraviolence in TMNT (I do), but because it takes some of the natural-ness out of the concept and can lead to narrative awkwardness.
I'm cool with non-killing Turtles but I feel like it needs to be baked into the overall concept better. Ninjas don't HAVE to kill, they still have the stealth technique angle and espionage and spying, that stuff is awesome and fun even without the assassination part. I actually tried to accommodate this in-universe by having Raph and Leo trade in their weapons for tonfa and bokken, respectively, but it fell through (you can even see Leo with a bokken on the #103 cover). Like might as well go all-in with it and have that be part of the characters' mission statement like how Batman does it, right?
I still thank you for probably the only Turtle kills in IDW history (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=938403&postcount=25). :D
About the change of pace in the ongoing: I actually got a little tired of Waltz' run to be honest and I sometimes wondered why I was still reading. Can't even put my finger on what bothered me the most but it simply bored me and didn't have me intrigued. I know that my favorite IDW series was TMNT Universe since it dared to experiment more and touched other genres. For that very reason the current storyline actually feels fresher and more interesting to me. I like those slice of life issues compared to the the action-oriented arcs before (one of my favorite TMNT comics was Tales of the TMNT V2 #55) and noticed that I suddenly regained interest in what happens next in the series. (I'll agree that some of those blooming romances feel a little staged, but I guess to an extent it suits the idea of an isolated and rising mutant society).
MikeandRaph87
11-05-2020, 08:55 AM
I believe losing its edge has been interpreted two different ways. Losing its edge could mean its no longer edgy while it could also mean the quality of the product has declined. I interpret it as the latter and agree that at some point during City at War IDW began a decline in its quality of story as it rushed some plots that have been weaved for a long while to a conclusion. Then what was chosen to be picked up with #101 of available plots was narrow and poorly executed as a wide range of TMNT fans such as big other media fans and those of the black and white comics who had found common ground are both being turned off.
Sophie Campbell
11-05-2020, 12:20 PM
That's a pretty fair post.
Though where does Nick draw the line, really? "The TMNT Shall Not Kill," OK, I get it, that's been clear since IDW TMNT began. Though can you guys have, like, at least Leonardo slice someone's tendon, disabling them? Raphael pinning someone's hand to the wall by ramming a sai into the palm, maybe? I feel like the answer even to things like that is "No," so it's not even as simple as just "The TMNT Shall Not Kill."
I don't know the nitty gritty details of the rule, and I don't know if there's an actual mandate written down or if it's more fluid and whatever seems right in the moment. I don't know what the exact limits of it are. I think it's probably more fluid than it seems, like the other poster mentioned Leo on the 2012 show beheading Shredder, like maybe Ciro convinced the PTB or caught them in a good mood.
I'm not sure about your other weapon examples, but I've gotten away with having Jennika draw blood with her claws (she is now also subject to the same rules as the other Turtles). In an early pitch I had Raph gouging out Hob's good eye. :tlol:
In any case I'm trying to stick with what Tom set up for the most part, he did good work with the characters' stances on violence and the discussion around that.
AquaParade
11-05-2020, 12:56 PM
Hearing a bit about restriction and mandates from Nick/Viacom really is fascinating.
PizzaPower1985
11-05-2020, 01:23 PM
I remember thinking, by the time I got done with City Fall... "these IDW guys are doing incredible things with TMNT. this book has such an edge." then I got to Northampton... my god... Introspective brilliance! Just incredible. And I had never seen Sophie's art before and loved what she did for that story. It just got better as it went along... But somewhere along the way, I don't know, it had to be after Attack on the Technodrome arc, after Donnie's death, maybe even after Shredder's death in #50... something fell off! Not going to speak for anyone else... but for me, maybe it was too many characters... too much toon influence? I DON'T KNOW!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-05-2020, 02:15 PM
I remember thinking, by the time I got done with City Fall... "these IDW guys are doing incredible things with TMNT. this book has such an edge." then I got to Northampton... my god... Introspective brilliance! Just incredible. And I had never seen Sophie's art before and loved what she did for that story. It just got better as it went along... But somewhere along the way, I don't know, it had to be after Attack on the Technodrome arc, after Donnie's death, maybe even after Shredder's death in #50... something fell off! Not going to speak for anyone else... but for me, maybe it was too many characters... too much toon influence? I DON'T KNOW!
For me, the wheels didn't come off entirely until "City at War". Like, I had the same complaints about "Vengeance" in retrospect, and seeing that the same thing was happening really did it for me. At least #50 had the huge fight between the Turtles and Shredder.
#100 didn't even have something like that.
Also, the Bishop reveal really bugged me, but that was more a specific issue.
The last IDW issue I really, really loved was Sophie's Leonardo Macro-Issue. Funnily enough, I seem to remember a lot of people here not liking it.
I think it only lost its edge recently, but I appreciate the more laid-back recent content. It’s only natural to take breathers.
I'm still loving the series.
Shark_Blade
01-15-2021, 02:42 AM
Same. I just love the bonding/brotherhood moments sprinkled across the issues. That’s the true “edge” in my opinion.
And also the violent fights, love em. Still reminiscing how Donnie’s “death” made the headline news globally.
PizzaPower1985
01-16-2021, 08:59 AM
I have been rereading the IDW book again and... I think I have determined where it lost its edge. Again, not speaking for anyone but myself, but I found it. For me, it happens around the Chasing Phantoms arc. That doesn't take away from this arc or anything that followed at all either.
The idea that Waltz and Co. maintained TMNT to that high of a standard for so long (up into the 60's as far as issues go), in my mind, is no mean feat. It means, for me at least, that Waltz is one of the greatest writers working in the field today, as comics are simply not what they used to be, IMO. Back when Denny O'neil or Gerry Conway, Marv Wolfman, Len Wein or Chris Claremont could do that, in the 70's and 80's... it meant the writing was spectacular, and even then it was a rarity. Tom W. deserves to be commended big time!
I am especially happy that the IDW comic was not marketed to kids and that TMNT has at least one outlet that older fans like myself can enjoy.
AquaParade
01-16-2021, 09:48 AM
I have been rereading the IDW book again and... I think I have determined where it lost its edge. Again, not speaking for anyone but myself, but I found it. For me, it happens around the Chasing Phantoms arc. That doesn't take away from this arc or anything that followed at all either.
The idea that Waltz and Co. maintained TMNT to that high of a standard for so long (up into the 60's as far as issues go), in my mind, is no mean feat. It means, for me at least, that Waltz is one of the greatest writers working in the field today, as comics are simply not what they used to be, IMO. Back when Denny O'neil or Gerry Conway, Marv Wolfman, Len Wein or Chris Claremont could do that, in the 70's and 80's... it meant the writing was spectacular, and even then it was a rarity. Tom W. deserves to be commended big time!
I am especially happy that the IDW comic was not marketed to kids and that TMNT has at least one outlet that older fans like myself can enjoy.
Interesting. What about that arc brought you to that conclusion?
I can’t remember it.
CyberCubed
01-16-2021, 10:31 AM
Wasn't that the arc with the Street Phantoms if I'm remembering right?
PizzaPower1985
01-16-2021, 12:18 PM
Interesting. What about that arc brought you to that conclusion?
I can’t remember it.
What brought me to that conclusion, I guess, was that it felt like kind of the true beginning of a new direction for the series. The Vengeance arc ended with Shredder's death and the Splinter taking over the Foot Clan... then, the intro to Leatherhead happened. I guess after Saki died and seeing Splinter take over the Clan... it just didn't feel... the same. The Street Phantoms arc felt like it was beginning new territory... familiar, but new... if that makes sense. Still kinda trying to process all of it.
Wasn't that the arc with the Street Phantoms if I'm remembering right?
It was indeed. A great arc too... just different from the rest IMO with Saki being gone!
hypered1
01-16-2021, 12:35 PM
What brought me to that conclusion, I guess, was that it felt like kind of the true beginning of a new direction for the series. The Vengeance arc ended with Shredder's death and the Splinter taking over the Foot Clan... then, the intro to Leatherhead happened. I guess after Saki died and seeing Splinter take over the Clan... it just didn't feel... the same. The Street Phantoms arc felt like it was beginning new territory... familiar, nut new... if that makes sense. Still kinda trying to process all of it.
It was indeed. A great arc too... just different from the rest IMO with Saki being gone!
I get what you're saying and I think it stems from Saki being a 'final boss' type character in many iterations (and Krang had been dealt with a few issues earlier), so where we knew that the original outline for the series would end at issue 50 everything since then has felt different because it was never as clear what the second/ third run of 50 issues was leading to.
Metropoliskid41
01-17-2021, 04:46 PM
Honestly I’m surprised that the Turtles aren’t allowed to be more violent & kill in the IDW series. I say this because of 2 reasons:
1) Comic Books in the current market structure skew to older, more mature readers. Don’t get me wrong, I’m a big advocate for a plethora of all ages comics to hook kids & bring in a new generation of comic readers to keep the media going for future generations. I think this is especially important for Turtle comics. But the comic book industry, as viewed thru the lens of traditional comic book publisher (in which I include IDW) have a severe channel/route to market problem under the current Direct Market parameters. With comics, including the IDW TMNT comics, you have to go to a specialty store just to get your hands on the comics. That limited availability & exposure to kids limits the market and book appeal to people that can drive to their local comic shop(mine is about 40 miles away). I recognize that digital is a way to overcome those comic shop proximity hurdles, and many kids have smart phones these days, but are they really downloading TMNT comics? Scholastic is cracking the code with their line of Children’s comics and graphic novels, but until Nick & IDW don’t appear to be going with that route to market to get Turtles comics in schools & in front younger audiences yet.
2) Nick has put out scarier, darker TMNT stuff than killing would be in a comic book. I mean, in the 2012 cartoon, they literally had a cult of shredder worshipping monster people open a portal to hell & summon a red, winged demon to raise Shredder from the hell. The demon overcame Tigerclaw’s influence & tried to bring about the end of the world with an army of evil ghosts, while the turtles battled a demonic zombie monster shredder. That’s some pretty dark, creepy stuff man. Way darker than mirage level violence, IMO. Darker than the image vol 3 level of violence (which they also republished btw). And they’re worried about killing some masked ninjas occasionally? I wonder how much of the curtailing of violence is actually Nick and how much of it is maybe a choice in sensibility of tone by IDW instead?
MikeandRaph87
01-17-2021, 09:05 PM
For me, the wheels didn't come off entirely until "City at War". Like, I had the same complaints about "Vengeance" in retrospect, and seeing that the same thing was happening really did it for me. At least #50 had the huge fight between the Turtles and Shredder.
#100 didn't even have something like that.
Also, the Bishop reveal really bugged me, but that was more a specific issue.
The last IDW issue I really, really loved was Sophie's Leonardo Macro-Issue. Funnily enough, I seem to remember a lot of people here not liking it.
This is where our interest crossover. It was all that build up with Krang's trial only for it to be negated by Leatherhead swallowing Krang. I got over it and the fan art end especially with #86's tease of Krang being a parasite and I understand Slash's sacrifice even if I don't like it and it reminds me of how well Archie did until he sacrificed himself there. It was the Bishop reveal that was the tipping point for me in truth. I was thinking it was the scene in which Big Louie was name dropped only to die in two pages after praising IDW for bringing out the potential in old favorites. It turns out that was just the symbolic tipping point that IDW takes old characters and enhanced them breathing new life into them and the slaughter of the mob bosses symbolically showed that IDW no longer could what I gave them so much credit for.
Then City At War had a lot to wrap up that it rushed to a conclusion that left unsatisfactory. There was tying up the Metalhead gone rouge storyline, Agent Bishop's pursuit, Arnold Jones Sr./Hun and Karai's rebuilding herself before usurping the Clan. Finally all that and there really was no fight with the Pantheon Dragon. I did not care about Metalhead gone rogue storyline and felt that Hun while he died for his son could have come around on his hatred of mutants first. I hope with Agent Bishop dead that there can be a course correction and he can transfer his essence into clones like the 2003 cartoon and a follow up to him murdering his father in 'Desperate Measures'. So the edge was lost before this Mutant Town direction that I am not happy with at all, it just took me awhile to determine when it was. It just happen to worsen with the #101-105 arc.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.