PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #116 Preview and Discussion


AlZarkovski
04-08-2021, 12:34 AM
First look:

https://is3-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication114/v4/72/19/76/721976ed-08c8-6a96-f795-ea314a879091/image-003.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is2-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication124/v4/fb/fa/3f/fbfa3f78-2650-812a-a5b4-0066d3a9cf34/image-004.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is4-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication124/v4/9e/05/93/9e05939e-cdb0-13a6-34d2-9a7b4dab7594/image-005.jpg/900x0w.jpg

Zog The Magnificent
04-08-2021, 01:09 AM
Okay, normally I don't mind at all, but something about that dialogue is just... nah.

lonewarrior20
04-08-2021, 03:12 AM
-5bLLVEOYXk

neatoman
04-08-2021, 07:46 AM
nKxvDYHkfSY

CyberCubed
04-08-2021, 07:53 AM
I feel this would have been better for a TV show where you could actually hear music they're playing rather than a comic, but oh well.

superstaff
04-08-2021, 08:20 AM
I've basically dropped this book recently, but do the actual TMNT do anything in these latest issues?

lonewarrior20
04-08-2021, 08:46 AM
I'm suprised the matress is still recognizeable. So, one down and who else to go?

CyberCubed
04-08-2021, 09:01 AM
I've basically dropped this book recently, but do the actual TMNT do anything in these latest issues?

The previous issue they have a big fight with rahzar/tokka.

FrederikWolferson
04-08-2021, 09:40 AM
Are they still on Namek Mutant Town?

MikeandRaph87
04-08-2021, 09:51 AM
The previous issue they have a big fight with rahzar/tokka.

More like Natsu enables Bebop and Rocksteady to beat Razhar and Tokka to near death before Karai calls them off.

How are Razhar and Tokka human infants turned into hulking mutants? If they were animals tampered with by Hob,okay,but really human infants mutated?

oldmanwinters
04-08-2021, 10:44 AM
Are they still on Namek Mutant Town?

Dang, that's the best shade comment I've seen on this Forum in a while! :tlol:

phillytmnt
04-08-2021, 10:53 AM
I have been a huge fan of the IDW run. Especially the first 50 issues. Though the next 50 were good as well. This does not feel like a TMNT comic to me anymore. I used to be so excited to get the next issue coming out. Now, I could care less. I just feel like the story is boring to me now. Nothing is really happening other than random mutants crying about their feelings. I’m glad some fans love this current run. It is just not for me. I’m so thankful that we have The Last Ronin. Hopefully due to it’s success, the ongoing will eventually be more like it and remember the turtles are ninjas . I’m fine with breather issues, but not for 15 issues straight. I hope the EPF comes in and wipes out all the mutants of mutant town so we can go back to focusing more on the turtles themselves, lol. There is also way more interesting storylines they could touch on like Saki being back, the pantheon, Chrell, Null, etc. For the first time, I’m considering dropping the book.

MikeandRaph87
04-08-2021, 11:23 AM
I have been a huge fan of the IDW run. Especially the first 50 issues. Though the next 50 were good as well. This does not feel like a TMNT comic to me anymore. I used to be so excited to get the next issue coming out. Now, I could care less. I just feel like the story is boring to me now. Nothing is really happening other than random mutants crying about their feelings. I’m glad some fans love this current run. It is just not for me. I’m so thankful that we have The Last Ronin. Hopefully due to it’s success, the ongoing will eventually be more like it and remember the turtles are ninjas . I’m fine with breather issues, but not for 15 issues straight. I hope the EPF comes in and wipes out all the mutants of mutant town so we can go back to focusing more on the turtles themselves, lol. There is also way more interesting storylines they could touch on like Saki being back, the pantheon, Chrell, Null, etc. For the first time, I’m considering dropping the book.

We are like minded in every word. I couldn't careless about the battle of the bands but we do have the 2021 annual coming up that will hopefully right the sinking ship.

CyberCubed
04-08-2021, 11:30 AM
There is also way more interesting storylines they could touch on like Saki being back, the pantheon, Chrell, Null, etc. For the first time, I’m considering dropping the book.

Shredder comes back in issue 118, and the Pantheon in the annual. So hopefully things will pick up there.

lonewarrior20
04-08-2021, 12:10 PM
Are they still on Namek Mutant Town?

This might have to be memed, clearly freiza would be played by mona but who would be goku, jennika? Diamond could be vegeta, future lita as krillen, and little lita as gohan, with either april or sheena as bulma.

ChosenOne
04-08-2021, 12:23 PM
Are they still on Namek Mutant Town?

F***ing brilliant!

Nothing is really happening other than random mutants crying about their feelings.

Welcome to progressive thinking, where everyone bitches about non-issues and nothing gets done to advance the plot/society.

This might have to be memed, clearly freiza would be played by mona but who would be goku, jennika? Diamond could be vegeta, future lita as krillen, and little lita as gohan, with either april or sheena as bulma.

How sad is it (for the comic) that you didn't mention a single one of the OG Turtles in that comparison?

lonewarrior20
04-08-2021, 12:52 PM
F***ing brilliant!



Welcome to progressive thinking, where everyone bitches about non-issues and nothing gets done to advance the plot/society.



How sad is it (for the comic) that you didn't mention a single one of the OG Turtles in that comparison?

Well I thought about having them be the namekiens.

ChosenOne
04-08-2021, 01:01 PM
Well I thought about having them be the namekiens.

They do feel like aliens in their own story sometimes, don't they?

oldmanwinters
04-08-2021, 01:40 PM
Well I thought about having them be the namekiens.

That sums it up pretty well.

Zog The Magnificent
04-08-2021, 02:18 PM
I don't know what Namek is...:(

Honestly, I don't think that it's all bad, but there's so much missed potential that it's really just dragging on and on. I mean, I just can't believe that 10 issues later, not only is the battle of the bands still a thing, but apparently is somehow the most important thing despite everything else happening. Hopefully it'll pick up once Shredder and the Pantheon come back.

ChosenOne
04-08-2021, 02:44 PM
I don't know what Namek is...:(

Honestly, I don't think that it's all bad, but there's so much missed potential that it's really just dragging on and on. I mean, I just can't believe that 10 issues later, not only is the battle of the bands still a thing, but apparently is somehow the most important thing despite everything else happening. Hopefully it'll pick up once Shredder and the Pantheon come back.

Go find out. I mean it. Go read and/or watch Dragon Ball, and start from the very beginning if you can, with the OG series. You won't regret it, you'll find out about a new franchise that's gonna blow your mind and become a fast favorite (there's enough overlap with TMNT and similar stuff to make me sure of that), and hopefully by the time you finish and come back, this comic will have gotten back on track. Hopefully. Fingers crossed.

TigerClaw
04-08-2021, 04:50 PM
First look:

https://is3-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication114/v4/72/19/76/721976ed-08c8-6a96-f795-ea314a879091/image-003.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is2-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication124/v4/fb/fa/3f/fbfa3f78-2650-812a-a5b4-0066d3a9cf34/image-004.jpg/900x0w.jpghttps://is4-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Publication124/v4/9e/05/93/9e05939e-cdb0-13a6-34d2-9a7b4dab7594/image-005.jpg/900x0w.jpg
Liking what I'm seeing so far, Cool that they manage to patch things up. Can't wait to see who else will join the ban.

neatoman
04-08-2021, 05:21 PM
I don't know what Namek is...:(

Honestly, I don't think that it's all bad, but there's so much missed potential that it's really just dragging on and on. I mean, I just can't believe that 10 issues later, not only is the battle of the bands still a thing, but apparently is somehow the most important thing despite everything else happening. Hopefully it'll pick up once Shredder and the Pantheon come back.

Right, quick explaination here. In Dragon Ball there is an arc where a few characters have to go to Namek because most of the other died, a planet that barely has anything on it except for a handful of natives. Most of the arc is about the main characters either hiding from, running away from or fighting the henchmen of the main villain. Unlike previous arcs, there is very little in terms of adventure, twists or even variety in scenery. Aside from introducing some very iconic elements of the series, it tends to come across as drawn out and a bit devoid of imagination.

Now out of the total 42 volume run, it takes up about 7 volumes (actually a little more than that but 7 in rough terms). Alternatively, when published in Weekly Shonen Jump it lasted from October 24 1989 to June 11 1991, so pretty close to 2 years out of the almost 11 year run. In the anime adaptation, it took 62 episodes to conclude, meaning it took up 21% of Dragon Ball Z (14% with Dragon Ball). Even in Kai, a cut of Z that removed most of the filler, it still took 35 episodes to conclude.

By my estimate, a completely new adaptation of the manga from start to finish would reduce the total episode count from 444 to a maximum of 130, in which case the Namek arc shouldn't be much longer than 20 episodes.

TigerClaw
04-08-2021, 05:33 PM
Are they still on Namek Mutant Town?
With comments like that, I think the writers will continue with Mutant Town as a spite.

Leo656
04-08-2021, 05:38 PM
I have no doubt that very much of what they've been doing is indeed out of spite.

The old Vince McMahon Logic. "People hate this? Cram it down their throats! That'll teach 'em... people will like what I TELL them to like!"

Always a sound strategy. That's why his business is doing so well, with record-high ratings and buyrates and... oh. Oh, my. You mean business is at a 40-year low, nobody's watching the product and if it weren't for Saudi blood money and high advertising rates they'd be completely in the sh*tter and possibly out of business? Golly, how on EARTH did THAT ever happen?! :roll:

ChosenOne
04-08-2021, 06:54 PM
Right, quick explaination here. In Dragon Ball there is an arc where a few characters have to go to Namek because most of the other died, a planet that barely has anything on it except for a handful of natives. Most of the arc is about the main characters either hiding from, running away from or fighting the henchmen of the main villain. Unlike previous arcs, there is very little in terms of adventure, twists or even variety in scenery. Aside from introducing some very iconic elements of the series, it tends to come across as drawn out and a bit devoid of imagination.

It's also pretty much the best arc in the series, hands down. Some of Vegeta's best moments happen there.

With comments like that, I think the writers will continue with Mutant Town as a spite.

In other words, cutting off the nose to spite the face. Always a savvy strategy in business or anything else.

lonewarrior20
04-08-2021, 07:02 PM
In other words, cutting off the nose to spite the face. Always a savvy strategy in business or anything else.

so, by that logic, skeletor is currently in charge of the series.
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/proxy/wIE91ymClhA9bixDhDPtoPeFJI71-4mtL2oJftLbkoFW4nzeQoKargjEdqOzV4EQNON9U0YKqdgeTcW YtPDohRquUoKspfcG9tkYZ3WVBWwnw2cBMErLHdK9xRORBnHFI Gn6nCcyy1gv40X0bnk

ChosenOne
04-08-2021, 07:06 PM
so, by that logic, skeletor is currently in charge of the series.
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/proxy/wIE91ymClhA9bixDhDPtoPeFJI71-4mtL2oJftLbkoFW4nzeQoKargjEdqOzV4EQNON9U0YKqdgeTcW YtPDohRquUoKspfcG9tkYZ3WVBWwnw2cBMErLHdK9xRORBnHFI Gn6nCcyy1gv40X0bnk

I always assumed Skeletor lost his nose in an unfortunate workplace accident that led him to turn to supervillainy but, y'know, it's entirely possible.

This guy too:

https://bigshinyrobot.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/skullmaster.jpg

lonewarrior20
04-08-2021, 07:12 PM
I always assumed Skeletor lost his nose in an unfortunate workplace accident that led him to turn to supervillainy but, y'know, it's entirely possible.

This guy too:

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/villains/images/5/50/Skullmaster.png

it's cause of this sketch i thought of him.
YWIMOf4hfjU

ChosenOne
04-08-2021, 07:17 PM
it's cause of this sketch i thought of him.
YWIMOf4hfjU

Oh. Forgive my ignorance. I'd never watched anything Robot Chicken-related until three minutes ago.

neatoman
04-09-2021, 08:55 AM
It's also pretty much the best arc in the series, hands down. Some of Vegeta's best moments happen there.


Yeah, it is good, hard to imagine the series without it. I just tried to point out why someone might find it tiresome.

CyberCubed
04-09-2021, 09:17 AM
Nah, the only problem with Namek is that Goku vs. Freeza goes on way too long. The whole first half of it leading up to that point is excellent (bar a few filler-ish stuff with Bulma that Toei threw in there). Even in Kai, Goku/Freeza still goes on quite a bit. But it was the most important fight of the series so it makes sense it goes on that long.

lonewarrior20
04-09-2021, 09:31 AM
really want to go fast, watch the "abridged" version.
"you punched me in the face!"
"you bit my tail!"

slashpieturtlemix
04-09-2021, 09:49 AM
Mutant town is that 400 episode Namek arc from dbz easily. Longest wait in history.

hypered1
04-09-2021, 11:13 AM
Nah, the only problem with Namek is that Goku vs. Freeza goes on way too long. The whole first half of it leading up to that point is excellent (bar a few filler-ish stuff with Bulma that Toei threw in there). Even in Kai, Goku/Freeza still goes on quite a bit. But it was the most important fight of the series so it makes sense it goes on that long.

The real reason that fight lasted for as long as it did and there are so many out of place extra episodes is because Toei continually had to create filler whenever their production outpaced Toriyama creating the manga it was being adapted from.

Joey Kamikaze
04-09-2021, 11:15 PM
Go find out. I mean it.

By watching Dragon Ball Z Abridged on YouTube.

ChosenOne
04-09-2021, 11:53 PM
By watching Dragon Ball Z Abridged on YouTube.

Good call but most of it's just gonna go over his head if he doesn't watch the real version first. Abridged is like watching a reaction video to a movie or show you've never watched before and know nothing about: still enjoyable but not as fun.

CyberCubed
04-10-2021, 12:48 AM
Abridged sucks. Watching it on its own is fine, but it's just a parody sub and not a replacement for a real show.

superstaff
04-11-2021, 08:01 AM
Abridged sucks. Watching it on its own is fine, but it's just a parody sub and not a replacement for a real show.

Yeah. I see way too many people recommend others watch DBZ and Yu-Gi-Oh Abridged without watching the originals, which is pretty dumb, in my opinion. Completely different experience, and it's less rewarding to watch those without seeing the originals.

Ninjinister
04-12-2021, 10:24 AM
I don't know what Namek is...:(

Honestly, I don't think that it's all bad, but there's so much missed potential that it's really just dragging on and on. I mean, I just can't believe that 10 issues later, not only is the battle of the bands still a thing, but apparently is somehow the most important thing despite everything else happening. Hopefully it'll pick up once Shredder and the Pantheon come back.

The battle of the bands was only introduced last issue....

Yeah. I see way too many people recommend others watch DBZ and Yu-Gi-Oh Abridged without watching the originals, which is pretty dumb, in my opinion. Completely different experience, and it's less rewarding to watch those without seeing the originals.

None of those "abridged" things are even entertaining in the least, either.

ChosenOne
04-12-2021, 10:57 AM
None of those "abridged" things are even entertaining in the least, either.

They can somewhat be, if one's already exhausted all other possible materials and is still craving for more. But in Dragon Ball's case at least I'd recommend the Multiverse fan manga over Abridged.

neatoman
04-12-2021, 01:00 PM
I'm honestly surprised that people would recommend DBZA to people without any familiarity with Dragon Ball. So many of the jokes rely on the viewer being familiar with the actual series, I just don't understand why anyone unaware of the references would get it.

If it's just to recommend to shorter version of the series, just tell them to read the manga. Seriously, it takes like two weeks to get through all of it. And if they refuse... Well... Ask if they're illiterate.

But if they really insist to only watch the anime, give them this watchlist:

Dragon Ball episode 1-29, 34-44, 46-78, 84-126, 133-148 (Yes, more than 20 episodes are filler, including the finale, maybe not pure filler but mostly filler).
All of Kai but preferably not the international version.
Battle of Gods
Resurrection F
Super episode 28-41, 47-67, 77-87, 92-131 (though to be honest, you might as well just watch the Tournement episodes where U7 members are either knocked out or knock out others).
Super Broly.


I still recommend reading the manga first and foremost. Not only is it far quicker and far less complicated than selectively watching the anime, there are actually two arcs not currently in anime form. And regardless of which you have to read Jaco to know who Jaco and the Galactic Patrol are, there is no adaptation as of yet but they are still important to the newer parts of the anime despite this lack of adaptation.

ChosenOne
04-12-2021, 01:03 PM
I'm sorry but recommending Kai, which doesn't have the original Kikuchi score, is just sinful if not downright monstrous.

neatoman
04-12-2021, 01:34 PM
I'm sorry but recommending Kai, which doesn't have the original Kikuchi score, is just sinful if not downright monstrous.

Yeah but... In terms of just making it shorter it's worth it. The problem with Z in it's original form is that the pacing is way too slow. There's really only about 30 episodes of pure filler that can be skipped but most episodes are dragged down with (at best) sub-plots and (typically) flashbacks. It's not really a good idea to recommend the show in it's original state to someone who just wants a shorter version. Kai is almost ideal in this case because it does remove a lot of the pointless scenes.

But as I wrote in a previous post, a remake would have been much better, that way there would be no filler at all or any other lingering attempt to slow things down. A new apatation of Raditz introduction to the ending of the original manga would not even be 80 episodes, it might even be as short as 55 episodes.

ChosenOne
04-12-2021, 02:05 PM
Yeah but... In terms of just making it shorter it's worth it. The problem with Z in it's original form is that the pacing is way too slow. There's really only about 30 episodes of pure filler that can be skipped but most episodes are dragged down with (at best) sub-plots and (typically) flashbacks. It's not really a good idea to recommend the show in it's original state to someone who just wants a shorter version. Kai is almost ideal in this case because it does remove a lot of the pointless scenes.

But as I wrote in a previous post, a remake would have been much better, that way there would be no filler at all or any other lingering attempt to slow things down. A new apatation of Raditz introduction to the ending of the original manga would not even be 80 episodes, it might even be as short as 55 episodes.

Yeah, it's a lot shorter and easier to watch if one doesn't care for filler, but the lack of Kikuchi, man... That soundtrack sticks with you for life, it's so damn gorgeous and iconic. Someone should rescore Kai with the original (Japanese!) soundtrack.

AlZarkovski
04-18-2021, 12:51 PM
Full preview (https://comic-watch.com/news/sneak-peek-preview-of-idw-publishings-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-116).

ChosenOne
04-18-2021, 01:07 PM
Is... Is Koya playing cards with Leo? :lol:

TigerClaw
04-18-2021, 01:54 PM
Full preview (https://comic-watch.com/news/sneak-peek-preview-of-idw-publishings-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-116).
This issue is gonna be fun.

CyberCubed
04-18-2021, 01:54 PM
Something about making a story about music in a comic book isn't going to go well, it isn't like a show/movie where you can hear the music playing.

phillytmnt
04-18-2021, 02:01 PM
I’m glad that after 16 issues post 100,we are getting a climactic battle in the form of a rock concert. Hopefully the next big battle will be decided by beer pong. Is this still a TMNT comic?

lonewarrior20
04-18-2021, 02:30 PM
i wonder if diamond moved in? it looks like their playing in one of the less renovated rooms.

TigerClaw
04-18-2021, 02:39 PM
i wonder if diamond moved in? it looks like their playing in one of the less renovated rooms.
Also Diamond is probably a good drummer too. I wonder who they will get for the vocals.

FrederikWolferson
04-18-2021, 02:43 PM
This is the "wouldn't it be funny" school of writing. Wouldn't it be funny if there is a battle of the bands? Lol,so random anf zany. ????

Zog The Magnificent
04-18-2021, 04:24 PM
It's like, I want to like it. I don't even mind it most of the time. I like to see where things go, and I'm along for the ride. But why in the name of all that is holy is a battle of the bands the most important subplot?!? There's like a million other things going on in this comic, all more interesting than this sublplot, and yet this one is the one that gets the most focus. I don't even hate the comic, I'm just disappointed.

TigerClaw
04-18-2021, 05:12 PM
It's like, I want to like it. I don't even mind it most of the time. I like to see where things go, and I'm along for the ride. But why in the name of all that is holy is a battle of the bands the most important subplot?!? There's like a million other things going on in this comic, all more interesting than this sublplot, and yet this one is the one that gets the most focus. I don't even hate the comic, I'm just disappointed.
Why not? I think its a fun thing in the comic.

CyberCubed
04-18-2021, 05:40 PM
At least this story arc is only 2 issues long.

Mutant Ninja Anole
04-18-2021, 05:43 PM
It appears the ‘music dealing with your past haunting trauma’ story is an ongoing theme.

I do wonder if this story was in part derived from old Jem and the Holograms story ideas Campbell never got to tell.

Zog The Magnificent
04-18-2021, 05:54 PM
At least this story arc is only 2 issues long.

I'm pretty sure if we count the first mention, the band took about 10 issues to resolve. Even for a comic known for it's slow burn storytelling, that seems a bit excessive.

lonewarrior20
04-18-2021, 06:16 PM
i wonder if rural route 5's important to diamond since it was painted on her wall and i had a thought, since we keep seeing peoples flashbacks maybe we'll see what diamond and who ever the other band members looked like before they mutated.

Leo656
04-18-2021, 06:18 PM
Why not? I think its a fun thing in the comic.

They literally explained it in the very Quote you're using, god dammit.

There's like a million other things going on in this comic, all more interesting than this sublplot, and yet this one is the one that gets the most focus.

And... they're right.

staypuftweepel
04-18-2021, 06:51 PM
I think as a kid I probably would have liked to see the TMNT play in a battle of the bands in some zany 90s comic. Hell I use to make my own TMNT concerts with the rock star toys. I can just picture some Ken Mitchroney art showing this in an Adventures comic. And it would have been great back then. This however is not a zany 90s comic, the Turtles aren’t even involved, and I’m 37. I don’t know who the audience is for this. There’s only like 2-3 people on here saying this is great while everyone else thinks this is lame. Kids aren’t even reading this. If kids were reading Turtles they’d have jumped ship once it got too boring and all of those kid friendly IDW comics wouldn’t have been canceled. I don’t think the art and storytelling works well for this type of story.

At this point I just think the editor needs to step in and move the book in a different direction. Also having Jennika “the brand new female turtle” be a punk rocker is one of the most cliche things you could do with her. Does every woman in every comic have to be punk and counter culture? I think she would be better as a Beatrix Kiddo type of character and not just the same girl you see in every cartoon nowadays. I think even making the porcupine into Jennika’s friend is lame. Does every character have to become friends now?

Andrew NDB
04-18-2021, 08:16 PM
I have no doubt that very much of what they've been doing is indeed out of spite.

The old Vince McMahon Logic. "People hate this? Cram it down their throats! That'll teach 'em... people will like what I TELL them to like!"

Always a sound strategy. That's why his business is doing so well, with record-high ratings and buyrates and... oh. Oh, my. You mean business is at a 40-year low, nobody's watching the product and if it weren't for Saudi blood money and high advertising rates they'd be completely in the sh*tter and possibly out of business? Golly, how on EARTH did THAT ever happen?! :roll:

z8cdBfMxFCw

ChosenOne
04-18-2021, 09:18 PM
Something about making a story about music in a comic book isn't going to go well, it isn't like a show/movie where you can hear the music playing.

I get the feeling we should be glad we can't hear it...

I’m glad that after 16 issues post 100,we are getting a climactic battle in the form of a rock concert. Hopefully the next big battle will be decided by beer pong. Is this still a TMNT comic?

Strip poker. It's why all the Turtles are wearing clothes now. *points at forehead*

Also Diamond is probably a good drummer too. I wonder who they will get for the vocals.

Well, there's a certain Japanese national coming back into play soon, so... I bet you the guy kills at karaoke. Among other things.

I'm pretty sure if we count the first mention, the band took about 10 issues to resolve. Even for a comic known for it's slow burn storytelling, that seems a bit excessive.

Imagine if ten years ago someone had told you that the major slow burn plots of this comic would be Kitsune's master plan, Null's master plan, and then the battle of the bands.

i wonder if rural route 5's important to diamond since it was painted on her wall and i had a thought, since we keep seeing peoples flashbacks maybe we'll see what diamond and who ever the other band members looked like before they mutated.

I'd much rather read a whole issue on Diamond's backstory that Jen & the Mutagrams, but at least it's almost over.

I think she would be better as a Beatrix Kiddo type of character and not just the same girl you see in every cartoon nowadays.

I was gonna suggest O-Ren, but we already have Karai... Jenny seems like she might end up as Vernita, making a go of a normal life some day or literally dying trying.

I think even making the porcupine into Jennika’s friend is lame. Does every character have to become friends now?

Yeah, it's a lot more fun when they're ticking time bombs like Stockman.

FrederikWolferson
04-19-2021, 01:16 AM
There are mangas that sell more then all the monthly American comics combined. Nobody knows why.

Cloudrunner
04-19-2021, 04:02 AM
There are mangas that sell more then all the monthly American comics combined. Nobody knows why.

Because manga stories tend to embrace the fantasy of whatever they are writing about, creating an immersive and different world that people can get lost in. Escapism is a huge deal, and western media (from comics, to movies, to games, etc) seems to have forgotten that in favor of stories that tie into or relate to real world events instead. Though a major part of that is people who are activists first, creatives second, and feel the need to inject political viewpoints or worldviews into everything.

Meanwhile those guys in Japan are more focused on telling good stories and giving fans what they want. And the difference in sales is astronomical. The top shonen jump mangas put even Marvel and DC's golden years to shame, and even low end manga tend to surpass sales of some of the most iconic western comics these days.

Honestly with how ****ed the comic industry is and how much of a juggernaut the manga industry is... you'd think the people in charge would get a clue and want to take a few pointers. But instead they wanna double down and drive their franchises into the dirt while continuing to hire activists from Tumblr to write for them.

Andrew NDB
04-19-2021, 04:33 AM
There is some pretty weird manga out there, but that's not a bad thing. While I don't see much of a pulse on there being a lot of actual activism in manga, there are definitely some components that could be construed as "political statements" threaded into many things... but never at the detriment of the story and characters, and never the driving energy behind it.

Though manga/anime/JRPGs does love their shady, evil megacorporations, for sure. Though I think it is more simply because these make for a consistently reliable antagonist force and less because these manga creators are trying to make a statement about Microsoft or Apple or anything.

frank_one
04-19-2021, 04:43 AM
I agree with everything you've said, Cloudrunner. The magic of telling a story just for the sake of it, that's something our part of the world has forgotten. Now it's all about pushing empty, stereotypical characters around trying to please minorances or to convey politic views.

Sad, sad, sad.

ChosenOne
04-19-2021, 09:03 AM
Political view, singular. It's always the same ideology. The other side, the normal folks, don't care one iota about pushing their agenda through entertainment and instead are only looking for good escapist fun. This will be a very interesting time for the historians of the future to study...

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 12:42 PM
I think comparing Japanese comics to the American direct market is apples and oranges, it's such a different marketplace/industry. Obviously the direct market has been in the toilet since the speculator boom in the 90s, but original non-licensed comics in the book market have continued to blow up and do insane numbers, like Raina Telgemeier stuff or the Amulet series, it's more similar to manga where it's original, new stories/characters and not revamped decades-old licensed material. The book market tends to be for younger audiences, though, maybe manga is like what American book market comics would be like if it had a broader age range. Every so often North America will get something that does manga-like numbers for older readers, like Scott Pilgrim, but that's like lightning in a bottle. Maybe someday we'll get there.

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 12:54 PM
It appears the ‘music dealing with your past haunting trauma’ story is an ongoing theme.

I do wonder if this story was in part derived from old Jem and the Holograms story ideas Campbell never got to tell.

No, I wasn't the writer on Jem, that was Kelly Thompson! I did get to write the Dimensions one-shot, though, I worked out all my leftover Jem wishes on that.

This current TMNT arc (113-117) actually originally had Armaggon in it, it was more like a Terminator thing, darker with more murder, and the music part was a much smaller aspect, so it definitely wasn't born out of unused Jem ideas.

ChosenOne
04-19-2021, 12:58 PM
This current TMNT arc (113-117) actually originally had Armaggon in it, it was more like a Terminator thing, darker with more murder, and the music part was a much smaller aspect, so it definitely wasn't born out of unused Jem ideas.

See, I read this and all I can think of is that you missed a chance, an historical groundbreaking chance, to have Armaggon tussle with Bebop, Rocksteady, Tokka and Rahzar... How could you?! :D

Disclaimer: I haven't read #115 yet and won't get it until Wednesday, so I'm just assuming there was a fight based on everything we've seen.

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 12:59 PM
At this point I just think the editor needs to step in and move the book in a different direction.

The editor is very involved, he's the only thing keeping me from killing all the characters and turning the book into a bloodbath.

Mutant Ninja Anole
04-19-2021, 01:19 PM
No, I wasn't the writer on Jem, that was Kelly Thompson! I did get to write the Dimensions one-shot, though, I worked out all my leftover Jem wishes on that.

This current TMNT arc (113-117) actually originally had Armaggon in it, it was more like a Terminator thing, darker with more murder, and the music part was a much smaller aspect, so it definitely wasn't born out of unused Jem ideas.

Ah, I confess I didn't read Jem so I'd forgotten that.

I don't think it's wrong to look at what manga and anime is doing and ponder why many kids and adults enjoy those instead of western comics and cartoons, but you are right that it's not a 1 to 1 comparison. And that we are, or have already moved on from newstands to things like trade paperbacks and such for comics/graphic novels. TMNT comics are one of a handful of comics I've bought as they came out, as opposed to reading the trade (Hoopla and Libby are great).

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 01:23 PM
I don't think it's wrong to look at what manga and anime is doing and ponder why many kids and adults enjoy those instead of western comics and cartoons, but you are right that it's not a 1 to 1 comparison.

Oh definitely, we should absolutely look at manga and figure out why it's overall so popular, I didn't mean we should just ignore it from a marketing/sales standpoint. I had a huge manga phase when I was younger, it was like a whole new world.

CyberCubed
04-19-2021, 02:42 PM
Manga is usually written and drawn by 1 person with a set ending in mind. American comics have constantly changing writers/artists and are written as if they can go on forever until whenever they get canceled.

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 03:05 PM
Manga is usually written and drawn by 1 person with a set ending in mind. American comics have constantly changing writers/artists and are written as if they can go on forever until whenever they get canceled.

Only American monthly comics, that's partly why I said it's apples and oranges and the book market is a better comparison, where it's more creator-driven the way Japanese comics is. There are some monthly series driven by one or two creators like at Image or Oni/Lion Forge, but licensed monthly comics are their own beast.

staypuftweepel
04-19-2021, 03:59 PM
The editor is very involved, he's the only thing keeping me from killing all the characters and turning the book into a bloodbath.

Interesting, so it sounds like a case of too much editorial haha. As a fan you never really know what’s going on inside the company. You can only speculate. I would imagine it’d be tough as writer, because if editorial was making decisions that fans disliked pretty much all of the criticism lands on the you. Also, I read your comments above. It would have been neat to see Armaggon show up here. Was your plan for TMNT post 100 very different from how things have become?

neatoman
04-19-2021, 05:08 PM
Editors are definitely part of a manga's direction. We were talking about Dragon Ball earlier and Toriyama wasn't exactly shy about talking about how his editors influenced him. The characters 16, 17, 18 and Cell (not to mention his various transformations) were only introduced because the editor wasn't satisfied with the designs of 19 and Gero, and kept complaining about the new villains' designs until Cell achieved his perfect form. When it came to aging Goku up he had to argue with the editors in order to make them understand the change was necessary, otherwise the series couldn't go in the more action oriented direction they wanted because it's too hard to draw convincing fight scenes with a child. The new Broly movie essentially exists because an editor convinced him that he should write a Broly centric story. And finally, the character Mashirito from Dr. Slump is a very obvious parody of the editor Kazuhiko Torishima, making fun of how Torishima kept rejecting his pitches.

So yes, technically a series like Dragon Ball is creator driven, Jump doesn't own the copyright as far as I can tell, they just publish it. That doesn't mean editors don't have any power, they still approve of ideas and it is their call to cancel the series if it performs poorly. I doubt we would ever see a Dragon Ball story where Goku snorts space cocaine and crushes Chi-Chi's head, even if that is what Toriyama really wanted.

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 05:44 PM
Interesting, so it sounds like a case of too much editorial haha. As a fan you never really know what’s going on inside the company. You can only speculate. I would imagine it’d be tough as writer, because if editorial was making decisions that fans disliked pretty much all of the criticism lands on the you. Also, I read your comments above. It would have been neat to see Armaggon show up here. Was your plan for TMNT post 100 very different from how things have become?

No way, it's just the right amount of editorial! Bobby is great. He lets me do a lot of what I want and helps finesse it, other times I'm not sure of something and he helps hash it out, other times I come to him with a bananas idea (like turning April into a mutant fly for example) and he'll have me sell him on it and then I realize yeah it's a stupid idea. :tlol:

My original pitch for post-100 had similar beats to what we're ending up with, but it was way more frenzied with more "big" things happening I guess you could put it, it involved Terrorpin (which I don't recall if we even have the rights to) and would have ended with a Mutant Town guerrilla warfare thing which I think was a good call to remove because it felt too similar to City at War. It also had things that were too much, like Raph gouging out Hob's other eye and Terrorpin eating Hob, and even MORE characters were involved like Shadow Jones (SOMEDAY I'll get her into the comic! lol). My initial pitch was definitely too much, I tried to cram way too much in.


So yes, technically a series like Dragon Ball is creator driven, Jump doesn't own the copyright as far as I can tell, they just publish it. That doesn't mean editors don't have any power, they still approve of ideas and it is their call to cancel the series if it performs poorly.

Yeah of course, I didn't mean editors don't do anything (except at Image or Iron Circus for example which don't employ editors), they're a big factor of the American book market comics I've been talking about since it operates more like traditional prose publishing. I mean creator-driven as in it's typically the creator who brings the story to the editor, the editor helps them shape it, and the creator is often the focus from a marketing standpoint.

lonewarrior20
04-19-2021, 05:50 PM
[QUOTE=Sophie (like turning April into a mutant fly for example.)[/QUOTE]
Would love to see the concept art.

MikeandRaph87
04-19-2021, 06:47 PM
No, I wasn't the writer on Jem, that was Kelly Thompson! I did get to write the Dimensions one-shot, though, I worked out all my leftover Jem wishes on that.

This current TMNT arc (113-117) actually originally had Armaggon in it, it was more like a Terminator thing, darker with more murder, and the music part was a much smaller aspect, so it definitely wasn't born out of unused Jem ideas.

I would have liked that better and no music necessary except maybe a Vanilla Ice look-alike.:tgrumble:

CyberCubed
04-19-2021, 06:58 PM
like Raph gouging out Hob's other eye and Terrorpin eating Hob.

:o

Poor Old Hob.

Sophie Campbell
04-19-2021, 06:59 PM
:o

Poor Old Hob.

He's got it coming!!!!

neatoman
04-19-2021, 07:20 PM
Wouldn't it be, i don't know, easier to demutate him or something? Considering we're talking about a series that has already had multiple writers and is expected to have more in the future, it might be better to consider methods of writing out characters in a way that is less permanent in theory?

Killing off characters that are mainstays in a book with multiple writers, is exactly the sort of thing that has lead to nonsense like War Machine, Black Widow, Red Skull and Doctor Octopus being replaced by clones so everyone in-universe can act as if they never died. Worse yet being when the death causes the writers to come up with contradictory resolutions, remember how the Phoenix was just a Jean Grey impostor and Madelyne Pryor was just a look-alike? Too bad they had to screw that one up...

Anyway, there are plenty of ways to write Hob out of the story, here are just a few examples:

Transform him back into a regular cat.
Banish him to Dimension X.
Have the EPF lock him up.


There's really no need to kill him.

CyberCubed
04-19-2021, 07:47 PM
He's got it coming!!!!

Wouldn't he be completely blind then even before being eaten? I can see why that pitch was turned down, Old Hob was introduced in the very first issue and was the breakout character of the IDW universe, having him killed off in such a way would be odd.

Mr_riddler
04-19-2021, 10:57 PM
Wow, Nick Furry doesn't deserve that kind of terrible fate.

Ninjinister
04-21-2021, 02:40 AM
Ha ha Bob and Carmen, awesome!

lonewarrior20
04-21-2021, 05:16 AM
i liked it, good work sophie, you had some good shout outs in this one.
was suprised tusk and koya became band members, glad my other guesses other than karai being a member were right.
sally's really getting a mane of hair growing and i see derbys still hanging out at the club along with the goth bat chick.

neatoman
04-21-2021, 07:18 AM
Can someone remind me again about why any of this matters? What happens if they lose? Bebop and Rocksteady get to play music at a bar whenever they want, that's it. And when this whole mutant town thing is over, then it's not like anyone will visit that makeshift bar ever again. If they win on the other hand, Bebop and Rocksteady aren't allowed to come back to mutant town, which also means nothing. Nobody in mutant town has any real authority and those two guys aren't exactly known to keep promises, why would anyone expect it to matter? And again, mutant town will be resolved somehow down the line, so who cares wheter or not they can set foot in a temporary slum?

The stakes were "Karai can't die or all hell breaks loose" which has effectively already been averted. The only reason for this band to exist is so that they don't "forget to have fun" and to make sure a similar scenario to Lita's future occurs. Of course since Karai already got to live, this future has already been averted and we have no idea about where things are going meaning there are effectively no proper stakes, so why should I care?

lonewarrior20
04-21-2021, 07:29 AM
Can someone remind me again about why any of this matters? What happens if they lose? Bebop and Rocksteady get to play music at a bar whenever they want, that's it. And when this whole mutant town thing is over, then it's not like anyone will visit that makeshift bar ever again. If they win on the other hand, Bebop and Rocksteady aren't allowed to come back to mutant town, which also means nothing. Nobody in mutant town has any real authority and those two guys aren't exactly known to keep promises, why would anyone expect it to matter? And again, mutant town will be resolved somehow down the line, so who cares wheter or not they can set foot in a temporary slum?

The stakes were "Karai can't die or all hell breaks loose" which has effectively already been averted. The only reason for this band to exist is so that they don't "forget to have fun" and to make sure a similar scenario to Lita's future occurs. Of course since Karai already got to live, this future has already been averted and we have no idea about where things are going meaning there are effectively no proper stakes, so why should I care?

sometimes, it's about the journey and not the destination.

CyberCubed
04-21-2021, 07:38 AM
I like how this issue brought back some of those new recurring mutants we've been seeing in the previous issues for the band, makes it feel like this arc is coming to a close. Glad to see Mona Lisa called out too.

Part of me still feels like all the future stuff Lita is saying is partly false, but who knows.

hypered1
04-21-2021, 08:15 AM
sometimes, it's about the journey and not the destination.

Star Trek Voyager fan?

lonewarrior20
04-21-2021, 08:30 AM
Star Trek Voyager fan?

well, it is the one i grew up watching. mutant towns in a way like voyager, a group of isolated people formed from multiple crews trying to survive with limited resources and in some ways trying to get back to humanity. i'm surprised they didn't get a species 8472 crew member or 2. one things for sure, hob is not tuvok. although sally does remind me of janeway. they also got into all kinds of side stories too.

superstaff
04-21-2021, 08:47 AM
sometimes, it's about the journey and not the destination.

This 'journey' feels like going to the dentist, waiting in the lobby for an hour due to your appointment being delayed, then getting your teeth checked, and being told you have a cavity and need to pay $xxx to get it filled.

lonewarrior20
04-21-2021, 09:00 AM
This 'journey' feels like going to the dentist, waiting in the lobby for an hour due to your appointment being delayed, then getting your teeth checked, and being told you have a cavity and need to pay $xxx to get it filled.

and yet, it needed done unless you want to lose the tooth, make your mouth worse from infection, or suffer in pain. i just noticed, leo's got his own garden/greenhouse on the roof. now that they've got the space, the boys are really branching out.

superstaff
04-21-2021, 09:17 AM
and yet, it needed done unless you want to lose the tooth, make your mouth worse from infection, or suffer in pain. .

I'm trying to say that it's been boring, long, and kind of annoying.

phillytmnt
04-21-2021, 09:31 AM
There has been no point to this story arc. It also has been painfully boring to read. And to think this storyline with Future Lita has been teased all the way back since issue 105! I know Sophia can write good stuff. I liked the Karai mini series a lot and her original ideas for this arc sounded good. I’m highly discouraged at the direction of this book. On the positive side, I love the art!

Sophie Campbell
04-21-2021, 12:15 PM
This 'journey' feels like going to the dentist, waiting in the lobby for an hour due to your appointment being delayed, then getting your teeth checked, and being told you have a cavity and need to pay $xxx to get it filled.

and yet, it needed done unless you want to lose the tooth, make your mouth worse from infection, or suffer in pain.

The easy solution would be go to a different dentist and next time make sure to brush/floss regularly.

superstaff
04-21-2021, 12:50 PM
The easy solution would be go to a different dentist and next time make sure to brush/floss regularly.

Ha. Well, I did drop your book a while ago. But based on what I read here, it doesn't seem like I'm missing much!

And I already do brush and floss regularly. :D

Sophie Campbell
04-21-2021, 01:33 PM
Ha. Well, I did drop your book a while ago. But based on what I read here, it doesn't seem like I'm missing much!

And I already do brush and floss regularly. :D

That's cool! Thanks for sticking around for a bit. :) Yes always floss!

superstaff
04-21-2021, 01:45 PM
That's cool! Thanks for sticking around for a bit. :) Yes always floss!

I like engaging in conversation about it since I am a TMNT fan, even if there's things I don't like. Who knows, maybe I'll read it again someday if the content shifts in a direction I enjoy.

lonewarrior20
04-21-2021, 01:47 PM
That's cool! Thanks for sticking around for a bit. :) Yes always floss!

so how long did it take koya to learn about dental hygiene since she was originally born with just a beak?

ChosenOne
04-21-2021, 02:01 PM
so how long did it take koya to learn about dental hygiene since she was originally born with just a beak?

Well, considering the fact that her best friend is a friggin' shark... Probably not long.

FrederikWolferson
04-21-2021, 02:30 PM
And it's not over yet.

CyberCubed
04-21-2021, 02:37 PM
Issue 117 is supposed to be the end of this "arc" although we still have Mayor Sally and Mona Lisa's storyline to go through...which will probably happen next.

FrederikWolferson
04-21-2021, 03:08 PM
Issue 117 is supposed to be the end of this "arc" although we still have Mayor Sally and Mona Lisa's storyline to go through...which will probably happen next.

The preview for #118 actually says: A new direction for Mutant Town. I doubt we are getting back to Ninja Turtles any time soon.

superstaff
04-21-2021, 04:15 PM
The preview for #118 actually says: A new direction for Mutant Town. I doubt we are getting back to Ninja Turtles any time soon.

And people wonder why I have problems with the current run...

Leo656
04-21-2021, 04:20 PM
They should just retitle the whole book "Adventures In Mutant Town - Guest-Starring The TMNT" at this point.

...Except then without the "TMNT" header there'd probably only be like eight people still buying it, instead of, like, twelve or whatever it is now.

Cloudrunner
04-21-2021, 04:31 PM
Man you've really shifted Mona from being a somewhat endearing new character to... frankly an insufferable bitch. I hope she gets some kind of character arc to restore some sense of likeability to her, unless the goal is to lead her down the same path as good ol' Mondo "Antifa" Gecko. As for this chapter... like... I dunno? I mean there's nothing inherently wrong with it other than the current plot not being interesting. I guess there's not really much point throwing more shade in that regard since other people are getting that point across already.

I like the art though! The colored past segments representing the songs is a nice artistic touch. I like that you're continuing to have fun dressing up Alopex in a new random shirt every time she shows up on panel. I still do like the romance dynamic between her and Raph and its nice to see it shown subtlety without needing to have them be overly mushy on every page. Just wish they had more ninja stuff to do alongside those moments I guess.

TigerClaw
04-21-2021, 06:37 PM
Man you've really shifted Mona from being a somewhat endearing new character to... frankly an insufferable bitch. I hope she gets some kind of character arc to restore some sense of likeability to her, unless the goal is to lead her down the same path as good ol' Mondo "Antifa" Gecko. As for this chapter... like... I dunno? I mean there's nothing inherently wrong with it other than the current plot not being interesting. I guess there's not really much point throwing more shade in that regard since other people are getting that point across already.

I like the art though! The colored past segments representing the songs is a nice artistic touch. I like that you're continuing to have fun dressing up Alopex in a new random shirt every time she shows up on panel. I still do like the romance dynamic between her and Raph and its nice to see it shown subtlety without needing to have them be overly mushy on every page. Just wish they had more ninja stuff to do alongside those moments I guess.
To be fair, She's not aware that the Turtles met Future Lita. If Mikey told her about Future Lita, Her reaction would just be like when Donnie told her his origin in one sitting.

Weapons@theready
04-21-2021, 07:58 PM
This Mutant Town miniseries isn’t as bad as some of y’all are making it out to be...

CyberCubed
04-21-2021, 08:06 PM
Tbh I'd have no problem with this story if it was part of a mini-series. I wonder when Tom Waltz will ever come back to write the main series. Surely The Last Ronin and the Annual can't be eating up all his TMNT-writing time.

hypered1
04-21-2021, 08:07 PM
To reiterate what's already been confirmed the next arc (118 - 123) will prominently feature Oroku Saki, so we'll finally get to see his new status quo since #100.

MikeandRaph87
04-21-2021, 08:45 PM
This Mutant Town miniseries isn’t as bad as some of y’all are making it out to be...

Miniseries? It has been going on since #101. I was tired of it after #103 and thought it would be back to serving the plot after #105 with the Turtles reunited,but nope.

CyberCubed
04-21-2021, 09:02 PM
Miniseries? It has been going on since #101..

It's sarcasm.

ChosenOne
04-21-2021, 09:36 PM
****, this was awful. And still one more issue to go... :roll: It breaks my heart to think of how much promise this comic started out with ten years ago, how much potential the post-#100 era had, and it's all been pissed away. Sigh... I'm not sure if even the Annual, The Armaggedon Game and/or a full-time return by Tom Waltz can right the ship now and save this from being cancelled sooner rather than later.

To be fair, She's not aware that the Turtles met Future Lita. If Mikey told her about Future Lita, Her reaction would just be like when Donnie told her his origin in one sitting.

Yeah, good luck with that whole reasoning-with-an-activist thing.

TigerClaw
04-21-2021, 10:02 PM
****, this was awful. And still one more issue to go... :roll: It breaks my heart to think of how much promise this comic started out with ten years ago, how much potential the post-#100 era had, and it's all been pissed away. Sigh... I'm not sure if even the Annual, The Armaggedon Game and/or a full-time return by Tom Waltz can right the ship now and save this from being cancelled sooner rather than later.



Yeah, good luck with that whole reasoning-with-an-activist thing.
She would've had a better understand if they had told her what's going on however.

Zog The Magnificent
04-21-2021, 10:16 PM
****, this was awful. And still one more issue to go... :roll: It breaks my heart to think of how much promise this comic started out with ten years ago, how much potential the post-#100 era had, and it's all been pissed away. Sigh... I'm not sure if even the Annual, The Armaggedon Game and/or a full-time return by Tom Waltz can right the ship now and save this from being cancelled sooner rather than later.

I have no doubt that it will get better, but yeah, I really hope that this doesn't result in an unceremonius cancellation. That would leave so much hanging, and we'd likely get another 6 issues or so to provide some semblance of closure, even though we really need at least another 50 to settle everything. Just once I'd like to see a TMNT comic get to the end without being cancelled.

TigerClaw
04-21-2021, 10:36 PM
I have no doubt that it will get better, but yeah, I really hope that this doesn't result in an unceremonius cancellation. That would leave so much hanging, and we'd likely get another 6 issues or so to provide some semblance of closure, even though we really need at least another 50 to settle everything. Just once I'd like to see a TMNT comic get to the end without being cancelled.
Looks like you all are taking this whole thing too seriously. The comic isn't gonna get canceled.

As far as my concern, The comic has been great, I love the direction it went. No more sewers, The only way to go is up to the surface.

Mutant Ninja Anole
04-21-2021, 10:42 PM
So there are certain aspects about this that I like, the subtle story telling with Jay no longer wearing his hood over his head, and the way the fonts and art lines let you “see” the music. I can see why Campbell might have wanted a musical story, simply as a chance to stretch out artistically. I’m mostly beyond arguing about the use of the setting and figure as long as I feel the desire to keep up with issues as they come out so I’ll engage with the series on its own terms. And in that regards, okay, cool art, okay set up to bring characters who’ve popped up over the course of the post 100 run for the big show down. I’ll probably buy the next issue, as I am interested in seeing if they go to town with the art for the battle of the bands. And then I am interested, though a bit anxious, to see good guy Saki in 118.

With regards to Mona, she is coming across as overzealous to the point of being a jerk here, and it seems intentional. I do hope it leads to something for her.

TigerClaw
04-21-2021, 10:45 PM
So there are certain aspects about this that I like, the subtle story telling with Jay no longer wearing his hood over his head, and the way the fonts and art lines let you “see” the music. I can see why Campbell might have wanted a musical story, simply as a chance to stretch out artistically. I’m mostly beyond arguing about the use of the setting and figure as long as I feel the desire to keep up with issues as they come out I’ll engage with the series on it’s own terms. And in that regards, okay, cool art, okay set up to bring characters who’ve popped up over the course of the post 100 run for the big show down. I’ll probably buy the next issue, as I am interested in seeing if they go to town with the art for the battle of the bands. And then I am interested, though a bit anxious, to see good guy Saki in 118.

With regards to Mona, she is coming across as overzealous to the point of being a jerk here. I sense that some people have a stronger reaction to people moralizing than I do. Same reason some people disliked Leonardo.
She also doesn't know that the Turtles got visited by a future version of Lita. If Mikey went into details what the other important thing was, She wouldn't believe it because its so crazy and out there.

lonewarrior20
04-21-2021, 10:51 PM
Looks like you all are taking this whole thing too seriously. The comic isn't gonna get canceled.

As far as my concern, The comic has been great, I love the direction it went. No more sewers, The only way to go is up to the surface.

no kidding, other than transformers, "spinoffs", and original stories what else does idw have? i kinda feel like i'm at a bar and hearing the others at the bar complaining on how the favorite team playing isn't following their plays that previous seasons did.

mrmaczaps
04-22-2021, 06:40 AM
Just picked up my copies (ugh) of 116 & Jennika 6. Mind numbingly boring. I really want to like this mess but I really don't give a rats @$$ about Jenny, the future turtle, the battle of the bands or any of this dreck. Either tell NINJA TURTLES stuff or cancel the series & start over. The Jennika issue had more action & even that wasn't much. Two YEARS of boring is a bit much. It picks up in the next 2 or 3 issues or I'm wiping my @$$ with this series. I'll pick up the final issues in a dollar bin some time in the future cuz thats the only place this mess will be....

superstaff
04-22-2021, 07:38 AM
As far as my concern, The comic has been great, I love the direction it went. No more sewers, The only way to go is up to the surface.

I don't mind that idea, of the TMNT being outed, and having to settle on the surface. Even the Mutant Town idea itself is ripe for good storytelling. My problem is the execution. It's very bad. The fact that the TMNT are still being sidelined is awful, and the actual stories being told in this setting have amounted to mostly shining a spotlight on Jennika, her band, and a bunch of other side characters. A lot of the stories being told also doesn't feel like TMNT at all.



With regards to Mona, she is coming across as overzealous to the point of being a jerk here, and it seems intentional. I do hope it leads to something for her.

I don't know... Based on what I've seen, it doesn't seem like we're supposed to dislike Mona Lisa. The tone reads as we're supposed to like and sympathize with her plights. I've found her to be unlikable, personally.

MikeandRaph87
04-22-2021, 07:58 AM
So #116, these ambiguous mutants who were jerks to the Turtles are recruited by the one they were cruel towards to help Jennika in a spontaneously put together heavy metal band and beat Bebop and Rocksteady in a music contest. Not exciting at all. The stakes are Bebop and Rocksteady either own a night club in a quarantine zone or are banned from it(though how are they going to forced to comply?). It's like the message is no one is the villain, but various shades of gray.The only thing I liked was Mona putting politics first was called out for being hypocritically selfish.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 08:07 AM
Right? Like WHY, for the love of all that is holy, are the TMNT guest stars at best in what is ostensibly their own book?

These types of stories are precisely what the "spin-off mini-series" gimmick was created for. It absolutely should not be the main book's primary story focus.

Point of fact, if someone like DC were publishing TMNT, this entire story would be one of those tie-in minis like "Final Crisis Aftermath: Dance!" that they sell you on by insisting that it's super-important to everything that's going on, then halfheartedly apologize for after the fact once they've got your money, once it turns out that it was indeed just self-indulgent filler nonsense. That is an absolute hard fact.

...Of course, if someone like DC were publishing it, it also would've been cancelled a long time ago on account of the fact that, y'know... nobody buys it and they're not running a charity but a business.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 02:07 PM
I think the reason why the Turtles are sidelined is so you can learn to love Jennika and accept her as the fifth turtle, but it seems like this Strategy is having the reverse effect with people. I’ve read all of these issues and I just can’t get into it. I hate to be a negative nelly, but the band idea is just so lame. Even Jennika putting on “band” clothes just seems like it’s trying too hard. The only thing that can possibly rectify this situation is if before they can even play next issue the two bands erupt into a fight to the finish. It’s always weird when writers try to write lyrics to songs that are supposed to be sung by comic characters. Unless it’s Judge Death singing as he’s slaughtering some cheesy metal band with the help of the Scarecrow. I think one of the biggest mistakes in this story is turning the vicious and evil Koya into a goofy goofer who’s mostly played for laughs and is now screaming in a metal band because she’s so angry. Ok. I just don’t understand why every villain has to be softened and turned into one of the turtles bff’s. The thought of her and Leonardo Eventually ending up together is awful.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 02:18 PM
I think the reason why the Turtles are sidelined is so you can learn to love Jennika and accept her as the fifth turtle, but it seems like this Strategy is having the reverse effect with people.

Historically, force-feeding people characters they didn't ask for, don't want, and don't care about has a way of not working out very well. But you'd have a very hard time convincing the pen-holders of this.

Case in point: "Batwoman" is still a thing, even though nobody reads her comic and nobody watches her show. Nobody cares right now, nobody cared 15 years ago, and nobody's gonna care 15 years from now. BUT, someone created her to make a point, and they're gonna keep pushing it even though Nobody Cares.

Jennika, same deal. Obvious Stunt-Casting Is Obvious. Nobody cares. BUT, there wasn't a chick Turtle before, and that's "problematic" in the Here and Now, so she exists. And so she's gonna be crammed down everybody's throats until they learn to love the taste, like it or not.

Remember when it was the READERS who got to decide what worked and what didn't, and the writers had to fall in line with that and not the other way around? Seems positively "quaint", nowadays. Now they just tell you what they're giving you and if you don't like it, "We don't want you to read it anyway, kthxbye." Heckuva way to run a business.

phillytmnt
04-22-2021, 02:23 PM
I don’t want to be negative either. I have loved this series for most of it’s run. But honestly in my opinion, story wise, this might be the worse stretch of TMNT comics that I have ever read in their history. I’m just flat at bored and uninterested in anything going on. I care for non of the mutant side characters . Why do we need Mona Lisa at all? I’m hoping things pick up when Saki comes back. I miss TMNT stories with the actual Turtles in it for more than a few pages.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 02:54 PM
Historically, force-feeding people characters they didn't ask for, don't want, and don't care about has a way of not working out very well. But you'd have a very hard time convincing the pen-holders of this.

Case in point: "Batwoman" is still a thing, even though nobody reads her comic and nobody watches her show. Nobody cares right now, nobody cared 15 years ago, and nobody's gonna care 15 years from now. BUT, someone created her to make a point, and they're gonna keep pushing it even though Nobody Cares.

Jennika, same deal. Obvious Stunt-Casting Is Obvious. Nobody cares. BUT, there wasn't a chick Turtle before, and that's "problematic" in the Here and Now, so she exists. And so she's gonna be crammed down everybody's throats until they learn to love the taste, like it or not.

Remember when it was the READERS who got to decide what worked and what didn't, and the writers had to fall in line with that and not the other way around? Seems positively "quaint", nowadays. Now they just tell you what they're giving you and if you don't like it, "We don't want you to read it anyway, kthxbye." Heckuva way to run a business.

You have this weird thing going on now where if you go on Twitter there’s a crap load of people who will swear Jennika is the greatest thing since sliced bread and will call you a bunch of names if you say you don’t like her, but you know that they’re also not buying the comic and you are. I don’t think any business should ever base anything they do on twitter’s reaction. I avoid twitter at all costs, but occasionally check out controversies for a laugh. I think it’s weird that people act like it’s a ground breaking idea, like The fifth turtle didn’t show up way back in adventures special 11 and Venus didn’t exist. Personally I agree with Peter Laird. It’s a lame idea. I think Laird made a lot of great choices for the line and some choices I didn’t agree with, but I think keeping the Turtles a 4 pack was important. Now three’s a crowd and the turtles have all turned into a bunch of wimps while Jennika acts like a ninja. Well when she doesn’t act like punk rocker. It’s a very cliche and lazy idea.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 03:06 PM
Consider the source. Even HAVING a Twitter is like wearing a giant sign that says "I'm A Huge Dumbass And Also Probably A Narcissist." The very existence of Twitter is the single worst thing to happen to humankind in the last two decades. It does nothing except give people a "voice" who either don't deserve one or are too stupid to know how to use it responsibly. The wisest, most self-adjusted individuals I personally know don't use ANY social media whatsoever. It's bad for you.

So basically, if "Twitter" collectively likes something, that's a pretty sure sign that it's bad. The "Moral Outrage Brigade" are the last people whose opinion anyone should put any stock into. That's who uses goddamn Twitter. They're the ones screaming to get people fired over jokes they made 30 years ago, or otherwise they're inciting riots. F*ck those people in the ear, nobody should listen to them.

They think Jennika's "great" because "It's 2021! We NEED a chick Turtle!" When the truth is, no, you really, really don't. It's just shameless pandering to the worst kind of people. "Real fans" don't care, and you can't force 'em to.

But honestly in my opinion, story wise, this might be the worse stretch of TMNT comics that I have ever read in their history.

Whew. Tough call. Vol. 4 still exists, and that's pretty godawful from a totally different direction. :lol:

At least this book doesn't look like someone drew it with their feet. So that's ONE point it has over Vol. 4.

FrederikWolferson
04-22-2021, 03:09 PM
And ofc,the Twitter people don't read the actual comic. Or any comic.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 03:12 PM
And ofc,the Twitter people don't read the actual comic. Or any comic.

They tend to struggle with anything that has more than 120 characters and doesn't allow Emojis.

Which is why the average 20-something Twitterista has to have Mommy and Daddy fill out their job applications for them.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 03:19 PM
Consider the source. Even HAVING a Twitter is like wearing a giant sign that says "I'm A Huge Dumbass And Also Probably A Narcissist." The very existence of Twitter is the single worst thing to happen to humankind in the last two decades. It does nothing except give people a "voice" who either don't deserve one or are too stupid to know how to use it responsibly. The wisest, most self-adjusted individuals I personally know don't use ANY social media whatsoever. It's bad for you.

So basically, if "Twitter" collectively likes something, that's a pretty sure sign that it's bad. The "Moral Outrage Brigade" are the last people whose opinion anyone should put any stock into. That's who uses goddamn Twitter. They're the ones screaming to get people fired over jokes they made 30 years ago, or otherwise they're inciting riots. F*ck those people in the ear, nobody should listen to them.

They think Jennika's "great" because "It's 2021! We NEED a chick Turtle!" When the truth is, no, you really, really don't. It's just shameless pandering to the worst kind of people. "Real fans" don't care, and you can't force 'em to.



Whew. Tough call. Vol. 4 still exists, and that's pretty godawful from a totally different direction. :lol:

At least this book doesn't look like someone drew it with their feet. So that's ONE point it has over Vol. 4.

Haha, Volume 4 had some negatives, but I at least felt invested in the story. The art was definitely a problem. I use to ask comic stores by me how Volume 4 was doing at the time because I generally want to see Tmnt comics succeed and know what are people’s responses. Almost all of them would say people never pick it up because the art sucks. I think Jim Lawson can be alright with the right inker. Unfortunately I don’t think the volume 4 inker embellished the pencils at all and just made it look exactly like the pencils. Did Peter Laird ink those? I can’t remember,.

I do agree about Twitter it is awful and seems to incite anger. I think social media can be a good thing. Facebook was fine for awhile when people were posting dumb cat videos and you could get in contact with people you hadn’t seen in a long time. I didn’t talk to a friend of mine from childhood for like 15 years since I moved and now we talk almost daily and he’s helped me get work with my art. The problem now is that people are slowly trying to turn Facebook into another finger waving political battle ground. It’s not one side either, it’s extremes on both sides. I usually just snooze people when I get tired of them.

FrederikWolferson
04-22-2021, 03:19 PM
Volume 4 comparison...V4 had some good ideas but the execution sucked (It also had a lot of terrible ideas). Mutant Town was a weak idea and the whole saga isn't even executed. It's just a boring nothing.

ChosenOne
04-22-2021, 03:19 PM
The concept of Mutant Town was great, could've been executed amazingly, and yet... Meh.

Jennika, same deal. Obvious Stunt-Casting Is Obvious. Nobody cares. BUT, there wasn't a chick Turtle before, and that's "problematic" in the Here and Now, so she exists. And so she's gonna be crammed down everybody's throats until they learn to love the taste, like it or not.

I wonder how long it'll be before we get a black turtle...? (****, now I'm giving them ideas.)

You have this weird thing going on now where if you go on Twitter there’s a crap load of people who will swear Jennika is the greatest thing since sliced bread and will call you a bunch of names if you say you don’t like her, but you know that they’re also not buying the comic and you are.

The hive mind functioning of the echo chamber at its finest.

Consider the source. Even HAVING a Twitter is like wearing a giant sign that says "I'm A Huge Dumbass And Also Probably A Narcissist." The very existence of Twitter is the single worst thing to happen to humankind in the last two decades. It does nothing except give people a "voice" who either don't deserve one or are too stupid to know how to use it responsibly.

No wonder almost all of them call themselves activists. Like moths to a flame...

If we ever find out Jennika's human surname, I hope it's Bohr. Jennika Bohr.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 03:26 PM
The concept of Mutant Town was great, could've been executed amazingly, and yet... Meh.



I wonder how long it'll be before we get a black turtle...? (****, now I'm giving them ideas.)

.

I’d make the argument that the original TMNT toyoine was already diverse. All of the turtles had four different skin tones.

TigerClaw
04-22-2021, 03:38 PM
no kidding, other than transformers, "spinoffs", and original stories what else does idw have? i kinda feel like i'm at a bar and hearing the others at the bar complaining on how the favorite team playing isn't following their plays that previous seasons did.
Exactly, Most fans out there kind of look down on the forum due to the shear amount of negativity going on, And its not a good look.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 03:50 PM
Haha, Volume 4 had some negatives, but I at least felt invested in the story. The art was definitely a problem. I use to ask comic stores by me how Volume 4 was doing at the time because I generally want to see Tmnt comics succeed and know what are people’s responses. Almost all of them would say people never pick it up because the art sucks.

Yeah, I've told my own anecdote a hundred times, but it's pretty much Exactly That. The guy who owned my local comics shop was FURIOUS about Vol. 4. "There's a new cartoon show on the air, new toys coming out... a Turtles comic should be flying off the shelves right now, but I can't sell two goddamn copies a month because it's a piece of sh*t." And two copies a month was all he ever ordered; I bought one, and one sat there collecting dust. The "big" store at the mall got bit really bad; they sold out of issue #1, obviously, but then they got stuck with like 20 unsold copies of issue #2. They just sat there for months. Eventually they just stopped ordering the book completely. Nobody wanted that stuff. Even if it wasn't obscenely boring, it was hideous.

I'm convinced that 100% of the issues of Vol. 4 that EVER sold, sold to people on This Forum and nobody else.

Exactly, Most fans out there kind of look down on the forum due to the shear amount of negativity going on, And its not a good look.

People on social media who haven't given TMNT a second thought since 1993 are not "fans", nor are people who would buy a piece of dog sh*t if it had a TMNT sticker on it so long as it would "support The Brand". And in either case they've got no business telling other people what opinions they're "allowed" to have.

People vote with their dollars. MOST people think the Status Quo sucks. A few good friends of mine recently quit this forum because the IDW comic was their last lifeline to TMNT, and they're sick of it sucking, so now they've just given up on TMNT - and this forum - entirely.

This Zootopia Fanfic stuff is Bad For Business and it's bad for morale. It's not the fans' fault it sucks. Deal With It.

Unless you're gonna buy ten copies of your own every single month, don't cry when it gets cancelled within the next two years. And don't you dare blame the fans WHEN that happens. Fair warning was given. People don't want This. They've been saying for almost TWO YEARS that they don't want it. You and your five furry convention buddies who still pay to read it aren't gonna keep it afloat forever. That fact might make you cry, but it is indeed a fact.

So WHEN it gets cancelled, you best not come in here blaming the Real Fans for their "toxic negativity". They've said over and over and OVER what they WANT to read and pay for, and they're sick and tired of being told that they don't matter.

We GET it already, you're gonna be the last rat on the sinking ship. That's nothing to be proud of.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 04:01 PM
Yeah, I've told my own anecdote a hundred times, but it's pretty much Exactly That. The guy who owned my local comics shop was FURIOUS about Vol. 4. "There's a new cartoon show on the air, new toys coming out... a Turtles comic should be flying off the shelves right now, but I can't sell two goddamn copies a month because it's a piece of sh*t." And two copies a month was all he ever ordered; I bought one, and one sat there collecting dust. The "big" store at the mall got bit really bad; they sold out of issue #1, obviously, but then they got stuck with like 20 unsold copies of issue #2. They just sat there for months. Eventually they just stopped ordering the book completely. Nobody wanted that stuff. Even if it wasn't obscenely boring, it was hideous.

I'm convinced that 100% of the issues of Vol. 4 that EVER sold, sold to people on This Forum and nobody else.

I believe it haha. It’s definitely for hard core TMNT fans or completionists. I think I came in around issue 12 and it was really easy in Pittsburgh at the time to find all of the issues I missed at one of the local comic stores. I still wish Peter Laird would have finished it though. I really miss the letters pages in the back and the small insights into Mirage Studios. The IDW letters page is nothing but positive letters. I can’t imagine that’s all they’re getting. Even Peter Laird would post negative letters and fight with people which I thought was great.

ChosenOne
04-22-2021, 04:01 PM
Exactly, Most fans out there kind of look down on the forum due to the shear amount of negativity going on, And its not a good look.

Oh, no, however will we live with ourselves? :roll:

Speaking for myself but with a sneaking suspicion that I'm not alone in this, I don't care about being liked on Twitter, and certainly not by that sort of people. I do care about a quality, engaging TMNT comic that manages to sell well enough to stave off cancellation until it's ready to finish on its own terms. And this was it, chief, this was it, but not anymore. You can label it as negativity all you want, me and everyone else without a pathological need for acceptance and fitting in with the hive mind see it for what it is: a reality check.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 04:13 PM
I believe it haha. It’s definitely for hard core TMNT fans or completionists. I think I came in around issue 12 and it was really easy in Pittsburgh at the time to find all of the issues I missed at one of the local comic stores. I still wish Peter Laird would have finished it though. I really miss the letters pages in the back and the small insights into Mirage Studios. The IDW letters page is nothing but positive letters. I can’t imagine that’s all they’re getting. Even Peter Laird would post negative letters and fight with people which I thought was great.

Yeah, I found him pretty self-righteous and whiny but at least he allowed for the pretense of an open discourse and not just an echo chamber. I respected that.

Not how it works in 2021, though. Now it's "If I just ignore the nasty people saying mean things, it'll all go away! Gee, I wonder why we can't move more than 10,000 copies of this book even if we Scotch tape it to a ham sandwich and hand it out to homeless people? It can't be US, it's the audience who's wrong!"

I honestly would like for Laird to finish Vol. 4. I'd probably hate it, but I'd also probably buy the last few issues just so as not to have an incomplete run. I'm supremely annoyed that I loyally bought and paid for so many issues of that dreck only for it to not even have an ending. Made all that suffering seem pointless. But I'd at least like to have a "complete" collection of it, so since I bought all the rest of them I'd buy the last few if he ever bothered making them. Otherwise, I wouldn't be interested at all.

But yeah, that book was a hard lesson in wasting my money on something I hated for no reason other than to "support the brand". It's really dumb to do that, and nobody ever should.

Powder
04-22-2021, 04:22 PM
Friendly reminder Tigerclaw hadn't read a single issue of this series until he heard through the grapevine it had become furry-adjacent. He also refuses to check out any of the previous issues. His posts aren't even worth acknowledging, he only crusades for his subculture.

This crappy little forum that nobody who even uses it enjoys anymore is hardly a bubble. I'm in TMNT groups all over the web, the opinions on this arc are pretty consistent. & it seems that the majority of those who fervently defend it, don't even read it, or never cared to read it before, or read it online for free, & stand by it now only because it suits their image.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 04:22 PM
Yeah, I found him pretty self-righteous and whiny but at least he allowed for the pretense of an open discourse and not just an echo chamber. I respected that.

Not how it works in 2021, though. Now it's "If I just ignore the nasty people saying mean things, it'll all go away! Gee, I wonder why we can't move more than 10,000 copies of this book even if we Scotch tape it to a ham sandwich and hand it out to homeless people? It can't be US, it's the audience who's wrong!"

I honestly would like for Laird to finish Vol. 4. I'd probably hate it, but I'd also probably buy the last few issues just so as not to have an incomplete run. I'm supremely annoyed that I loyally bought and paid for so many issues of that dreck only for it to not even have an ending. Made all that suffering seem pointless. But I'd at least like to have a "complete" collection of it, so since I bought all the rest of them I'd buy the last few if he ever bothered making them. Otherwise, I wouldn't be interested at all.

But yeah, that book was a hard lesson in wasting my money on something I hated for no reason other than to "support the brand". It's really dumb to do that, and nobody ever should.

OCD is a problem haha. It’s tough when you have to complete something just because you feel like you have to. At this point that’s how I feel about the last 16 issues of this run. I think the difference with Laird is he was writing the story he wanted to write. He didn’t care if you bought it, but I think he hoped you did. That’s a little different I think from that Kelly Sue Deconick video you posted where she was saying if you don’t like this I don’t want you to buy it. IDW at the moment seems to be a the comic they think people want to read, Or the comic they think will bring in more readers, but aren’t listening when people say it’s not the direction they want.

Zog The Magnificent
04-22-2021, 04:28 PM
Friendly reminder Tigerclaw hadn't read a single issue of this series until he heard through the grapevine it had become furry-adjacent. He also refuses to check out any of the previous issues. His posts aren't even worth acknowledging, he only crusades for his subculture.

I think we all knew that there was no substance, but apparently there was even less substance than I previously thought. How about that.

Regarding this series and Volume 4, I keep buying it because I'm a completionist with the stated goal to own at least one copy of every piece of the franchise. I'm almost there, too. But also, I do still care about the overall plot and want to see how it all resolves, even if the current focus is really boring. I would love to see an ending for Volume 4, even if it did suck. I've always held that an ending is better than no ending.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 04:34 PM
Friendly reminder Tigerclaw hadn't read a single issue of this series until he heard through the grapevine it had become furry-adjacent. He also refuses to check out any of the previous issues.

Is that a fact? I admit, I'm not up on my TigerClaw Biography, I mostly just know him as the Patron Saint of Bad Opinions. :lol: Like there's Good Taste on one side of the line and then Him way the f*ck on the other side, no matter what the topic is.

I'd think he was another "performance artist" like CyberCubed, if not for his persistent sincerity. Nobody's THAT committed to an act.

hypered1
04-22-2021, 05:01 PM
Friendly reminder Tigerclaw hadn't read a single issue of this series until he heard through the grapevine it had become furry-adjacent. He also refuses to check out any of the previous issues. His posts aren't even worth acknowledging, he only crusades for his subculture.
Is that a fact? I admit, I'm not up on my TigerClaw Biography, I mostly just know him as the Patron Saint of Bad Opinions. :lol: Like there's Good Taste on one side of the line and then Him way the f*ck on the other side, no matter what the topic is. I'd think he was another "performance artist" like CyberCubed, if not for his persistent sincerity. Nobody's THAT committed to an act.

Guys, don't attack people like that, it's completely unnecessary and I'm sure you wouldn't like it if someone did the same to you.
If they don't want to read the earlier issues of the series then that's entirely their choice, just the same as no one is forcing you to read the current issues.

hypered1
04-22-2021, 05:09 PM
I think the difference with Laird is he was writing the story he wanted to write. He didn’t care if you bought it, but I think he hoped you did.

THIS. This is what proves how hypocritical some of the so called fans on here are.

Because this is exactly the same situation with the people at IDW; THEY are writing what THEY want to write and THEY don't care if you buy it but they hope that people do.
That's how comics and books have always worked.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 05:28 PM
Aaaaaaaand WHEN it gets cancelled they'll blame US and say "You SHOULD have bought it" even though everybody hates it. Which is hypocritical and disingenuous.

Comics aren't "art for art's sake", it's a commercial medium where people vote with their dollars. If you don't give the audience what they want, they're perfectly within their rights to stop supporting your work. Refusing to give people what they want, force-feeding them something that they DON'T want, and then spitefully blaming Them when sales tank is just absolutely f*cking ridiculous.

The fact that this is a conversation Every Single Month like clockwork just illustrates how far off the rails this whole situation is.

Some Idiots: "It's TMNT, just like it and shut up! We're lucky we get anything!"
Anyone With A Brain: "That's not how any of this works."

And on and on and on and on and ON. For a goddamn year and a half.

I actually don't want the book to get cancelled anytime soon, I'd prefer it just get better and actually be a TMNT comic again. But I honestly can't wait for the apologists to completely flip their sh*t when it does inevitably happen, sooner than they want to believe. That's gonna be something to see, from the initial "HOW could this happen?" caterwauling to the "This is all YOUR FAULT!" finger-pointing. It's gonna be Epic.
-----------

Meanwhile, plenty of people have, and do, say a lot worse To and About me than anything I've ever said about TigerClaw, but I'm a grown-up and so I don't cry about it.

Also, not a nice guy and never, ever claimed to be, so yeah. I'd rather just be Right All The Time than "nice". Your notes about my conduct are duly noted, but I assure you they will absolutely not make any difference whatsoever, and so you needn't have bothered and should refrain going forward.

"Thanks".

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 05:45 PM
THIS. This is what proves how hypocritical some of the so called fans on here are.

Because this is exactly the same situation with the people at IDW; THEY are writing what THEY want to write and THEY don't care if you buy it but they hope that people do.
That's how comics and books have always worked.

I disagree. I think they know exactly what demographic they are trying to get. The problem is those people don’t buy comic books. I think they just want you to get over your hang ups and buy the book. The book reads as though it’s going for the whole Twitter/tumbler kind of crowd where everybody in the comic is friends and everything is a slice of life. Much like Stephen Universe enemies start out intimidating, but quickly become a joke. I love some slice of life issues of X-men comics, but I couldn’t see reading 16+ straight issues of it. you just called people out one comment above for “attacking” a member and now are doing the same thing claiming people are so called fans. Everybody can be a fan of anything for whatever reason they want. Just like everybody can have different negative feelings about the same subject. I don’t understand The whole ride or die mentality people have. Like when a band you love begins to suck people will be like “well real fans evolve with them”. Like they’ve become a part of you or something. They’re still getting my money I should at least have the right to say what I like or dislike about it.

Peter Laird did write his comics the way he wanted to and people complained and volume 4 sold like crap. If IDW fought with complainers in the letters it actually might make the book more interesting. Volume 4 was like an extra hobby for Peter Laird. He didn’t have to write it to make money. He was already stupidly rich and then became even richer once he sold the Tmnt. He could produce it just for the heck of it. This comic needs readers and buyers to buy it otherwise it will disappear. IDW supposedly is already having a lot of trouble. They could use the money from this book if they started making the book fun for readers who want classic ninja/sci fi Tmnt stories.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 06:21 PM
I disagree. I think they know exactly what demographic they are trying to get. The problem is those people don’t buy comic books. I think they just want you to get over your hang ups and buy the book. The book reads as though it’s going for the whole Twitter/tumbler kind of crowd where everybody in the comic is friends and everything is a slice of life.

BINGO.

For the record, I'm not allergic to whimsy or "slice of life" or any of that stuff. I wrote stupid fanfic that has a lot of that stuff. Sometimes A LOT a lot. So it's not like I don't get why it might appeal to some.

Thing is, 1. I'm not charging people four bucks an issue to read it, 2. I actually don't write it to be read by anyone at all, period, except maybe my wife, 3. It's not what I'd ever PAY to read in an actual TMNT comic, and 4. The vast majority of the audience would agree with me on the last point.

And if I ever WERE being paid to write a comic book, be it TMNT or otherwise, I definitely wouldn't treat the gig like it was my own DeviantArt page that I was getting paid to create. I'd feel like I had an obligation to both the audience and my employer to produce a product that would actually be a real success - as in draw a crowd and make money, not just appease certain "progressives" on social media who don't read comic books anyway. That approach has sent books down in flames every time it's ever been tried, with characters whose books sold a LOT more copies than TMNT does.

I just find the whole "Like it or don't read it, We Don't Care" attitude very arrogant and dismissive. Because when it gets cancelled, you already KNOW who they're gonna blame and what they're gonna say. They're gonna act like people didn't make it loudly and abundantly clear what they didn't like, what they'd rather have instead, and why they stopped buying the book. And they're gonna act like they were doing everyone a big huge favor just by putting out a book in the first place, and that everyone who didn't like it was to blame for it going under. When if they'd just listened to their audience, who knows, things might have improved.

Issue #100 sold a LOT of copies compared to the average for this title. That proves there was interest, even aside from all the speculators. They lost ALL of those people PLUS a bunch of them who had already been reading for the previous hundred issues. If that isn't cause for concern, it ought to be. And if nobody in The Office seems all that concerned... perhaps it's because they've already made peace with the fact that the book isn't gonna be around much longer, anyway, and just said "F*ck it, let's just do whatever we feel like." Stranger things have happened.

hypered1
04-22-2021, 06:36 PM
I disagree. I think they know exactly what demographic they are trying to get. The problem is those people don’t buy comic books. I think they just want you to get over your hang ups and buy the book. The book reads as though it’s going for the whole Twitter/tumbler kind of crowd where everybody in the comic is friends and everything is a slice of life. Much like Stephen Universe enemies start out intimidating, but quickly become a joke. I love some slice of life issues of X-men comics, but I couldn’t see reading 16+ straight issues of it. you just called people out one comment above for “attacking” a member and now are doing the same thing claiming people are so called fans. Everybody can be a fan of anything for whatever reason they want. Just like everybody can have different negative feelings about the same subject. I don’t understand The whole ride or die mentality people have. Like when a band you love begins to suck people will be like “well real fans evolve with them”. Like they’ve become a part of you or something. They’re still getting my money I should at least have the right to say what I like or dislike about it.

Peter Laird did write his comics the way he wanted to and people complained and volume 4 sold like crap. If IDW fought with complainers in the letters it actually might make the book more interesting. Volume 4 was like an extra hobby for Peter Laird. He didn’t have to write it to make money. He was already stupidly rich and then became even richer once he sold the Tmnt. He could produce it just for the heck of it. This comic needs readers and buyers to buy it otherwise it will disappear. IDW supposedly is already having a lot of trouble. They could use the money from this book if they started making the book fun for readers who want classic ninja/sci fi Tmnt stories.

On reflection I could have worded my second post a bit better (I was trying to point out the rose-tinted perspective some people seem to have and NOT directly attacking someone else's life choices like the others were) but the point still stands and you've just agreed that IDW has a target demographic. More to the point it's now beyond infantile that people on here are still whining until they blue in the face about the direction the comic has gone in despite the fact that Tom, Bobby and Sophie have all been on here and repeatedly explained why things are the way they are and why they will not be changing, ultimately it's probably not even their or IDW's call as at the end of the day it's Viacom/ Nickelodeon that call the shots (which everyone seems to consistently forget) and I sincerely doubt they care about the opinions of anyone here; the Bay films and Rise cartoon are proof of that.
Also for the record, I too would like to see more action or more classic TMNT-style arcs but I'm also accepting that there's going to be periods during the run that I'm not going to enjoy as much for whatever reason.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 06:42 PM
at the end of the day it's Viacom/ Nickelodeon that call the shots (which everyone seems to consistently forget) and I sincerely doubt they care about the opinions of anyone here; the Bay films and Rise cartoon are proof of that.

And those things did so, SO WELL, too! :lol:

...Maybe they ought'a START f*cking caring, huh? Couldn't hurt!

Or they can keep force-feeding people stuff they don't want, and keep blaming the audience when those things keep failing, bleeding money all the while on what used to be a really popular franchise and is now just a money pit kept afloat by people's nostalgia.

Glad it's not my f*cking money, that's all I gotta say.

ChosenOne
04-22-2021, 06:51 PM
Issue #100 sold a LOT of copies compared to the average for this title. That proves there was interest, even aside from all the speculators. They lost ALL of those people PLUS a bunch of them who had already been reading for the previous hundred issues. If that isn't cause for concern, it ought to be. And if nobody in The Office seems all that concerned... perhaps it's because they've already made peace with the fact that the book isn't gonna be around much longer, anyway, and just said "F*ck it, let's just do whatever we feel like." Stranger things have happened.

****, man... You're not exactly allaying my fears that there's a certain malicious glee involved in all this tearing down and burning to ashes and then dancing on top of the ashes of such a beloved and iconic franchise here, as is the way of all holier-than-thou "wokeness".

They can't create anything original that's even remotely good, so they take over other stuff and grind it down to dust.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 07:11 PM
I mean, I can only speculate. But I've been reading comics my whole life, at times I've been deeply invested in it. I've got like 28 longboxes full.

One thing I've noticed happen a lot, more than you'd think, is that when the writing is on the wall that "Screw it, we lost the audience, this thing is going down but we can still keep it going for a little while yet before we're forced to pull the plug," the creative team will just "vamp", because it doesn't matter anyway.

A lot of times In The Moment, a lot of books had a phase of "Why are they doing this?", and then later on it comes out that "Yeah, we knew it was going under soon but not immediately, so we just started kinda jacking ourselves off since it wasn't gonna make any difference." And in that context a lot of those questionable choices and decisions make sense, whereas at the time it was like "Don't they know this isn't gonna work?" Turns out yeah, they did, they just didn't really care anymore because they didn't have to. They were essentially just "taking a knee" until it was officially time to shut the lights off. If you go back and look at a lot of comic runs that had unceremonious ends, you'll see that happening towards the end. Not usually for this many issues, more like four or six or ten. But it happens.

Is that the case right now? I don't know, but it wouldn't shock me. What WOULD shock me is if this book made it to issue #200, or even #150.

lonewarrior20
04-22-2021, 07:26 PM
man, they way you guys are going on, it's almost as if you think there's a conspiracy at viacom and idw for the tmnt franchise to be a tax write off or something.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 07:38 PM
Viacom allegedly made back all their money from buying the brand within the first year or two of owning it, so anything since then is just "gravy". They own a ton of other stuff; if TMNT actually turns a profit then that's fine but if it doesn't, it's "oh well".

The entire comics industry is a loss-leader for toys and movies and TV shows, anyway; even the Big Guys lose money on their comics divisions but they make it all back selling toys. I doubt Viacom actually pays all that close attention to the IDW comic, aside from the fact that it's the only TMNT product that's actually on the market right now aside from the NECA and Super 7 toys, which absolutely make more money for Viacom than the comics do.

If they were in a position where the comic HAD to make money... it would have been cancelled by now. It coasts by because not only does it not have to make money, Viacom probably has no expectations that it ever will. The comic's only purpose is to remind people that "TMNT" as a brand exists while they work on another movie and cartoon. That's all any comic book is, anymore.

Powder
04-22-2021, 07:59 PM
THIS.Because this is exactly the same situation with the people at IDW; THEY are writing what THEY want to write and THEY don't care if you buy it but they hope that people do.

THEY didn't create TMNT. Peter Laird, did. The father of the property owes no-one. Apples & oranges.

lonewarrior20
04-22-2021, 08:17 PM
THEY didn't create TMNT. Peter Laird, did. The father of the property owes no-one. Apples & oranges.
actually i wonder what eastman and laird think of the current run. i mean how would their opinion weigh if they said they liked it?

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 08:27 PM
From what I understand Kevin Eastman was very supportive of Jennika when she was announced, but he also thought Venus was a good idea. Plus at this point Eastman draws a ton of covers for IDW so I don’t know if you could get an unbiased opinion out of him. Peter Laird was very protective of the series and could be very opinionated, up until he decided to sell it. I can’t imagine him caring much for this series. He wouldn’t even read it back when everyone was telling him to because they thought it was good. Venus supposedly helped drive the wedge between Eastman and Laird even further so I’m sure he wouldn’t care for Jennika at all.

MikeandRaph87
04-22-2021, 08:27 PM
actually i wonder what eastman and laird think of the current run. i mean how would their opinion weigh if they said they liked it?

Eastman will lie and endorse because of his financial stake. Laird will subtly jab and oerfer not to dive into it to avoid unnecessary frustration.

Let's just get out of Mutant Town at any cost!

Leo656
04-22-2021, 08:29 PM
Kevin is by now known to be a known shill who gushes over anything that keeps the brand out there. He'd say it was awesome, and nobody'd care either way.

He lost all credibility forever when he raved about how awesome the first BayTurtles movie was.

lonewarrior20
04-22-2021, 08:52 PM
so, by this logic, unless its something about how the comic is bad and you agree with it then its clearly a lie regardless if someone of authority is telling it.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 09:12 PM
1. Nobody on this Earth has any "authority" over Me, pal. Definitely not Kevin f*cking Eastman. I don't care what he created, frankly; to me he's Just A Guy. His opinion counts exactly as much to me as yours; which is to say, Zero Percent.

2. Saying it's good is a matter of taste. Poor taste, by many accounts.

Some people like black licorice, too. They're "allowed" to like it but nobody should ever give a sh*t what they say about anything, ever. Some people have the "opinion" That The Grateful Dead is good music. By law, they can have that opinion. But they're Wrong.

What the f*ck is with this whiny, insecure need/demand for other people to like the same sh*t that you do? Nobody's telling you that you can't like it; at most they're telling you that your opinion is a vast minority opinion. As long as thy can explain what it is they don't like, they can say whatever they want. Deal with it.

Not everybody wants to eat junk just because it says "TMNT" on the label. You can like the book all you want. You can say out loud why you like it, all you want. But quit trying to stifle people who have a dissenting opinion. For one, you're outvoted, and for two, it's vulgar and whiny.

For the millionth time, This Forum Is Not An Echo Chamber. If an echo chamber is what you want, stick to palling around with the Wokesters on Twitter and leave actual discourse to the Big Kids. A conversation forum isn't a one-way street where only one side gets to talk.

staypuftweepel
04-22-2021, 09:14 PM
so, by this logic, unless its something about how the comic is bad and you agree with it then its clearly a lie regardless if someone of authority is telling it.

No, I’m just being honest about Eastman’s motivation and Laird’s dislike of most Tmnt stuff that he didn’t work on. I don’t see how Eastman could really like the current storyline in Tmnt. Have you ever read the comics he’s made? His stuff is usually very fast paced, exciting, and full of action. He creates panels and page layouts that give you the sense of motion. He’s not going to read a Tmnt comic that barely moves and has a music battle unless it erupts in a car chase with machine guns. Sure Tmnt 11 volume 1 was a very slow and thoughtful comic, but that was right after the crazy ness of Leo and 10. Plus things picked back up again in issue 12, not 16 issues later. If you look at the comics he cites as his biggest inspirations it’s mostly action and adventure. Jack Kirby, Frank Miller, etc drew and wrote books to excite the reader and bring them along on an adventure.

frank_one
04-22-2021, 09:16 PM
I guess Kevin can't be considered "someone of authority" anymore. We will obviously forever love him but his word isn't worth a buck.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 09:21 PM
No, I’m just being honest about Eastman’s motivation and Laird’s dislike of most Tmnt stuff that he didn’t work on. I don’t see how Eastman could really like the current storyline in Tmnt. Have you ever read the comics he’s made? His stuff is usually very fast paced, exciting, and full of action. He creates panels and page layouts that give you the sense of motion. He’s not going to read a Tmnt comic that barely moves and has a music battle unless it erupts in a car chase with machine guns. Sure Tmnt 11 volume 1 was a very slow and thoughtful comic, but that was right after the crazy ness of Leo and 10. Plus things picked back up again in issue 12, not 16 issues later. If you look at the comics he cites as his biggest inspirations it’s mostly action and adventure. Jack Kirby, Frank Miller, etc drew and wrote books to excite the reader and bring them along on an adventure.

Yeah, this dude gets it.

Also, for the record, I'm really sick at the moment so if I'm coming off as way more short-tempered than usual, that would be why. My patience for nonsense is not in great supply right now so I imagine I'm coming off a lot more snippy than perhaps it's intended to be read. Just putting that out there.

Cloudrunner
04-22-2021, 09:55 PM
Friendly reminder Tigerclaw hadn't read a single issue of this series until he heard through the grapevine it had become furry-adjacent.

To be fair, I only started reading this particular run because I saw images of Alopex's sweet furry ass on some imageboards. But I ended up reading the whole thing from the start and really enjoyed it. Alopex herself, though some people will disagree (and I think that's partly because she's been handled pretty poorly at times in the book), I think fits very well into this book. I think she's had character development and growth and remained at least mildly interesting, with some low points, throughout the series. And even her romance with Raph is earned as they've been interacting for practically the entire run. I think she's a good addition that honestly, along with Old Hob, deserves to become a staple in other iterations (and no, I don't mean to have a completely different character wearing a Naruto outfit who's only similarity is having the same ****ing name). I DEFINITELY cannot say the same thing about the characters being added recently.

Even as someone who's also "furry-adjacent" though, Mutant Town does nothing for me. I don't need a whole town of random furries in this book. It used to be that each new mutant added was something new and interesting, you'd want to know what their abilities/traits were, what they'd add and what kind of threat (or rarely, help) they'd be to the heroes. Now it's just a bunch of background characters who's animal aspect is completely incidental. And Sophie in particular seems to have an obsession with making them gender ambiguous as well even though almost every new character turns out to be female lol. I'm just not exactly sure who those characters are for. Are you trying to bait furries or not? Cause I'm pretty sure the only one who's ever actually stuck with that crowd is Alopex... and you know why. :grin:

Assuming then that the book isn't being designed as some elaborate furry fanfic, I'd again have to wonder who all this is for. I don't think any of these new characters are resonating with people. Even introducing a new version of an existing character like Mona Lisa ends up just being a flash in the pan of like "Oh yeah! I recognize that name." And then it's gone. Cause the setting isn't interesting and thus the characters become uninteresting by proxy. It's like Mutant Town is a black hole, sucking the life out of every new reveal.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 10:08 PM
To be fair, I only started reading this particular run because I saw images of Alopex's sweet furry ass on some imageboards.

:lol::lol::lol: Your boldness makes me smile and I definitely needed that laugh today. Thanks, pal.

...She is pretty decent. I just wish she had bigger boobs. :trazz: That's why out of all the arbitrary secondary characters/love interests that have ever been crammed into the mythos, Ninjara remains the GOAT. :tgrin:

Andrew NDB
04-22-2021, 11:02 PM
Eastman will lie and endorse because of his financial stake.

I don't think that's true. I've heard him endorse TMNT things he had nothing to do with a few times.

He lost all credibility forever when he raved about how awesome the first BayTurtles movie was.

Not with NT:TNM, when he went into every interview talking about how much older and gritty the Turtles would be in it?

Peter Laird was very protective of the series and could be very opinionated, up until he decided to sell it. I can’t imagine him caring much for this series. He wouldn’t even read it back when everyone was telling him to because they thought it was good. Venus supposedly helped drive the wedge between Eastman and Laird even further so I’m sure he wouldn’t care for Jennika at all.

I think Peter would actually like a lot of unexpected things in IDW TMNT... but I generally think he would dislike more things than find things that he liked.

Leo656
04-22-2021, 11:47 PM
Not with NT:TNM, when he went into every interview talking about how much older and gritty the Turtles would be in it?


Yeah, that happened. But the fact that 20 years went by and he was still spewing nonsense just kind of compounds the sin.

Probably a pretty nice guy, all things considered. Wouldn't mind having a beer with him and shooting the sh*t. But some people practically deify him and Laird to a degree that I just can't get down with. They've both done Good Things and Awful Things in just about equal measure. So aside from the fact that "One night, they both got really high on weed and had a Really Cool Idea and remembered to at least sketch it down, and to this day we all benefit from it", I'm not terribly awestruck. People have gotten stoned and had As Good or Better ideas, they just didn't all get to have their own cartoon show out of it.

FrederikWolferson
04-23-2021, 12:35 AM
Laird and Murphy arguing with readers in the letters was one of the funnier artefacts of V4 and Tales V2.
IIRC,Lairds comment on IDW run (on his blog) was something along the lines of: I don't read it,but Kevin and co are doing good from what I hear.
So maybe he just doesn't care. Or didn't want to be a dick to Eastman.

Allio
04-23-2021, 01:14 AM
Issue was... okay. Lately I haven’t really been able to get into monthly comic book reads. I mean I can’t really feel something in less than 5 minutes

superstaff
04-23-2021, 06:00 AM
To be fair, I only started reading this particular run because I saw images of Alopex's sweet furry ass on some imageboards. But I ended up reading the whole thing from the start and really enjoyed it. Alopex herself, though some people will disagree (and I think that's partly because she's been handled pretty poorly at times in the book), I think fits very well into this book. I think she's had character development and growth and remained at least mildly interesting, with some low points, throughout the series. And even her romance with Raph is earned as they've been interacting for practically the entire run. I think she's a good addition that honestly, along with Old Hob, deserves to become a staple in other iterations (and no, I don't mean to have a completely different character wearing a Naruto outfit who's only similarity is having the same ****ing name). I DEFINITELY cannot say the same thing about the characters being added recently.

God, yes. Those two were amazing additions. Love them both, and those are two characters I'd like to see show up in other TMNT media. Alopex's inclusion in the 2012 show was great, but I was disappointed that she was immediately discarded since she only appeared once.

On the subject of Eastman and Laird, I've disagreed with many of their opinions over time. Anyone remember how Laird supported Back to the Sewers having baby turtles as the stars? Yeah. Good thing they didn't go with that idea... Not to mention, the volume 4 subject. But hey, I'll take the weirdness and off-putting storylines/reveals in volume 4 than the current IDW run because at least the focus is on the TMNT and their supporting cast.

I also agree with many of the comments here that say that the creators will point fingers at us if the comic failed. I've seen this happen before, in the comics industry and outside of it. I mean, both Tom Waltz and Sophie Campbell both told me and others on here to basically drop the book, and not read it anymore. It's very alienating to read that as a fan, and there's always this arrogance to their tone when they say that. Sorry if either of you read this comment, but it's how I feel... I think it's clear they don't view me as someone they respect or want to read their stories, for better or worse. Thus I won't, which is a shame because I am into TMNT again after years of being inactive, and there isn't much going on in the franchise aside from the IDW book, and the upcoming ROTTMNT movie.

However, I guess it's fine because I would've given up on the book already anyhow since I don't like it, and I can now focus on other things I do like. So...win-win, I guess?

neatoman
04-23-2021, 06:22 AM
Friendly reminder Tigerclaw hadn't read a single issue of this series until he heard through the grapevine it had become furry-adjacent. He also refuses to check out any of the previous issues. His posts aren't even worth acknowledging, he only crusades for his subculture.

I can't say I'm surprised, his opinion really does stink of selective reading.

Leo656
04-23-2021, 07:34 AM
Sheeeeeeiiiit, I wouldn't even say that a person being "furry-adjacent" is any excuse. I mean, if Krystal from Star Fox is "wrong" I'd never, ever wanna be "right"... but c'mon, there's like no ass in this book. :trazz: Alright, Alopex, but who else? WHO I ASK YOU?!

If someone is seriously getting their "furry fix" from THIS book they must have seriously low standards, that's all I gotta say.

neatoman
04-23-2021, 12:11 PM
Sheeeeeeiiiit, I wouldn't even say that a person being "furry-adjacent" is any excuse. I mean, if Krystal from Star Fox is "wrong" I'd never, ever wanna be "right"... but c'mon, there's like no ass in this book. :trazz: Alright, Alopex, but who else? WHO I ASK YOU?!

If someone is seriously getting their "furry fix" from THIS book they must have seriously low standards, that's all I gotta say.

Well, Robert did claim to be sexually attracted to Bugs Bunny when he was a kid and fondled the cover of a Bugs Bunny comic, so who really knows what it takes?
4NaQRyc6BkI

It does make me curious about which cover he was talking about, here are my best guesses based on the time they came out... And if there's anything remotely sexual about them...
https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/pRcAAOxyJ59RG8N2/s-l300.jpghttps://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/wYUAAOSw86pfw7p~/s-l300.jpghttps://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/Ix4AAOSw1PxezuEo/s-l300.jpghttps://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/618nHL3ONjL._AC_.jpg
https://d1466nnw0ex81e.cloudfront.net/n_iv/600/886347.jpghttps://d1466nnw0ex81e.cloudfront.net/n_iv/600/798351.jpghttps://cybercomicsandtoys.com/images/comics/8/Four%20Color%20Comics%20(Dell)%20142%20Bugs%20Bunn y%20and%20the%20Haunted%20Mountains.JPG

Leo656
04-23-2021, 12:28 PM
What the f*ck, man. :lol: You're kind of a nut, y'know that?

...Swap Lola Bunny in for some'a those shots though and I might need about a week's vacation. :lol:

neatoman
04-23-2021, 12:47 PM
Hey, don't look at me, Crumb is the one who claimed Bugs Bunny gave him a stiffy, I'm just trying figure out what cover gave him one! :lol:

... But my money's on the bondage one, seems to be in line with his typical kinks...

In all seriousness though, I find it interesting that it's Bugs Bunny that turned him on. If you look at his artwork, you'd never get the impression he's attracted to men.

Leo656
04-23-2021, 12:53 PM
O2djHEIxPVs

neatoman
04-23-2021, 01:34 PM
Well that one I can understand. When Bugs crossdresses it's typically for the purpose seduction, there is clearly meant to be a sexual component to it.

Plus, you know, Tex Avery...
xEilRFdjV80

Cyndaquilfan123
04-23-2021, 02:09 PM
Laird and Murphy arguing with readers in the letters was one of the funnier artefacts of V4 and Tales V2.
IIRC,Lairds comment on IDW run (on his blog) was something along the lines of: I don't read it,but Kevin and co are doing good from what I hear.
So maybe he just doesn't care. Or didn't want to be a dick to Eastman.

Out of curiosity, is there anywhere on the internet I can find these letters? I'd really like to read them.

Andrew NDB
04-23-2021, 02:12 PM
Laird and Murphy arguing with readers in the letters was one of the funnier artefacts of V4 and Tales V2.
IIRC,Lairds comment on IDW run (on his blog) was something along the lines of: I don't read it,but Kevin and co are doing good from what I hear.
So maybe he just doesn't care. Or didn't want to be a dick to Eastman.

Yeah, I remember him answering questions to that end mostly like, "I am happy that he seems to be happy working on the IDW comic."

FrederikWolferson
04-23-2021, 03:35 PM
Out of curiosity, is there anywhere on the internet I can find these letters? I'd really like to read them.

Trust me, you're not missing anything. Somebody writes in about environmentalist preaching or Bush and Murphy answers how hes not taking sides because he's a big brain centrist.

lonewarrior20
04-26-2021, 07:15 PM
while the battle of the bands is going on, who's watching the dojo? i mean the kid's will most likely be fine, but there's two large problems in the back yard.

TigerClaw
04-27-2021, 05:35 AM
while the battle of the bands is going on, who's watching the dojo? i mean the kid's will most likely be fine, but there's two large problems in the back yard.
They are probably out in the back yard playing with them.