View Full Version : TMNT #118 Preview and Discussion
TigerClaw
06-22-2021, 12:45 PM
Issue 118 comes out tomorrow, Here's a preview of it.
https://www.previewsworld.com/SiteImage/PrevuePage/STL186650/3
https://www.previewsworld.com/SiteImage/PrevuePage/STL186650/4
https://www.previewsworld.com/SiteImage/PrevuePage/STL186650/5
https://www.previewsworld.com/SiteImage/PrevuePage/STL186650/6
https://www.previewsworld.com/SiteImage/PrevuePage/STL186650/7
oldmanwinters
06-22-2021, 12:57 PM
"Uncle Shredder" needs a day job or something. Maybe he could become a lawyer in Bel Air?
CyberCubed
06-22-2021, 01:02 PM
Hm, how does Saki know Lita? Is he from the future timeline or something? Doesn't really make sense for the Saki who was just brought back to life 6 months ago to be on such friendly terms with her.
Coola Yagami
06-22-2021, 01:06 PM
What the flying hell is going on????? What happened to Saki in hell?
ChosenOne
06-22-2021, 01:11 PM
Hm, how does Saki know Lita? Is he from the future timeline or something? Doesn't really make sense for the Saki who was just brought back to life 6 months ago to be on such friendly terms with her.
Beat me to it. Unless there's a whole lot about him (his new "him") we don't know yet and this isn't as humungous of a plot hole as it looks right now... But on the surface, yikes!
What the flying hell is going on????? What happened to Saki in hell?
Saki the Friendly Ghost! The plot thickens... Holy hell (literally), am I excited for this!
lonewarrior20
06-22-2021, 02:15 PM
i'm wondering why the weasels didn't say anything other than not wanting to get into trouble. as for knowing lita, maybe it's a timey whimy thing.
ChosenOne
06-22-2021, 02:28 PM
i'm wondering why the weasels didn't say anything other than not wanting to get into trouble. as for knowing lita, maybe it's a timey whimy thing.
Could be. Maybe we're just overthinking this. Time isn't linear in the afterlife, after all, which makes them both time travelers in a way.
AquaParade
06-22-2021, 02:58 PM
Beat me to it. Unless there's a whole lot about him (his new "him") we don't know yet and this isn't as humungous of a plot hole as it looks right now... But on the surface, yikes!
Saki the Friendly Ghost! The plot thickens... Holy hell (literally), am I excited for this!
Wow I’m surprised to see you are excited for this book after your tantrum in the other thread, ngl. Glad you’re actually enjoying some of the IDW books, because I was certain you were arguing my point that IDW has been putting out a lot of great stuff.
Coola Yagami
06-22-2021, 04:08 PM
Wow I’m surprised to see you are excited for this book after your tantrum in the other thread, ngl. Glad you’re actually enjoying some of the IDW books, because I was certain you were arguing my point that IDW has been putting out a lot of great stuff.
Maybe because the plot is finally starting to pick up some? And cause it's finally starting to deal with character we actually care about, like Saki?
ChosenOne
06-22-2021, 04:15 PM
Wow I’m surprised to see you are excited for this book after your tantrum in the other thread, ngl. Glad you’re actually enjoying some of the IDW books, because I was certain you were arguing my point that IDW has been putting out a lot of great stuff.
Heh... "My" tantrum, yeah.
See? What did I tell you about not getting other people's points? Of course I'm excited for anything that gets this comic back on track, and giving us a glimpse at what Saki's been up to all this time and what his presence might entail in the future is no small part of that. I'm sure IDW puts out lots of great other stuff, but I came and stayed for IDW TMNT, which has been far from great in recent months. Even the smallest spark can rekindle the fires of hope, though.
Now please settle down and let's wait to see what tomorrow's issue brings.
Maybe because the plot is finally starting to pick up some? And cause it's finally starting to deal with character we actually care about, like Saki?
Beat me to it again. You guys are faster than Saki today!
CyberCubed
06-22-2021, 04:44 PM
Maybe because the plot is finally starting to pick up some? And cause it's finally starting to deal with character we actually care about, like Saki?
Judging by the first few pages, I think this issue will be a slow-burn.
ChosenOne
06-22-2021, 04:53 PM
Judging by the first few pages, I think this issue will be a slow-burn.
The last few months have redefined that notion. This kind of slow burn, I like.
AquaParade
06-22-2021, 05:45 PM
Heh... "My" tantrum, yeah.
See? What did I tell you about not getting other people's points? Of course I'm excited for anything that gets this comic back on track, and giving us a glimpse at what Saki's been up to all this time and what his presence might entail in the future is no small part of that. I'm sure IDW puts out lots of great other stuff, but I came and stayed for IDW TMNT, which has been far from great in recent months. Even the smallest spark can rekindle the fires of hope, though.
Now please settle down and let's wait to see what tomorrow's issue brings.
Well yeah, you had a fit, calling me a hive-mind, or something, because we disagreed about the comic book.
Point is, I'm surprised to see you excited for the book after your comments in that thread is all. Anyone would be. I guess seeing Saki really excites you? Makes sense if so, as he is a "main cast" character.
Allio
06-22-2021, 05:57 PM
Hm, how does Saki know Lita? Is he from the future timeline or something? Doesn't really make sense for the Saki who was just brought back to life 6 months ago to be on such friendly terms with her.
Well there is the whole past and future running side-by-side in hell, might be related.
ChosenOne
06-22-2021, 06:20 PM
Well yeah, you had a fit, calling me a hive-mind, or something, because we disagreed about the comic book.
Point is, I'm surprised to see you excited for the book after your comments in that thread is all. Anyone would be. I guess seeing Saki really excites you? Makes sense if so, as he is a "main cast" character.
You and I remember Budapest very differently.
Can't be that surprising, considering you then go on to summarize the exact reasons why I'm so optimistic about this particular issue... ;) And yes, consider this a confirmation of your theory. But let's wait and see what comes out of it.
lonewarrior20
06-22-2021, 06:24 PM
i think one of the weirdest things is seeing shredder smile.
ChosenOne
06-22-2021, 06:28 PM
i think one of the weirdest things is seeing shredder smile.
Yeah, but see, his scowl in the first panel balances it out. :D
CyberCubed
06-23-2021, 09:08 AM
For some reason Shredder despite now being alive, is now apparently able to move in ghostly-form, able to travel between walls and apparently long distances. I'm not sure when this was established, as I'm pretty sure this is the first time we're seeing this.
April on the run from mutant eels was nice as well as her getting bitten, but I hope she doesn't get mutated. Seems Baxter has finally turned on her, although it does feel a bit abrupt. The new black assistant feels like she will be a love interest for Baxter at some point. Good issue and better than the last few, but again the Turtles themselves hardly get any screentime.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 10:10 AM
Damn, that was brutal! The bite on April's leg is probably one of the most serious, bloodiest injuries we've seen in this comic. Sure, there have been other leg injuries, but none quite so bloody. I knew the classic April vs Baxter scenario would happen, I just didn't expect it to be so intense. This is good sh*t.
Null and the EPF are back in play too... Zara works for Null, right? As a liaison with the Mayor's office or what-have-you? She reminds me of Mercy Graves, though the character's name and her association with the baby Slitheries - aquatic monsters, pretty much - makes me hope she'll eventually meet the same end as a more infamous Zara. :tcool:
I expect this whole thing will end in a stalemate between April and Baxter in the public eye, partially thanks to the reporter, but she'll no longer have inside access. On the plus side, she now knows he is actively involved with Null and can (finally!) put the Turtles onto our favorite long-neglected little she-devil.
Gotta be honest, Saki suggesting a riff to Jennika is one of the silliest things I've ever read. And this is TMNT we're talking. Silly is the name of the game. His Big Damn Heroes moment in the sewers more than makes up for it, though.
Oh, and I love the little detail of Donnie using chopsticks to type on the laptop because of his fingers!
Please keep this edge-of-your-seat quality up, progress the actual plot threads instead of nonsensical SJW detours and give the OG Turtles a bit more focus, and we're golden.
spookycookies
06-23-2021, 10:35 AM
The IDW shredder was one of my favorite versions of the character and I'm interested to see where this goes.
I am surprised that they did print a negative letter but I'm not surprised at all with Bobby's dismissive reaction to it. The same message we've seen for the last year or so "if you don't like it you don't have to read it" washing their hands of any accountably for the mess that mutant Town has become.
Im really curious now as to what we should expect for the last half of the year. We should have a new writer in right? Who do you guys want to try and salvage this book? Who could IDW realistically hire? I think with Ronin taking as long as it has that Tom is out of the picture aside from his annual books he's been doing.
hypered1
06-23-2021, 10:36 AM
Pretty good issue, nice to see more of Baxter and Saki. I'm guessing the latter's new abilities are some sort of trade off from when the dragon was stopped in #100.
I'm also curious to know if anyone else read the second letter on the letters page; it certainly reminds me of a few people around here and Bobby's response pretty much hits the nail on the head for every point made.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 10:42 AM
Im really curious now as to what we should expect for the last half of the year. We should have a new writer in right? Who do you guys want to try and salvage this book? Who could IDW realistically hire? I think with Ronin taking as long as it has that Tom is out of the picture aside from his annual books he's been doing.
Ideally, I'd go with Tom but he can't do everything at once, so I'm okay with whoever, as long as they don't push their themes on the book. Just stick with the TMNT-ness of it. Can't go wrong that way.
I'm also curious to know if anyone else read the second letter on the letters page; it certainly reminds me of a few people around here and Bobby's response pretty much hits the nail on the head for every point made.
You mean Bobby's non-response? Yeah, I read it. Standard hollow boilerplate in these situations. Does absolutely nothing to defuse the fanbase's concerns, quite the contrary, actually.
CyberCubed
06-23-2021, 10:43 AM
Im really curious now as to what we should expect for the last half of the year. We should have a new writer in right? Who do you guys want to try and salvage this book? Who could IDW realistically hire? I think with Ronin taking as long as it has that Tom is out of the picture aside from his annual books he's been doing.
Sophie said she's on board till issue 123 at the least, so I don't know if that's her last issue or what's just been planned up to so far.
Tom Waltz really does need to come back to the ongoing at some point, although I imagine he is too busy with The Last Ronin, the Annual, and other IDW comics for the time being.
hypered1
06-23-2021, 10:50 AM
The IDW shredder was one of my favorite versions of the character and I'm interested to see where this goes.
I am surprised that they did print a negative letter but I'm not surprised at all with Bobby's dismissive reaction to it. The same message we've seen for the last year or so "if you don't like it you don't have to read it" washing their hands of any accountably for the mess that mutant Town has become.
Im really curious now as to what we should expect for the last half of the year. We should have a new writer in right? Who do you guys want to try and salvage this book? Who could IDW realistically hire? I think with Ronin taking as long as it has that Tom is out of the picture aside from his annual books he's been doing.
This issue is the start of a new arc and Sophie's also writing until #123 in November.
And I disagree, Bobby's response was appropriate; the letter read a lot like some of the comments on here and he's absolutely correct when he says that it's ok to dislike the current run just don't be rude about how you voice it.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 10:53 AM
And I disagree, Bobby's response was appropriate; the letter read a lot like some of the comments on here and he's absolutely correct when he says that it's ok to dislike the current run just don't be rude about how you voice it.
He basically said "Write to us politely and (if it's about this matter) we'll politely ignore it". Hence the boilerplate label. Of course someone who isn't worried about the comic's current course and has no concerns to defuse would find that appropriate.
lonewarrior20
06-23-2021, 11:01 AM
For some reason Shredder despite now being alive, is now apparently able to move in ghostly-form, able to travel between walls and apparently long distances. I'm not sure when this was established, as I'm pretty sure this is the first time we're seeing this.
April on the run from mutant eels was nice as well as her getting bitten, but I hope she doesn't get mutated. Seems Baxter has finally turned on her, although it does feel a bit abrupt. The new black assistant feels like she will be a love interest for Baxter at some point. Good issue and better than the last few, but again the Turtles themselves hardly get any screentime.
Can't help but do a bad pun April O'Eel. Zara might be the human dna donor that made the scorpion mutant.
hypered1
06-23-2021, 11:04 AM
He basically said "Write to us politely and (if it's about this matter) we'll politely ignore it". Hence the boilerplate label.
Then you completely missed the point of what he said at the beginning of the second paragraph:
"Frequently negative letters are written in absolutes where the author is certain of their opinion. This pretty quickly tells me what I need to know about the writer: that they aren't likely to respect other opinions and therefore their opinion can be taken with a grain of salt."
This is the exact behaviour that you and Leo656 and a number of others have been exhibiting on here for the past several months and yes it can be said to be dismissive to a degree, but as he points out it's because people like you refuse to accept that any point of view outside of your own could possibly be correct.
He's also correct to call out the way the writer directly attacks the unnamed artist as being entirely unconstructive vitriol.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 11:07 AM
Then you completely missed the point of what he said at the beginning of the second paragraph:
"Frequently negative letters are written in absolutes where the author is certain of their opinion. This pretty quickly tells me what I need to know about the writer: that they aren't likely to respect other opinions and therefore their opinion can be taken with a grain of salt."
This is the exact behaviour that you and Leo656 and a number of others have been exhibiting on here for the past several months and yes it can be said to be dismissive to a degree, but as he points out it's because people like you refuse to accept that any point of view outside of your own could possibly be correct.
Funny, that's exactly the way I view you people. Guess we'll have to agree to disagree. Except on the dismissive part. We fully agree there. Meanwhile this once-stellar comic is going to sh*t, the greatness that is #118 notwithstanding, and all Bobby can or will do is stick his fingers in his ears and go "Can't hear you! La-la-la-la!"... You're so convinced you're infallibly right, you're willing to let everything burn just to prove it. Sad.
spookycookies
06-23-2021, 11:13 AM
He basically said "Write to us politely and (if it's about this matter) we'll politely ignore it". Hence the boilerplate label. Of course someone who isn't worried about the comic's current course and has no concerns to defuse would find that appropriate.
I doubt they will ever own up or admit that anything they have done post 100 is critically worse than Tom's run.
It's perfectly valid that the core fanbase that has supported this book for a decade might not all be interested in what's been published lately. We haven't been given much alternative either, the sister book to the flagship title ALSO revolves around mutant Town and Jennika - sure there is Ronin but it is a totally different book with no impact on this universe.
They say that their sales are steady so we can all just quit reading, they don't need us any more apparently. I guess their sales aren't going back into the books budget because we have gotten less issues than the last few years with a smaller pool of artist and no 5 week event in sight.
This was my favorite book to pick up every month since it started but now it's just not the same and I wish there was a way for the staff to have an honest discussion about this era and it's flaws instead of condemning people who have negative opinions.
lonewarrior20
06-23-2021, 11:14 AM
Just noticed something, the eels are a mixture of two arms, quadropeds, and maybe bipeds. They might be mutating/evolving. I wouldn't put it past Baxter and null to cook up a mutation virus that can be administered through bite/blood contact.
spookycookies
06-23-2021, 11:18 AM
Just noticed something, the eels are a mixture of two arms, quadropeds, and maybe bipeds. They might be mutating/evolving. I wouldn't put it past Baxter and null to cook up a mutation virus that can be administered through bite/blood contact.
I never took it as April was actually "infected" or anything I just assumed it's an easy way for Baxter to keep her away from the public by making it seem like she's contagious.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 11:21 AM
This was my favorite book to pick up every month since it started but now it's just not the same and I wish there was a way for the staff to have an honest discussion about this era and it's flaws instead of condemning people who have negative opinions.
Everyone there who might still be interested in doing that openly and honestly is probably terrified of losing their jobs if they don't toe the "diversity" company line, as is the case everywhere else. Which is a shame because I'd really love to hear more about their rationale and plans for bringing back Saki, instead of just endless gushing about how awesome and amazing and perfect Jennika and Lita and the pig and all the new androgynous Mary Sue fanfic characters are.
MikeandRaph87
06-23-2021, 11:30 AM
The IDW shredder was one of my favorite versions of the character and I'm interested to see where this goes.
I am surprised that they did print a negative letter but I'm not surprised at all with Bobby's dismissive reaction to it. The same message we've seen for the last year or so "if you don't like it you don't have to read it" washing their hands of any accountably for the mess that mutant Town has become.
Im really curious now as to what we should expect for the last half of the year. We should have a new writer in right? Who do you guys want to try and salvage this book? Who could IDW realistically hire? I think with Ronin taking as long as it has that Tom is out of the picture aside from his annual books he's been doing.
Erik Burham, what does he have on his plate these days? What about Kyle Higgins? I know he was doing some creator owned thing over at Image, but he did fine with Dick Grayson and can take existing mythos and expand upon it without violating it. While Tom is my top choice I would like to see either of these guys take a crack at being head writer starting with #123.
I am surprised that after so many loyalist have been sounding the alarm that a constructive criticism letter was printed. It disappointed me that Bobby was dismissive of it. "Frequently negative letters are written in absolutes where the author is certain of their opinion. This pretty quickly tells me what I need to know of the writer: that they aren't likely to respect other opinions so their opinion can be taken with a grain of salt".
He continues, "In this letter the writer is certain we're trying to reach some sort of new market. Here's the thing: I have never instructed any creator to change the story to appease any audience and quite frankly think its a fool's errand, and, quite frankly impossible to do. Instead I focus on working with creators to tell the story they want to tell, as long as it works in the confines of the IDW universe. I've found that to be the best way to get enjoyable, well-crafted stories. I personally think that our recent storylines dealing with relationships, grief, and community building would not be interesting to younger readers. We have our animated comics focused on humor and adventure for that'.
So that reads to me that he is enabling the writer to write whatever. To me the social issues do not fit at all and I don't understand why Donatello is not working on a anti-mutagen formula as the number one priority. There are so many holes in what we have seen and questionable character actions.
I personally feel that the current trend of wokeness is being a targeted audience. It's hard not to see it any other way. Also, I want action and adventure. The last storyarc may have had time travel and Razhar and Tokka, but no real action that true me in. Just Bebop and Rocksteady beating up Razhar and Tokka.
Reading the letter response I feel let down.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 11:33 AM
Just Bebop and Rocksteady beating up Razhar and Tokka.
Even that was no fun at all, and actually constituted a new low for the pair's depiction considering they beat up on and even mutilated what amounted to two babies/helpless animals. Not a good look.
spookycookies
06-23-2021, 11:33 AM
Everyone there who might still be interested in doing that openly and honestly is probably terrified of losing their jobs if they don't toe the "diversity" company line, as is the case everywhere else. Which is a shame because I'd really love to hear more about their rationale and plans for bringing back Saki, instead of just endless gushing about how awesome and amazing and perfect Jennika and Lita and the pig and all the new androgynous Mary Sue fanfic characters are.
I just checked and apparently from an interview with Comic book Herald Sophie will still be writing past #123
Do you think IDW would ever make Bobby fully reboot the book or do you think that Mutant Town is going to be the way it is until Nickelodeon hands the publishing rights to someone else? What is it going to take to just tell some stories with the ninja turtles being ninja turtles in it?
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 11:36 AM
I just checked and apparently from an interview with Comic book Herald Sophie will still be writing past #123
Do you think IDW would ever make Bobby fully reboot the book or do you think that Mutant Town is going to be the way it is until Nickelodeon hands the publishing rights to someone else? What is it going to take to just tell some stories with the ninja turtles being ninja turtles in it?
If Campbell does continue on past #123, the best we can hope for is the focus shifting away from Mutant Town. Maybe the current shenanigans with Stockman and Hob blow the whole thing wide open (by which I mean bring that plot to a close for now, not necessarily bring down the walls), and the Turtles move on to addressing actual pressing matters. When there's an interdimensional warlord controlling a mutant alligator bent on world domination puttering around out there and you take the time to set up a rooftop greenhouse full of mature plants, you know there's something wrong with you. Or the people who write you.
spookycookies
06-23-2021, 11:40 AM
If Campbell does continue on past #123, the best we can hope for is the focus shifting away from Mutant Town. Maybe the current shenanigans with Stockman and Hob blow the whole thing wide open (by which I mean bring that plot to a close for now, not necessarily bring down the walls), and the Turtles move on to addressing actual pressing matters. When there's an interdimensional warlord controlling a mutant alligator bent on world domination puttering around out there and you take the time to set up a rooftop greenhouse full of mature plants, you know there's something wrong with you. Or the people who write you.
They will probably just mutate Pepperoni and take a year or two giving us issues about her love life.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 11:43 AM
They will probably just mutate Pepperoni and take a year or two giving us issues about her love life.
Pepperoni's love life with Anchovy. And a love triangle with a mutant Stegosaurus named Mozzarella. Or hell, why not go for broke and make it Armaggon...
Crap, now I'm giving her ideas. :o
spookycookies
06-23-2021, 12:04 PM
Pepperoni's love life with Anchovy. And a love triangle with a mutant Stegosaurus named Mozzarella. Or hell, why not go for broke and make it Armaggon...
Crap, now I'm giving her ideas. :o
What's spicer than Mutant Town? Mutant Town High School!
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 12:07 PM
What's spicer than Mutant Town? Mutant Town High School!
Well, we already have Mutant Town Kindergarten... Just give it time!
MikeandRaph87
06-23-2021, 12:13 PM
They say that their sales are steady so we can all just quit reading, they don't need us any more apparently. I guess their sales aren't going back into the books budget because we have gotten less issues than the last few years with a smaller pool of artist and no 5 week event in sight.
This was my favorite book to pick up every month since it started but now it's just not the same and I wish there was a way for the staff to have an honest discussion about this era and it's flaws instead of condemning people who have negative opinions.
I noticed that remark about sales being steady. I thought it was a steep decline in sales from 31k to 6.5k in sales.
Overtime once it settled it became my favorite book. It did not do everything I had hoped it would, but what work of fiction is 100% catering to s a specific individual that isn't writing it for him/herself? TMNT Adventures was my first comic and I was prepared to say this had surpassed it, but Mutant Town burned down that. If it didn't happen it would have.
ChosenOne
06-23-2021, 12:19 PM
It's such a shame, too, because the concept of Mutant Town could've really elevated this comic even further. The problem was the execution.
oldmanwinters
06-23-2021, 12:45 PM
Can't help but do a bad pun April O'Eel.
I think Baxter might have beaten you to it:
http://i.imgur.com/lxgK7mvl.jpg (https://imgur.com/lxgK7mv)
*Sigh* While I'm normally a big fan of various Mutant April looks, the Mutant Town emphasis has taken over the book to such a degree that adding one more female mutant protagonist to the bunch just feels like over-kill at this point. The Baxter-April dynamic was about the only thing I really looked forward to in this series, so I would hate it that era is coming to an end only for April to join the ranks of every other critter in the Mutant District.
I never took it as April was actually "infected" or anything I just assumed it's an easy way for Baxter to keep her away from the public by making it seem like she's contagious.
I hope you're right, but with the book these days, who knows?
TigerClaw
06-23-2021, 12:53 PM
I think Baxter might have beaten you to it:
http://i.imgur.com/lxgK7mvl.jpg (https://imgur.com/lxgK7mv)
*Sigh* While I'm normally a big fan of various Mutant April looks, the Mutant Town emphasis has taken over the book to such a degree that adding one more female mutant protagonist to the bunch just feels like over-kill at this point. The Baxter-April dynamic was about the only thing I really looked forward to in this series, so I would hate it that era is coming to an end only for April to join the ranks of every other critter in the Mutant District.
I hope you're right, but with the book these days, who knows?
Maybe we'll get Cat April O'Neil like in the original series. :tsmile:
https://www.shadowlordinc.com/media/T/TMNT/aprilprowlsplinter.jpg
oldmanwinters
06-23-2021, 01:09 PM
Maybe we'll get Cat April O'Neil like in the original series. :tsmile:
https://www.shadowlordinc.com/media/T/TMNT/aprilprowlsplinter.jpg
We already got a "what-if"...
http://i.imgur.com/hnUQaoql.jpg (https://imgur.com/hnUQaoq)
Actually, I'd be more interested to check-in on "Nightbug" April (https://turtlepedia.fandom.com/wiki/April_O%27Neil_(B%26RDE)#Nightbug_)and her platinum partner: Agent Honeycutt!
http://i.imgur.com/BMHq0YVl.jpg (https://imgur.com/BMHq0YV)
I guess that was Dustin Weaver's idea for a possible follow-up story though, so I'd prefer he be brought in to expand upon it.
Coola Yagami
06-23-2021, 01:14 PM
Wow that Bobby guy's a real jerk. Also, it's easy to act all 'don't like it, don't buy it' now that the book is finally back on track. He should know this series couldn't have handled another 10 issues of the battle of the bands crap.
neatoman
06-23-2021, 07:30 PM
Well at least something is happening again... Kind of... I just kind of get get the feeling this is little more than an excuse to have April stick around for a while again and then there's another string of """breather""" issue that somehow take up more pages than the actual plot. I remember getting a little excited when the Slithery first showed up and then we just the band prep horseshit, and we all know how lame the payoff for that was...
oldmanwinters
06-24-2021, 08:19 AM
I gotta say that I really enjoy the boarding/staging of April's escape spread over 6 pages. It communicates a lot of of kinetic energy and captures April's emotional state to everything that's happening very well. Reminds me a lot of her iconic escape from the Mousers in Mirage vol. 1. #2. If that was all Nelson Daniel's doing, then serious kudos.
shredder orokusaki
06-24-2021, 10:41 AM
Now iam preparing to attack and kill the turtles!! MUHAHAHAH And they dont suspect anything!!! I will kill them very soon!!!
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 10:55 AM
Now iam preparing to attack and kill the turtles!! MUHAHAHAH And they dont suspect anything!!! I will kill them very soon!!!
i was wondering how he'd spin this.
TigerClaw
06-24-2021, 11:04 AM
i was wondering how he'd spin this.
Also this Oroku Saki is different, Based on the new future timeline from Big Lita, Saki has been around protecting them ever since.
There's this big trend going on in Comicbooks, In which they are turning villains into anti-heroes now, This is something I think they can do to Oroku Saki as this version has been around in the comics since 2011.
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 11:09 AM
Also this Oroku Saki is different, Based on the new future timeline from Big Lita, Saki has been around protecting them ever since.
There's this big trend going on in Comicbooks, In which they are turning villains into anti-heroes now, This is something I think they can do to Oroku Saki as this version has been around in the comics since 2011.
i think if saki saw the 2003 and 2012 he'd say versions "ok, you guys need help."
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 11:31 AM
There's this big trend going on in Comicbooks, In which they are turning villains into anti-heroes now,
To be fair, that's always been a thing.
i think if saki saw the 2003 and 2012 he'd say versions "ok, you guys need help."
And that's before IDW Saki even reformed.
TigerClaw
06-24-2021, 11:41 AM
When you have a comic that's been around for this long, Eventually enemies will no longer stay as enemies, and become allies.
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 11:48 AM
When you have a comic that's been around for this long, Eventually enemies will no longer stay as enemies, and become allies.
Yep, and then some of them will circle back around to enemies. Look at Hob and Stockman. That's part of what keeps it exciting, few comics (outside of the Big Two) last long enough to get to this point. My mind once again drifts fondly to Invincible.
And then there's Karai, who's constantly ping pong-ing herself back and forth between ally and enemy...
TigerClaw
06-24-2021, 11:52 AM
Yep, and then some of them will circle back around to enemies. Look at Hob and Stockman. That's part of what keeps it exciting, few comics (outside of the Big Two) last long enough to get to this point. My mind once again drifts fondly to Invincible.
And then there's Karai, who's constantly ping pong-ing herself back and forth between ally and enemy...
The thing about Hobs is he has very valid reasons.
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 11:56 AM
The thing about Hobs is he has very valid reasons.
He absolutely does, that's what makes him such a good character. And so does Stockman, even if his are far less altruistic. Scratch that, he doesn't even know what altruism means outside of being a weakness of the people he mows down when they get in his way. But he's the hero of his own story, even if his story is one of ruthless pursuit of power. He merely sees it as survival in a hostile world.
Come to think of it, both Hob and Stockman, brilliant characters in their own right, have a lot in common. The fact that they're enemies makes it even better. This isn't like a Saturday morning cartoon where all the bad guys team up because they're evil and the good guys are good, no, there's different factions and characters among the villains with different goals, different approaches, who are just as much each other's enemies as they are the Turtle's, and those conflicts paint their every interaction. The shifting alliances and enmities is what makes me love this comic so much.
MikeandRaph87
06-24-2021, 12:40 PM
Yep, and then some of them will circle back around to enemies. Look at Hob and Stockman. That's part of what keeps it exciting, few comics (outside of the Big Two) last long enough to get to this point. My mind once again drifts fondly to Invincible.
And then there's Karai, who's constantly ping pong-ing herself back and forth between ally and enemy...
Talia al Ghul, forever a neutral character even if more consistently labeled evil. Unlike other Gotham related femme fatales she has been depicted as such since day one. Same goes for Karai.
At what point would we say Oroku Saki is reformed? I would have to comb through Shredder in Hell mini-series.
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 12:47 PM
At what point would we say Oroku Saki is reformed? I would have to comb through Shredder in Hell mini-series.
I'd personally say the minute he realized the folly of his ways and did a 180, so at the end of #50, but even a more strict application of the term would have to consider his actions during #118 as said point. If Splinter entrusted his children to his care, that's good enough for me.
CyberCubed
06-24-2021, 05:08 PM
I am worried about the idea of April being mutated through the eel bite. Normally I wouldn't think so, but the ending says she's mutant contagious now (whatever that means), and well 90% of the characters in this series are mutants now anyway.
Even if it's only temporary (obviously April wouldn't be a mutant for good), even just seeing it happen would feel too much. She's been mutated before in previous series but in IDW we don't need every human to be mutated.
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 05:22 PM
I am worried about the idea of April being mutated through the eel bite. Normally I wouldn't think so, but the ending says she's mutant contagious now (whatever that means), and well 90% of the characters in this series are mutants now anyway.
Even if it's only temporary (obviously April wouldn't be a mutant for good), even just seeing it happen would feel too much. She's been mutated before in previous series but in IDW we don't need every human to be mutated.
well, if she is mutated, it could be a slow mutation of taking of her bandage and finding scales by the bite and maybe be like cronanbergs the fly but slowly turning into an eel. didn't campbell say she wanted to have april mutate into a fly?
oldmanwinters
06-24-2021, 05:24 PM
didn't campbell say she wanted to have april mutate into a fly?
I'm not familiar with that one. [EDIT: found it]
With all the Pantheon lore supposedly coming back into focus, I'd be surprised if April didn't play a significant role in "the game."
CyberCubed
06-24-2021, 05:26 PM
If she's bitten by an eel wouldn't she become a fish creature?
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 05:36 PM
I'm not familiar with that one. [EDIT: found it]
With all the Pantheon lore supposedly coming back into focus, I'd be surprised if April didn't play a significant role in "the game."
yep, right here. https://twitter.com/mooncalfe1/status/1283919063874523138
If she's bitten by an eel wouldn't she become a fish creature?
maybe we could have a redo of leviathan u4ugObcErgc
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 07:04 PM
I think you guys are taking this whole April thing too literally. What else was Stockman supposed to say? What other valid, urgent reason could he give the EPF to hunt her down?
"Hello, Mr. EPF Commander, sir? This is the Mayor speaking. Yes, I need you to track down and subdue a dangerous individual. Why is she dangerous? Well, see, she accidentally found out I'm in cahoots with that devil lady who happens to be working against you and we've been plotting to traffick illegal mutant eggs into the quarantine zone for reasons, so can you please put a bullet or several hundred into this fugitive before she has a chance to get the word out to the press and/or warn those other mutants who took out Agent John Bishop and caused that whole hubbub with the frickin' dragon and with whom I've also been secretly working with for the past several months? Would that be okay?"
In short, I don't believe - at this point - that April actually will mutate. Not because of that bite, anyway. But of course, I've been wrong before.
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 07:29 PM
I think you guys are taking this whole April thing too literally. What else was Stockman supposed to say? What other valid, urgent reason could he give the EPF to hunt her down?
"Hello, Mr. EPF Commander, sir? This is the Mayor speaking. Yes, I need you to track down and subdue a dangerous individual. Why is she dangerous? Well, see, she accidentally found out I'm in cahoots with that devil lady who happens to be working against you and we've been plotting to traffick illegal mutant eggs into the quarantine zone for reasons, so can you please put a bullet or several hundred into this fugitive before she has a chance to get the word out to the press and/or warn those other mutants who took out Agent John Bishop and caused that whole hubbub with the frickin' dragon and with whom I've also been secretly working with for the past several months? Would that be okay?"
In short, I don't believe - at this point - that April actually will mutate. Not because of that bite, anyway. But of course, I've been wrong before.
well his orders were "she must be contained in the wall at all costs. if she attempts to escape, please do what must be done to protect the rest of new york." he's almost saying shoot on sight.
oldmanwinters
06-24-2021, 07:37 PM
well his orders were "she must be contained in the wall at all costs. if she attempts to escape, please do what must be done to protect the rest of new york." he's almost saying shoot on sight.
Huh... does Mutant Town not have any social media or traditional broadcasting capabilities where April could just share her inside scoop with the wider world within the confines?
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 07:43 PM
Huh... does Mutant Town not have any social media or traditional broadcasting capabilities where April could just share her inside scoop with the wider world within the confines?
with donnie they do.
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 07:44 PM
well his orders were "she must be contained in the wall at all costs. if she attempts to escape, please do what must be done to protect the rest of new york." he's almost saying shoot on sight.
Yeah, but he still needs to present the EPF with a valid reason for that. They're not about to shoot down a random, fully human, non-mutated citizen without justification. And shady organization or not, it certainly wouldn't be a good look for the Mayor of New York City to ask that of them out of the blue.
Huh... does Mutant Town not have any social media or traditional broadcasting capabilities where April could just share her inside scoop with the wider world within the confines?
Not usually, but it just so happens that there's a reporter on her way to cover the protest against the Mutanimals. Funny how that works, huh? :tcool:
CyberCubed
06-24-2021, 08:02 PM
The writing is on the wall for April to be mutated. She's already in mutant town often and this way she can stay there as a resident. But of course, it won't be permanent.
ChosenOne
06-24-2021, 08:10 PM
The writing is on the wall for April to be mutated. She's already in mutant town often and this way she can stay there as a resident. But of course, it won't be permanent.
April is in Mutant Town because the Turtles are in Mutant Town. She was injured and needed immediate assistance, both because of her injuries and to feel safe from Stockman, the police, the EPF or even Null if it comes to that. There's no one on the outside who could help her in the heat of the moment (getting the story to the press is of course a secondary concern given her condition) and I think it's even been established that the Mayor's office is right next door to or at the very least overlooks part of Mutant Town, so she was right there.
lonewarrior20
06-24-2021, 08:34 PM
The writing is on the wall for April to be mutated. She's already in mutant town often and this way she can stay there as a resident. But of course, it won't be permanent.
that and april was "human" in litas future.
oldmanwinters
06-24-2021, 09:13 PM
that and april was "human" in litas future.
Maybe she uses a holographic watch or something...
H8kCMdLOmZU
Coola Yagami
06-24-2021, 11:45 PM
that and april was "human" in litas future.
Did you not see Cybercubed say 'but of course it won't be permanent'.
I hate to say I agree with Cubed, but that kinda means that yeah, she can be mutant now for a bit and turn human, hence her human self in the future.
TheJ-manTurtleMan
06-25-2021, 12:27 AM
Damn, I guess we're not getting a marriage issue anytime soon then. :twink:
Coola Yagami
06-25-2021, 09:37 AM
Damn, I guess we're not getting a marriage issue anytime soon then. :twink:
Yeah, Jennika and Porker Gal.
spookycookies
06-25-2021, 10:41 AM
Yeah, Jennika and Porker Gal.
Jim Henson conditioned us for this pairing
lonewarrior20
06-25-2021, 11:11 AM
Jim Henson conditioned us for this pairing
now i wanna see sheena going "hi yaa!" and punching someone. that or she could go as her for halloween.
CyberCubed
06-25-2021, 12:15 PM
Jennika and Sheena's wedding will probably be the 150th climatic issue of this arc. Issue 50 was the first Shredder/Krang showdown and issue 100 was the Pantheon Dragon and City at War climax, so it's only fitting issue 150 is the long awaited lesbian wedding of Jennika and Sheena. Buckle up, everyone.
ChosenOne
06-25-2021, 12:32 PM
Damn, I guess we're not getting a marriage issue anytime soon then. :twink:
Jennika and Sheena's wedding will probably be the 150th climatic issue of this arc. Issue 50 was the first Shredder/Krang showdown and issue 100 was the Pantheon Dragon and City at War climax, so it's only fitting issue 150 is the long awaited lesbian wedding of Jennika and Sheena. Buckle up, everyone.
Between this and the idea of April mutating into an eel, are you trying to get me to slit my wrists in sheer horror?
If either of those scenarios come true, this book will have seriously jumped the shark.
A time traveling shark.
With frickin' laser beams attached to its head.
Which Campbell then proceeds to reveal as a female and/or LGBT Mary Sue type.
And takes over as protagonist while the OG Turtles recede even further into the background.
lonewarrior20
06-25-2021, 01:44 PM
maybe we all just need to lighten up a little bit. i mean this is just a comic series after, not a religion or lifestyle.
Coola Yagami
06-25-2021, 01:48 PM
maybe we all just need to lighten up a little bit. i mean this is just a comic series after, not a religion or lifestyle.
Say that when something you care about gets ruined.
lonewarrior20
06-25-2021, 02:08 PM
Say that when something you care about gets ruined.
oh, i've had things ruined but sometimes like art they become beautiful in a different way and you learn to like it again. thats how it was for me and the 2012 series. to me it started off horrible but then the story started to get interesting when karai was introduced.
slashpieturtlemix
06-25-2021, 02:09 PM
Jim Henson conditioned us for this pairing
This is the quote I came here for and I am happy I got to experience it.
ChosenOne
06-25-2021, 02:18 PM
Does Krang work well as Oscar the Grouch?
lonewarrior20
06-25-2021, 02:29 PM
Does Krang work well as Oscar the Grouch?
now you got me imagining krang talking like oscar.
LbIvDgXKMbQ
ChosenOne
06-25-2021, 02:33 PM
now you got me imagining krang talking like oscar.
They're both known for living inside a heap of metal, after all.
And then you need the Count as Stockman: "One... One person I've stabbed in the back! Two... Two people I've stabbed in the back! Three..."
Coola Yagami
06-25-2021, 07:32 PM
oh, i've had things ruined but sometimes like art they become beautiful in a different way and you learn to like it again. thats how it was for me and the 2012 series. to me it started off horrible but then the story started to get interesting when karai was introduced.
Ah but you said so yourself 'then the story started to get interesting'. What if it didn't? What if it stayed horrible? What it ruined it to the point it just gives you a bad taste in your mouth every time anyone so much as mentioned the phrase Ninja Turtle?
CyberCubed
06-25-2021, 07:34 PM
Also the beginning of the cartoon was very strong from the start.
lonewarrior20
06-25-2021, 07:51 PM
Ah but you said so yourself 'then the story started to get interesting'. What if it didn't? What if it stayed horrible? What it ruined it to the point it just gives you a bad taste in your mouth every time anyone so much as mentioned the phrase Ninja Turtle?
so your saying what if it was next mutation? at the very least i'd watch or read it at least once just to see what happens. might be worth it just to laugh at the ridiculousness or just try and have fun with it, hell might even to be fun to mst3k it. actually why not do that and instead of bitching all the time lets poke some fun at it.
besides i'm one of the nutcase's here that likes Campbells work. i love trying to find the easter eggs and coming up with theories of what might come in this mystery wrapped inside an enigma.
spookycookies
06-25-2021, 11:40 PM
so your saying what if it was next mutation? at the very least i'd watch or read it at least once just to see what happens. might be worth it just to laugh at the ridiculousness or just try and have fun with it, hell might even to be fun to mst3k it. actually why not do that and instead of bitching all the time lets poke some fun at it.
besides i'm one of the nutcase's here that likes Campbells work. i love trying to find the easter eggs and coming up with theories of what might come in this mystery wrapped inside an enigma.
Outside of a few design choices I think it's safe to say that Sophie is one of the top artists that IDW has had so far, but being a good artist does not always mean that you would be a fantastic writer. I can't think of any examples of anything she's written to the extent of what Mutant Town has become but I'm not going to blame it all on her ideas. From what has been said it does seem that Bobby has been happy to let most of the concepts we've seen play out over all this time. The only editorial marks I've glanced from the causal twitter remark is that Sophie wishes sometimes to push more extremes on bleeding swearing turtles but I can chalk that up to her just being edgy for her audience.
It's been said so many times by so many of us that the Turtles are just background characters in this series but here we are now with so many more mutants than we can even keep track of having bake sales and peaceful protests. I'm sure that IDW has seen us say we want the Turtles to be in the spot light, and all we have are reprint compilations to show for it.
Look at the Jennika books. I think that they are actually what Mutant Town should have been. A spin off that focused on the situation and introduced characters introduced by the mutagen bomb and all of the conflicts and slice of life that sprung from it. It being its own hub and a place the turtles could go visit and unwind in WHILE they are in the main book actually having adventures and interacting with each other would have been a much better direction than what we have been dealt.
Do you think when Tom Waltz's annual comes out the Turtles will still have to wear people clothes?
CyberCubed
06-26-2021, 01:02 AM
I imagine a lot of the stuff Sophie wanted to do for some time came to pass. She made posts a few years ago about wanting to introduce Rahzar/Tokka, and that happened. She made a post about wanting to have a same sex relationship in the series, and that happened with Jennika/Sheena. She also wanted to introduce Mona Lisa to the series, and that happened. Only thing we know didn't happen was introducing Venus (I imagine due to rights issues with Saban?), so we got Lita instead.
Basically after issue 100 ended, Tom basically left a blank slate for her to pick up with. I imagine the only things off limits is stories with the Pantheon and Krang/Leatherhead and the other Utroms which is why those haven't really been touched on and why his Annual is going to be covering that.
Joey Kamikaze
06-26-2021, 03:33 AM
Was that... good gods, was that the plot? Actually moving forward? Holy ****! I'd almost forgotten what that looked like.
Seriously, it felt like they crammed an arc or two worth of progress into a single issue after what's been going on in this book the last couple years.
I didn't mind Mutant Town for a couple arcs but good gods has it overstated its welcome at this point. Here's to hoping this next arc actually goes somewhere besides ****ing DeviantArt.
Coola Yagami
06-26-2021, 01:14 PM
Was that... good gods, was that the plot? Actually moving forward? Holy ****! I'd almost forgotten what that looked like.
Seriously, it felt like they crammed an arc or two worth of progress into a single issue after what's been going on in this book the last couple years.
I didn't mind Mutant Town for a couple arcs but good gods has it overstated its welcome at this point. Here's to hoping this next arc actually goes somewhere besides ****ing DeviantArt.
Mutant Town should have been a backdrop, not a story arc.
I mean in my case, I would have sent maybe 3-5 issues to introduce the initial concept and explain what made all these new mutants decide to stay in their own town rather than venture out into the world and whatnot.
And that's it. Back to adventures. Back to fights. Back to something worth reading. The Turtles can return to Mutant Town when the story called for it. Jennika's minis could deal exclusively with Mutant Town.
Hell, if needed, have a bad guy beat one of the Turtles within an inch of their life so they can stay in Mutant Town to heal. That ways we can catch glimpses of Mutant Town and how the place is progressing and whatever as the Turtle heals, while we still see the other 3 trying to avenge their brother.
CyberCubed
06-26-2021, 01:17 PM
In retrospect, April going back to work for Baxter again only to be betrayed by him and nearly killed once again has got to be some form of irony. They basically repeated the classic Baxter/April story just with those eel mutants instead of Mousers, with April being chased through the sewers nearly eaten.
Kinda odd they had April work with Baxter again all this time, I never understood where they were going with that arc even under Tom's writing and I guess now it's over again.
ChosenOne
06-26-2021, 01:24 PM
In retrospect, April going back to work for Baxter again only to be betrayed by him and nearly killed once again has got to be some form of irony. They basically repeated the classic Baxter/April story just with those eel mutants instead of Mousers, with April being chased through the sewers nearly eaten.
Kinda odd they had April work with Baxter again all this time, I never understood where they were going with that arc even under Tom's writing and I guess now it's over again.
You answered your own question: it was all to set up and execute the classic Baxter/April story.
I believe the only staple TMNT scenario missing from this comic right now is the Second Time Around being under siege and/or burning down.
lonewarrior20
06-26-2021, 02:35 PM
You answered your own question: it was all to set up and execute the classic Baxter/April story.
I believe the only staple TMNT scenario missing from this comic right now is the Second Time Around being under siege and/or burning down.
well given mr o'neils repairs, it might be an accidental electrical fire. the siege would be angry customers.
King Kahn
06-26-2021, 05:31 PM
Ah but you said so yourself 'then the story started to get interesting'. What if it didn't? What if it stayed horrible? What it ruined it to the point it just gives you a bad taste in your mouth every time anyone so much as mentioned the phrase Ninja Turtle?
If that is the case man then it sounds like you need to just walk away and find something else if this has ruined things too much for you.
ChosenOne
06-26-2021, 08:10 PM
well given mr o'neils repairs, it might be an accidental electrical fire. the siege would be angry customers.
I genuinely lol'd imagining this.
If that is the case man then it sounds like you need to just walk away and find something else if this has ruined things too much for you.
So your suggestion is to run away? Find something else? And when they get their claws into that "something else" and turn it into a SJW-fest fanfiction too, what then? What does one do when there's no "something else" left to find? I have a better idea: us fans (and I don't just mean TMNT fans but fans in general) push back, and let these people know that we like our entertainment to be, well, entertainment so they can take their propaganda elsewhere.
Coola Yagami
06-26-2021, 10:07 PM
If that is the case man then it sounds like you need to just walk away and find something else if this has ruined things too much for you.
No. I will not surrender my fandom to the woke crowd. I'll just check out another interation of the same that is good. I don't like the BayTurtles and don't care for Rose, but I still enjoyed Batman vs TMNT. It is also my wallet/my choice to not buy the entire mutant town crap and go back to buying it whenever the plot comes back.
Leo656
06-26-2021, 11:03 PM
No. I will not surrender my fandom to the woke crowd. I'll just check out another interation of the same that is good. I don't like the BayTurtles and don't care for Rose, but I still enjoyed Batman vs TMNT. It is also my wallet/my choice to not buy the entire mutant town crap and go back to buying it whenever the plot comes back.
Yep. I don't much like the idea of just "giving up" and letting something I care(d) about be hijacked by people who only care about using the brand as a platform for their personal politics rather than giving Real Fans what they want.
As Coola said not that long ago, a certain amount of "gatekeeping" is absolutely necessary lest everything that was once decent become fodder for the Tumblristas.
F*ck TMNT, though. This franchise is so "dead beyond saving" it's not even funny, anymore. I don't even mean the comics, I mean all of it.
But even though I don't care about TMNT anymore, and probably never will again... it's hard to walk away, and it's hard not to have opinions, because I DID care, a lot, Once Upon A Time. And it's hard NOT to have an opinion when you see people continuously defiling the corpse of something or someone you once loved.
spookycookies
06-27-2021, 03:31 AM
No. I will not surrender my fandom to the woke crowd. I'll just check out another interation of the same that is good. I don't like the BayTurtles and don't care for Rose, but I still enjoyed Batman vs TMNT. It is also my wallet/my choice to not buy the entire mutant town crap and go back to buying it whenever the plot comes back.
Yeah I guess the saving role for TMNT is that is constantly rebooting and starting over again so that we can move on from stuff like this clean. For me it's such an embarrassment because Tom built something I really did enjoy. I'm still buying the issues because when it's all said and done I want to have a full run of singles and I also want to support my LCS.
The thing that bothers me about rebooting is that we have to go through all of the TMNT origin tropes all over again the first Baxter encounter the first shredder and meeting April and Casey and leatherhead it just gets tiresome when you've been around for most every reboot but my hope is that maybe next year they will hire some decent writers and get things back to something half interesting.
Andrew NDB
06-27-2021, 04:02 AM
Yep. I don't much like the idea of just "giving up" and letting something I care(d) about be hijacked by people who only care about using the brand as a platform for their personal politics rather than giving Real Fans what they want.
As Coola said not that long ago, a certain amount of "gatekeeping" is absolutely necessary lest everything that was once decent become fodder for the Tumblristas.
F*ck TMNT, though. This franchise is so "dead beyond saving" it's not even funny, anymore. I don't even mean the comics, I mean all of it.
But even though I don't care about TMNT anymore, and probably never will again... it's hard to walk away, and it's hard not to have opinions, because I DID care, a lot, Once Upon A Time. And it's hard NOT to have an opinion when you see people continuously defiling the corpse of something or someone you once loved.
There is of course always the hope that maybe someday... someday there will be some new iteration that either "gets it" or blows one away by even defying expectations. Then we can be here and be like, "Yep. I've been here all along. This is what we have been waiting for."
But largely that hope died in 2009. I don't rule it out, I just know the likelihood of it happening dropped from "possibly sometime" to "probably never... but maybe."
FrederikWolferson
06-27-2021, 04:38 AM
Most of us kinda succumbed to the sunk cost fallacy. I already invested so much time into the IDW continuity and there are still a ton of plots left unresolved,so it will really suck when this gets cancelled unceremoniously like every other TMNT title that ever was.
AquaParade
06-27-2021, 04:52 AM
Yep. I don't much like the idea of just "giving up" and letting something I care(d) about be hijacked by people who only care about using the brand as a platform for their personal politics rather than giving Real Fans what they want.
As Coola said not that long ago, a certain amount of "gatekeeping" is absolutely necessary lest everything that was once decent become fodder for the Tumblristas.
F*ck TMNT, though. This franchise is so "dead beyond saving" it's not even funny, anymore. I don't even mean the comics, I mean all of it.
But even though I don't care about TMNT anymore, and probably never will again... it's hard to walk away, and it's hard not to have opinions, because I DID care, a lot, Once Upon A Time. And it's hard NOT to have an opinion when you see people continuously defiling the corpse of something or someone you once loved.
In a mainstream sense, it feels that way.
The figures, comics, and games are still pretty cool though. Neca figures, Mirage collections, The Last Ronin, that upcoming beat-em-up game developed by the highly acclaimed developers of the recent Double Dragon.
It's unfortunate that movies and animation - the two mediums with the widest reach - can't keep up, but there are still things coming out that make me glad the franchise is alive.
Between those examples, they are covering a pretty wide base, and all are generally good quality and respectful of the franchise roots.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 04:56 AM
The thing that bothers me about rebooting is that we have to go through all of the TMNT origin tropes all over again the first Baxter encounter the first shredder and meeting April and Casey and leatherhead it just gets tiresome when you've been around for most every reboot but my hope is that maybe next year they will hire some decent writers and get things back to something half interesting.
That's another thing. It's easy for people to just shrug and say "Well it's not like they're not gonna do another version, one day! Maybe TMNT Ver. 4293 will be more to your tastes!"
Meanwhile, as you've stated, every reboot means retreading some level of familiar territory, much of which has been done more than enough. But at the same time, we've already had HOW many versions of TMNT? And HOW many of those iterations had anything like an acceptable "conclusion"? Most TMNT stories don't even "end", they just get abruptly discarded to make way for the next reboot. And that, in itself, becomes an excuse or a crutch to dismiss any bad/lazy writing. "Don't like it? Wait for the next reboot."
How about just having ONE good version and seeing it through to the end, for a change?
Even as a kid, I felt like there were too many conflicting TMNT universes; now there's twice as many, each with their own Ups and Downs.
"Back in my day", reboots and retcons were a last resort, something you did only when you'd either run out of compelling stories OR completely sh*t the bed. It wasn't just a "Get Out Of Jail Free" card to do dumb sh*t, knowing that "If they don't like it we can just reboot." That's the way modern-day comics are written and I can't stand it.
So yeah, sure, maybe they'll just reboot it again. And again and again. But man, I'd much prefer it if there was a TMNT iteration that 1. Stayed good all the way through, and 2. Reached a natural and organic conclusion before someone hit the Reset button.
I can't think of a single version of TMNT that's had both of those things happen. If "The Forever War" had happened as-planned, the Archie book might've pulled it off. That's probably the closest any of them have gotten, off the top of my head.
Andrew NDB
06-27-2021, 04:59 AM
Even as a kid, I felt like there were too many conflicting TMNT universes; now there's twice as many, each with their own Ups and Downs.
My biggest thing has always been... in recent years (and I'm not really talking about IDW), we're getting recyclings of the recyclings of spinoff characters and things... that were never really good to begin with (IMHO). And then these recycled recycled things will surely just get... recycled again, in the next cycle. Harvesting this or that from the newer recycled versions.
I just bought my daughter some bunnies. I didn't know this going in, but I'm told they eat their poo and this is an essential part of their digestive system. They eat it and poo it out eat it again until there's no longer any digestible material left and then they abandon the poos. It seems kind of like that, except there is no "they abandon it" part.
This may sound really negative... but I'm a guy that just really, really never liked aspects like Bebop, "Dude Mikey" and tons of mutants around (and maybe specific ones more than others). I'm aware there are a lot of people that love these things and that's fine.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 05:11 AM
In a mainstream sense, it feels that way.
The figures, comics, and games are still pretty cool though. Neca figures, Mirage collections, The Last Ronin, that upcoming beat-em-up game developed by the highly acclaimed developers of the recent Double Dragon.
It's unfortunate that movies and animation - the two mediums with the widest reach - can't keep up, but there are still things coming out that make me glad the franchise is alive.
Between those examples, they are covering a pretty wide base, and all are generally good quality and respectful of the franchise roots.
The toys are one thing. We'll see if the game moves the needle in any appreciable way, or if it'll be like so many other of these "throwback" games that get "old schoolers" hard but don't have any impact otherwise.
You bring up "collected editions" over and over as if that's something incredibly relevant, though, and I kinda don't think it is. I mean, it's nice that they even bother, sure. But at the same time, I don't think that it makes any sense to trumpet something that essentially says, "Look how cool this brand USED to be" as indicative of how good things supposedly are NOW.
In fact, ALL of those "good things" are more exercises in nostalgia more than anything. The NECA toys are based on the only good TMNT movie along with "the only TMNT cartoon anyone remembers". The Super 7 toys are "do-overs" of stuff we already bought 30 years ago, just with a modern spin. The collected editions are just a reminder that the TMNT comics didn't always suck. The upcoming game is - once again - based on a cartoon (and a gameplay style) that's more than 30 years old.
When the best this brand can do is remind you how much better things were 30+ years ago... that is an admission of defeat. "We can't create New Things of quality, so let us serve you re-heated nostalgia instead."
And that's fine. The toys are cool enough, the game might be good, whatever... it's absolutely fine to enjoy those things for what they are and it's good that they exist. But ideally, there should be things to look forward to that DON'T require looking exclusively to the past. But that's all this franchise can do anymore, because when the Powers-That-Be try and come up with "new ideas", we get BayTurtles, "Rise", and Mutant Town.
This franchise isn't "alive"; it's a zombie, that only appears to simulate life because it has jumper cables jammed into every available orifice. But there is no "life"; just constant reminders that "30 years ago, this brand was the Hottest Thing Going".
Yeah. 30 years ago. Not now, and never, ever again.
It's depressing. Forget 1990 Nostalgia; I'd settle for 2003-ish nostalgia, when there were still only a few TMNT "universes" and MOST of them didn't suck. Think about THAT, for a second; we'll never, ever again be able to say "There's more Good TMNT than Bad TMNT." MOST TMNT product is garbage, and it would take a series of minor miracles to ever swing things back the other way.
Maybe that doesn't bother some folks, but it sure bothers me.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 05:24 AM
My biggest thing has always been... in recent years (and I'm not really talking about IDW), we're getting recyclings of the recyclings of spinoff characters and things... that were never really good to begin with (IMHO). And then these recycled recycled things will surely just get... recycled again, in the next cycle. Harvesting this or that from the newer recycled versions.
I just bought my daughter some bunnies. I didn't know this going in, but I'm told they eat their poo and this is an essential part of their digestive system. They eat it and poo it out eat it again until there's no longer any digestible material left and then they abandon the poos. It seems kind of like that, except there is no "they abandon it" part.
This may sound really negative... but I'm a guy that just really, really never liked aspects like Bebop, "Dude Mikey" and tons of mutants around (and maybe specific ones more than others). I'm aware there are a lot of people that love these things and that's fine.
I mean, that's certainly a fair opinion, especially since there's a lot of people who were fans before FW, or preferred the Mirage universe without any of the FW influence.
I kinda think that ship has sailed, though, to some degree. Things like Bebop & Rocksteady, "Dude Mikey", and Karai being Shredder's daughter are more or less "grandfathered in" through Pop Culture Osmosis, at this point. It's to the point where if you don't include them, you get so many people demanding them that it becomes a distraction. Even Eastman forgot that Karai wasn't originally Shredder's daughter; that tells you something.
But I'm with you on a lot of that. While I can forgive some characters like Bebop, Rocksteady, or Slash, I do think that "Too Many Mutants" is a problem most of the non-Mirage iterations fall into rather quickly and easily, whether it be due to toy sales pressure or just lazy writing or some combination of the two. I think the dated "Bill & Ted" lingo could be dialed down or phased out altogether. And I know I'm the vast minority, but I could live entirely without the pizza obsession being "Hard Canon". And there's other things or concepts I don't think they need to continually recycle just because they can. Characters like Mona Lisa, for example... do they NEED to be redone in every version just because they were in ONE episode of the original cartoon? I pulled that one off the top of my head, but I don't even have a problem with that character and I liked that episode of FW. It just seems an odd pick to recycle for future iterations, especially with every version of the character being unrecognizable to every other version.
It does seem like most of the time with TMNT reboots, what they choose to recycle isn't always thought very hard about or done for the best reasons. Both the Nicktoon and IDW have been pretty groan-worthy for me with a lot of that kind of stuff. I'm not even against bringing stuff back if it can be done well. I guess I'm just more a fan of the "John Byrne" method than the "Geoff Johns" method.
AquaParade
06-27-2021, 09:33 AM
The toys are one thing. We'll see if the game moves the needle in any appreciable way, or if it'll be like so many other of these "throwback" games that get "old schoolers" hard but don't have any impact otherwise.
You bring up "collected editions" over and over as if that's something incredibly relevant, though, and I kinda don't think it is. I mean, it's nice that they even bother, sure. But at the same time, I don't think that it makes any sense to trumpet something that essentially says, "Look how cool this brand USED to be" as indicative of how good things supposedly are NOW.
In fact, ALL of those "good things" are more exercises in nostalgia more than anything. The NECA toys are based on the only good TMNT movie along with "the only TMNT cartoon anyone remembers". The Super 7 toys are "do-overs" of stuff we already bought 30 years ago, just with a modern spin. The collected editions are just a reminder that the TMNT comics didn't always suck. The upcoming game is - once again - based on a cartoon (and a gameplay style) that's more than 30 years old.
When the best this brand can do is remind you how much better things were 30+ years ago... that is an admission of defeat. "We can't create New Things of quality, so let us serve you re-heated nostalgia instead."
And that's fine. The toys are cool enough, the game might be good, whatever... it's absolutely fine to enjoy those things for what they are and it's good that they exist. But ideally, there should be things to look forward to that DON'T require looking exclusively to the past. But that's all this franchise can do anymore, because when the Powers-That-Be try and come up with "new ideas", we get BayTurtles, "Rise", and Mutant Town.
This franchise isn't "alive"; it's a zombie, that only appears to simulate life because it has jumper cables jammed into every available orifice. But there is no "life"; just constant reminders that "30 years ago, this brand was the Hottest Thing Going".
Yeah. 30 years ago. Not now, and never, ever again.
It's depressing. Forget 1990 Nostalgia; I'd settle for 2003-ish nostalgia, when there were still only a few TMNT "universes" and MOST of them didn't suck. Think about THAT, for a second; we'll never, ever again be able to say "There's more Good TMNT than Bad TMNT." MOST TMNT product is garbage, and it would take a series of minor miracles to ever swing things back the other way.
Maybe that doesn't bother some folks, but it sure bothers me.
Doesn't seem like all nostalgia to me. The Last Ronin is exactly what plenty of older fans have been asking for. It's nostalgic, only in the sense, that it's coming directly from the roots of the franchise, which is as good as it gets for some of us. TMNT started as a gritty, goofy, indie comic. Having the creator back doing what made the world fall in love with the franchise in the first place? That's a best case scenario, in my eyes. That's the cream of the crop. Hard to call the franchise dead when that is alive, beating, and proving the franchise has more life in it, if you just lift up the right rock.
TMNT has been the biggest story in comics over the last year. Not just in page content, but in attention. Every comic podcast is talking turtles, all the sales charts are lit up with turtles. Back issues have quadrupled in price. People care and are talking about TMNT. Feels like it has a pulse, when you look at it that way.
I don't buy the argument that "it's only a few issues." To me, that sounds like moving the goal post.
Yeah, it just started. It's current. That's okay, it speaks even more to the point that way. The franchise can't be dead if new, fresh projects have just begun.
And they're chunky issues, with more on the way.
Some of the other stuff is more nostalgia-based, sure, but that stuff is quality and has reason to exist. People like it. That's a good thing.
The mirage reprints have been awesome because they were something we had a very hard time getting when Mirage owned the license.
Same with the figures - the brand is being treated better than ever, figure-wise, so even if it is nostalgia, it's something fans have been dying for, and it's actually aimed at longtime fans, which is great.
The game is a throwback to an older style of game, but they got beloved developers to make it. It's a good thing.
I see your point. A lot of it is nostalgia based, but the nostalgia-based products are great, and fans love them. And, again, it's really not all nostalgia-based - you have the last ronin. Maybe TLR doesn't cut it for you, but when it's lighting the comic world on fire, calling it dead seems willfully ignorant. Sure, the comic world isn't huge, but when tmnt is selling more than Batman and X-Men #1's...it ain't dead.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 10:04 AM
It's a mini-series.
When it becomes something more than that, I'll possibly admit that it's "revived" the brand from its grave.
Hot Take: Also? It's a weeeeeeee bit overrated. I'm pretty sure that if Every Single Other TMNT thing for the past 8 years wasn't complete and total garbage, it wouldn't have people wetting their pants over it to the degree that it does. Not saying it's bad. It's good. Just saying, when you're drowning in sh*t, ANYTHING that sparkles looks like a diamond.
It's fine. But I've read better. And I certainly don't think a mini-series of all things means we have a whole hell of a lot to celebrate, when the other upcoming Big Things on the horizon are... ((checks notes)) A "Rise" movie, and a Seth Rogen movie.
Jesus, this forum needs a "vomit" Emoji. Or better yet, a "shooting one's self in the face" Emoji. Because both of those projects make me want to do One of those things, followed by The Other.
Look, if you're happy, good for you. If you sincerely think all the nostalgia fan-wank stuff coming out means the brand is doing great, then good. We'll talk again when That Other Sh*t happens and sends the brand even further into the toilet... or sewer, as the case may be. I personally think you're grasping at straws, trying to spin straw into gold, Insert Your Metaphor Of Choice Here... but that's me. Do whatever makes you happy.
But if there's only two things you (or anyone) should know about me by now, and would consider before ever trying to convince me of anything at all, it's that:
1. I am a Jaded Cynic above ALL else, and...
2. Optimists make my f*cking skin crawl more than spiders do.
At least spiders, as distasteful as they may be, have a practical use in nature. Optimists, not so much. Creatures who dabble in "optimism" generally end up in the spider's web, getting their guts sucked out and wondering how they got into such a predicament.
....Aaaaaand now I'm hungry. Thanks, guy. :tgrumble:
AquaParade
06-27-2021, 10:39 AM
It's a mini-series.
When it becomes something more than that, I'll possibly admit that it's "revived" the brand from its grave.
Hot Take: Also? It's a weeeeeeee bit overrated. I'm pretty sure that if Every Single Other TMNT thing for the past 8 years wasn't complete and total garbage, it wouldn't have people wetting their pants over it to the degree that it does. Not saying it's bad. It's good. Just saying, when you're drowning in sh*t, ANYTHING that sparkles looks like a diamond.
It's fine. But I've read better. And I certainly don't think a mini-series of all things means we have a whole hell of a lot to celebrate, when the other upcoming Big Things on the horizon are... ((checks notes)) A "Rise" movie, and a Seth Rogen movie.
Jesus, this forum needs a "vomit" Emoji. Or better yet, a "shooting one's self in the face" Emoji. Because both of those projects make me want to do One of those things, followed by The Other.
Look, if you're happy, good for you. If you sincerely think all the nostalgia fan-wank stuff coming out means the brand is doing great, then good. We'll talk again when That Other Sh*t happens and sends the brand even further into the toilet... or sewer, as the case may be. I personally think you're grasping at straws, trying to spin straw into gold, Insert Your Metaphor Of Choice Here... but that's me. Do whatever makes you happy.
But if there's only two things you (or anyone) should know about me by now, and would consider before ever trying to convince me of anything at all, it's that:
1. I am a Jaded Cynic above ALL else, and...
2. Optimists make my f*cking skin crawl more than spiders do.
At least spiders, as distasteful as they may be, have a practical use in nature. Optimists, not so much. Creatures who dabble in "optimism" generally end up in the spider's web, getting their guts sucked out and wondering how they got into such a predicament.
....Aaaaaand now I'm hungry. Thanks, guy. :tgrumble:
TLR isn't Watchmen or even DKR, I agree. I don't even disagree that it is benefitting from comparing to years of neutered tmnt. It's an appropriate reaction though. It speaks to the potential of the brand.
But even so, it is a great book at the end of the day. The concept it cool, Kevin still has it when it comes to layouts, the pencils and colors are top notch. I mean, whatever. I don't mean to be a broken record but it's relevant to the discussion.
The book is a mini-series, but look at the effect it's having. I'm not saying it will 100% shift the brand direction but you can't make that big of a splash and not have some type of effect on the brand.
Let's at least say it's unlikely there won't be more like it, adapted from it, or spun off from it. It caught fire and Nickelodeon and/or IDW has to notice that. It's just business, you and I know that. There will certainly be comic spin-offs if nothing else. This is all but confirmed.
It didn't just have good sales, it outsold everything else, at twice the price, escalating in sales issue after issue, and was the talk of the comic book town. Do you know how rare it is for a comic to increase in sales as it goes forward? TLR didn't just happen, it's *still* happening. It just seems silly for that to be going on, while you are standing to the left going "call it. She's dead, alright. It's all over!!"
Besides, even if it were a mini-series, it's happening. Right now. Be Here Now. If it's alive, the franchise can't be dead.
I actually recognize a lot of truth in what you're saying. I just think you sort of take it way too far, compared to my perspective. It seems like something I would do if I needed a defense mechanism from the franchise or something. Like, stomping all hope into the ground, in fear of being blue balled. But at the end of the day, it's not that bad.
If it were all "fan wank", I guess that'd be one thing. But I can be happy with a side dish of nostalgia, as long as there is something new and pulsing to go with it.
The Last Ronin is certainly that, and even if I didnt love the IDW ongoing, I'd say it was still at least holding that torch in a smaller sense.
At the end of the day, I agree with some of what you're saying, but I feel like you take it way too far, because there are a some cool things keeping the franchise going. You just have to know where to look for it.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 11:13 AM
If Nickelodeon cared about making money or doing what's right, there's about a hundred different DVD box sets they could've sold at any point in time between 2002 and Now, but never bothered to.
I tell the story often about how they produced and manufactured a metric f*ckton of DVDs for the final seasons of "The Adventures of Pete & Pete", then sent all of it to rot forever in some warehouse a week before they were to go on sale because "Eh, nobody's gonna buy it, probably". They're probably still there. The cast and crew were like "Yeah, we all did commentary and interviews, they paid us... it makes no sense why they'd just bury it." You'd think making even one dollar back on all they'd spent on that project would be better than Zero... but then You and I are not Nickelodeon/Viacom.
But that's only one example. People have been crying for years for them to re-release proper discs of the 4Kids TMNT series, or even Season sets of their own TMNT show. Nope. The guy who played Sponge on "Salute Your Shorts" spent like a decade personally petitioning Nick to release that show on DVD, armed with fan petitions, charts of how the show used to fare in reruns, and numerous website polls stating that "Salute Your Shorts" is very likely THE most popular and requested TV series to never, ever have any disc release of any kind, and that enough people would definitely buy it to ensure a DVD set would be profitable. Nick: "Nah". "Sabrina the Teenage Witch" continues to sell DVD units to this day; Nickelodeon says, "Nah, people don't care about Melissa Joan Hart that much; nobody'd buy a 'Clarissa Explains It All' DVD set."
And so on and so forth.
And before sdp or some other douchebag comes in here to say "Nobody buys DVDs anymore anyway", let me reiterate two things:
1: Nick could have (and SHOULD have) released any or all of those things as far back as 2003 or so, when EVERY show was getting a 10-disc box set, so "Right Now" is irrelevant, and also...
2. "Zack Snyder's Justice League" drops on disc in multiple formats Sept. 7th, f*ckface, including a gigantic "trilogy" Blu-ray box set with MoS and BvS. So SOMEBODY buys these f*cking things or companies wouldn't keep making them.
So anyway, Aqua, your point is "When Nick sees how much money 'The Last Ronin' is making, they'll for sure back that horse going forward! For sure we'll get more TMNT in that vein! It's just good business... profit... common sense!"
I hear you.
And I counter with, "How Nickelodeon chooses to do business has NEVER ONCE had ANYTHING to do with good business, profit, OR common sense. They have left MILLIONS - hundreds of millions, truthfully - on the table over the past two decades through sheer inaction and an obstinate outright refusal to listen to their fans or give them what they want.
Look at their history. You can beg, cry, shout, stomp your feet and shove sales charts in their goddamn faces... they'll tell you you don't know what you're talking about and show you the door. And you won't get what you want, because They Don't Care What You Want. And it can't be as simple as "They MUST wanna make money, though!" because again, their own history thoroughly contradicts that theory.
At the end of the day, Nick/Viacom bought TMNT to sell toys to 6-year olds. That's their primary concern. A comic book like "The Last Ronin" only serves to keep people like us quiet for a while, while they cook up the newest reboot disaster they can use to push Happy Meal toys. I'm sure they're glad that it's doing well, but I doubt they CARE that it's doing well. It has nothing at all to do with their intentions for the brand as a whole.
So again, Time Will Tell who's right or wrong, or how much life is left in this franchise.
Maybe Seth Rogen will save us. Snerk.
But yeah, if "The Last Ronin" turns out to be the spark that lights a fire, it'll not only be a minor miracle, but it'll be the first time in forever that Nickelodeon actually made a decision based on either Fan Demand or Profitable Reward. They've more or less made their fortunes by ignoring both of those things entirely for many years, so suffice to say, I won't hold my breath.
ChosenOne
06-27-2021, 11:23 AM
Have you seen what Rogen's done for Invincible? I don't necessarily like him but have some faith in the guy. He knows his comics.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 11:27 AM
Actually naw. Never read the comics so I'm like "Eh." One day, maybe.
He also had a hand in "Preacher". Blech!
Given his track record in general, if "Invincible" is as good as everyone says it is then it's definitely because of Everybody BUT Him. I feel incredibly certain of that.
I'd say he's on track to give us the world's first boner joke in a TMNT setting, but then BayTurtles already lowered that bar.
AquaParade
06-27-2021, 12:52 PM
I hear you. I haven’t looked into the dvd thing but I’m sure you have a case. If nothing else, I’d love to see the 2k3 series released in a box-set. I’d pre-order that in a heartbeat, if it was produced with some care. And I don’t even love that show or buy many collectibles. I just think it’d be cool to have.
My perspective on TLR is prob different. You say it’s there to keep us hardcore fans quiet, but I’m pretty much happy to stay quiet if this is what they’re serving. Would I like to see an awesome TMNT film? Yeah, probably more than any other movie at this point. But at the same time, the comics are the cream of the crop for me. Everything else has always been a cool spin-off or adaption.
I suppose we could argue whether the franchise is “dead” or not from several different perspectives and both be right, so whatever.
PurpleMusic
06-27-2021, 01:36 PM
I'd say he's on track to give us the world's first boner joke in a TMNT setting, but then BayTurtles already lowered that bar.
https://tenor.com/view/turtles-schwing-tmnt-turtles3-turtles-schwing-gif-18649124
FrederikWolferson
06-27-2021, 01:47 PM
To try and be objective...I don't think IDW had all that much interference from Nick/Viacom. Because they don't give a crap about comics.
Do I think will see that fans want a more classic TMNT approach and course correct? Not really. This became a strange ideological thing for them and that kinda has its own logic.
Check the letter pages and try to find one that's not super positive about the Mutant Town arc. Feels very fake.
AquaParade
06-27-2021, 02:20 PM
Interesting. I guess we will see if they go down with the ship or announce The Last Ronin’s prequel series.
FrederikWolferson
06-27-2021, 02:24 PM
Interesting. I guess we will see if they go down with the ship or announce The Last Ronin’s prequel series.
If Eastman and Laird are interested,I can see IDW pushing for Before Last Ronin or Last Ronin Strikes Again. I just don't see the main series getting back on track.
Leo656
06-27-2021, 03:30 PM
https://tenor.com/view/turtles-schwing-tmnt-turtles3-turtles-schwing-gif-18649124
To be fair... most of the dumb 7-year old kids that movie was aimed at weren't fully aware of what "Schwing!" meant.
I kinda don't think the filmmakers did, either, or they probably wouldn't have put it in there. Very out of place.
AquaParade
06-27-2021, 03:34 PM
If Eastman and Laird are interested,I can see IDW pushing for Before Last Ronin or Last Ronin Strikes Again. I just don't see the main series getting back on track.
I can see that. I imagine we will see more of April or Casey Marie, one way or another.
Joey Kamikaze
06-27-2021, 03:39 PM
Mutant Town should have been a backdrop, not a story arc.
I mean in my case, I would have sent maybe 3-5 issues to introduce the initial concept and explain what made all these new mutants decide to stay in their own town rather than venture out into the world and whatnot.
And that's it. Back to adventures. Back to fights. Back to something worth reading. The Turtles can return to Mutant Town when the story called for it. Jennika's minis could deal exclusively with Mutant Town.
I would have been down for that. I liked the concept. It's the execution, and how long it's gone on, that's been the problem.
CyberCubed
06-28-2021, 10:53 AM
On the bright side Tom Waltz annual comes out in July so we know it’s focusing on the old plotlines.
MikeandRaph87
06-30-2021, 09:40 AM
So when does The Armageddon Game kick in after the annual starts it off? #123 in November which means that it will be left dangling from June until November?:tgrumble:
hypered1
06-30-2021, 09:45 AM
The annual is before #118 and we already know RK and Kitsune will be in this new arc, but we'll know better once both the annual and the next issue are out.
112 - 117 > JenII 4 - 6 > Annual '21 > 118 - 123
CyberCubed
06-30-2021, 10:15 AM
I think the Armaggedon game is going to be a mini-series rather than in the main ongoing, although I could be wrong. We haven't had any mini-series since the Jennika mini's ended, so this is probably the next one.
MikeandRaph87
06-30-2021, 10:15 AM
The annual is before #118 and we already know RK and Kitsune will be in this new arc, but we'll know better once both the annual and the next issue are out.
112 - 117 > JenII 4 - 6 > Annual '21 > 118 - 123
I was not aware of their inclusion in this arc, only Saki is playing helicopter parent as Sally Pride is to be injured at a senseless protest. I assumed that Rat King and Kitsune were going to set for the arc after that since they didn't seem to figure into the solicits.
hypered1
06-30-2021, 10:34 AM
I was not aware of their inclusion in this arc, only Saki is playing helicopter parent as Sally Pride is to be injured at a senseless protest. I assumed that Rat King and Kitsune were going to set for the arc after that since they didn't seem to figure into the solicits.
Hmm, good point. I was going by them both appearing at the end of #117 and by the above chronology being confirmed by Bobby a couple of months ago. Still Kitsune is a fair bet as she is Saki's partner after all.
That being said the solicits up to 121 seem to all confirm the arc as April vs. Baxter and the Mutanimals vs. Splinter Clan.
MikeandRaph87
06-30-2021, 10:52 AM
Hmm, good point. I was going by them both appearing at the end of #117 and by the above chronology being confirmed by Bobby a couple of months ago. Still Kitsune is a fair bet as she is Saki's partner after all.
That being said the solicits up to 121 seem to all confirm the arc as April vs. Baxter and the Mutanimals vs. Splinter Clan.
Perhaps we get a few pages that will lead into #123 and beyond that will focus on the Armageddon Game events as teases the way Tom would tease is of upcoming plot beats. So they may have a page or two here and there but not really do much until the above issue.
ChosenOne
06-30-2021, 12:23 PM
I've been here for almost as long as IDW TMNT has been going on, and I've never seen the solicitations go five whole days without being posted. It's very telling of the state this comic is in that no one even cares to do it anymore.
(Just to clarify, I was a lurker during the early years of the comic and only actually joined around #40 or so, the big brawl arc, but I was here nonetheless.)
hypered1
06-30-2021, 12:39 PM
I've been here for almost as long as IDW TMNT has been going on, and I've never seen the solicitations go five whole days without being posted. It's very telling of the state this comic is in that no one even cares to do it anymore.
(Just to clarify, I was a lurker during the early years of the comic and only actually joined around #40 or so, the big brawl arc, but I was here nonetheless.)
The guy that was doing it before, AlZarkovski, hasn't posted anything for a month and seems to just lurk more than anything.
I could do it myself but I'm not sure how deep into the details to go.
ChosenOne
06-30-2021, 12:53 PM
The guy that was doing it before, AlZarkovski, hasn't posted anything for a month and seems to just lurk more than anything.
I could do it myself but I'm not sure how deep into the details to go.
Al was a champ when it came to solicits and previews, it saddens me to see him so quiet lately. I did it a couple of times myself, I usually just copy-pasted everything in the solicit (page count, price, yada, yada, yada) but what annoyed me was getting the covers to display properly and I eventually gave up. If you're willing to pick up the slack, I think I speak for everyone here when I say we'd appreciate that very much.
PrestonC
07-06-2021, 04:37 PM
I feel like it would’ve been far more effective if the montage of Saki watching/interfering would’ve been sprinkled throughout the last 18 issues. That way we’d know there was some shadowy figure observing and occasionally getting involved, but they could’ve felt some speculation as to who it was until this issue when Saki and Kitsune have that discussion. Yknow, instead of what we got. Would’ve added more connective tissue between the last story arcs and this latest one.
mrmaczaps
07-08-2021, 01:08 PM
Finally got to read this issue and I find it really boring and it jumps all over the place. I'll be glad once the regular creative team comes back, if they manage to do so before this clusterf*ck of a run kills it. I read the letters column from time to time & the "hate" mail was an interesting read. :lol: The series does suck. So bad. Get Freddie Williams on art & retire the variant covers for a while and then find someone who can write worth a d@mn. I honestly hope this series gets cancelled rather than continuing at this point. Jennika needs to go the way of Slash...
Sumac
07-08-2021, 02:20 PM
I have a feeling she will go the way of Venus down the line.
More deserved than the Venus ironically.
MikeandRaph87
07-08-2021, 04:04 PM
Finally got to read this issue and I find it really boring and it jumps all over the place. I'll be glad once the regular creative team comes back, if they manage to do so before this clusterf*ck of a run kills it. I read the letters column from time to time & the "hate" mail was an interesting read. :lol: The series does suck. So bad. Get Freddie Williams on art & retire the variant covers for a while and then find someone who can write worth a d@mn. I honestly hope this series gets cancelled rather than continuing at this point. Jennika needs to go the way of Slash...
The sad part is the printing of the letter to prove its a majority of the write ins and the unfortunate non-response is what was the most interesting thing in the comic.
I want to get into Saki's psyche. Why reform? What is his objective? Why did he not oversee the peace deal with Karai and the Turtle right after coming back? So much potential!
mrmaczaps
07-08-2021, 04:43 PM
The sad part is the printing of the letter to prove its a majority of the write ins and the unfortunate non-response is what was the most interesting thing in the comic.
I want to get into Saki's psyche. Why reform? What is his objective? Why did he not oversee the peace deal with Karai and the Turtle right after coming back? So much potential!
Yeah, exactly. Its all deflection in his response. I don't care about the 2ndary characters or the 3rd level down characters or the d@mn mutant city characters even. If they wanted to do a mutanimals/mutant city series, do that. It would have stayed on the shelf... I want to read their ongoing TMNT series about the actual TMNT... I don't mind a few pages here and there to flesh out other characters but these last 18 issues still leave me no real idea who anyone is and I don't care who they are... It would be nice to see what Shredder has been doing, however if he goes "good guy", is there still really any decent stories to tell?
The Ongoing should have taken six months off, gone bimonthly OR better yet, stopped for the in continuity story "Last Ronin" tale... as nothing so far really sets it apart from the IDWs potential future.
MikeandRaph87
07-08-2021, 04:50 PM
Yeah, exactly. Its all deflection in his response. I don't care about the 2ndary characters or the 3rd level down characters or the d@mn mutant city characters even. If they wanted to do a mutanimals/mutant city series, do that. It would have stayed on the shelf... I want to read their ongoing TMNT series about the actual TMNT... I don't mind a few pages here and there to flesh out other characters but these last 18 issues still leave me no real idea who anyone is and I don't care who they are... It would be nice to see what Shredder has been doing, however if he goes "good guy", is there still really any decent stories to tell?
The Ongoing should have taken six months off, gone bimonthly OR better yet, stopped for the in continuity story "Last Ronin" tale... as nothing so far really sets it apart from the IDWs potential future.
The Ninja Turtles themselves did not appear in the 2020 Annual, yet it was the last thing that I really enjoyed in this continuity. So even though the titular characters are in absentia in their own title it was good and honestly the tease of not having a Turtle Van does not even bother me.
hypered1
07-08-2021, 05:16 PM
OR better yet, stopped for the in continuity story "Last Ronin" tale... as nothing so far really sets it apart from the IDWs potential future.
TLR isn't canon to the IDW continuity; the furthest future shown in the IDW run has Don as the last man standing whereas in TLR it's Mike.
That being said the recently teased 'Lita's future' doesn't match the future we saw in the 20/20 issue where Pepperoni was just much bigger than at present and not mutated like in the issue #117 panel, but then 20/20 isn't definitively canon either.
mrmaczaps
07-08-2021, 06:29 PM
TLR isn't canon to the IDW continuity; the furthest future shown in the IDW run has Don as the last man standing whereas in TLR it's Mike.
That being said the recently teased 'Lita's future' doesn't match the future we saw in the 20/20 issue where Pepperoni was just much bigger than at present and not mutated like in the issue #117 panel, but then 20/20 isn't definitively canon either.
I meant MAKE TLR a potential future so its in continuity.... not that it is currently.
ChosenOne
07-08-2021, 06:35 PM
TLR isn't canon to the IDW continuity; the furthest future shown in the IDW run has Don as the last man standing whereas in TLR it's Mike.
That being said the recently teased 'Lita's future' doesn't match the future we saw in the 20/20 issue where Pepperoni was just much bigger than at present and not mutated like in the issue #117 panel, but then 20/20 isn't definitively canon either.
And that being said, Lita's future isn't the definitive future the Turtles will have either. Every single potential (canon) future we've seen so far, including Splinter's vision, was averted due to the characters taking steps to prevent them or even just knowing about them. Like what the Turtles did to stop Shredder and Krang the first time around, or Lita traveling back to ensure the battle of the bands takes place and changes everything. Hence the real future will be the one the characters never see coming and we, the readers, get to experience in real time without any foresight. Does that make sense?
TigerClaw
07-08-2021, 07:07 PM
And that being said, Lita's future isn't the definitive future the Turtles will have either. Every single potential (canon) future we've seen so far, including Splinter's vision, was averted due to the characters taking steps to prevent them or even just knowing about them. Like what the Turtles did to stop Shredder and Krang the first time around, or Lita traveling back to ensure the battle of the bands takes place and changes everything. Hence the real future will be the one the characters never see coming and we, the readers, get to experience in real time without any foresight. Does that make sense?
Lita's future is from the year 2040, It will take a long time to get to that point. She told Leo before she left to remember the names Bob and Carmen. These are characters who appear to be important in Lita's future, And we did see them in Lita's new future timeline in this issue, So in a couple of issues we will be introduced to the young version of these characters.
ChosenOne
07-08-2021, 07:53 PM
Lita's future is from the year 2040, It will take a long time to get to that point. She told Leo before she left to remember the names Bob and Carmen. These are characters who appear to be important in Lita's future, And we did see them in Lita's new future timeline in this issue, So in a couple of issues we will be introduced to the young version of these characters.
Yeah, but Bob and Carmen being brought into the fold doesn't mean that particular, specific future will come to pass now. The (alternate) timeline is still there, but Future Lita did and said enough during her trip back in time to make sure the main timeline in the comic diverged from hers.
TigerClaw
07-08-2021, 08:13 PM
Yeah, but Bob and Carmen being brought into the fold doesn't mean that particular, specific future will come to pass now. The (alternate) timeline is still there, but Future Lita did and said enough during her trip back in time to make sure the main timeline in the comic diverged from hers.
Another thing to take into account, She told her younger self a secret, We don't know what this secret could be, But it could something that will happen to her in the future issue, Who knows what it could be, But it would be something little Lita will remember her older self telling her.
ChosenOne
07-08-2021, 09:59 PM
Another thing to take into account, She told her younger self a secret, We don't know what this secret could be, But it could something that will happen to her in the future issue, Who knows what it could be, But it would be something little Lita will remember her older self telling her.
I think the very fact that Future Lita was present to tell her past self said secret was enough - even disregarding everything else that happened - to split the timelines. It didn't happen the first time around, when Lita was growing up, so this is a completely new thing. The past changed and so will the future, but the other timelines (the one Future Lita came from and the one she went back to after fixing things) are still there. On top of the one that is still unfolding in the pages of the comic. At least that's how I see it, though admittedly time travel is always a complicated subject and liable to give anyone a headache.
hypered1
07-09-2021, 05:24 AM
I think the very fact that Future Lita was present to tell her past self said secret was enough - even disregarding everything else that happened - to split the timelines. It didn't happen the first time around, when Lita was growing up, so this is a completely new thing. The past changed and so will the future, but the other timelines (the one Future Lita came from and the one she went back to after fixing things) are still there. On top of the one that is still unfolding in the pages of the comic. At least that's how I see it, though admittedly time travel is always a complicated subject and liable to give anyone a headache.
It's been said enough times before but it's like Trunks changing the past in DBZ, his future remains and is unchanged but the future for the present timeline characters has changed.
TylerD
07-09-2021, 11:48 AM
Lita's future is from the year 2040, It will take a long time to get to that point. She told Leo before she left to remember the names Bob and Carmen. These are characters who appear to be important in Lita's future, And we did see them in Lita's new future timeline in this issue, So in a couple of issues we will be introduced to the young version of these characters.
Ya interested to see what these characters bring to the story as well as Saki being back and as a good guy (at least for the time being) they have opened up this universe so well with added characters. It’s exciting!!
ChosenOne
07-09-2021, 12:19 PM
It's been said enough times before but it's like Trunks changing the past in DBZ, his future remains and is unchanged but the future for the present timeline characters has changed.
Yes and no. The parallel with Trunks' timeline(s) is clear, and time travel seems to work in much the same way here. But... Lita traveled back in time because her timeline had gone so very wrong, and yet the future she returns to looks very bright and sunny and happy, and everyone is together. It doesn't add up unless we consider that she created another timeline by coming back to change things and is returning to that one, not the one she originally left. I dunno, this makes more sense in my head than I am able to put in writing. Time travel is always hard to explain.
TylerD
07-09-2021, 04:41 PM
Yes and no. The parallel with Trunks' timeline(s) is clear, and time travel seems to work in much the same way here. But... Lita traveled back in time because her timeline had gone so very wrong, and yet the future she returns to looks very bright and sunny and happy, and everyone is together. It doesn't add up unless we consider that she created another timeline by coming back to change things and is returning to that one, not the one she originally left. I dunno, this makes more sense in my head than I am able to put in writing. Time travel is always hard to explain.
Agreed with this completely, and not just with the Ninja Turtle universe... it's with any universe. It really depends on the writer and what their plans are for the script of the story. I have seen time travel changed so much through the years, especially when you involve multiverses and different time streams. Trying to keep up with the Flash is one of the most confusing.
ChosenOne
07-09-2021, 07:06 PM
Agreed with this completely, and not just with the Ninja Turtle universe... it's with any universe. It really depends on the writer and what their plans are for the script of the story. I have seen time travel changed so much through the years, especially when you involve multiverses and different time streams. Trying to keep up with the Flash is one of the most confusing.
Yep. There's only so many "Damn it, Barry!"'s one can hear before we stop giving a damn about Barry.
TylerD
07-09-2021, 11:21 PM
Yep. There's only so many "Damn it, Barry!"'s one can hear before we stop giving a damn about Barry.
Lmao, well said.
lonewarrior20
07-10-2021, 04:50 AM
Has anyone ever cared about one of the Beaver brothers?
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.