View Full Version : Do you think IDW TMNT will reach issue 200?
CyberCubed
01-22-2022, 02:31 PM
We're 125 issues in right now, so I assume they have at least a plan to issue 150 which is another 25 issues. We already know Waltz has the Armaggeddon war planned with the major villains as the next big arc. Beyond that, what do you think?
Lord Nightwalker
01-22-2022, 06:02 PM
Yes. I think they will make it to 200. Maybe well beyond that. TMNT will always have vast potential, it just needs to be properly harnessed. And that is possible.
Now, dose that mean every issue will speak to everyone? Of course not. Nothing dose.
But that certainly doesn't mean it won't be enjoyable or have merit.
Only time will tell.
mrmaczaps
01-22-2022, 07:03 PM
If it keeps going like the last 25 issues, I hope the hell not. More doesn't mean better...
ChosenOne
01-23-2022, 03:13 PM
If things stay the same as in 101-124, then no.
If future issues follow 125's lead, then yes. Definitely.
This poll needs a "Maybe" option.
Peter Palmer
01-24-2022, 09:00 AM
If things stay the same as in 101-124, then no.
If future issues follow 125's lead, then yes. Definitely.
This poll needs a "Maybe" option.
Nah. “Maybe” is too wishy washy for a poll like this. Of course it may get to issue 200…the poll is trying to figure out how many people believe it will.
I agree with the sentiment though. 101-124 were pretty weak. I have not read beyond that yet. I’d love to see the series go on well past 200, but only if the story and art is as engaging as issues 1-100 were.
I’d say no, it won’t make it to 200…but I’d love to be wrong.
Another thing to consider is that IDW is losing their woke G.I. Joe and Transformers franchises. The TMNT book has a lot of woke $#!( in it, but TMNT fans might be more accepting of those themes. But patterns like that are something to consider.
Either way though, 200 contiguous issues of a series is a hell of a feet nowadays. Off the top of my head the only other I.P.'s doing it without relaunches or "fad #1's" have been Spawn and Savage Dragon and Savage Dragon is literally a money pit for Larsen - he pays to keep it going. Even if IDW TMNT "only" makes it to 150, that's a a respectable run. Although people need to realize that all sales on these books are way artificially inflated nowadays. For example, there's a big difference between selling 30,000 copies a month to 30,000 readers and selling 30,000 copies with variants a month to 13,500 die-hards who buy everything.
TMNT #1 debuted in August 2011 in the top 50 (it was 48th) with 34,800 copies
TMNT #50 from October 2015 placed 67th in the top 100 and that was an anniversary issue. It distributed 33,553 copies.
For perspective, issue 90 in January 2019 saw 9,805 copies distributed and was at 189 on the sales lists for that month.
Issue 100, an anniversary issue gave the title a small sales boost for a while. Anniversary issues tend to do that, so it's not a true readership victory, unfortunately. Issue 101 distributed 20,470 copies. But those bumps do help push a title forward for another year or whatnot.
102 saw 13,780 copies. That's 13,780 copies with cover and ratio variants, and that drop came a month after a 20,470 copy order of issue 101. Don't think for a second that 13,780 individual people are buying the IDW book monthly. It just doesn't work that way. 104 fluctuated back up closer to 15,000 copies. Keep in mind that those issues were riding the high of the whole woke push and the orchestrated Jennika thing which got YouTuber attention as hype too.
So what it boils down to is that IDW is either making the smallest of profits from their woke TMNT book and clinging onto it for dear life, or more likely the ongoing is just another carrot in the greater soup of their TMNT publications (mini-series, one-shots, reprints, trades, etc) that as a whole they push the I.P. into profitability. My guess is that the monthly books don't make a lot of money, but the trades and reprints have kept IDW firmly in TMNT. And there's nothing wrong with using the whole meal to create the profitability if that's what is happening.
I think though that it wouldn't be unfair to say that IDW has been definitely used "event content" for sales hype. I don't know that the book would've made it this far simply on firm storytelling as opposed to politicized "zeitgeist" hype-content.
Andrew NDB
01-24-2022, 04:36 PM
At the very least it will be cancelled and relaunched with a new #1 long before then. They haven't done that trick yet, but it's still in their back pocket if need be.
MikeandRaph87
01-24-2022, 04:39 PM
If things stay the same as in 101-124, then no.
If future issues follow 125's lead, then yes. Definitely.
This poll needs a "Maybe" option.
What makes #125 an improvement? I noted before that the only characters that I want to see still are The Punk Frogs, Groundchuck, and Dirtbag. Though not under Campbell's pen and a Fraken-Venus to come? No, thank you!
At the very least it will be cancelled and relaunched with a new #1 long before then. They haven't done that trick yet, but it's still in their back pocket if need be.
Agreed with that, but that point speaks to what I was getting at with the "contiguous" point and the sales data in post #7 there...
CyberCubed
01-24-2022, 10:52 PM
I think if the series ends it'll be either because Viacom/Nick seems they can get more sales with the license for another company, or IDW as a whole goes bankrupt. I don't see them ending the current run just to restart at #1...at that point Viacom might as well see what either Dark Horse or someone else can do with the license rather than sticking with IDW for another few years. It'll be a sure sign the IDW series had run its course.
Andrew NDB
01-25-2022, 12:12 AM
I think if the series ends it'll be either because Viacom/Nick seems they can get more sales with the license for another company
I have no idea what sort of deal Nick has with IDW, but for all we know it's some kind of flat yearly fee. I seriously doubt Nick cares about the IDW comics in terms of actual sales... Nick is not getting rich off of anything IDW has given them back, ever. If IDW wants to continue paying the yearly fee? Cool, we'll keep extending it, and so on (again, speculation). I'm sure they do care about it a little in terms of "Is it putting forward the right image of the Turtles in print form?" and to a much lesser extent "Is it a viable 'hook' to get people maybe interested in our latest cartoons and toys?" If at all.
Even if IDW TMNT sells 50,000 copies every month, 50,000 viewers of a cartoon or 50,000 people buying a toy is nothing to Nick. They're not going to -- largely -- care about that. That's just a drop in a bucket. The kind of "moves" Nick makes with TMNT, they need millions of people to make a difference. And I don't mean that in a negative way, I mean that in a pragmatic way.
neatoman
01-25-2022, 02:57 AM
I would hope that if the series can get much better and stay better for at least, let's say 10-15, issues without another drastic drop in quality afterward we would get to 200. But if no such improvement happens then it might as well end at around 140 with a hasty wrap up of all the major plot threads, which would be about the best thing to hope for. Though, hilariously the quickest wrap up I could think of would be a sudden reveal that the EPF had an anti-mutagen bomb ready to go, the Utroms/Triceratons are relocated to some other vacant planet, Null goes out of business due to a market crash so she can no longer prepare Earth for invasion and whatever focus left goes to whatever was going to happen with the Rat King. It wouldn't be elegant but it would at least wrap it up. Of course, if the series does get better, then just let it breathe. The only thing I just want to wrap up yesterday is Mutant Town, the inclusion of it was a giant mistake from the start and I'm just so tired of it.
As for whether or not it will get to 200 issues isn't dependent on me or any other single person liking the direction, it depends on how long IDW can justify an ongoing. Even if an ongoing stops being lucrative, IDW may still find reason to publish 4-5 issues every year just to keep the license.
What makes #125 an improvement? I noted before that the only characters that I want to see still are The Punk Frogs, Groundchuck, and Dirtbag. Though not under Campbell's pen and a Fraken-Venus to come? No, thank you!
125 is an improvement in the sense that:
The inclusion of the Burnow Island sub-plot means the series is trying to get back to progressing the story.
The fact that we have three different plots going on means fewer pages feel like a waste.
The "Sheena wants her hair back" thing and this Barlow character seems like a more appropriate thing to explore with this setting than a Battle of the Bands.
Set up for a mystery plot with the Punk Frogs will probably mean the next few issues will continue to be a bit more busy.
The destruction of the Dojo might imply parts of Mutant Town might be coming to an end (though I will admit that might just be wishful thinking on my part).
That said of course, there are still many problems with 125, much of it feels rather sudden/random and much of what's going on actually seems rather awkward. But if I were to sum of up the improvements in one sentence it would be this: "It's not boring and I can see interesting stuff coming". The biggest problem with 101-124 is that almost nothing happened, there were other problems too and some of those are still present here, but least things are happening in 125. They could of course still be things that suck down the line but least it is something.
And as for Campbell's pen... I have to admit that I suspect 125 was at least partially ghost written and that's why it's an improvement. Apart from the pages about the Dojo and the Punk Frogs, the writing style doesn't match Campbell at all and even those pages are much more compressed than what she usually makes. While this possible ghost writer might be someone who hasn't worked on a TMNT book before, I suspect it might be Waltz because he has "Story Consulting" credit (which admittedly he has had since 101), the fact that he is coming back for the FCBD issue, wrote the last two annuals and may actually be coming back to write the book fairly soon. If not Waltz, then maybe Allor or Burnham since they wrote many of the minis. The alternative to there being a ghost writer is that Campbell came to terms with her flaws as a writer, took a writing class and drastically changed her style immediately, which is technically possible but I doubt is the case because of how quickly it must have happened.
And if it is true that 125 is indeed ghost written, then the next few issues credited to her may be as well, in which case her run is already over in all but the official sense.
I have no idea what sort of deal Nick has with IDW, but for all we know it's some kind of flat yearly fee. I seriously doubt Nick cares about the IDW comics in terms of actual sales... Nick is not getting rich off of anything IDW has given them back, ever. If IDW wants to continue paying the yearly fee? Cool, we'll keep extending it, and so on (again, speculation). I'm sure they do care about it a little in terms of "Is it putting forward the right image of the Turtles in print form?" and to a much lesser extent "Is it a viable 'hook' to get people maybe interested in our latest cartoons and toys?" If at all.
Even if IDW TMNT sells 50,000 copies every month, 50,000 viewers of a cartoon or 50,000 people buying a toy is nothing to Nick. They're not going to -- largely -- care about that. That's just a drop in a bucket. The kind of "moves" Nick makes with TMNT, they need millions of people to make a difference. And I don't mean that in a negative way, I mean that in a pragmatic way.
... Well, I guess technically a comic book is also good to have as a testing ground. Because they're dirt cheap to make, then they're ideal for things like: Testing new story ideas, introducing new characters, refining existing concepts, etc...
Since they don't have to worry too much about something working out in that format, it's always good if IDW does end up hatching a gem of an idea they can put into movies/cartoons/toylines, duds can just be ignored. Admittedly, the IDW ideas that have made it into other media are elements of character design, the revised origin in which the Turtles are intentional lab experiments and an in-name-only version of Alopex, but that would still be something.
ChosenOne
01-25-2022, 08:42 AM
What makes #125 an improvement? I noted before that the only characters that I want to see still are The Punk Frogs, Groundchuck, and Dirtbag. Though not under Campbell's pen and a Fraken-Venus to come? No, thank you!
Others have already put the possibility forward but I was the first to mention it on this thread and I stick to my guns: this issue doesn't feel like it was written by Campbell. At all. It's a true return to form for the series.
Naturally, IDW wouldn't throw her under the bus by admitting there's a ghost writer involved, but it appears that they finally noticed the writing (heh) on the wall (double heh) and went into damage control mode, trying to spin her run into something worthwhile at the very end.
And it does seem to be the end for her. Whether the ghost writer is Tom or not, the next few issues should tie into the big event later this year which we all know will be handled by him, so there's no more room left for woke, furry fanfiction.
As the song goes, "Ding, dong..."
hypered1
01-25-2022, 01:00 PM
Hate to burst people's bubbles but I've spoken with Sophie and she not only confirmed that #125 was written by her but that she's staying onboard for the forseeable future. You can complain all you want but Sophie isn't leaving anytime soon.
neatoman
01-25-2022, 02:50 PM
Hate to burst people's bubbles but I've spoken with Sophie and she not only confirmed that #125 was written by her but that she's staying onboard for the forseeable future. You can complain all you want but Sophie isn't leaving anytime soon.
Of course she would tell you that she wrote it, the point of ghost writers is to not share credit. If you hire ghost writers then you don't intend to reveal it. And using ghost writers is also not the same thing as not having put in any work yourself, she would still technically have told you the truth if it turned she just wrote the synopsis and let someone else do the actual script.
The reason we think this was ghost written is that it does not match her writing style, like at all. Issues 101-123 are very similar in the sense that they use very decompressed storytelling, heavy on dialogue without direct plot relevance, long montages and generally avoids subplots. After that we got 124 which intentionally leaves out word balloons and text boxes as a break between these two issues. Then we 125 which is drastically different in style, using at least three different plots and managing to get the point across much quicker.
Technically, it is possible that Sophie wrote all of this herself, it could be true. The problem is that would require me to accept that a writer completely overhauled the style she had been going with for 23 issues over night. Telling me I should just stop being suspicious because she said she said she didn't use a ghost writer, something that you naturally would deny doing regardless of whether it's true or not... That is to insult my intelligence.
hypered1
01-25-2022, 03:21 PM
Technically, it is possible that Sophie wrote all of this herself, it could be true. The problem is that would require me to accept that a writer completely overhauled the style she had been going with for 23 issues over night. Telling me I should just stop being suspicious because she said she said she didn't use a ghost writer, something that you naturally would deny doing regardless of whether it's true or not... That is to insult my intelligence.
1. Putting Sophie's name to someone else's writing would be incredibly disrespectful and offensive to the real writer if it were true and I can't see IDW or any other publisher doing something so low as that.
2. Professional writers are often capable of writing in a variety of styles and even other writers of this very series have done just that; compare the City Fall and Northampton arcs both of which were co-written by Kevin, Tom and Bobby.
3. You're insulting your own intelligence by behaving like conspiracy-theory nutjobs and believing in an idiotic unfounded assumption based upon zero factual evidence.
ChosenOne
01-25-2022, 03:53 PM
Are we sure Potato Joe was referring to Peter Doocy? I mean, it fits Campbellistas so well...
mrmaczaps
01-25-2022, 03:58 PM
1. Putting Sophie's name to someone else's writing would be incredibly disrespectful and offensive to the real writer if it were true and I can't see IDW or any other publisher doing something so low as that.
Calling Campbell a writer is incredibly disrespectful & offensive to other writers who don't suck nearly as much for 23 issues in a row...
Andrew NDB
01-25-2022, 03:59 PM
1. Putting Sophie's name to someone else's writing would be incredibly disrespectful and offensive to the real writer if it were true and I can't see IDW or any other publisher doing something so low as that.
Now, I don't think this is an actual ghostwriter situation with Sophie at all (again, short memories around here)... but what a stupid thing to say. So publishers have been being "disrespectful" and "offensive" to the hundreds of ghostwriters hired for the last couple of centuries? It goes with the f***ing job and its right there in the word "ghostwriter."
neatoman
01-25-2022, 04:09 PM
1. Putting Sophie's name to someone else's writing would be incredibly disrespectful and offensive to the real writer if it were true and I can't see IDW or any other publisher doing something so low as that.
2. Professional writers are often capable of writing in a variety of styles and even other writers of this very series have done just that; compare the City Fall and Northampton arcs both of which were co-written by Kevin, Tom and Bobby.
3. You're insulting your own intelligence by behaving like conspiracy-theory nutjobs and believing in an idiotic unfounded assumption based upon zero factual evidence.
Is this seriously the first time you have ever heard of ghost writers? Do you have the slightest clue as to how common they are? A ghost writer goes in knowing they won't get credit, that's their job. Publishers don't just credit others just for the sake of it, it's a very common practice. Bob Kane, the official creator of Batman, is credited with having written and drawn most early Batman comics but we know his involvement didn't stretch far beyond coming up with the basic concept. Any issue with Bob Kane writing credit was actually written by Bill Finger or someone else, not to mention that the art style shifts so drastically in those comics it's doubtful Kane had much to do with the artwork either. Kane didn't publicly admit this until 1989, 15 years after Finger died and 9 years before Kane himself died. DC comics itself didn't even officially credit Finger until 2015 because of contractual obligation. I'm sorry, but if you believe this isn't something that happens quite frequently I have to ask what rock you've been living under.
As for professional writers being able to write in multiple different styles, this is true but the example you brought up is nowhere as noticeable of a change as this. The pacing throughout Waltz run is fairly consistent and there are several key features of his writing you could use to identify him as the writer even if you don't know for sure it's him. Not to mention that Northampton and City at War were part of the same larger story with the same writer and if you read all the way through, you can see how one slowly transitions into the other. Likewise, there are several features of Campbell's writing consistent throughout the first 23 issue of her run and 125 is a very sudden change.
Are really not able to notice what a massive departure 125 is from the rest of Campbell's run? Technically yes, there is no factual proof that Campbell wasn't the sole writer on 125 as is the official credit, but if you have the slightest ability to analyse the content you'd notice the whiplash here. Why would the same exact writer do the same thing for two years straight and then completely change nearly all of her stylistic choices in a single issue? Of course I can't say for absolute certainty that was a ghost writer involved, it's the sort of thing we're not meant know but we can infer it.
hypered1
01-25-2022, 04:20 PM
Now, I don't think this is an actual ghostwriter situation with Sophie at all (again, short memories around here)... but what a stupid thing to say. So publishers have been being "disrespectful" and "offensive" to the hundreds of ghostwriters hired for the last couple of centuries? It goes with the f***ing job and its right there in the word "ghostwriter."
That was perhaps poorly worded but consider the context though; why would anyone accept a job ghost writing to cover up someone else's bad work? Why would anyone let a 'bad' writer's name be put on work that they've put time and effort into?
Ghostwriting in fiction is usually done to the effect that multiple writers are used to create a bulk of content that is all largely in the same style, tone and patterns. Having it be in completely different style and tone would defeat the purpose having a ghostwriter.
hypered1
01-25-2022, 04:23 PM
Are really not able to notice what a massive departure 125 is from the rest of Campbell's run? Technically yes, there is no factual proof that Campbell wasn't the sole writer on 125 as is the official credit, but if you have the slightest ability to analyse the content you'd notice the whiplash here. Why would the same exact writer do the same thing for two years straight and then completely change nearly all of her stylistic choices in a single issue? Of course I can't say for absolute certainty that was a ghost writer involved, it's the sort of thing we're not meant know but we can infer it.
https://www.memesmonkey.com/images/memesmonkey/4b/4b0539a05896f75cb1aabcba40f794c0.jpeg
jestergoblin
01-25-2022, 04:44 PM
I don't think IDW is going to exist in 6 years.
They've been selling (their entire tourism arm) and closing business units (they left the board game industry) non-stop the last few years just to stay afloat.
There has been so much turnover in their leadership the last two years - too many people are leaving for it to be a good sign.
ChosenOne
01-25-2022, 04:44 PM
That was perhaps poorly worded but consider the context though; why would anyone accept a job ghost writing to cover up someone else's bad work? Why would anyone let a 'bad' writer's name be put on work that they've put time and effort into?
Gee, that's a toughie... What kind of person has bills to pay and is happy to get a paycheck for something they know by definition won't stain their reputation? :roll:
frank_one
01-25-2022, 05:10 PM
why would anyone accept a jobSeriously, dude?
AquaParade
01-25-2022, 05:35 PM
I hope so. I haven't read the book in ages, but I love that they are keeping the train going. Whether or not I hop back on, I love that it's one of the few comics that has kept it's numbering.
Zog The Magnificent
01-25-2022, 05:42 PM
If it keeps going the way it's been going, along with IDW in general, probably not. I'd love it if it did, or it least I would have 2 years ago. Now, I'm kind of split between wanting it to just die already so we can stop dealing with all this woke crap, and not wanting it to end because it would annoy me if there was no ending, on top of the slim hope that it might recover. But I feel like I know better at this point than to hope for something like that.
Leo656
01-25-2022, 06:00 PM
Jesus. Every time one of the Tumblristas who make up the "brand new audience" for Campbell's TMNT run pipes up, it only reaffirms my position that this fanbase needs a LOT more elitism and gatekeeping, not less.
hypered1
01-25-2022, 06:42 PM
Seriously, dude?
That's out of context and anyone writing for a long running comic book is going to be at least somewhat established or known in the industry already and unlikely to be doing it 'just for the money', they'll want to make a bigger name for themselves to bring in more writing jobs so again ghostwriting in this fashion is self-defeating.
and the 'woke/ sjw' nonsense everyone keeps peddling isn't going anywhere; all media follows the current trends of what is popular to get them the biggest audience to make them the most money and if it means being 'woke' or including 'sjw' stuff then that's what they'll do.
Bahamut810
01-25-2022, 06:44 PM
Sophie Campbell does have a history of writing a certain way. I know that I have been able to pick out her issues that she was leading up before she took over on 100, and that she continued into 124. Its possible that she had a ghost writer or someone working with her to set things up in 125. Its also possible that there were barriers stopping her from writing certain things that have been moved out of the way because of staffing changes.
All of that is possible.
Regardless of that, 125 is in her name. Its a solid issue, and probably the best one that we have had since 100. New plots here hatched, Casey Jones is acting like a badass again, a new plot that feels like it might belong in both the TMNT we want and Mutant Town is starting. Im not going to bitch about it.
Thank you for a good issue, Sophie!
hypered1
01-25-2022, 06:54 PM
Its possible that she had a ghost writer or someone working with her to set things up in 125. Its also possible that there were barriers stopping her from writing certain things that have been moved out of the way because of staffing changes.
THIS.
It was said long ago that Sophie was restricted in what she was allowed to write by those above her - she wanted Raph to take out Hob's good eye remember?
Like Andrew said, people on here have got seriously short memories or permanent blinkers on and these same people need to accept that not everything right or wrong about the series lies at Sophie's feet.
Leo656
01-25-2022, 06:58 PM
Campbell's also a notorious liar but I'm sure that's just incidental.
hypered1
01-25-2022, 07:00 PM
Campbell's also a notorious liar but I'm sure that's just incidental.
I'd ask you to provide evidence but considering that you've never actually succeeded in providing any for any other allegation or assumption when I've asked in the past there's little point in me asking now.
But then you do have quite the reputation for spouting nonsense that has no basis in reality or factual backing so there's nothing new there then.
Leo656
01-25-2022, 07:35 PM
How cute. It speaks at me. It thinks it's people. :lol:
How cute. It speaks at me. It thinks it's people. :lol:
:lol::lol::lol:
What the real f?!? :lol::lol::lol:
Leo656
01-25-2022, 07:40 PM
I think messing with triggered1 is gonna be my new full-time forum position.
I can tell from the posting style they're either a woman OR a man-bun wearing soy-boy, and in either case those simply aren't people you speak to with respect. Just as a general rule.
It will learn. It will learn the hard way, if necessary.
frank_one
01-25-2022, 08:02 PM
the 'woke/ sjw' nonsense everyone keeps peddling isn't going anywhere; all media follows the current trends of what is popular to get them the biggest audience to make them the most money and if it means being 'woke' or including 'sjw' stuff then that's what they'll do.I don't know. Is woke stuff actually popular? Everyone I know either hate it or just don't care about it. Is there real people out there who actually appreciate products filled with woke elements? I mean, real people you can meet on the street, outside of social media.
Leo656
01-25-2022, 08:19 PM
Nope. Real-life people recognize it as a marketing trend, same as any other. It's an unfortunate side-effect of the fact that nowadays you get tons more word-of-mouth from a Tweet than you would with a commercial. As such, companies think that it's "good business" to pander to the interests of people who spend all their time online... Which, as it turns out, are predominantly overweight, rainbow-haired, perpetually-offended, sexually-confused, easily-triggered, Gender Studies Majors and other (barely) high-functioning social misfits.
That's who's online all the time, sharing Tweets and memes and "making themselves heard", and so in turn, companies feel forced to pander to them. Because it SEEMS like there's a lot of them, but the thing is, they're just incredibly loud. As we see in Real Life by how most "woke"-infested movies fail hard, the growing number of lawsuits nationwide to stop letting schools indoctrinate impressionable kids with their nonsense, and the fact that people really, REALLY love Chick-Fil-A, MOST people are definitely NOT on the bandwagon.
Companies are slowly coming around to this. By now they've figured out that most of these people don't have real jobs and are barely scraping by under the crushing debt of their Liberal Arts degrees, and so in turn it makes no sense to bend over for them.
hypered1
01-26-2022, 01:08 AM
I think messing with triggered1 is gonna be my new full-time forum position.
I can tell from the posting style they're either a woman OR a man-bun wearing soy-boy, and in either case those simply aren't people you speak to with respect. Just as a general rule.
It will learn. It will learn the hard way, if necessary.
As I have in fact said previously, I'm a straight white guy with a shaven head. You're still batting 0/1000 chump.
Andrew NDB
01-26-2022, 01:21 AM
As I have in fact said previously, I'm a straight white guy with a shaven head. You're still batting 0/1000 chump.
I don't want to weigh in on this much and I have no axe to grind with you... but I feel like I should point out the obvious that straight white guys (I don't see how the shaven head is relevant either way, or inherently some kind of "white power" angle if that's what you're suggesting being probably the 0.0001% reason dudes shave their heads) are probably the top perpetrators of what Leo is more or less suggesting, beaten out only by straight white women. You know, from this weird sense that they need to speak out for and defend and get justice for all of the groups/people/races that somehow can't do so for themselves and need their help, plus with the caveat of getting high fives from the similarly minded to reinforce that they're fighting the good fight. Most other ethnicities don't care about this stuff aside from loud pockets here or there.
hypered1
01-26-2022, 01:50 AM
I don't want to weigh in on this much and I have no axe to grind with you... but I feel like I should point out the obvious that straight white guys (I don't see how the shaven head is relevant either way, or inherently some kind of "white power" angle if that's what you're suggesting being probably the 0.0001% reason dudes shave their heads) are probably the top perpetrators of what Leo is more or less suggesting, beaten out only by straight white women. You know, from this weird sense that they need to speak out for and defend and get justice for all of the groups/people/races that somehow can't do so for themselves and need their help, plus with the caveat of getting high fives from the similarly minded to reinforce that they're fighting the good fight. Most other ethnicities don't care about this stuff aside from loud pockets here or there.
No the hair comment was to point out that I don't have a man-bun or any other idiotic hairstyle in a similar vein; truth be told I really can't stand those things.
My point was already made by him once again failing to back up his claim (that Sophie is a liar) with any kind of evidence because naturally he's doesn't have any such evidence.
Also for what it's worth, although we occasionally disagree about things, I do generally respect you and your perspectives.
Leo656
01-26-2022, 02:30 AM
Oh, God, that's so much worse. "Straight white dudes" unashamedly defending Campbell's stuff? Wow, that's just plain not acceptable.
Like, I'm also a straight white dude but I also can't imagine how it feels to hate my own dick as much as it seems you do. Hopefully I never will. :lol:
ChosenOne
01-26-2022, 03:18 AM
Like, I'm also a straight white dude but I also can't imagine how it feels to hate my own dick as much as it seems you do. Hopefully I never will. :lol:
That's a damn shame, you're missing out on a great career at IDW.
hypered1
01-26-2022, 03:44 AM
Oh, God, that's so much worse. "Straight white dudes" unashamedly defending Campbell's stuff? Wow, that's just plain not acceptable.
Like, I'm also a straight white dude but I also can't imagine how it feels to hate my own dick as much as it seems you do. Hopefully I never will. :lol:
Says the thug with a 'masculinity' more fragile than an egg-shell whose clearly terrified that the 'Women and Gays' are taking over. S/
Newsflash, it's the 21st century not the dark ages anymore.
neatoman
01-26-2022, 03:51 AM
I don't understand why it would be so difficult to analyse the content in an attempt to determine whether or not it's likely someone else was involved with the writing, why resort to calling people conspiracy theorists or throw out other insults here? Even if you liked 101-124, it's undeniable that 125 is written very differently. It seems really strange that someone would write 23 issues straight in a very distinct way, then after one issue deliberately written with without text, we get something that almost entirely discards the structure, priorities and stylistic choices from the first 23.
And someone else being involved with the writing isn't the same thing as Sophie having no involvement at all. Writing a synopsis that someone else scripts or scripting parts of the issue is still writing, but it can still be very noticeable.
It's also not like having access to facts is all that it comes down to for this sort of thing. There are people who specialise in identifying someone's work by analysing the contents. It's how people try to determine if a painting is the genuine work of the artist it's alleged to have been painted by, or if it is a forgery by a copycat. In terms of writing, even though the writers of the old testament are unknown, scholars have still been able to determine it was written by at least five people and where it was edited. It's not a perfect method and it is always better to have hard evidence, but it is still a useful tool.
If we were to apply such a method to this forum, if we were to take quotes from the top five posters here, someone would probably be able to connect the right quote to the correct poster very accurately by simply analysing how these people write.
ChosenOne
01-26-2022, 04:07 AM
A person's writing style is as unique to them as their fingerprints. Anyone with even the slightest understanding or practice in writing knows it.
Andrew NDB
01-26-2022, 04:07 AM
I don't know Sophie well, but I know enough to know she "gets" and digs down in the trenches gritty TMNT. Maybe it isn't her favorite thing (or maybe it is and she was encouraged to go a certain direction? I have no idea) but she's never had a problem putting that stuff out there. And quite well.
And she's been here since Tales V2. This isn't, like, someone entering things out of left field. And point is, yes, I'd bet she could and would be able to write accordingly if that's what was going on. She can shift gears. We've seen this already.
neatoman
01-26-2022, 04:29 AM
We're not talking about "grit" here, we're talking about how this thing is structured. If all there was to this was the introduction of a creepy surgeon and some agitated frogs but everything else was consistent with Sophie's writing, I probably wouldn't question it. The problem is that the pacing, the dialogue, compression level, etc. Are very different from the previous issues in this run.
AquaParade
01-26-2022, 04:56 AM
When did Sophie Campbell get a reputation for lying?
hypered1
01-26-2022, 06:08 AM
When did Sophie Campbell get a reputation for lying?
She didn't, 656 was just throwing out baseless accusations as usual.
ChosenOne
01-26-2022, 06:26 AM
Entering some serious Jim Jones territory here. Sheesh, just propose to her already... :roll:
mrmaczaps
01-26-2022, 07:49 AM
When did Sophie Campbell get a reputation for lying?
You want the most obvious straight up lie?
ChosenOne
01-26-2022, 07:51 AM
You want the most obvious straight up lie?
He probably means besides calling herself a writer.
frank_one
01-26-2022, 09:09 AM
Let's stop here, guys. There's no reason to be so disrespectful. I don't like what Sophie's doing with the series, actually I hate it, but that's it. I still respect her as a person and as an artist.
And, yeah, why calling her a liar? Where are all these lies you are talking about?
mrmaczaps
01-26-2022, 09:37 AM
He probably means besides calling herself a writer.
More obvious than that...
hypered1
01-26-2022, 09:41 AM
More obvious than that...
DON'T go there
ChosenOne
01-26-2022, 09:53 AM
I still respect her as a person and as an artist.
As a person and an artist, as in illustrator? Absolutely. As a so-called writer? Should've thought of that before doing what she did to TMNT.
mrmaczaps
01-26-2022, 10:24 AM
DON'T go there
Why not? What're you gonna do about it?
oldmanwinters
01-26-2022, 10:31 AM
At the very least it will be cancelled and relaunched with a new #1 long before then. They haven't done that trick yet, but it's still in their back pocket if need be.
Assuming IDW keeps the license (far from guaranteed at this point), I expect we'll see the renumbering stunt, but... when we get the 200 equivalent issue, they will pull the old Marvel trick from earlier in this millennium and temporary revert the book to its old numbering, just so they can promote the milestone 200th issue.... probably to be followed by another #1 a few months later.
AquaParade
01-26-2022, 11:05 AM
You want the most obvious straight up lie?
I get it. I don't get why it bothers anyone though. Literally has zero effect on your life.
Either way, I really dig Sophie's art and while I'm not into the story she's crafted over the last 25 issues, I still respect her. And I bet I'd be reading the book, flaws and all, if she were actually allowed to cut loose a bit.
That's a damn shame, you're missing out on a great career at IDW.
:lol:
Dromer post of the month, right there! 8) I'll admit that I used to like that IDW was carrying the "revive and continue the aging I.P." torch. Way more than a decade ago now I liked it.
But I think as for the rest of the mud-flinging in this thread it's safe to say that IDW has embraced woke nonsense to an extreme and their creative staff at large has doubled down on their virtue signaling even as sales have tanked and IDW has lost licenses. IDW has largely become a trash factory. It's not even a valid conversational-premise anymore as to whether or not their titles have merit or could be defended - it's a sinking ship. Only IDW-planted-posters and the deepest of clingers-on to their books continue to claim otherwise.
It's another example of woke $#!( idiots going on about "haters" and other such nonsense, but in complete disregard for the fact that the people they are rallying against as their "haters" don't even begin to touch the number of the world population who is not buying the books. If you sell a paltry 9,000 copies of a comic in a month globally and you complain that the people who aren't reading it are "bigots", "haters" and other nonsense then you are failing to realize that you are assaulting 99% of the world who doesn't want to read your woke $#!(. Therefore the problem is you and not your alleged "hate brigade".
When are you woke $#!( people going to realize that? You aren't fighting the "good" fight. Your just creating a fight.
BTW - ChoseOne, your post was honestly great. The rest of my post wasn't directed at your comment at all - you know... in case the context is lost to the internet ether and all that. :)
Bahamut810
01-26-2022, 11:31 AM
Why not? What're you gonna do about it?
No one can really do anything except the mods. The thing is, there is no need to do it. How she views herself is up to her. She is not around you at all. I'm not on her social media all the time or anything...but she seems pretty chill about some of the more woke twitter stuff out there and is not crapping on everyone who has different opinions (that I have seen). If she were, then yeah be and asshole about it. At the moment, she just writes a story you don't like.
BUT...I was wondering about the lies as well. I don't recall every hearing about anything solid she has lied about/stolen. You can dispute things that come down to opinion, which were the only thing mention, but not fact. If you are going to make an accusation then back it up with fact otherwise its a statement that can and *should* be disregarded.
ChosenOne
01-26-2022, 11:38 AM
:lol:
Dromer post of the month, right there! 8)
(...)
BTW - ChoseOne, your post was honestly great. The rest of my post wasn't directed at your comment at all - you know... in case the context is lost to the internet ether and all that. :)
Thanks! :D
Also, you guys... Please remain civilized and don't hate on Campbell for who she is/believes she is. That's her own personal matter and beside the point when it comes to the damage she has wrought on this comic, not to mention it does nothing but make us - her critics - look bad. There's plenty to criticize her for, no need to go below the belt in such a vicious manner.
mrmaczaps
01-26-2022, 12:41 PM
I get it. I don't get why it bothers anyone though. Literally has zero effect on your life.
Either way, I really dig Sophie's art and while I'm not into the story she's crafted over the last 25 issues, I still respect her. And I bet I'd be reading the book, flaws and all, if she were actually allowed to cut loose a bit.
Demanding people play into your delusions does affect them. And in some places, not playing into their delusions can land someone in jail. Thats a bit much. I don't HAVE to respect anyone, unless they first earn it.
mrmaczaps
01-26-2022, 12:44 PM
Thanks! :D
Also, you guys... Please remain civilized and don't hate on Campbell for who she is/believes she is. That's her own personal matter and beside the point when it comes to the damage she has wrought on this comic, not to mention it does nothing but make us - her critics - look bad. There's plenty to criticize her for, no need to go below the belt in such a vicious manner.
Its out there because Campbell wishes everyone to play into Campbell's delusion. I do not hate Campbell. I feel bad that rather than getting good help for the issues of the brain, this "modern" route was taken.... and everyone wishes the world to comply with it. I used to enjoy Campbell's work on the Turtles back during Mirage but this 101-124 hot garbage... Not even remotely.
Leo656
01-26-2022, 01:10 PM
That's not actually what I was getting at BUT I like that people are thinking. :lol:
So here's three right off the top of my head. Which triggered1 or some other plant/apologist is going to no doubt refute by moving the goalposts back and saying it's not good enough. But since baby needs their bottle, I'll indulge even though I don't have to.
1: Insisted that Sheena the punk-rocker was in no way influenced by the Ramones song "Sheena Is A Punk Rocker". Totally unrelated, you guys. Even though that song is one of only two Ramones songs anyone has ever heard of, and in fact EVERYONE has heard because it still gets daily radio play and is a popular staple of movies, TV shows, etc. Anyone who ever saw "Pet Semetary" has heard it, specifically right before the kid gets hit by the truck.
When confronted about this VERY on-the-nose reference, Campbell doubles-down and insists they've never even HEARD of the song.:roll: Yeah, okay. It's not even a big deal, it's a dumb reference since it's so blatant BUT not the kinda thing a person should lie about. Just admit "Yeah, I thought it was funny but I guess not everyone does." That's all. Chose to lie instead. Boo. Offsides.
2. When confronted about how their "The fate of the future depends on winning a Battle of the Bands!" plotline was heavily-derivative of Bill & Ted, and furthermore, that the timing of it was a bit suspect since Bill & Ted 3 was coming out at the exact same time... Campbell denies the similarity of concept AND - here's the kicker - says with a straight face "I had no idea Bill & Ted 3 was coming out or even existed." :roll: Despite the fact that it was one of THE most-hyped and heavily-advertised movies of the early pandemic, with commercials for it running CONSTANTLY. "I had no idea it was a thing!" :lol: Jesus. If a person went online AT ALL in 2020 - and we know for a fact that Campbell is online fairly often - they knew damn well about that movie. YouTube only made it an unskippable ad and every single entertainment website was only promoting it for weeks and months with articles and banner ads. But yeah, totally obscure. Come on.
3. At one point when a particularly bad issue of TMNT came out and people were being "mean" about it, Campbell's usual gang of blue-haired snowflakes went running to Twitter with cocoa and hugs. I was called out by name on there by some idiot, so despite not having Twitter I decided to see what people in the thread were saying. Turns out it was just the usual "That Technodrome place is full of Big Meanies! Don't let them get to you!" ass-licking nonsense.
BUT. Campbell indeed replied to someone by claiming, "I actually haven't been there (this forum) for months." Other times they claimed to have quit the forum entirely.
I can personally attest that at that time, and in fact EVERY time Campbell claimed to have quit the forum, not been on in months, whatever... I nonetheless saw them logged in EVERY SINGLE DAY for weeks and months during those supposed "breaks", often for hours at a time, checking on threads just like this one. Like clockwork, whenever there was a thread with people crapping on the way Campbell was writing the book, Campbell would be online at 3am or some such going over every post with a fine-tooth comb like some sort of masochist.
Which is their prerogative. But it's also A LIE to claim you haven't looked at a forum for months when you're presently still on it every day for hours, and the Current Activity tab gives your position away so you can't even claim "I was just replying to PMs."
To their credit, after I made a comment about how they sure are on here a lot for someone who publicly said they quit the place numerous times, I haven't seen them here at all. BUT, they most likely just set their name to "Hidden", is what I would guess.
Are these "big deal" lies? Nah. But they establish a consistent pattern of behavior about how when caught in a lie this person just weaves another web instead of just saying "Ya got me." I don't respect that. Not from anyone.
I happen to put a premium on honesty, and therefore it is my personal belief that there are no "small lies", and that even innocuous stuff is indicative of a person's general character. Especially when they get caught. SO, to some of you this stuff is all "Who cares?"-level, and I do get that. I'm more concerned with the Big Picture, and the fact that this person is SO committed to their own BS, great or small, that they're seemingly incapable of just saying "Okay, that may not have been completely honest" as situations warrant.
To me, a person who lies is simply a liar, and I never give that person the benefit of any doubt ever again. Others may see and think differently.
Meanwhile, Campbell can SAY they're "really" all about blood-n-guts TMNT while they stuff the book full of fuzzy pink unicorns discussing their feelsies over pudding, and then claim "The editors have me handcuffed, maaaaaan!", and people can choose to believe that if they want to. I, personally, take that statement with a shaker full of salt. Again, "pattern of behavior".
Some will claim those are "stupid examples". Okay. We have different values and different requirements for "honesty", I guess. Regardless, you asked and I answered.
------------------------------
And for the last time, I do not hate gay people. Just women.:lol:
hypered1
01-26-2022, 01:55 PM
Okay I'll give credit where it's due and fair enough you've actually provided some examples, small potatoes that they are, but a few things:
1: Insisted that Sheena the punk-rocker was in no way influenced by the Ramones song "Sheena Is A Punk Rocker". Totally unrelated, you guys. Even though that song is one of only two Ramones songs anyone has ever heard of, and in fact EVERYONE has heard because it still gets daily radio play and is a popular staple of movies, TV shows, etc. Anyone who ever saw "Pet Semetary" has heard it, specifically right before the kid gets hit by the truck.
When confronted about this VERY on-the-nose reference, Campbell doubles-down and insists they've never even HEARD of the song.:roll:
I've heard of the Ramones and of Pet Semetary, but I'd not heard of the song before this myself and I'll even admit that I thought the name was a reference to the singer Sheena Easton, but maybe I was wrong.
So is it possible Sophie was in the same boat? Sure. But we have no way of knowing either way.
2. When confronted about how their "The fate of the future depends on winning a Battle of the Bands!" plotline was heavily-derivative of Bill & Ted, and furthermore, that the timing of it was a bit suspect since Bill & Ted 3 was coming out at the exact same time... Campbell denies the similarity of concept AND - here's the kicker - says with a straight face "I had no idea Bill & Ted 3 was coming out or even existed." :roll: Despite the fact that it was one of THE most-hyped and heavily-advertised movies of the early pandemic, with commercials for it running CONSTANTLY. "I had no idea it was a thing!" :lol: Jesus. If a person went online AT ALL in 2020 - and we know for a fact that Campbell is online fairly often - they knew damn well about that movie. YouTube only made it an unskippable ad and every single entertainment website was only promoting it for weeks and months with articles and banner ads.
First off ad-blockers are a thing, but as with the first example you can be aware of the existence of a piece of media and still not know anything about it, same situation here and again no definitive proof leaning in either direction.
3. At one point when a particularly bad issue of TMNT came out and people were being "mean" about it, Campbell's usual gang of blue-haired snowflakes went running to Twitter with cocoa and hugs. I was called out by name on there by some idiot, so despite not having Twitter I decided to see what people in the thread were saying. Turns out it was just the usual "That Technodrome place is full of Big Meanies! Don't let them get to you!" ass-licking nonsense.
BUT. Campbell indeed replied to someone by claiming, "I actually haven't been there (this forum) for months." Other times they claimed to have quit the forum entirely.
I can personally attest that at that time, and in fact EVERY time Campbell claimed to have quit the forum, not been on in months, whatever... I nonetheless saw them logged in EVERY SINGLE DAY for weeks and months during those supposed "breaks", often for hours at a time, checking on threads just like this one. Like clockwork, whenever there was a thread with people crapping on the way Campbell was writing the book, Campbell would be online at 3am or some such going over every post with a fine-tooth comb like some sort of masochist.
Which is their prerogative. But it's also A LIE to claim you haven't looked at a forum for months when you're presently still on it every day for hours, and the Current Activity tab gives your position away so you can't even claim "I was just replying to PMs."
To their credit, after I made a comment about how they sure are on here a lot for someone who publicly said they quit the place numerous times, I haven't seen them here at all. BUT, they most likely just set their name to "Hidden", is what I would guess.
I'll be honest I haven't seen the tweets/ messages that this relates to so I can't speak to the accuracy of what you've stated here, but regardless who really cares whether someone frequents this forum or not? (Not to mention your own self-admitted behaviour of watching her movements comes across as pretty stalker-ish - yikes.)
All-in-all these are pretty weak examples and even then only really the third one has any kind of verifiable veracity - they're all leagues away from supposedly having an issue of a comic book be ghostwritten.
What this really boils down to is a bunch of mysogynists and transphobes who are terrified of admitting that they actually enjoyed something written by someone they've spent months damning out of the fear of being seen as weak or a conformist by their peers all for the sake of protecting their fragile egos.
AquaParade
01-26-2022, 02:53 PM
Gotta admit that last one is sort of I like “I followed her home, snuck in thru the garage, hid in her closet all night, and in the morning I caught her picking her nose.”
Leo, you already know this, which is why there is a giant disclaimer at the bottom of your post.
I can’t speak to the other examples. They sound pretty weird, if they are lies. Not a good sign of character. But I mean, I guess I don’t care enough to not give the benefit of the doubt. Not worth it.
Leo656
01-26-2022, 02:59 PM
"Chastises people for pushing 'conspiracy theories'. In the same breath, pushes a conspiracy theory about why people claim to hate Campbell's IDW TMNT." :lol: Typical Lefties, you can set your watch to 'em.
Here's something your ilk typically struggles with, but it will serve you well once you finally start applying it: When people tell you who they are (or what they're about) LISTEN, don't project.
In this case, people hate the IDW TMNT comic because it's boring, goes nowhere, has nothing to do with TMNT, actively displaces the central characters in favor of the author's Mary Sue and other fanfic characters, has taken two whole years for f*ck-all nothing to happen outside of various abrupt gay romances popping up everywhere, and on the whole, is about ten miles removed from what MOST people agree that a TMNT comic "should" be.
People have been saying Exactly That - loudly and often - for almost two whole years. Therefore, saying stuff like "They're all just bigots, maaaaaan" and projecting other motives as to why they hate the run when they have been VOCAL about exactly what they dislike, is unseemly. Don't do that.
-----------------
Since we're "giving credit", I have to applaud you for doing exactly as predicted. :lol: "Your examples aren't good enough!" Blow me.
Here's the thing: They ARE "small lies" and I admitted as such. That is not the POINT. The point is, these aren't things any person should feel compelled to lie about, at all. Just come clean. When a person CHOOSES to lie about things of such little consequence, it establishes a pattern of behavior and forces me to ask what ELSE they might make it a point to lie about. Because if they are willing to lie about whether or not they've ever heard a song that every person under age 50 has heard of, or whether or not they knew one of the most heavily-advertised movies of an entire calendar year even EXISTED... You're forced to admit they probably lie about bigger things, too.
As for making it a point to notice when various members are online, I do that with lots of people. When you've been here as long as I've been, you can't help it. Andrew, for example, tends to lurk often between the hours of 3am-6am EST whether or not he's actively posting. I notice this because I'm often online around the same time. Sumac, Zarius, and others have a similar pattern.
I guess I am "stalking" all of them, as well. It CAN'T just be as simple as "Whenever I log in between those hours, I see the same specific cluster of names and after X years it becomes very noticeable." CAN'T be as simple as THAT, goodness knows.
And again, if Campbell wants to lie about their forum activity in order to assuage the legions of ass-kissers on their Twitter by insisting "I don't see what they say, nor do I care," that's their prerogative. BUT. When you say such things when you spent hours logged in THE DAY BEFORE scrolling through every single post where anyone even mentioned your name... You're a liar AND a bit of a twat. Not my fault I caught them in an obvious lie. Don't lie, these things won't happen. Very simple.
It's like a person who gets caught cheating, and when caught, says "Well... YOU weren't supposed to find out about it! How DARE you invade my privacy!" :lol: Like, THAT is NOT the POINT, and deflection only compounds the sin.
I don't expect you to "get it". But others will, and do, and that's fine.
EDIT: Aqua, see above. I notice MANY people who are on the same time as I am. And I already explained the situation. Someone libeled me on Campbell's Twitter, I looked at it to see how/why, saw their claim about "not being on there in ages" and it jumped out at me because I had LITERALLY seen them on every single day for weeks.
Misdirection will not help anyone's case. The person was caught in a lie and the fact that I'm aware of the posting habits of MANY people here does not in any way diminish that fact.
Me noticing how they spend their forum time is NOT a bigger "issue" than Someone being a liar. So kindly don't paint it as such, mmmmmmkay. Just like the person who catches their spouse cheating by following them home from work is NOT "worse" than the one doing the cheating. Try and keep up, kids.
hypered1
01-26-2022, 04:59 PM
And once again we catch you backtracking to try to save face; You can indeed see who's online at any time by the 'Active Users' panel at the bottom of the forum boards but that only shows you that they are logged in - which just means a person is logged in not that they are actually reading, posting or doing anything else on the forum at any given time - and yet you specifically claimed to have watched Sophie *checking on threads just like this one* which is only possible if you were not only watching on her user page but regularly refreshing it to see the status actually changing.
And before you try to accuse me of anything I tested this out using a second window where I wasn't logged in and watched my own user page as I changed threads on the window where I am logged in.
At this point your behaviour is clearly not only stalker-ish but downright obsessive - it's actually amazing that you haven't been banned yet considering that cyber-stalking is a crime that you've freely admitted to.
MikeandRaph87
01-26-2022, 05:11 PM
"Chastises people for pushing 'conspiracy theories'. In the same breath, pushes a conspiracy theory about why people claim to hate Campbell's IDW TMNT." :lol: Typical Lefties, you can set your watch to 'em.
Here's something your ilk typically struggles with, but it will serve you well once you finally start applying it: When people tell you who they are (or what they're about) LISTEN, don't project.
In this case, people hate the IDW TMNT comic because it's boring, goes nowhere, has nothing to do with TMNT, actively displaces the central characters in favor of the author's Mary Sue and other fanfic characters, has taken two whole years for f*ck-all nothing to happen outside of various abrupt gay romances popping up everywhere, and on the whole, is about ten miles removed from what MOST people agree that a TMNT comic "should" be.
People have been saying Exactly That - loudly and often - for almost two whole years. Therefore, saying stuff like "They're all just bigots, maaaaaan" and projecting other motives as to why they hate the run when they have been VOCAL about exactly what they dislike, is unseemly. Don't do that.
-----------------
Since we're "giving credit", I have to applaud you for doing exactly as predicted. :lol: "Your examples aren't good enough!" Blow me.
Here's the thing: They ARE "small lies" and I admitted as such. That is not the POINT. The point is, these aren't things any person should feel compelled to lie about, at all. Just come clean. When a person CHOOSES to lie about things of such little consequence, it establishes a pattern of behavior and forces me to ask what ELSE they might make it a point to lie about. Because if they are willing to lie about whether or not they've ever heard a song that every person under age 50 has heard of, or whether or not they knew one of the most heavily-advertised movies of an entire calendar year even EXISTED... You're forced to admit they probably lie about bigger things, too.
As for making it a point to notice when various members are online, I do that with lots of people. When you've been here as long as I've been, you can't help it. Andrew, for example, tends to lurk often between the hours of 3am-6am EST whether or not he's actively posting. I notice this because I'm often online around the same time. Sumac, Zarius, and others have a similar pattern.
I guess I am "stalking" all of them, as well. It CAN'T just be as simple as "Whenever I log in between those hours, I see the same specific cluster of names and after X years it becomes very noticeable." CAN'T be as simple as THAT, goodness knows.
And again, if Campbell wants to lie about their forum activity in order to assuage the legions of ass-kissers on their Twitter by insisting "I don't see what they say, nor do I care," that's their prerogative. BUT. When you say such things when you spent hours logged in THE DAY BEFORE scrolling through every single post where anyone even mentioned your name... You're a liar AND a bit of a twat. Not my fault I caught them in an obvious lie. Don't lie, these things won't happen. Very simple.
It's like a person who gets caught cheating, and when caught, says "Well... YOU weren't supposed to find out about it! How DARE you invade my privacy!" :lol: Like, THAT is NOT the POINT, and deflection only compounds the sin.
I don't expect you to "get it". But others will, and do, and that's fine.
EDIT: Aqua, see above. I notice MANY people who are on the same time as I am. And I already explained the situation. Someone libeled me on Campbell's Twitter, I looked at it to see how/why, saw their claim about "not being on there in ages" and it jumped out at me because I had LITERALLY seen them on every single day for weeks.
Misdirection will not help anyone's case. The person was caught in a lie and the fact that I'm aware of the posting habits of MANY people here does not in any way diminish that fact.
Me noticing how they spend their forum time is NOT a bigger "issue" than Someone being a liar. So kindly don't paint it as such, mmmmmmkay. Just like the person who catches their spouse cheating by following them home from work is NOT "worse" than the one doing the cheating. Try and keep up, kids.
JcDea8n66So
Bahamut810
01-26-2022, 06:44 PM
Wow...this thread sort of went to hell. Its extremely off the original topic now :lol:
FredWolfLeonardo
01-26-2022, 06:47 PM
And once again we catch you backtracking to try to save face; You can indeed see who's online at any time by the 'Active Users' panel at the bottom of the forum boards but that only shows you that they are logged in - which just means a person is logged in not that they are actually reading, posting or doing anything else on the forum at any given time - and yet you specifically claimed to have watched Sophie *checking on threads just like this one* which is only possible if you were not only watching on her user page but regularly refreshing it to see the status actually changing.
And before you try to accuse me of anything I tested this out using a second window where I wasn't logged in and watched my own user page as I changed threads on the window where I am logged in.
At this point your behaviour is clearly not only stalker-ish but downright obsessive - it's actually amazing that you haven't been banned yet considering that cyber-stalking is a crime that you've freely admitted to.
You can also see what people are doing by going on Quick Links and then "Who's Online". You don't have to go on someone's profile, not that it matters.
hypered1
01-26-2022, 07:49 PM
You can also see what people are doing by going on Quick Links and then "Who's Online". You don't have to go on someone's profile, not that it matters.
That doesn't make it any better, you still have to refresh that page to see changes to what anyone is doing, which means that 656 would still have to be deliberately refreshing the page to follow Sophie's movements and watch her go from thread to thread.
frank_one
01-26-2022, 08:10 PM
Here's the thing: They ARE "small lies" and I admitted as such. That is not the POINT. The point is, these aren't things any person should feel compelled to lie about, at all. Just come clean. When a person CHOOSES to lie about things of such little consequence, it establishes a pattern of behavior and forces me to ask what ELSE they might make it a point to lie about.I'm with you on this. It's not the size of the lies that makes a person a liar, it's the pattern of behavior.
neatoman
01-27-2022, 01:58 AM
Jesus ****ing Christ, this thread... I don't want to clarify this but I feel I have to.
OK:
If the writing of 125 is radically different from 101-124, which it is and it doesn't some hyper-focused analysis to determine that it is, it is a very sudden change and of course people are going to question if some anonymous person was part of the writing process. If that is indeed the case, we don't know who it is and trying to claim we only believe it because of bigotry doesn't make sense, because for all we know this person could be someone else who could be a typical bigotry target. We may suspect who it is but we don't know.
The reason Campbell's writing sucked so hard in 101-124 is that virtually nothing of importance happened, it tended to be very low stakes with a lack of real conflict and could easily have been compressed to 5-8 issues. It is not, as some might claim, because there weren't enough fight scenes or because it shows some kind of character development under different circumstances. There are other problems as well but those are the big ones.
Trying to claim it is only disliked because Sophie is a transwoman is a false equivalence. Are there bigoted people who don't like that a transwoman is writing the book? Yes, there are. However, if the arguments for why the writing is bad have nothing to do with her gender identity, why assume the person making them is a bigot?
Being a transwoman does not shield Sophie from fair criticism. Nothing, and I mean nothing, should shield anyone from fair criticism. "Campbell should not write because trans" is obviously not fair criticism of course, but "Sophie is a bad writer because she has no sense of pacing" is. Saying that any criticism of Sophie or her writing is just evidence of bigotry is moronic. If I'm served spoiled sashimi by a Japanese chef and call him out on it, that would not mean I hate the Japanese, it would mean I got served a bad meal by an incompetent chef.
Writing is not all subjective. There may be certain aspects of writing that are, preferences towards certain themes and what not, but there are objective qualities to writing stories. There is a reason why comic books, American comic books in particular, usually have the writer and artist as separate people. They are different disciplines that take a lot of practice to get good at, if you focus your career in area, you're not likely to be very good at the other. Sophie Campbell, much like Todd McFarlane or Jim Lee, was primarily an artist and not a writer before scripting this book and it shows. Sophie is indeed a good artist, this is difficult to deny but the writing is still bad. I don't think anyone would claim Todd McFarlane or Jim Lee are good writers, which is probably why they ended up handing off the writing duties to others on their creator owned books. Writing is hard and not anyone can do it.
A pattern of lying is not a guarantee someone did lie, no. That is correct, it is a fallacy to assume someone lies because tend to lie. However if we are talking about suspicions about a ghost writer being involved then the pattern is sort of irrelevant. The question "Did you get someone else to write for you with the intention of you getting the credit?" will almost always be "no", especially if we're talking about something that was published last week. If the official writer did indeed write the book, the answer will be "no" because it is the truth. If a ghostwriter is involved then the answer would still be "no" because the intention is to make seem as if the official writer is the actual writer. In either case, no matter how truthful the person is otherwise, they are not a reliable source for determining if a ghostwriter was involved. I hate using this comparison because it makes the use of ghostwriters look like some ethical problem but I can't think of a better alternative, it is like asking someone directly if they cheated on a test, why would they ever tell you that they did?
I really, really, really don't like to bring up Sophie's gender identity and I have actively tried to avoid bringing it up as much as possible. This is not because I disapprove of transpeople or anything like that, because I really don't. I believe that quality of writing and the criticism of bad writing should be consistent regardless of who writes it. The problem is that quite a lot of people seem to have a difficult time not factoring in the fact that a transwoman wrote this comic and somehow feel it must be brought up as either in criticism or defense of it. It is very unfortunate that the transwoman in question turned out to be a terrible writer because it makes it difficult to criticise the book publicly, regardless of how fair the criticisms may be, because someone who really ought to know better can't help but to assume it's rooted in bigotry.
What I am ultimately trying to get across is that it isn't fair to harp on Sophie for being a transwoman, but Sophie being a transwoman doesn't make this book worth defending.
Andrew NDB
01-27-2022, 02:37 AM
Sophie being trans is a non-issue to me and always has been. When she came out I immediately changed her name in "Odyssey" for her contribution to it and I was happy to do it. I'm happy if she's happy and that's that. And regarding different kinds of storytelling previous to now... I don't know, I find this kind of insulting. Writers can shift gears and do so often. Plus we have no idea what has been going on behind the scenes at IDW. Perhaps there was an edict to deliver a certain kind of story over a certain amount of time... and maybe that edict has been lifted or shifted. Again, what I KNOW is that Sophie is perfectly capable of delivering the kind of story in 125 (or even far darker fare) and always has been.
hypered1
01-27-2022, 02:50 AM
This did get side tracked a couple of times but as I said before it just boils down to a bunch of people who don't have balls to admit that they actually liked something that Sophie wrote to point that they're trotting out idiotic theories that it must've been written by someone else and when they're then provided ample evidence to the contrary and that Sophie has a history of writing in this style (vis à vis her time on the Mirage iteration of the comic) they immediately ignore it like it was blasphemy.
neatoman
01-27-2022, 03:09 AM
Except Sophie Campbell hasn't written for Mirage. She did some covers and two front pieces but no writing. So to say she wrote for Mirage is straight up incorrect, it didn't happen as far as I can find. In fact, I can find very few writing credits Sophie has outside of this book and they're still more consistent in style with 101-124 than 125. So no, 125 is still a bit off here if we assume Sophie is the sole writer.
hypered1
01-27-2022, 03:28 AM
Except Sophie Campbell hasn't written for Mirage. She did some covers and two front pieces but no writing. So to say she wrote for Mirage is straight up incorrect, it didn't happen as far as I can find. In fact, I can find very few writing credits Sophie has outside of this book and they're still more consistent in style with 101-124 than 125. So no, 125 is still a bit off here if we assume Sophie is the sole writer.
So now you're calling Andrew a liar?
If you want to just stick with the IDW run then Sophie also wrote the 'Toad Baron's Ball' 2-parter and the 'Karai's Path' arc both the in Universe and they're more like #125 than the rest of the post-#100 issues.
neatoman
01-27-2022, 04:37 AM
So now you're calling Andrew a liar?
He's incorrect, possibly mistaken rather than lying, but incorrect regardless. Just because I may agree with him on a lot things, have similar tastes or because people here may generally like him does not mean he can't be factually wrong. Maybe Sophie wrote some Mirage book at some point but I can only find artist credit. If someone can find a Mirage TMNT book with writing credit to Sophie, I will apologise but I will not just assume it exists because someone tells me it does.
If you want to just stick with the IDW run then Sophie also wrote the 'Toad Baron's Ball' 2-parter and the 'Karai's Path' arc both the in Universe and they're more like #125 than the rest of the post-#100 issues.
Before I detail what I have to say about the Toad Baron story and Karai's path, if your intention is to use them as examples of how 125 is consistent with Sophie's style, as in a style she has usedall alone, those are actually bad examples. If you go ahead an read who is credited with the writing for those stories, the Toad Baron story says "Sophie Campbell and Bobby Curnow" and Karai's path says "By Erik Burham with Sophie Campbell". They are both examples of Sophie having a writing partner.
To say "These stories that Sophie wrote with someone else are good, therefore the good issue she allegedly wrote alone can't have had someone else helping out" is dumb. If her best writing credits are co-credits and all the other issues she wrote alone without significant help were bad, it doesn't exactly give me less reason to think someone else was involved with the writing process.
To clarify, I never claimed 125 was absolutely written by someone else in it's entirety, or even that I know anything for certain. All I have ever claimed about issue 125 is that I suspect someone else was at least partially involved with the writing process. Sophie Campbell could technically be the sole writer of 125 as is officially claimed, it's just that I doubt that is the case.
Now, I will agree that the Toad Baron two-parter and Karai's Path are better comics than 101-124 are. But like we have already established, we know they aren't solo written by Campbell so using their quality as a case for why 125 can't have a secret co-writer doesn't work. However, even assuming Sophie was the driving force on these comics rather than Curnow or Burnham and that they had minimal involvement (which I doubt), they aren't actually more similar to 125 than they are 101-124. The pacing and dialogue are much better in those comics than 101-124, this is true but like 101-124 there is a heavy emphasis on a main plot with little to no effort put into a sub-plot and there are long montages where the art takes focus with not much emphasis on progressing the plot at all. With 125 you pretty much get the opposite, every panel is dedicated to the plot and there are two (arguably three) sub-plots involved.
Going back to Andrew, a thing I mostly don't agree with him on quite frequently is that seems to consider "maturity level" and "level of grit" to be indicative of quality, and in this case also seems to think this is what style boils down to. I think you might be making a similar mistake here and need to tell you right now to try and think about this on a less surface oriented level (if I'm mistaken about where you are coming from, please correct me). Yes, 125 along with Karai's Path and the Toad Baron two-parter are "grittier and more mature" than what most of 101-124 were but honestly, not by much. More importantly, structurally 125 is still major departure from 101-124 and I need to be given a reason to think it's not in order to be convinced Sophie had to be the sole writer.
frank_one
01-27-2022, 06:05 AM
Except Sophie Campbell hasn't written for Mirage. She did some covers and two front pieces but no writing.As far as I know, you are right. The only collaboration I can remember between Mirage and Sophie is her doing covers for the "Raphael - Bad moon rising" miniseries. No writing at all.
CyberCubed
01-27-2022, 06:42 AM
Why do these threads always turn out like this.
https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/facebook/000/061/664/1275937249093s.jpg
ChosenOne
01-27-2022, 08:11 AM
Campbell has absolutely zero understanding or grasp of conflict, and it very much shows in the (ahem) quality of her writing. The fact that whoever wrote/co-wrote/ghost wrote/co-ghost wrote #125 did more with Sheena and her conflict as a character in just a couple of pages than Campbell did in twenty issues on her own is all the proof the pudding needs. Unwillingness to admit she is fallible out of sheer ideological blindness is another matter entirely.
MikeandRaph87
01-27-2022, 08:16 AM
There is a lot to read in this thread to catch up. I do think that the solution is simple. Replace the writer.
ChosenOne
01-27-2022, 08:28 AM
There is a lot to read in this thread to catch up. I do think that the solution is simple. Replace the writer.
Done. You have two wishes left.
Allio
01-27-2022, 03:37 PM
If things stay the same as in 101-124, then no.
If future issues follow 125's lead, then yes. Definitely.
This poll needs a "Maybe" option.
Not this poll in particular, but “maybe” is a cowards way out in nerd discussion.
ChosenOne
01-27-2022, 03:54 PM
Not this poll in particular, but “maybe” is a cowards way out in nerd discussion.
The reason I said that is because I haven't been able to bring myself to pick either option yet. The results are closer than I expected too. Might wait until #126 is out to make sure #125 wasn't a fluke and the comic really is back to its old form. If that makes me a coward, so be it.
Leo656
01-27-2022, 05:02 PM
So anyone who's ever clicked a User's name to see what they're up to is "a stalker". :lol: What else is even the point of having such a feature on a forum in the first place? If I want to see why a person who "quit" the forum is suddenly on it every day for hours, or see if someone else had seen the joke I made in a thread yet, or what a Banned user might be doing back here logging in despite being banned... That's my own business and I'll satisfy my personal curiosity any way I jolly well please to.
There's an "invisible" function if people don't want their name to show up as Active. I use it. It's not hard to figure out. Those who don't bother must not care if someone sees their activity. And that's their prerogative as well.
"Cyber-stalking." :lol: You f*cking loser. Go clean your room, your girlfriend's boyfriend is coming over to f*ck her later and he doesn't like dirty sheets. I hear they're gonna let you watch this time. :lol: Good for you, kid.
Andrew NDB
01-27-2022, 05:30 PM
"Cyber-stalking." :lol: You f*cking loser. Go clean your room, your girlfriend's boyfriend is coming over to f*ck her later and he doesn't like dirty sheets. I hear they're gonna let you watch this time. :lol: Good for you, kid.
https://c.tenor.com/TJgqSzFffa0AAAAM/spit-take-spit.gif
Ninja Toitles
01-31-2022, 03:08 PM
The book has toitle legs! It creeps along but it'll hit it's mark to 200!
IDSW Toitles isn't the best it's ever been, but we will keep buying it and reading it!
MikeandRaph87
02-05-2022, 05:53 PM
Done. You have two wishes left.
We see glimpses of The Armageddon Game but no indication in the title itself. Having read through #125 now, it still doesn't do it for me and this is with the inclusion of the characters that I asked for, The Punk Frogs, Groundchuck, and Dirtbag. When will Campbell be gone off the book? The only thing I have is The Armageddon Game and it's all Tom.
Leo656
02-05-2022, 05:54 PM
"Hope" is the most irrational of all human emotions.
MikeandRaph87
02-05-2022, 06:09 PM
"Hope" is the most irrational of all human emotions.
https://images.app.goo.gl/dS7GnnmWADJfzx2g9https://comicnewbies.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/saint-walker-hal-jordan-and-the-green-lantern-corps-14.png
Not while the blue light shines! I won't let you get into my head Sinestro!
Leo656
02-05-2022, 06:16 PM
I enjoy fictional stories.
Because in fiction, God is real, good people exist, bad people are punished, and sometimes there are happy endings.
In short, fiction is wonderful because it is the polar opposite of Real Life.
frank_one
02-05-2022, 07:49 PM
"Hope" is the most irrational of all human emotions.It is also the most human emotion and what pushes our daily actions. Hope is a functional illusion.
Leo656
02-05-2022, 08:01 PM
Yes but it fundamentally depends on a rejection of reality. "Hope" and "Reality" simply cannot occupy the same space at the same time. Furthermore, reality exists whether or not a person chooses to believe in it, whereas "hope" relies entirely on belief in order to be "real". Kind of like God, or Santa Claus. And regardless, no amount of "belief" can actually make those things exist, therefore they remain delusions/illusions. Just like "hoping" you win the lottery will never make it happen, just for one example.
We generally call grown adults who openly believe in either of those fictional characters delusional and/or mentally ill, and rightly so. So my question is, if like God or Santa the concept of "hope" is only real if a person believes in it, and even in that case calling them "real" is really stretching the definition of the term, why doesn't THAT also designate someone a crazy person?
I've never really managed to understand that. I, personally, laugh just as hard at someone whenever they tell me "I believe in Hope" as I do when someone says "I believe in God."
Whatever gets someone through the day, I guess. But I confess that I don't understand it. I probably never will.
ChosenOne
02-16-2022, 01:30 PM
After reading #126 and realizing that a) #125 wasn't a fluke and b) Campbell's writing has finally, thankfully, praise Jesus-ly gone the way of the dodo, I finally made up my mind and voted "Yes".
psychturtle
02-20-2022, 10:03 AM
That was a lot to read through. I don’t post as much anymore (life stuff), but I understand a lot of what people are saying. I won’t write a thesis but have to vent a little:
After issue 105 or so, I became VERY bored with tmnt. I often wondered what the overall arc was. Then I started believing that the goal wasn’t story building, it was essentially to watch the turtles “play house” and just date. I really became annoyed with it and wanted to just donate all the comics after #100. But just like gambling, I wanted to keep giving it one last chance. I found myself even skimming the dialogue, hoping for an enticing panel. Rat king is still captivating but just seeing the ridiculous banter and unnecessary drama amongst characters was a HUGE problem for me.
I wanted Sophie to do well, but I couldn’t help but be honest with myself about it. So I’ve deduced that either a) someone intervened for the latest two issues, or b) Sophie did a really, really poor job organizing her run. I hope it gets better but I really hope they reboot soon. Prolonging it is not helping.
Why do these threads always turn out like this.
Because of factioning that happens along a spectrum of society. It's the kind of factions you get with emotionally-uncertain-nerds in High School, or in low-level office environments where people align to the office-employee-factions they think will make them standout. Those factions usually involve the same opportunistic personal attacks you'll get here in response to ideology posts. Basically people at that level rally behind who they feel is a "nice guy" or rally against people who's insight challenges them because any challenge is an extension of their social or life failure.
People who fit this model also rarely rally behind truth when it doesn't fit their personal porcelain-narrative and even less-so if someone delivering the truth has challenged them to see the truth. Much of the vocal population of this forum fits that spectrum. Societal factions at the grassroots level. The same people would call this post a "wall of text" in disregard of it's content.
That was a lot to read through. I don’t post as much anymore (life stuff), but I understand a lot of what people are saying. I won’t write a thesis but have to vent a little:
After issue 105 or so, I became VERY bored with tmnt.
You hung on longer than I did, so God bless ya for that one. I dropped at 50 out of apathy. Then people were talking about what was going on in the book across 50 & 100 and long term I'm glad I just walked away from it back then.
But just like gambling, I wanted to keep giving it one last chance. I found myself even skimming the dialogue, hoping for an enticing panel.
You sound like a real fan. I did this with a decade of bad Iron Man stories. It's completely irrational, but I think a big part of fandom sometimes is just hanging in there on some irrational faith and desire that it's going to go back to what you loved. :lol:
I hope it gets better but I really hope they reboot soon. Prolonging it is not helping.
IDW's TMNT is one of the few long-form published books with contiguous numbering left on the shelves. I don't think they should reboot it with a new launch. I respect the book's staying power, so they should just change creative teams, give it a new logo and put a blurb on the cover that says "New Direction!" but stick with the numbering as a show of legacy for the book.
Rebooting and relaunches went a LONG way to killing the comic book industry.
Coola Yagami
02-20-2022, 12:21 PM
I wanted Sophie to do well, but I couldn’t help but be honest with myself about it. So I’ve deduced that either a) someone intervened for the latest two issues, or b) Sophie did a really, really poor job organizing her run. I hope it gets better but I really hope they reboot soon. Prolonging it is not helping.
Their writing is horrible, and now that it's mostly over and things are going back on track, it's too late for a lot of people. It's the equivalent of 50 horrible (and not in the so bad it's good style, I mean just BAD) Friday the 13th movies then someone comes with an actual good one.... Telling people 'this one is actually good, honest you guys' will be a tough sell after 50 failures.
TylerD
02-23-2022, 10:54 AM
If it keeps going like the last 25 issues, I hope the hell not. More doesn't mean better...
Starting to agree with this myself, just not loving where the storyline is going..... I thought maybe with a rebirth of good Oroku Saki, they could do something cool but it just seems like they are out of ideas right now.
With that said, I absolutely love the Ninja Turtles comics regardless, so I would hate to see this end without at least there being another storyline to come out.... Couldn't imagine not picking up the latest Ninja Turtle comic each month :( There might be one off short mini series, but still.
ChosenOne
02-23-2022, 12:14 PM
It's completely irrational, but I think a big part of fandom sometimes is just hanging in there on some irrational faith and desire that it's going to go back to what you loved. :lol:
Well, fandom is born of nostalgia...
CyberCubed
02-25-2022, 07:58 PM
The way the IDW comic is written is as if it's not coming to a close anytime soon. I guess it probably will run close to issue 200 assuming sales remain as they are now.
Coola Yagami
02-25-2022, 08:22 PM
The way the IDW comic is written is as if it's not coming to a close anytime soon
That barely matters. If the sales dip below a certain point, it'll get cancelled. Wouldn't be the first or last book to just get canned mid-story. Hell, even the Dreamwave TMNT comics were promising a big story and that didn't stop it from getting cancelled. It was too late no matter how much 'the next story is gonna be awesome and actually related to the show, we promise' they might have tried.
mrmaczaps
02-26-2022, 07:43 PM
I'd rather see the ongoing get canned and then IDW could do a couple "throwback" miniseries off of the existing material like the 90s movies or earlier comics and then doing a big Universal crossover & then retcon parts of their series, then pick up again with a new issue 1 without redoing the entire origin or having a million different mutants running around.
CyberCubed
02-26-2022, 07:47 PM
That barely matters. If the sales dip below a certain point, it'll get cancelled. Wouldn't be the first or last book to just get canned mid-story. Hell, even the Dreamwave TMNT comics were promising a big story and that didn't stop it from getting cancelled. It was too late no matter how much 'the next story is gonna be awesome and actually related to the show, we promise' they might have tried.
Nope that's not how IDW operates. If you look at their other series that got ended they gave their writers enough time to wrap up all the major story points, or as much as they could do.
IDW TMNT is constantly introducing new characters like Venus and the current plots, it doesn't feel like it's winding down.
Cowabung-Gal
07-28-2022, 11:15 AM
I don’t think so.
Less and less people are buying comics, and it’s not just because of the economy. It’s also because they don’t want to waste their hard-earned money on preachy meager comics that were written by narcissistic writers.
When TMNT fans picked up the 1st issue of the main IDW series back in 2011, they never would’ve suspected that it would eventually turn into a furry version of “Jem”. If they knew, they would’ve put the comic back on the shelf and walked away.
CyberCubed
04-28-2023, 10:26 PM
The results were an even split at 24 votes each, and sadly I guess we can say for sure it will be a, "No."
We're at issue #140 in June, we'll be lucky if we make it past 150 issues. But 200 issues would mean we have to go on another couple of years and that seems unlikely.
TheLabRat
04-29-2023, 01:28 AM
I don’t think so.
Less and less people are buying comics, and it’s not just because of the economy. It’s also because they don’t want to waste their hard-earned money on preachy meager comics that were written by narcissistic writers.
https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1597021145118953472
Surely it's not just Campbell.
Seriously, Splinter sacrifices himself to resurrect Saki who should have been dead. How could they call this is "The Cosmic Balance"? Saki should stay in hell and face his punishment and not be reincarnated until his sentence is over.
CyberCubed
05-04-2023, 01:06 PM
My prediction now is TMNT will end around issue 150 (which would put us 10 months from now, so into 2024), with maybe a 5-issue mini series after as a grand conclusion.
We'll hit #140 next month, so I think 10 more issues to 150 is at least very likely since that would put us halfway into 2024.
Weapons@theready
05-04-2023, 03:42 PM
The real question is do we want it to go to issue 200?
Zog The Magnificent
05-04-2023, 04:09 PM
The real question is do we want it to go to issue 200?
At this point, no. Even The Armageddon Game couldn't salvage two and half years of of furry OC, battle of the bands, plot derailing nonsense. TMNT IDW has already joined the long stretch of TMNT comics that never really pays off in the end, dating all the way back to Mirage Vol. 2. The sooner it gets its end over with, the better.
Andrew NDB
05-04-2023, 04:24 PM
My prediction now is TMNT will end around issue 150 (which would put us 10 months from now, so into 2024), with maybe a 5-issue mini series after as a grand conclusion.
We'll hit #140 next month, so I think 10 more issues to 150 is at least very likely since that would put us halfway into 2024.
I'd see something potentially more like, the book ending around #175, with a Vol. 2 beginning with a new #1 and lasting for about a year or so.
CyberCubed
05-04-2023, 04:27 PM
Will IDW as a company as a whole still be around by 2025 though? That's why I'm only willing to guess to issue 150...with only 1 issue out a month that will still put us at 10 months from now.
I think IDW might make it to the end of 2024 but I don't know how long they'll exist after. If IDW wasn't in dire straights I could have seen the comic going on a really long time still.
frank_one
05-04-2023, 05:14 PM
I don't see them dragging the story on to #200. I don't know about sales but I doubt many out there are still genuinely and actively interested in the series. For the most part they just wanna see how it ends. After that? IDW will probably attempt a reboot or something connected to previous series. What if they do new stories set in the Mirage universe? I mean, they have Eastman. I would love to see Lawson, Dooney or even Laird involved.
Bahamut810
05-04-2023, 05:14 PM
Will IDW as a company as a whole still be around by 2025 though? That's why I'm only willing to guess to issue 150...with only 1 issue out a month that will still put us at 10 months from now.
I think IDW might make it to the end of 2024 but I don't know how long they'll exist after. If IDW wasn't in dire straights I could have seen the comic going on a really long time still.
It will probably exist after being bought out by a larger company like Warner Brothers or Disney if for nothing else then its properties thought I wouldn't be surprised if it was rolled in with Marvel or DC at that point.
CyberCubed
05-04-2023, 05:50 PM
What would be the point of another company buying IDW though? All their comics are licensed properties and they can simply pick up the license instead.
Andrew NDB
05-04-2023, 05:54 PM
What would be the point of another company buying IDW though? All their comics are licensed properties and they can simply pick up the license instead.
That's true. There's really nothing much tangible to buy.
Bahamut810
05-04-2023, 10:17 PM
That's true. There's really nothing much tangible to buy.
I thought they owned some IP like Locke and Key and stuff?
Im not sure how it would work for reprints and whatever else people would want to do with it, but at least they own the comics they made (even if new contracts would have to be agreed to on licenses they have anymore).
Calvatron
05-05-2023, 07:52 AM
https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1597021145118953472
Surely it's not just Campbell.
Seriously, Splinter sacrifices himself to resurrect Saki who should have been dead. How could they call this is "The Cosmic Balance"? Saki should stay in hell and face his punishment and not be reincarnated until his sentence is over.
That's not really how eastern metaphysics work. Not punishment based. Beings move towards lives that reflect what they have an affinity for. Mara isn't considered a simple villain like western religions label their antagonist but a being with an integral job. Sake leading the netherworld in tmnt reflects this cultural nuance. Also splinter was the one who had fallen so the narrative is his fall and sake's "rise". Being appropriate to one's role is the focus not good=reward/bad=punish. Sake had refound his path and splinter had lost his on many levels.
I don't really see this story making it to issue 200. At this point i doubt idw will be publishing comics at that point. And idw has really made hash of trying to appeal to fans in their 40's/50's and the shipping crowd/teens and 20 somethings who don't buy comics much and generally specifically aren't interested in classic tmnt stories. Not really much overlap between those two groups so everybody is either pissed or basically not buying much. They should really end this series and start a new one that doesn't try to please everyone. I used to know who the audience for this comic was, now i'm not sure who it's actually for.
TheLabRat
05-05-2023, 10:53 AM
No, even if you admit your mistake, you still have to pay back your karma. Not all mistakes can be undone. Bad karma accumulated throughout a lifetime will eventually catch you at some point. If Saki chooses reincarnation. He may still have to continue to pay back his karma in his next life. This is also part of the work of eastern metaphysics.
I also rolled my eyess when I saw Saki say about Yin-Yang is light and darkness in the The Armageddon Game #3. In fact, dark edgelord Leo is Yang, not Yin.
CyberCubed
05-05-2023, 05:02 PM
There's probably some sort of irony that every TMNT comic publisher winds up somehow imploding before the series can have a proper ending. Happened with Mirage (twice, once at the end of Vol. 2 and now with Vol. 4 being unfinished for over a decade), Image, the Archie Adventures comics, and now IDW.
At least Image and Archie got proper conclusions eventually or good stopping points, but if IDW doesn't manage to wrap things up by issue #150 I'd be a little concerned.
Calvatron
05-05-2023, 06:48 PM
No, even if you admit your mistake, you still have to pay back your karma. Not all mistakes can be undone. Bad karma accumulated throughout a lifetime will eventually catch you at some point. If Saki chooses reincarnation. He may still have to continue to pay back his karma in his next life. This is also part of the work of eastern metaphysics.
I also rolled my eyess when I saw Saki say about Yin-Yang is light and darkness in the The Armageddon Game #3. In fact, dark edgelord Leo is Yang, not Yin.
What i'm trying to get at that is that karma doesn't function as a system of reward or punishment. That's a very western view applied over top of it. I'm not really expecting a super nuanced perspective from a ninja turtles story, but for the sake of discussion my impression is that saki's role in guarding/advising the turtles is a how his character can 'burn off' some karma. It's also a concept bound to attachment more than some cosmic score card or any direct 1:1 value like criminal court. Not to mention that he did already go to a netherworld given a "hell" title. But overall i expect any metaphysical concepts in this to be about as realistic as any techno jargon i encounter in Dr. Who or Star Wars. I'm not taking this particularly seriously.
TheLabRat
05-05-2023, 09:17 PM
What i'm trying to get at that is that karma doesn't function as a system of reward or punishment. That's a very western view applied over top of it. I'm not really expecting a super nuanced perspective from a ninja turtles story, but for the sake of discussion my impression is that saki's role in guarding/advising the turtles is a how his character can 'burn off' some karma. It's also a concept bound to attachment more than some cosmic score card or any direct 1:1 value like criminal court. Not to mention that he did already go to a netherworld given a "hell" title. But overall i expect any metaphysical concepts in this to be about as realistic as any techno jargon i encounter in Dr. Who or Star Wars. I'm not taking this particularly seriously.
But this does not affect the criminals will go to hell after death. They will still be judged and punished by The Yama King.
Although Hinduism or Buddhism have their own interpretations of karma, the common denominator is that actions determine fate. You reap what you sow.
Calvatron
05-07-2023, 10:44 AM
But this does not affect the criminals will go to hell after death. They will still be judged and punished by The Yama King.
Although Hinduism or Buddhism have their own interpretations of karma, the common denominator is that actions determine fate. You reap what you sow.
But why is that so important in a comic book? It's a fantasy escape, and it certainly doesn't fit the plot or narrative of this series very well.
Cowabung-Gal
05-07-2023, 03:11 PM
But why is that so important in a comic book? It's a fantasy escape
Honestly, what has a comic book ever been a “fantasy escape” in the last seven years?
https://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/wp-content/uploads/satevepost/SavageDragon.jpg
Sure, there have been a few exceptions, like The Last Ronin, but still….
Heck, the Jennika mini-series had MAGA people protesting the idea of letting mutants back into society. And they wonder why the entire comic book industry is crumbling
Monty Mole
05-07-2023, 03:31 PM
Honestly, what has a comic book ever been a “fantasy escape” in the last seven years?
https://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/wp-content/uploads/satevepost/SavageDragon.jpg
Sure, there has a few exceptions, like The Last Ronin, but still….
Heck, the Jennika mini-series had MAGA people protesting the idea of letting mutants back into society. And they wonder why the entire comic book industry is crumbling
I'm not a fan of forcing politics into things, but this drawing Jim Lawson did was hilarious! :tlol:
ChosenOne
05-07-2023, 03:38 PM
I'm not a fan of forcing politics into things, but this drawing Jim Lawson did was hilarious! :tlol:
Yes. "Hilarious".
Cowabung-Gal
05-07-2023, 04:38 PM
I'm not a fan of forcing politics into things, but this drawing Jim Lawson did was hilarious! :tlol:
Okay but who hasn’t punched Trump?
https://indepest.com/2017/11/28/superheroes-punching-trump/
https://www.dailydot.com/parsec/kamala-khan-marvel-donald-trump-fanart/
https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a46404/donald-trump-marvel-villain/
Has any comic character punched Bush, Obama, or Biden yet? I’m waiting….
I mean, good grief, add some variety and have a character tell Biden to stick it and I guarantee you that issue would sell like hotcakes.
Monty Mole
05-07-2023, 05:15 PM
Okay but who hasn’t punched Trump?
https://indepest.com/2017/11/28/superheroes-punching-trump/
https://www.dailydot.com/parsec/kamala-khan-marvel-donald-trump-fanart/
https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a46404/donald-trump-marvel-villain/
Has any comic character punched Bush, Obama, or Biden yet? I’m waiting….
I mean, good grief, add some variety and have a character tell Biden to stick it and I guarantee you that issue would sell like hotcakes.
They should do it the way South Park does, by hating everything equally.
hypered1
05-07-2023, 06:57 PM
Curious that the vote suddenly evened out at 28-28.
ChosenOne
05-07-2023, 07:19 PM
Curious that the vote suddenly evened out at 28-28.
Which one was leading before?
Coola Yagami
05-07-2023, 08:17 PM
I'm not a fan of forcing politics into things, but this drawing Jim Lawson did was hilarious! :tlol:
I'm pretty sure the turtles are the last to care about American politics. None of that **** affects them unless there's a 'flush all mutants out of the sewers' policy or whatever.
Cowabung-Gal
05-07-2023, 08:25 PM
Which one was leading before?
The “No” vote
Monty Mole
05-08-2023, 01:41 AM
I'm pretty sure the turtles are the last to care about American politics. None of that **** affects them unless there's a 'flush all mutants out of the sewers' policy or whatever.
Fair. I was just browsing through some of Jim Lawson's art and when i saw that, it made me chuckle.
ChosenOne
05-08-2023, 07:26 AM
The “No” vote
How odd that it would turn around on the very week when we got confirmation that IDW is sinking... No rest for the shills, I suppose.
hypered1
05-08-2023, 08:00 AM
And now there's another 3 votes to 'no'. Six extra votes in the space of a week out of nowhere after months of nothing feels like sockpuppet accounts are being used.
CyberCubed
05-08-2023, 11:25 AM
The username votes are public, I'm looking at the usernames and everyone voting has been here a long time. Which are the sockpuppet accounts? You can click each username to see when people either registered or have a low post count, but most votes are from people who have been on this forum for years.
Andrew NDB
05-08-2023, 11:46 AM
Though it is interesting to note that while almost all of the people voting "No" post at least once in a while on the board... the overwhelming majority of the people voting "Yes" don't post at all, or haven't in years (or when they did post, it was just to Supprt Currnt Turtle Product™).
neatoman
05-08-2023, 02:32 PM
Though it is interesting to note that while almost all of the people voting "No" post at least once in a while on the board... the overwhelming majority of the people voting "Yes" don't post at all, or haven't in years (or when they did post, it was just to Supprt Currnt Turtle Product™).
Yeah, a little sad isn't it...
Personally I'm not really willing to vote on this matter because I genuinely don't feel confident one way or the other. On one hand, it is true that the series only needs to last another five years to get to 200 issues and has somehow kept going for three years after it became a stinker, so never say never? On the other hand, IDW itself is circling the drain and we don't know if it can legitimately keep going for another five years, plus the fact that when a new writer takes over, I could easily them thinking the current IDW continuity is too tainted to bother continuing and just does a clean reboot (which would happen with a new publisher regardless).
So yeah, not sure what to say about this. I'm technically leaning towards no, but I genuinely don't know.
Bahamut810
05-08-2023, 06:23 PM
Though it is interesting to note that while almost all of the people voting "No" post at least once in a while on the board... the overwhelming majority of the people voting "Yes" don't post at all, or haven't in years (or when they did post, it was just to Supprt Currnt Turtle Product™).
That was my first thought. How many of them do you remember posting within the last few months? How many of them have 'real' sounding handles? For example...I dont recall ever seeing anything from "bgb1018" and the name looks 'sock puppet'-ish.
ChosenOne
05-08-2023, 06:48 PM
They're already on #140 and the TMNT brand of comics show no sign of slowing down. I feel like it's more likely than not that we'll get another 60 issues, regardless of perceived quality.
That being said, either option could happen. If it does end prematurely, I feel like the final issue will be closer to 200 than the opposite.
I actually voted "Yes" after a long time on the fence, and I (still) agree with this sentiment despite everything. It'll go beyond #150 for sure.
CyberCubed
05-09-2023, 04:58 PM
Interesting enough this years IDW Free Comic Book day issue is just a re-print of the first original cartoon comic and a Rise of the TMNT comic of all things bundled together.
Remember when IDW's Free Comic Book day issue would have some new content in it for IDW's main continuity? This is the first year they didn't do it and just re-printed an issue for the cartoons of all things. I wonder if this is a warning sign.
I'm honestly surprised they're doing an Annual this year but that was probably planned months ago before they knew they were cutting 39% of their workforce.
hypered1
05-09-2023, 05:04 PM
Interesting enough this years IDW Free Comic Book day issue is just a re-print of the first original cartoon comic and a Rise of the TMNT comic of all things bundled together.
Remember when IDW's Free Comic Book day issue would have some new content in it for IDW's main continuity? This is the first year they didn't do it and just re-printed an issue for the cartoons of all things. I wonder if this is a warning sign.
I'm honestly surprised they're doing an Annual this year but that was probably planned months ago before they knew they were cutting 39% of their workforce.
The only times the FCBD issue has been new content for the main IDW continuity was 2015, 2017, 2019 and 2022 - four years out of twelve since the series started.
We are however getting a fourth consecutive Annual issue this year after previously only having two in 2012 and 2014.
PrestonC
05-26-2023, 08:37 AM
If the comic had maintained the quality it had from issues 1-50, then yeah, it would reach 200 without question. But the quality has plummeted so far since 100, that even though I’m a huge TMNT fan, I hope they wrap up the remaining story threads and put it out of its misery. I’m multiple months behind because I just don’t care anymore. It’s so sad to see how far it has fallen.
CyberCubed
05-26-2023, 12:40 PM
I'd say they should have enough time to cover that future plot with Armaggon they seem to be setting up, but that could be the final story arc of the series.
MikeandRaph87
05-26-2023, 01:30 PM
I'd say they should have enough time to cover that future plot with Armaggon they seem to be setting up, but that could be the final story arc of the series.
I was actually confused by what exactly Armaggon is. He is not a mutant shark from a future timeline, but some arterial being?
CyberCubed
05-26-2023, 07:14 PM
I was actually confused by what exactly Armaggon is. He is not a mutant shark from a future timeline, but some arterial being?
Seems to be some sort of God creature I guess.
TheLabRat
05-26-2023, 09:40 PM
Not sure if I can still look forward to these. These big events are always hyped, but end up being disappointing anti-climaxes. It's all back to square one, the same thing over and over again, The Turtles has no real character development.
CyberCubed
05-26-2023, 10:52 PM
They'll just do the, "Turtles and their friends are drifting apart" story they already did like 5 times over and then have them all get back together again after 10 issues. And also the "forming alliances" nonsense which we already know is happening with Alopex joining with the weasels and Karai already doing that.
ChosenOne
05-27-2023, 07:02 AM
Alopex: I'm sick and tired of these ninja clans!
Also Alopex: I'm gonna start me a ninja clan!
TheLabRat
05-29-2023, 09:54 PM
The Turtles also become so passive and good for nothing. Always had to ally with old enemies to fight a greater evil. Their action may even enabled these villains. When things are over. These old enemies will only get more benefit, and may even become a greater threat in the future.
CyberCubed
06-20-2023, 12:05 AM
https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/54374/idw-publishing-loses-200-000-quarter
They lost $200,000 last quarter, although an improvement over 2022
https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/54374/idw-publishing-loses-200-000-quarter
They lost $200,000 last quarter, although an improvement over 2022
Again - news for the peasant thinker who wants to think that sales are "better".
Nnnnnope. That "loss improvement" is a result of the all of the job cuts and liquidations they held after their stock de-listing.
It's basically the equivalent of you being overextended so you cancel your monthly Nextflix and the next month isn't as bad because this time you don't have the 19.99 bill.
Bahamut810
06-20-2023, 03:49 PM
Two months ago, their stock dropped to .40. Since the start of june its floating in the .50 range
CyberCubed
06-20-2023, 05:41 PM
I wonder if they'll make it through 2024. 2025 is probably pushing it.
Donnie
07-01-2023, 12:18 AM
I'm going to be optimistic and say yes; however, that's because I'm surprised it has lasted this long.
Bahamut810
09-22-2023, 04:51 PM
Staggering losses for IDW..
https://youtu.be/cN86fBS27P8?si=WDMZ1wvAO1ciz3kz
GameCobra
09-26-2023, 12:21 AM
I don't know the full history of IDW over the years, but from a modern reader perspective, I feel this comic can definitely push 200 and more based on the direction the comic is going after comic version 100.
I loved the Mutant Town arc and the new turtle team with Jennika and Alopex replacing Splinter (Will definitely miss him :'( ) and the whole Splinter Dojo theme the comic was going with and the flood of more Mutants in New York in general. It generally felt like Sophie Campbell was setup to write the series into a transitional phase for the second generation and focus on a recovery phase after Issue 100, honestly.
I will say, though, is that I do feel like Dr. Barlow could've been introduced earlier in the comic and brought the turtles back into action alot sooner as early as 112. The only problem I had with the comic after issue 100 is that the slice of life stuff that the turtles and the rest of the case was well deserved after issue 100, but I felt it could've been done much shorter.
Andrew NDB
09-26-2023, 12:37 AM
Staggering losses for IDW..
https://youtu.be/cN86fBS27P8?si=WDMZ1wvAO1ciz3kz
Let me help you out there:
cN86fBS27P8
CyberCubed
09-26-2023, 05:43 AM
How much money in cash does a company need to have to still be able to run an operation? I admit I'm not too well versed on the business side of things. I've seen companies still running with barely any money left.
Cowabung-Gal
09-26-2023, 05:46 PM
So is Raph gonna quit the team again because he’s going back to being a simp for Alopex?
Bahamut810
09-26-2023, 06:42 PM
I don't know the full history of IDW over the years, but from a modern reader perspective, I feel this comic can definitely push 200 and more based on the direction the comic is going after comic version 100.
I loved the Mutant Town arc and the new turtle team with Jennika and Alopex replacing Splinter (Will definitely miss him :'( ) and the whole Splinter Dojo theme the comic was going with and the flood of more Mutants in New York in general. It generally felt like Sophie Campbell was setup to write the series into a transitional phase for the second generation and focus on a recovery phase after Issue 100, honestly.
I will say, though, is that I do feel like Dr. Barlow could've been introduced earlier in the comic and brought the turtles back into action alot sooner as early as 112. The only problem I had with the comic after issue 100 is that the slice of life stuff that the turtles and the rest of the case was well deserved after issue 100, but I felt it could've been done much shorter.
The big problem with the Mutant Town ark is that it wasn't TMNT. It was Jennika and friends, and Sophie wrote the way that I am sure she was hired to on other projects like Jem (which I have heard she was awesome at, and it was successful)...but Jem is not TMNT. There is a whole lot of sentiment (at least here) that agrees that it drug on just waaaaay to long.
I am a person that sticks on to stuff for a lot longer then I should because I am a completionist and I was about to quit when I heard about the latest event that happened so stuck around for that. If it goes back, I will be taking it off my pull list because its so boring and unsatisfying (like the battle of the bands).
If you enjoy it, more power to you though.
The big problem with the Mutant Town ark is that it wasn't TMNT. It was Jennika and friends, and Sophie wrote the way that I am sure she was hired to on other projects like Jem (which I have heard she was awesome at, and it was successful)...but Jem is not TMNT. There is a whole lot of sentiment (at least here) that agrees that it drug on just waaaaay to long.
I am a person that sticks on to stuff for a lot longer then I should because I am a completionist and I was about to quit when I heard about the latest event that happened so stuck around for that. If it goes back, I will be taking it off my pull list because its so boring and unsatisfying (like the battle of the bands).
If you enjoy it, more power to you though.
Yeah, there were better ways to write the “Coming out of Our Shells” arc that were more logical and featured other characters more prominently. IDW mutagen on humans was never able to turn them into Beastkin on contact, only via injection, but the aerosol mutagen bomb was never fully explained or built up to. The battles of the bands should have been for a better cause, possibly to raise funds for a cure for the mutagen aerosol. Way too many wasted cameos. Sadly, the way it was handled in the end was an Image-level red mark on the IDW series in the end, and later, more interesting events still feel the scars of it.
TheLabRat
10-08-2023, 08:25 AM
Mutant Town was supposed to have the potential to create a lot of interesting stories, but they wasted it.
The Turtls can have their secret identities. They can have normal daily lives where they socialize and help other mutants and use their various skills and strengths for the good of a downtrodden area, but they gotta stay ninjas. Imagine that, Donnie and Mikey both call themselves David, one is a repairman help others in town fix appliances or plumbing, and the other is a radio commentator and a novelist in Mutant Town. Leo and Raph were named John and George respectively. they are the gardeners and urban farmers. Greening the Mutant Town, providing agricultural products to others.
https://i.imgur.com/57AJTD2.jpg
Stockman won't just build a stupid giant wall, he would eventually build better and safer shelter, but the victims he takes in are mostly foreigners or families of rich people. Hob's bomb attack was supposed to be an international event. If there are other foreigners among the victims, other countries will be very concerned about this incident, and will not even allow a mayor of New York to imprison their own citizens. These victims, especially the rich, will become his future political supporters. Maybe there's a scene where Stockman is at a bigwig party, and all these rich people, both human and mutant, are praising him, while outside the window there's a crumbling mutant town, where many of homeless mutants are still sleep on the streets.
Mutant Town was supposed to have the potential to create a lot of interesting stories, but they wasted it.
The Turtls can have their secret identities. They can have normal daily lives where they socialize and help other mutants and use their various skills and strengths for the good of a downtrodden area, but they gotta stay ninjas. Imagine that, Donnie and Mikey both call themselves David, one is a repairman help others in town fix appliances or plumbing, and the other is a radio commentator and a novelist in Mutant Town. Leo and Raph were named John and George respectively. they are the gardeners and urban farmers. Greening the Mutant Town, providing agricultural products to others.
https://i.imgur.com/57AJTD2.jpg
Stockman won't just build a stupid giant wall, he would eventually build better and safer shelter, but the victims he takes in are mostly foreigners or families of rich people. Hob's bomb attack was supposed to be an international event. If there are other foreigners among the victims, other countries will be very concerned about this incident, and will not even allow a mayor of New York to imprison their own citizens. These victims, especially the rich, will become his future political supporters. Maybe there's a scene where Stockman is at a bigwig party, and all these rich people, both human and mutant, are praising him, while outside the window there's a crumbling mutant town, where many of homeless mutants are still sleep on the streets.
Thou hath won ye topic. There was so much potential beyond “Coming out of their Shells 2 Champion Edition”, potential I did not even realize.
CyberCubed
09-05-2025, 05:29 PM
Not counting the number restarting, I can see another 50 issues so we likely will hit 200 "main" series issues. But with all the specials/mini-series combined I'm sure IDW TMNT has over 300 issues already.
It really is insane how much output IDW has put out. Back in 2011 I never imagined IDW's universe going on this long and counting. It's surpassed pretty much everything in length, if you don't count Mirage's "breaks" it's almost there too. Mirage went from 1984-2010 give or take.
hypered1
09-05-2025, 07:16 PM
Not counting the number restarting, I can see another 50 issues so we likely will hit 200 "main" series issues. But with all the specials/mini-series combined I'm sure IDW TMNT has over 300 issues already.
It really is insane how much output IDW has put out. Back in 2011 I never imagined IDW's universe going on this long and counting. It's surpassed pretty much everything in length, if you don't count Mirage's "breaks" it's almost there too. Mirage went from 1984-2010 give or take.
The IDW continuity is currently at 316 issues, with another 22 - 24ish confirmed. In time terms I'd say Mirage ran for 20~ years (1984-95 + 2001-10), by comparison IDW just passed 14 years so there's still some catching up to do.
Stu_Padasso
09-06-2025, 01:45 AM
As per the original question… no.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.