PDA

View Full Version : Oroku Nagi, "pointless" or just removed for the kids?


neatoman
03-18-2021, 03:58 PM
I have seen Oroku Nagi described as "pointless" before, mostly because he's really only in Mirage and there he is dead, I'm just not sure that's really accurate and the adaptations might be missing something by removing him. Saying that he is "pointless" is kind of like saying the Burglar in Spider-Man is pointless if some adaptation chose to make Uncle Ben's killer the Sandman instead... Ahem...

Anyway, the way I see it, Oroku Nagi has not really been removed because he doesn't serve a purpose, rather to make Shredder seem more like a clear cut villain and Splinter/Yoshi as more heroic. It's not hard to see why that would be the case, Yoshi actually commiting manslaughter does give Shredder genuine reason to hate him and it might be kind of hard to explain why Shredder ruins other lives in children's cartoons. I just don't think that really equates to better, just arguably more appropriate for children?

Let's just go over how it's tackled in the adaptations:

The Fred Wolf cartoon obviously avoids the concept of death as much as possible, that's probably the reason why not just Nagi is removed but also why we never see Tang Shen and Yoshi gets a nonsensical combination with Splinter. It's pretty obvious why Archie retconned the origin to feature an actual murder, it's just generally concerned with making a bloodless origin at the cost of sense.
The 1990 movie combines Nagi and Shredder. Here we have the most clear cut case of Shredder being made as evil as possible and Splinter being as good as possible. Yoshi never kills anyone, Shredder murders Tang Shen for fleeing from him and Splinter only trains the Turtles to defend themselves.
In the 4Kids cartoon, we probably get the closest thing to keeping Nagi. He's not named Nagi and obviously isn't Shredder's brother. He is however clearly meant to be Nagi in all other regards, he murders Tang Shen and Yoshi kills him. On the other hand Yoshi's moral character is relatively intact, as he kills him in a duel. Shredder obviously doesn't really care about this guy either, so his death just wasn't a motivating factor.
IDW also doesn't have Nagi... Sort of... If Splinter being Hamato Yoshi's reincarnation is used as a round about way of somehow both making him Hamato Yoshi as well as still having Yoshi be a murder victim, then we can argue something similar with Shredder. He is the reincarnation of Takeshi Tatsuo and upon finding out how he died, he chose to avenge him. So that would give Takeshi Tatsuo the basic role of Oroku Nagi.
The Nickelodeon cartoon is a bit weird. It mostly copies the movie backstory but decides to give Shredder some sympathy points by making the murder of Tang Shen an accident he blamed Yoshi for. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, it kind of seemed like they wanted Shredder to still be a clear cut villain but also wanted him to have some sympathy points, and the solution was to make him delusional? The point still stands, Splinter did not kill anyone and Shredder is still to blame.
In the PD movies we straight up don't know that much his backstory. What we do know is that Shredder just wanted to poison people for money, he had no personal connection to April's dad (who kind of took on Yoshi's role) or anyone other than Sacks. He's pretty much just a generic bad guy.
In Rise he's not even really evil, he was just driven mad by a cursed armor. Which I guess means the armor is the true villain?


None of these reasons seems to really make it actually work better in terms of making Shredder, Splinter or Yoshi better characters. For the most part they only seem to exist to make Shredder more evil. If not they're just kind of weird, like avenging your own death or being a corrupted ghost in demonic armor. The only one of these that kind of seem as if it's meant to make him more sympathetic without the legitimate reason just relies on delusion, which is hardly elegant.

Zachatello00
03-18-2021, 04:24 PM
If Nagi is "irrelevant" it's only because we haven't seen him appear in any sort of Turtles media beyond the first issue of the comic. I personally like him being part of the "legend" of NT lore, but don't know that I find him altogether "necessary" in stories moving forward - for reasons that find themselves aligning with the arguments you've made. The idea of making Saki a more or less "clearly evil" character depending on how his backstory is handled is interesting to see. Personally, I like my villains black and white as opposed to a more relatable gray, but I digress. Is he pointless? I don't think so. Is he necessary? I'm not sure of that either. Looking forward to seeing how the thread shakes out as more opinions are shared.

Zog The Magnificent
03-18-2021, 04:34 PM
I think he's redundant. It makes for stronger story and stronger connection between the characters if the rivalry is directly between them. Oroku Nagi is just a glorified middleman who could be removed from the story and change nothing, as shown by the fact that literally every adaptation leaves him behind. I just think that in general, the rivalry is stronger and more personal if it's more directly between Shredder and Splinter.

AquaParade
03-18-2021, 04:34 PM
Nice summation. I'll have to think about this one. It sort of gets your imagination going.

FrederikWolferson
03-18-2021, 04:50 PM
He's not really needed,and every adaptation trimmed him out. He's fine in the Mirage continuity since a cycle of vengence is kind of a theme there. He did haunt a house in one Tales issue,and that's about all we get.

Afaik,the original cartoon is the only other version where Shredder actually has a brother.

frank_one
03-18-2021, 05:45 PM
I guess the family murder/revenge was a common theme in the plot of many Hong Kong movies in the 70s. If I'm not wrong Laird was a fan of Bruce Lee and martial art flicks like many other young Americans in that period so it is possible that the assasination of Nagi is a nod to those films.

neatoman
03-18-2021, 07:00 PM
I think he's redundant. It makes for stronger story and stronger connection between the characters if the rivalry is directly between them. Oroku Nagi is just a glorified middleman who could be removed from the story and change nothing, as shown by the fact that literally every adaptation leaves him behind. I just think that in general, the rivalry is stronger and more personal if it's more directly between Shredder and Splinter.

But how exactly do you remove Nagi without stripping Saki of reasonable motives and sympathy points??


If Saki just betrays Yoshi for power, he's just power hungry.
If he kills Yoshi and Shen out of envy, he's just a psycho.
If he kills them because they're traitors to the Clan, he's just following duty.
If he kills Shen and blames Yoshi, he's a delusional tool.
If he kills Yoshi because he failed to interrogate him, Yoshi is just a casualty of Shredder thinking tactically.


These cases either negate any sympathy for Shredder or it removes his emotional involvement almost entirely. Again, these changes were not in place to make a better character dynamic, they were made to make Shredder seem more evil. That is the entire point of the opening post, remove Nagi and you remove what little makes you feel sorry for Shredder.

"You killed my brother" is a very common trope but it is effective. And I'm not sure why you don't think that is especially personal, kill someone's family member and they're going to take it personally.

Zog The Magnificent
03-18-2021, 10:50 PM
But how exactly do you remove Nagi without stripping Saki of reasonable motives and sympathy points??


If Saki just betrays Yoshi for power, he's just power hungry.
If he kills Yoshi and Shen out of envy, he's just a psycho.
If he kills them because they're traitors to the Clan, he's just following duty.
If he kills Shen and blames Yoshi, he's a delusional tool.
If he kills Yoshi because he failed to interrogate him, Yoshi is just a casualty of Shredder thinking tactically.


These cases either negate any sympathy for Shredder or it removes his emotional involvement almost entirely. Again, these changes were not in place to make a better character dynamic, they were made to make Shredder seem more evil. That is the entire point of the opening post, remove Nagi and you remove what little makes you feel sorry for Shredder.

"You killed my brother" is a very common trope but it is effective. And I'm not sure why you don't think that is especially personal, kill someone's family member and they're going to take it personally.

I don't actually think that making him more evil is necessarily a bad thing. In some ways, I'm actually pretty tired of the general tendency that every villain has to be sympathetic or have some sort of elaborate tragic backstory. I miss the days of classic villains. Sometimes, I think it's okay to have a villain who is just evil because he's an a**hole. There are plenty of people like that in real life, and the point of a villain is to serve as the focal point and driving force behind the conflict. While it can result in a shallower villain, in the hands of a good writer there can still be a good story. I think a good example of this is Avatar: The Last Airbender. At the end of the day, Ozai is not a super deep character. He's evil because he's a douche and he wants power. The deeper characterization is afforded to Zuko and Azula. Even in Star Wars, Palpatine is not a super deep chracter in terms of his motivation, but he works great as a villain and as a consequence is one of the best parts about the franchise.

Regardless of that, and to answer your question, I think we can look at the IDW Shredder. Here is a case wherein Oroku Nagi is removed and the rivalry is between Splinter and Shredder. Shredder himself is just as evil as he always is, but he still has honorable qualties and is in part driven by outside forces that corrupted him, best shown in the contrast of his first death wherein he took the chance to accept seppuku as opposed to his Mirage counterpart. Beyond that, the character is sympathetic enough to the point that he got a bona fide redemption arc and is now on the side of the heroes. Without Oroku Nagi, he still managed to be just as evil, as well as ultimately sympathetic and a fully realized character.

As a separate point, I will also cite the 2012 Shredder, though I realize I may lose some points as it seems that show is not held in as high regard here. I will admit that the 2012 cartoon is my favorite of the cartoons, and despite the fact that the Shredder is less sympathetic, I think it still works really well. In this case, he is driven by rage and delusion, an inabilty to take responsibility for his part in things. This consumes him over the course of the show, as he gradually loses it and comes to sacrifice everything he has for the sake of a singular goal that he doesn't even have the right to be angry about in the first place, until it eventually gets him killed. It works because the story was never about him; it was about the turtles and Splinter. The story doesn't need us to root for him or even sympathize with him because he at the end of the day serves as an antagonist for our heroes, with the story being about how they react and deal with it. In that role, he serves very well as a villain and pushes the narrative forward, and in doing so pushes forward the development of our heroes. As a villain, he's quite good. In both cases Oroku Nagi was not present, and it didn't make the Shredder any less interesting of a chracter, because he played his role in the story well, and in the context of that story served it. It's sort of like the Utrom Shredder in that regard. I liked him for who he was within the context of the 2003 show, but I wouldn't want to see him in other shows because I don't think he'd work for other shows. For these reasons, I believe that Oroku Nagi is redundant, and that this doesn't necessarily have to affect the quality of the character of Shredder, as well as the idea that being more evil is necessarily a bad thing depending on the context of the new universe.

(edit): I should add, because I don't think I actually addressed it, but it's not that one's brother being killed isn't personal, it's that it makes it slightly less personal by adding a second step to the rivalry that could be just between the two men. From TMNT Entity, "I mean, I can see why most adaptations (such as the movies and the current IDW comic) cut him out; it makes for just as strong a revenge theme to have Oroku Saki be the one to menace Tang Shen from the get-go than to create an older brother character to menace her, then have Yoshi kill him, then have Saki swear vengeance, then have Saki kill them both" (Pellegrini, 2012). In addition, it further dilutes the origin because it never comes up agagin. Shredder never brings up Oroku Nagi, and it seems by all accounts that he had no impact on his life. You get the sense that this is the sort of thing he would be doing anyways and that he didn't really need the "excuse" of his brother getting killed to act. The fact that it never informs any part of his character afterward is also what I feel makes the case for his exclusion, as he isn't much more than a prop to get the plot going. You could have replaced it with another event and it would ultimately have had the same impact both from a narrative and character standpoint.

Leo656
03-19-2021, 06:30 AM
I don't think "pointless" is an apt word. But I can see "extraneous" or even "redundant" being valid.

When he's there, it does play more into the whole "cycle of vengeance" theme that's so recurring in Mirage. But for one thing, not every iteration of TMNT relies as heavily or at all on that theme. In cases such as that, his existence becomes less of a necessity.

I'm with those who say that Saki doesn't especially NEED to be sympathetic. He ends up becoming a pretty big sh*theel in most versions anyway, so whatever "honor" he originally had he willingly gave up long ago. He's probably killed lots of people's family members, so being all hung up on vengeance for one of his own just seems a little hypocritical anyway, even if it was Before All That.

I think you can cut to the actual chase a bit quicker if you leave Nagi out of it (notice how many of them also leave Tang Shen out of things, too, making the Shredder/Splinter rivalry more directly between just the two of them). So while it's fine if he's there I understand and agree that, depending on what kind of story they're ultimately telling, he doesn't explicitly HAVE to be. I mean in some cases they're definitely going to want to streamline things with regard to the backstory, and if you're in that position stuff like Nagi (and Tang Shen to a lesser degree) are definitely where you start trimming. Anything not directly related to the present day Here and Now generally is up for clipping, because the distance from what's going on Right Now makes it less relevant.

Andrew NDB
03-24-2021, 04:21 AM
I'm with those who say that Saki doesn't especially NEED to be sympathetic. He ends up becoming a pretty big sh*theel in most versions anyway

That's exactly the reason Nagi is so essential. Without Nagi and swearing vengeance as an innocent little boy, that sympathetic kernel and reasoning for what shaped his life... then he just becomes cardboard. Maybe a lot of people like their villains just cardboard and "evil for evil's sake" (like the 4Kids Shredder, and so on) but that's dumb.

Ironically, the only universe to make Saki sympathetic like that (Mirage) is the one that barely even used him at all. So like, Mirage was the one place where maybe it wouldn't have even mattered if he was multi-dimensional, yet he was.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 04:52 AM
These days every villain has to be sympathetic and have a tragic backstory,so actually seeing villains who are just evil is refreshing.
Does swearing a blood vengence really makes him more heroic? He still kills Tang Shen and is still a drug lord and Kingpin of New York.

Andrew NDB
03-24-2021, 05:03 AM
These days every villain has to be sympathetic and have a tragic backstory,so actually seeing villains who are just evil is refreshing.

Seeing villains who are just evil is not refreshing in the slightest and has been a thing in most, well, children's television since forever.

frank_one
03-24-2021, 05:38 AM
Does swearing a blood vengence really makes him more heroic? He still kills Tang Shen and is still a drug lord and Kingpin of New York.Not heroic but more real, three-dimensional. The death of his brother was a trauma that pushed him toward evil. No one is born evil, that's just a stupid assumption of the worst writers.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 07:36 AM
Seeing villains who are just evil is not refreshing in the slightest and has been a thing in most, well, children's television since forever.
Again not everyone needs a tragic backstory where their father beat them or something so they ended up a villain. And its been overdone in the last 10-15 years.

Andrew NDB
03-24-2021, 07:44 AM
Again not everyone needs a tragic backstory where their father beat them or something so they ended up a villain. And its been overdone in the last 10-15 years.

I'd agree that of late a LOT of films and movies and stuff are going out of their way to -- largely retroactively, but not just that -- make a lot of villains super, SUPER sympathetic to a point we're supposed to ask, "Wait, who is the bad guy again?" I have been seeing that and I think that particular predilection is wearing a bit thin. "Maleficent," "Joker," the upcoming "Cruella" and so on. Like, why?

But that's not what we're talking about here. You need a baseline of motivation for "evil" deeds from Big Bads and that means... you know, you need to do something. It doesn't even need to be much. It just can't be nothing. At least, in fare that is for audiences other than 5-12 year olds.

Yes, I love a lot of 80s and 90s cheese movies that maybe don't have fully formed bad guy villains... but I think we can look back at those in the same way we might look at villains in spaghetti westerns and the like. That was the thing.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 07:57 AM
If you are saying that it made Shredder more proactive... that's fair. But for the story to start- he needs to kill Hamato Yoshi (sometimes not even that) and Shredder older brother just feels like an extra step.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 10:18 AM
See, my problem in the whole "evil for evil's sake is Boring/Cardboard" is that, in my life I've been "blessed" to know a LOT of bad people. And most of the time they ARE just Bad People. Like yeah, some people had a "tragic" backstory, but not all or even most. And very few ever gave any inkling that they would have ever been Good People, "Were it not for this One Thing" in their backstory.

Most of those people didn't steal because they were in need or had ever gone without, they stole because they could. They did or sold drugs because it was easy and fun. They abused women and children because women and children are weaker. And so on.

Statistically, some people are "perpetuating a cycle", sure. But definitely not all and I'd argue not even most.

Maybe "they were just plain Bad People" is a little less "interesting" to read, but in my experience the whole "They weren't Bad until something MADE them that way" has nothing to do with Real Life.

Some people are just plain born with a strong sociopathic streak. The want/"need" for villains to have some sort of "It wasn't their fault!" backstory openly ignores the fact that some people are just plain rotten. And a lot of them DO come out of the box like that.

I guess maybe it depends on who you know. Personally, the "tragic backstory" villain trope has always rubbed me the wrong way because in my experience that is NOT how it really works.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 10:30 AM
To kinda get back to the topic- Nagi wasn't removed to make Shredder more evil,he gets removed just to simplify things. Shredder killed Hamato Yoshi,turtles want revenge,bum,lets go.

Maybe I would have cared more if we actually saw more of Nagi(he haunts a house once) or the Oroku family in general. Elder Oroku was supposed to be one of the leaders of the Foot IIRC.

Andrew NDB
03-24-2021, 10:42 AM
Simplified so it is simpler to just go, "Shredder bad because nothing or just the 1 thing and not 2, good guys good because good guys good. Whatever gets us faster to that is best."

And that's just inherently dumb.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 11:16 AM
Simplified so it is simpler to just go, "Shredder bad because nothing or just the 1 thing and not 2, good guys good because good guys good. Whatever gets us faster to that is best."

And that's just inherently dumb.

I feel like we are going in circles...he wasn't heroic anyway. He was running all of organized crime in NY. But thats okay,because he avenged his brother,I guess?

Andrew NDB
03-24-2021, 11:19 AM
I feel like we are going in circles...he wasn't heroic anyway. He was running all of organized crime in NY. But thats okay,because he avenged his brother,I guess?

You're again missing the point. It's not him ending up being heroic... it's us understanding on even a very basic level why he's doing what he's doing. If we don't have that, we don't care. Or at least, we care a good deal less.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 11:27 AM
You're again missing the point. It's not him ending up being heroic... it's us understanding on even a very basic level why he's doing what he's doing. If we don't have that, we don't care. Or at least, we care a good deal less.

Which every other version had without Nagi.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 12:05 PM
I am in no way ever more invested emotionally in Lex Luthor as a character because he was childhood friends with Clark or that he "turned Bad" because Superboy accidentally made his hair fall out.

That, to me, is "dumb". He's a Bad Guy because he's trying to kill Superman. That's plenty, that's all a reader "needs" to know about him. Like yeah, the more modern retcon that he was a misunderstood boy-genius whose Daddy beat him helps a little, but I'm still not inclined to care much. The fact that he's The Villain is infinitely more important than the Why of it all.

I mean, like it or not, "boring" or not, all these story outlines begin with "There's a Good Guy, and a Bad Guy, and they fight." The "Why" is always added later. So, yeah... it all really is just "Good Guy does Good Things, Bad Guy does Bad Things". That's how stories work. You can add different "sauce" but those flavors can change. The Bones remain the same, and they really are Just That Simple.

The only constant is "TMNT are Good Guys, Shredder is the Bad Guy". Every other thing can be (and has been) changed, but when you break it down to its absolute purest and most simple form, that's the fundamental bedrock of it. Every other thing is up for grabs and can be tinkered with or moved around, thus those elements become, to a point, extraneous.

Same with Superman and Lex, or Batman and the Joker. The "Why", the "How", isn't the point of the story. The point IS as simple as, "There's a Good Guy and there's a Bad Guy". Those are the only bits that are sacrosanct, the only thing you CAN'T change without breaking the entire story. Those are the only things between the characters that are a fundamental; everything else is garnish and dressing.

As to whether that "dressing" makes the story richer or "better" is an entirely subjective opinion of the individual reading/watching it. To one person, it makes the story "richer", to another it makes it "needlessly cluttered".

Most retellings aim to simplify. In that, it makes sense that characters and elements that are not overwhelmingly a factor in the Present Day story can be excised without much consequence.

I don't especially need to know WHY Krypton blew up. I especially don't need there to be a Bad Guy at fault so that present-day Superman can "get revenge" by punching them; it isn't necessary, it's only necessary that it blew up, the "Why" isn't ultimately important.

Any idea's "elevator pitch" needs to be something you can communicate to another person in two short sentences or less. Anything that doesn't fit within that can safely be excised. It doesn't mean that those extra elements make the story "worse" - again, that's subjective - it just means those elements are not in any way "necessary" to the story being told.

frank_one
03-24-2021, 02:53 PM
in my life I've been "blessed" to know a LOT of bad people. And most of the time they ARE just Bad People. Like yeah, some people had a "tragic" backstory, but not all or even most.It is possible that there are aspects of their lives you don't know, even if you've known them for 30+ years. Maybe stuff they are not confortable with so they never talk about that. People tend to hide what caused them trouble, anxiety and unhappy periods. Out of pride, shame or fear of being judged. Or just because they don't want to remember that sh*t.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 03:15 PM
I'm not saying that doesn't ever happen. It does.

I don't think it excuses a damn thing, frankly, because all life is about Choices and everyone, on some level, does fundamentally understand Right vs. Wrong. Even if a person had something "bad" happen to them, it in no way excuses the bad things they do Here and Now. They are still completely responsible for their own actions, regardless.

It's also a proven fact that some people simply lack empathy and only care about themselves. There's been people who from birth displayed sociopathic tendencies. Maybe they had a "secret origin" that somehow "pushed" them into being the way they are, but I'm not inclined to think that's the case all or even most of the time.

In the case of some people in my own family, it's not even a "secret origin". Their parents used drugs and alcohol and abused them as kids; now that they're adults, they in turn use drugs and alcohol and abuse their own kids. Is the link clear as day to see? Absolutely. Does it in any way excuse their behavior? Absolutely not. In some ways, it makes them worse, because they ought to know better but they act that way anyway. Especially when they, without irony, will use their own childhood trauma as an excuse to why they're so screwed up, oblivious to the fact that they're perpetuating the cycle. One doesn't need Freud to see what's going on, yet these people still see themselves as merely the "misunderstood hero" of their own story and don't realize that they've since become the villain of someone else's. At times, I've almost fallen victim to that trap myself, but thankfully I've been able to maintain balance because I fundamentally want to be a Good and Moral Person above all else. I had a lot of trauma in my own past, but I refuse to let it define me. And it certainly does not excuse the bad things I've done, that is 100% on Me and Me Alone.

All data is relevant. BUT. All Life Is About Choice. Both of those things are true. Doing things you know are wrong isn't in any way excused because you had a sh*tty childhood. Not for one second.

frank_one
03-24-2021, 03:30 PM
Even if a person had something "bad" happen to them, it in no way excuses the bad things they do Here and Now. They are still completely responsible for their own actions, regardless.I'm totally with you on this. Knowing what pushed a person toward evil can help you understand why that person acts badly but that doesn't makes him even an inch less evil.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 03:36 PM
Yeah, that's why I'm not sold that Saki's older brother being killed (or even existing) is all that relevant. Saki's still a scumbag when we meet him, and forevermore after that. So something bad happened to him, and he let it warp him. Alright, I still don't care enough to empathize.

To clarify, I'm not saying this as an argument as to why "Nagi shouldn't be in the story." He can be in the story. I'm merely saying, he's not a fundamentally necessary part of the story. The larger story still works just as well without him, and I think by now that's been proven given the fact that most iterations of TMNT excise him completely and still function just fine.

Sometimes Krypton blows up from natural causes, sometimes it's Brainiac or something else. Either works. The only thing that's written in stone is that Krypton Blows Up.

Likewise, Shredder being the Turtles' main villain is what's sacrosanct. The "Why" of it simply is not. He can be a "bad guy" for a hundred different reasons but the story would remain fundamentally the same.

To the thread title's question, I don't even think Nagi is often removed "for the kids". I think he gets removed because it gets the audience through all the Origin Set-Up a few steps faster. I remember as a kid reading the novelization of the 1990 movie, and while the movie has no Nagi the novelization does. And I remember being really confused because they spend an entire extra page worth of backstory on something I knew I did not watch in the movie. And then I realized, "they cut all of that out and the movie was still Exactly The Same." That whole page worth of stuff simply wasn't necessary. Shredder was still The Exact Same Character in both the movie and the novel even though Nagi, in the movie, didn't exist. Point of fact, the novelization never mentioned him again anyway outside of that one scene. It's not like Saki ever pined for his fallen brother or even thought about him again. It was just extra steps. And as a kid I'm like "Yeah, I'm just not gonna regard this, it has nothing to do with the plot." I had to re-read it a few times to get what the heck they were talking about, because at a glance I just assumed they'd spelled Saki's name wrong. Then I'm like "Ohhhh it's his BROTHER... ehhh, this is just padding." It did nothing but make That Version of the story needlessly more complicated. Because it never has any bearing on the plot and Nagi is never mentioned again outside of that. But, go figure, the movie still works Just Fine.

I get why he was still in the novelization because that was obviously based on the early shooting script, which was in turn based directly on Mirage. But cutting him out of the movie itself was a good decision. It wouldn't have made any difference whatsoever on the movie's plot. It just would have been longer.

superstaff
03-24-2021, 05:27 PM
Not heroic but more real, three-dimensional. The death of his brother was a trauma that pushed him toward evil. No one is born evil, that's just a stupid assumption of the worst writers.

Well, sociopaths and psychopaths exist.

Galactus
03-24-2021, 06:15 PM
Some villains suit being just pure evil. Largely universe conquering villains like Darkseid and Annihilus but some suit having an understandable triggering event or events that lead them down the path to villainy.

Strange that Mirage never mined that beyond the first issue but you could argue it was at least somewhat explored in a small way in the 2012 series. Tale of the Yokai had Saki as the antagonist but I would argue not irredeemably evil until after he accidentally killed Shen. So you don't necessarily even need Oroku Nagi to even portray Saki as twisted by circumstance but he exists in the canon I don't see why another version of the property wouldn't use. It's unlikely for many of the reasons already stated on this thread but it's possible.

Wentos
03-24-2021, 11:03 PM
IMO Oroku Nagi is hugely important. Not the character himself obviously, but the circumstances behind his death and what came afterwards.

In the original Mirage comics, the ongoing blood feud isn't between two men, it's between two clans. By the time the turtles are sent to kill the Shredder in issue #1, every participant in the original inciting incident is already dead. Only the feud itself remains, embroiling more and more people in the cycle of violence and reprisal.

I also feel it's important that Yoshi killed Nagi in a fit of rage because it makes the feud much more morally complex. Neither Nagi nor Yoshi are innocent. There's no good guy or bad guy, only a grudge where both sides have a legitimate point. And this extends to Eastman and Laird's TMNT run as a whole. There aren't really any value judgements being made. The turtles aren't portrayed as heroes or role models, they just deal with the circumstances they're put up against. They never go out looking for trouble, trouble always finds them.

Not to say that the turtles are bad guys of course, just that there aren't any easy answers. Half of City at War was the turtles grappling with their role in what was happening and figuring out what the right thing to do was. In the end the turtles brokered peace with the Foot so are the Foot really evil? And if they are, what does that make the turtles for making a truce with them?

Obviously none of this is going to play very well in a cartoon designed to sell toys, so I understand why the edges were sanded off to make it easier to merchandize. But IMO if you lose Nagi you lose a lot of the core complexity of the original Mirage comics.

FrederikWolferson
03-25-2021, 04:18 PM
Which also makes the Turtles kinda hypocritical when they preach against vengence to other people. Like the whole Leo/Cha Ocho rivalry.

Chet
04-16-2021, 06:20 AM
I always see it as streamlining. Nagi complicates the story, and if included, is still mostly a brief mention. I could see Nagi being important in a version where we spend a lot of time in Japan with Nagi, Saki, Yoshi and Tang before anyone goes to New York, and that could be cool to explore, but it seems unlikely because we'd just be pushing back the introduction of the main heroes, the turtles.

EDIT: As far as the whole villain motivation/sympathetic discussion... What about people who desire to be powerful leaders of companies and organizations that are good or neutral? Wealth, influence and an upper class lifestyle can be enough to drive someone to become a powerful leader, and whether they are good or evil can simply be a matter of what local organizations were around to "climb the ladder". If you're born into a location where crime or evil ninjas are in control, then you're just using that organization to achieve power and riches instead of something more honorable, and in that case, a person could simply be numb to the wickedness around them and view it as getting their hands dirty to achieve their goals. In that way I do think a character can be evil without being sympathetic, but still be something deeper than cardboard.

neatoman
04-16-2021, 06:52 AM
I did have this idea of making a version including Nagi in a twist sort of way.

The idea is that it starts off the same as Mirage, Nagi and Yoshi being rivals with Saki as the younger brother outside of it. Nagi does eventually decides to beat up Tang Shen, Yoshi still gets enraged and tries to kill Nagi. The difference here is that Saki steps in to help his brother but Yoshi accidentally kills him instead of Nagi. Nagi then goes on to be the Shredder in Saki's place and the rest of the story unfolds more or less the same.

Not sure how many people would be on board with Yoshi being child killer or the Turtles going off to avenge such a person, so maybe there should be the element of them not being aware of the horrible thing he did? It would help highlight the questionable morality of what they're doing at the very least.

superstaff
04-17-2021, 11:47 AM
The idea is that it starts off the same as Mirage, Nagi and Yoshi being rivals with Saki as the younger brother outside of it. Nagi does eventually decides to beat up Tang Shen, Yoshi still gets enraged and tries to kill Nagi. The difference here is that Saki steps in to help his brother but Yoshi accidentally kills him instead of Nagi. Nagi then goes on to be the Shredder in Saki's place and the rest of the story unfolds more or less the same.

Not sure how many people would be on board with Yoshi being child killer or the Turtles going off to avenge such a person, so maybe there should be the element of them not being aware of the horrible thing he did? It would help highlight the questionable morality of what they're doing at the very least.

It's not a bad idea. However, unless you want to paint Splinter in a more morally wrong light, him killing Saki should be portrayed as an unfortunate accident.