PDA

View Full Version : Modern IDW


MrAustin
03-24-2021, 11:15 AM
It's obviously fair to love or hate (or anything in between) modern IDW, but I do find it a bit silly how many Turtles fans seem to dislike a direction totally unique in this series' history; there are so many versions of the characters that focus on the 'ninja' part of their name that I feel as though a break from that action, with lovely character positivity is so nice.

mrmaczaps
03-24-2021, 11:17 AM
It's obviously fair to love or hate (or anything in between) modern IDW, but I do find it a bit silly how many Turtles fans seem to dislike a direction totally unique in this series' history; there are so many versions of the characters that focus on the 'ninja' part of their name that I feel as though a break from that action, with lovely character positivity is so nice.

Sure, thats fine for an issue or two but its been 15 f¤cking issues and its mind numbingly boring.

ChosenOne
03-24-2021, 11:31 AM
Sure, thats fine for an issue or two but its been 15 f¤cking issues and its mind numbingly boring.

This. I'll be honest and say I wouldn't mind nearly as much, or even at all, if all this Mutant Town stuff had been interspersed with other plot threads in sore need of addressing instead of being presented as a marathon. And I expect most detractors of Campbell's run will agree with me.

neatoman
03-24-2021, 11:36 AM
Yeah... It really has been going on for so long now it's kind of mind numbing. And it's not like this wasn't possible without cramming the characters into a walled off slum. I can easily imagine a "Dimension X vacation" story that would have a similar tone, which would also be a story where we also don't have to see the turtles "be normal and have fun" at the expense of people having their lives ruined.

I should also point out here that the characters introduced here aren't especially great. Those weasels have very little personality and only seem to exist to be cute, alongside Lita who also doesn't seem to serve much more purpse than to be cute. Pepperoni already existed to be the cute little mascot character, I really don't understand why we need five characters who do very little and just hang around to be cute. TMNT isn't exactly Teletubbies, I don't think we need a bunch of Teletubbies-like characters running around.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 12:15 PM
Why have them be ninjas, if they are not going to be doing Ninja Things?

It's the same sh*t when people say that their favorite thing about super-hero comics isn't when they do Super-Hero things, it's when they're cracking jokes over Starbucks coffee or standing in line at the bank. "Just like us!" :roll: Because most people totally, totally wanna read about THAT stuff in a comic where things like alien invasions, cross-dimensional chaos and people who bench-press planets and shoot eye-lasers are a reality. Let's do NONE of that, and have lots and lots of panels of them doing laundry and taking their pets to the vet. That Sells.

Likewise, TMNT has so many fantastical elements that it seems like a waste to not lean into them, while instead focusing entirely on the mundane.

You can absolutely do "slice of life" and when done well, it enriches the more fantastical elements rather than working against them. But this doesn't even feel like "TMNT" anymore. It's like they're just guest stars in a story that wasn't written about them and has no idea what to actually do with them.

There's a germ of a good idea in all of what's been done. I just think the execution hasn't been great and it seems like most people agree. If it were more of an action story and less of a "cutesy" drama/comedy with crammed-in Real-Life political overtones, I think it would be more well-received.

As I've said elsewhere, it's like why Mirage Vol. 4 failed. Not inherently a "bad" story, but absolutely not at ALL what a TMNT comic "should have" been if it actually wanted to grab people by the throat and make them read it.

AquaParade
03-24-2021, 12:34 PM
I haven't read the book in months, so I can't really comment on the current quality.

That said, when the execution is done right, I love the "slice of life" aspect. I think the balance between that, action, and mythology is what makes the Mirage comics so special.

CyberCubed
03-24-2021, 12:42 PM
I imagine the current direction was a result of wanting to slow things down a bit after the Turtles were in constant conflict one after the other from like issue 70 onward.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 12:45 PM
Mutant Town arc is just boring and has run for waaaay too long,IMO. I wouldn't really mind it as much if we still had TMNT Universe to give us some different stories,but as is,this is just keeping us away from Burnow island,Shredder,LeatherKrang and other stuff we actually care about.

ChosenOne
03-24-2021, 12:47 PM
It's the same sh*t when people say that their favorite thing about super-hero comics isn't when they do Super-Hero things, it's when they're cracking jokes over Starbucks coffee or standing in line at the bank. "Just like us!" :roll: Because most people totally, totally wanna read about THAT stuff in a comic where things like alien invasions, cross-dimensional chaos and people who bench-press planets and shoot eye-lasers are a reality. Let's do NONE of that, and have lots and lots of panels of them doing laundry and taking their pets to the vet. That Sells.

You've just watched the first episode of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, haven't you? :lol:

I imagine the current direction was a result of wanting to slow things down a bit after the Turtles were in constant conflict one after the other from like issue 70 onward.

There are better ways of doing that. Take everything that happened between City Fall and Attack on Technodrome, or immediately following Vengeance.

Mutant Town arc is just boring and has run for waaaay too long,IMO. I wouldn't really mind it as much if we still had TMNT Universe to give us some different stories,but as is,this is just keeping us away from Burnow island,Shredder,LeatherKrang and other stuff we actually care about.

This.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 12:59 PM
You've just watched the first episode of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, haven't you? :lol:


No, I don't watch Marvel stuff. :lol: I know that sounds impossible, I just don't. I've seen clips here and there, like anyone else. I just don't care for their material in general.

Last thing from them I watched A-to-Z was "Age of Ultron", in the theater. I liked it fine, but I also decided that if this was what they were all going to be like then I'd seen enough. Everything I've seen and read since tells me that, for myself, it was a wise decision.

mrmaczaps
03-24-2021, 01:41 PM
There is also the fact that both Jennika series deal with this "slice of life" sh¡t while still being more action packed than the ongoing and, as much as I hate to admit, better written than the ongoing. But really not by much.

They don't really seem to fit in anywhere either. Continuity wise anyways.

FrederikWolferson
03-24-2021, 03:37 PM
Slice of life works in small doses. "A day in the life" is a great issue,but it's a single issue. And we spent some 15 issues watching Turtles chase after kids,go to a punk concert and Mona trying to depose Old Hob. And I honestly couldn't care less about politics of Mutant Town.

TigerClaw
03-24-2021, 03:51 PM
It's obviously fair to love or hate (or anything in between) modern IDW, but I do find it a bit silly how many Turtles fans seem to dislike a direction totally unique in this series' history; there are so many versions of the characters that focus on the 'ninja' part of their name that I feel as though a break from that action, with lovely character positivity is so nice.
That's what I love about the current run. All the nice character development and so on. Sophie Campbell is doing an awesome job with the comics.

Leo656
03-24-2021, 04:26 PM
"Character development" for characters who are 1. Not the TMNT, 2. "Arguably" don't belong in a TMNT book (since they were made up specifically to tell This Story and not because they add anything to the TMNT mythos), and 3. Get way more attention paid to them than the TMNT, who are ostensibly the stars of the book.

I think most people would be fine with "character development" if it had more to do with the TMNT themselves, and not Everyone BUT Them. There's a little bit of development for the Turtles, yeah... but they're still very clearly "guest stars". The story isn't ABOUT them anymore and it really ought to be.

Powder
03-24-2021, 08:44 PM
Your dislike of people's justified criticism warranted it's own thread, where said criticism will follow, if not spitefully, then born of the natural flow of conversation? OK.

& if you think the slice of life element is what people are really taking issue with, then clearly your biases are getting in the way. TMNT was built on slice of life, done right, it's great.

Allio
03-24-2021, 09:32 PM
Love or hate post 100 issues, been re-reading the series and I have to give idw credit for going nearly 200 issues being consistent with only like 1 or 2 stories being bad.

Most comic books can’t like more than 10 being going to ****

Diorm
03-26-2021, 09:15 AM
there are so many versions of the characters that focus on the 'ninja' part of their name that I feel as though a break from that action, with lovely character positivity is so nice.

Weird. From my point of view, a lot of media are focusing too much on the Mutant part of the name. In that there are too many of them. There is definitely not enough ninja stuff.

AquaParade
03-26-2021, 10:15 AM
Love or hate post 100 issues, been re-reading the series and I have to give idw credit for going nearly 200 issues being consistent with only like 1 or 2 stories being bad.

Most comic books can’t like more than 10 being going to ****

Overall, it is the most consistent books in comics. And it ain't half bad. I just wish I liked it.

Andrew NDB
03-26-2021, 10:29 AM
there are so many versions of the characters that focus on the 'ninja' part of their name

You mean a grand total of 1?

Allio
03-26-2021, 10:43 AM
That’s going to be the problem with consistent titles like Usagi or One Piece. Either you love it from chapter 1 or you ain’t ever going to like it. It’s a good thing for the long time readers but bad thing for people that couldn’t get into it

superstaff
03-26-2021, 11:51 AM
Weird. From my point of view, a lot of media are focusing too much on the Mutant part of the name. In that there are too many of them. There is definitely not enough ninja stuff.

This is why my interest in the upcoming CGI movie piqued when Rogen said recently that the movie is going to focus on the 'Teenage' part of the TMNT title. That could either be a very good thing...or a very bad thing, depending on which route he takes. Nevertheless, I wouldn't mind the movie tackling some teenage related themes. (I fear he means 'teenage' as in he will litter the movie with toilet humor and sex jokes.)

Andrew NDB
03-26-2021, 12:12 PM
Come to think of it... can we even count Mirage as "focusing" on the Ninja side? There are some great Mirage stories where there IS ninja stuff, sure... but I feel like probably 90% of the other Mirage issues aren't about ninja stuff at all.

Crabfight
03-27-2021, 01:21 AM
Yup! I'm absolutely loving Sophie's post-100 run. Don't get me wrong, I do hope it eventually builds up into more action, but these calmer stories dealing with the trauma of their past conflicts are definitely a welcome change for me. I can't say I totally disagree with those who are voicing that the turtles themselves could use a bit more of a spotlight on them, but I've also really enjoyed the new characters and the careful build of the new status quo. It's definitely still by far my favorite comic on my pull list.

Mexiun
03-27-2021, 05:25 PM
Thing is, this Mutant Town story is not the reason why people bought the IDW TMNT in the first place, we bought it to see adventure, fighting, cool villians and ofcourse the obvious: the TMNT and their friends.
The whole Mutant Town thing is the exact opposite of why we bought it in the first place! For example: If Mutant Town was its own comic and was made instead of the TMNT IDW that we got, starting from #1 way back when IDW TMNT was released, would you think it would last over 100 issues? Nope, because TMNT fans are not interested in this, as seen in the many hate it gets.

Its like buying Spawn, you want to see him wreck people, blood and guts flying and awesome looking demons and great stories, now imagine if Spawn gets 15+ chapters of him just having a normal life with his buddies and occasionally fighting petty crime and every issue is him dating girls and getting rejected to make him a Myspace emo... yeah this wouldn't sit well with Spawn fans either.

Mutant Town is fun in small doses and not as a huge story arc for TWO FREAKING YEARS!!
I'm a huge TMNT fan and have been since the early 90s, this comic was my favourite TMNT comic and i was always hyped to read it, but even i stopped reading it and i never expected me to stop... it just felt like a chore, like homework, to read even a single page... i couldn't take it seriously at all, it felt like Deviantart fanfic or a Twitter story made into a comic.

If this Mutant Town bs stops then i'll pick it up again, bring back the original writer for the love of the fanbase...
The comic isn't selling well anymore either and that scares me because i don't want this comic to ever end.

Edit: If anyone is familliar with the manga Kyou Kare Ore Wa, the writer there did a great job with action and slice of life. It always went like this: 8-13 issue action story arc, then a 3-4 issue slice of life arc, then 8-13 action arc, then 3-4 slice of life arc again, repeat repeat.

FrederikWolferson
03-28-2021, 01:41 AM
This is why my interest in the upcoming CGI movie piqued when Rogen said recently that the movie is going to focus on the 'Teenage' part of the TMNT title. That could either be a very good thing...or a very bad thing, depending on which route he takes. Nevertheless, I wouldn't mind the movie tackling some teenage related themes. (I fear he means 'teenage' as in he will litter the movie with toilet humor and sex jokes.)
It IS Seth Rogen.

Allio
03-28-2021, 08:39 AM
Come to think of it... can we even count Mirage as "focusing" on the Ninja side? There are some great Mirage stories where there IS ninja stuff, sure... but I feel like probably 90% of the other Mirage issues aren't about ninja stuff at all.

Like many cases tmnt is ninja in a small sense of how pop culture sees them at certain point and time. Hell Rise Turtles are just as ninja as Shuriken Sentai Ninninger who uses the phrase of “we are ninjas that don’t hide.”

Rooish
03-28-2021, 09:38 AM
Come to think of it... can we even count Mirage as "focusing" on the Ninja side? There are some great Mirage stories where there IS ninja stuff, sure... but I feel like probably 90% of the other Mirage issues aren't about ninja stuff at all.

Yup that's true. I think that many of us fans have been waiting decades for a proper ninja story -- like an ongoing City at War -- and it's just never going to consistently happen. We have gotten snippets in the Image comics before the insertion of crossovers, and there were some Tales Vol. 2 moments by Tristan Jones, and a bit in IDW before it became clear the Turtles could never kill anyone. It seems that everyone who writes this series does not know how to keep it grounded. Yes it's a crazy spoof of an idea to begin with, but many fans love the "dark and gritty" ninja stuff and just want to see it consistently... and we never do. Maybe that **** is too hard to write long term? Maybe you can only do so much with the turtles having to hide forever? So many writers have tried and gotten bored of it and inserted wacky plots or original characters. Maybe it can't be done and we should all learn to draw and just do our own fan comics.

Andrew NDB
03-28-2021, 10:02 AM
Yup that's true. I think that many of us fans have been waiting decades for a proper ninja story -- like an ongoing City at War -- and it's just never going to consistently happen. We have gotten snippets in the Image comics before the insertion of crossovers, and there were some Tales Vol. 2 moments by Tristan Jones, and a bit in IDW before it became clear the Turtles could never kill anyone. It seems that everyone who writes this series does not know how to keep it grounded. Yes it's a crazy spoof of an idea to begin with, but many fans love the "dark and gritty" ninja stuff and just want to see it consistently... and we never do. Maybe that **** is too hard to write long term? Maybe you can only do so much with the turtles having to hide forever? So many writers have tried and gotten bored of it and inserted wacky plots or original characters. Maybe it can't be done and we should all learn to draw and just do our own fan comics.

To be clear: I'm more than OK with TPTB not leaning on the "Ninja" part of the equation even 50% of the time. Or even 40% of the time. My thing is that when it IS part of the equation, it's treated deadly seriously. Like, I don't care if there is two story arcs in space or out in the woods... when it's time for the next "ninja" thing, I don't want to see anything half-assed. But it should be ingrained in their day to day routine(s).

And also, say about something like Mirage, "You guys have had enough TMNT universes that focus on the ninja!"... um, that's the only one, and it barely even did that. To set the bar even LOWER than that, and gleefully, for future TMNT projects? Yeesh. You and I have nothing to talk about, lol!

Zulithe
03-29-2021, 03:00 AM
I really need to catch up on my IDW turtles... i've seen bits and pieces of the current arc through previews and yeah, I need to see more to form an opinion.

CyberCubed
03-29-2021, 09:13 AM
Issues 101-115 are basically about mutant town, with some slight plot stuff going on outside of it.

mrmaczaps
03-29-2021, 09:19 AM
I really need to catch up on my IDW turtles... i've seen bits and pieces of the current arc through previews and yeah, I need to see more to form an opinion.

Read issue 101 and then read issue 115 and you basically have the entire story so far.

miru
04-01-2021, 03:21 PM
This is more or less the same sort of atmospheric dry-spell Mirage went through after CAW and again after Splinter's death; then again, from what I've seen of 115, action is coming crawling back into the comic. Me? I actually do have a soft-spot for slower, more atmospheric arcs and storylines, especially in a comic where you can have splash panels for artwork. It's one of the very few ways they're able to lean on the "turtle" side of things.

FrederikWolferson
04-01-2021, 04:28 PM
Oh yeah,I can't contain my excitement for the upcoming Battle of the Bands. How zany and random.

CyberCubed
04-01-2021, 04:30 PM
The Rahzar/Tokka fight was cool

FrederikWolferson
04-01-2021, 04:32 PM
The Rahzar/Tokka fight was cool

But cut short and sorta one-sided. I feel kinda cheated.