View Full Version : TMNT #121 preview and discussion
hypered1
09-28-2021, 08:19 AM
https://graphicpolicy.com/2021/09/28/preview-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-121/
lonewarrior20
09-28-2021, 08:32 AM
Mona lisa with a baseball bat.
hypered1
09-28-2021, 08:46 AM
There's also an extra picture here:
https://twitter.com/IDWPublishing/status/1442620321119543300
ChosenOne
09-28-2021, 02:00 PM
I hope Hob f*cks that annoying self-righteous b*tch up.
TigerClaw
09-28-2021, 04:35 PM
Nice to see Mona Lisa getting in on the action, Also I noticed a reference to Avengers Endgame.
Ninjinister
09-28-2021, 08:47 PM
I hope Hob f*cks that annoying self-righteous b*tch up.
??????????????
bro u ok?
ChosenOne
09-28-2021, 10:01 PM
??????????????
bro u ok?
I'm not far gone enough to have any level of appreciation for this sh*tshow of a run, so the answer is clearly yes.
lonewarrior20
09-29-2021, 03:28 AM
well, i enjoyed it. hob got a whooping and mona can fight pretty good.
TigerClaw
09-29-2021, 05:26 AM
well, i enjoyed it. hob got a whooping and mona can fight pretty good.
Her tail is no joke. :tgrin:
lonewarrior20
09-29-2021, 06:15 AM
Her tail is no joke. :tgrin:
Lots of blood, fighting, hob in a cage, and I bet you their still going to complain cause it's not "my" turtles.
Ninjinister
09-29-2021, 10:45 AM
Lots of blood, fighting, hob in a cage, and I bet you their still going to complain cause it's not "my" turtles.
People are way too possessive of fiction.
Jephael
09-29-2021, 10:50 AM
People are way too possessive of fiction.
https://c.tenor.com/pyGugHcm4XcAAAAC/michael-scott-the-office.gif
Couldn't have said it better myself!!!
Andrew NDB
09-29-2021, 10:56 AM
Lots of blood, fighting, hob in a cage, and I bet you their still going to complain cause it's not "my" turtles.
People are way too possessive of fiction.
What kind of nonsense is this, now?
Jephael
09-29-2021, 11:05 AM
I mean lets face facts. Do any of us reserve the right to dictate what is and isn't acceptable? Heck, look back on all the fan fiction and RPGs that used to go around. The fan base was once chock full of people making up their own TMNT stories and a good amount of them were even set in the Mirage universe! Man what I'd give to chat with those folks again!
Zog The Magnificent
09-29-2021, 11:13 AM
I mean lets face facts. Do any of us reserve the right to dictate what is and isn't acceptable? Heck, look back on all the fan fiction and RPGs that used to go around. The fan base was once chock full of people making up their own TMNT stories and a good amount of them were even set in the Mirage universe! Man what I'd give to chat with those folks again!
We, as the consumer, absolutely have the right to determine what is acceptable or not. That's how the entire market is structured. People make stuff, and other people decide if they like it or not. It's then up to cretors to give people what they want, or risk losing money.
And comparing this run to fan fiction is not exactly a mark of high praise. Fan fiction in general is not exactly known for producing the best quality work, with a few exceptions. While fans will eventually write for franchises if they go on long enough, if the official work feels like fan fiction, and a bad one at that, then they haven't exactly done a good job. Also, and I feel like this is obvious, the IDW run isn't a fanfic. It's the offical work, and it hasn't been great for a while now. Canon shouldn't feel like it came from a fanfic.
Andrew NDB
09-29-2021, 11:17 AM
Heck, look back on all the fan fiction and RPGs that used to go around.
Let's not. 90% of it was the Turtles having a lot of sex with Mary Sue versions of the author(s)... or each other.
Jephael
09-29-2021, 11:38 AM
90% of [fan fiction] was the Turtles having a lot of sex with Mary Sue versions of the author(s)... or each other.
Yea and the other 10% were my stories about the Fred Wolf TMNT living with me in the real world :tlol:
We, as the consumer, absolutely have the right to determine what is acceptable or not. That's how the entire market is structured. People make stuff, and other people decide if they like it or not. It's then up to creators to give people what they want, or risk losing money.
And comparing this run to fan fiction is not exactly a mark of high praise. Fan fiction in general is not exactly known for producing the best quality work, with a few exceptions. While fans will eventually write for franchises if they go on long enough, if the official work feels like fan fiction, and a bad one at that, then they haven't exactly done a good job. Also, and I feel like this is obvious, the IDW run isn't a fanfic. It's the official work, and it hasn't been great for a while now. Canon shouldn't feel like it came from a fanfic.
You make some valid points, but I think one thing I keep forgetting to stress in all of this is we all have our different preferences. There are those of us who still enjoy the original 1987 cartoon series, while others consistently give the Mirage comics high praise and both sides tend to cancel each other out. I feel like I'm part of a small minority who likes almost all different iterations of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. I dunno why it's so hard to go with the multiverse route like DC and Marvel have been doing for years. I mean most comic book properties tend to end up telling a whole bunch of "What If?" stories.
TheJ-manTurtleMan
09-29-2021, 11:44 AM
I love the Mutant Town storyline, but man I hate this version of Mona Lisa.
Jephael
09-29-2021, 11:46 AM
I love the Mutant Town storyline, but man I hate this version of Mona Lisa.
I know what you mean. Why'd they have to go and make her so whiny? She was far more entertaining in the 2012 series, even if they made her into a space alien in that iteration.
ChosenOne
09-29-2021, 12:00 PM
Uh-oh, Twitter's leaking again...
Mary Sue versions of the author(s)...
These days we have Mona Lisa.
TigerClaw
09-29-2021, 03:38 PM
Lots of blood, fighting, hob in a cage, and I bet you their still going to complain cause it's not "my" turtles.
Its either that, Or they just hate women, Particularly lizard women.
TigerClaw
09-29-2021, 04:22 PM
Just finished reading the issue and thought it was great, I was surprised to see Pete coming back.Its been a long time.
Also seeing Mona Lisa kicking some ass was cool, Especially how she used her tail more then once.
ChosenOne
09-29-2021, 08:15 PM
Just finished reading too. The only points of interest in a 20-something-pages issue were Hob's mysterious associate, the exchange between Sally and Ray, and the (unintended?) comedy moment where Sally talls Pete that he's safe now in the same panel as the weasel trio notice he's a bird.
On the note of animal behavior, let's go over this again: reptiles do not have prehensile tails!
Stop making unscientific crap up just to give your author self-insert of a Mary Sue the spotlight.
I don't even know what this thing is anymore, apart from some weird furry-themed lolicon fanfiction. LMFAO at the clueless cult-like simps who think TMNT is solely about violence, blood and fighting, and not about good writing and even better characterization at the root of it all.
(And no, piling relationship upon relationship on the readers doesn't count as characterization.)
Lord Nightwalker
09-29-2021, 08:17 PM
It seemed. Well, short. ?
ChosenOne
09-29-2021, 08:18 PM
It seemed. Well, short. ?
You mean padded out with needless fight beats. This whole arc could've been told in three issues instead of a sprawling, what is it now, five?
What's the point of having Raph and Hob go at it again after we'd seen that just last issue? A need to fill up space, that's what.
CyberCubed
09-29-2021, 09:27 PM
I wonder if this was the issue Hob was originally intended to die in given Raph stabs him with the sai. So if Hob died here, they'd probably deal with heavy fallout of Raph killing him while Ray and the others would still be caged while figuring out what to do next. I prefer Hob kept alive so I'm glad that didn't happen, so we'll see where that goes.
I never really understood why Ray and Herman were so loyal to Hob, even going back to when Waltz was writing the series and did whatever he asked them to. I guess Herman views Hob as a father figure given he mutated him, and Ray just likes war violence I guess?
Pacing could have been better this issue, which is probably why it went by fast since so much of it was spent on Hob just being attacked and then running. Also anyone notice that poison frog character Jay feels like a replacement for Mondo Gecko? Given Mondo is absent since issue 100 he feels like he got effectively replaced with the blue frog character.
TigerClaw
09-29-2021, 09:40 PM
The weasels still view Hobs as a father, So I wouldn't be surprise if he manipulated them to get him out.
The next issue seems to hint at that, but you never know.
neatoman
09-30-2021, 02:16 AM
Lots of blood, fighting, hob in a cage, and I bet you their still going to complain cause it's not "my" turtles.
People are way too possessive of fiction.
https://c.tenor.com/pyGugHcm4XcAAAAC/michael-scott-the-office.gif
Couldn't have said it better myself!!!
Its either that, Or they just hate women, Particularly lizard women.
I'm not sure why any of you are willing to ignore what the actual criticisms are here, are you really so incapable of constructing a counter-argument that you have to pretend something else was said? Again, I'm not sure how many times this needs to be said, but the problem has not been been a lack of fighting or a lack of familiarity.
The problem has been been a lack of conflict in general, most issues of this run has been the characters just "hanging out" which is only recommended as single issue stories in between the conclusion of one arc and the start of another, it should not be the meat of the so-called plot because it kills the pacing. Seeing characters not really do anything of noticeable consequence is a waste of pages.
Secondly, the characters don't seem to behave all that consistently here. In general, these characters haven't been behaving according to what has been established about them, but rather according to what needs to happen in order for certain events to take place. The most noticeable example of this is how Bebop and Rocksteady behaved during the Battle of the Bands arc, in order to make that happen needed them to be arrogant enough to throw musicians off their stage to play themselves, but humble enough to admit a lack of skill at the end and leave. Even ignoring how other writers handled them, this is still pretty bad because it doesn't make any sense in context of this story alone. You should also remember that just because it's the most obvious with Bebop and Rocksteady, this writing also applies to most other characters in this run to a lesser extent, even characters created for this run.
And speaking of the characters created for this run, because they have this inept writing behind them it can somewhat hard to even understand them. Similar to Bebop and Rocksteady, Diamond went from being violent at the drop of a hat to being calm and reasonable for no clear reason, just so she could join the band. Then we have the weasels who have virtually no distinguishing traits between them, they have no clear goals or intentions either, both aspects just makes it hard to even care about them. Many of these characters seems to have been introduced purely because the writer wanted them around, not because they were going to have anything to contribute.
I will admit this issue and the last were a slight improvement because something actually seems to be happening but there are still problems here. This should have happened much earlier and from the looks of it, the writer already seems to wind it down for even more "downtime", which is just a horrible idea. The inept character writing is still clearly on display here, so why should I care about the action when the characters aren't even believable?
If you can't actually argue against any of this, then I'm just going to assume this run is a guilty pleasure for you (as in you notice the problems and still like it despite knowing it's bad), refuse to admit it and just go for strawmen and other weak arguments to shield it from criticism. Wheter you want to admit there are objective markers for a good story or not, you still have to be able to argue for your position without just dismissing what is being said.
Leo656
09-30-2021, 03:01 AM
If you can't actually argue against any of this, then I'm just going to assume this run is a guilty pleasure for you (as in you notice the problems and still like it despite knowing it's bad), refuse to admit it and just go for strawmen and other weak arguments to shield it from criticism. Wheter you want to admit there are objective markers for a good story or not, you still have to be able to argue for your position without just dismissing what is being said.
I'd put a ton of money down on most people who "like" the book basically just lying to themselves. They don't "really" like it, it's self-delusion due to emotional investment into the brand in general and the book specifically.
I kind of remember the feeling; I still watched WCW in 2000 through when they finally went out of business, and for whatever reason, at that time and in that moment I only barely recognized how terrible the stuff going on actually was. Basically, I was a fan, and I wanted them to do well, so I supported them. Not quite blindly, but... definitely more devoutly than what the product they were serving me deserved, by that point. Looking back at some of the things I smiled through my teeth at back then, and recognizing it now for what it really was all along, it's like "Jesus F'n Christ, what the f*ck was wrong with me for even defending this sh*t?" At the time, though? At the time I was outright defending sh*t like the Sting/Vampiro "Inferno" match and the KISS Demon with a straight face to people, with no irony at all, and I'm quite certain that those people must have thought I was quite insane. Those were definitely some completely wrong, flat-out f*cking terrible opinions I was pushing, back then.
So, I imagine that it's quite the same with most people Right Now with regards to this comic. Part of it is simply fear; if this comic goes away, all we have in the pipe for TMNT anytime soon (unless you buy overpriced collector's toys) is the upcoming Seth Rogen project, which promises to be lousy, and the mythical "Rise" movie which more or less ought to just be cancelled by this point since by the time it comes out most people will have entirely moved on from that failed iteration. The comic is the only thing pumping blood through the franchise's veins, right now, so for a lot of people - even though they won't admit it - their enthusiasm definitely comes from a place of, "Well if we lose this we don't have ANYTHING, so let's just force ourselves to find the good in what we have."
And maybe they do sincerely like SOME of it; however, if a "real" TMNT book were coming out instead, they'd certainly like that, too, and probably even like it more, since they're already predisposed to liking anything with a TMNT sticker on it to begin with. So it's not like they're purposely arguing against a better run coming along, they're simply choosing to defend the current run because "It's better than nothing and right now Nothing is the closest alternative."
It is pretty annoying that so many people insist on how "great" the run is despite the Very Real Problems that neatoman eloquently shines a light on, as if those things don't matter, or shouldn't - they should and They Do - but again, fanboy love is blind. Ten years from now, they'll most likely sober up and look back on the past two years and be like, "Jesus, I can't believe I ever put this stuff over so hard." Right now, they're more worried about the brand dying, so they're afraid to be honest, even with themselves. They probably do see a lot of those problems, but are more than willing to handwave them away so long as the book stays in print.
I mean, you see it in how vehemently some of them will rush to defend without actually saying anything of note about what's so "good". They'll often use terms like "refreshing change of pace" when this has been the book's status quo for almost two years, by now, so it's not That anymore; it's not a "change of pace", it IS the pace, and the pace (as neatoman points out) is mostly Neutral. A "refreshing change of pace", by this point, would be if Stuff Happened again that seemed important, or if characters stayed "on-model", behaviorally. Or sometimes they'll say, "Well, I like _____ character," when ____ character - again, as neatoman points out - generally is either out of character with previously-established behavior OR does nothing, depending. Just really flimsy reasoning as to why they "like" something. It's rare when anyone can string more than three sentences together about why run has been so "great", which is telling when any person who thinks it sucks can randomly pluck a novel's worth of grievances out of thin air without even trying.
Mark my words, if there were a good TMNT cartoon show currently airing, or a good movie upcoming that had a lot of positive hype behind it, the comic book would be getting a MUCH harsher reaction than it has been. When people have alternatives, they become a lot more critical and picky. But if you like burgers, and the only place within 100 miles that serves burgers is the place with the cook who has the leaky eye and scratches his nuts with his spatula... well, beggars can't be choosers. You'll choke it down and swear it tastes great, because the alternative is to just plain stop eating burgers altogether. And some people just plain need their fix.
Of course, you do sincerely have some people I won't bother to name who just have the absolute worst, sh*ttiest taste in absolutely everything, and so of course they sincerely love this, too. I imagine their kitchen is packed with nothing but White Claw and black licorice, and in their living room there's plastic on the furniture like some neurotic Italian family, and they've got that hideous red/orange shag carpeting from the 70s that some people's grandmothers still had all the way up through the early-90s. Wood-grain paneling on the walls; the whole place looks like someone's basement. And there's nothing but dubstep playing, 24/7.
That's the kind of person who sincerely loves this recent run of the TMNT comics. :lol: A person with a whole shelf full of Transformers movies and no discerning taste whatsoever. Someone who makes it a point to champion the absolute dirt-worst in Every Possible Thing.
Thankfully, that's actually not that many people. It's mostly the ones who lie to themselves. They're tolerable, perhaps one day even redeemable. A couple, though... yikes.
TigerClaw
09-30-2021, 05:27 AM
If you can't actually argue against any of this, then I'm just going to assume this run is a guilty pleasure for you (as in you notice the problems and still like it despite knowing it's bad), refuse to admit it and just go for strawmen and other weak arguments to shield it from criticism. Wheter you want to admit there are objective markers for a good story or not, you still have to be able to argue for your position without just dismissing what is being said.
I would have to disagree, Because this run has been great, This comic series has been around since 2011 and the direction it went was a welcome one, We don't want another rinse and repeat in regards to TMNT.
I love the fact that this comic continues to evolve with the characters, If you don't like it, You could always read something more to your liking, Even though it will have same cliches.
Jephael
09-30-2021, 08:11 AM
Okay, I'll be honest here. Yes it is a guilty pleasure to me, and yes they could do better with the current plot. There was a moment in the last issue with Raphael and Old Hob duking it out and I was like "Oh just kill off the one-eyed flea bag already!" and of course that didn't happen. I never liked Old Hob being leader of the Mutanimals and I really hope we see Kitty Pryde take over that group. Bebop and Rocksteady's forfeit was certainly out of left field, but hey maybe it's a sign they're beginning to grow a conscience. I dunno if you guys have been following along with the conversation here, but those of us who still like reading this series still have our nitpicks. Mona Lisa is so not what I was expecting. She's not the sweet, flirty, intelligent college girl turned mutant lizard from that 1990 episode of the original cartoon and it kinda bummed me out.
But hey them's the breaks. We're not the people working on this comic book, IDW is! They're the ones calling the shots, not us. They're the ones who dictate what gets to happen. We're just a bunch of fan-boys on a message board shooting the sh*t about it like how sports fans nitpick over a football game hundreds of miles away from their little frat house in College City, USA!
Dangv
09-30-2021, 10:23 AM
Think about it this way.. In the last 10 or so issues (let's say the last year) what happened to the Ninja Turtles in this Ninja Turtles comic book?
Raph - Motorcycle race, fight with Hob.
Mikey - Got poisoned, started a podcast :roll:
Leo - ?
Don - ?
We're talking a year of releases where absolutely nothing of importance happened to the main characters. It was all about a band, future pink turtle, angry confused Jennika, angry confused Mona, mayor Sally...
This is all fine for one issue, maybe two if it leads to something, but nothing ever leads to anything anymore.
Not the motorcycle race, they just stopped and decided to be friends.
The fight with Tokka and Rahzar, they just stopped and decided to settle it with a battle of the bands.
The battle of the bands, they just stopped because they decided to give up before it even started.
There is no point to these stories. It's all fluff writing and filler stories. They should've used the majority of these stories for the Jennika comic or something because it has little to do with the turtles at this point.
Also:
https://i.imgur.com/GIrpqwX.png
:???:
https://64.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mdo0gf8BYW1r2sxh6o1_500.gif
mrmaczaps
09-30-2021, 11:18 AM
Still boring as all hell. This entire 20/21 issue arc could have been told in 6 issues, tops. Can we just reboot the Ongoing or retcon this furries porn already?
oldmanwinters
09-30-2021, 01:03 PM
Also:
https://i.imgur.com/GIrpqwX.png
:???:
https://64.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mdo0gf8BYW1r2sxh6o1_500.gif
That's a little creepy. I'm not sure I've ever seen that effect in a comic book before. If it was a video game glitch, people would be mocking it online.
ChosenOne
09-30-2021, 01:39 PM
Imagine knowing you're just keeping the actual writer of the comic's seat warm while he wraps up other projects, knowing you're not allowed to write anything that actually impacts the longterm status quo in any way, knowing that you have free rein to deliberately fill up your run with whatever weirdness you deem "normal" even though it has nothing to do with the comic's premise, and then going online and seeing random weirdos defending your - ahem - "work" to their very last breath, even though some of them only came on board with #101 and the promise of furries... Beyond surreal at this point.
Dangv
09-30-2021, 02:44 PM
That's a little creepy. I'm not sure I've ever seen that effect in a comic book before. If it was a video game glitch, people would be mocking it online.
It's just lazy. Takes 5 seconds to correct in Paint.
https://i.imgur.com/fJfTHIS.png
Leo656
09-30-2021, 03:15 PM
I would have to disagree, Because this run has been great, This comic series has been around since 2011 and the direction it went was a welcome one, We don't want another rinse and repeat in regards to TMNT.
It's been around since 2011 and yet people who follow your posts closely have repeatedly pointed out that you never gave it the time of day UNTIL it became Zootopia Fanfiction.
So your defense rings entirely hollow and false. You only think it's "great" because Furrlough and Genus aren't in print anymore and this is the closest thing going. If the comic ever gets away from furries playing kissy-face and back to actual TMNT stuff, you'll probably abandon it again.
I got news for ya, pal; Sally Pride ain't gonna be whipping her tits out in this book anytime soon and there also aren't gonna be any explicit Donnie/Mona sex scenes, so if you're holding onto that hope you can go ahead and give it up.
The best thing anyone can honestly say about this run is that it's been "mostly harmless". There's definitely worse comic books out there in general. But it's still been a colossal waste of time.
TigerClaw
09-30-2021, 04:50 PM
Saw Sophie Campbell link to this article that talks about her work on the TMNT comic, Its a good read.
https://www.tcj.com/metamorphosis-the-comics-of-sophie-campbell/
Bahamut810
09-30-2021, 05:57 PM
I think that the big difference here is the writing style. In manga you have two large genres, Shonen and Shoujo. Shonen is much more action oriented, filled with comradery and more 'male' oriented themes (while all the main characters are badass). This is your Bleach, Naruto, My Hero Academia and Demon Slayer. Shoujo is much more emotion and relationship oriented, filled with emotion and relationships and even that ever elusive doki doki (I think the best description would be a moment where your heart flutters) and more 'female' oriented themes.
TMNT until 100- was Shonen. 100%. You had fights, betrayals and huge stakes as they fought for their place in the world.
Looking at Ms. Campbells history and what I have seen of the post 100 run, she is much more apt to write Shoujo. It seems like she is really good at it. I wont lie, if this run we are talking about was a different shoujo series? I would probably like it better. However, her scripts are very much not that shonen that we all were attracted to and desire.
ChosenOne
09-30-2021, 06:57 PM
I think that the big difference here is the writing style. In manga you have two large genres, Shonen and Shoujo. Shonen is much more action oriented, filled with comradery and more 'male' oriented themes (while all the main characters are badass). This is your Bleach, Naruto, My Hero Academia and Demon Slayer. Shoujo is much more emotion and relationship oriented, filled with emotion and relationships and even that ever elusive doki doki (I think the best description would be a moment where your heart flutters) and more 'female' oriented themes.
TMNT until 100- was Shonen. 100%. You had fights, betrayals and huge stakes as they fought for their place in the world.
Looking at Ms. Campbells history and what I have seen of the post 100 run, she is much more apt to write Shoujo. It seems like she is really good at it. I wont lie, if this run we are talking about was a different shoujo series? I would probably like it better. However, her scripts are very much not that shonen that we all were attracted to and desire.
Sorry, but while you're technically right regarding her inclinations, I don't think that's it. At least not for me personally. I loved and still love Sailor Moon, which is firmly shojo, just as much as I loved and still love Dragon Ball, the most famous shonen manga/anime ever. And I don't think Campbell could write Sailor Moon either. She has no grasp of conflict, by which I mean the drive behind a story and not punch-kick-punch conflict, making her ideal for slice-of-life, one-off stuff but not for a longform run like this and especially not a longform run of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
Bahamut810
09-30-2021, 10:29 PM
Sorry, but while you're technically right regarding her inclinations, I don't think that's it. At least not for me personally. I loved and still love Sailor Moon, which is firmly shojo, just as much as I loved and still love Dragon Ball, the most famous shonen manga/anime ever. And I don't think Campbell could write Sailor Moon either. She has no grasp of conflict, by which I mean the drive behind a story and not punch-kick-punch conflict, making her ideal for slice-of-life, one-off stuff but not for a longform run like this and especially not a longform run of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
Im basing my faith in her agility to write 'shoujo' on the good things I read about her Jem run, compared to what I have seen so far from her later TMNT comics. I don't think she has the mindset to write Sailor Moon or Magic Knights Reyearth (more action oriented), but I feel that she could write stories more akin to Ouren Host Club (old school), Fruits basket or Komi cant Communicate (new school) with some skill based on that. The most important thing about this though is that the target audience is EXTREMELY DIFFERENT then almost any shonen.
neatoman
10-01-2021, 01:30 AM
Yeah no, sorry. This isn't matter of genre, just quality. If you don't want to write action you still have to write some kind of a conflict and write the characters with some consistency, for example you can have a love triangle and explore how the characters react to jealousy. Any story needs to have intrigue and be believable in some way, this run has failed at both.
Andrew NDB
10-01-2021, 02:10 AM
I suspect there is a portion of people out there reading comments like these and going, "Nice! Exactly the right people are getting angered by this! This is a win!" and this kind of discourse being some kind of a "hah! The desired effect... achieved!" If that makes sense. Well, I hope nobody is saying or thinking this that I respect, but what can you do.
But I have no idea. And I'm not angered. I respect IDW TMNT as I do any of the universes that have persevered. I'm not, like, debating with anyone about why can't Rise of the TMNT be closer to what I'd be into... because why would I? In the case of IDW they wouldn't be on issue #121 if people weren't buying it and into it.
hypered1
10-01-2021, 07:59 AM
Bahamut810 does have the right idea though and it's kind of sad that people here just can't seem to accept or understand that they aren't the target audience anymore and that's nothing to do with Sophie's writing style; her writing is following what she's being dictated to write by the shot callers at Nick/Viacom - not being able to do more to Hob or even kill him off is proof of this: his eyepatch being knocked off was a subtle tease to whether Raph would take out his good eye, but turn the page and Raph just stabs him through the shoulder.
We know Sophie wanted to do more - she has said as much herself.
Long story short IDW/ Nick aren't making this comic for you guys they're making it for a very different audience, an audience who are enjoying it and want more of it.
Andrew NDB
10-01-2021, 10:44 AM
her writing is following what she's being dictated to write by the shot callers at Nick/Viacom - not being able to do more to Hob or even kill him off is proof of this
I can't fathom how being told she couldn't do something is proof that she is being told exactly what to write. Admittedly, though, there are a lot of "funny things" that have been going on with IDW TMNT in the past couple of years. Enough to make me wonder what's going on there and if Nick/Viacom is, in fact, meddling in ways they never did pre-#100s.
Also, the last time this came up absolutely nobody could offer up any shred of evidence that it was anyone at Nick/Viacom who told Sophie "no" about Hob being killed and not, say, just Bobbie in editorial on the ground level.
hypered1
10-01-2021, 11:07 AM
I can't fathom how being told she couldn't do something is proof that she is being told exactly what to write. Admittedly, though, there are a lot of "funny things" that have been going on with IDW TMNT in the past couple of years. Enough to make me wonder what's going on there and if Nick/Viacom is, in fact, meddling in ways they never did pre-#100s.
Also, the last time this came up absolutely nobody could offer up any shred of evidence that it was anyone at Nick/Viacom who told Sophie "no" about Hob being killed and not, say, just Bobbie in editorial on the ground level.
Admittedly we have only Sophie's word on this so far, but I don't see what would be gained by anyone if it wasn't true and at any rate it doesn't change the fact that the target audience has changed and people need to learn to accept that which they have no control over - no amount of whining or complaining from a small corner of the internet ever changes anything.
Zog The Magnificent
10-01-2021, 11:20 AM
Bahamut810 does have the right idea though and it's kind of sad that people here just can't seem to accept or understand that they aren't the target audience anymore and that's nothing to do with Sophie's writing style; her writing is following what she's being dictated to write by the shot callers at Nick/Viacom - not being able to do more to Hob or even kill him off is proof of this: his eyepatch being knocked off was a subtle tease to whether Raph would take out his good eye, but turn the page and Raph just stabs him through the shoulder.
We know Sophie wanted to do more - she has said as much herself.
Long story short IDW/ Nick aren't making this comic for you guys they're making it for a very different audience, an audience who are enjoying it and want more of it.
This is not an argument and people need to stop using it. The target audience for TMNT has not changed. The writing for this comic has. It would be one thing if this was an entirely different series- a slice of life manga, perhaps. One where there was no expectation that it would cater to our interests. But this is a pre-existing property that appeals to a specific demographic. They don't get to just come in and change the target audience, and then say "it's not for you." I'm sick of hearing this sentiment be used to hijack series after series. It is for us, and if their writing no longer appeals to the people it's for, then it's just bad writing. There are certain expectations of what TMNT is, and right now, IDW's TMNT is not meeting them, and is therefore doing a bad job at being a TMNT comic.
mrmaczaps
10-01-2021, 11:31 AM
This is not an argument and people need to stop using it. The target audience for TMNT has not changed. The writing for this comic has. It would be one thing if this was an entirely different series- a slice of life manga, perhaps. One where there was no expectation that it would cater to our interests. But this is a pre-existing property that appeals to a specific demographic. They don't get to just come in and change the target audience, and then say "it's not for you." I'm sick of hearing this sentiment be used to hijack series after series. It is for us, and if their writing no longer appeals to the people it's for, then it's just bad writing. There are certain expectations of what TMNT is, and right now, IDW's TMNT is not meeting them, and is therefore doing a bad job at being a TMNT comic.
Fvcking this all day. Right there.
Andrew NDB
10-01-2021, 11:47 AM
Admittedly we have only Sophie's word on this
In which nowhere did she say "Nick/Viacom told me no" but just a "I was told no." By who? By Nick/Viacom and not, say, the editor of the book? Why would we jump to automatically assume it's Nick/Viacom? I mean, it might be, though Nick/Viacom really don't have any stakes in Old Hob. It's far more likely it would just be Bobby saying no, given his and Tom's invested interest in the character.
This is not an argument and people need to stop using it. The target audience for TMNT has not changed. The writing for this comic has. It would be one thing if this was an entirely different series- a slice of life manga, perhaps.
Maybe. I'm looking at the posts debating about which kind of "ouren" or "shooju" manga style the book is trying to approximate and I'm kind of mentally going, "Eh. Who gives a sh** about this? It just needs to be good and tell a good story with rounded characters with character arcs" at the end of the day, not being beholden to one made up manga style over another.
hypered1
10-01-2021, 11:54 AM
This is not an argument and people need to stop using it. The target audience for TMNT has not changed. The writing for this comic has. It would be one thing if this was an entirely different series- a slice of life manga, perhaps. One where there was no expectation that it would cater to our interests. But this is a pre-existing property that appeals to a specific demographic. They don't get to just come in and change the target audience, and then say "it's not for you." I'm sick of hearing this sentiment be used to hijack series after series. It is for us, and if their writing no longer appeals to the people it's for, then it's just bad writing. There are certain expectations of what TMNT is, and right now, IDW's TMNT is not meeting them, and is therefore doing a bad job at being a TMNT comic.
Last I checked it's not up to you or anyone else on here to decide who the target audience are, but thank you for magnificently proving my point.
Zog The Magnificent
10-01-2021, 11:58 AM
Maybe. I'm looking at the posts debating about which kind of "ouren" or "shooju" manga style the book is trying to approximate and I'm kind of mentally going, "Eh. Who gives a sh** about this? It just needs to be good and tell a good story with rounded characters with character arcs" at the end of the day, not being beholden to one made up manga style over another.
I wasn't meaning that in terms of thinking that the writing is trying to emulate any specific kind of manga. I was just using that as an example of a different type of story that had different kinds of expectations as to what it would be, in contrast to TMNT which comes with expectations by virtue of what it is, and how they currently aren't being met. Slife of life manga was just the first thing I thought of, since it's usually on the complete opposite side of the storytelling spectrum compared to TMNT.
Zog The Magnificent
10-01-2021, 12:00 PM
Last I checked it's not up to you or anyone else on here to decide who the target audience are, but thank you for magnificently proving my point.
Ah yes, the old "Ha, you've proved my point!" argument, wherein you make no counterargument and then declare that you've won. Brilliant strategy.
And I didn't decide the target audience. Eastman and Laird did when they created the property. If you fall outside of even the most basic parameters of TMNT, then you're just doing a bad job.
Andrew NDB
10-01-2021, 12:03 PM
Last I checked it's not up to you or anyone else on here to decide who the target audience are, but thank you for magnificently proving my point.
Whatever that means. Though while we can debate the quality of the writing and all of that in matters of taste... you DO notice that the goal posts have moved, right? I mean, I haven't read the book for several years now (because long ago I did what you suggest when I figured out pretty early on I wasn't the target audience) but I can plainly see it is a radically different book from what it was in #1, or even #20. People that liked those early issues, there's a high likelihood they wouldn't be on board with what things are now, or even vice versa.
hypered1
10-01-2021, 12:21 PM
And I didn't decide the target audience. Eastman and Laird did when they created the property.
And now it's Nick/ Viacom's decision who the target audience is; this isn't still 1984 and most people are very different these days.
Whatever that means. Though while we can debate the quality of the writing and all of that in matters of taste... you DO notice that the goal posts have moved, right? I mean, I haven't read the book for several years now (because long ago I did what you suggest when I figured out pretty early on I wasn't the target audience) but I can plainly see it is a radically different book from what it was in #1, or even #20. People that liked those early issues, there's a high likelihood they wouldn't be on board with what things are now, or even vice versa.
And that's exactly my point. Does anyone here really think that if the powers that be were concerned with the opinions of the members of this forum that they would allow the current run to continue as it has? Of course they wouldn't. They aren't concerned because middle-aged white dudes aren't the demographic they're aiming for anymore, they want younger fans who are open to lgbtq ideals and that is their choice.
I'm sorry if it upsets anyone but that's the truth.
lonewarrior20
10-01-2021, 12:26 PM
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-becomes-teenage-mutant-punk-frogs-in-2022-tmnt-idw/
looks like we're getting the punk frogs in a few issue's, so can we please stop with the damn pissing contest? yes, some people hate the current run and some of us like it, lets leave it at that. i mean my god, we just keep arguing in a circle of madness, myself included. i mean look at us, the turtles have more humanity, honor, and discipline than us and they're fiction.
ChosenOne
10-01-2021, 01:07 PM
"Muh target audience has changed!", which is why I suppose The Armaggedon Game is brewing in the background of Campbell's entire inconsequential fanfic run - which will likely be undone or ignored as soon as she's done anyway - while she spins her wheels and keeps Waltz's seat warm... :roll::lol:
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-becomes-teenage-mutant-punk-frogs-in-2022-tmnt-idw/
looks like we're getting the punk frogs in a few issue's
Knowing Campbell, watch them be mutant West African frogs.
Zog The Magnificent
10-01-2021, 01:47 PM
"Muh target audience has changed!", which is why I suppose The Armaggedon Game is brewing in the background of Campbell's entire inconsequential fanfic run - which will likely be undone or ignored as soon as she's done anyway - while she spins her wheels and keeps Waltz's seat warm... :roll::lol:
Knowing Campbell, watch them be mutant West African frogs.
I love how, after all the complaints about how the TMNT feel like guest stars in their own book, that now they don't even get the cover title. It's poetic, really.
ChosenOne
10-01-2021, 01:53 PM
I love how, after all the complaints about how the TMNT feel like guest stars in their own book, that now they don't even get the cover title. It's poetic, really.
Mind you, this could have been an intriguing and even exciting gimmick. But definitely not so under current circumstances, however.
Andrew NDB
10-01-2021, 01:57 PM
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-becomes-teenage-mutant-punk-frogs-in-2022-tmnt-idw/
looks like we're getting the punk frogs in a few issue's, so can we please stop with the damn pissing contest?
https://c.tenor.com/dUzOqaxWGfwAAAAd/what-does-that-have-to-do-with-anything-coach-ben-hopkins.gif
Leo656
10-01-2021, 02:41 PM
they want younger fans who are open to lgbtq ideals and that is their choice.
Never mind, of course, that those "ideals" have f*ck-all nothing to do with TMNT and shouldn't have become the book's entire raison d'etre. Or that bending over for the Tumblristas and Twitter Twats is generally a sign of a failing brand desperate for relevance.
There's nothing wrong with exploring LGBTQ characters and themes. Most people here support that stuff, at least to some degree. What they don't like is that they went to bed one day and when they woke up, a book abut the TMNT was suddenly 110% about a bunch of self-insert OCs making kissy-face and talking about protests and government overreach and a bunch of hyper-political stuff that most of the TMNT audience doesn't want to read about. And that there was hardly any transition at all, on top of it.
A book called "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" should ostensibly focus on them, and this book doesn't. They barely factor into anything anymore. People are RIGHT to be annoyed about that.
But nah, they're just a bunch of misguided old people, sure. Not at all that they feel like they wasted their time, money, and emotional investment on what's become a massive bait-and-switch that doesn't even follow through on the resolution of its own plotlines.
Here's an idea to see just how many people give a sh*t about this Zootopia Fanfic sh*t: Switch the title of the book to something more honest, like "Adventures in Mutant Town - Guest-Starring the TMNT", and see if it goes six months without being cancelled. I don't think it would.
As for "trying to reach a new audience", if they're trying to make money then catering to a vocal minority of people who don't even buy comics UNLESS said comics are all about a bunch of Mary-Sues and their same-sex adventures... probably isn't the safest horse to back. They'd probably make more money catering to the 20,000+ people who all dropped the book post-100, rather than hitch their wagon to the sub-10,000 who stick around due to Battered Wives' Syndrome.
Basically, if they don't feel like the existing fanbase is still their priority... they should. You can't trade SJW Brownie Points for currency, and ignoring your existing audience to try and create a brand new one never, ever, ever works. They're NEVER going to replace all the people who stopped buying the book post-100, it's just not gonna happen.
Metaphorically-speaking, they gave up the chance to play stadiums because they'd rather make nickels playing to people in tiny dives. Not a good business strategy.
hypered1
10-01-2021, 02:57 PM
They'd probably make more money catering to the 20,000+ people who all dropped the book post-100, rather than hitch their wagon to the sub-10,000 who stick around due to Battered Wives' Syndrome.
Once again throwing around imaginary numbers without providing any kind of proof and yet...
28% increase in revenue for Q2 2021
https://idwmediaholdings.com/idw-reports-second-quarter-fiscal-2021-results/
and 19,294 sales for #119 in July
https://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2021/2021-07Diamond.html
https://i.imgur.com/mqEwfah.png
Actual proof that the comic is doing just fine right now.
Leo656
10-01-2021, 03:13 PM
"Numbers that would get any book cancelled by a real publisher" = "Fine". :lol: A'ight.
Thank goodness that IDW has such a low bar for "success".
And they're actually back to posting sales numbers again? Interesting. I'd love to know what the numbers were for all those months where said info was "unavailable". Far lower, I'd wager.
But yeah sub-20,000 is still awful, sorry. Those are not good numbers for a brand that's so ingrained in pop culture.
I'm more inclined to listen to the many comic shop owners who say they cancelled all their orders because the book doesn't sell to their customer base, to be honest. That paints a much more vivid picture about what's really going on. Companies always over-inflate their "success" but when you talk to shop owners, you find out what's actually going on. Which is why so many "successful" books get cancelled in short order. It's always the same thing; Marvel or whoever will come out trumpeting their latest SJW romp as a "success", while shop owners say out loud "Nobody buys the damn things". Then they get cancelled. And the shop owners are like "I told ya, nobody was buying it."
Either way, a comic that routinely sells under 20,000 copies isn't kept alive through popularity; it's pity.
We should be asking why such a "popular" franchise doesn't move more units. Millions of people self-identify as "TMNT Fans" and yet none of them buys this book.
That's not a situation where things are "doing fine". Nope. And rather than actually trying to get more people to buy it, they either make excuses or just go "We don't need those people, anyway"? Wow. That's awful!
Hayesbass
10-01-2021, 04:06 PM
Sales have increased steadily at my shop. Most of the adds are from younger readers but we also have a lot more younger readers checking out Turtles in general which I attribute to Last Ronin.
I know that doesn't fit the "TMNT is failing" narrative but it's the reality.
mrmaczaps
10-01-2021, 06:19 PM
My LCS is now only getting 4 copies of the Ongoing series... and they always end up damaged somehow... missed the last B cover again.
CyberCubed
10-01-2021, 06:39 PM
To be fair, IDW TMNT has always done regularly below 20,000 sales most of the time. If you go further back looking from issues 50-100, they always hovered between 16,000-19,000 in sales if I remember right for the main ongoing. I used to check comicchron every month to see how it was doing.
Outside of milestone issues like #1, #50, and #100 which have obvious huge sales bumps for obvious reasons, the issues always sunk back to pre-20,000 copies most of the time. I have no idea if those sales for Sophie's run are accurate, but that was the case under Waltz run.
Leo656
10-01-2021, 06:56 PM
Rather than settling for less and saying "It is what it is," anyone interested in growing their business would be asking questions like, "How do we double that audience, and furthermore, keep them invested long-term?"
If let's say one million people all bought the box set of the FW TMNT cartoon, for example, but only 20,000 or less of those same people are inclined to read a comic book about some of their "favorite" characters, we should be asking "Why not?" and not settling for excuses about how "Nobody reads anymore anyway" or whatever. The goal should be to somehow get the book into the hands of every single self-identified "TMNT Fan". And if they're refusing to read it, we ought to be figuring out Why and then addressing that.
Sales was a big part of my last job. And there was no such thing as "Good Enough is Good Enough." Every time we'd hit a quota, the topic of the next meeting wasn't about ass-pats and "Good enough, guys," it was about "How do we grow these numbers next month? How do we turn X sales per week into Y sales per week?" And rest assured, whenever numbers dropped by ANY percentage whatsoever, it was treated as a Crisis Event and discussed in terms of, "How do we replace those losses, and furthermore, prevent something like that from happening again?" There was no settling, because when you're trying to actually make money "settling" is officially Loser Talk.
20,000 a month on a comic is a pitiful number for something as recognized as this franchise is. And if they're seriously not having discussions on the regular about "How do we turn 20,000 into 40,000 and keep it there?" then they don't actually deserve to be successful. There ARE more than 40,000 people a month buying comic books, and way more than 40,000 people in the U.S. who'd say they were TMNT fans. Obviously, those people's needs simply aren't being met.
"It's fine because this book's numbers have always sucked anyway" would not be an acceptable response at any "real" company. Like you'd literally get fired for talking like that at anyplace I've ever worked at. Unless, again, your bar for "success" is so incredibly low that you're happy to have anything.
I mean, it's whatever, it's not my circus. But people obviously aren't looking at the Big Picture with regard to some of this stuff, and they're not asking the right questions, either. Obviously settling for less is plenty good enough for some folks, but that's a highly questionable position to take from a dollars-and-cents point of view.
Jephael
10-01-2021, 09:51 PM
I respect IDW TMNT as I do any of the universes that have persevered. I'm not, like, debating with anyone about why can't Rise of the TMNT be closer to what I'd be into... because why would I? In the case of IDW they wouldn't be on issue #121 if people weren't buying it and into it.
I always find it interesting how you and I are kind of like two sides of the same coin as I have a strong love for the Archie comics, which I grew up reading them throughout the course of my childhood, and while IDW has utilized all of my favorite secondary characters from that run, I have been somewhat disappointed with the direction they took with them. For me, IDW's Mutanimals is to me what the 4Kids TMNT from 2003 is to you.
Sumac
10-02-2021, 03:21 AM
And that's exactly my point. Does anyone here really think that if the powers that be were concerned with the opinions of the members of this forum that they would allow the current run to continue as it has? Of course they wouldn't. They aren't concerned because middle-aged white dudes aren't the demographic they're aiming for anymore, they want younger fans who are open to lgbtq ideals and that is their choice.
That is a stupid choice, because, TMNT already can be, arguably, seen as pro-diversity book, which doesn't really additional LGBBBQ+ stuff and, because, I doubt anyone will care about it, even if all characters in it become Gay trilinear Xirs.
I understand that zoomers are generally very infantile and stupid and can't understand metaphors or contexts. Thus they NEED to be fed story in the most direct and simple way possible, but it doesn't mean that story and characters (which are not that complex in the first place) should be dumbed down, because, some people in potential audience have no abstract or critical thinking skills.
Also, if their intention was to attract new audience, IDW had failed big time. Though its typical for most of the old franchises resurrected with the idea of making them more "diverse": most of them end pissing OG fans without attracting any new ones.
And all those Twatter activists do not count as an audience, because, majority of them are just virtue signaling without buying stuff, they so want to see "divertisified".
Andrew NDB
10-02-2021, 03:29 AM
I always find it interesting how you and I are kind of like two sides of the same coin as I have a strong love for the Archie comics, which I grew up reading them throughout the course of my childhood, and while IDW has utilized all of my favorite secondary characters from that run, I have been somewhat disappointed with the direction they took with them. For me, IDW's Mutanimals is to me what the 4Kids TMNT from 2003 is to you.
That makes a lot of sense. I think that's fair of you to say.
frank_one
10-02-2021, 05:06 AM
20k are still good numbers. This proves there IS an audience for whatever is going on in the current arc.
Andrew NDB
10-02-2021, 06:12 AM
20k are still good numbers. This proves there IS an audience for whatever is going on in the current arc.
In all fairness yes. If those numbers are right then they've absolutely proven that. And that's cool. I'd never begrudge people finding success in what they enjoy ever. When I stopped reading IDW it was even way before the current direction and I didn't bemoan anything... it wasn't for me! And that was fine. Most TMNT stuff since forever beyond the source material hasn't been. I might make a case for why they should try to attempt a certain way but... these are different times and TMNT is a corporate thing now. Has been for a great while now. Any actual meaningful pleas should have happened a decade ago, not now that it's a decade too late.
Look at it this way: the Vol. 4 lettercol people finally won. Everyone complaining in it to Laird. Be happy. It took a while but you won. At least there has been a good effort for collected editions of old stuff and a fantastic support of the Image Vol. 3. I never expected that but we got it.
AquaParade
10-02-2021, 07:26 AM
1. I mostly agree with what Leo is saying about the sales numbers. The property has potential for higher numbers. The Last Ronin proves that. When you do the tmnt right, people will come, as we are seeing now. I imagine some of that success has rubbed off on the ongoing.
2. I don’t think it’s relevant to the ongoing debate around here as to whether IDW has been letting numbers tank, just to push Jennika.
As Cybercubed said, the book has never done top Marvel or DC numbers, despite being IDW’s top book for years. We all pretty much understood that, but lately all talk regarding sales has been whether or not IDW is covering them up, because they are tanking. These sales seem refute that.
You know, unless there was an actual dip which sprang back up quite quick, again, due to TLR hype, which is possible to an extent. Even that wouldn’t really support the previous narrative, however.
It will be interesting to see where IDW goes from here. Now that they have tasted five issues of what, like 200k+ copies sold (More? Issue one is on its fourth printing, as of now), there is no way they can willingly go back to the way things were before TLR.
So what will it be? Talent change up on the main book? We’ll definitely be seeing more books from The Last Ronin series. Let’s see how long they can keep it up.
MikeandRaph87
10-02-2021, 07:50 AM
How in the world is this book doing 19.89k? I would have sworn half of that. Everyone including myself dropped the book at my LCS. The Last Ronin had a dozen sales. The audience has been turned away, nothing is happening. Where is the creative team change we were to expect?
AquaParade
10-02-2021, 09:29 AM
The ongoing probably costs less to produce without Tom and Kevin, so I imagine IDW are making okay money from it, in comparison to before.
In regards to TMNT, this last year, IDW are in the best shape they've ever been. The ongoing is going steady, with cheaper production costs, while the side book is leading industry sales at twice the cost of most books.
I find it very hard to criticize them right now, unless you're just personally upset over the direction of the ongoing, which, to be frank, isn't really their problem when sales are steady and production costs are down.
The issue will be whether they can maintain TLR sales or at least ride the momentum into more books with high sales. I expect a TLR spin-off announcement not long after issue #5 wraps, if not before then.
CyberCubed
10-02-2021, 10:12 AM
How in the world is this book doing 19.89k? I would have sworn half of that. Everyone including myself dropped the book at my LCS. The Last Ronin had a dozen sales. The audience has been turned away, nothing is happening. Where is the creative team change we were to expect?
If those numbers are accurate, then it most likely did pick up a new audience who came on board post-issue 100 and they replaced the older fans who had been following it from the beginning.
So the loss of older fans was countered by new people jumping in. People who like comics about a bunch of animals (and I imagine some of these people weren't actually TMNT fans prior), and jumped on board for this reason.
Sumac
10-02-2021, 11:13 AM
I'd like to imagine what will happen when / if TMNT will return back to its roots.
What those furries will do?
lonewarrior20
10-02-2021, 11:26 AM
I'd like to imagine what will happen when / if TMNT will return back to its roots.
What those furries will do?
Still enjoy the series.
neatoman
10-02-2021, 11:52 AM
20k are still good numbers. This proves there IS an audience for whatever is going on in the current arc.
Sales have increased steadily at my shop. Most of the adds are from younger readers but we also have a lot more younger readers checking out Turtles in general which I attribute to Last Ronin.
I know that doesn't fit the "TMNT is failing" narrative but it's the reality.
Having an audience and said audience actually liking the comic are not really the same thing. It should be said that the Clone Saga is generally considered the absolute worst Spider-Man storyline ever and the reason it kept going for as long as it did is because people kept buying the book. And why did they keep buying the book you ask? Probably the same reason the Lion King Remake, The Last Jedi, the Beauty and the Beast Remake and Iron Man 3 are in the top 20 highest grossing movies despite being largely hated.
ChosenOne
10-02-2021, 12:39 PM
I'd like to imagine what will happen when / if TMNT will return back to its roots.
What those furries will do?
Go back to the hole they were in before #101, hopefully. At this point, it'll be a welcome bonus to see the last of them.
TigerClaw
10-02-2021, 01:02 PM
Go back to the hole they were in before #101, hopefully. At this point, it'll be a welcome bonus to see the last of them.
TMNT is furry adjacent, They aren't going anywhere.
Mutant Ninja Anole
10-02-2021, 01:06 PM
Seems like a lot of quick goalpost moving from the negative side here. We went from sales are so bad the comic is going to be canceled to saying they should be going for twice what it was doing under Waltz.
Which is odd for me to say because frankly, I’m not too high on the storyline, mostly for missed opportunities and finding the dialogue awkward. Nevertheless, I don’t think I’d rate it as much worse than say, the Tricerton invasion arc. Good points but weirdly anti-climactic and small scale and why are street gangs and ninjas with weapons from Japan’s Edo period so much better at fighting the alien dinosaurs than the government with sci fi tech? So I’m in this weird state of thinking this storyline is in the lower end of the IDW line arcs but…guys I’ve read so many worse comics.
I missed on commenting for a few issues but just to catch up on things:
I confess 3rd grader me jumped up at seeing the Gharial (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gharial?wprov=sfti1) mutant in 119. Broadly speaking I actually like this direction more than the last arc simply because this is Hob getting what he really should have had earlier, but I’ve already gone on about that so, there’s that. I understand the idea behind making Man Ray the bad guy one that pushes things to violence but Hob had already rushed past several moral horizons that I’m not sure we can buy him as less than a villain. At this point I think it’d be best if he either turned himself in or left town. He already accomplished the goal of creating a viable Mutant population and Mutant society that wasn’t beholden to Stockman or Null so, on some level I feel like he can say he ‘won’ no matter what happens to him.
Not a fan of Casey’s treatment in his scene with Raph, but I do like having a pay off for the Turtles training Mutant civilians. Going forward I’m not sure what I want to see. While I’ve never wanted Mutant Town to ‘go away’ or its citizens cured, but I do think you can take down the wall and let the Turtles have stories elsewhere. You can always revisit Mutant Town and have new stories at another time.
TigerClaw
10-02-2021, 02:34 PM
Seems like a lot of quick goalpost moving from the negative side here. We went from sales are so bad the comic is going to be canceled to saying they should be going for twice what it was doing under Waltz.
Which is odd for me to say because frankly, I’m not too high on the storyline, mostly for missed opportunities and finding the dialogue awkward. Nevertheless, I don’t think I’d rate it as much worse than say, the Tricerton invasion arc. Good points but weirdly anti-climactic and small scale and why are street gangs and ninjas with weapons from Japan’s Edo period so much better at fighting the alien dinosaurs than the government with sci fi tech? So I’m in this weird state of thinking this storyline is in the lower end of the IDW line arcs but…guys I’ve read so many worse comics.
I missed on commenting for a few issues but just to catch up on things:
I confess 3rd grader me jumped up at seeing the Gharial (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gharial?wprov=sfti1) mutant in 119. Broadly speaking I actually like this direction more than the last arc simply because this is Hob getting what he really should have had earlier, but I’ve already gone on about that so, there’s that. I understand the idea behind making Man Ray the bad guy one that pushes things to violence but Hob had already rushed past several moral horizons that I’m not sure we can buy him as less than a villain. At this point I think it’d be best if he either turned himself in or left town. He already accomplished the goal of creating a viable Mutant population and Mutant society that wasn’t beholden to Stockman or Null so, on some level I feel like he can say he ‘won’ no matter what happens to him.
Not a fan of Casey’s treatment in his scene with Raph, but I do like having a pay off for the Turtles training Mutant civilians. Going forward I’m not sure what I want to see. While I’ve never wanted Mutant Town to ‘go away’ or its citizens cured, but I do think you can take down the wall and let the Turtles have stories elsewhere. You can always revisit Mutant Town and have new stories at another time.
Mutant Town is only the beginning, As hinted from Future Lita, Its quite possible there future could be a New York that is all mutants, This universe hasn't come up with some kind of retromutagen like past incarnations have.
neatoman
10-02-2021, 02:58 PM
This universe hasn't come up with some kind of retromutagen like past incarnations have.
Unless you count pumping the mutagen out of the system or reversing time.
Bahamut810
10-02-2021, 04:25 PM
Which is odd for me to say because frankly, I’m not too high on the storyline, mostly for missed opportunities and finding the dialogue awkward. Nevertheless, I don’t think I’d rate it as much worse than say, the Tricerton invasion arc. Good points but weirdly anti-climactic and small scale and why are street gangs and ninjas with weapons from Japan’s Edo period so much better at fighting the alien dinosaurs than the government with sci fi tech? So I’m in this weird state of thinking this storyline is in the lower end of the IDW line arcs but…guys I’ve read so many worse comics.
Because the edo period was badass and you know it. (https://youtu.be/yXErLiSbxXQ?t=16m35s)
CyberCubed
10-03-2021, 10:03 AM
If I were to condense this arc, I would have axed the Battle of the Bands arc and the whole future stuff with Lita entirely (including Lita's character), as well as axe that slithery storyline with the eel mutants which was pointless. Of course also get rid of the extra characters like Sheena, those hog mutants, etc.
I'd keep the Hob/Mutanimals stuff and Karai/Rahzar/Tokka arc and then go on from there. If you cut the stuff I said above out, you'd be 10 issues shorter than where we are now.
Mutant Ninja Anole
10-03-2021, 10:35 AM
If I were to condense this arc, I would have axed the Battle of the Bands arc and the whole future stuff with Lita entirely (including Lita's character), as well as axe that slithery storyline with the eel mutants which was pointless. Of course also get rid of the extra characters like Sheena, those hog mutants, etc.
I'd keep the Hob/Mutanimals stuff and Karai/Rahzar/Tokka arc and then go on from there. If you cut the stuff I said above out, you'd be 10 issues shorter than where we are now.
It’s easy to second guess, but I can’t help but wonder if you had Hob unseated by an angry mob at the very beginning, and Sally and co trying to pick up the pieces to rebuild Mutant Town, the government neglecting and making the situation harder for them, perhaps ironically radicalizing people as they seek ways to fend for themselves. One of those threads I thought the Jennika minis did well. I still think a character like Luci Rosetti as an opportunistic mob mutant operating in a place with no government supervision had so much potential. Then over time you see Mutant Town’s unique culture and identity develop …unfortunately at the time of issue #100 I think there was a deliberate choice to take things slower after the giant apocalyptic disaster leading up to City at War that a realistic take on the chaos of having so many people become mutants and having the government just leave a section of New York City isolated wouldn’t fit.
mrmaczaps
10-04-2021, 10:21 AM
If I were to condense this arc, I would have axed the Battle of the Bands arc and the whole future stuff with Lita entirely (including Lita's character), as well as axe that slithery storyline with the eel mutants which was pointless. Of course also get rid of the extra characters like Sheena, those hog mutants, etc.
I'd keep the Hob/Mutanimals stuff and Karai/Rahzar/Tokka arc and then go on from there. If you cut the stuff I said above out, you'd be 10 issues shorter than where we are now.
This entire arc could have been done in six issues. And there wouldn't have been nearly as much negative feedback about it. And I wouldn't be hoping & praying they fire the entire current creative team on the book. But instead, they double downed on fvcking stupid & we're going punk frogs take over next. Just nuked the whole series & start fresh. 1 to 100 was a great run and most all the mini series were great (not you, April & Casey mini)... No one currently working on the series should stay employed. Its absolutely sh!t.
ChosenOne
10-04-2021, 02:08 PM
Then over time you see Mutant Town’s unique culture and identity develop …
I know it's a take inspired by early 2000's X-Men comics, but I wish we could've seen a tailor specialized in making clothes for the Mutant Town denizens. Some of them underwent extreme physical mutations and need custom-made clothes, so it could've been an interesting glimpse into the local culture.
1 to 100 was a great run and most all the mini series were great (not you, April & Casey mini)...
The April & Casey mini is pretty inoffensive in hindsight, I've found. The only dodgy spots in the pre-#100 IDW series are really the first two Annuals, and even then they're okay. Certainly nowhere near as bad as what we're getting now.
mrmaczaps
10-04-2021, 02:23 PM
The April & Casey mini is pretty inoffensive in hindsight, I've found. The only dodgy spots in the pre-#100 IDW series are really the first two Annuals, and even then they're okay. Certainly nowhere near as bad as what we're getting now.
Oh for sure. I'm just saying looking at 1 to 100 and the mini series in that time, April & Casey was terrible. 101 to now took that idea and went full on furries with it. :teek:
ChosenOne
10-04-2021, 02:26 PM
Oh for sure. I'm just saying looking at 1 to 100 and the mini series in that time, April & Casey was terrible. 101 to now took that idea and went full on furries with it. :teek:
Yeah, if we had to pick the weakest spot, I think that would be it pretty unanimously. Either that or the Annuals.
On the other hand, best issue - for me - is a toss-up between #40 and #50. The latter probably wins because of its sheer plot importance.
mrmaczaps
10-04-2021, 02:30 PM
Yeah, if we had to pick the weakest spot, I think that would be it pretty unanimously. Either that or the Annuals.
On the other hand, best issue - for me - is a toss-up between #40 and #50. The latter probably wins because of its sheer plot importance.
The annuals, being Eastman stuff, just didn't seem to really connect to the series itself so much as they should... either in starting a new story or being the grand finale of the current storyline when they hit... Not that they were bad, just irrelevant.
ChosenOne
10-04-2021, 02:33 PM
The annuals, being Eastman stuff, just didn't seem to really connect to the series itself so much as they should... either in starting a new story or being the grand finale of the current storyline when they hit... Not that they were bad, just irrelevant.
That tradition should've been carried on.
By which I mean, Campbell should've been put in charge of the disconnected, inconsequential Annuals and let an actual writer handle the main title.
lonewarrior20
10-04-2021, 03:13 PM
so, who in idw would be a good writer for tmnt? i mean you guys must have someone in mind.
hypered1
10-04-2021, 03:37 PM
so, who in idw would be a good writer for tmnt? i mean you guys must have someone in mind.
They just want Tom Waltz or Bobby Curnow back, but clearly both of those guys wanted and needed a break after #100.
Not sure who else could be suggested.
mrmaczaps
10-04-2021, 03:48 PM
They just want Tom Waltz or Bobby Curnow back, but clearly both of those guys wanted and needed a break after #100.
Not sure who else could be suggested.
Does not need to be either of them...
They could have put Lawson & Lavigne on the book [h3ll, still could] and let them just tell some what if like stories (seeing as the current run is bad fanfic) & it would probably be selling better than the 19,000 copies this run is currently selling... or just get anyone else, anywhere to write the book.
Andrew NDB
10-04-2021, 04:01 PM
They just want Tom Waltz or Bobby Curnow back
Did Bobby ever leave? Someone else is editing the book now?
hypered1
10-04-2021, 04:14 PM
Did Bobby ever leave? Someone else is editing the book now?
Going by Ninja-notes, Bobby is still editing. I'm not sure how much writing he did before though.
ProphetofGanja
10-06-2021, 11:34 AM
I'm not sure why any of you are willing to ignore what the actual criticisms are here, are you really so incapable of constructing a counter-argument that you have to pretend something else was said? Again, I'm not sure how many times this needs to be said, but the problem has not been been a lack of fighting or a lack of familiarity.
The problem has been been a lack of conflict in general, most issues of this run has been the characters just "hanging out" which is only recommended as single issue stories in between the conclusion of one arc and the start of another, it should not be the meat of the so-called plot because it kills the pacing. Seeing characters not really do anything of noticeable consequence is a waste of pages.
Secondly, the characters don't seem to behave all that consistently here. In general, these characters haven't been behaving according to what has been established about them, but rather according to what needs to happen in order for certain events to take place. The most noticeable example of this is how Bebop and Rocksteady behaved during the Battle of the Bands arc, in order to make that happen needed them to be arrogant enough to throw musicians off their stage to play themselves, but humble enough to admit a lack of skill at the end and leave. Even ignoring how other writers handled them, this is still pretty bad because it doesn't make any sense in context of this story alone. You should also remember that just because it's the most obvious with Bebop and Rocksteady, this writing also applies to most other characters in this run to a lesser extent, even characters created for this run.
And speaking of the characters created for this run, because they have this inept writing behind them it can somewhat hard to even understand them. Similar to Bebop and Rocksteady, Diamond went from being violent at the drop of a hat to being calm and reasonable for no clear reason, just so she could join the band. Then we have the weasels who have virtually no distinguishing traits between them, they have no clear goals or intentions either, both aspects just makes it hard to even care about them. Many of these characters seems to have been introduced purely because the writer wanted them around, not because they were going to have anything to contribute.
I will admit this issue and the last were a slight improvement because something actually seems to be happening but there are still problems here. This should have happened much earlier and from the looks of it, the writer already seems to wind it down for even more "downtime", which is just a horrible idea. The inept character writing is still clearly on display here, so why should I care about the action when the characters aren't even believable?
If you can't actually argue against any of this, then I'm just going to assume this run is a guilty pleasure for you (as in you notice the problems and still like it despite knowing it's bad), refuse to admit it and just go for strawmen and other weak arguments to shield it from criticism. Wheter you want to admit there are objective markers for a good story or not, you still have to be able to argue for your position without just dismissing what is being said.
Almost* nothing after your post has been worth reading, neatoman. What a shame
...it's been "mostly harmless"...
https://i.imgur.com/XS5LK.gif
Andrew NDB
10-06-2021, 12:11 PM
Going by Ninja-notes, Bobby is still editing. I'm not sure how much writing he did before though.
Huh, I guess he did write a few. I didn't know that.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.