View Full Version : tmnt 120 discussion
lonewarrior20
08-23-2021, 12:23 PM
here's a preview of wendsdays issue. https://comic-watch.com/news/sneak-peek-preview-of-idw-publishings-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-120 enjoying this fight.
hypered1
08-23-2021, 12:41 PM
About time Hob got his butt kicked.
CyberCubed
08-23-2021, 01:05 PM
Old Hob did nothing wrong though.
hypered1
08-23-2021, 04:37 PM
For the mutagen bomb? For trafficking infant mutants for combat purposes? For withholding supplies from the rest of Mutant Town?
For any and all of those reasons.
Lord Nightwalker
08-23-2021, 05:01 PM
Betting Hob was being played from the inside. Seems Ray's the real enemy. Betting he throws a "mutagen mutiny."
Bahamut810
08-23-2021, 05:08 PM
For the mutagen bomb? For trafficking infant mutants for combat purposes? For withholding supplies from the rest of Mutant Town?
For any and all of those reasons.
Thank you for the background. I was actually about to ask if he did anything other then be a violent revolutionary for animal/animal based mutant rights. I am fairly new to the series, and whats between Volume 9 and only a few issues ago are a blind spot for me.
Ninjinister
08-24-2021, 05:46 AM
Launches one day after the book's tenth anniversary!
lonewarrior20
08-24-2021, 07:35 AM
Launches one day after the book's tenth anniversary!
Time flies when your having fun. Also gotta say this for the last panel "Hey Kool-aid!"
lonewarrior20
08-25-2021, 03:33 AM
well, that was interesting. liked how mona just started destroying everything in her path. now i really can't wait for the next issue with that last page.
CyberCubed
08-25-2021, 11:26 AM
Herman and Pete just kinda disappeared after everyone barged in, would have liked to see the Turtles reaction to them there.
Overall a satisfactory issue with some twists I didn't see coming, although it remains to be seen what they do with Old Hob. However this is just another issue where the villains give up too easily and just make amends (similar to Bebop/Rocksteady giving up on the battle of the bands without even trying, or Karai's decision to uphold a truce with the Turtles after Rahzar/Tokka nearly killed her), and so forth. It's a noticeable trend with Sophie's writing style over these last issues, let alone "good guy Shredder" that we've had too.
But this was a better issue than expected. The letters section implies we'll be in Mutant Town for awhile yet, so yeah I think we'll be here till issue 150 now.
ChosenOne
08-25-2021, 11:52 AM
Herman and Pete just kinda disappeared after everyone barged in, would have liked to see the Turtles reaction to them there.
That would necessitate Campbell actually being capable of complex, character-driven writing.
What a disappointing and lackluster 10th anniversary. I'm ready for this glorified fanfic to be over now, and Hob better not come to any harm.
neatoman
08-25-2021, 12:27 PM
Well, that was probably the best issue of this run (not like that says much) but I'm afraid the next issue might undermine it rather quickly.
lonewarrior20
08-28-2021, 06:32 AM
Just had a thought, I bet the rest of the Mutanimals are gathering to destroy the dojo since they weren't there and the next issue does say we get another confrontation there.
TigerClaw
08-28-2021, 09:07 AM
Just had a thought, I bet the rest of the Mutanimals are gathering to destroy the dojo since they weren't there and the next issue does say we get another confrontation there.
Unless Saki was keeping an eye on the Dojo while they were gone, I'm sure he can take on whoever tries to mess with the place.
mrmaczaps
08-29-2021, 06:49 AM
That would necessitate Campbell actually being capable of complex, character-driven writing.
What a disappointing and lackluster 10th anniversary. I'm ready for this glorified fanfic to be over now, and Hob better not come to any harm.
Agreed.
More action this issue buuuuut it goes nowhere. Is Campbell listening to Chumbawumba's "why can't we be friends" song on repeat or something? :tlol:
The issue was not great at all and this storyline needs to make a quick exit unless IDW ***WANTS*** to kill this series for some kind of reboot. Would be nice if they retconned the last 20 issues.... "this has all been a fever dream"... since issue 95 when Jennika gets stabbed. Splinter is still dead. Shredder is still alive. But everything else has been a nightmare.
TigerClaw
08-29-2021, 08:30 AM
Agreed.
More action this issue buuuuut it goes nowhere. Is Campbell listening to Chumbawumba's "why can't we be friends" song on repeat or something? :tlol:
The issue was not great at all and this storyline needs to make a quick exit unless IDW ***WANTS*** to kill this series for some kind of reboot. Would be nice if they retconned the last 20 issues.... "this has all been a fever dream"... since issue 95 when Jennika gets stabbed. Splinter is still dead. Shredder is still alive. But everything else has been a nightmare.
Aint gonna happen since the writers don't really listen what's been going on here, They are well aware of the stuff happening in this forum that it doesn't bother them.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 12:52 PM
Aint gonna happen since the writers don't really listen what's been going on here, They are well aware of the stuff happening in this forum that it doesn't bother them.
It's not just in this forum, believe me. Take a look at Ninja Notes if you don't.
It's getting to a point where they can't help but publish negative letters every month now, and this forum is far from being the only place in the Internet that has (rightfully) criticized Campbell's bullsh*t run. In fact, the only praise I ever see for it comes from Twitter and its hivemind drones.
As a great man said, everything woke turns to sh*t.
TigerClaw
08-29-2021, 01:12 PM
It's not just in this forum, believe me. Take a look at Ninja Notes if you don't.
It's getting to a point where they can't help but publish negative letters every month now, and this forum is far from being the only place in the Internet that has (rightfully) criticized Campbell's bullsh*t run. In fact, the only praise I ever see for it comes from Twitter and its hivemind drones.
As a great man said, everything woke turns to sh*t.
But if you look at the response, Mutant Town will stick around for longer, They understand the criticism, But its not gonna force them to change anything, As writers they don't have to take all feedback into consideration.
Most of the complains are just people who aren't following the story, Which is why the responses always mention about reading some of the other comics they have like The Last Ronin.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 01:14 PM
But if you look at the response, Mutant Town will stick around for longer, They understand the criticism, But its not force them to change anything, As writers they don't have to take all feedback into consideration.
Indeed, that's their prerogative. It's also their funeral.
Most of the complains are just people who aren't following the story, Which is why the responses always mention about reading some of the other comics they have like The Last Ronin.
I've also heard about some people who never even read the comic before Campbell came on board and now act like it's the greatest thing since bread came sliced post-#100, like they know all about what went on in the first 100-issues-plus-extras. Funny that.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 02:31 PM
It's not just in this forum, believe me. Take a look at Ninja Notes if you don't.
It's getting to a point where they can't help but publish negative letters every month now, and this forum is far from being the only place in the Internet that has (rightfully) criticized Campbell's bullsh*t run.
You've said this several times now but how about actually providing a source or some evidence or some links maybe, to back up this claim.
Tom Waltz gave us screenshots showing that orders numbers were good and I linked to information that confirmed that IDW turned a healthy profit in Q2 2021.
Time to put your money where your mouth is.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 03:22 PM
Time to put your money where your mouth is.
I've been doing that since I picked up the Raph micro ten years ago. Look how far it's got me.
MikeandRaph87
08-29-2021, 04:48 PM
You've said this several times now but how about actually providing a source or some evidence or some links maybe, to back up this claim.
Tom Waltz gave us screenshots showing that orders numbers were good and I linked to information that confirmed that IDW turned a healthy profit in Q2 2021.
Time to put your money where your mouth is.
Wait....I thought sales were tanking? When was this posted?
I picked up TMNT with issue #1. I was not thrilled with the first arc of the run #101-#105. I thought it would just be a few issues of ambiguous mutants playing punk music and tending a soup kitchen, but the bad arc keeps stretching and now we are 20 issues in. I quit with #117, an original reader. I have no alternative comic. Sure, there is The Last Ronin, and its okay, but its okay because this run is so bad and its the fact that The Last Ronin is taking up other talents time that it is negatively effecting the book/version I am invested in. We can only tolerate so much. The stretching of this arc is pure torture.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 05:04 PM
Tom posted I think in May and showed the order numbers for the following couple of months which were about 19,000 each, my post was around early July but I'm not sure which threads exactly but they were both in either solicitation threads or preview/review threads.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 05:19 PM
I've been doing that since I picked up the Raph micro ten years ago. Look how far it's got me.
Well that's a non-response if ever I saw one. You can keep complaining all you like but the numbers don't lie and the current story arcs are here to stay at least for the time being and probably until #150 now (that'll be around February 2024 to save you working it out).
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 07:16 PM
Wait....I thought sales were tanking?
They are. Fudging the numbers is a time-honored tradition.
Well that's a non-response if ever I saw one. You can keep complaining all you like but the numbers don't lie and the current story arcs are here to stay at least for the time being and probably until #150 now (that'll be around February 2024 to save you working it out).
You should be flattered right now, I save all my best non-responses for people just like you.
Speaking of money, the smart kind says this comic won't be around anymore on February 2024.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 08:33 PM
They are. Fudging the numbers is a time-honored tradition.
You should be flattered right now, I save all my best non-responses for people just like you.
Speaking of money, the smart kind says this comic won't be around anymore on February 2024.
Again I dare you provide any kind of proof to back up your assertions. I'll be waiting and until then I continue to believe that you're making up your own narrative like the loyal trump-ette that you are.
Sumac
08-29-2021, 08:50 PM
Again I dare you provide any kind of proof to back up your assertions. I'll be waiting and until then I continue to believe that you're making up your own narrative like the loyal trump-ette that you are.
Its not like loyal demRATS are known for their honesty either.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 09:02 PM
Again I dare you provide any kind of proof to back up your assertions. I'll be waiting and until then I continue to believe that you're making up your own narrative like the loyal trump-ette that you are.
:roll::lol::lol::lol::lol:
You "dare" me? What are you, six? (Is there an empty bottle lying on the floor between us I'm unaware of? 'Cause yuck.)
Its not like loyal demRATS are known for their honesty either.
Post-#100 is this comic's Afghanistan.
mrmaczaps
08-29-2021, 09:11 PM
:roll::lol::lol::lol::lol:
You "dare" me? What are you, six? (Is there an empty bottle lying on the floor between us I'm unaware of? 'Cause yuck.)
Post-#100 is this comic's Afghanistan.
Post 100 is America's dementia ridden resident of the WH. A total fvcking disaster but MSM & braindead zombies keep clapping like its the greatest thing since sliced bread. :tlol:
hypered1
08-29-2021, 09:12 PM
:roll::lol::lol::lol::lol:
You "dare" me? What are you, six? (Is there an empty bottle lying on the floor between us I'm unaware of? 'Cause yuck.)
Post-#100 is this comic's Afghanistan.
I've repeatedly asked you to provide links to other places that voice a negative view of the current run and every time you fail to provide anything that backs up your arguments.
Either grow some balls and give links to these other sites that 'hate the current run' or step off the soap box because you're embarrassing yourself.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 09:13 PM
Post 100 is America's dementia ridden resident of the WH. A total fvcking disaster but MSM & braindead zombies keep clapping like its the greatest thing since sliced bread. :tlol:
And it's only just begun, just like how we're (apparently) not even halfway through Campbell's dumpster fire of a run. Oy...
I've repeatedly asked you to provide links to other places that voice a negative view of the current run and every time you fail to provide anything that backs up your arguments.
Either grow some balls and give links to these other sites that 'hate the current run' or step off the soap box because you're embarrassing yourself.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Go home to mommy.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 09:28 PM
And it's only just begun, just like how we're (apparently) not even halfway through Campbell's dumpster fire of a run. Oy...
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Go home to mommy.
Well that appears to be proof enough that your assertions are entirely fictional.
Here's looking forward to the next two and a half years of the Campbell era, I'm sure your tears will be nice and salty.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 09:32 PM
Well that appears to be proof enough that your assertions are entirely fictional.
Here's looking forward to the next two and a half years of the Campbell era, I'm sure your tears will be nice and salty.
You're a very angry, intolerant and delusional young man. I feel sorry for you.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 09:36 PM
You're a very angry, intolerant and delusional young man. I feel sorry for you.
Yeah, yeah, whatever helps you sleep at night in your little fantasy world.
ChosenOne
08-29-2021, 09:40 PM
(...) little fantasy world.
I don't have a Twitter account, sorry.
hypered1
08-29-2021, 09:50 PM
That doesn't even make sense and I don't have a Twitter account myself
Mexiun
08-30-2021, 04:05 AM
I swear there was a post on this forum sometime ago (maybe some months ago) where it showed the sales are dropping like crazy.
Don't ask me to find it because i won't search for it, but its there somewhere in a preview topic of the currently awful run.
Besides i doubt the comic is doing better than pre-100 anyway, the numbers may still be okay at best but it definitely dropped after issue 100.
hypered1
08-30-2021, 06:44 AM
I swear there was a post on this forum sometime ago (maybe some months ago) where it showed the sales are dropping like crazy.
Don't ask me to find it because i won't search for it, but its there somewhere in a preview topic of the currently awful run.
Besides i doubt the comic is doing better than pre-100 anyway, the numbers may still be okay at best but it definitely dropped after issue 100.
There were a couple of posts showing the pre-pandemic numbers but they all cut off around #104-ish. Tom's post from Earlier this year were for the numbers of #117/118 and were around 19,000.
MikeandRaph87
08-30-2021, 08:07 PM
There were a couple of posts showing the pre-pandemic numbers but they all cut off around #104-ish. Tom's post from Earlier this year were for the numbers of #117/118 and were around 19,000.
That seems inflated even accounting digital sales.
I was thinking the last known sales were #110 which was around 16k in the Thinking Critical video. I was hoping further issues had an ideal sales number.
We should be celebrating a decade and the longest running TMNT version, but instead it passes by and I dismissed it with no signs of The Armageddon Game.
Coola Yagami
08-30-2021, 09:27 PM
Are they seriously gonna stretch this garbage storyline for another year or so? Did IDW just get tired of the Turtles and stopped giving a **** if the book will live or die now that the Turtle stuff died down?
For better of for worse, this comic started a month or so before the 2012 cartoon kicked off and endured both Bay movies, the entire run of the 2021 show and Rise. Now the only really 'turtlemania' type things left are just that retro TMNT game on the horizon and I guess their inclusion in that Nickcrossover game.
It almost feels like now that the Nick TMNT wave washed out, they could care less if the comic lives or dies anymore.
Leo656
08-30-2021, 10:34 PM
Coola, didn't you tell me recently that your local comic shop owner didn't carry the TMNT comic anymore since it wasn't selling? Or was that someone else?
Anecdotal, but I've had several people tell me that over the last few months; that their shop stopped ordering TMNT entirely because it just doesn't sell. My shop still gets it in, but they only order a handful of copies. Last Ronin apparently did okay, though.
The fact that any comic shop ANYWHERE would stop ordering TMNT due to low sales should be cause for concern. BUT, people with their head in the sand will of course continue to insist everything's fine and dandy. Right until the lights go out.
Joey Kamikaze
08-30-2021, 11:30 PM
For what it's worth, I don't trust the numbers Tom posted in the other thread a while back and suspect the editorial team is blowing smoke up our asses as they rearrange chairs on the deck of the Titanic.
This was such a great book up through #100. At this point I'm only continuing to buy it so I can have a full run of first prints after it piffles out in another year or two.
If there's a bright side, we're not quite to season eight of Game of Thrones yet. More like season six or seven.
hypered1
08-31-2021, 12:52 AM
That seems inflated even accounting digital sales.
I was thinking the last known sales were #110 which was around 16k in the Thinking Critical video. I was hoping further issues had an ideal sales number.
We should be celebrating a decade and the longest running TMNT version, but instead it passes by and I dismissed it with no signs of The Armageddon Game.
As I pointed out at the time everything in that video regarding sales figures was pure speculation - the numbers they gave were their own made up estimations and not based on real data whatsoever.
You also have to remember that CD is one these channels that feed off of hate clicks and have no real interest in the truth or veracity of what they report/ discuss.
Kyo Hisagi
08-31-2021, 01:42 AM
Coola, didn't you tell me recently that your local comic shop owner didn't carry the TMNT comic anymore since it wasn't selling? Or was that someone else?
Anecdotal, but I've had several people tell me that over the last few months; that their shop stopped ordering TMNT entirely because it just doesn't sell
Well I don't have any local comic shops on me but I've visited Turkey back in dec 2018 and there were NO TMNT in any comic shops I've visited (four pretty big ones). Plenty of Marvel, DC stuff, Hellboy, Image stuff like Saga. Manga, of course. TMNT? Nope. They said no one's buying that, guess they just order only for a few people who care for the green quartet.
It has nothing to do with the current situation, but I think sales were like this for awhile. And this is sad. At least Ronin does great. But Ronin isn't enough, especially with it ending after two more issues.
mrmaczaps
08-31-2021, 05:18 AM
My LCS has stopped ordering TMNT for the shelf. He gets 6 copies total. Two of those are for me. I even offered to buy 4 more so I could get the 1:10 & he said its hot garbage...
Coola Yagami
08-31-2021, 11:07 AM
Coola, didn't you tell me recently that your local comic shop owner didn't carry the TMNT comic anymore since it wasn't selling? Or was that someone else?
Anecdotal, but I've had several people tell me that over the last few months; that their shop stopped ordering TMNT entirely because it just doesn't sell. My shop still gets it in, but they only order a handful of copies. Last Ronin apparently did okay, though.
The fact that any comic shop ANYWHERE would stop ordering TMNT due to low sales should be cause for concern. BUT, people with their head in the sand will of course continue to insist everything's fine and dandy. Right until the lights go out.
Yep that was me. My smaller shop stopped carrying it cause no one was buying it. You'd have to special order it if you really REALLY wanted it, but they couldn't afford to just order copies to have em lying around.
My larger comic shop still carries, but since they're a bigger store with a bigger collection, I guess they can afford to take a loss.
Andrew NDB
08-31-2021, 11:56 AM
Yep that was me. My smaller shop stopped carrying it cause no one was buying it. You'd have to special order it if you really REALLY wanted it, but they couldn't afford to just order copies to have em lying around.
Reminds me of the last days of Tales V2 and TMNT Vol. 4.
"You know, Andrew, you're the only guy coming in here buying Turtles stuff!" Back then I'd like urge comic stores to put more Mirage stuff on the racks just in case. But they wouldn't.
oldmanwinters
08-31-2021, 12:30 PM
Are they seriously gonna stretch this garbage storyline for another year or so? Did IDW just get tired of the Turtles and stopped giving a **** if the book will live or die now that the Turtle stuff died down?
For better of for worse, this comic started a month or so before the 2012 cartoon kicked off and endured both Bay movies, the entire run of the 2021 show and Rise. Now the only really 'turtlemania' type things left are just that retro TMNT game on the horizon and I guess their inclusion in that Nickcrossover game.
It almost feels like now that the Nick TMNT wave washed out, they could care less if the comic lives or dies anymore.
WvAeWtyZ-uE
Yeah, it really feels like Nick wants to go all-in with the Retro-Turtles these days.
ChosenOne
08-31-2021, 12:59 PM
If there's a bright side, we're not quite to season eight of Game of Thrones yet. More like season six or seven.
You're implying there's a The Winds of Winter sometime in our future. Unless Waltz makes a grand comeback, I don't see it.
Every issue penned by Campbell makes "sunset found her squatting in the grass" look like Shakespeare.
lonewarrior20
08-31-2021, 02:22 PM
at least its not boruto and copying a dragonball z movie storyline.
ChosenOne
08-31-2021, 04:17 PM
at least its not boruto and copying a dragonball z movie storyline.
I haven't watched Boruto. Which one?
lonewarrior20
08-31-2021, 04:21 PM
I haven't watched Boruto. Which one?
tree of might.
ChosenOne
08-31-2021, 04:32 PM
tree of might.
Figured it would have to be either one of the early ones or Battle of the Gods. But then, even Dragon Ball copies Dragon Ball movie storylines.
hypered1
08-31-2021, 06:01 PM
I think there's at least 5 different versions of the first story-arc alone at this point.
Bahamut810
08-31-2021, 10:09 PM
I cant help but agree with the general sentiment of disappointment with the comic...especially with this issue. Im *really* new here. I am one of those TMNT back in the day type of guy who really started getting into it 7 months ago after seeing all of Rise and getting excited about the franchise again.
I got into the comic because I found a random issue 100 at my local shop I go to. I read it and thought it was bad ass, so I started picking up the Hardbacks and the current issue forward. I just got done with volume 9 and I cant help but think that Campbell has forgotten what stakes and struggles are. At the end of the volume is the action packed story of how Karai and Koya got their grooves back. I'm looking back at the books I have read over the past few months and all I see is build up, disappointment (Bebop and Rocksteady giving up? WTF?) and Deus Ex Machina in the form and 'ghost shredder'. This issue is no better! The conflict between Hob and Ray...Solved by Deus Ex Shredder stepping in when one of the Turtles was seconds away. The conflict between Hob and Raphiel? Children stopped it. Its like the writing is being engineered to make it the least satisfying it could possibly be.
What kills me, is that I know Campbell can do it. She worked on some of the highlights of Universe that had stakes (along with someone else, but still). I know she had a longer stint with more 'shojo' style stories...but how could the feel of the comic flip *so* drastically?
As a note for the sales of the comics. my store does not get too many copies I dont think. There is a shelf that has 2-3 sections depending on if Last Ronin is in. The two sections are *stacked* with old copies they cant get rid of of post 100 issues.
hypered1
09-01-2021, 12:53 AM
I cant help but agree with the general sentiment of disappointment with the comic...especially with this issue. Im *really* new here. I am one of those TMNT back in the day type of guy who really started getting into it 7 months ago after seeing all of Rise and getting excited about the franchise again.
I got into the comic because I found a random issue 100 at my local shop I go to. I read it and thought it was bad ass, so I started picking up the Hardbacks and the current issue forward. I just got done with volume 9 and I cant help but think that Campbell has forgotten what stakes and struggles are. At the end of the volume is the action packed story of how Karai and Koya got their grooves back. I'm looking back at the books I have read over the past few months and all I see is build up, disappointment (Bebop and Rocksteady giving up? WTF?) and Deus Ex Machina in the form and 'ghost shredder'. This issue is no better! The conflict between Hob and Ray...Solved by Deus Ex Shredder stepping in when one of the Turtles was seconds away. The conflict between Hob and Raphiel? Children stopped it. Its like the writing is being engineered to make it the least satisfying it could possibly be.
What kills me, is that I know Campbell can do it. She worked on some of the highlights of Universe that had stakes (along with someone else, but still). I know she had a longer stint with more 'shojo' style stories...but how could the feel of the comic flip *so* drastically?
As a note for the sales of the comics. my store does not get too many copies I dont think. There is a shelf that has 2-3 sections depending on if Last Ronin is in. The two sections are *stacked* with old copies they cant get rid of of post 100 issues.
As it's been said already, this isn't on Sophie Campbell; she's said before that what we're getting is what she being allowed to write and that the higher-ups haved tied her hands when it's comes to anything more substantial.
Those above Sophie at IDW/ Viacom are the ones you should be aggrieved with because they call the shots.
Kyo Hisagi
09-01-2021, 02:52 AM
It's up to writer to make a story as entertaining as possible.
MutantTown by itself is not a bad idea. Not at all. Even with some limitations you can create an amazing comic book. I mean... when you DO NOT have limitations as creative person? In movies? TV-shows? Come on. There are such things as higher-ups, risks, licensing issues, ratings etc etc. It's very rare for someone to have full creative control while working with characters you don't own.
CyberCubed
09-01-2021, 08:18 AM
I imagine the only plots Sophie's hands are tied with is The Pantheon and Krang/Leatherhead, for obvious reasons that those are Tom Waltz plotlines and he's already building up to them returning with the annual and whatever the Armaggedon game turns out to be.
So even if she can't do anything with the other Pantheon members or Krang/Leatherhead, there's still other stories she can do in the meantime. She's allowed to use Baxter Stockman, Karai and the Foot, and Old Hob at least as we've seen. So why not use those characters for more stories? We had some interesting stuff with Baxter going for a bit but its been sidelined for now.
Bahamut810
09-01-2021, 11:29 AM
As it's been said already, this isn't on Sophie Campbell; she's said before that what we're getting is what she being allowed to write and that the higher-ups haved tied her hands when it's comes to anything more substantial.
Those above Sophie at IDW/ Viacom are the ones you should be aggrieved with because they call the shots.
Ehhh, I just went and checked and story credits are in her name. The type of story being told seems to be much more at home with some of her other projects, like Jem.
Lets go with she is being told what to write, do you have a link to where she said this? Did she say what her direction was? If she said she is being told 'what not to write' and is just barred from writing about the pantheon....this is still her story that her name is attached to.
hypered1
09-01-2021, 12:11 PM
Ehhh, I just went and checked and story credits are in her name. The type of story being told seems to be much more at home with some of her other projects, like Jem.
Lets go with she is being told what to write, do you have a link to where she said this? Did she say what her direction was? If she said she is being told 'what not to write' and is just barred from writing about the pantheon....this is still her story that her name is attached to.
It was in a thread on here about a year ago; Sophie never got into any real specifics, but she did say that she'd asked about being allowed to do certain plot-lines but that a bunch of stuff was off limits.
I think Cybercubed's post is probably close to the mark but I do remember that the Utroms were a no-go and Raphael taking Hob's good eye was also dis-allowed (although that remains to be seen as a standing order with this current arc).
Andrew NDB
09-01-2021, 12:22 PM
Lets go with she is being told what to write, do you have a link to where she said this? Did she say what her direction was? If she said she is being told 'what not to write' and is just barred from writing about the pantheon....this is still her story that her name is attached to.
I haven't heard that here. Though it'd make a little bit of sense, in the bigger picture.
Pure speculation on my part:
* Tom gets all the way to #100 writing things as he will with minimum interference from Nick/Viacom.
* Suddenly Nick/Viacom takes an interest in IDW's TMNT comic. Maybe it's because of all the press Jennika garnered during that "Reveal," or maybe there it's just coincidental timing. Anyway, they start dictating to IDW that the comic be more "diverse," less about violence and more about inclusion and hand-holding, and so on. All of those kind of talking points.
* Tom sees the writing on the wall with the core IDW TMNT book and, together with Kevin (and Peter, in a roundabout way) pitch/resurrect/develop "The Last Ronin" to Nick/Viacom as a "way out" of being kind of forced to write the core book in the way that Nick/Viacom wants them to. Nick/Viacom bites. Tom goes full-time on "The Last Ronin," with the expectation/hope that Nick/Viacom would maybe stop being so heavy handed with their mandates after a certain point.
* The core book is handed over to Sophie, with the expectation being she'd fill in until Nick/Viacom stops wanting things to be "a certain way" on it.
* Years pass. Nick/Viacom still want the core IDW book to be done "a certain way." Sophie's run gets extended.
Does this sound... kind of right?
ChosenOne
09-01-2021, 01:15 PM
Campbell wanted to kill off Hob and wasn't allowed. That's what she was referring to, probably among other things in a similar vein. I guess he didn't fit in with her fluffy, furry, kumbaya-let's-all-be-friends-but-first-dispose-of-everyone-I-don't-like fanfic vision of what TMNT is supposed to be.
Bahamut810
09-01-2021, 04:11 PM
Does this sound... kind of right?
There is no telling. It doesn't sound wrong.
Campbell wanted to kill off Hob and wasn't allowed.
If we are lucky she will get her wish, at least something meaningful will happen...
ChosenOne
09-01-2021, 04:24 PM
If we are lucky she will get her wish, at least something meaningful will happen...
On the contrary, that would be the final straw.
Andrew NDB
09-01-2021, 04:42 PM
I doubt Sophie would even attempt to kill off Old Hob without at least consulting Tom. So if it even got on the docket at all for Nick to say "yes" or "no," I'm assuming it was with his blessing.
That in itself is a little worrisome, though, isn't it? Like IDW could create a brand new TMNT character tomorrow, then want to kill them off a year later... and Nickelodeon could just be like, "No, you can't do that"? Apparently? Yeesh. Or was the "no" from Tom and/or Bobby and not Nickelodeon?
ChosenOne
09-01-2021, 04:48 PM
I doubt Sophie would even attempt to kill off Old Hob without at least consulting Tom. So if it even got on the docket at all for Nick to say "yes" or "no," I'm assuming it was with his blessing.
That in itself is a little worrisome, though, isn't it? Like IDW could create a brand new TMNT character tomorrow, then want to kill them off a year later... and Nickelodeon could just be like, "No, you can't do that"? Apparently? Yeesh. Or was the "no" from Tom and/or Bobby and not Nickelodeon?
I don't know the specifics, only that it happened. Apparently she intended to have Hob lynched/beaten to death by the mob in the current arc, and it was soundly - and wisely - shot down.
Zog The Magnificent
09-01-2021, 04:54 PM
Even if certain things were off limits, that in no way absolves Sophie. This arc sucks because it sucks, pure and simple. Sophie clearly has talent, but is not using any of it to write this story. It's up to a writer to make a story good, regardless of any "limitations" put upon them (and this really sounds like a copout to me). Look at Tom Waltz. Go back and read the early stories in this run. They weren't even allowed to have blood for the longest time, and he still managed to create a compelling narrative, which only got better as restrictions were lifted and he was allowed to do more of what he wanted. Sophie has no excues. This run has sucked because Sophie took a good concept, focused on none of the interesting parts of that concept, and then dragged it out far past the point when we should have moved on, in addition to all of the incredibly shoehorned "diversity" that's making the comic insufferable.
Bahamut810
09-01-2021, 04:55 PM
More then anything I hope that this does not end with hob rolling over and admiting that he was totally wrong about everything forever. One of the things that I like about him in what I have read so far is that he is not 100% right or wrong. I can understand why he is doing what he is doing. It would feel like a betrayal of the character for him to go all 'gooey' like Aleopex and to a lesser extent Raphael have become.
Andrew NDB
09-01-2021, 04:59 PM
They weren't even allowed to have blood for the longest time
Did this ever change? As I recall, there was never a moratorium on blood or killing even at the beginning... but only as long as the blood wasn't being spilled by the Turtles themselves and they themselves weren't doing the killing. Like, they could have Shredder or some random villain kill someone on-panel with blood, but when it came to the Turtles... no go.
Which when that became clear (particularly during "City Fall"), coupled with the bandanna bait-and-switch, is when I had to let the book go.
Zog The Magnificent
09-01-2021, 05:07 PM
Did this ever change? As I recall, there was never a moratorium on blood or killing even at the beginning... but only as long as the blood wasn't being spilled by the Turtles themselves and they themselves weren't doing the killing. Like, they could have Shredder or some random villain kill someone on-panel with blood, but when it came to the Turtles... no go.
Which when that became clear (particularly during "City Fall"), coupled with the bandanna bait-and-switch, is when I had to let the book go.
Yeah, this changed. In the very first fight with the Shredder, for example, he beats the crap out of Splinter and no blood is spilled. In the earliest issues, not even the Villains spilled blood, and the very few times it happened, it was colored black. Later, they were allowed to have actual blood spilled by all parties, and the fights were actually allowed to be violent. The only thing that never truly went away was the moritorium on the Turtles themselves killing anyone, but I think Waltz managed to create a good story regardless of this.
ChosenOne
09-01-2021, 05:11 PM
It would feel like a betrayal of the character for him to go all 'gooey' like Aleopex and to a lesser extent Raphael have become.
You just know Campbell would love to push a love triangle between Raph, Alopex and Hob.
Zog The Magnificent
09-01-2021, 05:14 PM
You just know Campbell would love to push a love triangle between Raph, Alopex and Hob.
In the name of all that is holy, spare me.
ChosenOne
09-01-2021, 05:30 PM
In the name of all that is holy, spare me.
You and me both.
Powder
09-01-2021, 10:39 PM
I don't know the specifics, only that it happened. Apparently she intended to have Hob lynched/beaten to death by the mob in the current arc, and it was soundly - and wisely - shot down.
A visual metaphor of destroying the book's roots, how fitting.
Andrew NDB
09-02-2021, 03:43 AM
I really tend to believe such a thing was shot down on the editorial or writer side level, unless there's any proof otherwise.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.