View Full Version : June 2021 Solicitations
AlZarkovski
03-19-2021, 12:24 AM
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #118
https://i1.wp.com/blog.gocollect.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/TMNT118_cvrA-copy.jpg?fit=1032%2C1566&ssl=1
Sophie Campbell (w) • Nelson Daniel (a & c) • Kevin Eastman (c) • Karl Johnsson (c)
The Shredder returns! Oroku Saki has been to Hell and back, but will he now come to the Turtles as friend or foe? Meanwhile, April makes a stand against Baxter Stockman– with dangerous consequences.
FC • 32 pages • $3.99
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Annual 2021
https://i0.wp.com/blog.gocollect.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/TMNT-Annual2021_cvrA-copy.jpg?fit=1032%2C1566&ssl=1
Tom Waltz. (w) • Casey Maloney (a & c)
For millennia, the Pantheon family have played a deadly chess game with humanity, willingly sacrificing innocent and guilty alike in their twisted pursuit of victory. But now, one member of the family sees the opportunity to end the eternal contest once and for all — a final, crushing triumph over his immortal siblings and all of human- and mutant-kind. The time has arrived for the Rat King to make his most chaotic and destructive moves yet. The time has come at last for… THE ARMAGEDDON GAME! Written by Tom Waltz and illustrated by Casey Maloney, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Annual 2021 is the official prelude to the major TMNT event years in the making.
FC • 48 pages • $6.99
ChosenOne
03-19-2021, 01:03 AM
I thought I could only get so erect. I was dead wrong.
Technogeek29
03-19-2021, 01:19 AM
Never in my life have wanted something so badly until I receive it just now.
Zog The Magnificent
03-19-2021, 02:21 AM
The plot! It's back!
Though despite the hype, I am slightly concerned. The Pantheon is the story of IDW TMNT. When it's over, the comic is over, and there are still quite a few dangling threads left.
CyberCubed
03-19-2021, 08:02 AM
The Pantheon story will probably never end till the series does.
Glad we'll finally see Shredder properly and the Baxter/April stuff honestly should have come to a head awhile ago. I think we still need a set of minis for the Utroms/Triceratons/Ch'rell and if Krang makes contact with them again, it's probably one of the more interesting plotlines going that has been left on the shelf for more than 2 years now, even before issue 100 and City at War.
mrmaczaps
03-19-2021, 02:12 PM
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #118
https://i1.wp.com/blog.gocollect.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/TMNT118_cvrA-copy.jpg?fit=1032%2C1566&ssl=1
Sophie Campbell (w) • Nelson Daniel (a & c) • Kevin Eastman (c) • Karl Johnsson (c)
The Shredder returns! Oroku Saki has been to Hell and back, but will he now come to the Turtles as friend or foe? Meanwhile, April makes a stand against Baxter Stockman– with dangerous consequences.
FC • 32 pages • $3.99
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Annual 2021
https://i0.wp.com/blog.gocollect.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/TMNT-Annual2021_cvrA-copy.jpg?fit=1032%2C1566&ssl=1
Tom Waltz. (w) • Casey Maloney (a & c)
For millennia, the Pantheon family have played a deadly chess game with humanity, willingly sacrificing innocent and guilty alike in their twisted pursuit of victory. But now, one member of the family sees the opportunity to end the eternal contest once and for all — a final, crushing triumph over his immortal siblings and all of human- and mutant-kind. The time has arrived for the Rat King to make his most chaotic and destructive moves yet. The time has come at last for… THE ARMAGEDDON GAME! Written by Tom Waltz and illustrated by Casey Maloney, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Annual 2021 is the official prelude to the major TMNT event years in the making.
FC • 48 pages • $6.99
Good lord. This boring crap, still. Come ON already.
CyberCubed
03-19-2021, 02:51 PM
Good lord. This boring crap, still. Come ON already.
Are you trolling or do you still think this is about mutant town? #118 has the return of Shredder and the Annual is about the Pantheon. Sure they'll still be *in* mutant town, but I don't see what it is you find boring about these summaries since they're new stories?
hypered1
03-19-2021, 03:33 PM
Are you trolling or do you still think this is about mutant town? #118 has the return of Shredder and the Annual is about the Pantheon. Sure they'll still be *in* mutant town, but I don't see what it is you find boring about these summaries since they're new stories?
Yeah, it's a new arc as of this issue and the annual is entirely separate.
Zog The Magnificent
03-19-2021, 03:42 PM
The Pantheon story will probably never end till the series does.
Glad we'll finally see Shredder properly and the Baxter/April stuff honestly should have come to a head awhile ago. I think we still need a set of minis for the Utroms/Triceratons/Ch'rell and if Krang makes contact with them again, it's probably one of the more interesting plotlines going that has been left on the shelf for more than 2 years now, even before issue 100 and City at War.
I think the problem is that there can only be so many "final moves." We kind of already had one with the Dragon, which quite literally amounted to nothing after all this time, and now we have another that the Rat King is planning. Either it is the start of the final Pantheon storyline, in which case the comic ends and a bunch of plot threads are left, or it ends and the comic keeps going, awkwardly cleaning up what's leftover in way that feels anticlimactic since the big finish already happened. Alternatively, it could be a bunch of climactic stuff that gets resolved, but then the villain slinks away and promises to get everyone next time Dr. Claw style, which then begs the question of why this never seems to go anywhere and why they aren't beaten yet. I just think that based on that synopsis they might be playing their ace too quickly in either case.
lonewarrior20
03-19-2021, 04:08 PM
Good lord. This boring crap, still. Come ON already.
some people just can't be happy. i wonder if leo and saki are going to have a tea ceremony moment. are we going to see april reenacting one of her first mirage scenes running from mousers? i wonder how many of the patheon are going to be showing up in mutant town, much less how many are going to be noticed and not mistaken for mutants?
hypered1
03-19-2021, 04:17 PM
some people just can't be happy. i wonder if leo and saki are going to have a tea ceremony moment. are we going to see april reenacting one of her first mirage scenes running from mousers? i wonder how many of the patheon are going to be showing up in mutant town, much less how many are going to be noticed and not mistaken for mutants?
Hmm, I'd say that Jagwar, Toad Baron and Manmoth would be the only ones who could easily be mistaken for mutants, but I doubt any of them would ever want or need to go to Mutant Town.
I think it's possible we'll see some Rat King vs. Kitsune action though, now that Kitsune has presumably found some peace with Saki.
lonewarrior20
03-19-2021, 04:24 PM
Hmm, I'd say that Jagwar, Toad Baron and Manmoth would be the only ones who could easily be mistaken for mutants, but I doubt any of them would ever want or need to go to Mutant Town.
I think it's possible we'll see some Rat King vs. Kitsune action though, now that Kitsune has presumably found some peace with Saki.
just thought of something. maybe just maybe kitsune apologizes to both karai and alopex for all her crap. i almost see the line being spoken "you are like the daughter i've never had but always wanted."
oldmanwinters
03-19-2021, 05:49 PM
Might be worth picking up and reading immediately!
Mutant Ninja Anole
03-19-2021, 09:30 PM
I’m interested to see this, but a little anxious. When have we ever had a non villainous Saki? Aside from that one episode where he was brainwashed and thought he was Michelangelo? This is new territory, I just hope it gets handled well.
mrmaczaps
03-20-2021, 09:25 AM
Are you trolling or do you still think this is about mutant town? #118 has the return of Shredder and the Annual is about the Pantheon. Sure they'll still be *in* mutant town, but I don't see what it is you find boring about these summaries since they're new stories?
Not a fan of the Pantheon. Boring. They've done it. It was boring then. And I don't really give 2 sh!ts what Shredder has been doing or will be doing. Let's see more Triceratons, Turtles in space, Jennika skewered on the Empires antenna. Less gab, more action. 2 years of boring stories going nowhere and now we're going back to stuff we've done before. "Prelude to the major event years in the making" is the equivalent of lens flare.
Or maybe Raph knocks up an alien female & she pops out 7 eggs and suddenly there are some alien/mutant lil Raph's running around. That would be fun, new and entertaining.
TomWaltz
03-20-2021, 04:56 PM
Not a fan of the Pantheon. Boring. They've done it. It was boring then. And I don't really give 2 sh!ts what Shredder has been doing or will be doing. Let's see more Triceratons, Turtles in space, Jennika skewered on the Empires antenna. Less gab, more action. 2 years of boring stories going nowhere and now we're going back to stuff we've done before. "Prelude to the major event years in the making" is the equivalent of lens flare.
Or maybe Raph knocks up an alien female & she pops out 7 eggs and suddenly there are some alien/mutant lil Raph's running around. That would be fun, new and entertaining.
It's definitely going to be boring. You shouldn't buy it.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
TigerClaw
03-20-2021, 05:18 PM
It's definitely going to be boring. You shouldn't buy it.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
Looking forward to it. And please give us more Jagwar. I wanna know what she's all about. I know she's a gender swapped version of the Archie Comics version.
CyberCubed
03-20-2021, 10:56 PM
LOL.
Anyhow I'm interested to see how the "new" Shredder interacts with the Turtles.
Wentos
03-21-2021, 02:18 AM
I was never a huge fan of the Pantheon stuff to be honest. We're supposed to think these guys are playing this cosmic 4D chess and the reality is they don't really do much of anything. And if they did, the comic wouldn't be any fun to read because they're a higher level of being so the turtles can't really fight them. So basically they pop up once in a while to remind you that they exist and to indirectly stir the pot. I just don't see what the endgame is and why I should care.
On the flip side, I'm interested in seeing what Sophie does with Shredder. I always hate when the book resurrects characters and cheapens its own deaths, but what's done is done and I'm curious to see what good guy Shredder is like.
superstaff
03-21-2021, 08:51 AM
I have to agree with everyone else who says this is boring or the wrong approach to the next arc.
I've been waiting to see what happens after Mutant Town, and I just... I feel like I don't care about the IDW Comics as much anymore. I felt like Mutant Town was an interesting concept that got bogged down with a glacial pace, and events that didn't really excite me much either (mostly due to the way they were written even if they were interesting concepts).
I'm also tired of Jennika and the overt focus on her. People always gasp and act shocked because I'm a female fan, and they're like, "But Jennika's a girl turtle! She was created FOR YOU!" I never needed a fifth turtle, male or female, especially one that detracts from the team's dynamic, doesn't really fit in very well (she just keeps feeling like a Mary Sue-ish version of Raphael, to me, thus redundant), and also gets way too much focus in comparison to the actual lead characters.
Also, as Wentos wrote:
We're supposed to think these guys are playing this cosmic 4D chess and the reality is they don't really do much of anything. And if they did, the comic wouldn't be any fun to read because they're a higher level of being so the turtles can't really fight them. So basically they pop up once in a while to remind you that they exist and to indirectly stir the pot. I just don't see what the endgame is and why I should care.
And one more thing, I guess. I'm extremely iffy about 'Good Guy Shredder'. That's some sticky territory to go into. I have my doubts it can be done well without it coming off as saccharine or poorly done.
I'll probably take Waltz's advice, and just not read or buy this...
Powder
03-21-2021, 02:51 PM
I have to agree with everyone else who says this is boring or the wrong approach to the next arc.
I've been waiting to see what happens after Mutant Town, and I just... I feel like I don't care about the IDW Comics as much anymore. I felt like Mutant Town was an interesting concept that got bogged down with a glacial pace, and events that didn't really excite me much either (mostly due to the way they were written even if they were interesting concepts).
I'm also tired of Jennika and the overt focus on her. People always gasp and act shocked because I'm a female fan, and they're like, "But Jennika's a girl turtle! She was created FOR YOU!" I never needed a fifth turtle, male or female, especially one that detracts from the team's dynamic, doesn't really fit in very well (she just keeps feeling like a Mary Sue-ish version of Raphael, to me, thus redundant), and also gets way too much focus in comparison to the actual lead characters.
Also, as Wentos wrote:
And one more thing, I guess. I'm extremely iffy about 'Good Guy Shredder'. That's some sticky territory to go into. I have my doubts it can be done well without it coming off as saccharine or poorly done.
I'll probably take Waltz's advice, and just not read or buy this...
I'll echo this entire sentiment.
ChosenOne
03-21-2021, 03:03 PM
Y'all are hard people to please. I for one couldn't be more excited.
CyberCubed
03-21-2021, 04:21 PM
"Good guy" Shredder has a lot of potential if written well. I figure there has to be SOME reason they decided to bring him back, because if not, it really is going to be unfortunate.
For now I'll give the IDW team the benefit of the doubt to make it work, if not, then oh well.
Zog The Magnificent
03-21-2021, 04:23 PM
Mutant Town was an interesting premise. I think the main problem, beyond the slow pace, was that they consistently focused on the least interesting parts of that premise. You have this whole situation regarding a new suddenly created terriory, what is essentially a terrorist cell, how the rest of the city reacts to it, how Stockman deals with it, how the people inside deal with it and how it affects their relationships, how the turtles deal with it, etc. Instead, we focus on a battle of the bands for over 10 issues and the turtles fixing up an apartment. I also agree about Jennika. She is not nearly as importat as the narrative suddenly wants to make her, and elements of her character reek of blatent shilling. I'm actually excited because we're finally moving away from it. At this point I just want to see anything else. I'm just a bit cautious about it since the Pantheon plot didn't really amount to much last time, and because of the potential meta consequences of resolving the story too soon or being forced to amount to nothing so that the story can continue.
mrmaczaps
03-21-2021, 05:25 PM
It's definitely going to be boring. You shouldn't buy it.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
I mean, I don't need your permission or anything... I just find that the last 15 issues have sucked enough life out of the Ongoing that everything new is DOA. Typically, I like your work, Pantheon aside but again, 15 or so issues feeling like someone sh!t in my mouth & now you're gonna give me a pizza but its still gonna taste like sh!t....
Campbell did great work in the past. The Raph mini for Mirage during vol 4. Great stuff. This run, not even close. I even defended the creation of Jennika as a Turtle and that went nowhere for 5 issues to 100 and then has sucked every drop of fun & life out of the book. A giant turd nugget.
Make comics FUN again...
80gmrp
03-21-2021, 05:56 PM
....while I do have my own worries that I’m tired of repeating, I feel like this is becoming a problem thread as a whole when it shouldn’t be, judging from what I’m seeing. Waltz, as much as I’m sure you know how worried I’ve felt over a certain plot development, I realize that in the end, we’re talking about work that is yours and the rest of IDW’s, not my own, and I’ve gotten to a point where I respect and accept that.
lonewarrior20
03-21-2021, 06:33 PM
it's funny i explained mutant town and campbells run to a friend of mine and he's not a big fan of tmnt like me but it felt refreshing to hear a non turtle fan say "so some people are angry that the narrative turned slice of life?" so here's something, if it was one of you writing what would you do. seriously, what would be your storyline from this issue on? going from that, how long would your story last, 5 issues, ten? then what? that's one of the main reasons why i've loved campbells run so far, it might be a slow burn but there's clues and theories on whats to come and i love the emotion that's being portrayed on the pages.
your mad that its been about jennika right now? thats happened with all the turtles but it's normally been told only a few pages each issue over the last 100+ issues and the micros, spinoffs, and crossovers. this is her time.
your mad that alopex is happy. she's been manipulated/controlled most of her life. right now, she has a home, someone to love, and a bit of peace in a painful life.
and thats my final point, you seem to demand that the turtles have to be miserable and isolated from society, full of rage and loneliness of being the only ones of their kind. their only suppose to fight, keep fighting, why are you still not fighting? there is more to them than just the leader, the tech guy, the bruiser, and the party dude. they may just be characters in a comic book but their more than just their stereotypes. let them live their lives and grow up past being teenagers.
hypered1
03-21-2021, 06:44 PM
I find it little bit ironic that the people saying that there's currently too much Jennika are the same people who were complaining that she didn't have enough development when she was mutated.
They literally got what they were asking for and they're still whining like children.
Leo656
03-21-2021, 06:46 PM
Counter-point:
- The Turtles are often crowded out of their own story, in order to give more storyline real estate to characters like Jennika and Lita who were "made up" for no reason than to draw more women into reading the book.
There's like 80 million supporting cast members now and sometimes the Turtles themselves come off like "guest stars" in their own book. This was something the Superman books had a bit of a problem with in the late-90s, as well. It happens. But it usually starts to lose people after a while. For example, as someone who only dips in and out, I can't help but notice how this book is sometimes drowning in female supporting cast members, now. It's like someone heard all the age-old criticism about the Turtles mythos not having enough female characters, and decided to try and "fix" the last 30 years of that all at once. And sometimes it feels like all of a sudden the book is "about" them, when it's not their name on the "marquee". And it feels a little forced. Others have said more than a little, but I'm just trying to be nice.
I'm not sure "slice of life" is the problem in and of itself. I think it has more to do with the fact that most people would rather read about... y'know... the Ninja Turtles. A slower pace combined with tons of supporting cast and very little of the Ninja Turtles getting to do Ninja Turtles Stuff at times is probably more the problem than any one of those things in and of itself.
frank_one
03-21-2021, 07:44 PM
your mad that alopex is happy. she's been manipulated/controlled most of her life. right now, she has a home, someone to love, and a bit of peace in a painful life.In real life every man and woman should be happy and deserves to be loved, sure. But don't forget we are talking about comics characters here. Happy characters are boring after a while.
ChosenOne
03-21-2021, 08:22 PM
I wonder if the others will ever find out Kitsune killed Aka. Seems a pretty big thing that Patheon members are now "mortal' and can be killed off, and not just immortal gods.
They're magical beings, I just figured one of them could kill another. And the Dragon was dead, wasn't he? So we/they already knew that.
superstaff
03-21-2021, 09:05 PM
Counter-point:
- The Turtles are often crowded out of their own story, in order to give more storyline real estate to characters like Jennika and Lita who were "made up" for no reason than to draw more women into reading the book.
There's like 80 million supporting cast members now and sometimes the Turtles themselves come off like "guest stars" in their own book. This was something the Superman books had a bit of a problem with in the late-90s, as well. It happens. But it usually starts to lose people after a while. For example, as someone who only dips in and out, I can't help but notice how this book is sometimes drowning in female supporting cast members, now. It's like someone heard all the age-old criticism about the Turtles mythos not having enough female characters, and decided to try and "fix" the last 30 years of that all at once. And sometimes it feels like all of a sudden the book is "about" them, when it's not their name on the "marquee". And it feels a little forced. Others have said more than a little, but I'm just trying to be nice.
I'm not sure "slice of life" is the problem in and of itself. I think it has more to do with the fact that most people would rather read about... y'know... the Ninja Turtles. A slower pace combined with tons of supporting cast and very little of the Ninja Turtles getting to do Ninja Turtles Stuff at times is probably more the problem than any one of those things in and of itself.
Yes, very well said, Leo. This sums up much of my issues with the recent run. I don't have a problem with 'slice of life', but there's many problems plaguing the book right now, like the TMNT feeling like guest stars in their own series.
TigerClaw
03-21-2021, 09:09 PM
Well as Tom Waltz has said. You shouldn't buy it.
While the rest of us will, and enjoy all the slice of life they been giving us.
superstaff
03-21-2021, 10:24 PM
Well as Tom Waltz has said. You shouldn't buy it.
While the rest of us will, and enjoy all the slice of life they been giving us.
I won't.
Doesn't mean I can't share my opinion on what I didn't like previously. :P
Leo656
03-22-2021, 05:31 AM
I've learned that most of the time when TigerClaw gives something a ringing endorsement, the wise thing to do is run as far as you can in the opposite direction. :lol:
Yes, very well said, Leo. This sums up much of my issues with the recent run. I don't have a problem with 'slice of life', but there's many problems plaguing the book right now, like the TMNT feeling like guest stars in their own series.
Yeah, like I said it's a thing that happened a lot with the Superman books somewhere around 1996-1998-ish. They had a GREAT supporting cast and lots of great characters and subplots going on at once, BUT... I was struck upon re-reading those books at just how little Superman - you know, the title character? - actually appeared in some of them. Sometimes he'd be on 5 or 6 pages of a 22-page comic. Inexcusable, no matter how much you like the supporting cast (and to be clear, I LOVED the supporting cast and their individual storylines).
This was made worse by the fact that there were FOUR monthly books going on at that time and they ALL had the exact same problem, since the books were serialized weekly as one ongoing storyline spread across four titles. It was a great way to do the books, BUT the problem was that the good AND the bad got spread around through all of them. It wasn't like if you thought Action Comics was "too slow", you could pick up "Adventures of Superman" and it would be much different, because it was just continuing the story from the previous week. There were just plain Too Many Supporting Cast Members and Not Enough Superman at one point, and the books (and their sales) really suffered for it.
It got to the point where DC was seriously considering a Hard Reboot, throwing the entire Superman canon out the window and "starting over" again because things had become so unwieldy. But when plans for that leaked out, the fans kind of pitched a fit, so as a compromise, DC left the canon intact BUT they eliminated the ENTIRE supporting cast they'd spent ten years building up (some of whom never got their storylines resolved, and most of whom were never, ever seen again) and refocused the books just around Superman, Lois, and the core villains and Daily Planet staff. Sales went up immediately, and stayed strong, once word got out that "The Superman books are actually about SUPERMAN again!"
I personally feel that getting rid of the ENTIRE supporting cast was overkill. A lot of those characters had a lot of fans, and we'd spent a lot of time getting to know them. But the fact remains, the books had become unwieldy (and a little boring) and SOMETHING had to be done, and it was either that or Hard Reboot. DC chose to make a dramatic statement with their "back to basics" approach, and it did indeed pay dividends. So even though it's not the choice I would have made, it's hard to say it was the wrong decision.
Well as Tom Waltz has said. You shouldn't buy it.
While the rest of us will, and enjoy all the slice of life they been giving us.
Yes, in numbers that would get most comic books nowadays cancelled. :roll: They say that "Don't like it, don't buy it" stuff NOW, while ignoring or deflecting from the fact that they lost tens of thousands of readers since issue #100 hit an unprecedented high.
I already broke down the sales numbers months ago in another thread. They gained a ton of new readers in the build to issue #100, with every issue seemingly gaining more and #100 being the Big Huge Climax. And then immediately after that, they lost ALL of those people and sales plummeted to some of their lowest ever.
A business is not a charity. I'm all for Creative People having the freedom to do Creative Things, but the fact is that those things only survive so long if they're not making money. And again, the numbers that the TMNT book sells would get any other book cancelled. It survives on goodwill and a brand name, nothing more. IDW as whole probably makes enough money from other projects to sustain the loss, but not indefinitely.
So unless you, personally, are prepared to pick up the slack and buy an extra 10,000 copies per month to keep your favorite book afloat when others are jumping off it like rats on a sinking ship, it's probably best to can that "Don't like it, don't read it" crap. And somehow, I don't think you're going to buy the extra 10,000 copies per month to make up for all the people they've lost.
You have to look at the objective facts, not just what you want. If they'd have kept even half (or a third) of the new readers they gained in the build to #100, I'd feel differently. The fact is, they lost every single one of those people AND a bunch who were already reading the book beforehand. Most of them have moved on to other things and are never coming back.
Don't presume that "TMNT" as a brand name is so popular that the book can weather that kind of storm indefinitely. It's not. The economy is in the toilet and nobody's buying comics right now anyway. They're playing a very dangerous game by 1. Force-feeding readers a product that most of them don't like, and 2. Openly telling them to take their money elsewhere.
Show me a list of companies that stayed in business with that attitude. I'll wait. Even if you can find any, I promise you that the list of companies that went under is ten times as long.
After two years of record-low sales, my opinion is: If someone wants "Zootopia, Guest Starring the TMNT" fanfiction, they should start a blog and give it away for free. Not charge four bucks an issue for it and tell people to get f*cked if they don't like it. That is the very height of hubris, and - Spoiler Alert - it never ends well.
TigerClaw
03-22-2021, 05:36 AM
I've learned that most of the time when TigerClaw gives something a ringing endorsement, the wise thing to do is run as far as you can in the opposite direction. :lol:
Yeah, like I said it's a thing that happened a lot with the Superman books somewhere around 1996-1998-ish. They had a GREAT supporting cast and lots of great characters and subplots going on at once, BUT... I was struck upon re-reading those books at just how little Superman - you know, the title character? - actually appeared in some of them. Sometimes he'd be on 5 or 6 pages of a 22-page comic. Inexcusable, no matter how much you like the supporting cast (and to be clear, I LOVED the supporting cast and their individual storylines).
This was made worse by the fact that there were FOUR monthly books going on at that time and they ALL had the exact same problem, since the books were serialized weekly as one ongoing storyline spread across four titles. It was a great way to do the books, BUT the problem was that the good AND the bad got spread around through all of them. It wasn't like if you thought Action Comics was "too slow", you could pick up "Adventures of Superman" and it would be much different, because it was just continuing the story from the previous week. There were just plain Too Many Supporting Cast Members and Not Enough Superman at one point, and the books (and their sales) really suffered for it.
It got to the point where DC was seriously considering a Hard Reboot, throwing the entire Superman canon out the window and "starting over" again because things had become so unwieldy. But when plans for that leaked out, the fans kind of pitched a fit, so as a compromise, DC left the canon intact BUT they eliminated the ENTIRE supporting cast they'd spent ten years building up (some of whom never got their storylines resolved, and most of whom were never, ever seen again) and refocused the books just around Superman, Lois, and the core villains and Daily Planet staff. Sales went up immediately, and stayed strong, once word got out that "The Superman books are actually about SUPERMAN again!"
I personally feel that getting rid of the ENTIRE supporting cast was overkill. A lot of those characters had a lot of fans, and we'd spent a lot of time getting to know them. But the fact remains, the books had become unwieldy (and a little boring) and SOMETHING had to be done, and it was either that or Hard Reboot. DC chose to make a dramatic statement with their "back to basics" approach, and it did indeed pay dividends. So even though it's not the choice I would have made, it's hard to say it was the wrong decision.
Yes, in numbers that would get most comic books nowadays cancelled. :roll: They say that "Don't like it, don't buy it" stuff NOW, while ignoring or deflecting from the fact that they lost tens of thousands of readers since issue #100 hit an unprecedented high.
I already broke down the sales numbers months ago in another thread. They gained a ton of new readers in the build to issue #100, with every issue seemingly gaining more and #100 being the Big Huge Climax. And then immediately after that, they lost ALL of those people and sales plummeted to some of their lowest ever.
A business is not a charity. I'm all for Creative People having the freedom to do Creative Things, but the fact is that those things only survive so long if they're not making money. And again, the numbers that the TMNT book sells would get any other book cancelled. It survives on goodwill and a brand name, nothing more. IDW as whole probably makes enough money from other projects to sustain the loss, but not indefinitely.
So unless you, personally, are prepared to pick up the slack and buy an extra 10,000 copies per month to keep your favorite book afloat when others are jumping off it like rats on a sinking ship, it's probably best to can that "Don't like it, don't read it" crap. And somehow, I don't think you're going to buy the extra 10,000 copies per month to make up for all the people they've lose.
You have to look at the objective facts, not just what you want. If they'd have kept even half (or a third) of the new readers they gained in the build to #100, I'd feel differently. The fact is, they lost every single one of those people AND a bunch who were already reading the book beforehand. Most of them have moved on to other things and are never coming back.
Don't presume that "TMNT" as a brand name is so popular that the book can weather that kind of storm indefinitely. It's not. The economy is in the toilet and nobody's buying comics right now anyway. They're playing a very dangerous game by 1. Force-feeding readers a product that most of them don't like, and 2. Openly telling them to take their money elsewhere.
Show me a list of companies that stayed in business with that attitude. I'll wait. Even if you can find any, I promise you that the list of companies that went under is ten times as long.
Those sales numbers don't mean anything when they still have a lot of followers who will continue to support and read the comics. You may not like it, But there are other people who do and will continue buying and reading the comics.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 05:44 AM
So they're running a charity? :lol: No, they're not. They need consistent steady readership in order to survive. People saying on FB and Twitter how much they love the direction isn't worth squat. They have to MAKE MONEY or the book is going to go away sooner than you want it to. It's that simple.
"Followers" means nothing. CUSTOMERS. Actual, paying customers. You know... the people they're telling "We don't actually want your money."
Once more, since you didn't hear me the first time: Any other comic that didn't have "TMNT" on the cover would have already been cancelled for having sales numbers that low.
"The Last Ronin" numbers smoked what the monthly book sells. People, by and large, want more of That. They don't want This. YOU want This. That's Fine. You are One Person and your contemporaries are a dwindling minority.
Don't cry to me if the book doesn't make it to #150. I don't make the rules, guy, I just Observe and Report. Money talks, bullsh*t walks. Turns out, MOST people would rather see the Ninja Turtles doing Ninja Turtle Things, and not Zootopia Fanfic. Go figure! What a shocking development. I never would have guessed that 30,000 people would all jump off the comic once it became a longform plot about a bunch of furries sitting around talking instead of actually doing much of anything.
Again, when it gets cancelled, don't cry to me. You've all been warned. Goodwill doesn't keep the lights on. They need money. Paying customers. That's the end of it.
TigerClaw
03-22-2021, 05:51 AM
So they're running a charity? :lol: No, they're not. They need consistent steady readership in order to survive. People saying on FB and Twitter how much they love the direction isn't worth squat. They have to MAKE MONEY or the book is going to go away sooner than you want it to. It's that simple.
"Followers" means nothing. CUSTOMERS. Actual, paying customers. You know... the people they're telling "We don't actually want your money."
Once more, since you didn't hear me the first time: Any other comic that didn't have "TMNT" on the cover would have already been cancelled for having sales numbers that low.
"The Last Ronin" numbers smoked what the monthly book sells. People, by and large, want more of That. They don't want This. YOU want This. That's Fine. You are One Person and your contemporaries are a dwindling minority.
Don't cry to me if the book doesn't make it to #150. I don't make the rules, guy, I just Observe and Report. Money talks, bullsh*t walks. Turns out, MOST people would rather see the Ninja Turtles doing Ninja Turtle Things, and not Zootopia Fanfic. Go figure! What a shocking development. I never would have guessed that 30,000 people would all jump off the comic once it became a longform plot about a bunch of furries sitting around talking instead of actually doing much of anything.
Again, when it gets cancelled, don't cry to me. You've all been warned. Goodwill doesn't keep the lights on. They need money. Paying customers. That's the end of it.
The comics will be fine, People do read it. So its not about whether they will continue to make the money, They most certainly are. Since when did you become an expert on sales number? Most of the writers and artist tend to avoid the forum because of people like you.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 06:39 AM
I've been a comic book reader for a long time, pal. I've had plenty of books I liked get cancelled because other people didn't buy them. It is a thing that happens. "The Power Of Love" can't keep a book in print if they're not making any money.
As I said, I already went month-by-month months ago in another thread and illustrated how the book's sales hit unprecedented highs leading up to #100, and then dropped like a stone (some months having some of the lowest sales they ever had). I'm not gonna bother looking it up again, I have sh*t to do.
It's not rocket science, though. They went from like 15,000 readers per month on average, to about 50,000 readers around #100 or whatever the actual sales number was... THEN two months later they were at about 10,000 again.
Which means that almost 40,000 more people than their normal monthly average decided to take a look at the book, and ALL of them immediately said "Nah, I don't like this," and walked away from it. Some months, they got out-sold by He-Man. HE-MAN!!! And look, that's great for ME, I think He-Man is awesome and TMNT is pretty stupid. BUT. Even I know that nobody in 2020/2021 gives a crap about He-Man... yet apparently, at least some months, his comics can sell more copies than TMNT can. That's pitiful.
The monthly TMNT comic moves about 10-15,000 per month, when sales figures are made public (read: "When the numbers aren't so low they're embarrassed to make them public"). Again, MOST books would get cancelled for that. IDW clearly makes enough money from other books to let things slide on the monthly TMNT book, but that won't last forever.
Meanwhile, issue #2 of "The Last Ronin" saw over 130,000 copies printed. 130,000. 13,000, to 130,000.
In WHAT universe do more people want to read something like the monthly comic over something like Last Ronin? Supply and Demand. Supply. And. Demand.
YOU like the book the way it is. You and a very, very small number of other people. But you're outvoted. MOST people want Something Else. Numbers don't lie. You can't spin sh*t like this. Not when a TMNT book that couldn't be more different than this Zootopia sh*t comes out at the exact same time and sets sales records the TMNT brand has never seen in its entire existence. The monthly book would need a rocket up its proverbial ass to sell 130,000 copies. It never has, and it never will.
You have this serious problem, TigerClaw, where you refuse to ever accept that your subjective Opinion has no place in Objective FACT. And this is why nobody ever pays any attention to you. You're nothing but a mark. "Well, *I* like this thing!" You're allowed to like it. But it's driving the book's sales into the ground and it IS going to get cancelled sooner than later if things don't improve. That's REALITY. That's not what I'm HOPING for but it IS what's going to happen if something doesn't change. Denying that isn't going to help anything, it's only going to make it worse.
And like I said, WHEN it gets cancelled, I'm going to laugh my ass off at you sitting there wondering out loud HOW it happened and why.
Just repeat "13,000 versus 130,000", over and over again. Write it on the chalkboard a hundred times, until it finally f*cking sinks in.
When a quick Google search turns up multiple online threads about "How does the IDW TMNT comic stay in print with sales this bad?"... guess what? That means IT AIN'T JUST ME. Plenty of other people notice this stuff. I'm just perhaps one of the loudest guys in the room, but we're all thinking the same thing.
In fact, when I simply Google "IDW TMNT Sales", I get more stuff about "How does this book even stay in print?" than I do actual sales numbers.
Imagine That! :lol:
But no, sure, yeah, Everything Is Fine. :trazz: Whatever you say, Champ.
hypered1
03-22-2021, 07:13 AM
Meanwhile, issue #2 of "The Last Ronin" saw over 130,000 copies printed. 130,000. That means Last Ronin sold what an average monthly TMNT comic sells, times a hundred. Times a hundred. 13,000, to 130,000.
A person doesn't have to be "an expert" to figure these things out. They just have to not be a complete f*cking idiot and know how to do math.
Congrats for proving that you're an idiot: 130,000 is TEN times more than 13,000 not 100, even a 5th grader could get that right.
And Tigerclaw is correct when they say the creators avoid this forum because of all the negative commentary from people who are perpetually miserable and can't accept that not everyone agrees with their perspective.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 07:23 AM
You're right, I type fast when I'm angry, thus mistakes will happen. :lol: I accidentally typed "1300" instead of "13,000" into my calculator when doing the division. Whoops! :lol: It happens. "Thanks" for catching it so I could fix it, but really, no reason to be so salty about it, Champ. Maybe I could type numbers into my phone if I weren't shaking with rage every time the guy tries to reply to me. :trazz:
Edited that part out, but also took out some of the meaner bits because my problems with TC aren't personal. I just can't stand his bit where people say "The sky is Blue" and he insists that it's Pink. I try and be patient and kind with him but he makes it incredibly difficult. So I took out some of the things I said that were maybe Too Mean.
And I give so much of a sh*t what thin-skinned Nancies who charge exorbitant fees for their work but can't take any criticism think about this place. If people don't like their book, they should y'know, Do Better. Not yell at people for not buying it. That's the attitude that's gonna tank the book completely and it will not be MY fault.
lonewarrior20
03-22-2021, 07:25 AM
You think here is bad, you should see some of the tmnt threads on 4chans co. One guys obsessed with campbells gender and blames sophie for everything, even before 100. That's also the other thing why sales were most likely high. It was issue 100, people think it might be valuable in the future. Look how crazy they were in the 90's with the different variety of holographic covers with marvel. All we really are is a niche in the world of the comic industry. Remember this whole thing started with 2 guys in a non existent studio about a parody comic.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 07:33 AM
Obviously any book's Issue #100 is going to have an inflated readership, that's a given. just like the Grand Opening of a restaurant is going to get a lot of traffic from curious buyers.
If your product is strong, you can at least keep SOME of those people, though. That's the point I'm trying to make.
The IDW book sold an increase month-over-month up through issue #100. Obviously some people were speculators, but if the book had actually hooked them, then they wouldn't have plummeted down to under 15,000 again immediately.
About 40,000 people read the book but didn't like it enough to KEEP buying it.
That's Bad. I'm sorry, but there's no universe where that's a GOOD thing.
superstaff
03-22-2021, 07:35 AM
And Tigerclaw is correct when they say the creators avoid this forum because of all the negative commentary from people who are perpetually miserable and can't accept that not everyone agrees with their perspective.
Not sure why you assume I and others who've criticized these comics are 'perpetually miserable'. It's funny because the ones I see insulting people here are the supporters of the comics.
Criticism is important, and yes, there is a difference between legitimate criticism and bashing. There's many ways to discern the difference between the two as well, and not everyone is out to 'get' the creators when they air their grievances with a story.
As a writer myself, I try to take criticism into account. Sometimes I get reviews that feel uncalled for, and sometimes I get reviews that criticize my weaknesses in writing (ex: I have trouble describing things in detail sometimes), and the negative reviews always make me ponder ways I can improve. Yes, even the troll-ish ones.
Anyway, as I said before, I've felt my interest in the IDW comics waning for a while now, and I'll likely just drop the comic, and just read stuff I do like (which is becoming a smaller pool, sadly). There's nothing wrong with that.
hypered1
03-22-2021, 07:38 AM
I think it's also worth pointing out 2 things, 1: #100 and TLR naturally had higher sales because of the farfare and advertising they got and 2: any sales figures from last year are going to be much lower because of the pandemic as much as if not more so than a natural reader drop-off; people aren't going to buy things they don't need especially if they've lost there job and there's no denying that unemployment rates are way higher than they were before both in the US and here in the UK.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 07:49 AM
Not sure why you assume I and others who've criticized these comics are 'perpetually miserable'. It's funny because the ones I see insulting people here are the supporters of the comics.
Criticism is important, and yes, there is a difference between legitimate criticism and bashing. There's many ways to discern the difference between the two as well, and not everyone is out to 'get' the creators when they air their grievances with a story.
As a writer myself, I try to take criticism into account. Sometimes I get reviews that feel uncalled for, and sometimes I get reviews that criticize my weaknesses in writing (ex: I have trouble describing things in detail sometimes), and the negative reviews always make me ponder ways I can improve. Yes, even the troll-ish ones.
Anyway, as I said before, I've felt my interest in the IDW comics waning for a while now, and I'll likely just drop the comic, and just read stuff I do like (which is becoming a smaller pool, sadly). There's nothing wrong with that.
((Raises Hand)) I'm generally quite jolly. :lol: I guarantee you I laugh a lot more in Real Life than any of these miserable pricks do.
Here's the thing: I write stuff, too, but I am aware that what I write wouldn't "sell". Therefore, I don't ask people to pay me $4 a month for it. I keep it as a hobby.
It would be very arrogant of me to charge people money for my work, and then if they tell me "Here's what I don't like, I'm not going to buy it anymore unless you fix it," tell them they're the problem and that I'll be fine if they don't buy it. Like yeah, I'll be fine, so long as I don't wanna eat.
When Last Ronin is setting sales records that no TMNT comic before has ever come close to... it blows my mind that the IDW monthly can slump along with numbers that would absolutely get any other book cancelled and yet the diehards insist that "Everything Is Roses." It's not.
I think it's also worth pointing out 2 things, 1: #100 and TLR naturally had higher sales because of the farfare and advertising they got and 2: any sales figures from last year are going to be much lower because of the pandemic as much as if not more so than a natural reader drop-off; people aren't going to buy things they don't need especially if they've lost there job and there's no denying that unemployment rates are way higher than they were before both in the US and here in the UK.
130,000 copies for Last Ronin. DURING the pandemic.
Yes, speculators for issue #100 and the effects of the pandemic are factors.
But they don't dilute the rest of the story.
1. They lost 40,000 people overnight because people don't want Zootopia Lite fanfic in their TMNT comics. Again, if they'd managed to keep monthly sales above, say, 25,000, I wouldn't think much of it. But they didn't just lose "a few speculators" after issue #100, they lost EVERYONE except the diehards, the people who will buy the book no matter what. And diehards don't keep a book afloat forever.
2. Last Ronin, again, sold HUGE numbers despite all of those pandemic factors.
It's the CONTENT that's the problem. People don't WANT this. If they wanted it, they'd BUY it. YOU like it. Alright. TigerClaw likes it. Okay. The numbers are still terrible and other books ARE selling. And unless the two of you are gonna each buy the extra 10,000 copies per month to keep the book afloat, please do not cry if it gets cancelled sooner rather than later.
Again, I am not hoping for the book to be cancelled. I am simply saying, any other book would have been long before now, and the fact that Last Ronin blew the monthly book out of the water means that people can't just make excuses anymore for why the monthly book doesn't sell.
People don't want what the monthly book has to offer. That's it, and that's all. It can't be spun. People want a TMNT book... but not THAT one. It's very, very cut-and-dry.
It's Mirage Vol. 4 all over again. TMNT isn't super-popular, but kinda-popular. People didn't buy Vol. 4 because they didn't like it. They wanted a TMNT book, just not THAT one. Same thing Here and Now.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
03-22-2021, 09:17 AM
I would just like to point out that the last time creators were stating "if you don't like it, don't buy it", Peter Laird was writing Volume 4.
That didn't go so well. And that was for Peter ****ing Laird.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 09:19 AM
Peter Laird. AKA, "TMNT's answer to Ambien." :lol:
I'm kidding. But only a little!
mrmaczaps
03-22-2021, 09:31 AM
((Raises Hand)) I'm generally quite jolly. :lol: I guarantee you I laugh a lot more in Real Life than any of these miserable pricks do.
Here's the thing: I write stuff, too, but I am aware that what I write wouldn't "sell". Therefore, I don't ask people to pay me $4 a month for it. I keep it as a hobby.
It would be very arrogant of me to charge people money for my work, and then if they tell me "Here's what I don't like, I'm not going to buy it anymore unless you fix it," tell them they're the problem and that I'll be fine if they don't buy it. Like yeah, I'll be fine, so long as I don't wanna eat.
When Last Ronin is setting sales records that no TMNT comic before has ever come close to... it blows my mind that the IDW monthly can slump along with numbers that would absolutely get any other book cancelled and yet the diehards insist that "Everything Is Roses." It's not.
130,000 copies for Last Ronin. DURING the pandemic.
Yes, speculators for issue #100 and the effects of the pandemic are factors.
But they don't dilute the rest of the story.
1. They lost 40,000 people overnight because people don't want Zootopia Lite fanfic in their TMNT comics. Again, if they'd managed to keep monthly sales above, say, 25,000, I wouldn't think much of it. But they didn't just lose "a few speculators" after issue #100, they lost EVERYONE except the diehards, the people who will buy the book no matter what. And diehards don't keep a book afloat forever.
2. Last Ronin, again, sold HUGE numbers despite all of those pandemic factors.
It's the CONTENT that's the problem. People don't WANT this. If they wanted it, they'd BUY it. YOU like it. Alright. TigerClaw likes it. Okay. The numbers are still terrible and other books ARE selling. And unless the two of you are gonna each buy the extra 10,000 copies per month to keep the book afloat, please do not cry if it gets cancelled sooner rather than later.
Again, I am not hoping for the book to be cancelled. I am simply saying, any other book would have been long before now, and the fact that Last Ronin blew the monthly book out of the water means that people can't just make excuses anymore for why the monthly book doesn't sell.
People don't want what the monthly book has to offer. That's it, and that's all. It can't be spun. People want a TMNT book... but not THAT one. It's very, very cut-and-dry.
It's Mirage Vol. 4 all over again. TMNT isn't super-popular, but kinda-popular. People didn't buy Vol. 4 because they didn't like it. They wanted a TMNT book, just not THAT one. Same thing Here and Now.
I agree with ALL of this.... even the other posts you wrote.... and add that I did actually enjoy Volume 4 & still really wish Laird would either finish it or give his notes/ideas to Lawson & Lavigne to wrap up. Mikey with kids... wooo! Lol.
Get woke, go broke. Most people who like this probably pirate it anyways. I'll buy the book til it crashes & burns though just because the low print run could make them more valuable when a new ongoing starts up more in line with all the rumored The Last Ronin side-stories happen...
TLR $8.99 cover price. Outsold the f*ck out of the $3.99 Ongoing.... lol.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 09:50 AM
I do actually think Laird deserves to finish the story he set out to tell. It wasn't to my taste but believe it or not, I do side with The Artist more often than not, at the end of the day. I'm just firm in my belief that the story he set out to tell wasn't what people wanted to actually read. But as an artist he deserves to get it out there, yeah. Whether he ever wants to do it... only time will tell.
Same thing here though from a dollars-and-cents perspective. The conversation is tricky when Art intersects with Commerce. It's fine to support an artist in their endeavors. Art, obviously, is subjective. But a person can't say "Most people LIKE the book's direction" when the numbers just don't support that. And saying "Just don't buy it" is irresponsible if you actually want that book to... y'know, stay in print. Business Is Business.
Don't agree with my math errors, though, that was a complete "Oops" on my part. :lol: Note To Self: Wipe the mayo off your thumb before using the touchscreen calculator on your phone, you'll save a ton of embarrassment later. :lol: Whoof. I knew I should've used an abacus. :trazz:
But yeah, definitely agree with me about everything else, just not that part. :lol:
mrmaczaps
03-22-2021, 12:35 PM
I do actually think Laird deserves to finish the story he set out to tell. It wasn't to my taste but believe it or not, I do side with The Artist more often than not, at the end of the day. I'm just firm in my belief that the story he set out to tell wasn't what people wanted to actually read. But as an artist he deserves to get it out there, yeah. Whether he ever wants to do it... only time will tell.
Same thing here though from a dollars-and-cents perspective. The conversation is tricky when Art intersects with Commerce. It's fine to support an artist in their endeavors. Art, obviously, is subjective. But a person can't say "Most people LIKE the book's direction" when the numbers just don't support that. And saying "Just don't buy it" is irresponsible if you actually want that book to... y'know, stay in print. Business Is Business.
Don't agree with my math errors, though, that was a complete "Oops" on my part. :lol: Note To Self: Wipe the mayo off your thumb before using the touchscreen calculator on your phone, you'll save a ton of embarrassment later. :lol: Whoof. I knew I should've used an abacus. :trazz:
But yeah, definitely agree with me about everything else, just not that part. :lol:
Math was never my strong suit despite excelling at it in high school. :lol: [I took all my required math courses in Junior high and then first 2 years of HS & didn't need more while most people struggled to get them done in their 4 years of hs... ]
TomWaltz
03-22-2021, 12:48 PM
I do actually think Laird deserves to finish the story he set out to tell. It wasn't to my taste but believe it or not, I do side with The Artist more often than not, at the end of the day. I'm just firm in my belief that the story he set out to tell wasn't what people wanted to actually read. But as an artist he deserves to get it out there, yeah. Whether he ever wants to do it... only time will tell.
Same thing here though from a dollars-and-cents perspective. The conversation is tricky when Art intersects with Commerce. It's fine to support an artist in their endeavors. Art, obviously, is subjective. But a person can't say "Most people LIKE the book's direction" when the numbers just don't support that. And saying "Just don't buy it" is irresponsible if you actually want that book to... y'know, stay in print. Business Is Business.
Don't agree with my math errors, though, that was a complete "Oops" on my part. :lol: Note To Self: Wipe the mayo off your thumb before using the touchscreen calculator on your phone, you'll save a ton of embarrassment later. :lol: Whoof. I knew I should've used an abacus. :trazz:
But yeah, definitely agree with me about everything else, just not that part. :lol:
I was actually just responding to a Pantheon-based post specifically. Somebody on here said the Pantheon was boring. The Annual's going to be dealing with the Pantheon quite a bit (not exclusively, mind you, but they're there... some in ways you've never seen them), so I was just giving folks who don't like the Pantheon heads up that it'll probably be boring to them for that reason.
Now, I do happily invite anyone else to buy it, though -- think there's a lot of folks here who will dig the surprise ending... as well as the event that it serves as a prelude to... The Armageddon Game.
Gonna be fun (or boring, depending on your tastes -- and I fully respect the fact that we all have different tastes). The more the merrier!
Talk soon...
Tom W.
Leo656
03-22-2021, 12:54 PM
I actually think the Panthon bit sounds kinda neat, though... :tcouch:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
03-22-2021, 01:00 PM
As long as the Pantheon story arc doesn't involve cockroach orgies, IDW TMNT will never have sunk to the bottom of the Ninja Turtle barrel.
Sophie Campbell
03-22-2021, 03:03 PM
As long as the Pantheon story arc doesn't involve cockroach orgies, IDW TMNT will never have sunk to the bottom of the Ninja Turtle barrel.
HMMM... *takes notes*
lonewarrior20
03-22-2021, 03:09 PM
HMMM... *takes notes*
ok, if we're going there, we need las vegas rules. what happens in mutant town stays in mutant town.
hypered1
03-22-2021, 04:21 PM
So serious question here from someone who's not read the Mirage or Archie series, but what (if any) significant or noteworthy arcs/ plots from those series that haven't been adapted to IDW yet would be good for future adaptions/storylines?
TigerClaw
03-22-2021, 04:27 PM
So serious question here from someone who's not read the Mirage or Archie series, but what (if any) significant or noteworthy arcs/ plots from those series that haven't been adapted to IDW yet would be good for future adaptions/storylines?
The Future Shark Trilogy, That story arc had the present day Turtles being visited by one of the future turtles, and they go on this adventure in the future against Armaggon, This is the story arc that showed Future Raph punching Hitler.
The other story arc I wanna see is the Cyber Samurai arc. This was set about 150 years in the future, In which we see the future turtles that we were introduced in The Future Shark Trilogy. It was a 5 part story that was set in the future. This future timeline had future Raph being married to a mutant Coyote.
CyberCubed
03-22-2021, 05:06 PM
So serious question here from someone who's not read the Mirage or Archie series, but what (if any) significant or noteworthy arcs/ plots from those series that haven't been adapted to IDW yet would be good for future adaptions/storylines?
Mirage has hundreds of one-off stories and it's obvious none of them will be adapted. And they don't need to be. Let each series stand on its own.
Cloudrunner
03-22-2021, 05:09 PM
I think it's also worth pointing out 2 things, 1: #100 and TLR naturally had higher sales because of the farfare and advertising they got and 2: any sales figures from last year are going to be much lower because of the pandemic as much as if not more so than a natural reader drop-off; people aren't going to buy things they don't need especially if they've lost there job and there's no denying that unemployment rates are way higher than they were before both in the US and here in the UK.
As a counterpoint, I would argue that the media coverage of Jennika's introduction as the fifth turtle (FEMALE TURTLE!!!:trolleye:) dwarfed the coverage of the approaching 100th issue. I would be shocked if they even had to spend much money on advertising her either since most sites eat up any sort of "female representation" bits from comics.
Ninjinister
03-22-2021, 05:41 PM
turtles fans argue about the dumbest **** i stg
oldmanwinters
03-22-2021, 06:18 PM
As long as the Pantheon story arc doesn't involve cockroach orgies, IDW TMNT will never have sunk to the bottom of the Ninja Turtle barrel.
HMMM... *takes notes*
lolz, I can't argue with that!
Wentos
03-23-2021, 10:59 AM
and thats my final point, you seem to demand that the turtles have to be miserable and isolated from society, full of rage and loneliness of being the only ones of their kind. their only suppose to fight, keep fighting, why are you still not fighting? there is more to them than just the leader, the tech guy, the bruiser, and the party dude. they may just be characters in a comic book but their more than just their stereotypes. let them live their lives and grow up past being teenagers.
What an absolute load. No one says that the turtles have to be miserable. My personal favorite incarnation of the turtles, the original 1990 movie, could hardly be said to feature the turtles being overly sad.
The thing is, writing quality SoL/iyashikei is really difficult. The characters drive everything so they have to be incredibly likeable and/or compelling, to the point where the audience is content to just hang out with them no matter what they're doing. It's a big ask for a writer, and to be honest I don't think any IDW TMNT writer past or present is up to the task. Which is fine! I'm more than content to read the turtles bashing heads in. But if they aren't, what they ARE doing has to be just as good to keep my interest.
superstaff
03-23-2021, 12:03 PM
The thing is, writing quality SoL/iyashikei is really difficult. The characters drive everything so they have to be incredibly likeable and/or compelling, to the point where the audience is content to just hang out with them no matter what they're doing.
The thing is, slice of life can work. One of the best episodes of Avatar: The Last Airbender was Tales of Ba Sing Se from season 2, which has the cast just living their lives, and the overall story isn't pushed forward in this episode (save, I guess, for the final segment with Momo). However, what makes the episode brilliant is that each character develops, and/or you find out something about them.
Slice of life works when there is character development/drama happening. Having character sitting around, and there's no meaningful advancing of their characterization or of the story makes SoL boring and trite. Even sitcoms, which are typically "slice of life" do have things happening to the cast that help entertain the audience, and give them insight on the characters. ...Well, the good ones do, anyway.
Wentos
03-23-2021, 06:16 PM
The thing is, slice of life can work. One of the best episodes of Avatar: The Last Airbender was Tales of Ba Sing Se from season 2, which has the cast just living their lives, and the overall story isn't pushed forward in this episode (save, I guess, for the final segment with Momo). However, what makes the episode brilliant is that each character develops, and/or you find out something about them.
Slice of life works when there is character development/drama happening. Having character sitting around, and there's no meaningful advancing of their characterization or of the story makes SoL boring and trite. Even sitcoms, which are typically "slice of life" do have things happening to the cast that help entertain the audience, and give them insight on the characters. ...Well, the good ones do, anyway.
Let me try to clear something up here. There's a big difference between a slice-of-life series and a "breather chapter".
A slice-of-life/iyashikei series is a series that focuses almost exclusively on the mundane lives of its protagonists. Things that normal people would do, like taking a walk in the park, or going to a concert, or making a meal for a significant other-- these are the kind of things you would see in a slice-of-life series. This is what the series is about.
A "breather chapter" is when a series that is normally very action or plot-driven slows down briefly and decides to tell a more character-driven story. These kinds of breaks in a long-running story are very important, as they allow the audience to catch its breath, and like you said, they can show the audience what the characters are thinking and feeling at the time.
The Leonardo macro-series issue was a breather chapter. I adored that issue when it came out. Not only did it tell a great character-driven story with Leonardo, his brothers and Koya, it gave us a quiet moment in the middle of the huge, muddled mess the main series had become. Waltz was never really a character writer, and breather chapters were way too few and far between. The last one I can remember was issue #65, which was mostly the cast getting together to celebrate Christmas.
In comparison, the main series post-issue #100 (up until recently) had almost been soft rebooted into a slice-of-life series. Instead of fighting the Foot or Hob or whoever was stirring up trouble that month, the turtles were training kids, or starting radio shows, or going to concerts. It wasn't a break in the action, it WAS the action. It was what the book was about.
(Also, strong disagree on character development being necessary for quality slice-of-life. Yotsuba&! is one of the best slice-of-life comics ever made and the characters are completely static.)
TomWaltz
03-24-2021, 03:27 PM
The Leonardo macro-series issue was a breather chapter. I adored that issue when it came out. Not only did it tell a great character-driven story with Leonardo, his brothers and Koya, it gave us a quiet moment in the middle of the huge, muddled mess the main series had become. Waltz was never really a character writer, and breather chapters were way too few and far between. The last one I can remember was issue #65, which was mostly the cast getting together to celebrate Christmas.
Muddled Mess is my middle-name, actually! (Middle-names?)
Talk soon...
Tom W.
Wentos
03-24-2021, 06:50 PM
Hey Tom! I absolutely love The Last Ronin. For real. It's the best TMNT comic since Tristan Jones wrote for Tales Vol 2. Keep it up!
ChosenOne
03-25-2021, 01:16 PM
A really cool, Fighting Fantasy-esque bit of art from the annual straight from Tom Waltz's Twitter! (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1373067634971869187)
CyberCubed
03-25-2021, 01:24 PM
It seems like the Armageddon game after might be a mini-series of some sorts. It'll be interesting to see if it deals with the Pantheon being hit a major blow or some shake up with the status quo
slashpieturtlemix
03-25-2021, 02:40 PM
Is it to late to brand this entire thread as a theatrical drama? I feel like we could make a movie scene with just the arguments in the thread.
On a side note, I don't mind the mutant town stuff. I found the first few books (issues 1-10) very boring so I can understand all the determination to cast hate and criticism on the Mutant Town arc. Just let the arc end and lets see where the story is going. We literally got a new setting, new characters, new villains, and hopefully a new chaotic event about to unfold.
Just don't let your hate flood to many forums. There is a reason why we never seem to get endings to tmnt series and it's mainly just fans being vocal fans and convincing everyone they see to not read the series.
Technogeek29
03-25-2021, 09:09 PM
A pattern I see is that most of what we love about a version of the TMNT is often after it's passed. (This does not apply to every version)
The biggest take away any mainstream audience will take from IDW is reincarnation, Alopex (hopefully Hob?) and Splinter being more Altruistic. I would like a movie/ series to have Splinter technically be just as morally screwed up as Shredder. Nice change of pace for casuals and if pulled off well will get snobs talking about it, and it'll jut trickle down from there. Keeping the brand alive for many more decades. For better or worse?
ChosenOne
03-25-2021, 09:11 PM
A pattern I see is that most of what we love about a version of the TMNT is often after it's passed. (This does not apply to every version)
The biggest take away any mainstream audience will take from IDW is reincarnation, Alopex (hopefully Hob?) and Splinter being more Altruistic. I would like a movie/ series to have Splinter technically be just as morally screwed up as Shredder. Nice change of pace for casuals and if pulled off well will get snobs talking about it, and it'll jut trickle down from there. Keeping the brand alive for many more decades. For better or worse?
If they play their cards right, the Pantheon and Saki as an ally could go down in the franchise's history too. Mutant Town had the same potential but it might be a little too late for that one.
Technogeek29
03-25-2021, 09:14 PM
@Choosenone
Mutant Town might be too far gone here but another version can revisit the idea and do it better? Bt it might be something entirely different? I mean Vol. 4 of Mirage is how we got Fast Forward.
ChosenOne
03-25-2021, 09:33 PM
@Choosenone
Mutant Town might be too far gone here but another version can revisit the idea and do it better? Bt it might be something entirely different? I mean Vol. 4 of Mirage is how we got Fast Forward.
Yeah, maybe. It's a solid enough concept depending on the execution.
The one thing I dare say we'll never see again in any iteration is a female Turtle, not after the negative reaction to Jennika (whom I personally don't mind) and how risky it already was to give that concept a second go in TMNT history only to have it fall mostly flat.
Wentos
03-25-2021, 11:30 PM
Mutant Town might be too far gone here but another version can revisit the idea and do it better? Bt it might be something entirely different? I mean Vol. 4 of Mirage is how we got Fast Forward.
I maintain that the turtles being reluctant crimefighters/lawmen in a mutant-populated autonomous zone forsaken by the government is a kickass concept. It writes itself.
As far as Jennika goes, a fifth girl turtle will always be a creatively bankrupt idea, but man it could have been executed so much better. The reason the turtles have such great chemistry is because they cover very broad personality archetypes. The serious one, the angry one, the smart one and the funny one. Where does Jennika fit in? Nowhere. She's basically a less-Raph Raph. What they COULD have done is made her "the quiet one". That's a personality archetype that none of the other four turtles use. She could have been timid/shy, or socially awkward. It would have changed the group dynamic and given her a reason to exist.
But since Jennika has been met with mostly indifference I'm hoping this is the last time the concept is visited.
skylord
03-26-2021, 11:04 AM
Yeah, maybe. It's a solid enough concept depending on the execution.
The one thing I dare say we'll never see again in any iteration is a female Turtle, not after the negative reaction to Jennika (whom I personally don't mind) and how risky it already was to give that concept a second go in TMNT history only to have it fall mostly flat.
I dunno, sales figures did spike from it. Money talks after all. I think I'd prefer a version of Jennika that's there from the start though. Her origin is just too different to make her feel like a full fledged member of the team. I'm cool with an Alopex type joining the team later. Who hasn't had a friend's significant other join the squad?
The reason the turtles have such great chemistry is because they cover very broad personality archetypes. The serious one, the angry one, the smart one and the funny one. Where does Jennika fit in? Nowhere. She's basically a less-Raph Raph. What they COULD have done is made her "the quiet one". That's a personality archetype that none of the other four turtles use. She could have been timid/shy, or socially awkward.
I definitely agree that the big character archetypes are what make the turtles memorable. I can also understand not wanting to give the girl a subdued/passive role.
One suggestion, strong spiritual role. Leo is the serious leader as is and he sort of has the spiritual role too. I liked in Mirage when Donatello was incredibly spiritual but that's never going to happen again. I prefer him to be contentious with the spiritual side as he is so logic/data driven. Being spiritual, Jennika could easily butt heads with other characters but could have a more lighthearted attitude than Leo's spirituality typically is.
If she leaned into a flower child aesthetic I think each of the characters could respond fairly uniquely to her. It's still a fairly gendered aesthetic/archetype but one in which she has a bit more agency in general.
I could see how this can diminish from other characters though so I don't totally love the idea. I could do with a bit more brainstorming in this regard. Either way I do think giving her a strong trait like the others would go a long way.
MikeandRaph87
03-26-2021, 11:10 AM
That does bring up an interesting question. I think of her as the current most prominent supporting character in Splinter's absence. A lead character? She may have mutated into a turtle for now, but I never really considered her a full pledged main character.
superstaff
03-26-2021, 11:47 AM
I definitely agree that the big character archetypes are what make the turtles memorable. I can also understand not wanting to give the girl a subdued/passive role.
Yeah, shy/timid women don't exist and don't want any representation. The only representation female fans want to see is loud, brash, violent fictional women who win all/most of the fights they get into, and get along swimmingly with the other characters (except when they don't, and said fictional women are always portrayed as being in the right).
/s, in case anyone didn't think my post wasn't dripping with sarcasm...
Sophie Campbell
03-26-2021, 12:13 PM
As far as Jennika goes, a fifth girl turtle will always be a creatively bankrupt idea, but man it could have been executed so much better. The reason the turtles have such great chemistry is because they cover very broad personality archetypes. The serious one, the angry one, the smart one and the funny one. Where does Jennika fit in? Nowhere. She's basically a less-Raph Raph. What they COULD have done is made her "the quiet one". That's a personality archetype that none of the other four turtles use. She could have been timid/shy, or socially awkward. It would have changed the group dynamic and given her a reason to exist.
That's the route I took in my fan comic with my character Artemisia, she's like the shy worrywart turtle! It's a no-brainer. That's probably what I would've done with Jennika too if she hadn't been around since issue 51 and was never seen to be shy or anything like that even post-mutation. I did consider it, though, like having her mutation cause her to withdraw inward but it still seemed like too much of a shift. Maybe in the next TMNT incarnation! ;)
ChosenOne
03-26-2021, 01:05 PM
I dunno, sales figures did spike from it. Money talks after all.
One could argue - maybe cynically, maybe realistically - that sales figures spiked due to her mutation and the inherent market value of that particular issue going forward, not due to her characterization or any wonders she's done to the overall story.
All this talk about introverted Jennika is funny 'cause that was always the reading I got from her early pre-mutation appearances: a young woman who became socially awkward after being brought up by an underground ninja clan with a heavily medieval worldview.
Leo656
03-26-2021, 01:34 PM
One could argue - maybe cynically, maybe realistically - that sales figures spiked due to her mutation and the inherent market value of that particular issue going forward, not due to her characterization or any wonders she's done to the overall story.
Definitely. "They made a Fifth Turtle comic book canon! This thing is gonna be Worth BIG Bucks in 20 years!" was absolutely a factor.
superstaff
03-26-2021, 01:44 PM
Definitely. "They made a Fifth Turtle comic book canon! This thing is gonna be Worth BIG Bucks in 20 years!" was absolutely a factor.
Yep.
I've said this many times on here, but I still cannot fathom why so many people (readers and creators alike) think a fifth turtle is some revolutionary idea. It's just the laziest idea, and it seems like they can never get it to work. The fifth turtle always sticks out like a sore thumb, whether it's a concept that never got done (ex: Kirby, Turtle Shredder) or what we've gotten canonically.
Welp. Can't wait for the next TMNT movie or show or comic to implement their own Kirby or Jennika or Venus or what-have-you. Maybe add in Poochie as the next fifth turtle. I'm sure that'll be hailed as creative and revolutionary too.
Sophie Campbell
03-26-2021, 01:55 PM
One could argue - maybe cynically, maybe realistically - that sales figures spiked due to her mutation and the inherent market value of that particular issue going forward, not due to her characterization or any wonders she's done to the overall story.
It's not cynical to see it that way, it is what it is, and that's a lot of what drives sales spikes when it comes to single issues. Collectors and flippers will take anything they can get, like there are people trying to sell issue 106 for (relatively) big bucks because it's the first appearance of the Slithery (who cares????). Same goes for spikes around issue 100 or even the Last Ronin.
It's a combination of factors, too, like you have to take into account that with monthly issue direct market sales figures, it's not how many issues were sold to readers or speculators looking to invest, it's how many copies were ordered by retailers regardless if those copies were actually sold to eventual customers or not. So a lot of the spikes are driven by what retailers think might be big, which is why we get overblown solicitation/catalog text like "this issue is a gamechanger for the Turtles!!!" when it's not really at all, and why there are 10:1 retailer incentive variant covers (order 10 copies and get the special variant cover, etc.).
ChosenOne
03-26-2021, 02:06 PM
I've said this many times on here, but I still cannot fathom why so many people (readers and creators alike) think a fifth turtle is some revolutionary idea. It's just the laziest idea, and it seems like they can never get it to work. The fifth turtle always sticks out like a sore thumb, whether it's a concept that never got done (ex: Kirby, Turtle Shredder) or what we've gotten canonically.
The only "fifth turtle" that's ever been proven to work time and again is Slash, and even then it's because he usually starts out as a villain. Sort of a Green Ranger Syndrome, if you will. I'm not counting Tokka because there's a clear physical difference from the four OG Turtles, whereas Slash is usually portrayed as very similar to them and even wears a bandana himself.
It's a combination of factors, too, like you have to take into account that with monthly issue direct market sales figures, it's not how many issues were sold to readers or speculators looking to invest, it's how many copies were ordered by retailers regardless if those copies were actually sold to eventual customers or not. So a lot of the spikes are driven by what retailers think might be big, which is why we get overblown solicitation/catalog text like "this issue is a gamechanger for the Turtles!!!" when it's not really at all, and why there are 10:1 retailer incentive variant covers (order 10 copies and get the special variant cover, etc.).
Possibly a silly question, but what happens to the issues that were ordered by retailers and ended up not being sold?
Sophie Campbell
03-26-2021, 02:13 PM
Possibly a silly question, but what happens to the issues that were ordered by retailers and ended up not being sold?
Not a silly question! They either end up in the back issue bin or returned to the publisher (not all publishers have a return program, though).
lonewarrior20
03-26-2021, 03:58 PM
i kinda wonder how comics are going to be of value 10 years from now. will almost everything be just digital and as egon said "print is dead", will tmnt still be going on, or door number three the worlds currently at mad max levels where we have to defend against both the dc and marvel fans? we got a chance we've been raised on the "abridged" comic series on ninja fighting while they have giant six gemstone gauntlets and baterangs. or for all we know we'll have entered farenheight 451 territory and books have been outlawed.
CyberCubed
03-26-2021, 05:44 PM
Most unsold comics simply stay in the comic shop and go to "back issue bins." That's why you always see old DC/Marvel comics dating back years/decades in stacks on the floor or shelves. Even if they didn't sell when they were "new," there are always people who missed issues or are collecting for the first time so they stay there for a future sale.
Sophie Campbell
03-26-2021, 07:49 PM
i kinda wonder how comics are going to be of value 10 years from now. will almost everything be just digital and as egon said "print is dead", will tmnt still be going on, or door number three the worlds currently at mad max levels where we have to defend against both the dc and marvel fans? we got a chance we've been raised on the "abridged" comic series on ninja fighting while they have giant six gemstone gauntlets and baterangs. or for all we know we'll have entered farenheight 451 territory and books have been outlawed.
Hopefully comics won't be valuable at all and we can finally be rid of the speculator collectible stuff that keeps threatening comic shops. BARF. I'm sure TMNT will be still around 10 years from now, that's not a very long time. What about 100 years from now?!
Most unsold comics simply stay in the comic shop and go to "back issue bins." That's why you always see old DC/Marvel comics dating back years/decades in stacks on the floor or shelves. Even if they didn't sell when they were "new," there are always people who missed issues or are collecting for the first time so they stay there for a future sale.
Yeah most of the time they just end up in back issues or stored somewhere on the store's premises because the shop doesn't have any other way to deal with them, it's either hope someone buys them down the line or throw them all out. Part of the direct market's whole thing is non-returnability unlike when comics would be sold at news stands and grocery stores or whatever, but I think some publishers do returns every now and again these days?
I don't know, hopefully we'll eventually figure out something else besides the direct market, maybe the industry will move exclusively into book-format once the direct market everything collapses. Seems like it might with how Marvel and DC are switching to their own distributors and leaving Diamond high and dry.
ChosenOne
03-26-2021, 08:16 PM
What about 100 years from now?!
I'm pretty sure turtles can and will survive climate change. :tcool::D
neatoman
03-26-2021, 08:28 PM
I'm sure TMNT will be still around 10 years from now, that's not a very long time. What about 100 years from now?!
Interesting question. By 2121, all of the officially produced TMNT material made up until 2025 (with the possible exception of Rick Veitch's stuff) will have entered the public domain. The first two issues of Mirage will have been public domain for about 41 years.
If TMNT manages to be a cultural milestone until 2080, you can imagine a similar journey the Oz books have had. Tons of adaptations made because it's public domain but with a really weird dominance of some.
But yes, assuming some popularity is maintained by 2080, anyone can and will publish their own TMNT comics without the need for a license contract.
lonewarrior20
03-26-2021, 08:47 PM
Interesting question. By 2121, all of the officially produced TMNT material made up until 2025 (with the possible exception of Rick Veitch's stuff) will have entered the public domain. The first two issues of Mirage will have been public domain for about 41 years.
If TMNT manages to be a cultural milestone until 2080, you can imagine a similar journey the Oz books have had. Tons of adaptations made because it's public domain but with a really weird dominance of some.
But yes, assuming some popularity is maintained by 2080, anyone can and will publish their own TMNT comics without the need for a license contract.
all we need is shredder the musical. although, we could also go the way of trekies and almost make it into a religion.
"and then the green ooze pored onto the four ordinary turtles and then they changed into legendary heroes. leonardo the leader whose heart was gold. raphael whose whit could slay the mighty. donatello the forger of machines. and michelangelo the party dude."
Leo656
03-26-2021, 08:53 PM
Ah, the old "Frankenstein and Dracula" Public Domain Paradox.
Good: Literally anyone can produce a story with these characters and sell it!
Bad: Most people are idiots, and therefore almost all of the "new stuff" is absolute trash!
I once skimmed through a Frankenstein novel my wife's grandmother left laying around. It was a present-day sequel to the original novel, and The Monster was some kind of Black Ops government super-soldier or a spy or some sh*t. I read the back cover description, skimmed like four pages, and wished upon a star that every single person who'd worked on it would spontaneously combust.
I don't know if they did or not - I didn't check the news that week - but I was wishing, like, SUPER hard.
Stuff entering the public domain is one of those things that SOUNDS like a great idea in theory. In practice... eeeeeeeeehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.....
ChosenOne
03-26-2021, 08:59 PM
In theory, we can already get a pretty good idea of what will be done with the franchise once it enters the public domain by taking a look at fanfiction. And if other works in the public domain are any indication, none of those new approaches, even if they somehow manage not to suck, will ever take the place of the original version(s) in the public's heart.
Sophie Campbell
03-26-2021, 09:20 PM
Assuming copyright law is still similar to what we have now come 2080 or whenever it is, somehow I don't see TMNT legit entering public domain, I feel like Viacom will figure out a way to petition to extend their ownership of the property the way Disney has manipulated public domain in regards to their own IP. We're supposed to get Superman and Batman and other big ones like that entering the public domain in about a decade but there's no way Warner Bros. is going to let that happen.
I'm predicting that sometime before 2080, Disney is going to end up owning TMNT after buying out and absorbing Viacom. :tlol:
ChosenOne
03-26-2021, 09:25 PM
I'm predicting that sometime before 2080, Disney is going to end up owning TMNT after buying out and absorbing Viacom. :tlol:
Well, if that's what it takes for an official crossover with Daredevil to happen... :D
neatoman
03-26-2021, 09:29 PM
Ah, the old "Frankenstein and Dracula" Public Domain Paradox.
Good: Literally anyone can produce a story with these characters and sell it!
Bad: Most people are idiots, and therefore almost all of the "new stuff" is absolute trash!
I once skimmed through a Frankenstein novel my wife's grandmother left laying around. It was a present-day sequel to the original novel, and The Monster was some kind of Black Ops government super-soldier or a spy or some sh*t. I read the back cover description, skimmed like four pages, and wished upon a star that every single person who'd worked on it would spontaneously combust.
I don't know if they did or not - I didn't check the news that week - but I was wishing, like, SUPER hard.
Stuff entering the public domain is one of those things that SOUNDS like a great idea in theory. In practice... eeeeeeeeehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.....
Well, look at it like this:
Black Ops Frankenstein might be awful but Hammer Frankenstein isn't, both of these could only exist because the novel entered the public domain. The difference is, I don't have to read the crappy book. Same thing with Dracula, Dracula Untold being garbage doesn't make Castlevania any less fun to play.
Even if literally no new good material is made, the old material can still be shared freely. If I want to read Frankenstein in Swedish, I have at least four different translations to pick from. If I don't feel like reading it in Swedish, I can instead order it in German, Spanish, French, Romanian, Chinese, Portuguese, Italian, Catalonian, Latin, Dutch, Norwegian, Danish, Finnish, Estonian, Lithuanian, Turkish, Russian, Japanese, Hebrew, Irish, Korean, Thai, Armenian, Bulgarian, Arabic, Polish, Welsh, Icelandic, Greek and of course English. Hell, I don't even need to but it or even borrow it to read it in English, I can just download a PDF from Gutenberg for free.
neatoman
03-27-2021, 08:26 AM
Assuming copyright law is still similar to what we have now come 2080 or whenever it is, somehow I don't see TMNT legit entering public domain, I feel like Viacom will figure out a way to petition to extend their ownership of the property the way Disney has manipulated public domain in regards to their own IP. We're supposed to get Superman and Batman and other big ones like that entering the public domain in about a decade but there's no way Warner Bros. is going to let that happen.
I'm predicting that sometime before 2080, Disney is going to end up owning TMNT after buying out and absorbing Viacom. :tlol:
While it is true that copyright law in the US could change by 2080, there doesn't appear to be much incentive right now to change it. The "Mickey Mouse act" is what extended copyright duration to 95 and the nickname came from Disney lobbying for it about 5 years before Mickey Mouse would have entered the public domain. There wasn't any new push for legislative change in 2018 and the 95 year rule is still in place.
Maybe because extending it from 95 to 120 or more would be absurd. If that happened in 2018 then suddenly material from 1898 would be under copyright protection.
TigerClaw
03-27-2021, 11:38 AM
Assuming copyright law is still similar to what we have now come 2080 or whenever it is, somehow I don't see TMNT legit entering public domain, I feel like Viacom will figure out a way to petition to extend their ownership of the property the way Disney has manipulated public domain in regards to their own IP. We're supposed to get Superman and Batman and other big ones like that entering the public domain in about a decade but there's no way Warner Bros. is going to let that happen.
I'm predicting that sometime before 2080, Disney is going to end up owning TMNT after buying out and absorbing Viacom. :tlol:
If that happens, IDW would lose the TMNT License and then Marvel would be the one publishing the TMNT comics.
neatoman
03-27-2021, 11:59 AM
If that happens, IDW would lose the TMNT License and then Marvel would be the one publishing the TMNT comics.
... Yes, if Disney buys Viacom that would very likely be what would happen... But we are talking about a timeframe of a little under 60 years here, we can't be sure if Disney, Marvel, IDW and/or Viacom still exist by 2080.
TigerClaw
03-27-2021, 12:05 PM
... Yes, if Disney buys Viacom that would very likely be what would happen... But we are talking about a timeframe of a little under 60 years here, we can't be sure if Disney, Marvel, IDW and/or Viacom still exist by 2080.
That's because one company will be left standing. Disney will absorb all of them.
neatoman
03-27-2021, 03:11 PM
That's because one company will be left standing. Disney will absorb all of them.
At which point the US government would be forced into splitting the company up into smaller entities.
ChosenOne
03-27-2021, 03:20 PM
At which point the US government would be forced into splitting the company up into smaller entities.
Or Disney will just straight up own the US government. Either way works.
lonewarrior20
03-27-2021, 05:15 PM
nh6Hf5_ZYPI
Sophie Campbell
03-27-2021, 06:05 PM
At which point the US government would be forced into splitting the company up into smaller entities.
Ideally, yes, but... I'm guessing you don't live in the US. :tlol:
Leo656
03-27-2021, 09:37 PM
Would be funnier if not for the fact they have indeed done exactly that before.
Granted, "different time and place" and all of that, but there's still precedent.
slashpieturtlemix
03-29-2021, 10:52 AM
Assuming copyright law is still similar to what we have now come 2080 or whenever it is, somehow I don't see TMNT legit entering public domain, I feel like Viacom will figure out a way to petition to extend their ownership of the property the way Disney has manipulated public domain in regards to their own IP. We're supposed to get Superman and Batman and other big ones like that entering the public domain in about a decade but there's no way Warner Bros. is going to let that happen.
I'm predicting that sometime before 2080, Disney is going to end up owning TMNT after buying out and absorbing Viacom. :tlol:
Sophie is correct in that Disney had a master plan in the 80s / 90s in order to avoid several properties going into public domain. Disney started a project to take several of their IPs and make whole new shows for them in order to renew their copy rights on those characters. The shows included: Talespin, Darkwing Duck, DuckTales, Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers, Goof Troop, Bonkers, and Quack Pack. These new shows in effect renewed the copy rights for another term. That was something I learned while working with Phil Young at Savannah College of Art and Design lol
Sophie Campbell
03-29-2021, 12:19 PM
while working with Phil Young at Savannah College of Art and Design lol
Hey I went to SCAD too! :tcool:
superstaff
03-29-2021, 01:23 PM
Sophie is correct in that Disney had a master plan in the 80s / 90s in order to avoid several properties going into public domain. Disney started a project to take several of their IPs and make whole new shows for them in order to renew their copy rights on those characters. The shows included: Talespin, Darkwing Duck, DuckTales, Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers, Goof Troop, Bonkers, and Quack Pack. These new shows in effect renewed the copy rights for another term. That was something I learned while working with Phil Young at Savannah College of Art and Design lol
> Darkwing Duck
> Bonkers
What copyrights were those two shows trying to salvage exactly? Darkwing and Bonkers are original properties. Launchpad was from Duck Tales originally, though he was an original creation from there.
slashpieturtlemix
03-29-2021, 02:09 PM
> Darkwing Duck
> Bonkers
What copyrights were those two shows trying to salvage exactly? Darkwing and Bonkers are original properties. Launchpad was from Duck Tales originally, though he was an original creation from there.
Those two shows may have been original properties but their purpose was to salvage IPs already endangered of going into the public domain. You can see just from a quick search of Bonkers characters,
(https://www.google.com/search?q=bonkers+characters&sxsrf=ALeKk02AFm2kyBpq-KHU6G-zoqetiu95DQ%3A1617044654943&ei=riRiYNmDOdS0tQb_9Kdo&oq=bonkers+characters&gs_lcp=Cgdnd3Mtd2l6EAMyAggAMgYIABAHEB4yBggAEAcQHjI FCAAQhgM6CAgAEAcQChAeOgQIABAeUKGdAVjuowFg7KQBaABwA ngAgAHOAYgBowaSAQU2LjEuMZgBAKABAaoBB2d3cy13aXrAAQE&sclient=gws-wiz&ved=0ahUKEwjZkvnhmNbvAhVUWs0KHX_6CQ0Q4dUDCA0&uact=5)
that shows several of those characters are from older mickey mouse cartoons (especially clarabell cow, horace horsecollar, ludwig von drake, etc) and the same can be said about Darkwing duck. The shows may be original but they renewed copyrights on several older properties in the process, thus giving them 80+ years or whatever the current copyright extension is. It was a pretty smart move on their part.
Only the best come from SCAD Sophie lol nice to see more Bees out there!
ChosenOne
04-12-2021, 07:05 PM
More new art from the Annual, via Tom Waltz's Twitter (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1381667316543279105):
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EyyrCl3U4AICSsB?format=jpg&name=4096x4096
I look at that and wonder... Could the whole point of the Armageddon Game be the Rat King eliminating his direct competitors in the Pantheon's eternal power play? Two of them (Aka and Chi-You) are gone, removed from the board, and a third (Kitsune) has settled down in her ambitions for the moment. Maybe RK is looking to take out the others via his various unwilling proxies? It would certainly be the right kind of monologue to go with such a panel.
hypered1
04-12-2021, 08:02 PM
More new art from the Annual, via Tom Waltz's Twitter (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1381667316543279105):
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EyyrCl3U4AICSsB?format=jpg&name=4096x4096
I look at that and wonder... Could the whole point of the Armageddon Game be the Rat King eliminating his direct competitors in the Pantheon's eternal power play? Two of them (Aka and Chi-You) are gone, removed from the board, and a third (Kitsune) has settled down in her ambitions for the moment. Maybe RK is looking to take out the others via his various unwilling proxies? It would certainly be the right kind of monologue to go with such a panel.
I think it's possibly a flashback as Ratty looks kinda younger in that seated pic.
MikeandRaph87
04-12-2021, 08:55 PM
More new art from the Annual, via Tom Waltz's Twitter (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1381667316543279105):
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EyyrCl3U4AICSsB?format=jpg&name=4096x4096
I look at that and wonder... Could the whole point of the Armageddon Game be the Rat King eliminating his direct competitors in the Pantheon's eternal power play? Two of them (Aka and Chi-You) are gone, removed from the board, and a third (Kitsune) has settled down in her ambitions for the moment. Maybe RK is looking to take out the others via his various unwilling proxies? It would certainly be the right kind of monologue to go with such a panel.
This is what I want to see in the ongoing instead of battle of the bands in Furry Town.
ChosenOne
04-15-2021, 12:22 PM
My first reaction: Oh, my! :o
My second reaction: Where's Stockman? Where's Leatherhead? :cry: (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1382119178484678659)
AquaParade
04-15-2021, 12:23 PM
I'm glad Tom found something else to share. He was going ham on The Last Ronin. He even posted some images and took them down the same day, so I'm wondering if someone asked him to slow down.
Should have just shared them here, Tom!
neatoman
04-15-2021, 01:36 PM
My first reaction: Oh, my! :o
My second reaction: Where's Stockman? Where's Leatherhead? :cry: (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1382119178484678659)
I noticed a few characters who are meant to be dead.
hypered1
04-15-2021, 01:42 PM
My first reaction: Oh, my! :o
My second reaction: Where's Stockman? Where's Leatherhead? :cry: (https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1382119178484678659)
That is epic and I'd love to see it coloured, also I think Baxter is one the people eating pizza, not sure who the other two in the bottom left are though
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.