PDA

View Full Version : What do you think about this guy's opinion on the "Battke of the Bands" Arc?


ryu238
09-11-2021, 11:44 AM
https://www.reddit.com/r/TMNT/comments/nyzetj/ive_been_thinking_about_dropping_idws_ongoing/hceaklb/
"I suspect that most any writer of one of your cites would have handled the situation differently. Like having Bebop perform, and show themselves to be villains, by cheating. Or not being coordinated with their bandmates. Or trying their best, but not being as good as the other group. Anything but what occurred, where the universe bent to show that the characters are morally right, because the author can't see the other side as sympathetic. And portrays the heroes as so damn good, even the villains bow before their talent. And the heroes do nothing related to good-sportmanship, like point out that the competition has rules, and that by not allowing them to play, the crowd is violating that rule. They take the victory without a second thought."

I saw issue 117, didn't they just decide that it wasn't worth it?

ChosenOne
09-11-2021, 12:10 PM
A writer, any writer, who decides to portray IDW Bebop and Rocksteady as declining to engage in violence under the flimsiest of pretexts just isn't worth their salt, IMO. That is something so out of character, it's ridiculous. Which is to say, I agree. Campbell seems to lack any notion of how conflict - violent or otherwise - works. Everyone just gets along. Because. For reasons. Smart money says she even floated the idea of having B&R join the big friendly circlejerk at some point and was promptly shot down, which is the only reason why Leo still tells Karai that everyone else but them is welcome at the dojo.

hypered1
09-11-2021, 12:55 PM
https://www.reddit.com/r/TMNT/comments/nyzetj/ive_been_thinking_about_dropping_idws_ongoing/hceaklb/
"I suspect that most any writer of one of your cites would have handled the situation differently. Like having Bebop perform, and show themselves to be villains, by cheating. Or not being coordinated with their bandmates. Or trying their best, but not being as good as the other group. Anything but what occurred, where the universe bent to show that the characters are morally right, because the author can't see the other side as sympathetic. And portrays the heroes as so damn good, even the villains bow before their talent. And the heroes do nothing related to good-sportmanship, like point out that the competition has rules, and that by not allowing them to play, the crowd is violating that rule. They take the victory without a second thought."

I saw issue 117, didn't they just decide that it wasn't worth it?

Bebop decided that it wasn't worth trying to compete with Jennika's band, but Rocksteady took some convincing from Bebop and Natsu to backdown from the competition.

It's pretty clear that the person who wrote all of that hasn't actually read the issue (and probably not many since #101) and is just regurgitating what they've read elsewhere that fits in with the narrative they've decided is the 'correct' one.

Zog The Magnificent
09-11-2021, 02:48 PM
It's pretty clear that the person who wrote all of that hasn't actually read the issue (and probably not many since #101) and is just regurgitating what they've read elsewhere that fits in with the narrative they've decided is the 'correct' one.

What are you talking about? What that person described is exactly what happened in the comic. It's been a whole lotta that for over 15 issues now.

hypered1
09-11-2021, 03:09 PM
What are you talking about? What that person described is exactly what happened in the comic. It's been a whole lotta that for over 15 issues now.

As I said in my previous comment, it was Bebop and Natsu who decide they wouldn't compete.
The person on reddit was trying to say that it was the crowd and/or the turtles that wouldn't let them play which isn't the case at all. Sally did tell them to leave the club but that was after Rocksteady began threatening to start a fight.

Either the reddit person was incorrectly repeating what they've only heard about the issue or they've actually read it and they're being deliberately disingenuous with the facts to twist them into something sounds far worse than the truth.

ChosenOne
09-11-2021, 03:39 PM
(...) being deliberately disingenuous with the facts to twist them into something sounds far worse than the truth.

Pssh, that tactic is unheard of in our day and age.

neatoman
09-11-2021, 03:54 PM
What do I think about this arc? It is incredibly stupid, anti-climactic and poorly written.

Most of the characters who participate are uninteresting or poorly conceived, the stakes are laughably low, it includes a confusing yet pointless time travel element and it doesn't really go anywhere. We are told that it (somehow) lead to a nicer future but they already averted the really bad scenario before the competition was even proposed. And if the new future is somehow set in stone because of this, that would just be boring (not that I think it is, Sophie's replacement will most likely just contradict that particular future anyway). Oh, and yes, the conclusion does in fact require the reader to accept that Bebop and Rocksteady would act out of character just to allow it to even happen in the first place.

It is a dumb story that is part of a dumb arc built on a dumb premise and features dumb characters. It is easily the worst story in the IDW continuity so far.

lonewarrior20
09-11-2021, 05:07 PM
i think it was ok. i enjoy the turtles interacting with others and they helped find band members. how many here have played d&d? i think sophies writing is more attuned to her playing as the dungeon master, thats why i think she's mainly focused on enlarging the world by having as many characters as possible. we're finding out their stories and yes she tends to tell it slowly but to me it's been building, just not in the way some people want it to be. i still think it's better than some of the past stories from other tmnt iterations.

Zog The Magnificent
09-11-2021, 05:20 PM
As I said in my previous comment, it was Bebop and Natsu who decide they wouldn't compete.
The person on reddit was trying to say that it was the crowd and/or the turtles that wouldn't let them play which isn't the case at all. Sally did tell them to leave the club but that was after Rocksteady began threatening to start a fight.

Either the reddit person was incorrectly repeating what they've only heard about the issue or they've actually read it and they're being deliberately disingenuous with the facts to twist them into something sounds far worse than the truth.

Um, Jennika plays, Bebop and Rocksteady both act out of character and don't end up competing, and then when he protests, they get kicked out of the club without getting to play, then leave without a fight. Nothing in the original account contradicts the events of the comic, and everything that was said was entirely within the spirit of what happens. Nothing about it is "deliberately disingenuous." The points you take issue with almost seem like nitpicking at this point.

As for the arc itself, it was one of the absolute dumbest things TMNT has ever done. Every problem it has has already been desribed in great detail on the other issue threads, but I think the easiest way to see why it failed is that they tried to do a Battle of the Bands, a story that requires sound, in a print medium. There was never any chance of a real payoff even if both sides did compete. And even if they did, all that would happen would be that they would take 5 extra pages to tell us that Jennika won and we'd have to take their word for it since we wouldn't be able to hear any of it anyways.

neatoman
09-11-2021, 05:39 PM
i think it was ok. i enjoy the turtles interacting with others and they helped find band members. how many here have played d&d? i think sophies writing is more attuned to her playing as the dungeon master, thats why i think she's mainly focused on enlarging the world by having as many characters as possible. we're finding out their stories and yes she tends to tell it slowly but to me it's been building, just not in the way some people want it to be. i still think it's better than some of the past stories from other tmnt iterations.

We're not playing a game here, we're reading a comic book, there is a fundamental difference since a comic book is all about story and a game really only has story to contextualize the player actions. If this was an RPG I could just say "This Battle of the Bands side-quest sucks ass" and just drop it for the Burnow Island side-quest instead, but it's not a game and as such the Battle of the Bands is what we got. A game designer and a comic book writer's work are not interchangeable, try to write a comic book like a game and it's probably going to stink.

And adding a bunch of new characters would be fine if they were actually good characters. Despite being two dozen issues in I can't really tell what the personalities of most of these new characters even are. The only things I know about Sheena is that she's embarrassed that she lost her hair and is in a band, which is really lame considering she's meant to be the new love interest of what's ostensibly one of the main characters (well, main character until some writer gets bored of the novelty of a female turtle and just kind of forgets about her that is). The Weasels do have some semblance of a personality but it's all kind of just the same personality and it's extremely shallow, they just seem to be there to be "cute".

I'm sorry, but very little of this is good. Maybe the art is but the writing? Hell no. The plot is slow, the twists awkward, the pay-off poor, the set-up random, the characters weak, the setting constrained and the premise paper thin.

lonewarrior20
09-12-2021, 03:24 AM
Um, Jennika plays, Bebop and Rocksteady both act out of character and don't end up competing, and then when he protests, they get kicked out of the club without getting to play, then leave without a fight. Nothing in the original account contradicts the events of the comic, and everything that was said was entirely within the spirit of what happens. Nothing about it is "deliberately disingenuous." The points you take issue with almost seem like nitpicking at this point.

As for the arc itself, it was one of the absolute dumbest things TMNT has ever done. Every problem it has has already been desribed in great detail on the other issue threads, but I think the easiest way to see why it failed is that they tried to do a Battle of the Bands, a story that requires sound, in a print medium. There was never any chance of a real payoff even if both sides did compete. And even if they did, all that would happen would be that they would take 5 extra pages to tell us that Jennika won and we'd have to take their word for it since we wouldn't be able to hear any of it anyways.

actually, idws bebop has been a bit of a quitter. look how he was on their side comic. also i think people seem to forget the whole reason why lita showed up from the future. it wasn't just about jennika forming a band, it was the turtles and karai burying the hatchet before everyone killed each other in an endless eye for an eye revenge. it was about letting go of the past and moving forward to a new day of possibilities.

Zog The Magnificent
09-12-2021, 03:58 AM
actually, idws bebop has been a bit of a quitter. look how he was on their side comic. also i think people seem to forget the whole reason why lita showed up from the future. it wasn't just about jennika forming a band, it was the turtles and karai burying the hatchet before everyone killed each other in an endless eye for an eye revenge. it was about letting go of the past and moving forward to a new day of possibilities.

But it wasn't about that, not really. It was about getting to show how awesome Jennika is, and to give a spotlight to all of Sophie's new OCs while we slice-of-life it up for 2 years straight. The future stuff was just a big distraction to hide the fact that this story had no real reason to exist and justify it with something that sounds cool at first, but is really just window dressing to justify what the writer actually wants to talk about. And really, even if Sophie wanted to actually focus on what is ostensibly the main plot thread of this story, burying the hatchet once and for all with the Foot Clan, was a Battle of the Bands really the only way to do that? It just had to be a battle of the bands? There wasn't literally anything more interesting that could have been used as a vehicle to deliver that story with?

Leo656
09-12-2021, 11:14 AM
Kinda makes me glad nobody reads this book, or the TMNT brand might be an even bigger joke than it already is right now.

The gymnastics performances by this arc's defenders would make a contortionist green with envy. I have a strong feeling that a lot of it comes from just being terrified that there won't be a TMNT book and so they have to justify and defend it because it's better than getting nothing.

I'd disagree, personally. With stuff like this, we don't especially need a TMNT book that badly, I reckon. It's a blind, toothless, two-legged dog with scabies at this point, just waiting to be put out of its misery so the suffering can end.

Also, the original poster missed the chance to copy over perhaps THE single most relevant part of the reddit post they're citing:
"I suspect this is therapeutic for the author, to create a world where everyone agrees with their point of view."

I mean... there it is. That's literally It.

ChosenOne
09-12-2021, 01:06 PM
actually, idws bebop has been a bit of a quitter. look how he was on their side comic.

But he wasn't alone here. He had Rocksteady and their mutant velociraptor, and the opposition they faced wasn't even half as formidable as the one they pretty much fought to a standstill in #40. Certainly not enough to get them to back down. And he was never written as a quitter from a brawl, which is the whole point. You will forgive me if I have such a hard time believing two characters who have, before this point, consistently been written as bloodthirsty and violent with hair-trigger tempers, to the point that they slaughtered an entire Triad just because they got bored of waiting and murdered at least one old lady in cold blood for kicks, would just shrug and walk away from their raison d'être. It's not consistent writing or characterization.

also i think people seem to forget the whole reason why lita showed up from the future. it wasn't just about jennika forming a band, it was the turtles and karai burying the hatchet before everyone killed each other in an endless eye for an eye revenge. it was about letting go of the past and moving forward to a new day of possibilities.

So that didn't happen already when the Turtles saved Karai's life in #100 and lost their father to stop the cataclysmic events she naively set in motion, which included a friggin' dragon and a horde of demons invading New York City? That wasn't enough to teach her the lesson she sorely needed, but rescuing her from a helicopter crash and then playing guitar for five minutes was? By the time of this issue, either Karai is incredibly, suicidally stupid or saving her life from sh*t she stirs up herself is just gonna become a recurring hobby for the Turtles, assuming it doesn't kill them first. And yeah, in case anyone reading this wonders, I do think it's a damn shame the matter of the debt Karai already owed the Turtles before they pulled her bacon out of the fire again was never properly addressed post-#100. Not even a snide remark from Raph or whoever in this arc, about how she should've learned her lesson. It's actually kinda odd that there's apparently no bad blood between her and Kitsune. I'll just chalk this up to Campbell's Hello Kitty-level of writing around any and all possible conflicts.

Also, the original poster missed the chance to copy over perhaps THE single most relevant part of the reddit post they're citing:
"I suspect this is therapeutic for the author, to create a world where everyone agrees with their point of view."

I mean... there it is. That's literally It.

Leftists have issues. In other news, water is wet.

Sumac
09-12-2021, 10:53 PM
"I suspect this is therapeutic for the author, to create a world where everyone agrees with their point of view."
If I was a published writer I'd be appalled to create a world, where everyone agrees with me. Its like the most dumb childish thing writer, any writer can create.

Leo656
09-12-2021, 11:12 PM
If I was a published writer I'd be appalled to create a world, where everyone agrees with me. Its like the most dumb childish thing writer, any writer can create.

I mean, there's a saying that "All Art is Propaganda", in that it invariably reflects the views and beliefs of its creator.

There's some truth to that. But I think you need to read the room when you're working on a commercial property, and act accordingly.

There's no doubt that much of this is coming about because TMNT is all but invisible right now. If there was a successful cartoon show on the air and a successful movie franchise ongoing, the comic would be doing things more in-line with whatever those things had going on. But since the brand is "dead" again and nobody's really reading the comic much anyway, they have the "freedom" to do whatever they want and what they want to do is unfortunately This.

"If a once-popular franchise falls in the woods, but nobody's around to listen anyway, does its death-rattle make a sound?" It's basically like that.

Ninjinister
09-13-2021, 05:15 AM
I love the vast majority of everything happening since Mutant Town but yeah, this made no sense to me at all.

Not sure why the topic is "what do you think of one rando's opinion" though lmao. Nobody cares about that, just present the issue.

neatoman
09-13-2021, 06:35 AM
Obviously it's a horrible idea to create a fictional world where everyone agrees with the author's point of view. Stories are primarily about some kind of conflict, which is rather hard to write if the characters don't really disagree about anything.

hypered1
09-13-2021, 06:44 AM
I love the vast majority of everything happening since Mutant Town but yeah, this made no sense to me at all.

Not sure why the topic is "what do you think of one rando's opinion" though lmao. Nobody cares about that, just present the issue.

I agree that this is a pointless thread as it's just rehashing everything that was said on here 3 months ago in the issue's own preview/review thread.

Leo656
09-13-2021, 06:47 AM
Obviously it's a horrible idea to create a fictional world where everyone agrees with the author's point of view. Stories are primarily about some kind of conflict, which is rather hard to write if the characters don't really disagree about anything.

https://y.yarn.co/2357fe72-c25f-40f1-bbcc-a3c17bdf1b83_text.gif

Crappy gif, best I could find of this clip. Sorry, I know I'm usually better.

neatoman
09-13-2021, 08:16 AM
https://y.yarn.co/2357fe72-c25f-40f1-bbcc-a3c17bdf1b83_text.gif

Crappy gif, best I could find of this clip. Sorry, I know I'm usually better.

TS1Upcpl_1U

And yes, Peter was totally right. That movie seems terrible.

Leo656
09-13-2021, 08:28 AM
Sh*t, even I could've just gone on YouTube for the clip if it was THAT important, I just didn't know if it was funny enough to take the extra seventeen seconds out of my morning to bother. :lol:

Turns out it was. Ya bastid.

And that entire "movie" was just Bill Pullman's psychotic-break fantasy; he's actually on Death Row for murdering the Jeff Daniels character after he caught him runnin' around makin' pornos. :lol:

...I just saw "Lost Highway" last week for the first time ever.

MikeandRaph87
09-13-2021, 11:53 AM
It has no place in TMNT. It simply doesn't work for the plot. The solicits and articles on it make it read like a huge ramification and dire future. It could not have been more of a stretch.

oldmanwinters
09-13-2021, 12:24 PM
[Sees "Battke of the Bands"'
[Thinks "is that German?"]

ChosenOne
09-13-2021, 12:25 PM
I mean, there's a saying that "All Art is Propaganda", in that it invariably reflects the views and beliefs of its creator.

Good art does it with subtlety, though. It doesn't smack the reader/viewer over the head like a nunchuck with the author's views.

(...) dire future.

Weeell...

Leo656
09-13-2021, 12:56 PM
Good art does it with subtlety, though. It doesn't smack the reader/viewer over the head like a nunchuk with the author's views.


Strongly agree.

I don't ever think that trying to make a point or send a message or entertain a notion is "offsides", I just think there's a way to do it within a commercial piece of entertainment without bludgeoning people with it.

Like okay, some people may remember this. But once upon a time, Chuck Austen had a terrible, I mean f*cking awful run on Action Comics. Like all writers who handle the character, he wanted to "leave a stamp" on the Superman mythos, and one of the things he always felt like was that "Lois is a bitch, Clark should've ended up with Lana instead." And he wanted to explore that idea.

Problems arose from the very start of this. For one thing, in-story Lana was married with a kid; but Austen wanted her free to openly pitch herself at Clark so she suddenly acts like she doesn't care about her family and only ever got married or had the kid to keep up appearances while secretly pining for Clark the entire time. Further, Lois was very much NOT a bitch or a selfish uncaring wife who neglected Clark's needs or wants, at this point, but that's what Austen wanted her to be for the purpose of his story, so suddenly, she WAS that, out of nowhere. In the concurrent Superman books running at the exact same time, everything about her character and her marriage to Clark was shown to be healthy and stable, the exact opposite of what was going on in Austen's run. So right off, the writer was twisting the characters and the canon to fit the story they wanted to tell, and that's always bad to start with.

So it starts off with Lois being absent for a while while Lana all but throws herself at Clark for several issues, stopping juuuust short of flat-out telling him "She's a bitch, get a divorce so we can f*ck," even flat-out telling Clark that "Lois doesn't love you", which is f*cking absurd and contradicts everything we'd directly seen and read in any Superman books for over ten years. It got baaaaaaaad. So then Lois comes back, and the two of them start getting super-catty with each other, and it's cringe. The whole time, Superman's in recovery from getting his ass kicked by some loser super-villain Austen made up for this story who never mattered again afterwards, so he mostly just sits around moping about all this while his wife and his ex are about to have a catfight at the dinner table in front of Ma and Pa. Everybody f*cking hated it, it was awful.

It got to a point where Ma Kent in-story tells them both to stop being c*nts, tells Lana to stop being a homewrecking bitch and tels Lois she could basically be nicer to Clark (or something), and that's the end of that plotline after what felt like a million issues but was probably only like six or seven (his arc only ran for 11 issues, originally planned for 12 but he got kicked off it at the end). I imagine DC told him to drop it immediately due to the severely negative feedback they were getting, thus the clunk/thud "resolution" out of nowhere and it never coming up again. The rest of the story wasn't much better but people f*cking HATED the Lana/Clark/Lois stuff. And it was like HALF of what the story was about! It's become something of a legendary tale in how NOT to explore an intriguing idea within the confines of the established-fiction of a licensed property.

So we've got ignoring established canon and character behavior to fit your story, rather than writing a story to fit what's been established, and that's not how comics work. We've got a non-ending to a prominent plotline which takes up a lot of real estate but in the end turns out to be F*cking Nothing and a giant waste of time. And we've got characters acting in ways that directly contradict things they did Not Long Ago At All, just because the plot demands it. Sound familiar at all?

And it's not like the basic idea Austen went for in that case wasn't intriguing; it'd been a prominent theme in the past, particularly the Silver Age although it wasn't handled very gracefully there at all and was actually rather awful back then, too. The whole idea of Lana carrying a flame for Clark and there always being a spark of "What If?" between them is part of their entire dynamic. But this sh*t was bananas. In better hands, it COULD have been a real knockout subplot; instead, it ended with one of the characters IN THE STORY saying, "This is stupid. Stop it right now."

There's a Good and Bad way to utilize your soapbox when entrusted with familiar and beloved fictional characters. Every good writer is trying to make a point, but there's a way to do it with grace and a way to just smash it in people's faces. The latter generally doesn't much work because it's so transparent and lazy.

Bahamut810
09-13-2021, 08:03 PM
I almost dropped the series because of that. Even if Bebop was a 'quitter'...Checkovs gun. You hyped a battle of the bands...you showed everyone playing their instruments. GIVE US OUR BATTLE OF THE BANDS! That was *no* way to write a story. AT ALL.

ChosenOne
09-13-2021, 09:35 PM
Checkovs gun.

Guns are bad, m'kay? No one needs a high capacity assault writer.

Leo656
09-14-2021, 02:39 AM
[Sees "Battke of the Bands"'
[Thinks "is that German?"]

At a glance, I thought it said "Bukkake of the Bands" and I thought this whole conversation was gonna be a lot different. :lol:

ProphetofGanja
09-27-2021, 09:28 PM
At this point IDW’s TMNT cast is in danger of Too Many Cooksing itself out of existence

QrGrOK8oZG8

ryu238
05-15-2022, 06:14 PM
As I said in my previous comment, it was Bebop and Natsu who decide they wouldn't compete.
The person on reddit was trying to say that it was the crowd and/or the turtles that wouldn't let them play which isn't the case at all. Sally did tell them to leave the club but that was after Rocksteady began threatening to start a fight.

Either the reddit person was incorrectly repeating what they've only heard about the issue or they've actually read it and they're being deliberately disingenuous with the facts to twist them into something sounds far worse than the truth.

Thanks. I knew there was something wrong there.

ChosenOne
05-15-2022, 06:17 PM
There's a lot that's wrong, alright.

ryu238
05-15-2022, 06:18 PM
Kinda makes me glad nobody reads this book, or the TMNT brand might be an even bigger joke than it already is right now.

The gymnastics performances by this arc's defenders would make a contortionist green with envy. I have a strong feeling that a lot of it comes from just being terrified that there won't be a TMNT book and so they have to justify and defend it because it's better than getting nothing.

I'd disagree, personally. With stuff like this, we don't especially need a TMNT book that badly, I reckon. It's a blind, toothless, two-legged dog with scabies at this point, just waiting to be put out of its misery so the suffering can end.

Also, the original poster missed the chance to copy over perhaps THE single most relevant part of the reddit post they're citing:
"I suspect this is therapeutic for the author, to create a world where everyone agrees with their point of view."

I mean... there it is. That's literally It.

Except what politics were being pushed?

neatoman
05-15-2022, 06:28 PM
Except what politics were being pushed?

A point of view isn't necessarily a political one.

ChosenOne
05-15-2022, 06:41 PM
A point of view isn't necessarily a political one.

Ever heard the saying about hammers and nails?

neatoman
05-15-2022, 06:58 PM
Ever heard the saying about hammers and nails?

"Just because all you have is a hammer, that doesn't mean everything is a nail"

Is that the one?

ChosenOne
05-15-2022, 06:59 PM
"Just because all you have is a hammer, that doesn't mean everything is a nail"

Is that the one?

Oh, yes, that's the one.

ryu238
12-20-2024, 09:57 PM
Oh, yes, that's the one.

Thanks for admitting your problem

neatoman
12-21-2024, 04:26 AM
Thanks for admitting your problem

Why are you responding over two years later to a guy who has been permabanned?

ToTheNines
12-21-2024, 05:22 AM
What did ChosenOne do anyway? Be was always chill.

TheLabRat
12-21-2024, 06:48 PM
Does anyone really care about Jennika's band or future Lita's family issues? This is just another craps that IDW want to remind us why IDW turtles should continue to be hippies, and keep the villains alive and let them haunting the turtles again.