PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #110 Preview and Discussion


AlZarkovski
10-13-2020, 08:26 AM
First look:
https://is4-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication114/v4/24/63/09/246309c3-5add-102a-b530-5ab4c8f132e2/img_2.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is2-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication114/v4/84/72/56/847256a7-9665-8bc3-0139-29d8f1022621/img_3.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is4-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication124/v4/3b/8e/4b/3b8e4b54-30d6-6689-8aca-b2892f6e9669/img_4.jpg/900x0w.jpg

ChosenOne
10-13-2020, 10:10 AM
Honestly, how else was that ambush on Leo gonna go?

And why do I get the feeling Raph's getting ideas when he comments on how Alopex just gobbles it (the food) all up? 8):lol:

lonewarrior20
10-13-2020, 01:44 PM
the chair! give him the chair!

with raph and al i was reminded by this.
tpt6A-bQ8iQ

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-13-2020, 02:34 PM
Still catering to shippers and scalies, I see.

Thanks, 2020.

CyberCubed
10-13-2020, 03:00 PM
I wonder who the Octopus mutant belongs to.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-13-2020, 03:34 PM
Still catering to shippers and scalies, I see.

Thanks, 2020.

I wonder who the Octopus mutant belongs to.

Great, make that shippers, scalies, and hentai enthusiasts. :tlol:

AquaParade
10-13-2020, 10:19 PM
I kind of like how we aren't relying on a color to tell who Raphael is though. It's refreshing.

Powder
10-13-2020, 11:25 PM
Still catering to shippers and scalies, I see.

Thanks, 2020.

Yep. Haven't read in many months, checked in on this, no change.

MikeandRaph87
10-14-2020, 09:54 AM
Please show multiple ongoing plots instead of just mutant town!

Leo656
10-14-2020, 10:30 AM
So... I'm guessing the petition fell on deaf ears. :trazz:

lonewarrior20
10-14-2020, 10:31 AM
Please show multiple ongoing plots instead of just mutant town!

Technically there are multiple plots going on, they're just located in mutant town.

Leo656
10-14-2020, 10:39 AM
Frankly, having occasionally written things of a similar bent (like, suspiciously similar... in fact so many elements of my ideas have turned up in IDW's books over the years that I'm beginning to wonder if someone's hacked my hard drive), I can see why this style would appeal to some folks.

BUT. I'm also pretty sure - and I've said this with regard to why nobody but my wife and a very small number of people have or will ever read my stuff - it simply isn't what most people want from a commercial product that says "TMNT" on the cover. Like what might make an amusing fanfic read to pass a quiet afternoon isn't what someone wants to pay $4 to read monthly. Even if it's a well-written and well-executed exploration of concept it's not necessarily what the audience at large wants.

Pretty sure that most people putting their money down want something with a little bit more testosterone and a little less "meet-cute" stuff. That's just the temperature I'm getting from people.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-14-2020, 10:54 AM
So... I'm guessing the petition fell on deaf ears. :trazz:

Somebody bothered with a petition? :tlol: Musta missed that thread...

Leo656
10-14-2020, 10:58 AM
It wasn't a thread, I just hear things.

You got an email by the way. :trazz: Unrelated but relevant.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-14-2020, 11:47 AM
It wasn't a thread, I just hear things.

You got an email by the way. :trazz: Unrelated but relevant.

:tthumbsu:

CyberCubed
10-14-2020, 12:07 PM
Please show multiple ongoing plots instead of just mutant town!

Baxter got some eggs from that eel in the previous issue.

Sophie Campbell
10-14-2020, 01:04 PM
Nobody showed me any petition! :tconfuse:

Leo656
10-14-2020, 01:13 PM
At one point I was asked if I would participate in such a grassroots movement, but I respectfully declined. I'm not gonna "out" anybody who may have been involved, though, that's their business. They can speak up if they wanna, but I doubt they will.

I mean, the last guy who had a super-strong opinion about the book and said so out loud got Banned permanently. They were also probably a Banned member using a fake account anyway, which probably had more to do with the Ban, but it didn't do much to change the idea that you "can't openly criticize the TMNT Staff". Which is how a lot of members here feel, which is why they don't say much out loud.

Either way, I'm guessing it didn't gain much traction.

Sophie Campbell
10-14-2020, 01:24 PM
but it didn't do much to change the idea that you "can't openly criticize the TMNT Staff". Which is how a lot of members here feel, which is why they don't say much out loud.

That definitely sucks. Honestly we shouldn't be hanging around here and stifling reader discussion with our presence, anyway.

Leo656
10-14-2020, 01:33 PM
I wouldn't say all that. Engagement is a good thing, generally speaking.

There's just been a long and storied history around here of TMNT staff not being altogether the most graceful at handling criticism. It happens whether or not they're actively speaking out loud.

Laird used to use the Vol. 4 letter column to paraphrase me directly and address my Jim Lawson criticisms nearly word-for-word. He was obviously lurking here often even though he never said anything. That's life. It didn't change my opinion nor how I chose to speak it just because "The Boss" didn't like it. The way I figure it, he could come to me about if it he felt like. I'm not altogether hard to find. I just thought it was comical that he'd rather use his own soapbox as a way of rebuttal and avoid being direct about it. Like, he can say my opinion doesn't matter, but he's taking time out of his day to address it very publicly and people are paying for the privilege of reading it, sooooo... Kinda said more about Him than about Me, I figure.

And then there was the Ciro guy who decided to take his ball and leave when not everyone loved the Nick show at first. I wasn't here for that, people just told me about it. Pretty funny. Surely he would have been absolutely thrilled to meet me. Shame that never came to pass.

And of course, Ant Ward and his "ban that guy or we'll have our lawyers look into shutting this place down". That was a fun time.

Point being, I think the people here are grateful for the engagement. But some of the creatives don't take well to dissent, they overreact, and thus, it makes people feel like they "can't talk" sometimes.

But that doesn't mean that "the staff" aren't welcome or shouldn't engage. I just think there's just always going to be some awkwardness there.

ChosenOne
10-14-2020, 02:20 PM
That definitely sucks. Honestly we shouldn't be hanging around here and stifling reader discussion with our presence, anyway.

Allow me to disagree with that sentiment. There's no stifling at all, it's just that same people have no manners and always resort to aggression to voice their opinions. Those should be banned, IMHO, here or anywhere else with or without creators present. In short, hang away!

(This last sentence sounded better in my head...)

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-14-2020, 02:51 PM
I don't like the direction TMNT has taken at all (obviously), but I'm glad Sophie's around. :tsmile:

skylord
10-14-2020, 03:35 PM
Regardless of your thoughts on the series, I think it takes real humility to be around your audience. For the staff that stick around and don't take criticism too personally, its a treat. At the very least the fans here don't feel entirely ignored I'd hope. even then the writers clearly don't feel beholden to the thoughts of the fans.

I'm behind and can't say much about the current comic but I'm typically a fan of plots slowing down. It's refreshing and makes the later action more exciting. Restarting from the beginning so I'll be caught up just in time for this discourse to be dead in the dirt.

MikeandRaph87
10-14-2020, 04:24 PM
I don't like the direction TMNT has taken at all (obviously), but I'm glad Sophie's around. :tsmile:

I am like-minded in every word on this.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-14-2020, 04:35 PM
I am like-minded in every word on this.

High-five, amigo. :tsmile:

Weapons@theready
10-14-2020, 05:27 PM
I am like-minded in every word on this.

I too would like to echo this sentiment.

TigerClaw
10-14-2020, 06:23 PM
Nobody showed me any petition! :tconfuse:
Petitions don't even work. Just continue doing what you are doing and ignore the haters. You're doing a fantastic job with the comics. Can't wait for the next issue. :tsmile:

Leo656
10-14-2020, 06:36 PM
Petitions don't even work.

Zack Snyder says hello. :lol:

Granted, that's the One and Only Time it's ever worked in all of human history. Still... just saying. Sometimes they work. "Once Ever" can still technically mean "sometimes". Technically.

Oh, wait, I forgot the Sonic movie redesign. That also worked. Actually now that I'm thinking back, there have been a few others, too. Huh.

Yeah, come to think of it, sometimes they do work. Go figure... once again, TigerClaw gets things All Wrong. :lol: :trazz:

TigerClaw
10-14-2020, 06:56 PM
Zack Snyder says hello. :lol:

Granted, that's the One and Only Time it's ever worked in all of human history. Still... just saying. Sometimes they work. "Once Ever" can still technically mean "sometimes". Technically.

Oh, wait, I forgot the Sonic movie redesign. That also worked. Actually now that I'm thinking back, there have been a few others, too. Huh.

Yeah, come to think of it, sometimes they do work. Go figure... once again, TigerClaw gets things All Wrong. :lol: :trazz:
Some Petitions do if they make sense. But for stuff like this its a complete waste of time and never going to amount to anything. Especially when you have Petitions for some of the most ridiculous things.

MikeandRaph87
10-14-2020, 07:10 PM
Zack Snyder says hello. :lol:

Granted, that's the One and Only Time it's ever worked in all of human history. Still... just saying. Sometimes they work. "Once Ever" can still technically mean "sometimes". Technically.

Oh, wait, I forgot the Sonic movie redesign. That also worked. Actually now that I'm thinking back, there have been a few others, too. Huh.

Yeah, come to think of it, sometimes they do work. Go figure... once again, TigerClaw gets things All Wrong. :lol: :trazz:

It also contributed to how James Gunn got his place back as the director of the Guardians of The Galaxy franchise.

Yes, there are multiple plots within Mutant Town,however it is the core of everything right now and I need more plot diversity. There is the Foot Clan situation, the political situation with Baxter and Madame Null's connection, what Fugitiod saw that shocked him, other characters that could use expansion outside of Mutant Town, among other things.

Like I said I have much respect for the creative team so I am not taking to a message board to vent, I just simply recognize that I liked the overall direction for over 90 issues, but the overall tonal shift degraded by enthusiasm for a product that I invest in. I hope that my preferences can be seen in the near future and I continue to see creators presence no matter my enthusiasm level for the product they are producing.

Leo656
10-14-2020, 07:19 PM
Some Petitions do if they make sense. But for stuff like this its a complete waste of time and never going to amount to anything. Especially when you have Petitions for some of the most ridiculous things.

Buuuuuut that's not what you saaaaaaaid, you said they don't work and I got ya to admit that sometimes they do. Pppbbbbbbbth! Score is 15-Love, Roxx. :tgrin:

In this case I agreed with the spirit of said petition but since I wasn't paying for the book in a very long time even beforehand, it seemed disingenuous to attach my name to something like that. It seemed very specifically about people who stopped buying the book semi-recently because it turned into Furry Fanfic Shipper Showcase, and while I do find some cause to their grievance, I already wasn't buying the book. So it just didn't feel right. I only sign my name on Big Important Things.

Y'know, like putting the Rocky statue back where it belongs or making Jenna Jameson's Birthday a national holiday with paid leave. That kinda sh*t. Float me some'a that and I'm all over it.

Anyway. Personally, I feel like when a Whole Lotta People who've been buying a product for ten years all suddenly stop at once, and they say "Here's Why" in detail... it's definitely worth keeping an open ear at the very least. It's easy to say, "Those people can just come on back for the next round" when a new team takes over, but that historically isn't how most things work, especially in comics. When your audience leaves, they're gone. They don't come back for "the next creative team", they just find other things to do. Which is why the entire comic book industry has been in a downward spiral for going on 30 years after the last boom period went bust. Nobody in the business has any idea how to keep the readers that they already have, and are absolutely sure that right around the corner is the next big thing that's gonna bring everybody rushing back. But that simply never happens. Once someone who's in the habit of buying a book breaks that habit, regardless of the reason Why, it is almost impossible to ever get them back. Thus... it's always good to keep an open ear and mind when your customers say, "Here's What I Don't Like, and Here's Why I Left." IF you ever want them to come back at all.

Food For Thought.


Like I said I have much respect for the creative team so I am not taking to a message board to vent, I just simply recognize that I liked the overall direction for over 90 issues, but the overall tonal shift degraded by enthusiasm for a product that I invest in. I hope that my preferences can be seen in the near future and I continue to see creators presence no matter my enthusiasm level for the product they are producing.

I mean, I only dip in and out. But when people tell me (and they have), "This feels like it came off of some teenage girl's Tumblr", I absolutely see what they mean without having to dig very deeply at all. And I just kinda don't think that's the stuff most people who call themselves TMNT fans really care to see take center stage for $4 a month.

It can completely nail what it tries to do while still not being what most of that specific audience wants to read, and that's where the problem sets in. Vol. 4 was the exact same way from a completely different direction. It succeeded in telling the kind of story that it wanted to tell but absolutely failed at being worth its cover price insofar as entertainment value. It wasn't what a book called "TMNT" should be, which is why it was objectively a failure. I'm not trying to be mean, I'm just saying, by any objective standard, it was a bust.

Perhaps if Laird treated that book as a piece of commercial entertainment and not his own soapbox, and wrote it to amuse the audience rather than amuse himself, people might have bought it and he might not have had to sell everything to Viacom. Again, Food For Thought.

The people who've posted in this thread saying they dropped the book months ago and don't plan on coming back anytime soon were devout followers of the book for the longest time. Those aren't the kind of people any publisher should ever risk alienating. They at least ought to keep an open ear about what they say they don't like. That's just common sense.

TomWaltz
10-14-2020, 08:33 PM
Frankly, having occasionally written things of a similar bent (like, suspiciously similar... in fact so many elements of my ideas have turned up in IDW's books over the years that I'm beginning to wonder if someone's hacked my hard drive), I can see why this style would appeal to some folks.

BUT. I'm also pretty sure - and I've said this with regard to why nobody but my wife and a very small number of people have or will ever read my stuff - it simply isn't what most people want from a commercial product that says "TMNT" on the cover. Like what might make an amusing fanfic read to pass a quiet afternoon isn't what someone wants to pay $4 to read monthly. Even if it's a well-written and well-executed exploration of concept it's not necessarily what the audience at large wants.

Pretty sure that most people putting their money down want something with a little bit more testosterone and a little less "meet-cute" stuff. That's just the temperature I'm getting from people.

Sorry, but the hacking part was too easy. Your password was L656. Thanks for all the story ideas!

;)

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Leo656
10-14-2020, 08:57 PM
:lol: If anyone ever did truly borrow the fanfic ideas of someone who was 19 and fairly drunk when they first wrote it, then that hypothetical person doing the borrowing likely has much bigger problems than I'd have with securing my inbox. :lol:

Then again, they were "award-winning" fanfics... so maybe there actually are more sinister forces at work here... :trazz:

For now, we'll call it "serendipity". But I've got my eye on you cats.... :fshifty:

...And everybody knows the password was "80085". Y'know, like the calculator thing. HAH, it says "boobs". That's awesome.

ChosenOne
10-14-2020, 09:41 PM
even then the writers clearly don't feel beholden to the thoughts of the fans.

History shows that having writers beholden to the thoughts of fans is always an amazingly bad idea. We can provide feedback, sure, and it's not every creator who will put themselves out there like the IDW crew have on this forum, but other than that fans should really abstain from trying to influence the course of a story. It's not something we really want despite how much we think we do, and we wouldn't realize that until it would be too late. Not to mention the fact that there's always the odd weirdo who will take things a wee bit too far. Better to wait and see. Unpopular opinion (probably?), but other than #5 and the Raph micro, I was pretty damn bored during almost the entire first year of the comic. I still to this day really dislike the very first arc. And look where that got us.

Have faith, everyone!

Andrew NDB
10-14-2020, 09:48 PM
Perhaps if Laird treated that book as a piece of commercial entertainment and not his own soapbox, and wrote it to amuse the audience rather than amuse himself, people might have bought it and he might not have had to sell everything to Viacom. Again, Food For Thought.

I don't think that's quite right. It wasn't that (more) people might have bought the book... nobody even knew it existed. There wasn't any marketing. It was barely even in any comic stores and if it was, it would be 3 copies and be behind everything else. And the sales of Vol. 4 were hardly the make or break factor in taking the Viacom deal. Peter has said the amount of money Viacom offered (63 million, was it?) was so generous that he was, #1, shocked, and #2, basically said that he would have taken them up on that offer even if it came a decade before (though going any earlier than that Kevin would have to chime in... though since Kevin cashed in all of his TMNT rights in 2000 it's hard to believe he'd urge Peter not to).

Though had Peter endeavored to make his lettercol less... divisive, might it have improved the fandom's general sentiment toward the book (and Peter himself), perhaps even improved Peter's general sentiment toward the franchise and the fandom as a side effect (which in turn might have lessened the chances of him selling the whole kit and kaboodle)? Probably. We'll never know, but what's done is done. Personally, I never minded his conduct in the lettercol. I thought it was kind of cool to have such a discourse with a comic creator, especially when we're talking early 2000s when that wasn't really a thing. Though I do understand the people upset, and why. I kind of don't understand people putting their ire of the man over their love of the book, and the continued Mirage TMNT legacy.

Anyway, congratulations... the human heart of the TMNT was successfully driven out... now it's just a room full of executives with flow charts and toy sales reports and restrictions on what the TMNT can and can't do left to determine the direction and fate of the TMNT forevermore. I mean something like IDW undoubtedly gets a little bit of leeway (just a little) in that a comic book in today's market isn't really something anybody at the top is too worried about, but everything else? Eh...

CyberCubed
10-14-2020, 10:28 PM
Vol. 4 was also a bi-monthly comic, it's very weird for a comic to only come out every 2 months and I think that's why a lot of people fell out of it as it went on, besides the writing or Jim Lawsons art. I mean I was only 15 when Vol. 4 started...by the time we got to the last issue I was done with college and in my late 20's. :lol:

Leo656
10-15-2020, 04:20 AM
Well, I did say "perhaps".

I've spoken anecdotally on this before, and it is purely my own experience, but the shop owners I knew would have loved to pushed more copies of the book, and gave it prominent positioning in their stores to try and move more copies. It just didn't take. The first issue of Vol. 4, my main shop bought, I think, about a dozen issues expecting a big return, but a year later they still had a couple of unsold copies on the rack. Every issue they gradually ordered fewer and fewer copies, until for most of the run they ended up only ordering the one copy for me since it was on my pull list. They even gave it a "Recommended" spot up front near the register, early on, which they'd do sometimes to push "hot" new books and make sure people saw it (or move copies of unsold books featuring popular characters that just wouldn't move, like "The Dark Knight Strikes Again", which they couldn't give away). There wasn't a huge push in Wizard or anything, no - that definitely would have helped, as in the early-2000s people were mostly buying whatever Wizard told them to buy - but I knew a few people who were doing their best inside their own store to move copies, and it just never clicked.

What I was told from multiple shop owners was simple and direct: People would pick it up, flip through it, and put it back down. They'd get excited to see a Ninja Turtles comic - some of the cover art was very eye-catching - but they absolutely hated the artwork and plot-wise, nothing ever seemed to happen. Pages and pages of static shots and talking heads. So people would skim it and put it back down. It's not that they were altogether unaware, it's that when they would become aware, they simply did not like what they saw. In the opinion of the guys trying to sell it, based on customer feedback inside their own stores, "It needs to be in color, it needs to look better, and it needs more action like in the cartoons." Even the short-lived and abysmal Dreamwave comic got a much better reaction overall, because it simply skewed more in line with what people expected a TMNT comic to look like.

Meanwhile, at my main store, when back issues of Archie TMNT or even earlier Mirage would turn up, they'd vanish inside of a few days until I politely asked to get "first look" at all TMNT back issues that came in. Niche stuff like "Hepcats" would disappear quickly, too. And it's not like they'd hang up a sign that said "New back issues of _____ in stock"; the place just had a ton of foot traffic as it was in a really prominent position right off the highway, so they did awesome business for many, many years until the 2007-8 recession forced them under. They were the most prominent comics shop in the county, so basically, if they were having a hard time moving a book, you could estimate exponentially that said book was not doing well elsewhere, either. Especially because a lot of the owners were friends or at least acquaintances, and this state isn't that big, so if you asked a shopkeeper "What's the temperature on ____?" and they said "No heat, doesn't move", you knew it wasn't just a problem in that store, but everywhere.

As for lack of advertising... I'm sure that was a factor, because it always is, but I doubt it was the be-all and end-all. My main shop was one of the ones that got "everything" including Adult comics, and those comics would also move despite getting zero advertising and being relegated to their own small rack at the very back of the store. If they bough five copies of TMNT Vol. 4 and five copies of Genus, and put them each on the wall in their respective sections, Genus would sell those five copies in a week or two while the five TMNT issues would sit there. "Hot Moms", "Housewives At Play", "Bondage Fairies", I remember all of those books and a few others being on the back wall and selling out their three-to-five copies VERY fast, and I cannot imagine for the life of me that they were getting a ton of advertising and it's not like the store had a giant red arrow pointing people towards them, either.

My secondary shop was a big, giant place inside a shopping mall that got hundreds and hundreds of people a day inside. They took an even bigger bath on the early issues of Vol. 4, ordering like 15-20 copies of the first couple issues, but almost a year later they still had copies of Issue 1 floating on the wall. They quickly just gave up and dropped the book entirely. I mean COME ON, you can't get a comic that says "TMNT #1" to move off your shelves after a YEAR when you have about a thousand daily customers and you're doing everything you can on your end to make people buy it? That overrides any lack of advertising, in my mind. That tells me, quite bluntly, that people don't like that particular product.

I have to believe that ultimately, it's a case of in the free market, people will gravitate towards products they like and ignore the ones they don't. Advertising is a factor, sure, but so is word-of-mouth. And I know that things can still move copies solely on word-of-mouth IF people like what they see and in turn they each tell two friends.

If a book with "TMNT" on the cover can't sell five copies in a store that gets tons of traffic, at the same time a new TMNT cartoon is on the air and toys are on the shelves, and people are literally picking it up and then putting it back without buying it... that means someone on the creative end f*cked up.

All anecdotal, sure, but if you take what happened at these three or four shops I used to visit frequently and multiply it exponentially across the entire United States and allow for the fact that these things do usually roll in waves, you HAVE to reason that even if the book did a little bit better in certain areas, that on the whole it did bad business, at a time when the brand itself was doing really, really well otherwise. Laird can say "I never expected or cared if the book made money", but that's part cop-out, part sour grapes, and part flat-out lie. Anyone who sells a product wants to make money if they can. And they definitely COULD have. With a few tweaks, it could definitely have sold at least five copies per store multiplied by however many stores there are nationwide. That's a pittance of a return to expect for a book called "TMNT" released during a boom period for both comics and the brand. But in most stores they weren't even selling five copies. And that, quite frankly, is inexcusable.

Word-of-mouth could have gotten them there, but the word-of-mouth was bad. At the end of the day, I paid my money towards the book even though I didn't like it (although I did like Tales Vol. 2 quite a bit more). Other people, not so much. And it's not like those other people didn't know it existed. They knew; plenty of people knew. They just didn't care.

People in 2003-ish definitely wanted a TMNT comic book. But they definitely didn't want THAT one. The rest is history.

The moral of the story becomes, "Sometimes you really should listen to what your audience wants you to improve on." And if they get tired of waiting, well... there's no guarantee that they'll ever come back.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2020, 04:53 AM
Nah, Vol. 4 never really had a chance at achieving "big numbers." And Peter didn't care about that, and I respect that. Maybe with a little tweaking it would have done a bit better, but no more than that.

I think most people of sound mind can imagine what a real TMNT Mirage comic would have looked like that might have had a chance at "breaking big," and maybe this example is closer to what you're talking about. You know, cutting edge art, vivacious digital coloring, and edgy stuff with heart. Taking big chances. Comics made into actual story arcs (I'm not saying "written for trade" which has been the thing in the industry for too long now, but just 3-4 issue story arcs with the occasional one off issue that just is) and not some free-flowing thing that never ends and isn't clearly defined. It could have worked around 2003, that was about the "last chance" for such a thing to put in its hooks in the comic industry. But it was never wanted to be that by TPTB (Peter), but that's fine. He made exactly the comic he wanted to and I absolutely respect that. And I supremely enjoy what was given. I hope he comes back and wraps it up... or finally capitalizes on his 18 issues a year clause indefinitely.

Leo656
10-15-2020, 05:25 AM
Five measly issues per store is far from "Big Numbers" though, bruh. If your book can't even sell that many issues in a densely-populated area in a store with tons of foot traffic then it simply isn't that good at capturing its audience.

Explain to me how a book like "Housewives At Play" or "Bondage Fairies" can sell more copies than a book featuring one of the most popular pop culture brands of the 20th century in TMNT, when the latter got way more advertising than the former ones ever did.

Once people pick a thing up, then put it back down, the "nobody knew about it" defense just doesn't fly anymore. If people liked what they saw, they would have taken it home.

People didn't purchase the books because they didn't like what was in them. No other reason than that. We're not even talking "big numbers" or even "respectable numbers". Five issues per. That's all. I can't find the number of comic book stores in North America in 2004-ish, but frankly, if ANY store couldn't even move five lousy copies of a book with that big a brand name on it I'd say that's indicative of a huge problem. And a lot of people DID at least see it, were aware of it, and flipped through it. They just didn't think it was worth their money.

TMNT fans, not buying a TMNT comic book because it "Wasn't their flavor of TMNT". That's... that's a problem. In any time, place, era or climate... that's not something that should be handwaved and shrugged off. That's what's called a "Teachable Moment". Something to be learned from, not dismissed and ignored.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2020, 05:32 AM
Five measly issues per store is far from "Big Numbers" though, bruh. If your book can't even sell that many issues in a densely-populated area in a store with tons of foot traffic then it simply isn't that good at capturing its audience.

He was never concerned about that. At any point. Unabashedly. Though this has far more to do with what individual comic book stores order vs. what "Mirage Publishing" is actually able or has on hand to sell out. I was going between two comic stores in my area at the time... one flat out didn't carry it because it didn't sell (but you could add it to your "list" and you'd get it), the other one was the aforementioned 3 issues on the rack behind all of the indy stuff. Which isn't to say that it was the comic stores' fault. They know what sells and what doesn't, and have some idea of what people want vs. what they don't.

People didn't purchase the books because they didn't like what was in them. No other reason than that. We're not even talking "big numbers" or even "respectable numbers". Five issues per. That's all. I can't find the number of comic book stores in North America in 2004-ish, but frankly, if ANY store couldn't even move five lousy copies of a book with that big a brand name on it I'd say that's indicative of a huge problem. And a lot of people DID at least see it, were aware of it, and flipped through it. They just didn't think it was worth their money.

I don't disagree with you. But again... he didn't care. He gets to do that and admitted he was aware of it many times in the lettercol.

SHOULD he have? Well, that's separate discussion. But the guy in charge owning the rights and calling the shots and knowing which way the wind was blowing and still keeping the course... you kind of have to respect that. And I don't think Vol. 4's lack of sales really effected anything in the grand scheme of things (the sale, etc.). I mean, I don't. For all we know he wanted to sell the whole time and was just biding his time -- his blog suggested this was the case. The point is, he did exactly what he wanted to do with TMNT at every turn, particularly when the ball was entirely in his court (i.e., when Kevin sold him his half of the rights in 2000). I don't understand this crusade to undermine Peter when it was totally under his control. You know me. You know what I would want to see. But I didn't co-create TMNT. This is half of the equation putting out stuff... even if I don't like it, it's the real deal, from the source. Would I rather that be filtered through... I don't know... Viacom? No, not really at all. Though we all had separate ideas of what shape that would take in 2009, or at least hopes.

Leo656
10-15-2020, 05:51 AM
I mean... sure. But I'm kind of less concerned with whether or not Laird cared. I'd argue that he probably should have. But that's ultimately not my point.

My point as relates to the Here and Now is simply, it's another case where a whole lot of people would LOVE to buy the TMNT comic that's on the racks, but they don't because they don't like what's in it, and they say so. And in both cases, the people Up Top can say all day long, "We don't care if those people buy it," but that's still ultimately VERY questionable when you're running a business. And in the end, you get to prove how much you "don't care" when the lights get turned off and you're out of business.

I'm not ROOTING for that to happen, keep in mind. Simply pointing out that we've been here before.

It also bears mentioning that when Vol. 4 failed, it did so during a period of boom for the comics industry AND the TMNT brand. Things aren't so peachy for either TMNT as a brand nor comics as a whole, right now, with there being a ton of talk about whether IDW as a company or comics as a business are going to be around in two or three years. That's Serious Sh*t.

Thus, one could argue very potently that now isn't the absolute best time to get all "experimental" and risk alienating long-time readers. They might not ever come back, OR, if things dip badly enough, there eventually might not be anything to come back to.

Just looking at the big picture, is all. I don't really follow IDW but I wouldn't want them to fail or go under or have to cancel TMNT. BUT, I think that's more of a possibility than anyone wants to admit out loud, and saying "We can lose all those people in the short-term, it's fine, we'll get 'em back next year" is incredibly shortsighted and maybe even a little bit arrogant and presumptuous.

Why I brought up Vol. 4 at all, is that in both cases there are/were tons of people who picked up a TMNT comic, said "This really isn't for me" and walked away from it. Regardless of Why, we all know what happened to Vol. 4. So let's not pretend the same thing couldn't happen to IDW six months from now. Do I want that? Not at all. But I think it might. It's a very real possibility.

The same exact people who've been telling me for ten years "You really NEED to buy this book!" are abandoning it, and it's more than two or three people.

That should be taken into consideration, is all. These aren't casual fans they've pushed out the door. They're people who really cared, and really loved the book and want to love it again. BUT, time might run out on the book before they ever get more of what they once loved about it. And that's a shame.

Let's be honest, the people who are head-over-heels in love with the more recent creative direction are the types who would have bought the book no matter what. BUT, they lost other people. Are they gaining a whole bunch more new readers to make up the loss? Or are they really just hoping to "weather the storm" and hope all those people who left jump back on once the book gets a little bit less effeminate again?

If it's the latter, they might be shooting themselves in the foot. Or at least over-estimating their ability to get those people back.

We'll see. DC never really recovered from New 52. Same attitude of "We'll just win over new people", or "Those fans will come back when they're ready." Ten years in, they're still scrambling.

It's just all very much worth looking at and discussing in the Big Picture of things.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2020, 05:57 AM
Your pretense is that Vol. 4 "failed" because of sales. It didn't. He would have kept it going into issue #95 if he still enjoyed doing it, even if 5 people were buying it. He's said as much. The actual sales were beside the point to Peter. In terms of mainstream acceptance, it never had a chance, and that was fine. I don't believe at any point Peter believed, cared about, or wanted for Vol. 4 to be hitting sales levels of like... I don't know... Wolverine or X-Men or Batman at the time.

Guess what also people have no idea exists? Mirage Vol. 1, 2, and Image 3. I mean, most people. There's been good strides of late, but good luck tapping some comic guy on the street on the shoulder about it. Just because IDW has been good about reprints doesn't mean there's a ton of marketing to that end or a big change in people realizing there is something out there other than "Beebop and Rocksteady TMNT and cowabunga/Dimension X." Or whatnot. Like Vol. 4, that's also absolutely fine. I respect people living up to their convictions.

Leo656
10-15-2020, 06:27 AM
I do too, but you're assuming or at least supposing that it still would have ended prematurely even if it sold 200,000 copies per issue, and I have to think that no, it would have kept going. He might have handed it off to someone else since he was never very engaged with doing it to begin with, but things don't go out with a whimper like that if they're making money. "I don't care about money"? Then start a blog, don't charge people money for a very non-appealing commercially-sold product.

I get what you're saying entirely, and I definitely see your point, but you're getting hung up on the wrong part of my larger point. The ONLY reason I bring up Vol. 4 in the first place is the very direct parallel to what's currently going on in IDW, in that more people would read it and buy it IF they liked what was inside of it. People taking a peek at a TMNT comic book, saying "This isn't for me," and then walking away from it.

Same Sh*t, Different Day. That's the only reason I brought up Vol. 4. Should Laird have cared more about making money or at least pleasing the fans? It's only relevant in the sense that if the book sold a ton of copies it likely never would have ended, or at least not the way it did. "Authorial Intent" is something else entirely.

My point is simply, if you say "I don't care if fans like my product," then very soon you won't have a product to sell anyway and the whole thing will be moot.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2020, 06:34 AM
I get what you're saying entirely, and I definitely see your point, but you're getting hung up on the wrong part of my larger point. The ONLY reason I bring up Vol. 4 in the first place is the very direct parallel to what's currently going on in IDW, in that more people would read it and buy it IF they liked what was inside of it. People taking a peek at a TMNT comic book, saying "This isn't for me," and then walking away from it.

In that case, I agree with you. I mean... I'm not reading or buying it. I wanted to. I did, for a pretty good while. I gave it a chance. And then more of a chance. I even reviewed them for free for an up and coming comic review site because I was that excited for a bit. I know that every fan is different, and different 'strokes and all. I liked some of the stuff early on but then it kind of became everything I feared it might. But by the same hand I understand that for many others, it became exactly what they wanted it to be.

But also: if there wasn't Viacom/Nickelodeon restrictions... what could these same teams do? I don't know. Maybe I'd like that. Maybe I'd enjoy some smattering of Mirage with Archie and whatnot with a bit of consequence. I have no idea. Some of the voices coming from this park try to say they'd have been doing this regardless. I doubt it, though.

Leo656
10-15-2020, 06:46 AM
I bought most of the first dozen or so. It was okay. Like you, I felt like it tried a bit too hard to be "jambalaya" and get little bit of everything in there. But it was alright.

Frankly, what forced me out wasn't even creative decisions, it was the entire industry. Very few people bought more comic books than I did, but when the entire industry went to $3 and then $3.50 and up, I had to just quit buying everything. The closest shop to me is over 20 minutes away, now. Ten bucks in gas round-trip and $50 or more for not even 1/3 of how many books I used to be able to get for that money. Just wasn't even worth it, anymore.

I used to manage to dig up about $100 a week for comics from 2002 to 2008. That was a great time. Once that $100 didn't go half as far anymore, that was it for me. I'm not spending the gas money OR the wear-and-tear on our car just to pick up two or three "must-read" books. Frankly I don't really like ANY book that much, to put up with that.

I do miss going every week - not like that's even much of an option this year - but I had to put it to bed. Last few years, I'd go in like three or four times a year with $100 and just get as much as I could for that. Sad as it is to say, but I doubt I'll ever be a "regular consumer" of comic books again. I just don't have the money, the space in my house, or the inclination. From what I've seen, NOTHING coming out from any publisher is even that good.

I do really miss it, though. :ohwell:

The sad thing as relates to THIS conversation, though, is that for the last ten years people have been telling me, "At LEAST pick up the IDW TMNT book, man!" And now, those people aren't even buying it, themselves. The ones who worked the hardest to sell me on it, now no longer care about it. That's... a little bit frightening.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2020, 06:51 AM
I do too, but you're assuming or at least supposing that it still would have ended prematurely even if it sold 200,000 copies per issue, and I have to think that no, it would have kept going. He might have handed it off to someone else since he was never very engaged with doing it to begin with, but things don't go out with a whimper like that if they're making money. "I don't care about money"? Then start a blog, don't charge people money for a very non-appealing commercially-sold product.

I get what you're saying entirely, and I definitely see your point, but you're getting hung up on the wrong part of my larger point. The ONLY reason I bring up Vol. 4 in the first place is the very direct parallel to what's currently going on in IDW, in that more people would read it and buy it IF they liked what was inside of it. People taking a peek at a TMNT comic book, saying "This isn't for me," and then walking away from it.

Same Sh*t, Different Day. That's the only reason I brought up Vol. 4. Should Laird have cared more about making money or at least pleasing the fans? It's only relevant in the sense that if the book sold a ton of copies it likely never would have ended, or at least not the way it did. "Authorial Intent" is something else entirely.

My point is simply, if you say "I don't care if fans like my product," then very soon you won't have a product to sell anyway and the whole thing will be moot.

I think I understand. I guess the big basic difference is... jumping on your point (I think?)?

Mirage/Peter: I don't g.a.f. if you buy my comic. Sales? Pfft, doesn't matter.

IDW: Buy our comic! We want and need sales! You know, like every comic of ours out there on the stands! (just conjecturing, which would be way more than Mirage ever was on its best day publicity wise, objectively)

... and then your point. No, I understand. For me to truly comment on the state of IDW TMNT would require me to read all of what I have not... which would be a lot, at this point. Though I think I get a gist of it. As a writer of sorts myself, I loved the storytelling in the early parts of the series but tuned out when things kind of turned to exactly what I feared but trusted they wouldn't be turned to. Hung around a bit, like.... "Hah! Good job. Maybe there's a takeaway here to come! and this must be all a payoff to some big badass thing" But sadly no.

Leo656
10-15-2020, 07:02 AM
Ehhhhh sales always matter even if you don't beg. Some things are more "artistically motivated" than others, but if you TRULY don't plan on or care about making money, don't charge people for it. That's how I look at it.

I'm all about Art over Commerce myself, but at the end of the day, Business Is Business. In either book's case, if the people running their respective books hypothetically went in for a small business loan to be able to publish them, and openly said "We know the product is divisive, but we don't care, we figure anyone we lose in the short-term can just come on back next year if they want"... they're NOT getting that loan, simple as that.

It's very questionable business strategy to openly declare "We don't care if we lose money!" while at the same time asking people for their money. :lol: BUT, the "good" thing is, that never ends up going on for very long, one way or the other.

D Piddy 1982
10-15-2020, 11:20 AM
Just quickly skim-read as much of this thread as possible, in as short a time as possible!

Just some quick points that others have made that I agree with:
I dropped out after issue #100. I don't mean to sound mean, but I want my TMNT to be doing Ninja things in the shadows, taking risks (thrills) at being caught or found. Fighting, killing! I think Leo656 said it best, something along the lines of the current run feels like a fan-fic piece, or a teenage girls tumblr...

I have to be honest, I haven't read anything past 100 so I can't really say if the above is actually true or not, but I'm just basing it on what I see in the preview panes. Seems to be a lot of love stories, kissing, mutants walking around openly...:lol: I dunno, not really my thing. :roll:

The other point I wanted to raise, is someone mentioned confusion as to which Turtle was which without headband reference. That is one thing I would say about Mateus Santolouco, his Turtles had an individuality. You could tell each apart, without the headbands.

I guess that's why I hate the 2007 movie but love Rise - the individuality of the Turtles themselves.

AlZarkovski
10-18-2020, 10:23 AM
Full preview (https://comic-watch.com/news/sneak-peek-preview-of-idws-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-110).

CyberCubed
10-18-2020, 10:26 AM
I guess Bebop has some long lost twin brothers now. :tlol:

TigerClaw
10-18-2020, 11:54 AM
Full preview (https://comic-watch.com/news/sneak-peek-preview-of-idws-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-110).
Looks like this issue is gonna be fun. Now if only some of those Bikers were Mice. :wink:

lonewarrior20
10-18-2020, 04:26 PM
i know its probably just my imagination but are some of the bikers, girls?

hypered1
10-18-2020, 08:58 PM
i know its probably just my imagination but are some of the bikers, girls?

I think the one with curly hair possibly is.

TigerClaw
10-18-2020, 10:48 PM
i know its probably just my imagination but are some of the bikers, girls?

I think the one with curly hair possibly is.
Its quite possible given the clothing that mutant is wearing too.

https://cdn.shortpixel.ai/spai/w_1025+q_lossless+ret_img+to_webp/https://comic-watch.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/TMNT110_pr-page-006.jpg

lonewarrior20
10-21-2020, 08:56 AM
I liked it. Things are starting to heat up. And I was right they are girls, although I was a bit suprised tusk was one. Think we're gonna see some home alone traps next issue?.

CyberCubed
10-21-2020, 09:24 AM
First half of this issue with Raph/Alopex I was zoning out on, but I liked the second half with Leonardo sneaking into Hob's place. Also another crocodile mutant in this issue, and of course all the pigs/hogs, they're going to mix these characters up with Leatherhead and Bebop after awhile, heh.

Old Hob getting a town of mutants didn't seem to be what he expected, nor us, for that matter. Makes me wonder if they will find a de-mutation bomb or cure to revert everyone back to their past selves eventually, at least for the mutants who were previously human.

ChosenOne
10-21-2020, 10:37 AM
Great issue! I absolutely loved Raph going back to help Tusk and the entire second half with Leo sneaking into the Mutanimals' HQ. Nice to see things finally gearing up for what seems to be an all-out turf war in Mutant Town. Will we get to see those other gangs too?

(The Punk Frogs are a thing outside the second Ghosbusters crossover! Yay!)

Allio
10-21-2020, 10:50 AM
Pretty sure that most people putting their money down want something with a little bit more testosterone and a little less "meet-cute" stuff. That's just the temperature I'm getting from people.

Honestly I like slice-of-life stuff...but I get it. Considering how episodic is it's hard to get invested in 23 pages a month and keep that going for a long time.

Nah, Vol. 4 never really had a chance at achieving "big numbers." And Peter didn't care about that, and I respect that. Maybe with a little tweaking it would have done a bit better, but no more than that.


I'm just glad that Mirage TMNT didn't end up like...whatever the hell is wrong with Savage Dragon

Sharman
10-21-2020, 11:06 AM
Nah, Vol. 4 never really had a chance at achieving "big numbers." And Peter didn't care about that, and I respect that. ... He made exactly the comic he wanted to and I absolutely respect that. And I supremely enjoy what was given. I hope he comes back and wraps it up... or finally capitalizes on his 18 issues a year clause indefinitely.

I couldn't agree more. It's clear that PL, as a creator, was being true to himself with Volume 4 and surely, that is all any artist can hope for with their work - that it be true and not corrupted.

Leo656
10-21-2020, 11:43 AM
Honestly I like slice-of-life stuff...but I get it. Considering how episodic is it's hard to get invested in 23 pages a month and keep that going for a long time.


I love "slice of life", as a concept. It's almost exclusively what I write and I'm not kidding when I say that a lot of what's turning up in more recent IDW comics is very similar to things I've written over the last 20 years (most of which nobody's ever read and likely never will). People who have read it know what I mean and have said the same thing. Tonally and situationally, there are many similarities albeit loose ones.

There's a time and a place for it, and I don't believe it should be completely forbidden from ANY franchise. You can tell a lot of great stories in that style, and I do think TMNT has a lot of intriguing things you can explore that way, and that's what initially encouraged me to write those kinds of stories in the first place - just the fact that they were so "different" from anything that had ever been done with the characters. But what I like to write to amuse myself isn't at all what I'd write if I was asking people to pay me $4 a month for the privilege of reading it, that's all.

I feel like when people buy a book that says "TMNT" on it, they generally expect more action and less kissy-face stuff. And you can take a break from the former to lean into the latter every now and then, but I don't think it's wise to do so for too long or else you'll risk losing people.

Like with regard to my own stuff, good friends whose opinions I trust have more or less said, "This is well-written and I like it for what it is, but I'd never in a million years want any official works to go this route, it's too soap opera". And I fully understand and agree with that. If you're paying for a product, it's not enough that it be well-written and executed "for what it is". You need some'a the ol' Razzle-Dazzle and to give people what they want/expect, too.

I just feel like the whole "Come check us out Next Year and maybe you'll like it better by then" bit is a little shortsighted. Most people who walk away from a comic book walk away forever once they break the habit. Seems like a risky game to play, is all. I mean, who knows if IDW will still be publishing the books by then? One can certainly hope so, but things change fast in the comic book industry nowadays and absolutely nothing is guaranteed.

Mutant Ninja Anole
10-21-2020, 12:29 PM
So I’m genuinely curious, was this gang called the “Road Hogs” and their mutation was an amazing coincidence or did they come up with the name after the fact. I’m guessing they all were together, got mutated, and I don’t know, maybe after 3-4 months you feel comfortable enough to take an ironic approach to your situation.

martinitolove
10-21-2020, 01:50 PM
Old Hob getting a town of mutants didn't seem to be what he expected, nor us, for that matter. Makes me wonder if they will find a de-mutation bomb or cure to revert everyone back to their past selves eventually, at least for the mutants who were previously human.

Really hope "Mutant Town" will end soon for good and children (weasels & albino), amoureous relationships (same or opposite sex), fifth wheel on a cart (Jennika) - all will disappear. Turtles will again fight the Foot Clan, Shredder, B&R, Krang, Ch'rell, Hob, and Tom Waltz returns to writing. I LOVED the first 100 issues, but can't stand 101-onward. It's like watching Rise after loving 2003 and 2012. Hope this nightmare will end soon. And don't care about Last Ronin. Dear IDW, please make really good main series issues again! Please!

Do not want to offend anyone of the creative team, but can't remain silent any longer. Thank you for the stage.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-21-2020, 02:53 PM
Like with regard to my own stuff, good friends whose opinions I trust have more or less said, "This is well-written and I like it for what it is, but I'd never in a million years want any official works to go this route, it's too soap opera".

I've for sure said that. Just not as politely. :tlol:

I just feel like the whole "Come check us out Next Year and maybe you'll like it better by then" bit is a little shortsighted. Most people who walk away from a comic book walk away forever once they break the habit. Seems like a risky game to play, is all.

I know that I have hardly ever, ever gone back to a series once I dropped it. And I've dropped series far better than TMNT. A lot of Image stuff, for one. Saga, Birthright, Black Science, Outcast, Deadly Class, East of West...

Now granted, those were usually due to hiatuses. It's hard to get back into something after a year or two away, unless it's somehow managed to stay in the back of your mind.

The one thing TMNT has going for it over those series is I love TMNT and it'd be easier to pick back up. But will I? Will Powder or MikeandRaph or the others equally dissatisfied with the current direction?

Like Leo says, it's a risky bet.

Really hope "Mutant Town" will end soon for good and children (weasels & albino), amoureous relationships (same or opposite sex), fifth wheel on a cart (Jennika) - all will disappear. Turtles will again fight the Foot Clan, Shredder, B&R, Krang, Ch'rell, Hob, and Tom Waltz returns to writing. I LOVED the first 100 issues, but can't stand 101-onward. It's like watching Rise after loving 2003 and 2012. Hope this nightmare will end soon. And don't care about Last Ronin. Dear IDW, please make really good main series issues again! Please!

Do not want to offend anyone of the creative team, but can't remain silent any longer. Thank you for the stage.

I hear ya, brother.

Leo656
10-21-2020, 03:13 PM
I've for sure said that. Just not as politely. :tlol:


Ah, you weren't actually that far off, really. It was pretty much that. "Well-written but I'd never pay money for it, and if the actual comics were like this that would be terrible and I wouldn't be interested even a little." Which is perfectly fair and exactly what I'd expect from just about anyone. :) You also enjoyed the presentation of the characters themselves, which in a story like that which is mostly character-driven, is about all anyone could hope for.

If I were to try and write a "real" TMNT story to be packaged and sold... honestly, I don't know if I even could. It's just very hard for me to get inspired to try and do things that others have done before and much better. I know what people like and want, but I don't know if I'd have the ability to deliver that for $4 per issue every month. Monthly comics are a lot harder to write than anyone thinks!

Did You Know that Mario Puzo, who wrote "The Godfather", once tried to write a comic book and quickly gave up, saying it was by far the most difficult writing task he'd ever attempted? S'truth! Juggling your own ideas with what fans want/expect is an incredibly tricky balancing act, especially with how vocal comic book fans are in general. When I was a kid, I had aspirations to work in comics. As an adult? Pssssssssh, Lord no. That's a whole lotta headache and hassle for very little reward or appreciation.

I did once have an offer to work for an independent comic waaaaaaaaaay back almost 20 years ago, though. I thought about it for a minute, but in the end they'd end up owning what I'd created and I didn't wanna bother with that. It's not like there was any money in it whatsoever, it would've just been the novelty of saying "Something I wrote/drew was in a published comic book." But there was no real upside beyond that, so I didn't bother.

Plus, y'know... I'm just r e a l l l l l y lazy. :trazz:

funatic
10-21-2020, 04:07 PM
So I’m genuinely curious, was this gang called the “Road Hogs” and their mutation was an amazing coincidence or did they come up with the name after the fact. I’m guessing they all were together, got mutated, and I don’t know, maybe after 3-4 months you feel comfortable enough to take an ironic approach to your situation.

Lol! Well clearly they played the RPG and felt inspired:

https://thumbs2.imgbox.com/40/a9/7XfvPU8j_t.png

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-21-2020, 04:41 PM
Ah, you weren't actually that far off, really. It was pretty much that. "Well-written but I'd never pay money for it, and if the actual comics were like this that would be terrible and I wouldn't be interested even a little." Which is perfectly fair and exactly what I'd expect from just about anyone. :) You also enjoyed the presentation of the characters themselves, which in a story like that which is mostly character-driven, is about all anyone could hope for.

If I were to try and write a "real" TMNT story to be packaged and sold... honestly, I don't know if I even could. It's just very hard for me to get inspired to try and do things that others have done before and much better. I know what people like and want, but I don't know if I'd have the ability to deliver that for $4 per issue every month. Monthly comics are a lot harder to write than anyone thinks!

Did You Know that Mario Puzo, who wrote "The Godfather", once tried to write a comic book and quickly gave up, saying it was by far the most difficult writing task he'd ever attempted? S'truth! Juggling your own ideas with what fans want/expect is an incredibly tricky balancing act, especially with how vocal comic book fans are in general. When I was a kid, I had aspirations to work in comics. As an adult? Pssssssssh, Lord no. That's a whole lotta headache and hassle for very little reward or appreciation.

I did once have an offer to work for an independent comic waaaaaaaaaay back almost 20 years ago, though. I thought about it for a minute, but in the end they'd end up owning what I'd created and I didn't wanna bother with that. It's not like there was any money in it whatsoever, it would've just been the novelty of saying "Something I wrote/drew was in a published comic book." But there was no real upside beyond that, so I didn't bother.

Plus, y'know... I'm just r e a l l l l l y lazy. :trazz:

Having only recently started thinking about what sort of TMNT story I would tell, it is difficult to come up with something unique that puts a good flair and new twist (or presentation) on things while still being respectful to the franchise and still TMNT in heart and soul.

I remember Powder drawing some great Feudal Japan TMNT concepts; that would be cool someday. IDW gave us the reincarnation angle, and Nick (though definitely not my cup of tea) had the really interesting Utrom invasion and Karai is actually Splinter's daughter angles.

And, y'know, TMNT is doing the whole ship-fest Mutant Town. So there's a new angle. :trolleye::tgrumble:

Puzo is the man. Love his stuff, and I've heard that before. I can't really wrap my mind around what he might have done in the medium of comics.

Leo656
10-21-2020, 04:46 PM
Puzo gets credit for the Chris Reeve Superman movie script, although the movie they filmed only has like, 10% if that of anything he wrote. He got the script credit for legal reasons more than anything. It was a completely un-filmable script.

There was apparently a scene he wrote for the movie where Superman would have literally lifted the entire nation of China into the air to save them from some kind of disaster. So... if nothing else, Puzo thinks Big. :lol:

staypuftweepel
10-21-2020, 05:08 PM
I really liked most of the IDW up to 100, but I haven’t been enjoying 101 to now. I’ve been reading all of it, but it’s getting to be a chore. I won’t drop the book because my tmnt ocd keeps me attached. I just don’t like the cute extra mutants running around, the turtles in clothes, and the overall feel that the book has changed into a slow almost romance book. It just isn’t very exciting. Characters act very differently. Alopex in this issue acted like a completely different person. Raph use to be pretty tough in the IDW comics, but here he’s lost all of his edge. Im not saying that because of him helping the road hog later, but his earlier interactions with her. When it comes to having tons of mutants I always liked the Archie comic but I think it was executed better. I think this concept would have worked better as a separate miniseries or ongoing book. Even the cover of issue 111 looks too cutesy. I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but I hope things change up soon.

Allio
10-21-2020, 06:20 PM
guess I'm still enjoying it main because of the Power Rangers comic which has the opposite problem. Where as TMNT right now seems to be more along the line of a slow burn, the pacing in the Power Rangers comic is shot to death. Like the power Rangers comic needs to slow down and take it's time but it rushes through so much it burns one out.

Outside of Marvel's Ultraman or IDW's Sonic comic, i'm not really reading any other monthly comic book, mostly collecting older stuff (like fables) or getting stuff as they come out in trades or binge reading (like "Something is killing the children" or Usagi Yojimbo) or simply where I just don't enjoy stuff like western superhero comics.

neatoman
10-21-2020, 06:54 PM
So this issue is basically about Raph getting a motorcycle for the first half, the second half is Leo sneaking into the Mutanimals HQ overhearing Hob isn't very popular, to eventually find out Hob doesn't like having the Turtles nearby... both of which I'm sure we all figured out like six issues ago, right? Brilliant...

It seems to me that the first half could have been reduced to about 12-25% of the total page count, we really don't need half the issue just be an explaination for how he gets a bike, and if Tusk to return she could be fleshed out in a future issue. And the actual part about Leo sneaking around before he gets to spy on Hob could probably be reduced to about one page, then maybe the part with the disgruntled enforcers could be about one page as it is and the stuff about Hob could be reduced to about two pages.

By my count what we get here could have been done in about eight pages, twelve at most. Granted the idea of the grunts being dissatisfied and Hob being a bit focused on the wrong thing aren't bad set-up but it could be done in fewer pages. An issue like this, which is almost nothing but set-up, might want to set up even more things?

CyberCubed
10-21-2020, 08:56 PM
Pigeon Pete seemed a bit more intelligent in this issue, but he didn't get much dialogue so it's hard to say. Herman and Ray seem to still be with Hob too.

wyze2099
10-22-2020, 01:20 AM
I liked the issue. The motorcycle race with Tusk was fun, though this makes me wonder if gasoline is still being shipped into Mutant Town in enough quantities to make the continued running of vehicles worthwhile. I guess so.

It was nice seeing Raph and Alopex on a date. I like her playful banter mode whenever she's interacting with Raph.

And a cute detail I appreciated: the traffic-light style red, yellow, and green ellipses in Alopex's speech balloon as she signaled the start of the race. Nice graphic detail fitting for the drag race.

Leo's stealth mission in the Mutanimal HQ was intriguing, although I did find it odd that he didn't notice the Weasels. Guess they learned a lot from the classes. And Leo's disguises were fun, especially the tourist shirt and sunglasses. I always like seeing the stealth and disguise aspects of ninjutsu come into play.

I was hoping to learn the name of the octopus mutant, but it wasn't given unless I missed it. I did like that the fight with Leo was so one-sided in Leo's favor, though props to the octopus guy for actually being healthy enough to make it back to HQ, let alone give a debriefing after that beating.

The issue had several fights, a lot of conflict, a ninja stealth section, and some cute moments. So yeah, I liked the issue, and I'm curious to see where the storyline goes from here.

TigerClaw
10-22-2020, 05:51 AM
I read the issue last night. I thought it was pretty good. Good to see a lot more of Raph and Alopex. The whole thing with Leo sneaking into the Mutanimals base was pretty cool.

And it seems like Old Hob is having some second thoughts on things. Don't know what but it could because of what he's done.

Diorm
10-22-2020, 07:53 AM
I'm following a group of TMNT collector on Facebook. And there is that post right now about the arc from 101-110 and they all seems to find it boring and almost to the point of giving up.
Then someone talked about the "Fan comics" that are really good. Some other guy said he heard it was a guy named "Andrew" who made those. A lot of people expressed their interested to find them. I sent them in the right direction ;)

ChosenOne
10-22-2020, 11:53 AM
I was hoping to learn the name of the octopus mutant, but it wasn't given unless I missed it. I did like that the fight with Leo was so one-sided in Leo's favor, though props to the octopus guy for actually being healthy enough to make it back to HQ, let alone give a debriefing after that beating.

Same here. Even though I had already seen the preview, I half-expected Leo to chomp down on one of octopus guy's tentacles to break free during the fight. It'll be a waste if that doesn't happen at some other point down the line.

lonewarrior20
10-22-2020, 11:56 AM
Same here. Even though I had already seen the preview, I half-expected Leo to chomp down on one of octopus guy's tentacles to break free during the fight. It'll be a waste if that doesn't happen at some other point down the line.

Not to mention he blinded leo with ink.

ChosenOne
10-22-2020, 12:45 PM
Not to mention he blinded leo with ink.

Literally a dirty fighter! :D

Ninjinister
10-22-2020, 08:39 PM
So this issue is basically about Raph getting a motorcycle for the first half, the second half is Leo sneaking into the Mutanimals HQ overhearing Hob isn't very popular, to eventually find out Hob doesn't like having the Turtles nearby... both of which I'm sure we all figured out like six issues ago, right? Brilliant...

It seems to me that the first half could have been reduced to about 12-25% of the total page count, we really don't need half the issue just be an explaination for how he gets a bike, and if Tusk to return she could be fleshed out in a future issue. And the actual part about Leo sneaking around before he gets to spy on Hob could probably be reduced to about one page, then maybe the part with the disgruntled enforcers could be about one page as it is and the stuff about Hob could be reduced to about two pages.

By my count what we get here could have been done in about eight pages, twelve at most. Granted the idea of the grunts being dissatisfied and Hob being a bit focused on the wrong thing aren't bad set-up but it could be done in fewer pages. An issue like this, which is almost nothing but set-up, might want to set up even more things?

It's about the journey, not the destination. People who I talked to who love motorcycles and read the book were thrilled about the first portion. A lot of people also liked Leo doing The Ninja Thing complete with disguises.

TigerClaw
10-22-2020, 09:34 PM
One thing I noticed about this issue and I don't know if anyone ever brought it up. But it looks like those mutant weasels might have been animal born then human born. As soon as one of them yelled out DADA! Its more then likely that they are another result of Old Hob creating more mutants.

Also how Old Hob reacted to seeing them and then trying to apologize for what he did to them.

Really hope "Mutant Town" will end soon for good and children (weasels & albino), amoureous relationships (same or opposite sex), fifth wheel on a cart (Jennika) - all will disappear. Turtles will again fight the Foot Clan, Shredder, B&R, Krang, Ch'rell, Hob, and Tom Waltz returns to writing. I LOVED the first 100 issues, but can't stand 101-onward. It's like watching Rise after loving 2003 and 2012. Hope this nightmare will end soon. And don't care about Last Ronin. Dear IDW, please make really good main series issues again! Please!

Do not want to offend anyone of the creative team, but can't remain silent any longer. Thank you for the stage.
Not gonna happen its hear to stay. They are done with dealing with the Foot Clan for the time being. Right now they started there own clan to honor Splinter and are protecting the citizens of Mutant Town. The Foot Clan will no doubt make some appearances once in a while. But for now this series is moving forward and expanding on other areas.

Leo656
10-22-2020, 11:18 PM
I got curious and went poking around to see what the book's sales numbers have been for about the past year or so. I can only find sales numbers from the first quarter or this year, but if you look from last Summer through Early-Spring, those sales numbers do tell an interesting tale...

July.: TMNT #96 - 22,752
Aug.: TMNT #97 - 38,977
Sept.: TMNT #98 - 34,373
Oct.: TMNT #99 - 21,860
Dec.: TMNT #100 - 53,954
Jan.: TMNT #101 - 20,470
Jan.: TMNT #102 - 13,780
Feb.: TMNT #103 - 15,253
Mar.: TMNT #104 - 14,869

Obviously this excludes the various mini-series that came out around the same time. And I have no idea how the hiatus affected things from April-onward, since I can't find those numbers.

Allowing for all that, though... Ouch. Obviously #100's sales were artificially boosted by being a "Major Milestone" issue, and issue #101 was more in line with the book's standard sales going by the previous few months... but that's a helluva dip after that. This book's numbers seem "jumpy" and uneven in general, anyway, but at a glance, one could be forgiven for concluding that the "new direction" hasn't exactly been a hit. More than HALF of the people who bought the book last Summer have since disappeared for whatever reason. Again, mid-to-high 30s seems a bit artificially high for this series anyway, with sales in the 20,000 range apparently being much more typical overall, but even "just" a drop from 20,000 to 15,000 means that they lost a full quarter of their readership since the shift to the "Mutant Town" storyline.

That's something to seriously consider. #100 is an outlier, so disregard that number, and start with #101 and consider that the start of the "new direction". Over 20,000 people decided to give it a shot, but since then about 5,000-7,000 of them apparently didn't like what they saw. Those aren't inconsequential numbers.

I'm very curious to know what sales have been like since #105. I can only imagine they've dipped further, since it looks like almost all books' sales have dropped significantly since the pandemic hit. If we assume that they lost some more people due to forces outside their control (since that happened industry-wide) and estimate around 10,000 sales for TMNT just as a nice round number... that means potentially up to HALF the people who stuck around for #101 have since found better things to do. Again, it's not IDW's fault there was a pandemic that affected sales across the entire comic book industry, but it couldn't have come at a worse time for this book, specifically.

That pattern doesn't bode well, to be perfectly blunt. There's no way this storyline is "here to stay" UNLESS the book just plain gets cancelled before there's a resolution to it. Loss of readership is loss of revenue, and at the end of the day they're still running a business. They can't just bleed out another 3-5,000 people every two or three months. It's not likely that will actually happen - I expect it to pretty much stabilize between 10,000 and 12,000 at a guess - but if that pattern of loss DID continue, it would be catastrophic.

Put simply, this story arc simply can't keep going much longer for their own sake. They absolutely want to get those numbers back into the mid-20s, at the absolute least, not the low-teens. And it's safe to say that they haven't exactly won people over or attracted any new readers with "Mutant Town". Quite rather the opposite. It's all there in black and white.

I find it interesting that the first "big dip" came right around the time news of Jennika as the Fifth Turtle came out, right before #100. And things have just gone exponentially from there.

I think at the absolute least, it's safe to say that they over-estimated how well-received this whole entire experiment would be. I know that they had a predetermined endpoint in mind for the story, supposedly, but it wouldn't surprise me if they were already talking about moving things up a little bit, just to see if they can entice some of those wayward people back. It's been known to happen.

"Interesting".

Zog The Magnificent
10-23-2020, 12:45 AM
Y'know, regardless of whether or not you like Mutant Town, even if the sales numbers drop, I'm not super worried. If Mirage could survive the Guest Era, then IDW can survive this.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 03:33 AM
Not even close to the same situation, though. Mirage was independent and self-published. IDW has to pay a hefty licensing fee just to be able to produce the book, and they have to pay those fees whether they make a profit on the book or not. Whether sales were Up or Down, the decision to continue publishing the book at any point in time was entirely at the discretion of Mirage. The people at IDW don't have the same leeway. There's a lot of other factors involved now. It's just not a comparable situation at all, in any way, shape or form.

Personally, I don't think it'll get unceremoniously cancelled (at least not for real) so long as IDW is around. BUT, they've been reportedly on very shaky ground as a company anyway, for the last couple years, so that's its own problem. What I rather think might happen instead, is that the finish line of the Mutant Town storyline will maybe get bumped up to happen a few issues sooner if sales continue to slip. If they slip TOO far, they might pull the old "Cancel and immediately relaunch with a brand new #1 issue" gimmick, to better illustrate that it's another fresh start. That would be pretty desperate, but it's not like they'd be the first ones to do that.

But no, I don't think they'll "really" cancel it unless IDW itself shuts down. Which.... eh? Definitely not rooting for that to happen, but them being in rough shape is one of the more persistent rumors of the last two years or so. It's just a tough time for everybody in the comics game, right now.

skylord
10-23-2020, 10:55 AM
Sep 18 - 9,946
Oct 18 - 9,968
Nov 18 - 11,341
Dec 18 - 10,230
Jan 19 - 9,805
Feb 19 - 10,010
Mar 19 - 9,887
------------------
Jan 20 - 13780
Feb 20 - 15,253
Mar 20 - 14,869

It's not hard to pick numbers that make the comic look like it's doing pretty well. A comic that barely broke 10k hovering between 13-15k isn't that bad. I'm pretty certain publishers are aware of the sudden spike/fall of sales during big events.

Case in point sales after the issue 50 spike

#50 - 33,553
#51 - 23,247
#52 - 20,384
#53 - 17,190
#54 - 16,769
#55 - 19,631
#56 - 16,332

Keep in mind this is half a run ago. Almost all long running media will lose regular viewers/readers over time. I don't think there's much reason to be all doom and gloom on the sales numbers.

ChosenOne
10-23-2020, 11:03 AM
Jan 20 - 13780
Feb 20 - 15,253
Mar 20 - 14,869

This is pretty damn good! I'm too lazy to look it up myself, which issues are these?

skylord
10-23-2020, 11:04 AM
I should've used Leo's format but straight from his post

Dec.: TMNT #100 - 53,954
Jan.: TMNT #101 - 20,470
Jan.: TMNT #102 - 13,780
Feb.: TMNT #103 - 15,253
Mar.: TMNT #104 - 14,869

ChosenOne
10-23-2020, 11:08 AM
I should've used Leo's format but straight from his post

Dec.: TMNT #100 - 53,954
Jan.: TMNT #101 - 20,470
Jan.: TMNT #102 - 13,780
Feb.: TMNT #103 - 15,253
Mar.: TMNT #104 - 14,869

Thank you. Like you said, I see no reason for all the doom-and-gloom, and I hadn't even seen these numbers before.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 01:26 PM
Didn't go back that far. Didn't wanna make it an all-day project. I was only curious as to the acute effect the current storyline had on sales post-100.

So alright, we'll look at the larger pattern and we see that at one point they gained a bunch of people.... then lost them all again. Alright, doesn't really do much to disprove my point, just illustrates my other point that the book's sales are consistently "jumpy". It doesn't change the fact that as many as five times their normal audience jumped in for #100, which could have been a huge boon as it's more eyes on the product. But then HALF of those people decided that the next issue wasn't worth their time, and then almost half of the remaining people eventually decided the same thing over subsequent issues.

Not "doom and gloom", it's called "forecasting". And if you've ever worked a sales job, you'd know that those kinds of patterns DO mean something. And that they're worth paying attention to. In any business you're supposed to consistently grow your audience, not shrink it. "Well, we've done worse" isn't what anyone in a management position ever wants to hear, either.

The fact that they doubled their usual audience in the build-up to issue#100 was Good. The fact that they then very quickly lost ALL of those new readers is Bad. Get it?

It doesn't make sense to just disregard all that because you happen to like the creative direction. It ignores the larger point that the book has at several points managed to get more eyes on it, but can't keep them invested. That's a problem they'd do well to fix.

I'm also just gonna be straight-up mean and point out that 10-15,000 on average is pretty weak for a monthly comic book anyway, especially for a license as "popular" as TMNT. There's absolutely nothing to celebrate about that kinda thing. Stuff like "Red Sonja: Age of Chaos" apparently sells way more issues than TMNT does, and who even knows what that is?

They could quite simply be doing better. They could be doing a LOT better. I had no idea the book's sales were consistently that mediocre. But even if they've done worse in the past, that's nothing to dance a jig about. They had over 50,000 readers at one specific point but most of them said "No thanks". If I were The Boss, I'd wanna know Why.

An upswing over a 12-month period is pretty good in and of itself, though. Higher numbers in March '20 than March '19 IS growth. That shows that at one point they were able to build more of an audience. Good. But again, they couldn't sustain the momentum and there's a pattern of loss after the peak. Those things are also important and shouldn't just be disregarded.

skylord
10-23-2020, 02:15 PM
50,000 sales doesn't necessarily mean 50,000 regular readers. If I were to make a comparison I'd say it's similar to Football and the superbowl. Obviously the superbowl is going to attract a huge audience.

Lets compare regular viewers to superbowl viewership for 2015-2019
https://www.statista.com/statistics/289979/nfl-number-of-tv-viewers-usa/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_television_ratings#2010%E2%80%9319_2

Viewership in millions(regular/superbowl)
2015 - 17.9/161.3
2016 - 16.5/167
2017 - 14.9/172
2018 - 15.8/149
2019 - 16.5/148.5

Interestingly as regular viewership fell from 2015-2017, superbowl viewership rose. then from 2017-2019 the inverse occurred. Regular viewershp rose and superbowl viewership fell. Either way the superbowl doesn't seem to boost viewership of the regular season.

My ultimate point is that I think it's ultimately unlikely a big event at issue #100 is going to attract a lot of new regular readers. No matter how you slice it issue#101 just can never be an excellent jumping on point, especially in a world as complex/fairly unknown as TMNT. Just as most superbowl viewers are not truly invested in football, many of the new readers to the big 100 aren't invested in TMNT either.

I'm not going to argue against the base sales of TMNT being pretty poor. I don't know IDWs benchmarks and can't really comment on what they consider good sales. Just looking at trends, regular readership has never been all that high and if anything I'd take the fact that it's lasted this long as a sign that it will stick around for a while. Ultimately like most long running series with a plot focus it will have to end.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 02:38 PM
I already said that, though. I already said that I was allowing for the fact that #100 was an outlier because Milestone issues always skew high.

The fact remains that if we assume that all 50,000+ people who bought #100 actually read it - and that IS assuming quite a lot, but for the sake of argument let's assume they did read it and not just toss it in a box - then fewer than half of those people were intrigued enough to come back the next month and buy the following issue(s).

To relate it to something I have a more personal hand and experience in, look at a "Milestone" issue of a comic book as similar to a Free Trial Gym Membership. You know that your "promotion" is going to draw more eyes to the product as a matter of course, get people in the door, but KEEPING them is the ultimate goal. You know for a fact that you're not going to have 100% retention, BUT, the more people you keep, the better. If you advertise that you're going to give away 50 Free Passes, and it turns out 100 people ask for one and you end up doing 100 Free Passes, that seems good on the surface because there's more interest than you expected there to be. But if only TWO of those 100 people decide to actually join the gym, then guess what? You didn't gain anything. That means 98 out of 100 people all said "Eh, this isn't for me", and you failed in your ultimate goal. At this point is when the owners and management call a meeting and ask you why you "failed", and discussions begin about what needs to change (and who's not going to have a job very soon, because someone always has to fall on a sword). Believe me, I'm quite familiar with those kinds of scenarios.

So five times the regular "viewing audience" for TMNT decided to look at #100, but they failed to gain ANY new readers out of that and furthermore lost a big chunk of those who had been reading the previous six months. Even if we admit that any milestone issue is an outlier with an artificially high sales number, it's STILL an opportunity for sustained growth. And they didn't grow in readers in the aftermath, they shrunk.

One HAS to assume that wouldn't be the case if more people than not actually liked what they saw. That's all I'm trying to say.


I'm not going to argue against the base sales of TMNT being pretty poor. I don't know IDWs benchmarks and can't really comment on what they consider good sales. Just looking at trends, regular readership has never been all that high and if anything I'd take the fact that it's lasted this long as a sign that it will stick around for a while. Ultimately like most long running series with a plot focus it will have to end.

I'd agree on some level with this, although you can bet for sure that they wish they were selling more. It can't be a good feeling to know that on any given month, a ton of books nobody's ever heard of sell three times as many copies. I thought TMNT was this "evergreen" phenomenon and really, REALLY popular? Facts don't support that thesis. Not when they can't outsell Conan, or occasionally My Little Pony.

ChosenOne
10-23-2020, 02:40 PM
Apart from the fans and those who knew the inherent value of a #100, how many people would feel intrigued enough to come back next month and buy the follow-up to an issue that felt like a series finale, though?

Leo656
10-23-2020, 02:46 PM
Depends. I used to be a rabid consumer of comics until they got too expensive. The entire point of a Milestone Issue is that it's enticing to new or lapsed readers.

There were a TON of books over the years that I'd fallen out of for whatever reason, but figured that #25/50/75/100/etc. might be a good place to jump back in because it's a nice round number and usually indicative of what the current storylines are/where they're going. If I liked what I saw, I stuck around. If I didn't like it, I didn't buy it again.

I have to assume that most people who read comics are the same. "Oh, neat, ______ #100! I haven't seen this in a while, let's see what's going on..."

There's only two ways it CAN go, after that. Either "This is awesome, I'm gonna keep buying it," OR, "Nah, I don't like this, nevermind."

Numbers post-100 indicate a strong trend towards The Latter. That's alllllll I'm trying to say.

skylord
10-23-2020, 04:36 PM
I don't think a free gym trial is an apt comparison. My main point about the superbowl was about personal investment. The large majority of people who watch the superbowl don't care about football as a whole and so they don't return for the regular seasons in the future as regular viewers.

With a gym membership it is a fresh start. There's not a backlog of 10 years of information to buy/catch up on. Retention is far easier for a new gym membership than a 100+ comic jump on point.

This may just be a flaw with any long running medium that isn't a cultural phenomenon though. If you're game of thrones you get to see climbing numbers every season. Most tv shows have a fairly predictable decline in viewership with spikes for season finales/premieres.

Is post big event retention common in comic books? I'm willing to bet its no, especially for something that's 100 issues in.

Edit: Also not saying the current arc doesn't have problems (I haven't even read it yet!) but the data doesn't support the notion that there is a significant drop in readership. If anything it says viewership is up since prior to the jennika reveal. Perhaps we're still seeing the effects of the #100 boom but so far I've only seen anecdotal evidence that a significant amount of readers are dropping. Some people definitely don't like it but until the numbers show true evidence I'm not going to jump the gun and say nobody is reading it anymore.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 04:47 PM
It is indeed simply an analogy, and no analogy is perfect, but it still seems pretty apt. You extend an invitation towards new people to check out your product, and many do, but none of them stick around. The rest is just semantics.

And yes, if most people enjoy issue #100 of a book, issues #101-112 generally at least do pretty well. There's always a drop-off after a few months but it should never be that steep.

I'unno. It definitely appears that the book's numbers bounce all over the place and always have, but again, that's not a GOOD thing. It would appear that they have a pattern of hooking people in every so often but failing to hold their interest. That's the wrong kind of "consistency". 30,000+ is where a TMNT comic book SHOULD be on a consistent basis, at minimum, not "every now and again when it's coming up on a milestone". Once again, I thought this brand was "popular"?

skylord
10-23-2020, 04:52 PM
I'd argue that it's possible the spike was way higher than expected because of both 100 + Jennika. Press was buzzing and I wouldn't be shocked if that heightened buzz inflated sales overall. The spike from issue 50 was significantly less and sales shifted back pretty quickly too.

There's not doubt that the comic has never been a best seller. I'm honestly shocked they didn't just end it at 100. Won't be shocked if 150 is a planned end. Let's just hope they can make it there.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 04:54 PM
What seems most likely is that they'll "stop" around there but then relaunch. Although whether it'll be an entirely new universe/hard reboot OR just a way to signify a "fresh start" symbolically while keeping the same canon is anybody's guess.

skylord
10-23-2020, 05:02 PM
Looking back at the old sales thread and while the first post doesn't have much, the initial sales definitely could be better.

https://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=35767

Ongoing seemed to hover around 18-19k for the first 30 issues. Maybe that's considered successful for IDW though. Definitely shouldn't compare them to the juggernauts too closely.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 05:16 PM
Perhaps not... but why?

If characters like Superman and Batman regularly sell around 50,000, I don't think it's too much to expect a book like TMNT to consistently sell around 25-30 on the low end.

After all... TMNT, supposedly, is very popular and totally not just a fad that burned really bright for a couple years once upon a time and then gets dusted off every now and again to try and reclaim some of that old glory. It's "evergreen"... allegedly.

For as "big" as TMNT supposedly is, an average of 10,000 readers for a monthly comic is rather pitiful if we're being completely objective and honest about it. They sell 1/3 of "Guardians of the Galaxy" and not even ten years ago nobody even knew what the hell that was, whereas "everybody" knows what TMNT is. That's simply not an acceptable situation.

By any objective metric, they SHOULD be doing much better. The Whys and Wherefores are all speculatory. But I'd argue it's not unfair to point out that they can and should be moving a lot more books than they are, or have. Maybe they can't ever move Batman numbers, but if they can't even consistently outsell Conan and Red Sonja, then THAT is a very serious problem.

After all, TMNT is "popular", but "nobody" cares about Those Other Guys. You'd think the sales would reflect that.

skylord
10-23-2020, 05:46 PM
Maybe its because TMNT has never been seen as a comic book thing in the eyes of the public. Its primarily seen as cartoon/movie first.

I'll admit I assumed TMNT was more childish until I actually checked out the original comics. Comic fans overall might not respect it enough?

IDW seems content with the 10-20k sales it's bounced around in for most of its lifetime. I'm sure they'd be happier with more but they haven't outright cancelled it yet.

TigerClaw
10-23-2020, 06:04 PM
Maybe its because TMNT has never been seen as a comic book thing in the eyes of the public. Its primarily seen as cartoon/movie first.

I'll admit I assumed TMNT was more childish until I actually checked out the original comics. Comic fans overall might not respect it enough?

IDW seems content with the 10-20k sales it's bounced around in for most of its lifetime. I'm sure they'd be happier with more but they haven't outright cancelled it yet.
I discovered TMNT through the 87 series. I then tried to read the comics they had at the time but I couldn't get into the Mirage comics because it was not like the cartoon. And then they made the Archie comics which was more in line with the cartoon and loved reading those.

Leo656
10-23-2020, 06:07 PM
Maybe its because TMNT has never been seen as a comic book thing in the eyes of the public. Its primarily seen as cartoon/movie first.

I'll admit I assumed TMNT was more childish until I actually checked out the original comics. Comic fans overall might not respect it enough?

IDW seems content with the 10-20k sales it's bounced around in for most of its lifetime. I'm sure they'd be happier with more but they haven't outright cancelled it yet.

Who really knows, honestly.

Given the fact that the whole world is wired into the internet 24/7 nowadays, ignorance of the existence of a comic book as well as its content simply doesn't pass the smell test anymore. Back in the 90s, "I didn't even know there was a comic book!" was acceptable. In this day and age, if anyone claims to be a "TMNT fan" but avoids buying the comic book (or professes not to know about it at all), it just goes to show that they don't actually care that much.

Also, that TMNT/MMPR comic apparently did VERY good numbers, as well as the various Batman cross-overs, which implies that people will seek out and spend money on a TMNT comic if it has something in it that appeals to them. "Last Ronin" also seems to be tracking very well.

But I mean, who knows? I don't know, I just don't buy the "Most people don't know it's a comic book" supposition. I assume it's more that people do know, they just generally don't care.

The onus on IDW, in which case, is to MAKE people care. I mean if they can sell over 30,000 issues of a TMNT cross-over with Power Rangers, then the question ought to be, WHY can't they make those people stick around for the "real" book on a monthly basis? There are ways. If you can get 50,000 people to sample your wares ONCE, you can absolutely get 3/5s or greater to keep coming back if you show them that you're willing to cater to their tastes. If they take a bite and walk away, it means they didn't like the "sample" enough to stay committed.

Again, a lot of this is just coming from my experience in Sales and Marketing, and what's generally expected and accepted. "Good Enough" is never good enough, "We used to do worse" is a cop-out, "Not enough people know about our product" just means you don't do enough outreach to get eyes on your product, and "We were gonna lose people anyway" is self-defeating. You can't cite ANY of that in the quarterly meeting with your hypothetical Supervisor if you want to keep your job, is all. The goal is ALWAYS customer retention and growth, never "One step forward, two steps back (Or even one step back)."

It's ultimately not my problem or anything, I'm just saying. I'd never, ever looked at IDW's numbers before yesterday, but if I were "The Boss" I'd be very unhappy. Especially given the brand's potential and pre-installed fanbase and everything like that.

Frankly, speaking for me personally as a consumer, I guess I'm kind of a hypocrite because even if I didn't like the content I'm one of those suckers who'd still buy the comic anyway for "brand support". I just don't buy comics anymore because they're too expensive. :lol: If I don't have money for Superman and Batman then I definitely can't swing it for Ninja Turtles. BUT, I would if I could even if I didn't like the content, Just 'Cuz. I'm just saying, though, I kinda get why they're losing people and I hate that they're so inconsistent as a rule.

skylord
10-23-2020, 06:42 PM
Considering TMNT is one of IDW's consistently best selling comics, I'd say the low sales are a matter of perspective.

As for people not knowing it's a comic, I didn't mean fans of the cartoons or whatever. I just meant in general. Googling TMNT doesn't bring you straight to comics. In fact the related searches Google suggests are

Searches related to tmnt
tmnt 2007
tmnt characters
tmnt movie
tmnt 2012
teenage mutant ninja turtles (2014)
tmnt games
teenage mutant ninja turtles (2003)
tmnt 1987

and I see no signs of any comic book incarnations on the first page..

The brand is not viewed as a comic book series in the same way that batman or spider-man is.

That doesn't mean more people shouldn't know about the comics necessarily but that could all come down to marketing, which IDW may not spend a ton of money on. Their strategy seems to be relying on tentpole franchises to do the marketing for them. I think that's a pretty obvious flaw with IDW. Pick a bad property and you have no leg to stand on.

MikeandRaph87
10-23-2020, 07:12 PM
I discovered TMNT through the 87 series. I then tried to read the comics they had at the time but I couldn't get into the Mirage comics because it was not like the cartoon. And then they made the Archie comics which was more in line with the cartoon and loved reading those.

Same situation with me. However, the IDW comics are a porridge just right. A mix of the best elements of all incarnations and its own original takes. It took about a year to warm up to me, but I eventually enjoyed it as it took on other media elements. Now, well,I just want to focus on something other than Mutant Town. #113 looks like it will finally get out the funk I have been reading with frustration since #101. However, I really don't know as it could just be the weasels and the albino turtle grown up. The Future Shark trilogy remains my favorite Archie series story while Cyber Samurai Turtles remains my least favorite arc of the series. That being said it all comes down to presentation which is why I am weary despite the promises that #113 shows. I used to say #InIDWWeTrust now as big as an other media fan as I am I am all #LastRoninIsaMust! I thought the down time would last for one arc, but it keeps dragging on. I am not interested in mutant weasel children and an albino turtle orphan with plain clothes mutant turtles. I miss the bunker under the church, the intrigue with the Foot and really want to see all of the plots teases in the annual plus the Neutrinos and Fugitoid. Instead we get Raphael and Alopex out on the town challenged by a biker that turned out not to be too bad and Old Hob suspicious of the Turtles living in Mutant Town. I don't understand why the latter because the church/bunker is in Mutant Town. The one plus was the mentioning of The Punk Frogs though I don't want them introduced as citizens of Mutant Town, but an ally down the road instead.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-24-2020, 08:15 PM
I used to say #InIDWWeTrust

$hit, I forgot we used to say that. :tlol:

Yeah, IDW lost me as a customer. I'm happy to buy up to the Volume 13 IDW Collection hardback before completely bowing out, though.

Thinking about it, I guess the "Slippery" eel monster or whatever was when I said "enough is enough."

CyberCubed
10-24-2020, 08:51 PM
Why don't you guys just wait for the next arc after the mutant town stuff runs its course? I think they said its going on to issue 120 or so? They're obviously going to get back to the previous storylines of Karai/The Foot, the Utroms/Ch'rell and the Triceratons, Rat King/Pantheon stuff, and everything else eventually.

MikeandRaph87
10-24-2020, 09:09 PM
Why don't you guys just wait for the next arc after the mutant town stuff runs its course? I think they said its going on to issue 120 or so? They're obviously going to get back to the previous storylines of Karai/The Foot, the Utroms/Ch'rell and the Triceratons, Rat King/Pantheon stuff, and everything else eventually.

That is what I am doing and hoping for the above. IDW has until 120 to get me invested again. I know not to get my hopes up with #113 teases. I decided to not get Jennika II because it promises to be more of the #101 onwards stuff. I have bought everything IDWverse except for the 2 issue Lovecraft crossover and X-Files oneshot. This is the first one that counts though.

I cannot get into killer cursing all-red bandanas, but The Mutant Town direction has me saying #LastRoninisaMust to get my Turtle fix.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-24-2020, 09:41 PM
Why don't you guys just wait for the next arc after the mutant town stuff runs its course? I think they said its going on to issue 120 or so? They're obviously going to get back to the previous storylines of Karai/The Foot, the Utroms/Ch'rell and the Triceratons, Rat King/Pantheon stuff, and everything else eventually.

Perhaps. But perhaps not. That will depend on IDW throwing out an enticing enough hook in hopes of reeling me back in.

I was already a little disenchanted with IDW TMNT even before #101; "City at War" really did not meet up to my expectations, especially with the Turtles barely doing anything.

TigerClaw
10-24-2020, 10:14 PM
I'm enjoying the comics as they are right now. It took the things that happened after issue 100 to actually make me read the comics. I'm more interested in the world building then what came before because I seen all that stuff before in other versions. I love the whole mutant town thing because they took inspiration from the After The Bomb thing from the RPG. As much as I like the Turtles I'm also interested in the other characters that are inhabiting this universe. I find them very interesting. Seeing these Turtles finally be able to go outside and be around other mutants like them is so cool.

I love how a big chunk of this issue revolve around Raph and Alopex. It sort of reminds me of those TMNT Specials from the Archie Comics that were focused on Raph and Ninjara.

Luckyday
10-24-2020, 10:22 PM
Im enjoying the comics as they are right now. It took the things that happened after issue 100 to actually make me read the comics. I'm more interested in the world building then what came before because I seen all that stuff before in other versions. I love the whole mutant town thing because they took inspiration from the After The Bomb thing from the RPG. As much as I like the Turtles I'm also interested in the other characters that are inhabiting this universe. I find them very interesting. Seeing these Turtles finally be able to go outside and be around other mutants like them is so cool.

It's definitely refreshing to see them do something with their lives instead of them having yet again an existential crisis because the shredder is gone, them breaking up and eventually reuniting before the end of the volume.

Leo656
10-24-2020, 11:07 PM
Perhaps. But perhaps not. That will depend on IDW throwing out an enticing enough hook in hopes of reeling me back in.

I was already a little disenchanted with IDW TMNT even before #101; "City at War" really did not meet up to my expectations, especially with the Turtles barely doing anything.

That's the kinda thing I mean. Most people who read comics, once they fall off or "break the habit", it's incredibly hard to ever get them back. They get used to spending their time and money elsewhere, and they longer they stay out, the harder it is to win them over again.

That's why saying "come check back in a year, it'll be different by then" is really assuming an awful lot. You don't ever wanna do that. Most of those people simply aren't ever coming back. I've seen it all before, many times.

TheJ-manTurtleMan
10-25-2020, 03:47 PM
Do you think eventually they'll have a Raphael/Alopex wedding issue? Didn't Marvel do something like that with Deadpool recently? I don't follow Marvel comics, but I tend to remember hearing about Deadpool getting married.

TigerClaw
10-25-2020, 03:56 PM
Do you think eventually they'll have a Raphael/Alopex wedding issue? Didn't Marvel do something like that with Deadpool recently? I don't follow Marvel comics, but I tend to remember hearing about Deadpool getting married.
Its interesting that you say that because I wonder if Future Raph and Mezcaal ever had a wedding when she became Future Raph's wife in the future from the Archie comics.

MikeandRaph87
10-25-2020, 04:48 PM
One of the hallmarks about IDW is making old characters into better, viable characters. The crime bosses meeting in City at War which Big Louie was name dropped and looked nothing like the character is killed in two pages? That is crap that Nick pulls not IDW. Just don't give the character a recognizable name if fodder is all its meant to be as! Then there is the boring ghost in the shell angle with Metalhead turning evil instead of being a reliable ally to pull when needed and the sub part endings of Hun and Agent Bishop. I never expected Hun to last and while going out protecting Casey he died a mutant hater that never understood Casey's friendship. Also, I was not happy with Krang being eaten whole by neutral character Leatherhead, but this parasite angle might work and like with Krang I hope Agent Bishop is not done, I really don't like the deformed child using a robot casing of his father angle. I am hoping that he will transfer his essence into a cloned body. He was built up by killing his own father and Slash yet with the lack of intrigue in his IDW origin and his and Hun's wrap up seemed like a rushed end for the sake of tying a bow. Despite all of that I accepted Jennika mutating instead of dying, however the subsequent forcing down our throats has not allowed me to accept her, but roll my eyes as the embodiment of girl power. That is what made #103 the worst issue of the ongoing title. While I may not like how a plot turned out I don't take kindly to old characters names being slapped on new ones and having so many new characters that there is no investment at all. I don't even care enough to memorize their names. A long time investor should not take a comic that was a must read the day it was released to putting it on the bottom of the stack and reading it whenever and looking to see what issue number it is and figuring out how many months until #120. So like CKD my excitement and investment began to wane during City at War, but it was the direction taken starting with #101 that lead me to not buying Jennika II and considering dropping the title. I loved the 2020 annual, but the TMNT did not appear in it which is something CKD is having a major issue with. While I can be fine with the TMNT being in the background as the annual proved its four brothers that I have followed since I was a toddler that brought me into the franchise that I have been into my whole life not A Day in The Life of Mutant Town. The tease of Rat King vs Shredder had me so hyped that is what I want to see not a turtle and an artic fox going on a date and pigs you can't tell are male or female talking tough to them.

Leo656
10-25-2020, 04:49 PM
Dawg, you know I love you but paragraph breaks are your friend homie.

Mexiun
10-25-2020, 05:02 PM
Why don't you guys just wait for the next arc after the mutant town stuff runs its course? I think they said its going on to issue 120 or so? They're obviously going to get back to the previous storylines of Karai/The Foot, the Utroms/Ch'rell and the Triceratons, Rat King/Pantheon stuff, and everything else eventually.

Wait this Mutant Town arc is another 10 issues? Thats almost another year... come on...

The plot does not move forward AT ALL anymore.
We get one random villian of the month after the other to be never seen again in an arc that will never be mentioned again (That eel arc actually required 2 issues... like... really?)
We got introduced to an adult white Turtle girl (forgot her name) and i thought "Fiiinaallyy we're going somewhere!" but nope thats thrown out and we get random villian of the month and more filler again.

My issues with TMNT now:
- Way too much romance going on (that feels VERY forced), leave this to a fanfic site or something
- Too much pointless filler arcs and villians
- Some pages/panels of absolutely nothing going on that could've been skipped
- No sense of adventure, no sense of threats, no suspense
- Too much "this will happen sometime" going on (Shredder roaming around, white future turtle coming in the story, Baxter's mysterious plan, Hob's plan. Can we please stick to ONE thing? Its a mess now)

I'm just getting tired of it and if its another 10 issues then dear lord...

Sophie Campbell
10-25-2020, 05:21 PM
That is what made #103 the worst issue of the ongoing title. While I may not like how a plot turned out I don't take kindly to old characters names being slapped on new ones

Wait, who was the new character with an old character name in issue 103??

MikeandRaph87
10-25-2020, 06:20 PM
Wait, who was the new character with an old character name in issue 103??

I was referring to Big Louie in City at War in contrast to how old characters are dusted off and made good use of instead of namedropping to just kill immediately. This was not under your pen.

#103 was just hard for me to get through because of the plot in it.

MikeandRaph87
10-25-2020, 06:24 PM
Dawg, you know I love you but paragraph breaks are your friend homie.

Sorry, I was typing like a madman on my Android device. I can't always space on it.

One thing I noticed is, I do like checking in on other plots or characters in the midst of a focused plot but City at War proved that intersecting plots and making it all pay off does not always work effectively so its not Tom or Sophie, but just finding a point to end it and not drag it on or it will get messy like I attempted to explain above. Some plots will work out fine, others will be ruined by the drag.

neatoman
10-25-2020, 07:20 PM
Maybe they just figured Big Louie is either too obscure, too unimportant and/or too boring of a character for anyone to really care? Don Turtelli was given the same treatment, but I doubt anyone would have cared about seeing more of a character who is all about tickle torture.

CyberCubed
10-25-2020, 07:48 PM
Do you think eventually they'll have a Raphael/Alopex wedding issue?

Please no. We probably won't get an April/Casey wedding issue either, but at least that would be more bearable since its happened before.

ChosenOne
10-25-2020, 08:12 PM
I see people are forgetting how long it took for, say, Rat King to make another appearance after his first one, let alone as the actual villain of an arc, and just how many "this will happen someday" plot points we had hanging until the run-up to #100 got around to them. Also nice to see that we apparently have our own time travelers on the forum, it's not just adult!Lita on the pages of the comic. :) Patience is a dying art these days.

Mexiun
10-25-2020, 08:21 PM
I see people are forgetting how long it took for, say, Rat King to make another appearance after his first one, let alone as the actual villain of an arc, and just how many "this will happen someday" plot points we had hanging until the run-up to #100 got around to them. Also nice to see that we apparently have our own time travelers on the forum, it's not just adult!Lita on the pages of the comic. :) Patience is a dying art these days.

Guessing you're refering to me here.
And yes we have had these "it will happen someday" moments but they weren't randomly thrown into an issue and then also randomly forgotten for a long time. And all of these new ones happen in one town.

ChosenOne
10-25-2020, 08:41 PM
Guessing you're refering to me here.
And yes we have had these "it will happen someday" moments but they weren't randomly thrown into an issue and then also randomly forgotten for a long time. And all of these new ones happen in one town.

Crap... Sorry, I forgot to quote your post. Comes off more mean-spirited than I intended that way.

That's the thing, though, we don't know what Mutant Town is building up towards. And we currently have at least three other huge plot points left hanging outside its walls: Burnow Island, LeatherKrang and Null. I just don't see it as fair to say the comic has become all about Mutant Town when it's pretty clear other forces are on the move outside: Rat King, Karai (who should've learned her lesson by now, but alas...) and all the others I mentioned. We just don't know where it's going yet but it's clear it's headed somewhere that it couldn't get to without these handful of issues spent fleshing out the new mutants. Something big is coming with Null and Mutant Town will tie into that. Mark my words.

CyberCubed
10-25-2020, 09:36 PM
Honestly Rat King taking his time is expected, and we are getting follows up with Old Hob and Karai restructuring the Foot so it's not like everything has been left behind. Besides that the EPF are still on patrol around Mutant Town and with Bishop gone they have no leader besides the woman from the previous mini who is likely in charge now.

The only thing that does really bug me is leaving the whole Utrom/Triceraton stuff untouched for so long especially with Ch'rell out and about. That whole story should have been covered in a mini-series by now because I find it hard to believe after 6 months they're all still sitting on that island doing nothing.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-25-2020, 09:38 PM
I see people are forgetting how long it took for, say, Rat King to make another appearance after his first one, let alone as the actual villain of an arc, and just how many "this will happen someday" plot points we had hanging until the run-up to #100 got around to them. Also nice to see that we apparently have our own time travelers on the forum, it's not just adult!Lita on the pages of the comic. :) Patience is a dying art these days.

Yeah, bad example.

Rat King has not been done well by IDW. The potential was there, but it didn't materialize.

ChosenOne
10-25-2020, 09:45 PM
Honestly Rat King taking his time is expected, and we are getting follows up with Old Hob and Karai restructuring the Foot so it's not like everything has been left behind. Besides that the EPF are still on patrol around Mutant Town and with Bishop gone they have no leader besides the woman from the previous mini who is likely in charge now.

The only thing that does really bug me is leaving the whole Utrom/Triceraton stuff untouched for so long especially with Ch'rell out and about. That whole story should have been covered in a mini-series by now because I find it hard to believe after 6 months they're all still sitting on that island doing nothing.

I dunno, I hope it's either someone else in charge of the EPF or Bishop actually makes a comeback in a cloned body and crawls back into power. Ravenwood sounds too decent to be in charge of a paramilitary mutant hunting outfit. There's no conflict there.

And yeah, I agree, it's past time to show us what's going on in Burnow already!

Yeah, bad example.

Rat King has not been done well by IDW. The potential was there, but it didn't materialize.

How about Kitsune, IDW's own original character? Gone for a whole year between making her move on Splinter and us finally learning her big plan during the Pantheon family reunion, at a time when there were two ongoing titles, mind you. At this point, it's just how this comic works.

TigerClaw
10-25-2020, 11:16 PM
Please no. We probably won't get an April/Casey wedding issue either, but at least that would be more bearable since its happened before.
I would love to see a Raphael/Alopex Wedding. That would be quite something.

lonewarrior20
10-26-2020, 03:14 AM
I would love to see a Raphael/Alopex Wedding. That would be quite something.

they could get married at the old lair. the question is what kinda wedding would it be? Japanese style, regular, or just doing it at city hall?

ChosenOne
10-26-2020, 07:35 AM
they could get married at the old lair. the question is what kinda wedding would it be? Japanese style, regular, or just doing it at city hall?

A better question is, who would officiate?

TigerClaw
10-26-2020, 04:16 PM
they could get married at the old lair. the question is what kinda wedding would it be? Japanese style, regular, or just doing it at city hall?
The wedding will probably something similar to the one that happened in the 2003 TMNT series with Casey Jones and April just with these two.

I would picture a moment where Alopex tosses the bouquet of flowers over her shoulders to the people behind her to catch. Mona Lisa ends up catching it and smiles at Donatello. Because anyone who catches it is the next person to get married.

Diorm
10-27-2020, 08:37 AM
Arent they all still teenagers, or in school?... Why do you people talk about weddings?

CyberCubed
10-27-2020, 08:46 AM
Arent they all still teenagers, or in school?... Why do you people talk about weddings?

Are you talking about the Turtles here? A few years passed since the series started, they have to be around 18-19 now.

April was in College awhile ago, so she and Casey are in their early 20's.

Diorm
10-27-2020, 09:14 AM
Thats way too young for a wedding with today standard IMO. Let them have a real job first :lol:

lonewarrior20
10-27-2020, 10:01 AM
Thats way too young for a wedding with today standard IMO. Let them have a real job first :lol:

I think the only one who has a technical job is "handyturtle" donnie.

Mutant Ninja Anole
11-03-2020, 09:40 AM
I haven't totally decided how I feel about this arc to be honest. I enjoy the set up and ideas and plot points. But I don't know, I think the dialogue just seems off to me, but I'm no critic, I can't really explain why.

I don't think Mutant Town is going anywhere soon. We've seen futures in which Shredder leads a city or army of mutants, both in the Turtles in Time mini and in Shredder's vision while he was dead. There's evidence the mutations are escaping the town now, and let's be real, every Turtles continuity seems to end up in some Post-Apocalyptic future. So if anything I'm thinking the containment flat out fails and the mutants expand beyond the wall. Just my prediction.

Diorm
11-03-2020, 09:52 AM
https://thefinanser.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Yoda.jpg